Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Dodsworth (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. You can't do that to me. You cannot
- 0:19do that. The show that takes you through every
- 0:21Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today. I'm
- 0:24Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we've been recording for
- 0:2630 seconds. We felt a little silly goofy. A little
- 0:29silly goofy. A little silly goofy. We talked
- 0:30about Mexican food and now we're... Un poco loco.
- 0:34Well, we talked about Mexican food and specifically
- 0:36on how I think you sometimes are a little worried
- 0:40about how they're going to perceive how Latin
- 0:42you are, of whether you like burrito tacos or
- 0:45any kind of specific Mexican delicacy. And meanwhile,
- 0:48I'm more of a un poco loco kind of guy. Right,
- 0:52right, right. Where I just kind of ride fast
- 0:54and loose. What is your Mexican order of choice?
- 0:59You said you love some carnitas. Is that what
- 1:02you said? The carnitas look good on the menu
- 1:04that I saw from you. This says a lot to my Hispanic
- 1:09heritage. I'm a big nachos guy, so not super
- 1:12Hispanic. But I do really like a chili relleno.
- 1:16Oh, my God. I love some chili poblanos. Oh, I
- 1:19love them. I don't think I should have said that.
- 1:22You're doing great, man. No, I don't think I
- 1:24should have. Welcome to Mi Casa. i'm having a
- 1:28good time um i love some chili poblanos i i love
- 1:32chili reynos um i really try to like here's my
- 1:36problem and i hope this like resonates with like
- 1:38white people everywhere cool i try my best to
- 1:41be honoring to the culture without sounding performative
- 1:43right right i worry sometimes like i have a co
- 1:46-worker named like uh alissa yeah but she like
- 1:49said like oh you can call me like elisa and i
- 1:51was like 100%. And were you like, oh, Alisa.
- 1:54No, no, no. Okay. That would be too much. But
- 1:56I do say Alisa, right? So sometimes I hear other
- 2:00people refer to her as Alisa. And I'm like, I
- 2:02hope you don't think I'm being performative.
- 2:03I'm just trying to, like, you know, honor what
- 2:06she told me. That, like, she wants to go by Alisa.
- 2:09And she was like, there's, like, five things
- 2:10I can go by. I don't mind. Anyways, I just try.
- 2:12I hope it doesn't come across as performative
- 2:14when I try to roll the L's. I cannot roll my
- 2:17R's for the life of me. That whole, like, I can't
- 2:21do it. Sure. Even that attempt, you can see how
- 2:23I can't do it. Yeah. But the L's with, like,
- 2:26Rayeno, like, I try to, like, Y it a little bit.
- 2:28Yeah, yeah. I try to do that, but I hope it doesn't
- 2:31come across as, like, look at this guy. I used
- 2:33to be really good at rolling my R's until I moved.
- 2:35to Georgia. And then I started home of the, get
- 2:38those rolling R's out of here. Exactly. Yeah.
- 2:40So I, I lost a little bit of, of my heritage,
- 2:42but I try to stay true to my family's culture.
- 2:45And every time, uh, like I go to work at the
- 2:48haunted house and I see the, the kids that work
- 2:50there, I walk up and I say, Hey, and they're
- 2:55like, go away. Uh, yeah, I'm not quite at that
- 2:59level. I, thankfully, uh, I would like to thank,
- 3:03uh, Tia Paca for ingraining that in my blood.
- 3:08Who do I have to thank for ingraining what I
- 3:10know? You, I guess, maybe? Anything I learn is
- 3:13going to be through you, so thank you. Oh, great.
- 3:15Good luck with that. Everyone's mad at me, and
- 3:18then I tell them it's Kyle. Oh, that's why. Yeah.
- 3:20Now we're mad at Kyle. Ay caramba. I'm trying
- 3:25so hard to be good. I'm trying so hard to be
- 3:27on pace. Hey, you know what has nothing to do
- 3:30with Mexican food? I was just about to say, you
- 3:32know what? One thing I love to do is when we
- 3:33start these episodes, we have like a segue. And
- 3:35I need everyone at home to know that this segue
- 3:37does not exist. There is no Venn diagram. We've
- 3:41never had a segue. No, I think we've done a pretty
- 3:44good job of segue in the past. Yeah. When we
- 3:46talked about Beauty and the Bounty and Captain
- 3:48Blood, we talked about pirates and everything.
- 3:50And like, how do you feel about pirates? That's
- 3:52true. I think we found good segues. into it.
- 3:54Yeah. This one, there is no Venn diagram. There's
- 3:56not even a circle. We have so much space between
- 3:59the circle of Mexican cuisine and Doddsworth.
- 4:03I got you here. I got you here. Okay. Doddsworth,
- 4:06he would not have the huevos rancheros for breakfast.
- 4:10Doesn't matter if he's in Mexico, he would still
- 4:12have the eggs and ham. That's true. So there
- 4:15you go. I was just about to say, I feel like
- 4:17he would over his wife, Fran, but... I think
- 4:21you're right. No, she would get whatever for
- 4:23breakfast. Oh, she would get whatever is the
- 4:25culture. Yes. Okay. You're absolutely right.
- 4:28So we're talking about Doddsworth today. This
- 4:31was a really interesting one. I'm excited to
- 4:33get into this with you because I think there's
- 4:34a lot to talk about with it, obviously. And of
- 4:38the first things to talk about, it's going to
- 4:40be the nominations. And we have seven nominations.
- 4:43That's a lot. By the way, hindsight, I did. Recently,
- 4:48one of my directors at my job recently celebrated
- 4:52six years of working at the company. Nice. We
- 4:55have a thing called Bonus League where we can
- 4:56send points of, hey, congratulations on this
- 4:59thing. Thanks for your help, whatever it is.
- 5:01And you can put a GIF underneath it. And a lot
- 5:03of people were doing it for that person saying,
- 5:05congratulations on six years. And it was GIFs
- 5:08of jokes about the number six. I was like, what
- 5:11could I do? And I said, you know. Something very
- 5:14heartfelt, like, thank you for your, like, leadership
- 5:15and everything. Like, I was very, like, sweet
- 5:17and honest about it. And for understanding my
- 5:20movie references at the end. And then the GIF
- 5:23that I used was a movie reference, and it was
- 5:24The Dark Knight. And it was when the Joker goes,
- 5:27like, when he's, like, being interrogated and
- 5:30asks how many of his cop buddies that he killed.
- 5:33He's like, yes. And I shared that. And at the
- 5:37time, it was, like, really funny. And as soon
- 5:38as I shared it, I was like, is that bad taste?
- 5:41I hope not. Only if you work at the police department.
- 5:44Only if I work at the... Which we don't. Spoiler
- 5:46for me. There you go. The seven nominations include
- 5:48Sound Recording, which was Thomas T. Moulton
- 5:51of Samuel Goldwyn Recording Studios. Art Direction
- 5:55was Richard Day. Screenplay was Sydney Howard.
- 5:58Supporting Actress was Maria Ospenskaya. Actor
- 6:02was Walter Houston. Director was William Wyler,
- 6:05someone that we'll be talking about for a long
- 6:07time to come, and kind of the introduction to
- 6:10the scene. Right? Of this figure. Yes. And Outstanding
- 6:15Production was on behalf of Samuel Goldwyn Productions.
- 6:19Pictures. Pictures. Yeah. Look at that. Samuel
- 6:20Goldwyn Pictures. I made it. You made it. Nice
- 6:24work, man. I will say, supporting actress for
- 6:26Maria Ospenskaya, when I was writing this name
- 6:30down for the first time, I looked at it and my
- 6:33eyes just went really wide. I was like, that
- 6:35is a lot of letters. Yeah, it is a lot. That
- 6:37is a lot of vowels that I have to get it through.
- 6:40Great name. I'm excited to talk about her. Yeah,
- 6:43me too. Are you familiar with her? I'm not familiar
- 6:45with her, and I'll be honest, this was a movie
- 6:46where the whole time I was like, when's this
- 6:48Maria Ospenskaya going to show up? She does take
- 6:51a while to show up. And when she shows up, she
- 6:52shows up, but it is very short. Yeah. So this
- 6:56film follows the story of Sam Dodsworth and his
- 6:59wife Fran, and he is a... automobile manufacturer
- 7:04like tycoon and he is he has just sold his company
- 7:08so he's saying goodbye to the lifestyle that
- 7:12he has lived for so many years and he and his
- 7:15wife decide to take a journey to england and
- 7:18they do so by ship and while they're on this
- 7:21cruise ship headed to england they begin to discover
- 7:24things about themselves and their relationship
- 7:27and kind of their needs so this This is really
- 7:31like a heavy, heavy drama that I did not anticipate
- 7:34when I first put it on. I thought it was going
- 7:36to be kind of fun and cute and a little silly,
- 7:38maybe with some like serious theming. You know,
- 7:43I think when we talk about. when we talk about
- 7:46movies with like one name, we think of it like
- 7:48a biopic, right? Like an Aerosmith, or even though
- 7:51it's the great Ziegfeld, Ziegfeld. And while
- 7:55this isn't like necessarily like a one -to -one
- 7:57biopic, it does kind of like, we would think
- 8:01Dodsworth. Okay, cool. So who is this about?
- 8:03That's a Dodsworth. But this is more of a kind
- 8:05of like an introspective look at relationships
- 8:07and marriage than it is like the individual of
- 8:10Dodsworth. So it's almost like Dodd's Worths
- 8:12is like what the name should be. Right, because
- 8:15you are following the two of the married couple,
- 8:18Sam and Fran, and that is Walter Houston and
- 8:20Ruth Chatterton, respectively. And it's, yeah,
- 8:24I just did not expect this to be as heavy. Before
- 8:27I get too far away from it, this is based on
- 8:29the Sidney Howard stage play from 1934, which
- 8:33was in turn based on the 1929 novel by Sinclair
- 8:36Lewis. Which, isn't there a Lewis Sinclair? There
- 8:40is a Lewis Sinclair. Threw me for a loop. But
- 8:42yeah, yeah. Initially, like my first thoughts
- 8:47on this movie is this is so heavy in a way that
- 8:51shies away from like melodrama that we've dabbled
- 8:54in so often on the podcast. And I think there's
- 8:58a lot here that makes this feel kind of elevated
- 9:01beyond most of the dramas we've covered. This
- 9:04feels kind of real. And grounded. It does. And
- 9:07I think it's because from the get -go, it's not
- 9:09very clear what we're doing. I think that there's
- 9:12kind of an exploration of that once they get
- 9:14on the cruise ship. Because up until this point,
- 9:16we see Sam come home. And we think this is kind
- 9:19of a movie about Sam. He is the titular Dodsworth.
- 9:21And we're going to follow him and his journey
- 9:25into retirement. And maybe how he gets back to
- 9:27it. Maybe how he loses everything. Who knows?
- 9:29But in reality, it's much more of like a personal
- 9:32drama between these two people. I guess what
- 9:36we should do is we should set this up. What we
- 9:37find is that, you know, the working man of Sam
- 9:40Dodsworth finds that he just wants to kind of
- 9:44see the things that he wasn't able to. He wants
- 9:46to travel. He wants to see the joys in things.
- 9:49He wants to look out in the horizon and see the
- 9:51beam of light coming from the horizon. The lighthouse.
- 9:55The lighthouse, right. He wants to see everything
- 9:58and experience it. And sure, it's cold up there,
- 10:00but he wants to be able to experience these things
- 10:03and meet people. And his wife, Fran, is much
- 10:06more interested in being embraced in the culture,
- 10:09in the lifestyle of the places that they go to.
- 10:12So she wants to be a socialite. She wants to
- 10:14be out and seen and heard. Sorry, the phrase
- 10:18that Taylor and I always use is see and be seen.
- 10:21is she wants to be the life of the party, but
- 10:23she also wants to see everything. And this creates
- 10:26complications for them because doing so as a
- 10:30woman means that you're going to have to be in
- 10:32the company of a man a lot of the times, right?
- 10:35She's not that outspoken, so she wants to be
- 10:37dancing with someone or going through these things
- 10:40with someone. The thing that kind of bothered
- 10:43me is that it's never really like, you know,
- 10:45we talk about these films having a misunderstanding
- 10:46where if only you two could have talked about
- 10:49this and figured it out. There wasn't really
- 10:51a scene for me that I caught where it was like,
- 10:53she was like, hey, I really want to do this.
- 10:54And he's like, no, I don't want to do that. I'm
- 10:56going to go out and look at this. Right. It was
- 10:57just more like two ships passing in the night.
- 10:59And then they just never really crossed over.
- 11:01I saw a lot of him inviting her, but not a lot
- 11:03of Fran inviting Sam. Yeah. And that introduction
- 11:08is enough to tell you here that I was a little
- 11:10split on this movie about halfway in. Because
- 11:13I think what the movie wants you to feel is they
- 11:17want you to see that these are two separate people
- 11:19who neither of them are in the wrong, but they
- 11:21are just moving away from each other. Right.
- 11:24And I think what the movie, at least for the
- 11:26first half, and I would argue a little into the
- 11:28second half too, I think this suffers from an
- 11:30issue of characterization. I think that this
- 11:33movie suffers from the Fran character. I think
- 11:37Sam seems pretty built out. And I like Sam a
- 11:39lot. I really enjoyed Walter Houston as Sam Dodsworth.
- 11:42Yes. And I enjoyed Ruth Chatterton as Fran. But
- 11:46she is more like... I'm trying to find the right
- 11:49way to put this. She is a freight train in this
- 11:51movie. And she is constantly moving towards something.
- 11:55But I felt that she was one of the most... Actually,
- 11:58I'm going to take that back. I think she's the
- 12:00most selfish character that we've talked about
- 12:01on this podcast so far. Interesting. And... When
- 12:04I say selfish, I don't just mean like, oh, yeah,
- 12:06she's just interested in this or whatever. I
- 12:08mean, every action, every impasse that they come
- 12:11at us as a couple comes from her own preference
- 12:13and even her own actions. Early on when they're
- 12:17on the cruise ship, she strikes up a conversation
- 12:20and a flirtation, admittedly, on her part with
- 12:23another man, the captain. And this is portrayed
- 12:25by Captain Lockhart by David Niven. Right. This
- 12:30innocent flirtation is mostly just dancing while
- 12:34her husband is on the deck looking at like, you
- 12:36know, everything there is to be seen. And she's
- 12:39flirting. They're having a good time. She goes
- 12:42back to like his room and they're talking and
- 12:44he kind of expects a little bit more out of the
- 12:46connection than she does, even though he is getting
- 12:49very close. And he has this accusation, kind
- 12:52of lightheartedly, but still an accusation of
- 12:54like, oh, this isn't really what you want. You're
- 12:57going to tease that you want this. But in reality.
- 13:00You just want like to be free. Right. And this
- 13:04accusation makes her feel like she can't go to
- 13:07England anymore because now this well -known
- 13:09captain is going to spread word about her and
- 13:12she can't fathom the idea, stand the idea of
- 13:15her being perceived this way by other people.
- 13:18So she then disrupts their entire plan. And it's
- 13:21no longer that we're going to England and enjoying
- 13:23ourselves and your retirement. It is now we have
- 13:26to go to Paris because I can't stand the idea
- 13:29of me making this mistake. But instead of trying
- 13:31to correct the mistake, it's avoiding it altogether.
- 13:34So that's only one instance of, I think, many
- 13:37that start showing her selfish nature of, well,
- 13:39hey, you did this. Like, you caused this. And
- 13:42now we have to pivot our plans because of your
- 13:44action. And there's much, much more to come.
- 13:47But I think that's the first planting of that
- 13:49seed. Just looking at these two characters, what
- 13:53do you think of the characterizations and the
- 13:56way they were portrayed up to this point? Well,
- 13:58I think that in the first half of the movie,
- 14:01I was really into how the movie was showing,
- 14:05like you said, two people just kind of growing
- 14:07apart. And while she is more active, I think,
- 14:12in that dismantling than Sam is, I don't think
- 14:16she's portrayed immediately as villainous. I'd
- 14:20agree with that. That comes later. It does. I
- 14:22think my perception of her shifted a lot as the
- 14:25movie went on. But even her dancing and flirting
- 14:29and being with David Niven, I wasn't immediately
- 14:32like, oh, well, she's being reckless and she's
- 14:36out talking to whoever and this, that, and the
- 14:38other thing. I was like, okay, these are two
- 14:42people. He wants to leave his job. He's made
- 14:45that choice. Before they even get on the ship
- 14:48and you see them like in home together, there's
- 14:50like a minor moment where they bicker a little
- 14:53bit, but it's very lighthearted. And then friends
- 14:55come over to see them off to the ship in England.
- 15:00And they kind of like shoo them away. They end
- 15:02up offending them or kicking them out. And Sam
- 15:06and Fran, that scene ends with them like in love.
- 15:09They look very happy in love. So I really enjoyed
- 15:13how it felt like. Oh, they love each other, but
- 15:17there's something there that they can both kind
- 15:19of feel. And they're not—they're both trying
- 15:22to make choices for themselves. Sam wants to
- 15:24go to England. Fran wants to live a different
- 15:27lifestyle, but they're not ready to, like, speak
- 15:30that to each other. I was into that. I liked
- 15:33both of them at the start of this movie. I think
- 15:36I was—I'm in the same boat as you were, not intentional
- 15:39with the cruise of it all. I— The only thing
- 15:42is, I mean, I agree with you that it wasn't villainous.
- 15:45It wasn't portrayed as villainous here. I was
- 15:47annoyed by it. And like it was an annoying thing
- 15:50that she had to do. But that's in the character.
- 15:52You're right that the villainous like intention
- 15:54kind of comes later with some of the things that
- 15:56are to come. But even like, you know, this wasn't
- 15:59like something that she's hiding and she can't
- 16:00tell like Sam that she was, you know, I think
- 16:02other films, dare I say lesser films, would dare
- 16:06to just. Instead of her having the conversation
- 16:09with him, it would be something she hides, a
- 16:11shame that she has. It's not a shame that she
- 16:13has for other people to perceive her this way,
- 16:15but for her husband to perceive this way. But
- 16:17in reality, she's so close with her husband that
- 16:20almost without saying it, he's like, oh, you
- 16:22let this guy on, right? And he doesn't say it
- 16:24in an annoyed, like, how could you do this to
- 16:25me? But more like, oh, that happened, didn't
- 16:27it? And she's like, yes, but I can't be perceived
- 16:32this way. We can't let this happen. And he takes
- 16:35it really well. He's like, yeah, you know, I
- 16:36know nothing was ever going to happen, but he
- 16:39doesn't know that. So, of course, he's going
- 16:40to feel that way. And it was very level -headed.
- 16:42And it made me like Sam a lot. I really enjoyed
- 16:45Walter Houston in this. We haven't seen him pop
- 16:48up before, have we? No. Not in the major way,
- 16:51at least. Yeah. I really enjoyed his performance
- 16:54here. I think that a lot of the first half of
- 16:57this movie is kind of him having to be almost
- 17:00like a reconciliator. with his relationship and
- 17:04his wife. And then I think we see him take some
- 17:06more agency in the second half, and that's where
- 17:08I think he really shines. But he's doing a really
- 17:10good job in this. And for as much as I didn't
- 17:13like her character, I do think that the performance
- 17:16by Ruth Chatterton is pretty undeniable in that
- 17:19sense. But I do want to talk about something
- 17:21here, and it's that I did some research, and
- 17:23I guess there are some disagreements between
- 17:27Chatterton and Weiler. The director, William
- 17:30Wyler. There was some disagreements on the characterization
- 17:33of Fran. And specifically, I know Mary Astor.
- 17:38We haven't talked about her yet. Edith Courtright.
- 17:40She is a friend of both the Doddsworths here.
- 17:44No, I'm so sorry. Edith Courtright is the individual
- 17:48that we are introduced to later. Right. Correct.
- 17:51Okay. It's kind of Sam's. Interest. Interest,
- 17:54yeah. That we'll get to in a little bit. Kind
- 17:56of a jarring thing to say right now without talking
- 17:59about what happens in between. Right. But a later
- 18:01interest introduced is Edith Courtright. So Mary
- 18:04Astor, a really, by the way, we don't have a
- 18:07lot of time to get into this, but a fascinating
- 18:10individual to read about, about the set of this.
- 18:12She was going through a custody battle at the
- 18:15time of this. Yeah. And one of the only supports
- 18:17she had was Ruth Chatterton. So she and Ruth
- 18:20got very close. Yeah, I read that. She would
- 18:23work on set during the day and then at night
- 18:25she would go to court and Ruth would accompany
- 18:27her. That's right. Just crazy. Crazy. Absolutely
- 18:30nuts. So in this, they got very close. Mary Astor
- 18:33did write a novel or a biography about this later
- 18:37on. And in it, she wrote memoir is what I was
- 18:40looking for. In it, she wrote that Ruth Chatterton
- 18:43was hanging on to youth. Right. She was worried
- 18:46about getting older and she was really hanging
- 18:49on to the idea of like what it was to be younger.
- 18:52And she saw that in Fran and the characterization
- 18:54of Fran. So she really played that very strongly.
- 18:57There's a line early in the movie where she talks
- 19:00about like, you know, maybe it's halfway through.
- 19:03She mentioned something about like, you know,
- 19:05God forbid they mistake me for 30 or even 25.
- 19:08Right. And she's really trying to play that up,
- 19:11which there's a great, I believe there's a great
- 19:14reception or a great reaction from Sam where
- 19:17he's like, what? 25. Anyways, Wyler wanted to
- 19:22sympathize with Fran. He wanted the audience
- 19:25to be able to sympathize with Fran. But Ruth
- 19:29really wanted to play her more like a villainess.
- 19:32Interesting. And I'm interested in your thoughts
- 19:34on this, but my perception is that... Ruth Chatterton
- 19:37got away with this way more than Weiler did in
- 19:40the sympathetic sense. I didn't see Fran as very
- 19:47sympathetic throughout the second half. The first
- 19:49half of what you and I have discussed, I do.
- 19:52It's a little selfish, but I do see like, you
- 19:53know, okay, we're sympathizing with her a little
- 19:55bit here. But in her actions, we continue to
- 19:59see that I think personally that Ruth won out
- 20:02a little bit more and played her more villainous
- 20:04than she did sympathize. Yeah, and I agree that
- 20:07that is more evident in the second half of the
- 20:10movie. And I think it's kind of unfortunate because
- 20:12it's a much more interesting movie if it is her.
- 20:17I mean, it's the 1930s. If a woman wants a divorce
- 20:21from her husband, it's not an easy thing to do.
- 20:24It's very complicated. So I try and think of
- 20:28Fran as being in this unhappy marriage, and she's
- 20:33coming to terms with her age and her lifestyle,
- 20:36and she's kind of been riding the coattails of
- 20:39her husband throughout his successful career
- 20:41as an automobile manufacturer. And that's got
- 20:44to be difficult, you know, to come to terms with
- 20:46all of that. So I think it's a much more interesting
- 20:49story when you are able to be more sympathetic
- 20:51with that character. But I do think, especially
- 20:55towards the second half, she does lean much more
- 20:58villainous. And she starts doing things that
- 21:00are just blatantly obvious, especially when Sam,
- 21:05like, proposes a divorce and she is against it.
- 21:09I think at that point, it's like. hey, this is
- 21:12kind of what you want, and now you're almost
- 21:14like playing both sides of the field. Yeah, and
- 21:19you know, we've talked about movies, whether
- 21:21on the pod or just you and I off pod, where I
- 21:23feel like the way that characters are played
- 21:26by certain actors do turn me off the movie altogether,
- 21:29and I'm going to say, okay, well, it just wasn't
- 21:30effective. I'm going to continue to have issues
- 21:33with the characterization of Ruth. And I feel
- 21:37like the movie, you can feel the push and pull
- 21:39of Wyler really wants her to be sympathetic,
- 21:42but Ruth is just going to continue to play her
- 21:45as a villainess. Yeah. I think you can feel the
- 21:47push and pull of that. But even with that being
- 21:50the case, and I think that's throughout the movie,
- 21:52especially the first half, I want to say that
- 21:54this is a fascinating look at a relationship.
- 21:57It is. And this is not one that is full of, I
- 22:00mean, there is some melodrama, but it's not like
- 22:02misunderstandings and a comedy of errors. There
- 22:05is very little humor in this movie. It is pretty
- 22:09stark. Yeah. And I think that's really interesting.
- 22:12This is kind of unbelievable that this came out
- 22:15in 1936. Especially with the theming, like there's
- 22:18infidelity all over this movie. There's quite
- 22:21a bit of, what would you call it? Indecency,
- 22:26like implied at different moments. Implied is
- 22:29a really interesting word here because I think
- 22:31that's up into now what we would see. We talked
- 22:34a lot about like, well, you know, at this point,
- 22:36if anything is suggested, we take that as that's
- 22:38happened. Sure. And production code, we feel
- 22:41like that's just a straight up, like that's not
- 22:43going to be mentioned anymore. I think this is
- 22:45the, this movie. Dodsworth is the first time
- 22:48that we have actually seen a jump to the phrase
- 22:52make love. Okay. Yeah. Because we're jumping
- 22:56ahead here. But at one point, Ruth finds herself
- 23:00with a individual. Oh, what was his name? Arnold
- 23:04Iceland. Thank you. I even wrote him down here.
- 23:07Why didn't I see that? Portrayed by Paul Lucas.
- 23:08Thank you so much. So she finds herself with
- 23:10Arnold Iceland. While they're in France, we see
- 23:13Sam saying, I'm just not happy. We got to go
- 23:16back home. And she's like, well, I want to stay
- 23:17here. So why don't I just stay here and take
- 23:19in the sights by myself, just me, solo, no one
- 23:22else. And you head home and it'll be okay. And
- 23:25she's already met Arnold at this point. So she
- 23:28has an idea of what's going to happen here. He
- 23:29doesn't. And he agrees to go home. So she enjoys
- 23:32the company of Arnold Iceland in France while
- 23:35he heads home and kind of realizes how much of
- 23:38his life was dependent on Fran. And while he's
- 23:41doing this, she's living the life with Arnold
- 23:43Iceland. And he knows that she's married. She
- 23:46knows that she's married. And she gets a letter
- 23:48from her husband. And there is a... I kind of
- 23:51want to say beautiful scene, even though I hate
- 23:52the implication of it, where she receives a letter.
- 23:55He says like, hey, you got to read it. He's kind
- 23:57of like a very emotional scoundrel. Yes. Where
- 24:01he's like, hey, we can move forward with this
- 24:02affair and everything, but you should read that
- 24:04letter from your husband. Yes. Because it's probably
- 24:06important for you to make amends with what we're
- 24:08about to do. And she does. And then he helps
- 24:10her burn it. And there's a great scene where
- 24:14you can see the letter being burnt. And there's
- 24:17no kid gloves, no safety way of doing this. She
- 24:21is holding the letter. He pulls out a lighter,
- 24:24lights it, and then they gently just let it go.
- 24:26I know this scene was taken multiple times because
- 24:29Wyler wanted to get it kind of like dancing through
- 24:31the wind. Yeah. And he gets it the best way he
- 24:34could have without being able to control this.
- 24:36But it's a great scene of it kind of like flowing
- 24:38in the wind and a representative of their marriage
- 24:40of like burnt and then like left behind completely.
- 24:43Yeah. But it's this scene. where Paul Lucas'
- 24:47Arnold Iceland mentions, like, you know, I will
- 24:50make love to you. And, like, there's no hinting
- 24:53anymore. Right. There's no, hey, I've enjoyed
- 24:55being here with you. He says the phrase that
- 24:58he's going to make love to her. And to my recollection,
- 25:01this is the first time that we've heard this
- 25:03really embraced in that way. Yeah, I don't recall
- 25:05it being that blatant. There's a lot of, like,
- 25:07being together. I'm trying to think of different
- 25:10phrases that were used, but nothing that blatant,
- 25:11you're right. We had breakfast this morning,
- 25:14if you know what that means. Bringing back the
- 25:15Ernst Lubitsch of it all. Exactly, yeah. No,
- 25:18that's a great point, and I think that is an
- 25:22example of, like, how serious this movie is.
- 25:24They don't dance around any of these ideas. They
- 25:27are definitely happening. Before we move on from
- 25:31that scene, I want to point out, correct me if
- 25:33I'm wrong, but when she reads the letter, they
- 25:35don't show the contents of the letter on screen
- 25:37for you to read. Yes. It's just her reading the
- 25:40letter. That's correct. I love that so much because
- 25:44you don't have to know what it says. It is a
- 25:47rare opportunity in these early sound movies
- 25:51where they're not hearkening back to the silent
- 25:55picture days where they say, okay, now there's
- 25:56text on screen and you read it. Ironically, I
- 25:59miss from movies a little bit in the modern sense.
- 26:02But you get to see her read this letter and react.
- 26:05And there's a good pause where it's like 10 to
- 26:0815 seconds of her reading this letter in real
- 26:11time. And you just get to sit there with her
- 26:14and her emotions. You don't know what it says
- 26:17for sure, but deep down, you know what it says.
- 26:21I love that scene, even more so than the burning
- 26:23of the letter. I loved her reading the letter.
- 26:26Yeah, this was great. And there's a little bit
- 26:28of a hint from Arnold who has read the letter.
- 26:31Right. Right. He's read it and he kind of needs
- 26:33her to be able to make peace with this and read
- 26:35it. And so there's an implication that her husband
- 26:39is reaching out saying like, hey, I miss you.
- 26:41Like, I wish you were home. How are things? When
- 26:44are you coming back? And for her, she can take
- 26:46this and it's. not clear to us but we get an
- 26:50idea that this is a oh well i need to continue
- 26:52to be here and that is her active decision although
- 26:56i would argue she's already decided this in her
- 26:58head this is her like full declaration of i'm
- 27:01going to be in this relationship and she embraces
- 27:04with arnold and the letter falls to the wayside
- 27:07and we see a surprise visit from sam after this
- 27:12where he comes to visit fran and This part's
- 27:16a little muddy for me. I will admit that I think
- 27:18I may have just missed a scene or two, but it
- 27:20sounds like there was a co -worker from the company
- 27:23that Sam had, the automobile company. And he
- 27:26said, hey, I've seen your wife with another man,
- 27:29this Arnold Iceland guy. You might want to look
- 27:32into this. And he then goes back to France, surprises
- 27:36her, and not just surprises her with his appearance,
- 27:38but surprises her with also inviting Arnold.
- 27:42And the three of them have a conversation. And
- 27:44I will say that this is when the movie for me
- 27:46was like solidified and how fascinating it was,
- 27:49is that it was not one of those movies where
- 27:51it's like, when I get my hands on this guy, I'm
- 27:52going to absolutely destroy him. This was a completely
- 27:55like cordial, like communicative sequence where
- 28:00Sam was not interested in destroying anyone or,
- 28:04hey, you got to fix this right now. He was like,
- 28:06we got to sort this out. And he invites Arnold
- 28:08and the three of them, instead of like yelling
- 28:11at each other, are like standing slash sitting.
- 28:13I think she's sitting. But Arnold and Sam are
- 28:17standing and they don't have a conversation in
- 28:19front of her. It's like the three of them are
- 28:20having a conversation. And I thought this was
- 28:22honestly, I didn't know if this was going to
- 28:24go into like a polygamy type thing, like a conversation
- 28:26of them discussing that. But like it was a very
- 28:28open conversation of him being like, look. clearly
- 28:33I've caught you in this. Like you've lied about
- 28:35this. You're lying about it right now, but clearly
- 28:37I've caught you in it. And we got to figure this
- 28:39out. This is where you mentioned, he's like,
- 28:40do we just need a divorce? What do we need in
- 28:42this? And she then kind of goes back to this
- 28:46selfish thing of like, oh, I don't know what
- 28:47I was thinking. Yes, you were. It didn't really
- 28:50mean anything. Yes, it did. Like we know that
- 28:53she's not telling the truth about this. Maybe
- 28:55she's trying to convince herself. But then this,
- 28:58to me, immediately switches back over to the
- 29:01selfishness of she and Sam get a little closer.
- 29:04And he's like, by the way, we're going to be
- 29:06grandparents. And she's elated at this news.
- 29:08She's so happy to hear, like, you know, my baby's
- 29:10having a baby. Like, we got to be there. We got
- 29:12to go back home for. And I think he mentions,
- 29:15I think Sam mentions. You're taking the news
- 29:18of like being a grandmother really well or something.
- 29:20He reminds her that this doesn't just mean that
- 29:23she has her baby's having a baby, but that she's
- 29:26going to be a grandmother. Right. And it's when
- 29:28he kind of introduces this idea to her that you
- 29:30see her kind of like almost like a possession.
- 29:34taking over of like the realization of getting
- 29:36older. Right. And this is where I think Ruth
- 29:38is really channeling what Mary Astor brings up
- 29:41in that memoir in that she is leaning very heavily
- 29:44into the age and like the idea of getting older.
- 29:47Yeah. And this woman who has just exclaimed how
- 29:51excited she is to be with her daughter and support
- 29:53her daughter in this actively decides that she
- 29:56is not going to go back home. Right. And she
- 29:59is going to continue to stay away from home to
- 30:02avoid being seen as a woman of age that can be
- 30:05a grandmother. Yeah. That whole scene is very
- 30:10heartbreaking. It is. And I do really like how
- 30:14it doesn't turn into like a yelling match. It's
- 30:17interesting. There is like a good bit of yelling
- 30:20in this movie from Sam. Oh, yeah. To a point
- 30:23where there's a noise complaint. Right. Oh, man.
- 30:27What a good scene when they're having that conversation
- 30:29in the hotel room. And every argument in this
- 30:34movie, I think, is what solidifies this as such
- 30:38a grounded, real experience for me. Because when
- 30:41he gets that noise complaint, like, he's raising
- 30:45his voice, he's yelling, and then he goes to
- 30:47the phone, he answers it, hangs up, and he's
- 30:49like, we got a noise complaint. And she's like,
- 30:51great. And then they're whispering to each other.
- 30:54And they're still, like, arguing. And this is
- 30:56what I love about Walter Houston's performance.
- 30:58Maybe it's just the characterization of Sam Dodsworth.
- 31:01And I think it's something I recollect or I relate
- 31:05to in that he gets off the phone and there's
- 31:09no, like, what do you mean noise complaint? Like,
- 31:11he's not mad at this guy. He's like, okay, heard,
- 31:12understood. Yeah. Hangs up. He comes over and
- 31:15he's not like, so to be continued tomorrow or,
- 31:17you know, let's get out of here and talk about
- 31:18this. He's like, all right, so. obviously it's
- 31:21important we continue this conversation. So why
- 31:23don't we do it in like a more mild manner? Like,
- 31:25you know, us talking like this. And in more or
- 31:28less words, he says that. It's not just like,
- 31:30okay, so tell me what's going on. So the fact
- 31:32that he's like staying here, he's not like getting
- 31:35too emotional about like, you've cheated on me.
- 31:36You've done this. Like, how could you do this?
- 31:38He's more like, all right, let's figure this
- 31:40out. Like he is committed and he wants to make
- 31:42this work. And that's what makes this so frustrating
- 31:44of a watch. And not in, like, a bad way. But
- 31:47it's frustrating because you see this man who
- 31:49is, like, clearly trying to make this work. Even
- 31:51in his wife's infidelity. You can say that, like,
- 31:54he had a hand in whatever and, like, not being
- 31:56available to his wife and dancing or whatever.
- 31:58But, like, he's trying to make it work. And she
- 32:00is just defying any chance of opportunity. Sure.
- 32:05Man, even after all of that, I still am very
- 32:07sympathetic to Fran. That's interesting. But
- 32:11this was about... I think this was very close
- 32:14to no point of a point of no return. Yeah. Well,
- 32:17I don't think we're there just yet. The phone
- 32:19incident is earlier in the movie than when she
- 32:21is discovered with Arnold. Yes. So I think at
- 32:26the Arnold thing, that's when I'm like, okay,
- 32:28this is, this is like the last straw and things
- 32:31need to change now. And it's when she says, well,
- 32:34I'm not going back home that I was like. Okay.
- 32:36Well then, then you need to like move forward
- 32:39with that then, you know? So maybe that was the
- 32:41moment where I was like, okay, it's, it is selfish,
- 32:45but I'm still understanding of why you need to.
- 32:48be away but then you have to like cut ties you
- 32:52have to say okay we will get divorced and like
- 32:54i will live my life yes or you know to me even
- 32:57i was like even if you decide this you have to
- 32:59have a conversation with your daughter yes and
- 33:01you need to like tell her all of this but it
- 33:03is implied that she does not have communication
- 33:05at home and it is just sam relaying all this
- 33:08over to their daughter this is a good time to
- 33:11mention that earlier on uh on that cruise ship
- 33:14when they're going to england when fran was having
- 33:16this run -in with captain lockhart We saw that
- 33:19Sam, while he's trying to enjoy everything about
- 33:21what's happening around him and more intellectual
- 33:23talk, he comes into contact with someone named
- 33:27Edith Courtright. Now, this is portrayed by Mary
- 33:30Astor, as we mentioned previously. And she is
- 33:33a widower or divorcee? Divorcee. She's a divorcee.
- 33:39And they have a conversation. It is innocent.
- 33:42You can see that there's a connection being built.
- 33:44But there is no... pursue between the two of
- 33:49them right there is no hey we should continue
- 33:51this and like make this work she mentions where
- 33:54she lives and he notes this but there's never
- 33:57like a longing on his part afterwards of like
- 34:00oh i should have done this instead and Later
- 34:03on, when we see, like, you know, that Fran has
- 34:07decided to, like, stay and not go back home,
- 34:10we see that Sam says, well, I want to travel
- 34:13and I want to get around. So why don't I try
- 34:15traveling and see what this is like? And we see
- 34:17him traveling on his own. We see him not having
- 34:20a partner and not seeking a partner from anyone,
- 34:23but just traveling. And in this, he ends up,
- 34:25I think, is it Italy? Oh, I forget where he ends
- 34:29up, if I'm honest. It's definitely like surrounded
- 34:32by water. So I don't know why, but for some reason,
- 34:35I'm like, it's either Greece or Italy. I think
- 34:37it's Italy. But he ends up running into Edith.
- 34:41And he and Edith have a conversation and they
- 34:43start enjoying the company of each other more
- 34:45and more. And I think this is the dichotomy between
- 34:49the two of we see. fran rushing into all these
- 34:54relationships to where it's not like hey the
- 34:56two of us are in love it's more we are in this
- 34:58moment together and that's it where i think that
- 35:01we see sam and edith as much more of a genuine
- 35:05connection right and they find themselves like
- 35:07oh are we is this going to happen like do we
- 35:10need to like look into doing this but at this
- 35:12point he's embraced that even though he doesn't
- 35:14have a full divorce um or no i'm so sorry he
- 35:17does have a we skipped a thing There's a character
- 35:20named Kurt von Oberstdorf. Gregory Gay is the
- 35:25actor behind him. And we'll skip through this
- 35:28pretty quickly. That is an individual that Fran
- 35:31starts hanging out with to see more. Her next
- 35:32man. Her next man, really, yeah. And at one point,
- 35:36he proposes. And he says, hey. I really want
- 35:39to get together. I think this is something we
- 35:40should do. She doesn't take it very seriously
- 35:43at the time. But when she's confronted about
- 35:46this from Sam, she feels like he's been like
- 35:48stalking her or something. He hasn't. He's just
- 35:51come home. They have this loud argument about
- 35:54this. And she says, you know what? I am actually
- 35:57going to take him up on his proposal. We're going
- 35:58to get married and I am fully getting a divorce
- 36:00from you. Right. And that gives Sam the release
- 36:02that he needs to go and travel the world and
- 36:04do what he wants to do. And he does this. And
- 36:07that's what leads to Edith. But meanwhile, and
- 36:10I want to cut to you on this because I'd love
- 36:12to hear your thoughts. Meanwhile, we see Fran
- 36:15continuing this marriage or engagement with Kurt
- 36:19von Oberstdorf. Now, Kurt has some riches behind
- 36:24him. He comes from a long line. And she is then
- 36:27introduced by Kurt to the Baroness von Oberstdorf.
- 36:32And I would love to hear your thoughts on this
- 36:34scene. Well, the Baroness is Kurt's mother. Yes.
- 36:37So he brings her over to what Fran believes is
- 36:41you're going to get, like, my mother's permission.
- 36:44Yeah, we're going to have some, like, tea and
- 36:45laugh and have a good time. Yes. And the Baroness,
- 36:49played by Maria Ospenskaya, is, like, very, very
- 36:56serious. Very cold. Very cold. Very cold. That's
- 37:00a great word. She is—there's no— sense of humor
- 37:05or anything behind her character. And she is
- 37:08quiet and reserved, but very, very stoic in a
- 37:13way. And Fran is trying to be like sweet and
- 37:17fun and, oh, hello, you're going to be my mother
- 37:20-in -law. And the Baroness is just not having
- 37:24it. And ultimately what you find out is she is
- 37:27not there to grant them permission of marriage.
- 37:30She's saying, no, you can't marry my son. I won't
- 37:34allow it. You are a divorcee, and you're also
- 37:38old. You know what I liked about this is, and
- 37:41the only thing that I take issue with just a
- 37:43little bit, she's all those things that you mentioned,
- 37:46but she's not vindictive. She's not ready to
- 37:50call her old. But she'll be like, so what if
- 37:52he wants kids? Right, right. She kind of alludes
- 37:56to it, where she's like, I'm not going to call
- 37:58you old, but what if this happens? Yeah. And
- 38:01I took this as... the baroness is being very
- 38:05like straightforward not straightforward but
- 38:07like very like realistic and meanwhile fran is
- 38:10still performative right fran is kind of like
- 38:13in this honestly it's almost like a drug haze
- 38:16of like she's like oh this is gonna work this
- 38:18is perfect like this is everything it needs to
- 38:19be and she's not stopping to think this through
- 38:21and she's like well yeah i mean like you know
- 38:24it's perfect everything's gonna be happy because
- 38:26i i'm willing it to be she's like great What
- 38:29about kids? Yeah. She's like, well, you know,
- 38:31he's going to, if he truly loves me, he'll love
- 38:33me with or without kids. She's like, all right,
- 38:35cool. So you're going to be like that. So let's
- 38:37be like this. You're old. Like you can't bear
- 38:40children. Right. And he needs an heir for like
- 38:43their lineage and all of that. Right. So, I mean,
- 38:46you're right. She's not vindictive, but she is
- 38:49cold enough that she knows exactly how to target.
- 38:53fran and and really kind of hurt her to to get
- 38:56her point across and i don't mean this to be
- 38:58cute for the name of her son but she's very curt
- 39:00yeah she's just very straightforward about this
- 39:04and again no part of it comes across as like
- 39:06you know what it really seems like to me i don't
- 39:09know if it seems like this or it's just kind
- 39:10of funny to think about but we talk about someone
- 39:14who is being played kind of like a villainess
- 39:17And then we see kind of like the person who won't
- 39:19let this go any further. Everyone has kind of
- 39:21allowed her to be this character and allowed
- 39:23her to be like a free spirit, do whatever she
- 39:24wants. This is the first real villain in Fran's
- 39:28story of like, I won't let you do this. I cannot
- 39:32let you do this because I'm just going to be
- 39:34straightforward with you. Even her husband, you
- 39:36see him being like, look, I kind of know this
- 39:38is going on, but if we just pretend that it's
- 39:40not, maybe it's okay. So this is the only roadblock
- 39:43she has actually met. Is this woman, and I think
- 39:46she's kind of a representative of time. You know,
- 39:49I think not only does she remind her of time
- 39:51in her age, but she literally tells her, you
- 39:54are old. Yes. You cannot do this. I do like that
- 39:57this, like, gut punch of, hey, this is a serious
- 40:02thing. Your age isn't just something that you're,
- 40:05like, fearful of because of, you'll look a certain
- 40:08way. Like, children is a big thing that you're
- 40:12going to. You come into the realization that
- 40:14maybe maybe you're getting past that age. And
- 40:18it's it's such a like solid gut punch. And it
- 40:21comes from another woman. And I think that is
- 40:24really expertly done in this movie. Are you familiar
- 40:28with Maria? I might be, but not by name. So she
- 40:32is Maliva in the Wolfman movie. She's the one
- 40:37that's like, beware the moon and the wolf's bane
- 40:40and all of that stuff. So she has a history in
- 40:43the Universal Monster movies as a really haunting
- 40:45figure and a character in the horrified board
- 40:51game that is constantly getting killed. And I
- 40:54need her to chill out because I lose a lot because
- 40:56of her. But yeah, it's always fun when a Universal
- 40:59Monster star pops up. And I think that... She
- 41:03is so perfectly cast when you know what she goes
- 41:06on to become. She definitely has that, like,
- 41:10creepy lady vibes. Well, I mean, it's worth noting
- 41:13that in terms of the characters of this movie,
- 41:15I have seven people written down. And she is
- 41:19the last one written down. But she got the nomination
- 41:22for Supporting Actress. She did, yeah. And actor
- 41:26Walter Houston also got the nomination for this.
- 41:29But we didn't see Ruth Chatterton. We didn't.
- 41:32I think it's less about her performance and more
- 41:35about her character. I think so, too. Because
- 41:37she is good in this. She's great. But again,
- 41:39I really do stand by that you can feel the movie
- 41:42or the character. Well, actually both. The movie
- 41:45and the character pushing and pulling on the
- 41:47intentions. Yes. I think this conversation that's
- 41:50had with Maria Ospenskaya, which is incredible.
- 41:53And I understand the supporting nomination for
- 41:55this. And you know that it's good when you know
- 41:57about this nomination. And the whole movie, you're
- 41:59like, where is this person? And when they show
- 42:01up in, I guess, the last 20 % of the movie. You're
- 42:05thinking, okay, well this better blow me out
- 42:06of the water if this is the first time you're
- 42:08being introduced. And it does. It's so good.
- 42:10You know that it's effective. She's really great
- 42:12in that. But that's a testament to how important
- 42:17this scene is and how well acted this is from
- 42:21both of them. That that's nominated. And also
- 42:23that this is a reminder of that time that Ruth
- 42:26Chatterton is playing behind the character of
- 42:28Age. Yeah. And and at this point, like that's
- 42:31kind of the lead into what will be the climax
- 42:34of the movie, because now Fran, this has ended
- 42:38for her this this neck of her journey. And she
- 42:42doesn't have anybody now. She's she's lost Arnold.
- 42:45She's lost Kurt. And the clock is ticking in
- 42:49her eyes and she's getting very, very nervous.
- 42:51And Sam, at this point, he is gone. And he's
- 42:54like, OK, well, this is this is life now. He
- 42:57still hasn't reached the point where he's ready
- 42:59to move on. He's just kind of living his life
- 43:01and enjoying it, and he's spending time with
- 43:03Edith Cartwright. And just as they are starting
- 43:08to get close and realize, you know, maybe we
- 43:11do want more with each other, he gets a call
- 43:14from Fran, and Fran is in hysterics. She's like,
- 43:19hey, I need you, really, is what she's getting
- 43:22at. I miss you. I loved this whole scene because
- 43:26he's not the first one to find this out. Right.
- 43:28It's Edith. And Edith hears from her housekeeper
- 43:32or whatever that there is a call coming from
- 43:35where, I forget exactly where it is, but it's
- 43:38where she knows that Fran has been. Right. So
- 43:42she knows this is Fran. And she almost tries
- 43:45to rush Sam out of the house. yeah to like avoid
- 43:48this but he goes back for something and like
- 43:50the phone rings again and he just kind of takes
- 43:52it or no i'm so sorry the housekeeper's like
- 43:54oh this is for uh sam and for doddsworth he's
- 43:57like oh cool let me take this call yeah and as
- 43:59he takes it you see his realization at the same
- 44:02time it's a great it's not a split diopter or
- 44:04anything but you can see uh edith's reaction
- 44:07in the corner while he's taking the call and
- 44:09both of them are kind of reacting at the same
- 44:10time she knows that once that call is picked
- 44:12up uh she's lost him and he knows this too And
- 44:16it's a sad realization of, well, I got to go
- 44:18be there because, you know, technically that's
- 44:21my partner and like my, my ex -wife, like I have
- 44:23to go be there for whatever. And he does this
- 44:25and it's heartbreaking and it's sad because you
- 44:29want to see this continue. But the thing that
- 44:31to me, I wasn't mad at this because shortly after
- 44:34we see him getting on the boat with Fran and
- 44:38as he tries to like make peace with this life,
- 44:41he realizes very quickly how high maintenance
- 44:45she is. And how she needs someone to care for
- 44:48her. Right. And this kind of harkens back to
- 44:51when he came home the first time and didn't have
- 44:53someone. He was like, oh, well, she usually does
- 44:56this for me. And your mother has this here. And
- 44:57why would you move this? And, like, my whole
- 44:59life is different now. And I hate that. And now
- 45:02he is seeing that this person needs so much from
- 45:05him. Oh, that door is open. It's so cold. Why
- 45:07do they keep that door closed? Or why don't they
- 45:09keep that door closed? And he's like, well, let
- 45:11me get you, like, a blanket or something. And,
- 45:12like, why don't we get you a coat? Or let's close
- 45:14it. And no matter what, she's just always upset
- 45:17at something. And she starts judging other people.
- 45:20And he hates this, too. So he gets up and he
- 45:22decides, I'm leaving. I'm going to get off this
- 45:24boat as quickly as I can. And I'm going to Edith.
- 45:27And there's a great line that he has. And I can't
- 45:31remember the exact phrase of it. I have it. You
- 45:32have it? Yep. Okay. I did love this. Clearly,
- 45:35it resonated with you, too. Right. She mentions,
- 45:38you know, are you not the man I married? Are
- 45:41you not the man that I... Or that claims to love
- 45:44me. Yes. And he says, love has got to stop someplace
- 45:47short of suicide. And I think that's the moment
- 45:52where everything kind of clicks. And you're like,
- 45:54I think that's the last thing that's said. There
- 45:56might be someone that's like last person coming
- 45:58on the boat. But that's the last line between
- 46:00him or Fran. I believe you're right. Yeah. That
- 46:02is the end of their relationship. And it is.
- 46:06It's like everything clicks in that moment because
- 46:08you realize that. He was doing everything in
- 46:12his power to keep them together and happy, you
- 46:16know, to the extent of you go live in this other
- 46:19country by yourself and do whatever, you know.
- 46:22And when I find out that you've been unfaithful,
- 46:24I'm going to work through that with you too.
- 46:27And you know it's taking a toll on him, but you
- 46:30don't really see it. And I think this is a sign
- 46:32of the times as well where you don't see a man
- 46:35really be hit. massively by his emotions but
- 46:40you know that this is this has been weighing
- 46:42on him his entire life and now when he's finally
- 46:45found somebody that he's comfortable enough to
- 46:48to not only be with but to say goodbye to his
- 46:52previous life clearly that's taken a lot from
- 46:54him he finds edith and then fran shows up again
- 46:59And this is the moment where it's like the ultimate
- 47:01crossroad. Does he go back and take care of her
- 47:05again in her selfish ways, in her she only needs
- 47:10him when she's in distress or when somebody else
- 47:13isn't there? Or does he go live the life that
- 47:17he feels he deserves? And it's great that he
- 47:21comes to the realization that if he stays, it
- 47:24will eventually kill him. It's beautiful. It
- 47:27is beautiful. You know, a couple things about
- 47:30this I checked, because we talked about this.
- 47:33This is in the middle of the production code,
- 47:35right? This is not like, oh, it was just formed
- 47:37last year. This is happening. This has been happening.
- 47:40This is nothing new. This was shocking to us
- 47:42in a number of ways. A, the way that infidelity
- 47:44is portrayed. The way that it's not danced around.
- 47:47It is pretty, like... Not shown, but there's
- 47:49kissing between other people. There's the make
- 47:52love comment that's made. So this is, of all
- 47:55those things, this isn't where I'm leading, but
- 47:57it's a little related. This is the first time,
- 47:59this movie, that mid -code, a man walks out of
- 48:02a marriage without punishment. Right. Because
- 48:04she does say, well, I am going to go ahead and
- 48:07move forward with this other guy proposing. He's
- 48:09like, great, I'm leaving. And he leaves. And
- 48:11he leaves the country and travels. And there's
- 48:14no punishment shown of doing that in 1936, obviously
- 48:18a very different time. The other thing behind
- 48:20this, and I thought that was very interesting,
- 48:22but the other really interesting tidbit behind
- 48:24this movie is that we talked about how Walter
- 48:26Houston was nominated for Best Actor. And we
- 48:30also talked about how Maria Ospenskaya was also
- 48:33nominated for Best Supporting Actor, Actress.
- 48:36So this, along with My Man Godfrey, were the
- 48:40first films to be nominated for Best Actor and
- 48:43Supporting Actor or Actress. So those two films
- 48:47specifically were the first. To have a nomination
- 48:50in both an acting and a supporting? Correct.
- 48:53I see. That's awesome. Very cool. Obviously,
- 48:56it's something that's almost like a standard
- 48:58now in modern terms in 2020, post -2020. well
- 49:02before that too but i'm just saying modern times
- 49:04yeah uh we will see like you know when we talked
- 49:07about this uh at the oscar for the oscar ceremony
- 49:10of 1935 where we said that um you know it's very
- 49:14rare that we're going to see movies that were
- 49:16win for best picture but uh don't win anything
- 49:19else yeah right because everything else is kind
- 49:22of like a lead -up like a proof where's the evidence
- 49:24of how good the movie is yeah was it the acting
- 49:26was it the um under not under Below the line.
- 49:29Thank you. Below the line was the writing. Like,
- 49:32there's something that makes this movie a step
- 49:34above everything else. And you want to see that
- 49:35nomination. I think it's really interesting to
- 49:38see, like, the beginning of that. Yeah. Here.
- 49:40Yeah, I agree. I agree completely. The final
- 49:44shot of this movie, too, I love that even though
- 49:48the entire story hinges on Sam and Fran's relationship.
- 49:51Yes. The last shot is Mary Astor's face smiling
- 49:55and waving down to Sam. Because she sees that
- 49:58a boat is coming to her island where she is.
- 50:02And it's a reveal of, I think the mast is in
- 50:06the way. And once the boat turns, you can see
- 50:09it's a smaller boat. You see Sam is on the boat
- 50:13behind waving to her. And I think it's so great
- 50:17that they use Mary Astor here as Edith. Because
- 50:20she's thrilled that... OK, he's come back to
- 50:24me like I get him. There is that that level of
- 50:27it. But she's excited for him because this this
- 50:29means that he has made the choice on his own
- 50:32one to be with her, but also to give up that
- 50:36life that was weighing him down. And I just love
- 50:40that you see the happiness from her as an indicator
- 50:43of what is to come for Sam. Yes, I agree. And
- 50:47did you see that Mary Astor like this as well?
- 50:50I did, yeah, I read that. She was a big fan of
- 50:52it. Yeah, she wrote in her memoir how pleased
- 50:54she was that it ended with her for that exact
- 50:56reason. Yeah. Because you're right, the double
- 50:58meaning there is that, A, she's happy for herself
- 51:00that she gets to be with Sam, but I also think
- 51:02that it's that she's happy for him that he made
- 51:04a decision. Yes. And didn't just, like, feel
- 51:07like he had to be trapped. And you're seeing
- 51:09a woman who... Obviously cares so much about
- 51:12Sam in that moment in a way that Fran never did.
- 51:15So it's such a good choice to not end on Sam
- 51:18and to end on her. I agree. Beyond the story,
- 51:23like there was a lot in this movie that really
- 51:26impressed me. I've talked about like how grounded
- 51:29it feels and how it doesn't feel like a silly
- 51:32little melodrama. Like I think about Bad Girl
- 51:35and like. Bad Girl was fine. I think we both
- 51:38were okay on it. But it did feel a little cheesy,
- 51:42a little campy, a little goofy at times, even
- 51:45though the themes were very, very serious. This
- 51:48feels like there's no room for giggles or anything
- 51:53like that. And I really love that. I'm a big
- 51:57drama guy. And this is one of the first examples
- 52:00of like this type of drama. And man, I adored
- 52:03it. The sound. nomination here i also thought
- 52:07was interesting because it's obviously a drama
- 52:09there's not action and explosions going off but
- 52:13the arguments that do sound and feel very grounded
- 52:16and real i i love how much speaking over one
- 52:20another there is and i mean there are moments
- 52:23where fran is just kind of like spouting out
- 52:26like well you know i i want to be more like the
- 52:30the socialites and things and i want to eat what
- 52:32people in this country eat and sam is just like
- 52:35talking over her like a like a real couple does
- 52:39yeah and i think that element and having the
- 52:42clarity of those conversations come through still
- 52:44with the sound recording adds to the realism
- 52:47of the movie so i think it's one of the best
- 52:50examples of a sound recording nomination I think
- 52:53you're right. I think also the other example
- 52:55of this is whenever you have a moment in the
- 52:57movie that is alerting you to how loud it is,
- 53:00it needs to prove that. Yeah. So the noise complaint
- 53:04scene where they're arguing, you really do feel
- 53:07like it is shaking the room, like how much they
- 53:09are yelling at each other. So when that call
- 53:11comes in, you're like, yeah, totally. Like, oh
- 53:14man, it happens a little quickly for my taste,
- 53:16to be honest. It's like maybe 15 seconds after
- 53:18that they get a phone call that's like, hey,
- 53:19you're being too loud. Yeah. We received a noise
- 53:22complaint. I was like, that didn't happen in
- 53:2315 seconds. But you can, it's justified in the
- 53:27volume. And that's, again, the sound recording
- 53:29of like, they know to balance these things and
- 53:31you really have to like lean into this or have
- 53:33them scream louder to really convey the strength
- 53:37of like how loud this is. Yeah. So. I think in
- 53:40combination of talking over and multiple people
- 53:43in a room having a conversation, a similar thing
- 53:45of when Sam first comes home and he's almost
- 53:48grumpy at the idea of like things aren't ready
- 53:50for him and things aren't where he left them.
- 53:51You can kind of hear his daughter like trying
- 53:53to, okay, daddy, like calm down. Like it's going
- 53:56to be okay. While he's like freaking out, you
- 53:58can make out all these things. Yeah. So sound
- 54:00recording was very clear here. Oh, it's so good.
- 54:02And the scene again with the phone is incredibly
- 54:05written. The fact that that's an example. Of
- 54:09Sam's character, of letting the anger take control
- 54:12of him, but he's level -headed enough that when
- 54:15he does get that complaint, like, he brings it
- 54:17down. And the argument ramps back up again, just
- 54:21like it would in real life, but, like, that's
- 54:22such expert writing. Do you recall the scene
- 54:26where they're in a bedroom together and they
- 54:28get into an argument and he ends up looking for
- 54:32his cigarettes? Yes. So minor. But so good to
- 54:36have that in there to, again, make it feel like
- 54:39these are real people. They are having a real
- 54:41conversation, a real argument. I thought the
- 54:44writing was incredible. I don't mean to be a
- 54:48conspiracy theorist about this, but I say that.
- 54:52The only thing that stopped me from absolutely
- 54:54loving this movie was how the movie does feel
- 54:58at odds with itself of Ruth Chatterton, specifically
- 55:02the Fran Dotsworth character, and how the movie
- 55:06wants to portray her. And I think that if you
- 55:08look at the nominations, again, let's go through
- 55:10that. I mean, sound recording, art direction,
- 55:12but then let's focus on this. Best picture, screenplay,
- 55:16supporting actress, actor, director. I think
- 55:20that even the nominations, show that we are willing
- 55:24to give awards and recognition to just about
- 55:27everything and everyone except Ruth Chatterton
- 55:31yeah and I don't mean that's like a Ruth we hate
- 55:34you but I think that that is them looking at
- 55:36what works in the movie and what works in the
- 55:38movie is Maria Ospenskaya is incredible as the
- 55:41Baroness and she is a turning point in Ruth's
- 55:44character and it is it is a real I think I don't
- 55:47want to say condemnation but I think it's a real
- 55:49sign that in that scene that is a real turning
- 55:52point for that character, the nomination is going
- 55:56to the other person in that conversation and
- 55:58not Ruth. Same goes for Walter Houston. Same
- 56:01goes for the direction by William Wyler. And
- 56:03to your point, same goes for Sidney Howard in
- 56:05the screenplay. Like, I think it is so well written
- 56:08and so well directed, but it's just noticeable
- 56:10or it's assigned to me. That Ruth Chatterjee
- 56:13isn't nominated there? Because I think that is
- 56:15then recognized in this movie is fantastic, but
- 56:18there is an outlying factor that for me, at least,
- 56:21it's easy to read into what that might be. I
- 56:23wonder with the production code and all of that,
- 56:26if it is a sign of the times that we're not cheering
- 56:30for villains normally. The most you cheer for
- 56:33a villain is going to be in a horror movie. But
- 56:36a lot of those villains end up being sympathetic.
- 56:39Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde was nominated, but you
- 56:41have a character who is good, but then after
- 56:44the potion becomes evil. And I don't think that
- 56:48in the 30s audiences are cheering on villains
- 56:52to the extent of let's award characters that
- 56:56we don't like. And when I say villains, I don't
- 56:58mean like villains that are fun to root for.
- 57:00I mean like detestable villains. Yeah. And I
- 57:04would argue that. Fran is very unlikable in this
- 57:09movie. I would, by and large, say, well, let
- 57:12me rephrase that. I would agree, by and large.
- 57:15Like, I think that's right. But I do think that
- 57:18there are some exceptions. Charles Lawton was
- 57:20just nominated for his portrayal as Captain Blight
- 57:22in Mutiny on the Bounty, which, to the beginning,
- 57:25you might be able to say, okay, he has some,
- 57:26like, you know, you can defend him a little bit.
- 57:29By the last half of this movie, like... Really,
- 57:32once he survives the mutiny, you're just like,
- 57:34nope, this guy sucks. But is he fun? He's fun,
- 57:37sure. But then even the villain to Fran in this
- 57:41movie, like Fran would see Maria Ospenskaya as
- 57:44the villain of her story, and she gets nominated.
- 57:47So I think you're right, that we're not rooting
- 57:50for villains, but there are people who can have
- 57:51villainous qualities that will get nominated.
- 57:55And that too, I think if you are right, and I
- 57:58think you are. then I think that that speaks
- 58:00to what's wrong with this movie, is that she
- 58:02shouldn't be portrayed as this villainous person,
- 58:05which is clearly what Ruth Chatterton wanted
- 58:06to do here. And it should have been William Wyler's
- 58:09interpretation of there is some sympathy to her,
- 58:12and ultimately it's just a tragedy that she ended
- 58:14up in this place. Yeah. That's my thought. I
- 58:17think on a second watch through, I might even
- 58:20enjoy that towing the line element of it, because
- 58:25that kind of makes it feel real as well. Where
- 58:27it's like, this is a selfish person, but like
- 58:30their motives behind it, like fear of age and
- 58:34just being locked into something for the rest
- 58:36of their life. Like, I can be sympathetic towards
- 58:39that character at times. So, I don't know. I
- 58:42think on a first viewing, it's just like, yeah,
- 58:44I can't get into her because she does some despicable
- 58:48things. But yeah, I don't know. You want to get
- 58:50into ratings? I'd love to get into ratings. Man,
- 58:51I think this... Kind of story, just it always
- 58:55works well with me. And when I say this kind
- 58:59of story, I mean like you're really diving into
- 59:01characters here, you know, and getting into the
- 59:04daily lives of people that are going through
- 59:07this. I love that. And we didn't talk a whole
- 59:11lot about William Wyler, but he's doing very
- 59:14interesting things with the camera. That sounds
- 59:17like an understatement in a way. But like, I
- 59:20don't think the camera is ever... incredibly
- 59:23stationary in this movie. There's a really cool
- 59:26shot where the camera is set underneath a table
- 59:28in like a bar or restaurant. And we see Sam walk
- 59:33in, camera raises up above the table, and then
- 59:37it kind of goes left and right during a conversation.
- 59:40And it's not like, whoa, that was incredible.
- 59:42It's very elegant. Yes. And it's alive, you know?
- 59:46And that's what I love about this movie. It feels
- 59:48alive. It feels real. I like this way more than
- 59:53I expected. I gave it four stars. So I gave it
- 59:57three and a half, and I think it might be closer
- 1:00:00to four. But what I'm trying to do is I'm trying
- 1:00:03to wrestle with myself of where I want to land
- 1:00:05post -Ruth Chatterton. And again, this is a really
- 1:00:10unfortunate place to be in because it was a bad
- 1:00:11performance. You can just say, okay, bad performance,
- 1:00:13not good. It's a good performance. It's just,
- 1:00:16it's very muddied. And it makes the movie a little
- 1:00:18muddied in that. So to me, that's why it's harder
- 1:00:21to go just straight four stars. But having this
- 1:00:23conversation with you, it is not lost on me how
- 1:00:26much we praise this movie. And there's really
- 1:00:28nothing outside of the... the characterization
- 1:00:31of Fran that I think makes this difficult to
- 1:00:35make peace with four stars. So I think you're
- 1:00:38right about four stars. I rated it three and
- 1:00:39a half. I'm probably going to land at four to
- 1:00:42a point where when you were rating this on the
- 1:00:44podcast page for Letterboxd, I would go ahead
- 1:00:47and put four as like the median of two of us.
- 1:00:51But yeah, I mean, this was just like a fascinating
- 1:00:53look. And I thought this was so much fun is almost
- 1:00:57the wrong word. But you do have fun watching
- 1:00:59this of like this very bleak movie that does
- 1:01:02not have a lot of humor in it. And there might
- 1:01:03be some like a slight chuckle of like the way
- 1:01:06that the characterization is of like the conversations
- 1:01:09between Fran and Sam. You talked about them talking
- 1:01:11over each other, him almost like a that's rich
- 1:01:14kind of thing of when she says it. And he's like,
- 1:01:16yeah, sure, that'll be the day. Like a chuckle
- 1:01:18or something, but nothing humorous and funny.
- 1:01:21And to be able to do that in an hour and 40 minutes
- 1:01:23and keep us invested throughout, that's a tough
- 1:01:27act. And this is just very ahead of its time.
- 1:01:31I think so, too. That I really, really appreciated.
- 1:01:34I think that's what a lot of our favorite directors
- 1:01:37feel like is ahead of their time. Yes. And William
- 1:01:40Wyler, to me, I've seen a few of his movies that
- 1:01:43aren't like standout stories a lot of the times,
- 1:01:47but they're done so elegantly that I fall in
- 1:01:51love. with the film itself. And you know what
- 1:01:54it is? I think I just landed on my frustration.
- 1:01:57It is such an honest movie. And I think everything
- 1:01:59else that we've seen up to this point that deals
- 1:02:01with divorce is such like a comedy of errors
- 1:02:04of like, oh, well, sure, it may end in divorce,
- 1:02:06but look at all these wacky ways that we got
- 1:02:08there. Maybe we think it's a divorce, but it's
- 1:02:10not. So it's a happy ending. And this does have
- 1:02:12a happy ending. But otherwise, it's a very honest,
- 1:02:14brutal movie. It is. And the characterization
- 1:02:17of Fran to me is the only thing that seems dishonest.
- 1:02:21And that's why the movie feels a little muddied
- 1:02:23is it's a movie that I think preaches honesty,
- 1:02:25not preaches it, but like it just feels so earnest
- 1:02:28and honest. And I feel like disconnection with
- 1:02:31the Fran character. I feel like Fran is so real.
- 1:02:35Oh, I disagree. She's doing stuff that's selfish.
- 1:02:38She's. Well, I think she is so, so much trying
- 1:02:41to be someone that she's not. And she's defying
- 1:02:43her own age and defying her own like self. She's
- 1:02:47Alice Adams, all grown up. sure and that's someone
- 1:02:50who's trying to be someone she's not yeah which
- 1:02:52is which is i'm not saying that her like fran
- 1:02:55is honest i think the portrayal of that character
- 1:02:59is a very real to me it's the fact that like
- 1:03:02the movie is so honest but that character is
- 1:03:04not so that's the the real confliction conflict
- 1:03:08that's the real conflict that i have with this
- 1:03:10movie is just like the the muddied of that and
- 1:03:13again It would be an easy three -star movie if
- 1:03:16I thought that was the movie's fault. It's not
- 1:03:18the movie's fault. It's my own. I can't connect
- 1:03:20with it. So I do think four stars is appropriate
- 1:03:22because I enjoyed this and this conversation
- 1:03:25so much. Man, this is my favorite type of movie
- 1:03:28because you're not saying, not you, but we're
- 1:03:31not saying pirates are so much fun. We're having
- 1:03:35a conversation about morality and just... emotion
- 1:03:41in a way and like how we feel about these characters.
- 1:03:44And that's what I want from a movie. So you brought
- 1:03:48it up earlier of like, when are we going to find
- 1:03:50one that I'm like, Hey, that was great. Yeah.
- 1:03:53This is it for me. Yeah. I really liked Doddsworth.
- 1:03:56That's awesome. I'm so glad because I really
- 1:03:58enjoyed. I think this is the, not this point
- 1:04:01specifically, but I think this week was the turning
- 1:04:03point in me of like, oh, this is really interesting.
- 1:04:06Yes. So I'm glad you felt that way. Do you want
- 1:04:09to get into double features? I do. We are running
- 1:04:11long. I'll dive into mine real quick. I went
- 1:04:14with Midwinter Break. It's a movie actually this
- 1:04:16year, 2026, directed by Pauly Finley. This is
- 1:04:20a movie starring, I think it's Isabel Hooper.
- 1:04:23I might be wrong about that. And Siren Hines.
- 1:04:28And they are all. Also an older couple that travels
- 1:04:30to Amsterdam for a vacation. And in it, they
- 1:04:33both uncover some pretty dark secrets that make
- 1:04:37them question their relationship. I'm going to
- 1:04:40go ahead and say I haven't seen this movie. I
- 1:04:42have a lot of interest in it. But the setup to
- 1:04:44it while I was watching Doddsworth was like,
- 1:04:46oh, man, this sounds so much like that movie
- 1:04:47I want to see in midwinter break. Did some research
- 1:04:50into it. And the idea of a couple being traveling
- 1:04:52across country to, like, different locations
- 1:04:55and dealing with the mortality of their relationship
- 1:04:59and their marriage, I thought, resembled so much
- 1:05:03of what's in Doddsworth that I want to go and
- 1:05:05cite this. Yeah. Midwinter break. That's awesome.
- 1:05:10Anything that you compare to this, I'm like,
- 1:05:12oh, I want to check that out. Which, again, I
- 1:05:14haven't seen it, but just from the synopsis and
- 1:05:16what I've seen of it, sounds so similar to this.
- 1:05:19And in tone, I imagine it's pretty matched. Doesn't
- 1:05:22seem like a comedy, I'll say that. I love not
- 1:05:25a comedy, Ryan. So I had something written down,
- 1:05:29but I'm going to end up saving it. I think this
- 1:05:31is the third time I've crossed it out and gone
- 1:05:33with something else. But just as you were talking,
- 1:05:35I decided to go with Wong Kar Wai's... 2000 film,
- 1:05:39In the Mood for Love. Yeah. Have you seen that
- 1:05:42movie? I haven't, but I'm so familiar with the
- 1:05:44visuals of it. Man, I love that movie. It is
- 1:05:48two people who are in current relationships with
- 1:05:53other people and they meet each other and slowly
- 1:05:56start to, you know, get close to each other,
- 1:06:00but they never move past a certain point. And
- 1:06:05I think it is just a... Beautiful example of
- 1:06:07like two people that are on very different paths.
- 1:06:12And if just like one thing was different, maybe
- 1:06:14things would work out. And I don't, you know,
- 1:06:17that's not a one -to -one here, but I think the
- 1:06:19emotion that it captures is very similar to things
- 1:06:22in Doddsworth. I'm really excited to see it.
- 1:06:24I've heard all the praise for it, and I've seen
- 1:06:26the criterion for it pretty often. Yeah. So I'm
- 1:06:29very excited to get into it. Is it one we'll
- 1:06:32talk about for, not best picture, but was it
- 1:06:35international? I honestly, I don't know. You
- 1:06:39know what? I got it right here. Nope. Okay. Well,
- 1:06:42it wasn't nominated, but it is something I'm
- 1:06:45excited to visit. So good. So good. I know we
- 1:06:49ran long on this one, but I think it was very
- 1:06:52exciting to talk about something like this. This
- 1:06:56is a movie that I anticipated us to talk about
- 1:06:58in the 80s, 90s, 2000s. Yeah. Not in 1936. So
- 1:07:03very cool. I think this is a diamond in the rough.
- 1:07:06I don't mean that to say these movies suck. I
- 1:07:09think it's just more so this is just a standout
- 1:07:11that we weren't going to see very much of in
- 1:07:14this time or to come. We had a rough spell for
- 1:07:17a little while, and I think this has helped me,
- 1:07:19especially. So it's a diamond in the rough in
- 1:07:22two ways, because you're right about that. But
- 1:07:24the other side, too, is that it's just one of
- 1:07:26these things that's not like the other. This
- 1:07:27is a very different movie for the Academy. And
- 1:07:30I love that. At the time, at least. Absolutely.
- 1:07:32I agree. So the next film we will be covering
- 1:07:36is Libeled Lady from 1936 as well. And this features
- 1:07:40two of our favorite actors and just their chemistry
- 1:07:46together. infallible also some i don't want to
- 1:07:49say introductions but some people that are going
- 1:07:52to be very important yeah so we'll we'll talk
- 1:07:54about them uh liable lady i'm very excited to
- 1:07:57talk about and that will be our next episode
- 1:07:59yes so uh emails all of your thoughts at outaopodcast
- 1:08:04at gmail .com and if you would like to support
- 1:08:07the show check out patreon .com slash outaopodcast
- 1:08:11you're able to support us but also you have access
- 1:08:13to all of our fun bonus material But that's going
- 1:08:17to do it. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And
- 1:08:20we'll see you at the movies.