Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 18)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to get right
- 0:06back to the alex Acosta interview with the OIG Inspectors. Question.
- 0:12What I would like to do is ask a couple
- 0:14of questions in a couple of areas about the main
- 0:17Justice Review. Answer, okay, question, then take a short break,
- 0:22and then Redacted has some questions that are CVR related,
- 0:26and then we have some summary questions. Answer okay, question?
- 0:29Is that all right? Answer? Well, before you move on,
- 0:33can I address something that redacted was getting at? But
- 0:35it's getting late, so I'm going to circle back something
- 0:39that I thought you would bring up. So I think
- 0:42something to talk about is pre agreement and post agreement,
- 0:45I think are different. And one concern that I had,
- 0:48and I certainly shared with mister redacted, was once it
- 0:51was signed. So we had the initial issues with the case.
- 0:54Once the agreement was signed, we now have an overlying
- 0:57issue of is there is the agreement binding and to
- 1:01what extent it's binding? And so your question was why
- 1:05this level of process after the agreement was signed? And
- 1:08I said, I think you'll get back to that. And
- 1:10I think to some extent. There are two parts to that.
- 1:13One is the office shouldn't be afraid of review. We're
- 1:15part of the Department of Justice, and review, whether by
- 1:18main Justice or now you all, is part of the process.
- 1:22And so to the extent that they want to appeal
- 1:24to Maine, it would be unseemly sort of to say,
- 1:27don't review us, and I don't think it would help
- 1:29reviewing this. But the second part of it is we
- 1:33if we were to walk away from the agreement, that
- 1:35not only are we litigating the underlying criminal case, but
- 1:39we're litigating a civil criminal issue on top of that,
- 1:42which is did the agreement bind? And that's something that
- 1:46did inform the exhausting amount of process that they received,
- 1:51which didn't change any of the outcome. Question didn't bind?
- 1:55What answer? So if we were to walk away, could
- 1:58we still prosecute question? I see answer right, because having
- 2:03signed that, we were now parties to an agreement, and
- 2:06that would overlay any sort of prosecution, and so you
- 2:09had these collateral issues coming question. Just to make sure
- 2:14that we're clear, are you saying that there would have
- 2:17been difficulty in declaring a breach so that you could
- 2:20then indict? Answer correct? And so we'd have to litigate
- 2:24over a breach, because as much as they had collateral challenges,
- 2:28they are very careful in saying this is not a breach.
- 2:31We would just like review. And so one of the
- 2:34issues that overlaid the post the October going forward time
- 2:38period is on top of this, do we now want
- 2:41litigation over a breach? And so I think that is
- 2:44why the post agreement time period is different than the
- 2:46pre agreement time period question but was part of the problem.
- 2:50The result of the change from here is the date
- 2:53that you must comply to. You must use best efforts
- 2:57to comply answer possibly would whether it was or others
- 3:02or other parts of the agreement we can talk about.
- 3:04But once the agreement was signed and they do not
- 3:07and they start pushing the date, there becomes a legal
- 3:10issue over are they really in breach or not. I
- 3:14understand your perspective. I'm just saying, you know, earlier I
- 3:18said that there was a difference. You asked about the process,
- 3:21and I said, from my perspective, there's a difference between
- 3:24the pre agreement and the post agreement time period, and
- 3:27much of that difference is informed by if we declare
- 3:30a unilateral breach how does this hold up in court
- 3:33because now there's a signed agreement that the United States
- 3:36is party to. Question. Are you saying that part of
- 3:39the reason or maybe all of the reason that you
- 3:41continue to give accommodations and process and delay was because
- 3:45of the concern that you couldn't actually win a breach argument. Answer.
- 3:50I think that was a consideration. Another part of this
- 3:53consideration if a party wants to take I mean, Main
- 3:57Justice gave a lot of process. It was you know,
- 4:00it wasn't just too redacted, but it was up to
- 4:03it was up to the Assistant Attorney General for Criminal
- 4:06Division to be polite, but it was up to the
- 4:08dag bingo. This is what I've told you, folks from
- 4:12the very beginning. Maine Justice was the one who put
- 4:15this deal together. I don't care what a Costa says.
- 4:20And so if Main Justice is going to give this
- 4:22degree of process, we should be in the position of
- 4:25saying go forward, as opposed to I don't think it
- 4:27looks positive for the office to be viewed as fearing
- 4:30department review. Question, But were you giving the impression to
- 4:35the Department of Justice that you were the one who
- 4:37wanted this review so that they felt like, well, it's
- 4:40not just these defense attorneys who we can blow off.
- 4:43It's a United States attorney who was asking for this review,
- 4:46and so therefore we need to give the courtesy of
- 4:49reviewing this answer. I don't think I asked for it,
- 4:52as opposed to saying so from the very beginning, they
- 4:55said that they're going to take this to the Deputy
- 4:57Attorney General and the Attorney General, and I said, if
- 5:00you want to, fine. They just finally did, But that
- 5:04was that was not I think they raised that as
- 5:07early as August or September, and so I'm not surprised
- 5:10that it ended up there. I also thought it was
- 5:13important to not be in the position of fearing review.
- 5:17I think if you look at the contemporaneous record, there's
- 5:20an effort on our part to expedite the review redacted question.
- 5:25But there's a difference between have at it, go do
- 5:28what you want up at Maine and getting that non
- 5:31opposition and actually sending a signal in the case of
- 5:35the Criminal Division, the Assistant Attorney General in the case
- 5:38of the Dag's office, Mark Philippe or his assignee, that
- 5:43you supported their review and this appeal process. You could
- 5:46have said, look, we're going to go ahead and get
- 5:49on with our business. If you could have not so
- 5:52much to posed a review but not second, did their
- 5:54request for the defense request for review or not in
- 5:58fact invited the reviews? Answer? So, I'd be curious as
- 6:02to the timeline I would take issues with I invited
- 6:05the reviews, and I question whether did they initiate the
- 6:08reviews on their own? And then I have said, have
- 6:11at it or based on I mean, you've got more
- 6:14than the record than I do, or did I invite?
- 6:17I would say I did not invite the reviews? Question? Well,
- 6:21bad terminology. Perhaps. Let me ask you this, did you
- 6:25convey to the Criminal Division that you wanted them to
- 6:27review the matter as requested by the defense attorneys? Answer? So,
- 6:32from my perspective, I'm thinking back twelve years now. The
- 6:35very reason that we invited redacted to come down to
- 6:38Miami back in August was a sense that it would
- 6:41end up here. And so if it's going to end
- 6:44up here, let's bring redacted down, let's make them part
- 6:47of the initial meeting. You know, if there are some concerns,
- 6:50let's raise these, let's address them, let's get them out
- 6:53so we don't end up after we go forward with
- 6:55all of this back in front of redacted and redacted,
- 6:59and it's better to involve Maine Justice earlier. And so
- 7:02I would say I was trying, if anything, to involve
- 7:05Main Justice so that we didn't end up where we were,
- 7:09And it had been my expectation that October date would
- 7:12have been met the collateral review. Afterwards, the collateral appeals
- 7:17obviously did not go as we planned, and it was
- 7:20my sense we were going to end up at Maine
- 7:22Justice one way or the other. So my question is,
- 7:26in December, after the December meeting that you had with
- 7:29the Defense Council and they told you that they were
- 7:32going to Maine Justice to the Criminal Division, did you
- 7:35convey to Main Justice Criminal Division that you wanted them
- 7:38to conduct the review that Defense Council were seeking. Answer, so,
- 7:43I don't recall what I may or may not have conveyed.
- 7:45I think my recollection was if they want a review,
- 7:48that's the right. We're not as a department. We're not
- 7:51in the business of telling individuals that they can't take
- 7:54something to your supervisor or your superior. Whether Main Justice
- 7:58takes this or not is ultimately at their discretion. Question
- 8:03would it surprise you to learn that the Criminal Division
- 8:06Front office understood you to be requesting their review the
- 8:10review that was sought by defense counsel? Answer? Would it
- 8:14surprise me? Perhaps my understanding recollection is we shouldn't fear it.
- 8:19If they want it, that's their right. I thought, by
- 8:22inviting redacted down in the first place, that we had
- 8:25at least tried to address that early on. But I
- 8:28also thought that we might end up there in the
- 8:30first place. Question were you aware that a decision was
- 8:34made to grant the decision by your office to grant
- 8:36defense Counsel's request their insistence that redacted's role in the
- 8:40Criminal Division review be limited to review only and that
- 8:44he not be permitted, or that the Criminal Division I'm
- 8:47sorry I misspoke that because redacted had already been involved
- 8:51in essentially being a prosecutor on the case the Criminal
- 8:54Division in CEO's role vis a vee, this review should
- 8:58be review only, that they should be taken off the
- 9:01case as a partner. Answer, so I sought emails to
- 9:05that effect in the record, I don't have independent recollection
- 9:08of twelve years. Question do you think you were involved
- 9:12in that decision? Answer? To take them off question yes,
- 9:16answer to my recollection. I wanted them on as a partner.
- 9:20And I think the contemporaneous emails from redacted can you
- 9:24please come on board? Question? But that was earlier before
- 9:27this review process. Answer no, no, even after review process.
- 9:33I think there are contemporaneous emails where we're saying it's
- 9:36important that you be a part if we go to trial.
- 9:39It's important that you be part of the trial. As
- 9:42I went through the record, at least I remember an
- 9:45email perhaps from redacted to redacted that I'm copied on, saying, hey,
- 9:49can you reconsider it's important that you be part of
- 9:52this question reconsider the review only limitation? Answer no, reconsider
- 9:58being part of the trial? All right. So to be clear,
- 10:02do I understand that you correct me that you don't
- 10:05have any recollection one way or the other, whether you
- 10:07requested the Criminal Division to conduct the review or could
- 10:11it have happened? He cuts her off. So to the
- 10:15extent again, I'm going back twelve years, to the extent
- 10:19there is a request to it would be in the
- 10:21context of this is going to Washington, We're not fearful
- 10:24of this. Have at it question, and you would have
- 10:27conveyed that to Washington, not just the defense attorneys. Is
- 10:30that correct? Answer? I imagine in some way? Question? All right,
- 10:36just one more point, this one. This one was a
- 10:39little bit of an odd posture, however, because you had
- 10:42signed the agreement, and so you know, basically a contract
- 10:45between parties, and particularly on mister Epstein's side, a party
- 10:50who was extremely well represented. So is there any consideration
- 10:53on your part instead of saying, hey, everybody's got a
- 10:56right to review, knock yourself out, go to DC, as
- 11:00opposed to saying something like that ship is sailed. You
- 11:03sign this agreement, We're going forward. You don't go forward,
- 11:07you're in breach. End of story. Answer, So, as counsel
- 11:11are raising serious issues that go to ethics and go
- 11:13to fundamental relationships between sovereigns. In this twenty two dot
- 11:18fifty five appropriate as a matter of federal policy. Is
- 11:22what we're doing in overreach, you know, is what we're
- 11:24doing contrary to law? Are we extracting I'm characterizing this
- 11:28may or may not be accurate. Are we extracting unduly?
- 11:32Are we using criminal law to extract civil concessions in
- 11:36an ethically suspect way? Those are serious issues that isn't
- 11:40just is this a good case? Those are genuine issues.
- 11:44I happen to think, as I recall that we were
- 11:46in the right or we wouldn't have agreed to it.
- 11:49But by the same token, let's assume that Main Justice
- 11:52ultimately disagreed. Is that from a Main Justice perspective? And
- 11:56maybe I'm coming at this, you know, being informed by
- 11:59having been at Maine Justice question mm hmm answer where
- 12:03there was talk about can you believe what this ausa
- 12:06this AUSA may have done or may not have done
- 12:09without consulting that these are serious issues. They establish precedent.
- 12:14You know, maybe the DAG would have said this is
- 12:17not the kind of thing we'd support, and this is wrong,
- 12:19and so at the end of the day, let's move forward.
- 12:22But if once the issues are raised, I don't think
- 12:25a US attorney should say Main Justice should not review this.
- 12:29I think we're part of the department and these are
- 12:32valid issues. Main Justice doesn't need to take months to
- 12:35review this. Main Justice can expedite their review. But those
- 12:39are valid issues for the deputy and the AAG to review. Question.
- 12:44But one could look at it and say, well, those
- 12:46are all issues that the defense certainly knew about before
- 12:49they sign that agreement, and having signed that agreement, they're
- 12:53waiving all of that. That's what contracts are for. You've
- 12:56got all these issues. Don't sign the contract? Answer, and
- 13:00if I could. I think there's a December letter. I
- 13:04don't know if it's in the exhibits, but there's a
- 13:06December letter that I wrote. Maybe it's the nineteenth. The nineteenth,
- 13:11is you sort of ill fated NPA A dendum effort? Acosta? No,
- 13:17the letter to ken Starr that I wrote, the fourth
- 13:20letter to can Star Acosta. I'm sorry, question, is it
- 13:24the December fourth letter? Acosta? Yeah? Probably it's the December
- 13:30fourth letter redacted. Yeah, it didn't have a date. Question,
- 13:34All right, that's the one you wrote, Acosta. I think
- 13:39you know. I'm starting on page four. I have responded
- 13:42personally in some detail to your comments because I care
- 13:45deeply about both the law and the integrity of the office.
- 13:49I have responded personally and in detail as well, because
- 13:52your letter troubled me on a number of levels. Upon
- 13:55your understanding of the negotiations are the twenty two fifty
- 13:59five was first discussed July thirty First, you know, and
- 14:02one of these four points in the middle of two
- 14:04thousand and seven, your defense team decides ask to meet
- 14:08with me on September seventh. I met. After considering of
- 14:12the arguments, and after conferring with the FBI and redacted,
- 14:16our office decided to proceed with the indictment. At that time,
- 14:20I offered to delay our prosecutors to delay presentation to
- 14:24allow you to appeal our decision if you choose. You
- 14:28chose not to. Instead, you elected to enter into the NPA.
- 14:32Since the signing of the agreement, the Feds in our
- 14:34office have addressed several issues that have arisen, although the
- 14:38exchanges at the time were a bit litigious question, Could
- 14:42I point out that this letter is in response to,
- 14:46not at the request for a review by the Criminal
- 14:49Division that comes later. This is in response to ken
- 14:52Starr's letter to redacted about raising twenty two to fifty
- 14:55five issues that had not been raised with you before answer,
- 15:00which is in essence or review. I mean, they're coming
- 15:03to maand Justice, and you know it's against these many previous,
- 15:07foregone opportunities to object that I receive with surprise your
- 15:11letter requesting an eleventh hour after the fact review of
- 15:14our agreement. Although it happens rarely. I don't mind this
- 15:17office decision being appealed to Washington, and have previously directed
- 15:22our prosecutors to delay. Indeed, I'm confident in our prosecutor's
- 15:26evidence and legal analysis. I nonetheless directed them to consult
- 15:30with subject matter experts in the Criminal CEO's division to
- 15:34confer to our interpretation of the law before proceeding with
- 15:38the indictment. So I guess you know we consulted CEOs.
- 15:42I'm thus surprised to read a letter addressed to the
- 15:45Department headquarters that raises issues that either have not been
- 15:48raised with this office previously, or have been raised and
- 15:52in fact resolved with your client's favor. I'm troubled likewise
- 15:57by the apparent lack of finality in the agreement. The
- 16:00asas have been negotiating with Defense counsel and have for
- 16:03some time complained to me regarding the tactics used by
- 16:06the defense team. It appears to them that as soon
- 16:10as resolution is reached on one issue, defense Council finds
- 16:13ways to challenge the resolution collaterally. Question, so this is
- 16:18your protest? It sounds like Starr's effort to bypass you
- 16:22and go with new issues. Answer, it is, and I'm
- 16:28pushing back in that and I was inviting this, or
- 16:31I was sort of saying, you know that said there
- 16:34must be closure on the matter. Some in our office
- 16:37are deeply concerned that Defense Council will continue to mount
- 16:41collateral challenges to provision of the agreement even after mister
- 16:45Epstein has entered as guilty plea and thus rendered the
- 16:48agreement difficult, if not impossible, to unwind. In closing, I
- 16:52ask that you consult with co Council. If after consultation
- 16:56with your defense team, you believe that our agreement is unethical, unlawful,
- 17:01or unconstitutional, I'd ask that you notify us immediately so
- 17:05we can discuss the matter by phone or in person.
- 17:09I've consulted the chief prosecutor in the case, who has
- 17:12advised that she's ready to unwind the agreement and proceed
- 17:16to trial if necessary or appropriate. Question, So are you
- 17:20suggesting that this represents your protest of their appeal to adacted? Answer? So,
- 17:26protest is a loaded word. What I'm suggesting is that
- 17:30this is not invitation to appeal tomand justice. This is
- 17:33sort of saying enough is enough is enough? Question? But
- 17:36mister Acosta in fairness. This to clarify, this is in
- 17:40response to a letter directed to or adacted, dated November
- 17:44twenty eighth, two thousand and seven, raising issues that had
- 17:48not been raised with you. The appeal subsequently that I
- 17:52was asking about was an appeal for d'novo review, a
- 17:55d'novo review of the whole case. Answer understood. And the
- 18:00reason that I read this, you know, is this is
- 18:03not On one hand, I'm saying we do not fear review,
- 18:06but this is not an invitation to defense counsel to
- 18:10do a di novo. I'm not inviting them. I'm not
- 18:13saying let's have some more review. I'm saying enough is enough.
- 18:17If they appeal, that's fine, But this is not an
- 18:20invitation to appeal. Question. But there was nothing you could
- 18:24do to stop their appeal right except indict answer. And
- 18:27so the Department shouldn't stop an appeal to Main Justice,
- 18:30you know, by threatening question fair enough answer, because Main
- 18:34Justice has a right to review. Question. I should have
- 18:38said that that this this appeal process was stymying progress
- 18:42and resolving the Epstein case. Answer. It was question, and
- 18:46you had no way, You had no recourse other than
- 18:49at least Theoretically you could have just said, you know,
- 18:52we're going to tear it up and indict because you're
- 18:55in breach in effect answer, which would have raised civiltigation.
- 19:00Answer overlays, which is the point that I thought merited
- 19:04at least flushing out questions. So to be short of
- 19:08the Department itself getting a move on and getting this
- 19:11thing through expeditiously, did you feel like you just had
- 19:14to sit there and wait for everything to get done? Answer?
- 19:17I'm not sure it was sit there and wait. But
- 19:19ultimately the case did not get better with time, and
- 19:22there was frustration on our part. You know, the witnesses
- 19:25are not getting better. You know, time question, they're getting older.
- 19:30Answer they're getting which goes back to how a germ
- 19:32may see them redacted, right, Acosta and I do recall
- 19:37conversations of them getting older. You know, this case is
- 19:40not getting better, and now we have the civil overlay
- 19:43that we need to deal with. And so, yes, there
- 19:46was process, but while there was should we just call
- 19:49it a day? All of that factored into well, if
- 19:52the Department is reviewing, the Department is reviewing. All right, folks,
- 19:55we're going to wrap up this episode right here and
- 19:57then the next episode, we're going to pick up where
- 20:00we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 20:03this episode can be found in the description box.