Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Always Says Im Not Ready
Transcript
- Lucas: So we're halfway through 2026, and a stat from Gallup has been rattling around in my head — they found that 42 percent of employees say they often feel unprepared for new tasks. That's nearly half of the workforce who, when you hand them something outside their comfort zone, their first instinct is 'I'm not ready.' Luna: Yeah, I've seen that number. And I bet for managers, that phrase 'I'm not ready' triggers a mix of sympathy and frustration — because sometimes it's legitimate, but other times it's a reflex that holds people back. Lucas: Exactly. And before we dive in — you know, we keep Manager Mondays ad-free because we want these conversations to be as practical and uninterrupted as possible. If you find value in that, supporting the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps keep it that way. Just a low-key way to say the content matters. Luna: Totally. It's a small gesture that lets us avoid any sponsor-driven detours. So back to the 'I'm not ready' dynamic — what's really going on under the surface? Lucas: Right. I think the first thing to separate is whether this is a skill gap or an emotion gap. A genuine skill gap means they truly lack the knowledge or ability — they've never written a budget, never led a client meeting. An emotion gap means they have the capability, but they're afraid of falling short or making a mistake. Luna: And the tricky part is that they sound identical to the manager. 'I'm not ready' is the same sentence whether the issue is competence or confidence. Lucas: Exactly. So the manager has to diagnose before they prescribe. I like a simple three-step framework I picked up from a leadership coach named Sheila Heen — name the gap, shrink the step, and scaffold the win. Luna: Name the gap — so you explicitly say, 'Is this about not knowing how, or about not feeling ready even though you know how?' Lucas: Precisely. You ask directly: 'What specifically do you feel you're missing to be ready?' If they can articulate a concrete skill — 'I've never used our CRM reporting module' — then you've got a training need. If they say something vague like 'I just don't think I can do it,' that's an emotion gap. Luna: And step two — shrink the step — what does that look like in practice? Lucas: You break the task down into the smallest possible version that still feels like a win. So instead of 'run the quarterly business review,' you say 'start by preparing the slide deck with last quarter's numbers. I'll handle the narrative.' Then next time, they handle the narrative too. Luna: I've read research from the Harvard Business Review on what they call the 'growth zone effect.' When you give people just enough stretch — not too much — their brains actually release more dopamine, and they build confidence faster. Lucas: That aligns with what I've seen. The third piece — scaffold the win — is about setting them up for a small success. You might say 'I'll sit in on your first call and only jump in if the client asks something we haven't prepared for.' That safety net makes the 'not ready' feeling diminish. Luna: What about managers who hear 'I'm not ready' so often it becomes a pattern? At what point is it not about the task anymore? Lucas: Great question. If you've done the coaching, shrunk the steps, and provided the scaffold, and the employee still says 'I'm not ready,' then you might be dealing with a deeper issue — perfectionism, impostor syndrome, or even a lack of trust in you as a manager. Luna: Or it could be that they've learned that saying that lets them off the hook. If past managers backed off when they said 'I'm not ready,' they've been reinforced to keep using it. Lucas: That's a behavioral pattern. In that case, you need to shift the incentive. You say something like 'I hear you feel not ready. And I need you to take this on anyway. I'm here to support, but I can't let your discomfort delay the team's progress.' It's compassionate but firm. Luna: I think one of the hardest things for first-time managers is distinguishing between protecting an employee and enabling avoidance. When do you push, and when do you pivot? Lucas: Push when it's about growth — when they have the core skills, but they're afraid. Pivot when there's a genuine gap that requires training first, or when you realize the role is a mismatch. The mistake is always pushing without diagnosing or pivoting too early. Luna: Can you give a real example of a time you used this framework? Lucas: Sure. I had a junior analyst — brilliant with data, terrified of presenting. Every time I asked her to lead a findings review, she'd say 'I'm not ready.' I named the gap: 'Is it the data or the delivery?' She admitted it was the delivery. So I shrunk the step: 'This week, just present one graph — the one you're most confident in. I'll do the rest.' Then I scaffolded: I gave her the opening slide and a script. She nailed it, and over three months, she went from 'I'm not ready' to volunteering to lead the full meeting. Luna: And what about the opposite — someone who always says they're ready but aren't? That's a different episode, but it's worth noting that 'I'm not ready' at least signals self-awareness. Lucas: True. It's easier to work with someone who knows their limits than someone who overestimates. But the goal is to take them from self-limiting to self-expanding. Luna: So the key takeaway for managers listening: next time an employee says 'I'm not ready,' don't just accept it or dismiss it. Diagnose first, then coach deliberately. Lucas: And remember, 'I'm not ready' is often just 'I'm scared.' Help them face the fear, not avoid it. That's the manager's job — not to make them comfortable, but to make them capable.