Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E006: Drivers of Institutional Adoption and Understanding Custodial Risk, with David Thayer
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about stuff and we're
- 0:04going to be left, holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of down test. 1974 1987 1297 2000
- 0:18and whatever we're going to call this.
- 0:19It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell Awesome
- 0:31episode 6. The last trade gentleman is a
- 0:34lot going on in the world of Bitcoin and we are joined by
- 0:37David their executive advisor at Blackstone who has an
- 0:42interesting road to bitcoin and we're just riffing on it
- 0:45pre-record. Well, I was getting my audio
- 0:48fixed. You guys are pretty terrific on
- 0:50it, but I guess that stands as a good jumping-off point, David is
- 0:54your journey to bitcoin? And how you transition from the
- 0:58incumbent Financial World and found thick winter.
- 1:02Very passionate about her right now.
- 1:05Yeah, sure. Well it's a pleasure to be here
- 1:06and of course, I should preface it by just saying that obviously
- 1:11speaking on my own behalf, not a black stones but but as it so
- 1:16happens, a partner of mine at the firm and I both tend to lean
- 1:22libertarian were turned on to bitcoin way back in 2011 and it
- 1:27kind of immediately resonated because we serve understood the
- 1:31alternative fee on story and I forget the exact price of the
- 1:36time, you guys would know what it was eight cents or eight
- 1:38bucks or something. It's just so preposterously low
- 1:41but you know, the firm was growing and we had other
- 1:45distractions. So he neither of us did anything
- 1:47about it tragically? Even though we kind of set it.
- 1:50So the use case immediately and then it so happens that some
- 1:57years later, Alex, glassy and I, who am I known, by the way for
- 2:01years? I mean I was help helpful and
- 2:03launching hrf. And rights Foundation back.
- 2:05And I think 2005 got to tell you about Bitcoin and this is like
- 2:11the mid teens maybe and as you know, he was sort of the tip of
- 2:15the sphere when it comes to using Bitcoin.
- 2:19For the purposes of assisting dissidents around the world and
- 2:23his story as well done. Thank God, because it's done so
- 2:26much good for the world, but even then, I was sort of like,
- 2:30you know, swapping and comparing notes with with Alex.
- 2:35And yet still not investing partly.
- 2:36I'm sure out of Pride. And and finally in 2020 he gave
- 2:43me a good kick in the pants just like he sent me an article while
- 2:45in Alden. He's like, it's about stinking
- 2:47time. And thankfully the the pricing
- 2:50was fortuitous. So I got some of the upside but
- 2:53but you're forgetting who knew about it in 2011.
- 2:55It's kind of tragic that I didn't do more with it at the
- 2:59time, but while I'm on that point, I should mention as well
- 3:03that and I mentioned this Down in Miami outside hosted a
- 3:06function at the Bitcoin conference that you know,
- 3:10originally I was kind of think of it more as, as a financial
- 3:13investment. But now, perhaps you share this
- 3:16view, I see it as a social investment with a financial call
- 3:20option embedded because there are all many, there are already
- 3:25so many compelling, use cases that go well beyond investing in
- 3:29the hope that number go up. Yeah, it's a classic story that
- 3:34the three touch points over time with increasing regret and then
- 3:39acceptance. As part of that Journey,
- 3:43everybody has has their story for that.
- 3:45I mean, for me as a millennial, it was watching in 2013 seeing
- 3:51technology money, Digital internet, money shoot up in
- 3:54value and thinking and thinking I should have been on that.
- 3:59Like that was that was my bread-and-butter.
- 4:01My wheelhouse as an internet native I missed out and then you
- 4:06know that's the first point of regret for me and then you hear
- 4:08about it again and then he finally getting on the third
- 4:11time but you're right that it's it's an important aspect of
- 4:18Bitcoin that we don't talk enough about that by
- 4:21participating in Bitcoin. Your you are growing the network
- 4:25effect which benefits The whole world, it benefits, anybody
- 4:28who's in Bitcoin now, but it benefits, anybody who could
- 4:32benefit from Bitcoin in the future, which is everybody the
- 4:35entire world and especially everyone who's unbanked?
- 4:39Because if Bitcoin succeeds were elevating, the everyone in the
- 4:45world who's been cut off from 22, traditional finance and
- 4:48Banking and property rights. And so you participate in you
- 4:53coming to bitcoin even if you're, you know, upset that you
- 4:56should have In 2011, but you're prepared to get in and 2020 and
- 5:002021 that adds another node to The Social Network of Bitcoin.
- 5:07And, you know, adds to that exponential function of the
- 5:12network effects value. And that helps Elevate people
- 5:18who don't yet, know they need Bitcoin and we'll get the get
- 5:23here, 5 10, 15 years from now. Yeah one thing.
- 5:26Yeah David you shared in it I find you just hear heard of the
- 5:31past few years and if you have talked about it before but I
- 5:34don't think of it told you or maybe this group is 20/20 was
- 5:37almost like this this spiritual enlightenment that happened in
- 5:43that year where we talk about now like there's a lot of things
- 5:45happening in Marin I talk about this offline, a lot you see on
- 5:47Twitter, it's just like this Overton window moving but also
- 5:52in 2020 think about the amount of the number of people that
- 5:55came into the space and part of into Bitcoin and understood it
- 5:58and they had been hearing about it.
- 5:59There's a lot of people are like 16 17 18 but was 2020 when they
- 6:02really like put time and capital in and one of the common
- 6:05thoughts is it's because of you know M1 money supply the
- 6:08trillions that were printed and that was no mistake of was part
- 6:11of that. But what I found in my time and
- 6:15in like when we all were onboarding folks and capital was
- 6:18that, that Bitcoin you say. It's like it's not a an IQ test.
- 6:22Is a common sense test in the same function that it doesn't
- 6:24require supervision. Colleges requires time to look
- 6:27at the problem in the reality is most people don't have the time
- 6:30because they're, you know, the hamster wheel of life with their
- 6:32family or work in a net 2020. People are locked in a box and
- 6:36so, they were just able to look at this problem and understand
- 6:38like what I've been hearing about this.
- 6:40It's just fascinating that there was a lot of bad that happened
- 6:42in 2020, but at the same time, so many people were woken, like,
- 6:45woke up to what's happening. They'll never look backwards and
- 6:47to what happened before, or looking at the same way.
- 6:51Yeah, exactly. By the way, I should one think
- 6:55about it. Let me just share that.
- 6:56You know, I went to my first Bitcoin conference in Miami and
- 6:59I'm sure you guys were there in 2021 following my own little
- 7:04Surrey orange. Pilling thanks to Alex and he
- 7:08don't like being the nor merely I fly in.
- 7:12I figure, I'll just go right from the airport to the
- 7:13conference. So I have my luggage I'm
- 7:16wearing, you know, like normies not a sued but almost and you
- 7:20know, everybody's here in cargo shorts and flip-flops.
- 7:22And, you know, there's that line circling around the block and
- 7:26I've finally get into the venue and I'm like, okay, so where can
- 7:28I put my luggage there, like a luggage, like, what are you
- 7:30talking about? It's like, you know, I'm like
- 7:32preparing for like a corporate conference.
- 7:34And that was, that was sort of emblematic of, you know, the,
- 7:40the Wall Street nor me kind of waiting into the Bitcoin space.
- 7:46Well, that yeah, that's, yeah, that's true.
- 7:49People in Bitcoin are here to have here, to have fun because
- 7:51the they're casting off the old world and Don't want to wear a
- 7:56suit to a conference, sorry to interrupt Jesse when you know it
- 8:00also reminds me that give the contractors, obviously, I've
- 8:02gotten ever more professionals, the last couple had been just
- 8:05yelling wildly well-produced, I thought, and and so we're kind
- 8:10of. I hope meeting in the middle
- 8:11somewhere where as this piece is maturing and then other people
- 8:14are kind of entering the space as well as we as we grow.
- 8:18I think that's right. I think, I think the reality of
- 8:20this is as Bitcoin moves through the adoption, curve becomes More
- 8:26mainstream it. People are going to show up more
- 8:31and more professional. Because currently like early
- 8:34adopters, if you got in five plus years ago, you already have
- 8:39a little bit of fuck you money from that.
- 8:41And like you don't need anything.
- 8:43If your 2011 adopter, you're showing up to a Bitcoin
- 8:46conference to celebrate, you're not, you're not there to make
- 8:50deals probably and you know as as Time goes on and people are
- 8:57showing up to conferences because they're trying to, you
- 9:00know, Network or do something and professional seeing, I think
- 9:05that element will creep in and it will be a source of
- 9:13disappointment for early bitcoiners.
- 9:15You know as the culture shifts from the celebratory thing to a
- 9:18more professionalized environment.
- 9:20But that's that's the reality of successful adoption is you know,
- 9:23it becomes a professional. Part of the world.
- 9:27And, you know, there will always be that, that, that early set,
- 9:30but you know, Bitcoins for everyone.
- 9:33Yeah. Yeah.
- 9:35That able to later but the, the this BlackRock ETF in the
- 9:40follow-on ETF proposals filings are I think, to symptomatic,
- 9:48that Jesse right. I mean it's, you know, it's kind
- 9:51of going mainstream and it's reading this ripple effect,
- 9:54whereas like the Islands of the world think of crap.
- 9:57What are we doing here? And I'm sure, you know, I've
- 9:59heard the three of you say some of that as well.
- 10:02And yet by the same token is probably inevitable and maybe
- 10:07maybe it's worth to sort of accepting the inevitable and
- 10:09figure out that help us to go from here.
- 10:11I'm not sure. yeah, I think, I think there's two things to
- 10:16build on with this particular line of thinking, With Parker a
- 10:21couple of weeks ago, we sort of ran through the volatility
- 10:25question that people have like how can Bitcoin be store value
- 10:29if it's so vile tile? And I think Parker did a very
- 10:31good job of explaining. Why that can be the case and
- 10:35similar here with what you're saying earlier, Jesse is people
- 10:39get in early. See a lot of value creation as
- 10:43Bitcoin monetizes and most of the public looks at bitcoiners
- 10:48in the space and says, hey, you guys are just looking To get
- 10:50rich looking to pump your bags but you mentioned as Bitcoin
- 10:54Network effect, grows it benefits everybody.
- 10:57So I think that's another thing we can touch on is yes there are
- 11:01people who are early adopters, who will benefit massively from
- 11:04this but even the laggards will benefit from bitcoind option and
- 11:08the network effect that grows and then building on that
- 11:12obviously institutions, like BlackRock Fidelity.
- 11:14Citadel getting to the space will significantly increase the
- 11:18network effect on a liquidity. In Bitcoin and within the
- 11:23network. And so just building on those
- 11:25two things. Number one, why does Bitcoin as
- 11:28it appreciates benefit everybody and not just early adopters and
- 11:33what has been the Catalyst to push more institutions into the
- 11:36space? Yeah.
- 11:41Well, you know, the other thing, too.
- 11:43I know that you guys know this, but it's like, do we really
- 11:49resent? The guys who did the early
- 11:54pick-and-shovel work when it comes to, for instance, the
- 11:57internet. I mean, I'm sure there were some
- 11:59who, you know, resent that wealth.
- 12:01But I don't hear a lot about it and sort of social discourse and
- 12:06I'm hoping that the same goes for Bitcoin that over time
- 12:09people. Like, all right.
- 12:10Well, you know they're early adopters kind of one the brass
- 12:14ring but is that so bad? That's just kind of the American
- 12:17story. Yeah, I wrote a piece about
- 12:21this, a few months ago, this was, this was one of the final
- 12:26reservations. I had about like fully embracing
- 12:29Bitcoin future was everyone has this this feeling that?
- 12:34Because there's a finite Supply, whoever got, you know, a large
- 12:37chunk of it, early is going to be wealthy forever.
- 12:40You know, and their their future Generations will be you know the
- 12:44Billionaire's of 100 years from now and that's true to some
- 12:49extent. But the the American parallel of
- 12:54real estate in the west really helped provide an example for me
- 12:59of how this has played out in the past over the last couple
- 13:02hundred years and I'm in California, and then California
- 13:08land was originally distributed. David via the Rancho system that
- 13:11the Mexican Government set up and that was here.
- 13:16We're going to give you Mexican citizen that we trust 10,000
- 13:20acres of Southern California and land.
- 13:24It's, you know, it's rugged and you're going to have to you're
- 13:27going to be our Steward, our, you know, legal representative,
- 13:32the landowner responsible for this large chunk of land and
- 13:36Southern California. And that's how the LA area.
- 13:40All of south southern California was distributed to landowners.
- 13:44And of course, now fast forward a hundred hundred hundred fifty
- 13:48years. There aren't any 10,000-acre
- 13:50ranches in California anymore because those successive
- 13:55Generations sold off big chunks of those ranches, all of those
- 14:01ranches in most cases, in order to fund their lifestyle because
- 14:05suddenly there were sitting on a very valuable asset and they
- 14:08wanted to, you know, enjoy that well, 'The so they sold large
- 14:12acreage and parcel that often to real estate developers.
- 14:16So that's how you know, large chunks of wealth distribute over
- 14:21time in our recent history in the in the American story.
- 14:24And that's how Bitcoin is going to go as well. yeah, love that
- 14:31analog Yeah, I happened to come across that, because I went to a
- 14:39wedding for, like, six generation descendant of one of
- 14:43the one of those Ranchos, you know, families.
- 14:47So he of the family that that area is named for.
- 14:52And and, and so there's all these personal stories of like,
- 14:58you know, in fighting and you know, having to pay the
- 15:02inheritance tax. Over time and how do you do
- 15:05that? You sell more land.
- 15:08So you know very human way to learn about that mechanic of
- 15:12wealth distribution over time. Yeah, one thing we talked about
- 15:18that is a little controversial in the spaces, they like the
- 15:21order of operations on, you know, the people come in and
- 15:24Bitcoin is for everyone and it benefits everyone.
- 15:27But the reality is the majority. There's a centralization of
- 15:31capital in North America and nodes and there's just a
- 15:34function of the money coming in, providing more liquidity and
- 15:37providing more value for everybody, including emerging
- 15:39market. And I think that kind of
- 15:41sometimes gets misdiagnosed as we need to go to Certain markets
- 15:45and it makes sense to go everywhere and you know, have it
- 15:50make sense to go everywhere and expend the resources in time.
- 15:52But from a prioritization standpoint to benefit everyone
- 15:55at least in my mind, there is this function of building the
- 15:58right products for Capital to flow in because of that
- 16:02liquidity profile benefits everyone.
- 16:04And this ties into you know the black rocks and Citadel and
- 16:07everybody get a space. The reality is the markets going
- 16:09to give us and we have to take it and then build around it
- 16:12redundant or resilient products this is partially why?
- 16:14He ran on Iraq but I think there's not enough discussion
- 16:18about in my mind. Where is the focus we have
- 16:23exchanges, we've had the exchanges that look similar for
- 16:26the past 10 years. We have custodians that will
- 16:27look very similar the past 10 years and it's like how do we
- 16:31bridge that Gap with institutions pensions endowments
- 16:35into making them feel comfortable, whether it's with
- 16:37the familiarity of like asset management, style product,
- 16:40Services client services, and so, I guess, maybe on that date.
- 16:44I'd be interested in kind of like yeah, give it your
- 16:47background, what it is, what's been the thought, you know, up
- 16:50to date again, not speaking from blackstone's perspective, but
- 16:53just within your peer group on this asset class and looking at
- 16:56it as a alternative asset amongst others, you know, any
- 17:01thoughts you can share their own what, you know, the past I think
- 17:04you said you had involvement since 11:00 but not really until
- 17:062020 having a personal allocation but any thing you can
- 17:10share on just your peers and their familiarity or feedback
- 17:13about Bitcoin. sure, well, I guess if you things that mean
- 17:18one, is that You do look and feel counts for something.
- 17:23And so I think as the space develops sort of the less Tech
- 17:29Centric interfaces that that one encounters the better because
- 17:38you know if it looks and feels too techie and I've noticed this
- 17:43in logging on to some other exchanges and custodians you
- 17:48know the greater the barrier and that goes for Rules as well.
- 17:51But you know when it comes to institutions, I think one of the
- 17:54things is here reputational and I think we've been done no
- 17:57favors by the conflation with defy.
- 18:00And some of the harsh shows that were totally predictable that we
- 18:03witnessed over the past couple of years.
- 18:06And so, will collectively have to do a better job sting pushing
- 18:08ourselves. I know that everyone on this
- 18:12call is doing their best. To kind of make that happen, but
- 18:15beyond that too. I think it's ultimately about
- 18:20Safety security. The sense that one's Bitcoin is
- 18:26stored appropriately and that gets a lot of attention as you
- 18:30can. Well, imagine the institutional
- 18:32space, no matter what the asset class and, you know, ultimately,
- 18:36if one looks kind of underneath the covers and reads between the
- 18:40lines, not, not to mix metaphors.
- 18:42But it's, you know, it's really about making sure that the
- 18:47individual decision makers are not making massive mistake.
- 18:50Aches. And so something does go south.
- 18:54It's not sort of like, how could you have allowed that to happen?
- 18:57It's not sort of a career risk. And so there's a lot of focus
- 19:00placed on that. And so is a space isn't as a
- 19:03community. I think as we roll out new
- 19:05products and this would go for Honor.
- 19:08A well that you're placing an emphasis on that, I think would
- 19:15do a lot to gain institutional acceptance and then yeah.
- 19:19As as The ETFs come online. Assuming they do, I think that's
- 19:23going to go a long way in that direction, even though you know
- 19:26there's a lot of hair on these things that may not be ideal.
- 19:28Maybe we can discuss that a little bit later but I guess
- 19:31offhand. Those are some things that I
- 19:33think would help us matures a space and then as we give past
- 19:36this defy thing and Bitcoin is able to distinguish itself, I
- 19:41think it will gain some acceptance and let's face it
- 19:43already in the late. Teens, I think was Harvard and
- 19:46some other well-known endowments had invested in Bitcoin.
- 19:49So it's not like on unheard of and the the Sharpe ratios and
- 19:54the lack of correlation traditionally except for I guess
- 19:57it was last year has really, you know, reflected well upon the
- 20:04space not to mention the the world beating returns over the
- 20:09course of the past 10 years. Yeah, that's actually a super
- 20:14fascinating on me. It's something that Parker we
- 20:17talk a lot about is like you don't want to be an application.
- 20:20It's not technically it's not a technology application because
- 20:22it looks that it's almost like the prettier it is.
- 20:24It's almost scarier that he can just all evaporate you know
- 20:27versus something that's tangible.
- 20:29And then that also remind me of I think over time or this next
- 20:32test decade will see a Resurgence in like the corner of
- 20:36the corner bank or the bank that is it'll look you know dealer
- 20:40will merge with the traditional bank or just be a No, like brand
- 20:43new firm, where you take something that's ephemeral,
- 20:45that's out there. And then you're able to put a
- 20:47for a face and a name, and the kind of a, you know,
- 20:49accountability to it, where you can actually sit and talk to
- 20:53somebody. Because right now, everything
- 20:53went digital on the banking side, but I think there's
- 20:56something there that will play over the course, the next decade
- 20:59to build trust within the ecosystem.
- 21:02Yeah, one of the thing, actually, two things.
- 21:04One is the self custody is shown.
- 21:06I know you're working on solving some of those problems, but
- 21:10yourself custody still such Such a hurdle for people to a degree
- 21:14even including me it's like if someone can kind of crack that
- 21:17code to help people understand it and the importance of it and
- 21:22make it kind of user-friendly. I think that would go a long way
- 21:25and I should have mentioned earlier to that you know
- 21:28emphasizing as a community emphasizing the social good that
- 21:32Bitcoin does I think would go a huge way toward insertion
- 21:36accepted because that's that's not like some sort of gloss that
- 21:39were applying to the space. That's absolutely real.
- 21:42Intangible and and I don't think a lot of people are fully aware
- 21:47that it still has, you know, gets this sort of in this used
- 21:50for money launderer and this is like such an old story.
- 21:54And, of course, it ignores the, the place that good old cash
- 22:00plays in that whole sort of underground economy, and and so
- 22:05Bitcoins, even better than cash, right?
- 22:06I mean, even did you see the interview with?
- 22:08I think was no seem to lab that CNBC had done recently.
- 22:12We're he acknowledges that as sort of disadvantage of Bitcoin
- 22:16that can be too easily audit. I'm like wait what?
- 22:18Like that's that speaks. Its favor.
- 22:22But nonetheless and mental pretzel that guy found himself
- 22:25in on that CNBC interview is just an it's amazing.
- 22:28Bitcoin exposed is basically everybody over me enough time.
- 22:32Right. Right.
- 22:33You mentioned auditing and we were talking before the the
- 22:38podcast about you know, the various pieces of Background or
- 22:43specifically like traumas that led you to realizing the Bitcoin
- 22:47had legs or had value. And one of the things for me and
- 22:50I share this with a number of of Bitcoin Riders was, I was, I
- 22:56went through an accounting program.
- 22:58I went through the same accounting program is pure
- 23:00Richard, which was really training people to become
- 23:03Auditors in Big Four firms and then, here you encounter this
- 23:08thing. Once you get onto the surface
- 23:10and you start learning about it, it It's itself every 10 minutes.
- 23:15That's that's an incredible dream for someone who's you
- 23:18know, had to appreciate the importance of the audit function
- 23:24in from an academic sensor, whatever.
- 23:28And and here it is, this this dream realized and that was one
- 23:32of the pieces for me of like, oh, this has value.
- 23:37And and David, I was curious to hear a little bit of if you care
- 23:41to share about. You know, the sequence of events
- 23:45that led you to realize, oh, Bitcoin has value.
- 23:50Yeah, well maybe it's best cast in the light of what I did wrong
- 23:53which is so after that series of Revelations around about the
- 24:002020 timeframe, I then became interested in defying again,
- 24:04I'll mention that Alex warned me against it but nonetheless, I
- 24:07couldn't help myself. And so I went down that rabbit
- 24:10hole found a very interesting and you know, do you as if I
- 24:13miss Bitcoin? Maybe I can take advantage of
- 24:16the you know this growing. Space called defy invest in a
- 24:21few firms, you know, sort of hedge funds in that space and
- 24:26thank God. Thank God, I came back from the
- 24:282022 Bitcoin conference in the scales fell from my proverbial
- 24:35eyes. And I realized that no no, no,
- 24:38no, it's all about big point. And so they asked our advisor to
- 24:42ditch all those Investments and get back to bitcoin, only just
- 24:45in the nick of time. So, Yeah, I mean I kind of now
- 24:51recognize what doesn't have value at least in my estimation
- 24:54and and what does and you know Bitcoin is we've discussed has
- 25:00value Beyond just sort of mere Financial measures and it's
- 25:06really exciting. The you know the vibe.
- 25:08And I've been told this by others, the vibe and a Bitcoin
- 25:10conference is very different than at these other defy
- 25:13conference because there's other conferences are devoted to
- 25:15making money and I've no problem making money or Gail.
- 25:19Like, I'm a free market here, and I think that does a lot of
- 25:22social good for the world. I mean, that's the beauty of
- 25:24capitalism is that the profit incentive leads to exciting
- 25:28products at cheap, prices for everybody.
- 25:32And makes poor people much richer than they would otherwise
- 25:36be. It benefits the poor more, so it
- 25:38does anyone else. And so that's so it's not that
- 25:40I'm casting aspersions on the on the profit motive, arm, free
- 25:44markets. It's really just that there are
- 25:46these collateral benefits that Accrue to bitcoin Investments.
- 25:51And, and you know, there again, it benefits the poor most.
- 25:55So, the vibe at a Bitcoin conference very different
- 25:57because I think a lot of us are there because it's like, you
- 26:01know, to become sort of a social Mission and and it's really
- 26:04exciting. It's a, it's I mean, I love
- 26:06those conferences. I'm sure you guys do too.
- 26:09Yeah. And on that point, just to
- 26:12really sort of draw the picture for anybody, maybe new to
- 26:16bitcoin and new this podcast, particularly we discussed it
- 26:19last week and Michael mentioned, you order of operations.
- 26:22And I'm a big believer that one of the first order of operations
- 26:26for Bitcoins, long-term success and realizing the benefits it
- 26:30has for society more broadly is the energy sector, really tying
- 26:35Bitcoin mining as a part of the stack for the Energy sector
- 26:40makes them more profitable makes them more efficient and really
- 26:43helps dry prices, lower in the energy sector so that's just one
- 26:47way we're talking about the monetization of Bitcoin.
- 26:51Yes. Early adopters will massively
- 26:55benefit from its monetization process but one thing we have to
- 26:58mention is the goal of Bitcoin is to create a sound monetary
- 27:01system in the digital age of end of everybody benefits from that.
- 27:05Even if you're the very last person to adopt Bitcoin that is
- 27:08what has Really corrupted the world right now is the ability
- 27:12to corrupt, the pricing mechanism of the global economy,
- 27:16which is effectively the dollar right now, and if you can
- 27:20manipulate interest rates and expand and contract, the
- 27:22monetary base on a whim that really doesn't allow the market
- 27:26to have an accurate pricing mechanism, which Bitcoin brings
- 27:29to the market. And when it does, the economy
- 27:32globally, will be able to be able to be facilitated much more
- 27:38efficiently, capital Ian again, will come with true opportunity
- 27:42costs which in the long run makes forces people to make
- 27:46better decisions economically that hopefully increase
- 27:49productivity drive down prices and allow people that operate
- 27:54throughout the economy. Using good information, which is
- 27:56the pricing mechanism and then beyond that, just the network.
- 28:00So that's the asset side of things and the energy side of
- 28:02things and the peer-to-peer Network really drives value for
- 28:06individuals, like David was mentioning People in Emerging
- 28:11Markets or who are living under despotic regimes, the fact that
- 28:15Bitcoin is a peer-to-peer Network on top of that.
- 28:17And then the network can't or not the network, the despotic
- 28:23dictator or a government who doesn't like what you say what
- 28:26you say about a particular subject, cannot prevent you from
- 28:30accessing the network. So you have the energy Story,
- 28:34the accurate pricing mechanism in the peer-to-peer Network
- 28:37which can't can't. Don't show prejudice against
- 28:41individuals. It's fascinating because which
- 28:44you just described eloquently is very simple, but the mental
- 28:49model like it's inherently a positive sum game and I think
- 28:53David is waiting to like all coin and crypto, is it is a zero
- 28:56sum game, it's similar Fiat, you know, there's just a world where
- 29:00you can create more of the unit and it centralizes and all the
- 29:04things we know that come along with it.
- 29:06But when we talk to institutions endowments individuals, It just
- 29:10it doesn't match to the way that they were born into the world
- 29:14and how they think about the unit.
- 29:15So to hear that there was a singular unit and everybody
- 29:18benefits from it and you from an order of operations on how
- 29:21capital is allocated opportunity costs it doesn't map.
- 29:25And so there's just this like again period were just trudging
- 29:29along and people waking up and it's little find that point
- 29:32whatever. The number is, where then it's
- 29:33like accepted. But until then if there's just
- 29:36this like mental Gap that exists and what Marty just said that.
- 29:39It makes so much sense, again being common sense but still
- 29:42does not map to Fiat crypto in like almost traditional Venture
- 29:47where it's like, something's bigger faster better.
- 29:49So I need to go that route versus like this is the thing
- 29:51that works now we can all just benefit from it.
- 29:54Yeah. When Marty was talking there
- 29:57that this probably happens for everyone but I'd say probably
- 30:00once a week I get hit with just, the Staggering significance of
- 30:06Bitcoin, you know? And that was happening for me.
- 30:09I was Marcus. In about, it's just remarkable
- 30:12that it's the Silver Bullet for, like, the two most important
- 30:16things that you could try to install in the world, which is,
- 30:21which is, you know, abundant energy to Advanced civilization,
- 30:26abundant energy and deflationary, currency currency
- 30:30that allows Savers to grow their purchasing power over time, just
- 30:34by Saving and and those two things are fused together in
- 30:38Bitcoin. And it becomes this the most
- 30:43important cause in the world today it is like being a part
- 30:48of, you know, the American Revolution, you know, in our
- 30:52modern era. It is a it is a Cosworth
- 30:54advancing worth devoting your time to because it, you know,
- 30:59this is Western Civilization ideals embodied in an asset and
- 31:07this is this is the dream. And it and that's after that's
- 31:12after years and years, full time digging into it, it only becomes
- 31:16more and more true. And so, you know, yet for anyone
- 31:19whose early in their Bitcoin Journey, as far as I can tell
- 31:24your eyes are not deceiving you, it really is.
- 31:27The most important thing happening on the planet today in
- 31:31terms of Human Rights and liberties And it's very
- 31:38darwinistic in a sense like if you don't adopt it, but are
- 31:40repercussions, it's part of, I don't know if this is the right
- 31:44time, we have on the list, the chat about City lagging
- 31:47inflation and what's happening with small businesses and I
- 31:50thought about this for years and I seen this in a while this in a
- 31:54small taco shop. I think I'm even tweeted about
- 31:57it, but it was like it was a like deli style or style like
- 32:01style where you go up and you see the price the market market
- 32:05for You know the tacos and like the inputs or there, but it was
- 32:09like two years ago they started having the the it was almost
- 32:14like electrical tape over it. So the black because it was just
- 32:17constantly changing and this was like in the middle of Texas and
- 32:21I had this realization because it was another one across the
- 32:23street. But this one had like constant,
- 32:26you know, they at least were ahead in understanding it
- 32:29because what happens is a lot of restaurants is they don't
- 32:31actually know the inputs and they don't keep track because
- 32:33they're performing what they want to do or they're good at.
- 32:36You know, cretan, hospitality and food.
- 32:39And so, This Heart of this restaurant, was actually at
- 32:42least ahead of it in the sense of like, okay.
- 32:44Well, I know my inputs from the grocer or from like, you know,
- 32:47trios or tomatoes or increasing. So, I have to change the price,
- 32:50I can stay in business. A lot of restaurants actually
- 32:52don't operate like that. It's crazy, but it's just the
- 32:54reality and realizing will. And I try to talk to Mel
- 32:58Bitcoin, it didn't work out. But the idea was like, well,
- 33:00this firm at the end of the day, once we know what, we know, and
- 33:03the price appreciates or the cost of all the It's whether
- 33:06it's the, you know, actual like capex, op X.
- 33:10That the only way they stay alive in the stay around
- 33:12overtime, is for them to hold, and start accepting Bitcoin.
- 33:16And I was like, about two years ago and then some of the stuff L
- 33:19at Marty's gonna like, jump into it.
- 33:20But just thinking through like, in this future state with what's
- 33:23happening in the market and inflation.
- 33:25And inputs and essentially recession.
- 33:27And there's less buyers for those goods unless you're
- 33:29holding a currency that appreciate some time.
- 33:32You're basically working against yourself to the point where you
- 33:34won't be able to operate, and It was just yesterday or two days
- 33:37ago. I saw like Bed Bath & Beyond got
- 33:39acquired the like IP and rights for 20 million dollars which is
- 33:43just shocking to me because like you just assume like Bed Bath
- 33:46and Beyond it took a subsidiary of Best Buy, I don't know,
- 33:49hundreds of millions of dollars. Maybe a multi-billion dollar
- 33:52Corporation at one time and it got bought for twenty point five
- 33:55million dollars from some other you know p4r.
- 33:57It is just I think that's the way most businesses will see
- 34:01unless they understand what Jesse Martin what we're
- 34:03discussing here and recognize it.
- 34:07And we'll just the next 10 years will just be a like basically
- 34:10proof of those and to add more color to this a newsletter about
- 34:16it on Monday, or Tuesday, I believe.
- 34:20But Michael was actually you, he sent me a picture over the
- 34:24weekend when you went to get a haircut and it was essentially a
- 34:27letter from the owners of the salon saying hey it was a long
- 34:32one page letter that said, hey, we're really feeling the
- 34:35pressures that mean Mission, they specifically reference the
- 34:39CPI print from last June and explained that their input cost
- 34:44on the product side heading. Crease by 26%, their labor craw
- 34:48costs, had increased by 22%, I believe, and do to those cost
- 34:55pressures. They are forced to raise their
- 34:57prices on July 1st, which really sent me down.
- 35:01Like a thought experiment is okay.
- 35:03Like they reference the 2022. The June 2020 to see Pi print,
- 35:08is something that they recognized then but they did not
- 35:11raise their prices until a year later, they are not raising
- 35:15their prices until a year later and so as Michael just mentioned
- 35:18there were some Savvy entrepreneurs who are adjusting
- 35:21prices on the go as their input costs were Rising, but there has
- 35:26to be this subset of the economy, whether it be a salon
- 35:31shipping business, a pesticide business that really tried to
- 35:35keep prices stable. Bowl so that business want to go
- 35:38to competition and I actually wrote that is letter, send it
- 35:42out and I got a few responses of people and business owners, who
- 35:46said, yes is exactly what's going on.
- 35:49We've had our labor costs, go up significantly and we've held
- 35:52prices stable so that our customers don't go to the
- 35:55competition. However, the pressure is getting
- 35:58so immense that we can't hold anymore.
- 36:00So that's the sort of lagging inflation effect.
- 36:06That I think could hit markets later this summer.
- 36:09Is this subset of entrepreneurs who have helped prices stable in
- 36:14the face of rapidly Rising input costs that simply cannot hold
- 36:18back the damn of these pressures anymore are going to be forced
- 36:22to raise prices. How large is that subset?
- 36:25I guess that's yet to be seen. But I do think there are at
- 36:28least anecdotal data points that prove that there are businesses
- 36:32operating this way we could see price inputs increases.
- 36:37Throughout the summer. Yeah, one thing to add to that
- 36:40Marty is a data point. Peter say Jones talked about it
- 36:42this week of from 2020 2021 manufacturers have their input
- 36:46costs at a certain price that they're either held on like it a
- 36:51like a today already had it held it and so the price change from
- 36:55that time to you know because of inflation.
- 36:58So let's say the input was nine dollars on their book and they
- 37:00had a job in a generally. Sold for 10 they were okay with
- 37:03selling it for 1112 and it hit the book says Like an increase
- 37:07in Revenue which is basically what United States this year is
- 37:09showed from like a GDP but the reality is like that cost is
- 37:13going to increase their underlying you know capex off X.
- 37:17And now they're upside down with you know just the numbers and
- 37:20how and then also just the amount of people that are
- 37:23available to buy it at that price increase and then I think
- 37:26a different parallel but it's the same concept is what we see
- 37:29with like credit card debt and just the different functions of
- 37:33debt from the household that has increased.
- 37:36Because reality is a state. They're trying to stay constant
- 37:39with either, what they're used to living by or they're using
- 37:43debt to keep that constant, but the same time, like I can only
- 37:46go so far before, either they default on it or a bunch of
- 37:51other things associated with not being able to afford the cost of
- 37:54living that they're used to all just trending to a certain
- 37:57direction that is not good for anybody.
- 38:02And by the way, I should mention like there's so many
- 38:05misunderstandings at least in my view when it comes to inflation.
- 38:08Like I would argue that what the three of you just mentioned is
- 38:13not as really going to drive inflation.
- 38:16It's a symptom of inflation which in turn is obviously a
- 38:18symptom of rampant money printing to fund.
- 38:23What are often sir, boondoggle expenditures.
- 38:27And but so, what will happen as a result of what you're
- 38:32describing is that it's it's not necessarily going to drive price
- 38:35increases its symptomatic of excess liquidity and inflation
- 38:39in the economy, what will happen and maybe this is just sort of
- 38:43an obvious truth. But I'll say it anyway, is that
- 38:45it's going to impinge Upon Our standard of living rather going
- 38:49to spend less or going to save less or we're going to give away
- 38:53less to worthy causes. And that's ultimately what's so
- 38:57crushing about inflation and among alone among the four of us
- 39:00on this call? I remember 70s inflation.
- 39:03And that's exactly what happened.
- 39:04There was some it was it was horrific and we're just
- 39:09repeating that Playbook and the seventies inflation resulted
- 39:12from the many of the same factors, it was the Vietnam War
- 39:16and it was about wildly increased government spending
- 39:23serve as a result of the so-called Great Society
- 39:25programs. And we just didn't have enough
- 39:27money to go around to pay for which, obviously led to the
- 39:30events of August. I think was Teen was 1971 and
- 39:34divorcing ourselves from the gold standard and you know,
- 39:36we've been sloshing around liquidity ever since.
- 39:39Yeah, we didn't have enough gold to go around and so we changed
- 39:45what money meant at that point in time in order to make it
- 39:48possible to pay all these things.
- 39:49And I think that's like it's such a fascinating part of, I
- 39:54don't know. I spent many years in school
- 39:57learning about business and finance and never really History
- 40:02of how we went off the gold standard.
- 40:04Why we went off the gold standard?
- 40:06It was the escalating cost of Vietnam that were causing us to
- 40:11clip, are pegged to gold which which precipitated the French
- 40:18sending an aircraft carrier to New York City demanding, their
- 40:21gold, which we were holding for them.
- 40:23And then West, Germany was threatening to do the same in
- 40:271971 and those combined factors led to all right, Right.
- 40:32Well, we're going to just, you know, break the convertibility
- 40:35of gold and closed the gold window and and then that allowed
- 40:41for us to inflate away our debts, which is what the 70s was
- 40:48and my favorite chart in the WTF happened, in 1970 one.com,
- 40:53fantastic, set of charts to scroll through the most
- 40:58compelling. One is how there's a up until
- 41:011971 productivity and worker compensation we're lockstep.
- 41:06And then at 1971 they worker compensation flatlines while
- 41:14productivity continues its up and to the right trajectory,
- 41:18which is to say that by switching to a Fiat money
- 41:22standard, it became possible to You do not keep up with wage
- 41:29increases and not pay your your workers more despite the fact
- 41:35that they are continuing to produce more and that is kind of
- 41:39the point in time where the middle class starts to road.
- 41:43If you think of what has happened over the last 50 years,
- 41:46it's been a strong middle class. As you know, in the several
- 41:51decades built in the several, several decades following World
- 41:53War Two being eroded. Into into Despair and diseases
- 41:59of Despair. And the hillbilly elegy sort of
- 42:03world that that we now find ourselves in where we're more
- 42:07radical or populist politicians, have a greater reception in a
- 42:16more welcoming base because there's so much pain and
- 42:18suffering in the in the middle class, what used to be a proud
- 42:22middle class and it all comes back to that.
- 42:26Only one moment where? Because we start to change what
- 42:31a dollar means the measuring stick started to shift, faster
- 42:35than workers were able to demand that.
- 42:39They be paid more. And of course, there's there's
- 42:42globalization factors and offshoring that are also a part
- 42:46of the story and, and Technology technological deflation playing
- 42:49in as well. But you know, to me when I went,
- 42:54you know, having gone down this history, Recent history of money
- 42:57Rabbit Hole it all, feels like that was the point in time where
- 43:03the American way of life reached its Zenith and we have been
- 43:08eroding quality of the standard of living for for, you know,
- 43:13your median American ever since and it all comes back to the
- 43:18money, which is this surprising thing.
- 43:20It's not about politics really. You know, that's the thing that
- 43:24we fight about. The real driver under all of it
- 43:28is that your money buys you less every year and your wages are
- 43:35not keeping up with that. And then here's the solution,
- 43:39this Sly roundabout way of taking back that those rights of
- 43:44having a monetary unit, where your money buys, you more every
- 43:49year. And that's that changes.
- 43:52The world and it restores the American Values, that that got
- 43:58us to that place of preeminence and in the 50s 60s 70s.
- 44:05Jesse has floated, right? I mean it's I think you did
- 44:09write him. It's, you know, it has
- 44:13manifestations that one wouldn't expect to see whether it's the
- 44:16it maybe it was you Morty, I forgotten, but it's a quality of
- 44:19the architecture, its its ears example.
- 44:25I used to tell a buddy of mine when we see sir rampant over
- 44:28development in the Philadelphia area and Marty perhaps you're
- 44:30familiar with this here, are these beautiful Beautiful horse
- 44:36country, that's been overrun with these subdivisions.
- 44:39And I used to say to a friend, you know, thanks Central Banking
- 44:44and he thought it was nuts, but actually think there's some
- 44:47truth to that. So in addition to what you said,
- 44:49Jesse you also witness what austrians would call
- 44:53malinvestment. So you're seeing investment.
- 44:55And in assets that really do us. No good.
- 44:58Meanwhile, starving other sectors of the economy of
- 45:03investment that would do us. Look good.
- 45:05So, you have to ask the question.
- 45:06So few, do why did cars, why didn't buildings?
- 45:11Why did everything seemed to go? Downhill around about the
- 45:16culture, art it, go on and, on around about that time and one
- 45:20could argue it really does kind of boil down to the money.
- 45:26Yeah, to that point and something we're touching on
- 45:29earlier, is how do we really Drive Bitcoin?
- 45:32As this force of optimism in the world and and it's noon here and
- 45:37see how That's the the challenges of summertime
- 45:46outdoor, according, huh? Yes, yes, what has to be to be
- 45:51worried about that, going forward after recording, right?
- 45:53This time. But that point, Like, Jesse you
- 45:55mentioned, people are really focused on politics and they
- 45:57think Red vs. Blue, the other side driving the
- 46:00problems and is really created this framework of argumentation.
- 46:04That people have been stuck in for decades and no matter who's
- 46:07in charge, whether it's red team or blue team.
- 46:10We keep going into More debt, we keep misallocating money and I
- 46:14think that's something that we've all tried to do and
- 46:17probably do a better job of, but it's really moving the frame,
- 46:20moving the over to Windows like stop fighting Red Team Versus
- 46:23Blue Team. The money is the core of the
- 46:26problem. Like the polarity that we see in
- 46:28red versus blue is really being driven by the money Printing and
- 46:32the degradation in quality of life which is forcing people to
- 46:36go out and ask questions. Why is my life getting worse?
- 46:40Why am I not able to buy as much wine?
- 46:42And I be able to pull myself up for my bootstraps, when somebody
- 46:45pre 1971 was able to do so in a seemingly easy fashion, if they
- 46:51were motivated and productive and again the red team wants to
- 46:55bring the blue team, the Blue Team wants to blame the red team
- 46:59and we really need to figure out a way to move the framework of
- 47:02argumentation to. It's not red team versus blue
- 47:05team. You guys are driven to polar
- 47:07opposite sides of the spectrum because there is bad things
- 47:11going on in your life. Life.
- 47:12But your misdiagnosing, the problem and instead of attacking
- 47:16the quote unquote, other you should be attacking this thing
- 47:19that you're not even pay attention to, which is how money
- 47:21is created and distributed throughout the economy.
- 47:25Yeah. I think what's been interesting
- 47:27is if you think a lot of these discussions for years have been
- 47:30for the middle class, the lower class that need to preserve
- 47:36wealth and that others were like oh I'm fine, you know High net
- 47:40worth individual. We talked about Little bit David
- 47:42last pod, but that is starting to see more and more.
- 47:45Now with individuals that are already retired and how they
- 47:48plan their life, and the next 20 or 30 years and see that slowly
- 47:51being eroded. Because they had this thought
- 47:54that they save x amount and they're they're perfect.
- 47:57And then as you start to look at the inputs and the costs of you
- 48:00know, whether it's the vacation things, it starts to change that
- 48:02Dynamic and that goes up the stack and whatever's cost,
- 48:05whether it's the building the Investments or the deflationary
- 48:09things that we're seeing in like basically restructuring of debt.
- 48:11And that ten million dollars an hour not it doesn't exist
- 48:13anymore, he's part of your portfolio.
- 48:16So I think it's just it's just a function of like the times or
- 48:19Marty's point of seen both sides like has nothing to do with the
- 48:22politics has to do with much deeper rooted problem and
- 48:26everybody starting to recognize it because everybody balance
- 48:29sheet is starting to be hit year-over-year where their
- 48:31purchasing power decreasing Which ties it at engines and
- 48:35endowment conversation, right? It's like everybody's starting
- 48:38to become upside down. It's like how do they fix that
- 48:40hole? Plug it?
- 48:42Yeah, I've called all in skirt. Just the, the scenario here that
- 48:45I think a lot of retirees are probably in right now.
- 48:49Let's say you did really well as a baby boomer you, you've got a
- 48:54nest egg of five million dollars right now, fantastic.
- 48:58You did a great job and you know, that your bonds, you've
- 49:02you're shifting to 80% Bond portfolio.
- 49:05You want to play it conservative.
- 49:07You know your bonds are getting four percent right now.
- 49:10Fantastic, you're making two hundred thousand dollars a year
- 49:14and you're thinking. Okay, great.
- 49:16I'm making two hundred thousand dollars a year and when I've
- 49:20started out a house cost 50,000 dollars, I'm doing great.
- 49:25You know I'm crushing it. I can live off a two hundred
- 49:27thousand dollars a year and and live.
- 49:31Well for the next Next 20, 30 years, whatever it is.
- 49:37But the sneaky part is that inflation, the money printing
- 49:41that has to happen over the coming decades because of the
- 49:44amount of national debt. We've accrued 32 trillion at
- 49:48this point, the fact that we're already running two trillion
- 49:51dollars a year and in fiscal deficits and now we're adding
- 49:56interest expense on the national debt whereas before we had 0%
- 50:00interest rates for the last 10 years now it's suddenly 5%.
- 50:03We're looking at adding 1.5 trillion on top.
- 50:06Of our annual deficits that we've normalized over the last
- 50:0920 years, because we haven't balanced a budget since Clinton
- 50:13and that four percent return that people are going to be
- 50:16making, that are making right now.
- 50:19That's not going to cover the real cost of inflation every
- 50:23year. So every year, you're actually
- 50:24going to be losing wealth just by sitting in bonds.
- 50:28And that's this scary burning platform that I don't think
- 50:31retirees realizes there right now and that necessitates It's
- 50:36looking at what are the Assets in my portfolio that can
- 50:39actually generate reliable yield?
- 50:42And the weird thing about it is that the bonds the thing that
- 50:45you have been able to rely on and trust for you know since
- 50:50World War Two. Those are going to be the losing
- 50:53bet and the scary new internet asset, might be the thing that
- 50:58replaces the function of bonds of what that delivers to a
- 51:03portfolio. And so David, really excited to
- 51:05hear your Her thoughts on how pensions are navigating this.
- 51:09And if that scenario that I just laid out Rings Trove for, you
- 51:15know, the folks that you deal with Well, I think to your point
- 51:22and, you know, partly this is observation partly direct
- 51:26experience over the years. But is that because a lot of
- 51:30folks to my surprise still haven't asked the fundamental
- 51:32question as to what is money that they're not yet fully
- 51:36realizing the pickle, they may find themselves in and secondly,
- 51:41I've found that actually to the point where just making that it
- 51:45takes a while for people's perspective to shift, so, And
- 51:49dollars may seem like a lot of money to a baby boomer, but, but
- 51:53that was that was when they were younger that was a fortune and,
- 51:56and now it's it's more commonplace to kind of make that
- 52:01kind of money and then it was, you know, 50 years ago
- 52:04obviously. And so so I think that shift in
- 52:09perspective is changing. But one thing I will say when it
- 52:11comes to institutional investors is that you know, and I think
- 52:15Michael you'd mentioned this earlier that sometimes I have a
- 52:17hard time Finding which bucket is the appropriate?
- 52:22One into which to place a new investment and it did witness
- 52:28that first and and in our own sort of hedge fund life but I
- 52:33think absolutely Bitcoins that way.
- 52:34And that's why shorthand monikers like digital gold can
- 52:40really help get us. I think over that hump.
- 52:42It doesn't really tell the whole story I know we're ultimately
- 52:45seeking kind of means of exchange.
- 52:47But for now you know, Digital gold is an okay way of looking
- 52:50at it. I know that I think was Parker
- 52:52Lewis who recently mentioned that you know, it's okay.
- 52:55You know it's like it's okay to be a store of value.
- 52:59It can also still function as a means of exchange.
- 53:02But be that as it may I think just think of it as a store
- 53:04value is enough and it'll be you know very soon that these
- 53:09institutional investors are going to see their portfolio
- 53:12returns begin to decline because of the devaluing dollar and
- 53:16they're going to be few places to hide and Marty had mentioned
- 53:20earlier. I wanted to bookmark this as
- 53:21well just in terms of telling the story for institutional
- 53:24investors. In addition to what I just
- 53:25mentioned you know, the energy rap is a bad one.
- 53:29I think we all know that, and it's going to be hard to kind of
- 53:31get people over that hump. But one thing that should help
- 53:35them is that is the least two of the things that.
- 53:38Again, I think we know, but but we'll have to do a better job of
- 53:41conveying to the institutional space which is that when it
- 53:44comes to energy usage we're doing a lot of good when it
- 53:47comes to you know, load Lansing and securing the grid and and
- 53:53flaring gas. That would otherwise go to waste
- 53:56and be burned up into the atmosphere.
- 53:58So and then co-locating energy sources.
- 54:01I think Jeff Booth is talked about this in ways that in areas
- 54:06of the world including places like Africa, that previously
- 54:09couldn't take advantage of this energy now, can it's really
- 54:13exciting and Bitcoins making that app?
- 54:15And so, I think it's not just about the financial use cases.
- 54:19We've talked about it but it's the social use cases.
- 54:22Well, I think going to help us tell a story.
- 54:25Yeah. David on that note one thought
- 54:27we had a discussion this week Jesse and I and the team at
- 54:30on-ramp were talking with advisor group that oversees our
- 54:35helped, you know institutions to the tune.
- 54:37I think close to 30 billion dollars, understand various
- 54:40assets and one of them is they set up the blockchain, you know,
- 54:44task force or Consulting Group and you know, internally there's
- 54:49an Individual that, you know understands the signal or has a
- 54:51thesis around the signal Bitcoin versus you know blockchain and
- 54:54wants us to speak to it and part of the discussion on just in my
- 54:58side or the team side is like what does it look like to tell
- 55:00that story and historically with individuals we've gone through
- 55:04and previous lives with Parker and others.
- 55:06It's like you tell the story of, you know, whether it's the fed
- 55:08and inflation or the history of money and what constitutes a
- 55:12good money and I don't think there's a right or wrong but one
- 55:15of the thoughts we had in it kind of touched on what you just
- 55:17described is what What do they look at it?
- 55:20Like, what are their buckets? And so there's like this
- 55:21alternative asset class bucket. And there's this just trend from
- 55:252010 to 2020. This is directionally like 10
- 55:27trillion that is allocated. All turn to holds now.
- 55:30It's like will double that. And so there's this growing
- 55:32Trend in, you're looking for, you know, yield and to go into
- 55:36different alternative Investments and going to, okay?
- 55:39We'll term investments income. You know, one of the things are
- 55:41gold and Bitcoin is a better form of gold and let's talk
- 55:45about the principles of scarcity and starting off a base that can
- 55:48just meet them. Them where they're at and we all
- 55:50know that there's much more happening there, but I think
- 55:52it's, at least something we're going to test versus going to.
- 55:56Let's talk about money because once you start getting the
- 55:58money, and then you're basically telling them that we're on a
- 56:02different planet effectively because they're used to being a
- 56:04being on one planet. And if everything they know,
- 56:06now, we're saying, well, actually, you're not even on the
- 56:08right Planet, it just, it either turns them down the wrong
- 56:12direction, or it just gets a longer cycle of them
- 56:16understanding because they're coming at it from a different
- 56:18angle. And then one other note on that
- 56:21is the counterparty risk. I think we talked about this.
- 56:26You Mortals are goes for years about like what would you rather
- 56:28have it is an individual like 250k and BTC in cold storage or
- 56:32million dollars at a bank and you saw that kind of play out
- 56:35and I think most people would recognize that there's there's a
- 56:38discount on the money that you don't holders to the money, you
- 56:40do hold and I think that's going to overtime, start to become
- 56:44more, evident with institutions endowments and the like that as
- 56:48you start Art, you know, not only looking to have the
- 56:51annuities in the payments for your constituents, but then
- 56:53also, you can have the restructuring, the default.
- 56:56These, you know, there's so much billions of dollars allocated
- 57:00that we're going. There's no way that it can all
- 57:01just kind of stay, you know, solvent.
- 57:04There will be things that go to 0, but the, this it being scary
- 57:08that you may not be able to own that or like, basically thinking
- 57:11of the Wily coyote and underneath is are it's like, we
- 57:14know stocks and equities, you know, equities are inflated, we
- 57:17know bonds, you know, kind of Of hot potato, it can fall out any
- 57:22point. It's like what is that value
- 57:24premium of knowing that the PTC sits there similar to Gold, you
- 57:28can take possession and I think that we're still so far from
- 57:30that on the institutional side. But I do think if that Trend
- 57:33grows and what we thought of them, but individual side will
- 57:36continue to grow to the institution down because it's
- 57:38just game theoretical at that point, right?
- 57:40So you want to know you own the money to pay for the liabilities
- 57:43that you have and there's a world where you wake up and you
- 57:45don't own the money. And I don't think we're that far
- 57:47from that. Well, every year that Bitcoin
- 57:50exist makes the story a little bit easier to tell because the
- 57:53Bitcoin goes to zero, scenario becomes, you know, sort of
- 57:57recedes Beyond The Event Horizon and so and thereto.
- 58:01I think that the real concern that people have had over the
- 58:04years, certainly in these social spaces, will it be outlawed?
- 58:08And I think we're seeing that receipt as well and rightly so,
- 58:14but, you know, to your point Michael another easily
- 58:17digestible way. A to put it when speaking with
- 58:20institutional investors is, you know, Commodities have cycles
- 58:23and we're seeing already as Larry will.
- 58:25Pardon others will be sure to mention is that gold and silver
- 58:29to arguably are about to enter into a new commodity cycle.
- 58:33I would argue it's completely predictable because of, you
- 58:35know, again, the money printing in the last couple years, but
- 58:39even if it's just a cycle, I think he could talk to an
- 58:42Institutional Investor and say. Yeah, you know, this is very
- 58:45much like gold but as you said Michael to even better for the
- 58:48Following reason so you don't have to go into the, what is
- 58:51money? Are you on a different planet?
- 58:54Kind of, you know, rabbit hole because that's, that's a harder
- 58:57sell it. We can say that for the, like
- 59:00In-laws in the family members. So, you know, one of my favorite
- 59:03stories are Marty's Uncle hidden talent.
- 59:05I guess he he he probably told you can definitely better than I
- 59:08can. Plus you'll be I was a very it
- 59:12was a very adamant Schiller back in the 2013, 2014 error.
- 59:17And before the price run up your during the beginning of the
- 59:22price, run up during that cycle, essentially sent me email to a
- 59:25couple of my uncle's who are well off.
- 59:28Like, you guys should be looking into this, like, we've
- 59:30completely messed up the money. Here's the coin, here's how it
- 59:34works. And one of my emails off of my
- 59:37mother, her emailed, my mother and told her that I should not
- 59:42be giving crackpot, that's good advice successful.
- 59:46People like I should never reach out to pick people that she'll
- 59:50Bitcoin in that passion for the evening is I think you're crazy
- 59:55anyway then you can get away with saying things like that.
- 59:59Yes, it's funny too because it sounds in the 2017 bull market
- 1:00:03was Schilling, the Ripple so it all comes back full circle.
- 1:00:06So wait, what's so what do your uncle and your mother say now?
- 1:00:10now, I mean now that with the benefit of hindsight, I think
- 1:00:16for my uncle me being on Tucker, Carlson was a big, was a big
- 1:00:19Tipping Point for him? Where's they got Tucker gets it
- 1:00:22and you're talking about Bitcoin on Tucker, Must Be a thing but I
- 1:00:25think they get it was very early on.
- 1:00:27I was young I was like 22 as well, not as articulate and put
- 1:00:33together as I am, as I like to think of myself now.
- 1:00:36I think I've definitely gotten better at approaching it.
- 1:00:39And that's one thing everywhere I was talking about this, This.
- 1:00:44If we yesterday or the day before, yeah, it was.
- 1:00:47So I record a podcast with Sam wouters from River.
- 1:00:50We were talking about his most recent research report that he
- 1:00:53put out for them on Global Payments, remittances and
- 1:00:56Bitcoins Bitcoins position in that world.
- 1:01:00And he's done a lot of Education over the years and really the
- 1:01:04best way to approach Bitcoin education.
- 1:01:06We both agreed honest. Ask questions don't sort of give
- 1:01:10a full-frontal like here's we messed up the money.
- 1:01:14People don't know what money is. It's like, Michael was just
- 1:01:16saying you people, where they are the best way to do that is
- 1:01:19to ask questions. Like what do you understand
- 1:01:21about Bitcoin? How are you thinking about it?
- 1:01:25It's probably what I should have done in 2014, but I was a Brash
- 1:01:29young, man. You're, you're a nightmare for
- 1:01:32Thanksgiving dinner because most people have that, that Uncle who
- 1:01:37likes Target Tucker Carlson. And it will bring that into the
- 1:01:41conversation and create a rift. A few people have the the guy at
- 1:01:46the table who was on Tucker Carlson.
- 1:01:48It can speak with additional Authority about you know
- 1:01:51actually I know what I'm talking about here.
- 1:01:55Yeah staring it's still a no-go discussion for be at
- 1:01:59Thanksgiving. It's not worth it it's again let
- 1:02:03people come to you and then ask them questions.
- 1:02:05That's my approach to pick one education uh and it's in the
- 1:02:09green and Thanksgiving generally the Schiller and Thanksgiving
- 1:02:11gets it short-lived and the next Thanksgiving is Just like what
- 1:02:14did you tell me to do? Yeah.
- 1:02:18What else is new? I guess one thing Marty said
- 1:02:22about meeting people. I think like there's a great
- 1:02:25asymmetry and meeting people where they are.
- 1:02:28We're talking about David's background and the institutional
- 1:02:31space and knowledge. But also understanding back when
- 1:02:34understanding money and thinking about these things from first
- 1:02:36principles, its part about this part of the podcast, part of all
- 1:02:38the stuff we're building with on ramp, but just thinking about
- 1:02:41this pot as well, that like, very often the fund.
- 1:02:45And we think about the trust's like, well, Why hasn't it been
- 1:02:48done that? Where you can take deliver and
- 1:02:49click rule. There's there's reasons behind
- 1:02:51it and it has to do with the traditional person coming into
- 1:02:54Bitcoin was from Wall Street. They're probably never send a
- 1:02:57transaction, they may never want to, they're worried, there's
- 1:03:00Logistics that go into place and then on the other side of it,
- 1:03:03the individual that is concerned about custody and, you know, is
- 1:03:07fine with saying, you know, the mechanics of sending transaction
- 1:03:09wants nothing to do with anything structured around a way
- 1:03:13to bring in and meet people where there are and that's okay,
- 1:03:16and it's perfectly fine. Everything's cold lives in both
- 1:03:18of those worlds and it's what makes us such a great
- 1:03:21opportunity. Usually, you can play and have
- 1:03:24your feet in both and in that is where all the, you, I think next
- 1:03:2710 years of whether it's, you know, wealth will be generated
- 1:03:31but also relationships and network will continue to grow
- 1:03:35because you can kind of see, like, okay, I understand there's
- 1:03:37principles the Bitcoin to make it different than everything
- 1:03:39else. But I also understand there's a
- 1:03:40reason why the traditional World kind of structured around that.
- 1:03:43And how do you form fit? It around Bitcoins properties.
- 1:03:46So it has longevity. Eva tea while also still median
- 1:03:49individuals that hold the Capital because the reality is,
- 1:03:51it's 99.9% of the capital still sitting with individuals and all
- 1:03:55these other assets and needs to come into Bitcoin.
- 1:03:57And you have to be able to provide people people with the
- 1:04:00right products services and also to articulate in a way that
- 1:04:03meets them, you know, where they're at, so that you can make
- 1:04:08that on board and a seamless as possible.
- 1:04:11Yeah. I keep thinking about sort of
- 1:04:15combination of what what Michael and David were saying that, you
- 1:04:18know, in some ways we over complicated because for for
- 1:04:22institutional allocators, the story is still or should be.
- 1:04:27This is digital gold and this has a role as just that mean
- 1:04:30that the two word thought can really get the message across in
- 1:04:36terms of what this acid can do as a starting point.
- 1:04:39And that's the thing that you, you know, They aren't aware of
- 1:04:42it is digital gold as the minimum of what Bitcoin is.
- 1:04:47But you know, I love the story of the Winklevoss twins because
- 1:04:54that's their thesis. That's, that's how they got into
- 1:04:57Bitcoin in 2011, think they bought Bitcoin when it was $11,
- 1:05:03you know, they were fresh off of their Court winnings vs.
- 1:05:06Duck. I forget how much they they got
- 1:05:10from that. I think it was like, 60 Million.
- 1:05:12And I think they plunked like 10 million, but into Bitcoin,
- 1:05:16because they heard about it at a party in Ibiza beach, party in a
- 1:05:20Visa, and they looked into it. And I did the research and, and
- 1:05:25the thesis became for them, that this is digital gold, and it
- 1:05:29will match Gold over time. And that's, that's all.
- 1:05:33They thought it was. I think that's all.
- 1:05:35They still think it is. And obviously, they've because
- 1:05:39they don't fully understand Bitcoin.
- 1:05:41They've gotten, To altcoins and taking on some some, you know,
- 1:05:45gotten into a little bit of trouble with some yield
- 1:05:48products. So they don't fully understand
- 1:05:50Bitcoin. But they understood it enough
- 1:05:52and they still understand it. Enough to have a position and
- 1:05:55hold on to that position and that has turned them into
- 1:05:58billionaires and you know that we're still so far from that
- 1:06:04gold valuation that gold parody. That's I forget, that's
- 1:06:08something like four hundred thousand five hundred thousand
- 1:06:10dollars per Bitcoin. To match Gold in terms of the
- 1:06:14total valuation of that asset. And that's enough, you know
- 1:06:17that's a 20 x from here and if we can make that case to
- 1:06:24institutional allocators they can see that this is a has an
- 1:06:32asymmetric upside and is something that is currently
- 1:06:34missing from their portfolios on Jesse to it occurs to me that
- 1:06:41you know, We spend a lot of with this conversation talking about,
- 1:06:44how do you sell institutional allocators on bitcoin, But
- 1:06:47ultimately, I think the sales pitch is and it's self-evident
- 1:06:50to us. But potentially not to
- 1:06:54institutional investors that this will this is ultimately to
- 1:06:57the benefit of your underlying constituents, whether it's a
- 1:07:01pension holder, or what have you and, and we shouldn't lose sight
- 1:07:06of that, perhaps obvious point because this isn't about like,
- 1:07:11As something as crass is, just, you're maximizing returns
- 1:07:15months, as we want to do that on a risk-adjusted basis.
- 1:07:17It's really about making sure that we can meet the liabilities
- 1:07:21that in the case of a pension that they've accrued over time
- 1:07:25and the obligations, they owe their underlying pension
- 1:07:28holders. And so there is a noble purpose
- 1:07:31here beyond what we believe to be the noble purpose of Bitcoin.
- 1:07:35But strictly speaking within the institutional space it's about
- 1:07:40you know, No, expanding the footprint of an art museum, or
- 1:07:44yeah, meeting the obligations. You may have to a pension holder
- 1:07:48and many of whom are blue collar and you know, the First
- 1:07:52Responders and so forth. I mean, it's um it's I think
- 1:07:56that's something that ought to be explicitly conveyed.
- 1:08:00When we are talking to folks in the social space because it
- 1:08:05Bears mentioning now that is a really great point because it's
- 1:08:09something that I Thought through and as I've talked to the team,
- 1:08:12you think about going outbound and you go reach out.
- 1:08:15The reality is, we talk about it returns and numbers, but at the
- 1:08:17end of the day, it's all about people individuals and how
- 1:08:20they're basically livelihood is impacted vile the stand.
- 1:08:23So this we talked about being a positive sum game that you like,
- 1:08:26imagine what better world can you be that you can actually
- 1:08:29make, you can still be capitalistic, you can still
- 1:08:31generate and build a business. But at the same time, impact
- 1:08:34individuals, from what helped to save them, but help them benefit
- 1:08:40from where Are we all know this is heading, right?
- 1:08:43Because there's going to be winners are going to be losers.
- 1:08:45And so yeah, it's a great point. To really like, get back to the
- 1:08:48first principles of that, there's individuals that have
- 1:08:50liabilities over them. There's also individuals that
- 1:08:52are thinking about this and they're worried about their own,
- 1:08:54you know, situation as far as their balance sheet and meeting
- 1:08:57them and helping them. Understand it goes so much
- 1:09:00further from like an empathetic standpoint that I think will
- 1:09:02resonate. I think I can go across from
- 1:09:04anybody that's trying to get people involved or at least just
- 1:09:08paying attention to what's Happening Here.
- 1:09:15Can I go back to the point of risk-adjusted returns with
- 1:09:19Bitcoin? Specifically?
- 1:09:20I that's always one of the things that has perplexed me
- 1:09:25from the institutional class is because I used to work in a
- 1:09:28managed Futures fund. And so, we would index commodity
- 1:09:30trading advisors, we would fight for five percent portfolio,
- 1:09:34allocation in broader, and bigger portfolios of hedge funds
- 1:09:40and stuff like that. And it was the pitch was simply
- 1:09:42like, hey, obviously manage features aren't sexy but when
- 1:09:46things go to shit like they will be there to protect the the
- 1:09:49value of our overall portfolio with an uncorrelated return and
- 1:09:55when it comes to bitcoin and I think that's very obvious and
- 1:10:00putting that managed Futures hat on and it should be low lift
- 1:10:04where people are going institutions like, Hey we're not
- 1:10:06asking you to a pin, put fifty percent of your assets into
- 1:10:09Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 1:10:11We may believe that would be a smart move.
- 1:10:13Sure. Sure there's a lot of career
- 1:10:14risk with that but at the very least you should be looking at a
- 1:10:17small one to five percent allocation in case the rest of
- 1:10:21your portfolio blows up and Bitcoin does succeed.
- 1:10:23Can at the very least create stable value for your portfolio
- 1:10:28or in a optimistic scenario, increase the value of your
- 1:10:32portfolio and allow you to pay back those liabilities.
- 1:10:34They have Yeah, there's an irony here that we've reached a point
- 1:10:39in Bitcoin. Adoption has reached a point
- 1:10:41where it is much riskier to have a zero percent allocation to
- 1:10:44bitcoin. Then it is to have a one percent
- 1:10:46allocation to bitcoin. And most people haven't made
- 1:10:50that cognitive leap yet. So there's a lot of people
- 1:10:54taking on risk that there are not aware of because they
- 1:10:58continue to bucket Bitcoin as Internet Monopoly money.
- 1:11:03Now that's exactly right. And I'm certain, I'll No, I have
- 1:11:06them run the calculation but there must be those who have,
- 1:11:10but if you were to run the risk Frontier calculation, if Bitcoin
- 1:11:16is in your portfolio, I'm sure that you're getting a better
- 1:11:19optimized risk-adjusted return than if it were not there to
- 1:11:23your point Jesse. And I'm not sure what the
- 1:11:25optimal percentage allocation would be.
- 1:11:26But what I tell, I'm not sure what you guys do.
- 1:11:29But what I tell friends and family is just what's the harm
- 1:11:32in a one percent? Allocation, I don't think is
- 1:11:35going to 0. But what if it does, you know,
- 1:11:37you're still left with 99% her portfolio intact.
- 1:11:39So, so I think one percents the floor.
- 1:11:48And somewhat shift course here because I do think there is one
- 1:11:56Topic in the news that we should talk about in really touches on
- 1:12:00something that institutions have on their mind, which is custody
- 1:12:05and the counterparty risk that can exist in this space.
- 1:12:09If you don't choose the right counter party this week, we had
- 1:12:13prime trust, I guess the receivership.
- 1:12:16The files got got released to the market, and it became
- 1:12:20apparent that they really, did not know how to custody Bitcoin
- 1:12:24appropriately. So, little back story Prime,
- 1:12:27trust started doing their own custody, and transition to fire
- 1:12:33blocks, which does a lot of the, the custody for many brokers in
- 1:12:38the space, on the back end, they made that transition in 2021
- 1:12:41from their legacy address custody as they were doing and
- 1:12:45then at some point In 2021. They what the story that's being
- 1:12:52told is that they thought that they were pulling addresses from
- 1:12:55fire blocks, but they were actually pulling address from
- 1:12:57their, their, their mothballed legacy address structure which
- 1:13:02they had lost access to the private keys to.
- 1:13:04And so people were sending Bitcoin to wallets that Prime
- 1:13:08trust actually didn't have access to which highlights
- 1:13:13again, if you don't pick the correct.
- 1:13:15Custodian. Somebody who Stan's Bitcoin
- 1:13:17security and how to do it. The correct way.
- 1:13:20You could end up leveraging a third party that doesn't
- 1:13:23actually get Bitcoin or access to bitcoin.
- 1:13:25And so obviously this is a bit of a black guy on the space.
- 1:13:29You had prime trust which up until recently was one of the
- 1:13:32most trusted third parties in the space.
- 1:13:35And it has become abundantly clear that they actually didn't
- 1:13:39know how to do Bitcoin security, the correct way and so We do you
- 1:13:47not want me to him already? I think we go.
- 1:13:52There we go. So I can beg a big point of
- 1:13:55focus moving forward is all right.
- 1:13:57How do we ensure that institutions custom Bitcoin or
- 1:14:01doing it the correct way? So that you don't have this
- 1:14:05operational, risk effect institutions endowments,
- 1:14:08pensions whatever, baby, obviously.
- 1:14:12That's a big core of what on-ramp is trying to solve with
- 1:14:15multi-institution multisig. Yeah, I think 01 part
- 1:14:19independent of on-ramp. We can talk about a chill at.
- 1:14:22There's a website. I think.
- 1:14:23The thing that we talked about like this stuff in alien
- 1:14:26technology is that it's still not recognized at, this is the
- 1:14:29first asset that it can spread the, the security and risk
- 1:14:34around the multiple parties or multiple keys to sign, more
- 1:14:40multiple authentication methods. And I would go as far as to say
- 1:14:45whether it's an individual holding their own keys.
- 1:14:48Or an institution, you should look at it specifically where
- 1:14:52you have the majority of your wealth, you know, stored.
- 1:14:56So let's just say you have X percentage in Bitcoins money,
- 1:14:59maybe it's 80, 90 percent, whatever it is long-term
- 1:15:01savings. You don't want a single point of
- 1:15:03failure, it's in it just, it's again, going back to we're on a
- 1:15:08different planet. Now we're talking about Bitcoin,
- 1:15:10but the realities are in the history that we lived in is, you
- 1:15:13can call a bank. There's bailouts, you print more
- 1:15:16money, you get your socks back from Robin Hood.
- 1:15:18Different Mach that happens. You just get made whole because,
- 1:15:20and also in the United States that were used to it, but in
- 1:15:23Bitcoin that doesn't happen. And so we've just seen the past
- 1:15:2612 years of this ties into the truck, the prime trust
- 1:15:30situation. So, interesting is because
- 1:15:32people will go out and pontificate are explained that
- 1:15:34because it's a qualified custodian and Trust in Nevada,
- 1:15:36state Charter, and as always like legal structure around it,
- 1:15:39but at the end of the day, if you lose the Bitcoin, the
- 1:15:41Bitcoins gone, and good luck trying to get back the dollars
- 1:15:44or the BTC equivalent, there's ten years of History.
- 1:15:48Between Mount Cox and now of all the way up to the past year,
- 1:15:51with FTX of individuals hoping or block by hoping to get, you
- 1:15:55know, some pennies on their dollar.
- 1:15:57And so I think that's just more of a core like understanding.
- 1:16:00This is the first time in humanity that you have this
- 1:16:02after that can be held geographically in different
- 1:16:05places, or with different parties within a family
- 1:16:07structure. And then that goes from an
- 1:16:10institution, all the way down to an individual and an individual.
- 1:16:14I think of this is all this starts from individuals, whether
- 1:16:17you're explaining. Coin there, the CIO there, the
- 1:16:20president there, whatever of an organization.
- 1:16:22So generally you're going to get an individual that understands
- 1:16:25this, and then they're going to look to either buy or look for a
- 1:16:28custody solution like an on ramp or others like it and it ties
- 1:16:32into a conversation. I had with somebody and I think
- 1:16:342020 or 2021 that the common parlance is you know sell
- 1:16:38custody is the gold standard and you know single Sig or not your
- 1:16:42keys, not your coin and this guy thought the same thing.
- 1:16:45His 10 years got in like 2012. In 2013, he was in the UK, and
- 1:16:51he was a kind of person was probably a lot that was in the
- 1:16:54show and that our friends, I would say I would never work
- 1:16:56with anybody. I like non kyc, nobody knows I
- 1:16:59have the coin, don't deal with it.
- 1:17:01And then his brother passed away and mortality became real.
- 1:17:06And he had put all of this energy and his life and learning
- 1:17:09this stuff. Storing it all the capital, he
- 1:17:11had accumulated over the course of his life and then mortality
- 1:17:13became real. And he realized that his wife
- 1:17:17may get none of He gets hit by a bus.
- 1:17:19And so now he has to think about how do you protect that and
- 1:17:22think about the structure, we talked about multisig and
- 1:17:25different ways to plan for inheritance.
- 1:17:26But you can't naturally do with a single, you know, point of
- 1:17:29failure. So I think it's just more of an
- 1:17:31overarching, they want to share. It's like how you think about
- 1:17:33this asset is fundamentally different, whether it's an
- 1:17:35individual small business, or a pension.
- 1:17:39And that's what we talked about last week.
- 1:17:40It's like black rock is fundamentally, not understand.
- 1:17:42You're looking at this with at the right, the right lens
- 1:17:46because you can't put the old Playbook.
- 1:17:47Up to it. Because at a certain point over
- 1:17:49the course of that accumulation period, that basically, the
- 1:17:54denominator switches where the Enterprise Value goes up side
- 1:17:59down and the, you know, assets being held or larger than the
- 1:18:04liability. And now, everybody's worried,
- 1:18:05he's like, what happens if you lose it?
- 1:18:07And I think that by definition is what's gonna happen there, or
- 1:18:10should be in the minds of everybody because you're
- 1:18:11allocating to it to, you're expecting it to go 10x 100x and
- 1:18:15so, that should be the frame of mine, but it'll be the course.
- 1:18:18The next, you know, five to ten years, I don't think it's gonna
- 1:18:20be a slow burn in that being recognized and that's part of
- 1:18:22the Pod on-ramp is to like, help educate delhi's.
- 1:18:26Understand how to think about this and then everybody will
- 1:18:28make the decision that's best for them.
- 1:18:31But we've seen in the past few years and of again being very
- 1:18:35darwinistic. The game theory is not in your
- 1:18:36favor. If you can take the wrong steps
- 1:18:39with how you approach custody or counterparties?
- 1:18:43Exactly, just being personally, I've kind of spread the wealth
- 1:18:46around. I mean, it's hard to know when
- 1:18:49the space is still. So relatively young, you know,
- 1:18:51where best to and how best to store your Bitcoin.
- 1:18:54And and you guys are aware that I've invested in some Bitcoin
- 1:18:59adjacent funds as well. And and so, you know, when it
- 1:19:04comes to custody, I think, you know, age counts for a lot.
- 1:19:07And so being why melons been around since forever and I fed
- 1:19:11all these Around for a long time and it's, they have the
- 1:19:15advantage of, you know, the Legacy brand equity.
- 1:19:19And you guys at on-ramp will eventually acquire that as well,
- 1:19:23but connecting that to the institutional space, I think the
- 1:19:26release to get Bitcoin adoption underway, ever more, so than it
- 1:19:32already has taken place. You know, we may look to these
- 1:19:36Legacy institutions to help bring along.
- 1:19:40And then, you know, you touched on the ETF, I think you talked
- 1:19:43about this in your last pot, but you know, my hope is that if
- 1:19:47netf comes online, even if it's imperfect that it will lead
- 1:19:52people to say, okay, well, this is the easy way to get access
- 1:19:55within my IRA or my Donor, advised fund, or whatever might
- 1:19:59happen to be. But to you is let me.
- 1:20:00Look into this Bitcoin further, we're going to peel away some
- 1:20:03people who are going to say, okay let me look at this more
- 1:20:06carefully and maybe I can at least allocation allocate a
- 1:20:10portion of my Bitcoin to a more intelligent.
- 1:20:12Solution. So we may get some adopters.
- 1:20:15I think we will perhaps more so than we otherwise would have
- 1:20:17absent mainstream adoption by way of an ETF.
- 1:20:21But I know it's, you know, mildly controversial within the
- 1:20:24Bitcoin pure space. So, I'm not sure if there will
- 1:20:28be full agreement on that, but that's my personal View.
- 1:20:32Yeah I think that's something. Go ahead Martin I was just gonna
- 1:20:35say I think that's something we all agree.
- 1:20:36Like Black Rock will act as a massive top of funnel and
- 1:20:40overtime. Small percentages of people who
- 1:20:43get first access via that ETF will begin to go further down
- 1:20:46the rabbit hole. He's better security practices.
- 1:20:49And another thing to note, like, yes, I may not agree with
- 1:20:52BlackRock and they're pushing of ESG, but that's the other beauty
- 1:20:58of Bitcoin. Again, going back to the
- 1:20:59peer-to-peer Network. Anybody can access Is it whether
- 1:21:02you're a black rock or a refugee in some Emerging Market that's
- 1:21:07looking to escape the country with your wealth?
- 1:21:09There's nothing we can do about it.
- 1:21:12That's again, beauty of Bitcoin. The only thing we can do about
- 1:21:15it is try to build better more appealing products and compete
- 1:21:19on the market, which is a beautiful thing.
- 1:21:21Hopefully, Black Rock coming in. Just simply forces everybody to
- 1:21:25be sharper and build better products, which should be a
- 1:21:28massive benefit overall for the entire Bitcoin Network.
- 1:21:33Yeah, that's the one thing I will add here is that Bitcoin
- 1:21:38humbles everyone and it will humble Wall Street to some firms
- 1:21:45on Wall Street will get burned on by putting their hand on the
- 1:21:48stove and and that's because Bitcoin has its own way of doing
- 1:21:53things in this case. Custody of assets is different
- 1:22:00in Bitcoin than it has ever been.
- 1:22:03For the traditional world and Bitcoin is uncompromising in how
- 1:22:09it does things. It is what it is and you have to
- 1:22:12get on board with that you have to adapt to bitcoin.
- 1:22:16You cannot make Bitcoin adapt to you.
- 1:22:19That's just that's part of the game here.
- 1:22:21That's part of why Bitcoin has been successful.
- 1:22:25There is no compromise. And those factors mean that
- 1:22:32everyone gets humbled by Bitcoin in some way.
- 1:22:35You all everyone makes a mistake whether that's through trading
- 1:22:38or through trying to get a little juice or some yield
- 1:22:42product, en Bloc Phi and then poof, your money's gone.
- 1:22:47You burn, you burn your hand on the stove and then you learn to
- 1:22:51do things Bitcoins way and I think that we are now beginning
- 1:22:56a new chapter order of of hard learning, the Wall Street
- 1:23:02addition. And that's not to say that
- 1:23:06everybody will get burned on Wall Street, buy Bitcoin, but
- 1:23:11some will, and I think that's going to be.
- 1:23:16It's a really difficult thing to have to face that, you know,
- 1:23:21there's this incredible asset that has these remarkable
- 1:23:25properties and If you don't fully accommodate how it wants
- 1:23:29to be, you expose yourself to risk that you're not aware of
- 1:23:35and and it could burn you because of that.
- 1:23:37And then you'll learn the hard way and then you'll come to the
- 1:23:40corn on its terms and seems that sir that's just not how we as
- 1:23:45humans think because we try to bring our expertise and Wall
- 1:23:49Street, has so much expertise about how to deal with
- 1:23:51traditional assets and those two factors are going to run against
- 1:23:56each other. At some point in the next few
- 1:23:58years. Yeah, that's one of the biggest
- 1:24:01Curiosities over the next 10 years who still is around, who
- 1:24:03hasn't? Because I know it sounds very
- 1:24:05crazy, maybe not to this group but it's icy like the Netflix
- 1:24:07and Blockbuster you have this thing that just intermediates
- 1:24:09the physical world and one you know, it completely took them
- 1:24:13out and to see what financial service companies adopted, I
- 1:24:17think a shops a good example, but not at the highest tier of,
- 1:24:20you know, you know, Capital allocation but they were
- 1:24:23traditional, you know, Payment Processing Company.
- 1:24:25That is now fully We're what it looks like Embrace Bitcoin time
- 1:24:30to David on your side's. If that you're willing to share
- 1:24:33some of the learnings you've seen on your investing in
- 1:24:35Bitcoin infrastructure. How have you just approach it or
- 1:24:38thought through the dynamic in the traditional world that
- 1:24:42you've seen? And also the new world of being
- 1:24:44Bitcoin native and intersecting or like just a philosophy at
- 1:24:48all, would love to hear. Kind of English are there.
- 1:24:53Yeah, well, I'm not sure that's quite answer the question but
- 1:24:57but, you know, I guess when investing in the space, I kind
- 1:25:01of Applied the the lens that I had developed over time, both as
- 1:25:05an individual investor. But then also what I've
- 1:25:07witnessed in the space and as I mentioned earlier I think it's
- 1:25:12it's important When approaching the space whether individual or
- 1:25:17institutional to look at it and serve um, With risk in mind.
- 1:25:23And and that's why I kind of cast my bread upon the waters
- 1:25:26and and the investment of few different funds because it's
- 1:25:30hard to know, like, especially absent track record exactly how
- 1:25:33it's going to kind of pan out because everybody's basically
- 1:25:37new to the space. And but, you know, I think a lot
- 1:25:41of us in the space and other four of us are sort of active
- 1:25:44followers of folks who are intelligent commentators and and
- 1:25:49of course, a bunch of them have gotten involved.
- 1:25:51And I know Dylan's involved with on-ramp and he's great.
- 1:25:55I follow his stuff and met him a couple times and and so to the
- 1:25:59extent that they're involved in these projects, I think that
- 1:26:02provides a measure of comfort and then when they're also
- 1:26:06aligned with somebody who or team of people who also know bit
- 1:26:10about investing, no matter what the asset class that's also
- 1:26:14helpful. And then furthermore it's
- 1:26:17helpful to have somebody on the team is actually run the
- 1:26:20business of a A hedge fund or just to fund and and that's by
- 1:26:25the way, what I used to do. So, you know, it's kind of
- 1:26:28operations its Financial Acumen and then it's also Bitcoin
- 1:26:31knowledge. And you get kind of those
- 1:26:33combined together and frankly, you know, with the marketing
- 1:26:37team to boot, then I think you have a pretty special operation
- 1:26:41and thankfully there are several out there right now.
- 1:26:45I've Full Faith and confidence that there are 45.
- 1:26:49They're really going to succeed and and In general, I think
- 1:26:53their goal is to do, even better than Bitcoin would.
- 1:26:55We'll see if that's going to actually come to pass.
- 1:26:58I think there's an open question, by the way, as to
- 1:27:00whether or not, there's money to be made, because so many of the
- 1:27:02economic rents, kind of accrue to the holders of Bitcoin in the
- 1:27:06space as opposed to some other asset classes with the, where
- 1:27:11the money managers are the ones making the money as opposed to
- 1:27:14the underlying investors. But in this space, you know,
- 1:27:21it's a little bit Harder. I think, although again, it's
- 1:27:24early for the bitch, Bitcoin and Jason companies to make money
- 1:27:27that is perhaps in some other asset classes.
- 1:27:30But I think there's money to be made, and I think these funds
- 1:27:32will do well. And then to have also some
- 1:27:35Bitcoin invested on various different platforms.
- 1:27:39Is also really also. And then even give me the age of
- 1:27:42the space relatively young age, that's been my Approach.
- 1:27:45And I think, I don't know. I mean, early indications are
- 1:27:49positive and I think we're on the cusp here, obviously, of An
- 1:27:52uptick given prior Cycles. So the next few years will kind
- 1:27:56of tell the tale, but it's exciting time to be to be here
- 1:28:00obviously. Yep.
- 1:28:04Yeah, not at 10:31. We completely agree and
- 1:28:10recognize that it's in a Bitcoin World.
- 1:28:13Especially in Venture, you have to be allocating the companies.
- 1:28:16They're actually profitable and doing things the right way, will
- 1:28:20will reuse from fold actually had a great tweet.
- 1:28:22They got resurfaced yesterday that he sent out last year and
- 1:28:26basically highlighted that running a successful Bitcoin
- 1:28:29company particularly through multiple Cycles, really hardens.
- 1:28:32You You for multiple reasons that you're forced to run as
- 1:28:36lean as possible because of the volatility of the cycles that
- 1:28:39exist in Bitcoin. And then on top of that, you
- 1:28:42have a customer base, particularly in early Bitcoin
- 1:28:45adopters who are hyper focused on ux and security.
- 1:28:49So it forces you to really lean into your product, make sure the
- 1:28:53providing the most hardened bitcoiners, the best product
- 1:28:55possible and added value to their life, which should drive
- 1:28:59underlying value to your company as well.
- 1:29:02That's it's not a direct analog to traditional VC, particularly
- 1:29:08over the last 20 years where it's pray.
- 1:29:09Pray, hope you get a unicorn like uber that gets a lot of
- 1:29:14market cap. It doesn't really provide
- 1:29:15profits. It's really reorienting to
- 1:29:20basically the assumption that we're going to operate under a
- 1:29:22Bitcoin standard at some point in the future with that,
- 1:29:24Assumption of mind, like what are the successful business is
- 1:29:28going to be the ones that are actually providing utility and
- 1:29:31then getting profit. From that utility that they're
- 1:29:33providing their users in the market overall and Marty I know
- 1:29:37that you must obviously evaluate both, but if you were to
- 1:29:41evaluate, you know, the people on the team versus the the idea
- 1:29:46itself, what do you find most compelling when you're looking
- 1:29:49at new projects? I think we over-index towards
- 1:29:54the people on the team people that can actually because we re
- 1:29:58architecting a new monetary system and financial layers on
- 1:30:04top of that. And I think it's pretty easy to
- 1:30:06see if you get Bitcoin and you believe it's going to be
- 1:30:09successful and you see the future, you see everything that
- 1:30:12exists in the incumbent world and you reimagine that's going
- 1:30:15to be built on top of Bitcoin. I think that's lower hanging
- 1:30:19fruits. Really understanding rock and
- 1:30:22Sort of easy to see that these types of products are going to
- 1:30:25be built, but then it's who could actually build them, who
- 1:30:27understands Bitcoin, who understands how to create a
- 1:30:31company and a security architecture.
- 1:30:34Most importantly around custody the right way, and understands
- 1:30:38the nuances and how the protocol is changed over time, how it may
- 1:30:42change in the future and thinking, smartly about how you
- 1:30:46build your product with those things in mind.
- 1:30:49I think one of the interesting parts of that like Venture
- 1:30:52investment side as you referenced David like on the
- 1:30:56generating profits and it's very hard in the Bitcoin only space
- 1:30:59to generate profits because there's a lot, there's a lot of
- 1:31:01values be provided. You have to part with an asset,
- 1:31:03especially at a price of 20 or 30 K of do you hold it, you
- 1:31:07transacted, where's the value? But if it would have seen, it's
- 1:31:10kind of interesting recently, we saw Valor come in and Lead
- 1:31:14unchanged around. They have Investments, probably.
- 1:31:18I would say close to five. Maybe seven now.
- 1:31:22Ecosystem with lightning Labs back going some others but then
- 1:31:25Franklin Templeton and there's other firms.
- 1:31:27And it's almost like we chatted about will hold it on your
- 1:31:29balance sheet personal pension, you know, you're increasing your
- 1:31:32return, you know, during wealth, but where are the entrepreneurs
- 1:31:37and the companies that actually start, you know, holding Bitcoin
- 1:31:40or accepting it for goods and services and what happened does
- 1:31:44that change the investment profile as big as all these
- 1:31:47things propagate their kind of common knowledge of preserving
- 1:31:51wealth Giving a symmetric Edge in competition in the
- 1:31:54marketplace. What is it look like and who
- 1:31:56will be the general traditional DC's that start to recognize
- 1:32:00that? Because I think that is a an
- 1:32:02interesting landscape. They went into the crypto stuff
- 1:32:04and I think they got burned and they had her go back to her.
- 1:32:06Hopefully went back to First principles of like, what are we
- 1:32:08doing here? And some of these things are
- 1:32:10securities and all the stuff that happened the past 12
- 1:32:12months. But I think there's something
- 1:32:15there and seeing you know, traditional private PE firms and
- 1:32:18just others allocate to standard businesses that generate High
- 1:32:22returns and high profitable High Revenue.
- 1:32:25But then that lookin for whatever reason, whether it's a
- 1:32:27founder or something. Catches their bargain says, hey,
- 1:32:29we're actually starting to accumulate and store PTC and
- 1:32:32then we also just going to start recognizing that we'd like to
- 1:32:35accumulate in the best way to accumulate is via, you know,
- 1:32:37Revenue flows from our goods and services.
- 1:32:40That seems very interesting because it gives an asymmetric
- 1:32:42Edge in a world where the cost of goods continue to go up with
- 1:32:45against the dollar companies that are already within the
- 1:32:50marketplace and know. On for just traditional goods
- 1:32:53and service products, storing it in a form of currency that, you
- 1:32:57know, basically increases the the, that increases the burn
- 1:33:05rate. So basically they went from 5
- 1:33:08years to 10 years over, you know, the courts or whatever the
- 1:33:10time is as they're holding a currency that is increasing with
- 1:33:13other against all their goods and service cost.
- 1:33:17Yoga. Yeah, we took it took a lot
- 1:33:19about SATs Flows at 10:31 and really trying to hone it on the
- 1:33:23businesses that are baking. It a point to accumulate as much
- 1:33:27Bitcoin as possible on their balance sheet and I think
- 1:33:32leaning into like the people over the idea and we see that a
- 1:33:35lot in the mining space particularly here in the United
- 1:33:37States right now is bunch of people, jumping into the space,
- 1:33:41Asic prices are low. There's a lot of demand for
- 1:33:44Rackspace but what we've seen sort of Looking at projects that
- 1:33:49the, the founders that have been around for a couple Cycles
- 1:33:52definitely are approaching the mining space much smarter than
- 1:33:56those were just jumping in and seeing an opportunity with the
- 1:33:59man responds off-grid flare mitigation.
- 1:34:02They obviously see the idea in the opportunity there but in
- 1:34:06mining particularly I think mining is like the where the
- 1:34:12volatility of Bitcoin is most significantly pronounced.
- 1:34:16I think we see. See the founder being more
- 1:34:19important than the idea really acutely because unless you've
- 1:34:23been through a few cycles and understand the Dynamics of the
- 1:34:26mining industry and the economics around it, it's really
- 1:34:29hard to just jump in with a good idea and execute as well as
- 1:34:34people have been around for a couple seconds, that's actually
- 1:34:37a great point because Marty credit to end has been for years
- 1:34:40talking about the lead time and setting up these Mega Minds and
- 1:34:45what the process is an opportunity cost. we saw it play
- 1:34:47out on path, 18 months and you know that sure I think the most
- 1:34:51recent was marathon and their transition from large-scale
- 1:34:53miners to more kind of modular or more flexible you know just
- 1:34:58quick early time to get to production and you know start
- 1:35:00accumulating BTC and I think that's what we've seen also with
- 1:35:03other firms that get into financial services that if you
- 1:35:06come from General Wall Street, you know might get you up to a
- 1:35:08certain point but the reality is the underlying technology and
- 1:35:13the way that the market structure has to be built is
- 1:35:16different Another example is blocked by where they, you know,
- 1:35:19we're a darling the space for years until it was a zero and I
- 1:35:22think that's just a product is not fundamentally understanding
- 1:35:27what's happening here. Then I guess the last one is
- 1:35:28Jesse just came to mind. Jesse reference the Winkle by
- 1:35:31and they were trying to whatever the quote was do Bitcoin the
- 1:35:35right way or you know, regulate Revelations need rules or
- 1:35:38whatever they said and they were awfully close to a billion
- 1:35:40dollars because they try to get yield on behalf of their
- 1:35:43clients. So I think the person yet to two
- 1:35:46murders Point of your question, like person really matters.
- 1:35:49Especially this early on is very few people that have
- 1:35:52entrepreneurial backgrounds and also, as I've looked at this,
- 1:35:54like problem for that long to understand, oh, there's a
- 1:35:59different way to call than what somebody would just come in off
- 1:36:02the street or from a traditional Wall Street background.
- 1:36:05Think about Well also maybe a lesson in keeping it relatively
- 1:36:10simple that, you know, Bitcoin and and the case of Gemini, you
- 1:36:15know, all coins weren't enough. So they had to kind of juice it
- 1:36:19by offering these other services and that's where the, that's
- 1:36:23where they got into trouble. And so, you know, there are some
- 1:36:26really well relatively straightforward, use cases that
- 1:36:29are already being addressed and we'll see how this evolves, but
- 1:36:32it seems like when you get too cute on the margins, that's when
- 1:36:35you get in trouble. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:36:41We're that's I said this on stage during the live rabbit
- 1:36:45I'll recap it Bitcoin 2023 at the conference earlier this year
- 1:36:50is like the things that excite me most in the space from a
- 1:36:54venture perspective are the most boring products.
- 1:36:57Something like unchanged lending desk which just has
- 1:37:01multi-institution multisig with over collateralized loans,
- 1:37:07Insurance products coming to Market. at mining in the mining
- 1:37:11space just like boring sort of Arbitrage deals, we're looking
- 1:37:16for low-cost energy and then really trying to figure out how
- 1:37:18to Reduce your overall cap X from a price per per megawatt
- 1:37:25hour, it's a price per megawatt, excuse me, it's the boring.
- 1:37:30And again, this goes back to like do order of operations, I
- 1:37:32do think we will have the really exciting sort of.
- 1:37:36I think Bitcoin will consume the medium of web 3.0 eventually.
- 1:37:42But in this early stages, I think the products that are
- 1:37:45actually relatively boring are going to be the most successful
- 1:37:49and that That will allow a base to be said, for, which means
- 1:37:53more exciting products can be built, right?
- 1:37:59Yeah, we're still in that era where the base layer is where
- 1:38:05the action is at in my book and the piping and infrastructure to
- 1:38:12help people who haven't yet. On-boarded to that base layer,
- 1:38:17reach that base layer is, you know, still still the bulk of
- 1:38:22the work I think, for, for Bitcoin, and Bitcoin companies.
- 1:38:25Because, you know, we're building the In trail here.
- 1:38:31And there's a lot of infrastructure that needs to be
- 1:38:34built. And it's still Earthen ruts, you
- 1:38:37know, and and a sparse network of refilling stations and we
- 1:38:44have to bring all of, you know, the whole population over this
- 1:38:50path. And there's, there's money to be
- 1:38:53made by helping in that journey and helping people do that the
- 1:38:58right way. Well, I love that that analogy,
- 1:39:03right? Because you used to perform it
- 1:39:05explain so much and, you know, so you can imagine like a
- 1:39:08general store next to the Oregon Trail, but you know, maybe it's
- 1:39:12too early for the casino or something like that will come in
- 1:39:15time and for now, it's just about picks and shovels and just
- 1:39:19getting the basics, right? Exactly.
- 1:39:22Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:39:23Those as people died of dysentery on the Oregon Trail,
- 1:39:27the people had their Bitcoin locked and blocked by yield
- 1:39:30products It's this time. It's right.
- 1:39:38This has been an awesome conversation.
- 1:39:41We are running up on time. There any other topics you think
- 1:39:44we should touch on Michael Jesse David before we leave to sort of
- 1:39:49wrap up the focus of this conversation on where Bitcoin is
- 1:39:53and how institutions are approaching it?
- 1:39:56Why would have a question for you guys?
- 1:39:57So I haven't yet made it through True Confessions your last pod
- 1:40:02but about halfway through it. But so you know, I know that
- 1:40:07there's a recognition that the ETF products that are coming to
- 1:40:11Market or not perfect. And so I guess the question
- 1:40:15becomes from an educated perspective and viewing it
- 1:40:20through an opposite lens. You know what would make for if
- 1:40:23we're going to have a an ETF. It would make for Servant dream
- 1:40:27ETF. Yeah, so I think that the
- 1:40:32analogy that that I landed on to try to explain the good and the
- 1:40:37bad of what BlackRock is proposing is this bicycle that
- 1:40:41has one normal wheel and one square wheel and the good wheel
- 1:40:48is the grantor trust model, they've set up that allows for
- 1:40:51in-kind redemptions. That's awesome.
- 1:40:53That that is in line with Bitcoin and how people should
- 1:40:57look to You know, gain access to their Bitcoin, long term without
- 1:41:01a taxable event. The other side, the other wheel
- 1:41:05is the square wheel of BlackRock custody and governance where you
- 1:41:10know, they're applying the the expertise and experience and
- 1:41:16learnings of century of accumulated wisdom in
- 1:41:22traditional markets and saying a few things that you're leaving
- 1:41:26themselves open to a few. The things that do not jive with
- 1:41:31Bitcoin and how Bitcoin wants to be treated.
- 1:41:33One being the ability to re hypothecated whether or not they
- 1:41:36will TBD but that you know, is it something that that is done
- 1:41:42with ETFs, lending out the underlying asset to generate
- 1:41:45some more yield and that's dangerous with the coin.
- 1:41:49That's how you end up with a block 5 or 10 ft x.
- 1:41:52One point four billion dollars of paper Bitcoin that they
- 1:41:56didn't have that they owed. Reverse it.
- 1:42:00There's also the additional issue of forks and the
- 1:42:04politicization of forks since Black Rock asserts the right to
- 1:42:09choose which Fork is true. And that that's something you
- 1:42:13kind of need. You need you need to have that
- 1:42:16right establishing documents. But then it does leave this the
- 1:42:21champion of ESG and angle to potentially politicize which
- 1:42:26version of future bit. Bitcoin Fork is more in line
- 1:42:30with their politics. That's a little bit dangerous.
- 1:42:35And and those are the two big ones in my mind of why that
- 1:42:42model of the sort of traditional model of how you treat an asset
- 1:42:46in a fund is, is playing with fire when it comes to bitcoin.
- 1:42:51So, what we've tried to do with on-ramp is treat Bitcoin, the
- 1:42:57way it wants to be treated in terms Custody and governance and
- 1:43:00I think that's first and foremost by understanding
- 1:43:03Bitcoin, and appreciating its properties and wanting to do
- 1:43:08right by the end client, in terms of enabling the client to
- 1:43:13it receive all of the benefits of Bitcoin and all the rights
- 1:43:18that come with owning an asset like this.
- 1:43:22So it's a philosophical thing, it's an educational thing.
- 1:43:26And then it's Also a structural thing because having
- 1:43:32multi-institution multi-party custody is the best way to shift
- 1:43:39that the right from Black Rock or the issuer of the ETF and to
- 1:43:47the end client because when you have a multi-party custody or
- 1:43:53solution, like we've built with on-ramp, three institutions,
- 1:43:57hold the key. To the assets.
- 1:44:00And two of those institutions need to sign a transaction in
- 1:44:05order to effect control on the Assets in the vault and that
- 1:44:10makes it impossible to rehypothecation.
- 1:44:13It also mitigates the counterparty risk of you know,
- 1:44:17right now the US government could go to Black Rock and say
- 1:44:20give us your Bitcoin, you know, we know that you or coinbase are
- 1:44:25the two people that can hand it over to us right now.
- 1:44:28Now and having a multi-party custody solution makes that
- 1:44:34harder. It doesn't completely eliminate
- 1:44:36that potential but it but it requires coordination and, you
- 1:44:43know, chronological coordination as well.
- 1:44:47So, you know, those are the ways in which approaching this from a
- 1:44:52Bitcoin first point of view can deliver a better product for
- 1:44:57onboarding institutional Capital to bitcoin while and you know,
- 1:45:04making it so that they don't have to take on self custody
- 1:45:06right now and develop the processes and and roles and
- 1:45:11responsibilities of. How are we going to self
- 1:45:13custody? But enabling that in the future
- 1:45:16by when people are ready to take on self custody, if they decide
- 1:45:20that, that is a path that they want to explore.
- 1:45:23So, I hope that provides a little more color about like, I
- 1:45:27think that the ideal approach to a Bitcoin ETF is half of what
- 1:45:32black rock is done and then half of a Bitcoin first perspective
- 1:45:38and philosophy. Yeah I think just a few things
- 1:45:43to look. Jesse says the transparency you
- 1:45:45want to know if a large pool of assets we still don't even know
- 1:45:47where gbtc is Bitcoin. Is that?
- 1:45:49It's at coinbase but we never seen an address or no that's
- 1:45:51just not good for anybody. The you know obviously central
- 1:45:55point of failure, you want to produce that the ability to take
- 1:45:59possession is huge because over the course of time as a price
- 1:46:02appreciation of the asset, appreciate the risk profile
- 1:46:05changes. And then you want to at least be
- 1:46:07have that option ality to take it.
- 1:46:09One thing that Jesse didn't talk about About.
- 1:46:11And I think it's important and it had, we haven't seen in the
- 1:46:14asset management space is a, it's very easy to buy it.
- 1:46:18Like we talked about, I think I'm the last Potter.
- 1:46:20Matt did about exit liquidity, and that generally people enter
- 1:46:22into trade when the momentum is going, and then they're selling
- 1:46:25at the bottom. And, and I think a lot of that
- 1:46:27has to do in the Bitcoin space because they don't understand
- 1:46:30what they're holding and why they bought it.
- 1:46:32And so it's where I big focus at on-ramp and be part of Jesse's
- 1:46:35contact and others that were bringing on is like the
- 1:46:37educational focus and understanding the fundamentals.
- 1:46:41The price moves against your exposure you're saying oh it's
- 1:46:44not Bitcoin that blew up its Block B ft x and we haven't seen
- 1:46:48that in the space as partially why we're Bitcoin only because
- 1:46:50we can actually explain what's happening versus these other
- 1:46:52firms that are doing the long tail of crypto assets assets and
- 1:46:56baskets of all this stuff. They're kind of like sitting on
- 1:46:59their hands. If you imagine because their
- 1:47:00investors like what's happening and they can't say, oh we put
- 1:47:02you in all these policies may just blow up another
- 1:47:04unregistered Securities. They're just like whatever they
- 1:47:06tell them, they tell them but they can't tell them the truth.
- 1:47:09I can't imagine because then they're just like what Did you
- 1:47:11do this? Why did you put me in these
- 1:47:12positions? And so I think black rock is
- 1:47:15that's going to be a big part. It's like they don't understand
- 1:47:18it like maybe one person does, but ultimately the person that's
- 1:47:21having a call with a pension and endowment and institution, and
- 1:47:23they're buying the personally, pick up the phone, when it cuts
- 1:47:26in half, because it never lie will it'll do whatever it does
- 1:47:28and then something will happen. It's just a private price of
- 1:47:30the, you know, pricing Mecca pricing exposure in the market.
- 1:47:35Finding the, you know, the different equilibriums when it
- 1:47:37cuts in half, they're not going to know why there's can tell,
- 1:47:40you know, the The person is going to sell and then they're
- 1:47:42going to lose out on the games and all the things that we've
- 1:47:44seen over the course of. So I think that's a big part is
- 1:47:46like the education and being able to articulate like why the
- 1:47:49price is appreciating, why it's doing what it does, the supply
- 1:47:52mechanisms and everything, we know that goes along with it and
- 1:47:55I think that will be very helpful and institutions and
- 1:47:57building trust from going from 1% to 5% to 10% versus 1% 20
- 1:48:03because they're pissed off that you just you know you just lost
- 1:48:06they just hit 80 percent return drawdown and now everybody's
- 1:48:09yelling at them versus this. A long-term place you should
- 1:48:12size it, accordingly on your first step and then subsequent
- 1:48:15after that. Yeah.
- 1:48:19And not do it, not do it, Marty to dinner with you claim
- 1:48:21earlier, and that he's going to call and tell them to put 50%,
- 1:48:24or they should, but he won't. Hey, by the way, your occurs to
- 1:48:28me that I had said earlier, I don't know what the optimal
- 1:48:31allocation was I think. Actually, some years ago I read
- 1:48:34something that maybe nine digit put out that something on the
- 1:48:37order of 10%. Of course everybody has a
- 1:48:39different risk profile, but but then made sense and I can't
- 1:48:45quote it verbatim, but that did seem to Nate.
- 1:48:48So anyway, I just want to throw that out there now that we're
- 1:48:50talking about allegations again, you know down in Texas.
- 1:48:54We keep things pretty simple and the sayings and good friend says
- 1:48:59you buy enough Bitcoin. Where if it doubles in price you
- 1:49:02don't sell it. And if it cuts in half, you
- 1:49:05don't sell it. Yes, I love Hornet, you size it
- 1:49:08accordingly and that's like, should be your first exposure.
- 1:49:09So you're not freaking out, the price Cuts in half, you just
- 1:49:12feel good about it, you're like, okay, understand this could
- 1:49:14happen and if it doubles your not like oh my God just made
- 1:49:16incredible, gain life, changing You're out, just enough to get
- 1:49:20your first like bit of exposure and that's perfect.
- 1:49:23I did have another question which is, is alcohol.
- 1:49:27The glue that keeps the show together.
- 1:49:31So this is the July 4th pod. We're all or some of us are
- 1:49:35different places in the country visiting family, and some in
- 1:49:37mother-in-law's lake house and to in a corner of a bar, there's
- 1:49:45kids coming. So yeah, there's a little bit.
- 1:49:48My favorite part about that sign is, it looks like there's a bit
- 1:49:51of tape that covers up half of a word that and it should read.
- 1:49:55Alcohol is the glue that keeps this shitshow together, but it's
- 1:49:59over there. So bit of tape blocking half of
- 1:50:03that word, maybe I'll call is the glue that keeps this show
- 1:50:08together at some point, maybe that's enough.
- 1:50:12Our as you know, Michael, you're young.
- 1:50:15Father, I used to drink a lot. Auntie FTC in our HR and the
- 1:50:19early days early 20s and it's not worth it.
- 1:50:23Keeping drinking on the podcast anymore.
- 1:50:30Our good friend, Matt is still coming up that curve on purpose.
- 1:50:34This is the drinking, you're in the Pod.
- 1:50:36Yeah. Well, he and Jack mellors were
- 1:50:41dipping into the sauce on a recent podcast or forgotten who
- 1:50:44the host was, but they're being reviewed having just emerged
- 1:50:47from the Oslo Freedom forum. And it was clear that the other
- 1:50:52enjoying themselves as well, they should be.
- 1:50:57You got a, it's a heavy, heavy industry to be on, we talk about
- 1:51:01a lot of heavy topics and stuff like that.
- 1:51:04Everything in moderation went when appropriate I'm a fan of
- 1:51:09getting set for your Bitcoin, allocation should be 50%
- 1:51:11fairness. I kid I kid.
- 1:51:16Well David thank you for joining us this week.
- 1:51:18It's been an incredible conversation.
- 1:51:20I think whether you realize it or not individuals like yourself
- 1:51:26with your Or background coming out and supporting Bitcoin is
- 1:51:29massive for the space. If, if only for sending a signal
- 1:51:34to your peer group to like, hey, there, there is something here.
- 1:51:38And I think considering the the times we find ourselves in
- 1:51:43individuals like yourself, going out there and sticking your neck
- 1:51:46out. Your reputation on behalf of
- 1:51:49Bitcoin is is a massive benefit to the space overall.
- 1:51:55Super well, thanks for saying so and it's a pleasure to do it.
- 1:51:59It was a pleasure to participate.
- 1:52:00I'm a big admirer both each of you individually but also where
- 1:52:04you're done with on-ramp and in some of the other Associated
- 1:52:07Ventures. So thank you for having been
- 1:52:10such a worthy spokesman for the space because we need your
- 1:52:14voices and just as I mentioned you know, your writing style is
- 1:52:17so accessible, really appreciate that and and Marty your your
- 1:52:22Twitter posts keep me entertained.
- 1:52:25That too. So value to the space.
- 1:52:29Thank you. Thank you, David, really,
- 1:52:31appreciate that. And and I would Echo what Marty
- 1:52:33says is, you know, this is a game of viral propagation of the
- 1:52:39message of Bitcoin, the value of Bitcoin, and that's how we get
- 1:52:42through the adoption curve. And it's, it's everybody.
- 1:52:46But especially, as helpful when people like, you, you know,
- 1:52:52stand up and say this thing, This thing is real, it has value
- 1:52:56and people should pay attention. Yeah.
- 1:53:00Just like, oh that appreciate you.
- 1:53:01Joining also the signs of encouragement and in recognizing
- 1:53:04what we're doing because it means a lot on, you know, we
- 1:53:06come from the Bitcoin side, we think we're on to something, but
- 1:53:09then we've had no shortage of folks that have tenure in the
- 1:53:12traditional world that say, oh, this is how I see this plane
- 1:53:15out, or this is how we mirror both sides.
- 1:53:17And you know, traditional finance and then the Bitcoin
- 1:53:19Finance. Uh thanks for joining and have a
- 1:53:22good Edge alive 4th weekend and you know, see everybody next
- 1:53:25week. You guys do the same.
- 1:53:28It's pleasure that is take, mark, that I take more days end.
- 1:53:31Yeah, yeah. There we can end it.
- 1:53:33However, everybody enjoy your July 4th weekend.
- 1:53:37Do everything in moderation. Don't get too crazy out there
- 1:53:39except for your big one application.
- 1:53:42Love it.