Latest / Deep Dive / Zero Tax on Work: The Radical Future of Wealth and Risk
Transcript
- 0:00What if the secret to like a perfectly optimized economy, one
- 0:04that basically guarantees a permanent 6% bump in everyone's
- 0:08standard of living, required the government to drop your income
- 0:12tax to absolute 0? Right.
- 0:14But they also have to suddenly start acting like your financial
- 0:16partner at a high stakes casino, right?
- 0:18Yeah, exactly. I mean, it sounds like some sort
- 0:20of libertarian fever dream crashing into a socialist
- 0:23utopia, but, well, that is actually the mathematical
- 0:26conclusion of one of the most rigorous economic models
- 0:29published this decade. The catch, of course, is, you
- 0:31know, actually surviving the transition to get there.
- 0:33Wow. Yeah, Well, welcome to today's
- 0:36custom deep Dive. For you listening at home, it is
- 0:39Thursday May 14th, 2026 and our mission today is to really
- 0:43decode the mechanics of taxation.
- 0:46We're pulling apart how tax policy physically engineers our
- 0:49behavior. Right.
- 0:50How it redirects global capital and just fundamentally alters
- 0:53the structure of the economy. We're bridging that massive gap
- 0:56between the hot off the press policy changes happening
- 0:59literally right now, and the high level macroeconomic theory
- 1:02that explains, you know, why governments actually make the
- 1:05choices they do. Yeah.
- 1:07And we have a pretty formidable stack of sources to cross
- 1:09reference today for you. We're pulling Fresh and LCS on
- 1:12the massive 20262027 Australian Federal Budget that just dropped
- 1:17on Tuesday. Fresh.
- 1:18Off the press. Exactly.
- 1:19We're using breakdowns from K&L, Gates, the Australian
- 1:22Shareholders Association and ABC News and we're combining that
- 1:26real world data with a crucial 2024 policy piece from the
- 1:30Gratton Institute. Oh.
- 1:31The Gratton piece is so good. It really is.
- 1:33And finally, we're holding all of that up against a dense,
- 1:35really fascinating 2025 academic paper from the journal Economic
- 1:39Inquiry, which focuses on optimal tax theory.
- 1:42OK, let's unpack this because we need to start with the immediate
- 1:45reality the Australian budget handed down on Tuesday night, so
- 1:49May 12th. It fundamentally rewrites the
- 1:51mechanics of wealth accumulation in that country.
- 1:54Completely rewrites it. Starting July 1st, 2027, the
- 1:58government is just completely above abolishing the 50% capital
- 2:01gains tax discount for individuals and trusts.
- 2:04Yeah, and I mean, for 1/4 of a century, the mechanism was
- 2:08simple, right? Hold an asset for 12 months and
- 2:10you only pay tax on half the profit when you sell it.
- 2:13But that blunt instrument is gone.
- 2:16They're replacing it with a return to the pre 1999 system of
- 2:20CPI indexation. But, and this is the kicker,
- 2:23they're adding a highly aggressive new floor.
- 2:27It's a hard minimum tax rate of 30% on the inflation adjusted
- 2:31game. Let's actually walk through the
- 2:33math on how that changes an investor's reality, because it's
- 2:36wild. Under the old rules, if you made
- 2:38$100,000 profit on a property, you just sliced it in half.
- 2:41You added 50 grand to your taxable income and paid your
- 2:44marginal rate. Simple, right?
- 2:45Super simple. But now, under this new
- 2:48indexation model, the government looks at inflation first.
- 2:51So if inflation ate $20,000 of your buying power over the life
- 2:54of the investment, they subtract that.
- 2:56That leaves an $80,000 real profit.
- 2:59But instead of taxing that at your standard income bracket,
- 3:02they slap this hard 30% minimum floor on it.
- 3:06So for a top bracket earner, the difference might be, you know,
- 3:09subtle. But for a retiree on a lower
- 3:12income, the math completely flips.
- 3:14It does, and that ties directly into their second major
- 3:17structural shift because they are taking an axe to negative
- 3:22gearing for established residential properties.
- 3:25If you buy an existing home after budget night, you can no
- 3:28longer use the holding losses, which is primarily the interest
- 3:31on your mortgage, to reduce the tax you pay on your regular wage
- 3:35or salary. You just can't do it anymore.
- 3:37No, you can only quarantine those deductions against other
- 3:40property income. I really want to focus on the
- 3:42mechanism of negative gearing here because the way it shapes
- 3:45behavior is it's just wild. Imagine if your employer gave
- 3:49you a workplace subsidy where they agreed to cover a portion
- 3:52of your personal stock market losses using your pre tax
- 3:55salary. Right, But only if you bought
- 3:58specific blue chip stocks. That would completely alter your
- 4:01risk appetite. Exactly, you would aggressively
- 4:04bid up the price of those stocks because your downside is
- 4:07artificially protected by your day job.
- 4:09It's like changing the rules of Monopoly mid game right after
- 4:12players have already built their hotels.
- 4:14That is exactly what negative gearing did for the Australian
- 4:17housing market. It subsidized the holding cost
- 4:20of an asset that was almost guaranteed to appreciate using
- 4:24wage revenue. Right, but the government hasn't
- 4:26entirely killed the subsidy. They're keeping the old negative
- 4:30caring perk entirely intact if and only if you buy a newly
- 4:34built home. So there's the catch.
- 4:36And they're also introducing a new 30% flat tax on
- 4:40discretionary trusts starting in 2028, which let's translate that
- 4:44they are targeting legal lock boxes, you know, often called
- 4:47bucket companies. Right, the structures families
- 4:49use. Yeah, They use them to
- 4:50strategically distribute investment income to whoever
- 4:54happens to be in the lowest tax bracket that year.
- 4:57So between the trust tax, the capital gains minimum and the
- 4:59negative gearing restriction, the government is basically
- 5:02orchestrating a massive reallocation of capital.
- 5:04What's fascinating here is the scale of that reallocation,
- 5:08which is laid out in the Treasury projections reported by
- 5:11ABC News. The government actually
- 5:14anticipates these levers will force 75,000 established homes
- 5:18out of the hands of property investors and directly into the
- 5:22hands of first home buyers over the next decade. 75,000.
- 5:26Because the moment you remove that day job tax subsidy and
- 5:29investors simply cannot justify outbidding a dual income family
- 5:34for an existing house. Wait, I mean, if they're forcing
- 5:37investors to sell, how does the Treasury also project a net
- 5:40increase of 30,000 homes in the national supply?
- 5:43Because capital operates like water, right?
- 5:45It flows to the path of least resistance by preserving
- 5:48negative gearing strictly for new builds.
- 5:51The government is essentially erecting a dam in front of the
- 5:54existing housing market and digging a massive canal toward
- 5:57the construction sector. Oh, I see.
- 5:59Investors who want that specific tax shelter they have to fund
- 6:03new supply. It's behavioral engineering
- 6:05disguised as accounting. But that engineering is causing
- 6:08severe political friction. I mean, the coalition has vowed
- 6:11to block these property tax reforms entirely.
- 6:14Current investors are caught in a deeply volatile environment.
- 6:18They're trying to figure out how to navigate a system where the
- 6:21founding foundational rules of their retirement plans just
- 6:23changed overnight. Yeah.
- 6:25And the Australian Shareholders Association, the ASA, they
- 6:28immediately recognized that volatility.
- 6:31Their first directive to investors was very clear.
- 6:34Do not panic sell. Don't panic.
- 6:36Right, because the government is terrified of triggering a market
- 6:39collapse, so they've wrapped these reforms in incredibly
- 6:43complex grandfathering rules. The mechanics of this
- 6:46grandfathering are fascinating. Let's break it down.
- 6:48If you already own an investment property, you keep the old
- 6:51negative gearing rules indefinitely.
- 6:53You're totally safe. Yeah, you're entirely immune to
- 6:55the new restrictions. And for capital gains, any on
- 6:59paper gains your assets accrue up until July 2027, keep the old
- 7:0350% discount, right. It's only the growth from July
- 7:062027 onward that gets hit with the CPI indexation and the 30%
- 7:10minimum. Though, and this is huge,
- 7:12there's one massive trapdoor in the grandfathering legislation.
- 7:16Assets bought before 1985 have been entirely exempt from
- 7:20capital gains tax for 30 years. 40 years they were considered
- 7:24untouchable, but this budget finally drags them into the tax
- 7:27net. Any gains those pre 1985 assets
- 7:30make after 2027 will be taxed under the new system.
- 7:34I I got to say, I really struggle with the underlying
- 7:37philosophy of grandfathering because the political argument
- 7:40is that it's the fairway to transition without punishing
- 7:43people who played by the old rules.
- 7:45But mechanically, doesn't it fundamentally just pull the
- 7:48ladder up behind the people who are on property?
- 7:50It absolutely pulls the ladder. Up.
- 7:52You're permanently protecting the wealth generation tools of
- 7:55the demographic that bought in 20 years ago, while aggressively
- 7:58taxing the younger generation who are attempting to build
- 8:01wealth today using the exact same asset class.
- 8:04It does. But look, if the government
- 8:07refuses to grandfather those assets, they trigger an
- 8:10immediate catastrophic fire sale.
- 8:13If 2 million property investors suddenly realize their holding
- 8:16costs are going to double next fiscal year, they all list their
- 8:19properties tomorrow. Right.
- 8:21And the market drops. The housing market crashes,
- 8:23consumer spending evaporates, and the whole economy tilts into
- 8:26a severe recession. So the government is basically
- 8:28held hostage by the success of its own previous tax policies.
- 8:32They are, but your critique about generational equity is
- 8:36entirely validated by that 2024 policy piece from the Gratin
- 8:39Institute we mentioned. Oh yeah.
- 8:41Gratin explicitly warned that grandfathering exacerbates
- 8:45intergenerational inequality and severely distorts market
- 8:49behavior. Because if you hold a property
- 8:51under the old generous negative gearing rules and you know
- 8:54you'll lose that tax shield the second you sell and buy a
- 8:56different property. You never sell.
- 8:58You never sell, you hoard the asset.
- 9:01Grandfathering mathematically locks up housing supply.
- 9:05Let's dig into Gratin's modeling, then.
- 9:07What happens if the government actually ignored the panic and
- 9:10just ripped the Band-Aid off because the political rhetoric
- 9:13suggests that curbing these concessions would absolutely
- 9:16decimate property values? Well, Gratton's modeling
- 9:19completely dismantled that narrative.
- 9:21They found that abolishing these concessions completely would
- 9:24only drop overall property prices by roughly 2%.
- 9:28Wait, wait, only 2%? That's 2%.
- 9:31After decades of debate and political lobbying, removing the
- 9:34primary tax shelters for property only shaves 2% off the
- 9:38top. How is that mechanically
- 9:40possible when investors make up such a massive portion of the
- 9:43buying pool? Because investors don't set the
- 9:45floor price of a housing market owner occupiers do.
- 9:49Oh. OK, explain that.
- 9:50So investors running a pure yield calculation, right, saying
- 9:54if the tax subsidy disappears, the math stops work and they
- 9:56drop out of the bidding at auction, right?
- 9:58But a prospective owner occupier isn't calculating yield, they're
- 10:02calculating utility and emotion. They need a place to live, so
- 10:07they will stretch their borrowing capacity to the
- 10:09absolute maximum the bank allows.
- 10:11So the owner occupier sets the baseline value based on their
- 10:14wages and borrowing power, regardless of what the tax code
- 10:17says. Correct.
- 10:19That 2% drop just reflects the removal of the speculative
- 10:22premium at the very top of the auction.
- 10:24Yeah, but the crucial revelation in Gratton's analysis isn't the
- 10:27price drop, it's the demographic shift.
- 10:30Right. By clearing out that heavily
- 10:32subsidized investor competition at weekend options, Gratton
- 10:35estimated the overall home ownership rate would organically
- 10:39climb from 67% to 70%. The structural value of the
- 10:43market holds steady, but the composition of who holds the
- 10:47deeds shifts fundamentally from leveraged investors to families.
- 10:51OK, so we're looking at a real world system defined by messy
- 10:55compromises, grandfathered clauses, and these frantic
- 10:58attempts to shift capital without crashing the economy.
- 11:01It's incredibly inefficient. Very messy.
- 11:03So let's pivot to the theoretical If the current
- 11:06structural landscape is this compromised, what does a
- 11:09mathematically perfect tax system look like in a vacuum?
- 11:12Well, to map that out, we turn to that heavily analytical 2025
- 11:17paper published in Economic Inquiry by researchers Brendan
- 11:20Baer and Alexis Akira Toda. They utilized A sophisticated
- 11:24heterogeneous agent economic model.
- 11:26OK, let's explain what that model actually is, because it's
- 11:28not just some simple spreadsheet.
- 11:30No, it's a simulated mini economy.
- 11:33Heterogeneous agent simply means the simulated people in the
- 11:36model do not behave uniformly. The researchers programmed
- 11:39agents who experience random, unpredictable variations in
- 11:42their investment returns and labor income overtime.
- 11:45Some hit massive windfalls. Others face catastrophic
- 11:49bankruptcies. It simulates the chaos of a real
- 11:52market. And they run it over and over.
- 11:54Exactly. Millions of times, the goal was
- 11:57to find the absolute optimal flat tax rates that maximize the
- 12:01overall welfare of the society. And the baseline findings are
- 12:04jarring because to achieve maximum societal welfare, Baer
- 12:07and Toda found that the labor income tax, so the tax on the
- 12:10wages you earn from your day job, must be dropped to 0%.
- 12:13Total abolition of the income tax.
- 12:15It's crazy. And to replace that revenue, the
- 12:18government must rely on 2 levers, A consumption tax like
- 12:22AVAT or GST set at an aggressive 31%, and a capital income tax
- 12:27set precisely at 24%. By engineering the economy this
- 12:31way, the simulation generates a welfare increase equivalent to
- 12:34granting every single citizen a permanent 6.6% boost in their
- 12:39lifelong consumption. The 0 income tax makes intuitive
- 12:42sense, right? You want to unconditionally
- 12:43incentivize labor, but the 24% capital tax contradicts decades
- 12:49of conventional macroeconomic wisdom.
- 12:52Traditional models argue that taxing capital is inherently
- 12:55destructive because it punishes investment and drives money
- 12:57offshore. Sure, this raises an important
- 12:59question. How does this modern model prove
- 13:02that taxing capital at 24 percent is actually the optimal
- 13:06engine for growth? Because it operates on the Domar
- 13:08Musgrave effect, Bear and Toda argue that a capital tax only
- 13:12suffocates investment if it acts as a one way penalty on success.
- 13:15But in their optimized model, the 24% tax comes with perfect
- 13:19instantaneous offset provisions. Meaning you can deduct losses
- 13:22exactly. If you lose money on an
- 13:25investment, the government immediately allows you to deduct
- 13:28those losses. They effectively write you a
- 13:30check for 24% of the failure. It acts as an automatic
- 13:33stabilizer for private risk. So it's like a casino where the
- 13:37house takes 24% of your winnings at the roulette table, right?
- 13:41Normally you'd bet conservatively, but this casino
- 13:44also promises to instantly reimburse 24% of any chips you
- 13:48lose. That would absolutely make me
- 13:51willing to place bigger, riskier bets.
- 13:53Right, because your downside risk is massively mitigated,
- 13:56you're going to place highly volatile bets because the house
- 13:59is eating 1/4 of the downside. The analogy holds, but we really
- 14:03need to clarify the underlying economic motive here.
- 14:06OK, what is? It the government isn't
- 14:08operating this casino just to keep you entertained, they're
- 14:10doing it because they mathematically require you to
- 14:13take on massive leverage. The paper goes deep into the
- 14:17mechanics of the natural borrowing constraint.
- 14:20Which is basically the bank's limit on your risk.
- 14:23Exactly. If you're an entrepreneur
- 14:24building a factory, there is a hard mathematical ceiling on how
- 14:28much debt a commercial bank will let you take on before the risk
- 14:31of default is just too high. The bank cuts you off, which
- 14:35starts your business capital and slows down the broader economy.
- 14:38But, and here's the magic if the government is absorbing 24% of
- 14:42your downside risk through the tax code, your personal risk
- 14:46profile is artificially lowered. The bank looks at you, sees the
- 14:50government acting as a silent equity partner, absorbing the
- 14:53losses and clears you for a much larger loan.
- 14:56So the tax isn't a penalty at all.
- 14:57It is a structural mechanism to literally force entrepreneurs to
- 15:00borrow more money. That is the genius of the Domar
- 15:04Musgrave effect, and Bear and Toda found that at specific
- 15:07levels of market volatility, so in the variance of uninsurable
- 15:11investment risk sits precisely between .198 and 2.215 Dash
- 15:16Nash, the optimal capital tax rate mathematically spikes from
- 15:200% straight up to 18%. Wait, what does that volatility
- 15:24window actually represent in the real world?
- 15:26It represents an economy shifting from stable low yield
- 15:29industries like utilities into high risk, high reward sectors
- 15:34like tech startups or aggressive manufacturing.
- 15:37As the economic environment becomes inherently riskier.
- 15:40The social planner. So the theoretical government
- 15:43cranks up the capital tax rate. They purposefully take more of
- 15:47your profits purely so they can subsidized more of your losses.
- 15:51It keeps you fully leveraged and building capital when you would
- 15:54otherwise be too terrified of bankruptcy to innovate.
- 15:56That is a pristine, incredibly elegant theoretical framework.
- 16:00I mean abolish the tax on labor, implement a perfectly
- 16:04symmetrical 24% capital tax that insures against failure, and
- 16:08force maximum leverage. Beautiful on paper.
- 16:10It is, but now let's drag that elegant model back into the
- 16:13messy reality of the 2026 Australian budget.
- 16:16The discrepancies are staggering.
- 16:18They really are operating in entirely different universes.
- 16:20I mean Bear and Toda dictate that the tax on wages must be 0
- 16:24to maximize welfare. The Australian government,
- 16:26they're offering a highly conditional $250 working
- 16:30Australian tax offset and tweaking the lowest marginal
- 16:34bracket down to 14% by 2027. They are nowhere near 0.
- 16:39But the real structural divergent is how they treat
- 16:42capital. The academic model relies
- 16:44entirely on the symmetry of the Domar Musgrave effect.
- 16:48You need perfect instantaneous loss offsets to justify a 24%
- 16:54capital tax. Australia's doing the exact
- 16:57opposite. By introducing a minimum 30%
- 17:00capital gains tax rate. They are completely shattering
- 17:03that symmetry. Yeah, and the Australian
- 17:05Shareholders Association identified this immediately.
- 17:08They called the 30% minimum a blunt tool.
- 17:10It is if you're a self funded retiree and your actual marginal
- 17:13tax rate for the year based on your income is only 16%.
- 17:17The government is still taking a hard 30% minimum on your capital
- 17:20gains. Right, so the government is
- 17:21acting like a casino that takes 30% of your winnings but refuses
- 17:25to cover 30% of your losses if your income drops.
- 17:28They are taking the upside but abandoning their role as the
- 17:32silent equity partner, protecting the downside that
- 17:35destroys the incentive to take on the leverage that Baer and
- 17:38Tota say is necessary for maximum growth.
- 17:40It does. It absolutely discourages risk.
- 17:43So what does this all mean? Are policymakers just ignoring
- 17:47good economics, or is the academic model simply too
- 17:51utopian for the real world? If we connect this to the bigger
- 17:54picture, we have to look at the political reality outlined
- 17:57within the academic paper itself, because Baer and Tota
- 18:01actually acknowledge why governments don't implement
- 18:04this. Perfect system.
- 18:05If a country attempted to switch to the Optimize 0 labor tax
- 18:09model tomorrow, the transition period is devastating.
- 18:12Because you have to reallocate the entire economic engine.
- 18:15Precisely to reach that utopian future where everyone is 6.6%
- 18:19richer, vast amounts of societal resources must be immediately
- 18:22diverted away from current enjoyment and poured into
- 18:25building massive amounts of new capital.
- 18:27Yet in the immediate aftermath of the policy switch, aggregate
- 18:31consumption craters. Workers see a sudden 2.3% drop
- 18:35in their standard of living. Entrepreneurs who are suddenly
- 18:38carrying massive new debt loads face a brutal 10% drop in their
- 18:42immediate consumption. You cannot walk into a press
- 18:45conference and tell the electorate I am intentionally
- 18:49reducing your quality of life by 10% this year, but in a
- 18:52generation the math proves we will all be wealthy.
- 18:56I mean, you would be voted out by the end of the sentence.
- 18:58And the model proves that Baer and Toda calculated the
- 19:02political viability of their own optimized system.
- 19:05Even though 86% of all simulated agents benefit in the long run,
- 19:09when they ran a theoretical election during the transition
- 19:11period, only 26% of the entrepreneurs voted for the
- 19:14policy. The immediate wealth destruction
- 19:17is just too painful. Which is the exact reason the
- 19:19Australian budget looks like a patchwork quilt of compromises.
- 19:23Policy majors are trapped by the transition.
- 19:25They cannot RIP the Band-Aid off without triggering A revolt, so
- 19:28they rely on these targeted microscopic levers to engineer
- 19:32behavior. Right.
- 19:33For instance, instead of broadly incentivizing all corporate risk
- 19:37through perfectly balanced capital taxes, K&L Gates noted
- 19:41that the budget specifically lifts the research and
- 19:43development expenditure cap to $200 million for large
- 19:47corporations. They're micromanaging the risk.
- 19:50The government decides which specific industries get the
- 19:53downside protection, rather than applying the Domar Musgrave
- 19:57effect across the entire economy.
- 20:00It is mathematically inefficient, but it's
- 20:01politically survivable. Here's where it gets really
- 20:04interesting. When you pull all these
- 20:06mechanisms together, the Ledger of a federal budget transforms
- 20:09entirely. Taxes are not just a mechanism
- 20:12for funding roads and hospitals. They are the primary behavioral
- 20:16engineering tools of our society.
- 20:18The exact percentage of a capital gains discount
- 20:21physically dictates whether a family can afford a home at
- 20:23auction, whether an investor decides to fund a new apartment
- 20:26complex, or whether a business owner takes out a loan to build
- 20:29a factory. We saw the tension between the
- 20:32pure efficiency of 0 labor tax models and the political reality
- 20:35of grandfathered tax brackets. We're basically watching
- 20:38governments constantly attempt to balance the pure,
- 20:42frictionless efficiency of academic models against the
- 20:45rigid, unyielding reality of voter behavior and market panic.
- 20:49Which leaves you, the listener, with a fascinating and honestly
- 20:53highly disruptive concept to consider as these policies
- 20:56evolve. We just explored how the right
- 20:58kind of capital tax paired with risk mitigation forces capital
- 21:02to be productive. And we are seeing real world
- 21:05governments actively stripping away historical discounts to tax
- 21:09capital gains purely on their true inflation adjusted margins.
- 21:13They are desperately trying to tax true wealth creation.
- 21:16They're searching for the most accurate measure of economic
- 21:18growth. Right.
- 21:20So follow that logic to its ultimate conclusion.
- 21:22If the Domar Musgrave effect proves that the right kind of
- 21:25capital tax actually encourages risk taking, and governments are
- 21:28doing away with these discounts, what happens if society
- 21:31eventually shifts toward taxing unrealized capital gains on an
- 21:34annual basis? Oh wow, moving from a
- 21:37transaction based tax at the point of sale to an annual
- 21:40wealth tax on the theoretical value of the asset.
- 21:43Exactly if your property portfolio and your stock
- 21:46holdings are treated under a wealth tax rather than a
- 21:48transaction tax at the point of sale, how would that reshape
- 21:52your fundamental concept of ownership?
- 21:54Does an established house remain a safe haven for storing wealth,
- 21:58or does it transform into an expensive annual liability that
- 22:01forces you to constantly generate cash just to hold onto
- 22:05the deed? It would fundamentally change
- 22:07what it means to own an asset. It really would.
- 22:09Well, thank you for joining us on this custom deep dive.
- 22:12Keep exploring the why behind the numbers.