Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Cryptocurrency Tracing and Recovery in Matrimonial Disputes: A Practical Guide
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Cryptocurrency Tracing and Recovery
- 0:06in Metrimonial Disputes, a Practical Guide. I'm
- 0:11Philipp Behring, Chair of the Chair of the Law
- 0:13Section and Law Section. I'm delighted to welcome
- 0:17to our speaker Adam Snyder and Dr. Boris Richard.
- 0:23Adam is counsel at Umhofer, Mitchell and King
- 0:26LLP, where he represents founders, protocols,
- 0:29foundations and investors in securities. white
- 0:32-collar and complex commercial disputes involving
- 0:35digital assets. He obtained dismissals of an
- 0:38S &C enforcement action against Crypto Foundation
- 0:40and defended senior executives of a leading social
- 0:43media company through a federal criminal investigation.
- 0:47He is also CEO of UpAILC, shares UMKA's AI adoption
- 0:53task force and presents MCLE programs on cryptocurrencies
- 0:56and AI. Dr. Boaz Richard is the founder of UpAILC.
- 1:01a consultancy that pairs human expertise with
- 1:04AI and machine learning to deliver expert witness,
- 1:08blockchain analytics, asset tracing, and crypto
- 1:10valuation services. With over 25 years in security
- 1:14markets, he held trading and strategy roles at
- 1:17Goldman Sachs, Barclays Capital, and HSBC Securities
- 1:21before managing quantitative fixed income hedge
- 1:24fund portfolios. Since 2018, he has launched
- 1:27the digital asset practice as FTI Consulting,
- 1:30helped build a similar practice at JS Health
- 1:33and testified in matters involving token registration,
- 1:37crypto tracing, market manipulation, and digital
- 1:40asset valuation disputes. If you want to become
- 1:44a member or want to join our blockchain and web
- 1:49suite law section, please reach out to me. We
- 1:52have once a month a meeting. And Adam, you will
- 1:57take over. And now let's get started. Thank you,
- 2:01Philip. So yeah, I'm just going to speak very
- 2:03briefly because really who you're all here to
- 2:06hear from is Dr. Richard. But I just want to
- 2:09speak briefly on, you know, kind of why we think
- 2:13this is so important. You know, family lawyers
- 2:16have always chased hidden assets. That's nothing
- 2:19new. But crypto is the newest and it's the newest
- 2:23version of the old problem. where a spouse can
- 2:26now hold a seven -figure asset behind 12 words
- 2:29memorized or written on an index card in a desk
- 2:32drawer. For a self -custodied wallet, there's
- 2:35no bank subpoena, no statement in the mail, no
- 2:38help desk to help reset a password. And yet the
- 2:41same technology makes crypto easy to hide, makes
- 2:44it nearly impossible to erase. Every transfer
- 2:47is written to a public ledger permanently for
- 2:50anyone who knows how to read it. The reading
- 2:54it is the hard part and that is why we have dr.
- 2:57Boris Richard with us today Philip already went
- 3:02through some of his qualifications. So I won't
- 3:05go through all of that again But what I will
- 3:08say is that I can speak to this firsthand. Dr.
- 3:11Richard was recently a consulting expert on a
- 3:15tracing matter that my firm resolved with a very
- 3:18positive outcome and It was extremely helpful
- 3:23to have Dr. Richard, who can take a lawyer like
- 3:27me through a wall of transaction hashes and turn
- 3:31that into a brief one page story about where
- 3:35the money went and what happened. And I truly
- 3:41do believe that family law is among the most
- 3:45important places for exactly this skill to be
- 3:49used. And so I will ask that we, we're gonna
- 3:55hold questions for the end, but you can feel
- 3:58free to throw those in the chat. I'll compile
- 4:00those and we'll run those through with Dr. Richard
- 4:03if we have a few minutes at the end. So with
- 4:06that, I will turn it over and look forward to
- 4:10hearing from you. All right. Awesome. Thank you,
- 4:15Adam. It's a pleasure to be here. It's a pleasure
- 4:17to share what I know and what could be useful
- 4:21and what is really useful in the world of crypto
- 4:24assets. So let me share the screen and then we
- 4:30can get started. Okay. I just want to make sure.
- 4:37Do you guys see everything, Adam? Maybe you could
- 4:40just confirm. Okay. All right. So I This is a
- 4:47pretty dense presentation. So probably I will
- 4:52go through some of these fairly quickly in terms
- 4:57of, first of all, let me kind of delineate what
- 5:01we're looking to accomplish. And then I will
- 5:04try to do my best in terms of being efficient
- 5:07in covering the material and making it exciting.
- 5:10Indeed, it is a very exciting field. And I ended
- 5:14up being in cryptos almost by accident back in
- 5:182018, but ever since then, I never looked back
- 5:20because the area really brings up a lot of interesting
- 5:24questions that go way beyond just technical questions
- 5:27of how to find the assets. It's issues of valuation.
- 5:30It's issues of who owes what to whom. Anyway,
- 5:36as part of this particular discussion, I would
- 5:38like to quickly refresh or introduce some basic
- 5:42concepts related to distributed ledger technology,
- 5:44i .e. blockchain. Secondly, I would like to discuss
- 5:49real quick major types of crypto litigation that
- 5:53does require blockchain analytics. Because again,
- 5:56blockchain analytics as a tracing is a very,
- 5:58very wide field and it is applicable to marital
- 6:02law disputes. It is applicable to issues like
- 6:05sanction evasions, tracing illicit funds, double
- 6:10checking and confirming the accuracy of corporate
- 6:14disclosures. So taxation. So I will highlight
- 6:19a few examples, kind of real world examples where
- 6:22asset tracing in the crypto space is extremely
- 6:24important. Then I will go through some of the
- 6:28tools that are being used by blockchain investigators.
- 6:31Again, I will not get technical, but nevertheless,
- 6:35some of the tools could be used by anybody. And
- 6:38to the extent that they're public access, they
- 6:40could be used by attorneys as well. So I'm gonna
- 6:43kind of highlight a few examples of that. We
- 6:46will discuss some real life examples of blockchain
- 6:49investigation that I was part of and kind of
- 6:52highlight the breadth of this particular field
- 6:55and how useful the stuff could get. And then
- 6:59we definitely talk about some of the practical
- 7:02issues that are specific to cryptos and are specific
- 7:06to marital law. So in terms of the fundamentals
- 7:11of distributed ledger, technology, cryptographic
- 7:14assets, and blockchain transactions. So again,
- 7:18my apologies if that is already known and familiar
- 7:23to you guys, but let me just jump through it
- 7:26real quick. So blockchain is just a distributed
- 7:30database, right? It's a permissionless, anybody
- 7:33can join it. It is governed by consensus. The
- 7:36record of transactions is maintained at the entire
- 7:40network of computers. So, you know, looks like
- 7:44a really, you know, a distributed database. This
- 7:47is what blockchain is. The question is, how do
- 7:49you govern it? How do you impose the validity
- 7:55and how you prevent malicious actors from screwing
- 7:58up or posting wrong transactions on a blockchain?
- 8:02So blockchain is just a chain of blocks. and
- 8:06chain of blocks. You take transactions, you assemble
- 8:09them into the blocks, and then you create a chain
- 8:11of those blocks. And what's important in a blockchain
- 8:14is that that particular chain is immutable. It
- 8:18cannot be changed. It's not the centralized database.
- 8:21It's not like an accountant can go in and it
- 8:23will change a particular entry record, you know,
- 8:26five years ago. To the extent that these sequence
- 8:31of blocks and content of each block is agreed
- 8:34upon by a consensus, by a majority of participants
- 8:39in the blockchain, it is essentially immutable
- 8:42unless somebody can overwrite 51 % or more and
- 8:48create something that's called the fork. Did
- 8:51it happen? Yes, it did. These days, it's absolutely
- 8:55impossible because, for example, for Bitcoin,
- 8:57for someone to override or change a transaction
- 9:00or change the order of the blocks, they will
- 9:02have to amass a computing power in excess of
- 9:0551%. So basically, they have to gain a majority.
- 9:08And in the blockchain world of Bitcoin, it is
- 9:11just not impossible given the sheer size of computing
- 9:14power which is distributed worldwide. So blockchain
- 9:21is decentralized. It is decentralized blockchain.
- 9:25It is permissionless. In principle, anybody can
- 9:28join the network and participate in it. And it
- 9:31is trustless. It's not driven by some particular
- 9:34hard -coded rules. It is driven by the economic
- 9:38incentives of the participants. And that's why
- 9:40it is important that the majority, either of
- 9:43the tokens or the majority holding the computing
- 9:46power, enforces those rules. So, you know, kind
- 9:51of skim through real quick how the blocks are
- 9:55assembled and how they chain together as a chain.
- 9:58So we start with a bunch of transactions. You
- 10:01know, you assemble them into the block and then
- 10:04eventually you chain those blocks together. There
- 10:07is a continuity between the blocks in the blockchain
- 10:10because a hash or a header of the preceding block
- 10:14becomes a part of the hash of the following.
- 10:18So you have this sequence of hashes which trace
- 10:21the history of transactions and on the blocks
- 10:24from the inception, from the genesis of a particular
- 10:28blockchain. So that's kind of fascinating. Again,
- 10:33I'm going to skip this particular one. It talks
- 10:36about the data structure blockchain. If you have
- 10:38any questions and you would like to get technical,
- 10:41about how the blockchain works, so I'm happy
- 10:43to engage into that discussion. In terms of the
- 10:47participants and in terms of how it works, on
- 10:51this slide, it's very simple. You have a transaction
- 10:54request. Agent A wants to pay to Agent B a fraction
- 10:58of a Bitcoin. That particular transaction is
- 11:01broadcast to the entire world of people who participate
- 11:05in that blockchain. If there is enough of those
- 11:08transactions, they are assembled in a block.
- 11:11So you have a block building component. Then
- 11:13you chain the blocks together. Whoever validates
- 11:17the block gets either mining or staking rewards.
- 11:20Like in Bitcoin right now, the mining reward
- 11:24for validating a block is three and an eighth
- 11:27of a Bitcoin. So Bitcoin is about 81 grand today.
- 11:32So the dollar value to the miner who validates
- 11:36a particular block is about 240 ,000. Now these
- 11:40days the probability of somebody mining individually
- 11:42is almost, the probability of winning a block
- 11:46is almost zero. So that's why right now the mining
- 11:49is very centralized in the hands of actually
- 11:53even some of the publicly traded companies, I
- 11:56know like Hut Aid or others who have dedicated
- 12:01facilities, basically data centers with thousands
- 12:04and thousands of mining computers who do the
- 12:07work. So eventually this is kind of the sequence
- 12:12of how this plays out. In terms of the blockchain
- 12:16participants, number one, these are users who
- 12:20send in transactions. So in terms of the marital
- 12:23law or disputes that happen in the field of marital
- 12:26law, a husband or a wife would obviously be a
- 12:30user because this is what eventually you or an
- 12:35expert will have to trace if there is a dispute
- 12:37about human crypto assets. So in addition to
- 12:40users, there are those who are called miners.
- 12:45Miners, typically they are part of so -called
- 12:49proof of work blockchains. Bitcoin would be the
- 12:53primary example of a proof of work. A proof of
- 12:57work means that blocks are validated through
- 13:00solving cryptographic puzzles. So that's why
- 13:02it's actually work done by the computers, by
- 13:05the mining rigs. On other chains like Ethereum,
- 13:09which is the second largest public blockchain,
- 13:13those who validate the blocks, they're not called
- 13:16miners, they're called validators, or sometimes
- 13:18they're called block producers. And in Ethereum,
- 13:23the validation of blocks is different. It's not
- 13:25through the work. It's not through the computations.
- 13:27It's through staking your ETH and effectively
- 13:31tying up your capital and your rewards are in
- 13:36proportion to the amount of the stake that you
- 13:39have posted. The minimum stake to be a validator
- 13:43on Ethereum right now is 32. 32 ETH tokens. And
- 13:48again, it becomes a pretty sizable chunk of money,
- 13:52given that Ethereum right now is a few thousand
- 13:57dollars in terms of value. So again, Bitcoin,
- 14:02that's a major token, has 21 million. The total
- 14:07potential supply, I mean, is programmatically
- 14:11defined by the code. created by Satoshi Nakamoto
- 14:15back in 2009. So there could be no more than
- 14:1821 million Bitcoin. At the moment, about 96 %
- 14:23of Bitcoin has already been mined. So it's like
- 14:26it's 20 .1 million, I think is circulating right
- 14:29now. Albeit, people say that about 3 million
- 14:33of Bitcoin are permanently lost. Meaning that
- 14:36people who mined Bitcoin back in 2009, 10, 11,
- 14:40they didn't think about it as an asset with a
- 14:45long -term lifespan and some of the bitcoins
- 14:48are actually lost forever. To the extent that
- 14:51you have keys that you wrote down on a piece
- 14:53of paper back in 2009 and you lost that piece
- 14:56of paper, once you lose the private key, you
- 15:01effectively cannot recover the bitcoin from your
- 15:05unhosted wallet because in addition to the public
- 15:08key, you also need a private key. So anyway,
- 15:11that's Bitcoin. Everybody knows about it. I'm
- 15:16sorry. So any blockchain and any wallet has two
- 15:22components to it. The public key, which is effectively
- 15:26an address, right? You can think about an address
- 15:29as an alphanumeric string that defines your particular
- 15:35wallet or your particular address. and it is
- 15:37known. It's like a location. So if you want to
- 15:40move Bitcoin from point A to point B, the addresses
- 15:46in A and address in B are publicly known. This
- 15:49is how the transaction gets consummated. What's
- 15:53important is a private key. The private key is
- 15:56effectively, again, it's a secret piece of information
- 15:59that you're required to sign a transaction. If
- 16:03you want to send one Bitcoin from wallet A to
- 16:07wallet B, you must have access to the private
- 16:11key for wallet A because you must sign the transfer
- 16:15transaction. Otherwise the transaction will not
- 16:18work. So that's why the ownership of private
- 16:21key is of critical component because effectively
- 16:25a person who controls and knows the private key
- 16:28is the one who controls the cryptographic asset.
- 16:31So it's simple as that. Ethereum, again, that's
- 16:38number two, the largest one. Bitcoin right now
- 16:41is about 1 .6 trillion in market value. Ethereum
- 16:46is about 20 % of that. So the market value of
- 16:49Ethereum right now is just shy of 300 billion.
- 16:52Again, that's the second largest public permissionless
- 16:55blockchain out there with tokens circulating.
- 16:59And again, the difference is that Bitcoin is
- 17:01a proof of work. it is still the validation of
- 17:03the blocks is still based on cryptographic computations
- 17:07done by a bunch of computers. Whoever solves
- 17:11the puzzle gets the block and gets the three
- 17:14and an eighth of a bitcoin as a reward. In Ethereum
- 17:16it's different, it's proof of stake and therefore
- 17:19the probability of someone getting to validate
- 17:22the block is directly proportional to how much
- 17:26in Ethereum you stake. for being able to propose
- 17:31and validate the blocks. So again, wallets in
- 17:36marital law, in any kind of tracing, wallet is
- 17:40a very key concept. And sometimes people confuse
- 17:46the wallet as a cryptographic address with a
- 17:51software application. And again, the name wallet
- 17:56is used interchangeably. If you see a particular
- 18:00address on chain, some people say it's a wallet,
- 18:03but wallet could also be a software application.
- 18:06And again, the wallet could reside in your computer.
- 18:11In the days past, there was a paper wallet, which
- 18:14was just a piece of paper where you write down
- 18:16your public key and your private key. And you
- 18:18might also be familiar with a lot of hardware
- 18:20wallets. So basically like little tiny fobs,
- 18:24little tiny things that look like the flash drives.
- 18:27like I'm depicting here on this particular slide,
- 18:31a Ledger Nano. It's the hardware, it's a hardware
- 18:36application. You stick it in into the USB drive
- 18:38of the computer and it does store your public
- 18:41key. It does store your private key. And typically
- 18:44these hardware wallets, they can handle the cryptocurrencies
- 18:48across different chains. Not all of Bitcoin.
- 18:51Could be Ethereum, could be Solana, could be
- 18:53XRP, meme coins, what have you. So therefore
- 18:59kind of the concept of cryptocurrency addresses
- 19:03in the wallets is important because these are
- 19:06the kind of building blocks of how a tracing
- 19:09exercise is performed. And we'll see some of
- 19:13the examples of that later. Again, just talking
- 19:18about the ownership. Ownership in the crypto
- 19:20world is equivalent to who owns the private key.
- 19:25who has the authority to sign a push transaction,
- 19:28to sign the transaction to send one asset from
- 19:33point A to point B. Now, there are different
- 19:36ways of ownership of those crypto keys. There
- 19:40is a concept of something that's called multi
- 19:42-signature or multi -sig wallet. That's a wallet
- 19:45that is effectively controlled by more than one
- 19:49person. And therefore, to sign a transaction,
- 19:53each of those persons or at least the majority
- 19:55of those persons have to use their key to sign
- 19:58a transaction. You know, like the big hot wallets
- 20:02of crypto exchanges are typically multi -signature
- 20:05because this gives you an additional layer of
- 20:07security so that, you know, the companies, corporations
- 20:12may prevent fraudulent transactions from being
- 20:15signed. You need to have a sort of a set of trusted
- 20:19persons And those trusted persons have to agree
- 20:23on, you know, effecting certain transaction.
- 20:27And therefore they have, at least the majority
- 20:29of them have to sign. This is the purpose of
- 20:33the multi -signature wallet. There are other
- 20:35interesting technologies out there. You know,
- 20:38one called MPC or multi -party computation, where
- 20:43there is one single private key, but it's split
- 20:46into different shards. So it could be split into
- 20:50three shards and three counterparties. Nobody
- 20:55knows the entire key. You only know your particular
- 20:59one -third of the key. The other two -thirds
- 21:02of the keys are known to the other people on
- 21:05the team. For the transaction being signed, all
- 21:09three shards of that particular private key have
- 21:12to be put together, create a complete sequence,
- 21:15so that the transaction is properly signed. So
- 21:18again, offline, we can talk about different ways
- 21:22of how the security of private keys is enforced
- 21:26in a crypto space these days. Any questions at
- 21:31this point? So happy to, Adam, do you want to
- 21:34handle any questions right now? You want to move
- 21:36on and just kind of say them through the end?
- 21:39Yeah, most of what I'm seeing right now is a
- 21:42little in depth. So I think it will probably
- 21:43make sense to cover that at the end. OK. Okay.
- 21:48Perfect. All right. So let's move on to the section
- 21:51number two. Let me kind of walk you guys through
- 21:54major types of crypto litigation that requires
- 21:57blockchain analytics and asset tracing. So I'm
- 22:00going to give a few examples. And again, marital
- 22:04disputes is an important part of that universe,
- 22:08but we will see that other types of litigations
- 22:11require the ability to trace assets in a right
- 22:15way. So example number one, obviously, marital
- 22:19disputes. If the assets are hidden, if one's
- 22:22spouse does not properly disclose, you have to
- 22:25find where those assets are, how they were acquired,
- 22:30and you have to trace. And sometimes those tracing
- 22:33exercises become pretty convoluted. I've been
- 22:37in a particular, I mean, I handle several marital
- 22:40disputes. And in one of the disputes, the transactional
- 22:43history of the husband traced back to 2017. So
- 22:48and my work was done in 2023, 2024. So I had
- 22:54to trace at least seven years of transactional
- 22:56history, you know, through different exchanges,
- 22:59different wallets, different, different assets.
- 23:01So it is interesting, but sometimes it becomes
- 23:05convoluted. The second, you know, second activity
- 23:10where you need to know how to trace assets is
- 23:13computational damages. Again, I can cite a particular
- 23:17example where one founder of a blockchain company
- 23:20sued the co -founder of the same company. He
- 23:25believed that he was owed certain tokens. Tokens
- 23:28were not given to him at the proper time. In
- 23:31addition to that, he claimed that on top of the
- 23:34initial distribution of tokens, he should have
- 23:36received staking rewards. And staking rewards
- 23:39sometimes claim a very big proportion of total
- 23:42damages. Now, why do you need tracing? Because
- 23:47you need to ascertain which wallets that particular
- 23:50company had, whether there were actual transfers
- 23:54of token or not, whether the plaintiff indeed
- 23:57did not receive any tokens as he or she claims.
- 24:00So again, you have to validate all the claims
- 24:03on chain and you have to look at that particular
- 24:06blockchain data to see whether the allegations
- 24:10make sense and to what extent they make sense.
- 24:14So scams, we've heard about scams, hacks, exploits
- 24:19almost daily, exchanges lose money, the DeFi
- 24:23protocols or decentralized finance protocol gets
- 24:26hacked, get attacked, certain wallets get cracked.
- 24:32We all know about romance scams and pig butchering.
- 24:36situations where unfortunately people fall victim
- 24:40to perpetrators who steal the crypto assets from
- 24:46those victims of the big butchering. Again, understanding
- 24:49what happened to the assets, how they were lost,
- 24:53what was compromised, it's very important. It
- 24:58is also important because some of the centralized
- 25:01exchanges may block or freeze certain assets
- 25:05if they suspect a particular actor to be perpetrator.
- 25:11So again, understanding the anatomy of scams,
- 25:13understanding how the funds flow through blockchains
- 25:16is extremely important to be able to stop those
- 25:20fraudulent transfers and sometimes like put like,
- 25:23you know, court mandated injunctions and freezes
- 25:25on particular crypto assets and crypto wallets.
- 25:29Market manipulation inside of trading. Again,
- 25:32inside of trading is on everybody's minds. I'm
- 25:35sure you heard about the stories about inside
- 25:37of trades on polymarket, right? There is a particular
- 25:42criminal matter going on right now where a soldier
- 25:45is being, like a special forces soldier is being
- 25:48accused of putting on trades right in front of
- 25:52the capture of Maduro. Again, the allegation
- 25:55from the Department of Justice is that he, knowing
- 25:58that particularly non -public material information,
- 26:02traded with some token positions in the event
- 26:06market or polymarket and made about $400 ,000
- 26:09in profit. So it's a criminal matter that goes
- 26:12right now. Again, to trace insider trading, you
- 26:16have to know how to deal and analyze the transactions
- 26:23on chain. The prediction markets, they're interesting
- 26:28because all the data about bets, about the tokens
- 26:33being purchased, about the tokens being sold,
- 26:36it's all on the blockchain. So it's not a centralized
- 26:40flow system. You can see all the transactions
- 26:43either on Kalshi or Polymarket or Underdog or
- 26:47Robinhood. So basically any prediction market
- 26:50that you think of, Coinbase, Robinhood, call
- 26:54it market callus sheet, those transactions in
- 26:57the event markets are, you know, visible, they're
- 26:59anonymous. So obviously, there will be no names
- 27:02attached to particular wallets. But at least
- 27:04you can download a gazillion of trades. And that's
- 27:08important to understand the market manipulation
- 27:10and to identify instances of insider trading.
- 27:14So understanding market blocks once and what
- 27:17what went wrong and why, you know, certain collapses
- 27:21happen. I investigated a collapse in DPEG of
- 27:26TeraUSD. You might have remembered back in 2022,
- 27:31a big collapse of a 40 billion TeraLuna ecosystem.
- 27:38And it was really a black swan. And effectively
- 27:41that particular DPEG triggered the crypto winter
- 27:44of 2022. So you had a stream of bankruptcies.
- 27:48But I think that one of the trigger events was
- 27:51the collapse of that particular stable coin system
- 27:54to the tune of about 40 billion. Again, understanding
- 27:57why it happened and how the mechanics, how the
- 28:00DPEG happened in the stable coin, why it lost
- 28:03its value. Again, you need to understand the
- 28:05participants. You need to understand who did
- 28:08what and how it all came about. Regulatory investigations,
- 28:14that happens all the time. Securities and Exchange
- 28:17Commission. sometimes investigates frauds. I
- 28:20was working on a project. I was contracting with
- 28:24the Securities and Exchange Commission earlier
- 28:26this year. They were investigating a particular
- 28:30fraudulent investment scheme perpetrated by an
- 28:33investment fund. And my task was to understand
- 28:37the flows of tokens between the wallets of that
- 28:41particular fund and also how they collected funds
- 28:45from the investors. So it was investigation.
- 28:47It was a regulatory investigation, and I was
- 28:52assisting the Securities and Exchange Commission
- 28:54in that particular exercise. Compliance risks.
- 28:58So compliance risk, the importance of compliance
- 29:00risks, which means preventing money laundering,
- 29:04preventing illicit funds, flows, make sure that
- 29:08cryptos do not flow from sanctioned wallets located
- 29:12in Iran, Syria, Russia, and other jurisdictions.
- 29:17Cuba, that's very important. And again, tracing
- 29:20is key component of enforcing anti -money laundering
- 29:25controls, enforcing financial cry controls. This
- 29:29is especially important in the current environment
- 29:32because banks are trying to play their part in
- 29:37stable coins. They're trying to tokenize real
- 29:39world assets. So the entire traditional finance
- 29:43system is moving on chain. and the compliance
- 29:46risks and the compliance complexities of that
- 29:48move cannot be underestimated. Again, blockchain
- 29:51analytics, transaction monitoring is a key component
- 29:54of that. And again, risk scoring of wallets.
- 29:58You can always say a wallet is a risk because
- 30:01if you can trace that wallet to sanctioned jurisdictions,
- 30:04you can trace them to darknets, you can trace
- 30:06them to fraudulent websites or darknet, again,
- 30:12you can risk score and flag that particular address
- 30:15for those types of risks. So just a few examples
- 30:22how the tracing was real helpful. In February
- 30:252022, somebody called Ilya Dutchman, he and his
- 30:30wife, they stole about 120 ,000 Bitcoin from
- 30:34a Hong Kong exchange Bitfinex. In February, that
- 30:39was done in 2018. In February, 2022, DOJ seized
- 30:45three and a half billion. So by the time in 2022,
- 30:49the market value of that stolen Bitcoin jumped
- 30:52to three and a half billion. So, you know, Ilya
- 30:55Dodge was convicted, put in jail. It was interesting
- 31:00how the DOJ was tracing all the transfers. It
- 31:03was a very convoluted move. by which the stolen
- 31:07bitcoins were moved into the un -hosted wallets,
- 31:11then they moved into a bunch of other crypto
- 31:13exchanges. Some of those crypto exchanges were
- 31:15Russia, Ukraine based exchanges without your
- 31:19customer controls. But I'm not going to delve
- 31:23into the details, but this was one of the ways
- 31:27in which the DOJ and the feds were able to understand
- 31:30who was behind this particular scheme. Interestingly
- 31:34enough, the Ilya Lichtenstein or the Dutchman
- 31:38was released from prison early January 2026 under
- 31:42some bipartisan reform of criminal justice. I'm
- 31:46not really well familiar with that particular
- 31:47reform, but it turns out that something came
- 31:50out in early 2026 and this particular guy, Ilya
- 31:54Lichtenstein, was released from prison in January
- 31:572026. So again, I just mentioned damages, so
- 32:03I'm going to really skip that real quick. Again,
- 32:06when one party sues another party and one party
- 32:10claims damages, damages may come in the form
- 32:15of, you know, I didn't get the coins that I was
- 32:18supposed to. All right. So obviously, you know,
- 32:20these damages. But in addition to that, damages
- 32:23may involve foregone staking rewards. And the
- 32:30argument is very simple. Should I receive the
- 32:32tokens at the proper time? I would have staked
- 32:35them and I would have received staking rewards,
- 32:39you know, over the preceding four to five years.
- 32:42And again, recently I was part of a, of a marital
- 32:46dispute between the two co -founders of a blockchain
- 32:49company. They happened to be wife, wife, you
- 32:53know, husband and wife. And wife was claiming
- 32:56that in addition to the token that she should
- 32:59have received, she also entitled to get the staking
- 33:02rewards. and the cumulative staking rewards were
- 33:06a very big chunk of the total damages claim that
- 33:09was put forward by the wife. So again, tracing
- 33:14is very important because you have to quantify
- 33:17those foregone staking rewards. So you need to
- 33:20know which wallets would have been involved in
- 33:23staking, how much comparable wallets received
- 33:27in staking rewards over a similar period of time.
- 33:29So you have to understand the comparable numbers
- 33:34that would be characteristic and that would be
- 33:37representative of the four guns taking rewards
- 33:39in case of a plaintiff. So again, hacks, scams,
- 33:47exploits, it's something that happens all the
- 33:50time. Most recently, an exchange bid get got
- 33:56scammed of about $380 million. I'm sure that
- 34:00you read the news and you know about the hacks.
- 34:03routinely done by the North Korea. And again,
- 34:09the hacks perpetrated by North Korean actors,
- 34:12they are in billions of dollars. And again, these
- 34:15days, unfortunately, this is kind of a exposed
- 34:18analysis, but nevertheless, it's useful. And
- 34:22sometimes some of the transfers of the stolen
- 34:25funds could be stopped in their tracks if the
- 34:28exchanges cooperate between themselves. and they
- 34:31can freeze the intermediate wallets in short
- 34:36order. Okay. So let me move on. Any questions?
- 34:43Or should I just keep charging ahead? I think
- 34:47we're good for now. Good for now. Okay. So tools.
- 34:51So in this fascinating world of crypto tracing,
- 34:55what are the tools that are used by blockchain
- 34:57investigators? So let me just highlight a few.
- 35:01Let me start with this particular picture This
- 35:04chart is called a Sankey diagram, okay? In the
- 35:10middle, you have the green block. In green block,
- 35:14this is the wallet of interest or an address
- 35:17of interest. To the left of it, in a dark red
- 35:23color, you see the incoming transfers, all right?
- 35:27So the funds flow from basically like nine wallets
- 35:31on the left. they flow into the recipient wallet,
- 35:36which is the wallet of interest to us, which
- 35:38is a green block. On the right -hand side, a
- 35:42bunch of lighter red ribbons show the outgoing
- 35:47flows. So basically, this tells you how much
- 35:51of a particular token was transferred out of
- 35:55the green wallet and where it went. So SendKey
- 35:59is like a snapshot that basically shows you all
- 36:03the inputs and all the outputs. It may be fairly
- 36:09complicated. As you can see here, there were
- 36:12like nine inputs. So nine wallets were sending
- 36:14money to the green wallet. And then the green
- 36:17wallet distributed funds to several dozens of
- 36:23other wallets. Sankey diagram is kind of a starting
- 36:27point. You're really trying to understand whether
- 36:30that particular wallet is active, what's the
- 36:32total amount of funds that wallet received over
- 36:35a certain period of time on the incoming side,
- 36:38on the outgoing side, and what its current balance
- 36:42is. So this is kind of a starting point of any
- 36:45investigation. And then you kind of start unraveling
- 36:51this picture because then you have to trace assets
- 36:57not on a one hop situation. So this is like a
- 37:00one hop. You have one incoming hop, and you have
- 37:04one outgoing hop. But in many situations, you
- 37:07have to trace transactions over multiple hops.
- 37:12And therefore, you know, that becomes interesting,
- 37:15but at the same time, you know, it may become
- 37:17a little bit more complicated. So this is kind
- 37:20of a Sankey. Where do you get blockchain transaction
- 37:24data? The answer is very simple. For public blockchains,
- 37:30the full transactional history is publicly available
- 37:33and it is accessible by anyone. So unlike permission
- 37:38databases that have only access to them by their
- 37:43administrators, blockchain data is public. No
- 37:47matter what it is, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana,
- 37:51XRP, any of the meme coins, the transactional
- 37:55data underlying those tokens is publicly available
- 37:59on the internet, okay? And here I'm showing a
- 38:03snapshot of a transaction which happened at some
- 38:09point on Ethereum chain. Transactional data is
- 38:13identified by unique transactional cache, which
- 38:17is a cryptographic representation. And there
- 38:21is a basic information. What is the sending address?
- 38:24What is the receiving address? What is the type
- 38:28of cryptocurrency that was sent? The timestamp,
- 38:31basically when it happened, and also transaction
- 38:34cost and the amount. So effectively, if you go
- 38:38to on -chain data source and you pull a particular
- 38:43transaction, you will know everything about that
- 38:46transaction except for the identity. So the blockchain
- 38:50transaction data clearly does not have names
- 38:53because blockchain data is what's called pseudo
- 38:55-anonymous. There are no names attached in most
- 38:59of the situations, but it's pseudo -anonymous
- 39:02because you can still ascertain the ownership
- 39:07of a wallet through transactional analysis. Again,
- 39:14the question, where do I get that blockchain
- 39:16data? Blockchain data is publicly available on
- 39:20blockchain explorers. Each chain has its own
- 39:24blockchain explorer with that data publicly available.
- 39:27For Ethereum, it would be either scan. For Theta,
- 39:31I just happened to work on a particular marital
- 39:33dispute that involved Theta chain. I decided
- 39:37to kind of put an image here of a Theta explorer.
- 39:40Again, it's a public source. You can go there,
- 39:43you type in an address, or you're typing a transaction
- 39:45hash. the system will show you for an address,
- 39:50it will show you the history of transactions.
- 39:53Now, the explorers, they're publicly available,
- 39:56they're easy to work with. However, they do have
- 39:59limited tracing capabilities. So they're not
- 40:01particularly user friendly. If you want to trace
- 40:05funds from A to B, and there are multiple intermediate
- 40:08steps between wallet A and wallet B. So technically
- 40:12you can piece together that information. But
- 40:15blockchain explorers, you can think of them as
- 40:17repositories of public data, but they're not
- 40:20necessarily designed to be user -friendly in
- 40:24terms of particular tracing capabilities. So
- 40:31tracing capabilities, you need to have kind of
- 40:33more specialized tools. But in any event, the
- 40:36blockchain explorers is the first kind of a starting
- 40:39point. you know that anybody including attorneys
- 40:43including law professionals you know they want
- 40:45to quickly scan a particular address and understand
- 40:48its balance understands how many transactions
- 40:51that particular address had in its history that
- 40:53type of information will be available on a blockchain
- 40:56explorer and it's free and it's available to
- 40:58anybody. There are in addition to the blockchain
- 41:05explorer there are there are dedicated firms
- 41:10it's called blockchain analytic firms who sell
- 41:15that tracing software for living. So I'm giving
- 41:19here three examples. TRM Labs, Elliptic Chain
- 41:23Analysis, they trace a bunch of blockchains.
- 41:25They are expensive. The subscription cost per
- 41:28year may vary from anywhere between from 20 ,000
- 41:32to 100 ,000 a year. So depending on what kind
- 41:34of access you want to those blockchain analytic
- 41:38platforms. I sometimes use them in my work. Sometimes
- 41:45I create my own tools to trace because oftentimes
- 41:49it's much more cost efficient as opposed to going
- 41:52out and paying 30 ,000 to Elliptic for a couple
- 41:56of months worth of tracing exercise, which needs
- 41:59to be done as part of the litigation support.
- 42:04So graphical analysis is very prevalent and used
- 42:08very, very often. because you want to really
- 42:11visualize, and even for expert reports and for
- 42:14trial testimony, one picture is worth a thousand
- 42:18words. So quite often you have to put your tracing
- 42:21and analytics and tracing results into a graphical
- 42:25representation to show how the funds are moving
- 42:29between different wallets. With the one hop analysis,
- 42:32which is on the left hand side, it looks very
- 42:35neat. If you do two hops, it becomes complicated.
- 42:39And if you do three hops or more, then you have
- 42:42to really figure out what's the best way to graphically
- 42:45present your analysis so that you don't lose
- 42:47the audience. But in any event, the graphical
- 42:50analysis is important and very useful because
- 42:53it shows you the main nexus points that are involved
- 42:57in a particular transaction history. You identify
- 43:00the major hubs that you have to be investigating.
- 43:04because they seem to be receiving most of the
- 43:08funds or they seem to be sending out most of
- 43:10the funds. So this particular example is, I built
- 43:15it for Alameda Research. You might remember Alameda
- 43:18Research was a hedge fund created by Sembank
- 43:21and Freed, the founder of the failed FTX exchange.
- 43:25And I did some analysis related to particular
- 43:29Alameda Research and I just. You know, took some
- 43:32pains to put some of this graphical analysis
- 43:34together to try to understand where Alameda could
- 43:37have, you know, send the funds. So some real
- 43:43life examples. One case that I handled was it
- 43:50was tracing crypto sales via broker and exchanges.
- 43:54So a particular customer on the left hand side,
- 43:57these four blue nodes, they wanted to sell token
- 44:01and convert those tokens into cash. They didn't
- 44:04want to do it themselves, but because it was
- 44:07in a multi -million amount, they engaged a broker
- 44:11-dealer. And there are broker -dealers in the
- 44:14crypto space like GSR, like WinterMute, B2C2,
- 44:20Coinbase has its own dealer arm where they can
- 44:23handle large transactions on behalf of institutional
- 44:26clients. So in this particular instance, a large
- 44:31client wanted to sell a decent amount of tokens
- 44:34they hired broker dealer. So first they send
- 44:38the funds from their wallets to the cold wallets
- 44:41of that particular broker dealer. That broker
- 44:43dealer deposited those tokens onto a centralized
- 44:47exchange. So we're here looking in the middle
- 44:49part of this picture. So those tokens were flowing
- 44:54through the deposit address into the hot wallets
- 44:58of that exchange. Broker dealer sold those tokens
- 45:02and converted them into fiat on that particular
- 45:05cryptocurrency exchange and collected the fiat
- 45:08proceeds and then eventually that proceeds had
- 45:13to be transferred to the wallet of the seller.
- 45:19So therefore again that was an interesting tracing
- 45:21exercise that involved multiple millions of tokens
- 45:26and it was done through a broker dealer and through
- 45:28a particular centralized cryptocurrency exchange.
- 45:32Excuse me. Okay, moving next. This was another
- 45:41exercise that was interesting because it was
- 45:45cross -chain. And again, it does happen in marital
- 45:48disputes quite often because while there are
- 45:53different tokens in different chains, you can
- 45:56move a token from one chain to another. To give
- 45:59an example, if I have a Bitcoin, on a Bitcoin
- 46:03chain. Technically speaking, I can create a wrapped
- 46:07version of a Bitcoin and move it to Ethereum,
- 46:10another chain. I can do the same thing with Solana.
- 46:15Wrapping a token is one way to move it from one
- 46:17chain to another, but there is also a technology
- 46:21which is called a bridge. The bridge is a piece
- 46:26of software that allows to transfer tokens from
- 46:29chain one to chain two. So if you want to trace
- 46:33that particular cross bridge, cross chain transfer,
- 46:36you need to know an address on chain one, you
- 46:42need to know an address on chain two, and then
- 46:45you need to identify the link so that you really
- 46:48understand how the token moves from chain one
- 46:51through chain two. In this particular instance,
- 46:54it was an investigation of a move between Ethereum
- 46:59chain and a Terra chain. Wormhole is a piece
- 47:03of software that serves as a bridge that connects
- 47:06the two chains. And so my task was to trace the
- 47:10transfer of like about 15 million of stable points
- 47:15from Terra, from Terra chain to Ethereum through
- 47:19a bridge that's called Wormhole. So that was
- 47:22kind of an interesting exercise. you can trace
- 47:28how the funds move. Now, the reason why it's
- 47:30important is because even in marital disputes,
- 47:32I've seen situations where a spouse for the purpose
- 47:37of obfuscation and to make tracing more convoluted,
- 47:43they can move the funds from one chain to another
- 47:46chain. Sometimes it's done to make tracing more
- 47:51difficult and to hide the assets better. sometimes
- 47:55it's done for legitimate purposes. Like for example,
- 47:58I cannot stake Bitcoin, right? So I'm losing
- 48:02interest rate because Bitcoin is not stakeable
- 48:05because it's a proof of work. However, there
- 48:08are other protocols on other chains that take
- 48:12a tokenized or a wrapped version of a Bitcoin
- 48:16and they stake it on another chain. In the example
- 48:20of Babylon, there is a chain It's a proof of
- 48:24stake that allows people to transfer Bitcoin
- 48:27from Bitcoin chain to the Babylon chain and stake
- 48:31it and receive interest rate reward in addition
- 48:36to the potential price appreciation. So therefore
- 48:39moving tokens from one chain to another may be
- 48:43illicit and illegitimate if a spouse who want
- 48:46to hide and kind of cover the tracks. Sometimes
- 48:50it is legitimate because people are trying to
- 48:52make more money. They're trying to find additional
- 48:54sources of income. And if you can do it, you
- 48:59move it from a chain where that interest is not
- 49:02available to the chain where that particular
- 49:04interest and staking opportunities are available.
- 49:10This particular one, this was a real project
- 49:13that I worked on. It was a marital dispute. And
- 49:16that's exactly what I alluded to when I said
- 49:18that When I started working on it, it turned
- 49:21out that one of the spouses was a sophisticated
- 49:24trader, traded Ethereum and Bitcoin starting
- 49:27from 2017. The divorce was filed, I believe,
- 49:32sometime in late 2022. I was hired in the middle
- 49:36of 2023. And I had to trace several assets over
- 49:43seven, roughly seven year period. and the spouse
- 49:48was employing at least a dozen of different cryptocurrency
- 49:53exchanges. He was employing and using multiple
- 49:58what's called unhosted wallets. So the wallets
- 50:01only he had access to. And then the complication
- 50:05also was that to the extent that he could not,
- 50:10he could not maintain his presence on an offshore
- 50:13exchange because at some point there was a compliance
- 50:15driven crackdown. So US citizens could not maintain
- 50:20their accounts on offshore exchange like Binance
- 50:24because Binance was technically and legally prohibited
- 50:29from allowing US -based users to access their
- 50:32platform. So that happened in 2019. but that
- 50:36particular spouse decided, you know what, I'm
- 50:38still going to be maintaining my access to Binance,
- 50:42but I'm going to hire an unregistered investment
- 50:45manager who will be managing my money on that
- 50:48exchange on my behalf. So therefore, even though
- 50:52there were only two or three tokens involved
- 50:54in this particular marital dispute, it was convoluted
- 50:57for a variety of reasons. Number one, the sheer
- 51:01volume of transactional activity Number two,
- 51:03the fact that it was seven years of transactional
- 51:05history. Number three, multiple exchanges were
- 51:09used either by the spouse or by his unregistered
- 51:13investment agent. There was an offshore insurance
- 51:17company in Barbados that was also involved and
- 51:21was also involved in moving the crypto assets
- 51:24of that particular spouse. And in addition to
- 51:29that, there were questions of valuation. and
- 51:32the proper division of the crypto assets won.
- 51:35Those crypto assets were recovered, established
- 51:38and identified on chain. And additionally, there
- 51:41was also an interesting twist. That particular
- 51:44husband was an active trader. So he was trading
- 51:47those assets, not only in centralized exchanges,
- 51:49he was also trading them on a variety of what's
- 51:53called decentralized finance protocols. So this,
- 51:57I'm gonna skip its investment scheme, but again,
- 52:00the same key. the same key diagram that I showed
- 52:05you earlier could become more complicated if
- 52:09you wanna say, I wanna trace the inflows for
- 52:12two hops on the incoming side and for two hops
- 52:15on the upcoming side. So if you wanna do more
- 52:18stages of investigation. you know sometimes these
- 52:21graphical representations of transactional flow
- 52:23become relatively convoluted but again if you
- 52:27pay attention and you know all the addresses
- 52:29and you have all the underlying data that allows
- 52:32you to you know be very specific in terms of
- 52:35what happened. What I once also wanted to highlight
- 52:39for you guys is that AI tools are very actively
- 52:43coming into the world of crypto tracing. Yes,
- 52:48you can use and build your own customized tools.
- 52:51I do it all the time. You can use and I sometimes
- 52:56hire or subcontract tracing exercises to commercial
- 53:02vendors like Elliptic and TRM Labs, although
- 53:05they're very expensive. But in some simple situations,
- 53:11you can integrate a blockchain explorer with
- 53:15your large language model through some of those
- 53:18for MCP server, right? So you're probably all
- 53:20familiar with the MCP, which is Model Context
- 53:23Protocol. Effectively, it's a tool that came
- 53:26out probably earlier this year, like at the beginning
- 53:28of 2026. And effectively, it allows you to connect
- 53:33your large language model to a particular application
- 53:37so that the two talk to each other. Ethereum
- 53:43has its own blockchain explorer, Etherscan. And
- 53:47recently, they introduced a Flow agent, but you
- 53:52have to connect the Flow agent with your text
- 53:55prompt on Claude. And again, through the MCP,
- 53:59you can connect your Claude desktop, you can
- 54:02connect your Claude cohort, or you can connect
- 54:04your Claude code to the Etherscan Flow agent.
- 54:08And you can simply say, okay, you can say, you
- 54:11know, I would like to trace such and such, such
- 54:14and such address. So build me, please build me
- 54:17diagram. And, you know, this is, this is the
- 54:21outcome that I just, you know, picked up an address
- 54:24that I worked on earlier this year, which is
- 54:27highlighted in dark green in the middle of this
- 54:29page. You know, I kind of enabled this connection
- 54:34through the MCP server, you know, you subscribe
- 54:36to either scan. And you can, in a plain layman
- 54:39terms, you can say, you know, build me a two
- 54:41hop diagram for this political dress. I would
- 54:43like to see how the transfer look like. This
- 54:46is what Claude built for me. So this is not to
- 54:51say that it replaces the crypto tracing expert
- 54:54because again, these needs to be verified. You
- 54:58know, the large language models are prone still
- 55:01to hallucinations. You still have to double check
- 55:06the underlying transactional data, because I'm
- 55:08not claiming that this particular diagram doesn't
- 55:11have any errors, and quite likely it might be.
- 55:16But my point is that the AI and the MCP and the
- 55:21frontier models, they do come into the world
- 55:24of crypto tracing. And in simple situations,
- 55:29it gives you sort of a first step analysis of
- 55:31something you want to look at. you know as you
- 55:34get deeper into the litigation and there are
- 55:36testimony depositions and you have to write an
- 55:38expert report and you have to really double check
- 55:40and verify everything. This is where the experts
- 55:43are still you know needed you know to work in
- 55:45conjunction with kind of neat tools that have
- 55:47been appearing recently. So now let me talk to
- 55:53some about some practical crypto issues specific
- 55:56to marital lawyers and this is again I'm speaking
- 55:59from my own experience. to the extent that I
- 56:02was involved in some of these marital disputes
- 56:04in the recent past. Questions of property. I
- 56:10think by now this particular controversy is settled.
- 56:15Bitcoin is considered to be a property that could
- 56:18be seized and the freezing injunction may be
- 56:22imposed off. I wanted to highlight an interesting
- 56:25litigation, an entry lawsuit that was brought
- 56:28in New York City in May of 2026. Somebody is
- 56:33trying to claim legal ownership of about three
- 56:36and three quarter million Bitcoin and 39 ,000
- 56:39addresses. That's about 300 billion in current
- 56:41market prices. And they are invoking New York
- 56:45State lost and found property law. Basically,
- 56:48they say there are 39 ,000 of Bitcoin addresses
- 56:52the funds have not been moved from those addresses
- 56:56for more than five years. Therefore, under the
- 56:59New York State law, they constitute lost and
- 57:03found property and therefore anybody can claim.
- 57:07Now, whether there is anything substantive to
- 57:09that particular capability, so the guy, the plaintiff
- 57:12claims that he found a way to recover the lost
- 57:16private keys. This is very suspect because you
- 57:21know, recover lost Bitcoin key is impossible.
- 57:25But in any event, given that Bitcoin is a property,
- 57:29somebody in New York City is trying to basically
- 57:32gain access to 300 billion of Bitcoin on the
- 57:36sheer premise that it must have been lost and
- 57:39abandoned because nobody moved that Bitcoin for
- 57:42more than five years. Interestingly enough, shortly
- 57:45after May 1st, you could see on chain that some
- 57:48of the bigger wallets did move their funds. So
- 57:51effectively, people were trying to prove to this
- 57:53plaintiff that it's not abandoned. I still have
- 57:55a private key. I can still move my Bitcoin from
- 57:58point A to point B. But this is just kind of
- 58:02a funny story. In terms of the recent court decisions
- 58:06pertinent to cryptos, there was a pretty well
- 58:09-publicized case in 2026, again, in New York
- 58:12State, Supreme Court, Kings County. Again, a
- 58:16dispute between a husband and wife. the husband
- 58:19did not disclose about 2 .6 million in cryptocurrency.
- 58:24So he denied having those millions in cryptos.
- 58:27He claimed that he lost them because of the romance
- 58:29scam or because of some crypto scam or investment
- 58:33scam. So wife hired a crypto expert. And eventually,
- 58:41the court awarded 300 ,000 in additional council
- 58:44fees and 125 ,000 in expert fees. So the non
- 58:49-disclosure of crypto assets by one of the parties
- 58:52to the marriage dispute, it could be litigated
- 58:55very successfully. So what are the concerns?
- 59:02Not concerned with the issues. Number one, preservation
- 59:06of custody. So sometimes it's important if there
- 59:10is a divorce and you're afraid that one of the
- 59:13spouses will try to hide the crypto assets. It
- 59:18is important to move quickly and ask the court
- 59:21for preservation and custody if you know where
- 59:24those particular crypto assets could be residing.
- 59:29So preservation custody is important. Price volatility
- 59:33of cryptos, that's a notorious problem. I have
- 59:36one particular slide just later. What's interesting
- 59:39is that that creates a lot of valuation issues.
- 59:41How do you value? You have to deviate the assets
- 59:44in a fair way. but at what point and at what
- 59:48price do you value the cryptos if they move five,
- 59:5010 % a day, okay? Do you value assets in fiat,
- 59:56in cash, or do you value in kind? Discovery identification,
- 1:00:00again, that's a problem with tracing. This is
- 1:00:04where the tracing comes in. Injunctive relief
- 1:00:07standing orders, as I understand in California,
- 1:00:09there are some automatic restraints in the family
- 1:00:12code. Again, those need to be enforced to make
- 1:00:15sure that all the assets that are disputed are
- 1:00:20frozen in time. Even if you recover and find
- 1:00:25the assets, there are logistical and jurisdictional
- 1:00:27issues of liquidating digital assets. Sometimes
- 1:00:29it's difficult to liquidate the asset because
- 1:00:32it does not trade in the United States. It only
- 1:00:34trades in South Korea. It only trades in Japan,
- 1:00:37and you discovered that asset in some other country.
- 1:00:40but it cannot be traded in the United States.
- 1:00:44There are judicial issues of access and taxation.
- 1:00:47So if one spouse recovers some crypto assets
- 1:00:51from another spouse, who pays the taxes? So crypto
- 1:00:58asset volatility is something that's persistent.
- 1:01:03And again, Bitcoin moves sometimes four or 5
- 1:01:06% a day. Flash crashes happen. from time to time,
- 1:01:10like October of 2025, last October, in October
- 1:01:1510, I think Bitcoin crashed by like 15 % in one
- 1:01:18day. So therefore, volatility is key. And this
- 1:01:23is where you need to figure out how to value
- 1:01:27assets in kind or in fiat and as of what date.
- 1:01:32So there was a recent case. It was interesting
- 1:01:36that this particular case didn't come from the
- 1:01:39marital law. It came from the bankruptcy proceedings
- 1:01:43for Celsius Network. Celsius Network, and you
- 1:01:47might have heard the name Alex Maszynski, that
- 1:01:50particular crypto lender, they collapsed in 2022,
- 1:01:55in the middle of 2022. They were eventually liquidated.
- 1:02:00They were taking people's Bitcoin, offering interest
- 1:02:05payments. to the tune of eight to 10%. And so
- 1:02:09they basically, they were suggesting like effective,
- 1:02:11like a pool investment, but to be able to pay
- 1:02:16those eight to 10%, they invested Bitcoin in
- 1:02:19Ethereum into other enterprises, mining, and
- 1:02:23they invested in DeFi protocols. In any event,
- 1:02:26when the Terra Luna collapsed in May, 2022, eventually
- 1:02:30sales and network did go down as well. They filed
- 1:02:33for bankruptcy, I believe in November, 2022.
- 1:02:36the bankruptcy proceedings and the return of
- 1:02:39the funds has been going on until today. And
- 1:02:44there was a recent court order or court decision
- 1:02:49with respect to fraudulent conveyance. And I
- 1:02:54thought it's interesting because that judge laid
- 1:03:00out the rules how to value the fraudulently conveyed
- 1:03:05crypto assets under different scenarios. Again,
- 1:03:08it's not a part of marital dispute, it's part
- 1:03:10of the fraudulent conveyance, it's part of the
- 1:03:13bankruptcy matter, but I thought it could be
- 1:03:16directly relevant to the crypto dispute that
- 1:03:19happens in divorce. And so that particular judge
- 1:03:22said, if the coins fall in value between the
- 1:03:29time of the fraudulent conveyance, and the judgment,
- 1:03:34then the spouse should receive those tokens at
- 1:03:40the value, at the transfer date value. There
- 1:03:43is no reason for the spouse to suffer from the
- 1:03:49decline in value simply because the other spouse
- 1:03:52was sitting on their hands, was trying to hide
- 1:03:54the coins and the coins fell in value between
- 1:03:58the discovery date and the date of judgment.
- 1:04:01So if on the other hand, the tokens appreciated
- 1:04:05in price between the transfer date or the fraudulent
- 1:04:10conveyance date and the current date, then the
- 1:04:14spouse should receive the tokens in kind. Basically
- 1:04:17he or she should be entitled to the upside potential
- 1:04:21and upside appreciation that happened between
- 1:04:24the two dates. And if the fraudulent conveyance,
- 1:04:27the person who did the fraudulent conveyance
- 1:04:29sold that particular token, then the other party
- 1:04:32has to be awarded and has to recover the value
- 1:04:36at the sale price. So again, I'm not a lawyer,
- 1:04:39but I thought, you know, this bankruptcy related
- 1:04:43case that addresses the question of volatility
- 1:04:46in crypto prices might have some implications
- 1:04:49as to how the tokens have to be valid as part
- 1:04:51of the marital divorce and marital dispute. Again,
- 1:04:55I just want to kind of bring it out. I think
- 1:04:57it was kind of interesting and relevant. So crypto
- 1:05:01discovery, and let me wrap up. I understand that
- 1:05:04I'm already over one hour. So crypto discovery
- 1:05:08may get pretty complicated. You have to think
- 1:05:11outside of the box. The types of disclosure requests,
- 1:05:16the attorney have to think because cryptos, unlike
- 1:05:21fiat, have additional information types that
- 1:05:27need to be discovered through interrogatories.
- 1:05:30And again, some attorneys are very savvy in the
- 1:05:33crypto space and they can draft crypto discovery
- 1:05:36questions themselves. Sometimes I get involved
- 1:05:39and I help the council to draft those interrogatories
- 1:05:43because I can think, I have done some preliminary
- 1:05:46tracing analysis. I understand the scope of the
- 1:05:49problem. I understand the venues and the types
- 1:05:51of wallets. you know, the opposing party is using,
- 1:05:54and I can be helpful in drafting the questions
- 1:05:57that will be specific to discovery in this particular
- 1:06:02matter. So what kind of information to request?
- 1:06:07What particular wallets to target? What particular
- 1:06:12exchanges to subpoena or records? So all of these
- 1:06:16questions are very interesting, but they're very
- 1:06:19specific to a particular in a crypto situation
- 1:06:21in a particular manner to dispute. You have to
- 1:06:26be looking for red flags and crypto assets all
- 1:06:29the time. So the fact that it's crypto assets
- 1:06:31does not mean that you should not look into bank
- 1:06:34statements, brokerage accounts, insurance policies,
- 1:06:37electronic payment transfers, because quite often
- 1:06:41the initial point that allows you to start the
- 1:06:45investigation is Where did the first purchase
- 1:06:49of a crypto asset happen? And how did it happen?
- 1:06:52And quite often, a spouse will create an account
- 1:06:56on Coinbase. There will be first transfer of
- 1:06:59fiat funds from PayPal, from Venmo, from Zelle,
- 1:07:03from a brokerage account to Coinbase. You know,
- 1:07:06you subpoena Coinbase. Coinbase says, yes, we
- 1:07:08have this account, this particular person transacted
- 1:07:11and bought and sold such and such cryptos. But
- 1:07:14what's interesting is that oftentimes, the initial
- 1:07:17start of investigation is the fiat side. Where
- 1:07:21did the money come from? That allows you to establish
- 1:07:23the beginning of the history and then you can
- 1:07:26unravel it by following the trail on blockchain.
- 1:07:32So logistical jurisdictional issue liquidating
- 1:07:34digital assets against something that happens
- 1:07:37all the time. In my particular situation, I found
- 1:07:41assets that were hosted on offshore Binance exchange.
- 1:07:48that particular token did not trade in any exchange
- 1:07:52in the United States. So even if recovered from
- 1:07:55the husband, the spouse would not be able to
- 1:07:58sell that particular token in the United States
- 1:08:00because that asset is not listed on any of the
- 1:08:03US crypto exchanges. So additional things have
- 1:08:06to be done. In particular, that particular asset
- 1:08:09had to be converted into stable coins. And then
- 1:08:12stable coins had to be transferred to the spouse's
- 1:08:16address. so that she could liquidate those particular
- 1:08:21stable points on the US -based exchange. And
- 1:08:25then there was also a question of taxation. Obviously,
- 1:08:30if crypto assets have been accumulated for seven
- 1:08:33years and they were sitting offshore or offshore
- 1:08:37insurance accounts, they were never taxed in
- 1:08:40the United States, a recipient of those funds
- 1:08:43will have to pay taxes. And again, the issue
- 1:08:46is how you tax was the cost basis. So that's
- 1:08:50kind of an additional conversation to be had.
- 1:08:55So in summary, I hope that was kind of a good
- 1:08:59entry point into the fascinating world of tracing,
- 1:09:04how it could be done and how it could be helpful
- 1:09:07to make the outcomes of marital disputes fair
- 1:09:12to both parties. So happy to answer any questions.
- 1:09:16Adam, please take over and let me know. Yeah,
- 1:09:19so we got a few great questions throughout your
- 1:09:22presentation. Obviously, people can feel free
- 1:09:26to drop, but as long as you have a few minutes
- 1:09:30here, we'll run through a few of these. So one
- 1:09:35of the questions that we have talks about how
- 1:09:39basically much of crypto can be traced back to
- 1:09:43money laundering. Excuse me money laundering
- 1:09:47activity at some point It compares to you know,
- 1:09:51how 80 to 90 percent of dollars have a trace
- 1:09:53of cocaine on them And so the question is how
- 1:09:57do you show that your client is an innocent owner?
- 1:09:59When you can't do KYC all the way down the chain,
- 1:10:02so at least from a legal perspective You know,
- 1:10:06I the answer is gonna be a burden of proof that
- 1:10:09you don't need to prove that it's innocent It
- 1:10:12is on them to show that it is related to money
- 1:10:17laundering activity. But do you have anything
- 1:10:20on the more technical side of how you could kind
- 1:10:23of, yeah, kind of prove the innocence of the
- 1:10:29way the money was received and that it was not
- 1:10:31related to laundering activity? Do you understand
- 1:10:35what I'm asking? Well, I mean, yes. because you're
- 1:10:42kind of proving it negative is the difficulty.
- 1:10:44And so if there's if there's a way to do that,
- 1:10:48I'm curious, but I'm not familiar with it. Well,
- 1:10:52yes. I mean, to the extent that the travel rule
- 1:10:54is not enforced. Right. And you cannot prove
- 1:10:56the providence of the funds. I mean, one way
- 1:11:02one way to establish that is to say, OK, you
- 1:11:05know, I'm wallet A. Right. I'm being accused
- 1:11:08of receiving dirty money. Right. For example.
- 1:11:11How do I prove that? Well, I can show the history
- 1:11:15where I got that money from, right? Well, number
- 1:11:20one, if I received the money from an exchange,
- 1:11:23then that automatically breaks any kind of trail.
- 1:11:27Because if I receive money from a hot wallet
- 1:11:29of an exchange, by definition, you cannot ascertain
- 1:11:33any money laundering concerns, okay? If I did
- 1:11:37receive funds on the other hand from an unhosted
- 1:11:40wallet, then one way is to establish your innocence
- 1:11:44is to, there are multiple services that attribute
- 1:11:51ownership. So like people know wallets of different
- 1:11:56exchanges, people know wallets of different broker
- 1:11:59dealers. So if you can show that the entity is
- 1:12:04labeled, like somebody send me money and that
- 1:12:07particular wallet is labeled in a certain way
- 1:12:09on one of the blockchain explorers and we know
- 1:12:12that it's not related to money laundering or
- 1:12:14child trafficking or any others. So if you're
- 1:12:19lucky and you can show that the sources of your
- 1:12:22funds came from wallets that are not flagged
- 1:12:25as a listed finance and they have specific wallet
- 1:12:28attribution in terms of their ownership, so that
- 1:12:31would be the best scenario. The second best scenario
- 1:12:34is to use score ranking databases of the likes
- 1:12:39like Elliptic Terram Labs, Archem Intelligence.
- 1:12:43There are a lot of third party vendors who risk
- 1:12:46score wallets for the illicit finance and money
- 1:12:49laundering risks. So if a particular wallet is
- 1:12:53flagged as a sanctioned wallet, it will automatically
- 1:12:57get the risk score of 10, okay? And the DOJ,
- 1:13:03OFAC, right, the Office of Foreign Asset Control,
- 1:13:06FinCEN, they maintain the list of those sanctioned
- 1:13:09addresses. So if you have, let's say, I received
- 1:13:12something from five addresses and the risk score
- 1:13:15on those five addresses is one or two or three,
- 1:13:18that means that they are very low risk. They're
- 1:13:22very low risk. And therefore you can say, you
- 1:13:24know, if it were not the case and they were related
- 1:13:26to dark net, they were related to illicit finance,
- 1:13:29gambling, child pornography uh sanctioned right
- 1:13:34the then they would have been uh risk much higher
- 1:13:37you know seven eight nine ten because they're
- 1:13:40one two three that means at low risk there is
- 1:13:43no transaction history that will suggest that
- 1:13:45the sources of funds that were used to send in
- 1:13:47the money are illegitimate yeah i think that's
- 1:13:51helpful and i do think the uh the analogy to
- 1:13:54to dollars being used for illicit purposes is
- 1:13:57is a good one you know that the idea that Just
- 1:14:00because, you know, you get money from the bank
- 1:14:02just because it was used, you know, for drugs
- 1:14:05or whatever in the past that doesn't make it,
- 1:14:07you know, perpetually dirty. Oh, absolutely.
- 1:14:11Please. Yes. I mean, the best case scenario is
- 1:14:15if your wallet that sent you money are exactly
- 1:14:18entirely specifically labeled in terms of the
- 1:14:22ownership of attribution on chain. And again,
- 1:14:24certain proportion of addresses is labeled. You
- 1:14:27know, the Coinbase addresses. Basically, people
- 1:14:30know major wallet addresses for all major exchanges,
- 1:14:34for example. They know, quite often, they know
- 1:14:38wallet addresses for large broker dealers, you
- 1:14:42know, like the over -the -counter broker dealers.
- 1:14:44They may know some additional entities and they
- 1:14:47know that, oh, there's some investment funds,
- 1:14:49so they're legitimate. If that's not available,
- 1:14:53then again, risk scoring and showing that the
- 1:14:56particular sending wallet was a very low risk,
- 1:14:59you know, that that would be could have interrupt
- 1:15:02proof that, oh, I didn't get the money from a
- 1:15:04dirty source. And besides the illicit finance,
- 1:15:12illicit finance wallets have certain topologies
- 1:15:15of their transactional flow. So if an address
- 1:15:21was just use ones to transfer funds, right? Or
- 1:15:25it's not used as an accumulation point because
- 1:15:29sometimes like the mules accounts and other accounts,
- 1:15:31they have certain transactional patterns that
- 1:15:33make them suspect. For example, there could be
- 1:15:36accumulation point where they receive funds from
- 1:15:39like thousands of different little sources and
- 1:15:42then they make one big huge deposit on a crypto
- 1:15:44exchange. That's a red flag. because that particular
- 1:15:49address is accumulation point in some kind of
- 1:15:53a mining laundering scheme because it takes money
- 1:15:55from like thousands of small addresses and then
- 1:15:57transfers one big chunk into crypto wallet address
- 1:16:01at an exchange. But if those red flags with respect
- 1:16:06to topologies is not present, again, that's another
- 1:16:08testament that you didn't get the funds from
- 1:16:11dirty source. Alright, so since we're over I'll
- 1:16:17just we got two outstanding questions here that
- 1:16:19we can try to wrap up And have everyone out of
- 1:16:23here in the next 10 minutes or so where the question
- 1:16:28is basically about the valuing of crypto assets
- 1:16:32that if basically if the couple does not have
- 1:16:38a material amount they say a hundred bucks or
- 1:16:41so does it make sense from a cost -benefit uh
- 1:16:45analysis to value them i'm not aware of of uh
- 1:16:50much expense in kind of valuing crypto assets
- 1:16:53but is there anything that that you can think
- 1:16:56of uh i mean you can you can think of uh cryptos
- 1:17:01as a level one asset right because they're for
- 1:17:05most of the major tokens the prices are readily
- 1:17:08available yeah so I mean, you go to Coinbase,
- 1:17:12you go to Kraken, you go to any of the large
- 1:17:15exchanges, Binance, Robinhood, right? Anybody
- 1:17:19who offers crypto trading capabilities. So yeah,
- 1:17:24valuing the liquid stuff is absolutely no brainer.
- 1:17:27It's very, very simple. The only complication
- 1:17:29that might happen is let's say a token only trades
- 1:17:34on a decentralized finance protocol, does not
- 1:17:36trade on any centralized exchanges. it could
- 1:17:40be difficult to value it because of something
- 1:17:43that's called price slippage, right? Especially
- 1:17:46if it's a big chunk, let's say, you know, one
- 1:17:49particular holding, but it's a big chunk, the
- 1:17:52token is a liquid, only trades on Uniswap, for
- 1:17:56example, or PancakeSwap, right? Or any other
- 1:17:59small or Meteor or some other. So the price slippage
- 1:18:04may come into the play because if somebody says,
- 1:18:07okay, I'm going to value this amount of token,
- 1:18:09but the token is large versus the available liquidity.
- 1:18:11If you try to sell everything, then there will
- 1:18:14be big price slippage and you have to kind of
- 1:18:16model that situation because the DeFi protocols
- 1:18:20have certain structure to the price formation.
- 1:18:23But again, that's the only time where I can think
- 1:18:26that it could be a little bit more difficult
- 1:18:29to value an illiquid token that doesn't trade.
- 1:18:31If a token trades on centralized crypto exchange,
- 1:18:35I mean, anybody can do it. That is what the value
- 1:18:38is. Yeah, you can value $800 worth of crypto.
- 1:18:42You can value a million. Again, you have to be
- 1:18:45aware of liquidity. So if you value one million
- 1:18:48and you look at the price, you have to be careful
- 1:18:52to assign proper market value because you cannot
- 1:18:55liquidate a million worth of tokens if the daily
- 1:18:59trading volume is like 100 ,000, right? So you
- 1:19:05just have to be realistic and you have to assign
- 1:19:08certain price haircut to value it properly. But
- 1:19:12if it's a large token and the amount to be sold
- 1:19:15is small, yeah, it's not breaking. It's a level
- 1:19:18one asset. Sure. All right. And so then this
- 1:19:24last question is a little long, so I'll try to
- 1:19:30keep it short here, where it basically relates
- 1:19:33to a discovery dispute, where one of the spouses
- 1:19:40in a divorce is involved in a partnership, and
- 1:19:44it seems like a lot of the funds are kind of
- 1:19:49combined in that partnership. And they have discovery
- 1:19:54that is seeking accounts, transactions, wallets,
- 1:19:57transfers, IDs, public keys, et cetera. And the
- 1:20:02asker says that it implicates third party privacy
- 1:20:06interests. And basically, they have concerns
- 1:20:10about the hacking and all that they want to be
- 1:20:13able to protect. And so they're asking for any
- 1:20:16suggestions or workarounds to address privacy
- 1:20:21concerns and the security of the information.
- 1:20:25And so I know you spoke to a lot of this previously
- 1:20:28in terms of, you know, kind of transfers, public
- 1:20:31keys, all of that is already available. And so
- 1:20:36I don't know if Gabrielle wants to kind of clarify
- 1:20:42a little bit, feel free to kind of join in if
- 1:20:48you want to provide some more color. But I think
- 1:20:52the long and short of it is, is there a way,
- 1:20:56you know, to kind of segregate that sort of information?
- 1:21:05Gabriel, are you still here? Let's see. Is there
- 1:21:17a way to? I can answer. I mean, I can answer
- 1:21:21to the extent that I can think about it. If it's
- 1:21:26a multi -signature wallet or wallet jointly,
- 1:21:31controlled by partnership and several people,
- 1:21:33right? So that particular information has to
- 1:21:37be disclosed. However, if you subpoena crypto
- 1:21:40exchange, for example, right? I would imagine
- 1:21:44that it's possible for the exchange just to provide
- 1:21:46transactional records for a particular public
- 1:21:50key, right? For a particular wallet without disclosing
- 1:21:55the names and the PII of the other party that
- 1:21:58are not part of that lawsuit. So the respondent
- 1:22:03can always release certain information stored
- 1:22:07off chain, which is not publicly available on
- 1:22:10chain. Like the transaction records from exchanges
- 1:22:12are not publicly available on chain because they're
- 1:22:16off chain records maintained by Coinbase and
- 1:22:19other exchanges. So I'm sure they can release
- 1:22:22the transactional record. you know, while redacting
- 1:22:26the names and personal identifiable information
- 1:22:30of a party that's not part of the lawsuit. Yeah,
- 1:22:34I think if we wanted to get into more details,
- 1:22:37that would be the kind of thing where it makes
- 1:22:38sense to talk offline. So, Gabrielle, feel free
- 1:22:44to send me an email at adam at umklaw .com and
- 1:22:49we can kind of see if we can help you with a
- 1:22:53little bit more detail. But I think this has
- 1:22:56all been very helpful. So I think with that,
- 1:22:59we can start to wind down and I will thank you
- 1:23:03very much, Dr. Richard, for enlightening us today.
- 1:23:09And unless Philip or anyone else has any comments,
- 1:23:13I think we're ready to wind it down.