Latest / The HERD FIT / S05E150 Harmonizing CrossFit's Competitive Future: Leadership, Communication, and Judging
Transcript
- 0:05David Syvertsen: Hey everybody, welcome to the Herd Fit Podcast with Dr Sam Rhee and myself, Coach David Syverton.
- 0:10David Syvertsen: This podcast is aimed at helping anyone and everyone looking to enhance their healthy lifestyle through fitness, nutrition and, most importantly, mindset.
- 0:19David Syvertsen: All right, welcome back to the Herd Fit Podcast.
- 0:23David Syvertsen: I'm Coach David Syverton.
- 0:24David Syvertsen: I'm here with my co-host, dr and Coach Sam Rhee.
- 0:26David Syvertsen: Back to just us two today, after speaking with Amy last week, and we are going to kind of keep the discussion a little bit on the sport for just one more week, and then we have a couple other exciting guests coming up in the coming weeks and we want to talk about some solutions.
- 0:41David Syvertsen: Right, sam?
- 0:43David Syvertsen: What's one thing we always talk about with coaches?
- 0:44David Syvertsen: It's like all right, don't just talk about problems, bring some solutions to the table.
- 0:48David Syvertsen: Right, I don't want to hear about problems, I want to hear about solutions after we talk about the problems.
- 0:53David Syvertsen: And CrossFit sport is they're struggling dude, and I love them and I'm loyal to them and I love the people at the top.
- 1:03David Syvertsen: But if I was not involved in CrossFit as an affiliate owner, as an athlete, as a competitor, as someone that just has a lot of love and appreciation for guys like Dave Castro and Boz and Wilson, who I got to speak with a few weeks ago, and our new CEO, don Fall.
- 1:17David Syvertsen: I would look at it from the outside and be like this is a disaster.
- 1:21David Syvertsen: Just way too many mistakes that are getting repeated over and over, and I do think that they are really proactive with trying to find solutions to problems.
- 1:32David Syvertsen: They do.
- 1:32David Syvertsen: They change the season up every year, yeah, but some of the issues that are reoccurring are really alarming to me and I still don't think that the people that are making the decisions have come up with the right solution.
- 1:44David Syvertsen: And we're gonna here we going to talk about a couple of our solutions that might work, that might not work, why they could work, why there's no way they could work, and we also I just want to put the disclaimer out there we don't know all the details to their problems, but I do want to talk from the consumer perspective, as an affiliate manager, as a coach.
- 2:04David Syvertsen: From the consumer perspective as an affiliate manager, as a coach, as an athlete, as a competitor, that I'm kind of getting sick of a few things with the shortcomings, that in my opinion, they're really easy to fix, and as a business owner here, when we have issues, we have issues all the time it happens you have to try and simplify them as much as you can and knock out the easy parts first, or at least the foundation of the problem first, right, and then you kind of work your way up, and that's what I want to do here.
- 2:32David Syvertsen: So you know, just opening thoughts on this sam, where you know you're into the sport, you're not to die hard, but you're into it, you're very involved in it, and you now have a different label next to your name in terms of what you are to to cross at bison as a part owner.
- 2:48David Syvertsen: Now that I think that what you say about this means a lot, because and what you think about this does mean a lot because of how long you've been involved and bison is one of the biggest gems in the world when it comes to open registration and quarterfinal registration that I think what you say matters.
- 3:06David Syvertsen: So what are your opening thoughts?
- 3:07David Syvertsen: You don't have to hold back if you don't want to, because I think CrossFit needs to hear some of this stuff.
- 3:13Sam Rhee: I've heard people talk, especially on other podcasts talking Elite, fitness and Hiller and so forth about what the problems are and how they think it should be fixed.
- 3:24Sam Rhee: You're right, a lot of it is complaining, not so many solutions, right, exactly, yeah, but I would really like to hear your take on the solutions, because I've not been very happy with the solutions that a lot of people have proposed.
- 3:36Sam Rhee: I also know that CrossFit and we know them their leadership is very strong-minded.
- 3:43Sam Rhee: It's going to take a lot for them to change what they think is right, and so any solutions that are proposed have to really resonate with what they believe.
- 3:53Sam Rhee: I know you're a true CrossFit person, like your beliefs, and I think HQ beliefs actually align very closely.
- 4:01Sam Rhee: I agree, where I've seen their programming going, where I've seen them sort of try to approach their philosophy of growth, it really meshes, I think, with what our affiliate has done, which is, I think, why we've been so successful.
- 4:16Sam Rhee: But the solutions have to really align with the way they think in order for them to implement them.
- 4:24David Syvertsen: Yeah, yeah, and I think that is probably one of the biggest challenges that Dave Castro and Don Fallen and Boz have that you have to get everyone, every voice in that room to align.
- 4:33David Syvertsen: And one thing I know about CrossFitters a lot of egos are involved in this place and people that have a lot of success outside of CrossFit, so they're confident in their ability to make decisions and make calls because they've had success in these leadership type positions.
- 4:50David Syvertsen: And I would love to be a fly on the wall and I'm never going to be but like I would like to see some of these conversations that go down that who really is like the alpha in there, or are there too many alphas in there?
- 5:01David Syvertsen: There's too many cooks in the kitchen where, because of that, they there are too many alphas in there.
- 5:05David Syvertsen: There's too many cooks in the kitchen where, because of that, they can't come up with a really streamlined solution, and a lot of that comes from.
- 5:10David Syvertsen: You have to check your ego in these meetings and these decision-making processes and I give credit to Dave Castro for going.
- 5:16David Syvertsen: He's pretty transparent on his weekend reviews that he puts on YouTube.
- 5:21David Syvertsen: I don't think he gives us everything he shouldn't, but he's pretty transparent and that's one of my biggest complaints with CrossFit is how bad they are at being transparent with issues, with communication.
- 5:31David Syvertsen: They had a huge one this year.
- 5:32David Syvertsen: That really pissed me off and he, at least, will go on there.
- 5:36David Syvertsen: And he acknowledges that there's mistakes and he acknowledges that we're making changes next year.
- 5:40David Syvertsen: He said there's going to be a huge change next year.
- 5:42David Syvertsen: I have a feeling I know it's going to be too.
- 5:43David Syvertsen: What pissed you off?
- 5:45David Syvertsen: When the leaderboard was supposed to be final, it didn't become final until, I think, 18 hours after.
- 5:50David Syvertsen: Oh, I see, and that sounds not like a big deal, but when you're on the, when you're checking like refresh, if I made it, if not, if they made it, if they didn't, we need to make plans to communicate this to the gym and stuff like that.
- 6:03David Syvertsen: And you tell us it's going to be ready at 8 or 9 pm Eastern.
- 6:06David Syvertsen: It's not available till the noon the next day and in that time there's no communication.
- 6:11David Syvertsen: That, hey guys, there's a bug, we have an issue.
- 6:13David Syvertsen: I texted someone at CrossFit and I said this is what you guys are really bad at.
- 6:18David Syvertsen: I was like you're not.
- 6:19David Syvertsen: Just let us know you made a mistake or something happened.
- 6:22David Syvertsen: Right, let us know you made a mistake or something happened, right, like if if here at bison, if we said, uh, you know you couldn't design it, what happens every single time zen planner goes down?
- 6:30David Syvertsen: Remember, remember that zen planner was going down every now.
- 6:32David Syvertsen: And then, yeah, right around 5 am, 5 pm, 6 pm, when most of our people sign up, yeah, the first thing we do is go onto facebook.
- 6:40David Syvertsen: Hey guys, there's an issue with zen.
- 6:41David Syvertsen: You know, if we didn't like have and it has nothing to do with us either, but we did let the gym know that.
- 6:46David Syvertsen: You know, we notified zen, we notified their help desk.
- 6:49David Syvertsen: They're on top of it.
- 6:50David Syvertsen: And then what do we do when we hear back from zen?
- 6:52David Syvertsen: Hey guys, they're working on it.
- 6:53David Syvertsen: So at least you guys know that.
- 6:55David Syvertsen: We know that there's a huge issue and that's that.
- 6:58David Syvertsen: But, dave cashow, he only does these once a week, so that doesn't help you.
- 7:02David Syvertsen: We need more real-time communication and in today's world, not being able to communicate in a timely fashion, there's no excuse.
- 7:09David Syvertsen: There are so many mediums, so many outlets.
- 7:11David Syvertsen: You can put some information.
- 7:13David Syvertsen: A simple one-liner there's an issue, we're working on it, goodbye, that's it.
- 7:17David Syvertsen: That's all you got to do.
- 7:17David Syvertsen: It's very simple.
- 7:18David Syvertsen: So that's where I think Dave Castro does a good job of being transparent, but I wish the whole company was a little bit more transparent with issues like that.
- 7:27David Syvertsen: So let's talk about some of the history of the games.
- 7:30David Syvertsen: I'm not going to go give a history lesson, but I want you guys to know where this came from.
- 7:33David Syvertsen: You used to be able to sign up for anything that you wanted to do, including the games.
- 7:36David Syvertsen: I want to sign up, I want to go compete at the ranch, and then it became I have to qualify.
- 7:41David Syvertsen: Then it became I have to qualify.
- 7:46David Syvertsen: And then the open started in 2011 and if you finished, it used to be top 60.
- 7:48David Syvertsen: Then it was top 40.
- 7:48David Syvertsen: They switched the regions around, but basically, you started at the open and if you were good enough, you qualified for regionals and that was really what helped CrossFit games take off that whole regional scene going to these big arenas and people you know traveling all over the country to go watch these athletes and then, if you qualified from the games from there, that's when the actual CrossFit Games took off and they switched locations and kind of fields and everything.
- 8:11David Syvertsen: You also have to keep in mind Castro says this all the time it's a very young sport.
- 8:15David Syvertsen: If you want to go research he says this all the time go research what Major League Baseball was in its first 10 years.
- 8:24David Syvertsen: And NFL, I mean those guys are changing rules every year to make it better.
- 8:31David Syvertsen: So there is some grace given to.
- 8:32David Syvertsen: I don't mind making mistakes like that.
- 8:32David Syvertsen: That's a part of any process, any growing process, and they are still very early in the process.
- 8:34David Syvertsen: But repeated mistakes is where I start to get a little bothered by.
- 8:38David Syvertsen: So basically, when Greg Glassman took regionals away after 2018, and then COVID comes and then three or four different CEOs in a matter of four years, it's just a lot of instability in the company overall and the games kind of stayed alive.
- 8:53David Syvertsen: But they were qualifying through sanctionals and online and then they got invites and then they had one person from every country.
- 9:01David Syvertsen: Change, change, change.
- 9:02David Syvertsen: Basically, I think we've found a rhythm.
- 9:05David Syvertsen: We are back to now to a three-week open and if you're good enough, you're going to qualify for quarterfinals.
- 9:12David Syvertsen: I don't care what they do with it.
- 9:14David Syvertsen: Top 10%, top 25%.
- 9:15David Syvertsen: 25% makes sense to me because of the money.
- 9:18David Syvertsen: You get more money.
- 9:20David Syvertsen: Call it a money grab Done, it's a money grab Awesome.
- 9:23David Syvertsen: They need the money.
- 9:24David Syvertsen: So if they don't have the money, there's no games.
- 9:26David Syvertsen: Okay.
- 9:26David Syvertsen: I thought it was good for affiliates and a lot of athletes too, absolutely so I'm all about.
- 9:30David Syvertsen: I don't wanna make it top 50%, but I think 25% is a very good number.
- 9:34David Syvertsen: Okay.
- 9:35David Syvertsen: And if you qualify for semifinals for age groups, it's another online competition for Open Division.
- 9:42David Syvertsen: You go to a live competition that eventually brings people to the games.
- 9:47David Syvertsen: I think it's going to stay in that rhythm.
- 9:49David Syvertsen: I think it's a really good flow.
- 9:51David Syvertsen: Most people like a three-week Open.
- 9:53David Syvertsen: Quarterfinals are really cool.
- 9:55David Syvertsen: I think they're more affiliate-friendly now.
- 9:57David Syvertsen: Semifinals are really cool, whether it's Masters or individual, and then you've got the games.
- 10:03David Syvertsen: Do you like that flow?
- 10:06Sam Rhee: masters or individual, and then you got the games.
- 10:07Sam Rhee: Do you like that flow?
- 10:08Sam Rhee: Yes, I think that that sort of mimics what sort of worked before, but in a more cost efficient way.
- 10:12Sam Rhee: Uh, and I think it's the accessibility that they presented this year was was.
- 10:19Sam Rhee: They're all welcome changes and I think that if they kind of stick to an outline like this, that would work yeah.
- 10:23David Syvertsen: So that's what simplify the problem start from the bottom, create your format, and I think CrossFit has created their format.
- 10:30David Syvertsen: I hope they don't change it next year.
- 10:32David Syvertsen: Right, there's been a couple rumors that it's you know you're going to qualify for the semifinals from from the open or something like that, or they bring back regionals.
- 10:39David Syvertsen: I think this is the solution.
- 10:41David Syvertsen: They they found.
- 10:42David Syvertsen: They've tweaked it multiple times.
- 10:44David Syvertsen: It works three Three-week open online quarterfinals, semifinals in your gym for Masters and an actual location for Open Division Cool, then go to the games.
- 10:55David Syvertsen: I don't want to get too into how many people from each region qualify.
- 10:58David Syvertsen: That's like math.
- 11:00David Syvertsen: How many people are registering from certain regions.
- 11:02David Syvertsen: I don't want to get into that.
- 11:04David Syvertsen: The train wreck of two things leaking workouts, you know like this happened twice.
- 11:12David Syvertsen: It happened without dave cashrow and he said and he kind of like scoffed at it, laughed at it, and now it happened with dave cashrow in charge and he's pretty pissed off about it.
- 11:19David Syvertsen: He went on his weekend review and said he was pissed off about it.
- 11:22David Syvertsen: Why does that happen?
- 11:24David Syvertsen: Happen.
- 11:24David Syvertsen: I'm not a tech guy so I'm not really sure what happens.
- 11:28David Syvertsen: You know, something got posted as public and it shouldn't have been public.
- 11:31David Syvertsen: Someone pressed the wrong button which leak the open, leak the open workout.
- 11:35David Syvertsen: So 24.3.
- 11:37David Syvertsen: Yep, yep, does it bother you that it gets leaked?
- 11:41Sam Rhee: It just shows a sign of potential shoddiness.
- 11:45Sam Rhee: So it's not like that, it's such a big deal, but it just shows you like you don't have any everything squared away.
- 11:51David Syvertsen: So you're like, okay, if they're leaking this, what else isn't like yeah quite right, right, and now the semi-final workouts get leaked, and castro also said this.
- 11:58David Syvertsen: You know he didn't want to, he doesn't know who did it, but he goes now that we're going to these semifinal satellite locations.
- 12:05David Syvertsen: You know there's hundreds of people that need to know the workouts.
- 12:10David Syvertsen: Well, he said 51.
- 12:11David Syvertsen: Yeah, okay, outside of CrossFit.
- 12:12David Syvertsen: Yes, so I would say I would assume that that number right there one of those people from those competitions leaked it to someone.
- 12:20David Syvertsen: Yep, and that's kind of like that is what it is.
- 12:23Sam Rhee: Yeah, I mean we know that process.
- 12:25Sam Rhee: We had to sign NDAs before the open announcement, yep, and any one of us could have leaked it Absolutely.
- 12:30Sam Rhee: And but, for the grace of God, like listen, there are people who are willing to do that, right?
- 12:36David Syvertsen: So yeah, I think that Solution there would be control the narrative, put the workouts sooner, before the people have to know and hey, it's not a surprise anymore.
- 12:47David Syvertsen: Whatever, honestly, if anything, it might make for a better show.
- 12:51Sam Rhee: The technical issues.
- 12:53Sam Rhee: He got pissed.
- 12:54Sam Rhee: Yes, someone dropped the ball there.
- 12:55Sam Rhee: I will be shocked if that ever happens again.
- 12:58Sam Rhee: Technically, yeah, the vendors and other people who have to know who leak it.
- 13:02Sam Rhee: Unfortunately, if anything he said, there are going to be changes.
- 13:06Sam Rhee: What will probably happen is people will suffer because of it, like they won't release them, like the later, or the vendors won't have as much time to set up.
- 13:19Sam Rhee: Like there's going to be some negative changes overall.
- 13:21Sam Rhee: It's like, well, now you ruined for everyone, so we're not going to be able to release these properly yeah.
- 13:27David Syvertsen: So whoever released that really poor job by you, like really selfish decision, because now there's like going to be consequences that other people have to deal with now and that's just.
- 13:35David Syvertsen: It's just not right and really the only reason anyone would leak a workout to a coach or an athlete is for for selfish reasons.
- 13:43David Syvertsen: You know, and like that, that, that we need less of that.
- 13:45David Syvertsen: So, the biggest issue that we've had so far this season and this has been an ongoing issue, and this is why I'm so bothered why they haven't released it or haven't fixed this yet the online judging the subjectivity to that and giving out penalties.
- 14:01David Syvertsen: You know Sam's illustration that he gave is one of the best ever about getting a speeding ticket.
- 14:05David Syvertsen: Yes, athlet, athletes can't really be that upset about getting caught.
- 14:08David Syvertsen: Well, cheating, slash, not hitting the standards while others didn't.
- 14:12David Syvertsen: That's just not the way it works, ok.
- 14:15David Syvertsen: However, is there a better system to prevent this from happening?
- 14:20David Syvertsen: And or can you find a way to actually check the other people, meaning getting more cops on the side of the road to check if everyone's speeding to make it more quote fair, even though life is not supposed to be fair, it's never going to be fair.
- 14:32David Syvertsen: Is there a solution to this, and I think there are, and I think we're going to see something drastic next year.
- 14:37David Syvertsen: Does it bother you as much as it bothers me that every year there's a huge stink about online judging and videos and these people are getting away with this and these people are not getting away with that?
- 14:51David Syvertsen: It's there's got to be something that can be done.
- 14:55David Syvertsen: What do you think does it bother you?
- 14:56David Syvertsen: Or is it just like?
- 14:57David Syvertsen: Hey, it's like umpires calling strikes and balls is subjective um, the problem is me.
- 15:03Sam Rhee: The problem isn't the judging of the videos.
- 15:07Sam Rhee: The problem is there is such a sustained outcry every year and perception drives the narrative.
- 15:14Sam Rhee: So I don't necessarily think CrossFit's doing anything horrible, but when you have so many people making a big stink about it, that perception is what the issue is.
- 15:24Sam Rhee: So I have listened to these athletes and other people on these podcasts and they're like the process needs to be opened up.
- 15:31Sam Rhee: We need to be able to know what's going on with the penalties and how they're deciding, and how many people are looking at these videos and what standards are they looking at.
- 15:39Sam Rhee: Are they looking at a slow motion or fast?
- 15:42Sam Rhee: And forget that CrossFit will never open up that system for others to look at.
- 15:47Sam Rhee: You want to look at it because you want your finger in the pie and to figure out how to game it.
- 15:53Sam Rhee: How to game it.
- 15:53Sam Rhee: So screw the athletes who say open up the system.
- 15:56Sam Rhee: That is not the solution.
- 15:58Sam Rhee: Yeah, the solution is going to have to be CrossFit has to control the media perception with this.
- 16:06Sam Rhee: So how do you control the media perception with it and yet still be cost effective, still make it fairer, still make it work within?
- 16:16David Syvertsen: their control and Dave Castro does a decent job of that because he actually shared some statistics objective statistics of the amount of videos that were watched, the amount of videos that received penalties and the amount of videos that did not receive penalties.
- 16:30David Syvertsen: And it's overwhelming that almost all the videos that they are not, that are watching, are not getting major penalties.
- 16:35David Syvertsen: Some are minor penalties and a lot are no penalties and they are catching guys and they he did.
- 16:41David Syvertsen: He put out the number of thousands of videos, so that that means that that's peeling back the curtain enough that you can give some objective numbers and people like statistics.
- 16:50David Syvertsen: So this is what I think.
- 16:52David Syvertsen: Idea number one is and I had a feeling they were going to do this and they are doing this for something called the service open.
- 17:01David Syvertsen: So the service open is something I think you had to sign up for prior to the open and if you were military, police, police, fire, you can hashtag affiliate owner, affiliate coach and you can take on another kind of like a quarter final, semi-final level.
- 17:15David Syvertsen: Yeah, but it's rogue who's running this.
- 17:17David Syvertsen: Yeah, it's rogue that's running it, and you have to video things, which is weird because there's one with running in it, but don't want to get too deep into that.
- 17:24David Syvertsen: They have three leaderboards.
- 17:26David Syvertsen: Leaderboard number one competitive, with videos, so you have to video if you're in that leaderboard.
- 17:32David Syvertsen: Part two, community rx no videos, meaning it's your own leaderboard, you're not videoing.
- 17:39David Syvertsen: And then community scaled, which is basically your skill and workouts no video, only competitive.
- 17:45David Syvertsen: That's first section are eligible to move on, slash, get prizes, and so I think they might make people sign up next year for hey, if you're going to go the competitive track, you have to video everything Open quarters, semis.
- 18:00David Syvertsen: Now, let's say you qualify for quarters and like, hey, I'm probably not going to move on, or I don't want to move on.
- 18:05David Syvertsen: You don't have to video, but you're not going to be on the leaderboard.
- 18:08David Syvertsen: You're going to be on your own filtered leaderboard where it's just a bunch of people.
- 18:13David Syvertsen: We're just going to use their scores as reported.
- 18:16David Syvertsen: We're not checking them, but there's no prize, there's no moving on.
- 18:19David Syvertsen: And then you have your scale leaderboard, which is no videos.
- 18:21David Syvertsen: You know, just submit your score.
- 18:24David Syvertsen: Same thing, honor code.
- 18:25David Syvertsen: And well, dave, what if people cheat?
- 18:26David Syvertsen: Doesn't matter, because they're not moving on, they're not going to affect anyone's score.
- 18:29David Syvertsen: That's the direction I think we're going to go in.
- 18:31David Syvertsen: I don't think it's going to go well.
- 18:33David Syvertsen: I don't like it either, but that Dave Castro has been saying you guys want a solution.
- 18:38David Syvertsen: Well, we're going to have a solution.
- 18:40Sam Rhee: I think that's it I have my thoughts about this.
- 18:44Sam Rhee: Why tell me why you don't like this?
- 18:48David Syvertsen: I just I hate the idea of separating the community so much between, like, competitive and really good crossfitter that doesn't want to compete, example.
- 18:58David Syvertsen: Um, this is what's going to happen.
- 18:59David Syvertsen: Let's say we have an athlete that's a really good lifter, all right, struggles with a lot of other things, but a really good lifter, all right, struggles with a lot of other things, but a really good lifter and there's an open workout next year with a workout, blah, blah, blah and then a 100 max snatch, right, and that lifter doesn't get to see their name in that leaderboard with the competitive athletes.
- 19:16David Syvertsen: It's a really cool feeling to be like, wow, I came in 38,000th place in this workout, but I was 104th in the world in the snatch, isn't that like that's out?
- 19:27David Syvertsen: You're no longer gonna be able to see that unless you just manually pretend to put your numbers in that leaderboard.
- 19:32David Syvertsen: And that, to me, starts separating, fracturing the community at large.
- 19:38David Syvertsen: That if we get people on separate leaderboards because you like to compete and you don't, and that that happens a lot, we have a lot of athletes that are never going to qualify for anything beyond quarters or semis, but they have a specialty that they can be top 10, top 15 in the world in a certain workout, and now you rob them of that experience by having them in their own leaderboard, in a leaderboard where people aren't technically allowed to cheat because there's no one's going to ask them for this score.
- 20:07Sam Rhee: People aren't technically allowed to cheat because there's no one's going to ask them for the score.
- 20:10Sam Rhee: Does that make sense?
- 20:11Sam Rhee: It does.
- 20:12Sam Rhee: I understand, and I figured it would be a philosophical viewpoint, that it's a collective, not divided, right.
- 20:16Sam Rhee: But the issue is is let's suppose that person was competing this year and they didn't record their videos and they were in the top 50.
- 20:24Sam Rhee: Yep and CrossFit was like hey, where's your video?
- 20:27Sam Rhee: We need your video for this.
- 20:28Sam Rhee: Yeah, they're in the top 50.
- 20:29Sam Rhee: And they're like I don't have a video.
- 20:30Sam Rhee: They're like zero.
- 20:31Sam Rhee: Yeah, right, yep, and that has happened, yep.
- 20:33Sam Rhee: So is that a better solution?
- 20:36Sam Rhee: I don't know.
- 20:38David Syvertsen: It does suck that if someone doesn't have a shot at qualifying for the next stage.
- 20:42David Syvertsen: But they crushed a workout and CrossFit's like let me see that video and like I'll have it.
- 20:46Sam Rhee: Well, okay, zero's a little rough but I mean, look at Mandy, like she submitted whatever she had because she didn't think she was going to make semis, but the videos did show her workouts, maybe not quite to the standard, like you know, the recommended standard, right, but it was like the recommended standard, but she had something.
- 21:09Sam Rhee: But if she had nothing let's suppose she had no videos whatsoever don't you think that would have really hurt her in terms of qualifying for semis?
- 21:13David Syvertsen: Yeah, yeah, If they were really strict with that, which some people think they should be, she wouldn't have qualified and she would have robbed her of that first semifinal experience and that whole experience that she just had this weekend that might lay a foundation for her for her long term future as a competitor, and again she would have been robbed of that.
- 21:31Sam Rhee: So I like the philosophy, I believe and I agree with you.
- 21:35Sam Rhee: I just don't know technically or logistically that it would solve the controvert Like.
- 21:43Sam Rhee: So if we didn't do this, well, let's talk about the other solutions, right?
- 21:49David Syvertsen: yeah, the other one is my favorite one it hasn't been done yet it's the online judges.
- 21:52David Syvertsen: So basically, you leverage the community there's a lot of us and basically, if you pass the judges course, you're allowed to watch any video you want and you make everyone that wants to qualify for the next stage.
- 22:07David Syvertsen: I'm just talking about quarterfinals here, not the Open.
- 22:09David Syvertsen: Open.
- 22:10David Syvertsen: I think we have to keep it.
- 22:12David Syvertsen: Honor code Just submit your scores.
- 22:14David Syvertsen: You'll qualify great.
- 22:15David Syvertsen: If not, don't.
- 22:16David Syvertsen: And if you're in quarterfinals and you're talking about thousands of athletes like there were 23,000 Masters athletes alone right, if you want to qualify for the next stage, I think you should make the rule that you have to video all workouts and you have to post the video with your score so that I can go onto the leaderboard.
- 22:35David Syvertsen: Anyone that I want, I can click on their video and I can watch it.
- 22:39David Syvertsen: And you know there's thousands of people that will do this and I watch it.
- 22:44David Syvertsen: Hey, good video, bad video, and you're gonna have some immature people out there.
- 22:49David Syvertsen: Maybe you know giving thumbs down for a lot of different personal reasons.
- 22:52David Syvertsen: Like, oh, I don't like that, that bitch from that gym down the street.
- 22:54David Syvertsen: I'm gonna give thumbs down what?
- 22:56David Syvertsen: I don't think that that means anything that won't affect anyone's score, but I think cross could have a metric where, like, hey, if over 20 percent of someone's votes are negative, we need to go, it's flagged, we have to go check that one out.
- 23:10David Syvertsen: And but if, if these people have, you know, 91 percent of their videos thumbs up, they're moving on.
- 23:18David Syvertsen: We're not even going to spend a second watching them and that's where I think you can use.
- 23:24David Syvertsen: Now you have thousands, maybe tens of thousands of people doing the judging for you 24-7-365, because it's a global thing, whereas I bet the people that are watching videos it's like all right, well, tomorrow morning I'll get it done tomorrow afternoon, like I can't, where this would just around the clock for a week straight.
- 23:44David Syvertsen: You have people watching videos.
- 23:46David Syvertsen: You know the danger in it is that some of these, you know you might have a lot of unqualified people doing this and doing a bad job of online judging, and it could create more work, honestly, for some.
- 24:01David Syvertsen: I still think some people are going to sneak between the cracks just based on numbers.
- 24:06David Syvertsen: You're going to get lucky you might be the 188th ranked, 35 to 39 year old, and not one person watched any of your videos.
- 24:13David Syvertsen: But I think the net think it's, it's, I think the net positive, net negative.
- 24:19David Syvertsen: It would end up net positive for CrossFit if they did this.
- 24:23Sam Rhee: Uh, how would that have solved this year's controversy?
- 24:26Sam Rhee: So, for example, paige Powers got dinged on a video and I assume that CrossFit is still going to watch like the top 40 or 50 videos of every division.
- 24:39Sam Rhee: Right, they're not just going to trust the crowd, yeah, and so they saw it.
- 24:44Sam Rhee: They assigned a major penalty to it.
- 24:46Sam Rhee: She gets dumped down.
- 24:48Sam Rhee: Like does the crowdsourcing help that in any way?
- 24:52Sam Rhee: Because what happened was the athletes were pissed that it was a major penalty.
- 24:56Sam Rhee: They had no decision on how many.
- 24:58Sam Rhee: Like it was an arbitrary penalty that dumped them all the way down and then you have like 400 videos that you have to go through.
- 25:04Sam Rhee: Are you going to use the crowdsource to help judge those 400 videos between the top 40 and Paige Powers, who's now like 500th?
- 25:11Sam Rhee: I don't know?
- 25:12Sam Rhee: Like that gets kind of complicated.
- 25:13David Syvertsen: It does get.
- 25:14David Syvertsen: It does get complicated.
- 25:15David Syvertsen: I think Paige Powers someone like her would still be screwed.
- 25:17David Syvertsen: If you're getting bumped down to 600th place because of a major penalty, you're screwed.
- 25:21Sam Rhee: Right, I think that's really where the issue is.
- 25:24Sam Rhee: It's not like everyone who's 300th to 400th, it's like the top 40 or whatever.
- 25:29Sam Rhee: Do you think Paige Powers deserves to be in semis?
- 25:34Sam Rhee: No, but because she had 40 cleaner videos ahead of her, so it didn't matter if she was 40, if she got a minor penalty, got bumped to 41, right?
- 25:42Sam Rhee: If the 40 videos that they saw were better than her performance, then she doesn't deserve to go right that's why I think page powers.
- 25:50David Syvertsen: It's kind of like you're screwed whether this changes or not, but it depends on the penalty, like how severe should that penalty be?
- 25:59David Syvertsen: I think CrossFit gets the final say on that in this scenario where, if you and I are judging people from our home and we just give thumbs down, we're not assigning minor or major Right.
- 26:08Sam Rhee: But I think that's where the athletes don't like it.
- 26:09Sam Rhee: They're like well, why are you giving me a 20% penalty?
- 26:12Sam Rhee: Right, it should only be five.
- 26:18David Syvertsen: It 20% penalty.
- 26:19Sam Rhee: It should only be five.
- 26:19Sam Rhee: It was just 18 step-ups.
- 26:20Sam Rhee: Why not just deduct 18 reps from my score?
- 26:21Sam Rhee: So I think that it's the penalty part of it that I think bother people a lot too.
- 26:23Sam Rhee: A little inconsistent there, yeah, or opaque, let's just put it that way.
- 26:28Sam Rhee: They don't know what criteria.
- 26:31Sam Rhee: I think maybe if you post a video, you have to say everyone has to see it.
- 26:36Sam Rhee: So I want to see Paige Powers' video.
- 26:39Sam Rhee: I want to see like Vellner, yeah, like him.
- 26:43Sam Rhee: Posting it publicly made it so much better because you could watch and be like, oh, now I understand why they gave him that major penalty.
- 26:49Sam Rhee: That makes sense.
- 26:50Sam Rhee: So it's like I would say, instead of crowdsourcing it, just say hey, listen, if you're going to post a video as an athlete, it has to be public, it has to be public, everyone can see it.
- 27:00Sam Rhee: So then when I see Paige Powers' major penalty, I could be like, oh yeah, there's no more stinking.
- 27:06Sam Rhee: No way should she go.
- 27:07Sam Rhee: Or hey, that's a little minor, I don't know, maybe she should go and that way at least the athletes can all see each other's videos.
- 27:19David Syvertsen: Yeah, but I mean that could be a good solution.
- 27:20David Syvertsen: You're giving up a lot of privacy and you are do that give up, make everything public.
- 27:23David Syvertsen: I mean that's fine.
- 27:23David Syvertsen: You are just opening the door to so much more criticism.
- 27:26David Syvertsen: I mean, if you really watch even the best athletes in the world like when they're moving so fast, like you're, like there's a lot of like, that's not perfect movement, it's not, you know, even the best like they get away with a lot of like, that's not perfect movement, it's not Even the best.
- 27:41Sam Rhee: They get away with a lot of especially barbell cycling type stuff and ring muscle up stuff.
- 27:43Sam Rhee: It might mean more work for CrossFit to address some of the controversy when people are like, hey, 41, number 40, better than 40.
- 27:51Sam Rhee: I don't know, but I feel like, if you open up every video, because I will say, when I saw Vellner's video it explained a lot to me.
- 27:57David Syvertsen: Yep, yep, okay, all right.
- 28:00David Syvertsen: Outsourcing age groups and teams, all right.
- 28:05David Syvertsen: What I mean by this is CrossFit finds someone.
- 28:08David Syvertsen: They have Bob and Joe and Bob and Joe I know they're receiving support from CrossFit.
- 28:13David Syvertsen: Same thing with the teen division adaptive.
- 28:16David Syvertsen: All this receiving support from CrossFit.
- 28:17David Syvertsen: Same thing with the team division adaptive.
- 28:18David Syvertsen: All this If they really I think they if their issues are a lack of resources right, they just don't have enough people that can watch videos, right, and again, you just do the math on it, you just don't have time to watch all these videos.
- 28:30David Syvertsen: They might be better off the CrossFit Games.
- 28:31David Syvertsen: To me, as much as I love Masters and it's all about the individual, like that's what the games are to me Teams are kind of like a sideshow, Masters are a sideshow.
- 28:41David Syvertsen: So they've already made step one of like alright, hey, joe and Bob, go, take the Masters to Alabama, get them out of here.
- 28:50David Syvertsen: We'll still call down the games by legends, whatever, right, did the same thing with the teens.
- 28:55David Syvertsen: I think next up might need to be the teams t-e-a-m-s, right, not just the teens, and so that they can just put all their attention.
- 29:04David Syvertsen: This is, I want to quote uh, just go back to like a ben bergeron thing that I heard probably 10 years ago, where he was running gyms and competitive programs and he ran a really cool competition called the east coast championship.
- 29:15David Syvertsen: I remember it was like when I first got into crossfit I was watching like man, I want to go there someday.
- 29:19David Syvertsen: He's at this huge convention hall, all the.
- 29:21David Syvertsen: It was like a kind of like what guadalupalooza was prior to guadalupalooza.
- 29:24David Syvertsen: It was indoors in the northeast and it was really successful and and bergeron pulled the plug on it for for the reason of he goes, I just felt like I was trying to do eight things really well and they were.
- 29:37David Syvertsen: They were going well, but I actually would rather go do four things perfect than eight things kind of well.
- 29:43David Syvertsen: And that was the one thing.
- 29:45David Syvertsen: I remember him.
- 29:45David Syvertsen: I remember listening to it, like yesterday.
- 29:47David Syvertsen: I remember like what car I was in and everything when he was.
- 29:49David Syvertsen: Just like I'm pulling the plug on it because I want to make the other things that I'm doing better, where I think CrossFit could make the games better by getting rid of the sideshows and putting all of their attention on the judging and coming up with a better system for the open division of the CrossFit games and I'm not saying get rid of Masters Like hell.
- 30:07David Syvertsen: No, I mean we're huge, 23,000 people want to do something beyond the open.
- 30:11David Syvertsen: But just outsource it completely and just be like your problem.
- 30:16David Syvertsen: But just outsource it completely and just be like your problem.
- 30:19David Syvertsen: You guys figure it out, we're out, we will help with here and there, maybe some funding and sponsorships, but the whole leaderboard video review process on you guys.
- 30:25David Syvertsen: What do you think about that?
- 30:27Sam Rhee: I mean it would help decrease the manpower need that crossfit would need if they only focused on the individuals in terms of video review.
- 30:36Sam Rhee: I don't know if it would still solve some of the issues that the athletes have been yammering about in terms of the degree of penalties and all that sort of stuff.
- 30:45Sam Rhee: The process is still opaque and we don't have any information about it.
- 30:49Sam Rhee: But you're right, it would take the folk.
- 30:53Sam Rhee: They wouldn't have to worry about that.
- 30:54Sam Rhee: But then what do bob what and joe have to like?
- 30:58Sam Rhee: What are they going to do with?
- 30:59Sam Rhee: They still have the same problem.
- 31:01Sam Rhee: Well, crossfit had, you know, or the teams, or teams or or whomever like.
- 31:06Sam Rhee: Now they're like okay, what do we do to figure this like?
- 31:08Sam Rhee: Bob and joe wrestled mightily at legends dealing with the videos, and what they ended up doing is they themselves watched like a million videos which drove them nuts, yep.
- 31:19Sam Rhee: So I mean that's just passing the buck for them.
- 31:23David Syvertsen: I mean, that's I'm, but I'm I'm speaking from I'm not even talking from the, uh, the master's perspective.
- 31:29David Syvertsen: I'm talking about from CrossFit.
- 31:30David Syvertsen: What should CrossFit do?
- 31:31David Syvertsen: And, and I think to me it seems like they can't figure this out.
- 31:35David Syvertsen: So if you can't figure something out, have someone else try to figure it out and it's just no longer an issue.
- 31:42David Syvertsen: Because right now, to me, right now, I have a bad outlook on CrossFit for this.
- 31:45David Syvertsen: I look down on them.
- 31:47Sam Rhee: They can't figure this thing out what happens if Bob and Joe are like you know what, we're coming coming up with a totally radical solution for masters.
- 31:54Sam Rhee: You get a certified like and someone has suggested you get a certified judge.
- 31:58Sam Rhee: They come over, they judge you, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 32:00Sam Rhee: And then crossfit's like you know that doesn't really line with us and we're putting our name crossfit games masters on this.
- 32:07Sam Rhee: Yeah, like now you're fractured, yeah, and so it's like that giving up of control thing that crossfit hq always has an issue with.
- 32:14Sam Rhee: Yeah, like with they're willing to give up some control, but I don't see where they would give up that much control.
- 32:21David Syvertsen: Because it's still a pretty big, lucrative business.
- 32:24David Syvertsen: They don't want to give up on that and I always say everyone's going to be a Masters at some point.
- 32:29David Syvertsen: You can't push them to the side.
- 32:30David Syvertsen: It's a huge part of CrossFit, so the revenue is driven by Masters.
- 32:34Sam Rhee: We know that you look at registrations how much money the athletes, the demographics Like.
- 32:41Sam Rhee: I think they're going to want to try to keep some of that.
- 32:45David Syvertsen: Yeah, I agree.
- 32:46David Syvertsen: My last idea is I'm having a hard time putting into words.
- 32:52David Syvertsen: I was actually sitting on my computer last night.
- 32:54David Syvertsen: I was like stressing over this like a half hour while Brock was taking a bath.
- 32:59David Syvertsen: I was like, all right, I got to just kind of just talk about it and just see if something comes out, and putting more on the affiliates.
- 33:03David Syvertsen: I wonder if there's a way to put more of this pressure and solution to hey affiliates.
- 33:10David Syvertsen: You're going to have to figure this out.
- 33:12David Syvertsen: And my thought was you know, don't ask people to do work without paying them money.
- 33:16David Syvertsen: So make every athlete that registers for quarters or semis pay an extra five to ten bucks.
- 33:23David Syvertsen: All right, let's keep the math easy and say it's ten bucks, so it's $60 instead of $50.
- 33:28David Syvertsen: $50, that's going to CrossFit, $10 is going to the affiliate.
- 33:32David Syvertsen: And because now the affiliate is going to make money right, not a lot right?
- 33:37David Syvertsen: We had, I think, 50, 55 people signed up for quarters.
- 33:44David Syvertsen: It would have been 550 bucks in our pocket.
- 33:46David Syvertsen: But it does make us a little bit more motivated to be like all right, we need to be the ones that are accountable for the athletes moving in our gym.
- 33:50David Syvertsen: So I, as the affiliate manager, validate every score in the open all three weeks, like literally one by one.
- 33:57David Syvertsen: And I'll be honest with you, a lot of times I just click, click, click, click, click, click right.
- 34:02David Syvertsen: Like I don't like go to the leaderboard and go through the papers and be like, all right, did Susan Rhee actually get 101 or did she get 102?
- 34:09David Syvertsen: Like I'm trusting that she submitted her right score right.
- 34:12David Syvertsen: Every now and then I'll say, say, like I make sure they put rx and scaled for the quarters and semis.
- 34:17David Syvertsen: If I am responsible for their reps, their quarterfinals, I'm going to come up with my solutions at the gym to be like, hey, this is a legit score, this is not a legit score.
- 34:29David Syvertsen: Um, this is, you know, she actually hit weight, she actually did not hit this weight and you know you're still videoing and you're still sending in the videos.
- 34:40David Syvertsen: But it could be a sort of like a system where, hey, if you have a lot of athletes that are you know their videos are garbage, they're getting away with no reps.
- 34:50David Syvertsen: Our video review team is not agreeing with you and what you actually validated as the affiliate manager I don't want to say penalize, but you come down on them in some way, right, meaning I don't validate anything for the quarterfinals.
- 35:05David Syvertsen: Everyone just sends their scores in.
- 35:07David Syvertsen: I don't even look at like I don't see them.
- 35:09David Syvertsen: They can submit fake scores.
- 35:10David Syvertsen: I'll never know.
- 35:11David Syvertsen: Crossfit is responsible for making sure it's the right score.
- 35:14David Syvertsen: What if everyone from my gym that had to video I validate that.
- 35:21David Syvertsen: I have to watch their video.
- 35:22David Syvertsen: Or I find my staff to validate videos and I pay you guys $10 a video.
- 35:27David Syvertsen: Hey, everyone on the staff $5 a video.
- 35:29David Syvertsen: Right, validate that score for me.
- 35:31David Syvertsen: Now it's on us Problem.
- 35:33David Syvertsen: I know people will cheat, right?
- 35:35David Syvertsen: I want my athlete to make the games Like I do know that, but I think that's the case.
- 35:39David Syvertsen: No matter what.
- 35:39David Syvertsen: You're always going to be fearful, but now it's like you have someone to point the finger at Like, oh Dave, you had seven people make semis but our video review team disagreed with your ability to validate their scores and there's some sort of penalty that comes down from that or that your athletes get a huge penalty because of it, which basically knocks them out.
- 36:01Sam Rhee: I mean, I think that would be good for policing the community.
- 36:03Sam Rhee: I think some of these athletes are not affiliated with any box, and that's true especially the pro level ones, so that wouldn't necessarily work for them if they're.
- 36:12Sam Rhee: If they're independent, what if you said you had to go to an affiliate to do the?
- 36:14Sam Rhee: I mean, that would be nice most.
- 36:14Sam Rhee: So that wouldn't necessarily work for them if they're independent.
- 36:16Sam Rhee: What if you said you had to go to an affiliate to do the workouts.
- 36:18David Syvertsen: I mean that would be nice.
- 36:19David Syvertsen: Most of them do them at an affiliate.
- 36:20David Syvertsen: They do yeah.
- 36:23Sam Rhee: I would say maybe not.
- 36:24Sam Rhee: I mean, I don't know.
- 36:27Sam Rhee: I don't know if they're going to trust the affiliates.
- 36:30Sam Rhee: There's so many uneven the quality is a little uneven out there.
- 36:33Sam Rhee: I agree, maybe as a proxy, using that professional athletes, the CrossFit Professional Athlete Association, as a proxy in some way.
- 36:43Sam Rhee: Maybe not necessarily in terms of validating the videos, but if CrossFit was like here are the standards, it's your organization is responsible for making sure that the athletes know these are the standards.
- 37:00Sam Rhee: Like a lot of it again is just getting like if the pro athletes, the pro level athletes, were happy, there would be no controversy.
- 37:08Sam Rhee: It's not like you and I are are complaining, right, going on to these podcasts.
- 37:13Sam Rhee: It's, it's the ones who are using this as their livelihood, right?
- 37:17Sam Rhee: So how do you get them to shut up about this?
- 37:19Sam Rhee: The main thing is mostly it's about the level of penalties and how do you account for standards.
- 37:30Sam Rhee: And then the video review order, like in terms of ranking review order in terms of ranking.
- 37:39Sam Rhee: But I think if you got that PFA or whatever you want to call it involved and said, listen, we're going to do what we always do, but you guys are the ones that we're going to throw these standards towards and if there's an issue with standards or problems, the professional CrossFit association athlete association will handle that part of it.
- 37:55Sam Rhee: Or something like that, I don't know, but just to take the heat off of HQ because a lot of people are like well, they never enforce standards and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 38:05Sam Rhee: I agree, another entity can get involved, like you said.
- 38:07Sam Rhee: It could be the affiliates, could be the professional athlete association, someone to act as a proxy.
- 38:14Sam Rhee: You want to help sort of navigate this, mitigate some of the media exposure that's so bad, right, and at least make the athletes feel like they have some input.
- 38:26Sam Rhee: Um, I don't think crossfit h2 would ever let there be a um mediating type of session where you know, like how they have penalties for certain sports and then like it goes to arbitration and then they're like this was you know, just because you threw the basketball at someone that you don't get thrown out for five games, you get thrown out for three, or something like that.
- 38:51Sam Rhee: I don't think they would ever give up that level of authority.
- 38:53Sam Rhee: I don't think they would ever give up that level of authority, but they might give some amount of input to another proxy to help with this.
- 39:03David Syvertsen: Yeah, I mean, I think every solution that we come up with, they got to get help from someone else.
- 39:08David Syvertsen: They probably don't have the funding to create their own staff and hire more people and pay more people Agreed.
- 39:13David Syvertsen: So then you kind of leverage the community a little bit more.
- 39:15David Syvertsen: All right, well, that's's it, guys.
- 39:16David Syvertsen: Those are our solutions for the issues that are in this CrossFit season leading up to the games.
- 39:22David Syvertsen: I think the games are pretty good now.
- 39:23David Syvertsen: It's just like it's a machine.
- 39:25David Syvertsen: Once you get to that stage, I think everything is fine.
- 39:27David Syvertsen: But these stages leading up to that just need to be cleaned up a little bit.
- 39:31David Syvertsen: I hope CrossFit comes up with a good solution next year.
- 39:33David Syvertsen: It sounds like something big is coming in terms of a change.
- 39:36David Syvertsen: Yeah, and you know, just be ready for it.
- 39:40David Syvertsen: And I think that anytime we change anything you know people are.
- 39:44David Syvertsen: Their initial reaction is almost always negative.
- 39:47David Syvertsen: But just kind of keep the open mind to two things A, they're trying to fix it and B, it can be better.
- 39:55David Syvertsen: It might be better, but it does require, you know, at least some positive mindset and not just, you know, walking to a room and trying to find what's wrong with it, like you had to kind of put your best effort into whatever change to throw your way and then we go from there.
- 40:07David Syvertsen: Make sure you buy a GoPro.
- 40:08David Syvertsen: Thank you guys, bye.
- 40:11David Syvertsen: Thank you everybody for taking the time out of your day to listen to the Herd Fit Podcast.
- 40:20David Syvertsen: Be on the lookout for next week's episode.