Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 3 - Girlfriend)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserve listeners. This is chapter three in our deep Dive. I'm
- 0:03the psychology of Josh Powell. We are going to continue with the storyline and
- 0:09at the end we will provide our analysis. I will provide my analysis of
- 0:15their personalities, not only Josh Powell, but also his father Stephen. So
- 0:21let's get into it. What do you say, birth, Let's do it.
- 0:24This is the psychology in Seattle Podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda.
- 0:27I'm a therapist and I'm also a professor. My name is Umberto cas
- 0:31and I'm a zoo keeper coach. I want to provide a recap of what
- 0:37we've already established in chapters one and two. So very briefly, Josh Powell,
- 0:42second of five children to Stephen and Teresa Powell. The parents, Stephen
- 0:46and Teresa fought a lot. Stephen was also abusive, both physical and verbal.
- 0:52He sounded quite severe. He was particularly abusive to Josh. Stephen was
- 0:58also highly permissive with the children and highly undermined the mother's attempts to provide structure.
- 1:04There's also some very minor evidence that the mom might have been rejecting as
- 1:11well, So there's that possibility, But I don't know. I don't want
- 1:15to throw the mom under the bus, because she shouldn't be blamed for any
- 1:21of this. Also, Josh was struggling emotionally, which is understandable given everything
- 1:26that he was going through being abused and targeted, and he would write in
- 1:33his journal and there were observations from the outside that he was struggling emotionally.
- 1:37And one example of this is that he had a serious suicide attempt when he
- 1:42was a teenager and he went to a therapist or a psychiatrist or something.
- 1:48Now, there didn't seem to be signs of early psychopathy or early psychopathic personality,
- 1:55or any social personality at least not the typical pattern except maybe the pets.
- 2:01Right right, He did kill the sister's gerbils. I also heard or
- 2:05read that he didn't kill multiple gerbils. He just killed one gerbil. It
- 2:08doesn't really matter. Well, it kind of matters, because I want to
- 2:13know the details about that story. I killed my brother's fish when I was
- 2:17nine or ten on accident. No, yes, of course, yeah,
- 2:21yeah, I was visiting and I was just trying to feed them, and
- 2:24I didn't realize that you could totally overfeed fish. Really easily could have button.
- 2:29So not just you were jealous that he had access to your mom and
- 2:31you did it, but I mean, I love animals, so it's like,
- 2:35and this is what led me to become a zoo keeper coach. But
- 2:38it was sad. Yeah, right, So was it semi accidental? Was
- 2:44it extremely psychopathic like Jeffrey Dahmer kind of stuff? Did he dissect the body
- 2:51like Jeffrey Dahmer. There's a lot of options here. There's a lot of
- 2:54room on that spectrum, and we just don't really know, but you know,
- 2:58that is one sign of psychopathy. Also, there are reports that he
- 3:02was abusive to his mother, but again that was heavily modeled to him by
- 3:07his father. It would be surprising if he didn't have some aggression towards his
- 3:12mom, given the way that Stephen was acting towards everybody, including the mom.
- 3:16Now, what we don't see for Josh, I think this is important
- 3:21in the data, and I'm guessing we would have heard about this is we
- 3:24don't see a pronounced pattern of lying and cheating and exploiting others and breaking rules
- 3:30and breaking laws and having run ins with the police and getting sent to the
- 3:34principal's office and getting in physical fights and being impulsive. We don't hear a
- 3:39pattern of that the way we would with someone like Charlie Manson, for example,
- 3:46or other psychopaths that I work with. One of the things that when
- 3:49we were talking last time, I kept thinking that to me, the dad
- 3:53sounded a lot more generally, I don't know what the right word is for
- 3:57it, but generally aggressive and not k to be around. Whereas, like
- 4:01what you're saying, it seems like, at least in those early phases,
- 4:03other than troubled, potentially suicidal, well clearly suicidal and whatnot. Yeah,
- 4:10it didn't seem to fit the pattern of the right. If anything, he
- 4:14seemed shut down and depressed, inert if you will. What we also saw
- 4:20is avoid an attachment in that he was withdrawn and self reliance and perhaps narcissistic
- 4:30and restricted effect, restricted emotional expression. That's the reports, So we'll keep
- 4:36that in mind as we move forward. All right, So let's jump forward
- 4:42to ninety seven. Josh is in his early twenties, maybe twenty years old
- 4:47at this point, and he's in college now, and there were a lot
- 4:53of different reports of his years in college. He spent time in a a
- 5:00few different institutions. Community college U dubbed this sort of thing, so I
- 5:04might be getting some of the details wrong, but the broad strokes are the
- 5:09following that in his journal he would ride about not getting along with other students.
- 5:15He would live in the dorms or he would live in an apartment with
- 5:17other students. I couldn't tell if he knew these guys from high school or
- 5:21if he just met them or what. But he didn't get along because he
- 5:28struggled socially his whole life to some extent anyway. But also these guys were
- 5:32typical college guys. They were drinking and using marijuana and partying and doing all
- 5:41that kind of stuff. And Josh wasn't into that kind of thing. He
- 5:45didn't like to go to parties, he didn't like to drink at all,
- 5:47he didn't like to smoke marijuana. And sometimes this would escalate into violence fights,
- 5:54and he would say that he was being bullied, which I don't necessarily
- 5:58doubt, but it's from his account, so it's hard to know, right,
- 6:02You know, if we talk to the other guys, they might say,
- 6:03no, no, no, we didn't bully him. We gave him
- 6:05every chance. Yeah, one time it came to blows because he was throwing
- 6:11fistit. You know, who knows. But things are not going well for
- 6:15him. He also wrote that he thought he was depressed. He also wrote
- 6:18that he thought that his dad resented him. He initially after the divorce when
- 6:24he sixteen, went to live with his dad, but after going to college
- 6:29and being separated from his dad, he seemed to wonder if his dad was
- 6:33a problem, maybe that his dad resented him or had envy of him,
- 6:38because Stephen shows a lot of signs of narcissism, you know, and it
- 6:42makes me, well, if the father were to be jealous envious of Josh,
- 6:47if the father did, in fact suffer from narcissistic personality, what would
- 6:54Stephen, a grown man, probably like forty years old this point, be
- 6:58envious of Josh four at this point. Yeah, okay, that's a great
- 7:02question. Well, so there's a couple of things immediately come to mind.
- 7:06One is the simple, like, gosh, darn it, that's a younger
- 7:10version of me with the world ahead of him, and I'm getting older.
- 7:13Right. That sucks, that's my hypothesis, right. But then the other
- 7:16thing that comes to mind is. I don't know if there's account, like,
- 7:20you know, he just had a failed marriage, And I do wonder
- 7:25if if he was, you know, kind of accusatory of the influence that,
- 7:30because you know, if he is a narcissistic, he wouldn't blame himself
- 7:33for the failed marriage, right, so it'd be like, man, it's
- 7:36all the you know, it's all the kids or whatever could easily be and
- 7:41Josh being the oldest one, could probably take the brunch second oldest or sorry,
- 7:45yeah, but the oldest male whatever. Yeah, so I could see
- 7:47him being like, ah, it's his fault, you know, Okay,
- 7:50yeah it could be. So after attending community college, he eventually was a
- 7:57student at the University of Washington where you and I went. And I couldn't
- 8:01tell if he was at the Seattle campus or the Tacoma campus because he lived
- 8:05in Tama campus. Maybe not, but anyway, he might have been a
- 8:13student at the Seattle campus soon after you left, right because you left,
- 8:16you left, you dub what year, fall of ninety seven, So yeah,
- 8:20you might have just been missing him just by like one one term or
- 8:24something. Initially he wanted to study architecture, So what do you think about
- 8:31this choice, Birdle. What's the stereotype of architecture students that you dub I
- 8:37guess in my mind, they like art. They're very meticulous, very detail
- 8:43oriented, and probably have to do good in things like maths, so they
- 8:48can because you know, architecture, even though you're not like doing all the
- 8:50mouth, it is kind of an engineering I have some friends who worked in
- 8:56that industry, and what they would say is that a lot of architects are
- 9:01narcissistic. Oh really, yeah, I mean, I guess, okay,
- 9:05now that I think about it, but I don't. I mean, I
- 9:07could have looked up the research on it, but I didn't. But like
- 9:11they all read the fountain Head that and you're in control. Yeah, and
- 9:16it's a prestigious job. It's like a die like a surgeon or something.
- 9:18Yeah, like a fancy surgeon. Because you imagine an architect has a really
- 9:24cool, fancy house, you make good money, that kind of thing.
- 9:28So who knows. Maybe he was just in an architecture, but it's also
- 9:33possible that this was a manifestation of his narcissism, his attempt to fill the
- 9:41void inside of him that was left behind by Steven and the lack of attunement
- 9:48that Josh received growing up, and he's filling it with this grandiose, superior
- 9:54notion, trying to counteract the abyss in his personality. I have two architect
- 10:01uncles, and one of them lives in Colombian money stid Is, and he's
- 10:05built two of his own houses, and he currently lives and is retired in
- 10:09this house he built. I admire it so much, like just that skill
- 10:13of like being able to like plant it all out and figure out what materials
- 10:16you need and then do it and then live in it's and these are sweet
- 10:20places, you know. Yeah, it's kind of the ven diagram between genius
- 10:26artist and a doer, someone who actually can make things. That's yeah,
- 10:31exactly, you know what I mean. It's not just a painting on a
- 10:33wall, it's a functional You just know that their cabinets are super well designed
- 10:41and totally the flow of the hallways to the doors, you know, everything's
- 10:48just right. So he eventually, though, Burto, gives up on architecture.
- 10:54I don't know why, but he did. I imagine it was hard
- 11:00because I know architecture school can actually be quite grueling. I think the UDUB
- 11:03architecture school is prestigious on some level, and you can imagine there being a
- 11:07bit of a weeding out process. I don't know, he didn't really have
- 11:11a major at Disappointed at you Dubb, he starts taking drama. Did you
- 11:16ever take drama at UDUB? A lot of people took that really well.
- 11:20You and I weren't the typical general liberal arts students, but I think a
- 11:24lot of them would take the intro drama class. I have a lot of
- 11:28friends that took that class. Most of my classes were math and engineering,
- 11:31and then I have music exactly me too. Yeah, all my electives were
- 11:37music classes. One class I took was composition. So I'm in a class
- 11:43with a bunch of classical music writers symphony and piano, and I walk in
- 11:50with my shitty acoustic guitar and I'm writing like rock songs and folks songs.
- 11:56And I just went for and they accepted me. So he takes a drama
- 12:03class, and he suddenly decides that he wants to pursue a career in acting.
- 12:09No narcissist in acting. I think that this is evidence of a few
- 12:15things. One is that it's the beginning of a pattern of his that I'll
- 12:20provide more data of him changing his career very frequently, without any theme to
- 12:26it. It just seems to go all over the place. I think there's
- 12:31a number of reasons for that, which I'll provide later, but there's that.
- 12:35Also, there's this desperate need to fill a narcissistic supply, not in
- 12:41the same way that Stephen does. Stephen his father's much more typical in the
- 12:46narcissistic supply. For Josh, it's not as typical, but I think present
- 12:52also, Josh is depressed and knows it and is looking for something to grab
- 12:58onto. Also, Josh is looking for friends. And you know, when
- 13:03I was in drama in high school, it's a very bonding experience to go
- 13:09through production with people. There's a lot of backstage hanging out and after parties
- 13:16and depending on each other and fun on stage together. You know, like
- 13:22you have a scene with someone and Shenanigan's happened when you're rehearsing, and it's
- 13:28really bonding. So it was really sad in Colombia when I was still there.
- 13:33My friend Juant Miguel whom you met, and I we were in drama
- 13:37class and at first it started like I don't know, ten students, and
- 13:39slowly they started dropping out because it wasn't one of like the official classes.
- 13:43It was like an extra activity. And the last two remaining people in the
- 13:46class were us two and the guy you know, just kind of like trying
- 13:52his best life. Why did it? Why were people leaving? I think
- 13:54they either didn't like the teacher or they were like this is lame. I
- 13:58don't know. But he's like, it's okay, we'll put on a two
- 14:01person play with you too, and I was like all into it. Eventually
- 14:05was like, dude, I don't want to do this. This is embarrassing.
- 14:09So we ended up dropping. I mean it could have been cool,
- 14:11I think so with the right script, but we have very different personalities.
- 14:16I would have done a one person play. I'm surprised you didn't throw that
- 14:18out. I know, so let me just monologue. Yeah, So he
- 14:24decides he wants to pursue a career in acting after giving up on architecture,
- 14:31and he tried out for a play and he was hoping to get a really
- 14:37awesome part, which I find to be hubris because you start at the top.
- 14:41Yeah. Another narcissty out of college. Yeah, it's one thing when
- 14:46you're like a little kid in second grade, and you're like, no,
- 14:50I hope I can be Rapunzel or something. Still the first play, because
- 14:54there's no reports of him having acted before, and I'm guessing we would have
- 14:58heard about that. He certainly doesn't seem like the sort of person that would
- 15:01have done that before. And in college, your first foray, you're going
- 15:07up against people that had probably been in dozens of productions since they were seven
- 15:13years old. Of course, he didn't get a good part. He didn't
- 15:16even get a speaking part, and he immediately gave up on his career as
- 15:22an actor and he became depressed. He also wrote and recorded audio in his
- 15:28journal that he really wanted to have friends and he would plan things out.
- 15:35He's like, I need more friends, and I need to work on my
- 15:37social skills. And he decided that he was going to organize dinners at the
- 15:43apartment and people actually were coming, and he was quite proud in his audio
- 15:50journal that a few people were coming. And in the beginning of this process
- 15:56he was declaring it this huge success, which you know, okay, but
- 16:00he has this pattern in his journal of looking for anything to hold on to
- 16:06that this is how I'm hearing it. Sure, and when something's going well,
- 16:11he just latches on and is I think hoping that it's a sign of
- 16:17things to come, which isn't strange. A lot of people do that,
- 16:21I imagine mostly young people would be doing that as well, because you don't
- 16:26really know what your life is going to be like you haven't been on your
- 16:29own. He's only been on his own for a couple of years. But
- 16:32at the same time, in his journal he's complaining about his friends rifling through
- 16:37his fridge and eating all his stuff and it's costing him a lot of money.
- 16:41He's very focused on money, and he's very what people would call cheap
- 16:47or frugal or something. A lot of focus on that sort of thing.
- 16:51So having people over disaster for dinner, it's expected he's going to provide the
- 16:56food, right, or if they run out of food, they're going to
- 17:00start rifling through with stuff. And look, I remember those days. Yeah,
- 17:03Sure, in college it was a fighting offence. If you took even
- 17:11the small if you took like someone's pop tart, it was a firewall.
- 17:15You cannot cross that firewall because we didn't have any money, and if we
- 17:18bought something, especially if it was sought after, like pop tarts or chips
- 17:22or something. Never would I have bought a bag of chips, forget about
- 17:26it. That's just like too much money. And if someone ate it,
- 17:30Yeah, that would be the end of our relationship. Yeah. So hearing
- 17:36this journal, if I just try to tamp because initially I'm like, oh,
- 17:40there's that anger. You know, he's thinking about killing those people because
- 17:44Josh is a murderous psychopath. But I have to check that. And also
- 17:48a lot of the reporting, you know, when they will provide these clips,
- 17:52it seems like a lot of people are saying Monday morning quarterback. If
- 17:57you heard that phrase before, it would baseball right. In other words,
- 18:03twenty twenty in retrospect that look at that he's obviously got a problem with his
- 18:10personality, and if I heard this, I would think totally normal. And
- 18:17the fact that he's organizing dinners and he wants to have friends and he likes
- 18:19it that people like you know, I think I was telling you recently that
- 18:23I like having a house where people come over for parties and get togethers and
- 18:29casual things, and I like that I just leave my door unlocked and friends
- 18:33just walk in. They don't even knock on the door, partially because the
- 18:36dogs, but also because I don't know, I just want people to feel
- 18:41like they can walk like you. You know, you have the code to
- 18:42my security to the whole house, because Savin noticed when I break in in
- 18:48the middle of the night, and I always wanted that, and I think
- 18:52he wanted that too. He's a little awkward, but you know, that's
- 18:56all you can really say at this point. There's no there's not like a
- 19:00predictable path towards murder at this point. But it's also notable that in his
- 19:06journal there's nothing or very little about other people. The way he writes it's
- 19:11similar to the way Steven writes his father in that it's all about himself and
- 19:18all about how he's processing things. You know, there's nothing like And then
- 19:22Johnny told me that he likes this new job, and I'm really happy that
- 19:26he get or these two people are not getting along and I'm worried about their
- 19:33comfort level, you know what I mean. That's interesting. So I never
- 19:37thought of that aspect of Yeah, because of course there's this idea that if
- 19:40you read someone's journal you can learn a lot about them, But I actually
- 19:42never thought of that idea that if you read someone's journal and all they do
- 19:45is talk about their own experience and their own thoughts and feelings, it does
- 19:48say something, right, you know, well, like, what would your
- 19:52journal look like? It would be mostly about my thoughts and feelings. I've
- 19:57tried journaling throughout the years. I have little entries here and there, and
- 20:02usually it's about whatever I've been struggling at the time with. Yeah, and
- 20:07it's hard to draw conclusions personality wise. There are studies along these lines,
- 20:11and of course there's simplistic notions in our society that if you see the word
- 20:18I or me a lot, it correlates with narcissism. I actually think it's
- 20:22the opposite. I can't remember the research. It's not intuitive as a thing.
- 20:26Also, what's the purpose of a journal for an individual? For you
- 20:32and for a lot of people, it's when you're struggling, when you're upset,
- 20:36when you're sad, when you're struggling with your marriage, or when you
- 20:40just got in a fight with a friend, or your career is going back.
- 20:42So if you looked at your journal entries, it would look like all
- 20:47about you, and it would look very negativistic, right, but you don't
- 20:52use your journal to report on daily activities, or to talk about other people,
- 20:56or to talk about your joy in life or successes. So it's hard
- 21:02to draw conclusions about personality. However, I would say that the style of
- 21:07journal that he had it was the kind where it was daily. It was
- 21:11a personal log, and it is a sign of narcissism, maybe not severe
- 21:18narcissism, but on the spectrum somewhere in that one the individual feels that their
- 21:26life is important enough to document, you know what I mean. A lot
- 21:30of people are just like, well, why would I spend the time to
- 21:33document my stupid life? What's the benefit? No one cares, you know
- 21:38what I mean. It's sort of in the direction of thinking that there should
- 21:42be a biopic made about you, you know what I mean. Narcissistic people
- 21:48on one end of the spectrum would definitely think that would be true. Oh
- 21:51my life would make a wonderful movie, you know, that kind of thing.
- 21:55Lower on the spectrum, people might journal. Now, people who journal
- 21:59aren't as acessarily narcissistic, but it is one of the things that I have
- 22:03seen. The other aspect of narcissism that isn't usually talked about is isolation and
- 22:10loneliness. Narcissistic people are some of the most deeply lonely and isolated individuals on
- 22:15the planet because they were neglected emotionally when they were young, kept at a
- 22:21distance from zero to five, and learned to give up and to only rely
- 22:26on themselves, and so they don't even signal other people. They don't reach
- 22:30out, they don't provide, they don't signal their needs, they don't bid
- 22:34for love or support, and so people don't even know to come to them
- 22:40because they seem like they're strong and independent and they seem to have it all
- 22:45figured out kind of thing. And they also are terrified about extending themselves that
- 22:52way because in the past, when they were two years old, it never
- 22:53worked out for them or very rarely. So I mean I can relate to
- 22:56that. We've talked about that. How you know, for most of my
- 22:59life I never reached out. I still struggle with that anyways. But certainly
- 23:04there's a combin well, there's a combination of things. One though, is
- 23:07the idea that I didn't want to which I realize it's overdoing it, but
- 23:11I didn't want to fall in the trap of like say, my dad or
- 23:15other individuals like that where they become dependent and so I have like this phobia
- 23:18of becoming dependent on other people and again dial it to eleven when I didn't
- 23:22need to. But then also I think there is and just to put a
- 23:26fine point on that, there's nothing wrong with being independent, right of course
- 23:30and steering away from mooching off of other people. But the dark side to
- 23:34that is that no one feels like you need them exactly, and therefore you
- 23:41don't really care enough to be vulnerable around them, like emotionally especially, And
- 23:47I've experienced that both in micro and macro ways, where in a social situation
- 23:52people would just assume that I'm impervious to pain or suffering and everything's just fine
- 23:56with me. Well, and you give off to me as much in the
- 24:00last five years, but you give off a vibe that you're cool as a
- 24:06cucumber. Yeah, you can roll with any situation, even if internally it's
- 24:11pain and suffering. Yeah. Yeah. And then there's a macro of it,
- 24:14which is yeah, like just no one me not reaching out slash,
- 24:21no one calling up and going like, hey, are you okay? Right,
- 24:23like those kinds of things. And I think there is something to that
- 24:26where it's like what you were saying, you know, abandonment when you're young,
- 24:30the fear that well, if I do reach out, I'll probably be
- 24:33rejected anyway. So what's the point? You know? Are those kinds of
- 24:37things right? And in couple with what I mentioned about this kind of phobia
- 24:41of becoming dependent, it's interesting. I mean, so you feel that I've
- 24:47obviously processed through a lot of it, and actually a lot of our conversations
- 24:49have helped, like we had our whole hospital conversation hospital buddies conversation. Yeah,
- 24:55but I feel like I still have that for sure, where it's like,
- 24:59I I don't want to end up that way. You know when I
- 25:04look back that there was this period of my life when I was like thirty
- 25:08five or something where I could see, I see a fork in the road,
- 25:15and I saw that one side of the road led to me becoming dependent
- 25:18and like financially financially yeah, and I was like, oh God, And
- 25:22I had such a phobia of that future that I was able to steer myself
- 25:27away from that. And I really think that was that plus therapy where the
- 25:30main things that ended up saving me from that self fulfilling future. Yeah,
- 25:37there were a lot of elements that saved you. Also being vulnerable to your
- 25:41wife, right instead of just trying to weather the storm, you opened up
- 25:45and said, I have to tell you what's happening not only financially but also
- 25:51emotionally for me right now. And then you work together and pulled yourself out
- 25:57of that and now you're doing great. So when you are in that situation
- 26:03personality wise, that's the defense, the adaptation. Then you don't reach out
- 26:10to other people. You have to vent somewhere though usually, and a journal
- 26:17is perfect because you don't have to bother anyone. You don't have to depend
- 26:21on anyone. You're just internally in this closed loop of express and support and
- 26:30it's a lonely experience, but you're getting some need of expression, some need
- 26:36of communications and even supporting yourself in a way, you know what I mean.
- 26:41Let's take a break real quick. What do you say? Let's do
- 26:42it? Okay, we're back from the break. So I thought we would
- 26:52listen to some of his journal. This is on the Cold podcast, which
- 26:59is the definition of source for all things Josh Pal. Josh had a long
- 27:03history of failing to connect with girls. His written journals are full of entries
- 27:08about struggles in dating. His audio journals are even more telling. Here he
- 27:14is in his own voice, reacting to one rejection to lose such a good
- 27:18friend. I didn't want it to end. I know you're in a better
- 27:23place, but it's so broke my heart. So just chiming in here.
- 27:30The beginning of this recording this audio journal is a little confusing, but in
- 27:36a little bit it becomes more clear that he's talking about a girl or a
- 27:41young woman that broke up with him, and he's I think, trying to
- 27:45frame it in a positive way. And he filled me up. He replaced
- 27:51my broken heart with incredible joy, the greatest joy he possibly a bit.
- 28:00You taught me so much about where I want to be, and especially how
- 28:07to take care of people, and also who I am and who I want
- 28:11to be. I've never met someone so full of Your example is so powerful.
- 28:19They didn't take months or years. The footprints you've left in my heart
- 28:26or some of the deepest I've ever known. So thoughts on this audio journal,
- 28:33Bruto, It sounds very pained. I don't know if this was his
- 28:37usual speaking style. It is not in this exact mode. But that's the
- 28:45style soft would you say it's soft soft? But also it just sounds full
- 28:49of pain and fragile and fragile. Definitely fragile. Yeah, what else do
- 28:56you hear? What's interesting is and I'm sure that I'm biased because I know
- 29:00the outcome of this whole thing, but there is a sense of what I
- 29:04hear a little bit of is passive aggressiveness. There's there's this weird thing where
- 29:10it's like, on the surface, if you read the transcript, it all
- 29:14sounds so positive, right, because he's being dumped. He's been he's been
- 29:18dumped, right, and he's saying, you open my eyes, I'm more
- 29:23compassionate now you've inspired me. You're such a great person. But you think
- 29:30there's some well because for one thing, I don't think this was intended for
- 29:33that person to hear, right, Oh yeah, no no, because these
- 29:37are the kinds of things that would be great for that person to hear,
- 29:41right. And maybe he did. There were reports that he would say and
- 29:47write these kinds of things to okay these women. Maybe I'm wrong. He
- 29:52was sort of two different people when it came to dating. On one hand,
- 29:56he was like Stevens father in that he was obsessed in the beginning with
- 30:03the unavailable, or with the chase, or with the new infatuation, which
- 30:11isn't strange, you know, people can be that way. Plus, when
- 30:15you're narcissistic and you are denied that attachment early in life, you proceed to
- 30:22avoid attachment throughout your life. But you're desperate for attachment, and so when
- 30:30you are in that beginning infatuation, it will you know, that energy,
- 30:34that infatuation energy will overpower your defenses and alert you to this deep, deep
- 30:42need, and so you will become terribly infatuated and putting all your eggs in
- 30:51this basket that has finally come your way, you know, because you're not
- 30:55even vulnerable with your friends or anybody. So you're not only looking for a
- 31:00romantic or sexual partner. You're looking for like a romantic partner, a sexual
- 31:04partner, a best friend, a mother that will finally love you, someone
- 31:10that will listen to your dreams and compliment you and believe in you, and
- 31:14everything comes pouring out. Also, because you're narcissistic, you believe that everything
- 31:19you need, to believe that everything you do is special and superior in grandiose,
- 31:25and if you're having an emotion, it must be the most love anyone
- 31:30has ever felt. And if you have a good relationship with someone, it
- 31:33must be better than all other relationships. And if you love someone, then
- 31:38that person must be superior. And so there's a lot of things conspiring to
- 31:45severely amplify the initial infatuation. Then the other side is once you establish the
- 31:53ongoing relationship and you hit cruising speed, then you can't tolerate the closeness and
- 32:00the vulnerability, so you retract. So we're seeing one side right now.
- 32:07We're hearing one side of it. And I think he could have been very
- 32:10expressive to her in person as well. Yep, quite possible. So he
- 32:17would apparently confidently hit on a lot of young women. He would just walk
- 32:24up to women at stores or in class or at church. I don't know
- 32:30if he thought of himself as a lover boy, or if he was desperate,
- 32:35or if he just said screw it, you know, you gotta play
- 32:40the game in order to win the game, or some I don't let's there's
- 32:45probably some saying from somewhere right there is an aspect of correct me if I'm
- 32:51wrong, But there is an aspect to psychopathy where you don't feel fear the
- 32:55same way. Right, yep, yeah, yeah, that could be a
- 32:59factor. But again I don't see any extreme indications of psychopathy and that sort
- 33:06of classic anti social personality, but could be, could be. I think
- 33:12he desperately wanted to be loved, and I think he desperately wanted to belong
- 33:16as well. I don't think he just wanted a partner. I think he
- 33:19wanted to belong to an enmeshed I think he was looking for a mother,
- 33:23not consciously, and I think he was also looking for a family in some
- 33:28way. He was very distressed about his parents divorce. Children seem to enter
- 33:34this world with a desire for family and belonging and group bonding. Children are
- 33:42not only selfishly interested in keeping their family together because if parents split up,
- 33:47then they might not get their parents full attention because they'll only get attention from
- 33:52one parent at a time, you know. Or they might worry that if
- 33:55you're rejecting mommy, are you going to reject me? Is that you so?
- 34:00And that's normal and that's healthy and that's fine. But I also think
- 34:02that there's evidence that children just have an innate instinct for group cohesion. You
- 34:09know, it would make sense evolutionary wise that children and humans would be programmed
- 34:15that way. And I think that he suffered, like a lot of kids
- 34:20will, through divorce. And I think he was always looking for that because
- 34:23there were women, young women that he became infatuated with, not only because
- 34:30they were attractive to him and had the values that he was looking for.
- 34:35He's looking for like a a young woman that didn't drink and didn't swear,
- 34:39and went to church and was family oriented. Nothing wrong with that, but
- 34:44he also seemed to be attracted to women who were parts of groups, often
- 34:47religious groups, And not only was attracted to the woman, but also like,
- 34:52oh look at this, Like he became a born again Christian at one
- 34:57point, because it's the group belonging, not just the person. It's like
- 35:00a package deal, right, yeah, you all in one, right,
- 35:06not only love and sex and togethership, but also like she comes with family
- 35:13and group and community and religion. And he because there's this one woman that
- 35:19he dated and he talks about in his journal that he went to the born
- 35:22again meeting and you know, remember he's a he's a Mormon. Right,
- 35:28it's pretty far, you know, a lot of Mormons will say not all,
- 35:32but they will say Mormons are the only real of course, each sect
- 35:37says that, right, and you can't just like transfer that over, you
- 35:42know. And so he was at a born again Christian meeting of some kind
- 35:47and a kid came up to him, a little kid, and he talks
- 35:52about this in his journal, and the kid was, you know, I
- 35:55think said I love you eventually to Josh. And Josh was writing about that
- 36:01in his journal, and he's just like, it felt so good to have
- 36:06this kid say that he loved me. I want to be with this woman.
- 36:10You know, you just hear the vulnerability. And I want to talk
- 36:15about all this not only to provide the data, but also to show that
- 36:21Josh is a human being, not to humanize him, so to speak,
- 36:24for his benefit, but to dispel the nonsense out there that people that commit
- 36:32crimes like what he will eventually do in this timeline, not only murder and
- 36:38do horrible things to Susan's body to dispose of it, but also the murder
- 36:45of his two sons by his own hand and then blowing up his house.
- 36:50These are horrific, horrific crimes. The typical conceptualization is that these are monsters
- 36:57through and through one hundred percent of the time the day they were born.
- 37:00We're not hearing that. We're hearing you know, maybe a somewhat depressed and
- 37:07isolated, a young man who has been through a lot of abuse and a
- 37:13lot of family turmoil. He has been bullied by peers. Maybe he's a
- 37:20little socially awkward, but he seemingly has the ability to win people over at
- 37:25times. He's struggling with his career, but he's working on a business degree
- 37:31at the University of Washington, you know, pretty successful in academics. Smart
- 37:37young man, attractive to a lot of young women. Would say that he's
- 37:44an all American, attractive tall boy, has his life before him. The
- 37:49future is not written in stone in the least. And that's what I want
- 37:52to go over, not only to just dispel of the myths, but also
- 37:58to point out that the path to murder and suicide is many and this could
- 38:06have been changed. His future could have been altered if our society were different,
- 38:10if the family were different, if he was open to other things,
- 38:14if our society was different regarding masculinity. Maybe I don't know, there's a
- 38:19lot of things that we can do and we could have done to have prevented
- 38:22this, just in terms of his own personality. So that's what I want
- 38:27to talk about. So also during this time, he starts writing about he
- 38:32wants to repair his relationship with his mom and his older sister Jennifer, because
- 38:38during the divorce, remember he had to make that split. And over the
- 38:44years he would increasingly write in his journal and talk about in his journal he
- 38:47was realizing that Steve and his father was actually a bad influence. The father
- 38:53never taught him how to follow the rules, and that his father was conflictual,
- 39:00bative and was influencing the kids away from healthy paths, you know,
- 39:06the sort of thing. So in this point in his journal, if this
- 39:09is all that you heard, you would think you have someone that is emerging
- 39:15into health. And he's fairly self reflective. He's willing to talk about his
- 39:20deficits, that he has issues with social skills, and that he needs to
- 39:24remember to watch what he talks about with people because he doesn't want to alienate
- 39:31people. I think he even writes in his journal he needs to learn how
- 39:36to listen more. What good. So he eventually graduates with his bachelor's degree,
- 39:43in business, which is the exact same degree that I have. And
- 39:50it's a somewhat prestigious business school, the Foster School of Business. And it's
- 39:55not super hard, I wouldn't say that, but you know, it's a
- 40:00thing. And he did graduate, and that shows that he was functional enough
- 40:07for that. So at this point in the story, burto Josh meets his
- 40:13very first significant girlfriend, and there's a lot of parallels between his relationship with
- 40:20this first girlfriend and his second girlfriend, which is Susan his wife. Yeah,
- 40:27he presumably killed. And I want to go over that relationship because it
- 40:31sets the stage and it shows that Josh wasn't with Susan in a particular way.
- 40:38It was Josh, not them, you know what I mean. If
- 40:42he's the same way with both women, what's the common denominator? But before
- 40:46going into that, let's take a break. When we get back, the
- 40:49rest of this will just be for patrons of the podcast, So if you
- 40:52want to zone so, if you want to hear the rest of this episode,
- 40:55become a patron by going to patreon dot com. Patreon's over there,
- 41:00pointed at it, and otherwise, please take care of yourself because you deserve it.