Latest / Wisdom of the Ages Library / 06 - A Confession - Leo Tolstory
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter six of a confession by Leo Tolstoy. In my search for answers to
- 0:05life's questions, I experienced just what is felt by a man lost in a
- 0:08forest. He reaches a glade, climbs a tree, and clearly sees the
- 0:12limitless distance, but sees that his home is not and cannot be there.
- 0:16And he goes into the dark wood and sees darkness, But there also his
- 0:20home is not. So I wandered in that wood of human knowledge, amid
- 0:24the gleams of mathematical and experimental science, which showed me clear horizons, but
- 0:28in a direction where there could be no home, And also amid the darkness
- 0:32of abstract sciences, where I was immersed in a deeper gloom. The further
- 0:36I went, and where I finally convinced myself that there was and could be
- 0:39no exit, yielding myself to the bright side of knowledge, I understood that
- 0:43I was only diverting my gaze from the question, however alluringly clear those horizons
- 0:48which opened before me might be, however alluring it might be to immerse oneself
- 0:52in the limitless expanse of those sciences. I also understood that the clearer they
- 0:56were the less they meant my need, and the less they applied to my
- 0:59question. I know, I said to myself, what science so persistently tries
- 1:03to discover? And along that road there is no reply to the question as
- 1:07to the meaning of my life? In the abstract sphere, I understood that,
- 1:11notwithstanding the fact, or just because of the fact, that the direct
- 1:14aim of science is to reply to my question, there is no reply but
- 1:18that which I myself had been given. What is the meaning of my life?
- 1:21There is none? Or what will come of my life? Nothing?
- 1:23Or why does everything exist that exists? And why do I exist? Because
- 1:29it exists? Inquiring for one region of human knowledge, I received an innumerable
- 1:34quantity of exact replies concerning matters about which I had not asked, About the
- 1:38chemical constituents of the stars, about the movements of the Sun towards the constellation
- 1:42hercules, about the origin of species and of man, about the forms of
- 1:46infinitely minute, imponderable particles of ether. But in this sphere of knowledge,
- 1:49the only answer to my question what is the meaning of my life? Was
- 1:53you are what you call your life. You are a transitory, casual cohesion
- 1:57of particles, the mutual interactions and changes of these particles produce in you what
- 2:02you call your life. That cohesion will last some time. Afterwards, the
- 2:07interaction of these particles will cease, and what you call life will cease,
- 2:09and so will all your questions. You are an accidentally united little lump of
- 2:14something. That little lump ferments. The little lump calls that fermenting its life.
- 2:19The lump will disintegrate, and there will be an end to the fermenting
- 2:22and of all the questions. So answers the queer side of science, and
- 2:25cannot answer otherwise if it strictly follows its principles. From such a reply,
- 2:30one sees that the reply does not answer the question I want to know the
- 2:34meaning of my life, but that it is a fragment of the infinite,
- 2:37far from giving a meaning, destroys every possible meaning. The obscure compromises which
- 2:42that side of the experimental, exact science makes with the abstract science when it
- 2:46says that the meaning of life consists in development and cooperation with development, owing
- 2:50to their inexactness and obscurity, cannot be considered as replies the other side of
- 2:54science, the abstract side, when it holds strictly to its principles, replying
- 2:59directly to the question, and in all ages has replied in one in the
- 3:02same way, the world is something infinite, an incomprehensible part of that incomprehensible.
- 3:07All again, I exclude all those compromises between abstract and experimental sciences,
- 3:14which supply the whole ballast of the semi science is called judicial, political,
- 3:17and historical. In those semi sciences, the conception of development and progress is
- 3:23again wrongly introduced, only with this difference, that there it was the development
- 3:27of everything, while here it is a development of the life of mankind.
- 3:30The error is there, as before, development and progress in infinity can have
- 3:36no aim or direction, and as far as my question is concerned, no
- 3:38answer is given in truly abstract science, namely in genuine philosophy, not that
- 3:45which Sopenhauer calls professional philosophy, which serves only to classify all existing phenomena in
- 3:51new philosophic categories and to call them by new names. Where the philosopher does
- 3:54not lose sight of the essential question, the reply is always one and the
- 3:59same reply given by Socrates, Schopenhauer, Solomon, and Buddha. We approach
- 4:03truth only inasmuch as we depart from life, said Socrates, when preparing for
- 4:08death. For what do we who love truth strive after in life? To
- 4:12free ourselves from the body and from all evil that is caused by life of
- 4:15the body. If so, then how can we fail to be glad when
- 4:18death comes to us? The wise man seeks death all his life, and
- 4:21therefore death is not terrible to him. And Schopenhauer says, having recognized the
- 4:27innermost essence of the world as will, and all its phenomena, from the
- 4:30unconscious working of the obscure forces of nature up to the completely conscious action of
- 4:35man, as only the objectivity of the will, we shall in no way
- 4:39avoid the conclusion that, together with voluntary renunciation and self destruction of the will,
- 4:44all those phenomena also disappear. That constance striving an effort without aim or
- 4:48rest on all the stages of objectivity and which and through which the world exists,
- 4:54the diversity of successive forms will disappear, and together with the form,
- 4:58all the manifestations of the will, with its most universal forms space and time,
- 5:01and finally, the most fundamental form subject an object. Without will,
- 5:06there is no concept in no world before us certainly nothing remains. But what
- 5:12resists this transition into annihilation our nature is only the same wish to live will
- 5:16zumleebum, which forms ourselves as well as our world. That we are so
- 5:20afraid of annihilation, or what is the same thing that we so wish to
- 5:25live merely means that we are ourselves nothing but this desire to live, and
- 5:29know nothing but it. And so what remains after the complete annihilation of the
- 5:32will, For us, who are so full of the will, is of
- 5:34course nothing. But on the other hand, for those in whom the will
- 5:39has turned and renounced itself, this so real world of ours, with all
- 5:43its sons and milky way, is nothing vanity of vanities, says Solomon.
- 5:47Vanity of vanities, all is vanity? What profit hath a man of all
- 5:51his labor which he taketh under the sun? One generation patheth away, and
- 5:57another generation cometh, But the earth abideth forever. The thing that hath been
- 6:01is that which shall be, And that which is done is that which shall
- 6:04be done. And there is no new thing under the sun is there anything
- 6:09aware of it? May be said, see this is new It hath been
- 6:12already of old time which was before us. There is no remembrance of former
- 6:15things. Neither shall there be any remembrance of things that are to come with
- 6:19those that shall come after. I the Preacher, was king over Israel and
- 6:24Jerusalem, and I gave my heart to seek and search out by wisdom concerning
- 6:28all that is done under heaven. This sword travail hath God given to the
- 6:31sons of man, to be exercised therewith. I have seen all the works
- 6:35that are done under the sun, and behold, all is vanity and vexation
- 6:40of spirit. I communed with my own heart, saying, Lo, I
- 6:44am come to great a state and have gotten more wisdom than all they that
- 6:46have been before me over Jerusalem. Yea, my heart hath great experience of
- 6:50wisdom and knowledge. And I gave my heart to know wisdom and to know
- 6:55madness and folly. I perceive that this also is vexation of spirit. For
- 6:59in much wisdom is much grief. And he that increaseth knowledge increases sorrow.
- 7:03I said in my heart, go to now, I will provide thee with
- 7:06mirth, and therefore enjoy pleasure. And behold, this also is vanity.
- 7:12I said, of laughter, it is mad and of mirth, what doeth
- 7:15it? I sought in my heart how to cheer my flesh with wine,
- 7:17And while my heart was guided by wisdom, to lay hold on folly till
- 7:21I might see what it was good for the sons of men that they should
- 7:25do under heaven the number of days of their life. I made me great
- 7:28works. I built me houses. I planted me vineyards. I made me
- 7:31gardens and orchards, and I planted trees in them, of all kinds of
- 7:34fruits. I made me pools of water to water there from the forest where
- 7:39trees were reared. I got me servants and maidens, and had servants born
- 7:43in my house. Also I had great possessions of herds and flocks, above
- 7:46all that were before me in Jerusalem. I gathered me also silver and gold,
- 7:49and the peculiar treasure from kings and from the provinces. I got me
- 7:54men singer and women singers, and the delights of the sons of men as
- 7:58musical instruments, and all that of all sorts. So I was great and
- 8:01increased more than all that were before me in Jerusalem. Also my wisdom remained
- 8:05with me, and whatever mine eyes desired, I kept not from them,
- 8:09I withheld not my heart from any joy. Then I looked on all the
- 8:11works my hands had wrought, on the labor that I had labored to do,
- 8:16and behold, all was vanity and vexation of spirit, and there was
- 8:18no profit from them under the sun. And I turned myself to behold wisdom
- 8:22and madness and folly. But I perceived that one might even happeneth to them.
- 8:26All, then said I in my heart, as it happeneth to the
- 8:30fool, so it happeneth even to me. And why was I then?
- 8:31More wise? Then I said in my heart that this is also vanity,
- 8:35for there is no remembrance of the wise more than of the fool forever,
- 8:39seeing that which is in the days to come shall be all forgotten. And
- 8:43how dieth the wise man as the fool. Therefore I hated life, because
- 8:46the work that is wrought under the sun is grievous unto me, for all
- 8:50was vanity and vexation of spirit. Yea, I hated all my labor which
- 8:52I had taken under the sun, seeing that I must leave it unto the
- 8:56man that shall be after me. For what hath man of all his life
- 9:00labor and of the vexation of his heart, wherein he hath labored under the
- 9:03sun. For all his days are sorrows, and his travail grief. Yea,
- 9:07Even in the night his heart taketh no rest. This is also vanity.
- 9:11Man is not blessed with security that he should eat and drink and cheer
- 9:13his soul from his own labor. All things come alike to all. There
- 9:18is one event, to the righteous and to the wicked, to the good
- 9:20and to the evil, to the clean and to the unclean. To him
- 9:24that sacrificeth in him that sacrificeth not as is the good, so is the
- 9:28sinner, and he that sweareth, as he that feareth an oath. This
- 9:31is an evil in all that is done under the sun. That there is
- 9:35one event unto all. Yea. Also the heart of the sons of men
- 9:37is full of evil, and madness is in their heart while they live,
- 9:41and after that they go to the dead. For him that is among the
- 9:45living, there is hope. For a living dog is better than a dead
- 9:46lion. For the living know that they shall die. But the dead know
- 9:50not anything. Neither have they any more a reward. For the memory of
- 9:54them is forgotten. Also their love and their hatred, and their envy is
- 9:58now perished. Neither have they any more apportion forever than anything that is done
- 10:01under the sun. So said Solomon, or whoever wrote those words. And
- 10:07this is what the Indian wisdom tells. Sakyamuni, a young, happy prince
- 10:11from whom the existence of sickness, old age, and death had been hidden,
- 10:13went out to drive and saw a terrible old man, toothless and slobbering.
- 10:18The prince, from whom till then old age had been concealed, was
- 10:20amazed and asked his driver what it was, and how the man had come
- 10:24to such a wretched and disgusting condition. And when he learned that this was
- 10:28the common fate of all men, that the same thing inevitably awaited him,
- 10:31the young prince he could not continue his drive, but gave orders to go
- 10:35home that he might consider this fact. So he shut himself up alone and
- 10:39considered it, and he probably devised some consolation for himself, for he subsequently
- 10:43again went out to drive, feeling merry and happy, But this time he
- 10:46saw a sick man. He saw an emaciated, livid, trembling man with
- 10:50dim eyes. The prince from whom sickness had been concealed, stopped and asked
- 10:54what this was. And when he learned that this was sickness to which all
- 10:58men are liable, and that he, himself, a healthy and happy prince,
- 11:01might himself fall ill tomorrow, he again was in no mood to enjoy
- 11:05himself, but gave orders to drive home, and again sought some solace,
- 11:09and probably found it, for he drove out a third time for pleasure.
- 11:11But this third time he saw another new sight. He saw men carrying something.
- 11:16What is that? A dead man? What does dead mean? Asked
- 11:18the prince. He was told that to become dead means to become like that
- 11:22man. The Prince approached the corpse, uncovered it, and looked at it.
- 11:26What will happen to him now, asked the prince. He was told
- 11:30that the corpse would be buried in the ground. Why because he will certainly
- 11:33not return to life and will only produce a stench in worms? And is
- 11:37that the fate of all men? Will the same thing happen to me?
- 11:39Will they bury me? Shall I cause a stench and be eaten by worms?
- 11:43Yes? Home, I shall not drive out for pleasure, and never
- 11:46will drive again. And Sakia Mouni could find no consolation in life, and
- 11:52decided that life is the greatest of evils, and he devoted all the strength
- 11:56of his soul to free himself from it, and to free others, and
- 11:58to do so that even after death, life shall not be renewed any more,
- 12:03but be completely destroyed at its very roots. So speaks all the wisdoms
- 12:05of India. These are the direct replies that human wisdom gives when it replies
- 12:11to life's question. The life of the body is an evil and a lie.
- 12:15Therefore the destruction of the life of the body is a blessing, and
- 12:18we should desire it, says Socrates. Life is that which should not be
- 12:22an evil, and the passage into nothingness is the only good in life.
- 12:24Says Schopenhauer. All that is in the world, folly and wisdom and riches
- 12:28and poverty and mirth and grief, is vanity and emptiness. Man dies and
- 12:33nothing is left of him, and that is stupid, says Solomon. To
- 12:37live in the consciousness of the inevitability of suffering, of becoming enfeebled, of
- 12:41old age, and of death is impossible. We must free ourselves from life,
- 12:45from all possible life, says Buddha. And what these strong minds said
- 12:50has been said in thought and felt by millions upon millions of people like them,
- 12:54and I had thought and felt it. So my wandering among the sciences,
- 12:56far from freeing me from my despair, only strengthened it. One kind
- 13:01of knowledge did not reply to life's question. The other kind replied directly confirming
- 13:05my despair, indicating not the result at which I had arrived was the fruit
- 13:09of an error or of a disease state of my mind, but on the
- 13:11contrary, that I had thought correctly, and that my mind coincided with the
- 13:15conclusions of the most powerful of human minds. It is no good deceiving oneself.
- 13:20It is all vanity. Happy is he who has not been born?
- 13:22Death is better than life, and one must free oneself from life. End
- 13:28of Chapter six