Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 🔥Big Beautiful Bill 💸: Debt Storm or Economic Boom? Winners, Losers & the Trillion-Dollar Price Tag
Transcript
- 0:00OK, let's unpack this. July 1st, 2025, after this
- 0:04marathon all night session, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
- 0:07passes the Senate barely 5150 and this thing is huge. 940
- 0:12pages. It's set to completely reshape,
- 0:15well, everything. Taxes, the social safety net,
- 0:18federal spending. So what exactly is this One Big
- 0:22Beautiful Bill Act? And more importantly, what does
- 0:24it mean for you? Yeah, it's fascinating, isn't
- 0:26it? Because you're already hearing 2
- 0:28completely different stories about the exact same bill.
- 0:30You've got the White House saying, you know, this is
- 0:32fantastic pro growth, it'll even cut the deficit.
- 0:34But then you have nonpartisan analysts, people at the CBO,
- 0:37other groups sounding alarms. They're talking trillions added
- 0:40to the debt, big cuts to programs people rely on.
- 0:43Big disconnect there. Huge.
- 0:44So our mission today really is to try and cut through all that
- 0:47political noise. We're going to dig into the
- 0:49numbers, look at the analysis from the Congressional Budget
- 0:51Office, the White House's own economist, independent
- 0:54researchers, and try to give you a clear, data-driven picture of
- 0:57what the OBBA might actually do in the real world.
- 1:00And just getting it passed, wow, That whole legislative journey
- 1:04really tells a story about how divided things are in Washington
- 1:08right now. There's budget reconciliation,
- 1:09right? Exactly.
- 1:10That's the key procedural move. It let them avoid the usual 60
- 1:13vote filibuster hurdle in the Senate.
- 1:15So. They only needed a simple
- 1:16majority. Right, 51 votes, which led to
- 1:19that all night slog. The Voterama Republican
- 1:23leadership basically had to pull out all the stops, no room for
- 1:27error, and it ended with Vice President JD Vance casting that
- 1:30deciding 51st vote. And it wasn't even like all
- 1:33Republicans were thrilled about it.
- 1:34You mentioned some internal tension.
- 1:36Oh, yeah, You had senators like Thom Tillis voicing real worries
- 1:39about the Medicaid cuts. You know, people potentially
- 1:41losing health care. Susan Collins was pushing for
- 1:44more money for rural hospitals. Lisa Murkowski called the
- 1:47decision agonizing. Apparently worried about
- 1:49healthcare. Food stamps had some concessions
- 1:50for Alaska at the last minute, but the reporting suggests very
- 1:54few Republicans felt it was a perfect bill.
- 1:56Still, it passed, right? Which brings us back to that
- 1:58great disconnect. You mentioned how the cost is
- 2:00calculated. This seems crucial.
- 2:02Absolutely critical. If you want to understand the
- 2:05fog around this bill, you have to understand the baseline issue
- 2:07because that's where the wildly different numbers come from.
- 2:10A multi trillion dollar increase in the deficit versus a supposed
- 2:13deficit reduction. It all depends on your starting
- 2:15point. OK.
- 2:16Break that down for us, the CBO baseline first.
- 2:19So the CBO, the Congressional Budget Office, they're
- 2:21nonpartisan. They use what's called a current
- 2:24law baseline. That means they assume the law
- 2:27is currently on the books, stay in effect unless changed.
- 2:30And a huge part of current law is that lots in the 2017 tax
- 2:33cuts, they expire at the end of 2025.
- 2:36OK, so extending them isn't free under that view.
- 2:38Exactly. From the CB OS perspective,
- 2:40making those tax cuts permanent is a new policy choice, and it
- 2:43costs money. Under that standard CBO view,
- 2:45the OBDBA adds nearly $3.3 trillion to the deficit over 10
- 2:50years, 2025 to 2034. And when you add in the interest
- 2:53costs on that extra debt, other analysis put the total hit to
- 2:56the national debt over $3.9 trillion.
- 2:58Wow. OK, so what's the other side?
- 3:00The GOP baseline, right? The proponents like the White
- 3:04House. They use a current policy
- 3:06baseline. This basically assumes Congress
- 3:08was always going to extend those expiring 2017 tax cuts anyway.
- 3:12They treat keeping those cuts as the default, as costing nothing
- 3:16kind. Of like magic math, as some
- 3:17critics are calling it. That's the term some use, yeah.
- 3:20Because under that baseline, suddenly extending the tax cuts
- 3:23doesn't add to the deficit in their calculation.
- 3:25So they only count the cost of the other stuff in the bill
- 3:28relative to that baseline. And under that alternative view,
- 3:31even the CBO found the package would reduce deficits by about
- 3:34$500 billion. That's the number Republicans
- 3:37tend to cite. OK, $3.9 trillion added to the
- 3:40debt versus $500 billion saved. That's a massive difference
- 3:44based on an assumption. It's entirely based on that
- 3:46baseline assumption. And then you have the White
- 3:48House Council of Economic Advisers, the CEA.
- 3:50They take that current policy baseline, the one that assumes
- 3:53tax cuts are free, and then they layer on top very optimistic
- 3:56predictions about economic growth.
- 3:58Dynamic scoring, right? Right, dynamic scoring.
- 4:00They argue the tax cuts will spark so much growth that
- 4:03they'll mostly pay for themselves, leading to a deficit
- 4:06reduction of over $2 trillion. But, and this is a big but most
- 4:11independent economic groups, the Tax Foundation, AEI, Penn,
- 4:14Wharton Budget Model, they think those growth assumptions are
- 4:17way, way too optimistic, especially about how much people
- 4:20will actually work more just because of tax cuts.
- 4:22So bottom line on the cost, the disagreement isn't really about
- 4:26the new spending, it's about whether keeping the old tax cuts
- 4:29counts as a cost. That's the crux of the multi
- 4:31trillion dollar difference, yes. OK, fascinating and a bit mind
- 4:35bending. Let's move past the accounting
- 4:37arguments for a minute and get into the weeds.
- 4:39What's actually in this 940 page bill starting with the taxes.
- 4:42You said it's a transformation. It really is.
- 4:44The tax part is huge, about $4.5 trillion in tax reductions over
- 4:47the next decade according to standard scoring for
- 4:50individuals. The big headline is making the
- 4:522017 income tax rates permanent. That stops a big tax hike that
- 4:56was scheduled to happen. It also brings in some new
- 4:58breaks, like making income from tips tax free.
- 5:00Same for overtime pay. Interesting.
- 5:02What about families? The child tax credit.
- 5:04Yeah, the CTC gets a boost to $2200 per child, but the way
- 5:08it's structured means that many of the lowest income families,
- 5:11folks who don't owe much income tax, might not get the full
- 5:14amount. And then there was a big fight
- 5:16over the SALT deduction, state and local taxes.
- 5:18Right effects high tax states mostly.
- 5:20Exactly. So.
- 5:21As a compromise, they temporarily quadrupled the cap
- 5:24to $40,000 per household, but only for five years.
- 5:28And there's a new $6000 deduction specifically for
- 5:30seniors, folks over 65 with income under $75,000.
- 5:35OK. So quite a few changes for
- 5:36individuals. What about businesses?
- 5:38Just as significant there for smaller businesses, what they
- 5:41call pass throughs partnerships S core sole proprietors, the 20%
- 5:45qualified business income deduction, the QBI or 199 a
- 5:48deduction that's made permanent. That's huge for their long term
- 5:51planning. Plus they restored 100%
- 5:53immediate expensing, meaning they can.
- 5:55Deduct big purchases right away. Exactly.
- 5:57Investments in equipment, machinery, even R&D costs deduct
- 6:01the full cost in year one. That's meant to encourage
- 6:03investment. The Section 179 cap for small
- 6:06businesses also goes up permanently to $2.5 million.
- 6:10And then there's a bunch of complex stuff about
- 6:11international taxes, how U.S. companies are taxed on overseas
- 6:15profits, basically making permanent changes from 2017
- 6:18aimed at keeping U.S. companies competitive globally.
- 6:21So $4.5 trillion in tax cuts, how is that paid for or offset I
- 6:27guess? Well, that's where the spending
- 6:28cuts come in. The bill includes about $1.2
- 6:30trillion in spending reductions over 10 years, and the biggest
- 6:33target by far is Medicaid. The health insurance program for
- 6:36low income Americans. Right.
- 6:38Over $1 trillion in cuts projected for Medicaid, mostly
- 6:41through new, very strict work requirements.
- 6:43We're talking mandating 80 hours a month of work or volunteering
- 6:46for many adults, plus tighter eligibility rules.
- 6:49And they're cutting the federal matching rate for the ACA
- 6:51Medicaid expansion states. That shifts a huge cost burden
- 6:54onto those states. What?
- 6:55About that rural hospital little fund.
- 6:57Didn't Collins fight for that? She did, and there is a $25
- 6:59billion fund included. But critics are saying that's,
- 7:02you know, a drop in the bucket compared to a trillion dollars
- 7:05in overall cuts. It likely won't be enough to
- 7:07prevent serious problems for many rural providers.
- 7:10OK. And besides Medicaid.
- 7:12The other big area is SNAP, the Supplemental Nutrition
- 7:15Assistance Program, what used to be called food stamps.
- 7:18Work requirements are expanded there too, and this is a really
- 7:22big change. For the first time ever, states
- 7:24are being required to pay for part have the benefit costs
- 7:27themselves. Wow, states have to chip in for
- 7:29food stamps now. Yeah, that's a fundamental
- 7:31shift. It could force states to cut
- 7:33benefits or make it harder to qualify, especially if their
- 7:35budgets are tight and losing SNAP.
- 7:38That can knock people out of other programs, too, like free
- 7:40school lunches for kids or Head Start.
- 7:42Eligibility is often linked. So big cuts to safety net
- 7:46programs. Where is money being added?
- 7:48Any new spending? Oh yes, there's significant
- 7:51reallocation towards border and national security.
- 7:53About $350 billion in new funding there.
- 7:57That includes billions for the border wall, more migrant
- 8:00detention facilities, money to hire 10,000 new ICE officers.
- 8:05The stated goal is 1,000,000 deportations a year, plus $25
- 8:08billion for that Golden Dome missile defense system.
- 8:11And what about the environment? Climate change?
- 8:13There were big investments in the Inflation Reduction Act back
- 8:15in 2022. Yeah, this bill basically
- 8:17dismantles large ports of that. It repeals the tax credits for
- 8:20electric vehicles new and used. It cuts way back on incentives
- 8:23for rooftop solar, for battery storage.
- 8:26The greenhouse Gas Reduction fund is eliminated entirely,
- 8:29plus cuts to the National Park Service, the Forest Service, and
- 8:32mandates for more logging on federal lands.
- 8:34It's a sharp reversal on climate policy.
- 8:36OK. So we've got tax cuts mainly
- 8:38benefiting businesses and higher earners, paid for largely by
- 8:41Custer programs for lower income folks, plus a shift in spending
- 8:44towards security and away from climate.
- 8:47Let's pivot now to the impact. What does this all mean for
- 8:50American families? For you listening, these numbers
- 8:52are big, but how's it translate to kitchen table economics?
- 8:57Yeah, that's the crucial question.
- 8:58And the CBO analysis on who wins and who loses, the
- 9:01distributional effects, it's pretty stark.
- 9:04IT projects that on average, this bill will actually decrease
- 9:07the financial resources for households at the bottom end of
- 9:09the income scale, while increasing resources for middle
- 9:12and especially upper income households.
- 9:14Can you give us some numbers on that?
- 9:15Sure, the analysis suggests the wealthiest households could see
- 9:18their after tax income go up by an average of $12,000 a year.
- 9:22But the poorest households? They could lose an average of
- 9:24$1600 a year. That's mainly from the cuts to
- 9:27benefits like Medicaid and S and AP, plus higher healthcare costs
- 9:31potentially. So even if lower earners get a
- 9:34percentage tax cut, the loss of benefits outweighs it for the
- 9:37poorest. That's what the CB OS
- 9:39comprehensive analysis looking at both taxes and benefits
- 9:42suggests. Yes, it paints a picture of
- 9:45resources shifting upwards. So probably the starkest take
- 9:48away for families is that, according to the CBO, it's not
- 9:51lifting all boats. It appears to be systematically
- 9:53reallocating resources from the bottom towards the top.
- 9:56And the healthcare impact sounds potentially devastating for
- 9:59millions. It really does.
- 10:00The projection is 11.8 million more Americans uninsured by
- 10:032034, mostly because of those Medicaid work requirements and
- 10:07eligibility changes. If you can't document 80 hours
- 10:10of work a month, you could lose coverage.
- 10:12And even for those who keep insurance, costs could jump like
- 10:14$1650 more in annual out of talk.
- 10:17It costs for a low income family on Medicaid potentially, or over
- 10:20$8000 more a year for an elderly couple on Medicare.
- 10:23And rural hospitals getting squeezed.
- 10:25Severely. They rely heavily on Medicaid.
- 10:27That trillion dollar cut, even with the small fund, it puts
- 10:30them under immense pressure. We could see service cuts,
- 10:33maternity wards, closing ERS reducing hours, less mental
- 10:36health treatment and outright closures are a real risk.
- 10:39We saw projections for New York. I think potentially losing
- 10:4265,000 healthcare jobs just from these cuts.
- 10:45It ripple effects their entire communities.
- 10:47You mentioned states taking a hit too.
- 10:49It sounds like this bill pushes a lot of costs down to them.
- 10:51It absolutely does. Especially with Medicaid and now
- 10:54SNFP requiring state contributions, states will face
- 10:57really tough choices. Cut services deeply, raise taxes
- 11:01significantly, or some combination.
- 11:03It's a potential fiscal time bomb for state budgets, which
- 11:05impacts everything from schools to roads.
- 11:08And the food security aspect? Right, at least three million
- 11:10fewer people projected to get SNFP because of the work rules
- 11:13and the state cost sharing. And again, losing SNFP can mean
- 11:16losing school meals, Head Start access.
- 11:19It's a domino effect for struggling families.
- 11:21What about those other family provisions, the child tax credit
- 11:24and those new Trump accounts? Well, the child tax credit
- 11:26increased to $2200. As we said, the structure means
- 11:30it benefits middle and upper middle class families more fully
- 11:33than the lowest earners. Families earning up to $400,000
- 11:36get the full credit and the Trump accounts for kids.
- 11:39They get $1000 from the government to start, and
- 11:41families can add up to $5000 a year tax free.
- 11:45It sounds a bit like baby bonds, but the analysis suggests that
- 11:48because wealthier families are much more likely to be able to
- 11:50contribute the maximum $5000 each year, these accounts will
- 11:54likely end up widening the wealth gap over time, not
- 11:56closing it. OK, so significant impacts on
- 11:59households, especially lower income ones.
- 12:02Let's shift gears to the business world.
- 12:04Main Street. Wall Street.
- 12:06This bill clearly creates winners and losers across
- 12:08different sectors. Doesn't.
- 12:09It. Oh definitely.
- 12:10It's not an even playing field at all.
- 12:12For small businesses, especially those pass throughs, there are
- 12:14some clear wins. Making that 20% QBI deduction
- 12:17permanent is huge for tax certainty.
- 12:19The higher Section 179 expensing helps them invest, and keeping
- 12:23the lower individual rates helps most small business owners too,
- 12:25so Main Street get some desired stability.
- 12:28And large corporations. They do very well too.
- 12:30The permanent 21% corporate rate is obviously a major benefit.
- 12:34Restoring that 100% R&D expensing is a big deal for
- 12:37tech, pharma, advanced manufacturing, anyone doing
- 12:40innovation. Plus, there are specific
- 12:42incentives for building factories in the US that 100%
- 12:45expensing for qualified production property.
- 12:47But not all sectors are winners. The clean energy sector seems to
- 12:50take a big hit. A huge hit.
- 12:53Environmental groups are calling it, you know, catastrophic.
- 12:56Repealing the EV tax credits, slashing solar and wind
- 12:59incentives, gutting those investment funds.
- 13:01It's expected to have a real chilling effect.
- 13:04Billions in planned private investment might evaporate.
- 13:06Hundreds of thousands of jobs are potentially threatened.
- 13:08It almost certainly slows down decarbonization efforts and
- 13:11could hurt America's competitiveness in clean tech
- 13:14globally. And implicitly, this helps the
- 13:16fossil fuel industry in the near term by weakening their
- 13:19subsidized competitors. And the healthcare sector
- 13:22besides rural hospitals. The entire industry faces
- 13:24pressure. That $1 trillion plus Medicaid
- 13:27cut hits hospitals, community health clinics, doctors who
- 13:31serve Medicaid patients. It reduces their revenue
- 13:33significantly. They're facing fewer paying
- 13:36patients and potentially more people showing up needing care
- 13:38they can't pay for. So expect more pressure, service
- 13:41cuts, potential layoffs across the board in healthcare.
- 13:44OK, one more sector tech, specifically AI.
- 13:47You mentioned A twist there. Yeah, this was really
- 13:49interesting. The original bill had a
- 13:51provision. The big tech companies wanted a
- 13:5310 year ban on states making their own AI rules.
- 13:56They wanted one federal standard, but the Senate voted
- 13:59overwhelmingly, 99 to 1, to strip that out.
- 14:02Wow. So what does that mean?
- 14:03It means tech companies now face a potential nightmare, a
- 14:06patchwork quilt of different AI regulations across all 50
- 14:09states. Very complex, very costly to
- 14:11comply with. So it's a big set back for the
- 14:13industry's push for a uniform national approach, but kind of
- 14:17paradoxically, it might actually increase the pressure for
- 14:20comprehensive federal AI legislation down the road just
- 14:23to create some order out of the potential chaos.
- 14:25All right, So winners and losers in the business world.
- 14:28What about the financial markets?
- 14:30How are investors reacting? What's the signal for your
- 14:32portfolio? Well, the markets are getting
- 14:34some very mixed signals from this bill.
- 14:35There's a real tension. On one hand, you have the bulk
- 14:38case that focuses on the investment incentives, making
- 14:42full expensing for equipment and R&D permanent.
- 14:45That lowers the cost of investing, right?
- 14:47Proponents like the CEA are forecasting a big jump in real
- 14:51investment because of this, maybe 7% to 10%.
- 14:53It sounds positive, but there's always a but.
- 14:56There's always a but and the but.
- 14:57Here's the bear case, which centers on that massive increase
- 15:00in the federal deficit, the $3.3 trillion the CBO projects.
- 15:04To borrow that much money, the Treasury has to sell a ton more
- 15:07bonds. That competes directly with
- 15:09private companies looking for investment capital.
- 15:11It pushes interest rates up for everyone.
- 15:13The. Crowding out effect.
- 15:14Exactly. Crowding out private investment.
- 15:17Some analysis, like one from the Yale Budget Lab, argue this
- 15:20crowding out effect will eventually swamp the initial
- 15:22stimulus. They actually project lower long
- 15:25run business investment and a smaller economy because of the
- 15:28debt burden. So how is the stock market
- 15:30digesting this? It's kind of caught in the
- 15:33middle. We saw rallies leading up to the
- 15:35vote, you know, excitement about tax cuts boosting corporate
- 15:37profits. But the big worry is those
- 15:39higher interest rates sticking around because of the deficit.
- 15:42Higher rates make bonds look better compared to stocks.
- 15:45They also make future company earnings worth less.
- 15:47Today, that can drag stock prices down.
- 15:50We've already seen clean energy stocks get hammered because the
- 15:53subsidies were pulled. Some domestic manufacturers
- 15:55might get a boost, though. And the bond market, you said
- 15:57its reaction was clear? Unequivocally negative.
- 15:59Yeah. Bond investors are often called
- 16:01vigilantes because they punish governments they see as fiscally
- 16:04irresponsible by demanding higher interest rates.
- 16:07And we're seeing that the yield on the third year Treasury bond
- 16:10went above 5%. That hasn't happened since like
- 16:132007. The 10 year yield jumped too.
- 16:16And the 10 year is a key benchmark.
- 16:17Right. Huge benchmark effects, mortgage
- 16:19rates, corporate loans, everything.
- 16:21Investors are basically saying we need more compensation to
- 16:24hold U.S. debt now because there's more risk that Yale
- 16:27Budget Lab forecast. It predicts the 10 year yield
- 16:31will be 1.2 percentage points higher by 2054 purely because of
- 16:35this bill's debt impact. There's even a risk of something
- 16:38called fiscal dominance, where the government debt gets so big
- 16:40the Federal Reserve feels it can't raise rates to fight
- 16:43inflation because it would make the governments interest
- 16:45payments explode. That's a scary long term
- 16:48scenario. And finally, housing higher
- 16:50rates mean. Higher mortgage rates.
- 16:52Simple as that. The 30 year fixed rate mortgage
- 16:54is directly tied to Treasury yields.
- 16:56So as the deficit pushes Treasury yields up, mortgage
- 16:59rates go up too. That makes buying a homeless
- 17:01affordable, cools down demand, makes it more expensive for
- 17:04builders. Yes, the bill has some targeted
- 17:06things like tweaking the low income housing tax credit or the
- 17:09SALT cap change. But the big wave of higher
- 17:12interest rates driven by the deficit will likely overwhelm
- 17:15those smaller effects. It probably makes housing less
- 17:17accessible overall. So stepping back, looking at the
- 17:20big picture, this deep dive really highlights that massive
- 17:23gap between the economic future painted by the White House, CEA
- 17:26and the one described by the CBO and most independent analysts.
- 17:29One sees deficit cuts in a boom based on, let's say optimistic
- 17:32modeling and that current policy baseline.
- 17:34The other sees trillions in new debt, higher interest rates, and
- 17:37a long term drag from crowding out investment based on more
- 17:40standard methods. Understanding how they get these
- 17:42numbers is just as important as the numbers themselves, but the
- 17:45bottom line seems to be the US is heading down a significantly
- 17:48rocky or long term fiscal path under this legislation,
- 17:52according to most nonpartisan analysis.
- 17:54Which really leaves a big question for you, our listener.
- 17:56Given these starkly different analysis, these projections,
- 18:00what adjustments might you think about in your own financial
- 18:02planning maybe, or just in how you understand what's happening
- 18:05with economic policy? How are you going to navigate
- 18:07what seems like a new economic reality because these long term
- 18:11effects, especially the debt and interest rates, they could force
- 18:14some unexpected policy changes or create new economic
- 18:17challenges down the road. It certainly bears watching
- 18:19closely.