Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E003: The SEC Crackdown and Why Bitcoin-Only
Transcript
- 0:01It's Jesse Myers with a background of Excellence there.
- 0:07In the in-laws this week and the the Boomers did well, which did
- 0:13very well very well. this is a a background that really exudes,
- 0:22the The Excellence were going for with this show.
- 0:27Got a big week big, big news week this week gentlemen I'm
- 0:31sure there's a lot of institutional investors and
- 0:35people thinking about getting into Bitcoin who are bit scared
- 0:39everything going on right now. That's why we do this show and
- 0:42this week, we're joined by Tyler Campbell from unchain kick up
- 0:47almost a capital, just unchain now.
- 0:51Yes. Yeah, just unchain.
- 0:52Thank you for having I'm beyond excited to talk about the slow
- 0:56news week. Nothing going on.
- 0:58So you know nothing about did that dive into it.
- 1:01There's a lot going on, Tyler, don't sell it short.
- 1:04You've got a lot to get through. You've actually got one of your
- 1:06threads that you wrote a couple weeks ago, about the inability
- 1:10of Silicon Valley to grok Bitcoin that we're going to talk
- 1:14about. But before we jump into the
- 1:16topics of the week and the chaos in the markets, particularly the
- 1:20crypto markets right now, Tell us a little bit about yourself.
- 1:25Tyler, what are you doing, Unchained?
- 1:26What is unchain doing? And and I think high level how
- 1:30are you viewing the events of this week from, from a nun chain
- 1:35perspective. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:39So, Tyler Campbell. I'm a VP of concierge here at
- 1:42unchain, so I do lead our concierge team, the team of
- 1:46folks that I believe, as Marty said in the past, Auntie FTC
- 1:51will will completely take care of you.
- 1:52Sometimes will I will wipe your butt when it comes to setting up
- 1:55a multisig vault, but really, you know, our team is
- 1:59purpose-built to make people feel comfortable and confident
- 2:02in their Bitcoin security. So taking folks who either fits
- 2:05the first time holding Bitcoin with their own keys or if
- 2:09they've been using a hardware wallet for some years, but want
- 2:11to make the move to multisig. We really walk people through
- 2:14every step of the way that comes with a lot of Education as well.
- 2:18So been doing it for two years now, officially two years
- 2:22yesterday. Love.
- 2:23Every minute of it so far. Moved down from Minneapolis
- 2:27Minnesota to Austin, Texas to the Bitcoin capital of the
- 2:30world. And yeah, have I haven't looked
- 2:33back. Shout out to the Minneapolis
- 2:35Bitcoin crew though. Yeah.
- 2:38It's like from our perspective during times like this where
- 2:42there's kind of these shocks to the market and we've seen it
- 2:44over the past you know 48 months right?
- 2:46Going all the way back to like the block fi that FTX like
- 2:51there's there's things that happen and during these times of
- 2:53Chaos, EOS, it's really a. You know there's like a big
- 2:58Spotlight shown on why holding your own Keys is important.
- 3:01Right? The not your key is not your
- 3:02coins. Isn't just a mantra but it's
- 3:05incredibly incredibly important and so our phones are ringing
- 3:08off the hook and we're excited to help out hell, yeah, yeah,
- 3:13yeah. Tyler is excited to have Tyler.
- 3:16Join us this week being so close to the action with individuals
- 3:20when these you know, shocks to the system happen.
- 3:23Tyler and I previously working together seen the crazy inflows
- 3:27when you doing things the right way, there's a knowledge
- 3:31asymmetry and it starts to go out in the market as you wake up
- 3:34and find out your exchanges and let you take possession, you may
- 3:37not have any Bitcoin, actually sitting there.
- 3:40They may have a whole and so, and you Tyler probably been
- 3:43close to a lot of that, as well as being able to really talk
- 3:47through. And Marty mentioned it, a really
- 3:50interesting Thread about Silicon Valley and getting You know,
- 3:54Bitcoin, and maybe in the last that I think private Keys tie
- 3:57into that, because the idea of getting crypto, it's like, oh,
- 4:01it's fine. It's just another asset its own
- 4:03exchange. It's perfect fine.
- 4:04But the reality is, if you really going to understand
- 4:06what's happening here, you want to take possession of those
- 4:08keys. You want to figure out your
- 4:09custody model to have it more resilient than what Robin Hood
- 4:13would look like when you buy a stock or Bond and it just sits
- 4:15there. It's very different.
- 4:16And look, we like to say there's no bailouts in Bitcoin, so if
- 4:20you ever feel you can't print more Bitcoin if they're lost.
- 4:24And that's really the underlying philosophy behind it all.
- 4:27Yeah, it's like using Silicon Valley viewing crypto.
- 4:32As these assets that sit on exchanges, they can trade like
- 4:36they do a traditional stocks and bonds and other Financial
- 4:39assets. I think this week is
- 4:42particularly interesting because that is where all the focus is
- 4:45on two particular exchanges where a lot of these assets.
- 4:48It finance and coinbase. The SEC came out with Plaints
- 4:54against both, not exactly the same in each case with by Nance.
- 4:59I think the complaint is about unregistered offering,
- 5:03unregistered Securities commingling funds and then spoof
- 5:06trading as well has been levied against finance and then
- 5:10coinbase, I think the SEC is really honed in on they're
- 5:15staking service particularly in defining that as what they would
- 5:20deem to be a security. And so This is something that
- 5:25has been looming over the space if you will.
- 5:30And it's important to save like the space quote unquote because
- 5:34here I believe every individual on the show right now believes
- 5:37that there is a clean clean distinction between Bit Coin and
- 5:41crypto. And there's been a massive
- 5:45narrative battle that's been going on for the better part of
- 5:48a decade. Now within the space bitcoiners
- 5:51who are saying hey Bitcoin, It is where the signal is,
- 5:54everything else is somewhat of an affinity scam.
- 5:56In the exchanges, handling these assets and offering them to
- 6:00retail investors are number one. I would argue doing something a
- 6:06bit immoral because my opinion and I think objectively what
- 6:12history has shown us throughout the last decade is a lot of
- 6:15these assets are simply pump and up tokens that offer insiders
- 6:21quick exit or very. Very easy to dump on retail.
- 6:25And then number two, which is where things get a bit heated.
- 6:28And a lot of the, a lot of the contention on Twitter and online
- 6:37this week is stemmed from, is the fact that bitcoiners have
- 6:40been warning, these exchanges? Particularly like a, you're
- 6:44probably offering unregistered Securities to your customers.
- 6:47And at some point down the road, The Regulators are going to
- 6:51bring the hammer down and that is happened this week for
- 6:54finance and coinbase particularly, but this is a very
- 6:58big and Tangled yarn ball with a lot of nuance.
- 7:03Especially when you consider the fact that Bitcoin, a lot of
- 7:06bitcoiners lead towards a free market view of the world where
- 7:09people want to buy and sell tokens using their free will.
- 7:15They should be able to do that. But you have to Really separate
- 7:20that idea which I'm a big believer in if people want to go
- 7:25buy these assets and speculate on them, they should be able to
- 7:27do that. We have to separate that from
- 7:29the fact that we do live in a country with regulations with
- 7:35laws. May not like the laws but you
- 7:38can easily identify them and know they exist and point to the
- 7:43exchanges and say, hey, the SEC is probably going to come after
- 7:47you one day, they've been posturing.
- 7:49Like this for the better part of the decade and it's finally
- 7:52happened and it's created this massive contention in the in the
- 7:57space that bitcoiners are getting dragged into.
- 7:59That was a long diatribe. Just sort of set, the stage,
- 8:02Jessie will throw it to you. What are your thoughts on the se
- 8:06c--? S enforcement actions on finance
- 8:08and coinbase this week. Yeah so what you were just
- 8:12articulating made me think about how I like why why do these
- 8:17rules exist? Like why do why do we have the
- 8:19Howey test? And is there really any Merit
- 8:23to, you know, having classification of what's allowed
- 8:29when you're offering a security? And then you're making a
- 8:32distinction of what's not allowed and the reality is like
- 8:36without this without these distinctions, you end up with
- 8:40snake oil salesman, you end up with grifters, you know,
- 8:45promising the world and and Everybody that is foolish enough
- 8:51to believe them and you know, you can you can sort of imagine
- 8:56this happening. And in 1800s America people
- 9:01promising things that are not real and offering stocks and not
- 9:08read obviously not registering because because there was
- 9:11nothing to register at that point and that's what they're
- 9:14protecting against their, they're trying to make it so
- 9:16that you can't Can't just go trick grandma and and fool her
- 9:25and you know, investing in the next Google, when really there's
- 9:28no you're not going to do anything.
- 9:30So that's why we have these Securities laws and obviously,
- 9:34you could say like, you know, maybe maybe they do too much or
- 9:39maybe they're too restrictive, but the spirit of it is to like
- 9:43prevent grifting prevent scamming really and it's A
- 9:49sense. And that's what, the how we test
- 9:53is all about. And so, if you're running afoul
- 9:57of the Howey test, which is to say you're passing the Howey
- 10:00test because the Howey test is several tenants that, if you
- 10:04check one of those boxes, then you pass it because you are
- 10:08actually a security rather than not a security, and lo and
- 10:15behold all of these crypto assets out there, R are running
- 10:20a foul. They're passing the Howey test.
- 10:23And that means that they are really no different from some
- 10:28scammer in the 1800's promising, you know?
- 10:31Oh, I've drilled of drilled oil wells in in Texas, and you can
- 10:37invest now, and, and be a millionaire when actually, there
- 10:42was nothing and they were just scamming turns out that Century
- 10:47later that Crypto assets are spiritually similar to that kind
- 10:52of situation and that's obviously problematic for for
- 10:57the good of American citizens and not acceptable as a result
- 11:04of that. So you know that it's I think
- 11:07it's helpful to take it back to like what are these rules trying
- 11:11to protect against and then recognize it.
- 11:14Like, if you are triggering one of these classifications, Then
- 11:19then there you know it might be problematic for the good of
- 11:23America for the good of American citizens because you know, you
- 11:28can't promise the world and take Grandma's money and we don't
- 11:33want to live in a society like that.
- 11:35And yes, of course, there's ways in which overextends or goes too
- 11:40far. But the spirit of it is
- 11:43important to remember here. And and like when you think
- 11:47about it, Krypto, as, you know, the latest snake oil salesman
- 11:51Frontier. I think that's helpful, for me,
- 11:55at least to put it into perspective about, like what do
- 11:58we need to protect against as a society as a civilization and
- 12:03thankfully I, in my opinion, that's you see, is finally
- 12:06drawing that line. Yeah, well that brings into
- 12:13question something else to which is those in the crypto industry.
- 12:17Coinbase finance and others are basically coming out say hey,
- 12:22we've been asking for guidelines.
- 12:25We've been asking you SEC woman knocking on your door, been
- 12:27reaching out saying, hey, what do we need to do to be within
- 12:30compliance with the SEC to make sure that were above board and
- 12:35doing everything by the book in your eyes, and they would make
- 12:39the argument that the SEC hasn't really put a good foot forward.
- 12:44In terms of providing that guidance.
- 12:46That these exchanges, deem is necessary to operate within the
- 12:50letter of the law. Also, they're making the case
- 12:52that due to the lack of guidance.
- 12:54From the SEC, they've been sort of forced into this position
- 12:57where they're not in compliance. So they would posture that
- 13:01they've been sitting in limbo, begging for guidelines and rules
- 13:05that, that haven't been give it to them.
- 13:06Is there any Merit to this argument?
- 13:09In your opinion, Michael? Oil.
- 13:13I think there is I think that there's like an underlying
- 13:17fundamental issue with like the regulations the bureaucracy and
- 13:21the politicians, they all kind of like intertwined together and
- 13:23it's actually there's thinking about it at least for me it's
- 13:27the most fascinating part about all of this is How they can't
- 13:33get their shit together. Basically, on like a lining on,
- 13:38we know the SEC. And the cftc is basically at
- 13:42Arms to figure out who can govern, what?
- 13:46And what is a commodity, what's a security?
- 13:48And we know genzler, in nineteen at least bindings.
- 13:53His lawyers are saying that Gensler.
- 13:55I think was on the docket or requested or there was some
- 13:59discussion about become an advisor for my Nance. and we
- 14:04know, you know, to take the extent of Silicon Valley back
- 14:07into this or bring them back in is whether it's a 16z or we all
- 14:13remember that episode with the all in group and the getting in
- 14:17early on the pre-sale Salon Solana and dumping that the at
- 14:23the upper echelons of the like economic stack, they figured out
- 14:28a way because Venture already in itself has been like this Bucket
- 14:32or this whole of capital that's calling from sovereigns to you
- 14:35know, to effectively Venture firms and then to retail and,
- 14:39you know, this continue up, the stack of marking up prices and
- 14:41where's the exit liquidity coming from and that version of
- 14:45the world, basically found it on in crypto.
- 14:49And he found a way to basically Mainline that old product into
- 14:53this new crypto fast, know, within 12, 18 months, get early
- 14:56presale, Zelda, Zelda token don't bond retail, get your
- 14:59dollars, give it back to LP rinse and repeat.
- 15:01Pete. And part of that felt like that
- 15:03gave the cover for the past few years.
- 15:06Well, the marketing everything's up into the right to be able to
- 15:10whatever is done whether it's, you know, handshake deals or
- 15:12whatever to get the politicians, the, The Regulators everybody
- 15:15looking the other way. But as we know when the tide
- 15:18goes out, we find out who's swimming naked.
- 15:20And so while we're finding out exchanges or insolvent and
- 15:22people are bankrupt and all the things going on from the like
- 15:26mechanical sense of an exchange. There's also like on the regular
- 15:29side and who's getting paid and who's getting No, their hands
- 15:32Greece and what's happening there.
- 15:34And so it's kind of just it's more of like a fundamental issue
- 15:39with the US and everybody not necessarily being on the same
- 15:43page. I'm like what's actually
- 15:44happened here and everybody wanting their own stake of.
- 15:47How do they govern it? How who is regulated?
- 15:50Whose tax? And so I think it there's two
- 15:53parts of one. It's very difficult to build in
- 15:55the space and that's where, you know, we come at it from the
- 15:57angle of Bitcoin, only a commodity and all the things go
- 15:59along with it. But then, there's also just
- 16:01Macro structure of like American politics and making it very
- 16:06difficult for what is the individual?
- 16:09It's looking to build a productive business or asset and
- 16:11the amount of red tape that has to come through because of all
- 16:15the other things that go along, which similar to this agains are
- 16:18looking like the White Knight. But then we find out that he was
- 16:21trying to you know work with Finance all the way back to 2019
- 16:24and was sending them. I think there was a he went I
- 16:28think I want to say the Senate he went somewhere in DC and
- 16:31basically gave Finance or CZ. The heads-up of the whatever was
- 16:37explained to them before he even, but I think it was like to
- 16:40audit or say get your feedback before he went.
- 16:43So there's a lot of that and I think it all kind of intertwines
- 16:47to your point that there is some fundamental truth to they
- 16:52haven't been clear and it's created problems but at the same
- 16:55time I think that all of these groups would have claimed
- 16:59something to just be able to Continue to dump was effectively
- 17:03their bags on retail Market. Yeah, in my opinion, everybody's
- 17:10wrong here. Like the SEC, like you mentioned
- 17:12the SEC, the cftc have been fighting over who gets to
- 17:14regulate all this stuff and they've been opaque in a bit
- 17:18slow to move. Probably on purpose to get get
- 17:22these exchanges. And these token teams in this
- 17:26precarious position, where it looks like.
- 17:30The SE C's hand is forced to come Regulate but they sort of
- 17:32let this go on for so long without providing Clarity that
- 17:36they are to blame to a certain extent and then on the other
- 17:39side with the exchanges and the toking offer and offerings.
- 17:45That's I think that's what gets bitcoiners the most mad.
- 17:47Because like I said, earlier bitcoiners, do believe in free
- 17:50markets or I'm not going to speak for all bik winners but
- 17:52there's a large subset of bitcoiners who believe in free
- 17:56markets and if people want to make these decisions speculate
- 18:00on these assets, they should be able to To do so, with that
- 18:02being said, there's also a moral argument on the other side, if
- 18:07you're going to offer these tokens.
- 18:09If you launch these tokens, if you're going to put them on your
- 18:11exchange, there's somewhat of a moral burden that comes with
- 18:15that as well because as we know on this show, you don't really
- 18:21need a blockchain for anything. In fact, blockchain I would make
- 18:25the argument only works for money and if you have Bitcoin
- 18:30working As well as it has for the last Fourteen and a half
- 18:35years there. There simply is no, neither
- 18:38other need for blockchain. And that's the thing, I think
- 18:40frustrates. A lot of bitcoiners is a lot of
- 18:42these tokens again, our Affinity scams that are selling the
- 18:45world, but really have no fundamental reason to exist.
- 18:52They are not necessary to perform the function that their
- 18:57marketing that they're performing.
- 18:59We've had many waves of these These assets, whether it be back
- 19:03in 2013 to 2014, the the early proof of stake coins, the multi
- 19:09script algo coins that came out and then in 2017 you know the
- 19:13icos that came out of recovery company needed.
- 19:17A token associated with it and a blockchain predominantly running
- 19:20on a theory. Mm.
- 19:21And then you get to 2020 2021, you defy the Ft.
- 19:26Boom. And this is all culminated in
- 19:29this enforcement action that we're seeing This week from the
- 19:32SEC. But at the end of the day, these
- 19:35tokens I would argued do not need to exist.
- 19:39They do not provide the utility. They say they're providing.
- 19:43They are inherently centralized due to their issuance and the
- 19:47concentration of the supply that exists in a small group of hands
- 19:52and the ability to change these protocols on a web in that.
- 19:57So that that's like the weird sort of conflict that bitcoiners
- 20:01feel is Yes, they believe in free markets but they also want
- 20:04to call out scammers when they see them and that's I think what
- 20:08a lot of bitcoiners view the the crypto world as is a bunch of
- 20:11scammers just trying to grift to get quick exit liquidity.
- 20:14So they can get rich and wipe their hands clean because that's
- 20:18what history has shown us. There's very few tokens outside
- 20:21of Bitcoin that have really stuck around and actually
- 20:28operated for longer than five or six years at the rims.
- 20:31Probably the only But even that comes with massive problems,
- 20:34they're they're trading. Their narrative on the go, not a
- 20:37flip it to Tyler. Is there anything yet to add to
- 20:39this? No, just to go up your point.
- 20:42It's like the, you know, that's the Bitcoins marketing
- 20:45department, right? Is kind of moving in the shadows
- 20:48because you take people who let's say Gen-X husband and wife
- 20:53couple from Virginia, right? And they got into the 2017
- 20:58crypto Bull Run and we're buying He token that would go up but
- 21:03then over time it's these news headlines that are coming out
- 21:07about everything Bitcoin. It's, you know, these ticker
- 21:11symbols in the litigation that are everything but BTC it is
- 21:16aetherium roadmaps containing technobabble that these people
- 21:20just don't understand. And so and a long enough time
- 21:22Horizon, I do think things Converge on to bitcoin.
- 21:25So, you know, it's like all of this stuff regardless of SEC or
- 21:31the safe. See, it's like it's we're going
- 21:34to win on a long enough time scale because these projects are
- 21:38shooting themselves in the foot and you know, I think that's
- 21:41that was always going to be the situation.
- 21:44I'd love to rely on people doing their own research and finding
- 21:48out that a certain token is really just a landing page with,
- 21:51you know, 20 year old CEO who stands to gain a bunch but
- 21:56people just don't take that dive.
- 21:58So I think part of the answer is just going to be, you know, a
- 22:01slow bleed and and time scale necessary for people to find
- 22:06that coin. Yeah, that's actually one of the
- 22:09things that I, when I was referencing about the, the
- 22:12battle in the cftc SEC, there's the last component that I think
- 22:15adds to the underlying mugginess of it is the politicians not
- 22:21wanting to legitimize it. And so there's a recent bill
- 22:24that came out between McHenry from Montana Thomson Hill that
- 22:29the net of it, is that the CC would oversee anything.
- 22:34That would be deemed a security and they have obvious, you know,
- 22:36test for that and requirements on the digital asset side, and
- 22:40then proof of work /, you know, BTC on the cftc and give a clear
- 22:44delineation, but there's a direct quote from there.
- 22:47That says, one of them was like, let it burn and the other one it
- 22:53was a, it's all, it's all bullshit from the, from the
- 22:55Montana Democratic senator, Jon Tester with the idea that they
- 23:00do not want to Provide Clarity or a framework for individuals
- 23:06because you can imagine a world like that.
- 23:07To Tyler's point, if you had a clear delineation yet
- 23:10understanding that one is a commodity, one cannot be created
- 23:13by individuals manipulated and all the things that go along
- 23:15with it. It kind of takes some of that
- 23:17murkiness out of understanding what you're buying or at least
- 23:20what you're not mine. So I think that's just a
- 23:23comport, a component important component to recognize as we go
- 23:27and we have these discussions and kind of ties into some of
- 23:29the stuff we plan to talk about. Tyler's thread and Silicon
- 23:33Valley. It's like, you know,
- 23:34fundamentally understand what's happening because of that, they
- 23:37maybe not their fault, they just don't know the difference
- 23:38between, you know, token that screw tomorrow and Bitcoin these
- 23:42at the same. They're looking at it as a
- 23:43digital currency or digital asset.
- 23:46Yeah, I'd love to build on that to of like, coming back to the
- 23:51Howey test of. Maybe I have a little bit more
- 23:54appreciation for the spirit of the Howey test, then then the
- 23:59average like Bitcoin maximalist. Because so that was, that was
- 24:05from a different era of like that was from 1946 and the, how
- 24:11we test the, it's kind of incredible that the Howey test
- 24:14catches No assets in the wrong and for that matter, that
- 24:20Bitcoin was quite clearly deliberately designed to not run
- 24:26afoul of the Howey test. Because if you, so let's look,
- 24:31let's talk about what the how we test tenants are, right?
- 24:33So it's an investment of money with an expectation of profits.
- 24:40In a and it's an investment of money in a common Enterprise.
- 24:46And profit comes from the efforts of a promoter or third
- 24:51party. So, you know, when you think
- 24:54about aetherium, you've got a leadership team, a core group of
- 25:00developers that have a pre mine and their efforts are going to
- 25:06generate, you know, a brighter future for aetherium and drive
- 25:12the price up and, you know that Video of the taluk talking about
- 25:17how their efforts are going to cause the price of aetherium to
- 25:21go up over time. So that's a security right there
- 25:26and even though the how we test was made in 1946 and you know,
- 25:30obviously before the internet before any of this was possible
- 25:34or conceivable it was designed in an era.
- 25:37When like frankly, I think that lawmakers were were acting in
- 25:43the honest interest of Citizens, a little bit more than they are
- 25:46now. And I think it was a
- 25:48well-designed test to catch shit like aetherium while allowing
- 25:53for something like Bitcoin. Which, when you go through those
- 25:57four tenants, there is no expectation of profit, and I
- 26:02think Satoshi, quite deliberately stepped back and
- 26:05part because, you know, people weren't profiting off of his
- 26:10efforts, or you know, any core group's efforts.
- 26:13I mean, buddy, who Any kind of pre mind there was no pre mind,
- 26:17you know, you could make the argument that Satoshi was there
- 26:19and kind of advantage to to mime from day one because he knew
- 26:24about it. But, you know, that's as strong
- 26:26of an argument as you can make. And then he steps back to ensure
- 26:29that there is no expectation of profit based off of his efforts.
- 26:36And so you know, the contrast between etherium as representing
- 26:41all of altcoins all every other cryptocurrency.
- 26:44Ides Bitcoin, basically, and Bitcoin is completely Stark in
- 26:49terms of the Howey test. And so in that sense and we've
- 26:53gotten increasing Clarity from Regulators that Bitcoin is a
- 26:58commodity and nobody's coming after Bitcoin.
- 27:01We we have these quotes from Gary Gensler and the head of the
- 27:04cftc saying that saying that Bitcoin is a commodity and as
- 27:10for everything else You know, Gary Gensler makes the case that
- 27:15everything else is a security cftc.
- 27:18Had says nobody's coming after after Bitcoin.
- 27:22So Bitcoin is a commodity but everything else out there.
- 27:27Is a security be so long as so long as they have a team working
- 27:31on it, trying to catch up to their competitors, which is
- 27:36everybody because everybody is behind from Bitcoin, everybody's
- 27:39trying to spin up a narrative trying to out compete based on
- 27:41technological innovation while not realizing that this is
- 27:45actually about money and, and immutability not about
- 27:49Innovation and change. And so by that, very nature,
- 27:54since you have a team, trying to work on something and trying, To
- 27:57drive the price of the certain coin up and their their War
- 28:01chest. Their bankroll is rooted in the
- 28:04pre mine of their own coin. That is a security and it's
- 28:09Crystal Clear to bitcoiners because we've spent time
- 28:12thinking about this but most people come into crypto and
- 28:17think. Okay, so Bitcoins around and
- 28:21it's been a loud and all these other things are around and
- 28:24they've been allowed so I guess they're all good.
- 28:27And you know coinbase offers them in coinbase has a Super
- 28:30Bowl commercial so how risky could it really be?
- 28:33This is all on the up-and-up and and people aren't realizing that
- 28:38this is a bunch of entrepreneurs or or grifters or scammers
- 28:45trying to create a currency that they control and sell it to
- 28:49people and there's a lot of money to be made there.
- 28:51So people have acted first and ask in are asking questions
- 28:56second. And that's how you grow a big
- 28:58company. Like coinbase turbine ants in
- 29:01the matter of a few years by creating this casino for people
- 29:06to get rich and trade and most people get rekt.
- 29:10It's on the, on the margin. It is a is a net destructive
- 29:17Endeavor, for individual wealth. Whereas Bitcoin is designed to
- 29:23be different because all you have to do is hold for four
- 29:26years. And your purchasing power
- 29:28reliably increases. And so for everybody, in Bitcoin
- 29:33it's been quite clear for as long as I've spent time,
- 29:37thinking about, like, what, why is Bitcoin different from the
- 29:40rest of these things? And, for most of the world,
- 29:43they've been sleepwalking into this trap that they didn't
- 29:46realize. Had not yet been sorted out and
- 29:53I think we're entering that era of a reckoning for For
- 29:57unlicensed, Securities in the digital asset space and it's
- 30:01over. Do you know you can, you can
- 30:04call it status. So you can say that the SEC
- 30:07doesn't have a role in anything and we should have purely free
- 30:11markets. But, you know, I think the
- 30:14spirit of the Howey test is is in the interest of preserving
- 30:19Grandma's dignity, rather than allowing her to get scammed out
- 30:23of all her money and And I think that that hammer is finally
- 30:29coming down now. And you know it, you can see you
- 30:34could easily make the case that it's silly for us to be rooting
- 30:37on the state here. But I think it's it's routing on
- 30:42the the enforcement of Level Playing Field and and putting an
- 30:50end to the exploitation of the rules as they They are, so it's
- 30:59time and it's I think it's finally here.
- 31:03Yeah, it's that. I mean, I Trend more towards,
- 31:08like, the free market stuff, like, I don't like the SEC.
- 31:10I don't like the government. I don't think they're efficient,
- 31:13I don't think they're and I should, I should add that like,
- 31:18the spirit of the 1946 stuff. Like, I think it's, it makes
- 31:22sense. And over the decades, we've
- 31:25crept towards an increasingly like overreaching version of SEC
- 31:30and Regulators in general. So, you know, That has become
- 31:35more of a problem versus the original intent of it.
- 31:39And that's, that's the nature of the state, right?
- 31:41But but I see the purity of it and I appreciate it for that but
- 31:46it has its major problems in terms of enforcement.
- 31:49Yeah, I think there's a good opportunity here to provide some
- 31:54back story on how finance and coinbase.
- 31:57The two exchanges in question this week.
- 32:00Got to where they are two very different stories.
- 32:03Art with coinbase because it's older.
- 32:05I mean, coinbase started out as one of the first consumer
- 32:09exchanges consumer apps, where you can easily go and buy and
- 32:13sell Bitcoin. It was first place, I bought
- 32:16Bitcoin and it was an incredible product.
- 32:19In the beginning when it was simply you can buy and sell
- 32:22Bitcoin. It was the best way to get on
- 32:24board it on the Bitcoin. And at that point back, then,
- 32:282013 2014 Brian Armstrong seem to have really gotten Bitcoin,
- 32:32he Sure that Bitcoin would scale the side chains that all coins.
- 32:36There's Tweet back in the 2015 or 2016 where he said all coins
- 32:39are if any scans we should be focused on scaling Bitcoin via
- 32:43side chains in other layers. But somewhere along the way, I
- 32:46would, I would I believe the pressures from The Venture
- 32:52capitalists backing coinbase, things got corrupted and they
- 32:57saw. I would call the siren calls of
- 32:59the fees and the profits that come from enabling The trading
- 33:03of old coins and they went down that road where they essentially
- 33:07became an altcoin Casino obviously coinbase IP owed a
- 33:11couple years ago, a few years ago and has been somewhat of an
- 33:17above the board operation. Since its Inception back in
- 33:212012, its vc-backed came up in Silicon Valley.
- 33:26They really example of American innovation around Bitcoin in a A
- 33:33that that came up in did things above board to a certain extent.
- 33:38Comparatively when I say, comparatively compared to buying
- 33:42an swear by Nance, essentially filled the hole that was created
- 33:47when bitrex I believe or Palani X which were to altcoin
- 33:52exchanges back in 2016 2017 they were forced to add KY caml
- 33:59restrictions and so in the wild west of altcoin trading I'm back
- 34:03in the 2013 to 2017 era. The trend was that you would
- 34:07have an altcoin exchange pop up and they would allow you to
- 34:10trade without any kyc or am L compliance.
- 34:13You would simply put in an email address and you would be able to
- 34:16load your account up with Bitcoin and then trade into
- 34:21altcoins without giving the exchange.
- 34:24Any of your personal information in the way it worked was a new
- 34:28exchange no kyc a mellow pop up. It would start out with
- 34:32relatively low. Look, Today and low traction.
- 34:36But eventually everybody would flood to that exchange.
- 34:39And then once they got to a certain point of popularity, The
- 34:44Regulators, they would draw the ire of regulators.
- 34:47And the regulators and say, hey, like, you need to employ kyc a
- 34:51male compliance, start taking information on your customers.
- 34:53So we can, we can track them. And soon as that would happen,
- 34:57people would leave that exchange.
- 34:59Another would pop up. And so that's how by Nan started
- 35:01when bitrex, I believe. Earp Lonnie x, one of those two
- 35:05thrusts kyc, KML on their users by net sort of filled that void
- 35:09in came up as the exchange, no kyc, a Melody income trade here,
- 35:14without giving your personal information to us, eventually,
- 35:17they reach, massive scale. They're one of the biggest
- 35:19exchange is probably the largest Exchange in the world.
- 35:22They have since added kyc a male compliance, but I think they are
- 35:27the exchange that bucked. The trend of sort of seeding.
- 35:33The no kyc a mill exchanges in their wake.
- 35:36I think it got to a certain point in 2017 where Regulators
- 35:39were all over it. And I think Finance was the last
- 35:42one through the door that was able to accept themselves with
- 35:45no KY caml. And they've since grown to a
- 35:48massive exchange and they're extremely popular all around the
- 35:53world. And so that's how we got to
- 35:57where we are with these two particular exchanges.
- 35:59Going base, was the Silicon Valley, Ali consumer-facing app
- 36:04here in the US that blew up and made it very easy and then
- 36:06probably got corrupted by The Lure of profits from the fees
- 36:11that would come from, allowing users to trade shit coins in the
- 36:14by Nance sort of Rose From the Ashes of Palani acts and bitrex
- 36:20forcing kyc a about on their users.
- 36:24I do you think there's a there's a fascinating Thought on the
- 36:35there's very similar if you think about like what we're
- 36:37talking about offering of Securities and bucket shops and
- 36:40you know all this stuff. But I fundamentally think
- 36:42they're different businesses from a like efficiency
- 36:46standpoint and the entrepreneur like I would say that cz's,
- 36:49100x, entrepreneur than Brian. And from the number of
- 36:54employees, the amount of Revenue and net profits, all the way
- 36:57down to I'm pretty confident, especially in the The Bitcoin
- 37:01space people understand sees a capitalist and he knew exactly
- 37:06what he was doing and he was playing within within a world.
- 37:10That was, it was great and it was it, right?
- 37:12People lost money. But if we go to the other side
- 37:14where I like chalk, the coin basis and block size of the
- 37:17world, I fundamentally don't think they have any idea on what
- 37:20one what they're doing to what were the space or what is
- 37:24actually happening. And you can go back to you know
- 37:27Brian being at Airbnb and the aside.
- 37:30Idea of growth at all costs and top-line revenue.
- 37:33What is the look like? And so that thought of, you
- 37:35know, we need to add tokens and we needed to spread ourselves
- 37:38too thin, and you think about, you know, their market cap
- 37:40compared to the number of employees there.
- 37:43It looks very similar to an Uber that is just an unprofitable
- 37:47business and you think about it, how insane that could be to be
- 37:49an unprofitable business to be the first exchange the largest
- 37:52and all you had to do. You could print money and for
- 37:55some reason they do not and then you go over to see Z and you
- 37:58watch and see what they did. And like you mentioned From the
- 38:01Ashes and produce this, you know, what was the number like 8
- 38:05billion? I think that was like rumored to
- 38:07be moving around and like I think it was over a billion like
- 38:10net, net profit, in 20, maybe even higher than that.
- 38:14But the core idea is a that was with like I want to say five
- 38:16hundred or thousand core full-time employees so it's just
- 38:20an interesting Dynamic on. As you think about the
- 38:23entrepreneurs build in this space as well, block, line
- 38:26coinbase feel very different than then finance and Just how
- 38:30they their approach, this whole Market.
- 38:33Yeah, well finances is essentially employed the the
- 38:37pirate mentality there, like a pirate ship of a company and as
- 38:42the SEC levied in their complaint like like Finance has
- 38:49many offices all throughout the world I think they're domiciled
- 38:51officially in Singapore and so they do operate in this gray
- 38:55area and within that gray area they have it's hard to confirm
- 39:00The people have been speculating that they've been doing pretty
- 39:07pretty like questioningly their dubious things where they're be
- 39:13washed rating. They have their own token BMB
- 39:16and there's a lot of speculation that they're pumping the volumes
- 39:18to that to make it look like there's more activity going on
- 39:21there than there actually is. And So within that gray area,
- 39:24there are certainly using the levers they have at their
- 39:28disposal to just sort of pump. Metrics and pump markets and
- 39:32drive. Look what he's a lot of
- 39:34speculation, but I think it's speculation.
- 39:37That is that is pointing in the right direction towards towards
- 39:41some signal there. And it's a little more than
- 39:44speculation to because there appears to be like quite a
- 39:47shells company structure with Finance where CZ holy controls
- 39:56some subsidiary companies that are creating on Handsome like
- 40:02it's really reminiscent of FTX and Alameda and the connection
- 40:07between those two entities. Wear SPF was a 90% owner of
- 40:11Alameda and they were using FTX with with unfair advantage in
- 40:18terms of not having liquidation rules and also seeing order flow
- 40:24in real time. And in order to trade against
- 40:27FTX is customers the same thing appears to be happening.
- 40:30Opening with Finance at the direction of CZ the CEO.
- 40:35And so that really is kind of pirate, marauding buccaneering
- 40:40and, and taking from customers, which is how you grow, a very
- 40:48successful company like that in such a short amount of time in
- 40:52in this gray area of what's allowed and what's not.
- 40:56But yeah they the the level of Sketchiness between by Nance and
- 41:03coinbase is pretty Stark. Coinbase appears to have really
- 41:08just been offering products that the SEC is is deeming, security
- 41:15are deeming securities and that's a long list of pretty
- 41:20much everything that's on bitcoin.
- 41:22Whereas CZ has been engaging in Sam bakeman, freed Style.
- 41:31Catchiness it appears that that is speculation at this point,
- 41:34but yeah, there are different world.
- 41:38I mean I would push back a little on the like one to be
- 41:44clear. They're all like shit heads and
- 41:46they're all taken a bunch of people's money and like that.
- 41:49There's nobody didn't know. I'm more of like a Target as far
- 41:52as like the level of sophistication from a pure like
- 41:56entrepreneurial /. Marty mentioned Pirates and like
- 41:59pirate is generally looked at as Bad thing and I would make the
- 42:03claim or thesis that in the future world more.
- 42:05People are going to look like this easy model and not to say
- 42:08the sketchiness more of being everywhere.
- 42:10And nowhere, at once, being able to leverage at scale growth and
- 42:14number of individuals, you think about coinbase having the
- 42:18Stanford or whoever, you know, person coming from their school,
- 42:22and their pay them x amount of dollars to sit there.
- 42:24I think it was rumor, their Chief product officer got paid
- 42:25fifty million dollars, like that was nowhere near how CZ skill on
- 42:30the other. ER side of that.
- 42:32It's the little known secret that all these exchanges, all
- 42:35know that they're each wash trading or summer wash trading
- 42:39to keep the volume on others. Very similar to, if you've ever
- 42:42heard the rumors of like tether even when they didn't have it
- 42:46fully collateralized, it's in everybody's best interest to
- 42:49pretend. Like it is fully collateralized
- 42:51because all of these exchanges that's like they're they're you
- 42:53know, in and out mechanism and so even if it's at like 90
- 42:56percent 90 cents on the dollar it's in nobody's best interest
- 43:00to bring that up. And so I think like, for sure,
- 43:04it's this easy versus FTX is starkly, different music.
- 43:07They didn't have any money, finances, still processing
- 43:11withdrawals, the trading against I think that is again, going
- 43:14back to the beach. It has in, this is just like how
- 43:15they make profits, but I don't think like coinbase, they know
- 43:19that Charlie Litecoin, you know, rug pull that happened and what
- 43:23was that 18 and then we know, you know, whether it's like open
- 43:27sea or these other, I think open, see the guys went to jail
- 43:30but I think It even came out with coinbase that before they
- 43:32listed. They can show there was reports
- 43:34run on the pump and the token so like I don't know you know again
- 43:39they're all shed but it's just like coin basis is in my mind no
- 43:43better than than Finance bad to my mother actually worse because
- 43:49they just like pretended to pay off the politicians where you
- 43:52had this other guy just say, like f it, you know, I'm going
- 43:54to use the tools and things that I can do, and I'm not gonna like
- 43:59bend the knee and we all need this.
- 44:01Is coming. You know, Matt talks about all
- 44:02the time. It's like you know sees he's
- 44:04just riding around out there and so yeah I would I would I would
- 44:08agree with that because it's also really prevalent in the
- 44:11marketing for these two firms, right?
- 44:12You go to like coin basis website and it's their tagline
- 44:15right now. It's it's a you know, the future
- 44:18of money is here where the most trusted place for people to buy
- 44:22buy and sell and manage crypto. They're like you know, Google
- 44:26meta tags that are if you Google coin basis, like by crypto would
- 44:30trust, right? So they're kind of like layering
- 44:32this this veneer of almost masquerading as this really
- 44:37trustful institution and not as basically a crypto Casino.
- 44:40So at least, you know, again to Michael's Point like they're all
- 44:43shit heads but at least by Nance appears to be a little bit more
- 44:48and I don't want to use this word to the full extent of what
- 44:51it means, but a little bit more honest with what they're trying
- 44:53to do. It she go to you go to buy an
- 44:54ant's and it's you know, trade like a pro.
- 44:58It's like, all right. Well, at least you're telling us
- 45:00what your What you're offering instead of putting on this this
- 45:03mask of trust? Yeah.
- 45:05In one thing on the like mac side of that in this is
- 45:08something I don't know if we talked about and it wasn't
- 45:10really. A parent was a Gemini that was
- 45:13like the epitome of what was the slogan like institutional.
- 45:17I were like regulate us or Regulators hard or whatever it
- 45:19was. But they, they they have a
- 45:23crypto needs rules? Yeah, cryptic Krypton.
- 45:26He's rules in the, in the week of I, this is again ties into.
- 45:30I don't know if we want to get To them this poverty.
- 45:31I thought it was very like awesome framing that Balaji had
- 45:36with Marty on red blue and gray because I like I can just like
- 45:41like everything I've had that without having it heard in my
- 45:44mind. When you look at an individual
- 45:46like red blue gray, and I would say, CZ, gray, Brian Blue, Max
- 45:50blue blue with the check. So just like and the the idea is
- 45:58like the Winkle. Why?
- 45:58The complete blue like they got Bitcoin.
- 46:01Only like, just like just like Chum other whoever, but they
- 46:03didn't actually understand what was happening Bitcoin.
- 46:05So they played the game and trying to get the ETF and trying
- 46:08to do it. And then they rub themselves
- 46:10because they offered a burn product, and they try to
- 46:13legitimize it and had all these financial advisors using them.
- 46:15And then they put all their clients funds in Genesis and now
- 46:18their financial advisers can't get their clients funds in their
- 46:20ever supposed to be playing on the up and up.
- 46:22Until this point at least likes, easy was like a trade, 100x,
- 46:25leverage like, you know, use a VPN like, yeah, of course.
- 46:27It's sketchy. But, you know, you're getting
- 46:29rubbed and get rug in the business.
- 46:31The most beautiful part about all of it.
- 46:33Nobody's ever not been able to take their Bitcoin off of
- 46:36Finance in its it just made me think of it reminds me of it.
- 46:40Maybe say never. If they haven't halted
- 46:41withdrawals, they've slowed the process down by like forcing you
- 46:46to redo kyc a amount. So there but mainly like they
- 46:50have Bitcoin like they at least to this exact point.
- 46:53They have Bitcoin in a reminds me of bit but Max like bit, Max
- 46:58had. And this is the beauty of this
- 46:59ties in with next, it at the right.
- 47:01Yeah, that makes it the right way three or four, multi say you
- 47:04needed three everyday they process it with process
- 47:06withdrawals. All the way to like Arthur being
- 47:08in handcuffs at one of the other guys like being and house arrest
- 47:11and they could still process withdrawals like pure pirate.
- 47:15Sure. Maybe you shouldn't be trading
- 47:16but they did what they said they were going to do.
- 47:19Yeah. It's a really good point of like
- 47:22there's there's legality and and being a pirate.
- 47:25And there's also an element of like entrepreneurial hustle and
- 47:30like Building a business through offering things that people are
- 47:36one in terms of products and like, Arthur and button CZ have
- 47:39done that exceptionally well. So there's there's legality,
- 47:43there's entrepreneurial hustle and then there's deception,
- 47:46which I think you guys are right?
- 47:47The coinbase has subtly been the worst of the bunch, like, in
- 47:52terms of deceiving people, and, and misleading people into
- 47:57believing, they're there at the trustworthy source of
- 47:59information and Reliable trustworthy place to come in and
- 48:05get exposure to this new asset class.
- 48:08When in reality, they're no different because they make
- 48:11their money by people chasing altcoins because the more you
- 48:14trade, the more trading commission coinbase and all
- 48:18these other companies get and your you guys are right that the
- 48:22coinbase was deceptive in what they did in terms of trying to
- 48:28encourage that when when you've got a bright Ian Armstrong, I
- 48:31found the Tweet so it's one of those unbelievable tweets.
- 48:35That is worth articulating variant.
- 48:39Put in the slack so you can throw it up.
- 48:41Okay? Here all a route.
- 48:46Tweeted it out yesterday. So I will put it in the slack
- 48:54here. Hold on.
- 48:55But it you know this is from 2015.
- 48:57This is February 2015. And in Brian Armstrong's mine,
- 49:02it was clear. It was already clear that.
- 49:05You know what? Our who's the winner here.
- 49:08It's it is Bitcoin and that's deadly.
- 49:14Over and done and we should focus on bitcoin.
- 49:17So I sent send it to the slack. And here's the quote of this is
- 49:22Brian Armstrong tweeting in February 2015, Ripple stellar
- 49:27and altcoins are all a distraction Bitcoin is way too
- 49:31far ahead. We should be focused on bitcoin
- 49:34and side chains. And I feel like so often when
- 49:39were complaining about coinbase as bitcoiners people say, Oh,
- 49:44those are just the salty bitcoiners like, oh, they wish
- 49:47that that people hadn't moved on to, the more exciting altcoins
- 49:51that are out there. And, you know, they want, the
- 49:53focus is still be on bitcoin. But then you see a tweet like
- 49:56this from Brian Armstrong in 2015.
- 49:58He got it. He understood, you know, there
- 50:00was a reason why he was early is because he, well, he worked in
- 50:07Argentina for a little bit. And so he had experience with,
- 50:12you know, seeing how Now, that Society had been terribly
- 50:17damaged by inflation and and therefore the value proposition
- 50:23of Bitcoin jumped out at him, you know, we all have some
- 50:26reason some mixture of reasons why Bitcoin makes sense to us.
- 50:32And so, if you're in Bitcoin right now, you are early and
- 50:36there's some combination of factors from your life.
- 50:41That has resulted in Bitcoin making sense to you before 99%
- 50:46of the world. And that was true for Brian
- 50:48Armstrong because he had this visceral first-hand experience
- 50:51of seeing the damage of inflation.
- 50:53So he got Bitcoin and he and he was excited about Bitcoin enough
- 50:58to leave his job and start a company selling Bitcoin to
- 51:02people. But then the profit motive of,
- 51:07you know, what, it's great when we sell Bitcoin to people one
- 51:09time and we Take a 2% cut which is what they take.
- 51:12They take a 2% fee. What?
- 51:14Every time you do anything on on coinbase it's great.
- 51:20When we take a 12 percent fee one time selling people Bitcoin
- 51:24but it's even better if we can get people to buy that Bitcoin,
- 51:27take the 2% fee and then encourage them to explore.
- 51:31What else is out there? Because there's so much exciting
- 51:33Innovation and you might want to hold some Ripple, you might want
- 51:37to have some Litecoin and every time people jump around between
- 51:40These different assets. We take a 2% cut and that profit
- 51:44motive crapped in and changed changed.
- 51:47Brian Armstrong, from from being someone, who was a Bitcoin
- 51:53Enthusiast who was trying to help people get exposure to
- 51:56Bitcoin in in a regulatory compliant way and and frankly, a
- 52:01great user interface through with coinbase and that warped
- 52:08into, you know, like all these These platforms a crypto Casino
- 52:13where they make money when you stay at the table and so, yeah,
- 52:19you guys are right that, that coinbase deceived on a different
- 52:24level than then B, Max or Finance.
- 52:30Did I do think there is kind of a spectrum of the potential
- 52:35degree of P, legality of activities between, you know,
- 52:39FTX at the Extreme because there was literally a 10 billion
- 52:42dollar fraud, but they perpetuated perpetrated.
- 52:46And on the other side is coinbase.
- 52:51Who I think has been trying to do things within, you know,
- 52:56what's legally allowable because they are kind of the the Silicon
- 53:01Valley version of a crypto casino.
- 53:05But of course, they've been deceptive in terms of what
- 53:09they've been marketing. Ooh, and then the middle there
- 53:12is finance who has been that, you know, you kind of admire the
- 53:18buccaneer spirit and and the entrepreneurial chops.
- 53:22It's unbelievable. What Susie has built, but very
- 53:26much in a legal gray area in end trading against their own.
- 53:30It appears that they've been heavily trading against their
- 53:33own customers, which is not cool, but it is not a ten
- 53:38billion dollar Ponzi scheme like f, Ex did.
- 53:42Yeah. And we're talking a lot in the
- 53:44context of coinbase of it, being the Silicon Valley darling and
- 53:49being one of the Darlings in Silicon Valley comes with a lot
- 53:52of pressure from the capital providers backing you in the
- 53:56Venture space and I guess is a good segue into the thread that
- 53:59you wrote that we mentioned earlier.
- 54:00Tyler about Silicon Valley, not being able to grok Bitcoin and
- 54:05obviously Jesse you wrote your, your inability, the yuppies and
- 54:10ability T to grok Bitcoin. A few years ago that turns 3 in
- 54:14August, but Tyler, I think is a good time to really turn to
- 54:18like, all right? There's coinbase particularly
- 54:21they're definitely getting a lot of pressure from their backers
- 54:24saying hey look at all this out here like why are you focused on
- 54:27bitcoin? Only like you need to add all
- 54:29these coins is what is missing? What connection is missing for
- 54:34your typical, Silicon Valley, venture capitalist or
- 54:37entrepreneur to really Croc Bitcoin.
- 54:39What's going on here? Yeah, I definitely recommend,
- 54:43you know, listeners go check out Jessie's article about the
- 54:46Yuppie Elite misunderstanding or failing, to crack Bitcoin as
- 54:49well. Puts a lot more eloquently, but
- 54:52I was trying to convey in my Twitter thread is that, you
- 54:54know, I think it's all deeply rooted in just trust in the
- 54:57system at the end of the day, but that thread was inspired by
- 55:00a Memorial Day weekend that I spent with close family members
- 55:05up in the Midwest. And, you know, my uncle's great,
- 55:09you know, great guy really smart.
- 55:11You know, kind of a beneficiary of Silicon Valley success over
- 55:14the past 20 years. And as brilliant of a guy, as I
- 55:20think he is whenever we engage in conversations about Bitcoin,
- 55:23it just doesn't guess Inspire him as much as if I were to use.
- 55:30You know, the d word democratize Finance with a dow or some, you
- 55:34know, crap like that. That's what would get his
- 55:37attention. Instead of talking about, you
- 55:39know the most powerful. Money that the world's ever seen
- 55:42in Bitcoin. And so it's like I wrote the
- 55:45thread kind of thinking like what are the top three reasons
- 55:48why folks like like my uncle ironically named Uncle Sam
- 55:53right? Which I thought was kind of
- 55:54interesting given that the third point and my thread is politics
- 55:58in America but the three reasons that I boiled it down to was
- 56:02one. Bitcoin doesn't have this this
- 56:06one Durkin founder, founder type that it It's so much different
- 56:12than your average Airbnb or like yo, classic Silicon Valley
- 56:17darling child unicorn. There's no team, right?
- 56:20It's this open source. Ethos with cypherpunks and it's
- 56:22open source code. And so that's like kind of one
- 56:26thing. There's no Paul Graham
- 56:28mentoring, a y, combinator Bitcoin project right.
- 56:33Then for the second reason was it's just apathy right?
- 56:37You know if you were a Silicon Valley Elite and you are you
- 56:40have a cushy A check and you really don't need to think
- 56:44deeply about protecting yourself from inflation or how
- 56:49argentinians can you should be able to save their hard-earned
- 56:53Savings in a currency. That's not perpetually.
- 56:56Devalued like if you just don't have to face these problems and
- 56:59it becomes less of an issue for you.
- 57:01So apathy there's no founder. And then, of course, politics in
- 57:05America, right? So looking Valley is the bluest
- 57:07of the blue when you're reading the New York Times every day and
- 57:10this again Ties back to Marty's episode with Balaji is like, if
- 57:13you are being fed this information every day and all of
- 57:17a sudden it's not just food blogs, or travel blogs.
- 57:20It's like constantly jamming information down your throat
- 57:22about about Bitcoin, where these, authors at the New York
- 57:26Times, don't actually do their own research.
- 57:28They don't put boots on the ground.
- 57:29They just kind of write about what they think about.
- 57:31You combine all that together, and it's just this stew of a
- 57:36complete misunderstanding. But then you look at the
- 57:39coinbase, kind of the, the In it.
- 57:42They kind of the Bitcoin presence in Silicon Valley is
- 57:45coinbase. And I think the deception we
- 57:46were talking about goes a layer deeper because as soon as your
- 57:50coinbase and you start introducing all coins because we
- 57:53have that profit motive now, you know, you were inspiring, these
- 57:57Stanford graduates in 2017. 2018.
- 58:00These brilliant Engineers to work on.
- 58:03What's, you know, a project that's going to get, hopefully
- 58:05listed on coinbase, right? It's like, you are a completely
- 58:08altering. And dismantling, the
- 58:09incentive-based Ace of these kind of bright minds and Silicon
- 58:13Valley, and just poisoning them from the beginning.
- 58:16So whether their intent is malicious or not, doesn't
- 58:19matter, coinbase set the precedent that, hey, you can buy
- 58:23and sell crypto assets and there's Dao's or democratizing
- 58:27finance. And while it might be on the on
- 58:30the surface of it, a really lofty goal and something that a
- 58:33young entrepreneur wouldn't want to inspire to really they should
- 58:37be focused on building a Bitcoin and learning the lightning
- 58:40Network and Bitcoin wallet software and contributing to
- 58:43open source. And all of this stuff was put by
- 58:45the wayside because of kind of this this profit motive that was
- 58:50a, you know, thrown in the face of Brian Armstrong in the team.
- 58:53So don't want to go in too much of a diatribe there.
- 58:56But yeah, in to piggyback on were Jesse was coming from on
- 59:01coinbase and some of the like just not manipulation but just
- 59:05kind of misdirection and then what Tyler just reference, we're
- 59:09not just speaking ideologically like Cuz I think it's important
- 59:11the framing in a sense of like it is a from a practical long
- 59:16term low time preference. If you're looking to build
- 59:19something sustainable the focus on bitcoin going deep going
- 59:24their own. You think about what unchanged
- 59:26done River firms that are looking to build things the
- 59:28right way. There's so much of an attack
- 59:32surface from a security perspective from the tooling
- 59:34from the things needed to be developed.
- 59:36The only way to really do it properly and do it, right.
- 59:39That's a long-standing from Away from the people that you hire
- 59:43all the way to the tech is, to have a singular focus and in the
- 59:46products around it, and it may not come at the exact speeds of
- 59:49a block 50 recording, bass, or others like an fbx or by Nance.
- 59:54But at the same time, it only exists on a spectrum and at some
- 59:58point you know the rubber hits the road where the SEC comes
- 1:00:02knocking or the The Firm blows up because you're trying to grow
- 1:00:05your topper and Romanians, you're not cutting you not stop
- 1:00:08loss in on risk management. And now you're, you know, you're
- 1:00:10bankrupt. And so there's this real like
- 1:00:12practicality and and that's where like, I think the big, the
- 1:00:18Silicon Valley and this goes to do it again.
- 1:00:19The gray, blue and red. It's like there's this world of
- 1:00:24the Silicon Valley or the coastal wheat.
- 1:00:27They're not worried about money like that.
- 1:00:29From the core sense of like their own money like a Latin
- 1:00:32American country or emerging market that has bad money.
- 1:00:37So that that's not the angle, the other ink.
- 1:00:39So the angle there come at is from either the tech How to make
- 1:00:41more money, how to make the riches and so Bitcoin will
- 1:00:44there, it's already late. How do you do that?
- 1:00:46If you're not the one company around, it was like, okay.
- 1:00:48And you see to Tom's Point firms work for coinbase.
- 1:00:52And this is like, the next thing, which is the whole idea.
- 1:00:56If the next thing, whether it's like, AI or crypto, whatever it
- 1:01:00is like, that is the mindset. And not actually understanding
- 1:01:04what's happening. And so, like, the amjad of the
- 1:01:09world, they have a lot of respect for Somebody like that
- 1:01:11because he lives in that world but he also is an independent
- 1:01:14thinker and he's come to it on his own side.
- 1:01:17As he has a unicorn company, he's building in this space or
- 1:01:21outside of Bitcoin, but he understands the gravity what's
- 1:01:24happening with their coin. So he's looking to bring that
- 1:01:26into his firm. So he's using the mindset of
- 1:01:29first principles growth within reason, building a sustainable
- 1:01:32business and also understanding what Bitcoin is going.
- 1:01:35And so I think we'll see more of that.
- 1:01:36And that's one of the most exciting things at least some on
- 1:01:38my site. For like, the next decade is
- 1:01:40that Instead of understanding like thinking independently
- 1:01:44along with building sustainable businesses, I think will be very
- 1:01:48interesting. Yeah, I mean, this goes back to
- 1:01:52the perverse incentives and that's, I think we should feel.
- 1:01:56We don't feel for quite Miss, but like, a lot of these
- 1:01:59perverse incentives are sort of ceded by the capital Behind
- 1:02:03These companies, like the Silicon Valley, be seized the, a
- 1:02:0516 Z's of the world, the Sequoias Paradigm, whoever Or it
- 1:02:11may be like the again, like, we discussed earlier the ability to
- 1:02:16deploy capital and get a liquidity event in 12 to 18
- 1:02:19months with a 10 to 1000 x is extremely appealing to the to
- 1:02:25the venture capitalist out there.
- 1:02:26They're able to get these quick returns return money to LPS at
- 1:02:30significant multiples, and it's a great for them, the LPS,
- 1:02:34probably love it. And they probably making a lot
- 1:02:36of money, but in the long run like we're seeing nothing has
- 1:02:39staying power. And so, The moral question leaks
- 1:02:42and like, is this a good way to make you righteous?
- 1:02:46And then on top of that, the incentives of provides for the
- 1:02:49companies and this is why 10:31 exist is we've recognized that
- 1:02:53sort of Disconnect in the market where there's a lot of companies
- 1:02:56that would like to build on bitcoin.
- 1:02:58Only would like to focus on big go and have that narrow deep
- 1:03:01understanding and stack like the rivers, the Unchained of the
- 1:03:04world. The mining companies that exist
- 1:03:07out there they're really focused on bitcoin.
- 1:03:09It would there's many Teams like them out there that would like
- 1:03:12to do that. But cannot get the capital
- 1:03:14because the capital comes attached with strings, which are
- 1:03:17you need to offer these other tokens that are going to provide
- 1:03:21revenue for you. And so luckily over the last
- 1:03:25three years, particularly that trend is beginning to change.
- 1:03:29We've raised a lot of capital and deployed a lot of capital at
- 1:03:3010:31. There's other funds, like, ego
- 1:03:32death. That have risen, we got
- 1:03:35Trammell, we got TV, be still Mark.
- 1:03:37There's a lot of Bitcoin, Focus Venture funds that are that are
- 1:03:40coming. And raising a good amount of
- 1:03:42capital and going to the founders saying, hey, we're not
- 1:03:45going to attach those strings to this Capital.
- 1:03:47We get Bitcoin focus on it, build out the ecosystem and that
- 1:03:52is why we call our our funds low time preference, phones at 10:31
- 1:03:55and because we do believe that this is going to take time, but
- 1:03:59it's all it's like a marshmallow test.
- 1:04:01You're going to eat the marshmallow now like a bunch of
- 1:04:03the Silicon Valley. VCS have done with their quick
- 1:04:06exit liquidity or you're going to wait for twenty marshmallows
- 1:04:09down the road when the Open. He's that you're investing in
- 1:04:12have built out a solid foundation in layered stack on
- 1:04:15top of the Bitcoin Network that is going to drive a lot of
- 1:04:19value. For those companies in humanity,
- 1:04:22more broadly, Yeah, I just thought it was like these people
- 1:04:30hate you. I don't know if it's that far
- 1:04:31but that's what made me think of like Frederick.
- 1:04:33So you mentioned Paradigm friend, when they went public,
- 1:04:36he sold two point 1 billion dollars worth of shares at the
- 1:04:38top. And then recently obviously
- 1:04:41Paradigm, you know, pivoted to crypto /, AI or whatever the
- 1:04:46term is like the next thing and because those it those that's as
- 1:04:49close to being inside as you're going to be to know that.
- 1:04:51Like okay, this is hammers coming.
- 1:04:54We have a lot of dollars to deploy so we got to figure out
- 1:04:57what the next thing is. Sorry.
- 1:05:00Yeah, I want to build on what Tyler something, Tyler said
- 1:05:04they're like like coinbase, really created this incentive
- 1:05:09for, like Stanford. Young Engineers to get
- 1:05:13completely on the wrong track from the get-go and and has
- 1:05:18diverted so much, human capital and energy and potential
- 1:05:22building. Away from Bitcoin or other
- 1:05:26productive things and into the next altcoin, pump and dump and
- 1:05:32that but that makes sense. Because like when you think
- 1:05:36about the cantillon effect of of, you know, when we're
- 1:05:41printing money, the people that benefit the most are the people
- 1:05:44who are closest to the money printer the financiers.
- 1:05:47So the cantillon effect is money printing, quote financing, the
- 1:05:51financiers and That means, you know, whether that's direct
- 1:05:56stimulus of creating money at the federal level or whoever get
- 1:06:02has access to loans and you know, M2 created through
- 1:06:06Commercial Bank. Lending that is who can get the
- 1:06:11most juice out of a out of a monetary expansion Trend and the
- 1:06:20people in the world who have benefited the most from that.
- 1:06:24Have have been Silicon Valley venture capitalist.
- 1:06:27It's just that they are, you know, at the the most extreme
- 1:06:32end of that effect because they're taking on, you know,
- 1:06:37they're getting all this. This money pumped into them from
- 1:06:42the big Pension funds and endowments and whoever's trying
- 1:06:45to get some extra extra returns in their portfolio.
- 1:06:51And then they're, you know, getting Pumping that into the
- 1:06:55next. The next technology startup that
- 1:06:59they think can grow rapidly with with leverage and and that's the
- 1:07:04whole model and the Venture capitalists get to benefit from
- 1:07:07that immensely and so it's no surprise that coinbase comes
- 1:07:14from that world is part of that world is an is a great enabler
- 1:07:19and fuel for that that cycle. All of the cantillon effect
- 1:07:27coming to crypto and and finding a home in crypto.
- 1:07:31You know. Like let's make the next let's
- 1:07:34print the next type of money and will keep 20% of it and we'll
- 1:07:41hype it up with all of our accumulated, power, in Silicon
- 1:07:46Valley and all the connections we have and we'll dump it at the
- 1:07:50top and and rinse and repeat. A 16z is done awfully awfully.
- 1:07:56Well with with that formula and Chris Dixon is in my opinion,
- 1:08:01one of the worst actors in the space as a result of that
- 1:08:06incentive and the money that he has been able to make by playing
- 1:08:10that Playbook. And, you know, like we have to
- 1:08:14remember that Silicon Valley is not just an outcome of
- 1:08:20Technology, it is an outcome of Fiat.
- 1:08:24Money to and those things have converged to create, some great
- 1:08:27products and benefited the world in big ways.
- 1:08:32But it can also misfire and that misfires when there's this, this
- 1:08:37sort of incentive that that, you know, is in the Wheelhouse of
- 1:08:41what venture capitalist like to to do and see.
- 1:08:45And it just happens to be at the expense of everyone who falls
- 1:08:49for the marketing of, what's the next Bitcoin.
- 1:08:54You know. So coin basis is kind of the
- 1:08:58Public Enemy Number One, despite the fact that they have in my
- 1:09:01opinion, been the least criminal in their activities, they have,
- 1:09:07they have been the most deceptive and the most plugged
- 1:09:11into that, that Silicon Valley, ethos that is all about.
- 1:09:15Let's find them the, let's juice returns because it's a formula,
- 1:09:21that is Isabel in the Fiat era and Bitcoin phi's against that.
- 1:09:28And so, you know, part of what was hard about coming to bitcoin
- 1:09:32for me was was I went to Stanford and got steeped in that
- 1:09:37whole, ethos of innovation and leverage and you know,
- 1:09:45everything about Sandhill Road where all the Venture Capital
- 1:09:49firms are located and Bitcoin is the opposite of that.
- 1:09:54Is it is low time preference. It is savings rather than
- 1:09:58leverage and it is not about Innovation instead, it is about
- 1:10:06better money and that is outside of the Paradigm of what Silicon
- 1:10:11Valley thinks about, because you don't ever conceive of the
- 1:10:14possibility that there could be better money.
- 1:10:17Nobody ever talks about that, and nobody really understands
- 1:10:20money, so you don't, you're not not even asking the right
- 1:10:22question of what is money. And what?
- 1:10:23It's good money. So I think that, you know, it's
- 1:10:28interesting that to consider that coinbase has been a great
- 1:10:33source of evil in poisoning the the direction of Silicon Valley
- 1:10:40and and so many entrepreneurs that could have been building on
- 1:10:43bitcoin and instead are going through a painful journey and
- 1:10:46will eventually find their way to bitcoin the hard way.
- 1:10:49The way most people do. Yeah, like to say, what Venture
- 1:10:54capitalism is, you know, probably more accurate
- 1:10:58description and Venture capitalism, right?
- 1:11:00It's like printing uh, you know, printing money does not produce
- 1:11:04value and it's just, you know, and printing money means
- 1:11:08printing tokens, does not produce produce value, it's all
- 1:11:11the same thing. Yeah, I think they ties it in
- 1:11:14like the the sand like constrains breed creativity
- 1:11:19because if you think about it and should have before and it's
- 1:11:21just like the river. Opportunity cost to Capital, we
- 1:11:24talked about this. I think on the first episode is
- 1:11:27what like, Jesse's alluding to. There's like the secret.
- 1:11:30It's what's known as like, and SoftBank wanted to invest in in
- 1:11:34a firm. They would go to them and they
- 1:11:36would go and some people take it and others wouldn't, and before
- 1:11:39they went to take it and say, well, hey, if you don't, I'm
- 1:11:42going to point that the money candidate at the other company,
- 1:11:44and they recognize that like, you know, if they weren't, it
- 1:11:47was basically existential because if they got that
- 1:11:49Capital, then they were able to grow faster and so It's a
- 1:11:53reality of the game that's been there but it's also reality of
- 1:11:57we understand, you know in Jesse knows better and can talk to a
- 1:12:00better than anybody is like, the math doesn't add up and so the
- 1:12:03dollars were at a certain point will end the Bitcoin will exist
- 1:12:08and when you want to build a business, There's real
- 1:12:10opportunity cost in there. And it my background who are
- 1:12:13really went down, the rabbit hole, is that we work and it was
- 1:12:15read the Bitcoin standard. While realizing we were living
- 1:12:17the Bitcoin standard in the sense of misallocation of
- 1:12:19capital building buildings that were never going to be, you
- 1:12:22know, Which we did exactly that. They're still building all over
- 1:12:24the world that never knew were completed.
- 1:12:26Let alone. People said, you know, got to
- 1:12:29cut off his face and and it's not to say that it wasn't a good
- 1:12:32business or a productive business because it was it just
- 1:12:34was in the multiple was not what it was from a venture
- 1:12:37perspective. And so, they'll be real
- 1:12:40opportunity cost for somebody to give you their Bitcoin to take
- 1:12:43an equity stake, you know. Just look fundamentally
- 1:12:45different. And I think it's in the best
- 1:12:47interest of everybody to understand it sooner than later,
- 1:12:49especially on an entrepreneurial perspective because When that's
- 1:12:53recognized, then you start to look at the world in a different
- 1:12:55lens of like, well, what am I using my time?
- 1:12:57How am I thinking about growth strategy?
- 1:12:59Because that world will come sooner than later.
- 1:13:02And even if it was just a dollar roll for the next 10 years, it
- 1:13:04still makes sense because the back end of it, you end up with
- 1:13:07a zombie company, like we've seen once the cost of capital,
- 1:13:11you know, increases and but it will happen, Bitcoin, really
- 1:13:14money. And that whole world will
- 1:13:16change. And this is like, part of these
- 1:13:19discussions or to start thinking about that, or at least.
- 1:13:22Something gets part where you start going down that rabbit
- 1:13:25hole because nothing that we're saying or specifically this is
- 1:13:27for, this is just how things were when we had a form of
- 1:13:30money. That could not be printed.
- 1:13:32It's really just been so far removed from that and we grew up
- 1:13:34you know with a dollar that has really a relatively little
- 1:13:38meaning. And so this is this is the State
- 1:13:40of Affairs or in right now. Yeah.
- 1:13:44So to tie up the topic of the fcc's enforcement or their
- 1:13:49complaints against by notes and coin.
- 1:13:52Bass, let's go around the horn. What do you guys think is going
- 1:13:55to happen? What is the outcome of this by
- 1:13:57Nets and coinbase pay fine go about their way.
- 1:14:02I I saw an interesting observation that it's is in a
- 1:14:08way. It's a little unwise who the SEC
- 1:14:10decided to go up against because the legal teams for these two
- 1:14:14companies have got to be the best in crypto and they're going
- 1:14:20up against the SEC. Educators who are not known for
- 1:14:25being the best litigators in town.
- 1:14:29So it's a little bit of a David and Goliath situation in the in
- 1:14:35the way that you wouldn't expect because coinbase is going to be
- 1:14:38stacked you know, on their legal side.
- 1:14:42So I think that the SEC you know I think they have a case and
- 1:14:48they will extract some sort of concessions or victories.
- 1:14:52Yeah, but I wouldn't be surprised if coinbase
- 1:14:57successfully stands their ground in the big categories.
- 1:15:03And when it comes to by Nancy, that's a much more complicated
- 1:15:06case. Because, you know, like the
- 1:15:09biggest crime that coinbase has committed, as far as I can tell
- 1:15:12is is allowing customers to purchase.
- 1:15:16You know, Securities into that are staking, you know, and
- 1:15:20providing yield and that that Pretty, clearly runs runs
- 1:15:25against the Howey test whereas finances done, potentially is
- 1:15:30quite a few Shady things. So I you know, I don't know what
- 1:15:35the outcomes will be. I think that it won't be as
- 1:15:39clear, cut of a victory for the SEC as as it appears, it should
- 1:15:44be. And I do think that an outcome
- 1:15:48here is, you know, you end up with another FTX.
- 1:15:52Our offshore company that is, that is finding a way to serve
- 1:15:59US citizens illegally and that that this problem just pretend
- 1:16:06continues because you can't really stop that as quickly as
- 1:16:11you can stop coinbase from from doing it because they're
- 1:16:15domiciled in the US. Tyler.
- 1:16:18Yeah I would I would kind of I would think that while there's
- 1:16:23not a clear-cut win for the SEC or the exchanges.
- 1:16:28In this case, I would say potential outcome could be
- 1:16:31financed, u.s. gets gets may be obliterated, the ICC chalks, it
- 1:16:35up is a huge win, but I do think given the entrepreneurial Spirit
- 1:16:40of CZ kind of what we were talking about.
- 1:16:42It's like, you know, it'll be another Phoenix.
- 1:16:46It'll it'll exist somewhere. On the coinbase side of things,
- 1:16:50I do kind of think that as much as I would hate to see you know
- 1:16:54a commemorative nft be the way that you know they've proposed a
- 1:16:58fight. These these battles I think the
- 1:17:01point about like having a strong legal team is there, there's
- 1:17:03arguments that, you know, they were allowed to go public and so
- 1:17:06there's like these it's going to be a long drawn-out battle.
- 1:17:09So the end of the day, I do think coinbase will still be
- 1:17:11around stock price might tank. Hopefully there's a little bit
- 1:17:16more disclaimers they have To throw on their website and so
- 1:17:19just labeling themselves as a place of trust but like this
- 1:17:23should be we as bitcoiners should be.
- 1:17:25Looking at all. These events is not like let's
- 1:17:28sit back and grab the popcorn and watch what happens.
- 1:17:30We should be like. Okay, let's double down and
- 1:17:32education efforts, and try to help the people who are
- 1:17:34currently at funds on the coinbase and finance, right?
- 1:17:37There's nothing that comes close to holding your own keys and
- 1:17:40that should be Paramount. So that's what that's what I'll
- 1:17:42continue to do this. And everybody on this call is
- 1:17:43going to continue to do and we're going to win.
- 1:17:47Yeah, I think I think that's exactly right.
- 1:17:48I think the term that came up with this phrase.
- 1:17:51It came binds, the Trap has been set.
- 1:17:54The theme within, like the Wall Street circles and it may be
- 1:17:58public. I don't know if you guys have
- 1:17:59heard it's like s everybody's on the sto or used to be called an
- 1:18:02sto I don't know what is it called.
- 1:18:04Mallory was a security token offer and or whatever and it's
- 1:18:06like now it's like tokenizing you know whatever.
- 1:18:10So you got that that that's coming we got like probably you
- 1:18:13know so there's that I think about regulation around He's
- 1:18:17like critical defy protocol so like, you know, swap or any of
- 1:18:20these things that they're going to, you know, just set the stage
- 1:18:24between that we sto and in cdc's we're seeing with Jeremy a layer
- 1:18:29and circle. That is going to be the hey,
- 1:18:33bend the knee. We don't want to stifle
- 1:18:35Innovation, we don't stifle Innovation.
- 1:18:38So let's work within the framework that we establish
- 1:18:40everything. Oh, thank you.
- 1:18:42We're appreciated. Because at the end of the day, I
- 1:18:44think the thing that IG and probably all of us like don't A
- 1:18:47fully crashes were so far as a purpose of the show is like, so
- 1:18:51far on one side of understanding, what's happening?
- 1:18:54That it still seems Foreigner and saying that all this stuff
- 1:18:57can actually be zeros, like just completely zero like now, you
- 1:19:00know, use like hedge and say 99% or Securities, like they're all
- 1:19:03secures their all created by somebody.
- 1:19:04Like if nothing else wasn't creative individual and can be
- 1:19:08changed the monetary policy and so I think between you get the
- 1:19:12regulation or the framework around it for me it was easy.
- 1:19:14Does liquid single United States?
- 1:19:16Because he's just gonna Be a pirate.
- 1:19:18Do whatever you guys so you get SEO Zen like okay.
- 1:19:20Well we know there's Innovation on Securities and token offering
- 1:19:24whatever they make up there. We get D Phi because you find
- 1:19:28makes sense and its innovative or going to regulate that.
- 1:19:30And then cbc's, and we're going to get Capital just going to
- 1:19:34droves. But the reality is, we all know
- 1:19:36that with a click of a button, all of that gets stuck there.
- 1:19:39And so the point of all this is we discuss Bitcoin, we help
- 1:19:43people take the Bitcoin off of the exchanges because a she and,
- 1:19:46or reduce the counterparty risk and Yeah, I think big fines will
- 1:19:57be paid finance will get kicked out of the US and everything
- 1:20:02will will will persist. But with more regulatory
- 1:20:05scrutiny named strings attached from DC and that in I mean,
- 1:20:10that's another big question bitcoiners like you said, Tyler,
- 1:20:14I don't think we should be sitting here with popcorn or
- 1:20:16laps even though we've been predicting this and telling the
- 1:20:19people in crypto, like, hey, they're going to come down on
- 1:20:21you. I don't agree with the SEC.
- 1:20:24I don't think it. Should exist.
- 1:20:25I don't agree with the Securities laws but they do
- 1:20:27exist in the SEC does exist. And what you're doing is going
- 1:20:31to draw their ire that has happened, we've been Vindicated.
- 1:20:34But with that being said, I don't think they stopped at
- 1:20:37crypto like I think I don't think they like Bitcoin.
- 1:20:40They like really don't like Bitcoin because Bitcoin is the
- 1:20:43one they truly can't control and is truly out of their grasp of
- 1:20:47control. And so while we're Mo, many
- 1:20:50Bitcoins are sitting around bra bra like told you so I told you,
- 1:20:53so ha ha Like have fun staying poor like know that like this is
- 1:20:58going to be used as a precedent where everything gets hyper
- 1:21:01regulated and becomes very sanitized and sterile in the
- 1:21:07crypto world, then they draw their ire, at Bitcoin.
- 1:21:10We had a glimpse of this with Gary Gensler.
- 1:21:12'S comments earlier, this week, when he said, we already have
- 1:21:15digital currencies, we have digital dollars, we have digital
- 1:21:18Euros, we don't need and another digital currency while he didn't
- 1:21:23name Bitcoin. I think that was like a canary
- 1:21:26in the coal. Mine of them setting up for the
- 1:21:29dollar, is the digital currency that we have.
- 1:21:31We don't need Bitcoin. And so, I think this is just
- 1:21:34setting the stage for protecting your posturing like they're
- 1:21:38protecting retail from penny stocks in crypto and then once
- 1:21:44that's done, all right, focus on bitcoin.
- 1:21:46This is digital currency that does not fall into what we
- 1:21:50believe should be a digital currency.
- 1:21:53One thing you said, Marty that we've been talking about we
- 1:21:56chatted with Larry. It's like I think more and
- 1:21:59muniya killed for this is we should be aligning with gold
- 1:22:02with gold a lot more than we are.
- 1:22:04Like, if you think about, you know, the Texas will is it
- 1:22:06sexist thing of know like infringement or like it was
- 1:22:09something about that coin that recently came out in a positive
- 1:22:11light, but I think we're back to 2014 Kyle bass.
- 1:22:15Brought you tend Guns, Gold bullying down to Texas from New
- 1:22:19York and had it with the setup. Basically a sovereign Texan
- 1:22:23depository where the gold It's aggregated.
- 1:22:25They can view it any think of like aligning with which are
- 1:22:29referencing if you can you can play in the crypto world and you
- 1:22:32can play with the thing that has been recognized and has been
- 1:22:36established from whether it's being hold being held as an
- 1:22:39individual or being held within, you know, a sovereign or
- 1:22:42nation-state. I think there's there's
- 1:22:45something there that will offer some like protection in the
- 1:22:49sense of like, hey this is this is gold but it has the ability
- 1:22:53to be transferred or Seamless. So anyway, those are something
- 1:22:57that came to mind of like, has that happens more and more.
- 1:23:00There's some coverage there. I think we should play into.
- 1:23:03I agree. I like our gold bugs.
- 1:23:07I like Google Books, we line philosophically on many things,
- 1:23:10we just need to get it up, get him over a couple humps.
- 1:23:13Agreed. And I think, I think to that
- 1:23:16point Michael, I think we're in a bit of a Race Against Time
- 1:23:20here because Regulators are current, or as Marty was very
- 1:23:26rightly pointing out. Like there's an order of
- 1:23:29operations here before they can really circle the wagons and
- 1:23:33come after Bitcoin. Meanwhile Tick Tock next block
- 1:23:37like Bitcoin keeps doing its thing.
- 1:23:39The next having is coming. The adoption curve keeps going
- 1:23:44We keep getting more powerful people on board to, you know,
- 1:23:49the value proposition a Bitcoin. Whether the, whether that's
- 1:23:52people in Congress, presidential candidates heads of energy
- 1:24:00companies, who are looking to monetize their stranded at
- 1:24:03natural gas or other resources, and the more we can capture the
- 1:24:12minds of those people like Like plant the value, proposition of
- 1:24:16Bitcoin in these mines. The more the more formidable of
- 1:24:23intransigent minority, the Bitcoin Community becomes
- 1:24:29advocating for what Bitcoin is which is freedom of speech and
- 1:24:35property rights. Like that's that's all it is.
- 1:24:38At its core and the gold bugs are on that.
- 1:24:44You know, same wavelength and should the Allies for us, and
- 1:24:48we're in this Race Against Time of like, if we can get just a
- 1:24:51little bit further into the adoption curve such that, you
- 1:24:55know, right now we have RFK Junior and Ted Cruz saying that
- 1:25:01Bitcoin is a good thing. And they are you realistically
- 1:25:06Fringe personas in the National political Arena.
- 1:25:11Can we get a little bit further? Towards the mainstream before
- 1:25:15the SEC. And another Regulators have time
- 1:25:18to really attack Bitcoin having you know they have a few years
- 1:25:22before if they were to focus just on cleaning house and
- 1:25:25crypto it would take them a few years to do that from this point
- 1:25:28in time. So you know, we have a we have a
- 1:25:31few years of Runway to try to on board as many people as possible
- 1:25:35to the value proposition of Bitcoin and hard money in
- 1:25:37general, that includes gold. So hopefully, we can Run fast
- 1:25:44enough hard enough for long enough here to build the
- 1:25:48Coalition. We need to defend freedom of
- 1:25:52speech and property rights with Bitcoin and with gold before the
- 1:25:59cbc's come down hard. Yeah.
- 1:26:05There's one more topic I wanted to touch on Tyler unless you
- 1:26:09have anything to add to that. I don't work out.
- 1:26:11That was the definitely. I agree with both those
- 1:26:15framings. I think that also the episode
- 1:26:17that you guys stayed with, with Lawrence the parvez awesome.
- 1:26:21We do need to align ourselves maybe with Argus I guess start
- 1:26:24to educate and then take on the gold bug.
- 1:26:26So, just with open arms, I believe ya.
- 1:26:29Come here, Cole books. Give us a big hug.
- 1:26:31We love you philosophically. Aligned Now, the other thing I
- 1:26:36know we big week with the SEC, coming out your finance and
- 1:26:40coinbase something that's been choreographed by the SEC and
- 1:26:44predicted by many bitcoiners for many years.
- 1:26:46So, the fact that it happened this week, it makes sense that
- 1:26:49we would spend the Lion's Share of this episode talking about
- 1:26:52that. But another thing which I do
- 1:26:55want to talk about particularly since you're here, Tyler is the
- 1:26:58rumors that started last night. David Bailey sent out a text
- 1:27:02that there is a large crew. Because stir or Bitcoin,
- 1:27:05custodian that is on the verge of bankruptcy potentially
- 1:27:10happening and of market tomorrow, if things don't get
- 1:27:14solved, it's terribly, kept secret that it's likely Prime
- 1:27:19trust, which is a custodian that a lot of services leverage swamp
- 1:27:26Bitcoin used to they've since transition off to Fortress
- 1:27:29trust, which ironically was founded by the founder of prime
- 1:27:34Trust. He left and started.
- 1:27:35This strike has had Reliance on on Prime trust fold as well.
- 1:27:42They've all since moved off but you still have by Nancy us and
- 1:27:47this is probably what's causing the problem set at Prime trust
- 1:27:50this week. I would imagine it's Finance.
- 1:27:52U.s. okay X and a few others are still leveraging Prime trust.
- 1:27:59And it seems like They could be in a precarious situation.
- 1:28:04They hold both Bitcoin and dollar balances for customers,
- 1:28:08or a mixture or one or the other for particular customers.
- 1:28:12And if they go down, there could be even more Tremors in the
- 1:28:17industry to end the week. And I think this highlights why
- 1:28:23unchain and on-ramp exists is because the rumors are that they
- 1:28:27may not be whole on the Bitcoin. They're supposed to be holding,
- 1:28:31which Is something that can be solved Bitcoins, native multisig
- 1:28:34properties. So I guess just throw it out to
- 1:28:37the group. What have you guys been hearing?
- 1:28:39What do you think? The significance of a prime
- 1:28:41dress going down? Would be Just a little context
- 1:28:47to before I think Tyler has has some stuff to weigh in on here.
- 1:28:53So on on by Nance right now Bitcoin is trading at two
- 1:28:58thousand dollars more than everywhere else so there's a two
- 1:29:02thousand dollar premium on by manse for Bitcoin and that
- 1:29:06suggests that insiders it's not the Bitcoin is worth more.
- 1:29:10It's that insiders believe that the dollars In that ecosystem,
- 1:29:15the by Nance world are worth less meaning, you know that
- 1:29:20there's a risk that those dollars aren't there and so
- 1:29:25dollars on by an answer trading at a discount effectively.
- 1:29:29So that's the scale. And the, the realness of these
- 1:29:33rumors, insiders believe there's something to it, enough to
- 1:29:39create almost 10% Delta in Bitcoins price on one.
- 1:29:44Change versus all the others. Yeah, I think it's you know it's
- 1:29:48like Parker used to talk about this a lot and still does like
- 1:29:53this concept of extreme ownership and Bitcoin and that
- 1:29:57extreme ownership. Of course, is levied on the
- 1:30:01individual when it comes to extreme ownership over your
- 1:30:04wealth right over your portion of 21 million usual, the keys we
- 1:30:08were thinking about building a Bitcoin business, I think that
- 1:30:12extreme ownership needs to also be something that's taken quite
- 1:30:16seriously and I think this is you know a really big warning
- 1:30:20sign to two individuals running these businesses.
- 1:30:24You know, if you're running a Bitcoin business In house is
- 1:30:28going to be the way to go if you're going to offer a trading
- 1:30:32desk. If you're going to, you know, if
- 1:30:34you're going to build something as quality, as the likes of, you
- 1:30:37know, River Unchained on-ramp. You have these like these
- 1:30:40Bitcoin on the businesses while it is a low time preference
- 1:30:45method about about building about going about building.
- 1:30:48It's it's at the end of the day crucial and it might be the sole
- 1:30:51reason you remain alive, right? Hopping from kind of one back
- 1:30:56end to another Certainly one way to go and that might be out of
- 1:30:59necessity for a lot of folks. Right.
- 1:31:00It's like hard to grow a start-up or a young company but
- 1:31:04I do think this is like a warning sign right now where
- 1:31:06it's hey where there's smoke there's fire and you know
- 1:31:10there's going to be another fired up road at some point.
- 1:31:13It's inevitable. So taking the right steps now
- 1:31:15and taking extreme ownership now.
- 1:31:16It's going to be the best way to go.
- 1:31:19So it's like we work with clients day in and day out that
- 1:31:22are moving Bitcoin to their own funds.
- 1:31:24They ask about this stuff and this is also the really
- 1:31:26interesting resting just mental analogy.
- 1:31:28I think I've talked about it with you Marty before.
- 1:31:30It's like you look at Bitcoin held on exchanges and with its,
- 1:31:37you know, it's a clean base, right?
- 1:31:40Not related to Prime trust but even if it's Prime trust even if
- 1:31:43it's Bitcoin, all them Prime trust like they could be
- 1:31:45securing hundreds of millions or billions of dollars worth of
- 1:31:48bitcoin with a handful of keys where you look at the client
- 1:31:52base or somebody like Unchained, you know they're holding their
- 1:31:55Bitcoin with thousands. Keys, right?
- 1:31:58It's a tell my clients all the time when I'm working with them.
- 1:32:01It's just kind of how people talk, they'll say.
- 1:32:03So when I send my Bitcoin over to you guys, and I have to pause
- 1:32:06and say, so like that's kind of an incorrect framing or not,
- 1:32:09depositing your Bitcoin with us, right?
- 1:32:11You are holding the keys to your own Bitcoin.
- 1:32:14We're just a collaborative partner that and so being loud
- 1:32:18and educating about that is still really, really important.
- 1:32:20But yeah, that you know, however the chips fall where there is
- 1:32:23prime trust or some other entity that for some reason we have
- 1:32:26been It correctly about. I do think it's like an
- 1:32:29important and good healthy warning to bitcoin companies in
- 1:32:33the space that the extreme ownership low time.
- 1:32:36Preference building is the way to go.
- 1:32:38And another way to say extreme ownership, particularly in
- 1:32:42Bitcoin, which is the phrase popularized by Nick Szabo which
- 1:32:47is trusted, third parties are security holes.
- 1:32:49And so in the case of prime trust, it's a it's a third party
- 1:32:54that's leverage by many other actors in the space and Those
- 1:32:57actors are putting a lot of trust in Prime trust to actually
- 1:33:00do what they say they can do we inevitably with a lot of these
- 1:33:04trusted third parties, get to a point where they can't do what
- 1:33:07they say they can do. And that trust that you gave
- 1:33:11them comes back to bite you in the ass because you are not
- 1:33:16afforded the services. They said they were going to
- 1:33:18give you which is custom Bitcoin, facilitating the buy,
- 1:33:21and sell Bitcoin, facilitating US dollar transfers.
- 1:33:24It seems like many people that are trusting I'm trust are going
- 1:33:27to learn that hard lesson rumors at this point.
- 1:33:31Should clarify, that these are just rumors that are going
- 1:33:34around on Twitter. We will find out if there's any
- 1:33:38validity behind them, but it seems like they're there may be
- 1:33:41at this point, but again, like Tyler just mentioned like
- 1:33:45Bitcoin. Provide, you this beautiful
- 1:33:48ability to take possession of your asset of the you taxes that
- 1:33:55you hold and Not only that, it has this other beautiful
- 1:33:59property that you can do it in a way that distributes risk among
- 1:34:02multiple keys in the Unchained model.
- 1:34:05The user has two keys on chain has one, like Tyler said
- 1:34:08collaborative, Cassidy, it's a two or three multisig.
- 1:34:11If you ever need to move your Bitcoin and you have one key and
- 1:34:13the others somewhere else, but you really need to move it.
- 1:34:16You sign one key and unchanged. There the Sun, the other on
- 1:34:20ramp, like this is why you guys exist to.
- 1:34:22So like unchanged, probably deeper down the funnel than what
- 1:34:25you guys are offering but still even at the the trust trust in
- 1:34:30the financial asset or the structure definition of the word
- 1:34:36like this is a much better model than the gray scales of the
- 1:34:41world where yes the individual may not have a key in the Quorum
- 1:34:46but you distribute that key risk among different institutions
- 1:34:49Woods, which reduces the third-party risk that exists.
- 1:34:54Yeah, I think I think the core thing is like, decentralization
- 1:34:58is not an ideology idea, ology it is game.
- 1:35:02Theoretical the best game like, big best setup.
- 1:35:07And you think about, we always talk about this.
- 1:35:10We talk about like the decentralization of hash rate
- 1:35:13and why it's important to the network.
- 1:35:15But as Tyler alluded to decentralization of keys or just
- 1:35:18as important and we've seen this play out, we know what happened
- 1:35:21with gold in the centralization and so you think about it from
- 1:35:23somebody? Coming into Bitcoin.
- 1:35:25When you see my just from a long-term perspective, if
- 1:35:28Bitcoin is to be successful, you want those keys spread out as
- 1:35:30far into the network, simply from a perspective of you are
- 1:35:35going to challenge money. There's a number of reasons why
- 1:35:38you don't want it sitting at a honey pot and sitting on a
- 1:35:41certain exchange and then on the other side of that on owning the
- 1:35:45private Keys, it's a spectrum as Marty alluded to where different
- 1:35:50individuals come at it from different extreme ownership of
- 1:35:53what they're willing. I was Part of the, you know,
- 1:35:55sitting in Tyler. She's very early on and helping
- 1:35:58onboard individuals, and something that always resonator
- 1:36:00or kept in my mind was the higher, the net worth the
- 1:36:03individual. This is just the fact that is
- 1:36:05just reality, the more money, the person had the more angry or
- 1:36:09annoyed that they were asked or tasked with holding
- 1:36:13cryptographic material. It's not to say that they never
- 1:36:15will, or they won't some did it begrudgingly?
- 1:36:18And some said, like screw it. I'm not going to do it.
- 1:36:20And those people potentially may not have their Bitcoin anymore
- 1:36:22because they want they don't sexualize.
- 1:36:24Is and so that's really the idea.
- 1:36:26It's like, what are the one of the ways that we can help me
- 1:36:29people? Whether it's a chain or a other
- 1:36:31products to onboard, make it Seamless decentralised, get
- 1:36:34those keys out and not have a single point of failure and then
- 1:36:38ultimately, as information as a market shakes out, you can find
- 1:36:42other ways to to, you know, essentially hold your asset.
- 1:36:48And I don't, I used to have the view that there was like, one,
- 1:36:50right way to hold that coin and I don't actually have that more.
- 1:36:54I think it's just always moving all the time depending on your
- 1:36:57risk profile, your amount of Bitcoin, the status of the
- 1:37:00world. And at some point, I will do my
- 1:37:02keys right now, but a certain point if we're really well known
- 1:37:05and the price of Bitcoin is can do 1000x.
- 1:37:08What it is? I don't necessarily know if I
- 1:37:09want it to be known that I can always move my Bitcoin
- 1:37:11unilaterally having kids and things like that.
- 1:37:13So I think it's just it's a constantly moving Target with
- 1:37:16the core principle. You don't want a single point of
- 1:37:18failure and you want those keys as far out of the network.
- 1:37:22In more broadly. Speaking we got tweeted this out
- 1:37:26last night like I think on the other side of this hill if the
- 1:37:29rumors around Prime trust are true for the type of service
- 1:37:33that they're providing like multi-institution multisig
- 1:37:38should be the standard moving forward because the way
- 1:37:41multi-institution like in a financial products to use some
- 1:37:43chains, lending desk, for example, it's a multi
- 1:37:46Institution, Two or three, multisig corn, which the the
- 1:37:51borrower puts up Bitcoin. As collateral in this multisig,
- 1:37:55escrow wallet, they hold one key, the borrower does unchain
- 1:37:58holds a key and then Kingdom trust holds the third K.
- 1:38:01So in this agreement me as a borrower on the individual
- 1:38:06borrowing, I get the confidence of knowing that Unchained can't
- 1:38:10unilaterally move my Bitcoin. They don't hold two keys, it's
- 1:38:13spread out between them and another institution.
- 1:38:16Similarly With Honor, Ramp if you invest in the the on-ramp
- 1:38:21trust on-ramp holds the key Kingdom Trussell to keep it goes
- 1:38:25the key. Like you know, that's
- 1:38:26distributed among free institutions.
- 1:38:29They have to collude to move your Bitcoin which is unlikely
- 1:38:32given the fact that they want to uphold the reputations of good
- 1:38:35stewards of the keys that they hold in sign on behalf of
- 1:38:39individuals. And so this really acts as a
- 1:38:42forcing function for individual companies and Services offering
- 1:38:46Bitcoin. Products to act act correctly.
- 1:38:52Like you literally cannot miss allocate the funds because you
- 1:38:55would need to collaborate with another institution to do so and
- 1:39:00the likelihood of them willing to being willing to sort of
- 1:39:05erode their reputation because you want to do something with
- 1:39:08customer. Bitcoin is is lower.
- 1:39:12Yeah, especially if you can. Yeah, god well, I was just gonna
- 1:39:17add that, you know, that's especially true.
- 1:39:19When these parties involved are qualified custodian companies
- 1:39:24and their entire reputation is, is based on being responsible
- 1:39:28stewards for client assets. And they're not about to risk
- 1:39:32that to participate in some kind of collusion.
- 1:39:36Yeah, I think the two things to say is like that, there's a lot
- 1:39:40of things we've said that are theoretical And that people that
- 1:39:42are closer to the space will agree with or have come to those
- 1:39:45conclusions. The one that is not their
- 1:39:47abilities is practical and it is the state of the market is
- 1:39:52Unchained. Did not look at has never lost a
- 1:39:55lot. They had a form of custody that
- 1:39:58will we just loved. Marty just talked about and as
- 1:40:00the market and all the leverage and all things happen, they
- 1:40:02could not rehypothecation, they cannot move client funds.
- 1:40:05And so when we talk about, you know, multi-party custody and
- 1:40:09the way you want to distribute keys and why it is From a sense
- 1:40:12for pokes, whether it's Palm on collaborative, custody, holding
- 1:40:15one key or to whatever the setup is, there's this reality that it
- 1:40:20provides a assurances that don't exist in the old world of
- 1:40:24whether it's crypto or just traditional financial services.
- 1:40:27And to Jesse's point, this is the market structure now, but
- 1:40:31it's our view that as this gets accepted into the market, on the
- 1:40:35next run up, people will look for firms that provide services
- 1:40:40like this because they And that education gets disseminated
- 1:40:44Market, they realize that they do not want to leave their
- 1:40:46Bitcoin the precious book when on a single exchange and over
- 1:40:50time, you know, right now it's Bitcoin companies are Bitcoin
- 1:40:53and Jason companies, but you can imagine a world where a firm,
- 1:40:56hold the key that their balance sheet is completely different
- 1:40:58and they're tied economically. And like from their productivity
- 1:41:01there to revenue is tied to whether its Financial Services
- 1:41:05or some other offering, but they will the kids.
- 1:41:07So, just from a game theory, they're not incentivized to move
- 1:41:10the assets or collude. Because that is something that
- 1:41:13obviously comes up and the common answer to that is well,
- 1:41:16there's no, there's no perfect solution for just trade-offs and
- 1:41:19that's really the reality. It's like very often early.
- 1:41:21I don't change folks and say, well what you can collude with
- 1:41:24Kingdom trust or at the time it was Citadel to move the funds
- 1:41:27and it's like, well sure you can but your whole Enterprise Value
- 1:41:30would go to zero all the things that would happen along with
- 1:41:32that. And you're, if you're assuming
- 1:41:34that will you've already taken a step that block by would have
- 1:41:37already done that, which they happen to be doing that.
- 1:41:39So I think over time we will find more Our key Partners or
- 1:41:43key Partners will grow, they'll realize they want to step in and
- 1:41:46be a part of the Bitcoin ecosystem and it's a very low
- 1:41:48hanging easy way to participate. Build trust and just build a
- 1:41:53more like result resilient redundant part of the network.
- 1:41:57Yeah, I think an interesting backdrop to, to both on-ramp and
- 1:42:00Unchained. It's like, it's Bitcoin
- 1:42:02multisig, right? We don't have to worry about MPC
- 1:42:05like multi-party computation or whatever might be behind
- 1:42:08something like a fire box or something like that.
- 1:42:11Because As we're worried about other assets, being secured in
- 1:42:14multisig, right there is I think just MPC bug exploited, maybe a
- 1:42:17couple months ago, it's like we have Bitcoin multisig.
- 1:42:21It's a native Bitcoin property and we're using that to, you
- 1:42:25know, that at, that is what we're educating on.
- 1:42:27And we are, that's, that's what we're using to secure.
- 1:42:31I think, what is the Best Collateral ever, the best money
- 1:42:35ever, and like, that cannot be overstated.
- 1:42:39I think so. It's like, the, the native And
- 1:42:42protocols and then Michael nailed it.
- 1:42:43Exactly like, eliminating your single points of failure.
- 1:42:46At the end of the day, Prime trust is a single point of
- 1:42:49failure or who, you know, whoever it is, if it's one
- 1:42:51source, one signature required, to move funds into your in onto
- 1:42:58your Bitcoin address that you control.
- 1:43:00There's only one counterparty that is a trusted third party.
- 1:43:03That is a security hole and a single point of failure.
- 1:43:06Yeah, it was really ironic touching it back to what Jesse
- 1:43:10said earlier when you the Logan Valley, archetype the Silicon
- 1:43:15Valley VC archetype looks a bit coin, so there's no innovation
- 1:43:18like, that's the ironic thing because like something like this
- 1:43:21is incredibly Innovative for the building, like a new Financial
- 1:43:27system on top of the assurances that are provided with this
- 1:43:30multisig, multi-institution model, are an innovation that
- 1:43:35anybody really Grox. What's going on here?
- 1:43:37Should notice. Immediately and intuitively.
- 1:43:41Like this is a massive step function Improvement in the
- 1:43:45security of financial assets. Broadly speaking, not just in
- 1:43:49Bitcoin like for the world. Yeah, this is is trying to find
- 1:43:57like Innovation to add another level of cards on top of the
- 1:44:01House of Cards. It's built on Sand and they
- 1:44:03don't recognize when they see Bitcoin is laying a concrete
- 1:44:08foundation. Of a totally new separate house
- 1:44:11that doesn't register for them as Innovation because they're
- 1:44:13looking for the next tier of of cards.
- 1:44:16And in what is a doomed construction project from the
- 1:44:21beginning? Yeah, and the growth of went
- 1:44:25Jessica's reference in building that, you know, base like
- 1:44:28Foundation, Tyler keyed in on it and it's very little it's not
- 1:44:32necessarily talk or known but like the interoperability of
- 1:44:35event Emma. Again in a multisig is basically
- 1:44:38infinite. Scalable not from like the
- 1:44:41number of M of n, but from The Trusted parties that can
- 1:44:44continue to grow with it. And so you can build a resilient
- 1:44:48redundant base layer of custody with trusted parties as you're
- 1:44:52able to hold one of those keys and anything else doesn't
- 1:44:55provide that, and that's like the dirty secret because
- 1:44:57everybody who averages and then PC or like an HSM.
- 1:45:01Generally, the main players are far blocks Anchorage and, you
- 1:45:05know, somewhat Ledger and some other firms.
- 1:45:07But they use a clip to keep that closed systems.
- 1:45:09They can never go to another party and participate in that.
- 1:45:12And what's being built, here, we know, others are building it.
- 1:45:14And that's the beauty is like it's not competitive.
- 1:45:16In the sense of I think of it like strike and lights Park
- 1:45:20striping and playing this world of like you know
- 1:45:23enterprise-grade liquidity and tooling around payments and
- 1:45:27everything that they're building on interchange in lights.
- 1:45:30Work for an uninitiated like oh that's very competitive playing
- 1:45:33with the realities you want multiple people playing in that
- 1:45:35field, these were playing for the biggest game and so if
- 1:45:38others are Basically legitimizes and standardizes that you have a
- 1:45:43better form of a financial product and then others can jump
- 1:45:46in. And again, when you're talking
- 1:45:47about all the money and all the assets you want as many people
- 1:45:51participating and you don't want to be sitting alone, trying to
- 1:45:54do that and that's where like, adding additional key holders.
- 1:45:57Kenan trust was awesome to be early.
- 1:45:59Ryan's great, bit, go and there's discussions that I think
- 1:46:02everybody's having for folks, that would join a network like
- 1:46:06this. And as that continues to grow,
- 1:46:07you can imagine jurisdictions will I'll also come into play
- 1:46:10across the world and it just adds to the further robustness
- 1:46:13and attack surface that people are looking out to think about
- 1:46:17what maybe I want some keys that held outside the United States.
- 1:46:21I'll make the argument that Silicon Valley is intimidated
- 1:46:24but the level of innovation going on in Bitcoin because you
- 1:46:27know, it's not just these innovative business models.
- 1:46:29It's also many script and Frost with Taproot there's so many
- 1:46:34like interesting things that can be built on top of Bitcoin.
- 1:46:37So it's like you know, it's just, it's education, it's
- 1:46:40getting the word out there, it's inspiring these, you know,
- 1:46:44young, whether you're a product person or an engineer like work
- 1:46:48on bitcoin, the Austin seen, Seen Silicon Valley even could
- 1:46:52be, maybe a may be rescued or I guess, you know, ever ever, ever
- 1:46:57Redemption Arc, but there's so much Innovation going on in
- 1:47:00Bitcoin, so that might be where the about tweet thread later,
- 1:47:04any Marty's going to rescue Philadelphia before Silicon
- 1:47:07Valley, gets rescued. Absolutely Philly.
- 1:47:10I'm coming back. I'm going to I'm going to say
- 1:47:11Philly at some point not that it needs.
- 1:47:14I'm not gonna act like yeah I'm gonna say Philly at some point.
- 1:47:17I need saving. He's offered these Frankfurt.
- 1:47:19Oh you said New York City to look like Mad Max.
- 1:47:25I think they're a little trouble as well.
- 1:47:29Philly looks like that today. All the smoke is is gone to
- 1:47:32Philly but no I mean we need to build on the strong Foundation
- 1:47:38as Jesse as Jesse said. And that's really the sad thing
- 1:47:43about the Silicon Valley thing that's been sort of the seen.
- 1:47:45The overarching theme of this episode is the inability of the
- 1:47:50finances. Coin basis, Silicon Valley, VCS
- 1:47:53of the world to not eat the marshmallow and fall for the
- 1:47:57siren calls of crypto and the quick and fast gains that will
- 1:48:01come there at the end of the day.
- 1:48:04There's a very empty gain. See you.
- 1:48:05You're scamming people at the end of the day.
- 1:48:08Yes. You're making your LPS Rich.
- 1:48:09Yes. You're going public as a company
- 1:48:11but at the end of the day, are you actually pushing the ball
- 1:48:14forward in terms of creating the new digital Financial realm?
- 1:48:19I don't think so. I think the the scoreboard would
- 1:48:22show that you've really rubbed a lot of retail investors made
- 1:48:27yourself and your investors rich with nothing to show for it at
- 1:48:32the end of the day and all the cases.
- 1:48:35Is that wouldn't like it, there's nothing there.
- 1:48:38It's very morally bankrupt in my opinion and Bitcoin.
- 1:48:42A lot of people think it's slow dumb, stupid expensive, but it
- 1:48:47is as things for a reason. And as we just mentioned,
- 1:48:50Bitcoin is extremely Innovative. When you, when you factor in
- 1:48:53these native properties that allow you to build a strong
- 1:48:56Foundation that can actually fix the structural problems that
- 1:49:00exist throughout our financial banking system.
- 1:49:06Perfectly said, Marty excellent. Michael, do you want to say
- 1:49:11somebody saw you jump. I was just and also like the
- 1:49:15numbers just don't add up in the sense of all the crypto only
- 1:49:18exist. When the money sloshing like you
- 1:49:20there's a chart with the Venture for this year but then the thing
- 1:49:23that most people like and I don't know how they rationalize
- 1:49:25this but like whether it's crypto or the users, once the
- 1:49:29liquidity dries like once the market kind of, you know, does
- 1:49:32its thing in the cycle and everything is you know, buy
- 1:49:34Bitcoins tail went like all the activity ends.
- 1:49:37It's all washed ready, when you really like, look at it, like
- 1:49:39they try to make digital Primitives.
- 1:49:40On it and there's just a token that's being traded and then
- 1:49:44once it flows but it was like one of the money just so it
- 1:49:47doesn't add up because to your point Marty like you're saying
- 1:49:51the Innovation doesn't really like by definition.
- 1:49:53There is no innovation because the dollars there's so many
- 1:49:56dollars that it's chasing these like crazy things that don't
- 1:49:59make any sense in a second. The dollar slow down because the
- 1:50:02cost of capital goes everything just like come to a screeching
- 1:50:06halt and nobody's eating any of the crap there that everybody is
- 1:50:09positive. You're saying that they're like
- 1:50:10In the world and keep it, you know, whatever they say about
- 1:50:14the global South and the currencies and whatever crap
- 1:50:17that like they're trying to push to further this like you know
- 1:50:20Griff it'll just like comes to screeching halt and you're
- 1:50:23sitting there and there was no innovation, there was nothing
- 1:50:25done, a bunch of people lost it a bunch of money.
- 1:50:28So yeah, the crypto would suggest is and I think Point
- 1:50:30earlier like Kudzu crooked just basically gave like the highest
- 1:50:34Fidelity signal of the Venture sloshing of money, into the
- 1:50:38quickest way to dump on people. And in richest an individual or
- 1:50:43a group of individuals, it's been a fascinating conversation.
- 1:50:49Tyler, thank you for joining us this week.
- 1:50:51Any, any final thoughts before we wrap up here?
- 1:50:57A lot of folks listening to this, like, you know, if you
- 1:50:59haven't taken the move, just custody or Bitcoin or think
- 1:51:01about eliminating all single points of failure, like do it
- 1:51:05extreme ownership extreme responsibility.
- 1:51:08It's like nobody can do it but you get off the couch and go do
- 1:51:11it. There's so many great resources
- 1:51:14out there. In terms of Education, the blog
- 1:51:17at Unchained is excellent with some awesome team members that
- 1:51:19are just you know 50 feet away from me that right.
- 1:51:22Really best-in-class content just came out with the hollow
- 1:51:25caves. You can see the spread of
- 1:51:27returns for Bitcoin. Hold periods.
- 1:51:30I think that's really, really interesting.
- 1:51:31So go maybe make it a weekend of education, but no, this is
- 1:51:35awesome. You guys.
- 1:51:36I am really inspired to go back to my Silicon, Valley relatives
- 1:51:40and have another conversation. So thank you, you know, even
- 1:51:44episode of send him. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:51:46Exactly Jesse Michael anything. No.
- 1:51:51Yeah. I I think, you know, from the
- 1:51:54on-ramp perspective of Tyler's right?
- 1:51:57That eventually, I think everyone should be aspiring to
- 1:52:02self custody. Michael also talked about, you
- 1:52:05know, their scenarios where you it might make sense for people
- 1:52:09to consider at least part or majority through an Avenue where
- 1:52:15they can't unilaterally control their own coins for security
- 1:52:19purposes. And social engineering purposes,
- 1:52:22but you know, the aspiration should be towards self custody.
- 1:52:27However, for a lot of people listening, you know, they're
- 1:52:29bitcoiners, they've taken self custody or are ready to.
- 1:52:34But for a lot of people in your lives, they're not ready for
- 1:52:41Bitcoin because they're scared of of how to handle this new
- 1:52:47asset in a secure way. And that's We built on ramp to
- 1:52:51be a bridge for people to get into Bitcoin in a way where they
- 1:52:57know they have best-in-class security through multisig
- 1:52:59multi-party, vaults, but it allows them to keep open the
- 1:53:06option to take self custody when they're ready.
- 1:53:09So, you know, there's a learning process involved in Bitcoin and
- 1:53:12you don't want to get stuck in grayscale where you're not
- 1:53:14allowed to withdraw your Bitcoin and you don't want to be leaving
- 1:53:18it on coinbase because of the stuff they were seeing play out
- 1:53:21in the market in real time. So for those people in your life
- 1:53:25who are ready for Bitcoin better scared, we think the on-ramp
- 1:53:29helps lower that barrier to entry to get a position in
- 1:53:34Bitcoin and get started at the right way it while allowing for
- 1:53:39eventually transitioning to self custody with with a platform
- 1:53:43like Unchained or whoever makes sense for that individual.
- 1:53:46Yeah, that's actually a great point that I'll share, only with
- 1:53:51is something we talked about early days and chain, Parker.
- 1:53:55We go into meetings that the referencing at Tyler of like
- 1:53:58holding those private Keys. It makes something that's
- 1:54:00ephemeral to individuals that's just like up in the air
- 1:54:03tangible, and that they see these hard keys, the keys, the
- 1:54:06private key was on the device, they don't just get up and walk
- 1:54:08away. And so when they understand the
- 1:54:10mechanisms behind that they can actually Park real well, because
- 1:54:13our thought is that everybody wants exposure.
- 1:54:15Once they Best for NASA, the properties, but then they just
- 1:54:19shy away from it because it can't figure out the custody.
- 1:54:21And so whether it's holding a single key, multisig, real 23 or
- 1:54:25saying, oh, I understand that these keys are segregated or
- 1:54:28Like Hell by different institutions.
- 1:54:29They don't just get up and plug themselves in and this is how I
- 1:54:32can feel confident and getting exposure.
- 1:54:34And then I can go down the rabbit hole and get educated
- 1:54:36figure out what the best thing is.
- 1:54:38I think all of those unlock a lot of capital because a lot of
- 1:54:42people are scared that what's going to happen at by Nancy
- 1:54:44coinbase and FTX and blog fi So yeah, excited.
- 1:54:48And then I think a bunch of us are going to Nashville next
- 1:54:49week. So we'll, we'll see some folks
- 1:54:52there. And then, whoever, whether it's
- 1:54:54Tyler Marty or in the Commons office, go ping, ping Parker.
- 1:54:58I think we got em tentatively slated next week.
- 1:55:01He's supposed to be in Nashville as well so you guys can see it.
- 1:55:04But he was he was ducking down. Looking through the window right
- 1:55:06here. I think he's very happy with the
- 1:55:07group we have today, incredible group rips, re in the books.
- 1:55:13A lot of stuff's going on. This is where the signal is
- 1:55:16Bitcoin is a signal, don't listen to the people telling you
- 1:55:19the Bitcoin maximalist number one, they don't exist.
- 1:55:22There's no, like there's no like uniform group pick winners, who
- 1:55:27agree on everything. It doesn't exist to fiction of
- 1:55:31people's imagination. Read the receipts.
- 1:55:35We've been saying the stuff for years eliminate single points of
- 1:55:38failure. There's a lot of grift and
- 1:55:41morally, dubious morally, dubious activity, going on in
- 1:55:44crypto. We're here at the last trade to
- 1:55:48bring signal to help you understand this and hope you
- 1:55:51like this for. It will see you guys next week.
- 1:55:35Read the receipts. We've been saying the stuff for
- 1:55:37years eliminate single points of failure.
- 1:55:39There's a lot of grift and morally, dubious morally,
- 1:55:43dubious activity, going on in crypto.
- 1:55:46We're here at the last trade to bring signal to help you
- 1:55:49understand this and hope you like this for.
- 1:55:52It will see you guys next week.