Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 202:8-203:2
Transcript
- 0:01And this is on. Okay, morning, everyone, we are
- 0:07doing Hills, Broncos, raisch bet the broth of, okay, so if she
- 0:14responds early missions, hinder of God.
- 0:15But rather from now just quick, caveat, ideally my goal is that
- 0:24everyone should be able to read the show Hinata and no
- 0:27helicopter myself or Broca's and it Shouldn't be all that
- 0:31complicated when we're all done. Hopefully, I succeed.
- 0:36Because I think at the end of the day, if you just follow the
- 0:40few basic rules, it's not that complicated.
- 0:43It's more complicated. Is the Matthias.
- 0:47That's what sometimes gets more complicated especially with
- 0:50processed foods and then you need to know the process and
- 0:54what see covid tougher. Someone sent Moshe, Oscar sent a
- 0:58nice film on It's it's like yourself and Bamba, I did not
- 1:03listen to the whole thing but the put his the main point is
- 1:09that it's a special corn that's only used for Bamba.
- 1:12So that's why I might be heard AMA.
- 1:15But I did not finish listening and it really depends on the
- 1:17whole process and what's the E car and what to fell and Etc.
- 1:22So let's could I'd a listened and it's probably a gonna end up
- 1:26being a mclucas among the post game but I didn't finish
- 1:29reading. I will just bring it up right
- 1:34now because it comes up all the time right now.
- 1:40I'm going to give a quote, it's clear from the show kinara in
- 1:43general as we started reading, and from the Roma at the last
- 1:46couple lines on racial bet. We'll get there shortly.
- 1:51And and I know that's often not enough for anyone.
- 1:55So I'm going to read from the mission of Burgh.
- 1:58The eme whom is Super PAC. So High new a heart.
- 2:01This is the mission aboard and paid daleth the very end of race
- 2:05rabbit akarsha Lama in New York Oliveira.
- 2:09After you learn the cigarette and you get to an area where you
- 2:12can't really figure out, what the hell Outta is, it's unclear
- 2:19about Misha Lola mod. So that's going on the remote
- 2:23who says, once you learn to Surya and there's an area that's
- 2:27confusing, that's fine, go ahead and eat and say the bracha look
- 2:31up Kayla. That's the most common
- 2:33denominator so that you're safe, which is usually going to be
- 2:36Shackled, sometimes very Adama for the Holocaust that we're
- 2:39learning. Earning and this way, the hates
- 2:41is always covered, and that's no problem about Misha.
- 2:45Lola mod. The only time, it's a problem is
- 2:48if a person is lazy, so not learn the hella hoes and wants
- 2:52to remain completely ignorant. So then the gemara says, from
- 2:56broccoli slaw, Matt hey, Leo kolache allocates Oklahoma
- 2:59Lambda Broncos, then it's inappropriate to eat without
- 3:02asking the chacham. But once we learn the hollow
- 3:05Hood, it's pretty clear. Most of the time.
- 3:08What Brock are you make? Is clear and when it's not
- 3:12clear, there's two things that you do one is you follow the
- 3:15men. Hug what most people are doing
- 3:17or and it's often going to be two men hugging we're about to
- 3:20get to raspberries and you follow the minute and you don't
- 3:24worry about the broccoli. You always go after the Mars has
- 3:27many times took the COS a my Ahmad d'Ivoire what everyone's
- 3:30doing and that's like a pill that's the hello and you don't
- 3:33have to rethink it and worry about it or the other option is
- 3:38if it's really unclear and there's No clear minute.
- 3:40Then you generally go on the most common denominator.
- 3:46Again, if there's an area that I feel, feel free to reach out and
- 3:49let me know later to clarify. Okay, today we are at raisch
- 3:55bet. See if cut see you cut.
- 4:00The Bosch is I've met volume of our ecological, any liquid that
- 4:04comes out of a fruit, whether you choose has out or you
- 4:08squeeze it. A out the Broncos always shackle
- 4:12as the dinners a about Alma and that's always the broccoli.
- 4:15The only exceptions that we mentioned was grapes and olives,
- 4:21okay? LM asking you not see me calm in
- 4:23a parallel to any liquid any juice that comes out of a fruit.
- 4:26Could sneeze a team Veronica Maverick.
- 4:29Shaco that's the broccoli. That's what caused all
- 4:31established. It's called Z about Alma and
- 4:34it's not the main part of the fruit and that's okay.
- 4:40Tat. Jelly.
- 4:47Joey. So it depends if it's a new car.
- 4:51Think we mentioned this yesterday?
- 4:53Correct me if I'm wrong, if it's sneak are the fruit, then you
- 4:58would say the brachot of the fruit.
- 4:59If it's not in the car the I believe the fruit is the E car.
- 5:03Doesn't matter how much sugar you put in there and it doesn't
- 5:05go by majority. It goes by what the akari's
- 5:09sometimes? The majority defines.
- 5:11What the car is as we'll get there later.
- 5:13But so therefore, the gym Be proud.
- 5:18Be a mock Locker between this part of an Ashkenazi.
- 5:20Mm depends. If it's recognizable or not.
- 5:23Okay. And often it's going to be on
- 5:29bread or on amazonas, so then it's Plateau.
- 5:33Okay, now, Lamar screaming, okay, be right that.
- 5:35So Ted Sofia now him shame with Bosch leanly Olam, okay?
- 5:40So these are parts of the grapes that are never going to ripen.
- 5:43Okay? And I Lenovo gym tomorrow, I'm
- 5:45should be Psalms pharmakom the of shoe or you have that to
- 5:49Maryam that you they the much or how they get burnt or dried out.
- 5:55But we've Charcot Since the situation is you say shahada,
- 6:01cool. Anytime it's not the proper
- 6:03State, it's not the way that it's meant to be.
- 6:06It's meant to be eaten or it's meant to be grown and, okay?
- 6:11So that's simple principle. You would pay its nura, right?
- 6:17It depends. It's the case, is they're very
- 6:19dried out it, it's not normally eaten that way, right?
- 6:22That's not the way that it was the tree was intended to be
- 6:26made. If it's a Intended to, to be
- 6:28made that way, or both ways. Then for sure you would say,
- 6:33it's Good hero to share on OB shamayim Alpha patient.
- 6:40Has to. I'm a problem.
- 6:41I'm in a very short time. I'm Ella charcot.
- 6:44So here you cook. Fruit in water, right?
- 6:50Or you let them soak in there for days and then you want to
- 6:54have the liquid. So here, if you're having the
- 6:58fruit that's inside, most of us are familiar with compote or
- 7:02cooked fruits. So that's clearly hates.
- 7:05But here, we're going to see that again, but here, you're
- 7:08drinking just the liquid. So since you only have in the
- 7:11liquid and not the fruit itself, it becomes shackle Keep reading.
- 7:17The hruska tabs are such American stamp, Reba Miami
- 7:21various. Very predates.
- 7:23The rush held. It's not the halacha like
- 7:26Hillel. Is that since the flavor since
- 7:30you cook it and the flavor goes into the fruit, it becomes into
- 7:36the water. The flavor comes into the water.
- 7:38So they know the water takes on a portion of the fruit.
- 7:41And are you would say, I ate soooo on the fruit.
- 7:43So that's the opinion. It It's on the water.
- 7:47Thank you you would say needs and according to the rush.
- 7:50However that's not the hello, huh?
- 7:52However it is the helicopter David, in other words, if you
- 7:58said if I'm if you next to this water you also said hates on
- 8:05another fruit. Let's say at the same time and
- 8:07this water is in front of you and your and you knew you're
- 8:12going to be eating this this drinking.
- 8:16Water, since you said I ate and according to the Roche Goes On
- 8:21The Water, you would say Suffolk Rock Osaka.
- 8:24And you would if you drink it, you would not say abraha,
- 8:27because you already said, hey, it's ideally, you would find
- 8:30another Shackled to say to say it on.
- 8:33And again, I'll just throw it out there.
- 8:34Anytime you want to use a water, drink water to say, Shackled to
- 8:39Potter, another of Shaco it only works.
- 8:43If you're thirsty, you could. You can Use any other chacal,
- 8:47but you can't use water as a shackle to get you out of a
- 8:50Suffolk if you're not interested in drinking the water.
- 8:53Okay? You do Olive.
- 8:55But oh, and I just to point out something interesting, we're
- 8:58going to get to later if you take vegetables and you cook it
- 9:03in water and now you drink the water without the vegetables
- 9:07though, that soup is a dumber buy vegetables, is different
- 9:12than fruit. What's the difference?
- 9:14So the mission of work. Means there's really no
- 9:17difference. However, it's the minute of the
- 9:20mahkum that scovia for fruit. People don't grow the fruit to
- 9:25make soup. Usually it's meant normally to
- 9:28eat, you might make jam with it, might have comfort with it but
- 9:32you don't have it to make some kind of a liquid soup or a
- 9:36broth. So therefore that's the
- 9:39rationale for the shulkin Earth, if there would be a fruit.
- 9:42That's grown specifically, just to, or primarily to make soup.
- 9:46Soup. Then that would actually be a
- 9:48hates that liquid but by vegetables we know their
- 9:51vegetables are grown to make soup and therefore when you cook
- 9:55it together then the flavor of the vegetables goes into the
- 10:00liquid and that's what it's grown for.
- 10:02Its also grown to eat, but it's also grown specifically for both
- 10:06so therefore that's that's his distinction.
- 10:10Udall May Shreya tomoki. Mutiny among the shulam.
- 10:15The vertically I'm shocked. Oh, you would say gum LaRoche.
- 10:18So here you have a liquid water that's with.
- 10:23That's been soaking with, let's say raisins.
- 10:27So then Okay, so right now it's just soaking and raisins and
- 10:32they're all together in one cup or 11 jar.
- 10:35So then you say shahada cool. And this way, you're for sure
- 10:38covered. Okay, both opinions.
- 10:41Are we showing you how about brocco Sherlock?
- 10:43Her am usually stop it. But what broccoli do you make
- 10:47afterwards? Because since it's soaking in
- 10:49there, it's a McNugget, what Rocco one should make Shot,
- 10:54right? This is pick.
- 10:54This is followers yet. Because it takes in.
- 11:02So that's the opinion of the rush that it becomes, once it
- 11:07soaks or Cooks together. The Tom comes from the fruit and
- 11:11that goes in the water. So now they're fruit.
- 11:14The water gets the same bracha of the fruit.
- 11:16Tom kicker sort of above abraha she lock her away.
- 11:20Mmm, yeesh lease Topic in Mubarak Britannica Showtime of
- 11:23our rocket. In shallows garage, the problem
- 11:27is you don't know what bracha gonna do.
- 11:30And then we were in Chicago. Works on everything McDonald's
- 11:33works on everything but salt in water.
- 11:37But what do you do at a brothel Corona and the ain't shallows
- 11:40doesn't work on bringing a fascism Arena.
- 11:42Flashes does not work on Main challenge like hey you're a
- 11:46showman Louisa elevator has issued a are shamayim and this
- 11:50case was really going to be stuck if you have no fallback
- 11:54have no backup. So the best thing to do is only
- 11:57eat it in the middle of a pseudo.
- 12:00Yo, Kyle Prima Shiva. Meaning become mr.
- 12:02My or you say broccoli that needs an hour late and you say
- 12:05abraha that needs brain of Ashes, Kathy sheets directly,
- 12:09overhead Rocketman, shallow, subbarao a shot and then this
- 12:12way you get out of the Suffolk the eme mashina.
- 12:17This is different. Now.
- 12:18What happens? So that was if everything is in
- 12:21one container and you want to just to drink the water in this
- 12:25case is not so common but it's a good principle.
- 12:29So you have have the drink in a cup and you have the raisins
- 12:32with the water and you just want to drink the water, that's the
- 12:35scenario, because if you want to also eat the raisins, you would
- 12:38just say I ate sand, would be the water would be tougher.
- 12:41So that was that case. Now, what happens if you take
- 12:44the raisins out of the water, So let's read a moussaka,
- 12:49Miami-Dade alarm at Sea, became you pull out?
- 12:51The raisins, are you pour out the water?
- 12:55And now you're going to drink just the water.
- 12:56So the show economic rights. So in this case, have a guy in
- 13:00this is a case of wine because you can make wine from grapes
- 13:04and you can make wine from soaking, raisins and discussion
- 13:09one or three days, leave that for now obviously I'm a very
- 13:14elaborate for a given and then it's a full hug, a fan of Rock.
- 13:17Office mean shallows, who she is.
- 13:19Definitely a pretty girlfriend, Belushi hits him with Kim she
- 13:22ever have na, kahit. She need rocket on hates him and
- 13:26he's shot what kind of raisins can make potentially make wine
- 13:30only if the raisins still are not completely dried out.
- 13:34In other words, when we buy raisins, no good.
- 13:37It has to be raisins that. You can still get some kind of
- 13:41juice. When you squeeze out the
- 13:42reasons, I buy nothing comes out.
- 13:44I don't know about your reasons, but only be four raisins.
- 13:47That have some kind of liquid can still get squeezed out while
- 13:51they're dry before you soak them in water.
- 13:55About am Casey is rotem but all right when you try to squeeze
- 13:59them out later it's a ma'am shoom.
- 14:01Luckily trash but no liquid pours out, drips out low, that
- 14:07no longer could turn it into wine.
- 14:10Just side issue with are getting too complicated.
- 14:12Mike, look at acronym which number brings magazine around
- 14:15versus the majendie boram that it depends.
- 14:19Do you have to physically pull out the grapes or not?
- 14:23Not or it just yet, you made it on the dust to pull it out or it
- 14:28could be once. It's there three days, it
- 14:30doesn't matter. If you pull it out side
- 14:32discussion, not a very common case, okay?
- 14:37Your bet. Cole.
- 14:40Happy Rocha toven, I am a mousseline.
- 14:43So now any fruit that's edible and delicious when it's cooked
- 14:47or raw. It doesn't matter what you
- 14:50normally have, but as long as lots of people do it and it is
- 14:53the norm, you're going to topple him bug Asim apples.
- 14:58Pears Manheim, when we usually makes no difference, the various
- 15:02Beret Priya. It's, that's the broth over a,
- 15:05it's because that's what it's grown for.
- 15:06And that's what it's commonly used for the email and Eric
- 15:09local Hi, I'm Ella Mussolini, the only Derek is raw, sorry
- 15:14only cooked and aqua. I'm Keisha.
- 15:17Hey man. Hey man, you ate them when
- 15:18they're raw or vice versa. We'll see my very first shackle.
- 15:22You eat it, the wrong way. Then it's choco cashew, hey
- 15:26music, Lee and Brie periods, but if and if you have them when
- 15:30it's, if it's normally cooked and you eat uncooked, then it's
- 15:34hates because this fruit is normally if we're talking about
- 15:38a fruit that would normally not Not be eaten raw, so that's
- 15:44okay. Good Gilma Eggos government to
- 15:48come in to watch for nigra in. Do what Salome our New Year's
- 15:52Eve? Oracle of Rapier?
- 15:54It's, so again, this is talking about it not and it's normally
- 15:57eaten or normally eaten fried or roasted with oil.
- 16:05Okay, so this is all right, since that's the normal way.
- 16:08It's even then, that's the broccoli.
- 16:10You make very simple, you doll. It echoes rocks with washing,
- 16:14with Josh occurring on news, Scada Maverick.
- 16:18I love chocolate. So this is a soft Echoes.
- 16:21That is not normally eaten soft and therefore it's a shackle.
- 16:28And that's not there, you know, it wasn't grown to be eaten at
- 16:31this stage. It was okay when it's the
- 16:35mission where it says, it's better when it's small when it's
- 16:38soft and then it gets harder and it gets sweeter.
- 16:41So, it depends if it's the proper, if it's grown for this
- 16:46purpose, again, it's a simple rule.
- 16:48If it's grown for this purpose, you say the appropriate bracha
- 16:52and if it's not grown for this purse purpose, but you fix it
- 16:56like cooking. In it or adding stuff to it and
- 16:58it still stays stays chacal. Right?
- 17:06And therefore, it's not made for that.
- 17:11Yeah. Then of course, you'd make the
- 17:12bracha, whatever it's made for that, then you say it's for its
- 17:16highest brother. So the question is, Right
- 17:30Gershon, can you come here sooo many thing that we buy in the
- 17:33market is made? That.
- 17:34So it depends because sometimes you buy raw ingredients and it's
- 17:40used to be cooked or it's, and you're eating it raw.
- 17:45So it's, it depends. It depends how people use it.
- 17:49Basically, whatever is commercially sold.
- 17:53Obviously, it's it's intended to use like a chestnut, your
- 17:59losses, So chestnuts example, that's only eaten raw or roasted
- 18:08or cooked. But if you buy it in a package
- 18:15that's supposed to be eaten as is.
- 18:17So then, I think that's generally a every case by case,
- 18:21but that's going to be pretty much assumed, right, right.
- 18:29Okay. We are do the Haka in your doll,
- 18:34it with an automatic assumption choco.
- 18:39If it's not said, or not meant to be eaten while they're still
- 18:42green, but you made him ready since.
- 18:45That's not why it's grown. You say only shackle.
- 18:48Ted 12. I'll sugar Navarre chocolate.
- 19:00I'm assuming it's not normal, it's not grown for that purpose.
- 19:06That's not the main reason why it's growth Ted buff exact I'm
- 19:10sure there's going to be a borderline where it's like
- 19:12partially normal and okay then you follow them in ugh or you
- 19:17take the the shock order to be safe.
- 19:20Ted above all how sugar Mavericks chuckle Nebraska that
- 19:24we make on sugar is shocked over.
- 19:26Hate emotes, its cunning me to coach akal.
- 19:29Also, if you suck it from the cane, you would say, charcot now
- 19:32there is a Mac. Look at we shown him.
- 19:34It's a man who could do, it could be that the bracha is
- 19:37hates and because that's what it's made for.
- 19:39That's what the grows for the question is you call it a to do
- 19:42you call it? Say about Alma and it's a
- 19:45mockery shown him. The show cannot says to be safe.
- 19:48At least that's how the machine number represents.
- 19:50Syd. I did not look at it to base
- 19:51yourself on this one but the mission we represented, as he's
- 19:56doing, he's doing it to be safe to cover all bases.
- 19:58And therefore you say charcot, And therefore if someone says
- 20:03abraha hates or Adama on sugar, that had Fela, he shouldn't.
- 20:07But if he did keep eating your yard say, or find another
- 20:10Shackled to have, but you don't say new shahada.
- 20:13Once you already, okay, Ted's. I mean, I'll peel Bova Zhong
- 20:18feel, you've a shivalik love show, group lyrics little more
- 20:22negligible, coyote was ashamed of it in, with him, Klum, so if
- 20:29you have something that's not really Edible by itself.
- 20:34Maybe a little Peppers. Perhaps Black peppercorns, so my
- 20:41wife told me today. She once had one and that she
- 20:43was not a happy camper. So if it's something that's not
- 20:46normally edible or properly, edible, you don't even say a
- 20:50brothel on it whatsoever. But then once you make it ready,
- 20:54so it depends you going to say they're shocked.
- 20:57Allure Adama, or hates whatever it's appropriate.
- 21:00If that's how it's normally served or prepared.
- 21:04Yeah. So I think you go by, what's
- 21:15normal? That's a good question.
- 21:19I don't have a definite answer if a percentage of the community
- 21:23eats it and he's one of them then he would send that's
- 21:26normal. And that's one of the reasons
- 21:29why they're in the store are grown, then you would say, AIDS
- 21:32are Adama. So the person who wouldn't eat
- 21:41it, I think would say chacal. I don't have a, I don't know for
- 21:46sure if it's, you know, if it's 30 percent versus 70 percent,
- 21:56then there's a goal by the individual person.
- 21:59Probably Well, I know a lot of people eat hot peppers, so
- 22:09probably if that's normal, then they would, they would say their
- 22:11broccoli. We're going to get to a case
- 22:13like that momentarily on what, what what our shift has.
- 22:25She liscus. So, I'm talking world.
- 22:39Let's let's continue a little bit.
- 22:43What might be good? As also someone has wants to
- 22:46give a short list or just they have a random question on one,
- 22:49particular food or want to explain how it is.
- 22:53Maybe you could ask me afterwards, or put it on the
- 22:56Cobra group and what's up Hub or a group that would be good too.
- 23:01Right, your design but it's the principles that are crucial
- 23:06yields. I'm I Legos mushka great. 3/8
- 23:10Alcon, you can, you elaborate free Adama.
- 23:12So, again, these are foods. This is how they're normally
- 23:15eaten and therefore, they get their broccoli based on how
- 23:18they're normally eaten. If, if it's something that is
- 23:24You don't get normal Hannah the way they are then you're going
- 23:27to say shackle but if it's not normally eaten that way because
- 23:33you can't but you add sugar to it and then it becomes edible
- 23:36then because of the sugar you saved very pretty Adama for
- 23:40grows from the ground. In other words, Is that means
- 23:43inedible The Way It Is. By adding sugar, even though the
- 23:47sugar is doesn't become the car. It just it just the food itself
- 23:51is the car and you get that bra, the sugar only brings it up so
- 23:55that you could becomes edible. Okay?
- 23:59All right. Yeah, basically cannula is
- 24:07cinnamon. I believe cinnamon is hi-8.
- 24:14We could not Yeah, let's follow up on this but I'm pretty sure I
- 24:19believe cinnamon comes from a tree.
- 24:22It does come from. I know, it comes from a tree,
- 24:24and I believe cinnamon is hates because that's what it's for
- 24:33Right. So I had saw can't be cinnamon.
- 24:36Cinnamon does not grow on the ground.
- 24:38Cinnamon grows on a tree. It's the bark of a tree.
- 24:40It's very clear, right? So it's a tree.
- 24:48You mean on the bark itself? Interesting.
- 24:53Okay, so we have to look into that.
- 24:54I think it's a AIDs but someone says it's not a separate.
- 25:01I don't I don't think it matters.
- 25:06But he when he's describing something that grows on the
- 25:09ground. So that's a dumbass.
- 25:10So that's not what we're talking about it.
- 25:13So that's for sure. Camilla cannot be Haddam.
- 25:15According to the mishnah, Bora, that's a double push it
- 25:20Cinnamon, no, I know by itself but you can crush it and add
- 25:24some sugar and now it's edible. Okay.
- 25:28So it depends, if you call it a double.
- 25:30So your head, I'll peel bill was on vacation with tubing, very
- 25:36Adama, if it's eaten like that while it's well it's so moist
- 25:42fine. Then you say Adama okay, here we
- 25:44are. I got cool.
- 25:46A payroll Judea by him, shame ikarra Primavera.
- 25:48Carl, Liam were a prea. It's an important principle.
- 25:51Anytime, you know what the kicker Prius?
- 25:53That's hates which Noe Cara pre but there's it's not the occur.
- 25:57There's another Iker, right? Then you say Barry pre Adam In
- 26:02order not to be the car that has to be.
- 26:03It has to be an e-card, right? That has to be another fruit.
- 26:06That is the card, the Imam who mr.
- 26:09Park Bo Eun Hui, CarHop, real low.
- 26:12And if you're in doubt, if it's the ecar pre or not, then you
- 26:18say Burpee at the mud to be safe.
- 26:20We many a day of model and if you don't know what it is,
- 26:23they're very extra call. You say the brachot shackle.
- 26:27Okay, let's start this ratio. Most unique beer cuts.
- 26:31They wrote Our it's okay. Now we're back.
- 26:33Now, we're going down to the ground Olive.
- 26:35Oh, parents are somewhere appropriate.
- 26:36The money thing that grows from the ground.
- 26:38You say, very pre-adamite. But how to teamwork daily Miss
- 26:43neighbor pre Adama on bushes that grow on the ground.
- 26:47You say very predominant. So we're talking about really
- 26:50had AA, the low me create select remote, see Olive, uh-oh.
- 26:55So when is it called an AIDS? Is when you have leaves that
- 27:01come out from the 8 cm from the Tree of our Masha, Masha Allah,
- 27:06Masha. Blow me creates.
- 27:10The fact that it comes out of this short assume that are on
- 27:12the ground. That's not called tuna eights.
- 27:15You need to have a piece of wood and that stays there from year
- 27:20to year the honey cave on the colour eights up like a memory.
- 27:24But if you have something that the eights disappears from year
- 27:27to year it's not going to last it goes away but Clara we had
- 27:31our para me show. So you have the shore assume
- 27:34that remain there on the ground every year and doesn't have to
- 27:38last 100 years just has to laughs Last for more than a year
- 27:42for at least a cut to three seasons.
- 27:44I'm not sure, but it has to last a little bit.
- 27:46And then, but then if it shortish of is what lasts,
- 27:50there's a plant that stays on the ground forever.
- 27:53Let's say it's still only Mubarak and I love Beret, pre
- 27:56Adama. There's an order for it to be 8.
- 27:59It's the tree itself, the bark, the tree that are branches,
- 28:03perhaps that has to stay permanently, get nothing is
- 28:07permanent. So nothing has to last 25 years.
- 28:10But it does have to be there from year to year.
- 28:12Now, just there's lots of different books on the matter
- 28:17just to quote, from piske two of us.
- 28:18Perhaps but it's loved Africa for him and said it's obvious
- 28:22that there are certain things that we know don't last above
- 28:27whatever doesn't last above the ground on an AIDS, we're going
- 28:29to say Adama. So some obvious couple examples
- 28:33are pineapples strawberries by bananas.
- 28:39All those things are I had done had see, Liam eggplant papaya.
- 28:43Those are Adama. There are certain things which
- 28:47are a question. The raspberry we mentioned.
- 28:51The pie is a tri Pi is a problem he writes okay.
- 29:00And that's I don't understand is he right supplier as an Easter
- 29:04fire papayas on the tree that lasts from year to year.
- 29:07Okay. Okay so everyone here says, we
- 29:09have We have one, we've seen one, but pie it lasts from year
- 29:13to year and therefore you say, hey, it's okay.
- 29:18So raspberries are in its own category.
- 29:21Raspberries the, the main branch or the main trunk lasts for
- 29:26years, but it's the branches forget exactly what they're
- 29:30called canes or something. They have a special name in
- 29:33English, the branches, they give fruit for a year and then they
- 29:38fall off the branch that gives the raspberries.
- 29:42So there is a mock locate, I believe most say hi eights and I
- 29:46believe coming from America. I thought that was the custom
- 29:50but someone else Kagan says that the hug got Well, because of
- 29:57Bud, so he won't get there, but I think the shot of the mission
- 30:01of gura egress Moshe and shine Works a shine works, just a
- 30:05hi-8. And I'm not a time, but others
- 30:10show Mazama novela, she seemed to say Adama and basically, when
- 30:15it comes to raspberries, I would either say, follow your minute
- 30:18and both are correct starting from scratch.
- 30:24I don't know. Perhaps to be on the safe side
- 30:26and say Adama was to say, everybody.
- 30:32Used to say IA sunrise.