Latest / Her Moment: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / The Shame of SNAP Benefits While Living in Luxury | Her Moment
Transcript
- I walked into the grocery store with my designer tote and my cashmere coat, and for a second, I felt like an imposter in my own life. It wasn’t until I swiped my EBT card at the register that the ground beneath me shifted entirely. Let’s unpack that moment right there. You know the one. The fluorescent lights buzzing overhead, the squeak of sneakers on linoleum, the sheer, unglamorous reality of choosing between name-brand pasta and the generic kind because your budget says no to the fancy stuff. But here is the thing about that specific aisle. It’s where the mask slips. I was wearing this incredible, structured blazer that cost more than most people’s weekly grocery bill. My hair was done. I looked, by all external metrics, like I had it together. I was living what society calls a 'luxury' life. I have a nice apartment. I drink coffee from a ceramic mug that costs forty dollars. I take trips to places that require passport stamps. And yet, there I was, standing in line, waiting to use food assistance to buy chicken breasts and rice. It felt like a glitch in the matrix. Like I was pretending to be someone else, or worse, that I had been found out. The person behind me didn’t know. The cashier didn’t know. But I knew. And in that silence, before the beep of the scanner, I felt this hot, prickly shame crawl up my neck. It wasn’t just about money. It was about identity. It was about the story we tell ourselves about who deserves help and who doesn’t. Because if you look like you’re winning, why are you taking something for free? Why are you burdening the system? That question hung in the air, heavier than any shopping bag could ever be. We need to talk about the myth of meritocratic survival. We live in a culture that insists if you work hard, you should have enough. If you aren’t enough, it’s because you didn’t work hard enough, or you made bad choices. It’s a clean, tidy narrative. It puts the blame squarely on the individual. But life is messy. Life is not a spreadsheet. I’ve spent years watching my peers chase this idea that success is linear. You get the degree, you get the job, you get the house, you get the security. And for a while, I believed it too. I thought that if I just curated my life perfectly enough, if I posted the right photos and said the right things, I would be safe from want. But then came the rent hikes. Then came the medical bills that weren’t covered. Then came the industry downturns that left me staring at a laptop screen wondering how I was going to pay for next month’s groceries. Suddenly, the luxury wasn’t a shield; it was a trap. I was asset-rich but cash-poor. I had equity in things, but I didn’t have liquidity in my bank account. And so, I had to make a choice. I could keep up appearances and starve, or I could accept help and feel like a fraud. I chose to eat. I chose to survive. But the shame? The shame stayed. It followed me home. It sat at my kitchen table while I ate dinner prepared with funds that felt tainted by the very fact that they were necessary. Here’s the thing about our current cultural moment. We are obsessed with performance. We perform wealth on social media. We perform struggle on podcasts. We curate our narratives to fit a brand. But real poverty, or real financial precarity, doesn’t look like anything. It looks like silence. It looks like eating oatmeal for three days straight because you’re saving your lunch money for a bus fare. It looks like checking your bank balance every hour. And when you do that while looking like you belong in a different world, it creates a cognitive dissonance that is exhausting to manage. I remember talking to a friend about this once. She told me she felt guilty accepting a gift card from her mother because she still drove a nice car. She felt like she was lying. But why? Why is the appearance of independence more important than the act of receiving care? We’ve tied our self-worth to our ability to provide for ourselves without aid. We view assistance as a failure of character rather than a tool for survival. But think about it. When you need a jump start on your car, you don’t feel ashamed to ask a stranger for help. When your house floods, you don’t hesitate to call insurance. So why is food different? Why is the basic sustenance of human life treated as a moral failing if you can’t afford it outright? It’s absurd. And yet, the feeling persists. It lingers in the back of your mind every time you scan that card. It whispers that you are less than. That you are falling behind. That you are not as good as you pretend to be. Tell me more about how that felt. Because I want you to really sit with that question. How does it feel in your body when you realize the safety net you relied on isn’t as sturdy as you thought? For me, it was a tightening in the chest. A constant, low-level anxiety that hummed beneath everything else. Even when I was laughing with friends, even when I was planning a vacation, there was this other voice in the background saying, 'You don’t deserve this. You haven’t earned this. You’re using other people’s money.' It distorted my joy. It turned simple pleasures into sources of guilt. I started hiding my struggles. I stopped mentioning prices. I lied about what I could afford. I became a master of deflection, changing the subject whenever the bill came or when someone asked what I did last weekend. This isolation is dangerous. It keeps us from connecting. It keeps us from realizing that we are all just one paycheck away from needing help. Some of us just hide it better than others. Some of us wear nicer coats. Some of us have better hair. But the fear is the same. The shame is the same. And it is a lie. It is a lie constructed by a system that profits from our insecurity. By making us feel small for needing support, it ensures we stay compliant. It ensures we keep working, keep spending, keep striving, even when we are breaking. It keeps us chasing a horizon that moves further away every day. So, how do we break the spell? How do we stop letting the label of 'benefits recipient' define our worth when our outward presentation contradicts it? It starts with radical honesty. With myself first. I had to admit that I needed help. I had to admit that my previous strategies hadn’t worked. And I had to admit that accepting help didn’t make me a bad person. It made me a human being navigating a difficult economic landscape. I started talking about it. Not loudly, not for clicks, but quietly. To trusted friends. To family. To myself in the mirror. I began to separate my value from my wallet. I realized that my kindness, my creativity, my presence—these things were not for sale. They were not contingent on my ability to pay full price for milk. There is a profound liberation in shedding the need to look perfect. When I stopped trying to convince everyone that I was doing fine, I found that I was actually okay. Better than okay. I was resilient. I was adaptable. I was surviving. And there is dignity in survival. There is strength in asking for a hand up. It takes courage to say, 'I am struggling,' especially when you look like you have it all figured out. But that courage is contagious. It gives permission to others to drop their masks too. It builds solidarity. It reminds us that we are in this together, regardless of our zip codes or our wardrobe sizes. I want to leave you with this thought. Let’s redefine abundance. Abundance isn’t just about what you have in your bank account. It’s about community. It’s about knowing you can lean on others when the weight gets too heavy. It’s about recognizing that resources are meant to circulate, not to be hoarded by those who appear to need them least. The system is broken, yes. But our hearts don’t have to be. We can choose compassion over judgment. We can choose connection over comparison. When I look back at that grocery store moment now, I don’t see shame. I see survival. I see a woman who refused to let pride starve her. I see a testament to the fact that we are more than our circumstances. More than our credit scores. More than the labels we are given. You are allowed to take up space. You are allowed to receive help. You are allowed to be imperfect. You are allowed to be tired. And you are certainly allowed to eat. Let that sink in. Let it settle deep in your bones. You are worthy of nourishment, not because of what you earn, but because you exist. Because you are breathing. Because you are here. And that is enough. It has always been enough. We just forgot to remind ourselves. So today, I invite you to forgive yourself for whatever you are carrying. For whatever you are lacking. For whatever you are afraid to admit. You are not alone. You are seen. And you are loved, exactly as you are. Thank you for letting me into your space today. Take a deep breath. Be gentle with yourself. Until next time, I’m Heidi Ashman. This has been Her Moment. Stay present.