Latest / Putting the AI in MRKTNG / Why AI Search Is Recommending Your Competitor, Not You
Transcript
- Chris Heinemann: For more than 20 years, if you wanted to win customers online, you needed SEO. You chased rankings, you chased backlinks, you chased the number one spot on a page of blue links. But is that Google search page still relevant today? More and more, the answer to "what should I buy or "who should I hire?" comes straight out of an AI chat window, no click required. So today we're asking what happens to everything marketers spent decades building? And what actually determines whether AI recommends you or your competitor. Debbie Chew, a marketing strategist who has spent her career in SEO, is now helping marketers navigate the shift into AEO, GEO, and Digital PR. She joins the pod. Debbie Chew welcome to the podcast of Putting the AI in MRKTNG. It's just a delight to see you. Something's going on in marketing right now, and I couldn't think of a better person to have on the pod than you. So how you doing today? Debbie Chew: Yeah, well thank you for having me. Doing well. Excited to talk about all the things AI and marketing related. Chris Heinemann: Awesome. All right. Hope you're staying cool where you're at because it's probably I know you're over 100 degrees out Debbie Chew: Yeah. Chris Heinemann: there. So let's get right to it. Your feed, whether it's an Instagram feed, a Facebook feed, a LinkedIn feed, where wherever you're getting your social media from, is probably blowing up like mine. It's all about SEO, AEO, and GEO. And that's really what I wanted to have you on the pod today to talk about that. So we're gonna start with kind of the ABCs here, the the building blocks. So talk to us about. What is SEO and kind of the evolution into into GEO? Debbie Chew: Yes, so search engine optimization pretty much started as a practice to earn visibility and improve visibility within search engines, namely Google. And so we've been doing that for the past like 20-ish years. But then, you know, a few years ago, the rise of like ChatGPT, Claude and all the other LLMs have kind of changed the way that people search for information. So we used to go up onto Google, search a few keywords, and we'll get like the 10 blue links. And so search engine engine optimization was all around like how do I show up higher in that those 10 blue links. Now with the LLMs you don't you no longer get that 10 blue links. You just get an answer. So you ask a question and then it'll come back and kind of synthesize the information on the internet and get back to you on what they think is or what the LLMs think is the right answer for a question. And so that's kind of where it changes like. I think, from a technical perspective, it's still somewhat similar in terms of like it's going out there to look for information, but now it's kind of like aggregating that information and then sharing that with you. Whereas before you had to go do that aggregation step yourself. You'd have to click through each one and then determine, Chris Heinemann: Right. Right. Debbie Chew: like, okay, which one makes the most sense for me? So it's kind of like making it easier for you to get to an answer more quickly. So that's kind of in a nutshell, like what this whole AEO/GEO is about is like how do I then get my brand to show up in these answer engines, in these LLMs? And then there's like a lot of I guess there's a lot of things that are a bit different between the two sort of practices and happy to go into that in more detail in a bit. Chris Heinemann: Yeah, yeah. I for our audience out there, you know, define these if if if you're not familiar with the acronyms SEO search engine optimization, AEO answer engine optimization, and then GEO, generative engine optimization. And I I kind of like to think of them as, well, with Google, like you mentioned, rankings. You've got a list, you've got the blue links, and then with the AEO, you're getting a specific answer to a question that you may ask in the in the model of your choice. And then the GEO I kind of think of it as the brand. It's gonna surface the brand, the company. So I think collectively you wanna be that's the sweet spot, if you will, is you wanna make make sure that you're kind of hitting that GEO spot so that your brand as a company is really showing up and and taking that leadership position and showing up so your competitors aren't showing up as well. So you've been doing this for you know a long time. SEO's been around for you know more than a couple of decades. And You know, you mentioned three years ago there was kind of this pivot. Kind of walk us through, you know, what that looked like when that pivot started to happen. What what what's changed in such the short amount of time? Debbie Chew: Yeah. So previously with SEO we were looking a lot at like excuse me, things like traffic. How much traffic does the search engine drive to my website? And now Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: since the search journey has kind of shortened a little bit, when people visit your website, it's not necessarily during that information top of funnel stage. It might be Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: when they are a little bit closer to conversion, when they're almost ready to buy. And so you might most businesses might see less organic traffic overall, but when they do get to your website, they're going to your product pages, your pricing, your service pages, like your very bottom of funnel pages, and they're more likely to convert. So you're gonna see a higher conversion rates on your Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: pages from that traffic from LLMs. So I think that's like the biggest change. And then outside of that, we are now looking at like prompts, like tracking different prompts as opposed to keywords, and then also thinking about like you know, are we actually being cited in or mentioned in the response? Not necessarily are they are they clicking a link to get to our website? So there's just Chris Heinemann: Mm. Debbie Chew: a few like areas that we need to be mindful of when we're tracking the success of like these efforts. Chris Heinemann: Yeah. So it sounds like the way people are discovering, researching, evaluating, purchasing from companies has fundamentally changed. Or are am I overstating the impact of AI search or is it here to stay? And this is really kind of we've made this pivot in how we're searching now for what we want to purchase, whether a consumer, I need a pair of jeans, I need a restaurant, whatever it is, or as a B2B SaaS company, who's got the best, you know, contact center solution? Debbie Chew: Yeah. I mean, I think a a good way to look at it is like within your family and friend network, do you see people using LLMs more often when they're asking questions instead of like going directly to Google? And I Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: I think for me, that is definitely what I'm seeing. Even folks that maybe were a little skeptical about using AI, I can see that they've changed over time. Like they've been Chris Heinemann: Ha ha. Debbie Chew: a little bit more open to it. Google is showing showing you AI overviews. So you're you're it's kind Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Yeah. Debbie Chew: of getting shoved down your throat in a sense of like you can't avoid it. And Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Yeah. Debbie Chew: so I think it just due to how easy it is for us to now get the answers that we want, for us to ask more complex questions that we weren't able to do before, I do think that folks are just going to naturally change their behavior to lean more towards like using LLMs. With that said, I think fundamentally what works, what what works well for SEO, what is good for SEO is also Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: good for AEO and GEO. And Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: so despite, you know, companies have spent a lot of money over the years on SEO, that's still gonna be important in the sort of new age of search. Chris Heinemann: Right, right. You you're reading my mind. We we're not gonna throw the baby out with the bathwater with our SEO right? I Debbie Chew: Yeah. Let's not throw the baby at all. Chris Heinemann: hear. So you you know, you mentioned something, you talked about Google looking at your website and rankings, and you you could pay to get those rankings up, et cetera. So how are these models actually searching? What are they going out? I mean, they're obviously gonna be looking at your website and the information that's on that website, the copy, the text, the formatting, the structure. You know, the JSONs. I was just updating a website today for a client here at Refugio Partners and you know, updating all of the that code that goes in there now because that is something that the the AI crawlers are now looking at. So I'm just wondering, you know, if you you've made this investment as a business or a nonprofit and you can't throw that that investment out, so to speak, right? So it's so critically important that that you understand what these models are looking at. So for people that are out there listening and watching this podcast, explain to them how these crawlers are actually working. What are they looking at? Debbie Chew: Yeah. So I think one way to put it from like a high level perspective, there's kind of like three buckets. One, which you kind of touched on earlier, is around technical accessibility. Can both search engines and answer engines get to your site and read Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: what's on your site? Or are you like blocking them from actually accessing your site? Therefor, not even knowing that you exist? So, that's one thing to think about. Like, how do I make sure that LLMs can see and read my content? How do I structure it in ways that are easy for them to understand? How do I maybe like add schema to make it more like machine Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: readable? So those are definitely the things to think about for that first bucket. And then the second bucket would be around internal consistency. So the messaging that you use when you talk about your products and services and your brand, is it consistent across the website? if there are inconsistencies that's confusing to both LLMs as well as users, like what exactly are you? Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: And then the third bucket would be consensus outside of your website. So it's not enough for you to say, like, I am the best digital PR in the world. You have to have other folks who also feel the same way and describe you in that in that way as well. So, you know. you can say what you want about your your your brand on your website, but are other folks outside of your website, other companies, other businesses, are they saying similar things about you? So that's what informs LLMs of like their sort of worldview about you and Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: your brand. So these are the three things that you kind of have think about. The technical aspect of accessibility. And then the second is like messaging consistency on your website. And then the third part is like, is that messaging consistent outside of your website? Chris Heinemann: Right, right. You mentioned something digital PR. I I wanna get to that, but I wanna circle back on on something here real quick. I don't think what a lot of people realize with these crawlers and if when they're they're looking for data and why the data needs to be credible, that your brand consistency that's out there, it's looking at that and it's looking at its credibility. And if the model it's it's almost like there's a consciousness about the model. If the model doesn't believe it, it's gonna save its own reputation. Debbie Chew: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Chris Heinemann: For lack of a a a better phrase, I don't know how any other way to put it, but it's not gonna it's gonna look at you and say, Well, wait a minute. So because we're not really trusting what we're seeing here, there's mixed messages, there's mixed data, there's mixed structure in your site, whatever it may be, the digital PR aspect, things aren't lining up here. We're gonna protect our own self and our own reputation, and the models will call it out, their reputation, and be recommending other companies. You know, so it's it's something that people need and companies need to be aware of. Digital PR. I'm so glad you brought this up because I know you're leaning in super hard on this. I've been in the the PR AR game for a long time as well, but explain to folks who may not be familiar with this term digital PR, maybe how that is different from traditional PR in public relations. Debbie Chew: Yeah. So the way I sort of see the difference between traditional and digital PR is that traditional it would be more of like your TV, news, media, like physical sort of press. Right, right. Chris Heinemann: Trade in business press. Yeah. Debbie Chew: And then digital PR, I actually see it as very a little bit broad. So I kind of bucket it as like any third party site That is not your competitor, and that's not your own site, and that's not like social media that is talk that potentially could be talking about your brand. So you can think of like if for SaaS companies, it could be like integrations that you work with, those partners that you have, like if they're able to talk about you and you talk about them, like that's positive for like a from a digital PR standpoint. Think. fundamentally, digital PR is around earning visibility with third-party sources that your audience already trusts. So that's kind of like how I define digital Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Right. Debbie Chew: PR. So it can be like digital publications, like trade publications online. I think that's one aspect. another would be like getting on podcasts and going on like certain YouTube channels that your your your audience already listens to and pays attention to like getting on those platforms that's what I consider is digital PR. Chris Heinemann: Right, right. Yeah, for for our our our our tech heads that are out there, your G2s, your Gartner Peer Insights, your Trust Pilots all great sources for the models to be looking at and crawling that information. And then like you mentioned your partners, what you can do around news articles, videos, blogs, whatever you're doing, and not just what you're doing, but what they're doing and what they can say about you. Get a placement in Forbes if you can get it. Get it on that Forbes, you know, Cloud One hundred, for example, right? All really credible sources that the the crawlers are going to look at and say, hey, we see ACME Widget Company on there. And so we're going to be referencing that company. So in somewhat the premise of public relations, necessarily the practice of it hasn't changed. It's just kind of the application into now that we've got LLMs looking at this information and actually giving it high rankings, if you will, as credible information so that you show up. in those models. So I think it's more critical than ever that companies be looking at this. Do you in in in the work that you're doing on this? And I know you just you just spoke at a recent conference about digital PR. I mean, are there some really specific strategies and tactics that are just no-brainers that companies can be doing that you've seen that have had a success rate with these models to increase their presence? Debbie Chew: Yeah, I mean fundamentally I think it's just knowing that this area of like marketing is important and spending time to number one understand it. Number two, like taking baby steps towards it of like, okay, maybe let's get our leadership team on different podcasts or let's get them to write some thought leadership content and do some guest blogging. Like I think there are ways to do digital PR in a like without having a huge budget. But really the goal is like how do I get my brand out there, brand's name out there beyond just my website. so I kind of center around that. Outside of that, I think really thinking about like when you create content on your website, how can you create assets that are gonna be like attractive to journalists? And that tends to be like data journalism research reports. Chris Heinemann: Mm. Mm. Right. Debbie Chew: So those are things that you know I've worked on at at our previous company together and that those those are things that I see consistently work for businesses, no matter like the industry or like type of business. So in in my talk I kind of talk I I give this example of like Martinellis. it's probably gonna be too long to talk about it, but essentially I pitched the or I created an idea of like let's pitch Martinelli's as like the original mocktail. Original mocktail is probably Shirley Temple. That's like that's what folks associate is the original Chris Heinemann: Right. Right. Debbie Chew: mocktail but I would argue that Martinelli's it was actually around like even before Coca-Cola and so know how can you pull on that thread and create a story around like okay Martinelli's was the original mocktail and then I would say we could also do a survey of like maybe maybe let's say Martinellis is trying to reach more of the millennial Gen Z audience they can do a Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: survey of like a thousand non-alcoholic drinkers about like behaviors around like non-alcoholic drinks and like the options that that are available to you. So having this like data study pulling like interesting things from that study to create like here's some interesting stats about non non-alcoholic drinking. We can try to pitch to a bunch of different publications about this storyline that we've essentially created through this data study. So that in a nutshell, that's kind of like one of the the the X the examples that I walk the audience through in my talk. Chris Heinemann: Yeah, what how how was that received? I mean, did you get some people coming up and talking to you and like this is a whole new world for me? What you said kind of just blew my mind. Where do I start with with digital PR? Debbie Chew: Yes, yes. So definitely a lot of like interest and people like very positive feedback after the talk. One of like one feedback that I got was like, you need you need to pitch pitch this to Martinelli's, which I still need to do. so I think like Chris Heinemann: Good luck. Good. Debbie Chew: Thank you. like kind of just my goal go getting up on stage was really explaining to people like okay, this is an area of like SEO AEO, GEO that people do not talk about enough. Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: When we think about AEO/GEO we think about like what's on our website. And that's great. Like that's like fundamental. But at the same time, a lot of like the citations in LLMs, especially like when you get to when you're when you're on like when your users are typing something that is a bit more commercial, the LLMs will tend to cite third party sources and not your own website. And so Chris Heinemann: Mm. Debbie Chew: you have to show up again in those third party. sites like you have to have a good rating in G2 or you know, if an a like a Nerd Wallet is writing a listicle, you need to be on that listicle because that's gonna be what the Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: LLMs will base their answers on. And so I really just wanted to emphasize like why what what is digital PR, why it exists and why it's important and how to actually like start doing digital PR for your business. Chris Heinemann: Yeah, and it's I think an important takeaway too. It it's not about one offs either. You can't just kind of get a listing Debbie Chew: Mm. Chris Heinemann: and you're good to go. It takes consistency. It takes continuous Debbie Chew: Yes. Chris Heinemann: management of of doing this so that you will kind of build that credibility with the models and stuff. And do these companies realize this? I mean, as they've been laying off more and more people and there's more consultants and contractors out there, right? I mean, th this this takes a lot of work. I mean, there there are tools that you can use. to listen. Some companies are building their own tools to listen. And then they can tap into calls and video calls as well, but they may have their own agents doing other things. You can you know, SEM Rush, SEMrush, what's another one? Profound is another one that can Debbie Chew: Yes. Chris Heinemann: listen. So you've got to have people that are actually managing these applications and and listening and then to bring in this data to ensure that the company is showing up in the right way. as well, which is critically important, right? Debbie Chew: Right. Right, right. Exactly. I think it's a lot of folks are, you know, tracking the prompts within those tools. And I think there's a lot of like splits in terms of like how you can look at the data, you can look at the sentiment, and that's that's an area where maybe, Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: you know, every maybe all the LLMs are siding you, but they're in they're citing you in a negative way. And so at the end of the day, your metrics might look good in terms of like, you know, my brand is being cited 90% of the time. But then Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: if your sentiment is like very low, then that's a huge opportun or like an area that you should really look into. Like, how do Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: I actually improve that? And in order to improve that, it's going to technically it's typically typically going to rely on like how do you get third parties to say that you are a trusted brand because Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: again, like that's what they are basing that sort of opinion on. Chris Heinemann: Yeah, yeah. It's fascinating to me that we're we're tracking prompts, right? As as a data point that you've got to look at. I Debbie Chew: Yes. Yes. Chris Heinemann: mean, I I see it built into you know, CMS if you're using a Wix you know, content management system, for Debbie Chew: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Chris Heinemann: example. you can see on the back end that it can do that. So what happens? You've done everything right. You've got a great website, messaging's bang on. The the schema is, you know, your struct your your data, your structured good, the you know, your markup and the site is all tight and it's good. You've got brand ambassadors out there talking, saying the right thing, sales is saying the right things, your CEO saying the right thing, CMO, everybody's on board. There's consistency. But what happens when something is inaccurate, it's outdated, maybe just proportionally influenced by, you know, a negative review on Reddit or a Google review or whatever. Can digital PR play a role here and to manage that and to maybe swing that pendulum back and and make some corrections? Debbie Chew: Yeah, I think definitely yes. I think again, it's part of like this whole idea that people still need to be educated that you know like Reddit. Reddit comes up a lot when folks are asking questions and LLMs will cite Reddit and kind of like use that as as if it is the truth. And so Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: I think it's it's not so much like manipulating what's on Reddit, but act like Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. Debbie Chew: trying to be active. in those communities and then kind of you know there might be misconceptions within Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: certain communities about your brand, about your policies. And so you going in there, kind of letting those folks know, like, hey, you know, you know, there might be a some sort of confusion about like our policy and it's actually it means XYZ instead. That sort of behavior will help shape kind of both your users' perceptions of your brand, but also Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: like as you have more like positive reinforcement about like your brand in these communities that matter, then I think the sentiment over time will improve. So Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: to answer your question, yes, like it is definitely possible. It is definitely something that you need like both businesses need to look into of like, you know, are what number one, like what is being cited? And then number two, like how do I try to influence, not manipulate, but like how do I try to influence that? How do I monitor that? How do I jump into those conversations at an earlier time instead of waiting like a year later to answer something in a Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: subreddit? Chris Heinemann: Again, all traditional PR tactics, That hasn't changed. Debbie Chew: Yeah. Chris Heinemann: it's just you know, again, aligning to these models to ensure and you're managing all of this consistently across the board. So when I was thinking about bringing on on the pod, one of the things that that kind of got my attention that you said was you wanted to end the SEO, AEO and GEO debate. And you wanted to call it CEO. What is CEO? I know what it is, but I want Debbie Chew: Mm-hmm. Chris Heinemann: you know, tell our audience, what is CEO? Because I think you got to trademark this. Debbie Chew: So like a year ago, when we well we still haven't I feel like as an industry, the SEO industry hasn't really decided what to call this new sort of practice of AEO, GEO AI, search optimization. There's so many acronyms and I felt like we were mainly arguing semantics, but rather Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: I think fundamentally what we're we've been trying to do and what we should have been doing all along was to just focus on the customer. And so CEO, the the acronym stands for customer engine optimization. And so I wanted it to be something thank Chris Heinemann: Mm-hmm. I love it. I love it. Debbie Chew: you. that Instead of like focusing on optimizing for the search engine, optimizing for the answer engine, we should be optimizing for the user because again, like who's actually the the search engines, answer engines are trying to service the user. And so again, like it's it It kind of all goes back to the customer. And so as long as you are thinking about like when I create this piece of content, how do I optimize for the end user? There are ways like that'll naturally be or the way you write it will naturally be helpful to both LLMs and search engines. So it kind of again just all goes back to the the customer. And so I wanted the acronym to be focused around like let's not think about like, how do I optimize and manipulate the search engines? But it's more of like, how do I understand what my customer's pain points are? How do I write content? How do I show my brand to my customers in ways that resonate with them? And so all the activities that we do, technical SEO, digital PR, et cetera, it all goes back to the customer. Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Customer centricity. I I know when we were working together, people like yourself, Grace Lau, Andrea Boren we always used to talk about customer centricity and making sure that our messaging was always very customer centric, looking at it through the customer lens. Because I think especially for new companies and some of these maybe younger AI founders of these companies that are coming on board and it it's just product, product, product, product, that they need to stop and step back and it's not about what you're doing, it's about why you're doing it and Debbie Chew: Yeah. Chris Heinemann: who you're doing it for. Why do you exist? And so a lot of things Debbie Chew: Right. Chris Heinemann: we talked about today, including talking about customer centricity, these are all marketing principles, these are fundamentals. So I think I I Debbie Chew: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Chris Heinemann: don't want people and I'm I'm bringing this up because I don't want people to get overwhelmed in what we're talking about, because a lot of the the the marketing principles still apply. Your PR, Debbie Chew: Mm-hmm. Chris Heinemann: what you're doing, being customer centric in your messaging, brand authenticity, brand consistency. You know, in another podcast we talked about your leadership team now is kind of that top of funnel demand gen engine for you, right? Debbie Chew: Mm. Chris Heinemann: Because a lot of people are creating content that it's not believable. It's being just kind of pushed out the door for fast execution and it doesn't have that customer centricity about it. It doesn't have that authenticity about it. So I think that's the shift. And I think principles still apply, marketing principles still apply. But you, you know, you you've got to just kind of make that pivot in terms of of how these models again are looking at what you're doing. Cause people can see it, the models can see it. And when that happens, your brand's in trouble. Right. So I think that's that's the takeaway. So Debbie Chew: Yeah. Chris Heinemann: you're you're a small business out there, you know. You're an enterprise business, small business, nonprofit, you're thinking, you know, where can we start? Is is is an audit, you know, taking a GEO audit, for example, is that a good place to start? Debbie Chew: I mean, yeah, I think getting the lay the lay of the land of like, you know, what's showing up for when when your customers are typing in certain prompts, like what kind of answers are showing up, what type of citations show up, and then also just understanding, you know, your website, is it actually being accessible to Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: LLMs? And then from there, I think not only audit auditing your own website, but also like taking a look at like what what are competitors doing? When are they showing up? Like what types Chris Heinemann: Right. Right. Debbie Chew: of prompts are they showing up for? What's potentially working for them? And so I think Yeah, there it there's a lot of potential ways to understand and like to number one, like understand the lay of the land and then start strategizing, like Chris Heinemann: Yeah. Debbie Chew: creating understand like figuring out like what tactics do I need to then focus on, what should that overall strategy be? But Chris Heinemann: Uh-huh. Debbie Chew: yeah, it kind of at the end of the day, like similar to what you've mentioned, it's still like fundamentally all marketing. And so I think businesses instead of focusing on like maybe you know pushing out more AI slop since content is cheap now, I think it's more of like focusing on like Chris Heinemann: Mm. Debbie Chew: how do I make my content differentiated that Chris Heinemann: Right. Debbie Chew: actually will stand the test of time as opposed to like if I spin something up with an LLM, competitor can do the same thing. And so am I just really wasting my time. And so a a lot of it kind of Chris Heinemann: Right. Adding to the noise. Debbie Chew: Right, exactly. So it all comes back to like, okay, what is my brand? What do I stand for? How do I make that appear through all the marketing that I do, no matter what channel. Chris Heinemann: Brand, brand, brand. We're doing these podcasts and we keep talking about artificial intelligence, but it's the one word that keeps coming up in every discussion. Brand, brand, brand. So Debbie Debbie Chew: Yes. Chris Heinemann: Chu, pleasure to see you. It's been just a fascinating conversation. And really thank you for educating our audience on SEO to GEO, what those things mean, the relationship, the framework, and how important it is to, you know, again, just got to take a look at your business kind of from a different viewpoint. And that's how the AI crawlers are looking at your business because their reputation matters, apparently. And that all right, Debbie Chew: Yes, yes, reputation matters. But yeah, thank you for having me. Chris Heinemann: Great to see you. And let's stay in touch. This is gonna be a journey that's gonna be fascinating to to watch how this all unfolds and and how people continue to kind of maybe manipulate and exploit these models to their benefit. So stay tuned. Thank you. Debbie Chew: Thank you.