Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 📈Robinhood (HOOD) Business Model, Financial, Valuation, Risk Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're really digging into
- 0:03Robin Hood to name everyone knows, right conjures up those
- 0:06images of Commission free trading, meme stocks, maybe a
- 0:09bit of controversy to. Our mission here is to go beyond
- 0:13the headlines, really unpack Robin Hood's whole financial
- 0:16journey. We want to understand the
- 0:17business model, the risks they've navigated, how they
- 0:20actually became profitable and what the numbers are telling us
- 0:23now about where they might be headed.
- 0:25We've got a stack of sources, financial analysis, performance
- 0:27metrics, the whole deal. Yeah.
- 0:29And what's really interesting, I think, is how they just
- 0:31completely shook up the brokerage industry, made
- 0:34investing accessible, but then faced this wave of scrutiny.
- 0:37And now it seems like they're finding their feet again.
- 0:40We're going to look at the metrics that really tell that
- 0:42whole story, OK? So let's start right there with
- 0:45the model, this famous freemium approach, How did they pull off
- 0:48Commission free trading? I mean, that sounded almost
- 0:51impossible at 1st and it brought in millions of users, especially
- 0:54younger people, beginners. What was the actual mechanic?
- 0:57Well, the secret, if you want to call it that, was that it wasn't
- 1:00really free for Robin Hood, just for the user making the trade.
- 1:03The main engine historically, especially like back in early
- 1:062021 was something called Payment for Order flow PFOF that
- 1:11accounted for over 70% of their revenue back then.
- 1:14TFOF. OK, explain that a bit more.
- 1:16How does that work? Basically, they route your buy
- 1:19and sell orders to market makers, these big trading firms,
- 1:22and those firms pay Robin Hood a tiny fraction of a cent for each
- 1:26share traded for sending that order flow their way.
- 1:28It's kind of like a rebate system happening behind the
- 1:31scenes. OK, so a revenue stream that
- 1:33most users probably weren't even aware of, but surely that wasn't
- 1:36the only way they made money. No, not at all.
- 1:38And this is where things get really interesting, especially
- 1:40recently. The other huge piece is net
- 1:42interest income. This actually became their
- 1:44number one revenue source in 2023, overtaking PFOF by a
- 1:48significant margin. Net interest income.
- 1:51So like what banks do? Exactly like what banks do.
- 1:54They earn interest on the cash balances users hold in their
- 1:57accounts but haven't invested yet.
- 1:59They also earn interest from lending out securities to short
- 2:02sellers and on margin loans people take out.
- 2:05Then they subtract their own interest expenses, and this part
- 2:08just surged primarily because interest rates went up so much.
- 2:11Right, the Fed raising rates. Precisely that pushed this
- 2:14category to almost 50% of their total revenue in 2023.
- 2:18And that's a huge shift. You know, it signals they're
- 2:20moving away from relying solely on how much people trade, which
- 2:23can be volatile, towards a more stable almost bank like income.
- 2:27That really changes the narrative, doesn't it?
- 2:29Makes them seem less like just a trading app and more like a
- 2:32broader financial platform. So their fate is now much more
- 2:35tied to interest rates in the wider economy.
- 2:37Definitely, and they're leaning into that.
- 2:39They have other revenue streams growing too.
- 2:41There's Robin Hood Gold, that's their subscription. 5 bucks a
- 2:43month for premium features like higher interest on cash, bigger
- 2:46instant deposits, margin investing access.
- 2:49And people are signing up for that.
- 2:50Oh yeah, Gold subscribers grew really fast.
- 2:53By Q12025 they had about 3.2 million, which is what, maybe
- 2:5712.4% of all their funded customers.
- 3:00Plus they've launched things like the Robin Hood Cash card
- 3:02and they're planning a gold card.
- 3:04It's all about getting more of the customers financial life
- 3:06their wallet share. And what about the user base
- 3:08itself? The sources mentioned 25.2
- 3:11million funded accounts by the end of 2024, about 11,000,000
- 3:14active monthly. How does that connect with
- 3:17things like assets under custody AUC hitting $193 billion and
- 3:22this average revenue per user ARPU doubling to $164 in 2024?
- 3:27Well. It paints a clear picture.
- 3:28The strategy shifted. It wasn't just about getting
- 3:30more users anymore, it became about getting more revenue from
- 3:33the users. They already had that doubling
- 3:35ARP. That's the higher interest
- 3:36income kicking in. It's the gold subscriptions.
- 3:38They're successfully deepening the relationship, making each
- 3:40user much more valuable to the company.
- 3:42OK, that makes sense, but it hasn't all been smooth sailing.
- 3:46Robin Hood's journey has definitely hit some rough
- 3:48patches. What were some of those short
- 3:50term headwinds they had to deal with?
- 3:52Things like market slowdowns maybe?
- 3:54That crypto revenue drop in 2022 looked pretty sharp, down 52%.
- 3:59You're absolutely right, volatility cuts both ways for
- 4:01them. When markets are slow or retail
- 4:04trading cools off, their PFOF income takes a hit.
- 4:08That 52% drop in crypto revenue in 22 that was directly tied to
- 4:11the crypto winter, the big downturn right?
- 4:14But then when you get crazy periods like the meme stock
- 4:17frenzy or a crypto rally, their volumes explode and revenue
- 4:21spikes. But you can't build a stable
- 4:23business on those unpredictable waves.
- 4:25And as we just talked about, high interest rates help their
- 4:27net interest income. But if rates fall significantly,
- 4:30that could really squeeze those margins.
- 4:32It's a double edged sword. So those are the cyclical
- 4:34things. What about the bigger, maybe
- 4:35more structural risks, the ones that could fundamentally
- 4:37threaten the whole model long term?
- 4:39Yeah, there are definitely some big ones.
- 4:41The most talked about is the regulatory risk around payment
- 4:43for order flow. Regulators, especially the SEC,
- 4:46have serious concerns about potential conflicts of interest.
- 4:49Does routing orders for payment mean customers don't get the
- 4:52absolute best price? And they already got fined for
- 4:54that. Right.
- 4:54They did a $65 million SEC fine back in 2020 related to
- 4:58disclosures around PFOF and execution quality.
- 5:01If regulators decide to ban PFOF entirely, or even just curb it
- 5:05significantly, maybe force orders into auctions, that would
- 5:08fundamentally alter Robin Hood's economics.
- 5:10It's a major overhang. OK, what else?
- 5:13Competition must be fierce now. Absolutely fierce.
- 5:15When Robin Hood came out with Commission free, the big guys
- 5:18like Schwab, Fidelity, they eventually followed suit.
- 5:20So that unique selling point is gone.
- 5:22Now they're competing head on. And those established players
- 5:24have, you know, wider product sets, maybe more trust for
- 5:27wealthier, more sophisticated investors.
- 5:29Retaining users as they graduate is a real challenge for Robin
- 5:32Hood. And Speaking of trust, that
- 5:34GameStop incident in January 2021 when they restricted
- 5:38trading, that caused a massive backlash, didn't it?
- 5:41Oh, huge, huge outcry. They said it was due to clearing
- 5:45house deposit requirements skyrocketing overnight because
- 5:48of the volatility. Basically a plumbing issue.
- 5:50But for users who felt locked out of trades and for
- 5:53politicians looking closely, it looked terrible.
- 5:55It really damaged the reputation, raised questions
- 5:58about whether they were on the side of the retail trader.
- 6:00That plus some earlier platform outages, like a bad one in March
- 6:032020, definitely created trust issues they've had to work hard
- 6:06to overcome. So navigating all that, how did
- 6:10they manage on the cost side? A company growing that fast,
- 6:13then hitting headwinds, facing fines, It must have been tough
- 6:16to control spending. What does their cost structure
- 6:18look like? It's a mix.
- 6:20They have significant fixed costs, the technology platform,
- 6:22all the engineers, compliance staff, office space.
- 6:25Those costs ballooned as they grew rapidly through 2021,
- 6:28hitting like $3.46 billion in operating expenses that year.
- 6:31Yeah, but here's where they showed some discipline in 2022.
- 6:34Facing the market downturn, they cut costs aggressively, layoffs
- 6:38impacting around 29% of staff. I believe that really helped
- 6:41right size the ship and it paid off.
- 6:43By 2024, they achieved a pretty healthy operating margin of
- 6:46about 35.8%. It shows they can adjust their
- 6:49spending when needed. OK.
- 6:50So they can be lean when necessary.
- 6:52Now who's making these decisions?
- 6:54Who's actually steering the company?
- 6:56We know Vlad Tenef, the Co founder is CEO.
- 6:59Who else is key on the leadership team?
- 7:01Right. Tenev is still CEO and
- 7:02president. He's been there since the
- 7:04beginning. Co founded it in 2013.
- 7:06But they've brought in some heavy hitters too.
- 7:08Jason Warnick, the CFO came over from Amazon back in 2018, brings
- 7:12that big tech operational finance experience.
- 7:15And very importantly, Dan Gallagher is their chief legal
- 7:17and compliance officer. He's a former SEC commissioner.
- 7:20Oh interesting. Bringing the regulator inside,
- 7:22essentially. Exactly.
- 7:23That signals a real shift towards prioritizing compliance
- 7:26and navigating that complex regulatory landscape.
- 7:29It's a mix of the founders vision and seasoned operational
- 7:31and legal expertise. Now what about governance?
- 7:34I've heard about this dual class share structure.
- 7:37How does that work? And, well, how does it square
- 7:39with their whole democratizing finance mantra?
- 7:42Seems a bit undemocratic for their own shareholders.
- 7:46That's a really sharp point and it's a common criticism.
- 7:48The way it works is Tenev and the other Co founder by UPOT own
- 7:53Class B shares. Everyone else owns Class A.
- 7:55The Class B shares have 10 times the voting power of Class A
- 7:58shares. 10 * 10 times. So even though together they
- 8:00only own maybe 13% of the total company equity, they control
- 8:04something like 64% of the total voting power.
- 8:06Wow, so they effectively have complete control over major
- 8:09decisions, board elections, everything.
- 8:10Pretty much the argument for it is that it allows the founders
- 8:14to maintain long term strategic focus without being swayed by
- 8:17short term market pressures. But you know, the counter
- 8:19arguments is exactly what you said.
- 8:21It significantly limits the influence of ordinary Class A
- 8:23shareholders. So looking at their track
- 8:25record, especially with those past controversies, the outages,
- 8:28GameStop, have they actually learned?
- 8:31Has the leadership shown they can manage the company
- 8:33effectively now or is it still a bit move fast and break things?
- 8:36I think the consensus is that they have learned, though,
- 8:39perhaps the hard way. Those early lapses like the
- 8:42March 2020 outage and the GameStop restrictions were
- 8:45definitely bad, and they led to big fines, like that $70 million
- 8:49penalty from Fiara in 2021. But since then, management has
- 8:53demonstrably shored things out. They raised billions in
- 8:56emergency capital during the GameStop saga.
- 8:58They've massively increased customer support staff.
- 9:00They've improved their risk management systems and they are
- 9:02generally much more transparent now.
- 9:04It really does feel like a shift from the early startup days to a
- 9:07more mature compliance aware company.
- 9:10OK. So maybe a change in philosophy
- 9:12and are they aligned with shareholders now?
- 9:14I remember some noise about potential dilution from big
- 9:16stock awards early on. Yeah, but that's another
- 9:18interesting point. I mean, fundamentally the
- 9:20founders fortunes are tied to the stock price since they own
- 9:23so many shares. But a really significant move
- 9:26and kind of surprising was back in 2021, they actually cancelled
- 9:30a massive stock award plan for themselves precisely because of
- 9:33concerns about diluting existing shareholders.
- 9:36They. Cancelled their own bonuses.
- 9:37Effectively, yes, it created a big one time accounting charge,
- 9:41but it signaled they were listening to shareholder
- 9:43concerns. And then more recently, they
- 9:45started a share buyback program, started with $1 billion in 2022,
- 9:50expanded it to $1.5 billion in early 2025.
- 9:55For a company that was all about growth, growth, growth, starting
- 9:57to return capital to shareholders via buybacks,
- 10:00that's a notable shift. It signals confidence in their
- 10:02value and maybe a move into a different stage of their
- 10:05corporate life. All right, let's get to the
- 10:06bottom line. The numbers.
- 10:07The stock price itself tells the story, doesn't it?
- 10:09IPO at $38 in mid 2021, crashes down to like $8 by the end of
- 10:132022, then this incredible recovery to around $90.00 by mid
- 10:172025. What do the underlying
- 10:19financials tell us about that roller coaster?
- 10:21Oh, the numbers are just as dramatic.
- 10:23Take valuation ratios price to book, which kind of compares
- 10:25market value to the company's net assets.
- 10:28In 2022, it fell to one point, Arrow X.
- 10:31Basically, the market was saying the business was only worth its
- 10:33liquidation value. Extreme pessimism.
- 10:35Just worth the sum of its parts. Exactly, but by 2024 that PB
- 10:39ratio expanded to over 4X and by mid 2025 it was up around 10X.
- 10:44That's a massive re rating from total skepticism to really
- 10:47significant optimism baked into the price.
- 10:50OK. So investor sentiment slipped
- 10:52completely. What about the actual
- 10:53performance, revenue and crucially, profit?
- 10:57Revenue growth was explosive early on, up 10 times from about
- 11:00$278 million in 2019 to $2.95 billion in 2024.
- 11:05But the profitability swing is even more stark.
- 11:07They lost a staggering $3.7 billion in 2021 billion with AB,
- 11:11with AB largely due to those stock compensation expenses we
- 11:14mentioned being recognized. But by 2024, they swung to a
- 11:17positive gut income of $1.41 billion.
- 11:20That's nearly 48% Net margin. It really shows the potential
- 11:23leverage in the model. Once revenue covers those fixed
- 11:26costs, profits can really flow through.
- 11:28And cash flow is the profit turning into actual cash.
- 11:30Yes, free cash flow turns strongly positive in 2022 and
- 11:33then again in 2024, hitting almost $1.1 billion, one point
- 11:37095-B. That shows really good cash
- 11:39conversion. The earnings aren't just on
- 11:41paper, they're generating real cash.
- 11:42OK. Let's zoom in on the latest.
- 11:44What did the Q12025 results look like?
- 11:47Was that momentum continuing? Q12025 was frankly A blowout
- 11:51quarter. Really strong across the board.
- 11:53Revenue hit 927 million dollars, up 50% year over year.
- 11:56A huge chunk of that was driven by crypto trading revenue, which
- 11:59surged 700%. So again, you see how sensitive
- 12:03they are to specific market activity.
- 12:04Still riding those crypto waves? Still riding those waves when
- 12:07they come, but profitability was solid too.
- 12:09Net income of $336 million, a healthy 36% margin.
- 12:13And the user metrics, are people still coming bringing money?
- 12:15Yep. Funded accounts ticked up to
- 12:1725.8 million. Assets under custody reached
- 12:19$221 billion. And here's a big one.
- 12:22Net deposits hit a record $18 billion in that quarter. 18
- 12:25billion in three months. Yeah, huge inflows.
- 12:28Gold subscribers also jumped again to 3.19 million.
- 12:31So the overall picture from Q125 is strong growth, solid profits
- 12:36and a very healthy balance sheet with about $4.5 billion in cash.
- 12:40They were definitely benefiting from a positive market
- 12:42environment then. OK.
- 12:43Now for the big question, the one of value investor like
- 12:45Warren Buffett might ask, given everything we've discussed,
- 12:48what's Robin Hood actually worth?
- 12:49We're going to try a simplified discounted cash flow DCF
- 12:53analysis using that kind of value.
- 12:55Right. So for DCF, you need a starting
- 12:57point in growth assumptions. We'll use that solid 2024 free
- 13:01cash flow number, the $1.095 billion, as our base.
- 13:05Then let's run 2 scenarios. First a very conservative 1
- 13:09Assume FCF grows at just 5% a year for five years, then
- 13:12settles into a 2% perpetual worth rate like the long term
- 13:14economy. Okay, 5% growth.
- 13:16What does that give us? That conservative scenario spits
- 13:18out an intrinsic value of around $20.50 per share. $20.50 Okay,
- 13:23what if we're a bit more optimistic, maybe reflecting
- 13:25some of their recent growth? Right.
- 13:26Let's try a moderate scenario. Assume 20% annual FCF growth for
- 13:31the next 5 years, which is still pretty high, and then the same
- 13:342% terminal growth. That gets you an intrinsic value
- 13:37of roughly $25.98 per share. Let's call it $0.26.
- 13:41OK $20.50 conservative 26 cents moderate.
- 13:45Now here's the kicker. The stock as of mid 2025 is
- 13:49trading around $92.00. That's massive difference from
- 13:53are calculated intrinsic values. What does that tell us?
- 13:56Well, it tells us there's a huge disconnect.
- 13:58For the market price of $92.00 to make sense, investors must be
- 14:00expecting something way beyond our scenarios.
- 14:03Either they're banking on super normal growth, maybe much higher
- 14:05than 20% a year or sustained for much longer than five years
- 14:08driven by new products or massive market share gains.
- 14:10Or or they're willing to accept a very low expected future
- 14:14return on their investment from this price level, maybe
- 14:16something in the ballpark of only 6% or 7% per year going
- 14:19forward, which is quite low given the inherent risks.
- 14:21So the current price implies some extremely high
- 14:24expectations. And what about margin of safety,
- 14:26That core Buffett idea of buying something for significantly less
- 14:29than it's worth, just in case you're wrong?
- 14:30At $92.00 a share, based on our DCF, there's basically 0 margin
- 14:35of safety. In fact, you could argue there's
- 14:37a negative margin of safety. But what's really fascinating
- 14:39looking back is that in late 2022, when the stock was down at
- 14:438 or $10, the margin of safety was huge.
- 14:46Back then, the company's cashed on hand, plus its regulatory
- 14:49capital was actually close to its entire market cap.
- 14:52You're almost getting the ongoing business for free.
- 14:55Investors who saw that underlying value then, who had
- 14:57that margin of safety, were rewarded incredibly well when
- 15:00sentiment turned. That's a powerful illustration
- 15:03of the concept. So wrapping this up, Robin Hood
- 15:05has clearly made a huge transition from that
- 15:08controversial fast growing money losing startup to a much more
- 15:11balanced profitable company by 2024.
- 15:14They've cleaned up their act focused on cost, diversified
- 15:16revenue. But as we've seen, the results
- 15:18are still pretty sensitive to things like market swings and
- 15:20interest rates. Absolutely, which leads to the
- 15:23key question for you, the listener looking at Robin Hood
- 15:25today with the stock price where it is, are you essentially
- 15:28betting on that super normal growth continuing?
- 15:31Are you counting on new revenue streams materializing and
- 15:33scaling rapidly to justify this valuation?
- 15:36Or thinking like a value investor would you need a
- 15:39significant pullback, a much lower price to create that
- 15:42cushion, that margin of safety before considering it?
- 15:45It's a. Fascinating ongoing story.
- 15:46The disruptor trying to mature into a stable long term winner.
- 15:50Only time will tell if they can truly grow into the ambitious
- 15:53valuation the market is currently giving them.