Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E023: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System with BitGo & Coincover
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of Doctors 1974? 1987 92972. 1000 and whatever we
- 1:44want to call this. It's all just the same thing
- 1:46over and over. We can't help ourselves, I say
- 1:50when we sell. Hey, I say when we sell.
- 1:56Gentlemen, I'm sorry. We're five days late.
- 1:58It's my fault. It's on me.
- 2:00It's not. It's not on you.
- 2:01It was like there was a lot of travel last week A.
- 2:04Lot of travel. How was Vegas?
- 2:08I I heard this term once. It was What happens in Vegas,
- 2:11stays in Vegas. I've only heard it once.
- 2:16Just once. I caught.
- 2:19I didn't tell Mitch or Alex this yet, but I caught Michael.
- 2:22I was going to Missouri. He was coming back from Vegas
- 2:25and the Austin airport. We ran into each other.
- 2:29Yeah, it. Was a handing off of the baton
- 2:30to go orange pill other people? Yeah, it it it was very cool to
- 2:36be honest. It was great to, you know,
- 2:38probably talk more about this, but it was awesome to meet Alex
- 2:41and Mitch in person along with a lot more of the BET Go team.
- 2:46You know the the orange coin the the the Bitcoin side there's
- 2:49some work that on ramp can help with some of these these firms.
- 2:52We had some late nights and we're able to you know kind of
- 2:54pull people help get their allocations outside of these
- 2:58alternative currencies into the you know to where they should
- 3:01go. And I think we did some work on
- 3:04Mitch. Mitch is you know in in in New
- 3:05York and he's hanging out with with these groups and we're
- 3:08talking about Texas and land and a lot of the the freedom that we
- 3:12have here and that was part of the the sell when I we landed.
- 3:16Hit you and Parker in the the airport was like, oh, guys are
- 3:20headed out to go spread some more orange, orange coin.
- 3:24Good. And then texted Mitch was like,
- 3:25yeah, you know when you land in Austin you just find some
- 3:27bitcoiners, they're heading off into the thing hand off and go
- 3:31go back home and you know that the the world's in good hands.
- 3:34He's like, wow, that that kind of helped with the the pitch.
- 3:37And there probably couldn't be a a more different type of
- 3:40conference. I went to Jefferson City, MO, a
- 3:42town of 30,000 people. For a small conference of 200
- 3:48Missourians to Orange Pill the pensions in the state on
- 3:53Bitcoin, it was a great day, very focused on Bitcoin.
- 3:56That's the beauty of what we're doing here, right?
- 3:58We recognize that we have to meet people where they're at and
- 4:00they're everywhere. That's true.
- 4:03It was funny. Me and Michael, we're we're
- 4:05texting. I think it was was Monday or
- 4:07Tuesday morning just looking around the conference and we
- 4:10were just, I don't know probably 80,000 people were there.
- 4:14I don't know the real number, but it was it was tremendous and
- 4:17just looking around it was it was significant portion was trad
- 4:21fi and we're just you know saying we're we're just seeing a
- 4:23whole lot of people wear short Bitcoin here.
- 4:25So we got work to do. I mean, trad fi barons cover
- 4:30over the weekend, time to buy bonds.
- 4:32All the trad fi guys are like, hey, blood in the streets, we're
- 4:34buying bonds. We're aping in as the US
- 4:37government's about to print 1.37 trillion this fiscal year.
- 4:43It it is wild. I've never been, to be honest.
- 4:46I've been to a lot of conferences, you know, being in
- 4:48like traditional cells in my career and I've never seen the
- 4:51amount of kind of like just like wealth and money and people
- 4:54moving around in that conference.
- 4:57But that was part of it. It couldn't like help but look
- 4:59around like all these people are very short Bitcoin.
- 5:02And also there wasn't like a big.
- 5:04I know Mitch can speak more to this because he's attended
- 5:06previous ones, but there was a crypto presence.
- 5:10It was interesting. I went to go listen to a David
- 5:13Marcus talk, which happened to like coincide when they launched
- 5:16this new UMA protocol or whatever it is.
- 5:19And I thought there were, there was a group sitting there
- 5:22waiting for him. I thought it was waiting for
- 5:24him. But it was like digital wallets
- 5:25that Google and, like some other, you know, large
- 5:28conglomerates were setting up across the globe.
- 5:30Or whatever they're digitally doing in crypto.
- 5:34And then they all got up and laughed when Marcus came to
- 5:36talk. And so it's just like, you know,
- 5:37we really are early. Like, nobody even cares about
- 5:39this whole Bitcoin or Lightning thing.
- 5:42Yeah, you send a picture. I was like Oh yeah, there's
- 5:44nobody in there. The like money 2020 in general
- 5:50payments is a is a significant significant portion of of the
- 5:54attendees and you know from a crypto perspective you know
- 5:58lightning you know we're we're we are starting to mature there.
- 6:01But you know compared to the the volumes that you know you're
- 6:05doing in stables you know we we are we are certainly lagging you
- 6:10know from that perspective. So we've got work to do, but at
- 6:14the same time I I saw you know, very, very, very little, you
- 6:19know, lightning presence in MI 2020.
- 6:24Alex, what's your perspective going to Vegas from the UK?
- 6:28You know, it's interesting. One, it takes a special kind of
- 6:34person to build a city of that size in the middle of a desert.
- 6:38That's my UK take on that whole thing now, just like comparing
- 6:43the conversations that we were having at our joint launch party
- 6:48compared to trying to get into conversations on the floor of
- 6:51the conference. There's a lot of work to do,
- 6:54right? People still asking, oh, like,
- 6:56hey, what's coin cover? OK, cool, get that.
- 6:59Can you tell me a little bit more about crypto?
- 7:01OK like, where does Bitcoin come from?
- 7:04How do I know it's backed by anything?
- 7:07How do I use it? Where do I store it?
- 7:09Like that is the level of understanding where a lot of
- 7:12these very senior, very accomplished treadfly people
- 7:16are. And like there's a big gap in
- 7:20educating them. To get them to the point at
- 7:23which they're able to even, you know, understand, OK, some some
- 7:27very simple concepts around what sound money is and what it could
- 7:31be in the next 5-10, fifteen years, right.
- 7:34So there's a huge, huge gap, which is exciting because it
- 7:38means that we've got a lot of work to do, but sometimes you
- 7:41realise that this really is 15 years in still just scratching
- 7:47the surface of what it's going to be.
- 7:49And that was really my take away.
- 7:50Was that, OK, cool, I came away with, you know, I had a
- 7:53different job that wasn't just hanging out with you guys all
- 7:56week. I came away with zero leads and
- 7:59a big understanding like, Oh my God, there's there's a lot still
- 8:03to be done here. We're still early and you
- 8:05mentioned it 15 years in it's October 31st, 2023 white paper
- 8:11was. Was emailed out October 31st,
- 8:142815. Years.
- 8:17Nice. Number divisible by 5 it's it's
- 8:22pretty crazy to think. It's crazy to think I've been in
- 8:24it for 10 years now at this point.
- 8:28That is crazy. That's a lot of, it's a lot of
- 8:30time. A lot of like, it's it.
- 8:33Yeah. I can't imagine what it's like.
- 8:35I would think like, let's say half that time for myself and
- 8:38you start seeing patterns recognized.
- 8:40It's almost like you know. Kind of an edge, especially in
- 8:43like the business sense because you get to see what's what's
- 8:45working, what, what hasn't worked.
- 8:47But yeah, for 10 years. I can't imagine what it's like
- 8:49to be able to see the same And then also the Groundhog's Day or
- 8:52the, you know, alternative the what is it?
- 8:56The eternal September of, like every, you know, couple years
- 9:00you've seen this insane kind of like.
- 9:02Mining death spiral. It's not backed by anything and
- 9:04you're just gonna, you're just gonna live this for the next.
- 9:06It's like a curse for the next 15 years, Marty.
- 9:08What Alex just described is the eternal September.
- 9:11It's like, we're so in it. We're like, yeah, this thing's
- 9:13gonna change the world. And you go up to somebody,
- 9:15they're like, what? What do you what is this thing?
- 9:18They're not ready. They're not ready to understand,
- 9:20right? Did you, did you say it was
- 9:23emailed out? So that's a part of the story.
- 9:24I don't know who who received those emails.
- 9:28The. The cypherpunk mailing list, I
- 9:31believe. Or no, It's the P to P The P to
- 9:33P mailing list it's. Like an E Cash.
- 9:37Like an E Cash right I. Think it was an E cash thread?
- 9:40Maybe on the P to P mailing list.
- 9:43We can be specific here. I'll go to the Nakamoto
- 9:46Institute. Or actually, Logan, you look it
- 9:49up. Nakamoto Institute.
- 9:50Satoshi Email's first one. But yeah, it is crazy thinking,
- 9:54Alex, he said. What's this gonna be like, 5-10,
- 9:56fifteen years out before we even?
- 9:59Project out into the future, I guess.
- 10:02Since we're sitting here on White Paper Day, let's reflect
- 10:061st 15 years. Even though people in Vegas
- 10:10don't know what this is, it is pretty crazy how far this has
- 10:13come from an idea on an obscure mailing list to a software
- 10:19implementation a few months later to a $600 billion asset
- 10:23class within 15 years. Yeah, so that top one.
- 10:29Yeah, yeah. The Cryptography mailing list I
- 10:38think reflecting on the last 15 years and sort of where we are
- 10:41at today. I think the the two pretty
- 10:46breathtaking amazing things to me is #1 the fact that you know,
- 10:51obviously we're we're on the cusp of ETF approval and asking
- 10:55to have momentum going there. But #2, you know, I think we've
- 11:00always dreamed of Bitcoin being that safe haven asset that
- 11:03flights of safety. And you had Larry Fink on on
- 11:07CNBC doing the marketing for us and telling that.
- 11:10But I think, yeah, in watching Bitcoin price action when things
- 11:15go wrong, you know Marty, you've been doing this for 10 years
- 11:19generally, you know we the correlation reaches one and you
- 11:24know Bitcoin, you look at crash in in 2020 and you know we we
- 11:30tend to be correlated to the stock market in equities when
- 11:34you know when things do happen. But I think the amazing thing
- 11:37for me was when Silicon Valley Bank went down, I think we
- 11:43really had the moment where Bitcoin was the flight to safety
- 11:48and we actually were what we you know, it proved out to be what
- 11:53what we had always hoped for. And I think we're seeing some of
- 11:56that with the movements that are going on right now compared to
- 11:59what's happening in the bond market.
- 12:03This is what I'm you know obviously with you got the ETF
- 12:06and have been coming up but Bitcoin performing as that
- 12:10digital gold as that flight to safety as that non sovereign
- 12:14money, you know actually taking place with supply demand in in
- 12:19the marketplace. That's the beautiful thing that
- 12:21I'm seeing 15 years in and what I couldn't be more excited
- 12:24about. Yeah, I actually wrote about
- 12:25this last night, 2023, the year the Great Bitcoin Decoupling.
- 12:31This is a chart that exemplifies exactly what you just described,
- 12:35Mitch, which is the divergent between Bitcoin performance and
- 12:39these are the big banks and Logan.
- 12:40If you Scroll down, you'll see the regional banks.
- 12:45Which are faring much worse. And that's, I mean, I sort of
- 12:50played coy in the newsletters like, well, you know, only thing
- 12:53we know about Bitcoin's outperformance this year is that
- 12:56there's been more buyers than sellers.
- 12:57What's actually driving that imbalance in in supply and
- 13:01demand? Who knows.
- 13:02But if one were, yeah, to put out a reason why Bitcoin's to
- 13:08succeed, it's exactly because of the banking crisis and.
- 13:12Considering what the bank's balance sheets look like with a
- 13:14bunch of toxic assets, also known as Treasury bonds, as as
- 13:18their liquid reserves, it's it's makes sense that Bitcoin would
- 13:23outperform It's up 107% this year, while most banks are down
- 13:27more than 20%. The.
- 13:29BDS it's like these little inklings are slowly getting into
- 13:32people. The traders minds of I got a
- 13:35note from a mutual friend. Very tenured Wall Street
- 13:38individual worked for one of the largest hedge funds in his his
- 13:42note was the more it goes up when other stuff is going down,
- 13:45the more it goes up. It's the most reflexive asset
- 13:47I've ever seen because this is his first real cycle seeing kind
- 13:50of like not only the market but also just seeing the alternative
- 13:54to like what's happened in traditional space and it's just
- 13:58getting. Started.
- 13:59Yeah, just the beginning 15 years in and.
- 14:04What we're here to talk about today.
- 14:05I mean, Mitch was on the last episode, wasn't last week.
- 14:08I almost said last week, but we missed last week.
- 14:10Sorry everybody. No this is last week.
- 14:12We're gonna we're just we're it's it's a little extended.
- 14:14We saved it for White Paper day. There's a lot of travel people
- 14:17flying all over the country orange peeling.
- 14:18So this is part of last. Week, OK, I like that.
- 14:21Excuse we'll use that. But we've got Alex, as you may
- 14:25have picked up from coin cover on the show as well on ramp Coin
- 14:30cover bit go. Are working together to bring
- 14:34this multi institution multi sig custodial solution to the
- 14:38market. We got Mitch's story on the last
- 14:42episode, but Alex, let's learn more about Coin Cover, what you
- 14:45guys do, and why this partnership between On Ramp,
- 14:49Coin Cover and Bitco made sense for you guys.
- 14:54Yeah, absolutely. Thanks for having me on.
- 14:59Yeah, and an absolute pleasure to get to spend some time with
- 15:01both on ramp and bit go last week in Vegas as we launched
- 15:05this partnership. I think you know a good place to
- 15:10start is really in outlining what Coin cover is, how we
- 15:15communicate, what we do. We see ourselves as a risk
- 15:18mitigation company and really we've built a core business
- 15:22offer offering around. Mitigating the risks around
- 15:30losing access to private keys, I think, you know, it's it's the
- 15:34stat that everyone likes to spout off that 20% of Bitcoin is
- 15:39last forever. Great for everyone else, you
- 15:42know, Decreases the supply. A very core part of our mission
- 15:46here at Coincover is making all crypto.
- 15:49I won't say just Bitcoin. All cryptocurrencies safe to use
- 15:52and hold for everyone. And when you think about what
- 15:56that means, right, We were looking ahead doing some crystal
- 15:59ball, gazing 5/10/15 years. If we really want to see mass
- 16:06adoption of Bitcoin and other currencies, let's talk about
- 16:10Bitcoin. That risk around losing access
- 16:13to a private key, losing access to your Bitcoin must be solved,
- 16:17must be abstracted away in the same way that.
- 16:22Money, Fiat money that a lot of the problems around losing
- 16:25access to that have been solved. We must do the same thing for
- 16:28Bitcoin. And so really when you think
- 16:30about Coincover that's what drives us.
- 16:33There are other bits of tech that we build and we deploy to
- 16:36keep assets like Bitcoin safe And so when we were approached
- 16:43by on ramp to take part in this multi how, what are we
- 16:48describing as multi institution custody right?
- 16:51Yeah, we absolutely jumped. We jumped at the opportunity for
- 16:56a number of reasons, right? One, we see it as absolutely
- 17:01driving the state of custody forwards.
- 17:06We like and we can go into that in a minute, right?
- 17:09I think there are. There's a whole wealth of
- 17:12reasons why we wanted to get involved in it.
- 17:15But then on the other side, we've been partnered with Bitco
- 17:18for a good kind of four or five years now, offering all sorts of
- 17:22services through through to their clients, but again
- 17:25primarily offering hot key recovery, right.
- 17:28So on the hot wallets, when you sign up with Bitco and you want
- 17:31to use their hot wallets, you have to set up some way to back
- 17:36up this wallet so that if in any scenario if you lose key
- 17:40material, the very small chance that Bitco goes down for
- 17:44whatever reason. There is a way to then go and
- 17:47sign recovery transactions to get your assets back.
- 17:51And a very common option on that platform is to use Coincover.
- 17:54Toss that away to a trusted third party, abstract away the
- 17:57risk, abstract away the complexity around you having to
- 18:00look after these keys and then if anything goes wrong, you can
- 18:03give them a buzz and they'll help you get your assets back.
- 18:07We've been doing that for kind of, yeah, 5-6 years.
- 18:10I hear stories from our founders, Adam Smith and.
- 18:13David Genchewski of sitting in a meeting room in the big offices
- 18:18in Palo Alto with Mike Belchi kind of hashing it all out over
- 18:22the weekend and they definitely tell their stories with a kind
- 18:27of rose tinted glasses glory days look in their eyes, but
- 18:32it's amazing to see whether it's come and the kind of
- 18:34opportunities that have come out of that.
- 18:36Now working with on ramp to to really try things forward.
- 18:40What I will say is there's a lot of similarities.
- 18:43Around how we operated with Bit Go for a long time now looking
- 18:48after those wallets, we should dive into those right The the
- 18:53the narrative in the space has been focused on MPC for so long,
- 18:58it's refreshing to see the strength of multi sig.
- 19:02Sort of coming back to the fore that's sort of a a false
- 19:06narrative around it being a weaker set up.
- 19:09And so yeah, being able to leverage the expertise that
- 19:11we've built with bit go now deploy that through on ramp is
- 19:15is very exciting. Let's dive into that.
- 19:18The differences between MPC, multi party computation and
- 19:23multi sig. I think we may have done it once
- 19:24or twice in the past on this show, but it's always important
- 19:27to refresh because MPC has dominated.
- 19:31In a market of third party custody of crypto assets more
- 19:36broadly, and I think mentioning crypto assets is important
- 19:40because that's probably why MPC has dominated, because it's a
- 19:44sort of 1 solution for all these assets where multi sig is very
- 19:49particular to Bitcoin and so people would argue that.
- 19:55Just because MPC can do custody for all these different crypto
- 19:58assets, Bitcoin's sort of just been bucketed into that as well,
- 20:02and many would argue that it's a suboptimal solution for custody,
- 20:07Bitcoin specifically. And Marty to to sort of dive
- 20:12into that a bit. I I think we're where we got
- 20:15lost on sort of MPC superiority is is in the altcoin space.
- 20:20Bitco actually does multi sig for for all coins and even by
- 20:26all kinds of I'm I'm actually saying anything you non UTXO
- 20:29based. So there are some altcoins
- 20:31you've got like coin Bitcoin Cash that are UTXO based, do
- 20:34have native multi sig support. We previously actually did you
- 20:41know and still have a multi sig implementation for for the all
- 20:44coins. It's smart contract based.
- 20:47But what you what you have in that multi sig setup is it's
- 20:51expensive to do and that's when you know the MPC, you know
- 20:57companies are you know declaring victory because it's it's a
- 21:02costly transaction to to go use multi sig for for those wall for
- 21:05those transactions on the Bitcoin or UTXO side.
- 21:11Multi sig has always been superior.
- 21:13You've got you know transparency on chain for for who's signing
- 21:18the transaction. You know all three of those keys
- 21:22are are held on chain and you know true distribution of you
- 21:28know each of those keys takes place and you know none of them
- 21:33have to come together to go send that transaction.
- 21:36You can go sign from your own location and once the chain has
- 21:41both signatures, you're good to go and can broadcast a
- 21:44transaction. Yeah, I think that the two big
- 21:49ones, we're working on some real good material because I think
- 21:52like ultimately to help educate on this and Mitch and I were
- 21:56chatting about it in Vegas because it came up and is.
- 21:59Sometimes it'll get confused with MPC and multi sig because
- 22:02folks that use MPC will think about the sharding of keys and
- 22:05hear about how they can have multiple, you know, keys sharded
- 22:09that need to come together. But that's that's basically
- 22:13providing it's still a single key it has it's very different
- 22:16than again multiple signatures which we're going to have a
- 22:19basis of multiple private keys. But the two things that come to
- 22:23mind to make it like super simple is interoperability.
- 22:26And then auditability. So to Mitch's point, multi sig
- 22:30is part of scripting language that's native to the Bitcoin
- 22:32protocol. And it's my understanding that
- 22:34it goes back to cryptography decades previously, even
- 22:37Bitcoin. So it's it's been battle tested,
- 22:39it's hard and it's where Bicco leverages it for Bitcoin.
- 22:43And also if you think about like a coin base will leverage multi
- 22:46sig for their cold storage custody of Bitcoin while they'll
- 22:49leverage MPC and their proprietary instance of it for
- 22:53all coins. And then the interoperability,
- 22:57while it hasn't been as important, I think that if we
- 22:59can start to look at the landscape and we'll probably
- 23:02talk about this today of like why multi institution makes
- 23:05sense and why other products around you know effectively
- 23:08multi institution with just distribution of keys makes sense
- 23:11as you can't do that inherently with MPC because it's
- 23:15proprietary to the instance that's being leveraged for that
- 23:18institution. We're multi sig.
- 23:20If us three on a call wanted to set up a three of three or or
- 23:23three or four or whatever it might be, whether it's a
- 23:26institution, multiple institutions, multiple
- 23:28countries, it allows for that flexibility that doesn't exist
- 23:32in MPC. And so when you start thinking
- 23:34about just trying to build more resilient financial products,
- 23:38you're inherently going to be based on a closed network and a
- 23:41good example of this and not to like you know, throw shade at
- 23:43them, but it's just it is a product that exists.
- 23:46I'm sorry, Copper's loop network which is like a trading
- 23:50settlement layer, but it's within they, they have other
- 23:53parties that participate in it. But at the end of the day it's
- 23:55within their closed source ecosystem.
- 23:57It's not something that is open to other participants and the
- 24:01the keys that are participating in it and the just sort of
- 24:07windows. We referenced it in the last
- 24:09part but partially signed Bitcoin transactions.
- 24:12It's it BIP 174 which gives us the ability to have a standard
- 24:18where on ramp can can sign a transaction, Coincover can sign
- 24:22a transaction, we go can go receive that transaction.
- 24:25Because we have this agreed upon standard in you know the Bitcoin
- 24:29ecosystem where I can go receive and and understand and see that
- 24:34I had that half signed on chain and then goes counter sign on
- 24:37chain to send out a multi say transaction.
- 24:41Yeah, interoperability, it's very important.
- 24:45Yeah. And it might make sense like
- 24:46just to take a a bird's eye view to step back from like the
- 24:49minutiae because it is important from the the technical
- 24:52perspectives. But we talked about the past 15
- 24:57years and the things I wrote down and there was a few
- 24:59mentioned which was SVB which was the the latest and that was
- 25:03like from the money here in the States.
- 25:05But then, you know, we think about what happened with.
- 25:09The treasury market with Russia's treasuries or the the
- 25:13trucker instance like this, this value prop around why Bitcoin
- 25:17matters is has increased and we've seen it the past 15 years.
- 25:21But you know the WikiLeaks, I mean it's no shortage and we
- 25:27think about our part, you know participate in this.
- 25:30The same can be said for custody.
- 25:32And so it's really. Special to be here today but
- 25:35also just like in Vegas in the conversations we're having and
- 25:38to launch this multi institution at this like precipice of this
- 25:41time where I think we all feel bitcoins appreciation and price
- 25:44will occur. But imagine having the existing
- 25:46model that's been that's that's lit with all these poles.
- 25:50As the only option and there's been people that have done it
- 25:53the right way. Coinbase had you know to our
- 25:55knowledge has been OK well, you know probably people have lost
- 25:58funds. It's by their own instance, not
- 26:00not not Coinbase but it goes another.
- 26:02But to offer the market another product that is native to the
- 26:05protocol, that's interoperable to that is, is really incredible
- 26:10and like to make it really whole while we are setting this up and
- 26:15doing the testing. You know we're part of this
- 26:17multi institution product is not a name only where there's you
- 26:20know keys distributed and then in on RAMP or a third party can
- 26:23just go and start Willy nilly directing the the keys and the
- 26:26movement of funds. And it was really like powerful
- 26:31to get on a call as part of the process and testing with the
- 26:35Bitco trust team to go in and verify that the authentication
- 26:39when you think about all the process.
- 26:40So on RAMP has its own process? And then to go to bet, go and
- 26:43have somebody in a completely different location under a
- 26:46completely different entity have to verify before they would
- 26:49produce that signature. And then understanding that and
- 26:52then knowing coin covers best in class operator that they've been
- 26:55doing under the radar what they've been doing.
- 26:56Because it's almost like when I talked to, I think it was always
- 26:59from your team. Have you referenced it was very
- 27:02like thankless job when you think about Coin Cover's role
- 27:04because they're out there protecting but they're not at
- 27:06the forefront because you really want it to be known if you
- 27:08needed Coin cover, but you know that they're there and they've
- 27:10kind of changed some of that. You know we can probably talk
- 27:13about it, but knowing that those keys are distributed and really
- 27:16sitting there and and almost obviously I'm biased.
- 27:18But being able to go to the market which we've been chatting
- 27:20and say this is the best product in the market.
- 27:22This is the best way to custody Bitcoin from a large scale if
- 27:25you need redundancies and to know that like 1 institution or
- 27:29one entity can't rug you. It's pretty cool feeling.
- 27:32I think the model we're talking with banks, we're talking folks
- 27:34and they all see it and they're going to come in and we're
- 27:37excited about it. But to know that we're here like
- 27:39being at the forefront and participating is just really,
- 27:43really exciting to say like we've seen the value prop of the
- 27:46asset now we're seeing the value prop of understanding the
- 27:49custody solution and how we can participate in a different form
- 27:52of it for the next like chapter in bitcoins adoption look.
- 27:58I think. Go for my Mitch.
- 28:00No, you got it. Sure.
- 28:02I look I we we all see what's coming you know with you know
- 28:05the potential price appreciation you know and the new
- 28:09institutional players that are coming into the space and it's
- 28:12on us right now to go build those rails to to go handle you
- 28:16know like I mentioned the last one the the trillion dollar
- 28:18wallet rather than the billion dollar wallet and it's solutions
- 28:22like this that ultimately give us the capacity to to handle and
- 28:27reduce counterparty risk so we can handle the maturation of the
- 28:31industry. I I want to give a quick shout
- 28:34out to to coincover and you know I I don't know if there's a
- 28:38company that really fits the the value prop and you know right
- 28:42place right time of you know this this now push and
- 28:46excitement around multi institution custody like you
- 28:49guys you know you you talked about the the hot wallets that
- 28:53you know how you operate with Bicco in the past you know in a
- 28:57sense that was multi institution custody where you've got a key
- 29:00held by you know whatever company was using or had paid
- 29:04for the coin cover services and the BICCO services and you had
- 29:07spread a key across 3 three different companies and I I
- 29:09think that's you know it's we've been doing it for years it's
- 29:15been proved out that that it works and you know credit to you
- 29:18guys and then credit to on ramp for for seeing the vision and
- 29:21saying let's productize this and you know let's make sure we you
- 29:25know let's secure that that that third key you know to the
- 29:29standards that you guys do and productize that and you know
- 29:32build the story around that that this should be the future of
- 29:35custody and and go to market with that.
- 29:38So look the the foundation's been there and excited to see on
- 29:43ramp and you know the other Trail Blazers here go to market
- 29:46with us and and see how we do and.
- 29:48Alex, I'm particularly interested to get your
- 29:50perspective on how you see. Multi institution custody
- 29:54particularly the role of individual key agents cuz
- 30:00obviously you have this partnership with Bitco and on
- 30:04ramp down the hall you guys just announced something with
- 30:06Unchained and Kingdom Trust as well.
- 30:08So how do you see like the proliferation of key agents
- 30:13playing out into the future and how they interact with each
- 30:15other? Yeah, it's an interesting one.
- 30:21Because we have quite a unique take on that for the time being
- 30:25in that coin cover. Throughout its history, through
- 30:28all the various forms of delivering the services that we
- 30:30do, we've always maintained that we will be a non custodial
- 30:34entity. We were only ever interested in
- 30:37holding onto enough material, enough key material, so that we
- 30:40can look after it, take it away, encrypt it, keep it super safe.
- 30:45And then return it so that you've got enough material to
- 30:48either sign a recovery transaction or reconstitute some
- 30:50keys, whatever it is, whatever platform you're using.
- 30:53And we do that so that there are 0 conflicts of interest, right?
- 30:57You don't really want to be parking or seeking recovery
- 31:00services from an entity who's also running a a kind of
- 31:04custodial offering as well. So we've always been very
- 31:06careful to distinguish that and we will always be doing that.
- 31:11That's different perhaps from other key agents that are
- 31:15currently participating in in in this model.
- 31:20And so that I mean that that's one of the ways I'll be
- 31:23interested to see how that continues to play out.
- 31:26I think when you think about an institution entering the space
- 31:33for the first time, right. So this is reflected on the
- 31:35kinds of conversations I have with, you know, entities who
- 31:39haven't quite. Made-up their mind about where
- 31:42they wanted custody assets but they have decided that they want
- 31:45to use coin cover in some respect because what they're
- 31:47used to is you know good risk control, risk mitigations in
- 31:52place. Essentially what what they come
- 31:53to us for looking for is insurance and so we take them on
- 31:56a little bit of journey around like what does that mean in this
- 31:58space And really they go through this journey of OK, but there's
- 32:03the self custody option. I could use a hardware wallet.
- 32:07I could use one of the. And let's call them self
- 32:10custodial or direct custodial options of the market.
- 32:13And they realise that actually that's a lot of risk that
- 32:17they're taking on. And it's not just because all of
- 32:20that risk is centralized with you as the union of your own
- 32:22assets. There is the technical
- 32:25complexity, there's the operational process and the
- 32:29burden around looking after private keys and the knowledge
- 32:32and the expertise around that that you need to have in house
- 32:35in order to pull it off well. So they decide that option's not
- 32:38for them. And then they think, OK, well,
- 32:41maybe I'll go down the sort of QC routes and a lot of people do
- 32:44this, you know, awesome institutions build businesses
- 32:49out of this, but Go is 1, Anchorage is 1.
- 32:54But then again, this year we've seen some failings there as
- 32:56well, right? Just because someone has
- 32:57qualified custody status doesn't mean that behind the scenes, the
- 33:02management of private keys is being run to a high standard.
- 33:07And so enter this model where you have abstracted away the
- 33:11kind of complexities around looking after keys yourself.
- 33:15You've also removed the risk of a third party looking after
- 33:20these keys and having to trust them.
- 33:22And now all of a sudden you've got a set up where, OK, both of
- 33:25those risks are entirely mitigated just due to the fact
- 33:28that there are three parties involved.
- 33:31It's very. Easy to see how quickly someone
- 33:34who's gone through that journey goes.
- 33:36Ah, OK, well, there is a model that totally alleviates the risk
- 33:40for me. I still have the option for a
- 33:43recovery key partner in there. That's cool because I wanted
- 33:47that. But essentially, I can crack on
- 33:50and custody these assets without having to worry about
- 33:54counterparty risk in a way that I have been before, with neither
- 33:57of the custody options really giving me full confidence that.
- 34:02Those risks have been mitigated. So to me like it's a it's a no
- 34:06brainer. I expect, you know, companies
- 34:10who will come along and try to eat coin covers lunch, they
- 34:13should be, you know, kind of dialling up you guys right now
- 34:18trying to get involved in this because it's, yeah, quite quite
- 34:21obviously going to shake up the custody landscape quite
- 34:24extensively over the next 12 months.
- 34:27Thanks for tuning in to The Last Trade.
- 34:29If you're enjoying the show and want to dive deeper, check us
- 34:32out at on rampbitcoin.com where you'll find a full suite of
- 34:37institutional grade research and analytics including our recently
- 34:41published white paper bitcoins, full potential valuation and our
- 34:46new tool, the On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 34:51Yeah, just to add to like what Mitch said, huge kind of just
- 34:55you know shout out and also like just.
- 34:59Coin covers like core model. I I don't think honestly could
- 35:03have come up with a better archetype for what we needed in
- 35:07this solution or what somebody would need if they were
- 35:09leveraging. Especially in this role, I think
- 35:10there's different roles in primary, secondary, and then the
- 35:13backup as his current construct. And the three main things are
- 35:17jurisdictional. So if you're looking for
- 35:19something outside of the United States, they sit in the UK,
- 35:21which is valuable for for a number of reasons.
- 35:25That they're independent which is I think also very important
- 35:28where this like key architecture starts to go and multi
- 35:31institution is more from like game theory on who do you want
- 35:34to be holding a key and and ideally you want somebody where
- 35:37it's not their core business from a signing perspective that
- 35:40they have other businesses lines attached to it, but their
- 35:43reputation is attached to making sure that they fulfill those
- 35:46obligations. And this could be banks and
- 35:48other institutions that have a larger trust factor outside of
- 35:50just signing the key and that if they didn't fulfill that
- 35:53obligation. It would be a, you know, it
- 35:56would not be good for their business reputation.
- 35:59And then it's our core competency, which is probably
- 36:01the most important in this respect that they've been due
- 36:05for X number of years. But then also from this exact
- 36:08role of holding a key that does not need to be leveraged
- 36:13operationally while it can, you know on a, you know, T plus
- 36:16let's call it 24 hours or 48 hours that the reality is it's
- 36:19it's they're meant as a recovery agent.
- 36:22And so they have the processes in place from not only like the
- 36:25security, but the when it comes to like communications to make
- 36:29sure that the parties that they're working with.
- 36:31There's always a channels open to to confirm if that recovery
- 36:35is actually valid or not. To being able to authenticate
- 36:38you know annually or whatever cadence is required to make sure
- 36:41that that key is still exists and they're still operationally
- 36:44focused until you tie those things together and tell us is.
- 36:49Point it's like if you know we're all right we're going to
- 36:51see more people come to the space and step in and and try to
- 36:54you know re craft or create these offerings and it's I think
- 36:58it's good it's a good thing because we're basically
- 37:00rebuilding a financial system or at least I'd like to think we
- 37:03are. But ultimately they have such a
- 37:05leg up because they were doing this forever and again.
- 37:08Credit to them and Adam, their Co founder who's jumped on
- 37:11multiple calls with us and saw this vision of like, hey.
- 37:14This actually is part of what we've been doing.
- 37:16And if your vision of the future is potentially one that we can
- 37:19participate in and grow or maybe they're not the backup at all
- 37:22times, never heard them say that.
- 37:24But I can see a vision where they participate in other
- 37:26constructs and the economics are different for how they
- 37:29participate. It seems like a great
- 37:32opportunity and and a lot of firms we've talked to could have
- 37:35done this as well. But Coincover said, yeah, we see
- 37:37this, let's participate. So I think it's just really a
- 37:40testament and similar to bit go and just like being
- 37:42entrepreneurial internally while still having Rep, you know, very
- 37:44like sound businesses to say, hey, we see this vision of the
- 37:47future. We'd love to participate because
- 37:49we think this is where the puck's going to.
- 37:52You know, I think we, we've been focused on you know how do we
- 37:56build the best key agents in this model.
- 37:59But to go into a little bit more depth on, on what you mentioned
- 38:04Michael, I think where we fit in the signing process.
- 38:10You know there will be companies that are the best recovery key
- 38:13agent. There will be companies that are
- 38:15the best second signer, first signer in these setups.
- 38:19You know and what's important about each of those you know I
- 38:24guess the attributes that make up a a good key agent you know
- 38:28for for second third signer is going to be different.
- 38:32You know Bitco we've got the infrastructure to at least you
- 38:37know at the at the current point where we're we're best at 2nd
- 38:40signer. You know we ensure that you know
- 38:43policies that have been adhered to.
- 38:45We can do video verifications like we do for you guys to to
- 38:49check that you know the customer that it is a part of this wallet
- 38:54is indeed you know signing off on the transaction.
- 38:58We can broadcast out to our nodes.
- 39:01We we've got all the infrastructure in place to be
- 39:04that ideal second signer and we do have other jurisdictions that
- 39:08we that we can operate out of as well.
- 39:10But at the same time, you know coin covers value prop has been
- 39:14in recovery and has been recovery for years and being
- 39:18that entity that you know that's their core competency.
- 39:21They sit outside the transaction normally but have all the rails
- 39:26and security built that you know in case of that disaster, in
- 39:29case of key loss, you know this is what they're good at.
- 39:32And I think the, you know what we'll see over the next few
- 39:35years is it's not just saying I'm going to be the best key
- 39:39agent. It's here are the attributes why
- 39:42I am you know the particular key agent you need for for this part
- 39:46of the process and I like for for first signer and to to go
- 39:51into that a bit I I think the first signer should have the
- 39:53best relationship with the customer there should be a
- 39:56familiarity there to you know as a transaction takes place to to
- 40:02know that you know no fraud has occurred to see through a you
- 40:06know a deep fake for a video you know I I I know you know some of
- 40:11the Michael we've had a lot of we had a lot of chats in Vegas
- 40:14so sort of are the possible and you know where this goes but.
- 40:19Like ultimately to build out the the most security possible, you
- 40:23need to have a relationship with that customer to you know to to
- 40:27see around all the edge cases and and make sure that it is the
- 40:30customer that is showing up, you know that is asking for for that
- 40:34transaction to be signed. So there's a lot of ways to do
- 40:37it. It's very exciting and I know we
- 40:40can talk about that for a while, but I I do think each of these
- 40:43three companies fit beautifully, you know, in what we do best as
- 40:48our part of the key signing process.
- 40:53I mean, I don't want to give up. Just do a.
- 40:59That plays into it. Sorry, Alex, no way I.
- 41:05Was just trying to tie together to the threads, right?
- 41:08It's Coincover does occupy this unique space.
- 41:13In that it's not glamorous work, It's not sexy.
- 41:17When you think about, you know, buying a car and then you have
- 41:21to buy car insurance, like it's something you have to do, you
- 41:24don't relish that conversation. Backing up your private key is
- 41:28like starting to see, OK, that that is something you have to
- 41:31do. People are starting to learn
- 41:32that they don't relish that conversation.
- 41:36We exist simply to make that as easy as possible and to make
- 41:39that problem disappear, right? We're very privileged to be in
- 41:44that position because we did get a leg up.
- 41:46We started this very early on. Shout out to Adam and our Keys
- 41:50team and our brilliant engineers.
- 41:52It takes a lot of sweat to build up the infrastructure where you
- 41:57can be looking after backups of keys safely, right?
- 42:02Like you, you can't just open up.
- 42:04Vault somewhere, you know, over the course of three months and
- 42:08start tracking material inside and start hiring people and
- 42:11start scaling A-Team without seriously doing your due
- 42:15diligence and vetting every single inch of that process end
- 42:18to end. And you know that's something
- 42:21that Adam has been doing over a lifetime of work.
- 42:23That's what he brings to Coin Cover.
- 42:25That's what he brought through into our work with Bitco, and
- 42:29it's really only possible when you've been.
- 42:32Doing that for kind of 20 years plus, right, That knowledge,
- 42:36that expertise that builds into that core competency, it's not
- 42:40glamorous, but it's super, super effective and much needed And so
- 42:45yeah, very, very cool to be on that journey with coin cover as
- 42:50they found themselves in this unique position I.
- 42:52Would push back on that, I think.
- 42:55I think it's sexier than you think, and it's sexy because it
- 42:58is. An essential fundamental
- 43:02primitive to actually scaling this thing and many people will
- 43:06look at it as boring. But I think in the early days of
- 43:09Bitcoin, a most strong believer that there's an order of
- 43:11operations to Bitcoin's inevitable success.
- 43:14The amount of success that we all believe it can have on this
- 43:18call and services like Coin Cover is providing it is is an
- 43:24essential fundamental to get to where we want to go and even
- 43:28though. It may seem a little boring and
- 43:30unsexy. I think it's actually really
- 43:32sexy because it is an unlock that gets us to the really cool
- 43:35stuff, which gets into a point that you were bringing up
- 43:40earlier, Alex, which I think once you guys prove this model
- 43:44Unchained running with this model, Anchor Watch is coming to
- 43:47mark with this model. There's more and more companies
- 43:50coming with this model and we've discussed this.
- 43:53In the past, but I think it's worth repeating.
- 43:54Like I do think once it becomes glaringly obvious to the market
- 43:58that this is the optimal solution to custodying large
- 44:03amounts of Bitcoin, it's going to be demanded by end users and
- 44:07you're essentially on the tip of the spear of and acting as a
- 44:12forcing function on the rest of the market to get on board with
- 44:16this multi institution model. Yeah, we're, we're.
- 44:23Go ahead. Well, I was, I was going to say
- 44:26yes. And I think institutions will
- 44:28lead the way. Like I I think this will filter
- 44:29down into everyday people who wants to use Bitcoin as well,
- 44:33right? Like we've always posited that
- 44:37until you solve this risk, how do I put it?
- 44:41Being in charge of your own money is a huge responsibility
- 44:45and people have been conditioned over the past.
- 44:49People start banking at 200 years to do in, in a modern
- 44:53sense right over the past 200 years to give control of that
- 44:57over to another entity. What we're talking about is
- 45:00retraining and re educating people to know what that freedom
- 45:05is, to be in charge of your own assets and your own money but
- 45:09also be sensible around what the risks are, right?
- 45:13And that's just something people aren't used to and.
- 45:16When you think about the fact that this started 15 years ago,
- 45:19that is not enough time to generationally bet in this
- 45:22concept that OK, you're in charge of your own money again,
- 45:26what does that mean? How do I treat that?
- 45:30Yeah, well and truly tip of the spear.
- 45:33But you know, I don't know if I'm being corny and saying it's
- 45:37quite a noble aim to be really setting up a way for people to
- 45:42take. Control of their money again,
- 45:44right? And give them a viable way to
- 45:45look after it without being at risk of losing everything.
- 45:51It's extremely noble. No, we don't wanna blow smoke up
- 45:55our own asses. But again, going back to the
- 45:57order of operations, if Bitcoin is to succeed to the level that
- 46:02we would like it to, the the stuff is essential.
- 46:05We're not gonna get to the end goal of what many people think
- 46:10is possible without. Products like this, solutions
- 46:13like this, and it's crazy, I mean, meant you were mentioning
- 46:16it earlier, but this is truly unique to Bitcoin and other UTXO
- 46:21based assets where I think Bitcoin's the most advanced.
- 46:25With the PSPD standard. Like you can all work on this
- 46:29individually and just leveraging the standards that exist in the
- 46:33open source community to create solutions that work together.
- 46:39I I wanna one more time rehash the the the sexiness of of
- 46:44custody I I do agree that you know as far as topics you know
- 46:50fixing money you know there's a lot of really cool things to
- 46:53talk about here how you're storing it.
- 46:56I personally you know have been passionate about but order of
- 46:59operations you know it might be glossed over or glazed eyes you
- 47:03know when when you're talking about holding those funds at at
- 47:06the same time I I you know the biggest black eye we have as an
- 47:11industry right now is what happened at FTX.
- 47:13And you know generally when you're talking to the broader
- 47:16population about Bitcoin about crypto you know that's the first
- 47:21thing that comes to mind. And you know even coming back
- 47:24from the airport they were selling Michael Lewis going
- 47:27infinite cannabis bags at the airport gift shop.
- 47:31We've got work to do to to instill confidence in this
- 47:35industry and and making sure that the coins that that you've
- 47:39purchased are are still there. And you know it's only with
- 47:45telling stories like this and actually getting people to
- 47:50understand how coins are being held and how to check and verify
- 47:55that your coins are there. Are we going to have the success
- 47:58that we all want to? Yeah.
- 48:00I sorry, the weather got a little cold in Texas and so the
- 48:04power went out. So that's where the different
- 48:07different has changed. On Bluetooth, it's a catch 20.
- 48:12It's like two sides, right? It's like the most sexy thing
- 48:14and then least sexy thing in the sense of it's sexy because we're
- 48:17nerds and freaks and we're like, oh, like this is how the world
- 48:21changes. And then it's unsexy because if
- 48:23you think about market participants, they're going to
- 48:26wake up and be like, oh, you mean I can buy this thing and it
- 48:29doesn't get like, put in a Ponzi and get lent out.
- 48:32And it doesn't disappear overnight.
- 48:33Maybe now I can allocate $100 billion or whatever the number
- 48:37is and so. You know, I think it was just a
- 48:39natural evolution where I think that a lot of people haven't
- 48:42fully woken up to and this is what's like the most interesting
- 48:44in my mind. And because we were chatting
- 48:46with Coincover for close to a year with Tom, we got to give
- 48:49Tom a shout out because he was working with us for for a good
- 48:52while and he was in in Vegas with us that you like.
- 48:57Ultimately the vision of where this goes from multi institution
- 49:00to how do the funds move, but then ultimately like what are
- 49:03the financial products around multi institution?
- 49:06Because there's this notion that you shouldn't have your key, the
- 49:09custodian, which I think a single custodian doesn't make
- 49:12sense and there's also a notion where you want to hold your keys
- 49:14offline in your own multi second, I think for a portion of
- 49:16that it definitely makes sense. But if Bitcoin becomes money and
- 49:19you want to participate in a financial world where you either
- 49:22need to lock it up in a lightning channel because you
- 49:24have a certain provider that's going to provide liquidity and
- 49:26give you some interest on that and you have a trusted party or
- 49:31you are going to invest in a bond, whatever the case might
- 49:33be, you need to access that Bitcoin and there has to be
- 49:37nobody talks about, well, what's the way to get access to that
- 49:40Bitcoin other than going into deep cold storage if Bitcoin's
- 49:43money and now you have to go access your keys like you should
- 49:45not really be accessing that capital.
- 49:48That's. Long term, frequently because
- 49:51that's a a tax surface. And so as we think through some
- 49:55of these products and the things we plan to bring to market, it's
- 49:57really this foundation of like OK, well you can trust your
- 49:59parties or multiple parties that participate in this.
- 50:02And then now I can actually participate in an economy of
- 50:05financial services with knowing that I won't get rugged while I
- 50:07also won't, you know, be in, you know, increasing the chance that
- 50:12I could actually have something happen when the price of Bitcoin
- 50:14is 250K. And I have X Bitcoin and I need
- 50:17to go move a Bitcoin to do Y. And now people are looking at me
- 50:21or looking at like my patterns to understand what's happening.
- 50:24I think a lot of these things haven't really been discussed.
- 50:27And are there important factors if this thing actually turns
- 50:30into money and we want to use it, whether it's day-to-day or
- 50:33year to year? Yeah, It's optionality.
- 50:38That's what the market needs. The optionality has been sort of
- 50:42narrowly focused on. The wild early adopters who are
- 50:47comfortable taking the risk of self custody, spinning up their
- 50:50own wallets, spinning up their own multi sig quorums and buying
- 50:54a cold card, putting their Bitcoin in cold storage.
- 50:57And like you said, Alex, that has kept a lot of the
- 51:00institutions at more than arm's length, probably like a AA12
- 51:05foot pole worth of length between Bitcoin and them as
- 51:10'cause they really can't. Allocate to this asset in good
- 51:16conscious and somebody who worked at a fund, a fund of
- 51:19funds that index Ctas like even at that level like the amount of
- 51:22due diligence that we had to do just to invest in a fund,
- 51:26literally travel around the world, show up and look at the
- 51:29servers where people were executing trades like and that's
- 51:34something that on the back end of the financial system is
- 51:38really controlled by clearing houses and broker dealers, but
- 51:40you still had to do your due diligence at.
- 51:43The commodity trading advisor actually had the servers they
- 51:47they said they did and then when you bring that to Bitcoin, the
- 51:50the stakes are just so much higher because it's this digital
- 51:52bearer asset. Yeah, I mean, it's one of the
- 51:58most fascinating things that I can get past of like people
- 52:01can't allocate because they don't feel comfortable that the
- 52:03money's going to be there. Like, forget about all the
- 52:05principles of 21 million and the things.
- 52:07It's like they just can't get past the fact that, like,
- 52:10everything that's happened. The most recent FTX but it's
- 52:13like well why would that not happen to X individual because
- 52:16it's happened historically that's all they see and so you
- 52:20like present that to the world And then the other part and all
- 52:23of this is the trust like we talked about this on previous
- 52:27pods but like free banking and this idea of like I in my mind
- 52:32and this could be wrong but like when I think of free banking I
- 52:34think of just like a trusted part, a trusted entity and
- 52:37fulfilling the obligations and so there's this requirements and
- 52:39institutional world of. You know, DE QS and due
- 52:43diligence questionnaires or what are the process that you went
- 52:47through to assess? And while those are necessary to
- 52:50check a box, the ultimate barometer in my mind, and I
- 52:54think where we go, is do you fulfill the obligations that you
- 52:57were meant to do, whether it's like I leant against the Bitcoin
- 52:59you deliver, the Bitcoin you were meant to sign.
- 53:02And we're starting to see that and it'll continue to grow or it
- 53:06won't actually matter your qualified custodian license or
- 53:09whatever it is, but it's actually falls into did you
- 53:11fulfill the obligations in those track records of a coin cover a
- 53:15little bit go where on ramp you know aims to be you look and
- 53:18it's like as good as gold that they will sign.
- 53:20They will do what they're supposed to.
- 53:23I think plays into all this from a reputational perspective,
- 53:26starts to matter a lot more because some firms just won't
- 53:29fulfill the obligations that we've seen, as we've seen.
- 53:32Yeah. Now this has me very curious.
- 53:35Have either of you, any three of you gentlemen, run into an
- 53:39institution that has a pretty fleshed out DDQ for Bitcoin
- 53:44custody cause Again, going back to the fund that I worked at, I
- 53:49was on the portfolio management team and when we were going
- 53:51through the DDQI was again checking those servers.
- 53:54You had like emergency like fall back options like if somebody
- 53:58dies at the firm like who takes over, what is their contingency
- 54:01plan? Like has anybody even figured
- 54:02that out on the institutional side in regards to Bitcoin
- 54:04custody and what would that and what would that DDQ look like if
- 54:09they haven't. So I'd say we, we get very, very
- 54:14extensive DD QS from anyone from U.S. government to financial
- 54:19institutions around the world shout out to my solutions team
- 54:22who fills those out on a regular basis.
- 54:25You know it's a very, very extensive list, you know and I
- 54:31think some companies do great, some companies you know maybe
- 54:34miss the mark on what they should be asking.
- 54:36But you know those ZD QS certainly certainly exist and
- 54:41can be painful at times, but heart's in the right place for
- 54:44sure. But to on the other question,
- 54:49the fact of the matter is, you know it's not just being AQC,
- 54:52but it's the proof of work ultimately.
- 54:55And you know you've got a lot of history with Bicco and Coincover
- 54:58here. But ultimately you know the only
- 55:01ways that we're going to prove that an institution is
- 55:03worthwhile and being part of these setups is, is by doing the
- 55:07proof of work and showing you know having clients go in and
- 55:11doing test transactions. Actually seeing that funds move
- 55:16and you know being key agents and doing the roles that we do
- 55:19for a period of time that you know the market you know agrees
- 55:27is is you know is enough and you know builds the trust in you
- 55:32know this multi institution set up that we all believe that that
- 55:36we can deliver here. But it's the same that you know
- 55:39Becca's been around for 10 years and you know flywheel of assets
- 55:43you know does occur. You know as you stay in the
- 55:46industry longer you become the more trusted party and you know
- 55:51the the reputation does the marketing for you and you know
- 55:55that only helps our marketing team by you know being that you
- 56:01know we're still here. It certainly certainly helps and
- 56:05I I think it, you know, will only lend more credence to these
- 56:08multi institutional setups. Yeah, and I'm tying this back to
- 56:12like FTX. The lack of trust that exists
- 56:14out there because of FTXI mean people.
- 56:17Just look at SPF on the stand during this trial the last
- 56:21couple weeks. It's like, how the hell did
- 56:22anybody ever trust this guy with a cent of money, let alone
- 56:27billions of dollars. But going back, the point to
- 56:30make here is that having a low time preference going slow and
- 56:35steady, really focusing on doing things right and doing right by
- 56:40your end customer. At the end of the day,
- 56:42especially again 15 years since the white paper launched, like
- 56:46if the early companies, whether it be BICCO, Coincover on ramp,
- 56:52others in the space execute on building a good reputation and a
- 56:56good relationship with their clients.
- 56:57We're talking about institutions that could be around for more
- 57:00than a century. We could be seeing the emergence
- 57:02of the JP Morgans, Goldman Sachs, BNY Mellons in the
- 57:08Bitcoin space. In this 1st 15 years.
- 57:13Yeah, I never recognize and maybe this is naive me and I
- 57:16kind of use this, these weekly pauses like learning things in
- 57:20real time as we're building this business and and being able to
- 57:22share them. And one of the biggest is like
- 57:24who your counterparty is from like the very top down and
- 57:26founders or executives at a company.
- 57:28Because you just hit the nail on the head, Marty, with like you
- 57:31imagine the contrast between SBF and Mike Belgi.
- 57:34You couldn't literally have different people and the
- 57:36different companies and trajectories of them.
- 57:38And so like the DDQ and a lot of that is going to be coming to
- 57:43life when you think about what does it look like multi
- 57:45institution DDQ versus a single institution and we're starting
- 57:48out those discussions. But ultimately I don't think
- 57:51there's a single bullet for like how you evaluate your custodian
- 57:54in this world. It's more of like you know the
- 57:57leadership, the, the key partner, key partners, the
- 58:01vehicle product, the product vehicles and the reason for that
- 58:05is because. If you look at Bitcoin's past,
- 58:08let's call it 24 months or 15 years, you can probably go to
- 58:11every founder and executive and look at their track record and
- 58:14what they did before and be like.
- 58:15Maybe we should have looked at this a little further versus the
- 58:18ones that are still alive. And there's like this model of
- 58:22the future, this version of what they've been doing.
- 58:25And so I think that's just like this new thing that I've started
- 58:27to like realize like if you go assess a counterparty.
- 58:30You should want to really get into the weeds of like what is
- 58:33the vision of their future? Like where is their cash flow?
- 58:36How are they thinking about, you know, custody in this landscape
- 58:38and the future landscape? What are the other products?
- 58:41Who are their partners? Because I think you start to
- 58:42really put a whole picture around, is this a party, to
- 58:46Marty's point? Do you that you want to have for
- 58:48one year, 10 year, 100 year, 100 years, or is this something that
- 58:53hasn't been fully fleshed out? And yeah, I just like looking
- 58:57back, you can kind of see based on, you know, founders and teams
- 59:00who really can stand the test of time because they just have a
- 59:03foundational grasp and like what is happening here with the
- 59:06future of like this space versus somebody that's coming in and
- 59:09just kind of like duct taping things together and then
- 59:11ultimately we've seen what happens when that occurs.
- 59:16And it goes deeper than that, right?
- 59:19Like, is this the way that you want a custody assets of five
- 59:22years, 10 years, 50 years, whatever?
- 59:24I think it was on the last pod you guys were throwing around
- 59:29this idea that actually you need to be building for you know true
- 59:37trillionaires situations where you have assets consolidated at
- 59:42an address that is worth over a trillion dollars and like that
- 59:46has an insane amount of value to to think about protecting and
- 59:50keeping safe and what's nice is. When you you know, we do this at
- 59:55Coincover. When people come to us, we
- 59:58really like to reset the conversation because people
- 1:00:00think about, OK, I need this, I need this, can you can you solve
- 1:00:03this problem for me? And what we like to do is wind
- 1:00:06back and say actually, OK, let's start from the beginning, What
- 1:00:08are you trying to do? What are you scared of?
- 1:00:11What are you as an institution, actually worried about when it
- 1:00:14comes to risk? And it always comes down to, OK,
- 1:00:17well, I'm worried about getting broke, pulled.
- 1:00:19I'm worried about someone getting control of signing
- 1:00:21transactions and stealing from me.
- 1:00:24I'm worried about my assets being kind of commingled or
- 1:00:27mixed or or moved somewhere else without me knowing the same
- 1:00:30risks all the time. What's nice about this model is
- 1:00:33actually you have a really nice and simple answer to guide
- 1:00:38people through getting comfortable with those risks.
- 1:00:41And so when you think about a custody model that stands the
- 1:00:45test of time and also the test of having to be able to store
- 1:00:50trillions of dollars worth, today's dollars worth of assets
- 1:00:53inside them. You really need to be able to
- 1:00:56take people through that journey of getting comfortable with
- 1:00:58those risks and and educating them and allowing them to
- 1:01:01understand that, OK, fundamentally baked into the set
- 1:01:05up, you know, it's it's not superficial tools that we're
- 1:01:09laying over on top to to mitigate these risks.
- 1:01:12It's actually baked into the way that the solution can get.
- 1:01:17Yeah, it's it's goes back to what we chatted about the
- 1:01:19billion dollar like nobody's ever been a billionaire until
- 1:01:23Bitcoin that like you did. And if you think about it, we're
- 1:01:26basically getting ahead of where people's concerns are.
- 1:01:29And the question B would be from the outside is how the fuck
- 1:01:32would you guys know what my concerns are?
- 1:01:35And then already haven't shared this because we haven't caught
- 1:01:37up since Vegas, but I had this unlocked when I was talking
- 1:01:39about I think it was with Mitch at the event we hosted.
- 1:01:42And it's the reason we're able to articulate these concepts and
- 1:01:45build them is because we are either very smart or very dumb
- 1:01:48that we've been allocating A disproportionate amount of our
- 1:01:51capital to this space. And so we had to figure out, how
- 1:01:55do you custody it? Custody that right.
- 1:01:58And so then you think about, well, what was their early
- 1:02:01solution That was an early Unchained client.
- 1:02:02Parker identified Okay. This person is using this.
- 1:02:04Maybe he can actually go out and sell it and help, you know, get
- 1:02:07product market fit and develop that because he had internalized
- 1:02:10what is the risk when you have a disproportionate amount of your
- 1:02:12capital stored. And in that same respect is how
- 1:02:15this product and this like multi institution came about is
- 1:02:17realizing that as you go through thousands of onboardings and
- 1:02:20billions of dollars in allocation, it's like, OK, that
- 1:02:22works. But then there's a lot of people
- 1:02:24that can't do it that way for whatever reason, whether rental
- 1:02:26blocks or from an institutional fiduciary perspective cannot
- 1:02:29leap there. And that's ultimately how you
- 1:02:32come to these conclusions and there will be other ones.
- 1:02:34There will be different quorum structures and different
- 1:02:35entities and different regulations that are required.
- 1:02:38But we're just living effectively in the future
- 1:02:40because we've looked at this so long that we're like, OK, when
- 1:02:43that trillion dollar wallet exists, the person can't deal
- 1:02:46with Coinbase. It just can't make sense.
- 1:02:48And even though they don't know it, when that happens they're
- 1:02:51going to freak out. Just like holding a Ledger
- 1:02:53underneath your mattress when it's $10 million freaks people
- 1:02:56out today and they still do it and there's going to be an
- 1:02:58equilibrium point when the price hits 60 and then 72.
- 1:03:02And then 105 at every point going up where they start
- 1:03:05picking up the phone and and calling on RAMP or Unchained or
- 1:03:08any firm that's participating in things like this.
- 1:03:10Because the reality is like we just haven't put ourselves in
- 1:03:14the spot or most people haven't to be managing that amount of
- 1:03:18wealth knowing that if I mess it up, it's all gone and it can't
- 1:03:21even be there messing up. It could just be like external
- 1:03:24factors that mess it up for them.
- 1:03:27But anyway, that was another another unlock.
- 1:03:28Me, Me and Marty have been chatting like a week and 1/2, so
- 1:03:30I'm just kind of sharing things I generally would have had
- 1:03:32behind this. No.
- 1:03:33But you're you're spot on, right?
- 1:03:35Like we we've seen this in the past year at Coincover.
- 1:03:38Has it been a year, has been over a year ago.
- 1:03:41The moment FTX happened the phone started ringing, right.
- 1:03:45People were like, oh OK, this risk mitigation thing is real.
- 1:03:49Like I I need to be thinking about how safe for my assets and
- 1:03:53who has access to my private keys.
- 1:03:54What happens when private keys get lost?
- 1:03:56What am I doing to mitigate, like the risks of my assets
- 1:03:58being used for other things than what what I stored them there
- 1:04:03for? Right.
- 1:04:03And it's until people start to, until it becomes real, people
- 1:04:08feel a bit of pain and it becomes personal for them, they
- 1:04:12won't act. And we saw that with risk
- 1:04:14mitigation and that was great for us.
- 1:04:16I think you're spot on, Michael, that.
- 1:04:18Yeah. As that pressure increases and
- 1:04:22people start to sweat as Bitcoin grows next year and you know,
- 1:04:27we're all very, very bullish on it, I think people will start to
- 1:04:31pick up the phone and say, OK, I'm not, I'm now no longer
- 1:04:34comfortable with the risk here. I now need a better way to
- 1:04:38custody these assets. Yeah, fully expect to see that
- 1:04:42and like IA bit of confidence that we saw the exact same thing
- 1:04:45play out albeit differently, but it it will happen again and
- 1:04:48again. I think being a Bitcoin or
- 1:04:52you're acutely aware of the edge cases that turn into the actual
- 1:04:58cases. But when things go wrong, how to
- 1:05:00protect against them? There's an inherent paranoia
- 1:05:03that comes into you know, your keys or your money.
- 1:05:06There's no, you know, FDIC insurance that that bails you
- 1:05:10out when something goes wrong. So I think he, you know,
- 1:05:14inherently and you know, my keys are you know.
- 1:05:19A very, very significant portion of the of the wealth that you
- 1:05:23know my family has and you know we plan on passing on to our
- 1:05:26kids and living off of. So in you know building you know
- 1:05:33the the perfect or the ideal product and continuing to
- 1:05:36perfect that product. You know, I think it it is, you
- 1:05:42know, I don't know if there is anybody better at building for.
- 1:05:47In that scenario then you know the people who who worry about
- 1:05:51it or or have to worry about it as you know on an everyday basis
- 1:05:55because you know they're in those shoes.
- 1:05:57So I I do think we are building for that trillion dollar wallet
- 1:06:01because you know ultimately you know we're storing our our, our
- 1:06:07life force, our our, our earnings here and you know, I I
- 1:06:11would. Want to keep that with the you
- 1:06:13know the best standards that that that are humanly possible.
- 1:06:18Yeah. Like we said last week, that
- 1:06:21wall gets really heavy when the price starts running.
- 1:06:25Thank God there's solutions coming to market that make it a
- 1:06:30little a little weightless if you will bring Peace of Mind to
- 1:06:34the market. Yeah, I'm really glad you
- 1:06:37recorded that. On the white paper day, because
- 1:06:40I think this is going to be like a very good Evergreen like to
- 1:06:43like basically how we got here and then where we're headed.
- 1:06:46And I think Mitch, what he referenced is also like, Mitch
- 1:06:49has been a special part in all of this because he recognized
- 1:06:51what we're doing and had the autonomy within Bit Go.
- 1:06:53And bit go has a focus, you know, on Bitcoin infrastructure
- 1:06:55as well as crypto to build products of the future.
- 1:06:59And he had that problem in his own mind of like, how do I
- 1:07:02custody the thing and how do I think about it to see like, Oh
- 1:07:04well, others are going to have that.
- 1:07:06And so they're like we're we're sitting here today is like it's
- 1:07:09just a kind of like amalgamation of like the past, you know, 5
- 1:07:12plus years, however long people have been in the space, all with
- 1:07:15their own little parts in it coming together.
- 1:07:18And this is a big part of this podcast because we're able to
- 1:07:20like, share a lot of the like process that goes into it versus
- 1:07:24looking at a screen and saying, oh, this looks interesting and
- 1:07:26there's like there's a lot of. Back story and work.
- 1:07:29That was done to get this to to where it is today.
- 1:07:32And this is just be one of of what's you know what's coming.
- 1:07:36I you know we we had the conversations in Vegas.
- 1:07:40We've been having the conversations of you know are
- 1:07:43the possible for this whether that be you know truly multi
- 1:07:46jurisdictional or building and things like time locks or you
- 1:07:50know Marty flashed the card you know to to prove identity there.
- 1:07:53There are ways to step up here, and I think only real bitcoiners
- 1:07:59are going to keep pushing this forward.
- 1:08:01And you know bringing you know that that infrastructure and
- 1:08:06that redundancy to to make the best products out there in the
- 1:08:09industry. And I think that's how
- 1:08:11ultimately we end up differentiating from traditional
- 1:08:13finance tradition, like differentiating from the ETF and
- 1:08:18making sure that, you know, Bitcoin lives outside the
- 1:08:20brokerage account. Yeah.
- 1:08:23And with that, considering it's White Paper Day, we're talking
- 1:08:26about the 1st 15 years. Of Bitcoin where we may go in
- 1:08:29the future. Let's end it with a treat for
- 1:08:32anybody watching this podcast on YouTube or Spotify.
- 1:08:37Michael Goldstein, the meme king of Bitcoin, came out the great
- 1:08:41white paper video today that I think we should watch 'cause it
- 1:08:44really puts the context of everything that happened before
- 1:08:48Bitcoin launched into consideration, which many people
- 1:08:52don't realize. Bitcoin was birthed on the on
- 1:08:55the shoulders of giants. Make sure you start it from the
- 1:08:57beginning. I don't believe that we should
- 1:09:00ever have a good money again before we take the thing out of
- 1:09:05the hands of government, because we can't take them violently out
- 1:09:10of the hands of government. All we can do is pass some sly
- 1:09:13around the Broadway and to do something so you can't stop.
- 1:09:51None. The.
- 1:10:48Goosebumps. Found the slide roundabout way
- 1:10:52guys. We did it, but if you only need
- 1:10:572. Percent allocation, it's it's
- 1:10:59OK. Shout out to Michael, the meme
- 1:11:06God of Bitcoin. That that one gave me
- 1:11:08goosebumps. Actually had a behind the scenes
- 1:11:11look at how that was developed over the last few weeks.
- 1:11:13Could've waited for it to be dropped this morning.
- 1:11:17Love it. We have to give a shout out to
- 1:11:18to Jesse as well. I don't know if we addressed
- 1:11:20he's he's not on the pod today because he is in flight you know
- 1:11:24we're we like to build redundancies and strength in a
- 1:11:27in a unit and for having him in Texas is an important function
- 1:11:30of our operational. Our financial resilience and you
- 1:11:35know had a good discussion with Mitch and Alex in Vegas and it
- 1:11:38looks like you know Texas can be on the cards for them maybe to
- 1:11:40start to visit. But at some point you know I
- 1:11:44think we're starting the process of getting getting them their
- 1:11:47their units can be jurisdictionally segregated
- 1:11:49across the world but them from a personal perspective think Texas
- 1:11:53is in their. Future Michael was pretty
- 1:11:55instrumental in me realizing that I've.
- 1:11:58I'm long New York, in short, Texas.
- 1:12:00And you know the risk that that provides.
- 1:12:04Now, I'm not ready to make the jump yet, but I'm I'm at least
- 1:12:07aware of the risk. Touch points?
- 1:12:10Yeah, no, I am. I don't know if you remember
- 1:12:13this, but you did extend an invitation to myself and Tom to
- 1:12:16get a taste of that sweet, sweet freedom.
- 1:12:18So we will be coming over to have a look around.
- 1:12:22It's pretty sweet. It's pretty sweet.
- 1:12:24Somebody was in New York for a while.
- 1:12:26It is much different. As Michael says, you get to
- 1:12:29Texas at the price you deserve. That's.
- 1:12:33Right. Gentlemen, this has been a
- 1:12:35pleasure. Before we wrap up, is any anyone
- 1:12:39have parting notes on what you guys are building?
- 1:12:41Anything we didn't touch on, we can send the audience away with
- 1:12:45I'm. Just glad you guys joined.
- 1:12:49Excited that it was good to see you guys last week and then glad
- 1:12:54we were able to have this discussion today.
- 1:12:57Yeah, no notes. I was going to say no real point
- 1:13:02notes about coin cover, but if Mitch ever offers to play a few
- 1:13:07hands of Texas Holdem with you, I'd I'd advise to decline if if
- 1:13:15you. If you care about money, that's
- 1:13:17only you. Bam, Mitch.
- 1:13:18Mitch is a killer. Yeah, it was only taken Fiat, so
- 1:13:22it's OK my my take away from the the week.
- 1:13:27It was. It was really that this is the
- 1:13:29V1 here and the excitement is is toppable of that we're we're
- 1:13:37building the rails here and not stopping and I couldn't be more
- 1:13:41excited and nothing I'd rather be working on we're.
- 1:13:45Going to win? Happy White Paper Day,
- 1:13:46gentlemen. Got a happy White's mentality
- 1:13:51distributed. Multi sig, multi institution,
- 1:13:54multi jurisdiction, jurisdictional custody.
- 1:13:57It's the future. We're building it.
- 1:13:59Go forth, work hard, let's get it.
- 1:14:03We got the sly roundabout way. See you next week.