Latest / My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story / My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 38: The First Thread

Transcript

My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 38: The First Thread · My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story

0:00
Show me your wall sometime, I said. When it's
0:03
ready. Not to fix it. Just to stand in front
0:07
of it with you. When it's ready, she said. Which
0:10
from Saloni, about an unfinished beginning, is
0:14
the largest invitation there is. My Playful Wife.
0:20
Episode 38. The First Threat. Written by Mia.
0:27
In the weeks after we came home, the workroom
0:31
filled back up, and I made it my private study
0:33
to watch a thing I had been married to a maker
0:36
for years and somehow never once watched, a making
0:40
beginning. I had seen the ends of them. I had
0:44
stood at the edge of the December room and watched
0:47
a finished collection walk into the light. I
0:50
had sat on the stool while a centerpiece broke
0:52
her heart and been there for the recut, the middle
0:56
of a making. The part with the deadline in it.
0:59
I had even, this last time, learned to sit in
1:02
the empty room after. The spent end, the fallow.
1:06
But the beginning. The actual genesis, the part
1:09
that happens months before there is anything
1:11
anyone could photograph, when a collection is
1:14
not yet a collection but only a pressure behind
1:17
a maker's sternum, a color half seen at the edge
1:20
of sleep, a thread pulled out of nowhere and
1:23
held up to the light to see if it leads anywhere,
1:26
that I had never watched because for all the
1:28
years before the balcony I had not known it was
1:31
happening, and a beginning, unlike a deadline
1:33
or a show, does not. announce itself. It has
1:38
no date. It makes no noise. It is the quietest
1:42
and most important event in a maker's calendar,
1:45
and it is invisible, and I had walked past a
1:48
dozen of them. I have wondered since how many
1:51
beginnings I have failed to witness, and not
1:54
only hers, how many first stirrings, and how
1:57
many people I have loved, I have missed entirely.
2:01
Because beginnings are silent and undated and
2:04
so easy to mistake for moods. The world celebrates
2:08
completions. It throws the show, prints the review,
2:12
hangs the finished thing on the wall. It has
2:15
no ceremony at all for the day a thing first
2:18
stirs in someone. The bravest day. The one the
2:21
whole later edifice secretly rests upon. We are
2:25
a species that applauds arrivals and sleeps through
2:28
departures. And a beginning is a departure, the
2:32
quietest one there is, someone slipping off the
2:35
safe shore of the not -yet -started, alone, unwaved
2:39
off, into open water. I did not walk past this
2:44
one. It does not look like much, a making beginning,
2:50
which is the first thing nobody tells you. It
2:52
does not look like inspiration, the way the films
2:55
have it, the bolt from the blue. The maker seized
2:58
and transcribed. It looks like a woman wandering
3:02
around a room being faintly irritable. I say
3:05
this with love, and she would say it of herself,
3:08
because she knows her own weather better than
3:11
anyone alive. The maker at the start of a thing
3:14
is not the serene priestess of the popular imagination,
3:18
receiving the muse with an upturned face. She
3:22
is closer to a person trying to remember a word
3:25
that is on the tip of the tongue and will not
3:27
come, The same low itch, the same circling, the
3:31
same maddening nearness of a thing that refuses
3:34
to fully arrive. To live alongside it is to learn
3:38
not to take the irritability personally, to understand
3:41
that the frown aimed vaguely in your direction
3:43
across the dinner table is not about you at all,
3:46
but about a color three rooms deep inside her
3:49
that has not yet agreed to be seen. Saloni in
3:54
the first weeks of A Thing Is Not Serene. She
3:57
is restless, distractible, a little raw, prone
4:01
to standing in the middle of the workroom holding
4:04
a length of cloth and frowning at it as though
4:07
it had insulted her. She pinned things to the
4:09
wall, a scrap of indigo, a photograph torn from
4:13
somewhere, a leaf, a paint chip, a length of
4:17
the plain undyed base she had laid her hand on
4:20
the day we came home, and then took half of them
4:22
down again, and then put one back, and the wall
4:26
became... Over the weeks, a slow, accreting mess
4:29
of fragments that meant nothing to me and everything
4:32
to her. The visible outside of an argument she
4:36
was having with herself below the level of language.
4:39
I learned those weeks to read that wall a little
4:42
the way I had learned to read the bias of cloth.
4:45
Not to understand it, I will never understand
4:48
it, but to recognize its moods. Some days a new
4:51
scrap went up and the whole wall seemed to lean
4:54
toward it. to reorganize itself around the newcomer,
4:58
and those were the good days, the days when the
5:01
half -seen thing had come a half -step closer.
5:04
Other days she took everything down and the wall
5:07
stood bare and accusing, and she moved through
5:10
the house like weather, and on those days I made
5:12
the chai a little more quietly and asked even
5:15
less than usual, which was already almost nothing.
5:18
She started three things and abandoned all three.
5:22
She muttered, She went quiet at dinner in a way
5:25
that had nothing to do with us, and everything
5:28
to do with the thing pulling at her from inside,
5:31
the half -seen color she could not yet name and
5:34
could not stop chasing. To the untrained eye,
5:37
to the eye I had been for all the early years,
5:40
it would have looked like nothing, like a woman
5:43
in a mood, like a room getting cluttered. It
5:47
is, in fact, the bravest thing I know of that
5:50
anyone does routinely, without applause alone.
5:53
We reserve the word courage for the loud kinds,
5:56
the soldier, the rescuer, the person who runs
6:00
toward the burning thing. But there is a quieter
6:02
courage that no one pins a medal on, the courage
6:06
of the blank page and the empty loom and the
6:09
first day of any unproven thing, the nerve it
6:12
takes to begin in private, with no one watching,
6:15
knowing you might pour months into a nothing
6:18
and have only the wasted months to show for it.
6:21
The loud courage is over in a moment, adrenaline
6:24
fast, half reflex. This kind has to be summoned
6:29
cold, in daylight, again and again, with full
6:33
knowledge of the odds, and I have come to think
6:36
it is the rarer, and by far the harder of the
6:39
two. Because here is what a beginning actually
6:44
asks of a person, and why I have come to think
6:47
of the blank as the single most frightening place
6:49
a human being can stand. To begin a thing, really
6:54
begin it, a collection, a book, a marriage remade,
6:57
a notebook, is to commit your hands and your
7:00
months and some irreplaceable portion of your
7:03
one life to a thing you cannot yet see, with
7:06
no guarantee whatsoever that it will become anything
7:09
at all. The finished thing, when it exists, looks
7:13
inevitable. People stand in the December Room
7:16
and assume the collection always existed somewhere
7:19
and Celonie merely fetched it. But on the day
7:23
she begins, there is nothing. There is a blank
7:26
wall and a bolt of plaincloth and a feeling she
7:29
cannot prove to anyone, not even to herself,
7:33
and the demand the work makes is that she back
7:35
the feeling anyway. That she pour weeks into
7:38
chasing a color that might lead nowhere, cut
7:41
into good cloth on the strength of a hunch, stake
7:44
real time. She will never get back on the faith
7:47
that the half -seen thing is real and worth the
7:50
seeing through. Most of the failures in a life
7:53
are not failures of execution. They are failures
7:57
of beginning. They are all the things never started
8:00
because the blank was too frightening, the hunch
8:03
too unprovable. The risk of pouring yourself
8:06
into a nothing that stays a nothing too large
8:08
to face. The world is full of people who could
8:12
have made the thing and never began it. Their
8:14
reasons are always good. The reasons not to begin
8:17
are infinite and every one of them is sensible.
8:20
It might not work. The time is not right. Who
8:23
am I to make this? The blank is too large. I
8:26
will start when I know more. I will start when
8:28
I am sure. And sureness never comes. Because
8:32
sureness is the reward at the end of the beginning,
8:35
not the permission at its start. You do not get
8:38
to be certain first and begin second. You begin
8:42
uncertain, or you do not begin at all. Celonie
8:46
knows this in her hands. She has made her peace
8:49
with starting before she is sure, which is, in
8:51
the end, the only kind of starting there has
8:54
ever been. Celonie begins. Every time the fallow
8:58
and she walks back up to the blank wall and the
9:01
plain cloth and stakes herself, again, on a feeling
9:05
she cannot prove. I had watched her do it a dozen
9:09
times without seeing it. I see it now. It is
9:12
the most courageous thing in our home and it
9:15
looks like a woman being irritable near a cluttered
9:18
wall. And I noticed those weeks. watching her
9:24
stand at her blank, that I was doing the same
9:27
thing at mine. The fifth notebook was not the
9:31
first four. The first four had been begun by
9:34
catastrophe, written under the lash of a crisis
9:37
that made their writing compulsory. I did not
9:40
have to find the faith to begin them, because
9:42
grief began them for me. But the fifth I had
9:45
had to start cold, against no emergency. on nothing
9:50
but the hunch that the awake years were worth
9:52
the documenting, that there was a book in contentment
9:55
as well as in catastrophe, that the quiet thing
9:58
deserved the ink as much as the loud one had.
10:01
Some mornings I sat at the kitchen table with
10:04
the fifth notebook open to its blank cream page
10:07
and felt the exact thing I now watched her feel
10:10
at her wall. The vertigo of the empty, the unprovable
10:14
hunch, the question of whether the thing pulling
10:17
at me was real. or whether I was about to pour
10:20
months into a nothing. Her blank cloth and my
10:23
blank page were the same blank. The first stitch
10:26
and the first sentence were the same act of nerve,
10:30
the small daily heroism of making the first mark
10:33
on the empty, of backing the unprovable feeling
10:37
with real and unrecoverable time, of beginning.
10:41
We were, the two of us, in our separate rooms,
10:44
doing the identical frightening thing, and I
10:47
had spent years thinking her work and my scribbling
10:50
had nothing to do with each other, when in fact
10:52
they were the same faith practiced in different
10:55
materials, thread and ink, cloth and page, two
10:59
people who had each decided, again, to bet a
11:03
portion of a life on a thing they could not yet
11:05
see. It moved me more than I expected. This realization,
11:10
sitting at my kitchen table over a blank page
11:13
while she stood at her blank wall in the next
11:16
room. For years I had felt a quiet apartness
11:19
from her work, a sense that she was an artist,
11:22
and I was a man with a desk job who happened
11:24
to keep a journal, that we lived in different
11:27
countries of effort, and always would. And here's
11:30
the truth, plain once I finally saw it. We did
11:34
not. The materials differed, and nothing else
11:37
did. Every real beginning in any medium asks
11:41
the same single thing of the person beginning
11:43
it, and she and I were both, that night, being
11:46
asked it in our separate rooms and answering
11:49
it or trying to in thread and in ink. My job,
11:55
I understood, was to witness the beginning without
11:58
laying a finger on it. This is harder than it
12:02
sounds, and it is the exact inverse of what the
12:05
loving instinct wants to do. The loving instinct,
12:09
watching someone you adore struggle at the frightening
12:12
blank, wants to help, to suggest, to encourage,
12:16
to say, but what about this? To bring enthusiasm
12:19
to the table like a casserole. And every one
12:22
of those impulses, I have learned, is poison
12:25
to a beginning. A beginning is a shy animal.
12:29
It comes out only into a quiet, unwatched, unpressured
12:33
field, and the moment you point at it and say,
12:36
oh, how exciting, what's it going to be? I can't
12:40
wait to see it. You've put the maker on a stage,
12:43
converted her private, unprovable chase into
12:46
a thing now expected to deliver, and sent the
12:49
shy half -seen color bolting back underground.
12:52
The bucket under the spring again. The pressuring
12:56
enthusiasm dressed as support. So I did, in those
13:00
weeks, the hardest and least visible work available
13:03
to me, which was almost nothing. I made the chai.
13:06
I kept the house quiet around the edges of her
13:10
chasing. I did not ask what it was going to be.
13:13
I did not look too long or too admiringly at
13:16
the accreting wall. I did not bring my excitement
13:19
to her fragile blank like a gift she would then
13:22
have to be grateful for. I just kept the conditions.
13:26
the warm, quiet, unpressured field a beginning
13:29
needs to risk coming out into, and let her chase
13:32
her color in peace, and trusted that the most
13:35
loving thing I could do for the start of my wife's
13:37
next collection was to make myself, gently, almost
13:41
invisible, a guardian of the quiet she was beginning
13:45
in. There is a kind of love that is mostly presence,
13:48
and another kind that is mostly restraint, and
13:51
I had spent the first half of my marriage fluent
13:53
only in the first and entirely illiterate in
13:56
the second. The restraint kind is harder. It
14:00
is the love that does not help when helping would
14:02
intrude, does not speak when speaking would crowd,
14:06
does not carry its own feelings into a room that
14:09
needs to stay empty for a while, so that something
14:12
fragile can have the space to grow in it. It
14:15
looks, from the outside, and sometimes even from
14:18
the inside, like doing nothing at all. It is
14:21
in truth the most attentive thing I know how
14:23
to do, and it took me 40 years, and a broken
14:26
open marriage to so much as begin to learn it.
14:32
There was a night, late in those first weeks,
14:35
when she came out of the workroom and found me
14:37
at the kitchen table with the fifth notebook
14:39
open to a blank page I had been failing to begin
14:42
for an hour, and she stopped and looked at the
14:45
open empty page and looked at me, and something
14:48
passed between us that we did not have to say,
14:50
because we were both, at that moment, standing
14:54
at our blanks. You too, she said. Not a question.
15:00
She had seen the open -empty page and read the
15:03
whole of it. Me too, I said. Some nights the
15:08
page wins. She came and stood behind my chair
15:13
and put both hands on my shoulders, the warm
15:16
weight of them, the maker's hands, chalk still
15:19
faintly on them from her own blank in the other
15:22
room, and she looked down at the empty cream
15:25
page over my shoulder for a while. In the lamplight,
15:29
Two people contemplating a blank together, and
15:31
she said, I used to think you couldn't possibly
15:34
understand it. The work. I thought it was a country
15:38
you'd never have a visa for. Her thumbs moved
15:42
on my shoulders. And then you started keeping
15:44
these notebooks, against nothing, with no deadline
15:48
making you, just because you decided the quiet
15:51
was worth writing down. And I realized you'd
15:54
got yourself a visa after all. You're a maker
15:57
now too. A bad one, with terrible handwriting.
16:02
I could hear the smile in it. I have turned that
16:05
sentence over many times since, because it quietly
16:09
reordered something in me. My whole life I had
16:12
stood outside the country of making and assumed
16:14
the border was sealed to me, that some people
16:17
were makers and some were not, and I was simply,
16:20
constitutionally, of the second kind, an appreciator
16:24
at best, a man admiring from the cheap seats.
16:27
And here was the actual maker in my house telling
16:30
me the border was not where I had always thought
16:33
it was, that it did not run between the talented
16:35
and the rest, but between the people willing
16:38
to stand at the blank and the people who are
16:40
not, and that I had, without quite noticing the
16:44
moment of it, crossed over. But you stand at
16:47
the blank like I do. I didn't expect to get to
16:50
be married to someone who stands at the blank.
16:54
I reached up and put my hand over one of hers
16:57
on my shoulder. The color of it, the wordless
17:00
sentence, said for once almost in words. Show
17:05
me your wall sometime, I said, when it's ready,
17:09
not to fix it, just to stand in front of it with
17:12
you. When it's ready, she said, which from Celonie,
17:17
about an unfinished beginning, is the largest
17:21
invitation there is. I wrote it in the fifth
17:27
notebook that night. Managed, finally, to begin
17:30
the page the way you sometimes can only begin
17:33
once someone has stood behind you and called
17:35
you a maker. The first thread. Watched a making
17:39
begin for the first time in my life. The part
17:42
with no date, no noise, invisible. The part one
17:46
walked past a dozen times. It doesn't look like
17:49
inspiration. It looks like a woman wandering
17:52
a room being irritable near a cluttered wall.
17:55
It is the bravest ordinary thing I know. To back
17:59
a feeling you can't prove. To pour months into
18:02
a thing you can't yet see. To stake real time
18:05
on a hunch with no guarantee. Most failures in
18:09
a life are failures of beginning. The things
18:12
never started because the blank was too frightening.
18:15
She begins anyway, every time the fallow ends.
18:19
And I'm doing it too, at my own blink. The fifth
18:23
notebook, begun cold against no catastrophe,
18:27
on nothing but the hunch the quiet's worth the
18:29
ink. Her cloth and my page are the same blink,
18:33
the first stitch and the first sentence the same
18:36
act of nerve. My job. Witness the beginning without
18:40
touching it. Make the chai. Guard the quiet.
18:44
Don't point at the shy animal. She called me
18:47
a maker tonight. A bad one with terrible handwriting.
18:51
I'll take it. And below it, the working line.
18:56
The blank is the bravest place a person ever
19:00
stands. Everything finished looks inevitable
19:03
and was, at its beginning, an unprovable feeling
19:07
someone decided to back with their one life.
19:10
Honor the beginnings, yours and the beginnings
19:14
of the people you love, by guarding their quiet
19:17
and never, ever pointing at the shy half -seen
19:20
thing before it is ready to be seen. Make the
19:23
chai. Keep the field quiet. Let the beginning
19:26
come out on its own. And when you stand at your
19:29
own blank, remember it is the same blank she
19:32
stands at, and that the courage to make the first
19:35
mark on the empty is, in the end, the only courage
19:38
any making asks, and the one almost nobody gives
19:41
themselves credit for, because it looks, from
19:44
the outside, like nothing at all. To be continued
19:59
That was episode 38 of My Playful Wife. If this
20:04
story is staying with you, the next episode is
20:07
already waiting. Subscribe so you don't miss
20:10
it. The complete book is on Amazon and early
20:13
episodes plus bonus chapters are on my Patreon.
20:17
Links are in the description. I'm Mia. Thank
20:20
you for listening.