Latest / Deep Dive / Why Degrees Matter Less Than You Think in the Global Economy
Transcript
- 0:00For decades you've been told a lie.
- 0:02I mean, we all have. Oh absolutely.
- 0:04It's a very comforting narrative though.
- 0:06Right. It's super comforting.
- 0:07It's handed down from, you know, guidance counselors,
- 0:09politicians, economists, and it basically goes like this.
- 0:13Get a college degree, secure a high skilled job where you sit
- 0:17at a comfortable desk, and you will be completely safe from the
- 0:20tidal wave of globalization. Yeah, the idea being that the
- 0:24only people who need to worry about offshoring are the blue
- 0:26collar workers, right? The one standing on the
- 0:29assembly. Line exactly the manual
- 0:30laborers. But today we're looking at data
- 0:33that proves that map is worse than outdated.
- 0:37It is actively misleading. The conventional wisdom is just
- 0:40dead. It really is.
- 0:41It's the standard mid 20th century map of the economy, a
- 0:45map that assumes education is this impenetrable shield.
- 0:49But by the end of this deep dive, you're going to see why
- 0:52the blue collar plumber sweating in your basement might actually
- 0:55have the most economically secure job in the world.
- 0:58While the architect upstairs, holding a master's degree and
- 1:01drawing blueprints on a pristine computer, is entirely vulnerable
- 1:04to being replaced. It's wild to think about.
- 1:07We are witnessing A fundamental structural shift in how human
- 1:11capital is valued. The ground is completely shifted
- 1:14beneath us. It has.
- 1:15So welcome to the deep dive. We have an incredibly ambitious
- 1:18mission today. We are going to dismantle and
- 1:20completely rebuild how you think about your job, your skills and
- 1:24the global labor market. And to do that, we are leaning
- 1:26on two really strike making academic papers that tackle the
- 1:29two sides of the globalization coin.
- 1:31Yeah, the first is a 2010 paper from a team of German
- 1:34economists, Daniel Baumgarten, Ingo Guy Schecker and Holger
- 1:38Gerg. It's titled Offshoring Tasks and
- 1:41the Skill Wage Pattern. And they come through 15 years
- 1:44of incredibly granular German wage data to see who actually
- 1:48loses money when corporations send work overseas.
- 1:51And then we are going to look at the inverse.
- 1:53Yeah. The 2nd paper is a 2015 study by
- 1:55Australian geographer Sally A Weller called Accounting for
- 1:59Skill Shortages, Migration and the Australian Labor Market.
- 2:02Right, so if the German paper looks at the invisible export of
- 2:05tasks, you know, sending work out.
- 2:07The Australian paper looks at the highly visible imported
- 2:10bodies bringing humans in to fill a perceived gap.
- 2:14Exactly. So think about your own
- 2:15situation for a second. If your job title says manager
- 2:19or engineer or consultant, how safe are you really?
- 2:23Let's unpack this. Let's do it.
- 2:24I want to take us back to the classic economic mindset of the
- 2:271990's. The political rhetoric back then
- 2:30framed globalization as a battle of education.
- 2:34White collar versus blue collar. Right.
- 2:36If a factory moved to a country with cheaper labor, the manual
- 2:39worker suffered, but the high skilled knowledge worker, the
- 2:42one designing the product or managing the supply chain,
- 2:45theoretically benefited because their company became more
- 2:48globally competitive. That was the foundational
- 2:50assumption, yeah. Economists viewed offshoring
- 2:54almost exclusively through the lens of trading intermediate
- 2:57goods. Intermediate goods, meaning
- 2:58physical parts. Exactly.
- 3:00If we look at the historical context, picture a car
- 3:02manufacturer in the 90s. They might decide it's cheaper
- 3:05to cast the engine blocks in a different country, put those
- 3:08physical engines on a cargo ship, and then do the final
- 3:11assembly domestically. That is trading an intermediate
- 3:13good. Right.
- 3:14And the people who lost out in that scenario where the domestic
- 3:18steel workers and the factory floor hands who used to cast
- 3:21those engine blocks. But the engineers at the
- 3:23headquarters were perfectly fine.
- 3:25They were completely insulated, but the German economists point
- 3:28out that this model doesn't work anymore.
- 3:30No, it doesn't. They lean heavily on a highly
- 3:33influential theoretical model proposed by economists Gene
- 3:37Grossman and Esteban Rossi Hansberg.
- 3:39And the paradigm shift here is that we need to stop looking at
- 3:42offshoring as the trade of physical goods and start viewing
- 3:46it as trade in tasks. Trade in tasks.
- 3:49I love that phrasing, but how does that theoretical model
- 3:52actually change the math for a normal worker?
- 3:55Well, if we connect this to the bigger picture, the Grossman and
- 3:58Rossi Hansberg model fundamentally rewrites the rules
- 4:01because it recognizes the impact of the digital revolution.
- 4:04Right, the Internet changes everything.
- 4:06It drastically lowered the cost of transmitting information.
- 4:09You don't need a cargo ship anymore.
- 4:11When you trade in tasks, you are shipping a discrete packet of
- 4:15human effort across a border via a fiber optic cable.
- 4:18And the cost of shipping that task doesn't depend on how smart
- 4:22the person doing it is. Not at all, or how many degrees
- 4:25they have. It depends entirely on the
- 4:27nature of the task itself. Which brings me back to the
- 4:29analogy of building a house. Let's look at the plumber.
- 4:33In traditional economic terms, the plumber is classified as a
- 4:37manual lower skilled worker compared to an architect.
- 4:40Sure, but you absolutely cannot offshore a plumber.
- 4:44If a pipe bursts in your wall, the person fixing it has to be
- 4:48physically present in your local environment.
- 4:50Navigating the unique, unpredictable reality of your
- 4:53specific basement. Right.
- 4:55Their daily task is rooted in physical space and local
- 4:58interaction. There is no fiber optic cable
- 5:01that can fix a leaky valve. But then you look at the
- 5:03architect, highly educated, highly skilled, holding advanced
- 5:06credentials. They are sitting in a quiet
- 5:08office, drawing blueprints using CAD software.
- 5:11And the Grossman and Rossi Hansberg model suggest that the
- 5:14architect is completely vulnerable.
- 5:15A developer can hire a brilliantly skilled architect in
- 5:18another country to draw those exact same blueprints for a
- 5:21fraction of the cost. And those designs can be emailed
- 5:24to the construction site in two seconds.
- 5:26This is the new matrix we have to understand.
- 5:28The true metric of your economic armor isn't your education
- 5:32level. The researchers argue that we
- 5:34need to evaluate jobs on 2 specific spectrums right routine
- 5:39versus non routine and interactive versus non
- 5:42interactive. Let's define those clearly for
- 5:45the listener. Routine means you are doing a
- 5:48predictable, repeatable process. Like doing the same data entry
- 5:51over and over. Yeah, and non routine means you
- 5:54are constantly dealing with new unpredictable problems that
- 5:58require adaptation. Okay, and then you have the
- 6:00second access interactivity. Interactive means your task
- 6:04requires face to face contact, complex communication with other
- 6:08humans, or physical navigation of a local environment.
- 6:11While non interactive means you can sit in an isolated room,
- 6:14look at a screen or a piece of paper and get the job done
- 6:17entirely on your own. But wait, let me push back on
- 6:20this underlying premise for a second.
- 6:22Isn't interactivity entirely subjective?
- 6:24How do you mean? Well.
- 6:25Let's say I'm a low skilled worker.
- 6:27Maybe I drive a local delivery truck.
- 6:29Sure, I interact with people, but mostly I'm just handing a
- 6:32warehouse manager a clipboard to sign, right?
- 6:35Is that really the same economic armor as, say, a CEO interacting
- 6:39with a board of directors to negotiate a corporate merger?
- 6:42It feels like we are flattening the concept of interactivity to
- 6:46make a neat theory. That is a brilliant challenge,
- 6:49and it's exactly what the data attempts to address.
- 6:52The researchers aren't equating the value of the interaction,
- 6:55but rather the offshore ability of it.
- 6:57OK. So the offshore ability is what
- 6:59matters. Exactly.
- 7:00The truck driver handing over a clipboard is in fact navigating
- 7:03a complex local environment. They are dealing with local
- 7:07traffic patterns, adjusting to the mood of the warehouse
- 7:09manager, navigating a physical loading dock that might be
- 7:13blocked. I see you cannot outsource the
- 7:16physical delivery of those goods to someone in another time zone.
- 7:19Right. The CEO's interaction is
- 7:21obviously more financially lucrative and complex, but both
- 7:24tasks share the fundamental trait of acquiring local
- 7:27physical human presence. So any task that is highly
- 7:30routine and non interactive, regardless of whether it
- 7:34requires a high school diploma or a PhD, can be digitized,
- 7:38packaged and sent across the globe.
- 7:40Precisely, the researchers demonstrate that within the
- 7:43exact same educational bracket, the specific nature of a task
- 7:47determines a worker's financial fate.
- 7:50That's a huge shift in perspective.
- 7:51You can have two workers who both stop their education after
- 7:55high school. One is doing interactive non
- 7:58routine tasks. They are insulated.
- 8:00And the other is doing non interactive routine tasks.
- 8:03And their wages are in the crosshairs of globalization.
- 8:06Skills and tasks are not the same thing.
- 8:08They are entirely different axes of vulnerability.
- 8:11OK, that makes sense in theory. But it brings up a massive
- 8:14methodological problem. It's one thing for an economist
- 8:17to sit in an ivory tower and say, well, tasks matter more
- 8:20than skills. It's another thing entirely to
- 8:22mathematically prove it across an entire nation's workforce.
- 8:25Exactly how do you quantify a task?
- 8:28Normally economic surveys just ask people what is your job
- 8:31title? Which is incredibly limiting.
- 8:33If a survey asks what you do and you check a box that says
- 8:36manager, what does that actually mean?
- 8:38It could mean anything. It could mean you spend 8 hours
- 8:41a day silently looking at a supply chain spreadsheet in a
- 8:44cubicle. Or it could mean you spend 8
- 8:47hours a day on a chaotic retail floor, resolving interpersonal
- 8:51conflicts between angry employees and difficult
- 8:54customers. This job title gives us 0
- 8:56visibility into the routine or interactive nature of your day.
- 8:59So to get around this, the German researchers had to find a
- 9:02way to measure the unmeasurable. And the data they used is
- 9:06staggering. It really is.
- 9:08They started with the German socio economic panel, the SOEP.
- 9:12And this wasn't just a quick phone pole.
- 9:14This is a massive longitudinal study that tracked the exact
- 9:17same individual workers year after year from 1991 all the way
- 9:21to 2006. That time frame is crucial.
- 9:24From 1991 to 2006, we saw the aggressive rise of the Internet,
- 9:28the opening of Eastern Europe after the fall of the Berlin
- 9:30Wall, and China entering the World Trade Organization.
- 9:34It is the perfect Petri dish for studying offshoring.
- 9:36It is the SOEP gave them the baseline, you know, wages,
- 9:40demographics, education levels and industry sectors.
- 9:44But as you said, the SOEP just gives them job titles and
- 9:46paychecks to figure out the actual tasks.
- 9:49They had to merge that wage data with a completely different data
- 9:52set, the German Qualification and Career Survey.
- 9:54And instead of asking for job titles, this survey asked
- 9:57workers in exhausting detail about the physical and digital
- 10:01tools they used on the job. This is where the methodology
- 10:04gets incredibly clever. They mapped the tools.
- 10:08The researchers relied on previous task mapping frameworks
- 10:11developed by other economists, specifically Becker and Spitz.
- 10:14Owner right. Those previous researchers had
- 10:16figured out how to category authorize 81 specific tools
- 10:19surveyed in the German data. By looking at which tools a
- 10:23worker used they could mathematically code how
- 10:25interactive and how non routine a job was.
- 10:28Creating an index from zero to 1 for every single occupation.
- 10:31Exactly. Let's make this concrete,
- 10:33because when I was looking through the specific examples of
- 10:35how they coded these tools, it completely changed how I look at
- 10:39everyday office equipment. It's fascinating, right?
- 10:41It is. For instance, the survey asks if
- 10:44a worker frequently uses an overhead projector or a beamer.
- 10:48If you say yes, the researchers mathematically code your task
- 10:51profile as highly non routine and highly interactive.
- 10:56It sounds strange at first to link a piece of off equipment to
- 10:59job security totally, but think about the human behavior
- 11:03attached to that tool. If you are using a projector,
- 11:06you are almost certainly presenting information to a room
- 11:09full of people. That is the interactive
- 11:11component. Right, you're not projecting a
- 11:13spreadsheet to an empty room. Exactly.
- 11:15Furthermore, a presentation usually involves answering
- 11:18unpredictable questions, reading the room, persuading an
- 11:20audience, or adapting your pitch on the fly.
- 11:23That is the non routine component.
- 11:25You simply cannot easily outsource the person commanding
- 11:28the room. You can't.
- 11:29OK, so the projector equals safety.
- 11:31Now let's look at the other end of the spectrum.
- 11:33Another tool from the survey is Computer Controlled machinery.
- 11:36Right, if a worker checks the box saying they use that their
- 11:39job is coded as non interactive and non routine.
- 11:43It's non interactive because your primary interface is with
- 11:47the machine, a screen or control panel rather than a human being.
- 11:51But it retains the non routine coding because operating complex
- 11:54factory and machinery isn't just mindlessly pulling a lever.
- 11:58It requires constant adjustment, monitoring for errors, and
- 12:02complex problem solving if the machine malfunctions.
- 12:05But because it lacks the human interaction element, the task is
- 12:08partially vulnerable. We've seen this in
- 12:10manufacturing. The person monitoring the
- 12:12machine doesn't necessarily need to be standing next to it
- 12:15anymore. They could be monitoring the
- 12:17sensors from a Control Center in another country, exactly the
- 12:21risk the model predicts. And then there's the example I
- 12:23brought up earlier, the use of simple means of transport like a
- 12:27delivery van. The data codes the use of a van
- 12:30as highly interactive but highly routine.
- 12:32The driving itself, you know, getting from point A to point B
- 12:35on a highway is a largely predictable, repeatable, routine
- 12:39process. But the entire purpose of the
- 12:41van is to interface with the local economy.
- 12:45The driver is negotiating with warehouse staff, getting
- 12:48signatures from customers, navigating local construction
- 12:51detours. The van forces local
- 12:54interactivity. What I love about this
- 12:56methodology is how it reveals these brilliant quirks that defy
- 13:00all of our socioeconomic stereotypes.
- 13:02It really breaks the mold. When they map these 81 tools
- 13:04across the workforce, they found low skilled workers with highly
- 13:09interactive jobs. Truck drivers.
- 13:11Local tradespeople. Retail staff.
- 13:14They might not have advanced degrees, but their daily tools
- 13:17require navigating complex human environments.
- 13:20And conversely, they found high skilled workers with
- 13:22surprisingly low interactive jobs.
- 13:24Think about certain types of database administrators,
- 13:26quantitative analysts, or back end software developers.
- 13:30They possess immense technical skills and years of advanced
- 13:32education. But their daily tools dictate
- 13:34that they sit alone in front of a screen, writing code or
- 13:37processing data in isolation. Two people can ride the exact
- 13:41same commuter train into the city.
- 13:43They can have the exact same level of education.
- 13:45Maybe they even make the exact same starting salary.
- 13:48Yeah, but because one gets off the train and spends their day
- 13:51using a projector, and the other gets off the train and spends
- 13:53their day using a computer terminal in a quiet room, their
- 13:57vulnerability to the global economy is entirely different.
- 14:00We build our identities around our degrees, but the global
- 14:03market doesn't care about your diploma, It cares about whether
- 14:07your daily tasks can be packaged into a digital file and emailed
- 14:11to someone willing to do it for less.
- 14:13It is a profound realization about the mechanics of modern
- 14:16labor. So we have the theory trade in
- 14:19tasks and we know how they measured it by tracking 81
- 14:22different tools. Now we need to look at the
- 14:24actual fallout. What did this invisible export
- 14:27of tasks do to the German workforce?
- 14:29To set the scene, we have to look at the macro environment in
- 14:32Germany between 1991 and 2006. The researchers used a very
- 14:36strict definition of offshoring. They looked specifically at
- 14:39materials offshoring in the manufacturing sector.
- 14:43This means they were tracking intermediate inputs that a
- 14:46German industry could have produced itself using domestic
- 14:49labor, but explicitly chose to import from a foreign supplier
- 14:54instead. And over that 15 year window,
- 14:57that specific type of offshoring in the German manufacturing
- 15:00sector grew from about 6% to 8% of total production value. 2%
- 15:05might sound like a rounding error, but in a manufacturing
- 15:08juggernaut like Germany, a 2% shift in production value
- 15:12represents a Titanic reallocation of capital and
- 15:15labor. Huge.
- 15:17The question is, how did that macroeconomic shift impact the
- 15:20microeconomic reality of an individual worker's paycheck?
- 15:24The researchers broke the damage out into two different
- 15:26scenarios. The first scenario is what
- 15:28economists call partial equilibrium.
- 15:30Think of partial equilibrium as a sealed glass box.
- 15:33We are looking at the wage effects, assuming that workers
- 15:36are completely immobile. So nobody moves.
- 15:38Right. If you work in the automotive
- 15:40industry and the automotive industry suddenly offshores a
- 15:43large chunk of its data entry and routine assembly tasks, what
- 15:47happens to your specific wage, assuming you do not or cannot
- 15:51leave the automotive industry? We are holding everything else
- 15:53constant. When the researchers ran the
- 15:56numbers for partial equilibrium, the results were entirely
- 16:00counterintuitive. Let's look at the low skilled
- 16:03workers first. OK for a low skilled worker
- 16:05whose job was in the lowest 10% of interactivity, meaning they
- 16:09do almost everything in complete isolation, they lost about 32
- 16:13euro cents per hour due to offshoring over that period.
- 16:17If we assume a standard work year of about 1500 hours, that
- 16:20translates to a loss of roughly 390 to €480 a year.
- 16:25Which is a pay cut. It's a pay cut.
- 16:26It hurts, but it perhaps doesn't sound like the complete
- 16:30apocalyptic devastation of the working class that we sometimes
- 16:33associate with the word globalization.
- 16:35Right, but here is the real twist in the partial equilibrium
- 16:39data for low skilled workers who were in the highest 10% of
- 16:43interactivity, the ones constantly dealing with people
- 16:46in local environments. They didn't.
- 16:48Lose money. They actually gained money.
- 16:50Yes, their wages went up by about 150 to €225 a year
- 16:56specifically because of offshoring in their industry.
- 16:59This is a crucial mechanic to understand.
- 17:01Why would a domestic worker get a raise when their company is
- 17:05sending jobs overseas? Sounds backward.
- 17:07Because when an industry offshores it's highly routine,
- 17:11non interactive tasks to a cheaper labor market, the
- 17:14overall company saves money. The firm becomes more
- 17:17productive, more efficient and more competitive on the global
- 17:20stage. So the company's profit margins
- 17:22go up. Exactly.
- 17:23And that increased productivity and profit can actually trickle
- 17:27down as a wage premium to the local domestic workers who
- 17:30remain, provided those remaining workers are doing tasks that
- 17:33cannot be offshored. The interactive workers.
- 17:35Right. The managers coordinating the
- 17:38global supply chain, the salespeople dealing with local
- 17:41clients, the maintenance staff keeping the domestic
- 17:43headquarters running, they become more valuable.
- 17:46They are the essential local glue holding the new globally
- 17:50distributed operation together. I have to admit, when I first
- 17:54read that I was genuinely surprised.
- 17:56If I'm an interactive worker, partial equilibrium suggest
- 17:59offshoring is actually making me richer.
- 18:02It does. It almost paints A rosy picture
- 18:04of globalization, where the company gets leaner, the routine
- 18:07tasks are outsourced and the interactive domestic workers
- 18:11reap the benefits of the increased efficiency.
- 18:14But that assumes the economy operates inside that sealed
- 18:17glass box, and the autonomy is never a sealed glass box.
- 18:21It's not. Workers are not immobile.
- 18:23If a massive German factory offshore is 500 routine data
- 18:27processing jobs, those 500 domestic workers don't just
- 18:30vanish into thin air. They still have mortgages, they
- 18:33still have to eat, they have to go find other jobs.
- 18:34And that brings us to the terrifying part of the paper,
- 18:37general equilibrium. General equilibrium is the
- 18:40Ribble effect. Yeah, it breaks the glass box
- 18:43and recognizes that workers can and do move across industries.
- 18:47Exactly. An electrical engineer or a
- 18:49payroll clerk whose job gets offshore in the automotive
- 18:52sector might walk across the street and try to get a job in
- 18:55the machinery sector or the chemical sector.
- 18:57This introduces the labor supply effect.
- 19:00When offshoring frees up excess domestic workers, they flood the
- 19:04broader labor market. And the most basic law of
- 19:07economics, supply and demand, dictates that when the supply of
- 19:10Labor drastically increases, the price of that that labor gets
- 19:13crushed. And you don't even need actual
- 19:15physical movement to feel the effect of general equilibrium.
- 19:19Just the threat of movement changes the math.
- 19:22Oh, totally. If there is suddenly a massive
- 19:24pool of unemployed people with your exact skill set circulating
- 19:27in your city looking for work, your bargaining power at your
- 19:30current job evaporates. So when the German researchers
- 19:33factored in this cross industry mobility, when they looked at
- 19:36the general equilibrium, the numbers changed drastically.
- 19:39The minor paper cut became a deep systemic wound.
- 19:42Let's look at the real numbers under general equilibrium.
- 19:46The low skilled workers in the lowest interactivity bracket
- 19:49didn't just lose $0.32 an hour. No, the cross industry flood of
- 19:53displaced workers drove their wages down by 1.31 euros an
- 19:59hour. Over a standard working year,
- 20:01that is a cumulative wage reduction of up to €19165.
- 20:06That's huge. For a low skilled worker already
- 20:09living on the margins, taking a nearly €2000 pay cut purely
- 20:14because of the macroeconomic forces of offshoring is
- 20:17financially devastating. And it wasn't just the low
- 20:19skilled workers who took the hit.
- 20:21This is where the 1990s narrative completely falls
- 20:24apart. Yeah, the medium skilled
- 20:25workers. The people who did everything
- 20:27right, who got their upper secondary education or completed
- 20:29rigorous vocational training, they got absolutely hammered.
- 20:33Medium skilled workers with low interactivity lost up to €2460 a
- 20:37year. What this data emphatically
- 20:39proves is that the traditional economic model was wrong.
- 20:43It isn't just low skilled manual workers who suffer.
- 20:46Medium skilled educated workers, if they are trapped in routine
- 20:50non interactive tasks, are facing massive wage cuts.
- 20:53Not necessarily because their specific job was outsourced, but
- 20:56because of the cross industry spillover of displaced workers
- 20:59who can do the same routine tasks.
- 21:02Think about the reality of your own job for a second.
- 21:04Let's say you feel perfectly safe because your specific
- 21:07company is highly profitable and promises they will never
- 21:10offshore your department. Right.
- 21:12You think you're secure? What this general equilibrium
- 21:14data tells us is that your company's promises don't matter.
- 21:18If your industry gets disrupted, or even if a completely
- 21:21unrelated industry in your city gets disrupted by offshoring,
- 21:24you face a tidal wave of cross industry refugees.
- 21:27A tidal wave. If thousands of people who do
- 21:30the exact same routine tasks as you suddenly lose their jobs to
- 21:34an overseas firm, they're going to walk into your boss's office
- 21:37tomorrow and offer to do your job for 10% less.
- 21:42The invisible export of tasks fundamentally alters the
- 21:45domestic supply of Labor for everyone.
- 21:48It creates A vulnerability that education simply cannot shield
- 21:51you from. So we spent a lot of time
- 21:54exploring the invisible flight of tasks out of a country and
- 21:58how it creates this localized labor flood.
- 22:01But that makes me wonder what happens if a government tries to
- 22:04do the exact reverse. OK, let's look at that.
- 22:06What happens when a country looks at its economy, decides it
- 22:09doesn't have enough skills, and deliberately tries to suck human
- 22:12talent into the country to fix a problem?
- 22:14That transitions us perfectly from the German export of PASS
- 22:17to the Australian import of bodies, our second source.
- 22:21The 2015 paper by Sally Weller examines this exact phenomenon,
- 22:25and the consequences are just as counterintuitive as the
- 22:27offshoring data. To really understand what
- 22:30happened in Australia, we need just spend a minute setting the
- 22:32historical stage for how the country thought about migration.
- 22:35It's important context. Historically, Australia was
- 22:38always performing a high wire balancing act between two
- 22:41competing urges. On one hand, they had a
- 22:44facilitative purpose. Australia is a massive,
- 22:47geographically isolated, resource rich continent with a
- 22:50relatively small population. They inherently needed to import
- 22:54people to build the physical economy, populate the cities and
- 22:57become consumers. But on the other hand, they had
- 23:01a deeply ingrained protective purpose.
- 23:03The Australian government, heavily influenced by strong
- 23:06labor unions throughout the 20th century, felt a profound
- 23:09obligation to protect the wages and the job security of the
- 23:12local domestic workers. For decades, they operated on a
- 23:15strict Keynesian model where immigration numbers were
- 23:18inextricably tied to local unemployment rates.
- 23:20It was a simple thermostat. If domestic unemployment went
- 23:23up, they shut the integration doors to protect local jobs.
- 23:26And if the economy boomed and unemployment dropped, they
- 23:28opened the doors to let more workers in.
- 23:30It was a highly managed protective system.
- 23:32But then in the 1990s and accelerating into the 2000s,
- 23:37there's a massive philosophical shift.
- 23:39The thermostat broke. The government essentially
- 23:41unlinked migration from local unemployment realities.
- 23:45They abandoned the protective stance and went all in on the
- 23:49facilitative side. They bought into a new
- 23:51globalized neoliberal idea that highly skilled migrants are
- 23:56essentially just autonomous engines of human capital.
- 23:59But the theory was that if you bring smart, educated people
- 24:02into a country, they will magically create economic
- 24:04growth, innovate and generate wealth wherever they go,
- 24:07regardless of the immediate local employment metrics.
- 24:10And this philosophical shift collided with a massive economic
- 24:13event, the post crisis mining boom between 2005 and 2010.
- 24:19While much of the world was staggering through the global
- 24:21financial crisis, the Australian economy was actually growing.
- 24:25Fueled heavily by an insatiable demand for mining exports from a
- 24:29rapidly expanding China. To feed this economic engine,
- 24:32the Australian government implemented a highly aggressive
- 24:35points based migration system. The point system is crucial to
- 24:38understand. You didn't necessarily need a
- 24:40specific job offer to migrate. You were graded on a rubric.
- 24:44You got points for being in your prime working years, points for
- 24:48speaking advanced English, and points for holding tertiary
- 24:51degrees. But the absolute golden ticket,
- 24:55the trump card that virtually guaranteed your entry, was if
- 24:58your specific occupation was placed on the government's
- 25:01Migration Occupations in Demand list or the Modiel.
- 25:04And importantly for a crucial window of time during this boom,
- 25:08the number of visas they would issue for these in demand
- 25:11occupations was completely uncapped.
- 25:13There was no quota. None.
- 25:15If you scored the points and your job title was on the list,
- 25:17you're in. Which brings us to this
- 25:19specific, staggering case study of Weller's paper Accountants,
- 25:24Accountants. The Australian government looked
- 25:25at their economic models and declared that the country had a
- 25:28severe systemic shortage of accountants.
- 25:30So they put Accountant on the demand list and the floodgates
- 25:33opened. The numbers are almost hard to
- 25:35visualize. Between 2005 and 2012, under the
- 25:39General Skilled Migration Program, 63,675 migrant
- 25:44accountants arrived in Australia.
- 25:46I want to pause on that number because it requires context.
- 25:49Australia's entire population at the time was roughly 22 million
- 25:52people, right? Injecting nearly 64,000 fully
- 25:56qualified prime working age accountants into specific urban
- 26:00centers like Sydney and Melbourne over a span of a few
- 26:03years is a massive demographic event.
- 26:06It's a huge influx. And that number only counts the
- 26:08permanent arrivals. It doesn't count the temporary
- 26:11work visa holders who were also operating in the accounting
- 26:14space. Furthermore, the policy created
- 26:16an entirely separate domestic pipeline of accountants.
- 26:20Australian universities quickly realized that studying an in
- 26:23demand profession was an explicit pathway to permanent
- 26:26residency for international students.
- 26:28So the university's aggressively marketed accounting degrees
- 26:31globally. At any given time during this
- 26:34period, there were another 30,000 international students
- 26:37studying accounting in Australia.
- 26:39The vast majority of whom intended to stay and enter the
- 26:41labor market. So you have a localized labor
- 26:44market that is attempting to absorb close to 100,000
- 26:47potential accountants in less than than a decade.
- 26:50And here is the core paradox of the entire paper.
- 26:54Despite importing this massive, unprecedented army of numerical
- 26:58talent. Despite having universities
- 27:01pumping out thousands of new accounting graduates every
- 27:03semester. The Australian accounting
- 27:05industry still complain to the government that they were
- 27:07suffering from severe skill shortages.
- 27:09It sounds mathematically impossible.
- 27:11It divides every basic law of supply and demand.
- 27:14It really does. How is that possible?
- 27:16How can you bring in 100,000 accountants and still have an
- 27:20industry screaming that they can't find anyone to hire?
- 27:23Did all these highly educated professionals just forget how to
- 27:25use a balance sheet on the flight over?
- 27:28This raises an important question about how governments
- 27:30actually define reality. We tend to think of a labor
- 27:33shortage as an objective mathematical fact, like
- 27:36measuring the temperature of A. Room like there are empty desks.
- 27:39Right. If an industry has 100 empty
- 27:42desks and there are only 90 accountants in the city, you
- 27:46have a hard shortage of 10. The government looks at the
- 27:49thermometer, sees it's too cold, and turns on the immigration
- 27:52furnace. But Weller argues that Labor
- 27:54need is actually a highly politicized, deeply flawed
- 27:58social construct. Let's break down the flawed
- 28:00mathematics. How did the Australian
- 28:03government actually calculate that there was a shortage?
- 28:07It wasn't just a guess. They had a specific formula used
- 28:10by the Department of Employment. Yes, they calculated the
- 28:13shortage by taking the ratio of open job vacancies and comparing
- 28:16it to the number of experienced job seekers.
- 28:19The keyword in the entire formula is experienced.
- 28:22When the government ran their models, they explicitly excluded
- 28:25recent domestic university graduates from their
- 28:27calculations. Wait, really?
- 28:29And they also explicitly excluded recent migrants who
- 28:31didn't already possess local Australian work experience.
- 28:35Let me stop you there because we need to let the sheer audacity
- 28:38of that metric sink in. The government was trying to
- 28:41measure if there were enough accountants in the country, and
- 28:45to do so they intentionally ignored the 10s of thousands of
- 28:49people graduating with accounting degrees from their
- 28:51own universities. Exactly.
- 28:53It is a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 28:55They effectively ignored the mile long queues of highly
- 28:59qualified, freshly educated people who were desperate for an
- 29:02entry level job. They only counted the people who
- 29:05already had a resume full of local experience.
- 29:08By using a metric that artificially restricts the
- 29:11supply side of the equation to only seasoned veterans.
- 29:14Of course it looked like there was a perpetual shortage.
- 29:17The thermometer was fundamentally broken.
- 29:19But why would the industry lobby for this?
- 29:21To understand the reality on the ground, the researchers looked
- 29:24at a 2010 survey of accounting firms.
- 29:27They wanted to know who these employers actually were and what
- 29:30exactly they were demanding from the labor market.
- 29:33The reality of the Australian accounting sector was totally
- 29:35detached from the macroeconomic models in Canberra.
- 29:38The industry wasn't just a few massive glassy skyscrapers in
- 29:42Sydney hiring thousands of entry level analysts to train.
- 29:46The sector was heavily dominated by small suburban two to four
- 29:49person firms. These were small businesses
- 29:53doing local taxes, auditing local retail shops and managing
- 29:56suburban wealth. And those small suburban firms
- 29:59simply do not have the time, the budget, or the inclination to
- 30:03hire a raw entry level graduate, whether that graduate is a
- 30:06domestic student or a newly arrived migrant, and train them
- 30:09from scratch. No, they don't.
- 30:11They didn't want to teach someone how to use the specific
- 30:14tax software or how to talk to an Australian small business
- 30:17owner. They only wanted to hire people
- 30:19who could sit down at the desk and hit the ground running at
- 30:21100% capacity on day one. The 2010 survey revealed that
- 30:25the so-called shortage only existed for very, very specific
- 30:28niche roles. The firms wanted accountants who
- 30:31already possessed exactly three to five years of local
- 30:34Australian experience, and they often wanted them to work in
- 30:37regional or less desirable geographical areas where it was
- 30:40hard to attract senior talent. So there was absolutely no
- 30:43shortage of entry level accountants.
- 30:45In fact, there was a massive, overflowing glut of entry level
- 30:50talent. Exactly.
- 30:51So we have to ask the obvious question, if the government knew
- 30:54that suburban firms didn't want entry level workers, and if they
- 30:57knew there wasn't a real structural need for a 100,000
- 31:01new accountants, what were they actually doing?
- 31:03Why keep the immigration floodgates open?
- 31:06Weller proposes a fascinating interpretation of the
- 31:09government's motive. She suggests they were engaging
- 31:12in a proxy policy A. Proxy policy.
- 31:14It's a brilliant way to interpret macroeconomic
- 31:17strategy. Weller argues that the
- 31:19government wasn't actually trying to fill literal
- 31:21accounting desks. They weren't deeply concerned
- 31:24about the suburban tax firms. OK, So what do they want?
- 31:27The government realized that someone who manages to qualify
- 31:30as an accountant who can pass the exams, navigate the visa
- 31:33system and meet the high English language requirements is
- 31:36generally smart, highly numerical, competent with
- 31:39complex business concepts, and driven.
- 31:42They wanted those types of people in the country.
- 31:44They wanted young, smart professionals who would start
- 31:46businesses, stimulate the broader economy, pay taxes and
- 31:50buy houses in the suburbs. Exactly.
- 31:52So they use the accounting label as a proxy.
- 31:55It was a convenient, politically defensible filter to import a
- 31:59highly desirable a graphic, fully knowing that the actual
- 32:02accounting profession could never absorb them all.
- 32:05It allowed the government to achieve its facilitative goal of
- 32:08population and economic growth while using the protective
- 32:12language of fixing a skill shortage to pacify the domestic
- 32:16labor unions. It's like a company putting up a
- 32:18help wanted sign for an astrophysicist.
- 32:20Yeah, not because the company's actually building a rocket, but
- 32:23because the hiring manager knows that anyone who can pass an
- 32:26astrophysics exam is probably going to be really, really good
- 32:30at organizing their chaotic filing system and balancing the
- 32:33budget. That's a great way to put it.
- 32:35They are using a specific professional title to capture
- 32:38general human competence. Which is a clever macroeconomic
- 32:41strategy on paper, but it brings us to the inevitable messy
- 32:45reality of what happens to those 10s of thousands of human beings
- 32:49once they actually arrive at the airport expecting to work as
- 32:52accountants, only to find out that jobs don't exist.
- 32:55Right, Where do they go? Did we see the classic brain
- 32:57waste scenario? We all know the stereotype from
- 33:00the 90's, the brilliant foreign doctor or engineer who migrates,
- 33:03finds out their credentials aren't recognized by the local
- 33:06Guild and ends up driving a taxi for 20 years.
- 33:09Did 100,000 highly trained accountants end up washing
- 33:12dishes in Melbourne restaurants? To answer that, Weller has to
- 33:15challenge yet another outdated economic model, the dual labor
- 33:19market theory. For a long time, sociologists
- 33:22and economists argued that labor markets were strictly divided
- 33:25into two distinct tiers. OK, you had the elite primary
- 33:28market. These are the secure, well
- 33:30paying professional jobs with career ladders.
- 33:33And then you had the precarious secondary market, unstable low
- 33:36wage, manual or service jobs with no benefits.
- 33:40And the old assumption was that if a migrant couldn't instantly
- 33:43break into the primary market, if they couldn't get the
- 33:46accounting job, they plummeted straight down to the bottom tier
- 33:50from accountant to dishwasher. But Weller says that dual model
- 33:54is obsolete. Modern labor markets are
- 33:56multiply segmented. They are infinitely complex webs
- 34:00of overlapping skills, industries and niches.
- 34:03So they didn't just fall to the bottom.
- 34:05No, they diffused. They trickled across
- 34:07horizontally to related numerical fields, finding work
- 34:10in banking, insurance or financial planning.
- 34:13Or they trickled down vertically to slightly lower tier
- 34:17administrative jobs, becoming bookkeepers, payroll clerks, or
- 34:21office managers. To prove this diffusion, the
- 34:24paper utilizes an incredible data set called the Continuous
- 34:27Survey of Australian Migrants, or the C Sam.
- 34:30They tracked 2172 principal applicants who migrated to
- 34:34Australia specifically under the accounting label.
- 34:36And they didn't just look at them once.
- 34:38They interviewed them six months after they arrived and then
- 34:41again at 12 months to track exactly how they were navigating
- 34:44the economy. The variance in their fates is
- 34:47astonishing, and the C Sam data reveals that your trajectory
- 34:52wasn't primarily determined by your accounting skills, it was
- 34:56largely dictated by the specific visa pathway you used to enter
- 34:59the country. The visa dictated the destiny.
- 35:02Let's look at the best case scenario first, the employer
- 35:05nominated visa holders. These were migrants who already
- 35:08had a firm job offer from a specific Australian company
- 35:12before they even boarded the plane.
- 35:14Their outcomes were incredibly strong.
- 35:16Over 90% of them ended up in professional or managerial roles
- 35:20within the first year. 2/3 of them were working specifically
- 35:24as accountants because they had a guaranteed seat at the table
- 35:27waiting for them. They slotted perfectly into the
- 35:30elite primary market, bypassing the suburban bottleneck
- 35:33entirely. But then look at the independent
- 35:35skilled migrants. These were the people who
- 35:37applied from overseas purely based on their high point score.
- 35:41They have the degrees, the language skills, the perfect age
- 35:43profile. But they arrived without a
- 35:45pre-existing job offer. They had to hunt for work in
- 35:47that hostile suburban market. For them, the proxy policy
- 35:51reality hit hard. Only 30.8% of them actually
- 35:55actually found work as accountants.
- 35:57That means nearly 70% of these highly qualified people could
- 36:01not penetrate the profession they were explicitly imported to
- 36:04fill. So where did they go?
- 36:06The data shows that 22.5% of them ended up in administration
- 36:10and clerical roles. They couldn't be the senior tax
- 36:13accountant, so they trickle down and became the bookkeepers and
- 36:16the payroll clerks. And then we have the third
- 36:18category, the former students. These were the international
- 36:21students who paid for their degrees at Australian
- 36:23universities and then transitioned to a permanent
- 36:26residency. Their outcomes were the most
- 36:28diffuse of all. Nearly 30% of them ended up in
- 36:31completely non accounting related fields, trickling across
- 36:34into sectors like retail, management, hospitality or
- 36:37transport. But the C Sam data reveals
- 36:40something even more uncomfortable.
- 36:42It wasn't just the visa type that dictated their fate.
- 36:45There were stark demographic realities at play.
- 36:48The diffusion exposed deep structural biases within the
- 36:51Australian labor market. This is where the paper moves
- 36:54from raw economics into sociology.
- 36:57The data clearly shows that migrants originating from
- 37:00advanced English speaking countries, places like the UK,
- 37:04the US or South Africa, cruised almost effortlessly into
- 37:08management and professional roles.
- 37:10Even if they arrived on independent visas without
- 37:13employer sponsorship. Exactly.
- 37:15But equally technically skilled, fully qualified migrants
- 37:18originating from China and South Asia struggled immensely to
- 37:22break into the professional tiers.
- 37:24The paper notes that employers were often filtering out these
- 37:27candidates based on highly subjective criteria.
- 37:30It wasn't that the candidates couldn't do the math.
- 37:32No employers cited a perceived lack of cultural familiarity, or
- 37:36they desired highly nuanced communication styles and local
- 37:39colloquialisms that weren't captured by standard English
- 37:42proficiency tests. The suburban tax firm wanted
- 37:44someone who could effortlessly banter with the local plumber
- 37:47about the weekend cricket match, and they use that subjective
- 37:50cultural preference as a hiring filter over raw technical
- 37:54accounting skill. And because of that filter, we
- 37:56see this striking gendered and demographic in the data.
- 38:02Men from South Asia and China who couldn't break into
- 38:04accounting often shifted horizontally and downwards into
- 38:08less skilled non accounting work.
- 38:10Logistics, transport, Retail. And women from those same
- 38:14regions predominantly shifted vertically down, taking clerical
- 38:18and administrative roles. And this brings us to the
- 38:21ultimate synthesis of the paper. We have to look at the true
- 38:24macro cost of this proxy policy. From a high altitude
- 38:28macroeconomic bird's eye view. The Australian government could
- 38:31look at this CCM data and claim absolute victory.
- 38:34Sure. I mean a migrant accountants had
- 38:36an 80% overall employment rate. They were working, they were
- 38:39paying taxes, they were renting apartments.
- 38:41The Human Capital Engine was hunting.
- 38:43It looks like a textbook macroeconomic success.
- 38:46But that macroeconomic success masked A brutal localized
- 38:49reality. Think about those highly
- 38:51qualified migrants who trickled down into the clerical tier.
- 38:54By taking those middle tier administrative and bookkeeping
- 38:57jobs, they inadvertently displaced the local domestic
- 39:01entry level workers. Put yourself in the shoes of a
- 39:03small business owner. You need a basic payroll clerk
- 39:06or an office manager. You post the job and you have a
- 39:09choice between an 18 year old local High School graduate with
- 39:120 experience and a 28 year old migrant with a master's degree
- 39:16in accounting who is desperate to get a foothold in the economy
- 39:20and willing to work for the same wage.
- 39:22You are going to hire the master's degree every single
- 39:24time. The proxy policy worked
- 39:26brilliantly for the national GDP.
- 39:29It successfully imported 100,000 smart, capable humans.
- 39:33But in doing so, it created a cascading effect that crushed
- 39:37the domestic youth who were just trying to get their foot on the
- 39:40bottom rung of the corporate ladder.
- 39:42The burden of the policy wasn't borne by the senior accountants.
- 39:45It was borne by the local teenagers who suddenly found
- 39:48themselves competing against foreign master's degree holders
- 39:51for a filing job. It perfectly illustrates why
- 39:54defining labor outcomes merely by having a job or low
- 39:58unemployment is entirely insufficient.
- 40:00We have to look at the specific occupational trajectories and
- 40:03the hidden displacement effects within those multiply segmented
- 40:06markets. We do OK.
- 40:08We have covered an immense amount of intellectual ground
- 40:10today. We've travelled from the factory
- 40:12floors of 1990s Germany to the suburban tax firms of 20 tens
- 40:17Australia. Let's bring it all together.
- 40:20What is the ultimate take away from these two incredibly dense,
- 40:23paradigm shifting papers? Well, if there is one unifying
- 40:26truth across both the German offshoring data and the
- 40:29Australian migration data, it is that skills, as traditionally
- 40:33defined by university of degrees, job titles and formal
- 40:36qualifications are an obsolete metric for understanding your
- 40:39value and your vulnerability in the modern global economy.
- 40:42In Germany we saw the invisible export of tasks.
- 40:45We learned that having a low skill level doesn't
- 40:47automatically Doon you, and having a high skill level
- 40:50doesn't automatically save you. Your vulnerability is entirely
- 40:53dependent on the interactivity and the non routine nature of
- 40:56your specific daily tasks. If you use a projector and
- 40:59command a room, you're safe. If you use a computer terminal
- 41:02in isolation, your tasks can be exported and the resulting
- 41:06general equilibrium wave of displaced workers will crush
- 41:09your wages. And in Australia, we saw the
- 41:11highly visible import of bodies. We learned that when a
- 41:15government tries to import a skill based on a generic job
- 41:18title, those humans do not fit neatly into an economic
- 41:22spreadsheet. They diffuse across a complex,
- 41:24biased, multiply segmented market.
- 41:27They rarely land where the policymakers intended.
- 41:30And their presence trickles down to impact entirely unrelated
- 41:33sectors of the domestic workforce, displacing the most
- 41:36vulnerable entry level workers. O how do you alley this to your
- 41:40own life? The deep dive isn't just about
- 41:42understanding the world on an academic level, it's about
- 41:45navigating it better. To be truly well informed and
- 41:48career resilient today, you must look past your own job title.
- 41:52You need to conduct a brutal, honest audit of your own task
- 41:55portfolio. You need to ask yourself, what
- 41:57do I actually do all day? Are you sitting in a room
- 42:00processing routine data in isolation?
- 42:02If so, you are highly vulnerable to the invisible export of
- 42:05tasks, no matter how many letters come after your name.
- 42:08But if your day is highly interactive, if you are
- 42:10navigating complex local environments, mediating human
- 42:14conflicts, adapting to unpredictable physical or social
- 42:17variables, then you are insulated.
- 42:21You are the local glue that cannot be digitized and send
- 42:23across a fiber optic cable. You want to be the truck driver
- 42:27navigating the chaos of the loading dock or the manager
- 42:30mediating the unpredictable board meeting.
- 42:33You do not want to be the isolated coder or the routine
- 42:36bookkeeper because the global market is relentlessly hunting
- 42:39for routine tasks to offshore. It's about recognizing that the
- 42:43economic maps we were handed in the 1990s simply do not describe
- 42:47the treacherous territory of the twenty 20s.
- 42:49Which leaves us with a final lingering thought to Mull over.
- 42:53We spent the last hour proving that national governments and
- 42:56macro economists are still basing massive life altering
- 42:59policies on outdated ideas of job titles and degrees.
- 43:02Meanwhile, the actual ground level market is treating in
- 43:04granular tasks and demanding immense localized adaptability.
- 43:08The structural mismatch is staggering.
- 43:11So the question is if the entire global economy has secretly
- 43:14shifted to a matrix of routine versus non routine and
- 43:17interactive versus non interactive.
- 43:20Are our entire education systems, from elementary schools
- 43:23right up through universities, preparing us for an economy that
- 43:26doesn't actually exist anymore? Are we spending decades and
- 43:30taking on massive student debt to train our children for a map
- 43:34that has already been burned? It's a profound structural
- 43:37failure we have yet to fully reckon with as a society.
- 43:40Something for you to think about the next time you update your
- 43:43resume, or the next time you tell someone what you do for a
- 43:45living. Because what you do and the
- 43:47title you hold might be two entirely different things.
- 43:50Thanks for joining us on The Deep Dive.
- 43:52We'll see you next time.