Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / Borrowing With Intention: The Human Side of Leverage with Walt Postlewait, Co-Founder of Portfolio Watch
Transcript
- 0:00Do you borrow money because it's convenient?
- 0:01Or do you borrow because it's helping you reach
- 0:03a goal? There's a saying in finance, consumer
- 0:06debt destroys wealth, but strategic debt builds
- 0:09it. If we're taught anything at all, it's to
- 0:11fear debt and that being debt -free is the ultimate
- 0:13goal. And for the consumer, that's true. But
- 0:16if you look at the balance sheets of the wealthiest
- 0:18people and the largest companies, you won't find
- 0:20zero debt. You'll find leverage. Today on Escape
- 0:24the Clock, I'm speaking with a professional lender
- 0:26who has deployed over $600 million in commercial
- 0:29funding, He has sat on the other side of the
- 0:31desk deciding who gets the money to build their
- 0:33dream and who gets a rejection letter. We're
- 0:35going to break down the banker's blueprint on
- 0:37what is good debt, how to use leverage to accelerate
- 0:40the ways to freedom, and how to identify a bankable
- 0:42asset. Stay tuned to learn how to stop looking
- 0:45at debt like a consumer and start looking at
- 0:47it like a capitalist. Welcome back to Escape
- 1:09the Clock, the show where we discuss strategies
- 1:11for achieving financial freedom and having the
- 1:13option not to work. I'm your host, Daniel C.
- 1:16Rogers. In the personal finance world, we're
- 1:18often told to play defense, cut coupons, stop
- 1:22buying lattes, and pay off all debt. But if you
- 1:25look at the Federal Reserve's data, business
- 1:27owners have a media net worth nearly nine times
- 1:30higher than wage earners, 1 .3 million versus
- 1:33155 ,000. Why is that? Well, it's not because
- 1:37they skip more lattes, but because of leverage.
- 1:40In the project management world, we would use
- 1:42leverage to get more done with fewer resources.
- 1:45In the financial world, leverage works much the
- 1:48same way. It amplifies your results. It can amplify
- 1:51your wealth. or it can amplify your bankruptcy.
- 1:54It's a double -edged sword. So how do you use
- 1:56this weapon without cutting off your hand? How
- 1:59do you shift from saver to capitalist? Well,
- 2:02my guest today has both experience and insights
- 2:04to navigate that very question. Walt Postlewaite.
- 2:08has spent over 20 years at the intersection of
- 2:11commercial lending and risk management. He's
- 2:13overseen the development of over $600 million
- 2:15in funding to small businesses and real estate
- 2:17projects. He is currently the co -founder of
- 2:20Portfolio Watch, helping banks identify risk
- 2:23before it happens. Walt, welcome to Escape the
- 2:25Clock. Thank you, Daniel. I'm excited to be here.
- 2:28I think we've got a great conversation coming
- 2:30up. Yeah, I'm really interested in this. I'm
- 2:33probably one of the listeners here because this
- 2:36isn't something I did as much with as I probably
- 2:38should have. I probably could have accelerated
- 2:40my plan much faster if I understood this topic
- 2:43better. So I'm really interested because you
- 2:46have such a unique vantage point from all the
- 2:48decades you've spent approving loans as a banker,
- 2:50but also the borrowing money as an investor yourself.
- 2:54How did sitting on the lender's side of the table
- 2:57change the way you structure your own deals when
- 2:59it came to borrowing yourself? It gave me a lot
- 3:02of in -house knowledge. In banking and in finance,
- 3:06there's a lot of jargon. There's a lot of just
- 3:08kind of untold rules that are played by. This
- 3:12is why the people who have been borrowers and
- 3:16investors for a period of time get better and
- 3:19better at it, because they don't teach this stuff
- 3:21in school. They just don't. And like you said,
- 3:24the messaging out there is save money, work hard,
- 3:27and eventually you will be able to get ahead.
- 3:30And we talk with our kids quite often about finances
- 3:32and my son will be very quick to point out that
- 3:35strategy save work hard, get ahead. That might
- 3:39have worked in the 50s and 60s, but the new paradigm,
- 3:42that doesn't work. And so with the lending, the
- 3:45more you do it, the better you get. And for me,
- 3:49for my household, especially, and we'll talk
- 3:52more about the apartment complex we pulled off,
- 3:54that was creative financing through and through,
- 3:58leveraging limited capital, leveraging relationships,
- 4:02and leveraging kind of a unique situation. But
- 4:07as we'll talk about, it got uprooted by global
- 4:09events that unfortunately nobody can really control.
- 4:13And there's always luck involved. Absolutely.
- 4:16Yeah. I'm actually excited to talk to you about
- 4:18that because you've been through the stress test
- 4:20that so many of us think about when it comes
- 4:23to things like this. Cause you know, it's risky
- 4:25to think about borrowing and you need that leverage,
- 4:27but the more you borrow, the more nervous you
- 4:30can be about that. And the more risk you got
- 4:31to think about. I'm really curious though, since
- 4:34you were the one deciding who was getting approved
- 4:36or rejected. When a regular investor would bring
- 4:41a deal to the table, be it real estate or even
- 4:44just a business acquisition or whatever it was,
- 4:46what specifically separated the top 10 % of the
- 4:49people who you would say yes to versus all the
- 4:52rest who wouldn't get it? I would say kind of
- 4:56character is first and foremost. I spoke, you
- 5:00know, through my career, which spans over 30
- 5:02years now, so I'm dating myself, but I can remember
- 5:05having conversations with people who were flying
- 5:08by the seat of their pants. They might have a
- 5:11business plan. but it was not really well thought
- 5:15out to the other extreme where you have somebody
- 5:20who has a 50 page business plan whole bunch of
- 5:23fancy graphs all kinds of data but the sweet
- 5:27spot i found was actually somewhere in between
- 5:29those that had no plan and those that overachieved
- 5:34on the plan i would say i kind of put them in
- 5:36the same bucket where what i would try to assess
- 5:40was that person's acumen to actually pull off
- 5:44the plan and you know life happens so whatever
- 5:47your business plan is you have to know that it's
- 5:50not going to be exact there's going to be headwinds
- 5:53some things will work some things won't and so
- 5:56i would i would say character is really that
- 5:59driver how can that business owner articulate
- 6:02why i should believe when things go wrong that
- 6:07they're still going to be at the table and they
- 6:10have a greater vested interest in the success
- 6:14than i do because the reality is when you take
- 6:17on debt especially for a business enterprise
- 6:20the lender truly is taking on more financial
- 6:23risk because that's what leverage is while at
- 6:27the same time looking at a smaller return so
- 6:29it's kind of this inverted risk reward where
- 6:34the lender is taking on the majority of the risk
- 6:36but if the lender is charging seven eight ten
- 6:39percent well you're doing it because you want
- 6:42to make 25 50 and so you get to really connect
- 6:46with that lender and first and foremost daniel
- 6:48what i'll say is anybody in the audience who
- 6:51is either engaged in a business or wants to do
- 6:55some business, you've got to start by building
- 6:58a relationship with the lender. And I'm a big
- 7:00fan of community banks. I think smaller banks
- 7:03are far better for most people than the big national
- 7:07banks or the super regionals. Those institutions
- 7:10play a role in the financial scheme. But for
- 7:13most people, I really think it's the community
- 7:16banks. Credit unions are now able to do business
- 7:20lending, but they're still... kind of on a learning
- 7:22curve. And then there's another whole industry
- 7:25out there called Community Development Financial
- 7:28Institutions, CDFIs. And those are really good
- 7:34for business entrepreneurs. who aren't yet bankable
- 7:39because a CDFI's goal is to get you capital and
- 7:43then get you to a point where you can go into
- 7:45the traditional banks. But you've got to start
- 7:47before you're asking for money. And it can be
- 7:50as simple as knowing who your local banker is.
- 7:53take them out to coffee and pick their brain.
- 7:55They are always prospecting. If you can have
- 7:58a conversation and share your ideas, get some
- 8:02feedback from them. And then whether it's three
- 8:04months, six months, 12 months down the road,
- 8:06and now you're looking for some debt capital,
- 8:10you actually have somebody to talk to. And that
- 8:12person already knows kind of where you're going.
- 8:15So to me, that's first and foremost. Yeah, that
- 8:18makes a lot of sense. We had a... David Webb
- 8:20on the show a little while ago, the author of
- 8:23No Money Millionaire. And he was talking about
- 8:25how he had nothing he could even use for collateral
- 8:30when he was starting out. He was looking to use
- 8:33other people's money for leverage to start to
- 8:36invest into different properties. And the relationship
- 8:39part that you just talked about was so critical.
- 8:41But also the other thing you touched on earlier,
- 8:44which is having that kind of grit to just see
- 8:46it through. So it's really interesting to hear,
- 8:49like on the other side of the table, that's something
- 8:50that comes across. It needs to be there. Without
- 8:54that, it's almost like you're not going to get
- 8:56off the ground. Is there any specific red flags
- 9:00or anything that you would look for, though,
- 9:02in the deal that you would be like, OK, maybe
- 9:04it's credit score or something else? You're like,
- 9:05we can't even consider this. It's just too risky.
- 9:09Absolutely. And I would say that the kind of
- 9:11the generic ones are, you know, credit score.
- 9:15I'm not a big fan of a three -digit number. I've
- 9:17seen credit scores manipulated. I've seen somebody
- 9:21who had a bankruptcy two years prior do all the
- 9:25things right and drive their credit score higher
- 9:28than a multimillionaire who had 24 different
- 9:31properties. Just because they've got a lot of
- 9:34debt, because they've got a lot of assets, their
- 9:36credit score was actually lower than the two
- 9:39-year -old BK. Not a big fan of the credit scores,
- 9:42but the reality is credit scores do drive the
- 9:44bus. The other aspect is capital is still important.
- 9:48You got to have skin in the game. And normally
- 9:52I would say you should at least plan on at least
- 9:555 % of your cash or collateral or something at
- 10:00stake. You can always try other people's money.
- 10:04today i think that's harder than it was before
- 10:06not because the other people money is harder
- 10:09to attract because with the sideways stock market
- 10:13and assets varying in value frankly i think there
- 10:16is capital sitting out there that wants to help
- 10:19young entrepreneurs but the credit goes in cycles
- 10:21and right now it's pretty conservative but where
- 10:24i think the unknown red flag is just the accountability
- 10:30if i'm a typical lender i'm talking to four to
- 10:34ten businesses at any one time the businesses
- 10:37i'm going to work with are those that are engaged
- 10:40they return my phone call when i ask for another
- 10:43document or some information that is missing
- 10:46they get it back to me quickly the borrower is
- 10:49going to be most engaged in the credit activity
- 10:53when that prospective borrower is seeking money
- 10:56if a lender reaches out and it takes a week for
- 11:00you to call them back you go to the bottom of
- 11:03the pile because they know that down the road
- 11:06after the loan is made and you're gonna have
- 11:08to supply financial statements you're gonna have
- 11:11to provide information when things go bad the
- 11:13bank wants you to get engaged if you're not really
- 11:16engaged up front we know you will not be engaged
- 11:19at the back end and so to me that is the hidden
- 11:23red flag that most people don't understand and
- 11:28you know business owners are always busy You
- 11:30know, you wear a lot of hats, but you've got
- 11:33to take care of your most important relationships.
- 11:36And typically that is an around capital. You
- 11:39know, it dawned on me. You touched on pretty
- 11:42much all the five C's already of credit, character,
- 11:45capacity, capital, collateral, and conditions.
- 11:47And I am curious, I want to ask you about personal
- 11:49guarantees when it comes to collateral for a
- 11:52moment. I know a lot of people are really nervous
- 11:54about the idea of signing a personal guarantee.
- 11:56Is it possible in your experience to get leverage
- 11:59without betting some, like the house on it? How
- 12:02much would we be afraid of that? you're not going
- 12:05to like the answer your audience isn't going
- 12:07to like the answer for those starting out those
- 12:11that have the least amount of firepower the personal
- 12:15guarantees are going to be sought after more
- 12:17where you start seeing non -recourse loans. That's
- 12:19what we call it when there's no personal guarantee.
- 12:21There's no recourse back to you, the business
- 12:24owner. That tends to be on the larger loans,
- 12:26underwritten some loans here recently that are
- 12:29in the 25 million kind of range where they get
- 12:32structured, where there is no personal guarantor
- 12:34because there's a few different business entities
- 12:37that are involved. And so from a check the box
- 12:40kind of standpoint, there are corporate guarantees,
- 12:43but there's really no assets there. this kind
- 12:46of weird thing where the deeper your personal
- 12:49financial statement is the more likely you can
- 12:51get away from a personal guarantee even though
- 12:54your personal guarantee means a lot more and
- 12:57so i've always explained it to my clients as
- 12:59the personal guarantee is important because like
- 13:02i said we know that things are going to happen
- 13:05so if things start to go sideways we need to
- 13:08make sure that you will be at the table we're
- 13:12not going to necessarily take your house we're
- 13:14not going to you know do those things and frankly
- 13:16there's ways to play defense you know with different
- 13:19types of bankruptcies to protect that but that
- 13:22personal guarantee means that again i've got
- 13:25more financial risk than you have financial risk
- 13:28mr borrower so if the project goes sideways you
- 13:33need to be at that table so we can have a conversation
- 13:35because if i'm going to solve that problem i
- 13:37can tell you what i'm going to do i'm going to
- 13:39close the business i'm going to liquidate assets
- 13:41if you're interested in solving the the problem
- 13:44you have a lot more knobs to turn and levers
- 13:48to pull than i do so we need to make sure that
- 13:51individual the person who's making the decisions
- 13:53are at the table so you can ask try to get around
- 13:57a personal guarantee if you've got some other
- 14:00people's money coming in you can sometimes get
- 14:02a limited guarantee from them but i think the
- 14:06honest expectation is you're probably going to
- 14:08have to have that that personal guarantee that's
- 14:11really helpful and i think that it keeps coming
- 14:13back to relationships i think when i'm hearing
- 14:15this like you have to be able to build that relationship
- 14:18and that trust and work together like a partner
- 14:20trust is really important and frankly relationship
- 14:24is an overplayed word these days but it is just
- 14:28really important because money is money and from
- 14:31the the lender aspect and As a lay person, my
- 14:36clients don't really understand this, but if
- 14:38I do a loan and things don't go well, we have
- 14:42to default the loan, we liquidate collateral,
- 14:45and we go through that charge -off process. If
- 14:47I have to charge off $100 ,000, that is an actual
- 14:51real money loss to my organization. I have to
- 14:55go out and lend usually 10 times that amount
- 14:58to try to make it up on the loan fee or earned
- 15:01interest. If a lender loses on a credit, it takes
- 15:05a lot of effort to backfill what was lost. So
- 15:08that's why it's so important. And that's why
- 15:10lenders do say no, because of that credit risk.
- 15:14And it's so difficult to make it up on the backside.
- 15:17I want to get into the meat of it now a bit,
- 15:20which is most people, when they're going to think
- 15:22about borrowing, they're probably thinking about
- 15:25consumer debt, right? Like how am I going to
- 15:27borrow to buy the boat? But what we're talking
- 15:29about here is strategic leverage, borrowing with
- 15:32intention and part of your plan so that you could
- 15:35maybe buy a business, develop passive income.
- 15:38You could do something part of your freedom plan.
- 15:40And either from your perspective as someone playing
- 15:43that role and using that mindset shift, or imagine
- 15:46you're coaching somebody who's only ever really
- 15:49worked with consumer debt and is now interested
- 15:51to do strategic leverage well, how would you
- 15:55ideally want to see that go? Is there any kind
- 15:59of guardrails you think that someone needs to
- 16:00be put in place? How do I avoid bad debt and
- 16:03make sure what they're doing is on the good debt
- 16:05side? It's actually really easy in my opinion.
- 16:08I always tie it back to what is the debt related
- 16:11to, right? So you mentioned like a car loan.
- 16:14Actually, I think you said a boat loan, right?
- 16:16Right. and if the debt is related to a depreciating
- 16:21asset which means your asset is worth less tomorrow
- 16:25than it is today you probably shouldn't put a
- 16:29lot of debt on it i'm not saying that all consumer
- 16:31debt is bad i'm just saying that that's the bad
- 16:35kind of debt the credit card debt where it's
- 16:37not tied to any assets that's the worst right
- 16:40you know in the business world too i'd say the
- 16:42the utmost worst is the merchant service loans
- 16:46for a business that does a lot of credit card
- 16:49swipes. You can get a loan, you know, literally
- 16:52like an... two days or or tighter based on your
- 16:56swipes but you know they're taking out uh each
- 16:58that is a terrible debt cycle to get out of and
- 17:03the interest rates are really high and that's
- 17:05i would call that not bad debt but deadly debt
- 17:08i think once a business gets into that they're
- 17:10on a trajectory which is not favorable consumer
- 17:13debt where you are borrowing 80 90 percent of
- 17:18depreciating asset That's kind of bad debt. If
- 17:21a business is getting debt, you're doing something
- 17:25with that debt, right? If you're buying a business,
- 17:28you're buying a cash flow. That is how you buy
- 17:32a business and that's how you evaluate what that
- 17:34business is worth. And you're getting into that
- 17:37business for one of two reasons. One, you think
- 17:40that the price of that business meets the amount
- 17:44of money that is being produced and you're happy
- 17:47with that rate of return on that investment.
- 17:49perfectly okay. But most people are buying a
- 17:52business because they believe that the business
- 17:54is underperforming. That if I buy it for X, I
- 17:58put Y capital and Z time into it. my business
- 18:04will be more valuable because of these activities.
- 18:07And so these are assets that are increasing in
- 18:10value. You know, you could say real estate falls
- 18:12into this as well. Usually, whether it's a home,
- 18:16you know, a duplex or four blocks or commercial
- 18:19real estate or, you know, housing, multifamily
- 18:23housing, usually in most cycles, I used to say
- 18:26it always goes up, but I have, you know, experience
- 18:29has proven different. but usually those are assets
- 18:32that are increasing in value so leveraging debt
- 18:36there is okay there are cycles should you be
- 18:38in at 90 95 of leverage you know loan to value
- 18:43probably not because what i've seen both of my
- 18:47clients and frankly i experienced myself is when
- 18:51you leverage up that high typically you're using
- 18:55most of your earned income off of whether it's
- 19:00a real estate asset or a business asset you're
- 19:02kind of using up all your horsepower just to
- 19:05service the debt you know we've seen especially
- 19:08in the last five years and i would say for me
- 19:10over the last 30 years we have these cycles so
- 19:13your asset is a solid asset that will always
- 19:17have some value and it will always produce some
- 19:20amount of revenue But if today you go all the
- 19:24way up to the maximum leverage and now your income
- 19:27from that asset is like covering the debt plus
- 19:30a little bit more, what happens when there's
- 19:33a down cycle and now your revenue has dropped,
- 19:36the actual cash you do get from that asset drops
- 19:3915 %? Well, now it doesn't pay the loan anymore
- 19:43because that loan payment's probably going to
- 19:45be static. So now you're having to find money
- 19:47from other sources to put to service this debt.
- 19:51And now because the market changed and when you
- 19:53buy, this is why I like commercial real estate
- 19:56and commercial businesses far more than like
- 19:58a single family residence, which is much more
- 20:00emotionally driven. When you look at a business
- 20:03asset, whether real estate or a business, you
- 20:05truly are buying a stream of cash. So like I
- 20:09said, you bought here today, you leveraged all
- 20:12the way up, following your actual cash coming
- 20:15out of that asset has now decreased. That means
- 20:17that the value of that asset has actually decreased
- 20:20because now I'm having to feed it $1 ,000 a month
- 20:23on my own personal cash flow and I don't want
- 20:25to do that. So I look to sell it. Well, I bought
- 20:28it when it was producing this much cash on an
- 20:31annual basis. That cash flow has now dropped.
- 20:34The value of that asset has dropped. Yes, you
- 20:37can get into some kind of macroeconomics and
- 20:40interest rates may have gone down or changed.
- 20:42But fundamentally, you buy a commercial asset,
- 20:46a business asset for that stream of cash flow.
- 20:49So now you're having to feed that loan and your
- 20:52asset is not as valuable. So that's why I still
- 20:55think that don't want to. over leverage good
- 20:57debt all good things can come bad in overindulgence
- 21:01right and capital and debt is that well imagine
- 21:06for a moment i'm your client and i want to buy
- 21:09a laundromat i'm really interested in it i think
- 21:12it's a good investment and i might upgrade the
- 21:15machines and do a couple things right but i think
- 21:17it's going to have good cash flow especially
- 21:19pretty quickly i think it'll have a good turnaround
- 21:21how would you counsel me moving forward is there
- 21:24a certain debt to equity ratio i should be mindful
- 21:27of or interest rate i should be looking for and
- 21:30how should i be thinking about approaching it
- 21:32in a way where i'm not stressing myself out with
- 21:34just the borrowing part and i can because the
- 21:36business itself is going to have its own stress
- 21:39absolutely so with the banker hat on what i can
- 21:43tell you is let's look at the performa 90 % of
- 21:46the debt out there is cash flow lending. So where
- 21:50we start is, you know, you purchase this business,
- 21:53you know, you've seen what it does historically.
- 21:54The reason why you want to do new machines is
- 21:57because you think you can probably reduce the
- 21:59expenses. You're going away from quarters and
- 22:02you're using cards. So, you know, you can increase
- 22:05now your customers of your laundromat. So you
- 22:08kind of build out this future revenue. Hopefully
- 22:12you have built out what your expenses are and
- 22:15you know what your bottom line cash is going
- 22:18to be. You can have a conversation with your
- 22:20banker. You can get an idea of what that interest
- 22:24rate is going to be. And you can then kind of
- 22:26play around with my interest rate is going to
- 22:29be around, I'll say seven and a half percent.
- 22:32And I can. get since these are kind of hard assets
- 22:36you know between the real estate and the equipment
- 22:40i can do a 15 -year loan you now can't have enough
- 22:44information where you can build out some amortization
- 22:46schedules so you can look at this and say okay
- 22:49if i borrow a million dollars this is what my
- 22:52monthly my annual payment's going to be and this
- 22:55is how much i have left over At a minimum, you
- 22:58want to have net cash in your pocket of $1 .25
- 23:03for every dollar that you owe in a loan payment.
- 23:07And that's what's called a 1 .25 debt -to -service
- 23:10cover ratio. Very standard in lending. Some lenders
- 23:14might do 1 .20, so they want you to be making
- 23:18$1 .20 for every dollar. But with a laundromat,
- 23:21which tends to be very cyclical, I love laundromats.
- 23:26I really like mini storage. There's some low
- 23:29barrier of entry businesses out there that I
- 23:32really like and I've talked and I've helped finance.
- 23:35But I can tell you with some of these, because
- 23:38they have lower barrier of entries and they're
- 23:40cyclical, and this is usually a gateway drug
- 23:44for a business, right? So this is going to be,
- 23:46maybe it's a first time business owner or it's
- 23:50a W -2 wage earner. that sees this opportunity
- 23:53and this is, you know, call it a side gig, right?
- 23:56We're going to do, I'm keeping my day job, which
- 23:59is great because now as a lender, I can use the
- 24:02wages you earn to help offset my concern with
- 24:05the laundromat. So it's other collateral in a
- 24:07way. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah. It's an extra
- 24:09cashflow stream. So I'm a big fan of W -2 wage
- 24:14earners. you know going in this direction don't
- 24:16give up your day job too early because w -2 income
- 24:19really is more powerful than self -employed income
- 24:23for most people but anyway so because i know
- 24:26that these types of businesses tend to have these
- 24:31kind of first -time business owners I'm probably
- 24:34going to want a 1 .35 cover, meaning I want this
- 24:38business asset to really produce a buck 35. And
- 24:43I'm going to talk to you, right, Daniel, as far
- 24:45as this, you know, why do you think this revenue
- 24:47is going to stick? All right. Your revenue is
- 24:50up 40 % from what it's done pretty consistently
- 24:54for the last three years. Why do you think you
- 24:58can come in here sprinkle some seasoning on it?
- 25:00And now so so this goes back to our first part
- 25:03of our conversation about care I need you to
- 25:07clearly articulate to me Why you think you can
- 25:11execute this plan and if your numbers don't really
- 25:14sync with reality I may not say, no, the conversation's
- 25:19over, but I might stress test this, all right?
- 25:21If Daniel thinks that revenue is going to increase
- 25:2340 % and I can get to a 135 cover, what if revenue
- 25:28only goes up 15 %? What kind of cover do I have
- 25:31there? In my scenario where revenue only goes
- 25:35up 15%, now my cover is really only like a 115
- 25:39or 120. But you've got your W -2 wages over here
- 25:45and your personal debt. You don't have a whole
- 25:47bunch of credit cards and you're not getting
- 25:49a brand new F -350 every other year. So I can
- 25:52see that you've got additional discretionary
- 25:55income from your day job. Well, now I can get
- 25:58to a yes. But that's how we would walk through
- 26:00that process. Well, let's go into the stress
- 26:02testing because you lived through that. Like
- 26:04you had what I would call a black swan event
- 26:07in your life because you had 66 units and this
- 26:11was a big project for you. So maybe you can talk
- 26:14through what that was. And also for the listeners
- 26:17here who might be thinking about building their
- 26:19own portfolios, how they might think about stress
- 26:21testing before they even start having some of
- 26:24these conversations so they can anticipate some
- 26:27of the feedback and get in the right mindset
- 26:29to be adaptive to things that might go wrong.
- 26:31No, I had a mentor of mine. His name's John Burtis.
- 26:36He had a saying that falling down flat on your
- 26:38face is still forward movement, which it is technically.
- 26:41And I look at the apartment complex, got some
- 26:44wounds and scars that are still healing, but
- 26:46I learned a lot. This was built creative financing,
- 26:50you know, 501. I mean, this was pretty elaborate.
- 26:54The reality is I probably I ignored some red
- 26:59flags. We talked about red flags. I probably
- 27:01ignored some of the red flags that I should have
- 27:04caught, but I drank the Kool -Aid. Let's just
- 27:07say that. this was in a smaller rural community
- 27:12spent 20 years there in community banking i had
- 27:16a lot of relationships did a lot of community
- 27:18development the the community had transformed
- 27:22like most rural communities that are natural
- 27:25resource extraction based they change when we
- 27:29moved there it was kind of on the upswing it
- 27:32was becoming a tourist destination while we were
- 27:34there we went we were there for 20 years while
- 27:37we were there we saw seven brand new hotels built
- 27:40we saw restaurants get created we saw a lot of
- 27:43stuff get created and one of the best breweries
- 27:46in oregon right launched there and i think there's
- 27:49five or six breweries there now so the huge upswing
- 27:53in business and tourism and everything that that
- 27:56brings. Beautiful place to live, great community,
- 27:59saw a huge influx of retirees, two hours from
- 28:03one main metro area, three and a half hours from
- 28:05another ones. But what happened, again, and this
- 28:08is not unique to this rural community, housing
- 28:12costs went up considerably. And what we started
- 28:14to see is that the workers that are essential
- 28:18for these types of businesses and these kind
- 28:21of tourist economies, they couldn't afford to
- 28:24live in that community. And that's a shame. But
- 28:27there's all kinds of programs for low income
- 28:31housing projects, all kinds of tax subsidies.
- 28:33And that's probably a conversation for another
- 28:36day. But I think a lot of it's a racket because
- 28:38it shouldn't cost $500 ,000 a door to build a
- 28:42single bedroom and studio apartments. But that's
- 28:45what we saw happening. So you got the low income
- 28:48housing that is taking care of one type of population
- 28:51and you have, you know, strong market rent, which
- 28:54is taking care of another. But the gap in what
- 28:56we saw in this community was what I call workforce
- 28:59housing, which is where these are people who
- 29:02are employed. They're usually working 30 to 60
- 29:05hours a week in various restaurant retail type
- 29:09of customer service jobs. How do we create a
- 29:12place for them to afford? And so seeing what
- 29:16was happening, it was back in 2018, I started
- 29:19kind of thinking that there might be some tools
- 29:22here unique to the time event that this was all
- 29:27taking place. And because I had spent so much
- 29:29time in this community financing projects, knowing
- 29:32people, I had some good contacts. So there was
- 29:35this piece of land, beautifully located waterfront.
- 29:39you know, next to groceries. You could walk to
- 29:42the downtown core, you know, easily bike. I mean,
- 29:44it was a great piece of property. It was zoned
- 29:47commercially. So at the time it had some outright
- 29:52uses. It could be multifamily housing. It could
- 29:55be hospitality, hotel, motel. So we looked at
- 29:58this and we came up with a financial model. that
- 30:03we'd use a combination. It was actually three
- 30:06separate buildings, total of 66 units. We were
- 30:09going to use the waterfront building and use
- 30:12that as short -term housing, vacation rentals.
- 30:15The other two buildings, which were on the side
- 30:17streets, still nice location, nice units, would
- 30:21be what we'd call workforce housing because the
- 30:24short -term rentals we could generate more revenue
- 30:27off of that which then could help subsidize the
- 30:31the rents you know on this property and we could
- 30:34on paper make all this pencil where it would
- 30:38work for you know financially for us it would
- 30:41work financially for the bank it was to be a
- 30:44great asset for the community So the first warning
- 30:48sign I had on this, and we had very little money.
- 30:52I'm banker by trade, but we've had some rentals.
- 30:55We've had other things tend to always have kind
- 30:57of side hustle going on, but we were a single
- 31:00income family. I was blessed with a good career
- 31:04that allowed my wife to stay home for 19 years
- 31:06and raise the three kids. But we had to make
- 31:09a lot of sacrifices. And that sacrifice is, you
- 31:11know, I have a big 401k. And we had a few properties,
- 31:14but, you know, those were leveraged up. And frankly,
- 31:16we're using income from those properties to,
- 31:19you know, do vacations and do other stuff. So
- 31:21we looked at this project. It was bigger than
- 31:24I wanted. I wanted to do 12 units, but that parcel
- 31:27didn't work. It had a bunch of easements and
- 31:30stuff, sewer lines that weren't recorded anywhere
- 31:34in the due diligence. So we pulled the trigger
- 31:36on this. The first capital stack I put together
- 31:40was going to use Opportunity Zone. funding i
- 31:43knew somebody in the community who had sold a
- 31:46lot of property they had a lot of capital gains
- 31:48this was in an opportunity zone it was going
- 31:51to work out great you know we shook hands we
- 31:53were like trying things up but there was a conversation
- 31:56they had with some outside individuals in the
- 32:00community but not part of the table conversation
- 32:02they decided that this property should be a hotel
- 32:04had no interest in being involved in a hotel
- 32:07and i think there had been tons of headwinds
- 32:10because with the seven hotels that were built
- 32:12there were some others proposed and the community
- 32:14didn't want them so it's like no that's not what
- 32:15we're going to do so that was capital stack number
- 32:17one capital stack number two came along the the
- 32:21person i was talking to had a million dollars
- 32:23of liquidity that was going to be opening up
- 32:25in january part of his his stock option plan,
- 32:28if I remember right. Liked him, had the same
- 32:31vision, right? This was good investment, but
- 32:35it was a good investment for the community as
- 32:37well. But then unfortunately around Thanksgiving,
- 32:40his daughter survived, but she OD'd on heroin.
- 32:44And he was unaware of the drug addiction there.
- 32:47And he stepped back from everything and said,
- 32:50I have to focus on my family. And I applaud that.
- 32:52That was the right decision. So literally, we
- 32:55had to go through three different capital stacks.
- 32:59And at this point, we had probably $80 ,000 of
- 33:03our own money invested in all the surveys, all
- 33:06the studies and all that. so i should have walked
- 33:08away but i didn't had some i can recall an internal
- 33:12conversation that i had chose to stick with it
- 33:17Man of strong faith, kind of had a conversation
- 33:19with God and decided to go my own way. But anyhow,
- 33:23so we found a third option. People came to the
- 33:28table. Everybody was excited. I was working with
- 33:32the same lender that started with, you know,
- 33:34option number one. They were excited about the
- 33:37project. Ironically, the regional president I
- 33:41had worked with early on in my career at Bank
- 33:43of America. So we knew each other. Everybody's
- 33:46excited. And we closed on the property September
- 33:5130th of 2020. Yikes. 2020. So the process started
- 33:56in 2018 with the brainstorming. These various
- 34:00capital stacks happened in 2019. The Thanksgiving
- 34:04that I referenced where the gentleman's daughter
- 34:07had OD'd was 2019. So we were in COVID. We saw...
- 34:15things happening we were experiencing these shutdowns
- 34:18you know societal fabric was tearing but another
- 34:21red flag but i i was so emotionally invested
- 34:27with this project at this point that that i kept
- 34:30pushing for it so we finally closed on the land
- 34:33september 30th as a banker i know that you don't
- 34:36go into a construction project without all of
- 34:40the money present to finish the construction
- 34:43project so i broke one of my own personal professional
- 34:47rules because what the bank wanted to do and
- 34:50i can't blame the bank because we're 2020, we
- 34:54thought we were going to have loan approval in
- 34:55February. And then it became March and then it
- 34:58came April. And as COVID world is unwinding,
- 35:02banks didn't want to make any decisions because
- 35:04they had no idea what tomorrow was going to look
- 35:06like. So they were slow walking the whole process
- 35:09of approval. The person who we were buying the
- 35:12land from, I knew he was doing a very large seller
- 35:16carry back that was going to be subordinate to
- 35:19the bank. And then I brought another investor
- 35:23in who brought real money to the table. My wife
- 35:27and I borrowed equity out of our home. And so
- 35:29all this came together in September, but for
- 35:32the bank, it was only a land loan. So they were
- 35:36coming in for a small dollar amount because most
- 35:38of the purchase, a vast amount of the purchase
- 35:40price, the seller was carrying back, but it gave
- 35:44us enough money to start the dirt work because
- 35:46this was kind of bare land. We had a lot of infrastructure.
- 35:49Well, The bank said, we'll close on the overall
- 35:53project by the end of the year. Well, it actually
- 35:55took them a year. So we actually closed on the
- 35:58full construction loan in September 30th of 2021.
- 36:02So now we're like full on in COVID, right? And
- 36:05we've got all these, you know, money subsidies
- 36:07coming out from the government. Everybody's walking
- 36:10around with cash and what started to happen.
- 36:13Everything got expensive. We haven't even hit
- 36:16the supply chain issues, supply and demand. Demand
- 36:19goes up because everybody has all of this cash.
- 36:23Supply would stay the same, but everything started
- 36:25to go up. So it took us a year to get there.
- 36:27General contractor was kind of slow walking the
- 36:30construction because he knew the situation. I
- 36:32was very transparent with everybody. And he didn't
- 36:34want to get pinched with costs that couldn't
- 36:37be paid because the full construction one hadn't
- 36:39gotten closed. So anyway, we burnt a year of
- 36:42interest reserves. As most construction loans
- 36:45are, they're variable. So now we're a year into,
- 36:49I think the interest rate went from like three
- 36:52and a half. percent to four and a half, maybe
- 36:53four and three quarter. Everything's getting
- 36:56more expensive. Now we have issues with our contingencies,
- 36:59but we're moving forward. We're going vertical.
- 37:02Everybody's excited. And that's when the supply
- 37:05chain came in. So now the interest rate has doubled.
- 37:08We can't get supplies. We had to wait eight months
- 37:11for windows. And for anybody who's familiar with
- 37:14construction projects, you kind of need windows
- 37:16so you can then weather tight your property,
- 37:20which then kicks all of the interior stuff. So
- 37:22anyway, because of COVID, because of some things
- 37:26that were not in our control, however, I think
- 37:29there are things that were in our control that
- 37:31I missed, that I didn't want to acknowledge.
- 37:34We wound up getting to a point where we had spent
- 37:38pretty much all the money we had. And we did
- 37:42not have a complete project. Interest had more
- 37:44than doubled. Our contingency was gone. Our interest
- 37:47reserves were gone. And the bank said no more.
- 37:51And so when we were trying to renew the construction,
- 37:55we literally we needed six more months and we
- 37:57would have had everything done. But the bank
- 37:59didn't want to play. I had two investors that
- 38:03were kind of like the deep pockets. They didn't
- 38:06put any money into the project per se, but they
- 38:09were the deep pockets. They didn't want to put
- 38:11anything else in. And so we spent a year trying
- 38:14to find a solution. And for your listeners, Daniel,
- 38:18if you are going to use other people's money,
- 38:21your sole number one responsibility is if something
- 38:25goes sideways, you have to pay them back. And
- 38:28I am pleased to say everybody on our project
- 38:30got paid back. We wound up selling our project
- 38:33to the deep. pocket investors. They own thousands
- 38:37of doors. So they wound up after the bank started
- 38:41to lean on them. They bought the project out.
- 38:44The part where I can feel good is we survived.
- 38:47We paid back the investors. The people who had
- 38:50real money in this got their money back. And
- 38:53I'm not going to say that I won't make mistakes
- 38:55again, but I think I have improved my spidey
- 38:59sense where I can be more honest with myself
- 39:03that, yeah, I put together probably the most
- 39:06creative financing structure that I have ever
- 39:09seen, and I had a bank approve it, and it would
- 39:12have been awesome. But it was highly leveraged,
- 39:15and we talk about leverage. I did not have enough
- 39:17of that cushion to absorb the headwinds. I'm
- 39:21not sure I could have foreseen and built a model
- 39:23that would have weathered those headwinds. Again,
- 39:27luck and timing is a huge component. But at the
- 39:31end of the day, the asset got built for the community.
- 39:34It's now just market rate because things got
- 39:37stretched out and that community is very anti
- 39:40-short -term rentals, that they actually changed
- 39:43the zoning, which then put grandfather closets
- 39:46in. And because of the delays, they lost that
- 39:48status. So all it can be now is multifamily without
- 39:52going through a big process that won't change.
- 39:55But to me... The takeaway is you got to listen
- 39:59to those voices. I think, you know, I should
- 40:02have known better. If anybody should have known
- 40:04better, 28 year experience in banking should
- 40:06have seen it. I was too emotionally attached.
- 40:10And fundamentally, I go back to that conversation
- 40:14I had with myself when we were about $80 ,000
- 40:17into it, feeling like I couldn't walk away because
- 40:23me and my wife didn't have that $80 ,000 to lose.
- 40:26And that is how bad decisions get made. When
- 40:29you feel like you have to move forward because
- 40:33you can't afford the loss today, that's when
- 40:37you need to just absorb that loss and move on.
- 40:39Absolutely. We're going to probably make it out
- 40:42whole, at least my wife and I, but it burnt up.
- 40:45A couple of years of my life, the stress that
- 40:47I endured definitely had some bad side effects
- 40:51that, you know, we'll see how it plays out. But
- 40:53you got to be true to yourself and know, as Kenny
- 40:57Rogers says, you know, know when to fold them.
- 40:59And I probably should have done that. Wow. You
- 41:02know, in the project management field, we have
- 41:04kind of this belief that every failure is just
- 41:07experience that we learn from in order to grow.
- 41:13hopefully be better risk managers in the future.
- 41:15And we do these postmortems where we'll look
- 41:17back and we'll kind of, we'll pick it apart a
- 41:19bit, but with no blame, right. It's really just
- 41:21to try to understand and learn. And I kind of
- 41:24hear that as you were talking through it, like
- 41:26it's, it was painful and it was a long, large
- 41:28period of your life, but you did definitely get
- 41:30a lot of learning out of that. And I imagine
- 41:33that's making you a more, you know, seasoned
- 41:35person going forward. I do want to quickly explain
- 41:39one thing you touched on though, for the audience,
- 41:41in case you're not aware of it. You mentioned
- 41:43opportunity zones. So anyone who doesn't know
- 41:45what that is, it's a federally designated distressed
- 41:47community where new investments with certain
- 41:51conditions are eligible for different tax treatment.
- 41:54So if you have like capital gains, you can defer
- 41:56those capital gains. And so you don't have to
- 41:59worry about that. And it's a good investment
- 42:01opportunity to bring new money into those kinds
- 42:03of areas. It sounds like you were doing an OZ.
- 42:06So I wanted to kind of quickly touch on that.
- 42:08Quick follow -up here. The Bureau of Labor Systems,
- 42:11statistics say that roughly 20 % of all new businesses
- 42:14will fail in two years and construction face
- 42:17a 98 % chance of cost overruns and delays. That's
- 42:22a McKinsey study. These are sobering stats when
- 42:25it comes to the kinds of things that you're looking
- 42:27to do. I am curious now that you've gone through
- 42:30it yourself and you were very honest about when
- 42:33you were going through this about maybe you were
- 42:35a little too close to it and you were attached
- 42:36to it and things like that. But when things were
- 42:39at its worst, when they were going wrong, what
- 42:41behaviors did you find were the most useful for
- 42:43you? Were you over communicating to the bank
- 42:46and to your lenders? Is there some, because we
- 42:50all will get stressed like this. What is the
- 42:52best we can hope to do in that situation? I put
- 42:56this, you know, and we did a. Postmortem, you
- 42:58know, I did. The investor that brought real cash
- 43:03to the project was a former president of a large
- 43:08commercial construction outfit. I should have
- 43:11used him more because I think had I had him engaged
- 43:16more with the GC, there would have been a little
- 43:20bit more transparency. I have managed. hundreds
- 43:23of construction projects from the lender's side.
- 43:26I have worked with GCs, but when I'm the client,
- 43:31it was a different relationship. And I wish I
- 43:34would have brought him in because I think we
- 43:36could have used him more there. I tried to over
- 43:39-communicate with the bank. We talked about that
- 43:41before, relationship, right? So I was very honest
- 43:44when things were going sideways with the bank.
- 43:46We talked monthly, right? I had monthly draw
- 43:50requests. I told them, the delays were should
- 43:54have probably pushed a little bit more because
- 43:58it surprised me when they decided not to extend
- 44:03the construction period by six months because
- 44:07we had not maxed out the loan we had maxed out
- 44:10our interest reserves because interest rate doubled.
- 44:13And we had tapped into our emergency contingency.
- 44:18I think we probably had about 100 ,000, maybe
- 44:20125 left, but we still had a couple million dollars
- 44:25in the actual line to get to that. So I wish
- 44:29we probably would have had that, okay, let's
- 44:32start the extension today at six months because
- 44:35we're not going to be done. But again, it's kind
- 44:37of like that because of the world we were living
- 44:40in. even though I knew it should take 12 to 16
- 44:44months to build that project. with these you
- 44:48know are we having supply issues are we not having
- 44:51supply issues what is the issue you know what
- 44:53is the supply what are we trying to get that
- 44:56i i just never had a good feel and i don't think
- 45:00you know the general contractor did either i
- 45:02still like him i think things could have gone
- 45:06differently between him and i communicating i
- 45:08still think he's a decent person but he never
- 45:11lived through anything like that either right
- 45:12so usually when we're going through these things
- 45:16We rely on previous experiences to then come
- 45:20up with decision making. And nobody had lived
- 45:22through this before. I definitely should have
- 45:24engaged the two main investors more. I spent
- 45:27too much time problem solving before I started
- 45:32the conversation with them because our relationship
- 45:35went. sideways extremely quickly, surprisingly
- 45:39quickly when I brought the stark reality to them,
- 45:44but I also brought solutions to them. And this
- 45:46is a few months before the bank started what
- 45:49they did, but they felt like they were surprised.
- 45:51We would talk like every six months or so. And
- 45:54when you are running $10 million projects, I
- 45:58think you need to have team meetings on a monthly
- 46:01basis. But again, during that period of history
- 46:05there was so much weird stuff going on it was
- 46:09a full -time job just trying to keep your sanity
- 46:11and so that's where these things got missed but
- 46:14it was a learning experience i still like real
- 46:17estate one of the realities and again this is
- 46:20where you have to listen to those voices because
- 46:23Had this project gone the way we thought it was
- 46:26going to go, my wife and I would still be in
- 46:28that community. And we wouldn't be happy. The
- 46:31weather there sucked. We relocated to East Texas
- 46:34two years ago and have absolutely loved it. Our
- 46:37social network, our social activities are threefold
- 46:43what we had from that other community after being
- 46:46there for 20 years. So, you know, sometimes things
- 46:48work out. You know, like I said, I've got scars.
- 46:51I still have some wounds that are healing, but
- 46:53we are where we're supposed to be today. And
- 46:57truly, if that turned into the investment and,
- 46:59you know, my golden egg that I was believing
- 47:03it would be, we'd still be in that community
- 47:05because I'd have to be, you know, keeping tracks
- 47:07of it. But that brings up new and exciting opportunities,
- 47:10right? And this is where. Technology, I think,
- 47:13really comes in. And as we talk about the side
- 47:17gigs, the side hustles, and what W -2 wage earners
- 47:21can do to help break into their freedom is lean
- 47:25into where opportunities lie. Right now, I think
- 47:29everybody would agree real estate is overpriced.
- 47:34It's coming down in some markets. It's more difficult
- 47:37to actually buy a property. My wife and I had
- 47:40short -term rentals error, rental arbitrage for
- 47:44three years. Great experience. We ran it completely
- 47:47remotely. We got out of it a year, year and a
- 47:51half ago because the market had changed and we
- 47:54saw that shift happening. Right now, it's not
- 47:56really a good environment in most communities
- 47:59for short -term rentals because short -term rentals
- 48:01supposedly are the bane of all housing issues.
- 48:04Well, that's not the case either. We kind of
- 48:07stumbled onto a new opportunity and that's in
- 48:10and around AI. And with AI coding being... a
- 48:15banker for 30 plus years i know firsthand some
- 48:19of the struggles and challenges that that lenders
- 48:22have especially on the commercial side and i've
- 48:24always had a couple ideas running around my head
- 48:26on how to solve that but i'm just an average
- 48:29bloke there's no way i can jump in and actually
- 48:32put together some sort of you know software package
- 48:35to solve this but again having good relationships
- 48:38being a good partner brought me to a software
- 48:42development lab and what we have been able to
- 48:45do is. through the use of AI coding, which has
- 48:49reduced the cost of creating a solution by about
- 48:5375%. And so we're building this solution that
- 48:57we're taking to market for commercial lenders.
- 48:59And it's not really that expensive. Average people
- 49:03who see challenges, whether it's in their own
- 49:06industry or in their social networks or talking
- 49:11to their sphere of influence. And if you can
- 49:14come up with an idea, how technology platforms
- 49:17or systems can help solve that, the barrier of
- 49:21entry, the cost of developing that solution has
- 49:24never been lower. And it's probably going to
- 49:26keep getting lower for the next two or three
- 49:29years as this technology just kind of runs. And
- 49:32so what I would suggest to your listeners is.
- 49:35I'm still a big fan of real estate because real
- 49:37estate never goes away and they're not making
- 49:38any more of it. But you got to look for where
- 49:41opportunities lie. And I do think that there's
- 49:44a certain window of opportunity with this AI
- 49:49assisted, you know, fill in the blank. where
- 49:53people who are creative and are willing to work
- 49:57more than a 40 -hour week can come up with solutions
- 50:00that can unlock their futures. And what we have
- 50:04will be in the marketplace for the first part
- 50:06of next year. I'm still a W -2 wage earner. I
- 50:10love the work I do. I keep this W -2 job. But
- 50:13really, the financial freedom that my wife and
- 50:16I are going to have will come from this business
- 50:18that we are launching through this AI, which
- 50:21is... fantastic. Very excited about it because
- 50:23it provides a tangible solution to people that
- 50:26I know who are living day to day with these challenges
- 50:29in commercial lending. Yeah. I wouldn't ask you
- 50:31about Portfolio Watch. I use AI now more often
- 50:34to help be more productive in different things
- 50:37I'm doing. I know whenever I look at making an
- 50:39investment, I'm usually building kind of a business
- 50:41case analysis, like a slide deck. I even built
- 50:44one I presented to my own wife where I was like,
- 50:46look, this is why I think we should invest in
- 50:48this other city because the market has this type
- 50:51of growth. And I think we're going to be able
- 50:53to get. you know, really good rental income in
- 50:55a steady way and everything like that. Because,
- 50:57you know, she was looking and interested in a
- 50:59bunch of other places and I was looking at those
- 51:01as well. But I find that things like. notebook
- 51:04LLM. I'll just pick on one for a moment, which
- 51:06is a Google product. It makes it super easy.
- 51:08You can feed a lot of source material in. It
- 51:10can go and pull other statistics and it can build
- 51:13slide decks and even audio and video presentations.
- 51:17So it's really useful. I think it could be potentially
- 51:19something even a lender could use for ensuring
- 51:23they have a more productive conversation when
- 51:26they go to ask to borrow money with a banker
- 51:27or whoever. So I'm curious, maybe you can first
- 51:30start with talking about Portfolio Watch itself
- 51:32and how you're thinking about it as technology
- 51:34to help identify risk and how it might level
- 51:37the playing field a little bit here and also
- 51:40how you see the future going with these types
- 51:42of tools. So specifically with Portfolio Watch,
- 51:45and I think the good news for those listening
- 51:49is this tool is going to reduce risks that commercial
- 51:52lenders have. If risk across the portfolio can
- 51:56be reduced, they are going to be more willing
- 51:59to say yes and take on additional risks. So again,
- 52:03my heart lies with capital access and putting
- 52:06capital into the hands of small business owners.
- 52:08And so as a successful lender, what I saw play
- 52:13out in more than one organization I worked at
- 52:16is as my success as a lender grew, so did my
- 52:21loan portfolio but as we spoke about earlier
- 52:23if i take a loss in my portfolio it takes a lot
- 52:28of effort and a lot of new lending to backfill
- 52:30that loss so you got to pay attention to the
- 52:33loan portfolio but as a lender i am paid and
- 52:37my bonus Structure is based on the new loans
- 52:41that I do. So I'm successful year after year.
- 52:44My loan portfolio keeps getting bigger and bigger.
- 52:47Supposed to be collecting quarterly and annual
- 52:49financials from our clients. Every year I'm supposed
- 52:53to do an annual review on each borrower because
- 52:57we're assessing risk, right? You know, which
- 52:59of these businesses are struggling? And my saying
- 53:03is a good loan today can be a bad loan tomorrow.
- 53:06and it's a numbers game you have you know as
- 53:08a lender you don't really know which loan is
- 53:11going to go sideways i had in my career some
- 53:14great loans that i never expected to go sideways
- 53:17but things happen i had one that i thought was
- 53:19a great loan but my borrower died well we're
- 53:23supposed to have life insurance in place but
- 53:26money was getting tight they decided not to pay
- 53:29a premium the life insurance company never notified
- 53:33us my borrower dies now there's no life insurance
- 53:36to pay off the loan right so so these things
- 53:38happen so anyway what portfolio watch will do
- 53:41is it automates the system and it's not a big
- 53:44flashy huge workflow it does everything from
- 53:47the lender from the beginning to the end no we
- 53:49designed a very specific tool that can plug into
- 53:54the existing platforms that commercial lenders
- 53:57use it will actually do the outreach to the borrower
- 54:00it will collect the financial statements and
- 54:02tax returns it will automatically spread and
- 54:05do a financial analysis trend analysis on those
- 54:08it will actually do industry kind of macro economics
- 54:13on that industry type that that borrower is in
- 54:17it will actually produce an annual review which
- 54:20then the commercial lender can read and see what
- 54:23their borrower is doing. At any point in here,
- 54:27in real time if data comes in and there's a negative
- 54:32trend developing with that borrower it will actually
- 54:35alert the lender and you know acne manufacturing
- 54:39you know these you know the watch score as we
- 54:41call it has deteriorated these are the things
- 54:43of concern and it flags up for him and now he's
- 54:47got actually kind of a to -do list right he has
- 54:49an assigned task to reach out to that borrower
- 54:52have a conversation with them to find out Is
- 54:55this a false negative? Because these things happen,
- 54:59right? It's data. But why did they happen? Oh,
- 55:02this is why. The borrower is playing on doing
- 55:05this, this, and this. This really is not a risk
- 55:08for a default. Or, oh, these things are happening.
- 55:12There are these other bad things happening. This
- 55:14loan will not survive. if we don't do something
- 55:17and the goal is to identify this borrower who's
- 55:21experienced financial challenges before they
- 55:24miss a payment because if the lender can engage
- 55:27before a payment is missed you have all kinds
- 55:30of tools in the toolbox to then help that borrower
- 55:33if that borrower misses a payment misses two
- 55:36payments the road's kind of cast there's not
- 55:39a whole lot that can be done to now save that
- 55:42borrower so that's the tool that we're building
- 55:44and i think As we go on, AI just opens up more
- 55:50time for, in this case, lenders, right? Because
- 55:54now if I'm freeing up time on the lender's side,
- 55:57they have more time to go prospect and do what
- 56:00they're getting paid to do. Well, at the same
- 56:02time, I think portfolio launch. will do a far
- 56:06better job managing that loan portfolio than
- 56:09that lender or i ever could do just because there's
- 56:12only so much time in the day so pwc reported
- 56:15that 52 of financial service companies are accelerating
- 56:19their ai adoption specifically for risk management
- 56:22and fraud detection my point is Companies are
- 56:25going to be using these tools. Yes. And so they're
- 56:27going to be there. How do you see the role of
- 56:30the borrower in the future? Do you think it would
- 56:33be a mistake to not try to use tools yourself?
- 56:37knowing that all these companies are going to
- 56:38be using them to monitor and act on their end.
- 56:42And do you see things like portfolio watches
- 56:44leveling the playing field? And I guess I'm kind
- 56:46of asking, how do you see the future here? And
- 56:48is it almost like a necessity that people start
- 56:50thinking about adopting tools like this in order
- 56:53to borrow more effectively? I think the easy
- 56:56answer is yes. So when AI came along, for me,
- 57:00I realized AI is not going anywhere. We've had
- 57:03other technologies come and they're all exciting,
- 57:05but then they fade out or they evolve into something
- 57:08else. I think AI is here. Don't think AI is going
- 57:12to eliminate everybody's job. I'm not coming
- 57:14to it from a fear perspective. I'm coming to
- 57:17it as, how can it help me make better decisions?
- 57:21You had Jaden Sterling on. And he brought up
- 57:26data paralysis. I call it analysis paralysis,
- 57:30where you can freeze your decision -making process
- 57:35because you always want more data trying to look
- 57:38around all the corners. I think this is where
- 57:40AI comes in. It's a very useful tool that can
- 57:45help us make better decisions, but it should
- 57:48never replace our cognizant. decision that's
- 57:53being made, if that makes sense. We use it as
- 57:55a tool, but we shouldn't allow it to make decisions
- 57:58for us. I guess that's where I'm curious about
- 58:00it going, because if you look, you mentioned
- 58:02trading. Let's just use that example for a moment.
- 58:05So robo -advisors, which I've covered on the
- 58:07show before, are great ways to have algorithms
- 58:10understand your risk tolerance and to try to
- 58:13automatically take your contributions and invest
- 58:15it. based on building the portfolio and managing
- 58:18the allocation of the portfolio that you're looking
- 58:20to have. It's the replacement of a human advisor,
- 58:23right? And it's an algorithm -based one. So it's
- 58:25not very smart. It has a little bit of smarts
- 58:27in there. It's parameterized smartness, where
- 58:29AI would be learning and adapting and doing things.
- 58:33And you'd have to have a lot more trust that
- 58:35it could do it well. But if we get to AGI or
- 58:38something, I bet you it would be able to do a
- 58:40damn good job. Now, Jaden Sterling, I wanted
- 58:43to touch on that with him because he's literally
- 58:44building that kind of product. But I know companies
- 58:47like Robinhood, for instance, will go that route.
- 58:49Like you just know it. They gamify everything.
- 58:51They try to push technology hard. So I guess
- 58:54my question to you, though, is, yes, AI is going
- 58:57to be here. It's going to transform things. And
- 58:59it seems clear that people should be considering
- 59:01it as a productivity boost. But will it change
- 59:04the relationship we have when it comes to something,
- 59:07a person to person thing? Well, at some point,
- 59:10instead of dealing with a person behind a desk
- 59:13to try to borrow money, you're actually dealing
- 59:15with a system. And that system is actually automating.
- 59:20And I'm not saying we don't have people at all.
- 59:22I'm not saying that at all. I'm not saying the
- 59:24jobs are gone. I'm just saying that maybe. the
- 59:27ai would be the thing that you're going to have
- 59:29to interact with on that first round it's going
- 59:32to screen you out maybe well yes we have that
- 59:36today right you know in so much that that we
- 59:39do in touch we get screened out and that's all
- 59:42being driven by ai consumer lending has already
- 59:46been replaced with algorithms a long time ago.
- 59:50And we already talked about credit scores and
- 59:52the weaknesses with credit scores. That ship
- 59:54has left. And I may be naive, right? I already
- 59:57said, you know, I'm kind of a slow bloke and
- 59:59kind of, you know, old fashioned. But I don't
- 1:00:03think that AI will replace commercial or business
- 1:00:08lending because, you know, you asked me, what
- 1:00:11is the most important thing? And to me, it's
- 1:00:13character. To me, I have to know when things
- 1:00:18don't go right, and that day will come, but when
- 1:00:21they don't go right, how do you interact with
- 1:00:24me? How much trust can I have that you're going
- 1:00:27to pay me back my money? There's been more than
- 1:00:30one lender who has lost their job because they
- 1:00:33had a couple big loans that failed, right? And
- 1:00:36so if I'm an employee and I'm feeding my family,
- 1:00:41I got to trust that you're going to pay your
- 1:00:43loan back. Otherwise, I might lose my job. So
- 1:00:46I don't see how some will try. Right. Some some
- 1:00:50and it will probably be the bigger the bigger
- 1:00:52the bank, the more likely are going to try to
- 1:00:55control their expenses around lending. So they
- 1:01:00will try. To me, that opens up. more and more
- 1:01:03opportunities for these community banks, these
- 1:01:07credit unions, which are still on the learning
- 1:01:09curve, and these CDFIs, because to me, those
- 1:01:12are the ones who are relationship -based, and
- 1:01:16I don't see it moving. Yeah, they'll use AI for
- 1:01:19some of the credit analysis that's happening
- 1:01:21today, but no, that final decision, could they
- 1:01:25be used for screening out to a point? But if,
- 1:01:29again, if you don't have a business plan or if
- 1:01:31you have a 125 -page business plan, but in some
- 1:01:36of these other red flags, you have no cash, no
- 1:01:39collateral, and your credit score is 580, you
- 1:01:43should be screened out because you want that
- 1:01:46lender, when somebody who's listening today takes
- 1:01:50that business plan, That's well thought out and
- 1:01:53they're articulate and they're passionate goes
- 1:01:56to that banker. You want that banker to have
- 1:01:59enough time to spend with that entrepreneur to
- 1:02:03form that relationship, to believe in that relationship
- 1:02:05and get them alone. And if I'm having to deal
- 1:02:08with a hundred potential borrowers who are not
- 1:02:11ready, that still takes up time. There's still
- 1:02:13a process. So, you know, I don't want to say
- 1:02:17that screening out. With AI, it's always a bad
- 1:02:21thing. But what it can't do is get to a point
- 1:02:25where it's screening out good opportunities.
- 1:02:27And everything's a pendulum. So they might at
- 1:02:30first screen out too many, but then when they
- 1:02:33realize, well, now we're not doing loans, but
- 1:02:35the bank down the street that's not using AI
- 1:02:38is now getting more loans than I used to get,
- 1:02:41you know, they bring it back because life is
- 1:02:43fluid like that. And that's the difference between
- 1:02:45AI and some... smart algorithm, right? It'll
- 1:02:48learn and it'll get it right. And it's really
- 1:02:50interesting hearing that because your perspective
- 1:02:53there about why AI will not completely replace
- 1:02:56the human element is exactly my same professional
- 1:02:59opinion about why project managers will never
- 1:03:02be fully replaced by artificial intelligence.
- 1:03:04There is such an inherent human factor to that
- 1:03:07role. Yes, there's automation that will happen.
- 1:03:11It might reduce that role's capacity to a certain
- 1:03:14degree, but The human element is so critical
- 1:03:16to doing what that role needs to do that I think
- 1:03:21it's supposed to be a productivity gain, not
- 1:03:23a replacement. Thank you so much, Walt. It's
- 1:03:26been really insightful and eye -opening on all
- 1:03:29the different things we've touched. I think a
- 1:03:31large landscape, everything from how to understand
- 1:03:33where the lender is coming from to how to be
- 1:03:36a better borrower, how to prepare, what things
- 1:03:39to look for, how to get through it, and how to
- 1:03:41think about technology. I really appreciate all
- 1:03:43that. How can the listeners connect with you
- 1:03:45and also Portfolio Watch? Thanks for having me
- 1:03:48on, Daniel. This was a fantastic conversation.
- 1:03:50Portfolio Watch is on X. It's also in LinkedIn.
- 1:03:54Walt Polstowate is also in LinkedIn. You can
- 1:03:57also send me an email from PortfolioWatch .co.
- 1:04:01If you're interested in learning more, go ahead,
- 1:04:03hit me up there. I'd love to talk with you. Wonderful.
- 1:04:06Thanks again for being on the show. Daniel, thank
- 1:04:08you very much. Have a good day. For years, I
- 1:04:20treated borrowing money as a purely mathematical
- 1:04:22transaction. You have a credit score. You put
- 1:04:25up collateral. You get a check. But speaking
- 1:04:28with Walt today, I realized I was missing the
- 1:04:30variable that actually matters, the human element.
- 1:04:33He sat on the lender's side of the table for
- 1:04:35years. When I asked him what separated the top
- 1:04:3710 % of borrowers, he didn't say assets. He didn't
- 1:04:41say cash flow. He said character. I tend to obsess
- 1:04:44about the mechanics. trying to find that perfect
- 1:04:47debt service coverage ratio or lowest interest
- 1:04:49rate. But Walt reminded us that when the plan
- 1:04:52burns down, as it always seems to try to want
- 1:04:54to do, the spreadsheet isn't what saves us, it's
- 1:04:57the relationships. Walt lived this. He shared
- 1:05:00the story of his 66 -unit development disaster.
- 1:05:04He admitted to falling into the classic sunk
- 1:05:07cost trap. He was so emotionally invested that
- 1:05:10he ignored the red flags, and there were quite
- 1:05:12a few of them. Then the pandemic with all the
- 1:05:15rising costs and doubled interest rates and a
- 1:05:19supply chain crash, it was a recipe for bankruptcy.
- 1:05:23But because he had built those relationships
- 1:05:25and he had the grit to find solutions, he navigated
- 1:05:29a catastrophic failure without destroying his
- 1:05:32reputation. Everyone got paid back and he survived.
- 1:05:35The lesson here isn't to avoid debt. Really,
- 1:05:38the takeaway is to borrow with intention. to
- 1:05:41always be looking forward and to just be honest
- 1:05:44about limitations. Ultimately, the advice that
- 1:05:48I heard was to stop being a consumer borrower
- 1:05:50who's financing things like depreciating assets
- 1:05:53and to move towards being a strategic borrower,
- 1:05:56trying to accelerate the path towards your financial
- 1:05:59goals. And that starts with recognizing that
- 1:06:02there's good debt and there's bad debt. Taking
- 1:06:04out an 80 % loan for a boat, that's bad debt.
- 1:06:08Taking out an 80 % loan to revitalize a cash
- 1:06:12-flowing business, that is leverage. So whether
- 1:06:15you are looking at a business like a laundromat
- 1:06:17or trying to scale a tech startup with AI, the
- 1:06:20rules of the game hasn't really changed. You
- 1:06:22still need a business plan. You need to have
- 1:06:25capital. Most importantly, you need to have some
- 1:06:28grit because things are going to go wrong. And
- 1:06:31when they do, you still have to repay what you
- 1:06:33borrow. And that game is also only going to get
- 1:06:35faster. With 52 % of financial firms adopting
- 1:06:39AI, the screening process is becoming more automated.
- 1:06:42In the worst case, predatory lending is going
- 1:06:45to scale up. But in the best case, the algorithms
- 1:06:47will start to weed out the noise, leaving lenders
- 1:06:50with more time to help the people who actually
- 1:06:52have a plan. And those tools are out there now.
- 1:06:55And if the pinks are going to be using them to
- 1:06:57grade us, then we should be using them to vet
- 1:07:00our own deals. I'd love to hear from you. Have
- 1:07:02you ever let a sunk cost drag you down into a
- 1:07:05bad decision? How did you get out? Shoot me an
- 1:07:08email at contact at escape the clock .com. Best
- 1:07:10of luck borrowing with intention and escaping
- 1:07:12the clock. I'll catch you next week. Thanks for
- 1:07:17tuning into this episode. Remember, while I'm
- 1:07:20not yet a financial planner, I am getting my
- 1:07:22degree in wealth management. You should take
- 1:07:24anything you've heard here as tips and advice
- 1:07:26to making your plan. To learn more, visit www
- 1:07:29.escape the clock .com. There you can find the
- 1:07:33book resources, including the planner. and you
- 1:07:35can even schedule time with me. Please remember
- 1:07:38to like and subscribe so you don't miss an episode.
- 1:07:40Thanks for tuning in, and I'll catch you next
- 1:07:42time.