Latest / The Vegan Report / Is Palantir Spying on You? | Ep. 117
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan.
- 0:04And have you ever heard of Palantir? Palantir
- 0:08builds data software that governments and corporations
- 0:12use to organize massive databases and power mass
- 0:18surveillance. I won't go through every software
- 0:22they created, but you might know a few of them
- 0:25since their products always generate a backlash.
- 0:29Like Operation Laser, which is a software that
- 0:32allows you to predict crimes. Yes, exactly like
- 0:36the movie Minority Report. I think it was dismantled
- 0:41after public pressure and lots of lawsuits. Well,
- 0:45that same company has secured a $300 million
- 0:49contract with the United States Department of
- 0:53Agriculture. The goal of that partnership is,
- 0:57and I quote, empowering USDA with core capabilities
- 1:02that will enable it to secure American farmland,
- 1:08enhance supply chains resilience, and shield
- 1:11agricultural programs from fraud, abuse, and
- 1:15foreign adversary influence. Now, that is a lot
- 1:20of money. And that goal is very vague. And the
- 1:25company does not have the best of reputation.
- 1:29The USDA also does not have the best of reputation,
- 1:34siding again and again with private interests
- 1:37against the welfare of animals. All of that reeks
- 1:42and it has led my guest Today, Robert Griot,
- 1:47to raise concerns about the possibility of a
- 1:50mass surveillance operation against the animal
- 1:54rights movement. Robert Griot is an activist,
- 1:58author and speaker working to build grassroots
- 2:00momentum and popular support a plant -based food
- 2:04system. He founded the organization Free From
- 2:08Harm, which is dedicated to advancing plant -based,
- 2:12animal -free food production for a safer, more
- 2:15humane, and sustainable future. Together we discussed
- 2:20the place of money in the animal rights movement,
- 2:24but also its corrupting power in politics, how
- 2:28our movement lacks ambition, the promise of cultivated
- 2:33meat, and much more. Subscribe to or follow the
- 2:37show. Share this episode with the vegans in your
- 2:40life. Help sound the alarm about this possible
- 2:45danger and leave a five -star review. I truly
- 2:49appreciate your support. As always, thank you.
- 2:52Welcome back to The Vegan Report. Been a while
- 2:54since the last time we spoke. I'm really happy
- 2:58to see you back. Thank you. Yeah, it's great
- 3:02to be back with you. Okay, so let's get started
- 3:06with Palantir. That was the topic of Free From
- 3:11Harm's latest newsletter, which people should
- 3:14subscribe. It's really informative. It keeps
- 3:18you updated on your news, political news mostly.
- 3:25And I read that newsletter and my jaw dropped.
- 3:30The idea that the government would use this powerful
- 3:34tool that Palantir is, that powerful technology
- 3:38to spy on animal advocates. How did you come
- 3:45across that? And where are we right now in terms
- 3:52of this story? How did it evolve since you sent
- 3:56that newsletter? Well, yeah, so first of all,
- 4:01USDA inked a deal. with Palantir for, I think,
- 4:05about $300 million to provide what they call
- 4:09tools that will safeguard the US food system.
- 4:17And so they're not going to tell us, and we'll
- 4:22never know to what extent they actually use surveillance
- 4:28technologies from Palantir is quite notorious
- 4:32for. We'll never know the extent to which that
- 4:37will impact journals and activists, but we can
- 4:39almost rest assured that if past is precedent,
- 4:44right, it's been used in the past. FOIA records,
- 4:49you know, secret documents that were uncovered
- 4:53showing that Palantir technologies have been
- 4:58used in the past to identify people, activists,
- 5:04journalists, and to try to criminalize or silence
- 5:10them in other ways. And so this technology has
- 5:14the potential to be abused against people trying
- 5:21to do the right thing. Journalists and activists
- 5:25It can be it has been and it will continue to
- 5:29be used in that way because the technology is
- 5:33in the hands of people at authoritarian regimes
- 5:38and people who want to silence dissidents in
- 5:43their countries Including the u .s. Right and
- 5:47so this is just another Way for Palantir to get
- 5:52another claw into the US government, in my opinion.
- 6:00And the pretext to sign this deal is what we're
- 6:04hearing a lot of is that it's to safeguard the
- 6:06American food system, to prevent countries like
- 6:12China and what they call other adversarial countries
- 6:15to purchase property and control farmland here.
- 6:23But you know what's really ironic? Look, Smithfield,
- 6:26the largest pork producer in the US, sold the
- 6:30company to a Chinese company. The US government
- 6:35didn't do anything to stop that. So they're telling
- 6:39us, on the one hand, that this is so important
- 6:44to safeguard our farmland for Americans rather
- 6:49than foreign average series and yet they do nothing
- 6:52when animal ag strikes a deal and they do nothing.
- 6:59In fact, they enable JBS from Brazil who has
- 7:04a tremendous track record of wrongdoing in the
- 7:08past. They enable, they authorize, the Trump
- 7:12administration authorized JBS to be listed on
- 7:17the New York Stock Exchange and become a public
- 7:19publicly traded company in the US, opening up
- 7:22the door for all kinds of capital investments
- 7:24in that company and for them to grow in this
- 7:27market so much and so much more. And so this
- 7:31is just another, this Palantir deal and the rationale,
- 7:35the logic they're using behind it is just another,
- 7:42for me, it's like a game of smoke and mirrors.
- 7:45They're telling us they're protecting our resources,
- 7:49they're protecting our food system. And yet with
- 7:53that, they're allowing these companies to do
- 7:58terrible things to people here and abroad. So,
- 8:05but it's real confusing to the average person
- 8:09because it's this game of smoke and mirrors.
- 8:14I mean, I remember being in high school when
- 8:19that whole Snowden disclosure story happened.
- 8:25And we discovered that the US government was
- 8:28spying on its citizens through the Patriot Act.
- 8:34It was a whole thing. And so you would think
- 8:36that Americans had learned from that. And we're
- 8:42now had the distaste now for those kinds of technologies
- 8:46that spy on them or at least the will to spy
- 8:51on them using technologies. So is there, has
- 8:55there been any reaction from politicians, from
- 8:58reporters, from anyone, some kind of negative
- 9:04reaction, some kind of resistance to this agenda?
- 9:10Yeah, I have seen very little. like I would say
- 9:14in our own community or in our own animal vegan
- 9:19type movement. I haven't seen anything else come
- 9:24out from other groups or individuals sounding
- 9:28the alarm. For us, it was a huge sounding of
- 9:31the alarms that Palantir now has a deal with
- 9:34the USDA. The alarm bells went off in our heads
- 9:40and said, oh my gosh, we need to we need to really
- 9:44have this in our radar because the repercussions
- 9:50of this are really serious for activists. But
- 9:56I think there's a general sense of naivete and
- 10:01what's the word, laziness, lackadaisicalness.
- 10:09I'm not sure what expression to use, but There's
- 10:17this kind of sentiment, I think, among some people
- 10:21in our movement that we're not going to get involved
- 10:26in politics, that we have a choice. We're actually
- 10:30making a conscious choice. What we're asking
- 10:32for is not political, when in fact, everything
- 10:37is. everything that we're attempting to do, all
- 10:41the demands that we're asking for, whether it
- 10:43be a ban on foie gras in some state or it would
- 10:48be promoting cage -free eggs or whatever, all
- 10:53of this ends up into the political discourse
- 10:58and requires decisions from our political leaders,
- 11:04for better or worse. So I think the reason why
- 11:09we're not hearing too much about it is because
- 11:12of the slacks and also naive kind of sensibility
- 11:19that we have among people that think we're not
- 11:22engaged in the political process. Maybe the word
- 11:28you're looking for is apathy. That's the one
- 11:31I use. I feel like, yeah, I feel like that's
- 11:35something everyone is infected with. Like the
- 11:38general public is very much has a complete distaste
- 11:43in politics. Most people don't vote. Most people
- 11:47don't follow what's happening politically, even
- 11:51if it impacts them. They're distracted by their
- 11:57social economic situation. They're distracted
- 12:00by video games and cultural stuff that are more
- 12:06superficial, like that old saying, bread and
- 12:10games. And that's a question I asked recently
- 12:14in a past episode, but how do we get people to
- 12:19re -engage with politics? How do we wake them
- 12:25up from that feeling of apathy? And maybe this
- 12:31is the issue that will trigger that reaction,
- 12:36that engagement, because it's really existential.
- 12:40If they get to see everything we're doing, everything
- 12:44we're talking about, our private conversations,
- 12:48our internal strategy meetings and all of that,
- 12:54then how can we make any progress against this
- 12:58industry? Right. Well, I think it's true that
- 13:04there is an apathy disease that's very prevalent
- 13:10in society. But I also think that we could point
- 13:13to a lot of examples where people are stepping
- 13:18up and organizing to make change and to have
- 13:23positive outcomes. For example, there's been
- 13:27a recent stat floating around making headlines
- 13:31that half of the data centers that have been
- 13:34proposed and wanting to be built have been defeated
- 13:37by community organizing around the country in
- 13:41the US. So that's a pretty impressive thing that
- 13:46half have been have been shut down as a result.
- 13:50Or I guess in our own movement, we could point
- 13:54to this beagle rescue effort. And say, wow, that
- 13:58if, if whatever you think about that, or, um,
- 14:02one thing you certainly can't take away. Uh,
- 14:06from them is the fact that they were able to
- 14:08organize, mobilize and get so much attention
- 14:12on this issue. And if rescuing 2000 Beagles from
- 14:19a laboratory type setting is worth investing
- 14:25all of that. those resources, then what is the
- 14:29proportionate response for something like this?
- 14:33Where all of us are impacted as activists or
- 14:38journalists and our food system is at stake and
- 14:44the planet's at stake and billions of animals
- 14:46are at stake by the kind of decisions that the
- 14:50people in power are making on our behalf. So
- 14:53If we're willing to do that for 2000 dogs, then
- 14:56what are we willing to do to step up to actually
- 15:00change something that has far reaching, um, you
- 15:09know, far, far reaching implications like this.
- 15:12That's my question for Pete, for our, for our
- 15:15movement or, or even just for society. Like,
- 15:19and I think I think some movements are stepping
- 15:22up. I'll just say that I'm finding that when
- 15:27it comes to food system change, which is what
- 15:29we're focused on, free from harm, I'm seeing
- 15:33more leadership by some environmental groups
- 15:36than I'm seeing from people in the AR and vegan
- 15:39movement. And it took me a while to figure that
- 15:43out, but I'm seeing it more and more, and I'm
- 15:46starting to realize that That's where the real
- 15:49change is is brewing right now So I mentioned
- 15:55a few consequences of that But all of that is
- 16:00the product of my imagination. I'm just you know,
- 16:02picturing what it would be like do you think
- 16:06I'm off the mark or No No, I don't and I I think
- 16:13we need to be in front of this rather than behind
- 16:16it. And so brainstorming and speculating about
- 16:20what could happen is part of that process that
- 16:24we should be thinking about. And the scale of
- 16:28that transaction, $200 million. We don't have
- 16:33that in this movement. You know, I had an interesting
- 16:37conversation with Bruce Frederick and he said,
- 16:41you know, um, activism is done activism. won't
- 16:46do anything for us. The future, how we end factory
- 16:50farming is through cultivated meat. And at the
- 16:52same time, he made the point that cultivated
- 16:55meat was not funded enough, even with all the
- 16:59billions. But as he was saying that, I was thinking,
- 17:02well, in terms of donations, what we're receiving,
- 17:06the nonprofits, the activists and so on, is a
- 17:10fraction of a fraction of that. So most animal
- 17:13rights nonprofits, don't make more than a million
- 17:17dollars. They don't even have a million dollar
- 17:19budget. So forget about billions. What do you
- 17:24make of that? Right. So the question assumes
- 17:28something important that I think we should talk
- 17:31about that money drives change. But I would argue
- 17:38that social change is not a business transaction.
- 17:44even though we've been conditioned as a society
- 17:47to believe that the philanthropists call the
- 17:51shots, decide what to invest in and determine
- 17:54how change is going to play out. That's what
- 17:59the history books kind of tell us. That's the
- 18:02dominant narrative that is thrown at us and fed
- 18:06to us. But the reality is that If we look at
- 18:11successful change movements around the world,
- 18:15many of them succeeded with their goals despite
- 18:20having no resources or money or funding. Now,
- 18:25that should be a really important lesson to us,
- 18:28shouldn't it? Because if there's groups and movements
- 18:30around the world that are able to achieve their
- 18:33goals, overthrow dictatorships and do incredible
- 18:38things with very little or no resources or money,
- 18:42then maybe that means that we haven't quite tapped
- 18:47into what motivates people to organize and mobilize
- 18:53around a change that they need. And that money,
- 18:58while we need it, for movements to, you know,
- 19:02for resources and, you know, we need it to a
- 19:08certain extent, but it's not the change. It's
- 19:11just a tool that we need in the process of making
- 19:15the change. And I think the other important point
- 19:21here is that, you know, the markets are opportunistic.
- 19:26And so they respond to changing consumer attitudes
- 19:32and preferences, they don't create them necessarily.
- 19:40They can, though, however, because if we look
- 19:42at the history of the tobacco industry and the
- 19:46meat industry, they basically came to the top
- 19:49ad execs, ad agencies in the country in the 50s
- 19:53and 60s and 70s and said, we want to create a
- 19:56market of millions of smokers. And the meat industry
- 20:00said, we want to increase our market share by
- 20:0440%. We want Americans to eat 40 % more meat
- 20:09and dairy and egg products. And the ad industry
- 20:14said, sure, no problem. And they made it happen.
- 20:17The proof is the fact that they made those markets
- 20:20grow. However they did it, they did it. So if
- 20:25they want to create a market for something, they
- 20:29can do it and that's why we Recognize that we
- 20:35need to be in front of those powerful people
- 20:37Because if they can pull strings like that and
- 20:40make markets appear like that out of thin air
- 20:45We need to be holding those people accountable
- 20:48Because there's all of this going on behind the
- 20:53scenes that consumers don't know about And yeah,
- 20:58consumers have their own personal responsibility
- 21:01for what they purchase. But when you have a powerful
- 21:04machine like this behind the scenes, creating
- 21:07markets, then that has to be a big part of the
- 21:13equation of how we, how we make change in the
- 21:16food industry. Yeah. When you said that, yes,
- 21:22sorry. I know that's kind of a. circuitous route,
- 21:27like to answer the question, I think I went off
- 21:32the topic a bit and got into other things. So
- 21:36excuse me for that. No, not at all. That's what
- 21:41organic conversations are. That's what podcasting
- 21:44is all about. Can I just say, I mean, I think
- 21:47Bruce is genuinely, his worldview is based on
- 21:53the belief that there is no future for activism
- 22:02or social movements, but contrary to what he
- 22:06says, there's examples of remarkable changes
- 22:11happening by people -powered movements around
- 22:15the world and in our own country. So contrary
- 22:17to that claim, we could point to many examples
- 22:22of that. But I also reject the idea that The
- 22:28market is the only solution we have been told
- 22:31time and time again every time there's a bright
- 22:34and shiny new technology It's somewhere on the
- 22:37horizon. All we have to do is invest in it and
- 22:40wait for it and believe in it And it's gonna
- 22:42solve all our problems. It's going to cure cancer.
- 22:45It's going to Solve climate change. It's going
- 22:49to end poverty. It's going to end animal suffering
- 22:54It's always on the horizon. It's always a new
- 22:57technology. It's never actually here to solve
- 23:00the problems that we need solved now. And this
- 23:05is a technocratic kind of view of how technologies
- 23:11can solve social problems. And they rarely actually
- 23:17do. When they do come around, They rarely actually
- 23:23meet the promises, the big lofty promises that
- 23:26they make. And they end up serving special interests
- 23:30and powerful people more than they actually do
- 23:33anything to solve social problems. And I don't
- 23:40know the cultivated meat with all the promises
- 23:44that it's made. I don't know if it's any different,
- 23:47because we just don't know yet. Exactly. We don't
- 23:51know, but they don't have the choice to, to try
- 23:56to convince us that it's the solution because
- 23:59they have to get that investor money and you
- 24:02don't get investor money when you say, I don't
- 24:06know, maybe if, you know, right. So you've got
- 24:11to make some big, big claims. Exactly. They're,
- 24:15uh, salespeople. That's the thing. And we need
- 24:18to recognize that bias. That's what I don't understand
- 24:21how in our movement, the nonprofit world decided
- 24:26to unite with this corporate world in order to
- 24:32instill change. It feels like an unnatural union
- 24:36here. It's very strange. Um, I agree. I sat in
- 24:45on a workshop last week on branding for nonprofits.
- 24:56And the people on the panel were very established
- 25:01and very top people in what they do. They spoke
- 25:08very well and they were very passionate about
- 25:10it. I don't doubt their passion, but what I walked
- 25:15away from was this feeling that one of the questions
- 25:22that came up was how do we maintain our mission
- 25:26for whatever it is we want for animals or the
- 25:30planet, and then also appeal to these corporate
- 25:35donors, the corporate donor class in order to
- 25:40Reflect their values and I don't think anyone
- 25:44actually had a very good answer to that because
- 25:47it's a very difficult question and there's an
- 25:50inherent conflict of interest as you pointed
- 25:52to in that question Because let's be real My
- 25:58experience has been at least and I think I don't
- 26:01I'm not alone in this Those with the philanthropists
- 26:07that are really the top people giving are not
- 26:13on the front lines of social struggles. So they
- 26:17don't really have a sense for what it takes to
- 26:23make change on an everyday operational basis.
- 26:27But they have this abstract ideas of what they
- 26:32think it takes. But they're often not right.
- 26:35They're not reflective of what people on the
- 26:39front lines know and experience every day. And
- 26:42I think this disconnect is a big problem in the
- 26:45fundraising for a lot of movements and groups,
- 26:52including my own free from harm. So the solution,
- 26:58or at least what we have found to be more consistent
- 27:03with what we're trying to do is to build as much
- 27:08grassroots support as possible. So kind of think
- 27:12about the Bernie Sanders model of raising funds,
- 27:16right? We're going to try to get it from individuals
- 27:21more as much as possible and reject large corporate
- 27:24donors that tie all of these strings to the money
- 27:30that they're going to give you and tell you how
- 27:32they want you to operate. That's kind of, you
- 27:39know, we strive to raise funds from the individual
- 27:42donors that support us. And yeah, we've applied
- 27:45for grants and sometimes we get grant money,
- 27:49but it's not money that dictates how we operate,
- 27:57right? We still feel like we're the ones that
- 28:01can best make the decisions. for how to make
- 28:05the change we want. And the people that give
- 28:09to us believe that, if that makes sense. Yeah,
- 28:14I think that's the assumption of most funders.
- 28:20I think that as a donor, when I give to an organization,
- 28:25I don't want to get involved in the operational
- 28:28stuff. Like, you know better than I do. I want
- 28:33to support your expertise and I admire your work.
- 28:37You convinced me that you're going to make an
- 28:39impact with my donation. And so I'm showing trust
- 28:44to you, but I do think that's not the agenda
- 28:47of every funder. And that's where there is a
- 28:51nuance and you have to think about it deeply.
- 28:56Absolutely. So when you mentioned how you don't
- 29:02need much resources to make a difference, my
- 29:06mind went right away to military conflicts. Now
- 29:11that's a violent image and comparison, but it
- 29:17is a useful one. was born in North Africa in
- 29:22a country called Algeria. My people are very
- 29:24familiar with guerilla tactics in order to reach
- 29:29social goals. That's how Algeria became independent.
- 29:34It had to face this big, powerful nation, which
- 29:40is France, an army, and it succeeded at driving
- 29:45it out of its land through Small gary tactics
- 29:51that were that did not need much money and we
- 29:56have seen that in so many military situations
- 29:59I could point to current events of big countries
- 30:04coming to smaller countries and finding out that.
- 30:09It's not as easy as I have the biggest you know
- 30:12the more ammo and I have I mean we can point
- 30:16out to Vietnam that's I think one of the best
- 30:18example of that. So yeah I think your your point
- 30:22is a good one a solid one. Yeah I just I think
- 30:30you know we. People do need to get paid a living
- 30:34wage or figure out how they're going to. Survive
- 30:38as an activist and I for one live on very modest
- 30:44means I'm okay with that. It's a choice. I've
- 30:47made I can pay my bills and I can live. Okay,
- 30:52I mean, you know and I Can do what I want to
- 30:57do the activism work that I want to do I know
- 31:01that it's not as easy for others. I know that
- 31:05some decisions that people make are based on
- 31:08maybe things that they don't necessarily believe
- 31:11in. But because of the constraints of life and
- 31:15having to make a living, they make those decisions.
- 31:20So I'm not judging anyone. I just think that
- 31:25we should be aware that there's a system in place
- 31:30that forces people. to make decisions that could
- 31:37be contradictory to what they believe. But it
- 31:42allows them to do some work in the movement and
- 31:48play a role, even though it might not be exactly
- 31:51how they want it to be. So every situation is
- 31:55different. There's a model for compensation.
- 32:01I forgot the name of it. It was popularized by
- 32:05the Mark and Paul Engler. So I think it's called
- 32:10needs -based compensation. And it's a way to
- 32:16power and fund social movements. It's really
- 32:22kind of interesting to explore if you're interested.
- 32:26I can send you something on it, but it's Mark
- 32:29and Paul Engler and it's their model of needs
- 32:32based compensation. Let's tie this conversation
- 32:41about compensation and money and the difference
- 32:44it makes to politics. I guess when I think about
- 32:50politics and money, The first thing that comes
- 32:53to mind is the economic barrier to getting involved
- 32:58in politics. I think that most politicians come
- 33:02from upper middle class families or wealthy families.
- 33:07You see that a lot in American politics, Canadian
- 33:10politics too. many billionaires, sons of billionaires
- 33:14and so on. They're the ones who have the time
- 33:17to spare to go into a political campaign. They're
- 33:22the ones who have the friends to fund that political
- 33:25campaign and to get them in media appearances
- 33:30and all of that. It's a small world of wealthy
- 33:34elite people. They are all highly educated. They
- 33:40all have college degrees or, um, graduate degrees,
- 33:45most often from the best universities. And so
- 33:49you, um, start getting that sense that there
- 33:53is a, like a social class of a ruler in, in our
- 33:58society. Um, yeah. What do you make of that?
- 34:04I think that yes, we place politicians on this
- 34:09kind of pedestal and kind of a cult worship type
- 34:13of pedestal where our expectations are that they
- 34:18are the makers of change. And I think the way
- 34:20history is written shows this too. So for example,
- 34:27when the Supreme Court ruled that gay marriage
- 34:30was the law of the land here, the Clintons and
- 34:36the Obamas, who for years had said repeatedly
- 34:40that marriage is between a man and a woman, all
- 34:45of a sudden were saying, no, actually, no, we
- 34:48believed in this all along. And so what we did
- 34:57in that case is we credited the Supreme Court
- 35:00and the people in power took Took credit for
- 35:05the change that happened, even though whether
- 35:08they believed in it or not was all over the place,
- 35:11right? And what the history books didn't tell
- 35:17us was that there was a whole movement of people
- 35:21organizing to make this kind of change possible
- 35:26for decades, doing all kinds of interesting work
- 35:30to build public consensus in a very strategic
- 35:35way that is necessary to then get on the radar
- 35:43and influence politicians to pass laws to codify
- 35:47that change into law. And the credit always goes
- 35:51to those that do that end work because they're
- 35:54the ones in positions of power and they have
- 35:57the attention of the media. Um, and the credit
- 36:02never goes to, so we never get this holistic
- 36:05understanding of how change happens because we
- 36:08don't, we only see the end product and, and,
- 36:11and we have, um, you know, Trump or Clinton taking
- 36:17credit for the change. And we think it's not,
- 36:19um, you know, society then thinks, well, Oh,
- 36:23wow. What a wonderful thing. Clinton did that.
- 36:25No, Clinton didn't do that. Generations of. of
- 36:30people that and their blood sweat and tears,
- 36:33uh, organizing for the cause did that. They just
- 36:38basically were on stage accepting credit for
- 36:42it at the right time. And this happens repeatedly.
- 36:48Yeah. So the reason why I brought up this question
- 36:51is I feel like as a movement animal advocacy
- 36:56movement, we want to push our people to become
- 37:00those elected officials. But you're saying we
- 37:04don't need that necessarily. In fact, you know,
- 37:08our view of who puts in place laws and makes
- 37:14the changes we want to see is a bit distorted.
- 37:20We should look at politicians as having a very
- 37:23specific role. And that is that they Their job
- 37:27is to pass laws to codify a change into law that
- 37:32we need. So we should look at them as in a very
- 37:37utilitarian way, rather than worshiping them.
- 37:41Um, that's all they that we need from them. Everything
- 37:46that comes before that is our job is our role
- 37:51because we need to build public consensus. around
- 37:56what we want to a point where politicians have
- 38:01no other choice than to adopt that position,
- 38:04supporting the cause because there's too much
- 38:06support not to. And so how we do that takes many
- 38:12forms, but the only thing we need from them is
- 38:16what they have the power to do, which is vote
- 38:19in a piece of legislation that's gonna solve
- 38:22our problem. And that's my view. You know, there's
- 38:29no reason to worship them. There's no reason
- 38:32to, they're just doing their job. This is what
- 38:34they've put themselves in a position to do. It
- 38:39benefits them in many ways to be in that position.
- 38:43Okay, I'm not necessarily interested in taking
- 38:48away those benefits for them, as long as they
- 38:53do what we need them to do. Well, do you think
- 38:59then it is useful to have more Cory book book
- 39:02bookers bookers Cory bookers in in our crowd
- 39:07of elected officials more people that share our
- 39:11values I Don't know that Cory does I think he
- 39:17He's a very nice person and a very charismatic
- 39:23leader of the Democratic Party. He's now, I believe,
- 39:27the fourth ranking Democrat in Congress. He has
- 39:31presidential aspirations. And believe me, his
- 39:36career and his presidential aspiration is going
- 39:42to be his top priority, whatever it takes to
- 39:45get there, right? So we should be very mindful
- 39:50of that, that he can work to our advantage or
- 39:56he can work to our disadvantage. But it's all
- 40:01about, you know, it's up to us to, you know,
- 40:05apply the pressure that's needed if we want a
- 40:08certain change. Now, what he's been behind is
- 40:13the saving prop 12, you know, the animal protection
- 40:17laws that were passed by the state of California.
- 40:21And to save that in the farm bill, to save that
- 40:25from the Save Our Bacon Act, which would repeal
- 40:29that legislation. And that's really just a symptom
- 40:37of the disease. It's not really the core problem.
- 40:41So what we did for a while with Cory Booker was
- 40:44we pressed him on this. We said, it's great that
- 40:48you want to save Prop 12 and those animal protections.
- 40:54But let's just say we do it. Let's say you get
- 40:56enough people in the Ag Committee, the Senate
- 40:59Ag Committee, to vote to protect it. We still
- 41:04have this problem of subsidies and money and,
- 41:09you know, the money that's corrupting the system,
- 41:12because the only reason why we had a challenge
- 41:15to Prop 12 Is because of special interest money
- 41:19in politics which said pass this you know pass
- 41:23this bill to repeal those animal protections
- 41:25from the animal ag industry if we didn't have
- 41:28that undo influence and money. In in congress
- 41:33we wouldn't have any bad bills like this but
- 41:36we're going to be continually chasing bad bills
- 41:38like save our bacon until we confront the underlying
- 41:42problem of special interest money in politics
- 41:44we don't just walk away. When we say and declare
- 41:48victory when when Cory Booker saves the day and
- 41:53says, oh, we saved California's animal protection
- 41:56law. No, that's just the beginning. That's just
- 41:59one small milestone in a long process of confronting
- 42:05this problem of money and politics. And someone
- 42:08like Cory Booker will not really talk about this
- 42:14underlying problem because I don't know why,
- 42:18maybe he has special interests that support his
- 42:21campaigns, but we should always be mindful that
- 42:23these people in power like Cory Booker, they're
- 42:28gonna be tethered by these special interests.
- 42:32As long as they're receiving money from very
- 42:35powerful groups, we should recognize that their
- 42:40decisions are going to be affected by that. We
- 42:47shouldn't be surprised when they vote against
- 42:52something they said they believe, you know, they
- 42:55said they believe in veganism and protecting
- 42:57animals. And then we find that they do something
- 43:00that's really completely contradicting that.
- 43:04Um, so my point is we need to address head on,
- 43:12just like all these other social movements that
- 43:14represent other industries. We've got to get
- 43:17the special interests out of politics, out of
- 43:21Congress. And we can align with all these other
- 43:25movements. We're doing this for the food system.
- 43:28Another group is doing it for pharma industry,
- 43:30or health care, or the energy sector, or for
- 43:33climate protection. But all the other social
- 43:39movements understand that this is the underlying
- 43:42problem. All we're doing is chasing one bad bill
- 43:48after another. And we're always going to be in
- 43:53this loop. We're always going to be like Sisyphus
- 43:56climbing the hill until we address the real core
- 44:01problem. That's what I see. And I know you're
- 44:08the one who made that apparent to me. And once
- 44:13you see it, you can't unsee it. And it gets tiring.
- 44:19Why do you think we don't have any appetite for
- 44:24that conversation in the movement? I mean, going
- 44:27back to that conversation about funders, if I
- 44:31approach funders with that, I think they don't
- 44:35have any framework to assess that proposition,
- 44:39like how many chickens are you going to free
- 44:43or how many people are you going to turn vegan?
- 44:48Those are the frameworks we're working with.
- 44:52So how to present that to the movement, to sell
- 44:56that view to the movement? Well, I think it's
- 45:03about the value of big picture, systemic change,
- 45:11and the fact that we are capable of making those
- 45:19kinds of changes, that we are ready for it. And
- 45:24the only obstacle in our way is our low self
- 45:28-esteem, our sense of powerlessness. our sense
- 45:34that this system is too big to fail, so all we
- 45:37can do is settle for crumbs. All we can do is
- 45:40settle for small wins because the system is too
- 45:46corrupt to change. Well, that's simply a myth.
- 45:54And the reality is that there are already efforts
- 45:58in Congress underway That are proposing really
- 46:03big bold changes to our food system by congresspeople
- 46:07But they're not being properly supported by our
- 46:12movement and They need our support. They need
- 46:16us to build the grassroots momentum the popular
- 46:20support for these Efforts they want to to translate
- 46:24into to go bills In order to make that happen
- 46:29so It's already happening. If we want it, we
- 46:34can have it. We can make it happen. But it's
- 46:38a question of where we decide to put our priorities.
- 46:41Are we going to be forever in the cycle of settling
- 46:45for small wins on the fringes of the problem?
- 46:50Or are we actually going to address the core
- 46:53root problem of animal suffering, which is, of
- 46:57course, animal agriculture? as a whole, and I
- 47:03say we're ready for that because, and I'll give
- 47:05you one example of why I think that, but I could
- 47:09give you many. We're looking for trigger events.
- 47:13We're looking for issues that could really accelerate
- 47:18change, could trigger people into action. So
- 47:23for example, With the whole bird flu crisis that
- 47:27has been unfolding for the last several years
- 47:29now, in a recent hearing in Congress, the leading
- 47:34spokesperson for the chicken and egg industry,
- 47:37the poultry industry, told Congress that if we
- 47:41don't solve this bird flu problem, there will
- 47:44be no future for the chicken and egg industry.
- 47:49No one ever picked up on this. It was one of
- 47:54the most important statements, I think, in terms
- 47:57of indicating to us how important this issue
- 48:01is and how we could leverage it to our advantage.
- 48:08I didn't see anybody quote this person or pick
- 48:12up on this, but we did. And the point is that
- 48:19When a leading industry spokesperson makes a
- 48:22statement like this, we should be listening and
- 48:26we should really be listening to them because
- 48:29this is giving us what we need to know in terms
- 48:33of what are the weaknesses, what are the Achilles'
- 48:37heels in this structure, the system, and how
- 48:43can we use that to gain power and to shift things
- 48:47in the right direction. Um, it's a trigger of
- 48:52it. Bird flu could be a trigger. Bird flu itself.
- 48:59Um, you, I get the sense that you believe that
- 49:04we're capable of implementing that ambitious
- 49:08change. And I've been thinking lately why vegans
- 49:15and vegetarians and animal welfareists. We represent
- 49:20such a big segment of the population. Why aren't
- 49:25politicians catering to us? Why, despite all
- 49:31of our resources, why aren't we capable of pursuing
- 49:36more ambitious goals? Like we have all of that
- 49:40energy and we're investing it in such small tasks.
- 49:45And I was thinking maybe that's why there is
- 49:48so much in finding in our movement, because there
- 49:52is so much surplus energy. We have so much to
- 49:57give, so much we can do, and yet it is put in
- 50:03such small things. We lack that vision, that
- 50:08ambition, and so we end up putting that energy
- 50:12in. in fighting. So, yeah, are you optimistic
- 50:18about pursuing ambitious goals? I am, yes, because
- 50:24I think what we have untapped is that we are
- 50:30finding support in other areas where we didn't
- 50:36think we would like. So there are certain environmental
- 50:39groups like Friends of the Earth, like Center
- 50:43for ecological diversity that are really leading
- 50:49food system change, plant -based food system
- 50:51change. And they are not coming from the vegan
- 50:59base necessarily, but the work they're doing
- 51:05is bringing together what used to be very disparate
- 51:11elements, disparate groups and movements into
- 51:15one coalition, demanding support for plant -based
- 51:21food system, which has enormous benefits to the
- 51:25animal movement in terms of numbers and scale
- 51:28of animals and reducing suffering, has tremendous
- 51:33benefits to the environmental movement in terms
- 51:36of reducing climate and environmental impact.
- 51:40have immense benefits to the public health movement,
- 51:46which is so impacted by the diseases spread by
- 51:52animal agriculture and the pesticides used and
- 51:56all that. So I think I asked that question that
- 52:05you asked a lot. I think part of it is that many
- 52:12people are already invested in very specific
- 52:15kinds of campaigns to say ban guagua in the city
- 52:24of DC or to get certain brands to purchase cage
- 52:30-free eggs or whatever it is. So these are long
- 52:35-term campaigns. Um, we talked about before how
- 52:42some people could be making a living. Some of
- 52:45the leaders in that, those campaigns could be
- 52:47making a living and I'm carrying out those campaigns.
- 52:53Um, so I think it's a complicated answer that
- 52:58has to do with where the money is incentivizing
- 53:02our movement in areas that aren't necessarily
- 53:05what you're talking about. And then that and
- 53:09and just a lack of focus like people I find a
- 53:12lot of especially younger activists who just
- 53:16They will want to try different things and they
- 53:18should they should try different kinds of activism
- 53:20and see what resonates with them But at a certain
- 53:23point we have to decide where can we have the
- 53:26biggest impact? With the scarce resources and
- 53:30numbers that we have where can we have the biggest
- 53:33impact for animals and planet? And it's a hard
- 53:38question because it means we might have to give
- 53:41up and rethink certain things that we're doing.
- 53:46And it's a question I ask myself every day. It
- 53:51does change depending on the circumstances. But
- 53:56we should be able to adapt our tactics and strategies
- 54:03to the circumstances that are changing and And
- 54:07not get stuck in campaigns that just because
- 54:11we've invested a lot of time in them Doesn't
- 54:16necessarily mean they're worth Continuing if
- 54:21something more important comes along, you know,
- 54:24so But I think that's part of the problem is
- 54:34There are certain people that I know that believe
- 54:37that we should just work on the fringes and that
- 54:40we should settle for small wins and build from
- 54:43there. But this mindset has existed for decades.
- 54:50And at what point do we decide that we're ready
- 54:53to then tackle the real change that we want?
- 54:58At what point is that going to be? Is it going
- 55:02to be decades away? Is it going to be in our
- 55:05lifetime? Um, and the logic just doesn't play
- 55:10out for me because, um, again, as I said, there's
- 55:14already big changes taking place. We can either
- 55:17be on the station or we can be on the train.
- 55:20Like we can be a part of this change, the big
- 55:22changes, or we can be left at the station. Uh,
- 55:28It's our choice, but they're already happening
- 55:31regardless. They're already gonna happen Do you
- 55:37believe in the theory of that by a thousand cuts
- 55:40so we are Having so many battles on so many different
- 55:45fronts that at some point this Giant that is
- 55:50factory farming will collapse. I don't know.
- 55:52I think that more focused energy is probably
- 55:55needed You know, we have really important movement
- 56:01leaders that really mapped out the evolution
- 56:05and anatomy of a social movement and how it plays
- 56:08out. I think of the Movement in Action Plan,
- 56:14and we have a lot of good resources, and we have
- 56:17a lot of good examples of change. And I think,
- 56:21generally speaking, A movement needs like grassroots
- 56:26momentum in the early stages. And then once it
- 56:30builds the popular opinion, popular support that
- 56:33it needs, then it's more inside game players,
- 56:39lobbyists, legislators, inside game people to
- 56:44get the change codified into law and make it
- 56:48stick. So yeah, I think it does require um battles
- 56:56on different fronts um but i also think uh you
- 57:01know we we don't have enough people working on
- 57:05the outside of the system um building grassroots
- 57:08momentum putting pressure on the system from
- 57:10the outside um and the importance of that is
- 57:15is so multifaceted but one of the most important
- 57:18things that it shows the public is that anyone
- 57:22regardless of their means, regardless of their
- 57:27influence or lack thereof, can get in front of
- 57:32the people we need to get change made. Anyone
- 57:36can do it. And that inspires people. It also
- 57:42reinforces the democratic process that we are
- 57:47supposed to be having. by putting everyday people
- 57:54in front of powerful people and demanding change,
- 58:01we're sending this message that we're demanding
- 58:05transparency and we're demanding that it's still
- 58:08possible to make change from people -powered
- 58:11movements. And it gives people hope, it inspires
- 58:16people to join because they think that they can
- 58:20have a difference. And when we only put professional
- 58:24spokespeople in front of our audiences and in
- 58:27front of the public, then we're sending the message
- 58:31that, well, you have to be a veterinarian or
- 58:33a nutritionist or an attorney or a lobbyist or
- 58:38a politician or whoever of some skill or expertise
- 58:44in order to have any impact. Even if we don't
- 58:49say that, If we only put professional class people
- 58:54in front of the audience we want to reach, that's
- 58:57the message we're sending. It really intimidates
- 59:01everyone else that should have a voice in the
- 59:03future of our food sister. So what we try to
- 59:08do is we try to debunk that idea by putting everyday
- 59:15people in front of the camera and being in front
- 59:18of powerful CEOs or powerful Congress people
- 59:23making decisions about our food system. I absolutely
- 59:28love like a democratization of of activism. Yes,
- 59:35I absolutely love that idea. I do think I mentioned
- 59:40how there's an economic barrier to getting into
- 59:44politics, but I think Before that, yes, it's
- 59:47the self perception of this is not me. This is
- 59:50not for me. I'm not part of that crowd. I'm not
- 59:53good enough. I don't have the right credentials.
- 59:57That's the inner dialogue that stops people from
- 1:00:01being more ambitious and assuming political responsibility.
- 1:00:05Let me give you a number 219 million. That's
- 1:00:11how much was spent on lobbies, the big ag lobby.
- 1:00:15in 2025. So that's how you get 200 million spent
- 1:00:23to purchase Palantir. That army made that possible,
- 1:00:28that army of lobbyists. And it's growing this
- 1:00:33year, 2026. I'm sure it will be in the 300 million,
- 1:00:36would not surprise me. What do you make of that
- 1:00:40number when you hear that number? What are the
- 1:00:43first thoughts you have? The first thoughts I
- 1:00:46have, so if I'm not mistaken, I think the Palantir
- 1:00:49deal is a $300 million deal, but what comes to
- 1:00:57mind is times when we were in Congress and we
- 1:01:03were in hearings and before and after the hearings,
- 1:01:07we got face -to -face with these lobbyists from
- 1:01:11the Turkey egg. Pig Beef industry sheep industry
- 1:01:19They bring the best of their industry spokespeople
- 1:01:23and lobbyists to these hearings to make the best
- 1:01:27cases possible For our tax dollars and what we
- 1:01:34realized is that this We're the only ones that
- 1:01:41I'm aware of that were actually even attempting
- 1:01:44to get in front of these lobbyists and ask them
- 1:01:47why they're doing this. They're corrupting our
- 1:01:50democracy. They're demanding money for their
- 1:01:54industry when every tax dollar that is going
- 1:02:00to them could be used to actually provide services
- 1:02:04that the public needs rather than benefit an
- 1:02:08industry that is already making record profits.
- 1:02:11and is worth $300 billion plus in 2026. And of
- 1:02:19course, they don't want to talk to you, and that's
- 1:02:21a given. Of course, they're ashamed, many of
- 1:02:25them. But the point is, what do we really expect
- 1:02:31if we're not in front of them, if we're not exposing
- 1:02:36this and making video of it and broadcasting
- 1:02:40this? How do we expect any change to happen if
- 1:02:44we're not even exposing the issue? We're not
- 1:02:49even doing the work of journalism, which is just
- 1:02:53expose the problem. Activism then takes it further
- 1:02:57and says, let's remedy this problem. So it's
- 1:03:03funny to me that we think that That we would
- 1:03:09expect anything different when we're not there
- 1:03:11to they're not meeting any resistance They're
- 1:03:15not meeting any public resistance. They're not
- 1:03:17being exposed And so until we really step that
- 1:03:22game up I think we will continue to see this
- 1:03:26we we see it in other industries, too There are
- 1:03:29groups Fighting war in Congress that are holding
- 1:03:34the defense industry accountable, like Palantir,
- 1:03:39they're in Congress every day. They're chasing
- 1:03:42Congress people down the halls and doing protests
- 1:03:45and hearings every day. And this is an example
- 1:03:55of how you could do it. But you got to be there.
- 1:04:02There's you got to be in the middle of this you
- 1:04:05got to be in the discourse You got to be present
- 1:04:07you got to be in the spaces of power if you want
- 1:04:10power to shift And that's exactly what we need
- 1:04:13to see happen Otherwise our other option is we
- 1:04:19can throw up our hands and say That the system
- 1:04:22is too corrupt and there's nothing we can do
- 1:04:24about it. And that's a really easy way out, isn't
- 1:04:26it? This is such a great way of putting it when
- 1:04:34will this Palantir deal going to? be finalized
- 1:04:40I honestly think that I Think the USDA I don't
- 1:04:45know what kind of approval process they had if
- 1:04:48any And I believe it's and I think it's in effect
- 1:04:53But things it doesn't mean that we can't We can't
- 1:05:02have an impact to change that. Contracts get
- 1:05:07canceled, right? There's always a chance. There's
- 1:05:11always an opportunity to do something. So right
- 1:05:16now we have the farm bill coming through the
- 1:05:20Senate. Now it got passed through the House.
- 1:05:23And now it's going to go through the Senate.
- 1:05:25It may not really go anywhere. Honestly, the
- 1:05:29Senate might not take it up for weeks or months
- 1:05:33or who knows. But, you know, while that's kind
- 1:05:40of a hot topic right now, our focus is mostly
- 1:05:45on that. And how could we activate people to
- 1:05:48go, you know, right now, if you look at what
- 1:05:52our movement is doing is saying, call your congressperson,
- 1:05:56call them right now. and tell them not to vote
- 1:05:59for a farm bill that includes the Save Our Bacon
- 1:06:02Act, which is the repeal of the animal protection
- 1:06:05laws. And yet, what we really need is more than
- 1:06:15phone calls, right? Because you and I, everyone
- 1:06:18knows that phone calls are not enough. You need
- 1:06:22to get into these spaces of power. You need to
- 1:06:25be Showing up and you know, I told a group that
- 1:06:30if you could get 30 to 50 people Involved in
- 1:06:34an action at one of these hearings. There's a
- 1:06:37good likelihood. We could actually shut down
- 1:06:39the hearing because they're already chaotic and
- 1:06:43there's prone to lots of disruptions and Cancellations
- 1:06:49and people not showing up and So there's a lot
- 1:06:53of chaos already and we wedge ourselves into
- 1:06:55that chaos and we get them to cancel it and reschedule
- 1:06:59it or whatever. We can have an impact with 30
- 1:07:04to 50 people in there easily. But that would
- 1:07:10mean, you know, I have to leave my home and my
- 1:07:14home office and take the road and that's tough.
- 1:07:20The interesting thing is that these same people
- 1:07:23are willing to die on the hill and repeatedly
- 1:07:27go to a restaurant and protest at this restaurant
- 1:07:31to get them to adopt a foie gras free or fur
- 1:07:36free policy. So, okay, by that logic, what's
- 1:07:45the proportionate response for a bill that It
- 1:07:50impacts billions of animals and a trillion and
- 1:07:53a half dollars for animal ag. So if you're willing
- 1:07:57to do that to get a restaurant to do something,
- 1:08:01what are you willing to do to get Congress to
- 1:08:05act on something huge for animals? I'm trying
- 1:08:10to use their logic and appeal to their logic
- 1:08:15and encourage them that, hey, Okay, let's use
- 1:08:21that, but let's use it on a scale that has never
- 1:08:24been used before because we have the power to
- 1:08:27do it. Yeah, that's my point about being giants
- 1:08:33and having all of that energy, but spending it
- 1:08:36on the smallest of tasks like local restaurants
- 1:08:40instead of something more ambitious. I think
- 1:08:47those are great final words. Robert, by the way,
- 1:08:52we say hello to our friends at Palantir. I hope
- 1:08:57you enjoyed that conversation. I guess weird
- 1:09:02things will start happening because of that deal.
- 1:09:06Let's keep an eye open for that. Robert, did
- 1:09:14you want to add something before we stop the
- 1:09:18recording? Yeah, I mean the creepy thing about
- 1:09:22the Palantir deal is it's gonna be real difficult
- 1:09:26for us to even know what impact that has because
- 1:09:31the only way we'd know is if like certain activists
- 1:09:35end up getting arrested and then legal proceedings
- 1:09:39determine that Palantir technology was used to
- 1:09:43implicate those activists. And then that would
- 1:09:48tell us one case, but it wouldn't give us the
- 1:09:51full picture of what is really going on. And
- 1:09:54that's what's so sinister about the surveillance
- 1:09:57technology that they're using. So yeah, we got
- 1:10:02to be on, we got to really keep an eye on that.
- 1:10:07Yeah. Yeah, that's an interesting question. Also,
- 1:10:14are you safe if you're just donating a few dollars
- 1:10:19here and there to animal causes? Will you get
- 1:10:21into the radar if you're giving to the wrong
- 1:10:26nonprofit? I think we have a responsibility to
- 1:10:32protect our community of supporters too and donors.
- 1:10:35So what about them? Absolutely. Okay, well the
- 1:10:43locations are huge right it's just like if they
- 1:10:46know everything about us and where we spend our
- 1:10:49money and where we go and what we like and you
- 1:10:53know on social media and all that then What are
- 1:10:56all the implications of that? How could it be
- 1:10:58used? against us It's a it's hard to get your
- 1:11:03head around it. Yeah, and I think you know employers
- 1:11:06will start using some kind of yeah Palantir a
- 1:11:13corporate product version. And then, you know,
- 1:11:17uh, you'll get denied a job because you were,
- 1:11:20uh, one of those, uh, dangerous activists and
- 1:11:24it will be a red flag on your resume. Um, yeah,
- 1:11:30if, if there are any jobs in the future, that's,
- 1:11:33that's another question. That's the other question,
- 1:11:35right? Well, on that sinister note, Robert, it's
- 1:11:46always a pleasure talking with you. I think you're
- 1:11:49an amazing person and actor in this movement.
- 1:11:53We're really lucky to have you. And I'm really
- 1:11:57lucky to be able to share your perspective and
- 1:12:00thoughts with other animal advocates. So thank
- 1:12:04you so much, Robert. Oh, thank you so much for
- 1:12:07having me. I look forward to the next time. Thank
- 1:12:11you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:12:14to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:12:17Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:12:21thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:12:24next Tuesday for a new episode.