Latest / Crypto Coin Show / What is needed for Crypto’s next Bull Run to happen? w/ Lars Christensen | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashon Addison from block West Capital for Investment, Pitch Media, and today
- 0:04on the Crypto Point Show. If Lars Saya Christensen, co founder of Concordium.
- 0:09Lars, welcome to the show and thank you for taking the time.
- 0:12Thank you for having me. Very welcome. I'm excited to dive into Concordium's
- 0:16Layer one blockchain, your insights into the crypto world where it stands right now,
- 0:21what it needs to get to to get to the next bull run.
- 0:24And I would love to start off our conversation by first of all hearing a
- 0:27little bit about you your background in banking and blockchain and how that led to
- 0:32Concordium, and then we'll dive into all those details. Yeah, I spent
- 0:37most of my life in trat FIU founded a bank back in the early nineties
- 0:43which was a very early adopter of the Internet. So we wrote out one
- 0:49of the first Internet trading platforms in the world back in the day, late
- 0:52nineties. So obviously, once you've you've experienced some sis with a transformative technology
- 1:02once you can't help looking for the next one. And hence I have been
- 1:07very interested in blockchin for quite a while. You know, I was made
- 1:10aware of bit kind quite early, maybe twenty eleven, twenty and twelve,
- 1:15and followed the space since then and become increasingly convinced about, particularly around what
- 1:22blockchain can can add to many processes and many industries in terms of of making
- 1:29processes safe for a more securely anchored, better finality, better settlement. So
- 1:36for me, for me, it's really the blockchain that interests me a lot
- 1:40of what that can bring to the party, more so than the crypto speculation
- 1:44on that side of it. But but of course the two things are interconnected,
- 1:49definitely. Yeah, and seeing not just early days in crypto, but
- 1:55starting a bank as well, I see where you get that feeling where you
- 2:00want to it's exciting to witness this innovation, but also you see that nothing
- 2:05is perfect in the way that it evolves. And I think that there's a
- 2:07lot of imperfections in the way that some of these blockchains are run in setting
- 2:14them up to be poised for more mainstreament option. And I'm guessing that you
- 2:17would have some criticisms or as a constructive feedback on sort of the current heavy
- 2:23entities in space and what might not be perfectly set out for the next stage
- 2:30of growth. Yeah, let's stay on the constructive side, because, as
- 2:32you said, any new technology will will take some time to find its place
- 2:38and its role and to be fully fully developed. And I mean the Internet
- 2:44and early to midnight so which was not a particularly well developed space either.
- 2:49And then there's a lot of similar problems there actually in terms of lack of
- 2:53general adoption, a lot of criticism, a lot of skepticism will there's ever
- 2:59be meaningful in the economy. And had many discussions back then with other trading
- 3:04people and that pure heavily trying to come into it that I was wasting my
- 3:07time completely with the Internet, and I see a lot of parallels actually today
- 3:14where you have the same you know, you haven't really achieved serious critical mass.
- 3:19Most people don't really understand the space because they don't feel threatnedpired or don't
- 3:25see the opportunities. They don't feel the need to really understand it. And
- 3:30these things change over time. But but personally, I feel we're sitting here
- 3:34with the transformance of technology with the potential not very similar to the Internet and
- 3:38in many ways providing exactly what the Internet needs. Because the problem about the
- 3:44Internet is that there's so much insecurity around using it, around who you're interacting
- 3:50with, who owns the digital files, et cetera. And then actually the
- 3:54Internet needs are blockchain to to sort of anchor it more firmly and create a
- 3:59safer world. So many parallels, and I think it's quite beneficial to have
- 4:04lived through the early days of the Internet because I think history repeats itself and
- 4:10I think that's what's happening now. Yeah, No, that's great to experience
- 4:16it firsthand. I wish I would have had the privilege to run through the
- 4:19dot com boom myself. My father did, and he instilled a little bit
- 4:24of that knowledge into me, and that's part of the reason why I've stuck
- 4:27around in blockchain since twenty fourteen as well. Now, from your firsthand experience,
- 4:32what are you you know, obviously you're seeing a lot of parallels.
- 4:35What are some of the current parts of blockchain that you think are stifling the
- 4:41progression to the next stage of adoption. I think that's a number of things.
- 4:47Right. First of all, this is early, very heavy focus on
- 4:51the crypto part of it, right, which is understandable, But we have
- 4:57to remember that I would say the key innovation here in many ways in this
- 5:00blockchain and the various tokens and coins are really they had to facilitate use use
- 5:08each other the blockchain, and would perhaps not even be needed if we had
- 5:11an efficient payment system in the in the traditional world, right, But because
- 5:15of the sort of lack of early adoption, which is what's exactly the same
- 5:20in the Internet day, so there wasn't a lot of interesting stuff happening there
- 5:23and for several and several years, and because it hasn't been that much of
- 5:29real use cases, you know, a lot of focus has gone to the
- 5:30cryptoside of it, and hence you kind of put a little bit the car
- 5:35in front of the holes in my view right there. And while that,
- 5:39on the other hand, has generated a lot of interest that maybe otherwise wouldn't
- 5:43have been there, I also think it maybe has moved too much with the
- 5:46focus away from the real from the real offer that that blockchain is to many
- 5:53processes, you know. So it's kind of it's kind of good and bad,
- 5:57you know, because clearly the interest that has been generated in this space
- 6:01has largely been because of crypto and crypto speculation and people being willing to invest
- 6:06in the promise of future developments of the technology, and without that probably the
- 6:13interest would have been less. But it has also a little bit removed the
- 6:15focus from what is a real deal here, which is blockchain can do an
- 6:19awful lot to improve existing processes and support entirely new business models that we haven't
- 6:28really thought of yet, you know. And in that sense, again a
- 6:31number of characters to early Internet, where you know, if you believe it
- 6:36was very evident that a lot of stuff could be done much much more efficiently
- 6:41via the Internet than what we were used to, and the same thing here,
- 6:46but obviously it's always a progression where there's some early often very nerdy adapters
- 6:51that I'll take a liking to a new technology, maybe don't see the need
- 7:00to make it more approachable for the mainstream because they understand it. So if
- 7:04other people don't understand it, it's their problem. But at the end of
- 7:08the day, it becomes also the industry's problem if it's too complicated for mainstream
- 7:14adoption. And if you think back at the Internet before we had browsers and
- 7:17before we had apps, that that wasn't a fun place to be for the
- 7:20average guy, right, it was fun for the net, but mainstream adoption
- 7:26came when it became easier to interact with and I think that's what we need
- 7:30to see and just some extend are beginning to see in blockchain. You know,
- 7:33the day that just as we're talking now over the internet, but we
- 7:36don't even pay a milli secular attention to that fact because it's so ingrained and
- 7:44just the utility of what we're what we're actually using. Here. The day
- 7:49that people use blockchain to navigate safer, having greater confidence in in in in
- 7:57who they're talking to and then various ass it's that they transacting but without having
- 8:03to think about the blockchain. That's when we will have arrived in many ways,
- 8:07you know, when when it's not front of your mind, but it's
- 8:09just something that provides utility and makes makes processes better. Yeah. And then
- 8:16of course there's an important point which I'm probably more focused on than most because
- 8:20I spent so many years in SHRADFA, and that's a role of regulation.
- 8:24I mean, if you look at the financial services industry back in the sixties,
- 8:30seventies, eighties, deep into the nineties, that was pretty much the
- 8:33wild West. You know, there wasn't much regulation. People could do whatever
- 8:37they want. And while that creates a certain freedom. It is also a
- 8:43hurdle to adoption because people simply don't dare to get involved. Right And once
- 8:48we then got regulation in particularly the UK in the mid eighties and the rest
- 8:54of Europe in the mid nineties and the US around year two thousand, of
- 9:00course I created a more difficult environment to navigate for many people. You needed
- 9:03to assign resource, you needed to respect the regulation, you needed to adopt
- 9:09it and integrate it. But you were rewarded the people that wanted to go
- 9:11through that with much more business because many more people were comfortable engaging and getting
- 9:16involved. And I think history repeats itself and we're going to see the same
- 9:22here. So it's very important to get regulation clarified as much as possible.
- 9:26Hopefully not to honor is hopefully not stifling innovation, but to have a clear
- 9:31rule set of what you can and what you cannot do is absolutely a precondition
- 9:35for a certainly for traditional finance to get involved, but also for most other
- 9:39industries. I think, yeah, no, that's a great perspective Larsen and
- 9:45I agree, And I'm curious on your thoughts on the parallel of the Wild
- 9:50West and the early days in banking and you know the wild West of crypto,
- 9:54which was supposed to be a few years ago. But what we saw
- 9:58in twenty twenty two, you know, with the failure of FTX and the
- 10:03lending companies, the earning companies, it seemed like there were some issues there
- 10:07on the compliance side that put a lot of people that would have all their
- 10:13trust in blockchain and crypto in the whole. Do you think that the worst
- 10:20is over in terms of you know, how could it get worse than than
- 10:24twenty twenty two and through through that process of fixing all those issues that happened
- 10:30last year, will come out with a regulatory framework that will ensure that won't
- 10:33happen again, or what do you sort of think of that situation? Well,
- 10:37be sally, particularly ft X was actually an example everything that's wrong with
- 10:43the existing system because that was a centralized failure, right There was a bunch
- 10:46of people that either didn't know what they were doing, or had bad intentions,
- 10:50or didn't know about risk management or what do I know, We'll we'll
- 10:54figure out exactly what happened, but but that was exactly a centralized problem,
- 10:58which is what we know from a traditional sector, right, Uh, and
- 11:03then then an example of of a failure in areas that we already know where
- 11:09where actually boxing has pretended to avoid those kind of failures, and we see
- 11:13that in many defied projects that actually don't have similar problems. So I think,
- 11:18in a funny way, it's also a validation that this movement towards decentralization
- 11:22is in fact valid, you know that being said, of course, uh,
- 11:28you know, it's very easy to get taught with the broad brass when
- 11:31when when there was something with grip to involved. And it's probably a finer
- 11:35point to say that what happened at FTX is exactly the same as happened with
- 11:39Lihman Brothers back in the day, right had not a lot to do with
- 11:43blockchain technology, just with poor rich manishment and poor poor governance and and and
- 11:48and lack of regulation. But but that's the fact that that was the problem
- 11:52there, right, So when that happens, it kind of points in two
- 11:58directions. It points at the people that irresponsibly abuse perhaps a lack of regulation,
- 12:07but it also points to people that didn't come up with regulation and time
- 12:09so that these things could be avoided. Right now, regulation necessarily must always
- 12:15be a little bit behind the curve. That's naturally you need to spot that
- 12:18something new is going on, then you need to understand it. Then you
- 12:20need to to take some input on and then you come up with suggestions for
- 12:26for regulation legislation, then you need the politicians to vote for it, and
- 12:31then you need to implement it. So it must always be somewhat behind the
- 12:35curve. It can't be any other way. So so I think you know,
- 12:39now now we've seen the problems that can occur, we know some of
- 12:45the dangers of this. Also the ICO era, where you know, a
- 12:50lot of people sort of got got engaged on very thin, thin grounds if
- 12:56you if you, if you will, and got hurt by it. So
- 13:00so I think the time now has come for regulators to step up and do
- 13:03their bit right. And I think in some gurisdictions you're seeing that you know,
- 13:07Switzerland has been has been looking at it for a long time. The
- 13:11MICA legislation and in the EU is a step in the right direction. I
- 13:16think that the US situation is a little bit more confused, where seems like
- 13:20you're more trying to fit these new models into old regulation, which is understandable.
- 13:28I mean, if you've called the Secures Exchange Commission. You know,
- 13:33everything looks like a security, right, And if everything looks like a security
- 13:37and you already have securities laws, it's a natural thing to say, well,
- 13:41follow those laws, right, And in many ways that's one way to
- 13:43deal with it. But I think also there needs to be a regulation that
- 13:46here are some new ways of doing stuff, just like the new way the
- 13:52Internet allowed new ways of delivering financial services and ultimately you managed to accommodate that
- 13:58with regulation. So so yes, I think we're over the worst. Also
- 14:03because people obviously will be a little bit more careful going forward. I think
- 14:09there are good science that regulators are trying to do their job, and we
- 14:13need we need both the industry to become more responsible. And then and and
- 14:18understand that it's natural that there's the world around you that will have certain views
- 14:24on how you should do think, particularly if you're asking for their money,
- 14:28that that is a reasonable expectation, or that that world around you will say,
- 14:33well, we don't want you to support criminal activity or facilitate terrfinancing and
- 14:39all this stuff. That is completely normal requirements from the society around you.
- 14:43And then and you should accept that. Then you should accept that anonymity is
- 14:48a problem. Privacy is not. That's a justified and reasonable requirement for many
- 14:54people, but anonymity and lack of accountability is a problem. And then if
- 14:58you blindly support that, well you can't expect you can't expect regulators to take
- 15:03a very kind view of you, and you can't expect serious businesses to get
- 15:07involved. So it's a little bit to be done on the industry side,
- 15:11and there's a bit to be done on the regulation side, and hopefully we'll
- 15:13come out in a place that allows for more mainstream adoption after that. Great
- 15:20perspective, Lars, And in terms of you know, where does the onus
- 15:24lie for this, I'm curious on your thoughts into how much should you know
- 15:31the layer one blockchain at the protocol level itself be involved as a you know,
- 15:37decentralized network that as they say, some no one's really running. It
- 15:43depends on which network and you know how much you dig into it. Should
- 15:48the protocol itself have certain enforcements around the privacy, anonymity KYC or the application
- 15:56level for adapts or just to the changes or all three or a mixture.
- 16:03Well, you can argue for many views around that. You know, in
- 16:07my view, the layer one sort of war or argument is by no means
- 16:14concluded. Right, we don't have at the moment a layer one out there
- 16:18that takes all the boxes. And what are all the boxes? It is
- 16:22obviously scalability, it is privacy, It is also accountability for users. I
- 16:29that that, I think that the ID obligation is logical to include in a
- 16:37layer one so that you can you can spread that across the entire network instead
- 16:41of people having to build more silos. It's around finality that things act incantly
- 16:45rolled back. I think we're living a little bit in in a in a
- 16:51fantasy world that blockchains are very secure. They're not. They can be rolled
- 16:55back if you get control of them. And therefore finality that we don't discuss
- 16:59as much as we should. It's very important. But you know, scalability,
- 17:03privacy, finality, accountability, I think is things that naturally lies within
- 17:11a well designed layer one. Because these are complex things to build. They
- 17:14are tech heavy, their cryptography heavy if you want to get them right,
- 17:18and you can't expect the average sort of adapt to have to build this.
- 17:23So I think, like we did with our own layer of one, can
- 17:27calling where we're trying to cover this sort of based foundation in order to allow
- 17:33people to then add their belts and whistles and things that are more obvious for
- 17:37the layer two. You know, your special use case, your special business
- 17:41model, your special offer. But I think you you you have have an
- 17:47advances if you can anchor in a blockchain that does most of the heavy lifting
- 17:52on the sort of the care things that go across all blockchains, and that
- 17:56to me is a problem that is not solved by the bigger it works out
- 18:00there. At this point. We're trying to We're trying to come up with
- 18:03a solution for it. One more thing is that fees cannot be as unpredictable
- 18:08as they are on many of these blockchains today, because you can't have a
- 18:12situation where you build a brilliant use case that was based on its am fees
- 18:17three years ago and now fees are completely different places and your bid, then
- 18:21your your business case is out the window. Right. So also finding ways
- 18:25to deal with the predictability of fees and preferably very stable fees, I think
- 18:30it's sort of key components with the other ones that I mentioned, And I
- 18:34think if you can build that into a layer one and it might view you
- 18:37can. Why not. I mean, you're doing your layer two and your
- 18:41use case is a big favor by them not having to build it. And
- 18:45secondly, you're doing the whole space of favor by not creating the dependency on
- 18:51a whole bunch of layer two. So that actually just takes us back to
- 18:55where we came from. You know, more things that can go wrong,
- 18:57more things that you have to check, more things that create points of failure.
- 19:03So as much as you can build sort of the basic solidity into the
- 19:08foundation, I think you should do it. And that's what we're trying to
- 19:11do at one voting. I'd love to hear a little bit more on I
- 19:17know that your team is focused on the compliance and on the identity side,
- 19:22how exactly you've implemented that with Concordium, and what you think the optimal path
- 19:26is for other layer ones to take in terms of identity. I think idea
- 19:30is a core responsibility also to avoid that everybody has to build it in siloed
- 19:37ways, so you have to repeat and repeat and repeat just as it is.
- 19:41And for example, the financial sector today, if if my banks there's
- 19:44an idea on you and you then say, well, now I'd like to
- 19:47trade with another bank, that bank has to go through exactly the same process,
- 19:51which means an almost complication of watergloads. Right, So so why not
- 19:56trying to deliver that in one gover? Right? So the idea which is
- 20:02a pretty binary thing, right, either you're asking or you're not right,
- 20:06either I'm lost or not. So, so that is something you can realistically
- 20:10built into a layer one, right, And you can do that in a
- 20:12decentralized way without sort of a centralized gatekeeper. And we've we've found ways to
- 20:18do that, which also means that you and I have the ability to in
- 20:23any contakes verify to each other that we are in fact the people that we
- 20:29claim to be, which I think is a big value and will only be
- 20:33more and more important with you know, AI and metaverses and various virtual environments
- 20:37where you know, part of the proposition actually is I want to be something
- 20:42that I'm not in everyday life, which is fine. But if we then
- 20:47inside that environment decide to do a piece of business or strike up a close
- 20:52and social relation or something, then then you do need to sometimes know who
- 20:56you're dealing with. And and I think that should be an optional function provided
- 21:00by infrastructure and not something that every single metaverse and every single use case has
- 21:06to build. So I think it's it's doable. KYC, on the other
- 21:10hand, there's a million different things ideas binary either you are or you're not.
- 21:15But KYC can be a million different things for a million different use cases.
- 21:18Right, If you want to trade the sophisticated derivatives on soy beings denominated
- 21:26in Japanese yen, well you need I need to know something about you in
- 21:30order to offer that service. If on the other hand, you want to
- 21:33be a member of the local panel cup or something, they might want to
- 21:37know that you live in the area, or you know how to hold a
- 21:40racket. But it's a different kind of KYC. So from EKYC is more
- 21:45a layer two responsibility. But the funder of the fundament of any KYC is,
- 21:49of course that the person we're doing KYC is is in fact the person
- 21:55that the person claims to be. So in that sense, I think KYC
- 21:59is more more or layer to responsibility because it's so different from use pas to
- 22:03use pas and application to application. But that doesn't stop that you can make
- 22:07that life easier by building you know, KYC containers that you can then populate
- 22:14with the questions you specifically need answers to and easily integrate that, which is
- 22:18what some of the areas that we're looking at. But at the end of
- 22:22the day, if you want to, you know, set up a business
- 22:26that sells used used toys or used furniture or whatever, I can't I can't
- 22:33predict what ky you will feel it's necessary, or what a what a regulator
- 22:38might feel it's necessary if you buy a very expensive piece of toy or furniture
- 22:44and a lot of money change his hands. So that's for the use pasee.
- 22:47But we will build some containers to make it simple for you to ask
- 22:51you necessary questions and convert them into a digital certificate that you can then link
- 22:56to the ID. Right. But the actual for relation of those KYC questions
- 23:00I think is mostly opposite the use case because they vary a lot from from
- 23:06apps from tapp to that. Right. Very interesting, Lars and looking towards
- 23:11the future, how do you see this playing out with layer ones trying to
- 23:18figure out what's the best way to comply and it seems like you know,
- 23:22they're like the sec for example versus coin base. You know, they were
- 23:26asking for more clarity on the regulation and they just really didn't have an answer
- 23:30and sort of like stifling the innovation on, like they don't know exactly what
- 23:33to do to get to the next level of adoption. How do you see
- 23:38this sort of playing out versus the protocols and the regulation in what needs to
- 23:42come first and how can we get to that point of further mainstream adoption.
- 23:48I think that obligations to provide clear regulation must necessarily live with alemakers and with
- 23:56regulators, right, So I think it is not the reason or let you
- 24:00say, well, how can I be compliant and the regulators say you find
- 24:04out, right, I mean tell us how to be compliant, which is
- 24:07kind of the European approach, and and then you should be compliant, right.
- 24:15I don't like the sort of approach where you say you figure out and
- 24:18you take your own legal advice, et cetera. Right, And I think
- 24:21the only reason that that can be done is because you have this legalsly regulatory
- 24:25environment where you're kind of saying, well, let's just fit it into that
- 24:27and you must figure out how you comply. Right now, you can't do
- 24:32that forever. If you have innovations and new technique aways of delivering something,
- 24:36you also need to update regulation, right, And I very much hope that
- 24:41that will happen in as many jurisdictions as possible, right, And I think
- 24:44that is happening to to a good extending in the EU, where I do
- 24:48think that meek has a decent first step in that direction, right, that
- 24:52it's clarifying a number of things, and I think over all that that is
- 24:59a reflect of the EU being quite constructive towards block chaining, towards towards also
- 25:04using blockchain as a funding mechanism, because they are very aware, for example,
- 25:08that all is a knee sector is facing a lot of funding issues because
- 25:15of banking. The banking sector really wants a big clients and a keen on
- 25:19on on funding small small businesses. And I know for a fact that in
- 25:26the EU Commission a lot of people see blockchain as part of the solution to
- 25:29that within an organized regulatory environment. So that since I think it's constructed and
- 25:37then on a good on a good path as far as I can see,
- 25:41you know, we're but no, we're no, no, No one stands
- 25:45of the imagination towards the end of that half, and we actually never will
- 25:48be. That's another misconception in this space that oh, if we could just
- 25:52get regulation, then everything would be clear and we can move on. Right,
- 25:56That's not the way it works. Regulation continues because new things development.
- 26:00Regulators need a job too, so they will keep keep innovating regulation if you
- 26:07will. So so that's a never ending process. So don't go around and
- 26:10dream that you know, once we get this clarity, then everything will be
- 26:14forever after like that. That's not how regulation works. So it's a continuous
- 26:18adjustment of of of regulation to the reality that that is out there. Right,
- 26:23So I think, I think, but basically I think that the primary
- 26:30obligation for securing a regulation must lie with lawmakers and regulators that they come up
- 26:37with something that you can actually comply to, because otherwise you're in a very
- 26:41dangerous spot where where you know, some people can argue, well, we
- 26:45didn't have anything to comply with, so we could do whatever we wanted to,
- 26:48right, And we've seen that multiple times over the last decades in trad
- 26:53FI. You know that people abuse the situation that there's there's not to comply
- 27:00to. So the soooning get a clear regulatory picture in the better Yep,
- 27:04great insights, Lars. Thank you so much for everything around this compliance on
- 27:10Concordium. Is there any ways that we can follow more of your work or
- 27:15more of Concordium. Yeah. I would say the easy way to start out
- 27:22would be going to our website compordium dot com, where you can see all
- 27:26our various channels and you can you can follow the various communities, et cetera.
- 27:30And we're actually bringing out a new version of the website much improved in
- 27:37just a week or two, so that's a good place to stop. And
- 27:41from there, depending on the amount of interest you have, you can sort
- 27:44of go on into the various communities around it, whether that's as a developer,
- 27:48as a user, or a general enthusiasts. We we welcome you and
- 27:52we try to be responsive and be there if you have any questions. So
- 27:56I want to build a use case, I just want to know more.
- 28:00Sounds great. Thank you so much, Lars. I'll leave those links in
- 28:03the notes as well below. All the best with everything moving forward in Concordium,
- 28:07and thank you for bringing more clarity towards the blockchain industry. Let's definitely
- 28:11follow up in the near future. Thank you very much for having me asked.
- 28:15I appreciate it.