Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Job Posting Is Still Open
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, a listener named Priya wrote in with something that I think a lot of people have experienced but rarely talk about. She found her own job posting on LinkedIn — same title, same responsibilities, even the same team description — and it had a salary range that was about fifteen percent higher than what she's currently making. Luna: Oh, that is a gut punch. I'd be spiraling. Is she about to be replaced, or is the company just bad at taking down old listings? Lucas: Right, and the answer is: it could be either, but most of the time it's the latter. Companies are notoriously slow at removing postings, especially if they're using an automated system that reposts every thirty days. But here's the thing — even if it's a real opening, it might not be for her job. It could be a backfill for a different team, or a duplicate listing from a recruiter who's building a pipeline. Luna: Okay, so what's the first step? Does she confront her manager with a screenshot and demand an explanation? Lucas: No, absolutely not. Confrontation is the fastest way to blow this up. The first step is to do a little detective work. She should check the posting date, see if it's been reposted multiple times, and look at the specific wording. If it's an exact copy of her own job description, that's a red flag. But if it's slightly different — maybe a more junior title or a different location — it's probably not her seat. Luna: That makes sense. So she's gathering intel. But what about the salary range? That's the part that would bug me the most. Lucas: Yeah, and that's actually the most useful piece. Even if the posting is stale, the salary band is a data point. It suggests the company is willing to pay that range for the role — and she can use that in her raise conversation. But she needs to frame it carefully, not as an accusation but as a question about how her compensation aligns with the market. Luna: So the conversation is less 'Hey, I saw my job posted, what's going on?' and more 'I noticed the market rate for my role is X, and I'd like to discuss my compensation.' Lucas: Exactly. And she can mention that she saw a similar role advertised with a range, without specifying that it was her own job posting. That keeps it professional and focused on the value she brings, not on her anxieties. Luna: But what if her manager gets defensive and says something like, 'That posting is for a different team' or 'We're just keeping it up for future hiring'? Lucas: Then she can pivot to the broader point: 'I understand. I'm just thinking about my own growth and whether my compensation reflects my contributions and the market.' That way, she's not cornering them about the posting, but she's still putting the topic on the table. Luna: Okay, so it's a delicate dance. But is there any scenario where the posting really does mean they're planning to replace her? Lucas: It's possible, but it's rare. Usually, if a company wants to manage someone out, they don't advertise the role openly while the person is still there — that creates legal and cultural problems. More often, it's a sign of poor internal communication or a lazy recruiting process. However, if she's also been getting negative feedback or her projects are being reassigned, that's a different story. But on its own, a live posting isn't a death sentence. Luna: So what's the actual script? Give me the words. I want to know exactly what she should say when she books that meeting. Lucas: Alright, here's a version. She says: 'I've been reflecting on my role and the value I've added this year, especially with the product launch and the client retention work. I also noticed that similar roles in the market are posting salary ranges above my current band. I'd like to discuss how we can align my compensation with that market data.' Luna: That's good. It's confident, it's data-driven, and it doesn't mention the job posting directly. But what if her manager says, 'Well, that range is for a more senior person'? Lucas: Then she can ask, 'What would it take for me to be considered at that level?' That flips the conversation from a demand to a roadmap. It shows she's serious about growth and willing to work toward it. And she should document the response, because that gives her a clear target for the next six months. Luna: I love that. It turns a potentially awkward moment into a career development plan. So, let's zoom out. What's the broader lesson here for anyone who spots their own job listed online? Lucas: The lesson is: don't panic, don't assume the worst, and don't let it fester. Use it as a prompt to have a proactive conversation about your worth. And also, remember that job postings are often inaccurate — they might be for a role that's already been filled, or they might be a generic template that a recruiter reused. So gather your evidence, but keep your emotions in check. Luna: And if the posting really is for her exact job, what then? Should she start interviewing elsewhere? Lucas: That's the pragmatic move. If she has any suspicion that her role is at risk, the best insurance policy is a strong network and maybe some conversations with recruiters. But again, that's not the first step. The first step is to talk to her manager and give them the chance to clarify. Most managers aren't plotting against their direct reports — they're just overwhelmed. Luna: Speaking of managers being overwhelmed, I think a lot of listeners might relate to that. And you know, this show has helped so many people navigate these tricky conversations. If it's been useful to you, and you want to keep it ad-free, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Every little bit helps us keep doing this. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate it. It's what keeps the show independent and free for everyone. But back to Priya's situation — let's talk about timing. When should she actually have this conversation? Luna: Is there a best time? I feel like right after a big win is ideal. Lucas: Yes, that's spot on. If she just delivered a big project or got positive feedback, that's the moment to strike. It's also smart to schedule the conversation right before a performance review cycle, so the raise can be formalized. And she should avoid doing it when the company is in a panic, like during layoffs or a bad quarter. Luna: What if the manager says, 'The budget is frozen'? That's a classic response. Lucas: Then she can ask for a different kind of compensation — like a one-time bonus, more vacation days, or a title change that positions her for a raise later. But if the manager is consistently giving her the runaround, that's a signal that she might need to look elsewhere. But we've covered that in previous episodes. Luna: Right, we have. So, Priya should take a deep breath, do her research, and have the conversation with confidence. What's the one thing you want her to remember? Lucas: The posting isn't the problem — it's the conversation you're avoiding. The moment you see something like that, it's a wake-up call to advocate for yourself. Don't let it sit in the back of your mind and poison your work. Use it as fuel to have a constructive dialogue. Luna: And if that dialogue doesn't go well, at least you know where you stand. That's valuable information too. Lucas: Exactly. Sometimes the best outcome is clarity, even if it's not the raise you wanted. It lets you decide what's next with open eyes. So, Priya, and anyone else in this situation — take a breath, gather your facts, and go have that talk. You've got this.