Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / CUSO EXAMS What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:00getting a QSO review, if your books and records are clean and your
- 0:03services are well documented and you can do a good job of controlling the
- 0:08narrative when NCUA comes in, when that happens, it's actually, can be a plus.
- 0:13Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:18I hope you enjoy.
- 0:22Do you wanna maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:25Join Mark Trico as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:29your exam with flying colors.
- 0:31The With Flying Colors Podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:34Exam Solutions by Mark Trico.
- 0:37If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and
- 0:40receive support to optimize your results with NCUA, so you save time and money,
- 0:45visit us@marktrico.com to find out more.
- 0:55Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:58Today's podcast is about credit union service organizations or
- 1:04QSOs and QSO exams, if you will.
- 1:08I had the pleasure of being interviewed on another podcast, a new podcast
- 1:12in the Q and In preparation for that, I was reminded that being
- 1:18interviewed is harder than doing the interview and thoroughly enjoyed it.
- 1:22I'm actually going to have the host of the show on my show coming up and
- 1:28his name is Michael Heller of QSOLAW.
- 1:31com.
- 1:33And with this fresh in my mind, I thought I would talk about QSO examinations.
- 1:38So a lot of people are familiar with the NSUA examination process at credit unions.
- 1:44And in the podcast that I was on, I was asked about what differences
- 1:49there are with a CUSO examination.
- 1:52And before talking about what's different about CUSO exams, you know, credit unions
- 1:57over 1 billion in asset size get exams annually, and that's if they're a code
- 2:02one or a code two, if you're a code.
- 2:05Three or worse, you're going to see NCOA anywhere from every
- 2:08six months to every four months.
- 2:10And by the way, code threes and code fours are increasing.
- 2:13If you're less than a billion dollars, you will see NCOA if you're a code one
- 2:17or a code two, every 12 to 24 months.
- 2:20Now the QSO exams.
- 2:22Are less frequent than that.
- 2:24And there are three types of QSO exams.
- 2:27There's an exam, integrated exam, meaning it's done as part of an NCOA
- 2:32exam, which is essentially a light touch and there's the standalone exam, which
- 2:37focuses specifically on one QSO and are typically conducted in response to
- 2:42NCOA or state staff recommendations, these reviews are performed by the
- 2:47same team of examiners that are.
- 2:49Utilized for an examination.
- 2:51So that's one of the similarities is that the staff who does QSO exams are the
- 2:56same staff that do credit union exams.
- 2:58So for example, if you have a QSO that makes commercial loans or makes
- 3:04indirect loans or make student loans, you can expect to see either problem
- 3:09case officers with experience in loans or regional lending specialists that
- 3:14would likely do those independent.
- 3:16QSO reviews when other differences, they're substantially more rare.
- 3:21Now, back when I was a regional director, uh, for the 10 years,
- 3:25I was a regional director.
- 3:26There were years that I did zero.
- 3:28The region did zero standalone QSO reviews.
- 3:32And there were years that perhaps we did three or four.
- 3:36Of course, it's a resource issue.
- 3:38And if you're going to go in, you need to have a good reason to go in.
- 3:41You just don't willy nilly decide.
- 3:44To go into a credit union for a stand alone CUSO review.
- 3:49I was also asked about CUSOs that while CUSOs are not directly
- 3:53subject to NCUA supervision.
- 3:56How is it that NCUA is able to do the reviews?
- 3:59And that goes to NCUA's regulation on CUSOs.
- 4:04And that requires any federally insured credit union with a loan to or investment
- 4:09in a CUSO to, among other things, enter into a written agreement with
- 4:14that CUSO that will provide the NCUA with complete access to any books and
- 4:19records of the CUSO and the ability to review the CUSO's internal controls.
- 4:25So any records, complete access to any books and records, that's pretty broad.
- 4:32So while NCUA doesn't have the regulatory authority over CUSOs, they
- 4:39build that authority in by creatively requiring, if a credit union is going
- 4:46to invest, Uh, or make loans to a CUSO that the CUSO agrees that they will
- 4:53make the books and records available.
- 4:55And that means any books and records.
- 4:57And we'll get into that a little bit as well.
- 5:00Now it's often asked what type of CUSOs get looked at.
- 5:05It really depends on what's going on in the industry.
- 5:09And for example, back when credit unions started to get into commercial loans
- 5:14more, which is a very labor intensive.
- 5:18Product credit unions and credit union exams were taking
- 5:22exceptions to the ability of the staff that credit unions had.
- 5:26And so QSOs were an excellent method for getting the economies of scale, where
- 5:32you have the skill sets and abilities to make those loans housed in a QSO.
- 5:37And that would create synergy for the credit union.
- 5:40So when that started to take off and, and into a side growth in
- 5:43those, then there would be reviews, independent, standalone reviews at.
- 5:48Commercial loan CUSOs.
- 5:50When student lending took off like a racehorse some 10 12
- 5:54years ago, same thing happened.
- 5:56But before all that was indirect auto loans.
- 5:58And so back when I was a regional director in 2003 2004 2005, there were some
- 6:05indirect loan CUSO reviews that happened.
- 6:08So really, As new services grow in QSOs, you can expect that those services are
- 6:14the ones that NCUA may pay attention to.
- 6:16So what does that mean?
- 6:18FinTech.
- 6:18NCUA Board is very supportive of FinTech, but I would bet that you are
- 6:23going to see or credit union service organizations that are in FinTech
- 6:27get looked at, whether that's this year, next year, or the year after.
- 6:30That's something, if it grows, that you can expect NCUA will Add to
- 6:35their list of those few independent QSO reviews that they do each year.
- 6:41By the way, getting a QSO review, if your books and records are clean and
- 6:45your services are well documented and you can do a good job of controlling the
- 6:50narrative when NCUA comes in, when that happens, it's actually, can be a plus.
- 6:55There are, you know, I have some clients who are owners of QSOs
- 6:59that receive copies of QSO exams.
- 7:02Um, And they were excited when they got it because it showed that they had a good
- 7:06partner and that things were going well.
- 7:08So a review can actually go well, just like while they don't do camel codes,
- 7:12getting a code one or a code two can show your board, you're doing a good job.
- 7:16Not that if you don't get a code one or a code two, it means
- 7:19you're not doing a good job.
- 7:20But getting a good report in a QSO review can play positive dividends.
- 7:24So NCOA coming in to do one can be a good thing.
- 7:28So what type of risk is NCOA looking for?
- 7:31It really comes down to when NCOA does a risk assessment at
- 7:36a QSO, is there systemic risk that they need to worry about?
- 7:40For example, like I said, a QSO is growing and it's It's impacting more
- 7:45and more assets and it's impacting more and more credit unions.
- 7:49That would be systemic risks that because there's growth,
- 7:51they want to take a look at it.
- 7:53Or it could be individual credit union risk.
- 7:55Let's say there's a type of loan product that has anywhere from three to 10
- 8:00owners and those three to 10 owners are booking a substantial amount of
- 8:04loans of a certain type or a new type.
- 8:07That's the type of thing that could end up getting looked at.
- 8:10So NCOA, just like a credit union, when a credit union has a new service.
- 8:14N two A is gonna take a look at that.
- 8:15If that service is growing, they're gonna take a look at it.
- 8:18So if you're a qso, same thing is gonna happen.
- 8:21You see growth in a particular area, that's where they may want to look
- 8:24and see if it's a new risk that they need to be concerned about.
- 8:28So one of the issues that QSOs face, since they're not examined so frequently, they
- 8:34don't know what NCUA is going to look at.
- 8:36And as I mentioned, the regulation says that you will provide complete access
- 8:41to any books and records of the QSO and.
- 8:45Any is very broad that means any so, you know, oftentimes it's asked,
- 8:49do you want to push back on that?
- 8:50And you may want to ask why they need it.
- 8:53But in the end, if NC way says they need to see something to assess the
- 8:57safety and soundness of the queue.
- 8:59So you are going to.
- 9:01Have to give it to them because it does say that they
- 9:04have access to any documents.
- 9:06So what type of documents might they ask for?
- 9:09You can break them into just general types of documents.
- 9:12You can talk about certain plans like strategic plans or a disaster
- 9:16recovery plan or profitability plan.
- 9:20They could ask for documents as it relates to staffing, an organizational
- 9:24chart, who's on the board of directors.
- 9:27Uh, what that staff does, what type of training the CUSO does for staff, copies
- 9:33of monthly board minutes is something that they ask for credit unions, that's
- 9:37something you could expect to see them ask from the CUSO, a list of customers,
- 9:42credit union customers, a list of owners, a list of lenders, policies, procedures,
- 9:48other documents in that arena, or underwriting or making recommendations
- 9:53to the client, for example.
- 9:55If there are legal opinions that show that what you're doing is consistent
- 10:00with your contracts with your clients or the credit unions that you serve, you
- 10:04could see that they might ask for that.
- 10:07Of course, there's the issue of the corporate veil.
- 10:09I mean, going back, they want to make sure that the QSO cannot pierce the corporate
- 10:13veil of the, of the credit union.
- 10:15And that's because credit unions are limited, federal credit
- 10:18unions are limited to 1 percent investment or 1 percent of loans.
- 10:21So max 2 percent of assets.
- 10:24Could be at risk and if you can pierce the corporate veil, of course, that number
- 10:29can go up and they want to make sure that there are independent structures.
- 10:32So, for example, that the board of the CUSO is different than the
- 10:35board of the credit unions that the staff of the CUSO is different than
- 10:38the staff of the credit unions.
- 10:39They need to be independent groups and that's something that they would
- 10:42look at, but organizational structure.
- 10:45Is it LLC?
- 10:46Are there bylaws?
- 10:47Is there a certificate of good standing?
- 10:50Uh, compliance with the laws in the state in which it operates.
- 10:52Now NCUA is not going to delve into the state laws or laws that aren't
- 10:57specifically related to the regulation, but if they become aware of something
- 11:01along those lines, they may point it out.
- 11:03What type of insurance policies do you have?
- 11:05What type of insurance policies might you have?
- 11:07Uh, if you've got loan participations, they may want to see the loan
- 11:11participation agreements.
- 11:12So there's an exhaustive List that NCUA has in their examiner's guides
- 11:18of what they might look at, but those are some examples of what
- 11:21they potentially could look at.
- 11:24You could see them also get into IS& T and data processing type documents
- 11:28and review of strategic plans, board and management oversight, vendor
- 11:34management, information security program, intrusion detection and responses,
- 11:39software development and acquisitions.
- 11:42Uh, NCUA's guidance does have very broad amount of questions and
- 11:47documents that they may look into.
- 11:49Doesn't mean they will in every instance, but again, any document be
- 11:53made available means any document.
- 11:55So push come to shove.
- 11:57If NCUA asks for something, my recommendation would
- 12:00be to give it to them.
- 12:01But, you know, one of the discussions came, that came up earlier in my.
- 12:05My podcast interview with In The Queue was the importance
- 12:08of controlling the narrative.
- 12:10Having the same person, or having one person in control of the documents that
- 12:15are going to NCUA, and then also making sure that The team members at the QSO are
- 12:22communicating so that if NCUA is asking a question on one side of the QSO review and
- 12:27asking a question on the other side, that things don't get taken out of context.
- 12:31That's why it's very important to have a contact person for
- 12:33a QSO review or for any exam.
- 12:36And, you know, I counsel my clients on that and participate in some of those
- 12:41meetings that go on that are led by the contact person during an NCUA examination.
- 12:46A common question, it relates to the concept of primarily serving a credit
- 12:52union, and the question becomes, how do you determine primarily serves?
- 13:00So one way I always like to figure out what a word means is to go to dictionary.
- 13:08com.
- 13:09Or something similar and look up the word.
- 13:11So what does primarily mean it means first and foremost,
- 13:15first in essence, fundamentally.
- 13:17So that doesn't give a percentage.
- 13:19It doesn't say 51.
- 13:20It doesn't say 91.
- 13:22It doesn't say 12, but a substantial portion of the services should be.
- 13:29For credit union members now, and sua does have in their regulation says
- 13:34may only invest in or lend to a Q.
- 13:36So that primarily serves credit unions and their members as
- 13:41opposed to the general population.
- 13:43While the insulate is not defined primarily serves.
- 13:46It has been the agency's longstanding position that the determination as
- 13:51to whether a CUSO complies with the customer based requirement be made
- 13:55on a case by case basis using the totality of the circumstances test.
- 14:00So what does that mean?
- 14:01It means the body of work.
- 14:03It means the legal term, totality of circumstances.
- 14:06So that basically means all the facts that they're going
- 14:10to take it into consideration.
- 14:11Said another way, what's the definition of beauty?
- 14:14They'll know it when they see it.
- 14:16The reality though, is they're not going to take exception of something.
- 14:19Ty is going to go to the runner, if you will, using a baseball terminology.
- 14:23If you can come close to looking that you're safe at first base, they will
- 14:28land on the side of primarily serves.
- 14:31It also goes on to give some examples that when determining if a QSO meets
- 14:36the customer base requirement, a federal credit union should review
- 14:39several variables, including the number of affiliated members served.
- 14:44Gross or net revenues derived from members, members assets under management,
- 14:49the number of policies sold to members, and of course, some of these might
- 14:53not apply to particular QSOs, but these are examples of how you could
- 14:56show that you're in compliance with the Primarily SERVS requirement.
- 15:01The number of services sold to members and the availability or
- 15:04accessibility of services to members.
- 15:07So, again, they must primarily serve, but it's not a one and
- 15:12done black and white statistic.
- 15:14If you're at this percentage, it counts, and if you're at
- 15:16this percentage, it doesn't.
- 15:18But if you're questioning whether or not you do primarily serve, you
- 15:23might want to make sure that you can, again, control the narrative.
- 15:27That you can document or show or explain why you are in compliance
- 15:33with that regulatory requirement.
- 15:35So NCUA has expanded the ability for CUSOs to do more and more over time.
- 15:40They've pre approved many other regulations.
- 15:43Services and there's ways to get onto the list of services that are pre approved.
- 15:49And I'm not going to go in that here today.
- 15:51That's a story for another day.
- 15:53There is a past podcast that I did with Brian Lauer of NICUSO and also
- 15:58of CUSO Law, where we talked through some of those changes and it would be
- 16:02best if you're interested in that, go back in the archives and take a look.
- 16:06For that podcast, I'll put a reference in the show note to
- 16:10what podcast number that was.
- 16:13All right.
- 16:13That's it for today.
- 16:15Credit union service organizations.
- 16:16They grow and they grow and they grow and they continue to help credit
- 16:19unions, credit unions, members.
- 16:21And I see this as a.
- 16:24Very positive steps in the industry that NCOA has taken
- 16:27to expand things in this arena.
- 16:30I also will say that the NCOA board has a proposed rule on eligible
- 16:35obligations and loan participations.
- 16:37And I know that per the last board meeting, they're looking at that
- 16:41possibly coming out as soon as July, perhaps no later than September.
- 16:45The interesting thing about that is board member Rodney Hood,
- 16:49who is very passionate about.
- 16:51that topic.
- 16:52His term is up in August.
- 16:53I know he would rather like to see it in July.
- 16:56Uh, and I know staff is working on it based on what Chairman Todd Harper
- 16:59said at the last board meeting.
- 17:01All right, that's it.
- 17:02That's a wrap.
- 17:02This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 17:11Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 17:14Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 17:18experts talk Of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with N.
- 17:22C.
- 17:22U.
- 17:22A.
- 17:23If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check out
- 17:26our services at mark triple dot com.