Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Dealership Deals Surge, VW Dealers Sue Scout, Ford Reinvents the Car Door
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It's Monday, March 9th. I think we had a spring, a little bit of a spring. It's Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Dale. It's Kyle Mats here.
- 0:08Today we're talking about dealer buy sales, VW dealers suing Scout and Ford, reinventing the car door- The people really want love... or at least how the car door functions.
- 0:17Don't, don't get too excited on that spring, okay? That's a big- Next week, March is gonna mess with us. March is a liar. I tell everybody that. March is gonna be a liar next week. March... Oh, for sure, March is a liar.
- 0:25But no one cares about that. Unbelievable. You don't care that the other person is a liar when they're doing the nice things, right? [laughs] You're just like, "You know what? Maybe they've changed."
- 0:35You're beautiful outside. Maybe they- [laughs] Maybe March has changed. Maybe it's turned over a new leaf. March has changed. [laughs] Yeah. Maybe, maybe it'll be different this time. Classic.
- 0:42I feel bad for, uh, all, all, like, everybody that's on spring break this week, which I don't know when your spring break is. We start running spring break way early down here in the south. Yeah.
- 0:51So we got, like, half the crew on spring break this week, half next week. 'Cause it feels like spring. Yeah. Everybody this week- [laughs]... is like, "We're good." Next week everybody's gonna be like, "Really?
- 0:59This week?" Yeah. "The one where you decided to make the whole country cold?" Yeah, I know. It's wild. Well, I mean, if you're up here you go south. I mean, even... I don't know. I don't know.
- 1:08I don't even know when spring break is. [laughs] 'Cause now, like, I have- You homeschool your- We home... Number one, we homeschool. Number two, now I have, like...
- 1:14We, we usually follow, like, the local school calendar as much as possible. Yeah. But now my 16-year-old's taking college courses, and they have different spring break weeks. You're all upside down. Uh, totally.
- 1:23I guarantee straight up. Totally. It's been an amazing weekend. Um, it's been an amazing season so far. [laughs] Two One and Automotive is really, like, tackling stuff- I'm ready... taking care of stuff.
- 1:31I, I think everybody's ready. I'm so ready. Everybody's... We're, we're ready as a group. Um, we wanna- We came, we came running off that NADA just hot. Let's go. Yes. Yeah.
- 1:40Speaking of people who are ready, we wanna thank our sponsors, iPacket, for, uh, sponsoring the show today. If your value conversation doesn't begin with factory build data, what are we even doing here?
- 1:50[laughs] Uh, iPacket Value builds, uh, every appraisal from 100% OEM-verified factory build data, real options, real packages, and the actual window sticker.
- 2:00And then you tailor the comp sense by CPO, model, year, and geography so the value reflects your market, not just the "internet," air quotes. Uh, it's clean and defensible and it moves the deal forward.
- 2:11They say start with build data, finish with confidence. You can check out- Yes... iPacket.us to learn more. That's iPacket.us. Thanks to our partners over there. St- Go, go figure. Start with the actual data.
- 2:24Start with the data. The data you know is true. Oh, you and I had, like- Some good ideas on this one. Yeah. I still... We're still gonna pitch iPacket. We're gonna pitch you an idea- Well, well, look-...
- 2:33if you happen to listen to this show... but also on data this weekend, you and I- Oh, yeah, we... Oh, gosh... we got sideways.
- 2:37We could probably spend a whole show on it, but we don't wanna talk about it too early- For sure... because we're still formulating our thoughts. But I think that, uh,
- 2:44that knowledge graph, like, just if, if you wanna understand, just knowledge graph are the words. Start thinking about that. Yeah. [laughs] Yeah.
- 2:52Uh, we're gonna be thinking about that a lot at our upcoming AutoIndustry.ai summit on May 12th, the day before ASOTU Con. Um, you should be there.
- 3:00This is gonna be people who are thinking about knowledge graphs and things like that.
- 3:04Uh, some of the most cutting-edge practitioners and the people who are just realizing they need to go a little bit more in on AI, we're getting together on May 12th.
- 3:12You can go to summit.autoindustry.ai, summit.autoindustry.ai, and, uh, you can join us. It is a very inexpensive event. If you're going to ASOTU Con already, it's only gonna cost you another 20 bucks. You can be there.
- 3:26We have some great keynotes we're gonna announce soon, probably this week. And, uh, again, being in the room with the other people that are thinking, like, iron can sharpen iron. You can learn a lot.
- 3:35It's a working summit, so bring your laptop, get ready to go. Get ready. News time? That's it. News time. Yeah, I think so. That's it. It's a news time? It's news time. News time.
- 3:44[laughs] The dealership buy/sell market closed 2025 strong. The transaction count only ticked up slightly to 112, but the stores and franchises behind those deals hit some multi-year highs. Oof.
- 3:55A delayed release from a slower first half shaped by tariff uncertainty, um, and also the longer deal timelines. We scooped a bunch of those up the end of year. Great auto- automotive news story on this today.
- 4:06Dealerships trading hands jumped 19% to 163, while franchises involved went up a lot more, 35%. It went up to 261 year-over-year.
- 4:18Stellantis led all brands with 25 CDJR stores changing hands, more than double what happened in Q4 of 2024. Wow.
- 4:25Chevy came in second with 24 source- store sold, driven by what Kerrigan Advisors calls, quote, "The tremendous demand tied to GM's domestic manufacturing position and relatively clean EV writedowns." That's a key one.
- 4:39It is. Hudson Automotive Group was the top buyer with 12 Louisiana stores acquired from All Star Automotive. Lithia was second with six purchases. This is an interesting one.
- 4:49California recorded the most transactions with 24 dealerships changing hands, driven by strong throughput, but also regulatory complexity.
- 4:57Haig Partners President Alec Ha- Alan Haig said, "Major retailers began investing in California again once the emissions uncertainty was removed." That's a big deal.
- 5:08Uh, looking at California, there's a lot more stability out there, uh, with, with the emissions questions not there. Uh, here's, here's the story to me.
- 5:16Transactions up only a bit to 112, but number of dealerships trading hands, 163. Franchises involved up 35%, 261.
- 5:27That means, to me, what I'm hearing, is that the consolidation is not just meeting the purchase behavior but also the sales behavior. Sell- stores selling off two, three, four, five stores, right?
- 5:40Obviously we see Hudson and Lithia in at 12 and 6 stores, but, but that two to five store range is, is the fast sell-off.
- 5:49I, I actually, I remember very, very early on, I'm, I'm sure I could pull it up, but early on in my podcasting, I remember having a conversation with someone and saying anyone in the one to five dealership group d- uh, is going to have to make a decision over the next five years.
- 6:05And we're kind of at that five-year point, whether to buy or sell.Yeah And, and that's, that's gonna be the pathway and, and I think that that 112 to 261 number is, is that in practice. Yeah. Get bigger or get out. Poof.
- 6:20Speaking of getting bigger or getting out. Oh. Segway. [upbeat music] Oh. [laughs] Not quite. Listen, we're, we just preve- present the facts. We never give any commentary. It's just the news.
- 6:30We never, [laughs] never give any commentary on this show.
- 6:33A group of Volkswagen dealers have filed a class action lawsuit representing roughly 600 US dealers challenging Scout Motors' plan to sell vehicles directly to consumers.
- 6:41Volkswagen dealers arguing it's a violation of the franchise system since Scout is owned by VW Group. One New York dealer even bought land next to a store expecting a Scout showroom that never came.
- 6:53I, wow, that's, I mean- That's a bold move. That is bold. Now, who's promising him things? [laughs] That dealer, uh, Fred Ippolito, didn't hold back.
- 7:02He said, quote, "Volkswagen built their success on the backs of the dealer network, and now they're putting knives in the backs of the same dealers that helped them grow this in this country."
- 7:11Scout CEO Scott Keogh says the direct model is simply more efficient for modern automotive retail.
- 7:16He says, quote, "You can be dramatically more efficient with every single car that you make and exactly where that car goes."
- 7:23VP of Commercial Operations To- Cody Thacker said the company repeatedly hears customers asking for direct sales, noting, quote, "We have heard over and over again, 'Please give me an alternative.'
- 7:34You see that there is very little trust in auto dealers today." Oh. Uh, automotive dealer- Oh...
- 7:39advisor Dave Canton summed up the stakes saying, quote, "To have a wholesaler like VW support and back this direct-to-sale philosophy, um, that's what is creating the uproar." Look- [laughs] Spicy...
- 7:53everybody wants an alternative, and we still argue that an alternative o- is okay. Look at mattresses. We talked about this last week. We're gonna talk about it ad nauseam.
- 8:03Our only commentary on this is we believe that, that customers should be able to purchase the way that they want to, and there is a small segment of the market, it is very small still, that may wanna purchase in that way.
- 8:14But again, I think the VW dealers- They're right. Yeah... have it right. They should have the access to sell these at some hybrid level of model. And yeah, I mean, they, they built the brand.
- 8:23The, all the finances to make this thing came from dealers selling these vehicles. So I don't know what they're doing out there.
- 8:28It, it's, I, like, I, I see both sides of it, and that's why I believe that both sides should have a fighting chance at coming to the market.
- 8:36It would be an interest- like, again, we, we talked about the mattress thing where, you know, Casper and Purple and all these companies have mattresses inside
- 8:46mattress stores, and you can lay on them, try them, or you could buy it direct, and it would be really great to have a small Scout showroom, you know, that could be a part of VW- Well, and actually, you know-...
- 8:54so given the opportunity to sell it. However, I understand from Scout's position, they're so dialed in on brand, right? That they're like, "We don't wanna share the brand experience," so.
- 9:03Well, this is what I would love to see, and what I would love, uh, y- even those brands, Purple, Casper, they all came out fully direct to consumer to start, right? Mm-hmm.
- 9:12But then they realized over time, actually, they, they initially said, "We're not going into showrooms," but they realized that there was a buyer that they were missing, right?
- 9:20And so I think what would be really smart of Scout is say, "Hey, look, we're gonna go direct to consumer first because we know that our core buyer is looking for this purchase experience." The enthusiasts. Right.
- 9:30The, the enthusiast. Mm-hmm. The one, they're already in, and we can actually maintain a profitability line that will make it easier for us to support our dealers in the future, and we have...
- 9:40Like, that narrative would pencil so great to me. Um, and, and I think that the consumer would love that, too, right?
- 9:47Because there's going to be a consumer, that late adopter, that wants to see, drive, experience that vehicle alongside some of the other vehicles that they're looking at, and they're gonna wanna have that person interacting with them.
- 9:58So I just think that, that, that's gotta be the way.
- 10:00See, this would be like, this would be very similar to a scenario where you're, like, opening a car door and you're about to hit a pole, but then there's a little bit of something that happens that stops- Segway time...
- 10:10I mean. We could be that something. We could, we, I think we are that something right now. Won't be that something, uh, but Ford is trying to be that something, trying to save your car door and your neighbor's paint job.
- 10:20A newly surfaced patent reveals a smart door system designed to slow or stop a door before it hits nearby objects, combining sensors, software, and a mechanical brake.
- 10:31Ford's patented system is using accelerometers and obstacle sensors to detect how quickly a door is opening and whether something is in its path.
- 10:39If a collision is likely, a small mechanical brake with springs and pads engages to slow or stop the door, preventing those little dents, dings, or even worse.
- 10:48Uh, the design intentionally includes mechanical components to avoid the reliability issues sometimes seen with fully electronic systems.
- 10:55Door safety is getting more attention across the country as Kia recalled 51,000 Carnival minivans after sliding doors continued closing on obstacles, causing several injuries. Oh, my goodness. I like this idea.
- 11:06I mean, everybody has had that, right? The, how about even if the wind picks it up? Does it go the other way, too? Oh, right. Right? Yeah. Come in so, flying in. Like, just a velocity sensor.
- 11:15[laughs] I think that's probably done as e- I mean, like, this is a fun, a fun little thing. I think it's a, a common problem. Whenever you can come up with a solution to a very common problem.
- 11:23Um, but you know, flip side. Here, here's one more thing- It's wild. It-... that can break... and what happens when it breaks. [laughs] Right.
- 11:31Well, and, and my other thing is, like, I, uh, I don't know if your car has, like, the, the smart braking sensor on, like, slower roads where it's like- Yeah... brake, and then it slams the brakes. Yeah. Right?
- 11:42It does, actually. And you're like, "No, I'm watching that person turn. They're gonna be out of the way." Yeah. "You didn't need to slam the brakes right there." Yeah.
- 11:50That's, like, my one- It scares the crap out of everybody... like, human intuition thing. Yeah. You know? So I don't know. I know.
- 11:54But hey, look, if my kids don't have any door dings from now in the future, I mean, that's why we have a van, because, dink. Yeah. [laughs] You know? Exactly. All right.
- 12:03We hope you're ready for this Monday the way we are. We're so thankful that you're here. And listen, we want you to be with us in person at ASOTU CON.
- 12:10You should go to asotucon.com, check out the event, and we hope you'll get a ticket today.
- 12:19[upbeat music]