Latest / Bloomberg Law / Menendez Charges & Baseball Exemption
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:18Speaker 1: The sounds of baseball not only the national pastime and
- 0:22Speaker 1: a more than ten billion dollar industry, but also the
- 0:26Speaker 1: only sport in the country that's exempt from the anti
- 0:29Speaker 1: trust laws. And now some minor league teams are asking
- 0:33Speaker 1: the Supreme Court to eliminate baseball's anti trust exemption. Why,
- 0:38Speaker 1: as they put it in one brief enough. Already joining
- 0:42Speaker 1: me is anti trust expert Harry First, a professor at
- 0:45Speaker 1: NYU Law School. Harry tell us how baseball got this
- 0:49Speaker 1: anti trust exemption.
- 0:51Speaker 2: Well, this is one of the most reviled exemptions from
- 0:56Speaker 2: the point of view of antitrust lawyers unless they represent
- 1:00Speaker 2: baseball companies or teams or leagues, and even the courts
- 1:04Speaker 2: don't like it. So it came about originally because of
- 1:10Speaker 2: a decision in nineteen twenty two by the Supreme Court
- 1:14Speaker 2: called Federal Baseball. And this is an opinion written by
- 1:19Speaker 2: Justice Holmes Uliver Wendell Holmes distinguished jurists, and it was
- 1:25Speaker 2: an effort to actually push out some competing leagues. And
- 1:30Speaker 2: Holmes said that, well, the any trust laws don't cover this.
- 1:34Speaker 2: Baseball is neither commerce nor interstate commerce. It's just sport
- 1:41Speaker 2: and it just takes place locally. So even though players
- 1:46Speaker 2: even then traveled from state to state and there was
- 1:50Speaker 2: a lot of money involved, perhaps Justice Holmes as the
- 1:55Speaker 2: Boston Brahmin disdain baseball. It was sort of like us
- 1:59Speaker 2: now raised with a certain kind of entertainment reviewing video games.
- 2:03Speaker 2: What is that? And is there so much money involved?
- 2:07Speaker 2: Are you serious? So maybe that was a poem's reaction.
- 2:11Speaker 2: I don't know, But in any event, that was a
- 2:13Speaker 2: decision any trust laws didn't apply. So that's nineteen twenty two.
- 2:18Speaker 2: The Supreme Court reaffirmed that decision in a case called
- 2:23Speaker 2: Toolson in nineteen fifty three involving New York Yankees. My
- 2:27Speaker 2: memory is correct, and the court said, even though the
- 2:31Speaker 2: decision was sort of dubious when made, it's now precedent,
- 2:36Speaker 2: and all aspects of that decision had been undermined. Even
- 2:40Speaker 2: in the intervening period, the courts had a rather a
- 2:44Speaker 2: narrow conception of what constituted interstate commerce, perhaps in nineteen
- 2:48Speaker 2: twenty two, but it had expanded clearly in the New
- 2:50Speaker 2: Deal era, and any trust cases had gone along. And
- 2:55Speaker 2: there's no doubt that baseball should have been considered an
- 2:57Speaker 2: interstate commerce all along point a business, but the Court
- 3:02Speaker 2: said in business of baseball is exempt from any trust
- 3:06Speaker 2: laws from the Shermanac. And then the third case in
- 3:10Speaker 2: this is a case called Flood against Kune. This involved
- 3:13Speaker 2: Kurt Flood, who didn't want to be bound by what
- 3:17Speaker 2: was called the reserve clause, which prevented players once they
- 3:22Speaker 2: were under contract from going to some other team even
- 3:26Speaker 2: after the contract was over. And this was an opinion
- 3:29Speaker 2: written by Justice Blackman. This goes beyond it put of
- 3:32Speaker 2: any trust law. If you teach a course in law
- 3:36Speaker 2: school about precedent and the need to follow precedent, you
- 3:41Speaker 2: know you would want to teach this opinion because it's
- 3:45Speaker 2: a payon to baseball and the greats of baseball and
- 3:50Speaker 2: how they flourished under this system. I mean, it was
- 3:55Speaker 2: very clear that Harry Blackman was a great baseball fan
- 4:00Speaker 2: and loved all these players. And now you come along,
- 4:03Speaker 2: Kurt Flood, You're going to challenge the system. Give me
- 4:06Speaker 2: a break. You know, everyone prospered. So on the basis
- 4:11Speaker 2: of the doctrine of starry decisives, let the decision stand.
- 4:15Speaker 2: The Supreme Court refused to overrule Tulsen and Federal Baseball
- 4:20Speaker 2: behind it, saying no, we've had this exemption, this decision
- 4:25Speaker 2: too long, no matter what we think of it, legally
- 4:27Speaker 2: were bound. Now there's no one who will stand up
- 4:31Speaker 2: for this, as I said, except people who represent baseball teams. Now,
- 4:36Speaker 2: there is one final little bit of a change, which
- 4:39Speaker 2: is Congress passed the law in nineteen ninety eight called
- 4:42Speaker 2: the Kirk Flood Act, which took out of the exemption,
- 4:46Speaker 2: put back into anti trust any contracts involving the employment
- 4:51Speaker 2: of major league baseball players at the major league level,
- 4:55Speaker 2: So just for major league baseball players like Kurt Flood,
- 5:00Speaker 2: that would now be subject to sort of the normal
- 5:02Speaker 2: rules of anti trust and labor law for that matter.
- 5:05Speaker 2: But these clauses aren't used anymore anyway, so it's sort
- 5:09Speaker 2: of in some sense factually irrelevant, but maybe a little
- 5:14Speaker 2: legal issue. Congress left everything else that this law doesn't
- 5:18Speaker 2: apply to anything else involving baseball. So in effect, the exemption,
- 5:23Speaker 2: which Congress never approved, very different from all other exemptions
- 5:28Speaker 2: that we have. Virtually all other exemptions Congress never approved
- 5:32Speaker 2: this one. The exemption continues.
- 5:35Speaker 1: Does baseball operate like a monopoly? And is that unlike
- 5:40Speaker 1: football or basketball or hockey.
- 5:43Speaker 2: So we could argue whether football and hockey and all
- 5:47Speaker 2: of those operate like monopolies, separate argument. At least they
- 5:52Speaker 2: are all subject to the anti trust laws. So all
- 5:57Speaker 2: sports professional the NCAA, you know, college sports, all sports
- 6:03Speaker 2: have been subject to the anti trustlaws. In the court,
- 6:07Speaker 2: sport after sport will say, you know, baseball is its
- 6:13Speaker 2: own thing. You're covered. So they are not free to
- 6:19Speaker 2: violated any trust laws. Now, whether what they do is
- 6:22Speaker 2: legal under d any trust laws is another story. And
- 6:26Speaker 2: your quest is a really good one because in the
- 6:30Speaker 2: most recent Supreme Court case involving organized sports, which involved
- 6:35Speaker 2: the NCAA with NCAA against Allston and the effort of
- 6:41Speaker 2: the NCAA to suppress the amounts of compensation to quote
- 6:45Speaker 2: what they like to call student athletes, and basically they
- 6:49Speaker 2: wanted to argue in the Supreme Court that you should
- 6:51Speaker 2: really treat us differently, and the Supreme Court wrote, no,
- 6:54Speaker 2: we're not treating you differently. You don't have any reason to.
- 6:58Speaker 2: And Justice Dorsach for a majority sort of dropped a
- 7:02Speaker 2: little hint about this and mentioned that the Supreme Court
- 7:05Speaker 2: in the past had balied this is his word with
- 7:08Speaker 2: what looks like an exemption for professional baseball. But we're
- 7:12Speaker 2: not going to give it to you, folks. So you
- 7:16Speaker 2: andCA are fully subject to the any trust laws, and
- 7:20Speaker 2: your conduct is subject to any trust laws. So the
- 7:24Speaker 2: court seems to have recognized, as this decided in twenty
- 7:27Speaker 2: twenty one again, that baseball is a bit of an aberration.
- 7:33Speaker 1: In this case, you have minor league teams who are
- 7:36Speaker 1: eliminated alleging a violation of the Sherman Act caused by
- 7:41Speaker 1: a horizontal agreement between competitors that has artificially reduced and
- 7:46Speaker 1: capped output in the market for MLB teams affiliated with
- 7:50Speaker 1: MLB clubs, and a federal judge dismissed it because of
- 7:54Speaker 1: the baseball exemption right, Federal Judge Andrew Carter said, plaintiffs
- 7:59Speaker 1: believe that the Supreme Court is poised to knock out
- 8:01Speaker 1: the exemption, like a boxer waiting to launch a left
- 8:05Speaker 1: hook after her opponent tosses out a torbid jab. It's possible.
- 8:10Speaker 1: So this would squarely present the baseball exemption to the
- 8:14Speaker 1: Supreme Court.
- 8:15Speaker 2: So that's correct, that's what's seeing up the interest at
- 8:18Speaker 2: the moment. The case went to the Court of Appeals
- 8:21Speaker 2: which just sort of summarily agreed with the trial court.
- 8:25Speaker 2: Great quote that you read there. And now the minor
- 8:29Speaker 2: league teams who alleged a violation by being excluded from
- 8:34Speaker 2: an agreement that the majors have made which limit the
- 8:38Speaker 2: number of minor league teams they can affiliate with, are
- 8:41Speaker 2: now asking the Supreme Court to take the case. So
- 8:45Speaker 2: it's not clear whether the Court will actually take the case.
- 8:50Speaker 2: The Court has discretion as to whether they take it
- 8:52Speaker 2: or not, So the first question is will they take it,
- 8:56Speaker 2: And presumably if the Court takes it, it means that
- 8:59Speaker 2: they're interested in overruling the three cases that I mentioned.
- 9:05Speaker 2: And the Supreme Court, you know, doesn't lightly overrule cases.
- 9:11Speaker 1: Well maybe I should say recently, yeah, And the.
- 9:17Speaker 2: Court has overruled on occasion longstanding any trust precedent that
- 9:23Speaker 2: parties had followed for many years. The case is called Legion,
- 9:28Speaker 2: which involved the legality of setting resale prices. The Supreme
- 9:32Speaker 2: Court overruled an older case which had stood for ninety years,
- 9:36Speaker 2: even longer than Federal baseball. So it's possible that the
- 9:41Speaker 2: Court would would take this case, but I would wait
- 9:45Speaker 2: to see if the Justice Department expresses desire to have
- 9:51Speaker 2: the court take the case and overrule these other three cases.
- 9:55Speaker 2: So I'm not certain whether the Justice Department will away
- 10:00Speaker 2: in on this case. They did already in this particular
- 10:03Speaker 2: case in the district court and in the Court of Appeals,
- 10:06Speaker 2: but they did not ask the courts which couldn't actually
- 10:10Speaker 2: to you know, ignore the exemption.
- 10:13Speaker 1: Do you think this exemption is lasted because baseball is
- 10:16Speaker 1: seen as you know, the national sport.
- 10:19Speaker 2: The exemption is a sport in itself. You know, that's
- 10:23Speaker 2: a very good question. So there's been a fair amount
- 10:26Speaker 2: of litigation around this issue, with Litigan's trying to narrow it,
- 10:33Speaker 2: you know, to keep it very closely read as an
- 10:37Speaker 2: exemption as they you know, bring cases in lower courts
- 10:40Speaker 2: that you know, are forced to follow the three cases
- 10:44Speaker 2: that I mentioned. So there has been an effort by
- 10:49Speaker 2: parties to do something about it, not an effort by
- 10:52Speaker 2: the government to do something about it. As I think
- 10:54Speaker 2: about it, you know, not to tuch this positive. So
- 10:58Speaker 2: why has it lasted? Well, you know, part of it
- 11:00Speaker 2: is a very basic theory of story decisives of following precedent.
- 11:06Speaker 2: Courts are forced to do that, and the Supreme Court
- 11:09Speaker 2: hasn't paid attention to this area that much, and for
- 11:12Speaker 2: a while wasn't paying much attention to anti trust. Now
- 11:15Speaker 2: that's sort of changed recently, so maybe now the court
- 11:19Speaker 2: will have an appetite to look at it. They've messed
- 11:23Speaker 2: around with other sports, why not baseball.
- 11:26Speaker 1: In twenty twenty two, the MLB Commissioner wrote to the
- 11:30Speaker 1: Senate Judiciary Committee, who is hearing this issue, that players
- 11:34Speaker 1: could lose job opportunities and communities could lose minor league
- 11:38Speaker 1: teams if baseball is stripped of its anti trust exemption.
- 11:42Speaker 1: But let's say this does go to Supreme Court, what
- 11:44Speaker 1: kind of an argument could they make that they should
- 11:46Speaker 1: still have an anti trust exemption?
- 11:48Speaker 2: Yes, in a case in which communities are losing their
- 11:51Speaker 2: minor league teams exactly because without this asciliation they don't
- 11:55Speaker 2: have the financial support to continue. Well, they're not going
- 11:58Speaker 2: to make that argument, I guess this case. Presumably they would.
- 12:01Speaker 2: They would pitch a lot of it on stability and
- 12:05Speaker 2: expectations that parties have based their relationships over the years
- 12:11Speaker 2: on operating collectively. Leagues need to operate collectively, and this would,
- 12:18Speaker 2: you know, subject this sport to needless litigation, which might
- 12:22Speaker 2: in the end result in massive costs and not produce
- 12:27Speaker 2: better baseball. It's a hard argument to make when every
- 12:30Speaker 2: other sport is subject to any trust laws. So I
- 12:35Speaker 2: think when it gets the Supreme Court, they'll have to
- 12:37Speaker 2: look for things which explains for some reason why this
- 12:41Speaker 2: sport should be sort of outside normal rules of competition law.
- 12:46Speaker 2: And the Court, once presented with that sort of actual argument,
- 12:50Speaker 2: will often say, you know, hey, not our call, pardon joke,
- 12:56Speaker 2: not our coal. Congress generally says, you know that we
- 13:00Speaker 2: like competition, and if you think that competition is not
- 13:04Speaker 2: the way to go here, go to Congress. You've never
- 13:07Speaker 2: done that. You've never gotten congressional approval to this. You know,
- 13:11Speaker 2: lots of other industries have. So if you want to
- 13:15Speaker 2: make your case, make it there, don't make it here.
- 13:18Speaker 2: The normal rule is competition, and we don't really like exemptions.
- 13:23Speaker 2: So I think maybe in the end the question is
- 13:26Speaker 2: going to be whether the Supreme Court thinks this is
- 13:29Speaker 2: important enough to take or you know, let's just sort
- 13:32Speaker 2: of rock along this spike. Certainly, baseball is a big
- 13:36Speaker 2: enough industry, and you know, normally we like commercial relationships,
- 13:41Speaker 2: particularly when lots of money's involved and lots of consumer interests,
- 13:46Speaker 2: lots of labor interests, frankly community interests. You know, normally
- 13:51Speaker 2: we like that to be decided by marketplace.
- 13:54Speaker 1: The best argument I thought was the minor league teams,
- 13:57Speaker 1: in a brief to the Second Circuit, said, but the
- 14:00Speaker 1: court should, if it sees fit, dispatch this case to
- 14:03Speaker 1: the Supreme Court, where the message attached enough already.
- 14:06Speaker 2: Well, you know there's precedent for courts of appeals to
- 14:11Speaker 2: do just that, to sort of say, look, our hands
- 14:14Speaker 2: are tied. This is a terrible result, but our hands
- 14:16Speaker 2: are tied, and sort of say, please take this now.
- 14:20Speaker 2: The Second Circuit didn't quite do that, actually, I mean,
- 14:23Speaker 2: they could have gone through the reasons. And there are
- 14:27Speaker 2: opinions like this in other areas of any trust, going
- 14:30Speaker 2: through the reasons for why this is so out of step.
- 14:34Speaker 2: Commentators have written about this, there are books on this,
- 14:37Speaker 2: uniformly condemned it, and you know why. They say it
- 14:42Speaker 2: would only help fans and everybody except maybe the owners
- 14:46Speaker 2: of these franchises. But owners of sports franchises seem to
- 14:50Speaker 2: be doing pretty darn well even when the anti trust
- 14:53Speaker 2: wall was applying, So they could have done more. But
- 14:57Speaker 2: I'm actually waiting to see what the Justice departm.
- 15:01Speaker 1: I do think they need a sports case this term.
- 15:03Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Harry, it's always a delight. That's Professor
- 15:06Speaker 1: Harry First of NYU Law School. Coming up next, we'll
- 15:10Speaker 1: look at the charges against New Jersey Senator Bob Menendez.
- 15:14Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 15:17Speaker 3: Everything I've accomplished, I've worked for despite the naysayers and
- 15:21Speaker 3: everyone who has underestimated me. I recognize this will be
- 15:25Speaker 3: the biggest fight yet, but as I have stated throughout
- 15:29Speaker 3: this whole process, I firmly believe that when all the
- 15:32Speaker 3: facts are presented, not only will I be exonerated, but
- 15:37Speaker 3: I still will be the New Jersey's senior senator.
- 15:39Speaker 1: New Jersey Senator Bob Menendez told the public he was
- 15:43Speaker 1: not guilty of bribery and corruption charges and entered a
- 15:47Speaker 1: not guilty plea in court today. The Democratic senator has
- 15:51Speaker 1: faced corruption charges before, his last trial, ending with a
- 15:55Speaker 1: deadlock jury in twenty seventeen, but this time it appears different,
- 16:00Speaker 1: and his fellow Democratic senators are calling on him to resign,
- 16:05Speaker 1: including New Jersey Senator Cory Booker, who said the indictment
- 16:08Speaker 1: showed shocking allegations of corruption and specific disturbing details of wrongdoing.
- 16:15Speaker 1: The office of the Manhattan US Attorney, Damian Williams brought
- 16:18Speaker 1: the charges.
- 16:19Speaker 4: The indictment alleges that through that relationship, the senator and
- 16:23Speaker 4: his wife accepted hundreds of thousands of dollars of bribes
- 16:27Speaker 4: in exchange for Senator Menendez using his power and influence
- 16:31Speaker 4: to protect and to enrich those businessmen and to benefit
- 16:35Speaker 4: the government of Egypt.
- 16:37Speaker 1: And there were pictures of some of the evidence seized
- 16:40Speaker 1: from Menendez his home, the gold bars worth more than
- 16:43Speaker 1: one hundred thousand dollars, nearly five hundred thousand dollars in
- 16:47Speaker 1: cash stoffed in envelopes and hidden in clothes and closets,
- 16:51Speaker 1: and the Mercedes convertible. Joining me is former federal prosecutor
- 16:55Speaker 1: Jennifer Rogers, a lecturer in law at Columbia Law School.
- 17:00Speaker 1: The allegations against Menendez were stunning to many people, So
- 17:06Speaker 1: tell us about them.
- 17:07Speaker 5: Well, he's charged in three counts of bribery. They basically
- 17:11Speaker 5: used the same facts to charge it, using three different statues,
- 17:15Speaker 5: kind of a belt and suspenders approach. But it's effectively
- 17:19Speaker 5: that he did favors official acts in his role as
- 17:24Speaker 5: senator and as chair of the Foreign Relations Committee for
- 17:27Speaker 5: these three businessmen who then paid him for those favors
- 17:31Speaker 5: and cash and gold bars and a Mercedes convertible and
- 17:36Speaker 5: some other stuff.
- 17:37Speaker 1: The one hundred thousand dollars in gold bars sort of stands
- 17:40Speaker 1: out because who has gold bars? And add to that
- 17:44Speaker 1: his Google search for how much is one kilo of
- 17:47Speaker 1: gold worth? Do you think the prosecutors framed this in
- 17:52Speaker 1: a way to bring out the dramatic in it.
- 17:56Speaker 5: Well, you know, there's always a little bit of flair
- 17:58Speaker 5: for the drama, I think. You know, jackets stuffed with
- 18:01Speaker 5: cash too has a sort of flare that looks good
- 18:05Speaker 5: in the photos too. But you know, really, prosecutors have
- 18:08Speaker 5: to prove three things. They have to prove that something
- 18:11Speaker 5: of value was given, and that's the point of saying
- 18:14Speaker 5: this cash was found, the gold bars, the car. They
- 18:18Speaker 5: have to prove that official acts by the public official
- 18:22Speaker 5: were promised or given. And then they have to prove
- 18:24Speaker 5: the quid propo the connection between the two things. So
- 18:28Speaker 5: you know, prosecutors have to prove all three of those things.
- 18:31Speaker 5: So they're going to be careful to make sure to
- 18:33Speaker 5: do that. But I think, you know, they just took
- 18:35Speaker 5: advantage of the fact that this is really a textbook
- 18:39Speaker 5: bribery case. You so clearly have all three of those things,
- 18:43Speaker 5: and it's just so obvious. I mean, who keeps that
- 18:46Speaker 5: kind of cash around? Who keeps it in that way?
- 18:48Speaker 5: You know, not in a safe, stuffed in jackets and things.
- 18:51Speaker 5: So I just think it was so photogenic. I guess,
- 18:55Speaker 5: if you will, just such a kind of textbook, quintessential
- 18:58Speaker 5: bribery case that it makes it easy to be a
- 19:00Speaker 5: little bit dramatic with it.
- 19:03Speaker 1: Tell me what you think of Menandez's explanation for the
- 19:07Speaker 1: nearly five hundred thousand dollars in cash he had in
- 19:09Speaker 1: the house for thirty years.
- 19:12Speaker 3: I have withdrawn thousands of dollars in cash from my
- 19:16Speaker 3: personal savings account, which I have kept for emergencies and
- 19:20Speaker 3: because of the history of my family facing confiscation in Cuba.
- 19:25Speaker 3: Now this may seem old fashioned, but these were moneys
- 19:29Speaker 3: drawn from my personal savings account based on the income
- 19:32Speaker 3: that I have lawfully derived over those thirty years.
- 19:37Speaker 5: Yeah, that's just silly. I mean, he's really just begging
- 19:40Speaker 5: them to do what would be called an unexplained wealth analysis, right, like, oh, really,
- 19:44Speaker 5: that's all his legitimate money from his paychecks. All right, Well,
- 19:48Speaker 5: let's look at what his paychecks are and what other
- 19:50Speaker 5: means he has. I mean, is he independently wealthy? Does
- 19:53Speaker 5: he have major investments that he converted to cash? You know,
- 19:57Speaker 5: what is the explanation for having that kind of cash
- 19:59Speaker 5: in the first place when you look at his bank
- 20:01Speaker 5: accounts and how much money he makes being a senator.
- 20:04Speaker 5: And I don't think it's going to stack up. So
- 20:06Speaker 5: I doubt that that defense, well he kind of offered
- 20:09Speaker 5: it in the first instance, is going to make its
- 20:12Speaker 5: way into the trial. I think that they'll have to
- 20:14Speaker 5: focus on other things if they end up actually taking
- 20:17Speaker 5: this to trial.
- 20:18Speaker 1: So what struck me? And you know, maybe this happens
- 20:20Speaker 1: more often than I know, But how often do the
- 20:24Speaker 1: FEDS test money for fingerprints and DNA especially?
- 20:30Speaker 3: Yeah?
- 20:30Speaker 5: Not very often. Yeah, I understand that there was some
- 20:33Speaker 5: DNA sound on I think on an envelope that some
- 20:36Speaker 5: of the money was in. You know, it's not a
- 20:39Speaker 5: great conductor of fingerprints. You know, metal and other surfaces
- 20:43Speaker 5: are much better. But you really do want to try
- 20:46Speaker 5: if you can to establish the connection between the bribes
- 20:50Speaker 5: and the people who were giving the bribes. So in
- 20:52Speaker 5: this case, it makes sense to test if you think
- 20:54Speaker 5: you can get something like fingerprints, and it worked. They
- 20:58Speaker 5: were able to establish a link between that particular bunch
- 21:01Speaker 5: of money and one of the business men who was
- 21:04Speaker 5: one of the bribe wars and co defendants, so it
- 21:07Speaker 5: worked for them.
- 21:07Speaker 1: Is the toughest part of this case for the prosecution
- 21:10Speaker 1: to prove the quid pro quo.
- 21:13Speaker 5: I think actually in this case. I mean that often
- 21:16Speaker 5: is the toughest I think in this case because they
- 21:18Speaker 5: have such a wealth of evidence with the text that
- 21:22Speaker 5: they recovered that they I think did a wire tap
- 21:25Speaker 5: on that really sets out the scheme in the back
- 21:27Speaker 5: and forth. So I think the most challenging thing in
- 21:30Speaker 5: this case is actually proving the official acts that the
- 21:34Speaker 5: things that Menendez did and promised to do for the
- 21:37Speaker 5: bribe Wars his co defendants were actually technically official acts.
- 21:41Speaker 5: Because over the years, the last ten or so years,
- 21:44Speaker 5: the Supreme Court really has narrowed what that means to
- 21:47Speaker 5: be an official act, and we don't yet exactly know
- 21:51Speaker 5: the outside contours of that because you know, every time
- 21:54Speaker 5: you litigate one of these cases and the Supreme Court
- 21:57Speaker 5: speaks on it, then you kind of know on that
- 21:59Speaker 5: particular set of facts. So you know whether or not
- 22:02Speaker 5: every single thing that Menendez did and agreed to do
- 22:05Speaker 5: will be ultimately deemed an official act under the Supreme
- 22:09Speaker 5: Court's version of that is undetermined. I still think they
- 22:13Speaker 5: have a strong case. I think many of the actions
- 22:15Speaker 5: are clearly official acts. But that's where it gets a
- 22:17Speaker 5: little bit muddy on the edges about what they can
- 22:20Speaker 5: try to challenge.
- 22:22Speaker 1: So he's also accused of giving Egyptian officials highly sensitive information.
- 22:27Speaker 1: Is that part of the charges or is that just background?
- 22:32Speaker 5: So that's a really interesting piece of this. They did
- 22:35Speaker 5: not charge him with being a foreign agent or anything
- 22:39Speaker 5: that would require them to prove that he basically was
- 22:42Speaker 5: acting and he just interests against the US's interests. It
- 22:47Speaker 5: is a piece of evidence in the bribery case because
- 22:48Speaker 5: it's one of the things that he did for them, right,
- 22:51Speaker 5: one of the things that he gave them was this information,
- 22:55Speaker 5: and they bribed him for it. They gave him money
- 22:57Speaker 5: or you know, whatever the case may be. In that particule,
- 23:00Speaker 5: regular instance, they give him a bribe for that information.
- 23:02Speaker 5: So it does come in. It's part of the bribery case,
- 23:05Speaker 5: but it's not charged separately in terms of like a
- 23:09Speaker 5: foreign agent charge or anything like that. And I think
- 23:12Speaker 5: prosecutors were very smart about that, because charging that kind
- 23:16Speaker 5: of case leads to all sorts of complications with classified information,
- 23:22Speaker 5: makes discovery more complicated, makes the trial more complicated. They
- 23:26Speaker 5: charged it just lean and mean, just the bribery, very strong, unclassified,
- 23:31Speaker 5: easy to do discovery, easy to do the trial if
- 23:33Speaker 5: it comes to that. So I think that was a
- 23:35Speaker 5: wise strategic decision.
- 23:37Speaker 1: Do you think the Justice Department learned from the last
- 23:40Speaker 1: trial and didn't want the same thing to happen twice.
- 23:45Speaker 5: Well, it's a different group of prosecutors. This prosecution is
- 23:48Speaker 5: out of the Manhattan US Attorney's Office. The other one
- 23:51Speaker 5: was out of Main Justice, So it's not the same people.
- 23:54Speaker 5: But sure every time you see a case falter, you
- 23:58Speaker 5: learn from that experience and you know the thing is
- 24:01Speaker 5: here is really just a completely separate set of facts.
- 24:05Speaker 5: You know, last time the charges involved someone allegedly bribing Menendez,
- 24:09Speaker 5: who was a close personal friend, and ultimately I think
- 24:12Speaker 5: the jurors couldn't figure out whether the official accidne were
- 24:15Speaker 5: because of the bribes or because of the friendship here,
- 24:18Speaker 5: there's no relationship like that. This was purely transactional. It's
- 24:21Speaker 5: all laid out there in the text, so they don't
- 24:23Speaker 5: have the same challenges. But yeah, I mean, anytime you
- 24:27Speaker 5: have a loss, hopefully you learn something from it.
- 24:29Speaker 1: Why is a Manhattan US attorney bringing this And how
- 24:33Speaker 1: much of a disadvantage is that for Menandez not having
- 24:36Speaker 1: a sort of a home court advantage.
- 24:39Speaker 5: Well, I don't exactly know. I mean, it would depend
- 24:42Speaker 5: in part on which FBI office started the investigation. You know,
- 24:46Speaker 5: what they learned first that kind of triggered the case
- 24:49Speaker 5: for them to trigger the investigation. You know, sometimes there
- 24:53Speaker 5: are multiple offices involved, and then the Department of Justice
- 24:56Speaker 5: main Justice will decide who gets it. So it's hard
- 24:59Speaker 5: to know. You know, they obviously will have to have
- 25:01Speaker 5: some ties to Manhattan or else they wouldn't have venue.
- 25:05Speaker 5: But it's not exactly clear. And I mean, I think
- 25:08Speaker 5: he probably would prefer to be in New Jersey because
- 25:11Speaker 5: you know, those are his constituents. But you know, at
- 25:14Speaker 5: the end of the day, everybody knows Bob Menendez. I
- 25:18Speaker 5: don't know that he would get a better jury in
- 25:21Speaker 5: New Jersey than he'll get in Manhattan. It's still if
- 25:24Speaker 5: you want to think about it politically, it's still a
- 25:27Speaker 5: very blue area. I guess if he's a Democratic senator,
- 25:30Speaker 5: and you may think that that helps them. Now, I'm
- 25:32Speaker 5: not exactly sure why I ended up there, but listen,
- 25:35Speaker 5: that's my old shop, and so I'm biased, but I
- 25:37Speaker 5: think they're the best prosecutors anywhere, So I think it's
- 25:40Speaker 5: a good thing that it did.
- 25:42Speaker 1: Coming up next, I'll continue this conversation with Jennifer Rogers
- 25:46Speaker 1: and we'll talk about what possible defenses Menendez may have.
- 25:49Speaker 1: I'm June Gross. When you're listening to Bloomberg, I've been
- 25:52Speaker 1: talking to former federal prosecutor Jennifer Rogers about the federal
- 25:56Speaker 1: charges against New Jersey Senator Bob Menendez. For just explain
- 26:01Speaker 1: in a little more depth what happened during that twenty
- 26:05Speaker 1: seventeen trial.
- 26:06Speaker 5: Yeah, so there were a few things that happened.
- 26:09Speaker 1: You know.
- 26:09Speaker 5: First of all, as I said, there's been this kind
- 26:11Speaker 5: of ten year period where the Supreme Court has been
- 26:14Speaker 5: changing the law effectively in these public corruption cases, and
- 26:18Speaker 5: so prosecutors really have been at a disadvantage in terms
- 26:21Speaker 5: of figuring out what to charge, how to charge how
- 26:24Speaker 5: to ask for jury instructions and then crossing their fingers
- 26:27Speaker 5: that it would get all undone by the next public
- 26:30Speaker 5: corruption case that went up to the Supreme Court. So
- 26:32Speaker 5: some of that is kind of the uncertainty. But they
- 26:34Speaker 5: charged two kinds of bribes in that case. And this
- 26:38Speaker 5: basically is the relationship between the Senator Menendez and his
- 26:42Speaker 5: close personal friend and ophthalmologists from Florida, doctor Melgan. And
- 26:47Speaker 5: you know, they charged two kinds of bribes. They charged
- 26:50Speaker 5: campaign donations. And the challenge with campaign donations, if you
- 26:54Speaker 5: charge them and they are reported properly and so on,
- 26:56Speaker 5: is you have to prove an explicit quid problem that like,
- 27:00Speaker 5: I'm giving you these campaign donations in exchange for the
- 27:03Speaker 5: following official acts, right, which is virtually impossible to actually get.
- 27:08Speaker 5: So they had trouble with that one. They didn't have
- 27:10Speaker 5: that proof of trial. And then they charged a set
- 27:12Speaker 5: of bribes that were in the form of trips, basically
- 27:16Speaker 5: trips where doctor Melgan and Senator Menendez went together on
- 27:20Speaker 5: the private jet to the fancy home sometimes overseas, etc.
- 27:25Speaker 5: And those are deemed gifts to Menendez, right, he didn't
- 27:28Speaker 5: pay his friend doctor Melgan back for the expenses associated
- 27:32Speaker 5: with those trips. But the problem with that theory is
- 27:35Speaker 5: that I think a lot of the jurors thought, well,
- 27:37Speaker 5: how do we know that that's not because of the friendship.
- 27:40Speaker 5: I mean, if you had a really wealthy friend, maybe
- 27:42Speaker 5: that friend would spring for you to go on vacation
- 27:44Speaker 5: with him or her. Right, So they had trouble saying
- 27:48Speaker 5: that the things that Senator Menendez did for doctor Melgan,
- 27:51Speaker 5: and there were things, I mean, he did definitely try
- 27:54Speaker 5: to influence certain official actions on behalf of doctor Melgan.
- 27:58Speaker 5: Like that side of the case was okay, But the
- 28:00Speaker 5: question is we're the bribes actually in exchange for those benefits,
- 28:05Speaker 5: and that's where that case had trouble.
- 28:07Speaker 1: Can you see a defense that Menandez could raise.
- 28:11Speaker 5: The case is very strong, I think on all fronts.
- 28:13Speaker 5: The most likely place where they have a little bit
- 28:16Speaker 5: of wiggle room some arguments to make is the official
- 28:19Speaker 5: act piece of it, because it's not entirely clear the
- 28:23Speaker 5: outside limits of what an official act can be. We
- 28:27Speaker 5: know from the Supreme Court case the McDonald case about
- 28:30Speaker 5: the former Virginia governor that it has to be something governmental, right,
- 28:34Speaker 5: not just that you do because you're a senator, for example.
- 28:38Speaker 5: But it really goes to kind of a typical government function,
- 28:41Speaker 5: so passing a piece of legislation, holding up a piece
- 28:44Speaker 5: of legislation, doing an investigation in Congress like those are
- 28:48Speaker 5: the sorts of things that would definitely be seemed to
- 28:51Speaker 5: be an official act, but it's not one hundred percent
- 28:54Speaker 5: clear that other things to just using your influence would
- 28:58Speaker 5: necessarily clear that bar So they've charged him with or
- 29:02Speaker 5: they've mentioned in the indictment that he tried to influence
- 29:06Speaker 5: prosecutors in New Jersey about cases that his co defendants
- 29:09Speaker 5: were interested in. They said he tried to influence an
- 29:12Speaker 5: official at the US Department of Agriculture to help these
- 29:15Speaker 5: co defendants in a business that they wanted. Those sorts
- 29:19Speaker 5: of things are a little bit on the line, so,
- 29:22Speaker 5: you know, I think they could be deemed to be
- 29:24Speaker 5: official acts, but it's not one hundred percent clear. So
- 29:27Speaker 5: if I'm menndez a lawyers, That's where I'm probably going
- 29:31Speaker 5: to be looking and seeing if there are arguments to
- 29:34Speaker 5: make there for you know, those things maybe distasteful, but
- 29:37Speaker 5: are they technically official acts as far as the statute goes.
- 29:40Speaker 5: That's what I'd be looking for.
- 29:42Speaker 1: Do you think prosecutors are going to try to flip
- 29:45Speaker 1: some of the other defendants, not his wife, but the others.
- 29:49Speaker 5: They might, I assume would at least be open to
- 29:52Speaker 5: talking to those lawyers and those defendants about that issue.
- 29:55Speaker 5: I mean, you know, they have so many communications, they
- 30:00Speaker 5: have all these text messages, and so I don't know
- 30:02Speaker 5: that they need a cooperator in the way that you
- 30:05Speaker 5: often really want one in a case like this. That said,
- 30:08Speaker 5: prosecutors in my experience are always willing to listen to
- 30:11Speaker 5: a defendant who wants to come forward and say, here's
- 30:14Speaker 5: why I deserve a cooperation agreement. So I think they'll
- 30:18Speaker 5: probably listen to them and listen. If they can provide
- 30:21Speaker 5: evidence that they don't already have that will help them
- 30:24Speaker 5: with their case, they probably would sign one of them
- 30:27Speaker 5: up or two of them up, depending on you know
- 30:29Speaker 5: what the facts are.
- 30:31Speaker 1: Would all the defendants be tried together or do you
- 30:33Speaker 1: think Menandez might be able to get his trial severed.
- 30:38Speaker 5: I think they'll all be tried together. I mean, usually
- 30:42Speaker 5: to conserve resources, they try to keep cases like this together.
- 30:46Speaker 5: The only real reason he would have to try to
- 30:49Speaker 5: sever it is if there are defenses that conflict with
- 30:52Speaker 5: each other. You know, if there's no fair way to
- 30:55Speaker 5: try them together because they're pointing the finger at each
- 30:58Speaker 5: other in an antagonistic way, you know, that's where you
- 31:01Speaker 5: would see a problem with something like that. But you know,
- 31:05Speaker 5: I we'll have to see how it developed. I think
- 31:07Speaker 5: there's a you know, there's a presumption for keeping cases
- 31:11Speaker 5: like this together because obviously to try it twice, you know,
- 31:15Speaker 5: not to mention five times with five defendants, would be
- 31:18Speaker 5: just too much of a burden on the system.
- 31:20Speaker 1: So this is a bit of an opinion question. But
- 31:23Speaker 1: it seems like Senate Democrats have already tried and convicted
- 31:27Speaker 1: him just based on the allegations and the complaint. I'm
- 31:30Speaker 1: wondering if you think that's because the allegations are so
- 31:33Speaker 1: striking or just because it's politics.
- 31:38Speaker 5: You know, it's hard to know what they're all thinking.
- 31:40Speaker 5: As far as the political side. I will say there
- 31:43Speaker 5: might be a bit of fatigue with Senator Menendez because
- 31:46Speaker 5: we have been through this before, and even though he
- 31:50Speaker 5: ended up with a hung jury and not being convicted,
- 31:53Speaker 5: you know, there were clear ethical violations there the Senate
- 31:57Speaker 5: down So you know, here we go again, right on
- 32:00Speaker 5: the heels of the determination that he wouldn't be retried
- 32:04Speaker 5: on that case. He's you know, meeting up with these
- 32:07Speaker 5: people and starting a similar scheme all over again. I
- 32:10Speaker 5: also think that the nature of the evidence has explained
- 32:12Speaker 5: in the indictment is pretty black and white. It's not
- 32:15Speaker 5: as if they say, you know, in the indictment, we
- 32:18Speaker 5: have a cooperating witness c W one and the witness
- 32:21Speaker 5: says X, Y and Z, and you can think, well,
- 32:23Speaker 5: maybe the witness is lying, maybe his credibility problems. You know,
- 32:26Speaker 5: they have these communications, they are what they are, black
- 32:30Speaker 5: and white. There will be transcripts, so you know, I
- 32:33Speaker 5: think those things together probably suggest to these politicians that
- 32:38Speaker 5: there's not a lot of opportunity to wiggle out of this.
- 32:42Speaker 5: And you know, we'll see when the discovery gets turned over,
- 32:46Speaker 5: which should be pretty soon, whether Menendez comes off of
- 32:49Speaker 5: his claim that he won't resign and you know, is
- 32:52Speaker 5: going to surge forward. I think once he actually confirms
- 32:56Speaker 5: that what is in the indictment is accurate, he's probably
- 32:59Speaker 5: going to be talking to his lawyers about how to
- 33:01Speaker 5: try to mitigate this and look for some sort of
- 33:04Speaker 5: plea deal to a lesser offense or something like that.
- 33:07Speaker 1: You think that's possible that the prosecutors would agree to
- 33:11Speaker 1: a lesser offense.
- 33:13Speaker 5: Sure, sure, I mean the trick in a case like
- 33:15Speaker 5: this is finding one, honestly, because all three of these
- 33:20Speaker 5: offenses that they've charged are really just different ways to
- 33:22Speaker 5: charge bribery, and the sentencing guidelines are going to be
- 33:25Speaker 5: the same for all of them. So the trick would
- 33:28Speaker 5: be trying to find something with a lesser guidelines range.
- 33:32Speaker 5: But yeah, prosecutors are always looking to save resources by
- 33:35Speaker 5: pleading things out. And you know, when you have a case,
- 33:38Speaker 5: a public corruption case with a corrupt politician who is
- 33:41Speaker 5: still in office, prosecutors have an interest in getting that
- 33:45Speaker 5: person out of office. So if he comes in and says,
- 33:48Speaker 5: you know, listen, I'd like to take a plea, they're like, great, that,
- 33:51Speaker 5: you know, wraps up our case. We don't have to
- 33:53Speaker 5: do a long period of pre trial and then go
- 33:56Speaker 5: to trial. And if it includes a deal that he'll
- 33:58Speaker 5: resign all about, you know, he's he's out sooner than
- 34:01Speaker 5: he would otherwise be. So I'm sure prosecutors would be
- 34:04Speaker 5: willing to think about that. The question is, you know,
- 34:06Speaker 5: what can they find it would be agreeable to both
- 34:09Speaker 5: sides For him to plead.
- 34:10Speaker 1: To Do you think that any deal would have to
- 34:13Speaker 1: include jail time.
- 34:14Speaker 5: I don't know. Yeah, I don't know where prosecutors would
- 34:17Speaker 5: come out on that. You know, on the one hand,
- 34:20Speaker 5: he's on the older side, you know, is he I
- 34:22Speaker 5: was going to say, is a recidivus? I guess actually
- 34:24Speaker 5: if he is a recidivist, because we had the other
- 34:27Speaker 5: case and then this one on the heels of it.
- 34:28Speaker 5: But if he's removed from office, you know, the opportunity
- 34:31Speaker 5: for this sort of thing will be obviously significantly lessened.
- 34:35Speaker 5: So I'm not sure whether they would insist on something
- 34:37Speaker 5: with jail time. I mean, prosecutors never get to decide
- 34:40Speaker 5: the sentence anyway. Even if you agree on a range,
- 34:42Speaker 5: is ultimately up to the judge. So you know, I
- 34:45Speaker 5: certainly could see them picking a range that is low
- 34:48Speaker 5: enough that a judge might decide, you know, ultimately to
- 34:51Speaker 5: just give probation. But you know, they know the case
- 34:54Speaker 5: much better obviously than we all do from the outside,
- 34:57Speaker 5: So yeah, I'm not sure how they would view the
- 35:00Speaker 5: and decide, you know, what they think is the appropriate Then.
- 35:03Speaker 1: What's interesting is several people told Politico that after Friday's
- 35:08Speaker 1: indictment Menandez seemed emboldened almost. And I saw he was
- 35:13Speaker 1: being questioned by reporters yesterday as he was running through
- 35:16Speaker 1: the Senate halls, and he said, because I'm innocent, what's
- 35:19Speaker 1: wrong with you guys? But maybe when he sees the evidence.
- 35:23Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean he may just his knee jerk reaction
- 35:27Speaker 5: may have been, you know, I beat you before I
- 35:29Speaker 5: can beat you again, forget about it. But you know,
- 35:33Speaker 5: in the cold, sober light of day, when they have
- 35:36Speaker 5: the evidence, when he's sitting down with his lawyers, and
- 35:38Speaker 5: when they explain to him the differences between this case
- 35:41Speaker 5: and the prior case, you know, I suspect he won't
- 35:45Speaker 5: have so much bravado, at least in private. You know,
- 35:48Speaker 5: who knows what he'll continue to maintain in public. He's
- 35:51Speaker 5: kind of on the ropes politically, right with all of
- 35:53Speaker 5: these colleagues of him, of his calling for his resignation.
- 35:56Speaker 5: So maybe he feels like that's the face he has
- 35:59Speaker 5: to put on to fight that battle in this moment.
- 36:02Speaker 5: But you know, behind the scenes, I'm sure he'll be
- 36:05Speaker 5: more thoughtful about this case.
- 36:07Speaker 1: So always great to have you on, Jennifer and to
- 36:09Speaker 1: get your insights that's former federal prosecutor Jennifer Rogers a
- 36:13Speaker 1: lecture in law at Columbia Law School. And that's it
- 36:17Speaker 1: for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
- 36:19Speaker 1: can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg
- 36:22Speaker 1: Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 36:26Speaker 1: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law,
- 36:31Speaker 1: And remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 36:34Speaker 1: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso
- 36:38Speaker 1: and you're listening to Bloomberg