Latest / The Learning Corner by Precursor / Episode #31: Do We Need a VC Prenup?, Lightspeed Becomes an RIA, Financing the AI Revolution
Transcript
- 0:00I've talked to founders who feel this same frustration, which is, hey.
- 0:04I signed up for the venture capital rocket ship.
- 0:07Now that I know more about my business, it isn't one of those.
- 0:10How do I get off?
- 0:11It's the week of May 5.
- 0:13Welcome to the Learning Corner, a Ventures podcast.
- 0:21Welcome to The Learning Corner by Precursor.
- 0:24I'm Mia Farnam, and I am joined by our GP and managing partner, Charles Hudson, where we will
- 0:29be talking through the articles and Goodreads that caught our team's attention over the past
- 0:34week.
- 0:34This week, we're also lucky enough to have one of our awesome graduate school interns, Leon,
- 0:40join us in our virtual studio.
- 0:42Welcome, Leon.
- 0:43I always learn so much from our discussions.
- 0:45Thank you for letting me join this week.
- 0:46Excited to jump in.
- 0:47Cool.
- 0:48So our first topic is a blog post from Edited Capital titled, we need a VC prenup creating
- 0:53off ramps for tech businesses.
- 0:55It addresses a growing tension in venture.
- 0:56What happens when a startup no longer fits the traditional scale or die model, but still has a
- 1:00viable business?
- 1:01The Post proposes that instead of forcing a binary outcome, either raise more capital or
- 1:06shut down, we should develop better off ramps for founders.
- 1:09Written from the POV of a PE firm, this obviously could include private equity
- 1:13acquisitions or growth buyouts that allow a company to keep operating even if it doesn't
- 1:17have venture scale upside.
- 1:19It's a really compelling argument in a time when we're seeing venture evolve with new
- 1:23instruments, secondaries, liquidity tools, giving founders more optionality.
- 1:27But historically, private equity and early stage VC live in separate universes.
- 1:31We're starting to see a little bit of a blurring of lines between late stage growth,
- 1:35crossover capital, and then earlier PE moves.
- 1:37Perhaps this becomes more of a natural step.
- 1:39You know, we've talked about this and how the eventually goes to some seems to be growing up.
- 1:43We're seeing more continuity between early stage VC and PE firms rather than the more
- 1:49traditional graduations to late stage venture.
- 1:51Do you think that's a good thing?
- 1:52What kinds of relationships should early stage funds be building with downstream capital
- 1:57partners today?
- 1:57I mean, I read through the article, and I was like, yes.
- 2:00We already have many companies that, with the best intentions, will fall off the venture
- 2:04rocket ship.
- 2:05And, you know, I've talked to founders who feel this same frustration, which is like, hey.
- 2:11I signed up for the venture capital rocket ship.
- 2:13Now that I know more about my business, it isn't one of those.
- 2:17How do I get off?
- 2:18And I think the author is right.
- 2:20We don't have a good off ramp.
- 2:21And I think some of this is just the structural differences in what makes a good venture
- 2:25capital investment and what makes a good PE investment.
- 2:28And, you know, we have companies in our portfolio that are trying to navigate this.
- 2:31They're growing, but they're not growing fast enough to maybe unlock the next round.
- 2:35But they're not companies that in under any circumstances should be shut down.
- 2:39And the difficulty is actually in how do you take a company where most of the product and
- 2:45operating decisions that were made for the first couple of years were all oriented toward
- 2:50growth.
- 2:50The hiring plan, the product development plan, the business model, the pry were all oriented
- 2:55towards growth.
- 2:55And then you have to sort of, like, in midair, change gears and say, all the things we were
- 3:00focused on, growth, and, you know, now we're to our profitability.
- 3:03We're gonna flip our whole mindset.
- 3:05If you wanna get on that PE path because that's a path that does prioritize financial
- 3:09performance, profitability, operational excellence.
- 3:12And you also think that the other thing that's missing here is for that to even be on the
- 3:15table, you have to hit some minimum scale.
- 3:17Maybe it's $10,000,000.
- 3:18Maybe it's $5,000,000.
- 3:19Maybe it's 20.
- 3:20There's some minimum scale.
- 3:22So I would argue that we have a good off ramp right now for companies that are not on the
- 3:26venture trajectory but are subscale.
- 3:28Those companies should shut down or sell.
- 3:30So if you can't get to a couple million in ARR and you've raised VC, the most likely outcome
- 3:34for your business is shut down or sale.
- 3:36And I think as you get to the ten or fifteen million dollar revenue market, it gets more
- 3:39interesting because then you could build a business that's more profitable.
- 3:43That could be a tuck in acquisition that could be interesting to PE.
- 3:45But oftentimes, I find the people who are interested in signing up for fast growth are
- 3:49not necessarily the people who are interested in or best suited to run the more profitable,
- 3:54slower growing version of the same company.
- 3:56Elaborating on that last part that you mentioned, at the earliest stages when we come
- 4:00in, have there been signals that you've seen that you can almost tell years before that
- 4:05perhaps divergence in the road occurs that this could be potentially a great route for a
- 4:10private equity kind of path or buyout versus this is a company that's either going to shoot
- 4:14off and grow rocket ship wise or will be shut down.
- 4:17Because I think we're gonna be starting to straddle the middle road a lot, so it'll be
- 4:21figuring out how to discern between the two paths quickly.
- 4:23I mean, historically, the answer has been, if you're a venture capitalist, you should try to
- 4:27screen out those companies that you think are gonna get on this path, and you should avoid
- 4:31them.
- 4:31Yeah.
- 4:31And when I read a lot of the things about seed strapping that people are writing, I don't know
- 4:36how much of that is aspirational versus it's actually actionable.
- 4:40There are more people I've talked to, and I I've come around this.
- 4:42We're gonna have two kinds of venture backed companies.
- 4:44We're gonna have companies that raise $10,000,000 or less and figure out how to get
- 4:48on their own self sustaining, ideally, high growth path.
- 4:51And then we're gonna have companies that raise as much money as humanly possible, and I don't
- 4:54think we're gonna have that much in between.
- 4:56And the question for the companies in the middle is gonna be, can you still get
- 5:00attractive outcomes if you raise a little bit of money?
- 5:02I think about companies like Buffer and others that have been fairly judicious in the amount
- 5:07of money they've raised and are still, even in our own portfolio, healthy.
- 5:09Like, there are companies I think there is not an inherent tension between being capital
- 5:14efficient and growing.
- 5:14It's funny.
- 5:15Back in the stone ages of venture, companies got profitable, like, fairly early in their
- 5:19life.
- 5:19It was an important step to make sure that the business actually worked because you were gonna
- 5:23take that company public someday, and we've we're pretty far away from that.
- 5:26When did that change?
- 5:27Can you harken back to those days and about
- 5:30what happened?
- 5:30Thousands.
- 5:31It's like everyone's like, well, growth is more important.
- 5:33We'll solve profitability later.
- 5:34We never sort of came back to that in the venture business.
- 5:37There was so much more money that's coming to the business.
- 5:39There are people who will finance longer stretches of upside down financial performance
- 5:43than before.
- 5:44It used to be you had to fix this stuff because the next person in the chain demanded it, and
- 5:48now you can go pretty far in your life as a private company without solving for
- 5:52profitability.
- 5:53My last question for this one is what role should we as early stage investors play in
- 5:58helping our founders navigate this decision?
- 6:00Is there a clear duty of care to helping them explore off ramps, or are we still too anchored
- 6:05to the power law model?
- 6:07And is this just something that's happening now more than ever, just given all of the
- 6:10conversation around liquidity and need from LPs, etcetera?
- 6:12I don't think most VCs want to be in this business.
- 6:16When say this business, I mean the business of working with companies that they've invested in
- 6:20that are subscale, but maybe there's an alternative path.
- 6:23I think most VCs I know wanna spend their money and time on the rocket ship companies.
- 6:26But I do think there's this duty of care that, you know, if you made a commitment to a founder
- 6:30to work with them, it hopefully was a thick and thin commitment.
- 6:33And I wonder if firms will start to in the same way as they added board partners, I wonder if
- 6:38some firms will just say, hey.
- 6:39Look.
- 6:40These companies require a different set of resources, a different set of guidance.
- 6:43I wanna spend my time on the high growth stuff.
- 6:45We're gonna bring in an operating partner whose job it is to be the board member and shepherd
- 6:49these companies to the second path.
- 6:51Because I think right now, the belief is that second path is a lower scale outcome path.
- 6:55If you get a few of those things that really pop, attention follows money, and GC firms will
- 6:59pay a lot more attention to those companies.
- 7:01Well, it's a great bridge from my point of view into our next topic.
- 7:04Bloomberg reported last week that LightSpeed Venture Partners has officially become
- 7:09investment adviser, an IRA, joining other larger firms like Sequoia, Andres and Horowitz,
- 7:14and General Catalyst, and evolving beyond the traditional venture capital model.
- 7:18This move enables Lightspeed to invest in a broader range of assets beyond just start up
- 7:22equity, including secondaries, public stocks, crypto, and AI led roll ups without being
- 7:27limited to this 20% cap that typically applies to non RIA firms.
- 7:31This shift underscores a larger transformation in the venture ecosystem as larger firms adopt
- 7:36PE style strategies and blur the lines between venture capital, private equity, and asset
- 7:41management.
- 7:42This reclassification reflects the growing consensus that venture capital, especially at
- 7:47scale, is becoming more diversified in structure, strategy, and ambition, and that
- 7:52traditional VC alone may no longer be able to meet the expectations of LPs or the operational
- 7:57goals of larger firms.
- 7:59Charles, from your perspective, are these firms setting the pace for what the future of venture
- 8:04looks like, or are they simply outliers playing a completely different game altogether?
- 8:09I think that all of the big firms that aren't RIAs are going to become RIAs for a couple
- 8:14reasons.
- 8:15The nice thing about being what's called an exempt adviser is as long as you're a venture
- 8:18capital firm or no more than 20% of your activity is in the areas you mentioned, you
- 8:23have a much lighter regulatory compliance burden with the SEC, with other regulators too.
- 8:27So if you're a small venture firm like Precursor, it means you don't have to have a
- 8:30full on compliance team, and we don't have to have a compliance person editing the learning
- 8:35quarter to make sure we're not making a forward looking or marketing.
- 8:38It's just easier, but it's a limiting factor.
- 8:40And I think this is, as you highlighted, it's a function of venture getting bigger.
- 8:45And, you know, below a certain scale, the trade off between being exempt but being limited in
- 8:50the products you can offer is probably a good trade off for most firms, unless you really
- 8:54wanna do crypto or secondaries.
- 8:55And now I think these firms are like, well, we're not really venture capital per se.
- 8:59We are broadly diversified asset management firms that are anchored in venture capital as
- 9:04our core product.
- 9:05In the same way that, like, BlackRock is a multi asset firm, a lot of the PE firms have
- 9:09private credit arms now.
- 9:10And I think this opens the door for a couple of things.
- 9:12One, you've already seen General Catalyst essentially start to acquire other venture
- 9:16firms.
- 9:16I think you will see registered investment adviser VC firms acquire other adjacent
- 9:21businesses.
- 9:21You know, two of the three firms you mentioned already have or will have wealth management
- 9:25practices on their own platforms.
- 9:27I expect they will look a lot less like venture capital firms.
- 9:30I also think if the management I have no reason to believe this is true.
- 9:33I have no inside information.
- 9:34If the management of those firms have any interest in going public or being acquired by a
- 9:39larger private equity firm.
- 9:40All the people who would buy them are registered, and in order to go public, they
- 9:44would likely need to be registered.
- 9:45And the last thing I'll say is it's very clear to me that the largest firms in our industry
- 9:49plan to continue to get bigger.
- 9:51And at some point, the only way to get bigger is you have to have products other than venture
- 9:55capital under your umbrella.
- 9:56So I think this was like the natural evolution for these firms, given their desire to grow AUM
- 10:02and, you know, to scale.
- 10:03How do you think this affects the way early stage firms, like precursor, are perceived by
- 10:08founders and LPs to create pressure at the GP level to expand scope of our offerings, or is
- 10:14staying focused still a good competitive strategy?
- 10:17I think it's actually quite smart of these firms to register.
- 10:21Because at some point, you know, we've spent the last two years being like, what is venture
- 10:25capital?
- 10:26Like, what counts?
- 10:26And I think these firms are like, well, whatever a venture capital does is venture
- 10:30capital.
- 10:30But even that has a ceiling.
- 10:32So at some point, you're like, we're actually not a venture firm.
- 10:35We are a broadly diversified private investment firm.
- 10:38And at some point, I'm sure these folks will dabble in other things like private credit or
- 10:42maybe even public equities.
- 10:44But at some point, you're just like, we're so big that we're not just a venture capital firm,
- 10:47so that's the wrong label.
- 10:48I'm very curious to see what these folks decide to call these new businesses.
- 10:52Most of the terms have been pejorative, and most of the pejorative terms have come from
- 10:56little VC funds, asset gatherers, you know, investment banks, you know, all all designed to
- 11:01poke fun at their size and scale.
- 11:03And given how many smart people there are, I think somebody at one of those places is gonna
- 11:06rebrand these mega funds as some new cool sounding asset in service of raising more
- 11:12money.
- 11:12Last question here because we talked about LPs, GP.
- 11:16For founders with this sort of move, what should this mean for them if they're engaging
- 11:20with different funds who are considering these new types of ways to diversify?
- 11:24And also, does it matter from their perspective?
- 11:26I don't think it matters today Yeah.
- 11:28Because even though a lot of these firms are branching into other things, you know,
- 11:31secondaries is very much still in the lane of venture.
- 11:34Crypto can be, but doesn't have to be in the lane of venture.
- 11:37I would argue despite their size, most of these firms still have venture capital, an early
- 11:42stage venture capital as an important piece of what they do.
- 11:45It's not impossible to imagine a world five to ten years from now where venture is less than
- 11:50half of the AUM and activity at these firms.
- 11:52They've got so many other businesses.
- 11:54And then you start to ask yourself, as a founder, do I wanna be at a firm where venture
- 11:58is the main event, do I wanna be an only event, or do I wanna be at a firm where venture is a
- 12:02part of what they do?
- 12:03Historically, founders have chosen the pure play over the side hustle VC thing.
- 12:07I don't know if that will continue to be the case because if you could still get Marc
- 12:11Andreessen or Roloff on your board, even though Sequoia and Andreessen are much bigger firms, I
- 12:16think most founders would be like, I don't care how much time he spends on, you know, Sequoia
- 12:19Heritage or Andreessen Perennials.
- 12:21As long as he's got time for my board meeting and he's giving me advice, I'm in.
- 12:23It makes me think about those funds that are kind of in the middle, so not small, not mega
- 12:28yet, where their minds will go after seeing these mega funds create more diversified
- 12:32strategies around how they move money.
- 12:34I'm curious to know where they will lean.
- 12:36I think a lot of people have deep questions about if you think about the barbell, I think
- 12:40most people can tell you a story about what happens on either end.
- 12:43I think the middle and most people are like, is that a sustainable place to live?
- 12:46What does it mean to be one of those firms?
- 12:49And I think that's the next unanswered question in venture.
- 12:52What happens to the three hundred and fifty to seven hundred and fifty million dollar series a
- 12:57focused venture fund?
- 12:58Like, is that a model that works today?
- 13:00In our final piece, the information shares highlights from their recent events on the
- 13:04state of AI today and where investors examined whether top AI companies were the next Googles
- 13:09or Yahoos.
- 13:11Even as enormous amounts of capital are flowing into foundational models like OpenAI and
- 13:15Anthropic, many investors still remain uncertain about things like monetization,
- 13:19enterprise adoption, and sustainable differentiation.
- 13:22The piece really noted that many AI companies actually haven't found their AdWords moment
- 13:27yet.
- 13:27In other words, many companies are still using subscriptions as a stopgap as they figure out
- 13:31monetization.
- 13:32And the current state of AI revenue is unpredictable.
- 13:35Enterprise adoption is cautious and picks and shovels infrastructure plays like GPU, rental,
- 13:41data centers carry significant risk, and then geopolitical and regulatory uncertainty only
- 13:46continue to add to those challenges.
- 13:47Across your career, Charles, you've seen multiple technology cycles, Internet, cloud,
- 13:52mobile.
- 13:52You know, investors are overlaying those learnings from these past cycles as a lens to
- 13:56make sense of the current AI waves.
- 13:58But what are some of the themes from previous cycles that still hold true today?
- 14:02As you know, Leanne, I have a lot of maybe out of step views, and I'll tell you as I I've told
- 14:07the team.
- 14:07My lesson from February is everybody was pretty much directionally right about what the
- 14:12Internet was gonna mean for the economy and society.
- 14:15If anything, we underestimated the potential.
- 14:17People hadn't really thought through.
- 14:19Really, the consumer commerce opportunities in Internet were were obvious.
- 14:22I don't think we really knew how much we would use the Internet to communicate, and I think no
- 14:25one I knew had really pieced together what does the Internet plus mobile mean for just, like,
- 14:30redefining communication site?
- 14:31And I say we were directionally right because we were totally wrong on the timeline.
- 14:35If you look at the just ironically, amounts of money that were lit on fire in, we'll call it,
- 14:39'97 to 02/2001, it felt big because the scale of the venture business was much smaller then.
- 14:44We could light that amount of money on Fire Today and Venture and probably not notice.
- 14:48So one is the never confuse, basically, being directionally correct with getting timing
- 14:52right.
- 14:53And as I've told many of you, I have deep concerns that our enthusiasm about AI is
- 14:58directionally correct, but we're one generation of companies too soon for all of the pieces.
- 15:03And when I say all the pieces, it's not just the technology.
- 15:06It's the business model.
- 15:07It's distribution.
- 15:08It's user behavior.
- 15:09It there's, like, a lot of things that have to you know, I I was talking with someone about
- 15:13the differences between Webvan and Instacart.
- 15:15And aside from Instacart not having warehouses and all these other things, Instacart happened
- 15:19after Uber.
- 15:20It wasn't just a technology shift.
- 15:22There had been a behavior shift that people were used to getting stuff delivered on their
- 15:25phone.
- 15:25There were other companies that had figured out some of the like, a lot of stuff had been
- 15:29figured out, and it wasn't just the technology piece.
- 15:32So one is the direction and timing are really important.
- 15:34The other thing is it oftentimes takes time to figure out where the real value capture
- 15:40opportunities are in a new ecosystem.
- 15:43In the Internet, everyone was like, oh, I wanna be infrastructure.
- 15:47And then it turned out that, like, there are people who built data centers, and for a while,
- 15:50that was a good idea.
- 15:51Then it turned out that building routers was a good idea.
- 15:53So if you were Cisco or Juniper and building the plumbing, but maybe laying fiber in the
- 15:57ground and trying to operate fiber wasn't as good at business even though we really needed
- 16:01fiber.
- 16:01And I I say this because when I look at AI, I don't have really any doubts that directionally
- 16:06it's gonna be a transformative technology and probably on a faster time cycle than mobile or
- 16:12cloud, which I would argue were fifteen to twenty year cycles before we really had the
- 16:17plumbing in place.
- 16:17But even if it's twice as fast and it takes seven years, that to me suggests there's a lot
- 16:22of companies that are being funded that will not make it.
- 16:24And the other thing is, from those other cycles, is exuberance.
- 16:27There's a period of time where people are like, I just need to invest in this theme.
- 16:30And if you read that article from The Information, my takeaway is a lot of people
- 16:34don't have a well developed thesis on how this is all gonna play out.
- 16:39They're just like, this is the hot thing, and my job as a venture capital investor is to
- 16:43invest in the hot thing and hope that when the dust settles and we figure this out, that I'm
- 16:48in the right companies.
- 16:49That's really not how I operate.
- 16:51So we're taking the risk of just saying the alternative path is you do some investing in
- 16:55this theme, but you also wait until you have enough clarity around what you think works and
- 16:59where you think value is gonna accrue, that you start investing in those companies.
- 17:02So if you'd waited and done sort of some of the second generation Internet stuff, you would
- 17:06pick up some good companies.
- 17:07For example, once we knew that the web server was an important piece of the three tier
- 17:11architecture, they were really great company.
- 17:13Once we figured out that, you know, gen one website builders like Angel Fire and those
- 17:17weren't really that valuable.
- 17:18But with some Squarespace, like in a lot of cases, you waited and said there will be a
- 17:23better version of this thing that comes along, you could have made a lot of money.
- 17:25I wanna go back to that example that you had about Uber and Instacart and how Instacart
- 17:29started later and that behavior change for from a consumer perspective laid the groundwork and
- 17:34a really strong foundation for it to be successful.
- 17:36What do you think needs to happen from a consumer standpoint when we think about AI?
- 17:42And when I think about consumer, yes, I think individual people using them, but also on the b
- 17:46to b side as well, companies, etcetera, in order for folks to feel like there's going to
- 17:50be a stronghold and people will know how to actually use leverage and build upon these.
- 17:56I think it's kind of like Internet search.
- 17:57I think in the beginning, people didn't know how to use the Internet.
- 18:00They didn't know how to use Google to search.
- 18:02But there was a set of people who understood Boolean operators and understood how to write a
- 18:05good query.
- 18:06And if this sounds like prompt engineering, it reminds me a lot of it.
- 18:09There were people who were, like, more skilled in using the tool, and those people were able
- 18:12to get a lot more out of it.
- 18:13And eventually, people understood, I'm gonna have to know how to use this in my job and in
- 18:19my life.
- 18:19I'd argue most people still aren't that good at searching for information on the Internet, but
- 18:23it would be embarrassing to say you don't know how to use Google today.
- 18:26I don't know that it's embarrassing to say you're not good at ChatGPT today.
- 18:29Don't know if it's embarrassing at all.
- 18:30And I think right now, the funny thing is investors and people who use this stuff a lot
- 18:34are reasonably skilled at getting good information out of ChatGPT, and they're getting
- 18:38a lot of leverage out of it or or Anthropic or LAMA, whatever you wanna use.
- 18:42But most people aren't.
- 18:43But most people also don't have to be good at it yet.
- 18:46And so I think what needs to happen is most people need to get comfortable and familiar
- 18:50with AI.
- 18:51And that might not be typing into a text box.
- 18:53It might be talking to a device.
- 18:54It might be voice is the thing that unlocks it for people.
- 18:57It might take Apple getting AI right to cross that Rubicon.
- 19:00But I think once people are like, I use AI regularly to do stuff.
- 19:03I think right now, it's students and knowledge workers on either end are really maybe for
- 19:08maybe for different reasons.
- 19:09Knowledge workers may be out of fear and a desire to be more productive, and students out
- 19:13of a desire to do well, I won't say.
- 19:14To do better in school, we'll say.
- 19:16And I think for the people in the middle, it doesn't feel urgent or necessary to be good at
- 19:20AI yet.
- 19:20And I think once people are used to using it, you can take for granted that people will know
- 19:24what to do with AI enabled products.
- 19:25And I think right now, that's just not true.
- 19:27And there's a difference between playing around with products versus weaving them into your day
- 19:30to day life.
- 19:31There's so much more to be discussed there, I'm really excited to see how it all turns out.
- 19:35But we are all out of time for today.
- 19:37Thank you, Charles, for joining in.
- 19:38Thank you, Neon, for joining in as well.
- 19:41We will talk with everyone next week, but please like and subscribe in the meantime.
- 19:45Thank you.
- 19:45Bye.
- 19:46Bye.
- 19:47Bye.