Latest / Surrounded / Lila Rose vs 25 Pro-Abortion Activists
Transcript
- 0:00It does break my heart that if you're sharing you had an abortion,
- 0:03that there could be a child,
- 0:04I don't know how old they'd be,
- 0:0510 years old today,
- 0:06who would be cheering you on saying,
- 0:07go get him,
- 0:08Mom,
- 0:08you got this.
- 0:08I can promise you that would not be the case with
- 0:11your statistic and your information had a right to live.
- 0:13You don't get to speak for my child.
- 0:15You don't get to speak for my child.
- 0:18Let's start right there.
- 0:21From Jubilee Media,
- 0:22this is Surrounded,
- 0:23where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:26Let's get into it.
- 0:28Hey everybody,
- 0:28I'm Lyla Rose.
- 0:29I am the president and founder of Live Action.
- 0:32I am a mom of 3,
- 0:33a wife,
- 0:34and the host of the Lyla Rose podcast,
- 0:36and today I'm surrounded by 25 pro-choice activists.
- 0:43My first claim is abortion leaves women scarred for life.
- 0:53So,
- 0:53from my understanding is
- 0:55scar means permanent,
- 0:56and I would argue that life is permanent.
- 0:59And so by not allowing women
- 1:01to an abortion,
- 1:02you're basically saying
- 1:03you have to have this permanent
- 1:05being that exists in this world.
- 1:07Death is also permanent.
- 1:08And that's what a lot of women struggle with,
- 1:10especially on the anniversary of when that baby would have been born.
- 1:13For many women,
- 1:14again,
- 1:14I'm talking,
- 1:14I've talked to hundreds just personally,
- 1:15but there are thousands and millions more out there
- 1:18on the anniversary of when that baby would have been born,
- 1:201234 years old.
- 1:22There's deep regret and pain,
- 1:23and some
- 1:24struggle with mental illness afterwards or other struggles,
- 1:26or they have fertility issues.
- 1:28There have been several studies done that show that women have
- 1:30higher suicidality who have abortions and that women that give birth.
- 1:34There's a California study which is 200,000 Medicaid patients,
- 1:38150% more likely to commit suicide if they had had an abortion
- 1:43than if they had given birth,
- 1:44right?
- 1:45So I think,
- 1:45so what do you think about that?
- 1:46So I have that I can be.
- 1:48I also want to talk about the fact that I
- 1:50My understanding is you did go undercover into Planned Parenthood,
- 1:53and I have many friends that work at Planned Parenthoods,
- 1:55which honestly,
- 1:55I'd,
- 1:56I'd feel a little unsafe if someone was like going undercover to mask something.
- 1:59Do you also,
- 2:00the other thing is women,
- 2:01women abortion clinics.
- 2:02Oh,
- 2:02hold on,
- 2:03hold on a minute.
- 2:03I think women,
- 2:04abortion is not an easy choice for women.
- 2:06I don't go,
- 2:07oh,
- 2:07you know what,
- 2:07what do I want to do today?
- 2:08So go see a movie or have an abortion?
- 2:11It's not an easy
- 2:12choice.
- 2:12Like,
- 2:12why is abortion not an easy choice?
- 2:14It's not easy for any woman.
- 2:15Why?
- 2:15Why?
- 2:16Because you are literally deciding your own future.
- 2:20On your own terms and you're allowing women the choice.
- 2:22And,
- 2:22and why is that,
- 2:24why is that decision so,
- 2:25so heavy?
- 2:25For example,
- 2:25I could go in,
- 2:26the decisions,
- 2:27I could go in and get a wisdom tooth removed,
- 2:30and I'm not going to an elective like I'm
- 2:32not gonna have this heavy decision around it.
- 2:34Why is abortion such a uniquely heavy decision?
- 2:36Why are women the only ones it's having to
- 2:38choose these and were shamed instead of men,
- 2:41because the men who are committing acts of assault.
- 2:43Let's see,
- 2:44I don't think they're father of the year,
- 2:45quite frankly.
- 2:46If they're committing acts of violence,
- 2:48we are in total agreement on that.
- 2:49We're in total agreement.
- 2:50OK,
- 2:50you're a mother.
- 2:51How many adopted children do you have?
- 2:52I don't have any adoption.
- 2:53OK,
- 2:53so what about all the children to adopt?
- 2:55OK,
- 2:55so great.
- 2:56Let's call up the agency tomorrow.
- 2:57It'll take a couple years to go through the adoption process.
- 2:59Well,
- 2:59leading children in foster care,
- 3:01are you into the system?
- 3:02Are you aware thus affects them and causes a guard against the woman.
- 3:05There are 2 million families.
- 3:07There are 2 million.
- 3:07Families who would like to adopt a newborn baby,
- 3:09and they can't.
- 3:10OK,
- 3:10are you helping them?
- 3:11Because if you're providing resources,
- 3:12we do promote and help them,
- 3:13but you know what,
- 3:14you know the reason why they can't adopt,
- 3:16the reason they're not able to adopt is because we have a million abortions a year.
- 3:20Our country kills children.
- 3:22If there were a million abortion abortions,
- 3:24I would say that a scarring exists,
- 3:25and those are all legal abortions,
- 3:27to be clear,
- 3:27those a million abortions a year are all being Catholic,
- 3:30right?
- 3:30Are you not going to feel Catholic?
- 3:31Guilt when all the women are dying in parking lots from illegal abortions.
- 3:35So
- 3:35I,
- 3:36people,
- 3:36women are dying right now from legal abortions.
- 3:38Women who take the abortion pill,
- 3:4030,000 of them are going into the emergency room every year because of the abortion.
- 3:43The legal abortions are now in fear of.
- 3:45The media is lying to you guys.
- 3:46The media is lying to you guys because legal abortion kills women.
- 3:50It killed Tanya Reeves and a Chicago Planned Parenthood.
- 3:52I have a lot of friends who had abortions.
- 3:53They're lying.
- 3:54I was talking to them yesterday.
- 3:55They're pretty,
- 3:55they're pretty.
- 3:56Chill,
- 3:56they're actually really great.
- 3:56They're in therapy because they made that choice to
- 3:59have children when they are ready to have children.
- 4:01There's tens of thousands of women who go
- 4:03to emergency rooms because of the abortion pill.
- 4:05There are dozens of women who die from if they have safe access in education,
- 4:07sex education early on.
- 4:10Those were women and legal abortions that they were having men
- 4:13and women would have access to education to understand sex.
- 4:17You've voted out by the majority.
- 4:18Thank you.
- 4:19Nice to meet you.
- 4:21Mhm
- 4:28So I just wanna like clear it up,
- 4:30but when you say scarring for life,
- 4:31like what do you mean?
- 4:33I mean it leaves at minimum emotional wounds on
- 4:36many women and some of them physical wounds.
- 4:39I think
- 4:40something to like focus on is like the emotional part.
- 4:43It's the shame that you get from pro-life activists.
- 4:46I know what it's like to go to Planned Parenthood and walk out and then see
- 4:50people protesting,
- 4:52calling
- 4:52the women murderers,
- 4:54chanting religious prayers at them.
- 4:55I think that's what's
- 4:57the scarring part emotionally.
- 4:59So I've had the privilege of interviewing now almost
- 5:011000 women who've had abortions and hearing their stories,
- 5:05and many of them share about how everyone.
- 5:07told them it was the right thing to do,
- 5:08that no one had,
- 5:09there was nobody opposing it,
- 5:10and they had the abortion,
- 5:12and then,
- 5:13and then years later,
- 5:15and this is their story,
- 5:16and then years later they would say focusing on people,
- 5:18well,
- 5:18this is their story,
- 5:19not mine,
- 5:19and they would tell me,
- 5:20and they would report about how after
- 5:23their abortion,
- 5:23sometimes it would be years later,
- 5:25they would remember it and they would say,
- 5:27what about the I wish I had never done that
- 5:29don't regret or they would face mental health challenges,
- 5:32they'd face addiction,
- 5:33some of them would face infertility.
- 5:35Interviewing the people who don't regret it,
- 5:37who think that their life would have been
- 5:39worse off if they
- 5:41didn't get the abortion.
- 5:41So I think if what you're saying is there's some women who don't regret it,
- 5:44I think it's absolutely true.
- 5:45There are some women who would maybe sit right here and say,
- 5:47I had an abortion.
- 5:48I don't regret it at all.
- 5:49It was great.
- 5:50But I,
- 5:51that doesn't mean that abortion isn't leaving women scarred for life because it is.
- 5:54Well,
- 5:54you're,
- 5:56those stories usually aren't all,
- 5:57those stories aren't usually made or told by
- 6:00typical media groups.
- 6:01Usually in media and in the entertainment world,
- 6:03you hear the stories of the women that are saying,
- 6:05Abortion is great,
- 6:06it empowers me.
- 6:07There are thousands and thousands of
- 6:08women who experienced bitter abortion regret.
- 6:12And then there's also women can have abortions,
- 6:14and
- 6:15they want to have
- 6:16kids
- 6:17in the future,
- 6:17but they know that they're not in the position for it right then and now,
- 6:20so they can
- 6:21have guilt,
- 6:22they can feel sorry,
- 6:23but that's not all women,
- 6:24and that's totally valid.
- 6:26I think there's a stigma today,
- 6:27if I may,
- 6:28I think there's a stigma today on a lot
- 6:29of women that they can't share their abortion regret,
- 6:32because society's telling them that abortion's your right,
- 6:34it's empowering.
- 6:35It's a reproductive freedom.
- 6:36And so if you have abortion regret,
- 6:37there's not really a space to share that stigma.
- 6:40You're feeding into the harmful narrative.
- 6:41What harmful narrative?
- 6:42That women are getting abortions and then
- 6:45that they
- 6:46shouldn't feel regret about it because they're murderers and
- 6:49that they should own up to their actions.
- 6:50That's what the pro-life people are arguing.
- 6:53I think what our narrative,
- 6:55if you want to call it that,
- 6:55is to say this is a human life,
- 6:57the science tells us this.
- 6:58It's always wrong to take a human life,
- 7:01and abortion does leave deep scars on a lot of women.
- 7:03Thank you.
- 7:11OK,
- 7:12so when you say that abortion leaves women scarred for life,
- 7:15I have had an abortion before.
- 7:16I had an abortion actually a week before my 21st birthday.
- 7:19I'm a young black woman in America,
- 7:20come from a low income family.
- 7:22I'm also adopted.
- 7:23How do you feel about your abortion?
- 7:25How do I feel about my abortion?
- 7:25That's what I'm about to tell you.
- 7:27So,
- 7:27um,
- 7:28I wouldn't want to have to make
- 7:31the decisions of
- 7:33what's next
- 7:34after a child is born.
- 7:36I personally did not feel like I was in the proper mental state,
- 7:39financial state,
- 7:40emotional state,
- 7:41physical state.
- 7:42I did not feel like I was in the best of any of those states to be able to bear a child,
- 7:45to be a parent,
- 7:46exactly.
- 7:47My circumstance was a little bit different with the father of would have been child.
- 7:51He actually wanted me to keep the child,
- 7:53but I chose not to because of my body.
- 7:55Did you,
- 7:56I'm curious if you considered adoption.
- 7:57I absolutely did,
- 7:58but like I said,
- 7:59based on my testimony and what I've experienced,
- 8:01I grew up in a home with foster children in and out.
- 8:04I have an adopted brother as well.
- 8:05We're 2 years apart.
- 8:06Um,
- 8:07during my foster stay at my home,
- 8:09which is now my lifelong home that I've been at.
- 8:11I've seen all different kinds of circumstances.
- 8:13I've seen babies having withdrawals.
- 8:14I've seen babies who come from rape victims.
- 8:16I've seen all of it.
- 8:18I've seen all of it,
- 8:18you name it.
- 8:19It's not
- 8:21the best environment that I,
- 8:22in my opinion,
- 8:23that I would want to raise a child in,
- 8:24OK?
- 8:24I have friends who have multiple children and they're struggling
- 8:27because they don't have the resources that they need.
- 8:29They don't have the proper support system that they need.
- 8:31The whole thing about this pro-life and pro-choice,
- 8:34it's not
- 8:35I'm choosing to
- 8:37Kill this baby.
- 8:38Pro-choice is
- 8:39the choice of what I want to do with my body,
- 8:41not what you think I should do with my body.
- 8:43Wait,
- 8:43I'm not done yet.
- 8:44So,
- 8:45um,
- 8:45anyways,
- 8:46what I wanna do with my body,
- 8:48who are you to judge me?
- 8:49I go to church.
- 8:50I,
- 8:50I'm actually a new member of the church,
- 8:51which is,
- 8:52which is funny.
- 8:52I didn't believe in God a couple of years ago.
- 8:54That's great that you're going to church.
- 8:55Thank you.
- 8:56And you know,
- 8:56the decision that I made maybe wasn't the thing that I
- 8:59100% wanted to do.
- 9:01It was definitely something?
- 9:02Did you feel pressured to have the abortion?
- 9:03No,
- 9:03absolutely not,
- 9:04because everybody around me was in support of whatever I did,
- 9:07especially my mother and especially the father of the child.
- 9:09But I didn't feel pressured at all.
- 9:11In fact,
- 9:11I felt as if it was harder to make the decision
- 9:14based on how I'm going to feel.
- 9:16Exactly.
- 9:17And as you're saying,
- 9:17women are scarred from this.
- 9:19I don't feel.
- 9:20Scarred.
- 9:20I definitely have an effect from it,
- 9:21but I don't think that saying
- 9:23this
- 9:24procedure scars women for life because you don't
- 9:26know what I'm going through up here.
- 9:28Absolutely not.
- 9:28I don't care who you are,
- 9:30what you stand for,
- 9:31what organization you're behind.
- 9:32I'd not to respond to what you're get to judge me.
- 9:34I'd love to respond.
- 9:34The flags are going up and I'd love to respond before you go,
- 9:37um,
- 9:37but you know,
- 9:37like I,
- 9:38my whole point is you have absolutely no idea what people go through.
- 9:41So I understand you're experiencing and you're telling me your experience,
- 9:44which is important.
- 9:45Everybody's experience is important.
- 9:46A lot of the women that I've had the privilege of talking to,
- 9:49their abortion wasn't.
- 9:50Yesterday,
- 9:50their abortion was a couple of years ago,
- 9:515 years ago,
- 9:5210 years ago.
- 9:53As you get older,
- 9:53you get more established in your life.
- 9:54You're a young woman,
- 9:55and I'm not saying that
- 9:56that's let me just finish here.
- 9:57Let me.
- 9:58Well,
- 9:58that's the,
- 9:58that's the key,
- 9:59right?
- 9:59Because we make big decisions,
- 10:01right?
- 10:01Especially when we're young,
- 10:02we can make big decisions.
- 10:03They have an effect down the line.
- 10:04And so my advocacy is saying this is a big decision.
- 10:07This is a human,
- 10:08but is it your right to make the decision for me or to say what decision is right?
- 10:11Because God's the only one that can actually judge me and based on my beliefs,
- 10:14it's not my right to tell you,
- 10:16it's not my right to tell you what to do with your personal life,
- 10:19but it is the.
- 10:20Government's responsibility to protect the right to life of
- 10:23every life in this country with what you're saying.
- 10:24Do you want the government to protect you from being killed?
- 10:26You know,
- 10:27I want,
- 10:27you want the government I want God to protect me from everything evil in this world.
- 10:30Absolutely.
- 10:30Do you want,
- 10:31do you think you have a,
- 10:32I can't guarantee that.
- 10:33I can't guarantee that I'm not going to walk out this door and get shot in the head.
- 10:35But do you think if someone,
- 10:36do you think that if somebody tries to do that,
- 10:38you would hope someone would intervene?
- 10:39Honestly,
- 10:40I'm just going to pray for the best.
- 10:41Well,
- 10:42I would hope someone would intervene,
- 10:43and I want to live in a country where I don't think there would be a
- 10:45penalty for that person that might wanted somebody
- 10:47to intervene with the protection of life.
- 10:50You would be
- 10:51kind of,
- 10:52you know,
- 10:52getting more background on these,
- 10:53on these women and why they do the things that they do.
- 10:56Well,
- 10:56I think I'll,
- 10:56yeah,
- 10:57thank you.
- 10:57Nice to meet you.
- 10:58You too.
- 10:58Thank you.
- 11:05OK,
- 11:06so do you know the number one emotion,
- 11:08um women get after having an abortion is relief?
- 11:12Are you,
- 11:12are you referring to the turnaway study with that information?
- 11:15OK,
- 11:16so the turnaway study has been heavily debunked because it's done by
- 11:21those that support abortion.
- 11:21And they said they were going to follow 1000 women to
- 11:23see if there was an abortion regret after their abortions.
- 11:26Only 150 women would complete the study with them.
- 11:29The rest of them dropped off,
- 11:30some of them struggling with issues may be connected to that abortion,
- 11:33but only 150 completed it.
- 11:35So that's a survey of only 150 women.
- 11:38And again,
- 11:39I think we need to look at women at large and their experiences,
- 11:42and there will be some women who say,
- 11:43Well,
- 11:44I feel great.
- 11:44I'm good.
- 11:45This is good.
- 11:45I don't regret it.
- 11:46And then there's a lot of women whose stories aren't being told.
- 11:49But you don't look at women at deep with their experiences.
- 11:52That's what,
- 11:52that's what we do.
- 11:53And those women deeply regret their abortions.
- 11:55They feel scarred by their abortions.
- 11:57Some of them suffer mental health issues afterwards.
- 11:59That's not true at all.
- 12:0095% of people who got abortions said it was the right decision.
- 12:03You're referring to the Turnerway study,
- 12:05which is only following.
- 12:06You could search that up.
- 12:08It's better to look at a study like the Medicaid study in California.
- 12:10200,000 women,
- 12:13not 150 women doing a study with a pro-abortion group.
- 12:15It was a California 200,000 survey of women.
- 12:18Of those that had abortions,
- 12:20they were 150% more likely to commit suicide than
- 12:23those that gave birth and did not have abortions.
- 12:25In Finland,
- 12:26there were two studies done of women there that found that
- 12:28women who had abortions had a higher likelihood of committing suicide
- 12:32than women who did not have abortions.
- 12:34People deserve to know this.
- 12:35Women deserve to know this because when they have an Abortion,
- 12:37that's a huge life altering decision,
- 12:39not just for ending the life of a baby,
- 12:41but it's life altering for the woman.
- 12:43It is life altering for the woman because,
- 12:45you know,
- 12:45pregnancy is a big deal.
- 12:46Having a baby is a big deal,
- 12:47having a baby is very,
- 12:49very expensive.
- 12:49And if you're willing to put
- 12:51survivors,
- 12:52children on top of that,
- 12:54and the shame that they have to go through,
- 12:56forcing an 11 year old to go through a pregnancy,
- 12:58and yes,
- 12:59they're not forced to be a parent,
- 13:01but the adoptive and foster care systems are very,
- 13:04very broken my friend Liana Rebelao,
- 13:05she was.
- 13:07Brutally in a gang by age 12.
- 13:10She went to the doctor,
- 13:11she found out she was pregnant.
- 13:12She had severe mental health issues,
- 13:13suicidality from the trauma of the,
- 13:15right?
- 13:16She goes to the doctor,
- 13:16the doctor says,
- 13:17you're pregnant,
- 13:17and the doctor says,
- 13:18Do you want an abortion?
- 13:20And she says,
- 13:20will the abortion take away
- 13:22the trauma of that,
- 13:24the,
- 13:24the,
- 13:25the horror I feel in my body,
- 13:27but the doctor said.
- 13:28Just finish what she said,
- 13:29and the doctor said,
- 13:29no,
- 13:29it will not.
- 13:30He was honest with her,
- 13:31and she said,
- 13:32Why would I
- 13:33take the life of this baby
- 13:36because of the trauma that I.
- 13:38Not everybody,
- 13:39not everybody will.
- 13:39It's a belief,
- 13:40but it's also a fact that it was a human being inside her.
- 13:42It was an innocent third party because of that.
- 13:44So that was perpetrated upon her.
- 13:47Thank you.
- 13:48Nice to meet you.
- 13:57So
- 13:59based off,
- 14:00you've given incredible points,
- 14:01genuinely and truly,
- 14:02I'm learning quite a bit.
- 14:03Thank you.
- 14:04So for the people that you say have the abortion young,
- 14:07how old do I look out of curiosity?
- 14:09Hmm.
- 14:10You're never supposed to answer that,
- 14:12right?
- 14:12No,
- 14:12go ahead.
- 14:13By all means.
- 14:13Will you tell me you'll do me if I do you?
- 14:15Yeah,
- 14:15OK.
- 14:16All right,
- 14:16you are 25.
- 14:17I appreciate that.
- 14:18At about 10 more years.
- 14:19So
- 14:20by your awesome.
- 14:20Thank you.
- 14:21You look amazing.
- 14:21By your logic,
- 14:22I should be
- 14:23in that age range of people who abort,
- 14:26let's say,
- 14:27you know,
- 14:27who,
- 14:27who should be feeling the regret and everything.
- 14:30If I had carried a term,
- 14:31I would be labeled a drug addicted black mother,
- 14:33and if I had kept the baby,
- 14:34I would have been labeled an
- 14:36incompetent single mother.
- 14:39So my question for you is,
- 14:41what is
- 14:42your perception of how I should feel about my abortion?
- 14:45So,
- 14:46a couple things.
- 14:46First of all,
- 14:47sometimes a regret happens later in life.
- 14:49It's not within even 5 or 10 years that trauma they feel might
- 14:52come out later when they have their own other children or grandchildren.
- 14:55So every woman,
- 14:56it's going to be different.
- 14:57Sometimes it's immediate,
- 14:58sometimes it takes years.
- 15:00I mean,
- 15:00I think,
- 15:01I think you're amazing.
- 15:02I think if that's what you've overcome in your life,
- 15:03I think that's incredible,
- 15:05and you should be proud of.
- 15:06Overcoming so many tough things in your life.
- 15:09It does break my heart that if you're sharing you had an abortion,
- 15:11that there could be a child,
- 15:13I don't know how old they'd be,
- 15:1310 years old today,
- 15:14who would be cheering you on saying,
- 15:16go get him,
- 15:16Mom.
- 15:16You got this.
- 15:17I can promise you that would not be the case because
- 15:20I can almost promise you that would not be the case,
- 15:22because I say again,
- 15:23I'm in a domestic violence shelter.
- 15:25I've got a dog.
- 15:26I can barely take care of.
- 15:27You're expecting excuse me,
- 15:29you're expecting me to sit here
- 15:31and let you tell me how I'm supposed to feel.
- 15:34You're trying to.
- 15:34Scare me.
- 15:35I'm not telling you how to feel.
- 15:36Yes,
- 15:36you are.
- 15:37Yes,
- 15:37I'm not telling you how to feel with your statistics,
- 15:38but I am telling you that your baby,
- 15:39your statistics and your information with your statistic
- 15:43and your information had a right to live.
- 15:45You are completely wrong because,
- 15:46yes,
- 15:46and I wish someone had been helping you more.
- 15:47Listen,
- 15:48that's the other thing.
- 15:48Listen,
- 15:48but you deserve more help.
- 15:50Everybody always likes to say,
- 15:51oh,
- 15:51keep the baby,
- 15:52give it up for adoption.
- 15:53I know what our foster care system is like.
- 15:55But,
- 15:55but when you,
- 15:55you can't tell me I would have a child cheering
- 15:57me on and when you place a child for adoption,
- 16:00hold on,
- 16:00you're not don't go into foster care.
- 16:01You don't get to speak for my.
- 16:02Child,
- 16:03you don't get to speak for my child.
- 16:05Let's start right there.
- 16:07You don't get to speak for my child saying,
- 16:08oh,
- 16:08mommy would be cheering you on and everything like that.
- 16:10You don't know that.
- 16:11You don't know that at all.
- 16:12You don't know what my child would be.
- 16:13I,
- 16:14I may not even have my child
- 16:16because I was so unfit at the time.
- 16:17Drug addiction,
- 16:18sex work,
- 16:19everything like that.
- 16:19Yes,
- 16:20I,
- 16:20I'm a proud pro ho.
- 16:21That is exactly what I do.
- 16:23But you're telling me
- 16:24how my child would feel
- 16:26and what gives you the right,
- 16:27what gives you the right,
- 16:29what gives you the right.
- 16:30Right,
- 16:31I would love to respond to you.
- 16:32I would love to respond to you.
- 16:33I think,
- 16:34yes,
- 16:34your,
- 16:34your child had a right to life,
- 16:36and I would say that there are,
- 16:37I wish there were more people helping you at the time.
- 16:39It sounds like you were at a really rough time in your life,
- 16:42and I think that you mattered,
- 16:43that baby mattered,
- 16:44and you both deserved more help.
- 16:46That's what I would say.
- 16:47That's what you would say.
- 16:48But you're saying my child would be cheering me
- 16:50on right now that if you chose to parish,
- 16:52and you said you would hope,
- 16:53I would hope you would hope.
- 16:54So all of this is going off of hope.
- 16:57Please return to your seat.
- 16:58You too.
- 17:08So,
- 17:08I just want to start off,
- 17:10and you're saying that a lot of women have abortion regret,
- 17:13right?
- 17:14So,
- 17:14I'm gonna tell you about what happened to my best friend's mom.
- 17:17She had a late-term abortion,
- 17:18which I know you
- 17:20don't find morally acceptable,
- 17:22but how far along was she?
- 17:24I'm not sure of the exact week,
- 17:26but she was told that her child would not live for more than one hour.
- 17:30However,
- 17:31if she gave birth to that child,
- 17:33she would never be able to have children again.
- 17:35That is literally what they told her.
- 17:37I'm so glad that she was able to get
- 17:38an abortion because my best friend wouldn't be alive
- 17:41if her mother wasn't able to have an abortion before she was even born.
- 17:46So I just like,
- 17:47Yeah,
- 17:47there are some women
- 17:49who regret abortions,
- 17:50but we shouldn't just ban all abortions because
- 17:53of some of those women regretting it.
- 17:54So there are many women,
- 17:55I'd love to respond.
- 17:56I've heard so many stories of medical professionals who tell the woman,
- 18:00you have to have an abortion X,
- 18:01Y,
- 18:01and Z is their opinion,
- 18:02right?
- 18:03And then I talked to many other,
- 18:05and I talked to many other medical professionals,
- 18:07if I can finish,
- 18:08I talked to many other medical professionals who say
- 18:10if you have a high risk pregnancy or there's a disability that the baby has,
- 18:13there is healthcare for you to protect both your life and the baby's life.
- 18:17That's what women deserve.
- 18:18They don't deserve to be told by the abortionist or the doctor,
- 18:21just kill this baby,
- 18:21that's the solution,
- 18:22have the abortion.
- 18:23So we can do better for both the mom and the baby.
- 18:26Dr.
- 18:26Anthony,
- 18:26just,
- 18:27just as an example,
- 18:27Dr.
- 18:28Anthony Levitino.
- 18:29He worked with
- 18:30tens of thousands of high-risk pregnancies in upperstate New
- 18:33York dealing with these very high risk pregnancies.
- 18:35He said in the in the number of pregnancies where we had to do an abortion
- 18:39was 0.
- 18:40Sometimes we would have to do an early delivery,
- 18:42but we would never have to intentionally kill the baby
- 18:45to deal with the health risks for the mother.
- 18:47So,
- 18:48so,
- 18:48correct.
- 18:48And so as an example,
- 18:49your friend,
- 18:50right,
- 18:50you said she had a late-term abortion because her baby had a health issue
- 18:53and was going to die and And otherwise she would have an issue.
- 18:56The doctor and my,
- 18:58you know,
- 18:58Dr.
- 18:58Anthony Levitino as an example,
- 19:00could have done an early delivery to give that baby a chance at life instead of
- 19:04intentionally killing that baby
- 19:05in I don't understand,
- 19:06which is what an abortion here across the table.
- 19:08There are thousands of medical professionals who fight for
- 19:11both the life of the baby and the mother.
- 19:12Tell me what my best friend's mother could have had done to her.
- 19:15She deserved better medical care.
- 19:17She deserved better medical care than what she was told that it was unfair and wrong.
- 19:20She was told
- 19:21she wasn't given a choice.
- 19:23She was given a,
- 19:23they told her,
- 19:24you're going to die.
- 19:25They told her,
- 19:25you,
- 19:26you have to have this abortion.
- 19:27That's what they told her.
- 19:30She deserve.
- 19:30She cannot deliver children if she had not had that abortion.
- 19:32Did you know?
- 19:33So why do you think that she should have,
- 19:35just to be clear,
- 19:36in a late-term abortion,
- 19:37you have to remove the baby,
- 19:38right?
- 19:39And
- 19:40what is the difference between a late-term abortion where you remove the baby dead
- 19:43and an early delivery where you can remove the baby alive?
- 19:47One is an abortion
- 19:49and one is a life saving act.
- 19:50What she deserved was a life saving act for both her and that baby,
- 19:53and an early delivery could have been what she did.
- 19:55I agree,
- 19:55because she wanted that child and that's why
- 19:57it's devastating that they told her that.
- 19:59It's wrong that they told her that.
- 20:00No,
- 20:00but they were right.
- 20:01No,
- 20:02how,
- 20:02how can you say that when they're
- 20:04Because I know that,
- 20:05there's thousands of medical professionals who say
- 20:07that abortion is not medically necessary.
- 20:09It's not my opinion,
- 20:10it's thousands of medical professionals who say that.
- 20:13I appreciate that,
- 20:14but you're not a doctor and you weren't her doctor.
- 20:15There's thousands of medical professionals who say you
- 20:17can care for both mother and baby,
- 20:19but it's,
- 20:20you
- 20:22can doctors be wrong?
- 20:24Doctors.
- 20:26Could her doctor have been wrong?
- 20:30My next claim is abortion cannot be justified under any circumstance.
- 20:39So a couple of things.
- 20:39First,
- 20:40uh,
- 20:40correct me if I'm wrong,
- 20:41I'm gonna make a lot of assumptions about your organization.
- 20:43I don't know the specifics,
- 20:44but when you say alternatives to abortion,
- 20:46I assume that you're saying philanthropic
- 20:49assistance when it comes to helping people with pregnancy or start families.
- 20:52Is that true?
- 20:53promoting options that are not killing the baby,
- 20:55basically.
- 20:56So,
- 20:57that could be without that moral language,
- 20:59I do adopting the baby,
- 21:00yeah,
- 21:00and I think that's valuable to a lot of people,
- 21:02especially if they don't have the economic means in order to start a family.
- 21:05So I want to commend you on that.
- 21:06When it comes to the policy proposals that you propagate as an organization,
- 21:10I would say that those don't help anybody,
- 21:12especially when it comes to just adding punitive measures.
- 21:14Are you familiar with our policy proposals?
- 21:16Because we,
- 21:16we support making birth free.
- 21:18Do you support making birth free?
- 21:20Yeah,
- 21:20I think we
- 21:22we support more cash credits for families who have kids so that they can
- 21:26invest back into their families and take care of,
- 21:27better take care of their kids.
- 21:28So part of what we do on the public policy side,
- 21:30it's smaller than our educational efforts is.
- 21:33All of the policies,
- 21:34then I'll specifically criticize the ones
- 21:36that are punitive measures against women
- 21:37or against doctors who are facilitating this type of reproductive health care.
- 21:41That's not something that's going to help people unfortunately,
- 21:43and I'm assuming that there's,
- 21:45there's a lot of ideological similarities with
- 21:46a lot of other conservative movements.
- 21:48So when it comes to things like gun rights,
- 21:50what I hear so much from conservatives are
- 21:52guns are something that's a necessary evil.
- 21:54If there was a world where we could get rid of all guns,
- 21:56that would be awesome.
- 21:57It's just one thing where there are going to be bad people with guns,
- 22:00and
- 22:01In order to counteract that,
- 22:02you're going to need good people with guns.
- 22:03And I would say the same thing for abortion.
- 22:05I think in,
- 22:05in an ideal world,
- 22:06we wouldn't have any abortions.
- 22:08Unfortunately,
- 22:08the reality of the situation is it's going to exist,
- 22:10whether or not that it's legal and can't have safe
- 22:13actual procedures,
- 22:14or it's going to happen in the alleyways where It is going to damage women.
- 22:17And so to continue to advocate for punitive measures,
- 22:19and I'll let you speak after this,
- 22:21I think that that does more harm to women at large
- 22:23than it does to help protect the unborn life.
- 22:26Here's a question for you.
- 22:27Do you think that
- 22:28it is always wrong to kill an innocent person,
- 22:30an innocent human?
- 22:31I would say the intentional killing of somebody who's
- 22:34innocent is something that we should advocate against.
- 22:36What I will say though is the right is an abortion in your view?
- 22:38One sec,
- 22:38I got to finish my point.
- 22:39What I will say is the rights of people's bodily
- 22:41autonomy is something that supersedes the preservation of life,
- 22:43especially when it comes to the government enforcement of that.
- 22:45Do I have the right as a mother to kill my child?
- 22:48So I think there are two ways that we determine what rights are in a society,
- 22:51right?
- 22:51It's either we all have rights and then we decide as a society that there
- 22:54are some actions that we need to restrict just because we live in a.
- 22:57world
- 22:58or we have no rights and we just have the
- 22:59grace of the government that grants us some rights.
- 23:01I have a question.
- 23:02What I would start is,
- 23:03I think that we do have all rights.
- 23:04I think that we restrict things that would be unnecessary and bad.
- 23:07I wouldn't count somebody's rights to their own
- 23:09bodily autonomy as something that we need to.
- 23:11So it sounds like you're saying,
- 23:12making the argument that dependency means that a mother should have the child to
- 23:16end the life,
- 23:17should have the right to end the life of her child.
- 23:18I wouldn't say dependency because I'm sure the child's dependent on her body,
- 23:21right?
- 23:21That's what you're saying.
- 23:21I'm assuming you're going to go.
- 23:22Like a toddler is dependent in order to be fed by their parents.
- 23:25A newborn is totally dependent on their parents,
- 23:27but it doesn't rely on we can never end the life of a newborn.
- 23:29I know,
- 23:30but it doesn't rely on the specific bodily functions it fully relies on the,
- 23:33on the functions of everybody.
- 23:34Well,
- 23:34no,
- 23:34because you can opt out.
- 23:35You can give that to an adoption agency relies on the functions of other adults,
- 23:38for sure,
- 23:39but it doesn't have to do with that biological mother.
- 23:41The mother can't put it up for adoption if they don't have the means in order to.
- 23:44So what you're saying,
- 23:44let me make sure I say it back to you.
- 23:45You're saying the biological mother has the right.
- 23:48To end the life of her biological child,
- 23:50but somebody else who's not biologically connected could end the life
- 23:53of a young child that's totally dependent on them physically.
- 23:56No,
- 23:56I wouldn't say that.
- 23:57Then what are you saying?
- 23:58Well,
- 23:58you like to go into a lot of biology.
- 23:59Do you know what an FMT is?
- 24:01Tell me.
- 24:02So it's a fecal microbacterial transfusion.
- 24:04It's necessary for people who don't have
- 24:06proper intestinal responses for immune disorders,
- 24:09and what it is is basically a transfusion of someone else's feces into that person.
- 24:14What's funny to me,
- 24:15what's funny to me is we don't enforce people in order to like
- 24:19collect their own poop in order to preserve life.
- 24:21So it's funny that we protect the sanctity
- 24:23of people's poop over people's wombs and uterus.
- 24:26Like the womb is designed for a baby,
- 24:27a baby,
- 24:28right?
- 24:28Not all wombs are designed for babies.
- 24:31What else are they designed for?
- 24:32I hate to do it,
- 24:32guys.
- 24:32I don't,
- 24:33I hate interrupting you,
- 24:34but it's the only way to,
- 24:35to keep
- 24:36no worries rotating.
- 24:37Nice to meet you.
- 24:38Good to meet you.
- 24:38Thank you.
- 24:48So your claim is that abortion cannot be justified under any circumstances,
- 24:52is that right?
- 24:53Correct.
- 24:53Well,
- 24:53I want to tell you a story.
- 24:54So I'm from Florida,
- 24:56and I remember when I heard the story of Anya Cook and her husband Derek,
- 25:00uh,
- 25:00they really wanted to have a baby,
- 25:02um,
- 25:02and they kept on trying and trying,
- 25:05and they had miscarriage after miscarriage after miscarriage,
- 25:07and then finally,
- 25:09they were able to conceive and,
- 25:11you know,
- 25:11the pregnancy kept going and they reached 16 weeks and they were
- 25:14so excited because they were finally going to have a baby.
- 25:16And they went out for dinner to celebrate it,
- 25:18and on the ride back home,
- 25:20Anya felt something going down her leg,
- 25:22and she said,
- 25:23I really hope that's not what I think it is.
- 25:25Uh,
- 25:25but it was,
- 25:25and it turned out that her water had broken.
- 25:27She had to go to the emergency room and they turned her away.
- 25:31Because even though the pregnancy was completely
- 25:34not viable,
- 25:35and the doctor said,
- 25:36um,
- 25:37you,
- 25:37you're gonna lose your baby without a doubt,
- 25:39100%,
- 25:40but if we,
- 25:41uh,
- 25:41give you a procedure right now,
- 25:43um,
- 25:44it would count as an abortion,
- 25:45uh,
- 25:46under Florida's 15-week abortion ban.
- 25:47This isn't even when they went
- 25:49um to the 6-week abortion ban in Florida.
- 25:50This was when it was still 15 weeks.
- 25:52Um,
- 25:52they said.
- 25:53Because
- 25:53you're 16 weeks,
- 25:54that would count as an abortion.
- 25:56We could go to jail,
- 25:56we could lose our medical license.
- 25:58We can't operate on you.
- 25:59So she had to go home with
- 26:00her stillborn baby that she had been so looking forward to having
- 26:04still inside her.
- 26:05Um,
- 26:05and
- 26:06the next morning she felt so sick,
- 26:08and she said that she thought she was gonna die,
- 26:10but she wanted to get her hair done first so
- 26:11that her mom didn't have to get her hair done.
- 26:13So while she was at the hairdresser,
- 26:15She felt like something was gonna happen,
- 26:17so she got out of the chair,
- 26:18went into the bathroom,
- 26:19and that is when
- 26:20she saw her baby,
- 26:21and she had to call her husband in and her husband took care of her,
- 26:24um,
- 26:25and then she was bleeding out all over the floor,
- 26:27everywhere.
- 26:28She ended up losing half of the blood in her body that day.
- 26:30They operated on her for 8 hours,
- 26:32and Derek and all of her whole family was there praying for her the whole time.
- 26:36Um,
- 26:37and miraculously she survived,
- 26:39but she would not have had to go through that if she was able,
- 26:42um,
- 26:42to get the medical care that she needed.
- 26:44And this is why I think
- 26:45that instead of having the government
- 26:47legislate,
- 26:47oh,
- 26:48abortion should be illegal,
- 26:49except,
- 26:50um,
- 26:50in this case,
- 26:51that case,
- 26:51the other case,
- 26:52we,
- 26:53it's,
- 26:54it's impossible to have something so black and white as the law.
- 26:57Legislate something that is so individualized and
- 27:00so complex as every person's experience,
- 27:03and that's why I will always trust,
- 27:05um,
- 27:05a mother
- 27:06and her family to make the right decision for her instead of the government trying to
- 27:10make things so black and white,
- 27:11and that's what abortion bans do.
- 27:13They
- 27:14cause people to get really sick and even die
- 27:16uh because they're denied the medical care that they need.
- 27:19OK,
- 27:19so I'd love to respond.
- 27:20Thank you for sharing the story.
- 27:22Here's the deal.
- 27:23The baby had passed away was,
- 27:24you mentioned the baby was stillborn,
- 27:26or you said that we used the word stillbirth.
- 27:28If the baby was,
- 27:29was dead,
- 27:29if this was a miscarriage,
- 27:30the baby was dead,
- 27:31it was medical malpractice for the emergency room to turn her away,
- 27:35and she would have had a lawsuit against them.
- 27:37In any pro-life state in the in the country,
- 27:39any kind of care for miscarriage,
- 27:41to complete a miscarriage if the baby has passed away is completely legal,
- 27:45and that's actually written in the books.
- 27:46So I think that's a really important point that medical.
- 27:49Malpractice unfortunately does happen and that could have happened in the case.
- 27:51Abortion bans actually cause doctors to have to do medical malpractice.
- 27:55There's a lot of,
- 27:56there's a lot of narratives out there saying that,
- 27:58but that's inaccurate to justify,
- 27:59oh,
- 27:59if it's this exception or that exception.
- 28:01There are,
- 28:01there are thousands of medical professionals,
- 28:03including many in pro-life states who say we are able to do miscarriage care.
- 28:06We're able to deal with the baby pregnancy was still alive.
- 28:09She was under the pro-life.
- 28:10Her water had broken,
- 28:11but her baby was,
- 28:12was doomed.
- 28:13She was,
- 28:13it was going to die.
- 28:15Nice to meet you.
- 28:16Thank you.
- 28:27Um,
- 28:28so I am the executive director of one of
- 28:30the oldest rape crisis centers here in the nation,
- 28:33and one of the things that I need you to understand
- 28:36is that abortion care is health care
- 28:39for survivors,
- 28:40and it also gives them the options
- 28:43that they need in order to move forward
- 28:45after they have had
- 28:47so many choices that have been taken away from them.
- 28:50So let's remind ourselves
- 28:52that most women
- 28:53um who have been,
- 28:55um.
- 28:56Who have been assaulted know they're assaulters.
- 28:59Um,
- 29:001 in 20 women who have had pregnancies
- 29:03have had pregnancies that result from assault.
- 29:06In addition,
- 29:071 in 4 women have had abortions.
- 29:09Um,
- 29:10so these are women who are making these choices
- 29:12because they need to make these choices.
- 29:15And when you say to someone
- 29:17who has already had choices taken away from them,
- 29:21that in addition
- 29:22to,
- 29:23I have had my body violated,
- 29:25I have had my choices taken from me,
- 29:28that I then have to carry a child
- 29:31to birth,
- 29:33and then.
- 29:35Have my life put in danger and reminding ourselves that as a black woman,
- 29:40as a black woman,
- 29:41I have a higher rate of death
- 29:44in our society
- 29:46just by birthing,
- 29:47so I'm putting my life in danger
- 29:50just to
- 29:51carry a child
- 29:52that has resulted from an assault,
- 29:55so you cannot tell me.
- 29:57That
- 29:58there is no circumstance where I don't make that choice
- 30:02for my body
- 30:03and for the tissues that are in my body.
- 30:06There is always a space for me to make a choice for what is going to happen to my body.
- 30:13I'd love to respond,
- 30:14if I may
- 30:151st of all,
- 30:16we are aligned that is absolutely horrific.
- 30:18We're aligned on that.
- 30:19And part of the work at Live Action is we do interview survivors of sexual assault,
- 30:23and we talk to survivors of sexual assault,
- 30:25as well as
- 30:26children conceived via sexual assault.
- 30:28That's part of their story.
- 30:29And we're aligned that it's absolutely horrific,
- 30:32where it sounds.
- 30:33We're not aligned is that I don't believe that
- 30:35two wrongs make a right,
- 30:37that if there is a horrific act of an assault,
- 30:39if I may just explain my position here,
- 30:41if there's a horrific act of assault,
- 30:44and a pregnancy results and a new life is conceived,
- 30:47that ending that new life,
- 30:48giving that new human being the death penalty for the guy you
- 30:51just finished the death penalty for the crime of the father,
- 30:54that's correct.
- 30:55There has been a fertilization of an egg,
- 30:57if I may finish,
- 30:58if I may finish.
- 30:58So as an example.
- 30:59For example,
- 30:59my friend Rebecca Keisling or my friend Ryan Bamberger,
- 31:02two amazing people,
- 31:03conceived in brutal,
- 31:05and they go around and they say,
- 31:06I was that embryo,
- 31:08I was that fetus,
- 31:08I was that unborn baby.
- 31:10Do I not have a right to live?
- 31:11Should I have gotten the death penalty for the crime of my father?
- 31:14And,
- 31:15and just,
- 31:15just one more,
- 31:16one more thing to say that mother made a choice.
- 31:18Well,
- 31:18that mother made a choice.
- 31:20I,
- 31:21I,
- 31:21as a person who has been assaulted,
- 31:23then get to make that choice for my body.
- 31:26And that's the difference.
- 31:27No,
- 31:28actually,
- 31:28the difference is I get to choose
- 31:31what happens to my body
- 31:33because I didn't get to make that choice with that assault.
- 31:36I didn't get to make that choice with that rape,
- 31:38but I do get to make the choice with what happens with that fertilized egg,
- 31:42and that
- 31:43is a problem.
- 31:45And when I am sitting here with a 10 year old child
- 31:48who didn't have a choice
- 31:50about what happened to her body.
- 31:52To then say you must,
- 31:55you must
- 31:56carry that child
- 31:57until
- 31:58you give birth,
- 32:00that is,
- 32:00that is unfort,
- 32:01if I can respond with a couple of things that are really important,
- 32:04I think.
- 32:04First of all,
- 32:04Rebecca Keisling,
- 32:05my friend who was conceived in,
- 32:06her mother tried to have an abortion.
- 32:08It was illegal and she couldn't access one.
- 32:10So she ended up placing Rebecca for adoption and Rebecca goes around and says,
- 32:13what about my right to life?
- 32:15And she ended up meeting with her mother years later and her mother said,
- 32:18I'm actually glad I wasn't able
- 32:20to end your life.
- 32:21And I'm abortion,
- 32:21I'm think.
- 32:22If I can just finish,
- 32:23if I can just finish,
- 32:24one of the key things that we need to be,
- 32:26we need to acknowledge is that abortion isn't something that's going to heal
- 32:29abortion.
- 32:30If I can just abortion,
- 32:33if I can just finish the abortion,
- 32:35I,
- 32:36I'd love to respond to you.
- 32:37I'd love to just have a moment.
- 32:39Abortion
- 32:39can add trauma.
- 32:40It's another act of violence.
- 32:42It does not trauma.
- 32:44There is no evidence that abortion adds trauma.
- 32:46If I may respond,
- 32:47in the state of California,
- 32:49200,000 Medicaid patients,
- 32:51women,
- 32:52150% more likely
- 32:55to commit suicide for those that had an abortion,
- 32:58if I may just finish,
- 32:59than those that gave birth.
- 33:00There is no psychological evidence.
- 33:02There,
- 33:03there have been a lot of studies that have been
- 33:04done that show that abortion can be profoundly traumatizing.
- 33:08There is actually.
- 33:09correlation
- 33:10to the trauma
- 33:12of having to carry the birth
- 33:14to term,
- 33:15there is correlation to the trauma
- 33:18of the I think stigma of early delivery might
- 33:20be the right decision because keep in mind,
- 33:22what is an abortion?
- 33:23It's the forced birth of a dead fetus or embryo.
- 33:26An abortion is the forced birth of a dead
- 33:28abortion is an actual medical procedure to remove tissue
- 33:32from your body so that you are what kind of tissue is being removed in an abortion?
- 33:36Fetal tissue of what,
- 33:37of what?
- 33:38Of a what?
- 33:40Of a fetus of a fetus,
- 33:41and what is a fetus?
- 33:43A fetus could,
- 33:44could
- 33:45a fetus could
- 33:47grow to be
- 33:48a live birth.
- 33:49So is a fetus alive?
- 33:52Not necessarily.
- 33:52If the fetus is dead,
- 33:53why do you have to have an abortion?
- 33:55Well,
- 33:56you have to have an abortion to remove the fetus.
- 33:59If from the the fetus is already dead,
- 34:00I have no problem with removing a dead baby you.
- 34:02But if the baby's alive,
- 34:03what,
- 34:04what,
- 34:04what is,
- 34:04is the fetus alive when you're doing an abortion,
- 34:06an elective abortion?
- 34:08So sometimes a fetus is not alive when you do an elective abortion.
- 34:11We would agree that that would be a miscarriage,
- 34:12and we are both fine with that if the baby has already passed away.
- 34:15Absolutely not,
- 34:17because there just to be clear,
- 34:18I'm,
- 34:18I am only against
- 34:19an abortion
- 34:20that is intentionally taking the life of an innocent human.
- 34:25Thank you.
- 34:25Thank you so much.
- 34:35Um,
- 34:36so your claim is that there's no right for abortion under any circumstance at all,
- 34:40which obviously I disagree with,
- 34:41because,
- 34:41and I'll just define abortion really quick just for clarity
- 34:44because it was you don't really need to for me,
- 34:46the intentional killing of a living,
- 34:48whatever you want to call it.
- 34:49I don't disagree with it anyway,
- 34:50so
- 34:51my point though is that there is,
- 34:53there should be exception.
- 34:54I mean,
- 34:55I think you should be able to get it if you want one,
- 34:57but under any circum for the,
- 34:59the 10 year olds that are,
- 35:00which you know,
- 35:01that 10-year-old in Ohio who was raped by her father.
- 35:04Then was told she couldn't have an abortion,
- 35:06had to go to a different state.
- 35:07So you're more than comfortable with
- 35:09holding down a 10-year-old once again to make her do
- 35:12something with her body she doesn't want to do.
- 35:14So an abortion is another act of violence in my view,
- 35:17both of that baby and of a survivor.
- 35:19I think this view that we have that abortion is somehow going
- 35:22to heal that 10 year old is crying and begging you,
- 35:25I don't want to give birth.
- 35:26I don't want to carry it for 9 months.
- 35:28I don't want to be a I think she deserves the best support and care.
- 35:31She needs to be taken out of that.
- 35:32Abusive healthcare and this case would be an abortion,
- 35:35but,
- 35:35but we can't take the life of an innocent child.
- 35:37I think in that case,
- 35:38in that case,
- 35:39an early delivery,
- 35:40if I can just,
- 35:40if you're just affording,
- 35:41no,
- 35:42you're affording more empathy toward a zygote more than you are a living,
- 35:46breathing 10 year old who just went through something seriously traumatizing.
- 35:50So your empathy is in a place I don't understand.
- 35:53If I,
- 35:54if I can respond now,
- 35:54you can absolutely.
- 35:55So
- 35:56is absolutely horrific.
- 35:57incest is absolutely horrific.
- 35:59We are completely aligned on that.
- 36:00We need more.
- 36:00Penalties for abusers.
- 36:02I think one of the things that I have about that case that
- 36:04I've seen is there's no story about what happened to her abuser.
- 36:07Was she protected from her abuser?
- 36:08It's like that's left out of the narrative.
- 36:10I mean,
- 36:10but what I've heard you say before,
- 36:12she been protected.
- 36:13She didn't punish a child for what you called generational sin.
- 36:16But if I can,
- 36:17if I can finish,
- 36:18if I can finish,
- 36:19but which child are you not?
- 36:20You got to let me,
- 36:21you got to let me make the case.
- 36:22You got to let me make the case.
- 36:23You got to let you're worried about punishing a child,
- 36:25but which one?
- 36:25The 10 year old who was already punished?
- 36:27Can I respond?
- 36:28No,
- 36:28you can.
- 36:29In a case of incest and there's a new life that's been conceived,
- 36:33there's another human being now we're talking about.
- 36:35It's not just the abuser and the victim.
- 36:37There's another potential victim,
- 36:39and we need to care for both.
- 36:40They're both human beings.
- 36:42And in the case of a very young girl who's been the victim of a horrific assault,
- 36:46the idea to hold her down again,
- 36:47the idea,
- 36:48well,
- 36:48in an abortion you're literally held down and you
- 36:50have to submit your body to an act that will
- 36:53deliver she would want to have done you rather than the other.
- 36:55You're speaking for her right now.
- 36:56We're talking about the 10-year-old who wanted to get that abortion.
- 36:59But the point here is,
- 37:01is that there are human rights now in play for an unborn child and a born child.
- 37:05They both have rights,
- 37:06and I think the medical care is very key,
- 37:08as well as the counseling and the support that she deserves.
- 37:10And probably an early delivery would be what would be necessary to protect her
- 37:14health and to make sure that the baby would have a chance to live.
- 37:17But at the end of the day,
- 37:18you don't give the death penalty
- 37:19to the baby because they were conceived by a rapist,
- 37:23because their father is an.
- 37:24User,
- 37:24we don't even give the death penalty in this country to.
- 37:27Or were you aware of that?
- 37:28My question for you can't even get the death penalty for
- 37:31why would we be OK with giving the death penalty
- 37:33to a child because they're conceived of rape?
- 37:35It's not a child.
- 37:36What are they in a zygote.
- 37:37It's what is,
- 37:37what is an embryo?
- 37:38What is?
- 37:39And I'm not going to get into the science behind
- 37:40it because the thing you don't think the science matters,
- 37:43not in this argument right now.
- 37:44You don't think there's no right for an abortion for any reason,
- 37:48but there definitely are.
- 37:49That's like Nancy Davis.
- 37:51Louisiana,
- 37:51because her,
- 37:52her child is going to be born with a crania,
- 37:54meaning without a skull,
- 37:56you thought,
- 37:57and you said this to her,
- 37:58you said,
- 37:59I think your child should have died in the loving arms
- 38:02of their parents instead of at the tools of the abortionists.
- 38:05Now this woman was going to give birth to a child that will die
- 38:09within minutes of being born,
- 38:10so you're not bringing life into the world
- 38:13at that point.
- 38:13You know what abortion procedure would have been done on her baby?
- 38:16Do you know what abortion procedure would have been done on her baby?
- 38:18In a later term abortion that she had in the 2nd trimester,
- 38:21if I can,
- 38:21if I can just complete what my sentence here,
- 38:24either there would have been a lethal injection of that baby
- 38:27to kill that baby,
- 38:28or that would have been a live dismemberment of that baby.
- 38:30Those are the abortion procedures used in the 2nd or the 3rd trimester.
- 38:33And you don't think either one should have been,
- 38:34but you support that?
- 38:35Do you support that?
- 38:37Thank you.
- 38:45Hello.
- 38:46Nice to meet you.
- 38:47Nice to meet you too.
- 38:48You're very brave.
- 38:50You are too.
- 38:51So,
- 38:51um,
- 38:52I would like to ask you.
- 38:53So,
- 38:54I believe in abortion at all levels whenever the person chooses,
- 38:57but I would like to ask you why you think
- 39:00the attention
- 39:02and responsibility
- 39:03and all the,
- 39:05the shame that you guys give to people that get abortions instead of the,
- 39:08the father.
- 39:09Like,
- 39:09why are we spending so much time on punishing
- 39:12the woman or the person that got pregnant
- 39:14and not the person that made them pregnant
- 39:15when they can control when they ejaculate?
- 39:18Women can't control when we ovulate.
- 39:20So really,
- 39:21if you want to have responsibility,
- 39:22it should be with the person who
- 39:24bothered the child.
- 39:25I think you're totally right that men bear equal responsibility for any pregnancy,
- 39:29and I'm,
- 39:29I'm,
- 39:30well,
- 39:30I would say it's equal.
- 39:31It takes two to make the baby,
- 39:32and I think not all men,
- 39:34sometimes you get held against your will.
- 39:35Well,
- 39:35in that case,
- 39:36yes,
- 39:36it's even more horrific,
- 39:37and the man not only is responsible,
- 39:39but he should be put in jail.
- 39:40I mean,
- 39:41that's even a horrific situation,
- 39:42right?
- 39:43So we're not use your efforts for that.
- 39:44But,
- 39:44well,
- 39:45I think I'm not sure how familiar you are with our work,
- 39:47but a lot of our work includes reporting.
- 39:49On women who are being coerced into having abortions by men
- 39:53who would not take responsibility for that baby that was conceived,
- 39:56but that's because a lot of,
- 39:57a lot of men,
- 39:58especially abusive men,
- 40:00they see their
- 40:02subject of abuse,
- 40:03that woman,
- 40:03if she gets pregnant or that girl,
- 40:05if she gets pregnant,
- 40:06they see that as a
- 40:09something in the way of them being able to continue to abuse and use her.
- 40:12They don't want her to be pregnant.
- 40:13And so one of the research reports that we've done
- 40:15shows that in the life of a sex trafficking victim,
- 40:18she'll have To at least one and up to multiple forced abortions in her life because
- 40:24her pimp doesn't want her to be pregnant because he can't monetize her basically.
- 40:28So this is some of the horrific underside of the
- 40:30abortion industry that they actually profit off of coerced abortions,
- 40:34but again,
- 40:34rape-based abortions,
- 40:35trafficked victims' abortions,
- 40:37pregnant and not the perpetrators.
- 40:39What do you mean by shaming?
- 40:40Just to be clear,
- 40:41I'm saying that women or people that get pregnant are not making decisions that are
- 40:45right for their own bodies.
- 40:46You're empathizing them.
- 40:48And then you're also not putting responsibility on people that actually
- 40:52caused the situation.
- 40:53Well,
- 40:53if it's a rapist,
- 40:54we are in full,
- 40:55I think we're probably in full agreement that they should be held fully
- 40:58criminally responsible and put in jail for the rest of their life.
- 41:00And my view to say that,
- 41:01but the conservatives do not act like that.
- 41:04They act like it's entirely women's responsibility.
- 41:06I can only speak for myself here and my organization,
- 41:09and we'd work with liberals,
- 41:10we work with conservatives,
- 41:11we work with Republicans,
- 41:12we work,
- 41:13work with Democrats.
- 41:13So we're a nonpartisan organization.
- 41:15It's nice to meet you.
- 41:16Nice to meet you.
- 41:21Hey,
- 41:22before we go any further,
- 41:23we want to take a moment to say thanks so much to
- 41:25Straight Arrow News for powering the fact checks in this video.
- 41:28Straight Arrow News is an app and website that is on a mission to
- 41:32raise the bar on journalism in a time of media bias and mistrust.
- 41:35Their team of journalists believe that unbiased news should
- 41:38be the standard and not just the exception,
- 41:40so they report.
- 41:41Down the middle with facts,
- 41:42delivering news without bias,
- 41:44filter,
- 41:44or spin,
- 41:45plus their media miss tool allows you to discover news that's being underreported
- 41:49or not even reported at all by different sides of mainstream media.
- 41:53That's why
- 41:53we're so happy
- 41:54to be partnering with Straight Arrow News.
- 41:56The work they're doing gives us a complete picture
- 41:58of the news straight from our phones and tablets.
- 42:01With their app,
- 42:02go to SAN.com/surrounded
- 42:04or click the link in the description to check it out.
- 42:07By clicking that link,
- 42:08you're not just supporting this channel,
- 42:10you're also supporting a group of journalists that are raising the
- 42:12bar on news and focusing on serving you unbiased straight facts.
- 42:16Thanks again to Straight Arrow News for partnering with us on this episode.
- 42:20Now let's get into it.
- 42:22My next claim is every unborn child has the right to life.
- 42:30So when you say a child,
- 42:31I feel like you're kind of like preemptively
- 42:33loading the prompt with a lot of emotions.
- 42:35Um,
- 42:36a child implies a person,
- 42:37and I don't believe personhood begins until around 22 weeks of gestation when
- 42:41if you want to get into neuroscience,
- 42:42the thalamus connects to the cortex and the brain finally has the capacity
- 42:45to support a subjective experience.
- 42:47Experience.
- 42:48So why do you think that a fetus at 10 weeks,
- 42:508 weeks,
- 42:51for example,
- 42:51that has no capacity to be self-aware to experience pain or anything else
- 42:55should be valued equal to the bodily autonomy of a woman?
- 42:58OK,
- 42:58so a few questions for you to get to answer that
- 43:01is,
- 43:01do you believe that a fetus,
- 43:02a human fetus is a human?
- 43:04It's a human,
- 43:05yeah,
- 43:05sure.
- 43:05OK,
- 43:06so your argument is that some humans don't have human rights,
- 43:08because my argument is that every human has a human right and this is right is life.
- 43:12This is getting into semantics like the colloquial way we
- 43:14use the word human versus maybe a more scientific way.
- 43:16So obviously
- 43:17a fertilized egg and beyond has human cells.
- 43:19The question is,
- 43:20when we talk about protecting that life,
- 43:22when does it become on the same level as
- 43:24the life of the mother who has bodily autonomy?
- 43:26Uh,
- 43:26and the,
- 43:26the answer there is 22 weeks because again,
- 43:28prior to that,
- 43:29there's nothing,
- 43:29there's the car is on,
- 43:30but there's no driver in the car.
- 43:32And you don't apply traffic laws to an empty car,
- 43:34right?
- 43:34There has to be a subject present.
- 43:35It can't be a some thing.
- 43:36It has to be a someone.
- 43:38So does a newborn baby have the same capacity,
- 43:41brain abilities as a 3 year old?
- 43:44Uh,
- 43:44no.
- 43:45And does it has the same capacity for consciousness though,
- 43:47because the thalamus and cortex are connected.
- 43:49So you're defining human life as consciousness.
- 43:51That's your definition,
- 43:52yeah,
- 43:52the ability to have a subjective experience,
- 43:53consciousness.
- 43:54Sure.
- 43:54So if someone is unconscious,
- 43:55are they no longer a human?
- 43:56They still have connections with their thalamus and cortex,
- 43:58whether they're on their.
- 43:59Anesthesia,
- 43:59whether they're asleep,
- 44:01whether they're they're in a coma,
- 44:02that you would say they're still a human they still
- 44:03have the neural pathways connecting those parts of the brain.
- 44:06If you're an unborn child before you've developed your brain fully,
- 44:08right,
- 44:09because we all started life
- 44:11before our brain was developed,
- 44:12right?
- 44:12And then eventually after a few weeks we would develop
- 44:14our brain and then develop more capacities with our brain.
- 44:17But that child before it has developed its brain has the natural capacity for
- 44:21a brain because that's what will happen if no one kills that child.
- 44:23When you say before it's developed a brain,
- 44:25do you mean prior to 22 weeks?
- 44:2622 weeks.
- 44:27And,
- 44:27and there are parts of a lot has happened in the brain activity even before 22 weeks,
- 44:32as I'm I'm sure you know.
- 44:33Sure,
- 44:34but it's not sufficient to support a subjective experience.
- 44:36And when you talk about prior to 22 weeks,
- 44:38I would agree a potential life has some value,
- 44:40but it's not equal value to an actual person
- 44:43who has a right to bodily autonomy.
- 44:45If 200 years in the future,
- 44:46thanks to like medical technology advancements,
- 44:48we can safely remove an 8-week fetus from a mother,
- 44:51respect her bodily autonomy and protect the fetus,
- 44:53I don't think anyone's.
- 44:54To call for abortion in that situation,
- 44:55but the reality is
- 44:57respecting her bodily autonomy typically is mutually
- 44:59exclusive with terminating with keeping that pregnancy.
- 45:02So,
- 45:02so make sure,
- 45:02make sure I'm tracking your argument here.
- 45:04You're saying that before this specific moment when
- 45:06there is a certain level of brain development,
- 45:09because the brain has begun developing connections between brain regions,
- 45:11and,
- 45:12and,
- 45:12and why for you is that the level of humanity?
- 45:15Why,
- 45:15why for you does that give that person human rights?
- 45:17Because that includes anyone we'd want to include,
- 45:19people that are asleep,
- 45:20people that are under general anesthesia if they have a.
- 45:21Brain developmental disorder where they're missing part of their brain and so
- 45:25for example,
- 45:25and those connections aren't there,
- 45:26would you say they're not a human anymore?
- 45:28They'd still be a human and like I said earlier,
- 45:29they don't have those brain connections that you're talking about.
- 45:31I'm talking about personhood versus being a human.
- 45:33That's what I'm talking about too.
- 45:34So I'm saying,
- 45:35so I want to be clear with the terms here.
- 45:36When you say they're a human,
- 45:37I'm agreeing that even a fertilized egg is a human is a person that should be given.
- 45:41So are you saying that a person with a brain developmental disorder,
- 45:43like a significant developmental you're talking about anencephaly,
- 45:46for example,
- 45:47as an example that they would not be a person as I.
- 45:49It's OK to kill that person.
- 45:50No,
- 45:51that's not what I'm saying.
- 45:51Then what are you saying?
- 45:52As I said earlier,
- 45:53when there's a potential life,
- 45:54a partial life,
- 45:54you still give it some value.
- 45:56You have to take reasonable steps to protect it.
- 45:57If someone's born,
- 45:59would you give it if someone's born with anencephaly,
- 46:01there's no conflict there between the bodily autonomy
- 46:03of a woman and the person with anencephaly.
- 46:05The reason you do an abortion is not like,
- 46:06oh,
- 46:07I want to kill this fetus for fun.
- 46:08There's a conflict between the woman's bodily autonomy and the fetus developing.
- 46:12If there's some way to resolve that and respect both parties,
- 46:15that would be great,
- 46:15but we don't have that kind of medical.
- 46:17So the,
- 46:17the position is that if you are a human,
- 46:20you have human rights,
- 46:21regardless of how developed your brain might be,
- 46:23because some people have severe developmental disabilities and
- 46:26that doesn't make them less of a human,
- 46:27or they have less.
- 46:29Well,
- 46:29your argument actually infers that it does actually,
- 46:32because it's saying that this particular level
- 46:34of developmental ability that your brain may have
- 46:37gives you exists by the way,
- 46:38in pretty much anyone other than people with an encephaly,
- 46:41and those people usually die in a couple of days.
- 46:44OK?
- 46:44To kill that person before they die naturally,
- 46:46because of,
- 46:47because they lack this if they're still in the womb or after birth.
- 46:49But what if they're,
- 46:50OK,
- 46:50let's,
- 46:50let's take your scenario.
- 46:51What if they're after birth and they lack the specific connections that you're
- 46:54saying defines personhood a brain stem and they're and they're after birth.
- 46:58There's a little boy named Jasper.
- 46:59He lived almost,
- 47:00I think,
- 47:0034 years,
- 47:02and with a severe
- 47:03condition,
- 47:03a developmental condition in his brain.
- 47:04It's not OK to kill that.
- 47:06But why would it not be OK to kill them when they lack
- 47:08this specific brain connection that you're saying makes it OK to kill the.
- 47:11The reason that it makes the reason it's OK to kill the fetus
- 47:15prior to 22 weeks is not because it's just good enough itself.
- 47:18It's because it's the only way to resolve the conflict
- 47:20between the bodily autonomy of the woman and the fetus.
- 47:22If someone's born with anencephaly,
- 47:24their existence is not impeding on the bodily autonomy of anyone else.
- 47:27And then you want to take
- 47:28all reasonable steps to help that person,
- 47:30not harm that person.
- 47:31So I think we agree on bodily autonomy to a
- 47:33degree because I agree that I have bodily autonomy,
- 47:35you have bodily autonomy,
- 47:37but I think my bodily autonomy ends.
- 47:39When another human being's bodily autonomy begins,
- 47:43even,
- 47:43even before they're fully developed.
- 47:45So it's not that it outweighs,
- 47:47it's that they're two lives.
- 47:48Like it would not be right for me to be killed by you,
- 47:51right?
- 47:51I have a right to live.
- 47:52And similarly,
- 47:53if I had another body inside my body
- 47:56that was a developing human being,
- 47:57which is what pregnancy involves,
- 47:59right?
- 47:59Maybe 1,
- 48:00maybe 2,
- 48:01they have a right to live and to not be killed.
- 48:03So I don't have the right,
- 48:04even though
- 48:04there is a responsibility I now have,
- 48:07they're using my body to develop.
- 48:08That's how we all behave in our life.
- 48:10Then that child still has a right to not be killed.
- 48:12Parents have natural right does obligations a right to still have her
- 48:15bodily functions kept intact and have like her bodily autonomy kept intact.
- 48:20When you,
- 48:20when you can deliver the baby,
- 48:21sure,
- 48:22deliver the baby,
- 48:22don't wot designed for.
- 48:23What is the womb designed for?
- 48:24Like gestation,
- 48:25gestation of what
- 48:27the baby,
- 48:28right?
- 48:28So the womb is designed for the baby.
- 48:30OK,
- 48:30nice job.
- 48:31Thank you.
- 48:31Nice to meet you,
- 48:31Adam.
- 48:33Mhm
- 48:40So my first question is,
- 48:41are you familiar with an anime or a manga series called Monster?
- 48:44I'm not.
- 48:45Tell me about it.
- 48:46In Monster,
- 48:47essentially you have a doctor and this doctor has a choice.
- 48:49He has a choice to decide between
- 48:51either saving this young boy's life
- 48:53or saving the life of,
- 48:55I believe it's a sponsor of the hospital.
- 48:57He chooses to save the young boy's life.
- 48:59This young boy grows up to be the titular monster,
- 49:01worse than Hitler.
- 49:02Does that child have a right to life?
- 49:04Yes,
- 49:04every child has a right to life,
- 49:05even if they turn out to be the most monstrous thing you could possibly produce.
- 49:08Even if,
- 49:08even if,
- 49:09even if,
- 49:09even if their life
- 49:11means the life,
- 49:12life ending of everyone here,
- 49:14does their life still hold?
- 49:16I believe monsters are not born,
- 49:17they're made.
- 49:18So just because a child might eventually do something when they grow up and
- 49:21become an adult doesn't mean we have a right to kill them before that.
- 49:24I don't know what went on in their childhood or the choices that they made,
- 49:27but at the end of the day,
- 49:28everyone has a right to life,
- 49:29especially a child.
- 49:30They're innocent.
- 49:31Let's say this child grows up
- 49:33and their life is miserable
- 49:35to the point of where they would want to end their life,
- 49:38and that's going to obviously leave some kind of ricochet effect.
- 49:41Everybody's going to be desperately devastated by that.
- 49:44Would you say that the parent who believes that
- 49:46that is where their child's life is going,
- 49:49Does that child still deserve the right to life?
- 49:52Are you saying that if a child is being abused,
- 49:54then we should be in support of killing that child?
- 49:57Then let me be more specific.
- 49:58What would you say to me as someone who is a 3rd generation suicide survivor,
- 50:02my mother,
- 50:03my grandmother,
- 50:04and their lives are miserable?
- 50:05I'm so glad that you're here.
- 50:07So sorry that that's part of your history and that
- 50:10that your,
- 50:10your,
- 50:11your mother,
- 50:11your grandmother endured that,
- 50:13and I'm so glad that you're here.
- 50:14I think your life is awesome and I think every life is awesome.
- 50:18Now,
- 50:18would you say the same if you knew that I was living
- 50:19in a domestic violence shelter where I considered taking my life frequently?
- 50:23Would you still say that I don't deserve to
- 50:26Not only,
- 50:26not only in that life,
- 50:27but especially as somebody who did have an abortion,
- 50:29as somebody who had to make the decision to escape their
- 50:32abuser,
- 50:32their predator,
- 50:33their captor,
- 50:34someone who was trafficked and pimped,
- 50:36would you still say that raising that child under those those circumstances
- 50:40would have either made my life difficult,
- 50:41or would you still say that child has a right to life if I made the decision,
- 50:44I don't want to be tied to a predator for the rest of my life.
- 50:47I don't want to be tied to my captor for the rest of my life.
- 50:50So if someone's dealing with Horrible abuse,
- 50:52and I hope that didn't happen to you,
- 50:53but if you were dealing with horrible,
- 50:55I am,
- 50:55and I'm so sorry.
- 50:56That's absolutely horrible.
- 50:57You deserved much better.
- 50:59You deserve to be
- 51:00taken out of that,
- 51:00rescued from that,
- 51:01and given a better life.
- 51:02And that would be my hope for every person
- 51:04and what I'd want to work towards for every person
- 51:06as opposed to saying death is the answer or a
- 51:08suicide is the answer or abortion is the answer.
- 51:11I think choosing life is,
- 51:12is always better.
- 51:13Now,
- 51:14what would you say if I were to say,
- 51:15yes,
- 51:16thank you as well.
- 51:16Appreciate it.
- 51:23So first
- 51:25I'm a mother.
- 51:26Awesome,
- 51:26congrats,
- 51:27and I know you're a mother too,
- 51:29and I think that as mothers
- 51:32having our bodily autonomy,
- 51:34the right to control our own body and make our own decisions,
- 51:39especially when it comes to pregnancy,
- 51:41is paramount.
- 51:43And I think that calling
- 51:45an unborn child,
- 51:47an embryo or fetus,
- 51:48an unborn child
- 51:49as mothers is disingenuous and it is disempowering for us.
- 51:54I don't know how a child would fit in my uterus.
- 51:58It doesn't even really make sense.
- 52:00So when we're talking about an unborn
- 52:02child,
- 52:02I think we should say in this space,
- 52:04like out of respect for everyone,
- 52:06it's a fetus.
- 52:07It's an embryo.
- 52:07Do you know the meaning of the word fetus.
- 52:10Yes,
- 52:10what is it?
- 52:11It's a baby,
- 52:12an unborn baby.
- 52:14I'm not here to argue
- 52:15anything scientific with you.
- 52:16I'm here to talk about bodily autonomy does matter.
- 52:19The bodily autonomy is what I'm here to talk to you about.
- 52:21Well,
- 52:21I think both matter,
- 52:22right?
- 52:22So the science tells us you just had a guest who argued science with you.
- 52:25I am not a scientist.
- 52:26I'm a mother.
- 52:28I am too,
- 52:28but I'm saying the science,
- 52:29I think,
- 52:29does matter.
- 52:30I'm so glad it matters to you.
- 52:32Everyone here has a different reason
- 52:34why abortion rights matter to them.
- 52:36And as me,
- 52:37a mother,
- 52:38and as someone who in a red state,
- 52:40when they were trying to pass a 6-week
- 52:42heartbeat
- 52:43abortion ban,
- 52:45I went into the ER and I was questioned about
- 52:47what I had done to cause a possible miscarriage,
- 52:50because at that time,
- 52:51the state legislature was working to ban abortion at 6 weeks,
- 52:54and I was 11 weeks,
- 52:55and I was turned away.
- 52:56I was questioned about what I had done.
- 52:58I want,
- 53:00wanted that pregnancy.
- 53:01I want another pregnancy.
- 53:02I have a child.
- 53:03I want to stay alive for.
- 53:04My child.
- 53:05So my bodily autonomy
- 53:07is the paramount,
- 53:08is the most important thing.
- 53:10And to say women's bodily autonomy should be sacrificed
- 53:14for
- 53:15a hypothetical baby,
- 53:17a hypothetical child,
- 53:19because a pregnancy,
- 53:20that is not a child,
- 53:21it's a baby,
- 53:22it's a fetus,
- 53:23and it's an embryo.
- 53:25So I'd love to respond to what you're saying.
- 53:26Um,
- 53:27first of all,
- 53:27well,
- 53:28first,
- 53:28before you respond,
- 53:29I just want to hear one argument,
- 53:31because I've never heard anyone from your.
- 53:33Organization,
- 53:34make an argument of why the government or you or anyone
- 53:38knows better for my body than me.
- 53:41So I'd love to respond if I how you know better about my body than me.
- 53:44So I,
- 53:45I don't know your body personally,
- 53:47you don't know anyone's me,
- 53:48but what I,
- 53:49but what I can say is if you would let me respond,
- 53:51I'd love to respond to what you're saying.
- 53:53So your argument is that bodily autonomy,
- 53:55your bodily autonomy is more important than the unborn child's right to life.
- 53:59OK,
- 53:59so you,
- 54:00do you have the right.
- 54:01To kill your unborn child.
- 54:03My bodily,
- 54:03you have the right to kill your unborn child.
- 54:05I have a right
- 54:06to use my body and my organs however I kill your unborn child.
- 54:10No one has the right to use my body or organs without my consent.
- 54:13So does that mean you have the right to kill?
- 54:15How is it killing him?
- 54:16My 5 abortion is killing that child.
- 54:18My 5 year old son needs a kidney or he will die.
- 54:22If I don't give him my kidney,
- 54:23is that killing him?
- 54:24Is that killing him?
- 54:25If I don't give him my kid I can respond,
- 54:26I can't,
- 54:26we can't have a conversation if I can't respond.
- 54:28And abortion is the.
- 54:29Intentional killing of that child.
- 54:30So abortion is your definition,
- 54:32it's a medical procedure.
- 54:33It's a healthcare medical if you would let me respond.
- 54:35So an abortion involves either poisoning the baby to death via an abortion pill.
- 54:38It involves suctioning the baby to death in a first trimester abortion.
- 54:42It can involve live dismemberment of that baby in a second trimester abortion,
- 54:46or in a third trimester abortion,
- 54:47it involves a lethal injection.
- 54:49So in all of those bodily autonomy,
- 54:50in all of those cases,
- 54:51it's bodily autonomy.
- 54:52Explain what pause,
- 54:54Whitney.
- 54:54I'm so sorry.
- 54:55Oh by the majority.
- 54:56Thank you,
- 54:57Whitney.
- 55:08OK,
- 55:08so I just want to get some clarification on your definitions here.
- 55:12How do you define a child?
- 55:13What is a child?
- 55:14OK,
- 55:14great question and great thing to do.
- 55:17First of all,
- 55:17an unborn child is a member of the human species
- 55:21that is not born yet.
- 55:22So that would include a child in the womb or it could.
- 55:25Include a child that's in an IVF.
- 55:27What characteristics that are distinct that create
- 55:29the definition of a human?
- 55:31How do you define a human?
- 55:32A human is a member of the,
- 55:33of the,
- 55:33um,
- 55:34human species.
- 55:35So that's under the law,
- 55:37yes,
- 55:37under the law of biogenesis,
- 55:39a human would be the offspring.
- 55:42Of a
- 55:43of parents in the same species.
- 55:45OK,
- 55:45so what is the distinction between a human and a living other living organisms?
- 55:50Um,
- 55:50genetically we might be pretty similar in some ways,
- 55:53but there's some key differences.
- 55:54What is the key difference?
- 55:55Uh,
- 55:55the human genetic code is,
- 55:57is,
- 55:58uh,
- 55:58substantially different than any other.
- 56:02Could you say maybe a level of awareness is something that distincts us from just,
- 56:06you know,
- 56:06let's say bacteria or plants or other.
- 56:08Life,
- 56:09yes,
- 56:09we have the ability for reason.
- 56:11We have to have
- 56:12a conscious experience.
- 56:13Yeah,
- 56:13ultimately human beings have a natural capacity
- 56:16to be able to reason and to be able to
- 56:19choose and love and do things that,
- 56:21you know,
- 56:22animals might
- 56:23have some,
- 56:24so you say that's a determinant relate to in some ways,
- 56:25but not the human
- 56:27human being.
- 56:27That's what determines a human being,
- 56:28having awareness and a conscious experience.
- 56:30Well,
- 56:31I mean,
- 56:31you know,
- 56:32animals have conscious experience,
- 56:33but we have the ability to reason.
- 56:35Ultimately,
- 56:35human beings have a natural capacity.
- 56:37This is what makes us distinct from living other living organisms like plants or,
- 56:41but just to be clear,
- 56:41human beings have the natural capacity for reason,
- 56:44but they don't all have the active capacity.
- 56:46So a newborn baby doesn't have an active capacity for language,
- 56:50for reasoning,
- 56:51for making arguments
- 56:52that a maybe adulthood.
- 56:54And similarly,
- 56:55we all know that an unborn baby is a human,
- 56:57even though the blueprints the same as a building?
- 56:59Like,
- 56:59are the blueprints the same as a building?
- 57:02No,
- 57:02OK,
- 57:02so if you go up to and you see
- 57:04the structural integrity of something that a building's,
- 57:07there's all these pieces that they
- 57:09have set aside,
- 57:10someone goes
- 57:11and they vandalize that,
- 57:12would they say,
- 57:12oh,
- 57:13you vandalized the I hear what you're saying,
- 57:14but it,
- 57:14it,
- 57:14the analogy doesn't fit because how does unborn fit
- 57:17because an unborn baby is not a blueprint.
- 57:18OK,
- 57:19it's not a blueprint,
- 57:19the genome,
- 57:20all the,
- 57:21the genetic.
- 57:21Your,
- 57:21your,
- 57:22your DNA is a blueprint,
- 57:23but the unborn baby is also made of cells,
- 57:25which are,
- 57:26like you said,
- 57:26the building blocks,
- 57:27so they're not building because you even said yourself that
- 57:29a level of awareness and consciousness is what defines humanity,
- 57:32which happens in the 3rd trimester,
- 57:33and we see that actually 90% of abortions occur according
- 57:36to the Gut Macer Institute the 1st trimester pause.
- 57:49So,
- 57:50um,
- 57:50my fundamental issue with a lot of pro-lifers is they have a misreading
- 57:53or a misunderstanding of why exactly we grant moral consideration to other humans.
- 57:57It is not unlike your view,
- 58:00because we are simply
- 58:01of the human species and a live organism.
- 58:03Under your worldview,
- 58:04and correct me if I'm wrong,
- 58:05at the moment of conception
- 58:07that you have a right to life and that right to life is equal amongst all human,
- 58:11uh,
- 58:11beings,
- 58:11is that correct?
- 58:12At the moment of fertilization,
- 58:13yes,
- 58:13we all have an equal right to life when a single cell embryo.
- 58:16So the science shows us at the moment of fertilization,
- 58:19well,
- 58:19it's important,
- 58:19a single cell embryo comes into existence.
- 58:21I'm,
- 58:21I'm not even that's unique and genetically distinct from his or her mother.
- 58:24Yeah.
- 58:24So you would prefer a world where there are less rights
- 58:26violations than a world where there are more rights violations.
- 58:29Is that correct?
- 58:29Of course,
- 58:30of course.
- 58:30OK,
- 58:31so in a,
- 58:31in a world in which someone shot and killed a born human baby,
- 58:35you would prefer that world over someone destroying a tray full of frozen zygotes.
- 58:41Under your worldview,
- 58:42if those,
- 58:43if that is a.
- 58:43world in which there are more rights violations happening,
- 58:45a tray of frozen zygoats,
- 58:48zygotes,
- 58:48and petri dishes would be worse under your worldview than a
- 58:51world in which someone shot and killed a born baby.
- 58:53Can you concede to that?
- 58:54I think we were talking about this sense of can you concede whether or not that would,
- 58:57if you'll let me respond.
- 58:58So here's,
- 58:58here's the deal.
- 58:59If someone,
- 59:00there was a burning building,
- 59:01right,
- 59:01and they're,
- 59:02I think you're kind of using this analogy with this tray of babies that are frozen,
- 59:06right,
- 59:06in vitro fertilization babies,
- 59:10you know,
- 59:10nobody,
- 59:10nobody colloquially.
- 59:11uses the term baby to refer to human embryos,
- 59:13human embryos.
- 59:14They're human embryos,
- 59:15right?
- 59:15Or the born baby.
- 59:17Yes,
- 59:17I mean,
- 59:18under the law of familiarity,
- 59:19and also if I was in a household and there was in the first room my son,
- 59:23in the second room,
- 59:24some other person,
- 59:25I would pick my son.
- 59:26I'm not,
- 59:26I'm not asking in the law of familiarity.
- 59:28I'm asking under your ethical worldview with respect to rights violations,
- 59:31which is what we're discussing doesn't mean
- 59:33that the embryos are less valuable or that
- 59:35the person in the room that I didn't choose to save is less valuable.
- 59:37This is really.
- 59:38But with respect to rights violations,
- 59:40I'm gonna come walking back because you're not actually,
- 59:43you're not directly actually responding.
- 59:44I am trying to,
- 59:45if I may,
- 59:46if I may,
- 59:47if I want to save in your analogy,
- 59:49this newborn baby from being shot,
- 59:51I think is what your analogy is,
- 59:52which is obviously horr horrible,
- 59:54or save this tray of,
- 59:55um,
- 59:55embryos,
- 59:56human embryos who are in the in vitro fertilization clinic.
- 59:58Yeah,
- 59:59I probably would pick,
- 1:00:00I would pick that newborn baby.
- 1:00:01That's not because the,
- 1:00:02um,
- 1:00:02embryos are less valuable.
- 1:00:04So then you just.
- 1:00:05You yourself because you said that you prefer a
- 1:00:07world in which there are less rights violations,
- 1:00:09but that would be a world in which there
- 1:00:11are more rights violations under your exact worldview,
- 1:00:13because you conceded earlier that at the moment of conception,
- 1:00:17we all have an equal right to life,
- 1:00:18which means if we have an equal right to life,
- 1:00:20all of those embryos have an equal equal rights to life,
- 1:00:22and that means there are more rights violations under
- 1:00:24the worldview in which the tray is destroyed versus,
- 1:00:26to be clear,
- 1:00:27if there was a baby and it's like,
- 1:00:28go save that baby or go save these 10 men over there,
- 1:00:31I also might pick the baby.
- 1:00:32It doesn't mean that these 10 men are not asking.
- 1:00:34I'm not asking whether or not,
- 1:00:35and it doesn't mean that the 10 men don't have human rights.
- 1:00:38It's just that this is a baby right.
- 1:00:39I'm not asking whether or not you have some personal empathy,
- 1:00:43more empathy towards a baby or,
- 1:00:44but no,
- 1:00:45but,
- 1:00:45but,
- 1:00:45but I'm,
- 1:00:46I'm specifically asking because we're discussing
- 1:00:49human rights,
- 1:00:49as you put it,
- 1:00:50because I also have us,
- 1:00:52all of us all have a much stronger form to empathy towards women.
- 1:00:55We don't have,
- 1:00:56sure,
- 1:00:56and then if I could just say sorry,
- 1:00:57time's up,
- 1:00:58that's OK.
- 1:00:58Thank you,
- 1:00:59Nice.
- 1:01:04Abortion is unconstitutional and should be banned.
- 1:01:11I'm a lawyer,
- 1:01:12so I'm actually really glad that you brought up the constitutionality.
- 1:01:15So what do you find unconstitutional about the right to an abortion?
- 1:01:18I'm just curious.
- 1:01:19Well,
- 1:01:19first of all,
- 1:01:19the Supreme Court has found in the reversal,
- 1:01:21the undoing of Roe v.
- 1:01:22Wade,
- 1:01:22that abortion actually is not a constitutional right.
- 1:01:25So that's currently the decision of the Supreme Court.
- 1:01:27But most,
- 1:01:28but most importantly,
- 1:01:29the Fourth Amendment to our Constitution.
- 1:01:32Has something called equal protection under the law for all persons,
- 1:01:35and it says that no state has the right to deprive
- 1:01:37any person of life without due process under the law.
- 1:01:40There's no,
- 1:01:41there's no due process for the unborn child in the womb.
- 1:01:43They're innocent
- 1:01:44and they're a human being just like you and I.
- 1:01:45I believe they're a person under the law and they have the right to live.
- 1:01:48That's true.
- 1:01:48But there's also in that clause something called the due process clause.
- 1:01:51You cannot deprive an individual life,
- 1:01:53liberty,
- 1:01:54or property.
- 1:01:55The baby due process before they're killed.
- 1:01:56Wait,
- 1:01:56wait,
- 1:01:56substantive due process,
- 1:01:57all right,
- 1:01:57there's two different things,
- 1:01:58liberty,
- 1:01:59right?
- 1:01:59We have to focus on.
- 1:02:00The liberty aspect.
- 1:02:01Individuals have liberty
- 1:02:03to do things in their life,
- 1:02:04right,
- 1:02:04that the government cannot infringe upon.
- 1:02:06One of those things is the right to marry.
- 1:02:08You cannot limit it based on race,
- 1:02:09right?
- 1:02:10But we don't you cannot limit it,
- 1:02:11right?
- 1:02:11We don't have the right to,
- 1:02:12I'm getting there.
- 1:02:13Liberty also means that you have the liberty to decide when you become a parent,
- 1:02:18right?
- 1:02:18That's what kind of Roe was based off of.
- 1:02:20It was the liberty to decide
- 1:02:22when individuals become parents.
- 1:02:24If you're pregnant,
- 1:02:25is there a child that exists?
- 1:02:28Technically we had.
- 1:02:28Conversation earlier,
- 1:02:29we're on the legal aspect,
- 1:02:30right?
- 1:02:30We're going to talk about,
- 1:02:32I want to talk about that because that's
- 1:02:33one of the reasons the pro-life position is that
- 1:02:35this isn't,
- 1:02:36this is law.
- 1:02:37I want to talk about substantive law here,
- 1:02:39right?
- 1:02:39Substantive due process
- 1:02:41determined that we have a right to determine when we become parents under Roe v.
- 1:02:46Wade.
- 1:02:46The beauty about Roe v.
- 1:02:47Wade
- 1:02:48was that it gave the 50 states the opportunity to
- 1:02:50set the ceiling for where they decided viability was,
- 1:02:53while also protecting women's rights to an abortion in all 50.
- 1:02:57I'm a parent of a one year old it back to
- 1:02:59the states while also protecting women's ability to have that decision.
- 1:03:03I have a question for you.
- 1:03:03If I'm a parent of a one year old and I'm saying I cannot deal with this one year old,
- 1:03:07I am mentally incapacitated,
- 1:03:08I can't handle this,
- 1:03:10am I allowed to do child neglect and just leave that one year old?
- 1:03:12That's not the same thing.
- 1:03:13Viability.
- 1:03:14Why is that not the same thing?
- 1:03:15Because we're not,
- 1:03:16we've had this discussion on biology.
- 1:03:17The first,
- 1:03:18you just made a claim that the reason that abortion is constitutional
- 1:03:22is because parents have the right to decide when they want to be parents.
- 1:03:25To the degree to the point where they could end the life of their child,
- 1:03:29for the point of viability,
- 1:03:31which was the issue in Roe and later in Casey.
- 1:03:33Dobbs threw.
- 1:03:34Let's talk,
- 1:03:34I want to talk about.
- 1:03:35Why was Dobbs,
- 1:03:36why did the justices in Dobbs overturn Roe?
- 1:03:38What was the reasoning?
- 1:03:39I'd love to respond to what you're saying,
- 1:03:40but we got to,
- 1:03:40it has to be give and take here.
- 1:03:42So if you're saying that a parent has the right to end the life of their child,
- 1:03:45provided the baby is before viability,
- 1:03:47is that your position,
- 1:03:48then it would be constitutional.
- 1:03:50Is that what you're saying?
- 1:03:50The point of viability is determined by the states.
- 1:03:53Anything before that.
- 1:03:54Why does my viability define my humanity?
- 1:03:57As an example,
- 1:03:57I'm not viable on Mars,
- 1:03:59right?
- 1:03:59You and I,
- 1:04:00you and I wouldn't be able to live viable on Mars when we become parents.
- 1:04:03Not Uncle Sam cannot come in and say now you have similarly,
- 1:04:06a baby in the womb,
- 1:04:07that's their natural habitat.
- 1:04:08They're not supposed to be able to survive outside the womb at 10 weeks.
- 1:04:11They're,
- 1:04:11they're,
- 1:04:11they're actually in their natural environment where we all started our life,
- 1:04:14right?
- 1:04:15Me and my wife are conscious that individuals who
- 1:04:17know our they have the natural capacity for consciousness.
- 1:04:19Give them a few more weeks.
- 1:04:21They're a human beings just like you.
- 1:04:22Well,
- 1:04:22that's when the states decide when the point of viability is
- 1:04:25a newborn baby before that is me and my wife's decision.
- 1:04:28A newborn baby has less consciousness than a 2-year-old
- 1:04:31has less consciousness and rational abilities than a 10-year-old.
- 1:04:34We're always,
- 1:04:35you don't fully develop your brain till you're in your mid-20s of Roe,
- 1:04:38right?
- 1:04:38But that doesn't mean a mid-20s person is more
- 1:04:40valuable than a newborn or an unborn baby,
- 1:04:42but they cannot go under the floor.
- 1:04:45That's the point of Roe and the beauty.
- 1:04:46It is messy legally.
- 1:04:47I'll do your job for you.
- 1:04:49The reason why people went.
- 1:04:51Constitutional.
- 1:04:51This is why it was unconst Jackson overturned Roe because,
- 1:04:54but I'll answer the question for you.
- 1:04:56The reason people are against Roe was because they said,
- 1:04:59well,
- 1:04:59it doesn't fit the substantive due process analysis.
- 1:05:02Obviously it is a right that the founders did not intend in there.
- 1:05:05It is in the spirit of the law to have
- 1:05:07the liberty interest to bring a child into this world.
- 1:05:09I'm arguing from the 14th Amendment,
- 1:05:11not from Roe or Dobbs.
- 1:05:13I'm saying that the Dobbs came from
- 1:05:14substantive due process under the Fourth Amendment.
- 1:05:17You're arguing from a different,
- 1:05:18that's not.
- 1:05:19has the right to deprive anyone of life,
- 1:05:21and it provides equal protection under the law.
- 1:05:23That's the argument,
- 1:05:25if I can just give the argument,
- 1:05:26the argument is a child in the womb
- 1:05:28has the same equal protection under the law as a newborn baby.
- 1:05:31The birth canal doesn't confer you legal rights.
- 1:05:33That's actually,
- 1:05:34well,
- 1:05:34there have been,
- 1:05:35there have been poorly decided decisions like Roe which were overturned.
- 1:05:38Dred Scott was a poorly decided Supreme
- 1:05:41Court decision that was overtnedsition against that
- 1:05:45legal belief.
- 1:05:45Everything in the legal field,
- 1:05:46I'm a lawyer,
- 1:05:47right?
- 1:05:48is based on subjective stuff.
- 1:05:50Pleasure though.
- 1:05:51Thank you.
- 1:05:59A couple of quick questions first before we begin.
- 1:06:00Do you believe that the Constitution's inherent?
- 1:06:04That you mean it's,
- 1:06:04it's perfect the way that it is?
- 1:06:06Well,
- 1:06:06I think that what is in the Constitution is good.
- 1:06:08I think it's possible and sometimes the right
- 1:06:10thing to do to add new constitutional amendments
- 1:06:13so that the Constitution can be more clear in who it's
- 1:06:16meant to protect and the rights that it's meant to protect.
- 1:06:18And
- 1:06:18that's what happened obviously with the 13th,
- 1:06:2014th,
- 1:06:20and 15th Amendment.
- 1:06:21And that's why I think.
- 1:06:23Historically we have
- 1:06:24back when the 14th Amendment was put in the Constitution,
- 1:06:27most of the country
- 1:06:29saw a child in the womb as a person.
- 1:06:30So I'm glad that you admit that amendments
- 1:06:32are something that make the Constitution malleable,
- 1:06:34make it better,
- 1:06:35can make it better,
- 1:06:36right?
- 1:06:36Absolutely.
- 1:06:37So it's not undoing past parts of the Constitution,
- 1:06:39it's making it better.
- 1:06:40Well,
- 1:06:40there,
- 1:06:40there are certain,
- 1:06:42uh,
- 1:06:42there are certain clauses within those amendments that will expand upon things
- 1:06:46that were unclear or had a little bit of murky areas,
- 1:06:48and I would say that if abortion was going to
- 1:06:50be something that was a constitutional right and amendment,
- 1:06:52you'd agree that even if it is part of my argument,
- 1:06:54to be clear,
- 1:06:55is that abortion is already unconstitutional.
- 1:06:57I think you're trying to evoke an authority that under you wouldn't
- 1:06:59subscribe to if abortion was to be added to the Constitution.
- 1:07:03So I'm not sure what you mean by abortion added to the Constitution.
- 1:07:05What do you mean by that?
- 1:07:06If,
- 1:07:06if the right to privacy was again reinforced and bodily autonomy was added to that,
- 1:07:10right,
- 1:07:11so just to be clear,
- 1:07:11I support the right to privacy and I and I support bodily autonomy people,
- 1:07:15like making sure,
- 1:07:16well,
- 1:07:16I support those things.
- 1:07:17So it's not,
- 1:07:17those are not in conflict for me.
- 1:07:19I just don't think those things mean that I have the right to take the life of my child,
- 1:07:22right?
- 1:07:22I,
- 1:07:22I,
- 1:07:23I,
- 1:07:23I can see to you that an abortion is wrong,
- 1:07:25right?
- 1:07:25Let's just agree on the same moral framework that abortions are bad.
- 1:07:28The termination of a life is something that's bad.
- 1:07:30That doesn't necessarily mean that.
- 1:07:31That needs to be illegal for all those Jordan Peterson fans out there.
- 1:07:35Jordan Peterson made this argument.
- 1:07:37Jordan Peterson
- 1:07:38specifically said that even if something is wrong,
- 1:07:40it doesn't necessarily mean that it's something that should be illegal.
- 1:07:43We would all agree that killing is wrong,
- 1:07:45but we understand just war theory that there are
- 1:07:47certain instances in which killing is something that's acceptable.
- 1:07:49I see where you're going with this,
- 1:07:50and I agree with you,
- 1:07:51largely speaking.
- 1:07:51I think so when it comes to something like abortion,
- 1:07:53when it again is trying to supersede the right to bodily autonomy,
- 1:07:56this is not.
- 1:07:57Something that we can guar guarantee.
- 1:07:59You can't guarantee to preserve that life
- 1:08:02in favor of making a woman the presumption at the heart
- 1:08:05at the heart of what you're saying is that a woman
- 1:08:08without abortion,
- 1:08:08women are going to die.
- 1:08:09I think that's the presumption.
- 1:08:10And so their rights are somehow in conflict.
- 1:08:12The rights to life that women are going to die,
- 1:08:13but going through pregnancy is not a simple process.
- 1:08:16It's not a simple of physiological changes with good medical care,
- 1:08:19you can care for both the mother and the child.
- 1:08:21And so my view is that
- 1:08:22you should not.
- 1:08:23Pit their rights against each other,
- 1:08:24but we should care for both mother and child,
- 1:08:26both as patients.
- 1:08:26It's not that the child's more important than the mother.
- 1:08:28It's not that the mother's more important than the child.
- 1:08:30It's that we care for both patients,
- 1:08:31and healthcare professionals can do that that's when they put in the work.
- 1:08:35That's the beauty of having a pro-choice perspective is
- 1:08:37because if women want to go through that,
- 1:08:39we absolutely should be providing that's an
- 1:08:40elective abortion that you're referring to.
- 1:08:42The woman is choosing it because of,
- 1:08:44you know,
- 1:08:44her,
- 1:08:44her own personal reasons for whatever they might be.
- 1:08:46It's not that it changes her body.
- 1:08:48Again,
- 1:08:48it's not a.
- 1:08:48Simple.
- 1:08:49If someone doesn't want to go through those physiological changes,
- 1:08:52you deliver a baby,
- 1:08:53to be clear,
- 1:08:53when you have a newborn child on your hands,
- 1:08:56that changes your body too.
- 1:08:57That child needs to nurse,
- 1:08:58that child needs to something that you feed off of an adoption facility.
- 1:09:01You don't have to go through that yourself once the baby is born.
- 1:09:04When you are changing your body,
- 1:09:05that is not something that's,
- 1:09:06here's the bottom line as I see it on Parents have,
- 1:09:09parents have natural rights and natural responsibilities.
- 1:09:12A parent has a natural right and responsibility.
- 1:09:14The responsibility for a mother does include
- 1:09:17letting that child grow and not killing that child
- 1:09:19before the child can survive outside of the womb.
- 1:09:22So that is a natural responsibility.
- 1:09:24It is,
- 1:09:24and that's how we all started our life,
- 1:09:26and that's because the child has a right to live.
- 1:09:28Thank you.
- 1:09:36So,
- 1:09:37I come from the standpoint that the laws in
- 1:09:39the United States should represent the general public's opinions,
- 1:09:42and when you look at the bell curve,
- 1:09:43the majority upwards of 70% of Americans believe that we have the right to abortions
- 1:09:48up to a certain point.
- 1:09:49Everyone has a different view on when that life becomes a life,
- 1:09:53but I think that it's so wrong to only cater to the very farthest end of the bell curve.
- 1:09:57When you're when you're cutting off the rights from so many women.
- 1:10:01Whose opinions are valid and who might have so many different reasons
- 1:10:05to get an abortion,
- 1:10:06economic,
- 1:10:07just they're not in the place to have a family.
- 1:10:09There are often Supreme Court decisions that happen,
- 1:10:12that are made that do not reflect the general poll consensus of the country.
- 1:10:17And this is also the story of part of our history.
- 1:10:19Some of our worst human rights abuse as a as a country.
- 1:10:22If you had taken a poll of the deep South,
- 1:10:23you would have found.
- 1:10:24Them during the time of slavery that they were for slavery.
- 1:10:27That was horrible,
- 1:10:28right?
- 1:10:28But you don't take a poll and say,
- 1:10:29well,
- 1:10:30you,
- 1:10:30you support slavery,
- 1:10:31so slavery is just.
- 1:10:32So that's why we live in a democratic republic that also
- 1:10:34has a judicial system that also looks at what is constitutional,
- 1:10:38what is not.
- 1:10:38And abortion is unconstitutional because we have a 14th Amendment
- 1:10:42that provides equal protection under the law for all persons,
- 1:10:45regardless of the color of your skin.
- 1:10:47Mental abilities,
- 1:10:48your sex,
- 1:10:49your race,
- 1:10:50anything,
- 1:10:50you should have equal protection under the law.
- 1:10:52And the child in the womb
- 1:10:54has the same human person as a child will be when the child's born,
- 1:10:57and they deserve equal protection under the reason that Roe v.
- 1:10:59Wade was put into place though is because it was determined that it
- 1:11:01was too difficult to determine exactly when a life becomes a life.
- 1:11:04There was no poll with Roe v.
- 1:11:06Wade to say let's legalize abortion or not.
- 1:11:08It was,
- 1:11:08that was actually 9 unelected.
- 1:11:11Men on the Supreme Court,
- 1:11:127 who decided that they were going to make abortion the law of the land,
- 1:11:15and it undid the laws of many pro-life starting at conception
- 1:11:20is so unfair to the women whose lives are
- 1:11:22actually being affected by these long term decisions.
- 1:11:25I understand that from your perspective,
- 1:11:27you think that a woman should have the child no matter what
- 1:11:30because it's too difficult to decide like case to case or something.
- 1:11:34Well,
- 1:11:34and we're big advocates for adoption too,
- 1:11:36because if they feel they're not in the position to be a parent,
- 1:11:39if there's addiction or going to be born without a brain,
- 1:11:41if they're ready to,
- 1:11:42they can place the child for adoption not fair to make a woman.
- 1:11:45Go through all that and because it is permanent damage to
- 1:11:48a woman's body to bring that baby along for 9 months,
- 1:11:50just for a lot of cases,
- 1:11:52the reason that they choose an abortion is for their safety
- 1:11:55or for their long term health effects.
- 1:11:57Do you know the reason for over 90% of abortions?
- 1:12:00They have nothing to do with safety,
- 1:12:02they have nothing to do with abuse,
- 1:12:03they have nothing to do with health conditions.
- 1:12:04They're purely done,
- 1:12:05they're
- 1:12:06done for the convenience of the woman.
- 1:12:08And there's a million abortions a year,
- 1:12:09so it's hundreds of thousands of abortions that are done because the woman,
- 1:12:11the woman said it would be should be put in place.
- 1:12:15Nice to meet you.
- 1:12:16Nice to meet you.
- 1:12:17I do believe that the decision should be between a doctor and the woman
- 1:12:20because those are the people who have the best interests for the woman.
- 1:12:32I'm not really massively into debating.
- 1:12:34I'd honestly just rather hear your opinion.
- 1:12:35Thanks for being here.
- 1:12:36100%,
- 1:12:37yeah,
- 1:12:37um,
- 1:12:37because it's,
- 1:12:38it is a complex issue and I absolutely see the value of your side.
- 1:12:42I do.
- 1:12:43Um,
- 1:12:43I'm just curious then,
- 1:12:44um,
- 1:12:45if we ban it,
- 1:12:46how does that play out?
- 1:12:48Like how does that look then?
- 1:12:49Let's say we ban it today.
- 1:12:52What does the next 15 years look like?
- 1:12:54It's a really good question,
- 1:12:55and it's one we think and talk about all the time.
- 1:12:57And in pro-life states,
- 1:12:58it's ones that they're wrestling with,
- 1:12:59right,
- 1:12:59because they've banned abortion in many states in this country already,
- 1:13:02and it looks like a few things.
- 1:13:03First of all,
- 1:13:04I think we've got to double down on resources for women.
- 1:13:06There are a lot of resources that exist,
- 1:13:08but sometimes women don't know that they exist and
- 1:13:10that there's people that want to help them.
- 1:13:12A lot of women don't know,
- 1:13:13for example,
- 1:13:13that with adoption,
- 1:13:14that there are
- 1:13:15literally
- 1:13:16over a million couples who would want to adopt a newborn baby,
- 1:13:19and you can actually
- 1:13:20pick and choose the couple that would adopt.
- 1:13:22You can pick and choose
- 1:13:25how much involved you want to be in that child's life if you choose adoption
- 1:13:27or if you choose parenting,
- 1:13:29that there are a lot of organizations that want to help.
- 1:13:31In California,
- 1:13:32there are hundreds.
- 1:13:33Of pregnancy resource centers
- 1:13:35that provide free confidential care to women before and after birth.
- 1:13:39People need to know that this stuff exists so
- 1:13:41that they can get the help that they deserve.
- 1:13:43I don't,
- 1:13:43I don't actually disagree with that.
- 1:13:44My,
- 1:13:44I'm more and then also education on the trauma of abortion,
- 1:13:47the harm of abortion.
- 1:13:48I think that's also part of
- 1:13:49what's important,
- 1:13:49kind of like to balance it out,
- 1:13:50right,
- 1:13:51because right now it's,
- 1:13:51it's very much like a,
- 1:13:53I guess,
- 1:13:53abortion centric narrative where it's like that's the way to go.
- 1:13:56So you kind of want to balance it out by saying,
- 1:13:58hey,
- 1:13:58actually there's an alternate way of doing things.
- 1:14:00What I'm more curious about is abortions will continue to happen.
- 1:14:03You'd probably agree with that,
- 1:14:04even though there's a ban.
- 1:14:05Yes,
- 1:14:05there will be,
- 1:14:06and that's the thing
- 1:14:07with any ban of anything,
- 1:14:09anything,
- 1:14:10there will be still some illegal activity or things that happen.
- 1:14:13How do you want to address that?
- 1:14:15Well,
- 1:14:15I think that we need to work on helping women never choose that,
- 1:14:19you know,
- 1:14:20using free will as much as we can.
- 1:14:21They will still choose it.
- 1:14:22So for those,
- 1:14:23for those that do,
- 1:14:23I would definitely say make sure that they get good medical care.
- 1:14:26Because
- 1:14:27at the end of the day,
- 1:14:28abortion is dangerous,
- 1:14:29whether it's legal or illegal.
- 1:14:30Abortion hurts women.
- 1:14:32The ones that choose to get abortions,
- 1:14:34there needs to be,
- 1:14:35I think,
- 1:14:35good medical care for women and especially for,
- 1:14:38I'm more curious about like,
- 1:14:39because if it's a ban,
- 1:14:40then it's illegal.
- 1:14:42So are you asking who should be criminalized?
- 1:14:44I guess,
- 1:14:44yeah.
- 1:14:44Do you think that it should be?
- 1:14:45I think the abortionists should absolutely be criminalized 100%.
- 1:14:48The,
- 1:14:49the doctor or the person that's selling abortions,
- 1:14:52yes.
- 1:15:01So we were just talking about you brought up the fact that you think doctors should be
- 1:15:06um
- 1:15:07uh what was it liable if they commit abortion because it's murder in your opinion,
- 1:15:13just like there are already statutes for illegal abortion to that is what,
- 1:15:17just to be clear,
- 1:15:18there's already statutes for illegal abortion,
- 1:15:20yeah,
- 1:15:20but there's statutes against infanticide,
- 1:15:21etc.
- 1:15:22OK,
- 1:15:22anyway,
- 1:15:23but with the doctors like,
- 1:15:24so do you think the doctors should be sent to prison?
- 1:15:26Like if this is murder,
- 1:15:28why don't we treat it like murder?
- 1:15:30It should be treated because it's not.
- 1:15:31Well then,
- 1:15:31if I hired a hitman to kill my husband,
- 1:15:33I'd still go to prison even if I didn't pull the trigger.
- 1:15:35Anyone involved would you think that's a good thing or a bad thing?
- 1:15:37Well,
- 1:15:37I don't think abortion is a bad thing,
- 1:15:39so I don't think that would ever be on the table.
- 1:15:41I understand that,
- 1:15:42but I think yes,
- 1:15:43there should be penalties for people that kill
- 1:15:44other do you think should happen to me?
- 1:15:45I had an abortion when I was 19.
- 1:15:47So what in your mind,
- 1:15:49in your perfect world,
- 1:15:50what would happen to me?
- 1:15:51So if abortion were banned now,
- 1:15:52I,
- 1:15:52I wouldn't want it to be retroactive for people that had abortions in the past.
- 1:15:55No,
- 1:15:56no,
- 1:15:56no,
- 1:15:56I'm talking about,
- 1:15:56let's say I have one.
- 1:15:57Well,
- 1:15:57I think that's an important point.
- 1:15:58Like,
- 1:15:59no,
- 1:15:59no,
- 1:15:59no,
- 1:15:59if you,
- 1:15:59well,
- 1:15:59if you had an abortion and it was banned,
- 1:16:01I'm talking about now because this is who it affects,
- 1:16:03affects people now.
- 1:16:04So what do you think?
- 1:16:05If you think it's murder and you want to call it murder,
- 1:16:07why aren't you treating it like murder?
- 1:16:09So you're saying because what you do is actually villainize and shame women,
- 1:16:13and that
- 1:16:14Has ripple effects throughout society.
- 1:16:17So in this scenario you're saying if you,
- 1:16:18if abortion was banned and you went and had an abortion tomorrow,
- 1:16:21you're asking me what I think should be.
- 1:16:22Yeah,
- 1:16:22I want to know,
- 1:16:23do you think I'm a murderer?
- 1:16:24Well,
- 1:16:24here's the thing,
- 1:16:25I would want to know.
- 1:16:26Did you know that that was a baby that you were killing?
- 1:16:28Yeah,
- 1:16:29well,
- 1:16:29yeah,
- 1:16:29do you think it's a baby?
- 1:16:30I'm aware of what I'm doing.
- 1:16:31I'm,
- 1:16:31what are you doing?
- 1:16:32What are you doing?
- 1:16:33I'm,
- 1:16:34I'm not letting my pregnancy go to.
- 1:16:36But what do you think that is?
- 1:16:37Do you think you're ending the life of a human being?
- 1:16:38You know,
- 1:16:38I'm not here to I think say that.
- 1:16:39What I'm talking about right now.
- 1:16:41We're talking about the Constitution in law and in law,
- 1:16:43I don't even know if you can let me finish,
- 1:16:45it's important in our criminal statute,
- 1:16:47there's different kinds of penalties or no penalties depending on,
- 1:16:52depending on how the trimester it depends on the amount of intent,
- 1:16:57it depends on self-defense,
- 1:16:58it depends on the amount of intent that goes into the act
- 1:17:00and the amount of knowledge and freedom that goes into the act.
- 1:17:03So it's not me deciding that that would be the law,
- 1:17:05that would be the law,
- 1:17:06because the government's job is to protect human rights.
- 1:17:09And the government protects the children.
- 1:17:11The government's job is to protect human rights,
- 1:17:13and that includes the human rights of children.
- 1:17:14Just because I'm a newborn baby,
- 1:17:17it's not a child.
- 1:17:17What is it?
- 1:17:18I'm so sick of people calling it a kid when it's not a kid.
- 1:17:21It's not.
- 1:17:21What is it if it's not a child?
- 1:17:22It's a zygote.
- 1:17:23It's an embryo.
- 1:17:24It's a fucking fetus.
- 1:17:26It is not a child.
- 1:17:27I'm done.
- 1:17:27And I'm also done hearing you call women murderers.
- 1:17:30That embryo or that fetus has a mother and a father.
- 1:17:34Not if what does that make them to.
- 1:17:36That is,
- 1:17:37that's still,
- 1:17:37that's still a life.
- 1:17:38It's still a life.
- 1:17:39According to you,
- 1:17:40nobody in the your life is valuable and they're decided on when
- 1:17:43life starts.
- 1:17:44No one in the science community has decided on when life actually starts.
- 1:17:48You can open any human biology about when they come together
- 1:17:50and it will tell you at the moment of fertilization,
- 1:17:53you have a unique single cell
- 1:17:54embryo that's a unique.
- 1:17:56It still has to go through utero.
- 1:17:57It still has to go through all these phases.
- 1:17:59Well,
- 1:17:59and you looked a lot different when you were a newborn baby than you look now.
- 1:18:02We all look different at different phases in our human development.
- 1:18:04When you're a 10 week old embryo,
- 1:18:06you're supposed to look like a 10 week old embryo.
- 1:18:08You're not going to look like a newborn,
- 1:18:09you're not going to look like an adult.
- 1:18:10Human development,
- 1:18:11well,
- 1:18:12human development,
- 1:18:12you look different at different stages.
- 1:18:14Thank you,
- 1:18:15Sexy.
- 1:18:23You said that persons have equal protection under the law,
- 1:18:26and I would just say that like a fetus prior to 22 weeks is not a person.
- 1:18:29I don't want to necessarily rehash you're saying
- 1:18:31that I was rehash the entire argument,
- 1:18:33but the state doesn't have an interest in protecting a zygote at 10 weeks or 8 weeks,
- 1:18:37for example,
- 1:18:38because
- 1:18:38would you say that the First Amendment covers freedom of thought?
- 1:18:42Yes,
- 1:18:43but back to the argument they don't even have the capacity to have thoughts.
- 1:18:46So they have a,
- 1:18:48again,
- 1:18:48you know,
- 1:18:48the difference between active capacity and natural capacity.
- 1:18:51So with a natural capacity that has to do with a skill
- 1:18:53that we haven't developed yet or we're not able to develop,
- 1:18:55but we have that natural capacity due to our human nature.
- 1:18:58Active capacity,
- 1:18:59we have the skill,
- 1:18:59we're employing it,
- 1:19:00right?
- 1:19:01If you are to be employing it,
- 1:19:02I have the active capacity to jump right now,
- 1:19:04but I'm sitting in a chair.
- 1:19:05That's true.
- 1:19:05So if you're before birth,
- 1:19:06your brain isn't fully developed yet,
- 1:19:08you have a natural capacity for reason.
- 1:19:10Language and all of those things,
- 1:19:12it's not active yet.
- 1:19:13Your human,
- 1:19:14your human value is not defined by your active capacities,
- 1:19:17because if we defined human value by active capacities,
- 1:19:20somebody who was the fastest runner,
- 1:19:22had the highest IQ,
- 1:19:23was the strongest person on the block,
- 1:19:24they would be more valuable and have more human rights than
- 1:19:27the person with a disability can have a gradient of capacity,
- 1:19:29but still have a binary.
- 1:19:30Would you agree that one is not more valuable than the other?
- 1:19:32I don't agree with the premise because,
- 1:19:33for example,
- 1:19:34if I rub two sticks together,
- 1:19:35a flame is going to start eventually.
- 1:19:37After that ignition,
- 1:19:38it's a flame,
- 1:19:38whether it's a wildfire.
- 1:19:39Or a tiny spark.
- 1:19:40Prior to that,
- 1:19:41it's something else.
- 1:19:41So
- 1:19:42when you have sufficient spark,
- 1:19:43that's fire,
- 1:19:43right?
- 1:19:44Yes,
- 1:19:44and when you have the sufficient connection there's in a human embryo,
- 1:19:46that's a human.
- 1:19:47That's not the spark.
- 1:19:47When you have sufficient connections in the
- 1:19:49brain to sustain a subjective experience,
- 1:19:51that's when that spark you're arguing from a position of what I would call ableism.
- 1:19:54You're saying that until that person has a certain,
- 1:19:57because you're saying that until they have is my definition,
- 1:20:00if you'll let me finish,
- 1:20:00you're saying that
- 1:20:02that person making an accusation,
- 1:20:02you're excluding people who have the active capacity for certain abilities,
- 1:20:06and I'm saying if you have a.
- 1:20:08That is not encompassed.
- 1:20:09Well,
- 1:20:09the baby with anisephaly or hydrocephaly,
- 1:20:11we were talking about earlier,
- 1:20:12but they're do you remember what I said earlier as well,
- 1:20:14which is that if someone is a partial or potential human,
- 1:20:16they should still be protected.
- 1:20:17The reason you have an abortion,
- 1:20:19logic though,
- 1:20:19no,
- 1:20:19it doesn't.
- 1:20:20That is I value an acorn and I value an oak tree.
- 1:20:23They're not the same thing,
- 1:20:24and I would never sacrifice an acorn for an oak tree.
- 1:20:26You're saying they have the value with hydrocephaly,
- 1:20:28but then
- 1:20:29that's only after 22 weeks.
- 1:20:31But even though they lack the same,
- 1:20:32they lack the same level of value.
- 1:20:34They don't have full personhood.
- 1:20:36Good job.
- 1:20:38He
- 1:20:45You had mentioned that regardless if it is illegal or not,
- 1:20:48women are still going to get abortions.
- 1:20:50So how do you justify the fact that they'll have far less if it's illegal?
- 1:20:53The abortion rate goes down dramatically when it's illegal.
- 1:20:56They're not going to report if they're doing it illegally,
- 1:20:58because there's going to be repercussions.
- 1:20:59So why?
- 1:21:00We can prove that live births go up in states where abortion is illegal.
- 1:21:04That is
- 1:21:05the fact of what has happened after Dobbs v.
- 1:21:07Jackson and some of the trigger laws went
- 1:21:09into effect in some states made abortion illegal.
- 1:21:11So we know more women are having babies.
- 1:21:13So even with unreported illegal abortions,
- 1:21:15live births are still going up.
- 1:21:17But
- 1:21:17do you understand that people,
- 1:21:19people,
- 1:21:19when they know that abortion
- 1:21:21is illegal or that women have more difficulty receiving abortions,
- 1:21:25they're more,
- 1:21:26they're going to carry babies to term because they're out of fear
- 1:21:28of abortions.
- 1:21:29Why not?
- 1:21:30Why would you
- 1:21:31pretty much want to defund places like Planned Parenthood,
- 1:21:34places that actively help women have safe abortions,
- 1:21:37and then it further prevents miscarriages in the future.
- 1:21:39But I abortion.
- 1:21:40I really want to work against,
- 1:21:42and some of the work I'm trying to do now
- 1:21:43is
- 1:21:44work against this narrative.
- 1:21:45That gives women so much fear about children.
- 1:21:48We are,
- 1:21:49we are told to fear pregnancy,
- 1:21:50we're told to fear birth,
- 1:21:51we're told to fear being mothers,
- 1:21:53and our society also tells us to celebrate abortion.
- 1:21:56And I think that's a very anti-woman view.
- 1:21:58And I think we should flip the script on that,
- 1:22:00and instead say,
- 1:22:01actually,
- 1:22:02our superpower as women is the ability to bring life
- 1:22:04into the world and nurture men can't do that.
- 1:22:06Our superpower of women is the power to choose.
- 1:22:09That's feminism,
- 1:22:09the power of choice if you want to be a mother
- 1:22:11or you don't want to be a mother.
- 1:22:13That's feminism.
- 1:22:14If you want to be a.
- 1:22:14Home mom,
- 1:22:15you want to go to work.
- 1:22:15The difference,
- 1:22:16my friend,
- 1:22:16is this when you're pregnant,
- 1:22:17you're already a mother,
- 1:22:18and we can't deny the scientific reality of that human life.
- 1:22:22If you,
- 1:22:23that is a human life,
- 1:22:23a child,
- 1:22:24a son or a daughter that has rights too.
- 1:22:26If you force women to have pregnancies
- 1:22:29and you force women to basically change their entire life,
- 1:22:32we're not forcing the men to do that.
- 1:22:34Well,
- 1:22:34I think we should force the men to do that,
- 1:22:35frankly,
- 1:22:36great.
- 1:22:36Well,
- 1:22:36have you met a man?
- 1:22:38You think they're going to do that?
- 1:22:39They're not going to do that.
- 1:22:40They're really not.
- 1:22:41But what you're getting at,
- 1:22:42which I think is a really good point.
- 1:22:43is that we have this sort of approach in
- 1:22:46our society when it comes to sex and relationships,
- 1:22:48where
- 1:22:49men and women,
- 1:22:50and a lot of times men,
- 1:22:50I don't want to just say men do this,
- 1:22:51women do this too,
- 1:22:52where we treat this very maybe casually.
- 1:22:55We have this all backwards.
- 1:22:57Instead of looking at sex and relationships as something really beautiful,
- 1:23:00something you commit to for life,
- 1:23:01you sacrifice for the other person,
- 1:23:03you love that other person,
- 1:23:04and then if you conceive a baby,
- 1:23:06you love that baby,
- 1:23:07you fight for that baby.
- 1:23:08I think that is the view we should be moving towards as a society instead of sex being.
- 1:23:12Casual.
- 1:23:13If you get pregnant,
- 1:23:13just have an abortion.
- 1:23:14The man abandons the woman heterosexual view because we're not including
- 1:23:18queer sex in this narrative in which sometimes sex is,
- 1:23:21well,
- 1:23:21if the queer sex brings life into the world,
- 1:23:23either way,
- 1:23:23I think at the end of the day,
- 1:23:24we're still talking about human life.
- 1:23:25That's great.
- 1:23:26But also,
- 1:23:26but in this regards,
- 1:23:28in this argument,
- 1:23:28we're not,
- 1:23:29we're not giving people sexual education.
- 1:23:31If you go,
- 1:23:31if you go into Plan planned Parenthood,
- 1:23:33they not only
- 1:23:34give abortions,
- 1:23:34they also provide STD testing.
- 1:23:36They allow men into Planned Parenthood,
- 1:23:37people without health insurance.
- 1:23:38If we're talking about healthcare as a right,
- 1:23:41up.
- 1:23:45Now choose someone from the circle to debate again for another 10 minutes,
- 1:23:49but based on a claim of their choice.
- 1:23:51I,
- 1:23:51there's several of you I'd love to keep talking to,
- 1:23:53so I really appreciate everyone doing this.
- 1:23:54It's awesome.
- 1:23:55Um,
- 1:23:56I actually would love to chat more with Dana.
- 1:23:57I think she's
- 1:23:59behind me.
- 1:24:06I chose Dana because I didn't feel like we actually got to have the conversation.
- 1:24:10I got to hear from Dana about some of your position and why your belief,
- 1:24:14what you believe.
- 1:24:15I didn't really feel like we got to dialogue about that a lot,
- 1:24:17so I'd love to do that more,
- 1:24:18and I'd also love to hear what your
- 1:24:20claim would be that you want to talk about as well.
- 1:24:22So my claim is that
- 1:24:24um
- 1:24:25my bodily autonomy
- 1:24:28is the prevailing right
- 1:24:30in this debate.
- 1:24:32Thank you.
- 1:24:32And I feel like that's something that's come back up again and again
- 1:24:34in the conversation as a through a through theme that we're having.
- 1:24:38So,
- 1:24:38I hear what you're saying.
- 1:24:39I agree that
- 1:24:41we have bodily autonomy.
- 1:24:42I have the right to not someone to come and hit me,
- 1:24:44hurt me,
- 1:24:45etc.
- 1:24:46But there's a very unique relationship when a
- 1:24:48woman is pregnant with another human life,
- 1:24:50with another body,
- 1:24:52and that's her son or her daughter.
- 1:24:53Whether she
- 1:24:54wanted to get pregnant,
- 1:24:55intended to get pregnant,
- 1:24:56when she's pregnant,
- 1:24:57there's that unique relationship that springs into
- 1:24:59existence with the existence of that new.
- 1:25:01Human life.
- 1:25:02And a few times it's been said today,
- 1:25:03well,
- 1:25:03the science doesn't matter.
- 1:25:04We're just having my,
- 1:25:05my opinion,
- 1:25:06my personal story.
- 1:25:07The science does matter a lot
- 1:25:08because science can help tell us what is real and what is not real.
- 1:25:12And science does tell us when human life begins,
- 1:25:14and it doesn't magically begin at birth.
- 1:25:17Human life begins before birth and human
- 1:25:19life begins at the moment of fertilization.
- 1:25:21And so,
- 1:25:21well,
- 1:25:21I'm all for bodily autonomy.
- 1:25:23I believe that our bodily autonomy as women ends
- 1:25:26where another human being's life begins.
- 1:25:29And when I'm pregnant,
- 1:25:30there's another body inside my body,
- 1:25:32and they deserve.
- 1:25:32deserve the right to live.
- 1:25:34And yes,
- 1:25:34that's going to mean maybe a few months of me
- 1:25:37trying to hopefully take care of my body because it's feeding that body,
- 1:25:40and then delivering that child.
- 1:25:41And if I feel I can't parent,
- 1:25:42then there's other options.
- 1:25:44But I still have a responsibility not to kill
- 1:25:47that child via an abortion.
- 1:25:48So,
- 1:25:49I'm,
- 1:25:49I'm going to tell you a story.
- 1:25:50Um,
- 1:25:51so,
- 1:25:51I am a mother.
- 1:25:52Um,
- 1:25:52I have a 22-year-old son,
- 1:25:54um,
- 1:25:55who has autism,
- 1:25:56um,
- 1:25:56and I became pregnant,
- 1:25:58um,
- 1:25:59when he was around 6 years old.
- 1:26:01Um,
- 1:26:01and I didn't want to have that child,
- 1:26:03and so I had an abortion,
- 1:26:05um,
- 1:26:06and
- 1:26:07I had an abortion when I was about 6 weeks alone,
- 1:26:11um,
- 1:26:11because it wasn't a child,
- 1:26:13it was a mass of cells,
- 1:26:15um,
- 1:26:15and I made that decision very distinctly,
- 1:26:18um,
- 1:26:18I didn't have any,
- 1:26:20um.
- 1:26:20I didn't have any regrets about that decision.
- 1:26:23I actually didn't have a lot of
- 1:26:26debate about that decision.
- 1:26:27I had a child where
- 1:26:29I lived in an estate where we didn't have an insurance mandate,
- 1:26:33so I was working really hard to get my son the the help that he needed
- 1:26:37with his autism,
- 1:26:38um,
- 1:26:38and I did not want to be pregnant.
- 1:26:41Um,
- 1:26:41I was in a relationship.
- 1:26:43We made a choice
- 1:26:45because,
- 1:26:45because that was,
- 1:26:47that was a choice that I made
- 1:26:49for the mass of cells that was in my body.
- 1:26:52I totally hear you're saying,
- 1:26:53and I,
- 1:26:54and I need you to understand
- 1:26:56that
- 1:26:57it wasn't about what am I killing,
- 1:27:00what am I keeping alive.
- 1:27:01It was what was best
- 1:27:04for my body,
- 1:27:06because I then would have had to carry that child to term.
- 1:27:10And I also want you to know that when I had my child,
- 1:27:14um,
- 1:27:15I am a black woman in this world,
- 1:27:17and my birth
- 1:27:19was,
- 1:27:20was actually very dangerous,
- 1:27:22as was many of the women in my family,
- 1:27:24because black women don't get the same type of health care that you receive.
- 1:27:29I'd love to respond to what you're saying.
- 1:27:30I think it's absolutely horrible that women,
- 1:27:33because of the color of their skin,
- 1:27:34are not getting good healthcare.
- 1:27:35I think that's ridiculous and horrible.
- 1:27:37So
- 1:27:37we are aligned on that.
- 1:27:39Um,
- 1:27:40when you talk about your baby and you saw that baby as a clump of cells,
- 1:27:43you said it wasn't a baby to you,
- 1:27:44it wasn't a child,
- 1:27:45and you had that abortion,
- 1:27:46you have no regrets.
- 1:27:47Our
- 1:27:48feelings or our beliefs about other people
- 1:27:52don't change that other person,
- 1:27:54that other human's value.
- 1:27:56So I could have feelings or beliefs about my son,
- 1:27:58about a person I walk past down the street,
- 1:28:01about anybody in this room,
- 1:28:03but that doesn't change whether they're good feelings,
- 1:28:05bad feelings,
- 1:28:05good beliefs,
- 1:28:06bad beliefs.
- 1:28:07That doesn't change that person's innate human value.
- 1:28:10And they have innate human value,
- 1:28:11not because of their capacities,
- 1:28:13not because of their abilities.
- 1:28:14But because of their innate human nature that we all share,
- 1:28:17and human nature doesn't start at birth,
- 1:28:19doesn't start a few weeks or even a month before birth.
- 1:28:22It starts at the beginning of a human person's life,
- 1:28:24which is fertilization.
- 1:28:26But that,
- 1:28:26but that's your,
- 1:28:27but that's your opinion.
- 1:28:28So there,
- 1:28:28there isn't actually scientific evidence
- 1:28:31that states
- 1:28:32that human life begins at conception.
- 1:28:35There is a tremendous amount of scientific evidence that
- 1:28:37shows that if you open any human biology textbook,
- 1:28:40you're going to find
- 1:28:41that.
- 1:28:41The development process begins with fertilization of the human life it says
- 1:28:45is that and also if you're an in vitro fertilization clinic,
- 1:28:48if you're a technician,
- 1:28:49there is cell multiplication,
- 1:28:52but it's not just any cell multiplication because you're made of cells,
- 1:28:55right?
- 1:28:55I'm made of cells,
- 1:28:56right?
- 1:28:56OK.
- 1:28:56You're,
- 1:28:57you and I are clumps of cells,
- 1:28:58right?
- 1:28:58100%.
- 1:28:59But we're unique clumps of cells.
- 1:29:01We're individual clumps of cells that constitute a whole human.
- 1:29:04And at the moment of fertilization,
- 1:29:05you know what you got?
- 1:29:06You got a whole human.
- 1:29:07They're very small,
- 1:29:08but you have a
- 1:29:08Who human that just needs,
- 1:29:10you have a whole human at the moment of fertilization
- 1:29:12that just needs time and nourishment to grow,
- 1:29:14but has a unique genetic distinction,
- 1:29:16distinct from the mother that way.
- 1:29:18So for example you could miscarry,
- 1:29:19yes.
- 1:29:20But that's still a loss of the,
- 1:29:21that's still a human being,
- 1:29:22but when I had my miscarriage,
- 1:29:24um,
- 1:29:24I had,
- 1:29:25I had a clump of cells,
- 1:29:27um,
- 1:29:28that then grew
- 1:29:30and then did not grow into a human child.
- 1:29:33I have a,
- 1:29:34I have a question for you.
- 1:29:35Did you see You have a son.
- 1:29:36How old is he now?
- 1:29:3722.
- 1:29:38I am.
- 1:29:38He's 20.
- 1:29:390 my goodness,
- 1:29:40you look great,
- 1:29:41by the way.
- 1:29:42I have a question.
- 1:29:42Did you,
- 1:29:43I'm just curious because you're talking about the baby you miscarried,
- 1:29:45the baby you had the abortion of,
- 1:29:47and you called them clumps of cells.
- 1:29:48Did you see
- 1:29:50your son when he was unborn as a clump of cells,
- 1:29:51or did you consider him in your mind as a,
- 1:29:53as a,
- 1:29:53as a son,
- 1:29:54as I didn't consider him a clump of cells.
- 1:29:56You did or you didn't.
- 1:29:57I did,
- 1:29:57absolutely.
- 1:29:58So so for you,
- 1:29:59you didn't really feel connected to even him until he was born.
- 1:30:03So I knew that until he was actually out of
- 1:30:07my body that there was that there was not necessarily
- 1:30:11um a live birth that was going to happen
- 1:30:14because I lost a child
- 1:30:16and I understood
- 1:30:18that
- 1:30:19having a pregnancy does not mean that you have a live birth
- 1:30:23and a baby at the end of that is absolutely true.
- 1:30:25And so for me
- 1:30:28that
- 1:30:29that choice.
- 1:30:30About what is happening to my body that were you sad after the miscarriage?
- 1:30:34I'm just curious,
- 1:30:34or were you kind of felt fine afterwards,
- 1:30:37because I had a miscarriage too.
- 1:30:38I felt deeply sad,
- 1:30:40sad by it.
- 1:30:40So I,
- 1:30:41I was women feel differently.
- 1:30:42I was ambivalent.
- 1:30:44I was,
- 1:30:44I was not ready to have a child,
- 1:30:47um,
- 1:30:47and I was going through a divorce at the time.
- 1:30:50Yeah,
- 1:30:51no,
- 1:30:51it sucked.
- 1:30:51It sucked.
- 1:30:52But also,
- 1:30:53but also it was,
- 1:30:54it was OK
- 1:30:56because.
- 1:30:57I was not ready to be at that point and I didn't even make that decision.
- 1:31:01So here's my body made here's the thing for me.
- 1:31:03I hear everything you're saying,
- 1:31:04but here's the reality.
- 1:31:05You're,
- 1:31:05you're strong.
- 1:31:06You are the one,
- 1:31:07when you're pregnant,
- 1:31:07if I get pregnant,
- 1:31:08I've been pregnant now 4 times,
- 1:31:10I'm more powerful than that baby,
- 1:31:11right,
- 1:31:12because I have the power to
- 1:31:14talk,
- 1:31:14walk,
- 1:31:14do whatever I'm going to do,
- 1:31:15and that baby is completely dependent on me,
- 1:31:17right?
- 1:31:17And even when there's a newborn,
- 1:31:19totally dependent
- 1:31:20on everybody around them,
- 1:31:21if not their biological mother,
- 1:31:22whoever they're handed off to,
- 1:31:23right?
- 1:31:24It's,
- 1:31:25it's incredibly important
- 1:31:26for rule of law,
- 1:31:27for justice,
- 1:31:28for human rights
- 1:31:29that we
- 1:31:29are especially careful to protect the rights of those that are dependent and weak,
- 1:31:33because if we live in a society that just says the
- 1:31:35strong get to choose what they want because they can,
- 1:31:38that's not a just or a loving society.
- 1:31:40And that's why I'm so pro-life.
- 1:31:41I'm so pro-life because that baby,
- 1:31:43you're right,
- 1:31:44they're totally dependent on the mother.
- 1:31:46They're completely unable to defend themselves,
- 1:31:48speak for themselves,
- 1:31:49and that's all the more reason why we as a civil and just society.
- 1:31:54care about their
- 1:31:55right to live and by the way,
- 1:31:56help that mother.
- 1:31:57It goes 2 and 2,
- 1:31:58right?
- 1:31:58Because you can't just care for the baby and not care for the mother.
- 1:32:01You've got to care for them both.
- 1:32:02And when that is a viable life outside of my body,
- 1:32:06100%.
- 1:32:07Well,
- 1:32:07we should care at the beginning of human development.
- 1:32:09That's my,
- 1:32:10that's my position.
- 1:32:12And and women who are pregnant need extra care too.
- 1:32:13It's not like you just get care when the baby's born.
- 1:32:15You should get extra care before,
- 1:32:17they do,
- 1:32:17because you're carrying a new life.
- 1:32:19While that is still in my body,
- 1:32:21this is my body.
- 1:32:23And that is my choice about what happens
- 1:32:26to the things that are in my body.
- 1:32:28That is the choice.
- 1:32:29Here's a question for you.
- 1:32:30Your,
- 1:32:31your womb,
- 1:32:31what is the,
- 1:32:32what is the womb designed for?
- 1:32:34A woman's uterus?
- 1:32:34What's it designed for?
- 1:32:35It is designed to,
- 1:32:37um,
- 1:32:37carry a,
- 1:32:39a clump of cells
- 1:32:40to eventually,
- 1:32:42um,
- 1:32:43sometimes
- 1:32:44grow a,
- 1:32:45a,
- 1:32:45a fetus.
- 1:32:46And how did you start your life before birth?
- 1:32:49Where were you?
- 1:32:51Oh gosh,
- 1:32:52I don't know.
- 1:32:53Come on,
- 1:32:53you know,
- 1:32:54where were you before you were born?
- 1:32:56Um,
- 1:32:56I was in my mother's,
- 1:32:57um,
- 1:32:58egg sack.
- 1:32:59OK.
- 1:32:59You were in your mother's egg sack.
- 1:33:00You mean you were in her uterus,
- 1:33:01right?
- 1:33:02No,
- 1:33:02I was in my mother's egg sack in her,
- 1:33:03in her,
- 1:33:04well,
- 1:33:05actual,
- 1:33:05well,
- 1:33:05that wasn't you yet.
- 1:33:07An egg is not you.
- 1:33:08The egg
- 1:33:09was a fertilizer was a part of me.
- 1:33:11And then
- 1:33:12the other part of me was in my,
- 1:33:14my dad's,
- 1:33:15I guess,
- 1:33:15testicles,
- 1:33:16so.
- 1:33:17I mean it wasn't,
- 1:33:18it wasn't you yet because you is when there's a whole human,
- 1:33:22right,
- 1:33:22and a unique individual genetic identity.
- 1:33:25Well,
- 1:33:26but the science shows,
- 1:33:27come on,
- 1:33:27the science shows at the moment of fertilization,
- 1:33:29sperm egg fusion,
- 1:33:30you have unique,
- 1:33:31that's when
- 1:33:32it does show that you have unique individual
- 1:33:34genetic identity that's distinct from your parents.
- 1:33:36That when an egg is fertilized,
- 1:33:38that there is cell multiplication,
- 1:33:41but that does not kind of cell multiplication.
- 1:33:42It's not like skin cells.
- 1:33:44Well,
- 1:33:45it's not skin cells.
- 1:33:45What is it?
- 1:33:46It becomes skin cells.
- 1:33:47Well,
- 1:33:48it develops its skin eventually,
- 1:33:49but what is it?
- 1:33:50What is it?
- 1:33:50Come on.
- 1:33:51What is it?
- 1:33:51It's a massive cells,
- 1:33:53but what is it?
- 1:33:54It's a human embryo,
- 1:33:55right?
- 1:33:55Well,
- 1:33:56yes,
- 1:33:57that's developing rapidly but it is a clump of we already said we are clumps of cells,
- 1:34:01so you're kind of using that pejoratively like,
- 1:34:03oh,
- 1:34:03you're a clump of cells,
- 1:34:03you can be aborted,
- 1:34:04you can be miscarried,
- 1:34:05it doesn't matter who cares.
- 1:34:06You and I are clumps of cells,
- 1:34:07so it's a little dehumanizing.
- 1:34:09You're being a little dehumanizing.
- 1:34:10Yes,
- 1:34:10I am being dehumanizing because it is a clump of cells,
- 1:34:13but we are clumps of cells.
- 1:34:14We already,
- 1:34:15you acknowledge that.
- 1:34:16So you're not wanting to dehumanize us,
- 1:34:18right?
- 1:34:19Why wouldn't you dehumanize us that term,
- 1:34:22but you dehumanize actually outside of my body.
- 1:34:25There are no rights
- 1:34:27because if there were my friends,
- 1:34:29but I keep asking you why there were and
- 1:34:31you keep saying just because it's in your body,
- 1:34:34why does that would already be laws on the books,
- 1:34:37and currently there are no laws on the books
- 1:34:40that say that anything that happens before
- 1:34:44that birth
- 1:34:45means that
- 1:34:46they are not actually
- 1:34:47alive.
- 1:34:48That's actually.
- 1:34:48accurate.
- 1:34:49So even in states like California,
- 1:34:51there's such a thing.
- 1:34:52There,
- 1:34:52there has been such a thing until recently,
- 1:34:54in the last two years,
- 1:34:55as illegal abortions.
- 1:34:56Are you aware of that?
- 1:34:57So,
- 1:34:57even in states that are blue states,
- 1:35:00there are illegal abortions where it says,
- 1:35:01yes,
- 1:35:02before birth,
- 1:35:02there is a,
- 1:35:03this is a person that has some rights,
- 1:35:05and we're going to protect them.
- 1:35:06And similarly,
- 1:35:07if you're Scott Peterson,
- 1:35:09one other example.
- 1:35:10It's about the medical procedure.
- 1:35:12Another example.
- 1:35:13Here's another example.
- 1:35:13Scott Peterson,
- 1:35:14he killed his pregnant wife Lacey and their unborn son Connor.
- 1:35:19Connor,
- 1:35:19in your view,
- 1:35:19was just a clump of cells.
- 1:35:20He wasn't burned yet,
- 1:35:22but his dad killed him.
- 1:35:23Should he have been penalized for killing both his wife and
- 1:35:27the pregnant
- 1:35:29part of his wife,
- 1:35:29the baby,
- 1:35:30the boy,
- 1:35:31his son Connor?
- 1:35:32No,
- 1:35:33so you think Scott Peterson should have got off scot-free
- 1:35:36Peterson for killing his 8 month old unborn son.
- 1:35:39Scott Peterson should have been
- 1:35:41penalized for killing his live
- 1:35:44wife,
- 1:35:45but not Connor.
- 1:35:46She had,
- 1:35:46Connor had no right.
- 1:35:47Connor was not alive.
- 1:35:48So if I,
- 1:35:49Connor,
- 1:35:50was in her body,
- 1:35:51so if I'm a woman,
- 1:35:52so if a woman,
- 1:35:53her boyfriend,
- 1:35:54and was not
- 1:35:55a human being with rights
- 1:35:58on this planet,
- 1:35:59this is very dark because you're saying.
- 1:36:00If a woman
- 1:36:01is pregnant and her boyfriend slips drugs into her her drink
- 1:36:05to force an abortion on her,
- 1:36:07she wants to have this baby.
- 1:36:09He puts drugs in her drink.
- 1:36:10Would you say that there should be no penalties for that
- 1:36:12man and what he did to her against the mother?
- 1:36:15But you just said the baby is not born yet,
- 1:36:17so it has no rights against the mother's body,
- 1:36:19not against that.
- 1:36:20What if it that child does not have rights?
- 1:36:23It's just a drug designed to kill the baby.
- 1:36:25It's just designed to kill the baby in her womb,
- 1:36:26but it's designed.
- 1:36:28To harm the tissue that is in her body
- 1:36:31because that's her body.
- 1:36:32So you're saying it would have been wrong.
- 1:36:34Scott Peterson should have been given penalties for killing Connor,
- 1:36:38for harming Lacey,
- 1:36:40but not for harming Connor,
- 1:36:41for harming Lacey.
- 1:36:42So if a man,
- 1:36:42Connor is a part of Lacey,
- 1:36:44then it's harming Lacey.
- 1:36:45So if a man kills his girlfriend's unborn baby,
- 1:36:50he should not be penalized for killing the unborn baby,
- 1:36:52only for harmed in some way harming her.
- 1:36:55That's time.
- 1:36:57Thank you.
- 1:36:57Thank you so much.
- 1:36:59I appreciate
- 1:37:00it.
- 1:37:04I mean I thought it was great
- 1:37:05um I really appreciated everyone coming and
- 1:37:08giving it their best.
- 1:37:09I mean I think we all tried to have conversations that were meaningful and I
- 1:37:13mean I think this is the most important issue that we're facing as a country.
- 1:37:16I thought it was really interesting,
- 1:37:17uh,
- 1:37:18myself as a mother to talk to another mother.
- 1:37:20Um,
- 1:37:21who's on the other side of this.
- 1:37:22I was disappointed though that I,
- 1:37:24I didn't hear any arguments I hadn't heard
- 1:37:27before just doing this activism for seven years.
- 1:37:29I wasn't going to change her mind and she wasn't going to change my mind,
- 1:37:33which is often the frustration going into these.
- 1:37:35Do you need me to be PG-13 or no?
- 1:37:38OK,
- 1:37:38because I think Lyla's a,
- 1:37:40she is OK with holding a 10 year old down and making them give birth,
- 1:37:43like she's gross.
- 1:37:45That's what I think of Lyla.
- 1:37:46There were some women that shared that they had had abortions.
- 1:37:49Obviously that can be really raw.
- 1:37:51I think that goes to one of the things that we
- 1:37:54try to spread awareness about,
- 1:37:55which is that abortion does hurt women,
- 1:37:57that abortion leaves trauma.
- 1:37:58Honestly,
- 1:37:59I wanted to swing.
- 1:38:01I really wanted to swing.
- 1:38:02Your whole lack of empathy and you telling me
- 1:38:04that my child should be standing right here,
- 1:38:07like,
- 1:38:07I promised you we could have gotten Jerry
- 1:38:08Springer real quick if y'all had allowed it.
- 1:38:10You absolutely know nothing of this experience,
- 1:38:12which is why I like that a lot of the black
- 1:38:13and brown women really got in her face about that.
- 1:38:15She felt like
- 1:38:16she had no choice.
- 1:38:17She was saying I was drug addicted or she,
- 1:38:19I don't remember all the details of her story,
- 1:38:20but if you felt like you had to have
- 1:38:21this abortion because of domestic violence and poverty,
- 1:38:24is that really a choice?
- 1:38:25So I firmly believe that Dana and Zeke.
- 1:38:27We're the strongest,
- 1:38:29uh,
- 1:38:29debaters in this.
- 1:38:30Mason's really well informed.
- 1:38:32Mason's really smart.
- 1:38:33Two that really stood out to me were,
- 1:38:35uh,
- 1:38:35Cici
- 1:38:36and Dana,
- 1:38:37Ms.
- 1:38:37Dana,
- 1:38:38hands down,
- 1:38:38just to see someone who had been
- 1:38:41through what I had been through but older and having that
- 1:38:45wisdom,
- 1:38:45having that patience,
- 1:38:47being able to have an opportunity to push back
- 1:38:50against a narrative that is harmful,
- 1:38:52um,
- 1:38:53to people with uteruses,
- 1:38:54I think is.
- 1:38:55Always a valuable space.
- 1:38:57Is there a middle ground where abortion is OK in some circumstances?
- 1:39:01I would say no,
- 1:39:01these are lives,
- 1:39:02human lives,
- 1:39:03and it's life or death for that child.
- 1:39:05I don't know that there will ever be a middle ground because
- 1:39:08what I'm talking about is health care
- 1:39:11and what she's talking about
- 1:39:12is her emotions.
- 1:39:14Honestly and truly,
- 1:39:15yes,
- 1:39:15we can find a middle ground,
- 1:39:17but there has to be a lot
- 1:39:19less shaming from pro.
- 1:39:22Life people,
- 1:39:23because
- 1:39:23I'm not,
- 1:39:24I don't care what you say,
- 1:39:25I'm not a murderer for choosing
- 1:39:27myself,
- 1:39:27and honestly and truly I believe it was her children in this situation,
- 1:39:30she'd have a completely different tone.
- 1:39:32They often do.
- 1:39:33I think it's incredibly important to have
- 1:39:35conversations with people that you disagree with,
- 1:39:37and so I'm really grateful for everyone that came today and I'd,
- 1:39:39I'd love to do it again.
- 1:39:41Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:39:44your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:39:46And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:39:48subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.