Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Housing and Homelessness
Transcript
- 0:03[♪♪]
- 0:09GOOD EVENING.
- 0:10WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16ABOUT FOUR-THOUSAND KENTUCKIANS
- 0:17WILL GO TO SLEEP TONIGHT WITHOUT
- 0:18A PERMANENT HOME.
- 0:20HOMELESSNESS HAS BEEN A SUBJECT
- 0:22OF DEBATE FOR DECADES, BUT THAT
- 0:24DEBATE HAS INTENSIFIED IN RECENT
- 0:27WEEKS, AFTER THE KENTUCKY
- 0:28GENERAL ASSEMBLY PASSED AN
- 0:30ANTI-CRIME BILL THAT BANS
- 0:32SO-CALLED “UNLAWFUL CAMPING” —
- 0:34WITH FINES AND EVEN JAIL TIME
- 0:35FOR PEOPLE VIOLATING THE LAW.
- 0:37HOMELESS ADVOCATES HAVE
- 0:39DENOUNCED THAT BILL FOR MAKING
- 0:40HOMELESSNESS A CRIME.
- 0:42IT INSPIRED PROTESTS IN SOME
- 0:43KENTUCKY CITIES.
- 0:45LAST WEEK, THE U.S. SUPREME
- 0:48COURT HEARD ARGUMENTS IN THE
- 0:50CASE OF JOHNSON V. GRANT’S PASS,
- 0:52INVOLVING AN OREGON CITY
- 0:54ORDINANCE THAT WILL DETERMINE IF
- 0:55THE CONSTITUTION’S PROTECTIONS
- 0:56AGAINST CRUEL AND UNUSUAL
- 0:58PUNISHMENT INCLUDE PEOPLE WHO
- 0:59SLEEP OUTSIDE.
- 1:00WE’LL TALK ABOUT THAT CASE THIS
- 1:01EVENING AND THE IMPACT THE HIGH
- 1:03COURT’S RULING COULD HAVE ON THE
- 1:04NEW KENTUCKY LAW.
- 1:08WE ARE JOINED, IN OUR LEXINGTON
- 1:09STUDIO, BY: RICHARD NELSON,
- 1:11EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
- 1:12COMMONWEALTH POLICY CENTER;
- 1:14GEORGE EKLUND, DIRECTOR OF
- 1:16EDUCATION AND ADVOCACY FOR THE
- 1:18COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS; PAUL
- 1:19SALAMANCA, UNIVERSITY OF
- 1:21KENTUCKY LAW PROFESSOR; AND
- 1:24KUNGU NJUGUNA, POLICY STRATEGIST
- 1:27FOR THE ACLU OF KENTUCKY.
- 1:28WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU.
- 1:29YOU CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:32COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:33-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 1:36SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:37K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:40OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:42O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 1:42OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:45WELCOME TO OUR GUESTS.
- 1:50THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE TONIGHT
- 1:52THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT TOPIC.
- 1:54THIS IS GEORGE'S SECOND TIME AND
- 1:58KUNGU'S SECOND TIME BEING ON
- 1:59THIS PROGRAM TO TALK ABOUT THIS
- 2:01ISSUE.
- 2:01BEFORE WE GET TO THE SUPREME
- 2:03COURT CASE AND OTHER FACTS ABOUT
- 2:05WHAT KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 2:06DID, I WANT US TO TALK ABOUT THE
- 2:10STATE OF HOMELESSNESS IN
- 2:12KENTUCKY.
- 2:13THE 4,000.
- 2:13IS IT A GROWING PROBLEM?
- 2:15I SAID IT WAS BUT DO WE HAVE
- 2:17STATS THAT PROVE IT IS A GROWING
- 2:18PROBLEM?
- 2:19AND HOW DO WE DEFINE
- 2:21HOMELESSNESS SHELTERED VERSUS
- 2:24UNSHELTERED AND WHY DOES THAT
- 2:26MATTER FOR THE PURPOSES OF
- 2:27TONIGHT'S DISCUSSION?
- 2:28>> FIRST, I WANT EVERYONE TO
- 2:30KNOW THAT HOMELESSNESS IS
- 2:31GROWING BUT THAT IS LARGELY A
- 2:33FUNCTION OF OUR HOUSING MARKET.
- 2:34AT DIFFERENT POINTS IN OUR
- 2:35HOUSING MARKET WE SEE IT TIGHT
- 2:37WITH AVAILABLE RENTAL.
- 2:39AND THE AVAILABLE HOMEOWNERSHIP
- 2:41OPPORTUNITIES AND THAT HAS A
- 2:43SPILLOVER EFFECT FOR THOSE
- 2:46EARNING THE LEAST.
- 2:47THEY HAVE THE FEWEST AMOUNT OF
- 2:49OPTIONS TO GET INTO HOUSING.
- 2:51PEOPLE ARE PLAYING MUSICAL
- 2:52CHAIRS IF I'M COMPETING AGAINST
- 2:54SOMEBODY WHO HAS MORE RESOURCES
- 2:57OR I MIGHT HAVE A DISABILITY OR
- 2:59I HAVE SOME OTHER ISSUE THAT
- 3:01PREVENTEDS ME FROM GETTING INTO
- 3:03HOUSING.
- 3:04AND WHEN I LOSE I END UP
- 3:07BECOMING HOMELESS.
- 3:08FOR US THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
- 3:09ISSUE.
- 3:10AND IN ORDER FOR US TO REALLY
- 3:13ADDRESS THE ISSUE OF
- 3:14HOMELESSNESS IN KENTUCKY, WE
- 3:16REALLY NEED TO START DELVING
- 3:18INTO WHAT IS OUR SUPPLY LOOK
- 3:21LIKE?
- 3:21HOW DO WE INCREASE AFFORDABLE
- 3:23RENTAL OPTIONS IN KENTUCKY FOR
- 3:26EVERYONE.
- 3:26>> Renee: DO YOU BELIEVE THE
- 3:28ASSEMBLY ADDRESSED THAT PROBLEM?
- 3:29>> AT HOUSE BILL 5, NO.
- 3:30AT THE END OF THE DAY RENT IS
- 3:32TOO HIGH AND HOUSE BILL 5 DOES
- 3:36NOT DO ANYTHING TO ADDRESS THE
- 3:37RENT AMOUNTS IN KENTUCKY.
- 3:39>> Renee: IS THERE ANY
- 3:42CAUTIONATION BETWEEN COVID-19
- 3:43AND THE UP PARTICULAR OF
- 3:45HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS IN
- 3:47KENTUCKY?
- 3:48>> SINCE 2018 WE'VE SEEN 78%
- 3:52INCREASE IN KENTUCKY.
- 3:53WE'VE SEEN A 58% RISE IN OUR
- 3:56AVERAGE RENTS ACROSS THE STATE.
- 3:57>> Renee: THIS SIDE.
- 3:58THERE WAS A SURVEY CONDUCTED BY
- 4:00THE INSTITUTE INVOLVED IN THE
- 4:02POLICY MAKING OF HOUSE BILL 5
- 4:03AND THEY HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN
- 4:05OTHER STATES IN HELPING THEM
- 4:07ALSO CRAFT SIMILAR LEGISLATION.
- 4:09THEY CONDUCTED A SURVEY IN
- 4:10JANUARY THAT FOUND THAT 56% OF
- 4:12ALL VOTERS PERCEIVE HOMELESS
- 4:15ENCAMPMENTS AS A THREAT TO
- 4:16PUBLIC SAFETY.
- 4:1768% SAYING THEY WOULD AVOID THE
- 4:20AREAS SOME OR ALL THE TIME.
- 4:2387% BELIEVE MOVING HOMELESS
- 4:25INDIVIDUALS TO SHELTER IS MORE
- 4:27COMPASSIONATE.
- 4:2976% DO NOT THINK INDIVIDUALS
- 4:30HAVE A RIGHT TO CAMP ON THE
- 4:32STREET WHEN SHELTER OPTIONS ARE
- 4:34AVAILABLE AND A MAJORITY 56%
- 4:36WANT TO PROHIBIT PUBLIC STREET
- 4:38CAMPING.
- 4:39TO YOU Mr. NELSON TO SEE IF
- 4:42THE POLLING NUMBERS JUSTIFY FOR
- 4:44THE REASONS A HOUSE BILL 5
- 4:48PARTICULARLY THOSE PROVISIONS
- 4:49DEALING WITH IT THE PUBLIC
- 4:52ENCAMPMENTS WERE THE RIGHT THING
- 4:53TO DO?
- 4:53>> I THINK SO.
- 4:54OF COURSE, HOUSE BILL 5 THE
- 4:56SAFER KENTUCKY ACT ADDRESSED
- 4:59CRIME IN A NUMBER OF LEVELS AND
- 5:00THEY UPDATED OUR CRIMINAL
- 5:02STATUTES.
- 5:03SOME HAD NOT BEEN UPDATED IN 50
- 5:05YEARS.
- 5:06PART OF THE DISCUSSION IS
- 5:08HOMELESSNESS.
- 5:08AND I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT YOU
- 5:10ELUDED TO THIS A MOMENT AGO, BUT
- 5:14WE SHOULD TALK ABOUT
- 5:15DEFINITIONS.
- 5:15THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 5:17HOMELESS AND THOSE UNSHELTERED.
- 5:19THE NUMBER LAST YEAR, THE NUMBER
- 5:21I'M LOOKING AT WAS 4766
- 5:24HOMELESS.
- 5:25BUT OUT OF THAT NUMBER IT WAS
- 5:271470 UNSHELTERED.
- 5:29AND THAT'S THE SEGMENT OF THE
- 5:32POPULATION THAT HOUSE BILL 5
- 5:34ADDRESSES.
- 5:34WHEN YOU TALK ABOUT A LARGE
- 5:36GROUP OF UNSHELTERED PEOPLE
- 5:38CAMPING IN PUBLIC, THAT'S A
- 5:41PUBLIC POLICY ISSUE.
- 5:42THERE ARE HEALTH ISSUES
- 5:44ASSOCIATED WITH THAT.
- 5:45THERE ARE CRIME ISSUES
- 5:47ASSOCIATED WITH THAT.
- 5:48THE LIKELIHOOD OF CRIME
- 5:50PERPETRATED AGAINST THE HOMELESS
- 5:52OR THOSE UNSHELTERED OR
- 5:55PERPETRATING CRIME AGAINST
- 5:56OTHERS IT INCREASES WITHIN A
- 5:58RADIUS OF THAT AREA.
- 5:59AND THAT IS WHAT THE STATE
- 6:00GENERAL ASSEMBLY TRIED TO DO.
- 6:03>> Renee: DOES HOUSE BILL 5 IN
- 6:05THIS PROVISIONS DEALING WITH
- 6:06CAMPING DOES IT DIFFERENTIATE
- 6:09BETWEEN HOMELESS AND
- 6:10UNSHELTERED?
- 6:11>> I BELIEVE IT DOES.
- 6:12THERE IS A PROVISION, BY THE
- 6:14WAY, AN EXCEPTION THAT ALLOWS
- 6:16FOR THOSE WHO LAWFULLY ARE
- 6:19STAYING IN THEIR CAR.
- 6:21>> Renee: UP TO 12 HOURS.
- 6:22>> UP TO 12 HOURS THERE IS AN
- 6:24EXCEPT SHOP FOR THAT.
- 6:25I BELIEVE IT DOES DISTINGUISH
- 6:26THE TWO CATEGORIES.
- 6:30>> I DON'T THINK IT'S CORRECT IT
- 6:32SAID THAT A PERSPECTIVE WHO IS
- 6:34CAMPING WITH THE INTENT TO SLEEP
- 6:36IS VIOLATING THE ANTI-CAMPING
- 6:40STATUTES.
- 6:40IT DOESN'T MAKE A DIFFERENCE
- 6:42BETWEEN THOSE TWO.
- 6:43>> Renee: AND THAT IS THE CASE
- 6:44IN SECTION 17 PARAGRAPH TWO A
- 6:48PERSON IS GUILTY OF UNLAWFUL
- 6:50CAMPING AND WHEN THEY REMAIN ON
- 6:53A PUBLIC STREET, UNDER BRIDGE,
- 6:55PATH, PARK, CEMETERY OR
- 6:57DESIGNATED FOR USE BY
- 6:58PEDESTRIANS OR VEHICLES
- 7:00INCLUDING AREAS USED FOR INGRESS
- 7:03OR EGRESSES TO BUSINESSES, HOMES
- 7:07OR PUBLIC BUILDINGS.
- 7:09PROFESSOR?
- 7:09>> I AGREE WITH KUNGU THAT IT
- 7:17FOCUSES ON WHAT LAWYERS CALL AN
- 7:20ACT TUS REYES.
- 7:21AN ACT.
- 7:22THAT IS ILLEGAL IS AS YOU JUST
- 7:25SAID, RENEE, IS HAVING CAMPING
- 7:29PARAPHERNALIA OR HAVING SOME
- 7:31SORT OF CAMPING STRUCTURE A CAMP
- 7:34FACILITY.
- 7:34BUT THERE'S ALSO IN ANOTHER
- 7:38LAWYERLY PHRASE, ACTUSRAYS, AND
- 7:44MEN'S RAIA, THE CRIMINAL MIND
- 7:47AND THERE IS AN INTENT.
- 7:49YOU HAVE TO HAVE AN INTENT TO
- 7:52SPEND THE NIGHT.
- 7:53THERE ARE MOVING PARTS IN THIS
- 7:56THING.
- 7:57INTENT TO SLEEP.
- 7:58>> WITH THE INTENT TO SLEEP.
- 8:01YOU WERE --
- 8:02IT IS A NEAR WHERE YOU WERE
- 8:05QUOTING IN LINE 20 IF YOU ARE
- 8:07LOOKING AT THE UNOFFICIAL COPY
- 8:09OF 17 SUB2.
- 8:12>> Renee: INTENT.
- 8:12I MEAN THAT SEEMS HARD TO
- 8:16DETERMINE.
- 8:16PERHAPS?
- 8:18HOW DO YOU MEASURE INTENT?
- 8:19>> IT'S SURROUNDING
- 8:21CIRCUMSTANCES IF SOMEONE HAS IF
- 8:23THEY ARE LAYING DOWN IN A
- 8:25BLANKET, THAT'S THEIR INTENT TO
- 8:27SLEEP.
- 8:27BUT I THINK TO GEORGE'S POINT, I
- 8:30THINK HB5 DOES NOTHING TO SOLVE
- 8:34OUR HOMELESS PROBLEM IN THIS
- 8:37COMMUNITY.
- 8:37WHAT WE NEED MORE HOUSING NOT
- 8:40HANDCUFFS.
- 8:40AND HB5 LOOKS TO CRIMINALIZE
- 8:44BEHAVIOR TO SOME OF THE MOST
- 8:46MARGINALIZED PEOPLE IN OUR
- 8:47COMMUNITY AND WHO ARE AT RISK.
- 8:48AND HB5 DIDN'T INVEST IN
- 8:50AFFORDABLE HOUSING, IN
- 8:52TRANSPORTATION, IN EDUCATION,
- 8:53AND ALL THE THINGS THAT COULD
- 8:55HELP GET PEOPLE NOT BE HOMELESS.
- 8:57HB5 DIDN'T DO ANY OF THAT.
- 8:59AND THAT'S IMPORTANT TO POINT
- 9:00OUT.
- 9:00>> AND THIS IS AN IMPORTANT
- 9:03THING THAT I WANT EVERYONE TO
- 9:04KNOW.
- 9:05WE HAVE A SHORTAGE OF SHELTER AS
- 9:07WELL AS HOUSING N LOUISVILLE WE
- 9:09HAVE 1600 PEOPLE HOMELESS EACH
- 9:12NIGHT AND 750 SHELTER BEDS.
- 9:15WE CAN FLEX UP DURING EXTREME
- 9:17WEATHER BUT THAT GETS US 150.
- 9:19PEOPLE DON'T HAVE AN OPTION TO
- 9:21GO IN.
- 9:21AT THE SAME TIME, ONLY 33
- 9:24COUNTIES HAVE AN ACTIVE SHELTER
- 9:26IN THEIR AREA.
- 9:27SO THERE ARE LARGE SWATHS OF OUR
- 9:29STATE THAT DON'T HAVE A PLACE
- 9:31FOR PEOPLE TO GO AT NIGHT.
- 9:34>> Renee: LOUISVILLE ADDRESSED
- 9:35THE ENCAMPMENT ISSUE?
- 9:38>> YES.
- 9:38A COUPLE YEARS AGO WE PASSED A
- 9:41BILL THAT MADE IT ILLEGAL TO
- 9:43CAMP OUTSIDE.
- 9:44AND IT WAS AN ATTEMPT TO ADDRESS
- 9:46THIS ISSUE THAT HOUSE BILL 5 IS
- 9:49ATTEMPTING TO ADDRESS.
- 9:50THAT BY DEFAULT PEOPLE DON'T
- 9:52HAVE AN OPTION TO GO IN, MOST
- 9:54DAYS OF THE WEEK.
- 9:54WE HAVE MANAGED THE COORDINATED
- 9:57SHELTER ACCESS LINE AND ALL THE
- 9:58BED RESERVATIONS ARE FILLED BY
- 10:0110:30.
- 10:01LINE OPENS AT 10 AND IT'S FULL
- 10:03WITHIN 30 MINUTES.
- 10:04>> RENEE, FORGIVE ME FOR
- 10:08INTERRUPTING.
- 10:08I AGREE WITH MY FRIENDS THAT
- 10:10THIS IS A PROBLEM.
- 10:11THIS IS OBVIOUSLY A VERY SERIOUS
- 10:14PROBLEM AND IT'S SOMETHING WE
- 10:16ALL NEED TO ATTEND TO.
- 10:18BUT IT DOESN'T MEAN THAT HB5 IS
- 10:20WRONG.
- 10:21BECAUSE ONE PIECE OF LEGISLATION
- 10:22WHICH ADDRESSES ONE ISSUE, ONE
- 10:24PART OF ONE ISSUE DOESN'T DO
- 10:26EVERYTHING THAT WE NEED TO HAVE
- 10:28DONE, DOESN'T MEAN THAT THE
- 10:29PIECE OF LEGISLATION IS WRONG.
- 10:31HB5 IS TRYING TO PROTECT OTHER
- 10:35IMPORTANT INTERESTS.
- 10:36RICHARD MENTIONED SOME OF THEM.
- 10:37IT'S TRYING TO PROTECT THE
- 10:39INDIVIDUALS THEMSELVES WHO ARE
- 10:40VULNERABLE AND PROTECT PEOPLE
- 10:41NEAR THEM.
- 10:42THAT IS NOT WRONG.
- 10:44GEORGE'S POINT AND KUNGU'S POINT
- 10:46IS THAT WE'VE GOT MORE TO DO.
- 10:48AND I DON'T DENY THAT.
- 10:50WE DO.
- 10:52IT'S COLD.
- 10:52>> I ARGUE THAT HB5 ISN'T
- 10:56HELPING PEOPLE WHEN YOU ARE
- 10:57SUBJECTING THEM TO BEING FINED
- 10:59$250 AND UP TO 90 DAYS IN JAIL.
- 11:02THAT IS NOT HELPING THEM.
- 11:03JAIL IS NOT A SAFE PLACE FOR
- 11:05THESE INDIVIDUALS.
- 11:06WE KNOW IN LOUISVILLE WE HAD A
- 11:07PERIOD OF TIME WHERE UP TO 12
- 11:08PEOPLE DIED IN OUR JAIL.
- 11:10FOUR OF THOSE PEOPLE IN THAT
- 11:12JAIL WERE CHRONICALLY UNHOUSED.
- 11:14JAIL IS NOT A SAFE PLACE FOR
- 11:15THEM.
- 11:18AND FINING PEOPLE $250 THEY
- 11:20DON'T HAVE THE MONEY.
- 11:20YOU WILL CREATE A CYCLE OF
- 11:23ARRESTING PEOPLE WHO CAN'T PAY
- 11:24THE FINE, PROBABLY DON'T SHOW UP
- 11:26TO COURT BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE
- 11:28A ADDRESS OR A TELEPHONE GETTING
- 11:30BENCH WARRANTS AND GETTING THE
- 11:32CYCLE OF PEOPLE IN AND OUT OF
- 11:33OUR JAILS.
- 11:34IN LOUISVILLE COSTS $88 A DAY.
- 11:37LIKE WHAT ARE WE DOING?
- 11:39HB5 SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABOUT
- 11:41CREATING MORE SHELTERS AND
- 11:43SERVICES FOR THOSE MARGINALIZED
- 11:45FOLKS.
- 11:45>> Renee: THIS IS A QUESTION
- 11:46WE'VE HAD POSED ON THIS PROGRAM
- 11:48AND OTHERS WHEN WE'VE TALKED
- 11:50ABOUT HOUSE BILL 5.
- 11:50AND DEALING WITH VIOLENT CRIME
- 11:52AND REPEAT OFFENDERS.
- 11:54THREE STRIKES ET CETERA.
- 11:56WHY THESE PROVISIONS IN THIS
- 11:57PARTICULAR BILL?
- 11:58I WANT TO ASK YOU PROFESSOR WHY
- 12:00IS THIS A MATTER OF PUBLIC
- 12:02SAFETY OR ANTICRIME ISSUE?
- 12:04>> WELL, I THINK WHEN YOU PUT --
- 12:08WHEN YOU HAVE AREAS WHERE THE
- 12:09POLICE CAN'T MONITOR PROPERLY
- 12:11BECAUSE THERE ARE A LOT OF
- 12:12THINGS GOING ON THAT ARE ILLEGAL
- 12:14IT BECOMES MORE LIKELY OTHER
- 12:16ILLEGAL THINGS WILL HAPPEN
- 12:17THERE.
- 12:17IF YOU HAVE A LOT OF TENTS IN
- 12:21CLOSE PROXIMITY IF THE POLICE
- 12:23DON'T DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT
- 12:25CHANCES ARE THERE WILL BE MORE
- 12:27DEALING OF DRUGS AND MORE
- 12:30PROSTITUTION.
- 12:31CHANCES ARE ORDINARY
- 12:32CONVENTIONAL BUSINESSES THAT ARE
- 12:33NEARBY WILL CLOSE BECAUSE PEOPLE
- 12:35WON'T WANT TO SHOP THERE.
- 12:36YOU HAVE DETERIORATION OF THE
- 12:39NEIGHBORHOOD.
- 12:40SO IT'S NOT PARTICULARLY SAFE
- 12:42AND I DON'T WANT TO SAY IT'S NOT
- 12:44RELATIVELY SAFE FOR THOSE
- 12:46PEOPLE, BUT IT'S NOT SAFE ON THE
- 12:47WHOLE.
- 12:48I WANT TO MAKE ONE ADDITIONAL
- 12:50POINT ABOUT INCENTIVES.
- 12:52I AGREE WITH KUNGU AND I AGREE
- 12:55WITH GEORGE THAT CYCLING PEOPLE
- 12:57IN AND OUT OF JAIL ISN'T GREAT.
- 13:00IF YOU DON'T HAVE INCENTIVE FOR
- 13:03PEOPLE TO DO THE BEST THEY CAN
- 13:04TO FIND A SHELTER THEN THAT
- 13:07MISSING INCENTIVE MATTERS.
- 13:08THE WOMAN IN JOHNSON VERSES
- 13:13GRANT'S PASS WOULD NOT GO TO THE
- 13:15SHELTER BECAUSE THEY WOULD NOT
- 13:16TAKE HER DOG.
- 13:17WE HAVE SOMEONE WHO HAD ACCESS
- 13:19TO A SHELTER.
- 13:20MS. JOHNSON THEY WOULDN'T TAKE
- 13:23HER ROTWEILER.
- 13:24IF WE HAVE A STATUTE THAT SAYS
- 13:26YOU CAN GET IN TROUBLE IF YOU
- 13:28SLEEP IN THE PARK EVERY NIGHT.
- 13:29AT LEAST YOU WILL HAVE AN
- 13:32INCENTIVE TO GO TO THE SHELTER
- 13:33AND OUTSOURCE YOUR DOG.
- 13:36>> RENEE, IT WAS MENTIONED HOW
- 13:38MUCH MONEY WAS SPENT AND I AGREE
- 13:40TO YOUR POINT ABOUT CYCLING
- 13:42PEOPLE THROUGHOUT REALLY WE NEED
- 13:44TO TALK ABOUT ADDRESSING CORE
- 13:46ISSUES.
- 13:47AND LARGE NUMBER OF UNSHELTERED
- 13:49PEOPLE IN PARTICULAR SUFFER FROM
- 13:52MENTAL ILLNESS, A LARGE NUMBER
- 13:54SUFFER FROM ADDICTION ISSUES.
- 13:56I TRIED TO FIND NUMBERS FOR
- 13:58KENTUCKY I DID FIND SOME NUMBERS
- 14:01FROM CALIFORNIA.
- 14:02THERE WAS A REPORT LAST YEAR
- 14:05THAT CALIFORNIA STATE-WIDE STUDY
- 14:06OF PEOPLE EXPERIENCING
- 14:08HOMELESSNESS TOWARD A NEW
- 14:10UNDERSTANDING AND THEY FOUND 80%
- 14:11OF PEOPLE IN CALIFORNIA
- 14:15EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS
- 14:15REPORTED SERIOUS MENTAL HEALTH
- 14:17CONDITIONS.
- 14:18ONE OUT OF FOUR HAD BEEN
- 14:19HOSPITALIZED.
- 14:20AND SAME REPORT A DIFFERENT
- 14:21REPORT, THE NATIONAL COALITION
- 14:23FOR THE HOMELESS FOUND THAT 68%
- 14:26OF U.S. CITIES REPORTED THAT
- 14:29ADDICTION IS THE SINGLE LARGEST
- 14:30CAUSE OF HOMELESSNESS.
- 14:31WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT THESE
- 14:33ASPECTS AS WELL.
- 14:34I DON'T THINK THAT UNTIL WE
- 14:36ADDRESS THOSE CORE ISSUES
- 14:37HELPING THEM.
- 14:38AND THAT IS COMPASSIONATE.
- 14:40HELPING THEM WITH BASIC NEEDS
- 14:42THEIR MENTAL HEALTH STATE.
- 14:43IF NAY NEED ADDICTION RECOVERY,
- 14:46GOVERNOR BESHEAR MENTIONED THAT
- 14:47KENTUCKY HAS PER CAPITA THE
- 14:49LARGEST NUMBER OF ADDICTION
- 14:51RECOVERY BEDS IN THE COUNTRY.
- 14:53>> I WILL RESPOND TO THAT AND
- 14:55THROW IT TO GEORGE HE HAS
- 14:58KENTUCKY NUMBERS AND THAT THE IS
- 14:59GREAT WE HAVE THE MOST RECOVERY
- 15:00BEDS.
- 15:01AS A PERSON IN LONG-TERM
- 15:03RECOVERY I CAN APPRECIATE THAT.
- 15:04AS I SAID THE FIRST TIME WE WERE
- 15:06ON HERE, THERE ARE BARRIERS TO
- 15:10ACCESSING THOSE BEDS.
- 15:11FOR ONE, IT'S NOT A SOLUTION
- 15:13BECAUSE MOST RECOVERY CENTERS
- 15:14ARE 28-DAYS OR 30-DAYS.
- 15:18SOME REQUIRE YOU TO HAVE
- 15:19INSURANCE.
- 15:20SOME ARE SECTARIAN BASED
- 15:21RELIGIOUS BASED.
- 15:23THERE ARE BARRIERS GETTING TO
- 15:24THE BEDS.
- 15:25I WILL LET GEORGE TALK ABOUT THE
- 15:27NUMBERS.
- 15:27>> BASED ON THE STATE-WIDE COUNT
- 15:30ADMINISTERED BY THE KENTUCKY
- 15:32HOUSING CORPORATION, 37% OF
- 15:33FOLKS HAVE A SEVERE MENTAL
- 15:35ILLNESS OR SUBSTANCE USE
- 15:37DISORDER HERE IN KENTUCKY.
- 15:39FOR US KUNGU SAID IT WELL, IS
- 15:42PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING THROUGH
- 15:43THESE MOMENTS IN THEIR LIFE LIKE
- 15:45THEY HAD AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
- 15:47CRISIS BEFORE THEY WENT INTO
- 15:48RECOVERY AND THEY WILL HAVE ONE
- 15:50WHEN THEY EXIT.
- 15:51SURE WE INVESTED IN RECOVERY
- 15:53OPTIONS IN KENTUCKY AND THAT WAS
- 15:55A HUGE GOD SEND FROM THE STATE
- 15:57GOVERNMENT BUT THAT GOT US 3500
- 15:59BEDS.
- 16:00OUR NIGHTLY COUNT IS 4,000.
- 16:01IT IS STILL NOT A PANACEA FOR
- 16:04ALL OF OUR ISSUES IT IS AN
- 16:06OPTION THAT CAN BE EMPLOYED BUT
- 16:08WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT WHERE ARE
- 16:10PEOPLE COMMITTING TO ON DAY 29.
- 16:13>> Renee: WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT
- 16:15CHRONIC INDIVIDUALS PEOPLE IN A
- 16:18CHRONIC CONDITION?
- 16:19>> WHEN YOU ARE CHRONIC YOU HAVE
- 16:22BEEN HOMELESS FOR YEARS AND
- 16:23MONTHS OFF AND ON OVER THE
- 16:25COURSE OF TWO TO FIVE YEARS.
- 16:27IT IS A HIGHER PRESENCE OF
- 16:30PEOPLE WITH SMI OR SUD BECAUSE
- 16:33THAT IS BECAUSE YOU CANNOT
- 16:35MAINTAIN EMPLOYMENT TO PAY YOUR
- 16:37RENT.
- 16:37FOR US, THE BEST INTERVENTION
- 16:40FOR THAT POPULATION IS WHAT IS
- 16:41CALLED PERMANENT SUPPORTIVE
- 16:43HOUSING WHERE WE GET SOMEBODY
- 16:44INTO A HOUSE AND SHELTERED AND
- 16:46WE SEARCH RESOURCES AND CASE
- 16:49MANAGEMENT TO FIGURE OUT THE
- 16:50NEXT STEP.
- 16:51I'VE HAD FRIENDS OF MINE THAT
- 16:53HAVE BEEN HOMELESS.
- 16:55THEY HAD SUFFERED FROM SUD, AND
- 16:58THEY ONLY GET SOBER BECAUSE THEY
- 17:00HAD THE STABLE HOUSING PIECE.
- 17:02AND ONE PERSON LIKE WE'RE
- 17:04TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE HOUSED FOR
- 17:06DECADES AT THIS POINT.
- 17:07AND BECOMING A MUCH MORE
- 17:09FRUITFUL MEMBER OF OUR SOCIETY.
- 17:10>> Renee: WELL, WE MENTIONED AT
- 17:12THE BEGINNING OF THE SHOW HOW
- 17:14LAST WEEK THERE WERE SEVERAL
- 17:15KENTUCKY CITIES I BELIEVE FOUR
- 17:17WERE PROTESTING THOSE PROVISIONS
- 17:19IN HOUSE BILL 5.
- 17:20AND SO WE WANT TO GO TO A PIECE
- 17:22OF VIDEO THAT WE PRODUCED FOR
- 17:24KENTUCKY EDITION THAT AIRED LAST
- 17:26MONDAY ABOUT A RALLY HELD IN
- 17:28LOUISVILLE.
- 17:28THIS WAS PRODUCED BY KENTUCKY
- 17:31EDITION'S JIM LOEFFLER.
- 17:32>> THE COALITION FOR THE
- 17:36HOMELESS ESTIMATES ON ANY GIVEN
- 17:37NIGHT IN LOUISVILLE ABOUT 600
- 17:39PEOPLE SLEEP ON THE STREETS.
- 17:41ANGIE JOHNSON HAS BEEN THERE.
- 17:42>> I'D RATHER DIE THAN TO LIVE
- 17:45BACK ON THESE STREETS.
- 17:46BECAUSE I KNOW HOW PEOPLE
- 17:48DISRESPECT YOU ON THE STREETS.
- 17:51THEY SPIT ON YOU.
- 17:53THEY WALK OVER YOU.
- 17:55THEY JUST TREAT YOU LIKE YOU ARE
- 17:56A PIECE OF DIRT.
- 17:58>> KENTUCKY ELECTED OFFICIALS
- 18:00SAID AT A RALLY MONDAY, THE ONLY
- 18:02SOLUTION TO HOMELESSNESS IS
- 18:03AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
- 18:04>> IT'S NOT A DIFFICULT
- 18:05SOLUTION.
- 18:06AND IT'S NOT NEW.
- 18:08BUT WHAT IT NEEDS TO BE
- 18:10SUCCESSFUL IS FUNDING.
- 18:12AND WHAT WE DO NOT HAVE RIGHT
- 18:14NOW IS THE POLITICAL WILL TO
- 18:17INVEST IN OUR COMMUNITIES AND IN
- 18:19OUR PEOPLE.
- 18:20>> HOUSING ADVOCATES GATHERED IN
- 18:21RESPONSE TO A CASE BEFORE THE
- 18:24U.S. SUPREME COURT.
- 18:25JOHNSON V GRANT'S PASS.
- 18:28THE TOWN IN OREGON IS DEFENDING
- 18:30ITS STREET CAMPING BAN WHO LOWER
- 18:33COURTS RULE SECOND CRUEL AND
- 18:34UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT UNDER THE
- 18:36U.S. CONSTITUTION.
- 18:38HOW THE COURT DECIDES WILL
- 18:39LIKELY IMPACT LAWS IN KENTUCKY
- 18:41LIKE HOUSE BILL 5.
- 18:42>> THE KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 18:44SET STATE-WIDE PENALTIES FOR
- 18:47PEOPLE SETTING UP TENTS OR
- 18:49SLEEPING IN PUBLIC SPACES
- 18:50INCLUDING FINES AND A CLASS B
- 18:52MISDEMEANOR.
- 18:53>> ONE OF THE MAIN REASONS WHY
- 18:56OUR GOVERNOR VETOED HOUSE BILL 5
- 18:59WAS BECAUSE THERE IS A PRINCIPLE
- 19:01THAT HE AND I BELIEVE IN.
- 19:03YOU ARE NOT A CRIMINAL BECAUSE
- 19:06OF YOUR LIVING SITUATION.
- 19:10IF ANYTHING, WE HAVE AN
- 19:12OBLIGATION TO EXTEND OUR HANDS
- 19:14AND INVEST RESOURCES TO PROMOTE
- 19:17AND PURSUE REALIZE HEALING NOT
- 19:20TO DISCARD YOU AND THROW YOU
- 19:22AWAY.
- 19:22>> ACCORDING TO A LOCAL
- 19:24ORDINANCE IN LOUISVILLE POLICE
- 19:25OFFICERS CAN ISSUE $200 FINES TO
- 19:27PEOPLE SLEEPING IN CARS OR
- 19:28CAMPING IN PARKS.
- 19:30>> IF YOU ARE ON THE STREET THE
- 19:32LIKELIHOOD OF YOU BEING ABLE TO
- 19:33AFFORD A FINE OR A TICKET IS
- 19:35LESS THAN LIKELY.
- 19:36IF YOU COMPOUND TOO MANY TICKETS
- 19:39THEN THAT MEANS YOU HAVE NO
- 19:40CHOICE AND THE POLICE ARE FORCED
- 19:41TO TAKE YOU TO JAIL BECAUSE YOU
- 19:43HAVE WARRANTS OR UNABLE TO MAKE
- 19:46YOUR COURT DATE BECAUSE YOU
- 19:47DON'T HAVE TO PLACE TO RECEIVE
- 19:49THE MESSAGES.
- 19:49>> PROPONENTS SAY HOMELESSNESS
- 19:52IS A BLIGHT THAT CITIES HAVE TO
- 19:53DEAL WITH.
- 19:54AND LEAVING PEOPLE TO LIVE
- 19:56OUTDOORS IS NOT SOME HUMANE
- 19:59SOLUTION.
- 19:59DURING TESTIMONY FOR HOUSE BILL
- 20:005, REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS SAID
- 20:02THESE LAWS COULD LEAD PEOPLE TO
- 20:05ADDICTION TREATMENT.
- 20:05>> FORMERLY ADDICTED HOMELESS
- 20:08PEOPLE SAY WE NEED SOMEBODY TO
- 20:10FORCE US INTO REHAB BECAUSE WE
- 20:11ARE IN THE THROES OF ADDICTION.
- 20:15>> OPPONENTS SAY SOME PEOPLE
- 20:17MIGHT NEED TREATMENT BUT THE
- 20:18FIRST THING EVERYONE NEEDS IS
- 20:20HOUSING.
- 20:20AND HAVING TO PAY FINES AND
- 20:22GOING TO JAIL DOESN'T HELP THEM
- 20:23WHEN LOOKING FOR A PLACE TO
- 20:25STAY.
- 20:27>> Renee: AND THAT WAS KENTUCKY
- 20:30EDITION'S JIM LOEFFLER.
- 20:32THIS FROM BRIAN IT, SUNDERLAND,
- 20:35THIS IS THE ORGANIZATION WE
- 20:37MENTIONED IN THE SHOW THAT
- 20:38HELPED CRAFT THE LEGISLATION IN
- 20:40KENTUCKY AND ALSO OTHER STATES.
- 20:42HE PROVIDED THIS STATEMENT
- 20:43EARLIER THIS EVENING.
- 20:45THE INSTITUTE HAS BEEN AT THE
- 20:47FOREFRONT OF STATES TAKING BACK
- 20:49CONTROL OF THE POLICY RESPONSE
- 20:51TO HOMELESSNESS AFTER DECADES OF
- 20:53MISMANAGEMENT.
- 20:54THE CONVENTIONAL HOUSING FIRST
- 20:55APPROACH LEAVES HOMELESS
- 20:57INDIVIDUALS TO SLEEP ON THE
- 20:58STREETS WHILE RESOURCES ARE
- 21:01DIVERTED FROM SHELTERS AND TO
- 21:03HOUSING PROGRAMS THAT HAVE
- 21:04LITTLE TO KNOW ACCOUNTABILITY
- 21:07AND LACK SOBRIETY AND TREATMENT
- 21:09REQUIREMENTS.
- 21:09AT THE CORE OF GRANT'S PASS
- 21:11OREGON IS THE QUESTION OF JUST
- 21:13HOW MUCH DISCRETION A LOCAL
- 21:15GOVERNMENT SHOULD HAVE OVER ITS
- 21:16COMMUNITY RESPONSE.
- 21:17TO HOMELESSNESS.
- 21:18A GROWING NUMBER OF STATES ARE
- 21:19WORKING TO IMPROVE SAFETY FOR
- 21:21THEIR COMMUNITIES BY
- 21:22IMPLEMENTING DESIGNATED
- 21:23GOVERNMENT APPROVED CAMPING
- 21:25AREAS FOR HOMELESS INDIVIDUALS.
- 21:27THESE AREAS INCLUDE PROVISIONS
- 21:29FOR SUBSTANCE ABUSE AND MENTAL
- 21:32HEALTH INTERVENTIONS AND
- 21:33SERVICES AS AN ONRAMP TO
- 21:35TREATMENT.
- 21:35THIS BREAKS DOWN WHEN THE
- 21:38FEDERAL JUDGE OVERRIDES
- 21:39COMMUNITYS' DECISIONS IN
- 21:40RESPONSE TO THE CASE THAT WE'LL
- 21:42TALK MORE ABOUT.
- 21:42I WANT TO GET A RESPONSE FROM
- 21:45YOU, GEORGE AND KUNGU ABOUT WHEN
- 21:47WE HEARD THE REPRESENTATIVES SAY
- 21:50THAT THIS IS INTENDING TO FORCE
- 21:53PEOPLE INTO REHAB BECAUSE
- 21:55OTHERWISE THEY PERHAPS WOULD NOT
- 21:56GO.
- 21:56I WANT YOU TO RESPOND TO THAT.
- 21:58>> ONE, FORCING PEOPLE INTO
- 22:01REHAB.
- 22:01PEOPLE GOT TO BE READY AND
- 22:03WILLING.
- 22:03I DON'T KNOW HOW SUCCESSFUL THAT
- 22:04IS.
- 22:05YOU HAVE TO BE WILLING HIT YOUR
- 22:07ROCK BOTTOM TO DO THAT.
- 22:08AND ALSO IT MISSES THE POINT.
- 22:10AS GEORGE SAID ONLY A THIRD OF
- 22:12THE PEOPLE WHO ARE HOMELESS OR
- 22:15UNSHELTERED SUFFER FROM A MENTAL
- 22:17ILLNESS OR SUBSTANCE USE
- 22:19DISORDER WHICH LEAVES THE
- 22:21MAJORITY OF THOSE INDIVIDUALS
- 22:23NOT IN THAT.
- 22:24THE THREE MAIN PLAINTIFFS IN
- 22:26GRANT'S PASS JOHN LOGAN HAD A
- 22:28JOB.
- 22:29HE WAS A LICENSED IN-HOME CARE
- 22:32PROVIDER AND DIDN'T MAKE ENOUGH
- 22:34MONEY SO HE HAD TO LIVE IN HIS
- 22:36VAN AND CLIENTS LET HAD HIM STAY
- 22:39THERE.
- 22:39AND THE OTHER PLAINTIFFS WERE
- 22:41PEOPLE ONE WAS RETIRED ON SOCIAL
- 22:43SECURITY, DIDN'T MAKE ENOUGH
- 22:45MONEY BECAUSE RENT IS TOO HIGH.
- 22:47IT MISSES THE POINT AND TRIES TO
- 22:48COME UP WITH ONE SOLUTION FOR
- 22:51ALL THE FOLKS WHO ARE
- 22:54UNSHELTERED AND THEY ARE NOT A
- 22:56MONOLITHIC GROUP.
- 22:58>> Renee: PROFESSOR?
- 22:58>> I FEEL LIKE I WANT TO
- 23:03REITERATE A POINT I MADE EARLIER
- 23:04AND I THOUGHT I HEARD
- 23:06REPRESENTATIVE HODGESON SAY IT
- 23:08FOR ME, WHICH IS THAT IT DOES
- 23:11PROVIDE AN INCENTIVE FOR PEOPLE
- 23:12WHO ARE ON THE STREET TO BE A
- 23:15LITTLE BIT LESS INTOLERANT OF
- 23:17THE OPTIONS THAT ARE OUT THERE.
- 23:19IT DOES PUT A LITTLE BIT OF A
- 23:21THUMB ON THE SCALE.
- 23:22IT SAYS TO THE PEOPLE IF THERE
- 23:25ARE OPTIONS YOU SHOULD EXPLORE
- 23:27THEM AND IT IS NOT AN ANSWER
- 23:29THAT YOU DON'T LIKE AN OPTION
- 23:31THAT IS OUT THERE.
- 23:33>> Renee: ONLY APPLIES TO A
- 23:33THIRD OF THE POPULATION?
- 23:35>> I DISAGREE WITH YOU ON THAT.
- 23:37BECAUSE THEY DON'T WANT TO GO
- 23:38INTO A SUBSTANCE ABUSE PROGRAM
- 23:40BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE A
- 23:42PROBLEM DOESN'T MEAN THERE IS
- 23:44NOT ANOTHER SHELTER AVAILABLE TO
- 23:46THEM.
- 23:47AND WHAT WE WANT TO DO IS SAY TO
- 23:50PEOPLE ONE OPTION YOU DON'T HAVE
- 23:51IS NOT EXPLORING ANYTHING.
- 23:53YOU CANNOT SAY TO THE POLICE I
- 23:55DON'T LIKE THIS AND I DON'T LIKE
- 23:59THIS AND I HAVE A RIGHT TO BE
- 24:00HERE.
- 24:00IN FACT, DEPENDING WHERE RIGHT
- 24:02HERE IS YOU DON'T.
- 24:03SO YOU'VE GOT TO TRY TO FIND
- 24:05SOMETHING ELSE.
- 24:06KUNGU MENTIONED COUCH SURFING IT
- 24:09IS NOT AN IDEAL SOLUTION BUT IT
- 24:12PUTS THAT PERSON OUT OF HARM'S
- 24:13WAY AND OFF THE STREET.
- 24:15>> Renee: AND YOU HAVE TO FIND
- 24:17SOMEONE WHO IS WILLING.
- 24:19>> THERE WAS A TIME WHEN PEOPLE
- 24:20SPENT MORE TIME WITH THEIR
- 24:23IN-LAWS THAN THEY DO NOW.
- 24:26>> PAUL BRINGS UP THERE IS A
- 24:28LACK OF SHELTER ACROSS THE STATE
- 24:29RIGHT NOW.
- 24:30IN LOUISVILLE WE NEED ANOTHER
- 24:32800 BEDS TO MEET THE NEED WE
- 24:34HAVE EACH NIGHT.
- 24:35AND IT IS NOT LIKE A FOR
- 24:37SOMEBODY WHO IS SLEEPING OUT, IT
- 24:39IS NOT LIKE I'M OUT EVERYDAY.
- 24:41THERE MIGHT BE A TIME THEY HAVE
- 24:43MONEY TO GO INTO AN EXTENDED
- 24:45STAY MOTEL.
- 24:46THEY MAY HAVE FAMILY THAT THEY
- 24:47CAN STAY WITH.
- 24:48THE FACT IS THAT FOR SOMEBODY
- 24:50WHO IS HOMELESS IT IS A CONSTANT
- 24:53STRUGGLE TO FIND WHERE YOU ARE
- 24:54GOING TO LAND THE NEXT DAY.
- 24:56UNTIL THE CITY AND THE STATE
- 24:58INVEST THE DOLLARS TO SPAN OUR
- 25:00SHELTER SYSTEM, THE FEDERAL
- 25:02MONEY GEARED TOWARDS HOUSING IS
- 25:04THE ONLY INTERVENTION THAT IS
- 25:05GETTING RESULTS.
- 25:06>> I DON'T THINK YOU CAN
- 25:08DOWN-PLAY WHAT HE SAID.
- 25:09ONE OF THE STATS HE SAID ONLY 33
- 25:12COUNTIES HAVE A SHELTER OUT OF
- 25:15120.
- 25:17SO SOME PEOPLE HAVE SOMEWHERE TO
- 25:19GO IN JEFFERSON AND FAYETTE WHO
- 25:21ARE THE COUNTIES DOING THAT
- 25:23DON'T?
- 25:23HE IS TALKING ABOUT WHAT OPTIONS
- 25:25THEY HAVE.
- 25:26THERE AREN'T SHELTERS.
- 25:27>> ONE THING I'M SORRY, RICHARD.
- 25:30I THINK ONE THING WE'RE GLOSSING
- 25:32OVER HERE THOUGH, IS CAN LOCAL
- 25:34GOVERNMENTS OR THE STATE
- 25:35GOVERNMENT HAVE RULES FOR WHAT
- 25:37WE ALLOW IN PUBLIC PLACES?
- 25:38IF I WERE TO GO TO A PARK I'VE
- 25:41HOME THANKS GOD, BUT IF I WERE
- 25:44TO GO TO A PARK AND CAMP OUT
- 25:46MAYBE THERE WAS A RIVER I WOULD
- 25:47GET FINED.
- 25:48THIS DOESN'T BAN PUBLIC CAMPING
- 25:50OTHER THAN IN PUBLIC PARKS I
- 25:53SHOULD SAY THERE IS A PROVISION
- 25:55WHERE THE CITIES OR LOCAL
- 25:57GOVERNMENTS COULD CREATE AN AREA
- 25:59WHERE THEY CAMP.
- 26:00AND THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE FOR
- 26:02SANITATION AND THERE WILL BE
- 26:05SECURITY.
- 26:06IT IS A SAFER AND MORE
- 26:08DIGNIFYING OPTION.
- 26:10AND I BELIEVE THAT IS OFFERED IN
- 26:11LOUISVILLE.
- 26:12SO I THINK THAT ADDRESSES
- 26:13SOMETHING.
- 26:14BUT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I
- 26:15THINK WE'RE FORGETTING IS THE
- 26:16LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND STATE
- 26:18GOVERNMENTS SHOULD PROVIDE RULES
- 26:19THAT WE ABIDE.
- 26:20YOU SHOULDN'T BE ABLE TO SLEEP
- 26:22ON A SIDEWALK.
- 26:23IT'S NOT DIGNIFYING TO ALLOW
- 26:25PEOPLE TO BE EXPOSED TO THE
- 26:27ELEMENTS OR VULNERABLE TO
- 26:28ASSAULT WHICH HOMELESS PEOPLE
- 26:30ARE.
- 26:30>> I HATE THAT WE ARE IN A STATE
- 26:32WHERE PEOPLE HAVE ONLY THE
- 26:34OPTION TO SLEEP OUTSIDE.
- 26:36EVERYONE IN HOMELESS SERVICES WE
- 26:38HAVE A VISION WE WANT PEOPLE TO
- 26:40HAVE ACCESS TO SAFE AND
- 26:41AFFORDABLE HOUSING.
- 26:42THAT IS THE BENCHMARK OF ALL OF
- 26:45THE WORK WE ARE DOING.
- 26:47IF YOU ARE HARASSING SOMEBODY,
- 26:48IF YOU ARE PUBLICLY INTOXICATED,
- 26:53LOITERING THERE ARE RULES ON THE
- 26:54BOOKS.
- 26:54WE DON'T NEED TO TAKE IT A STEP
- 26:56FURTHER.
- 26:57BECAUSE WE KNOW ANOTHER FINE,
- 26:59ANOTHER CHARGE ISN'T GOING TO
- 27:01MOVE PEOPLE ANY FASTER TO
- 27:03HOUSING THAN SERVICES AND
- 27:06HOUSING NAVIGATION AND HOUSING
- 27:08VOUCHER WILL.
- 27:09>> BUT, GEORGE, IF YOU LOOK AT
- 27:11THE SURVEY THAT RENEE SHARED
- 27:13EARLIER, LARGE NUMBER OF
- 27:15KENTUCKIANS ARE AFRAID TO GO
- 27:16NEAR THE HOMELESS ENCAMPMENTS
- 27:18THEY ARE NOT GOING TO THOSE
- 27:20AREAS AND THE PUBLIC HAS A RIGHT
- 27:21TO USE THE PARK OR WALK DOWN THE
- 27:23STREET OR THE SHOP OWNER HAS A
- 27:25RIGHT TO GO TO HIS SHOP IN THE
- 27:28MORNING AND NOT HAVE SOMEBODY EN
- 27:30CAMPED THERE.
- 27:30AND AGAIN, LET'S GET BACK TO THE
- 27:33CITY OF LOUISVILLE THEY STARTED
- 27:34THIS.
- 27:35THEY ENACTED A CITYWIDE
- 27:37ORDINANCE TO NOT ALLOW PUBLIC
- 27:39CAMPING.
- 27:40>> Renee: THAT BRINGS UP A GOOD
- 27:42POINT ABOUT HOME RULE AND
- 27:43SOMEONE WHO IS A PROPONENT OF
- 27:45SMALL GOVERNMENT AND ONLY
- 27:47NECESSARY GOVERNMENT WHY
- 27:48SHOULDN'T LOCALITIES BE ABLE TO
- 27:50CHOOSE THE SOLUTIONS THAT BEST
- 27:51FIT THEIR COMMUNITIES.
- 27:52MAYBE THAT IS A DIFFERENT
- 27:54RESPONSE THAN LEXINGTON FAYETTE
- 27:56COUNTY WOULD HAVE?
- 27:57>> THAT IS A FAIR POINT.
- 27:58I THINK IT'S BECAUSE IT IS A
- 28:01STATE-WIDE PROBLEM AND ENSURES
- 28:02THAT LOCAL GOVERNMENTS ACTUALLY
- 28:04STEP UP AND DO WHAT THEY ARE
- 28:06DOING.
- 28:06I'M NOT SURE WHAT LEXINGTON IS
- 28:08DOING.
- 28:08BUT THIS IS A STATE ISSUE.
- 28:10IT'S WIDESPREAD.
- 28:12AND I MEAN HOME RULE, HOPEFULLY
- 28:15VOTERS WILL ELECT CITY COUNCIL
- 28:17MEN TO HAVE LAWS PUT ON THE
- 28:20BOOKS PUBLIC POLICIES THAT ARE
- 28:22PRACTICAL AND MAKE SENSE.
- 28:23BUT I THINK AT SOME POINT THE
- 28:26LEGISLATURE STEPS IN AND SAYS
- 28:28HEY THIS IS A KENTUCKY ISSUE AND
- 28:30THAT IS WHAT THEY DID WITH HOUSE
- 28:32BILL 5.
- 28:33>> Renee: AND THEY HAVE
- 28:33PENALTIES FOR LOCAL OFFICIALS
- 28:34AND GOVERNMENTS THAT DO NOT
- 28:37COMPLY THAT THE KENTUCKY
- 28:38ATTORNEY GENERAL CAN INTERVENE
- 28:39AND FILE A CIVIL ACTION AND GET
- 28:42REIMBURSED FOR COURT COSTS SEEMS
- 28:44REASONABLE TO YOU, Mr. EXLUND?
- 28:46>> I MEAN, NO, I DON'T.
- 28:50BUT FOR US WHAT WE NEED IN
- 28:53LOUISVILLE IS WE NEED TO
- 28:54INCREASE OUR SERVICES AND WE
- 28:55NEED TO INCREASE OUR SHELTER
- 28:57OPTIONS.
- 28:58AND SURE, LIKE THE SANCTIONED
- 29:03ENCAMPMENTS SOUND LIKE A GOOD
- 29:04IDEA BUT WHAT NEEDS TO BE STATED
- 29:05IT LIMITS US TO DOING THIS ONLY
- 29:08IN COMMERCIAL OR INDUSTRIAL
- 29:10ZONED AREAS.
- 29:10AND THAT IS ONLY 16% OF OUR
- 29:12COUNTY.
- 29:13IT DOESN'T TAKE INTO ACCOUNT
- 29:15PROXIMITY TO SERVICES, PROXIMITY
- 29:17TO A BUS LINE.
- 29:18AND WE NEED MORE IN TERMS OF
- 29:20WHAT DOES EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
- 29:22LOOK LIKE?
- 29:23WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO WHEN A
- 29:25SEVERE THUNDERSTORM IS COMING
- 29:26THROUGH?
- 29:27OR WHEN WE HAVE A COLD-SNAP IN
- 29:29THE MIDDLE OF DECEMBER OVER NEW
- 29:31YEAR'S EVE?
- 29:32FOR FUSS WE'RE GOING --
- 29:34FOR US, IF WE ARE CREATING
- 29:37ENCAMPMENT WE MIGHT PUT THAT
- 29:39INDOORS WHERE PEOPLE ARE MORE
- 29:42DIGNIFIED TO BE OUT OF THE
- 29:43ELEMENTS AND STABLE ENOUGH TO
- 29:44GET THEM INTO A HOUSING PROGRAM.
- 29:46>> Renee: WHEN WEE LOOK AT
- 29:47TENNESSEE AND MISSOURI, THE
- 29:49SUPREME COURT DID STRIKE THEIR
- 29:51LAW DOWN.
- 29:52TENNESSEE HAS DONE THIS.
- 29:53DO WE KNOW IT'S YIELDING THE
- 29:56RESULTS ANTICIPATED FOR
- 29:57KENTUCKY'S HOUSE BILL 5?
- 29:58>> I AM NOT AWARE OF IT.
- 30:00A LOT OF MONEY HAS BEEN
- 30:02APPROPRIATEIATED TO HELP THE
- 30:03HOMELESS AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL IT
- 30:05WAS $3.1 BILLION FROM THE BIDEN
- 30:09ADMINISTRATION.
- 30:10KENTUCKY GOT $34 MILLION TO
- 30:12ASSIST WITH HOMELESS.
- 30:14THERE'S 20 SOME MILLION DOLLARS.
- 30:15MONEY IS COMING IN.
- 30:17I HAVE READ AND GEORGE I'M NOT
- 30:19SURE IF YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH
- 30:20THIS BUT THERE'S BEEN AN
- 30:22ARGUMENT MADE THAT THE MONEY IS
- 30:25MISALIGNED.
- 30:27THE FEDERAL MONEY IS SETUP TO GO
- 30:30TOWARDS PERMANENT HOUSING
- 30:31INSTEAD OF THE TEMPORARY
- 30:33SHELTERS WHICH IS WHAT IS
- 30:34NEEDED.
- 30:35IT'S MORE DIFFICULT TO GET
- 30:36PERMANENT HOUSING AND EASIER TO
- 30:38GET TEMPORARY SHELTER.
- 30:39SO I THINK THAT'S SOMETHING THAT
- 30:41SHOULD BE ADDRESSED IS THE MONEY
- 30:42BEING USED CORRECTLY?
- 30:43>> I THINK IT IS.
- 30:45LARGELY THAT 34 MILLION IS GOING
- 30:48TOWARDS THE THREE COC'S.
- 30:51>> CONTINUUM OF CARE.
- 30:52>> FUNDING ENTITIES THERE'S
- 30:56LEXINGTON, JEFFERSON DOWN AND
- 30:57THE BALANCE OF STATE.
- 30:58THOSE ARE HUD PROGRAMS THAT ARE
- 31:00GEARED TOWARDS HOUSING FIRST
- 31:02INTERVENTIONS.
- 31:03WHAT WE DON'T HAVE IS ANY LOCAL
- 31:07DOLLARS FLOWING INTO THIS.
- 31:09THERE'S LITTLE MONEY IN
- 31:10LOUISVILLE GOES TOWARDS SHELTER.
- 31:11THERE IS NO MONEY IN THE STATE
- 31:14GOING TOWARDS IMMEDIATE
- 31:17INTERVENTIONS.
- 31:18AND SHELTER IS AN INTERVENTION
- 31:20THAT IS ABOUT KEEPING SOMEBODY
- 31:21ALIVE IN THAT MOMENT.
- 31:22FOR US IF WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 31:24ADDRESSING THE ISSUE WE NEED TO
- 31:26INCREASE THE NUMBER OF HOUSING
- 31:28VOUCHERS AND THE UNITS THAT
- 31:30PEOPLE HAVE ACCESS TO.
- 31:31BECAUSE IF SOMEBODY GETS A
- 31:34HOUSING VOUCHER A PERMANENT
- 31:36HOUSING THESE ARE DIFFERENT
- 31:37TOOLS THAT WE HAVE IN OUR KIT,
- 31:39THEY ONLY HAVE A SET AMOUNT OF
- 31:40DAYS TO GET THEM IN.
- 31:42WE CAN'T FIND A SPOT THAT WILL
- 31:44TAKE THEM BECAUSE OF THEIR
- 31:45BACKGROUND AND THE VOUCHER, THEY
- 31:47STAND TO LOSE THAT VOUCHER AND
- 31:48IT GOES TO THE NEXT PERSON.
- 31:50>> GEORGE, I WONDER, ABSTRACT
- 31:53FROM THIS, IS A LOT OF YOUR
- 31:55ARGUMENT ARGUABLY ECONOMICALLY
- 31:57UPSIDE-DOWN?
- 31:58PERHAPS THE REASON THAT SO MANY
- 31:59COUNTIES IN KENTUCKY DON'T HAVE
- 32:02ANY ACTIVE SHELTER PROGRAM IS
- 32:03BECAUSE THEY DON'T NEED THEM.
- 32:05AND IT MIGHT BE AT THE PROBLEM
- 32:07OF HOMELESSNESS OR
- 32:10UNSHELTEREDNESS USE A DIFFERENT
- 32:11WORD IN LOUISVILLE AND LEXINGTON
- 32:12IS A FUNCTION THEY ARE
- 32:14ATTRACTIVE PLACES TO BE AND A
- 32:15LOT OF PEOPLE COME TO LEXINGTON
- 32:17AND LOUISVILLE WHO DON'T HAVE A
- 32:19JOB WHO DON'T HAVE A LOT OF
- 32:20MONEY OR HAVE A JOB AND DON'T
- 32:23MAKE MUCH MONEY.
- 32:24AND ARE WE REALLY SOLVING THE
- 32:26PROBLEM BY SPENDING THE MONEY TO
- 32:28ENABLE THEM TO LIVE IN
- 32:30LOUISVILLE?
- 32:32LIKE SAYING YOU CAN LIVE IN
- 32:34DOWNTOWN MANHATTAN.
- 32:34>> 82% OF PEOPLE IN LOUISVILLE
- 32:37THEIR LAST HOME ADDRESS WAS
- 32:39KENTUCKY.
- 32:39WE ARE NOT SEEING A PIPELINE OF
- 32:41PEOPLE COMING FROM UNHAPPY OR
- 32:44CINCINNATI.
- 32:44>> ARE THEY COMING FROM RURAL
- 32:46KENTUCKY.
- 32:46>> IT'S A MUCH MORE DYNAMIC
- 32:49SITUATION.
- 32:49I HAVE A COUSIN WHO LIVES IN
- 32:51LOUISVILLE I WILL GO HOPING I
- 32:54CAN COUCH SURF AND FIND A JOB
- 32:55BUT THINGS FALL APART AND I STAY
- 32:57IN THE EXTENDED STAY.
- 32:59I THINK THERE IS A FLUIDITY
- 33:01AROUND IT ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU
- 33:03HAVE AN ECONOMIC CENTER LIKE
- 33:06LOUISVILLE, LEXINGTON, BOWLING
- 33:07GREEN.
- 33:07THE OTHER FACTOR WE HAVE TO TALK
- 33:09ABOUT WE HAVE SEEN SO MUCH
- 33:11ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT COMING IN
- 33:13TO DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE STATE.
- 33:14WHERE WE ARE GOING TO SEE A
- 33:20SPILLOVER EFFECT LIKE, IT'S NOT
- 33:22GOING TO AFFECT THOSE WORKERS OR
- 33:25YOUR SCHOOL WORKERS WHAT IT WILL
- 33:26DO IS START DRIVING THE GROCERY
- 33:28STORE WORKERS, YOUR GAS STATION
- 33:31EMPLOYEES INTO THE NEXT COUNTY
- 33:32AND IT WILL TIGHTEN UP THEIR
- 33:34HOUSING MARKET.
- 33:35HOMELESSNESS IS AN ECONOMIC
- 33:37ISSUE WHERE WE ARE SETTING
- 33:38PEOPLE UP TO FAIL AT THE LOWER
- 33:39END OF THE INCOME SPECTRUM
- 33:41VERSUS OTHER PARTS OF THE
- 33:43HOUSING MARKET.
- 33:44>> AREN'T YOU EXACERBATING THE
- 33:47MISPLACED INCENTIVES IF YOU MAKE
- 33:49SURE THAT PEOPLE CAN LIVE PLACES
- 33:51WHERE THEY CAN'T AFFORD TO LIVE?
- 33:52A LOT OF PEOPLE DON'T HAVE
- 33:54GAINFUL EMPLOYMENT AND GIVEN UP
- 33:56ON GAINFUL EMPLOYMENT.
- 33:57WHAT IS THE POINT OF SPENDING
- 33:58THE MONEY TO ALLOW THEM TO LIVE
- 34:00SOME PLACE WHERE THEY DON'T HAVE
- 34:03GAINFUL EMPLOYMENT.
- 34:04THERE MIGHT BE GAINFUL
- 34:05EMPLOYMENT SOMEWHERE ELSE?
- 34:07>> FOR US, LIKE, WE JUST HAVE TO
- 34:09LOOK AND SEE WHAT IS IN FRONT OF
- 34:11US.
- 34:11WE SEE THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE THAT
- 34:13ARE HOMELESS.
- 34:14AND IF WE BELIEVE THAT HOUSE
- 34:16SOMETHING ESSENTIAL LIKE OUR
- 34:17FIRST STEP TO ANY INTERVENTION
- 34:19IS TO GET THEM INTO HOUSING.
- 34:21AND THAT IS WHY LIKE THE BUSH
- 34:26ADMINISTRATION, GEORGE W. BUSH
- 34:27ADMINISTRATION STARTED SHIFTING
- 34:28TOWARDS THE HOUSING FIRST
- 34:30METHODOLOGY WHERE IT GOT RID OF
- 34:33THIS ONE-SIZE-FITS-ALL APPROACH
- 34:34WITH HIGH BARRIERS TO REQUIRE
- 34:37THINGS LIKE SOBRIETY OR HAVING A
- 34:39JOB BEFORE YOU ACCESS SERVICES.
- 34:41BECAUSE IT WAS A WASTE OF TIME
- 34:43ON THE SERVICE PROVIDER AS WELL
- 34:45AS THE PERSON EXPERIENCING
- 34:47HOMELESSNESS.
- 34:47>> SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE
- 34:49HIGHLIGHTED GEORGE TOUCHED ON IT
- 34:51IS HB50 ADDRESS THIS ISSUE, HB5
- 34:55LOOKS TO CRIMINALIZE PEOPLE WHO
- 34:59ARE UNSHELTERED AND DO THE
- 35:00ECONOMIC THINGS THAT WOULD HELP
- 35:02PEOPLE GET HOUSING.
- 35:03A HOUSING VOUCHER.
- 35:05DURING THE SESSION THEY PASSED
- 35:07HB5 THEY PASSED PB18 WHICH
- 35:10OVERRODE LOCAL GOVERNMENT'S
- 35:12ABILITY TO PREVENT LANDLORDS
- 35:14FROM DISCRIMINATING AGAINST
- 35:15SOURCE OF INCOME.
- 35:16THAT IS NOT HELPFUL.
- 35:18OTHER PEOPLE CAN'T GET
- 35:20EMPLOYMENT IF YOU HAVE A
- 35:22CRIMINAL RECORD.
- 35:23THERE WAS A BILL THAT WOULD HAVE
- 35:25HELPED AUTOMATE THE EXPUNGEMENT
- 35:27PROCESS.
- 35:28THAT DIDN'T GET A HEARING.
- 35:29THAT WOULD HAVE HELPED SOLVE
- 35:31THIS.
- 35:32>> Renee: WHAT ABOUT THE
- 35:32BIPARTISAN BILL THAT BY TWO
- 35:34LOUISVILLE REPRESENTATIVES ONE
- 35:36DEMOCRAT ONE REPUBLICAN THAT
- 35:37WOULD HAVE PROVIDED FOR NO COST
- 35:39BIRTH CERTIFICATES DID THAT MAKE
- 35:41IT ACROSS THE FINISH LINE FOR
- 35:43FOLKS UNSHELTERED?
- 35:44>> IT DID.
- 35:46>> Renee: THERE IS ONE VICTORY
- 35:47AND WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES THAT OR
- 35:49WILL THAT MAKE?
- 35:50>> THAT IS LIKE AN INCREDIBLY
- 35:52HELPFUL TOOL FOR US TO START THE
- 35:54JOURNEY OF GETTING SOMEBODY IN
- 35:56HOUSING.
- 35:56GETTING THEM A JOB WE HAVE TO
- 35:58FIGURE OUT HOW THEY WILL
- 36:00ESTABLISH THEIR IDENTITY AND
- 36:02THAT IS THROUGH A BIRTH
- 36:03CERTIFICATE AND ID SERVICES.
- 36:05THAT PASSED IN HOUSE BILL 8 WAS
- 36:08ACCESS TO FREE ID SERVICES FOR
- 36:10PEOPLE THAT ARE EXPERIENCING
- 36:11HOMELESSNESS.
- 36:11THAT IS LIKE ONE OF THE
- 36:13BENCHMARKS OF THE WORK WE'RE
- 36:14DOING IN FRANKFORT IS HOW DO WE
- 36:16REMOVE THE BARRIERS THAT PREVENT
- 36:18PEOPLE FROM GETTING INTO
- 36:19HOUSING.
- 36:20THAT INCLUDES CRIMINAL
- 36:21BACKGROUNDS.
- 36:22THAT INCLUDES ACCESS TO HOUSING
- 36:24VOUCHERS.
- 36:25IT INCLUDES ANY KIND OF WAY THAT
- 36:28WE CAN STREAMLINE THE PROCESS
- 36:30LIKE ID'S AND BIRTH CERTIFICATES
- 36:33TO GET PEOPLE ON THAT PATH INTO
- 36:36BACK INTO HOUSING.
- 36:37>> Renee: BACK TO SOMETHING THAT
- 36:38Mr. NELSON SAID WHEN WE
- 36:39STARTED OUR PROGRAM.
- 36:40AND I WILL ASK THE QUESTION
- 36:42BECAUSE HE RECITED STATISTICS
- 36:44ABOUT THOSE WHO WERE UNSHELTERED
- 36:47NOT JUST BEING THE VICTIMS BUT
- 36:49PERPETRATORS OF CRIME.
- 36:50IS THERE STATISTICS THAT SUPPORT
- 36:52THAT THOSE WHO ARE UNSHELTERED
- 36:54ARE HOMELESS ARE MORE VICTIMS
- 36:57LIKELY TO BE VICTIMS OF CRIME OR
- 36:59PERPETRATORS OF CRIME?
- 37:00ARE THESE CAMPS HOTBEDS OF
- 37:02CRIME?
- 37:02>> IT CUTS BOTH WAYS.
- 37:04ANYBODY WHO IS SLEEPING OUT, WHO
- 37:07IS UNSHELTERED IS EXPOSED TO
- 37:10NUMEROUS TRAUMAS AND NUMEROUS
- 37:12ISSUES.
- 37:13AND IT IS BOTH THE PERSON WHO
- 37:15MAYBE PERPETRATOR IS ALSO A
- 37:16VICTIM IN CERTAIN SITUATIONS.
- 37:18WHEN WE SEE AN UPTICK IN CRIME
- 37:21BETWEEN CAMPS IS WHEN WE SEE
- 37:23CAMPS BEING BROKEN UP.
- 37:24CAMPS ARE COMMUNITIES.
- 37:25LIKE PEOPLE ARE INCREDIBLY
- 37:29RESOURCEFUL AND THEY ARE
- 37:31FIGURING OUT WHAT IS GOING TO
- 37:33MEET THEIR NEEDS IN THE MOMENT.
- 37:34WHEN WE BREAK UP A CAMP WE ARE
- 37:36BREAKING UP A COMMUNITY AND
- 37:37SOMEBODY VENTURES INTO A NEW
- 37:39CAMP WHEN YOU START SEEING AN
- 37:41UPTICK IN INNER CRIME BETWEEN
- 37:44FOLKS THAT ARE HOMELESS.
- 37:45>> GEORGE, THE CITY OF
- 37:46LOUISVILLE SPENT $842,000 TO
- 37:49CLEAN UP OR REMOVE THE CAMPS.
- 37:52THE CITY LEADERS SAID IT WAS A
- 37:54HEALTH ISSUE.
- 37:55PEOPLE WERE USING JUST GOING TO
- 37:58THE BATHROOM ANYWHERE.
- 38:00THEY WERE CLEANING UP NEEDLES.
- 38:01SO WHEN WE TALK ABOUT COMMUNITY,
- 38:04I MEAN I HAVE NOT BEEN TO ONE.
- 38:06AGAIN I'M GRATEFUL I'M NOT
- 38:08HOMELESS AND WE SHOULD HAVE
- 38:10COMPASSION TOWARDS THE HOMELESS
- 38:11BUT IS IT NOT BACK TO THE IDEA
- 38:13OF HAVING A DESIGNATED AREA IN
- 38:15THE CITY WHERE SANITATION WOULD
- 38:18BE PROVIDED.
- 38:19THERE WOULD BE SHOWERS.
- 38:22THERE WOULD BE PORT-A-POTTIES
- 38:23AND POLICING TO PROTECT THE
- 38:26HOMELESS, THE VULNERABLE
- 38:27UNSHELTERED.
- 38:28IT DOES NOT MAKE SENSE AT A
- 38:29NUMBER OF LEVELS TO ALLOW PEOPLE
- 38:31TO CAMP OUT MYSELF, YOU, ANY OF
- 38:34US TO CAMP OUT WHEREVER.
- 38:38I DON'T THINK IT'S
- 38:40COMPASSIONATE.
- 38:41I DON'T THINK IT'S GOOD PUBLIC
- 38:43POLICY AND THERE IS A MONETARY
- 38:46ELEMENT AS WELL.
- 38:47I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY IT IS A
- 38:49RIGHT TO CAMP ANYWHERE YOU WANT
- 38:50IN A PUBLIC PARK OR IN A PRIVATE
- 38:53ENTRY WAY TO A BUSINESS.
- 38:55AND I THINK THAT'S WE NEED TO
- 38:57TALK ABOUT THAT.
- 38:57I DON'T SEE HOW IT'S HARMFUL TO
- 39:00THE UNSHELTERED TO HAVE A
- 39:02DESIGNATED AREA.
- 39:02>> CRIMINALIZING PEOPLE FOR
- 39:05SLEEPING OUT IS NOT ADDRESSING
- 39:07THE ROOT CAUSES IT ISN'T GOING
- 39:09TO LEAD TO THE RESULTS WE HAVE.
- 39:11>> I TAKE ISSUE WITH THAT
- 39:14CRIMINALIZING THE HOMELESS.
- 39:14WE ARE TALKING ABOUT AN
- 39:16ACTIVITY.
- 39:17I CANNOT GO TO A PARK AND SLEEP
- 39:18OVERNIGHT AND THERE IS A REASON.
- 39:20THERE'S OTHER RULES YOU CANNOT
- 39:22SKATEBOARD ON SIDEWALKS.
- 39:24CAN'T RIDE A BIKE ON THE
- 39:25SIDEWALK BECAUSE OF THE GENERAL
- 39:26PUBLIC AND THE THINK THE SAME
- 39:28WITH THOSE CAMPING OUT IN PUBLIC
- 39:29AREAS AS WELL.
- 39:30THERE ARE SAFETY CONCERNS.
- 39:32THERE ARE HEALTH CONCERNS.
- 39:34THERE'S A FEAR CONCERN FROM THE
- 39:35PUBLIC.
- 39:37THE PUBLIC TAX-PAYING PUBLIC IS
- 39:39USING THESE AREAS AND THEY ARE
- 39:40NOT ABLE TO GO TO THE AREAS AND
- 39:41FEEL SAFE.
- 39:43>> I THINK THERE'S OTHER
- 39:44ELEMENTS WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT.
- 39:46>> IF LOUISVILLE IS SPENDING
- 39:48800,000 TO CLEAN UP CAMPS THAT
- 39:51MONEY COULD BE SPENT IN
- 39:52EXPANDING SHELTER OPTIONS.
- 39:53IT IS A MUCH MORE BETTER BANG
- 39:55FOR OUR BUCKS TALKING ABOUT
- 39:57INDOOR OPTIONS FOR ME IN A
- 40:00SANCTIONED EN COMMENT OUTDOORS
- 40:01IS AN INTERVENTION OF LAST
- 40:03RESORT AND SHOULD BE PART OF A
- 40:05LARGER PLAN.
- 40:05I DON'T WANT IT TO BE WE'RE
- 40:07GOING TO CREATE AN
- 40:10INSTITUTIONALIZED CAMP THAT WILL
- 40:11BE THERE FOR DECADES.
- 40:12>> I DON'T ANY ANYBODY WANTS
- 40:14THAT.
- 40:15>> I AGREE WITH YOU.
- 40:16THESE ARE COMPLEX AND IT'S
- 40:18DIFFICULT.
- 40:19I THINK WE CAN ALL AGREE WITH
- 40:20THAT.
- 40:21THESE ARE REALLY TOUGH PUBLIC
- 40:24POLICY QUESTIONS THAT CITIES
- 40:25HAVE TO GRAPPLE WITH.
- 40:26AND THAT IS WHY WE NEED TO LOOK
- 40:29AT HOLISTIC APPROACHES AND
- 40:30GEORGE MENTIONED IT DOESN'T MAKE
- 40:33SENSE TO SPENT $842,000 CLEARING
- 40:36CAMPS INSTEAD OF PROVIDING
- 40:38SERVICES.
- 40:38AND THE OTHER PART IS WE ARE
- 40:41CRIMINALIZING HOMELESSNESS AND
- 40:42IT GETS TO THE CASE.
- 40:45GRANT'S PASS IS BECAUSE IF YOU
- 40:47ARE UNHOUSED, UNSHELTERED, YOU
- 40:50HAVE TO SLEEP.
- 40:50AND THE ONLY PLACE TO SLEEP IS
- 40:53IN PUBLIC.
- 40:54AND ARE WE REALLY GOING TO CITE
- 40:56SOMEONE AND PUT THEM INTO JAIL
- 40:58FOR THAT?
- 40:59THAT IS NOT COMPASSION.
- 41:01THAT IS NOT HAVING EMPATHY.
- 41:06THAT IS IN GRANT'S PASS WHEN
- 41:07THEY DECIDED TO DO THIS, THEY
- 41:09HAD A COMMUNITY MEETING.
- 41:11AND THERE ONE OF THE CITY
- 41:13COUNCIL MEMBERS TALKED ABOUT
- 41:14DOING THIS TO MAKE IT AS
- 41:16UNCOMFORTABLE AS POSSIBLE FOR
- 41:18HOMELESS PEOPLE TO STAY IN OUR
- 41:19COMMUNITY.
- 41:20THEY TALKED ABOUT DRIVING REPEAT
- 41:23OFFENDERS AND DROPPING THEM OFF.
- 41:24THAT IS UGLY AND REPUGNANT.
- 41:27AND I THINK ALL OF US CAN REJECT
- 41:29THAT.
- 41:30>> KUNGU I AGREE WITH YOU.
- 41:32WE SHOULD HAVE COMPASSION AND WE
- 41:33SHOULD BE CAREFUL WHEN
- 41:34ADDRESSING THIS ISSUE.
- 41:36REAL PEOPLE ARE INVOLVED.
- 41:38IMAGE BEARERS OF GOD ARE
- 41:39INVOLVED BUT IT GETS BACK TO A
- 41:41ROOT QUESTION THAT I BROUGHT UP.
- 41:42IS CAN LOCAL GOVERNMENTS OR THE
- 41:45STATE GOVERNMENT ENACT POLICIES
- 41:46THAT ARE DEEMED FOR THE BENEFIT
- 41:48OF ALL FOR THE GENERAL WELFARE?
- 41:50AND THE CITY OF LOUISVILLE AND
- 41:52THE STATE GOVERNMENT DECIDED
- 41:54CAMPING IN PUBLIC, PUBLIC PARKS
- 41:56OR IN PRIVATE AREAS, IN FRONT OF
- 41:58PRIVATE BUSINESSES, IT'S NOT
- 42:00GOOD.
- 42:01IT'S NOT DIGNIFYING TO THE
- 42:03UNSHELTERED.
- 42:04IT'S NOT SAFE TO THE PUBLIC.
- 42:05THERE IS A BETTER WAY TO DEAL.
- 42:07AND AS FAR AS MONEY, TOO --
- 42:10>> THEY CAN DO THOSE LAWS IN THE
- 42:12CASES THEY TALKED ABOUT ALL THE
- 42:13OTHER THINGS THAT CITIES CAN DO.
- 42:15AND THEY CAN DO THAT.
- 42:17AS IT APPLIES TO SOMEONE WHO IS
- 42:20UNHOUSED OR UNSHELTERED AS TO
- 42:22THOSE INDIVIDUALS IT IS A
- 42:24VIOLATION OF THE 8TH AMENDMENT.
- 42:26>> Renee: WHICH IS CRUEL AND
- 42:28UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT.
- 42:29I WANT TO GO TO ONE OF THE OTHER
- 42:32PROVISIONS IN HOUSE BILL 5 IS
- 42:33THE USE OF ALLOWS PROPERTY
- 42:35OWNERS TO USE DEADLY FORCE
- 42:37AGAINST SOMEONE CAMPING ON THEIR
- 42:38PROPERTY IF THEY REFUSE TO LEAVE
- 42:40OR FEEL LIKE THEY ARE BEING
- 42:42THREATENED OR BEEN THREATS
- 42:44AGAINST THE PROPERTY OPENER.
- 42:47SO IS THAT HOW DOES THAT SIT
- 42:49WITH YOU?
- 42:50>> IT DOESN'T SIT WELL WITH ME.
- 42:53PEOPLE THAT THE NATIONAL
- 42:58HOMELESS LAW PROGRAM CITED THAT
- 42:59IS THE MOST HORRENDOUS PART OF
- 43:01HOUSE BILL 5 IT MAKES OUR
- 43:03LEGISLATION ONE OF THE WORST IN
- 43:04THE COUNTRY.
- 43:04FOR US, LIKE PEOPLE THAT ARE
- 43:07HOMELESS OFTEN ARE IN CRISIS.
- 43:09AND THAT PERSON SHOULD BE
- 43:11ENGAGED BY A TRAINED
- 43:12PROFESSIONAL THAT HAS MENTAL
- 43:13HEALTH BACKGROUND OR A TRAINED
- 43:15OUTREACH WORKER TO MOVE THEM
- 43:16INTO A NEW SPACE.
- 43:20AND I DON'T WANT TO DEPUTIZE A
- 43:25PERSONAL PROPERTY OWNER TO BE
- 43:26THE FIRST POINT OF CONTACT FOR
- 43:27SOMEBODY WHO IS HOMELESS.
- 43:30>> Renee: IS THAT
- 43:30CONSTITUTIONAL?
- 43:31>> I DON'T THINK SO.
- 43:38THE PREDICATE OF USE OF DEADLY
- 43:40FORCE IS MORE ACUTE THAN WE'RE
- 43:42SAYING NOW.
- 43:43THE PERSON HAS TO BE ATTEMPTING
- 43:44TO DISPOSSESS THE HOMEOWNER OF
- 43:48HIS OR HER DWELLING UNDER A
- 43:50CLAIM OF RIGHT OR POSSESSION OR
- 43:53COMMITTING OR ATTEMPTING TO
- 43:54COMMIT A BURGLARY, ROBBERY OR
- 43:56FELONY INVOLVING THE
- 43:57USE-OF-FORCE OR COMMITTING OR
- 43:59ATTEMPTING TO COMMIT ARSON.
- 44:00WE ARE TALKING ABOUT AUTHORIZING
- 44:02PEOPLE IN LAWFUL POSSESSION OF
- 44:04PROPERTY TO USE DEADLY FORCE TO
- 44:06PROTECT THEIR HOMES FROM
- 44:11DISPOSSESSION, BURGLARY, ROBBERY
- 44:12AND ARSON.
- 44:13THAT ISN'T CRAZY.
- 44:16NOT PEOPLE BEING SHOT AT FOR
- 44:17BEING THERE.
- 44:18WE'RE TALKING ABOUT PEOPLE BEING
- 44:20SHOT AT LET'S SAY BECAUSE THEY
- 44:22ARE THREATENING THE PEOPLE
- 44:23ALREADY THERE.
- 44:23AND THAT IS PART OF OUR LAW
- 44:25ALREADY.
- 44:26THIS JUST CODIFIES SOMETHING IN
- 44:28LAW.
- 44:29YOU CAN PROTECT YOUR PROPERTY IT
- 44:31FOLLOWS BY A KENTUCKYISM.
- 44:32YOU HAVE NO DUTY TO RETREAT
- 44:34EITHER.
- 44:35I THINK THIS IS A CODIFICATION
- 44:38OF SOMETHING UNLESS I'M
- 44:41MISUNDERSTANDING THE LAW
- 44:42SOMETHING THAT IS TRUE ALREADY.
- 44:43>> I AGREE WITH HIM.
- 44:44I THINK THIS IS REALLY JUST A
- 44:48REWORDING OF KENTUCKY'S CURRENT
- 44:50SELF-DEFENSE LAW.
- 44:50I KNOW A LOT OF PEOPLE GOT
- 44:52WORRIED ABOUT THIS BECAUSE OF
- 44:53THE WAY IT'S PHRASED.
- 44:55THE CONCERN IS IS WHEN IT WAS
- 44:57UNNECESSARY LANGUAGE BECAUSE I
- 44:59THINK THERE IS THIS MAYBE
- 45:02APPEARANCE TO HAVE PEOPLE ENGAGE
- 45:04IN THIS CONDUCT WHEN WE TO MAYBE
- 45:08GO THE EXTRA STEP THAT THEY
- 45:09SHOULDN'T.
- 45:10IT ALMOST SAYS GO AHEAD AND BE
- 45:12THAT VIGILANTE OR DO THIS AND I
- 45:14THINK THAT IS THE SCARY PART.
- 45:16WE WOULD RATHER HAVE PEOPLE CALL
- 45:18THE POLICE OR CALL A DIFFERENT
- 45:23RESPONDER TO DEAL WITH SOMEONE
- 45:24IF THEY ARE NOT LEAVING YOUR
- 45:26PROPERTY RATHER THAN TO ENGAGE
- 45:28INTO A PHYSICAL ALTERCATION
- 45:30WHERE YOU MAY GET HARMED AND
- 45:32THAT INDIVIDUAL MAY GET HARMED.
- 45:34>> Renee: IS KENTUCKY MORE
- 45:35LENIENT WHEN IT COMES TO
- 45:37UNLAWFUL CAMPING?
- 45:38IN TENNESSEE HAVE THEY ELEVATED
- 45:40THAT TO A FELONY CHARGE.
- 45:42DID KENTUCKY TAKE A MORE SUBDUED
- 45:44APPROACH?
- 45:45>> THAT IS ONE TAKE ON IT.
- 45:46IT IS A NATIONAL TREND TO
- 45:48CRIMINALIZE HOMELESSNESS.
- 45:49OUR ISSUE IS RIGHT NOW WE'RE
- 45:54CRIMINALIZING STREET CAMPING
- 45:54WHAT IS NEXT?
- 45:55ARE WE GOING TO START
- 45:58CRIMINALIZING ANYBODY SITTING ON
- 45:59A CURB?
- 45:59ANYBODY WHO IS TAKING UP SPACE
- 46:01ON A PARK BENCH?
- 46:02OTHER CITIES ON THE WEST COAST
- 46:04HAVE DONE SIMILAR LAWS LIKE
- 46:06THAT.
- 46:06SO FOR US, LIKE IT'S WE DON'T
- 46:08WANT TO START GOING DOWN THAT
- 46:10ROAD BECAUSE WE'RE DOING IT
- 46:12LENIENT THE FIRST TIME DOESN'T
- 46:13MEAN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY ISN'T
- 46:15GOING TO COME BACK AND INCREASE
- 46:17PENALTIES WHEN WE DON'T SEE THE
- 46:19DESIRED OUTCOME OF HOUSE BILL 5.
- 46:21>> Renee: IS THIS ENOUGH FOR YOU
- 46:23AND YOUR SIDE OR SHOULD IT GO
- 46:25FURTHER?
- 46:25WOULD YOU LIKE IT TO BE UPGRADED
- 46:27TO FELONY?
- 46:28>> I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS
- 46:30NECESSARY.
- 46:31BUT I JUST WANT TO ADDRESS WHAT
- 46:32GEORGE SAID.
- 46:33I DON'T THINK IT'S REASONABLE TO
- 46:35SAY THAT THE LEGISLATURE IS
- 46:36GOING TO COME BACK AND FINE
- 46:38PEOPLE FOR SITTING ON THE CURB
- 46:40OR ON A PARK BENCH.
- 46:44YOU ARE DEALING WITH PRESERVING
- 46:45THE HEALTH, SAFETY AND WELFARE
- 46:47OF YOUR COMMUNITY.
- 46:47IF WE NEED TO FIND TEMPORARY
- 46:49SHELTER FOR THE HOMELESS THERE'S
- 46:51DO THAT.
- 46:52DELL 32 MILLION CAME TO THE CITY
- 46:55OF LOUISVILLE TO ADDRESS
- 46:56HOUSING.
- 46:5732 MILLION.
- 46:57THE CITY OF LEXINGTON HAS 4
- 47:00MILLION.
- 47:00THEY HAVE AN OFFICE OF TO
- 47:03ADDRESS HOMELESSNESS THEY HAVE A
- 47:04BUDGET $1.4 MILLION THIS YEAR.
- 47:07SO WE HAVE MONEY.
- 47:08WE HAVE RESOURCES.
- 47:09LET'S LOOK AT A WAY TO HELP
- 47:11THOSE UNSHELTERED IN A DIGNIFIED
- 47:13WAY.
- 47:14AND, AGAIN, WE ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 47:16THE UNSHELTERED.
- 47:17ONE MORE POINT ABOUT THAT
- 47:18POPULATION.
- 47:19I WOULD LIKE TO SEE A SURVEY OF
- 47:22THOSE UNSHELTERED AND HOW MANY
- 47:24ARE STRUGGLING WITH ADDICTION
- 47:27AND WITH MENTAL ILLNESS.
- 47:29MY GUESS IT'S HIGHER THAN THE
- 47:3137% THAT YOU SHARED EARLIER.
- 47:32>> I AGREE WITH YOU THAT WE NEED
- 47:35TO BE THE CITY HAS A
- 47:36RESPONSIBILITY TO TAKE CARE OF
- 47:37THE HEALTH AND WELFARE OF ITS
- 47:41CITIZENS.
- 47:42OUR UNSHELTERED BROTHERS AND
- 47:45CITIZENS ARE PART OF THAT
- 47:46COMMUNITY.
- 47:47THEY ARE PART OF THAT AND WE
- 47:48NEED TO BE MAKING SURE WE ARE
- 47:50TAKING CARE OF THEM AS WELL.
- 47:53>> THE AREA WE DISAGREE IS DO
- 47:55THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO CAMP IN
- 47:57PUBLIC?
- 47:57THERE ARE RULES WHEN YOU ENTER
- 47:59PUBLIC SPACES WE ARE ALL
- 48:01OBLIGATED TO FOLLOW WHETHER WE
- 48:03ARE HOMELESS OR NOT AND WE ARE
- 48:05ON DIFFERENT SIDES.
- 48:06>> AND IT IS NOT A QUESTION IF
- 48:08THEY HAVE A RIGHT.
- 48:09IN LOUISVILLE THERE IS NO
- 48:10OPTION.
- 48:11WE HAVE 800 SHELTER SPOTS FOR
- 48:13THE ENTIRE COUNTY AND WE'RE
- 48:15TRYING TO SERVE 1600 PEOPLE ON
- 48:17ANY GIVEN NIGHT.
- 48:18FOR US, LIKE WE WANT PEOPLE TO
- 48:23GET THE SERVICES THAT THEY NEED.
- 48:25AND THE 32 MILLION I WILL TAKE
- 48:28EVERY DOLLAR THAT WE CAN AND PUT
- 48:29IT INTO PAYING SHELTERS TO
- 48:32EXPAND SERVICES I WILL PUT IT
- 48:34INTO GOING TO 24 HOUR SHELTER
- 48:37MODELS.
- 48:38WHERE PEOPLE HAVE BETTER OPTIONS
- 48:39TO GO IN.
- 48:41BECAUSE ULTIMATELY, I BELIEVE
- 48:42THAT PEOPLE ARE MAKING A CHOICE.
- 48:44THEY ARE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT
- 48:45WHAT IS THE LESSER OF ALL THE
- 48:47EVILS THAT I'M FACING RIGHT NOW.
- 48:49AND I'M TRYING TO ONE IS TRYING
- 48:51TO FIGURE OUTDO I GO INTO A
- 48:54SHELTER AND DO I GET WOKEN UP AT
- 48:566:00 A.M. AND I CANNOT COME BACK
- 48:58UNTIL 6:00 P.M.
- 49:00HOR DO I STAY OUT AND STAY WITH
- 49:03MY PEOPLE AND MY STUFF I'M WITH
- 49:05MY PET OR I'M WITH MY PARTNER.
- 49:09BECAUSE A LOT OF TIMES FAMILIES
- 49:11CANNOT GO IN TOGETHER.
- 49:12IF YOU ARE A MOTHER WITH AN
- 49:1418-YEAR-OLD SON YOU CANNOT GO
- 49:16INTO SHELTER YOU HAVE TO BE I
- 49:18SEPARATED.
- 49:18OUR SHELTER SYSTEM NEEDS HELP.
- 49:20OUR SHELTER SYSTEM NEEDS
- 49:23RESOURCES TO MEET THE NEEDS THAT
- 49:24WE'RE SEEING TODAY IN THE MODERN
- 49:26ERA.
- 49:27THE SHELTER SYSTEM THAT WE HAVE
- 49:28IS DESIGNED SOLELY TO KEEP
- 49:30PEOPLE ALIVE UNTIL TOMORROW.
- 49:32AND FOR US, HOUSE BILL 5 DOESN'T
- 49:35HELP US MEET THOSE NEEDS OF
- 49:37GETTING PEOPLE IN AND GETTING
- 49:38PEOPLE SERVICES AND GETTING
- 49:40PEOPLE MOVED TOWARDS HOUSING.
- 49:41>> Renee: Mr. NELSON YOU SAID
- 49:43SOMETHING EARLIER ABOUT
- 49:44SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER AND
- 49:46MENTAL HEALTH AND WE HEARD THE
- 49:47REPRESENTATIVE SAY THIS IS MEANT
- 49:48TO GET THOSE PEOPLE INTO THE
- 49:50SERVICES.
- 49:51YET YOU JUST ASKED THE QUESTION
- 49:54ABOUT DATA HOW MANY KENTUCKIANS
- 49:57UNSHELTERED OR HOMELESS WHO
- 49:58SUFFER FROM THAT.
- 49:59WAS THE POLICY NOT PREMATURE.
- 50:02WE TALK ABOUT DATA-DRIVEN BASED
- 50:04PUBLIC POLICY.
- 50:05DID THEY NOT HAVE THAT
- 50:07INFORMATION PRIOR TO MAKING
- 50:09THOSE PROVISIONS IN SECTION 17
- 50:10OF HOUSE BILL 5?
- 50:11>> I'M NOT SURE, RENEE, WHAT
- 50:15DATA THEY HAVE.
- 50:16AND WE LOOKED TO OTHER STATES.
- 50:18AND I THINK YOU CAN EXTRAPOLATE.
- 50:20IT WILL NOT BE PERFECT
- 50:23CORRELATION BUT I THINK THAT WE
- 50:26DO KNOW I DON'T KNOW IF
- 50:27YOU'VE --
- 50:28I THINK MANY OF US HAVE BEEN IN
- 50:29BIG CITIES.
- 50:30LOUISVILLE OR OTHERWISE WHERE
- 50:33WE'VE SEEN HOMELESS UNSHELTERED
- 50:35PEOPLE.
- 50:35AND YOU CAN TELL THAT THERE ARE
- 50:38ADDICTION ISSUES AND THERE ARE
- 50:39MENTAL ILLNESS ISSUES.
- 50:40I DON'T KNOW THE EXACT NUMBERS
- 50:42BUT WE KNOW THAT THE NUMBERS ARE
- 50:44HIGH IN OTHER CITIES.
- 50:46>> RENEE THERE IS A GUY GREG HE
- 50:49WROTE A BOOK CALLED HOMELESSNESS
- 50:50IS A HOUSING PROBLEM.
- 50:51AND HE DID AN ANALYSIS ARE
- 50:54DRIVERS OF HOMELESSNESS LIKE
- 50:56WEATHER, OR WE HAVE GOOD
- 50:57SERVICES OR SMI SUBSTANCE USE
- 51:01DISORDER AND MENTAL ILLNESS THE
- 51:03ONLY THING HE FOUND BETWEEN WHAT
- 51:06YOUR AVERAGE RENT WAS AND YOUR
- 51:08VAN CANDIDACY RATE WAS.
- 51:10IN SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER WAS
- 51:11THE BIGGEST DRIVER OF
- 51:14HOMELESSNESS WE WOULD SEE WEST
- 51:16VIRGINIA AND KENTUCKY LEADING
- 51:17THE COUNTRY AND WE DON'T SEE
- 51:19THAT F POVERTY WAS THE ISSUE,
- 51:21DETROIT WOULD HAVE THE BIGGEST
- 51:23LARGEST HOMELESS NUMBER IN THE
- 51:24COUNTRY.
- 51:25WHAT WE SEE IS WHERE YOUR RENT
- 51:28IS SKYROCKETING AND VACANCY IS
- 51:31BELOW 5% IS WHEN YOU SEE AN
- 51:35UPTICK OF PEOPLE TRYING TO GET
- 51:36INTO HOUSING.
- 51:37>> I WOULD SAY I THINK THERE'S
- 51:39OTHER FACTORS.
- 51:42THERE ARE JOBS EVERYWHERE.
- 51:44PEOPLE ARE LOOKING TO HIRE.
- 51:46I THINK THAT THERE ARE OTHER
- 51:48ELEMENTS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO THE
- 51:50HOMELESSNESS.
- 51:54AND IT IS A COMPREHENSIVE ISSUE.
- 51:56WE NEED TO LOOK AT IT
- 51:58HOLISTICALLY.
- 51:59I THINK JUST PUTTING A ROOF FOR
- 52:01A MATTER OF DIGNITY, WE SHOULD
- 52:04HOUSE THOSE UNSHELTERED.
- 52:05BUT WE ALSO SHOULD HELP THEM IN
- 52:07OTHER WAYS.
- 52:08WHETHER IT'S JOB TRAINING,
- 52:10WHETHER IT'S WORKING ON
- 52:12RELATIONAL SKILLS WHATEVER IT
- 52:13MIGHT BE.
- 52:14>> AND THAT IS THE GOAL OF
- 52:16HOUSING FIRST PROGRAMS IS ONCE
- 52:17YOU GET IN, IT'S NOT HOUSING
- 52:19FIRST ONLY.
- 52:20IT IS SURGING RESOURCES AND CASE
- 52:22MANAGEMENT TO FIGURE OUT LIKE
- 52:23WHAT IS THE PLAN TO TALK ABOUT
- 52:26SEVERE MENTAL ILLNESS THERE'S
- 52:27WELL SPRING THAT IS THEIR WHOLE
- 52:29ENTITY WE GET PEOPLE HOUSING AND
- 52:31WE MAKE SURE THEY ARE GOING TO
- 52:33TALK WITH THEIR THERAPIST THAT
- 52:34THEY HAVE THE SUPPORTS TO MAKE
- 52:36SURE THEY ARE ON THEIR MEDICINE.
- 52:38AND THEY HAVE SUCCESSES LIKE IN
- 52:40LOUISVILLE, WE HAVE A 97%
- 52:42SUCCESS RATE OF KEEPING PEOPLE
- 52:44HOUSED AND PERMANENT HOUSING
- 52:46PROGRAMS AND WE SEE THAT NUMBER
- 52:48REFLECTED IN THE OTHER TWO
- 52:50CONTINUUMS OF CARE.
- 52:51>> Renee: AS WE WRAP UP THE
- 52:52DISCUSSION WHICH HAS BEEN
- 52:54ENGAGING.
- 52:54TO YOU PROFESSOR.
- 52:56LET'S SAY THE U.S. SUPREME COURT
- 52:57WHICH IS EXPECTED TO RENDER A
- 52:59RULING ON THIS IN JUNE, SAYS
- 53:02THAT IT IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL
- 53:04GRANT'S PASS VERSUS JOHNSON AND
- 53:07THAT UNLAWFUL CAMPING DOES
- 53:10VIOLATE THE EIGHTHTH AMENDMENT
- 53:11AGAINST CRUEL AND UNUSUAL
- 53:14PUNISHMENT WHAT COULD IT MEAN
- 53:15FOR THE HOUSE BILL 5 AND THOSE
- 53:18PROVISIONS?
- 53:19IS THERE SEVERABILITY CLAUSE
- 53:20THAT WOULD ALLOW THE REST OF THE
- 53:22BILL TO GO INTO EFFECT?
- 53:25>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 53:27I HAVE NOT READ ALL OF HB5 IT IS
- 53:29A LONG BILL.
- 53:31IT MAY HAVE ITS OWN SEVERABILITY
- 53:34CLAUSE BUT WHETHER IT HAS IT OR
- 53:37NOT, THERE IS AN OMNIBUS
- 53:39SEVERABILITY CLAUSE THAT APPLIES
- 53:40TO EVERYTHING.
- 53:41THE ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION IS
- 53:43YES.
- 53:43I WOULD ALSO SAY AND YOU DIDN'T
- 53:45ASK THIS, I THINK THE SUPREME
- 53:48COURT IS NOT GOING TO DO THAT.
- 53:49I THINK THE SUPREME COURT IS
- 53:51GOING TO REVERSE THE 9TH
- 53:52CIRCUIT.
- 53:53WE HAVE NOT TALKED ABOUT THE
- 53:54CASE VERY MUCH.
- 53:55I THINK THAT THE 9TH CIRCUIT'S
- 53:58DECISION ALTHOUGH IT THEY DO
- 54:00CITE A COUPLE OF OLDER CASES
- 54:01FROM THE 1960s, I THINK IT'S A
- 54:04LITTLE BIT OF AN OUTLIER.
- 54:05AND I THINK I'M NOT SURE, BUT I
- 54:08THINK THE SUPREME COURT WILL
- 54:10CLIP THE 9TH CIRCUIT'S WINGS.
- 54:12>> Renee: AS YOU LOOK AT THE
- 54:14NEXT GENERAL ASSEMBLY A 30-DAY
- 54:16SESSION WHAT WILL YOU ASK THEM
- 54:18TO DO EITHER ONE OF YOU?
- 54:20>> FOR ME IT'S ALL ABOUT
- 54:22INCREASING OUR HOUSING SUPPLY.
- 54:24REDUCING BARRIERS FOR ACCESS
- 54:27THAT HOUSING AND SUPPORTING LOW
- 54:28INCOME RENTERS TO MAKE SURE THEY
- 54:31DON'T LOSE HOUSING THROUGH
- 54:33LANDLORD TENANT REFORMS AND
- 54:34GETTING EMERGENCY RENTAL ATIES
- 54:38ASSISTANCE.
- 54:38>> Renee: SHOULD THIS PART OF
- 54:39THE BILL STAND?
- 54:41HOW DO WE WE'RE DOING IT RIGHT?
- 54:42>> WE'LL SEE THE RESULTS IN OUR
- 54:45BIGGER CITIES.
- 54:46AGAIN, THE INTENT OF THE
- 54:47LEGISLATURE WAS TO PRESERVE OUR
- 54:49COMMUNITIES.
- 54:50TO PRESERVE THE HEALTH, SAFETY
- 54:52AND WELFARE TO KNOW IF WE'RE
- 54:54DOING IT RIGHT.
- 54:55LOOK, IF WE FIND A BETTER AVENUE
- 54:58FOR THE UNSHELTERED WE WILL KNOW
- 55:00WE HAVE DONE IT RIGHT.
- 55:01WHETHER A PUBLIC DESIGNATED
- 55:03ENCAMPMENT OR WHETHER FOR
- 55:05TRANSITIONING BETTER THEN WE'LL
- 55:07KNOW WE'VE DONE IT RIGHT.
- 55:09>> Renee: WELL, WE'LL SEE HOW
- 55:10THINGS GO AND WE MENTIONED HOUSE
- 55:12BILL 18 WHICH WAS THE SOURCE OF
- 55:14INCOME AND SO WE'VE TALKED ABOUT
- 55:16THAT ON THIS PROGRAM BEFORE.
- 55:17SOME WOULD SAY THAT EXACERBATES
- 55:20THE ISSUE FURTHER?
- 55:21>> FOR US IT MEANS SERVICE
- 55:23PROVIDERS WILL WORK TWICE AS
- 55:25HARD TRYING TO FIND A LANDLORD
- 55:27TO TAKE A HOUSING VOUCHER.
- 55:30>> Renee: GOOD DISCUSSION AND WE
- 55:31HOPE YOU'VE ENJOYED IT.
- 55:33YOU CAN WATCH THE PROGRAM
- 55:34ON-LINE IF YOU MISSED ANY OF IT
- 55:36OR LIKE TO SEE IT AGAIN.
- 55:38IT WILL BE AVAILABLE TOMORROW AT
- 55:43KET.ORG/KY TONIGHT AND JOIN US
- 55:45EACH WEEKNIGHT FOR KENTUCKY
- 55:47EDITION WHERE WE INFORM AND
- 55:50INSPIRE AT THE SAME TIME AND
- 55:51BREAKDOWN THESE KINDS OF ISSUES
- 55:52THAT WILL STILL BE DEBATED IN
- 55:54SOME FORM OR ANOTHER IN THIS
- 55:56STATE AND ELSEWHERE.
- 55:57AND ALSO WE INVITE YOU TO JOIN
- 55:59BILL BRYANT AND A TEAM OF
- 56:02JOURNALISTS TO DISCUSS THE NEWS
- 56:03OF THE WEEK ON "COMMENT ON
- 56:05KENTUCKY" FRIDAY AT 8:00 P.M. 7
- 56:07CENTRAL.
- 56:07THANK YOU FOR WATCHING.
- 56:10"KENTUCKY TONIGHT".
- 56:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 56:12UNTIL I SEE YOU AGAIN, TAKE
- 56:14REALLY GOOD CARE.
- 56:15[♪♪]