Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Job Reference When Your Industry Is Volatile
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to start with a specific listener question that hit my inbox this week. The listener works in marketing — specifically at a mid-sized agency that's lost three of its biggest clients in the last six months. They're now looking to move, but every former colleague they might ask for a reference is either laid off, freelancing, or at another agency that's also shrinking. Luna: Right — so it's not that they don't have people who could vouch for them. It's that those people don't have stable jobs or company emails anymore. Lucas: Exactly. And this is becoming more common. We've talked about asking for references when you've had short stints, when your boss left, when your company reorged. But what about when the entire industry feels unstable? When the company you're leaving is itself a question mark on your resume. Luna: And if today's conversation helps you think through a reference request or any career decision, I want to mention quickly that the show stays ad-free because listeners support it. If you find this useful, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a simple way to keep these episodes coming without interruption. And speaking of interruptions, let's get into the volatile-industry reference problem. Lucas: So let's break down what's actually blocking this listener. They feel like they can't ask anyone because their network is scattered. But I'd argue the scatter is actually an opportunity — you have more potential references now than when everyone was in the same building. Luna: How so? If those people are gone, aren't they harder to track down? Lucas: Harder to find, yes. But when you do find them, their recommendation can be more specific. Because they're not reading from a corporate script — they're talking about the actual work you did together on a particular campaign or account. And that specificity is gold. Luna: I saw a LinkedIn survey from early 2026 — 38% of professionals in industries that experienced major layoffs or consolidation in the past year said they're worried about who to ask for a reference. That's a huge number. Lucas: It's about one in three, roughly. And the worry is rational. But the fix is to shift your reference strategy from 'who had a stable title at a stable company' to 'who can speak to a specific outcome I delivered.' Luna: So you're saying the listener should think about a former client rather than a former colleague? Or maybe a vendor they managed? Lucas: Both are great options. Let's start with clients. In marketing, you often have a direct relationship with the client's marketing director or brand manager. That person saw your work — your deliverables, your responsiveness, your strategic thinking. And they're not affected by your agency's instability. They may even be at a company that's hiring. Luna: But there's a risk: some employers might look at a client reference and think it's less objective than a manager's reference. Lucas: That's true for some industries. But I've seen data from hiring managers — especially in marketing, consulting, and tech — that a strong client reference can actually carry more weight because it's a third-party validation. The client paid for the work and was satisfied. That's a powerful signal. Lucas: So if our listener wants to go the client route, they should identify one or two clients where they had a significant role. Then write a short email that acknowledges the industry shakeup upfront. Luna: What's the script? I think listeners want actual language. Lucas: Something like: 'Hi, I'm exploring a new opportunity and I'm hoping you might be willing to speak to my work on the from last year. I know the agency landscape has shifted, but I believe the results we delivered together speak for themselves. Would you be open to a brief call?' Luna: I like that it doesn't apologize for the industry volatility. It just acknowledges it and moves on. Lucas: Exactly. The worst thing you can do is sound embarrassed about your company's situation. You didn't cause the instability — you performed despite it. Lucas: Another option is a former colleague who's now in a different company or freelancing. Their email domain might be Gmail or a personal website, but that's fine. A thoughtful reference from someone who knew your work five months ago is better than a polished reference from someone who barely remembers you from two years ago. Luna: What if the listener is worried that a Gmail address looks unprofessional? Should they ask that person to use their new work email? Lucas: Only if it's natural. Don't ask a freelancer to pretend they're at a company. Hiring managers understand that people move. What matters is the content of the reference, not the domain. In fact, a personal email can signal that the person is vouching for you personally, not just checking a box. Luna: I want to bring up another angle — what about asking for a 'future-focused reference'? I've seen some career coaches suggest that when your industry is volatile, you ask a reference to speak less about your past and more about your adaptability. Lucas: That's smart. You could say to a reference: 'If the hiring manager asks about challenges, I'd hope you could mention how I handled the account restructuring in Q3.' That frames your past instability as evidence of resilience. Lucas: And here's a tactical tip: when you ask for the reference, give the person a brief update on your situation. Say something like, 'I know the industry has been turbulent, but I'm focusing on roles where I can bring that agility.' That helps them tell a coherent story. Luna: It also makes them feel more comfortable. They might be wondering, 'Will I look bad if I mention the layoffs?' But if you've already framed it as a learning moment, they can lean into that. Lucas: Right. And that brings us to a broader point: the reference request itself is a networking opportunity. Even if the person can't give a reference right now, you've reconnected. Six months from now, that same person might be at a company that's hiring. Luna: So the volatility might actually accelerate your network growth? Because people are scattering to different companies and industries. Lucas: Exactly. One listener in a previous episode mentioned that after their company downsized, they ended up with contacts at twelve different organizations — each one a potential reference or lead. That's a broader network than if everyone had stayed put. Lucas: Let me give a concrete example. A marketing manager I know — let's call her Sarah — worked at an agency that lost its biggest account. She reached out to the client's CMO, who had left the previous year. That CMO gave her a reference that landed her a job at a brand-side role. The reference was from someone who had also been through the volatility. Luna: That's a great story. So the key takeaway is: don't let industry instability paralyze you. Instead, look at it as a chance to diversify your reference pool. Lucas: And be upfront about it. Hiring managers in 2026 have seen plenty of resumes from volatile industries. They're not going to penalize you for a company's misfortune. They want to know how you performed when things were hard. Luna: I think one practical tip we haven't covered is how to handle the reference check form itself. Some companies have automated systems that require an email address from a corporate domain. What then? Lucas: Great question. If the system forces a corporate email, you can put in a personal email and add a note: 'This reference is from a former colleague who has since left.' Or ask the reference if they have a former corporate email that still forwards. Some people keep their alumni emails for a year. Luna: But if the system rejects it, you might need to escalate to a human recruiter. That's actually a chance to explain your situation and build rapport. Lucas: Exactly. And if the recruiter is any good, they'll understand. They've probably placed candidates from the same industry. Lucas: Let's wrap with a one-sentence summary: In a volatile industry, your best references are the people who saw you navigate the volatility — not the ones who had the most stable titles. Luna: I'd add: don't wait until you're applying to reconnect. Start those conversations now, while the industry is still shifting. It's easier to ask for a reference when you're already in touch. Lucas: Good note. And if you have a specific reference scenario we didn't cover, drop it in the show notes or send it in. We'll keep this thread going.