Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Why Doesn’t Prayer Work? Understanding Unanswered Prayers
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, Why doesn't prayer
- 0:04work? There's some great theologians
- 0:08from throughout history that has some really cool points about
- 0:11this. I can't wait to share this with
- 0:12you. Here we go.
- 0:15Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:18Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:22hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger on Together for Good.
- 0:26Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:29supports you without expectations.
- 0:32Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:34religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:37we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:40No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:43you're here. Welcome to together for good.
- 0:46So what's to do with prayer? This question that as a pastor I
- 0:50actually get a lot, and people want to know how they're
- 0:53supposed to be praying. And usually more to the point,
- 0:57they want to know how they can pray in such a way that they'll
- 1:01get what they want. Most of the time when we come
- 1:06with prayer, it is with really good intentions.
- 1:08I don't think there's many people who try to use prayer as
- 1:12just another quick life hack to get them exactly the job, the
- 1:17body, the finances that they've always dreamed of.
- 1:20I think we realize that there's something deeper and more
- 1:24intentional about prayer. But what we do often want is we
- 1:27want our prayers to be able to enact change in the world in the
- 1:31way that we see fit. And so we will pray for specific
- 1:35outcomes within the political sphere or within the national
- 1:41global sphere, or we'll pray for specific outcomes as it relates
- 1:46to deeply troubling moments. We'll pray for healing for a
- 1:51friend or family. That's probably one of the most
- 1:53common ways that prayer gets utilized.
- 1:57And this in turn creates the issue because people will be
- 2:01praying so fervently, so faithfully, not for themselves,
- 2:06but for someone else who is suffering.
- 2:09And sometimes, unfortunately, they will not see or find the
- 2:14result they were hoping for on the other side.
- 2:17This is deeply troubling and and can really shake someone's faith
- 2:22when you pray so hard for healing and it doesn't come or
- 2:26it doesn't resolve anywhere near the way that you were expecting
- 2:30or hoping for. And it leads you into these
- 2:33moments of despair wondering, God, where are you?
- 2:37Why wouldn't you want this God? Why would you allow for this
- 2:42terrible tragedy to take place? Why would you ignore my prayers
- 2:46for this tragedy to be averted? And yet it happens anyway.
- 2:50You can start to see why this becomes such a difficult trying
- 2:56moment for so many people, and I'm sure many people have
- 3:00stories of how they lost their faith because prayers went
- 3:02unanswered. But I believe that all of this
- 3:08is operating under incorrect assumptions about what prayer is
- 3:13actually about. And for there is in great
- 3:18Lutheran, yeah, shout out Lutheran's theologian, Friedrich
- 3:22Schleiermacher, who was in Germany in the 1800s.
- 3:26I believe it is 1718 hundreds. And Schleiermacher wrote about
- 3:31this phenomenon specifically, and he talks about prayer as an
- 3:35act of absolute dependence. But in his explanation of it,
- 3:39one of the things he points out is just the logical fallacy that
- 3:44we enter into if we believe that prayer is our mechanism for
- 3:48changing God's mind. Because what Schreinermacher
- 3:51says is, if God is an infinite divine being, the most supreme
- 3:57being in all the universe beyond our comprehension, then that
- 4:01being also by definition must be beyond our control.
- 4:06And so if God can be swayed by the prayers of individual human
- 4:12beings who are so much lesser than God, well, if that's the
- 4:18case, then that's not really much of A God at all.
- 4:22That's not a supreme, divine, all powerful being.
- 4:25That's a being that can be manipulated by the prayers of,
- 4:30you know, these little thoughts in someone's head of a human
- 4:34being. I'm putting it all pretty
- 4:36flippantly, but that that's ultimately Schleidermacher's
- 4:38point. It's like this, this can't be
- 4:40what prayer is all about because it makes no sense.
- 4:43God, he didn't use these terms because it was a long time ago,
- 4:47before the advent of vending machines.
- 4:48But God is not a vending machine.
- 4:50It's not, you know, punch in C5 and get a Twix bar.
- 4:56God has to be something so much more beyond than a simple
- 5:03transactional type of relationship.
- 5:06It's like, OK Nate, like, great. That sounds wonderful.
- 5:09You just kind of ruined prayer for everyone.
- 5:11Then what is the point of praying at all?
- 5:14Great question, please stick with me.
- 5:17The point of prayer is connection with God and being in
- 5:22God's presence. Paul Tillich, another Lutheran
- 5:26theologian, he was in the writing in the 1940s, fifties
- 5:30and 60s primarily, and what he writes about is that God that he
- 5:35says is the ground of being and speaks about God in this way.
- 5:39And you can hear echoes of Schleiermacher there, right?
- 5:43Absolute dependence, ground of being.
- 5:45You're getting the idea. What Paul Tillich says is that
- 5:50God is not some sort of being, but God is the existence itself,
- 5:57being itself, the ground of being itself.
- 6:00What I really appreciate about that, as confusing as it is and
- 6:03as hard as it is to wrap our minds around, but there's
- 6:06something about that definition that immediately starts with us
- 6:08recognizing that we cannot comprehend or understand God.
- 6:14God is the absolute soup of existence itself.
- 6:19That's what Paul Tillich would say.
- 6:21Or to that effect. And so if that's the case, then
- 6:25there's no real way for us to sway the opinions of this God as
- 6:30if God is another person. OK.
- 6:32By the way, I'd like to put in a formal request for this event to
- 6:36take place like. Well, that's not really how it
- 6:39works because God is all events at all times and in all places.
- 6:45When we start to understand and, and come to God with this sense
- 6:48of humility, just the, the bigness, the vastness, the
- 6:51incomprehensibility of God. Yeah.
- 6:55Then in turn, the way that you pray is going to be very
- 6:58different. And So what Paul Tillich would
- 7:01say is that prayer connects us to what is ultimate.
- 7:05Prayer is a way of connecting with this ground of being.
- 7:09It's a way of rooting ourselves in something bigger than
- 7:14ourselves. And with that it it's more about
- 7:19trust, which leads me to Martin Luther, another good Lutheran
- 7:24theologian. He was in the 1500s, and he
- 7:27talks about how prayer shapes us into dependent trust.
- 7:33We believe that there is some sort of force goodness, that God
- 7:38is loved, and that God is everywhere at all times and in
- 7:42all places. So hard to fully wrap our minds
- 7:45around, but that's the point, that somehow there's something
- 7:48bigger going on than our struggles with the current
- 7:52moment. As it relates to prayer, one
- 7:56thing to remember is that Jesus himself prayed and had his
- 8:01prayer go unanswered. Or in fact, Jesus prayed and the
- 8:05opposite took place on the night of his betrayal in the Garden of
- 8:10Gethsemane. We're told in the Gospels that
- 8:13Jesus prays for this cup to pass from him.
- 8:16And that obviously is not what happened.
- 8:19And I love that our scriptures include this story that Jesus,
- 8:23you know, the the one who was really good, who followed all of
- 8:27the law, who did everything exactly right.
- 8:30He prays and doesn't get what he wants.
- 8:35And so we don't need to start thinking that our prayers went
- 8:37unanswered because God thought we were bad or that we weren't
- 8:40good enough, because even Jesus wasn't able to get the prayer
- 8:44answered in the way that he wanted.
- 8:46But more so than that, it also just reveals to us that prayer
- 8:49has to be about something different than changing God's
- 8:53mind. Jesus was praying for this, but
- 8:56what was actually going on in his heart at that moment?
- 9:00What was he hoping to accomplish on this incredibly tumultuous
- 9:05moment in his earthly life? I think what prayer is about is
- 9:12bringing our concerns to God, bringing our longings to God,
- 9:18and simply trust it. Not expecting necessarily for
- 9:22everything to change, but recognizing that there is
- 9:28something so healing and helpful about expressing what sits in
- 9:35our hearts so deeply and sharing that with this divine eternal
- 9:43presence that is God, this ground of being.
- 9:49You see, prayer is the space, often times, where your ache and
- 9:54God's presence meet. There's so much in this world
- 10:00that troubles our hearts and that scares us and that makes us
- 10:05anxious. And prayer can be that practice
- 10:08that allows us in some small way to let go and to turn it over
- 10:13and to discover some sense of hope, Maybe hope, yes, that that
- 10:19things will actually change right now in the present moment,
- 10:23but also maybe grounding us in a hope that's so much bigger than
- 10:26the present moment. You see so much of the story of
- 10:32Jesus and the Scriptures and the Gospels.
- 10:35I think the message of the Christian faith is that God
- 10:38encounters us in moments of suffering and difficulty, that
- 10:43that that's where God's power is revealed most fully.
- 10:48Theologians call this the theology of the cross, this idea
- 10:51that God's power is most fully revealed in Jesus's suffering
- 10:55and death, and we extrapolate out from that.
- 11:00OK, if that's the case, then yes.
- 11:03Like when I am suffering or struggling to be able to have a
- 11:08way to connect with the presence of God, that is with me when
- 11:13things seem really, really bad. That's what prayer is about and
- 11:17what it provides us with. Obviously, there's other times
- 11:21that you might want to pray. Prayers of Thanksgiving, prayers
- 11:25of just presence and listening. That's a really big, important
- 11:28practice. But notice how all of these are
- 11:31just allowing you to take moments in the history of your
- 11:34life and to link them with the ground of being, to connect you
- 11:40with that which is ultimate, as Paul Tillich would say, to root
- 11:46you in a sense of absolute dependence, as Schleiermacher
- 11:49would say, to create a new dependent trust, as Martin
- 11:55Luther would say. See, all these great theologians
- 11:57have been trying to point us towards this reality for
- 11:59hundreds and hundreds of years. And yet I think what we really
- 12:03want is the vending machine God. We want it to be easy to just
- 12:07press the buttons and get exactly what we want.
- 12:09And yet if that was the case, if God had to answer every prayer
- 12:14exactly as it was articulated, the world would be chaos.
- 12:18Because there's many people out there who are praying for very
- 12:21different things. There are many people praying
- 12:24for one very particular place thing to take place and other
- 12:27folks praying very fervently for the exact opposite to take
- 12:32place. And so maybe it's more about how
- 12:36can we allow this practice to root us in a sense of hope that
- 12:41is eternal and so much bigger than the present moment and our
- 12:45current feelings or opinions, because those are always subject
- 12:49to change as well. What you pray for today, you
- 12:53might be praying for the exact opposite in five years.
- 12:56Where would we be then? The point of prayer, I think,
- 13:00especially at moments of deep sorrow and difficulty, is for us
- 13:05to recognize that God is with us.
- 13:09When nothing changes on the cross, Jesus cries out, My God,
- 13:16my God, why have you forsaken me?
- 13:18And that moment has captured the imagination of theologians and
- 13:23pastors and philosophers for thousands of years because it's
- 13:27such a revelatory detail about how God relates to us.
- 13:35Jesus is God Incarnate. And through that cry of
- 13:38dereliction, Jesus is stating that he knows what it's like to
- 13:44feel abandoned by God. And yet Jesus is God greatly.
- 13:49This is circular logic. It doesn't make sense.
- 13:52It's so hard to wrap our minds around.
- 13:53But what it points us to is to recognize that God is with us
- 14:00even when we feel those moments of being completely abandoned by
- 14:04God, those moments of complete despair, when all we're left
- 14:09with is doubt and lament. Somehow God is present in
- 14:15moments like that too. And in fact, God has experienced
- 14:20that in God's very being through the cry of Jesus.
- 14:26It's a lot to think about. It's hard to fully wrap our
- 14:29minds around, but I hope it can be a value to you because I know
- 14:34I get this question all the time.
- 14:36Why didn't God answer my prayers?
- 14:38And I don't have a great answer for you on saying like, I'm not
- 14:42sure why God didn't give you exactly what you wanted.
- 14:45It seems so logical, yes, that this would be what God would
- 14:49hope for and what God would will.
- 14:51And yet I think what we need to start to wrap our minds around
- 14:54is this idea that prayer isn't about changing God's mind.
- 14:59It's about bringing us and allowing our us to be shaped by
- 15:05dependence and trust in God and dependence and trust in a bigger
- 15:09promise. Because that's also part of all
- 15:12of these pieces that I'm saying here is that prayer connects us
- 15:15with this ground of being, with something infinite and vast and
- 15:17eternal and beyond our imagination.
- 15:19And it helps us hopefully recognize in some small way that
- 15:24the promises of God, that the answers from God to us are
- 15:29bigger than the present moment as well.
- 15:32And so maybe the prayer isn't answered exactly the way we
- 15:34wanted in this moment, in this point in history.
- 15:38And yet can we trust that God's promises are bigger than just
- 15:44this isolated moment? That maybe the answer we were
- 15:47hoping and praying and longing for is yet to be revealed.
- 15:53This ties us to an eternal understanding, an everlasting
- 15:58understanding of the ways that God's work, that God works.
- 16:02And maybe in some small way the practice of prayer is what helps
- 16:06root us in those types of eternal promises.
- 16:10So there you go, a lot of thoughts on prayer. 3 dead
- 16:16German guys who all happened to be Lutheran.
- 16:20But yeah, Paul Tillich, Frederick Schleiermacher, Martin
- 16:23Luther, and those are the three we covered.
- 16:24If you want to Google them and learn more, send this to someone
- 16:28who maybe has asked you about prayer, why you pray, how it
- 16:31works, or someone who's struggling or having a difficult
- 16:34time. And yeah, this week I challenge
- 16:37you to see prayer as a way of rooting yourself in eternal
- 16:43promises of God and see it as the act of trust, that source of
- 16:47connection to the ground of being that is our God.
- 16:51As always, thanks for listening, everyone.
- 16:54Stay in peace. Thank you for listening to the
- 16:57Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 17:00your walk of faith, please visit our website bethany-denver.org
- 17:05or download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 17:09your phone's App Store.