Latest / StarQuest Media / Did the Virgin Mary Invent Chili? (& More Weird Questions)
Transcript
- 0:00Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is brought to you by the StarQuest
- 0:03Dom Bettinelli: Production Network and is made possible by our many generous patrons.
- 0:07Dom Bettinelli: If you'd like to support the podcast, please visit givemysterious.
- 0:11Dom Bettinelli: fm.
- 0:12Dom Bettinelli: You're listening to episode 441 of Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World, where we look at mysteries from the twin perspectives of faith and reason.
- 0:22Dom Bettinelli: In this episode, Jimmy will be again answering listeners' weird questions.
- 0:26Dom Bettinelli: I'm Dom Bettinelli, and joining me is Jimmy Akin.
- 0:30Dom Bettinelli: Hey Jimmy!
- 0:31Jimmy Akin: Howdy, Dom.
- 0:32Dom Bettinelli: Folks, be sure to stick around to the end of the episode.
- 0:34Dom Bettinelli: We'll have your feedback on our recent episode number 430
- 0:38Dom Bettinelli: on Buck Nelson, the Ozark Spaceman.
- 0:42Dom Bettinelli: As we've said earlier
- 0:44Dom Bettinelli: in this month, this is Weird Questions Month in October 2026, and we're getting to our last episode of Weird Questions.
- 0:51Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, what topics are you going to be answering questions about today?
- 0:55Jimmy Akin: Today we're going to talk about questions like, did the Virgin Mary give the recipe for chili
- 1:00Jimmy Akin: to a bilocating 17th century nun?
- 1:04Jimmy Akin: What evidence points to UFOs or UAPs being advanced earthly beings rather than visitors from outer space?
- 1:12Jimmy Akin: Do animals praise God in their own way?
- 1:16Jimmy Akin: Are cryptid UFO and ghost
- 1:18Jimmy Akin: sightings thought projections, or are they objectively real?
- 1:22Jimmy Akin: Would confession, communion, and baptism work through a remotely controlled
- 1:27Jimmy Akin: flesh and blood robot body?
- 1:30Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:30Jimmy Akin: what
- 1:31Jimmy Akin: was Jesus looking at when a remote viewer
- 1:33Jimmy Akin: saw him turn and look back
- 1:35Jimmy Akin: Can you wear a cowboy hat and boots without owning a horse?
- 1:39Jimmy Akin: How does time work in purgatory?
- 1:42Jimmy Akin: Could a vampire cop
- 1:43Jimmy Akin: serve a search warrant on a home he wasn't invited into?
- 1:47Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:47Jimmy Akin: was Adam formed from fossilized dinosaur remains or from dirt that predates
- 1:53Jimmy Akin: the dinosaurs?
- 1:55Dom Bettinelli: Those are some very good questions.
- 1:57Dom Bettinelli: And here are your answers.
- 2:03Cy Kellett: You know we're about to have fun.
- 2:05Cy Kellett: Kathy Cancer
- 2:06Cy Kellett: was live.
- 2:06Cy Kellett: I am Cy Kellett, your host.
- 2:08Cy Kellett: When you hear that music, you know we're about to have a fun two hours of weird questions with Jimmy Akin.
- 2:13Cy Kellett: It's the only thing
- 2:14Cy Kellett: We do, I think, that has its own theme music.
- 2:17Cy Kellett: There was another thing we did, wasn't there, that had its own theme music?
- 2:20Cy Kellett: But uh
- 2:20Cy Kellett: this is the only uh program we do with its own theme music.
- 2:23Cy Kellett: That's the
- 2:24Cy Kellett: uh
- 2:25Cy Kellett: uh weird questions
- 2:26Cy Kellett: uh theme music.
- 2:27Cy Kellett: Jimmy Akin, of course, uh the guy behind uh
- 2:30Cy Kellett: Mysterious World, Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World, where he
- 2:33Cy Kellett: covers all kinds of m mysteries and also
- 2:36Cy Kellett: I think uh even without Mysterious World
- 2:38Cy Kellett: has the reputation of
- 2:39Cy Kellett: you got a question, he'll take your question.
- 2:41Cy Kellett: Whatever it is, let's apply
- 2:43Cy Kellett: uh
- 2:43Cy Kellett: reason uh to it.
- 2:44Cy Kellett: Let's look at it through the lens of faith and see what we come up with.
- 2:47Cy Kellett: uh Jimmy Akin.
- 2:48Cy Kellett: Welcome.
- 2:49Jimmy Akin: Thank you.
- 2:50Jimmy Akin: Very nice to be here, Sy
- 2:51Jimmy Akin: Kellett.
- 2:52Cy Kellett: Did is did
- 2:53Cy Kellett: did you always have this reputation or is this something like like if I
- 2:56Cy Kellett: If I had called
- 2:57Jimmy Akin: Which which
- 2:58Jimmy Akin: which
- 2:58Jimmy Akin: reputation?
- 2:59Cy Kellett: Of being willing to take weird questions, being willing to take on things that other people might go, I
- 3:03Cy Kellett: don't know anything about that.
- 3:04Cy Kellett: I don't
- 3:05Cy Kellett: I don't want to get into that.
- 3:06Cy Kellett: Uh
- 3:06Cy Kellett: was that
- 3:10Jimmy Akin: I mean I'll be polite about it, but I'll say I'm sorry I'd have to research that
- 3:14Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 3:14Cy Kellett: Um
- 3:15Jimmy Akin: but
- 3:16Jimmy Akin: y uh
- 3:16Jimmy Akin: uh
- 3:17Jimmy Akin: the
- 3:17Jimmy Akin: in I mean you don't just walk into
- 3:20Jimmy Akin: any area of life and have a reputation for something.
- 3:23Jimmy Akin: All reputations are earned.
- 3:24Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 3:25Jimmy Akin: So
- 3:26Jimmy Akin: I made a decision
- 3:28Jimmy Akin: very
- 3:28Jimmy Akin: early in my apologetics career that I would take I would answer every question straight.
- 3:33Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 3:34Jimmy Akin: And
- 3:35Jimmy Akin: um
- 3:36Jimmy Akin: so
- 3:36Jimmy Akin: one
- 3:37Jimmy Akin: of the consequences of that is I never look down on any question I'm asked.
- 3:41Jimmy Akin: I'm never
- 3:42Jimmy Akin: uh
- 3:43Jimmy Akin: I never want
- 3:44Jimmy Akin: to make a a questioner feel bad.
- 3:47Jimmy Akin: for ask
- 3:48Jimmy Akin: or embarrassed for asking something.
- 3:50Jimmy Akin: And
- 3:51Jimmy Akin: that's not something every apologist does.
- 3:54Jimmy Akin: I've
- 3:54Jimmy Akin: I've seen apologists who
- 3:56Jimmy Akin: who kind of scoff
- 3:58Jimmy Akin: at questions they're given or don't treat them seriously.
- 4:02Jimmy Akin: And I decided early on I wasn't going to do that.
- 4:05Jimmy Akin: So
- 4:06Jimmy Akin: every question that comes in, no matter what it is, I want to give it the best straight answer I can.
- 4:12Jimmy Akin: And
- 4:13Jimmy Akin: people started noticing that.
- 4:15Jimmy Akin: And that's how I acquired a reputation.
- 4:18Jimmy Akin: And and people
- 4:19Jimmy Akin: decided, well, if it's
- 4:20Jimmy Akin: If it's safe to ask Jimmy a question and he's not gonna make fun of it or scoff at it, then let's ask him what I'm really wondering about, even if it's strange.
- 4:30Cy Kellett: Ghosts or UFOs or something.
- 4:32Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 4:32Jimmy Akin: And
- 4:33Jimmy Akin: and people
- 4:34Jimmy Akin: uh
- 4:34Jimmy Akin: got to you
- 4:35Jimmy Akin: and those are examples of questions that others might scoff at.
- 4:39Jimmy Akin: It's like someone calls in and asks about UFOs, they'll say, Oh, UFOs, you know, and they kinda scoff at it.
- 4:45Jimmy Akin: It makes a person feel bad.
- 4:46Jimmy Akin: I don't want
- 4:47Jimmy Akin: do that.
- 4:49Jimmy Akin: But
- 4:50Jimmy Akin: eventually
- 4:51Jimmy Akin: we noticed that at Catholic Answers Live that people were asking me
- 4:57Jimmy Akin: Weirder questions
- 4:58Jimmy Akin: than uh
- 4:59Jimmy Akin: than
- 5:00Jimmy Akin: other folks got asked and so we decided let's devote a show to it.
- 5:04Cy Kellett: Yeah
- 5:05Cy Kellett: And and uh and hence all the fun, all the years of fun we've had.
- 5:08Cy Kellett: And here uh
- 5:09Cy Kellett: Frankie
- 5:10Cy Kellett: uh is uh I'm
- 5:11Cy Kellett: I think the
- 5:12Cy Kellett: the
- 5:12Cy Kellett: way to pronounce it is Frankie.
- 5:13Cy Kellett: Uh
- 5:14Cy Kellett: the
- 5:15Jimmy Akin: Could be a silent E
- 5:16Jimmy Akin: could be Frank.
- 5:17Cy Kellett: It could be Frank, uh
- 5:18Cy Kellett: with
- 5:18Cy Kellett: what I think of as the quintessential
- 5:21Cy Kellett: weird question.
- 5:22Cy Kellett: This is a great weird question to start with.
- 5:24Cy Kellett: This is uh
- 5:25Cy Kellett: the kind of thing that Jimmy will not scoff at
- 5:28Cy Kellett: And others might not take seriously.
- 5:30Cy Kellett: And I'm actually anxious to hear the answers.
- 5:32Cy Kellett: So uh
- 5:33Cy Kellett: Frank, Frankie, thank you for the question.
- 5:35Cy Kellett: Did the Virgin Mary invent chili?
- 5:38Cy Kellett: I first
- 5:39Cy Kellett: heard of this on an episode of Tasting History with Max Miller.
- 5:43Cy Kellett: He talked about Sister Mary of Agrada.
- 5:46Cy Kellett: who
- 5:46Cy Kellett: was reported
- 5:47Cy Kellett: to be billocating from her convent in Spain
- 5:51Cy Kellett: to the Humanos
- 5:52Cy Kellett: Indians in New
- 5:53Cy Kellett: Spain
- 5:54Cy Kellett: All I've been able to learn about her is from Wiki P
- 5:57Cy Kellett: Wikipedia where it says she is a venerable of the church from the 1600s.
- 6:02Cy Kellett: Apparently
- 6:03Cy Kellett: the Humanos
- 6:04Cy Kellett: Indians reached out to friars
- 6:06Cy Kellett: in the area that
- 6:09Cy Kellett: they had been visited by a lady in blue to seek help
- 6:13Cy Kellett: And according to Max Miller, the lady in blue also gave them
- 6:18Cy Kellett: the recipe for chili.
- 6:20Cy Kellett: According to Wikipedia, Sister Mary also wrote books about the Virgin Mary, so I was thinking
- 6:25Cy Kellett: maybe the Virgin Mary gave Sister Mary the recipe for chili.
- 6:29Cy Kellett: to give to the Indians, it makes my heart warm to think uh uh
- 6:32Cy Kellett: thinking that the Virgin Mary gave us chili
- 6:36Jimmy Akin: And how much your heart warms will depend on how much capsaicin is in the chili.
- 6:41Cy Kellett: Not heart burn, I think.
- 6:43Cy Kellett: I think this might be a different thing.
- 6:45Cy Kellett: Uh
- 6:45Cy Kellett: I get the heart burned.
- 6:47Cy Kellett: Frankie.
- 6:47Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 6:48Jimmy Akin: So
- 6:49Jimmy Akin: um
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: so
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: I
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: there are a few things to say here.
- 6:52Jimmy Akin: First one, for people who may not be familiar, tasting history with Max Miller
- 6:56Jimmy Akin: is a YouTube
- 6:56Jimmy Akin: program, and I've seen it
- 6:58Jimmy Akin: too.
- 6:58Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 6:59Jimmy Akin: there's this
- 7:00Jimmy Akin: guy named Max Miller
- 7:01Jimmy Akin: and he looks up recipes from history and then makes them and talks about the history of the period.
- 7:08Jimmy Akin: when
- 7:08Jimmy Akin: this recipe was in use
- 7:10Jimmy Akin: and then he tries the recipe and
- 7:12Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:12Jimmy Akin: gives you cooking tips
- 7:14Jimmy Akin: and and says what he thinks about the recipe after he tries it.
- 7:18Jimmy Akin: And I've seen that show a few times.
- 7:20Jimmy Akin: I don't recall seeing this episode.
- 7:23Jimmy Akin: But
- 7:24Jimmy Akin: I am familiar with the reports about
- 7:28Jimmy Akin: the
- 7:28Jimmy Akin: Native Americans, and they're native to like New
- 7:31Jimmy Akin: Uh New Mexico.
- 7:33Jimmy Akin: the modern state of New Mexico, uh, who reported being visited by a lady in blue
- 7:38Jimmy Akin: who has been identified as Saint Mary of
- 7:41Jimmy Akin: Agreeda.
- 7:42Jimmy Akin: And
- 7:42Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:43Jimmy Akin: and
- 7:44Jimmy Akin: parts of this
- 7:45Jimmy Akin: account that Frankie
- 7:47Jimmy Akin: Anorino2860 to give his full name
- 7:51Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:51Jimmy Akin: is discussing.
- 7:52Jimmy Akin: Parts of it are true.
- 7:54Jimmy Akin: Um
- 7:55Jimmy Akin: the one part of it that's true is
- 7:58Jimmy Akin: that
- 7:58Jimmy Akin: um
- 7:59Jimmy Akin: some of the Native Americans did
- 8:01Jimmy Akin: approach
- 8:03Jimmy Akin: um
- 8:04Jimmy Akin: Friars, I believe they were Franciscan, and asked for baptism
- 8:09Jimmy Akin: and so forth
- 8:10Jimmy Akin: because the lady in blue had told them
- 8:12Jimmy Akin: that they needed to be baptized.
- 8:14Jimmy Akin: They needed to become Christians.
- 8:16Jimmy Akin: And
- 8:17Jimmy Akin: that part's true.
- 8:18Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 8:19Jimmy Akin: it's also true that Saint Mary of
- 8:22Jimmy Akin: Greita
- 8:22Jimmy Akin: reported
- 8:24Jimmy Akin: bilating.
- 8:25Jimmy Akin: to
- 8:26Jimmy Akin: a far
- 8:26Jimmy Akin: distant location where she told
- 8:29Jimmy Akin: native peoples
- 8:31Jimmy Akin: about
- 8:31Jimmy Akin: the Catholic faith
- 8:33Jimmy Akin: And
- 8:34Jimmy Akin: so you've got these two
- 8:36Jimmy Akin: similar stories on opposite sides of the
- 8:39Jimmy Akin: of the Atlantic Ocean
- 8:41Jimmy Akin: And
- 8:42Jimmy Akin: this was something that got looked into.
- 8:44Jimmy Akin: Now, first thing I'll mention, notice
- 8:47Jimmy Akin: this by
- 8:48Jimmy Akin: location.
- 8:50Jimmy Akin: could
- 8:50Jimmy Akin: also be called an apparition.
- 8:53Jimmy Akin: Normally
- 8:54Jimmy Akin: when we use
- 8:55Jimmy Akin: uh the word apparition, we're thinking about the appearance.
- 8:59Jimmy Akin: That's what apparition means.
- 9:00Jimmy Akin: Something that appears
- 9:02Jimmy Akin: is an apparition.
- 9:04Jimmy Akin: And
- 9:04Jimmy Akin: normally when we use the term apparition, we're thinking about appearances
- 9:09Jimmy Akin: of
- 9:10Jimmy Akin: departed humans, you know, people who are dead, or
- 9:14Jimmy Akin: angels
- 9:15Jimmy Akin: or things like that, but
- 9:17Jimmy Akin: th
- 9:18Jimmy Akin: it is also
- 9:19Jimmy Akin: actually much more commonly reported than reali
- 9:22Jimmy Akin: than they
- 9:23Jimmy Akin: than is commonly realized for there to be apparitions of the living.
- 9:27Jimmy Akin: And that's what would be going on in this situation
- 9:30Jimmy Akin: when if if St.
- 9:32Jimmy Akin: Mary of Agrida was appearing to people in another part of the world, well, she was alive when she was doing that.
- 9:38Jimmy Akin: So this would be an apparition of the living.
- 9:40Jimmy Akin: In fact, there was a major study
- 9:44Jimmy Akin: of
- 9:44Jimmy Akin: apparitions of the living that was done by the British Society for
- 9:49Jimmy Akin: psychical
- 9:50Jimmy Akin: research in the eighteen nineties.
- 9:52Jimmy Akin: And even back then, you know, more than a century ago, they they came up with this big
- 9:57Jimmy Akin: huge Hulk in two volume
- 9:59Jimmy Akin: set
- 10:00Jimmy Akin: that they published of Apparitions of the Living, and it was called Phantasms
- 10:04Jimmy Akin: of the Living.
- 10:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 10:07Jimmy Akin: so
- 10:07Jimmy Akin: this is a known phenomenon
- 10:09Jimmy Akin: and
- 10:10Jimmy Akin: We have to always
- 10:12Jimmy Akin: whenever we have
- 10:13Jimmy Akin: um
- 10:14Jimmy Akin: you know a report
- 10:16Jimmy Akin: of
- 10:16Jimmy Akin: such a thing happening, we need to if we want to know if it's true, we need to investigate it.
- 10:22Jimmy Akin: And
- 10:22Jimmy Akin: in this case
- 10:23Jimmy Akin: we were
- 10:25Jimmy Akin: uh
- 10:25Jimmy Akin: we benefit from the fact that we have reports from both sides of the ocean.
- 10:30Jimmy Akin: If we only had
- 10:31Jimmy Akin: St.
- 10:32Jimmy Akin: Mary Agretta's report
- 10:33Jimmy Akin: or if we only had the Native American report, we wouldn't have any verification.
- 10:39Jimmy Akin: that it actually took place.
- 10:41Jimmy Akin: But we do have these two reports, so what we want to do then is look at the content of the two reports and see if they match.
- 10:49Jimmy Akin: And they do.
- 10:50Jimmy Akin: Um
- 10:51Jimmy Akin: the
- 10:52Jimmy Akin: I haven't looked into
- 10:54Jimmy Akin: all the details myself, but my understanding is that they were looked into by church authorities
- 11:00Jimmy Akin: and they the details did match.
- 11:03Jimmy Akin: And I plan on devoting a future episode of Mysterious World
- 11:07Jimmy Akin: specifically to this, um, to this incident.
- 11:11Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 11:11Jimmy Akin: Ha
- 11:12Jimmy Akin: having said that, we
- 11:13Jimmy Akin: then got the chili.
- 11:15Jimmy Akin: idea.
- 11:16Jimmy Akin: And
- 11:17Jimmy Akin: the
- 11:18Jimmy Akin: and so even though the billocation or apparition of the living is
- 11:22Jimmy Akin: that seems to have an evidential basis, the chili
- 11:26Jimmy Akin: part
- 11:27Jimmy Akin: does not.
- 11:28Jimmy Akin: The chili
- 11:29Jimmy Akin: part seems to be a legend.
- 11:30Jimmy Akin: Now, when
- 11:32Jimmy Akin: um
- 11:33Jimmy Akin: Sister
- 11:33Jimmy Akin: Mary was
- 11:34Jimmy Akin: appearing
- 11:36Jimmy Akin: to the Indians, that was in the sixteen hundreds, and chili didn't develop until later.
- 11:42Jimmy Akin: It's uh
- 11:43Jimmy Akin: it's a North American dish
- 11:46Jimmy Akin: that uh kind of came together through influences from Spain, Mexico, and Texas.
- 11:53Jimmy Akin: And
- 11:54Jimmy Akin: uh
- 11:54Jimmy Akin: and so it looks like that
- 11:57Jimmy Akin: part of
- 11:57Jimmy Akin: of
- 11:58Jimmy Akin: what Frank has
- 11:59Jimmy Akin: or Frankie
- 12:00Jimmy Akin: has
- 12:01Jimmy Akin: uh
- 12:01Jimmy Akin: is wondering about
- 12:03Jimmy Akin: is not historically based.
- 12:05Jimmy Akin: That's a later legend.
- 12:07Jimmy Akin: It is something that you will read about, but that part of it seems to be legendary.
- 12:12Jimmy Akin: Um
- 12:13Jimmy Akin: so it looks like neither
- 12:16Jimmy Akin: the uh
- 12:18Jimmy Akin: that chili
- 12:19Jimmy Akin: was neither invented by Saint Mary Agretta or by the Virgin Mary, uh
- 12:24Jimmy Akin: so far as we know.
- 12:26Jimmy Akin: We don't have any any evidence for that.
- 12:29Jimmy Akin: But we do have evidence about uh
- 12:31Jimmy Akin: Sister Mary Agrida
- 12:33Jimmy Akin: herself.
- 12:34Jimmy Akin: And just recently when I was on a road trip out to California, I was listening to
- 12:40Jimmy Akin: a uh
- 12:41Jimmy Akin: an audiobook by Father Herbert Thurston, who was a Catholic parapsychologist in the early 20th century, and he has a whole chapter.
- 12:49Jimmy Akin: on St.
- 12:50Jimmy Akin: Mary
- 12:50Jimmy Akin: Greta, and I plan
- 12:52Jimmy Akin: on using that chapter, among other resources, as the basis for a future mysterious world episode about
- 12:59Jimmy Akin: her.
- 12:59Cy Kellett: That uh I'm so happy that Frankie
- 13:02Cy Kellett: asked that question, did the Virgin Mary invent chili?
- 13:04Cy Kellett: Because I didn't know the Sister Mary Agrata
- 13:06Cy Kellett: story.
- 13:07Cy Kellett: So even w
- 13:07Cy Kellett: Without a yes to that, which would have been awesome if if the Virgin Mary had invented it, that is a fantastic story to know.
- 13:14Cy Kellett: I can't wait to
- 13:14Cy Kellett: do that on Mysterious World.
- 13:17Jimmy Akin: Yeah, it should be a lot of fun.
- 13:24Jimmy Akin: Yeah, they they compared the reports from both sides of the ocean.
- 13:28Cy Kellett: I gotta see that one.
- 13:30Cy Kellett: All right, Jimmy Akin's our guest.
- 13:31Cy Kellett: It's Weird Questions with Jimmy Akin.
- 13:33Cy Kellett: You never know where these questions will take you.
- 13:35Cy Kellett: And uh lots of great questions to come right after this on Catholic Answers
- 13:38Cy Kellett: Live.
- 13:42Cy Kellett: Jimmy Akin, our guest.
- 13:43Cy Kellett: That music means it's weird questions with Jimmy Akin, which I guess we get to do about once a month, and it's always fun when we get to do it
- 13:50Cy Kellett: And
- 13:50Cy Kellett: Jimmy, I had a follow-up
- 13:52Cy Kellett: that I I
- 13:52Cy Kellett: neglected to ask you before we went to the break.
- 13:54Cy Kellett: While you were talking, I was thinking, okay, this is a
- 13:56Cy Kellett: um
- 13:57Cy Kellett: uh uh
- 13:58Cy Kellett: would you say
- 13:58Cy Kellett: uh apparition of the living or
- 14:00Cy Kellett: uh some people would
- 14:01Cy Kellett: say by-location or whatever.
- 14:03Cy Kellett: But there's a secondary thing here.
- 14:04Cy Kellett: If
- 14:05Cy Kellett: if Sister Mary is in Spain
- 14:07Cy Kellett: and she's speaking with the Humanos
- 14:10Cy Kellett: Indians in Texas or
- 14:12Cy Kellett: or New Mexico.
- 14:14Cy Kellett: This is also an example of speaking in tongues.
- 14:17Cy Kellett: There's a secondary spiritual thing here.
- 14:19Jimmy Akin: Maybe.
- 14:20Cy Kellett: Oh
- 14:21Cy Kellett: man, I thought I had this.
- 14:22Cy Kellett: All right.
- 14:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 14:23Jimmy Akin: so
- 14:24Jimmy Akin: first
- 14:24Jimmy Akin: we we need to clarify our terminology
- 14:27Jimmy Akin: because we need to have a precise definition for speaking in tongues if we're going to evaluate
- 14:32Jimmy Akin: is this that or not.
- 14:34Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 14:35Cy Kellett: Um
- 14:36Jimmy Akin: So the New Testament obviously reports at least one phenomenon that it refers to as speaking in tongues.
- 14:44Jimmy Akin: Um, some people think it's more than one phenomenon in the New
- 14:47Jimmy Akin: Testament, but I don't.
- 14:49Jimmy Akin: I think it's one phenomenon.
- 14:51Jimmy Akin: And
- 14:52Jimmy Akin: Based on the study I've done, I think that uh well, I guess first I should mention what the two phenomena are that people talk about.
- 15:00Jimmy Akin: The first
- 15:01Jimmy Akin: one is
- 15:02Jimmy Akin: speaking in tongues is a real language.
- 15:05Jimmy Akin: So you're that you have not studied.
- 15:08Jimmy Akin: So
- 15:08Jimmy Akin: like I've never studied
- 15:10Jimmy Akin: what's a language I haven't studied?
- 15:13Jimmy Akin: Um
- 15:14Jimmy Akin: I've never studied Berber.
- 15:17Jimmy Akin: Okay, Berber is a language spoken in North Africa.
- 15:20Cy Kellett: I gotta say I'm disappointed.
- 15:21Cy Kellett: I'm
- 15:22Jimmy Akin: Yeah, well I've studied other languages from North Africa, like Egyptian,
- 15:27Jimmy Akin: but I've never studied Berber.
- 15:29Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 15:29Jimmy Akin: And so
- 15:30Jimmy Akin: I've met Berber people.
- 15:31Jimmy Akin: I've just never
- 15:32Jimmy Akin: I've been to North Africa where they speak it.
- 15:34Jimmy Akin: I've just never studied it myself
- 15:37Jimmy Akin: But if
- 15:37Jimmy Akin: God
- 15:38Jimmy Akin: endowed me with the ability to speak Berber, even though I've never studied it, that would be
- 15:44Jimmy Akin: an example of speaking in tongues
- 15:47Jimmy Akin: of the
- 15:49Jimmy Akin: real
- 15:49Jimmy Akin: human language
- 15:50Jimmy Akin: sword.
- 15:52Jimmy Akin: There's another theory, and there's actually several theories, but for our purposes, there's another theory
- 15:58Jimmy Akin: that says
- 15:59Jimmy Akin: like
- 16:00Jimmy Akin: Speaking in tongues is not a real human language.
- 16:03Jimmy Akin: It's a private prayer language that God enables someone to speak.
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: Or
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: maybe it's a an angelic language or something like that.
- 16:12Jimmy Akin: But it's not a real
- 16:14Jimmy Akin: human
- 16:14Jimmy Akin: language.
- 16:15Jimmy Akin: Now
- 16:16Jimmy Akin: having said that, I'm convinced there's just one phenomenon in the New
- 16:21Jimmy Akin: Testament.
- 16:22Jimmy Akin: Speaking in tongues, the way the New Testament uses the term.
- 16:25Jimmy Akin: I'm convinced
- 16:26Jimmy Akin: is real human language.
- 16:28Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 16:29Jimmy Akin: But because there are these two different ideas about what it might be, later
- 16:34Jimmy Akin: people
- 16:35Jimmy Akin: have
- 16:36Jimmy Akin: uh developed some specialized terminology
- 16:39Jimmy Akin: that they use to refer to them.
- 16:43Jimmy Akin: Sometimes
- 16:44Jimmy Akin: speaking in tongues in general
- 16:47Jimmy Akin: ,
- 16:47Jimmy Akin: regardless of which theory you buy, is called glossolalia.
- 16:52Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 16:53Jimmy Akin: glossa
- 16:54Jimmy Akin: is the Greek word for tongue
- 16:56Jimmy Akin: and
- 16:56Jimmy Akin: lalia
- 16:57Jimmy Akin: is
- 16:57Jimmy Akin: or lalea
- 16:59Jimmy Akin: is the word for speaking.
- 17:01Jimmy Akin: So
- 17:01Jimmy Akin: pretty straightforward.
- 17:03Jimmy Akin: Speaking in tongues, glossalia.
- 17:05Jimmy Akin: But some
- 17:06Jimmy Akin: people use the term glossolalia just for the second theory, for the private prayer language theory.
- 17:13Jimmy Akin: So they need
- 17:14Jimmy Akin: another term to refer to the real
- 17:17Jimmy Akin: language theory.
- 17:19Jimmy Akin: Real human language theory.
- 17:22Jimmy Akin: And they call that
- 17:23Jimmy Akin: xenoglossy.
- 17:25Jimmy Akin: Xenos is the Greek word for a stranger or a foreigner.
- 17:30Jimmy Akin: And
- 17:30Jimmy Akin: uh
- 17:31Jimmy Akin: glossa, as we said, is the word for tongue.
- 17:34Jimmy Akin: So if you're doing xenoglossy, you're speaking in a foreign tongue.
- 17:39Jimmy Akin: And so, and that's the term that tends to be used among parapsychologists
- 17:43Jimmy Akin: because there are reports of xenoglossy or speaking in a foreign language you've not studied
- 17:50Jimmy Akin: that uh that crop up.
- 17:52Jimmy Akin: in parapsychological events.
- 17:53Jimmy Akin: And so it's not just Christians who are interested in this, also
- 17:57Jimmy Akin: scientists who study parapsychology are interested in this.
- 18:02Jimmy Akin: And
- 18:03Jimmy Akin: um
- 18:03Jimmy Akin: so
- 18:04Jimmy Akin: would
- 18:05Jimmy Akin: uh
- 18:06Jimmy Akin: Saint Mary
- 18:07Jimmy Akin: Greta
- 18:08Jimmy Akin: be
- 18:09Jimmy Akin: uh
- 18:10Jimmy Akin: engaged in xenoglossy
- 18:12Jimmy Akin: when she communicated with the Indians.
- 18:15Jimmy Akin: Well, maybe I'd have to check and see what was reported, but I don't think it's necessarily the case.
- 18:22Jimmy Akin: Because I can think of a of
- 18:24Jimmy Akin: a couple of other options
- 18:26Jimmy Akin: besides her speaking in their native language.
- 18:29Jimmy Akin: Well, Saint Maryagretta would have known Spanish
- 18:32Jimmy Akin: being from Spain.
- 18:34Jimmy Akin: Wouldn't be modern Spanish, but it'd be Spanish
- 18:37Jimmy Akin: And
- 18:38Jimmy Akin: uh
- 18:38Jimmy Akin: and you know what the Franciscan missionaries also would have spoken?
- 18:42Cy Kellett: Spanish.
- 18:43Cy Kellett: Spanish.
- 18:45Jimmy Akin: And they could have taught the Native Americans how to speak Spanish.
- 18:50Jimmy Akin: So
- 18:50Jimmy Akin: it's possible that St.
- 18:52Jimmy Akin: Maria
- 18:52Jimmy Akin: Greta
- 18:53Jimmy Akin: was talking in Spanish
- 18:56Jimmy Akin: to the Native Americans, at least some of whom understood Spanish.
- 19:01Jimmy Akin: and could translate what she said for others into their native language.
- 19:06Jimmy Akin: So that's one possibility
- 19:09Jimmy Akin: alternate possibility, but it's not the only
- 19:12Jimmy Akin: other
- 19:12Jimmy Akin: possibility.
- 19:13Jimmy Akin: There's another.
- 19:15Jimmy Akin: Because if you appear to someone without your physical body present,
- 19:20Jimmy Akin: and you communicate with them
- 19:22Jimmy Akin: How are you communicating with them?
- 19:25Jimmy Akin: You're not using your physical tongue
- 19:28Jimmy Akin: to do that.
- 19:29Jimmy Akin: You don't have a speech tract.
- 19:31Jimmy Akin: because
- 19:31Jimmy Akin: your body is not here.
- 19:33Jimmy Akin: So
- 19:33Jimmy Akin: any communication you must have is going from your mind
- 19:37Jimmy Akin: to their
- 19:38Jimmy Akin: minds.
- 19:39Jimmy Akin: And that would mean it's telepathy.
- 19:42Jimmy Akin: to use a term that was coined also in the eighteen nineties
- 19:46Jimmy Akin: by uh
- 19:46Jimmy Akin: the Society for Psychical Research.
- 19:49Jimmy Akin: And so
- 19:51Jimmy Akin: t
- 19:51Jimmy Akin: uh
- 19:52Jimmy Akin: telepathy may
- 19:53Jimmy Akin: not involve
- 19:55Jimmy Akin: l
- 19:55Jimmy Akin: actual human language.
- 19:57Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 19:58Jimmy Akin: human thought is expressed,
- 20:01Jimmy Akin: this is a term that's sometimes used by cognitive scientists.
- 20:04Jimmy Akin: It's expressed in what is sometimes called mentalese, the language of thought.
- 20:10Jimmy Akin: And
- 20:11Jimmy Akin: normally
- 20:12Jimmy Akin: It's very hard for us to think
- 20:14Jimmy Akin: in pure mental ease
- 20:16Jimmy Akin: because we associate our thoughts and have since early childhood, we associate our thoughts with language.
- 20:22Jimmy Akin: So it's very hard for us to express
- 20:26Jimmy Akin: thoughts in pure mental ease
- 20:28Jimmy Akin: uh uh
- 20:28Jimmy Akin: when we're just trying to do it you know
- 20:31Jimmy Akin: on our own
- 20:32Jimmy Akin: but it is possible
- 20:34Jimmy Akin: um
- 20:35Jimmy Akin: I was driving once
- 20:37Jimmy Akin: uh
- 20:38Jimmy Akin: down
- 20:39Jimmy Akin: a really
- 20:40Jimmy Akin: s
- 20:41Jimmy Akin: twisty switchback road in California on a mountainside or hillside.
- 20:46Jimmy Akin: And
- 20:47Jimmy Akin: I
- 20:48Jimmy Akin: I was coming around a turn
- 20:50Jimmy Akin: and there was like
- 20:51Jimmy Akin: some
- 20:51Jimmy Akin: um
- 20:52Jimmy Akin: some
- 20:53Jimmy Akin: rocks on the little bitty
- 20:54Jimmy Akin: gravel on the road and I my truck started to slide
- 20:59Jimmy Akin: and I thought
- 21:00Jimmy Akin: if I don't
- 21:02Jimmy Akin: Push the brake right now.
- 21:04Jimmy Akin: I'm gonna slide off this curve
- 21:06Jimmy Akin: and
- 21:07Jimmy Akin: hit some
- 21:08Jimmy Akin: trees or whatever was in front of me.
- 21:11Jimmy Akin: And
- 21:12Jimmy Akin: and so I stepped on the brake, I slowed down enough to take the curve safely.
- 21:17Jimmy Akin: And then
- 21:18Jimmy Akin: I realized
- 21:19Jimmy Akin: I did not use words to think any of that.
- 21:22Cy Kellett: Oh, right.
- 21:23Jimmy Akin: I thought it
- 21:24Jimmy Akin: in pure mental ease.
- 21:26Jimmy Akin: And you can also kick yourself into mental ease, assuming
- 21:30Jimmy Akin: that you don't have aphantasia, which is not
- 21:34Jimmy Akin: a lack of mental images.
- 21:35Jimmy Akin: You could also kick yourself into
- 21:38Jimmy Akin: into mental ease by thinking about mental images.
- 21:42Jimmy Akin: If you start twisting images around in your brain,
- 21:45Jimmy Akin: then
- 21:46Jimmy Akin: you're not using words to do that.
- 21:48Jimmy Akin: You're manipulating images in your brain and that's also mental ease.
- 21:53Jimmy Akin: So
- 21:54Jimmy Akin: um
- 21:55Jimmy Akin: so
- 21:55Jimmy Akin: it's possible that St.
- 21:57Jimmy Akin: Mary Agretta
- 21:59Jimmy Akin: Thought a
- 21:59Jimmy Akin: she may have
- 22:00Jimmy Akin: been thinking with Spanish accompaniment, but underlying that would have been her mental ease.
- 22:06Jimmy Akin: And then
- 22:07Jimmy Akin: that could have been what was transmitted to the Native Americans, and then they interpreted her mental ease in their language.
- 22:14Jimmy Akin: So
- 22:15Jimmy Akin: Mar
- 22:15Jimmy Akin: St.
- 22:16Jimmy Akin: Mary Agretta wouldn't have to be speaking in any
- 22:19Jimmy Akin: other language than Mental
- 22:21Jimmy Akin: Ease, which everybody speaks.
- 22:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 22:24Jimmy Akin: it's possible that this could have been a case of xenoglossy, but it's
- 22:29Jimmy Akin: other options.
- 22:30Jimmy Akin: Two other options.
- 22:31Jimmy Akin: One, she could have been speaking in just Spanish
- 22:33Jimmy Akin: or she could have been communicating telepath
- 22:36Jimmy Akin: just telepathically in mental ease.
- 22:39Cy Kellett: I'm I'm talking to you in mental ease, right?
- 22:41Cy Kellett: I'm trying to
- 22:42Cy Kellett: you
- 22:42Cy Kellett: getting anything?
- 22:43Jimmy Akin: Unfortunately
- 22:43Jimmy Akin: your mic's not picking it up.
- 22:45Jimmy Akin: Lean
- 22:46Jimmy Akin: put your head a little closer.
- 22:47Cy Kellett: I thought I'd give it a shot.
- 22:48Cy Kellett: See if I could do the next question in mental ease.
- 22:50Cy Kellett: Alright, Jimmy Akin, our guest.
- 22:52Cy Kellett: And it's weird questions with Jimmy Akin today.
- 22:55Cy Kellett: And up next is a question from George.
- 22:58Cy Kellett: What evidence do you find that UAPs
- 23:02Cy Kellett: or UFOs are not from outer space?
- 23:06Cy Kellett: but from earthly beings that are far
- 23:08Cy Kellett: advanced compared to us.
- 23:11Jimmy Akin: Okay, so
- 23:12Jimmy Akin: um
- 23:13Jimmy Akin: so
- 23:14Jimmy Akin: this is uh a question asking
- 23:16Jimmy Akin: what evidence is there for
- 23:18Jimmy Akin: that at least I know of
- 23:20Jimmy Akin: that would support the proposition that they're not extraterrestrial but some kind of advanced human race.
- 23:27Jimmy Akin: Um
- 23:28Jimmy Akin: I'm not asked what's the evidence against this.
- 23:31Jimmy Akin: I'm only being asked
- 23:32Jimmy Akin: what's the evidence for it.
- 23:34Jimmy Akin: So that's what I'll give you
- 23:35Jimmy Akin: because I don't have time to cover both sides of the story before the break.
- 23:41Jimmy Akin: So
- 23:42Jimmy Akin: the idea that there's an advanced race here on earth
- 23:46Jimmy Akin: that we don't currently know about
- 23:49Jimmy Akin: is one
- 23:50Jimmy Akin: that actually has a name
- 23:53Jimmy Akin: Um
- 23:53Jimmy Akin: and there have been some
- 23:54Jimmy Akin: some authors who have written about this.
- 23:57Jimmy Akin: The idea is this hidden race
- 24:00Jimmy Akin: uh
- 24:00Jimmy Akin: would be
- 24:01Jimmy Akin: or could be called crypto terrestrials.
- 24:05Jimmy Akin: In Greek, kryptos
- 24:06Jimmy Akin: means hidden
- 24:08Jimmy Akin: So
- 24:08Jimmy Akin: crypto-terrestrials would be a hidden terrestrial race, a
- 24:13Jimmy Akin: hidden race here from Earth.
- 24:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 24:16Jimmy Akin: and
- 24:16Jimmy Akin: it's possible that
- 24:19Jimmy Akin: If there is such a race
- 24:21Jimmy Akin: and
- 24:21Jimmy Akin: how we would not have discovered them is a separate question that's hard to overcome
- 24:26Jimmy Akin: But if it's true that there is a hidden race here on Earth, then they
- 24:31Jimmy Akin: could be responsible for UFOs or UAPs
- 24:35Jimmy Akin: or whatever you want to call them.
- 24:36Jimmy Akin: But
- 24:37Jimmy Akin: but that is not the only option
- 24:40Jimmy Akin: for
- 24:41Jimmy Akin: uh
- 24:42Jimmy Akin: for
- 24:43Jimmy Akin: how
- 24:44Jimmy Akin: uh
- 24:44Jimmy Akin: UAPs could be
- 24:46Jimmy Akin: the product of an advanced human race.
- 24:49Jimmy Akin: There's another possibility
- 24:52Jimmy Akin: which is
- 24:53Jimmy Akin: that
- 24:53Jimmy Akin: the
- 24:54Jimmy Akin: uh
- 24:54Jimmy Akin: the UAPs
- 24:56Jimmy Akin: or their creators
- 24:57Jimmy Akin: come from a different time
- 25:00Jimmy Akin: that is
- 25:01Jimmy Akin: their
- 25:01Jimmy Akin: time
- 25:02Jimmy Akin: travelers
- 25:03Jimmy Akin: or what's sometimes called extra
- 25:05Jimmy Akin: tempestrials, meaning
- 25:07Jimmy Akin: extra means outside.
- 25:09Jimmy Akin: Tempestrial from tempus, which means time, so there would be people from outside our time.
- 25:15Jimmy Akin: And this is
- 25:17Jimmy Akin: also
- 25:17Jimmy Akin: a proposal that's been out there about UAPs.
- 25:21Jimmy Akin: And
- 25:21Jimmy Akin: there is
- 25:22Jimmy Akin: uh
- 25:23Jimmy Akin: some evidence you could s
- 25:24Jimmy Akin: you could cite in support of both of these theories.
- 25:27Jimmy Akin: The first piece of the evidence is how much they look like
- 25:31Jimmy Akin: us.
- 25:32Jimmy Akin: Now, some
- 25:33Jimmy Akin: uh
- 25:33Jimmy Akin: at least
- 25:34Jimmy Akin: are reported to look like us.
- 25:36Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 25:37Jimmy Akin: many
- 25:38Jimmy Akin: uh
- 25:38Jimmy Akin: UFO occupants are reported to actually look
- 25:42Jimmy Akin: human.
- 25:43Jimmy Akin: They
- 25:43Jimmy Akin: the
- 25:44Jimmy Akin: some of them
- 25:45Jimmy Akin: have uh
- 25:45Jimmy Akin: light skin and blonde hair
- 25:47Jimmy Akin: and stuff like that and those are called Nordics.
- 25:50Jimmy Akin: in the UFO community.
- 25:52Jimmy Akin: Well
- 25:52Jimmy Akin: Nordics look human, so maybe they're a crypto-terrestrial race, or maybe they're time
- 25:57Jimmy Akin: travelers.
- 25:58Jimmy Akin: Even the grays
- 26:00Jimmy Akin: that are famous
- 26:02Jimmy Akin: look
- 26:02Jimmy Akin: like
- 26:03Jimmy Akin: a lot
- 26:04Jimmy Akin: like humans.
- 26:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 26:06Jimmy Akin: they've got the same bipedal body structure with two arms and two legs and a head
- 26:11Jimmy Akin: and eyes and nose
- 26:12Jimmy Akin: and, you know, ears and everything.
- 26:15Jimmy Akin: And
- 26:15Jimmy Akin: uh
- 26:16Jimmy Akin: so they look a lot like us.
- 26:17Jimmy Akin: They could be a crypto-terrestrial race
- 26:20Jimmy Akin: or
- 26:20Jimmy Akin: uh
- 26:21Jimmy Akin: they could be time
- 26:22Jimmy Akin: travelers.
- 26:23Jimmy Akin: In fact, there are proposals that
- 26:25Jimmy Akin: there are books that I've I've
- 26:27Jimmy Akin: read
- 26:27Jimmy Akin: That propose
- 26:28Jimmy Akin: they're from a future time
- 26:30Jimmy Akin: and they're a d
- 26:32Jimmy Akin: future evolution of mankind.
- 26:34Jimmy Akin: Because you wouldn't expect someone from a totally other planet to look as much like us as they do.
- 26:40Jimmy Akin: The other aspect is they seem to be able
- 26:43Jimmy Akin: to breathe our air and resist our germs and that's more likely if they're from Earth, either the past or either the present or the future, than if they're from a whole other planet.
- 26:53Jimmy Akin: So there is some evidence one could cite
- 26:56Cy Kellett: Welcome back to Kath Cancers
- 26:59Cy Kellett: Live.
- 27:00Cy Kellett: That music means it's weird questions with Jimmy Akin
- 27:03Cy Kellett: today.
- 27:03Cy Kellett: And
- 27:06Cy Kellett: we've been around.
- 27:06Cy Kellett: We've been to Texas and Spain
- 27:08Cy Kellett: and.
- 27:09Cy Kellett: Possibly visited.
- 27:10Cy Kellett: New
- 27:10Jimmy Akin: Mexico.
- 27:11Cy Kellett: Uh New Mexico.
- 27:12Cy Kellett: Possibly visited with uh
- 27:14Cy Kellett: what do we call them?
- 27:14Cy Kellett: Crypto terrestrials, time travelers, all that.
- 27:17Cy Kellett: Uh now we'll
- 27:18Cy Kellett: let's uh
- 27:18Cy Kellett: do an animal question.
- 27:19Cy Kellett: This one comes from
- 27:21Cy Kellett: Deepica
- 27:22Cy Kellett: 8545-M9P.
- 27:25Jimmy Akin: Got the whole name.
- 27:26Jimmy Akin: Good for you.
- 27:27Cy Kellett: I know, but I'll say Deepica
- 27:29Cy Kellett: from now.
- 27:29Cy Kellett: Uh
- 27:30Cy Kellett: do animals praise God in their own way?
- 27:33Jimmy Akin: Well, there's certainly passages in the Bible that you could uh
- 27:37Jimmy Akin: cite
- 27:38Jimmy Akin: uh
- 27:39Jimmy Akin: in support of that.
- 27:40Jimmy Akin: For example, if you look in uh Psalm 148.
- 27:46Jimmy Akin: The psalmist
- 27:47Jimmy Akin: is writing
- 27:47Jimmy Akin: and he says, Praise the Lord from the earth.
- 27:51Jimmy Akin: You see
- 27:52Jimmy Akin: monsters
- 27:53Jimmy Akin: and all deeps, wild animals
- 27:56Jimmy Akin: and all cattle.
- 27:57Jimmy Akin: creeping things and flying birds.
- 28:00Jimmy Akin: So the psalmist
- 28:01Jimmy Akin: just names several different types of animals.
- 28:05Jimmy Akin: Sea monsters
- 28:06Jimmy Akin: is
- 28:06Jimmy Akin: not an exact translation, but it basically means big sea beast.
- 28:11Jimmy Akin: Um
- 28:12Jimmy Akin: so
- 28:12Jimmy Akin: s
- 28:13Jimmy Akin: you know, sea creatures, wild animals, cattle, which are domesticated animals.
- 28:18Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 28:19Jimmy Akin: and it's more than just cows, like goats and sheep are also considered cattle, the way the term is used historically.
- 28:25Jimmy Akin: Also
- 28:26Jimmy Akin: creeping things, that would be
- 28:28Jimmy Akin: um
- 28:29Jimmy Akin: you know, like lizards
- 28:31Jimmy Akin: and
- 28:32Jimmy Akin: uh
- 28:33Jimmy Akin: and
- 28:33Jimmy Akin: and various creeping insects
- 28:36Jimmy Akin: and
- 28:36Jimmy Akin: and my favorite, one of my favorites, the Gila
- 28:39Jimmy Akin: Monster.
- 28:40Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 28:40Jimmy Akin: which
- 28:41Jimmy Akin: is native to the desert southwest here in America, and also flying birds.
- 28:46Jimmy Akin: And the psalmist
- 28:47Jimmy Akin: exhorts all of these creatures to praise God.
- 28:51Jimmy Akin: So
- 28:52Jimmy Akin: um
- 28:53Jimmy Akin: If they do that, if they heed what the psalmist
- 28:56Jimmy Akin: says, then
- 28:58Jimmy Akin: they would be praising God.
- 29:00Jimmy Akin: Now, would it be in their own way?
- 29:02Jimmy Akin: Well, sure, because they don't speak English.
- 29:05Jimmy Akin: At least, you know, not unless God gives them the ability to have xenoglossy
- 29:11Jimmy Akin: like Balaam's ass.
- 29:14Jimmy Akin: Um
- 29:15Jimmy Akin: there
- 29:15Jimmy Akin: are also other passages.
- 29:17Jimmy Akin: There's quite a number of passages you could appeal to like this.
- 29:20Jimmy Akin: Um
- 29:20Jimmy Akin: there's another psalm that talks about lions roaring for their prey.
- 29:26Jimmy Akin: as if they're praying to God, like the roar is a prayer
- 29:30Jimmy Akin: to God
- 29:31Jimmy Akin: that they'll be able to find prey and eat.
- 29:36Jimmy Akin: So
- 29:36Jimmy Akin: you do have these biblical passages, a lot of them in the Psalms or at least in the prophets
- 29:42Jimmy Akin: ,
- 29:43Jimmy Akin: but
- 29:44Jimmy Akin: there are
- 29:45Jimmy Akin: two cautions.
- 29:46Jimmy Akin: The first one
- 29:47Jimmy Akin: is
- 29:49Jimmy Akin: We
- 29:49Jimmy Akin: don't really have good
- 29:51Jimmy Akin: evidence that animals can think
- 29:54Jimmy Akin: about God
- 29:55Jimmy Akin: or conceptualize God
- 29:57Jimmy Akin: or
- 29:58Jimmy Akin: even
- 29:58Jimmy Akin: use
- 29:59Jimmy Akin: language in the robust way that humans can
- 30:02Jimmy Akin: So
- 30:04Jimmy Akin: it's hard to see how they would praise God if they're not able to conceptualize God.
- 30:10Jimmy Akin: Um
- 30:11Jimmy Akin: and
- 30:12Jimmy Akin: that's one reason for caution.
- 30:14Jimmy Akin: Another reason for caution
- 30:15Jimmy Akin: is
- 30:16Jimmy Akin: based on the genres of the Bible
- 30:18Jimmy Akin: because the psalms
- 30:20Jimmy Akin: are poetry.
- 30:21Jimmy Akin: That's what psalms
- 30:23Jimmy Akin: are, is
- 30:24Jimmy Akin: poetry
- 30:25Jimmy Akin: set to music
- 30:26Jimmy Akin: um
- 30:27Jimmy Akin: and the prophets similarly they use
- 30:29Jimmy Akin: lots of poetry.
- 30:31Jimmy Akin: So you don't typically take poetry literally, at least
- 30:35Jimmy Akin: you can't
- 30:36Jimmy Akin: as an initial assumption
- 30:38Jimmy Akin: assume
- 30:39Jimmy Akin: that lines in poetry are meant to be taken literally.
- 30:42Jimmy Akin: They're meant to do something else.
- 30:44Jimmy Akin: And so
- 30:46Jimmy Akin: uh
- 30:47Jimmy Akin: passages like Psalm 148 saying, Praise the Lord, all these animals
- 30:52Jimmy Akin: It's not clear that the psalmist
- 30:54Jimmy Akin: really expected them, the animals, to do that, and
- 30:58Jimmy Akin: it's not clear that they even have the ability.
- 31:02Jimmy Akin: to do that
- 31:03Jimmy Akin: because they can't conceptualize God.
- 31:05Jimmy Akin: Now animals do have language
- 31:07Jimmy Akin: and they can conceptualize some things and they can conceptualize some things more than we thought they could
- 31:15Jimmy Akin: For example, a lot of people have the idea that animals don't
- 31:19Jimmy Akin: uh
- 31:19Jimmy Akin: for a long time
- 31:20Jimmy Akin: have had the idea that animals don't have the concept of death.
- 31:24Cy Kellett: Oh.
- 31:25Jimmy Akin: But
- 31:26Jimmy Akin: that's not necessarily the case
- 31:28Jimmy Akin: because, you know, one of the things that animals like us are programmed to avoid
- 31:34Jimmy Akin: Death
- 31:35Jimmy Akin: and
- 31:36Jimmy Akin: death
- 31:37Jimmy Akin: is a very common thing in the animal world.
- 31:40Jimmy Akin: In fact, the majority cause of death
- 31:44Jimmy Akin: for
- 31:44Jimmy Akin: animals
- 31:45Jimmy Akin: is
- 31:46Jimmy Akin: other animals
- 31:47Jimmy Akin: And
- 31:48Jimmy Akin: so, you know, as part of the predator-prey cycle, whether you're a prey animal seeking to avoid death
- 31:55Jimmy Akin: or
- 31:57Jimmy Akin: watching
- 31:57Jimmy Akin: your
- 31:58Jimmy Akin: your pack
- 31:59Jimmy Akin: mates or herdmates get slaughtered,
- 32:02Jimmy Akin: you're going to have some experience with it.
- 32:04Jimmy Akin: And if you're a predator that causes death,
- 32:07Jimmy Akin: for other animals, you're gonna have experience with it too.
- 32:10Jimmy Akin: Otherwise you don't eat.
- 32:12Jimmy Akin: So
- 32:13Jimmy Akin: um
- 32:13Jimmy Akin: there's been some recent literature, including a book I've got, arguing that no an
- 32:19Jimmy Akin: uh
- 32:19Jimmy Akin: most animals, at least
- 32:21Jimmy Akin: higher animals like birds and mammals, they understand death just fine.
- 32:26Jimmy Akin: And
- 32:27Jimmy Akin: we've recently begun to
- 32:30Jimmy Akin: decode
- 32:31Jimmy Akin: uh
- 32:31Jimmy Akin: animal languages.
- 32:33Jimmy Akin: uh
- 32:34Jimmy Akin: and understand
- 32:35Jimmy Akin: more about
- 32:36Jimmy Akin: what they're able to conceptualize.
- 32:38Jimmy Akin: Like
- 32:38Jimmy Akin: for example, there's been
- 32:40Jimmy Akin: there have been experiments done
- 32:42Jimmy Akin: on uh prairie dogs
- 32:45Jimmy Akin: and they're they're chirps.
- 32:47Jimmy Akin: They have a kind of chirping language.
- 32:49Jimmy Akin: And
- 32:51Jimmy Akin: we've been able to establish
- 32:54Jimmy Akin: some
- 32:54Jimmy Akin: remarkable facts about prairie dog language and thus their
- 32:59Jimmy Akin: concepts.
- 33:00Jimmy Akin: Um
- 33:01Jimmy Akin: a lot of animals
- 33:03Jimmy Akin: have
- 33:03Jimmy Akin: alarm cries that they give to alert other members of their species when there's something dangerous around, like a predator.
- 33:12Jimmy Akin: But uh
- 33:13Jimmy Akin: prairie dogs go way beyond having a predator
- 33:16Jimmy Akin: cry.
- 33:17Jimmy Akin: when
- 33:17Jimmy Akin: one of them becomes aware of a predator, they can specify what the danger is.
- 33:23Jimmy Akin: So
- 33:24Jimmy Akin: they have like a different cry for an eagle than for a wolf.
- 33:30Jimmy Akin: And
- 33:31Jimmy Akin: we've actually tested them by introducing them to objects they've never seen before, like a big black oval.
- 33:40Jimmy Akin: You know, they
- 33:41Jimmy Akin: got a big black oval, they put it on a little cart, and they drug
- 33:45Jimmy Akin: it through a pr
- 33:45Jimmy Akin: set of prairie
- 33:46Jimmy Akin: dog mounds and then listen to the sounds the prairie dogs would make.
- 33:51Jimmy Akin: And they came up with a new name for the big black oval.
- 33:54Cy Kellett: Really?
- 33:55Jimmy Akin: Yeah, they
- 33:57Jimmy Akin: also
- 33:57Jimmy Akin: can
- 33:58Jimmy Akin: um
- 33:59Jimmy Akin: not only
- 34:00Jimmy Akin: do they have a s a s
- 34:01Jimmy Akin: a call for human, they can describe the human
- 34:05Jimmy Akin: and say
- 34:05Jimmy Akin: like
- 34:06Jimmy Akin: human with a green shirt
- 34:08Cy Kellett: Weird.
- 34:09Cy Kellett: And
- 34:10Cy Kellett: that is weird.
- 34:11Jimmy Akin: So they have a more robust understanding and way to express thought.
- 34:16Jimmy Akin: than we previously realized.
- 34:18Jimmy Akin: Also, um
- 34:19Jimmy Akin: a lot of birds are really intelligent like corvids, like ravens and so forth.
- 34:25Jimmy Akin: They hold grudges
- 34:27Jimmy Akin: against people.
- 34:29Jimmy Akin: And
- 34:30Jimmy Akin: um
- 34:31Jimmy Akin: they can identify individual humans and figure out, okay, that's the person who tormented me five years ago.
- 34:38Jimmy Akin: And they'll like
- 34:39Jimmy Akin: dive
- 34:40Jimmy Akin: bomb that person
- 34:41Jimmy Akin: and stuff.
- 34:43Jimmy Akin: But that doesn't get us, that shows considerable conceptualization.
- 34:48Jimmy Akin: and memory, but it doesn't get us to communication or language, but
- 34:54Jimmy Akin: they can teach
- 34:55Jimmy Akin: they can somehow tell other crows that's a bad person.
- 35:00Jimmy Akin: And
- 35:01Jimmy Akin: so
- 35:01Jimmy Akin: somehow they're communicating that, which might be a form of language.
- 35:05Jimmy Akin: So
- 35:06Jimmy Akin: they're able to do more than we think, but thus far we don't have any evidence that they can actually conceptualize God.
- 35:14Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 35:14Jimmy Akin: So
- 35:15Jimmy Akin: how has
- 35:16Jimmy Akin: this idea of ain't of animals praising God
- 35:19Jimmy Akin: been
- 35:20Jimmy Akin: interpreted
- 35:22Jimmy Akin: in Catholic teaching?
- 35:24Jimmy Akin: Well, there's actually a
- 35:26Jimmy Akin: uh
- 35:26Jimmy Akin: a paragraph in the Catechism of the Catholic Church that addresses this.
- 35:31Jimmy Akin: It's paragraph 2416, if people want to look it up
- 35:35Jimmy Akin: It says, animals are God's creatures.
- 35:39Jimmy Akin: He surrounds them with his
- 35:41Jimmy Akin: providential care.
- 35:42Jimmy Akin: By
- 35:43Jimmy Akin: their mere
- 35:44Jimmy Akin: existence, they bless him
- 35:47Jimmy Akin: and give him
- 35:48Jimmy Akin: glory.
- 35:49Jimmy Akin: So
- 35:50Jimmy Akin: if you want to cash out
- 35:51Jimmy Akin: what are these, you know, praise the Lord, o
- 35:54Jimmy Akin: you
- 35:55Jimmy Akin: wild animals
- 35:56Jimmy Akin: passages mean.
- 35:58Jimmy Akin: One way of conceptualizing it is the one in the catechism that just by existing and displaying the characteristics, the traits that God gave them, that shows
- 36:10Jimmy Akin: God's
- 36:11Jimmy Akin: uh
- 36:11Jimmy Akin: creative
- 36:12Jimmy Akin: power and imagination
- 36:14Jimmy Akin: and
- 36:14Jimmy Akin: so forth, and thus
- 36:16Jimmy Akin: aspects of his
- 36:17Jimmy Akin: greatness, and thus
- 36:18Jimmy Akin: by their very
- 36:20Jimmy Akin: being.
- 36:21Jimmy Akin: they
- 36:21Jimmy Akin: could be understood poetically
- 36:23Jimmy Akin: as blessing God and giving him
- 36:25Jimmy Akin: glory.
- 36:26Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 36:26Cy Kellett: including the Gila
- 36:28Cy Kellett: monsters.
- 36:28Cy Kellett: Uh
- 36:30Jimmy Akin: just
- 36:30Jimmy Akin: just be careful because they're poisonous.
- 36:34Cy Kellett: They got gross mouths, those healer monsters.
- 36:36Cy Kellett: Don't get don't get too close to them.
- 36:37Cy Kellett: Give them space.
- 36:38Cy Kellett: They're called monsters.
- 36:39Cy Kellett: Give them some space.
- 36:40Cy Kellett: Alright, well I'll tell you what.
- 36:41Cy Kellett: Perfect time to take a break.
- 36:42Cy Kellett: More weird questions coming up for Jimmy Akin on Catholic Answers Live
- 36:51Cy Kellett: Uh
- 36:51Cy Kellett: that's uh
- 36:52Cy Kellett: another weird question.
- 36:52Cy Kellett: That's a weird question, music.
- 36:54Cy Kellett: Another weird question for uh Jimmy Akin.
- 36:56Cy Kellett: But first I gotta add
- 36:57Cy Kellett: well I
- 36:58Cy Kellett: said he's uh
- 36:59Cy Kellett: from Mysterious World, thousands and thousands of
- 37:01Cy Kellett: of people, hundreds and hundreds of episodes.
- 37:03Cy Kellett: Mysterious World is
- 37:04Cy Kellett: a huge uh success in the world of podcasting.
- 37:07Cy Kellett: But I never said, Jimmy, uh, what's dropping today?
- 37:10Cy Kellett: Uh
- 37:10Cy Kellett: September, Friday, September 18th.
- 37:12Jimmy Akin: Today
- 37:13Jimmy Akin: I have an episode about veridical
- 37:16Jimmy Akin: NDEs.
- 37:17Jimmy Akin: So people may be familiar with NDEs or near-death
- 37:21Jimmy Akin: experiences.
- 37:22Jimmy Akin: These are cases where someone comes close to dying and maybe even
- 37:27Jimmy Akin: maybe even clinically
- 37:28Jimmy Akin: dies
- 37:29Jimmy Akin: and then they're able to bring the person back
- 37:31Jimmy Akin: and they report having experiences
- 37:34Jimmy Akin: while they were close to or actually dead.
- 37:37Jimmy Akin: These include things like
- 37:40Jimmy Akin: uh
- 37:40Jimmy Akin: passing through a tunnel, um
- 37:43Jimmy Akin: meeting a being of light, seeing your body from outside
- 37:47Jimmy Akin: all kinds of things like that.
- 37:49Jimmy Akin: But there are different kinds of NDEs, and some
- 37:54Jimmy Akin: are particularly interesting
- 37:56Jimmy Akin: because they contain what's called veridical
- 37:59Jimmy Akin: information
- 38:00Jimmy Akin: Vertical information
- 38:02Jimmy Akin: is
- 38:03Jimmy Akin: information
- 38:03Jimmy Akin: that a person did
- 38:05Jimmy Akin: not know beforehand, could
- 38:08Jimmy Akin: not be guessed by random chance, and still turns out to be true.
- 38:13Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 38:14Jimmy Akin: And so if a person comes back with information they didn't know, couldn't guess, and is nevertheless
- 38:21Jimmy Akin: true
- 38:21Jimmy Akin: after that
- 38:22Jimmy Akin: that they got during an NDE, then that's evidence that they
- 38:26Jimmy Akin: really were
- 38:28Jimmy Akin: having a conscious experience that corresponded to reality.
- 38:32Jimmy Akin: It wasn't just like a hallucination they had once their heart restarted or something.
- 38:37Jimmy Akin: It was a real experience.
- 38:40Jimmy Akin: And so
- 38:40Jimmy Akin: parapsychologists and those
- 38:43Jimmy Akin: who study NDEs
- 38:45Jimmy Akin: are always on the lookout for NDEs that contain vertical information.
- 38:50Jimmy Akin: And
- 38:51Jimmy Akin: they found a lot of them.
- 38:53Jimmy Akin: Um
- 38:53Jimmy Akin: there's a whole book called The Self
- 38:56Jimmy Akin: Does Not Die
- 38:57Jimmy Akin: by a group of researchers.
- 38:59Jimmy Akin: It contains more than a hundred
- 39:01Jimmy Akin: Cases of vertical NDEs, and not just vertical NDEs, but one where someone else
- 39:07Jimmy Akin: besides the person who died
- 39:10Jimmy Akin: Was able to vouch for the experience.
- 39:13Jimmy Akin: Like a a doctor or someone.
- 39:15Jimmy Akin: So you've got independent verification
- 39:17Jimmy Akin: of the vertical information.
- 39:19Jimmy Akin: Like, yes, I was talking in the hallway and that's what I said and then the person came back and reported it
- 39:25Jimmy Akin: accurately
- 39:26Jimmy Akin: what I said in the hallway where they couldn't have heard even if they were alive.
- 39:30Jimmy Akin: Um
- 39:31Jimmy Akin: and so
- 39:32Jimmy Akin: In uh
- 39:33Jimmy Akin: in this Friday's episode of Mysterious World, I look at a whole bunch of different cases of veridical NDEs.
- 39:40Jimmy Akin: I put them into categories.
- 39:42Jimmy Akin: um
- 39:43Jimmy Akin: but they're
- 39:43Jimmy Akin: the
- 39:44Jimmy Akin: they're a kind of of near-death
- 39:46Jimmy Akin: experience that contains extra evidence
- 39:50Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 39:51Jimmy Akin: that
- 39:51Jimmy Akin: something real
- 39:52Jimmy Akin: is going on here.
- 39:54Jimmy Akin: It's not just hallucinations.
- 39:56Jimmy Akin: Something paranormal is definitely happening.
- 39:59Cy Kellett: Oh
- 39:59Cy Kellett: man.
- 40:00Cy Kellett: All right.
- 40:00Cy Kellett: Check it out.
- 40:01Cy Kellett: Uh
- 40:01Cy Kellett: Mysterious.
- 40:02Cy Kellett: fm.
- 40:03Cy Kellett: Wherever you get your podcast, just check for Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World or check it out on Jimmy's
- 40:08Cy Kellett: YouTube
- 40:08Cy Kellett: channel.
- 40:09Cy Kellett: Look for Jimmy Akin
- 40:10Cy Kellett: on YouTube.
- 40:11Cy Kellett: Uh
- 40:12Cy Kellett: this next question comes from
- 40:13Cy Kellett: uh
- 40:14Cy Kellett: r
- 40:14Cy Kellett: Robert uh
- 40:15Cy Kellett: cogshall.
- 40:17Cy Kellett: Three
- 40:18Cy Kellett: z
- 40:18Cy Kellett: d
- 40:18Cy Kellett: what, do you think I'm getting that wrong?
- 40:20Jimmy Akin: Yeah, well it could be
- 40:21Jimmy Akin: I don't know, it could be uh
- 40:22Jimmy Akin: cogshall
- 40:23Jimmy Akin: or coggoshall.
- 40:25Jimmy Akin: Cogshall.
- 40:27Jimmy Akin: I could be a number of those.
- 40:29Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 40:29Cy Kellett: because
- 40:29Cy Kellett: I I remember um
- 40:31Cy Kellett: uh
- 40:32Cy Kellett: uh
- 40:33Cy Kellett: Cogshall Cogs, uh
- 40:34Cy Kellett: wa
- 40:35Cy Kellett: oh wait, no, that was Cogswell Cogs.
- 40:37Cy Kellett: I apologize.
- 40:38Jimmy Akin: Yeah, Cogswell Cogs is a different guy.
- 40:40Cy Kellett: It's basically Spockets
- 40:42Jimmy Akin: Yes,
- 40:42Jimmy Akin: basically sprockets.
- 40:44Jimmy Akin: Um
- 40:45Jimmy Akin: the
- 40:46Jimmy Akin: uh but I saw that
- 40:47Jimmy Akin: R
- 40:48Jimmy Akin: Cogasall
- 40:49Jimmy Akin: Cogashall and I immediately thought of Ralph Cogashall.
- 40:53Cy Kellett: Oh I don't know of that.
- 40:54Cy Kellett: Who's Ralph Cogeshaw?
- 40:55Jimmy Akin: Yeah, he he was an English historian that lived in the 1200s.
- 40:58Cy Kellett: Oh.
- 40:59Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 40:59Cy Kellett: Oh, I missed that.
- 41:00Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 41:01Cy Kellett: Uh
- 41:01Cy Kellett: all right, so I'm
- 41:02Cy Kellett: I'll say
- 41:02Cy Kellett: Robert Cogashaw.
- 41:05Cy Kellett: 3071 is who it is.
- 41:07Cy Kellett: Sorry, Jimmy.
- 41:07Cy Kellett: Go ahead.
- 41:08Jimmy Akin: Oh no, I was just saying I I run across uh references to things that Ralph Coggenshaw mentioned and wrote about and stuff like that from time to time.
- 41:17Cy Kellett: I
- 41:18Cy Kellett: uh you know
- 41:19Cy Kellett: SpaceX
- 41:19Cy Kellett: is this huge corporation now.
- 41:21Cy Kellett: I really think it should have been named Space Least Rockets.
- 41:24Cy Kellett: I think that would have been so awesome if they had just named
- 41:26Cy Kellett: Space Least Rockets.
- 41:35Cy Kellett: Are sightings of cryptids, UFOs, ghosts, etc.
- 41:39Cy Kellett: all thought projections
- 41:41Cy Kellett: or real?
- 41:44Jimmy Akin: Okay, so the first thing I need to do is talk about what a
- 41:47Jimmy Akin: what Robert is calling a uh thought projection.
- 41:51Jimmy Akin: I assume what he's referring to is what's sometimes called a thought
- 41:55Jimmy Akin: form.
- 41:56Jimmy Akin: This is an idea that that
- 41:58Jimmy Akin: has been talked about in
- 42:00Jimmy Akin: East Asia for some
- 42:03Jimmy Akin: time.
- 42:04Jimmy Akin: For example, in Tibetan Buddhism, they'll sometimes talk about
- 42:09Jimmy Akin: uh
- 42:09Jimmy Akin: they
- 42:09Jimmy Akin: use different term.
- 42:10Jimmy Akin: They call them tulpas.
- 42:12Jimmy Akin: The idea is
- 42:14Jimmy Akin: that a living person
- 42:17Jimmy Akin: could
- 42:17Jimmy Akin: uh
- 42:18Jimmy Akin: concentrate their mind in such a way
- 42:21Jimmy Akin: as to
- 42:22Jimmy Akin: kind of
- 42:23Jimmy Akin: build
- 42:25Jimmy Akin: an
- 42:26Jimmy Akin: entity
- 42:26Jimmy Akin: that
- 42:27Jimmy Akin: has
- 42:28Jimmy Akin: a kind of dependent reality.
- 42:31Jimmy Akin: It's not independent
- 42:33Jimmy Akin: of the person
- 42:34Jimmy Akin: who
- 42:34Jimmy Akin: who came up with it.
- 42:36Jimmy Akin: but
- 42:36Jimmy Akin: it's at least able to
- 42:39Jimmy Akin: exist
- 42:40Jimmy Akin: um
- 42:41Jimmy Akin: for a time at least, even if the person's not
- 42:45Jimmy Akin: consciously thinking about it.
- 42:47Jimmy Akin: And so
- 42:48Jimmy Akin: um
- 42:49Jimmy Akin: so
- 42:49Jimmy Akin: you could create a tulpa
- 42:52Jimmy Akin: of
- 42:52Jimmy Akin: maybe
- 42:53Jimmy Akin: yourself
- 42:54Jimmy Akin: and have a kind of double
- 42:56Jimmy Akin: of yourself that other people might see
- 43:00Jimmy Akin: um
- 43:01Jimmy Akin: and
- 43:01Jimmy Akin: maybe photograph or drive around in a car with
- 43:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 43:06Jimmy Akin: and
- 43:07Jimmy Akin: then
- 43:08Jimmy Akin: in the
- 43:09Jimmy Akin: late 1800s, uh
- 43:12Jimmy Akin: the religious movement of theosophy
- 43:15Jimmy Akin: which
- 43:15Jimmy Akin: was founded by a Russian immigrant named Helena Blavatsky or Madame Blavatsky.
- 43:22Jimmy Akin: Um
- 43:22Jimmy Akin: theosophy ended up popularizing this idea in the West
- 43:25Jimmy Akin: where the
- 43:26Jimmy Akin: and
- 43:26Jimmy Akin: it was also some of Blavatsky's followers that really popularized it.
- 43:31Jimmy Akin: But um
- 43:32Jimmy Akin: they popularized this idea in the West
- 43:34Jimmy Akin: only to make it more
- 43:35Jimmy Akin: transparent.
- 43:37Jimmy Akin: To Westerners, what they were talking about, they didn't call them tulpas.
- 43:41Jimmy Akin: They called them thought forms.
- 43:43Jimmy Akin: And so the idea is that at least under certain circumstances, your thoughts could
- 43:50Jimmy Akin: give rise to a semi-independent entity.
- 43:55Jimmy Akin: And so what Robert is asking is, well, could cryptid sightings
- 43:59Jimmy Akin: involve thought forms, or could UFOs
- 44:02Jimmy Akin: be thought forms, or could ghosts
- 44:06Jimmy Akin: be thought forms?
- 44:07Jimmy Akin: Um
- 44:08Jimmy Akin: and
- 44:09Jimmy Akin: well, uh
- 44:11Jimmy Akin: he asks, are
- 44:12Jimmy Akin: they?
- 44:13Jimmy Akin: Well, it
- 44:14Jimmy Akin: the idea that they might be
- 44:16Jimmy Akin: is certainly something that's been talked about.
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: Um
- 44:20Jimmy Akin: there
- 44:21Jimmy Akin: are
- 44:22Jimmy Akin: So
- 44:22Jimmy Akin: if ghosts are really
- 44:24Jimmy Akin: the survival of departed human souls, which I think they are, but
- 44:30Jimmy Akin: at least the ones that, you know, aren't
- 44:32Jimmy Akin: mistakes, you know, like someone hears
- 44:34Jimmy Akin: a noise and they think it's a ghost, but it's really just water
- 44:38Jimmy Akin: bubbles
- 44:39Jimmy Akin: bumping around in their water pipes or something.
- 44:42Jimmy Akin: Well that's a mistaken interpretation.
- 44:44Jimmy Akin: But I think
- 44:45Jimmy Akin: that
- 44:46Jimmy Akin: paranormal ghosts are departed human spirits, but there have been
- 44:51Jimmy Akin: non-survival interpretations
- 44:54Jimmy Akin: of
- 44:55Jimmy Akin: of
- 44:55Jimmy Akin: ghosts
- 44:56Jimmy Akin: and
- 44:57Jimmy Akin: where they're not human spirits.
- 44:59Jimmy Akin: And well, hypothetically they could be a thought form.
- 45:02Jimmy Akin: Maybe
- 45:03Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 45:04Jimmy Akin: maybe you've just lost your
- 45:06Jimmy Akin: your daughter, let's say, God forbid.
- 45:09Jimmy Akin: But let's suppose someone's lost their daughter.
- 45:11Jimmy Akin: and
- 45:12Jimmy Akin: they
- 45:13Jimmy Akin: really want
- 45:13Jimmy Akin: their daughter to be alive in the afterlife and they think about their daughter
- 45:18Jimmy Akin: and they think about their daughter
- 45:19Jimmy Akin: and maybe their thoughts congeal
- 45:22Jimmy Akin: and come up with a thought form of their daughter
- 45:25Jimmy Akin: who who
- 45:26Jimmy Akin: who
- 45:26Jimmy Akin: acts like and looks like
- 45:28Jimmy Akin: and
- 45:29Jimmy Akin: their daughter, so that they can have the
- 45:32Jimmy Akin: to reinforce their belief that their daughter really survived death.
- 45:36Jimmy Akin: So
- 45:37Jimmy Akin: this would be a non survival
- 45:39Jimmy Akin: the
- 45:40Jimmy Akin: daughter
- 45:40Jimmy Akin: didn't really survive, uh, at least, you know, on this scenario, but the daughter seems to survive because there's a thought form.
- 45:50Jimmy Akin: Similarly, uh
- 45:51Jimmy Akin: UFOs
- 45:53Jimmy Akin: are
- 45:53Jimmy Akin: a
- 45:54Jimmy Akin: sometimes they've been
- 45:55Jimmy Akin: they're a popular idea in culture.
- 45:58Jimmy Akin: Um
- 45:59Jimmy Akin: they
- 45:59Jimmy Akin: 've sometimes been uh called a modern myth.
- 46:03Jimmy Akin: So
- 46:03Jimmy Akin: lots of people believe in him
- 46:05Jimmy Akin: and maybe the thoughts of all those people
- 46:08Jimmy Akin: could give rise to independent entities as thought forms that
- 46:13Jimmy Akin: look like flying saucers or whatever
- 46:16Jimmy Akin: and fly around
- 46:17Jimmy Akin: and
- 46:18Jimmy Akin: maybe even
- 46:19Jimmy Akin: aliens, you know, at times.
- 46:21Jimmy Akin: Um
- 46:22Jimmy Akin: so that's been proposed too.
- 46:23Jimmy Akin: In fact that's one of the major theories in ufology.
- 46:28Jimmy Akin: for
- 46:28Jimmy Akin: what
- 46:29Jimmy Akin: UFOs
- 46:30Jimmy Akin: could be
- 46:31Jimmy Akin: if they're not extraterrestrial.
- 46:33Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 46:34Jimmy Akin: similarly, lots of people believe in Bigfoot and other cryptids, so maybe all of their thoughts could kind of congeal and give rise to
- 46:42Jimmy Akin: cryptid sightings like a Bigfoot or whatever.
- 46:46Jimmy Akin: So
- 46:46Jimmy Akin: these have all been proposed, but what Robert's asking is
- 46:50Jimmy Akin: are they
- 46:52Jimmy Akin: Are these reports of thought forms
- 46:55Jimmy Akin: or are the
- 46:56Jimmy Akin: or projections
- 46:57Jimmy Akin: he called
- 46:57Jimmy Akin: calls them
- 46:59Jimmy Akin: or are they real?
- 47:00Jimmy Akin: And the answer is
- 47:02Jimmy Akin: I don't know.
- 47:03Jimmy Akin: I can't I can't say for sure.
- 47:06Jimmy Akin: Um
- 47:07Jimmy Akin: the
- 47:07Jimmy Akin: uh
- 47:08Jimmy Akin: uh
- 47:08Jimmy Akin: my suspicion is
- 47:11Jimmy Akin: that
- 47:11Jimmy Akin: uh
- 47:12Jimmy Akin: ghosts are real
- 47:14Jimmy Akin: Now, I can't eliminate that there might be some ghosts that are thought forms, but I think we've got pretty good evidence, including from things like vertical near-death
- 47:23Jimmy Akin: experiences, that
- 47:26Jimmy Akin: the human soul really does survive death.
- 47:28Jimmy Akin: And so I
- 47:30Jimmy Akin: I
- 47:30Jimmy Akin: my starting assumption for ghosts is going to be they're not thought forms.
- 47:34Jimmy Akin: They're real.
- 47:35Jimmy Akin: At least some of them
- 47:37Jimmy Akin: are.
- 47:37Jimmy Akin: Um
- 47:38Jimmy Akin: with
- 47:38Jimmy Akin: UFOs, they also leave physical traces.
- 47:42Jimmy Akin: These are what um
- 47:44Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 47:44Jimmy Akin: Jay Allen Heinek
- 47:46Jimmy Akin: called uh close encounters of the second kind
- 47:49Jimmy Akin: where the UFO has an impact on its environment, like l
- 47:53Jimmy Akin: mark
- 47:54Jimmy Akin: depressions in the ground from landing struts
- 47:57Jimmy Akin: or
- 47:58Jimmy Akin: vegetation that got bent or set on fire by the exhaust from the UFO.
- 48:04Jimmy Akin: There are these
- 48:05Jimmy Akin: uh
- 48:05Jimmy Akin: CE2s, close encounters of the second kind.
- 48:09Jimmy Akin: where
- 48:09Jimmy Akin: there are r uh i effects on the environment
- 48:12Jimmy Akin: and while a thought form
- 48:13Jimmy Akin: might be able to do that
- 48:15Jimmy Akin: it's
- 48:16Jimmy Akin: more natively consistent with a physical object
- 48:20Jimmy Akin: doing that.
- 48:21Jimmy Akin: When it comes to cryptids, same thing.
- 48:25Jimmy Akin: There are reports of
- 48:27Jimmy Akin: cryptids like Bigfoot
- 48:29Jimmy Akin: having an impact on the environment, sometimes leaving behind hair.
- 48:33Jimmy Akin: or scat, or bending tree branches, or throwing stones.
- 48:39Jimmy Akin: And
- 48:39Jimmy Akin: while I can't rule out that a thought form might be able to do those things, they're also consistent with a physical creature
- 48:47Jimmy Akin: doing those things.
- 48:49Jimmy Akin: And
- 48:50Jimmy Akin: the only way to settle
- 48:52Jimmy Akin: to ultimately settle it would be to get some thought forms and experiment on them.
- 48:57Jimmy Akin: And nobody's been able to do that.
- 49:00Jimmy Akin: So
- 49:00Jimmy Akin: we can't find out what they
- 49:02Jimmy Akin: what they would be able to do, and we can't even verify that they exist.
- 49:08Jimmy Akin: So
- 49:09Jimmy Akin: y
- 49:09Jimmy Akin: is it possible that all these things are thought forms?
- 49:12Jimmy Akin: Yeah, but
- 49:14Jimmy Akin: um
- 49:15Jimmy Akin: but that's
- 49:16Jimmy Akin: but if we just say, oh well that's what they are
- 49:19Jimmy Akin: w
- 49:19Jimmy Akin: we're kind of explaining one unknown in terms of another unknown and I don't even know that thought forms are real.
- 49:26Jimmy Akin: So I'd say it's a possibility, but I don't have evidence that that's what they are.
- 49:32Jimmy Akin: And
- 49:33Jimmy Akin: my default assumption is if it looks like a physical being and walks like a physical being and quacks like a physical being,
- 49:41Jimmy Akin: Or if it's a ghost, which, you know, we have other evidence for human survival, I'm gonna assume it's real until I get evidence otherwise.
- 49:50Cy Kellett: Well uh
- 49:50Cy Kellett: you know,
- 49:51Cy Kellett: cause you invest
- 49:52Cy Kellett: you're uh you know, an investigator of these things.
- 49:54Cy Kellett: If somebody
- 49:55Cy Kellett: like you talked about the go
- 49:56Cy Kellett: of course there's l lots of
- 49:57Cy Kellett: times when we m we misinterpret our environment.
- 50:00Cy Kellett: That's just
- 50:00Cy Kellett: gonna be a given.
- 50:01Cy Kellett: So you
- 50:02Cy Kellett: uh
- 50:02Cy Kellett: But that doesn't say whether or not there's ghosts or not.
- 50:05Cy Kellett: So
- 50:05Cy Kellett: somebody says to you, Jimmy, I think I saw a ghost.
- 50:08Cy Kellett: What are the questions you want to ask them?
- 50:10Cy Kellett: Like what are you what are the things you want to say?
- 50:12Cy Kellett: about that.
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: Well
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: the first thing is tell me what happened.
- 50:15Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 50:16Cy Kellett: Um
- 50:17Jimmy Akin: and
- 50:18Jimmy Akin: and
- 50:18Jimmy Akin: I would then want to look at their environment and see
- 50:21Jimmy Akin: are there factors in the environment
- 50:23Jimmy Akin: like
- 50:24Jimmy Akin: water pipes that have bubbles in them that could, you know, explain the different aspects of their experience.
- 50:31Jimmy Akin: But basically
- 50:32Jimmy Akin: what you do is
- 50:33Jimmy Akin: you
- 50:34Jimmy Akin: uh
- 50:34Jimmy Akin: you ask initial questions, you get complete descriptions of the phenomena that are occurring
- 50:39Jimmy Akin: occurring, then
- 50:40Jimmy Akin: you make a list
- 50:42Jimmy Akin: of all
- 50:43Jimmy Akin: the possible explanations
- 50:45Jimmy Akin: for what's reported, starting with the normal, natural explanations
- 50:52Jimmy Akin: because
- 50:52Jimmy Akin: normal phenomena are more common than paranormal phenomena, then you go down the list and see which of the explanations you can eliminate.
- 51:02Jimmy Akin: And if you can eliminate all the natural explanations, that gives you an uh
- 51:07Jimmy Akin: evidence that it's a paranormal explanation in this case.
- 51:10Jimmy Akin: So that's the general process.
- 51:17Cy Kellett: Church does the same thing when it encounters an apparition or something, but I couldn't.
- 51:20Jimmy Akin: Or miracles.
- 51:21Jimmy Akin: It does.
- 51:21Cy Kellett: Roughly that.
- 51:22Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 51:23Cy Kellett: Jimmy Akin, our guest.
- 51:25Cy Kellett: It's weird questions.
- 51:26Cy Kellett: So much weirdness to come.
- 51:30Dom Bettinelli: We'd like to take a moment to thank our patrons who make this show possible, including Deacon Gregory W.
- 51:36Dom Bettinelli: John
- 51:37Dom Bettinelli: S.
- 51:37Dom Bettinelli: Hans G, Joey
- 51:39Dom Bettinelli: C, and Anthony M.
- 51:41Dom Bettinelli: Their generous donations at givemysterious.
- 51:44Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 51:44Dom Bettinelli: make it possible for us to continue Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World and all the shows at StarQuest
- 51:50Dom Bettinelli: More than 90%
- 51:51Dom Bettinelli: of our financial support comes from individual donors like you, and you can join them by visiting givemysterious.
- 51:58Dom Bettinelli: fm.
- 51:59Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is also brought to you by Ms.
- 52:03Dom Bettinelli: D
- 52:04Dom Bettinelli: 's Honeybees, a small
- 52:06Dom Bettinelli: family-operated honey company that specializes in making delicious
- 52:10Dom Bettinelli: all-naturally flavored honeys
- 52:12Dom Bettinelli: and loose-leaf
- 52:13Dom Bettinelli: teas.
- 52:13Dom Bettinelli: With sweet options like chocolate, salted caramel and lemon, or savory
- 52:18Dom Bettinelli: like garlic jalapeno, ginger honey, they have something for everyone.
- 52:23Dom Bettinelli: A portion of Miss
- 52:24Dom Bettinelli: D
- 52:24Dom Bettinelli: 's Honeybee's proceeds help
- 52:26Dom Bettinelli: fund educational and housing programs for the poor in a small town in Mexico.
- 52:31Dom Bettinelli: Taste something sweet and do some good.
- 52:34Dom Bettinelli: Visit misdeeshoneybees.
- 52:36Dom Bettinelli: com and use the discount code MISTERIOUS
- 52:40Dom Bettinelli: for 20%
- 52:41Dom Bettinelli: off your first order
- 52:43Dom Bettinelli: And
- 52:43Dom Bettinelli: by
- 52:44Dom Bettinelli: Father Dwight Longnecker.
- 52:46Dom Bettinelli: Are you inspired by sharp, witty writing about faith and culture?
- 52:50Dom Bettinelli: Does imaginative, thought-provoking content help you see the world, the church, and yourself with fresh vision?
- 52:57Dom Bettinelli: Popular convert, Catholic priest and author Father Dwight Longnecker, writes daily at his Substack and at his award-winning website, Standing on My Head
- 53:05Dom Bettinelli: where
- 53:06Dom Bettinelli: you can read answers, apologetics, and explorations of the mysteries of this world and the next.
- 53:12Dom Bettinelli: Read his blog, get his new book, Bloodshed
- 53:14Dom Bettinelli: in Blessing, and be in touch at DwightLongnecker.
- 53:18Dom Bettinelli: com
- 53:30Cy Kellett: Welcome back, Catholic Dancers
- 53:33Cy Kellett: Live, more
- 53:33Cy Kellett: of that music.
- 53:34Cy Kellett: means more fun with Jimmy Akin.
- 53:36Cy Kellett: It's weird questions
- 53:37Cy Kellett: with Jimmy Akin
- 53:39Cy Kellett: uh today on Kathy
- 53:40Cy Kellett: Answers
- 53:41Cy Kellett: Live and people love to send Jimmy uh their weird questions.
- 53:44Cy Kellett: Sometimes they send us stuff send them to us and we we get them to Jimmy.
- 53:47Cy Kellett: Jimmy also has
- 53:48Cy Kellett: Lots of other ways people stay in touch with them.
- 53:50Cy Kellett: But if you got a weird question, get it to one of us
- 53:52Cy Kellett: and uh we'll we'll
- 53:54Cy Kellett: uh
- 53:54Cy Kellett: get it on the list of weird questions to ask.
- 53:59Jimmy Akin: By the way, Cy.
- 54:00Cy Kellett: Yes.
- 54:01Cy Kellett: Um
- 54:02Jimmy Akin: so last hour we were talking about uh
- 54:05Jimmy Akin: how to pronounce a particular name.
- 54:07Cy Kellett: Oh yeah
- 54:08Jimmy Akin: Because we like to pronounce names correctly.
- 54:11Jimmy Akin: And we had a questioner named some
- 54:13Jimmy Akin: whose name was
- 54:15Jimmy Akin: Robert, and then the word we weren't sure how to pronounce.
- 54:20Jimmy Akin: Which might have been
- 54:24Jimmy Akin: cogishall
- 54:25Jimmy Akin: or a number of variants we experimented with.
- 54:28Jimmy Akin: So during the break, I looked up, I mentioned that
- 54:31Jimmy Akin: um
- 54:32Jimmy Akin: that
- 54:33Jimmy Akin: uh
- 54:34Jimmy Akin: uh uh
- 54:35Jimmy Akin: i
- 54:35Jimmy Akin: the name reminded me of the
- 54:38Jimmy Akin: uh
- 54:38Jimmy Akin: 12th
- 54:39Jimmy Akin: s
- 54:39Jimmy Akin: or
- 54:40Jimmy Akin: thirteenth
- 54:40Jimmy Akin: century
- 54:41Jimmy Akin: British monk and historian
- 54:43Jimmy Akin: Ralph
- 54:45Jimmy Akin: of
- 54:45Jimmy Akin: Kagashall
- 54:47Jimmy Akin: or however it's pronounced.
- 54:48Jimmy Akin: So I looked up how to pronounce it.
- 54:50Jimmy Akin: And according to what I was able to find, there are two
- 54:55Jimmy Akin: modern English pronunciations
- 54:58Jimmy Akin: in England.
- 54:59Jimmy Akin: for this name.
- 55:01Jimmy Akin: One of them is it's pronounced Cogishol.
- 55:05Cy Kellett: Okay.
- 55:06Jimmy Akin: The other is it's pronounced Coxol.
- 55:09Cy Kellett: Oh, I wouldn't not gotta
- 55:10Cy Kellett: either of those.
- 55:11Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 55:12Jimmy Akin: Also there's uh
- 55:14Jimmy Akin: there's
- 55:15Jimmy Akin: there's an American English pronunciation
- 55:18Jimmy Akin: which is
- 55:19Jimmy Akin: cogishole, different than cogishole
- 55:22Jimmy Akin: the British pronunciation.
- 55:24Jimmy Akin: So
- 55:25Jimmy Akin: those are some of the options of
- 55:28Jimmy Akin: how to pronounce that last name.
- 55:30Jimmy Akin: I don't know if Robert pronounces it that way.
- 55:33Jimmy Akin: Also,
- 55:33Jimmy Akin: I have to say
- 55:34Jimmy Akin: with the historian that I'm familiar with, Ralph of Coxall, I'll just say it that way because it's easy.
- 55:41Jimmy Akin: Um, I'm not sure how he pronounced his first name either, because the name Ralph
- 55:46Jimmy Akin: R-A-L-P-H
- 55:49Jimmy Akin: can
- 55:50Jimmy Akin: is sometimes pronounced
- 55:51Jimmy Akin: wrafe.
- 55:52Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 55:52Cy Kellett: So
- 55:53Jimmy Akin: it's like the L
- 55:54Jimmy Akin: drops out.
- 55:55Jimmy Akin: And you see an example of that in the Gilbert and Sullivan operetta, The Pirates of Penophore uh not
- 56:01Jimmy Akin: uh sorry, HMS Penophore, not the Pirates of Penzance.
- 56:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 56:06Jimmy Akin: But
- 56:06Jimmy Akin: uh
- 56:07Jimmy Akin: but in
- 56:08Jimmy Akin: Pirate
- 56:09Jimmy Akin: in the HMS Pentafor, uh
- 56:11Jimmy Akin: one of our main characters is a sailor.
- 56:14Jimmy Akin: You'd say it as an American, his
- 56:16Jimmy Akin: name is Ralph Rackstraw.
- 56:19Jimmy Akin: But if you watch performances, they use British pronunciation and often call him Rafe.
- 56:25Jimmy Akin: Rackstraw.
- 56:27Jimmy Akin: And I actually knew a rafe
- 56:28Jimmy Akin: uh growing up, but he
- 56:30Jimmy Akin: his name was spelled without the L
- 56:33Jimmy Akin: So
- 56:34Jimmy Akin: um
- 56:34Jimmy Akin: there's some
- 56:36Jimmy Akin: variation in all this.
- 56:37Cy Kellett: I know that that's uh that's uh like that's real, but it it always feels fake to me.
- 56:42Cy Kellett: Like, oh
- 56:42Cy Kellett: really I gotta call you Rafe?
- 56:44Cy Kellett: Like it's
- 56:45Cy Kellett: your name is Ralph
- 56:46Cy Kellett: You just don't like it.
- 56:48Jimmy Akin: I like the name Rafe.
- 56:50Cy Kellett: Yeah, it's nice.
- 56:50Cy Kellett: It's nice.
- 56:51Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 56:52Jimmy Akin: And I can whistle all the ears from that infernal nonsense penafore.
- 56:56Cy Kellett: I'm sure you can.
- 56:57Cy Kellett: I know you can
- 56:58Cy Kellett: 't.
- 56:58Jimmy Akin: And give you every detail of Caractacus'
- 57:00Jimmy Akin: uniform.
- 57:01Cy Kellett: Yep.
- 57:01Cy Kellett: Don't get Jimmy started on uh
- 57:04Cy Kellett: Gilbert and Sullivan.
- 57:06Cy Kellett: Uh
- 57:06Cy Kellett: all right, I got a question for you from Ridiculous 1371.
- 57:10Cy Kellett: And
- 57:11Cy Kellett: this is not that troublesome
- 57:12Cy Kellett: ridiculous 1370 we've dealt with before.
- 57:15Cy Kellett: This is uh ridiculous 1371.
- 57:18Cy Kellett: Uh hi
- 57:18Cy Kellett: Jimmy.
- 57:18Jimmy Akin: It's ridiculous either way.
- 57:20Cy Kellett: Either way.
- 57:21Cy Kellett: Hi Jimmy.
- 57:21Cy Kellett: Here's a weird question
- 57:23Cy Kellett: Like in the movie Surrogate, imagine you're at home controlling a flesh and blood robot.
- 57:30Cy Kellett: If you were to go to confession, would it be valid or would it be like confessing over the phone to a priest
- 57:36Cy Kellett: And if you were to attend Mass and
- 57:39Cy Kellett: receive Holy Communion, would the grace transfer to your spirit?
- 57:44Cy Kellett: Would the flesh and blood robot be considered an extension of your body?
- 57:48Cy Kellett: or need baptism to make it eligible for the sacraments, if it was engineered from human DNA because of Adam and Eve's original sin.
- 57:56Cy Kellett: Thank you.
- 57:57Cy Kellett: Uh
- 57:57Cy Kellett: love
- 57:57Cy Kellett: the show
- 57:58Cy Kellett: Damien.
- 57:59Cy Kellett: Oh
- 58:00Cy Kellett: ridiculous
- 58:01Cy Kellett: Damien
- 58:02Jimmy Akin: So
- 58:03Jimmy Akin: um
- 58:04Jimmy Akin: I have not seen the movie Surrogate.
- 58:06Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 58:07Jimmy Akin: it's one of a number of Bruce Willis movies I haven't seen.
- 58:09Jimmy Akin: Did you like it?
- 58:11Cy Kellett: As I recall, I
- 58:12Cy Kellett: it was long I mean to me that's like thirteen, fourteen years ago.
- 58:15Cy Kellett: That's too long to really remember, except in general.
- 58:18Cy Kellett: Yes, I think I liked it.
- 58:20Jimmy Akin: So um
- 58:21Jimmy Akin: so I haven't seen the movie, so I'm basing this only
- 58:25Jimmy Akin: on what uh Damian
- 58:27Jimmy Akin: says in his e
- 58:28Jimmy Akin: in his
- 58:28Jimmy Akin: in his email.
- 58:30Jimmy Akin: And
- 58:30Jimmy Akin: that means
- 58:32Jimmy Akin: because
- 58:32Jimmy Akin: he says
- 58:33Jimmy Akin: I'm controlling a flesh and blood robot.
- 58:36Jimmy Akin: Now
- 58:38Jimmy Akin: Even though if you read
- 58:40Jimmy Akin: uh
- 58:40Jimmy Akin: the original play, uh
- 58:43Jimmy Akin: Rossom's Universal Robots that gave us the name Robot,
- 58:47Jimmy Akin: They end up being living beings
- 58:50Jimmy Akin: that are intelligent living beings.
- 58:52Jimmy Akin: That's not what the word means to most people.
- 58:55Jimmy Akin: It's it's not a complete
- 58:57Jimmy Akin: person.
- 58:58Jimmy Akin: And so I'm gonna assume that we're dealing with a robot in the conventional sense, not an artificially created human.
- 59:06Jimmy Akin: Because controlling a robot that happens to be made out of flesh and blood
- 59:11Jimmy Akin: and controlling a human
- 59:13Jimmy Akin: that
- 59:14Jimmy Akin: that you've created are two different things.
- 59:17Jimmy Akin: So I'm going with the robot interpretation
- 59:20Jimmy Akin: where it's an it's not a full human, um, even if it has human DNA as part of its engineering.
- 59:27Jimmy Akin: Um, okay.
- 59:29Jimmy Akin: So
- 59:30Jimmy Akin: given that, could I go to confession over the phone?
- 59:35Jimmy Akin: I'm sorry.
- 59:37Jimmy Akin: Could I
- 59:38Jimmy Akin: use the robot to go to confession?
- 59:40Jimmy Akin: Could I like send it down to the church and have it wait in the line that goes on forever and ever and ever
- 59:46Jimmy Akin: because they don't schedule confessions frequently enough or for long enough?
- 59:51Jimmy Akin: and people spend waste way too much time in there instead of just confessing their sins and being done with it.
- 59:57Jimmy Akin: Um
- 59:58Jimmy Akin: could I
- 59:59Jimmy Akin: and then
- 59:59Jimmy Akin: could I do that and be validly absolved?
- 1:00:02Jimmy Akin: Well there's not an answer to this question in terms of church doctrine.
- 1:00:06Jimmy Akin: This is a matter of theological opinion.
- 1:00:09Jimmy Akin: Damien, though, has been
- 1:00:12Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:00:13Jimmy Akin: he
- 1:00:13Jimmy Akin: says
- 1:00:14Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:00:15Jimmy Akin: would it be valid
- 1:00:17Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:00:17Jimmy Akin: would it be like confessing over the phone?
- 1:00:20Jimmy Akin: Well, who says confessing over the phone ain't valid?
- 1:00:24Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:00:25Jimmy Akin: that's an
- 1:00:26Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:00:26Jimmy Akin: some people have said it wouldn't be, and that's a an opinion that should be, you know, carefully considered.
- 1:00:33Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:00:33Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:00:35Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:00:35Jimmy Akin: it that's also not a church teaching.
- 1:00:38Jimmy Akin: And I think there is a basis
- 1:00:40Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:00:41Jimmy Akin: proposing that even though you shouldn't do it, because
- 1:00:45Jimmy Akin: government
- 1:00:46Jimmy Akin: spying
- 1:00:47Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:00:48Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:00:49Jimmy Akin: confession over the phone uh
- 1:00:51Jimmy Akin: actually
- 1:00:52Jimmy Akin: would be valid.
- 1:00:54Jimmy Akin: Because
- 1:00:54Jimmy Akin: unlike
- 1:00:55Jimmy Akin: this is one of two sacraments, the other being matrimony
- 1:00:59Jimmy Akin: that is based on information exchange.
- 1:01:02Jimmy Akin: Nobody has to touch anybody during confession
- 1:01:07Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:01:08Jimmy Akin: there's you
- 1:01:08Jimmy Akin: you don't receive communion, you don't have water poured on you, you don't have chrism applied to you.
- 1:01:14Jimmy Akin: It's just information-based.
- 1:01:16Jimmy Akin: You communicate information to the priest.
- 1:01:19Jimmy Akin: The priest communicates information back.
- 1:01:21Jimmy Akin: Just like in a marriage, one party gives consent to the other and the other party gives consent to be married back.
- 1:01:29Jimmy Akin: It's information exchange.
- 1:01:31Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:01:32Jimmy Akin: you know what
- 1:01:33Jimmy Akin: The church recognizes you don't have to be physically present for
- 1:01:38Jimmy Akin: marriage.
- 1:01:39Jimmy Akin: The church recognizes what are called proxy
- 1:01:43Jimmy Akin: marriages.
- 1:01:45Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:01:46Jimmy Akin: s
- 1:01:46Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:01:47Jimmy Akin: and that of course
- 1:01:48Jimmy Akin: brings to mind the
- 1:01:50Jimmy Akin: the A
- 1:01:51Jimmy Akin: Bin Crosby and Andrew
- 1:01:52Jimmy Akin: sisters s
- 1:01:53Jimmy Akin: uh song where Ben
- 1:01:54Jimmy Akin: Crosby sings
- 1:01:55Jimmy Akin: I'm getting married by proxy.
- 1:01:57Jimmy Akin: It's like
- 1:01:58Jimmy Akin: Really, that's really rare.
- 1:01:59Jimmy Akin: But what you do in a proxy marriage
- 1:02:02Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:02:03Jimmy Akin: you appoint someone
- 1:02:05Jimmy Akin: to go to the marriage service and
- 1:02:08Jimmy Akin: give consent on your behalf.
- 1:02:10Jimmy Akin: So you're transmitting
- 1:02:12Jimmy Akin: your
- 1:02:12Jimmy Akin: consent
- 1:02:13Jimmy Akin: through this other person who represents you.
- 1:02:17Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:02:17Jimmy Akin: the other person
- 1:02:18Jimmy Akin: can do the same thing.
- 1:02:20Jimmy Akin: They can send a proxy.
- 1:02:21Jimmy Akin: So you could actually have two different people
- 1:02:24Jimmy Akin: who
- 1:02:25Jimmy Akin: get
- 1:02:25Jimmy Akin: who come together and exchange consent
- 1:02:28Jimmy Akin: properly authorized
- 1:02:30Jimmy Akin: on your behalf and your spouse's behalf, and then you two
- 1:02:33Jimmy Akin: are married.
- 1:02:34Jimmy Akin: Not the two proxies who showed up.
- 1:02:36Jimmy Akin: All they did was communicate the information, but now the two of you are married
- 1:02:41Jimmy Akin: and the church recognizes that as valid.
- 1:02:45Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:02:46Jimmy Akin: if
- 1:02:47Jimmy Akin: we have
- 1:02:48Jimmy Akin: validity without personal presence
- 1:02:50Jimmy Akin: in the case of one information exchange sacrament,
- 1:02:55Jimmy Akin: You would think
- 1:02:56Jimmy Akin: we could also have validity
- 1:02:59Jimmy Akin: in the case of the other
- 1:03:01Jimmy Akin: information exchange-based sacrament.
- 1:03:04Jimmy Akin: I can also
- 1:03:05Jimmy Akin: strengthen that in another way
- 1:03:07Jimmy Akin: because it is undisputed
- 1:03:09Jimmy Akin: that like if you go to confession, but it's hard for you to orally confess your sins, either
- 1:03:15Jimmy Akin: for reasons of shame
- 1:03:17Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:03:17Jimmy Akin: for reasons of memory
- 1:03:20Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:03:21Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:03:22Jimmy Akin: you don't speak the language, maybe you're
- 1:03:24Jimmy Akin: maybe you're deaf and the priest doesn't know sign
- 1:03:26Jimmy Akin: language.
- 1:03:27Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:03:28Jimmy Akin: you can
- 1:03:29Jimmy Akin: write out your sins on a piece of paper, hand
- 1:03:33Jimmy Akin: the piece of paper to the priest, and he can read your sins you've just confessed and he can absolve you.
- 1:03:42Jimmy Akin: Okay, well if I can do that, why can't I take the piece of paper, put it in an envelope, put the envelope in a mailbox, pull up the flag that I recently forgot to pull up when I was mailing a letter
- 1:03:55Jimmy Akin: So it stayed there for a week.
- 1:03:57Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:03:58Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:03:59Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:04:01Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:04:02Jimmy Akin: then the postman carries the letter to the priest, he opens the envelope and reads it and can absolve you.
- 1:04:08Jimmy Akin: And maybe send you a note back saying
- 1:04:10Jimmy Akin: I absolve you.
- 1:04:12Jimmy Akin: So,
- 1:04:13Jimmy Akin: you know, if I can
- 1:04:14Jimmy Akin: if I can confess by letter
- 1:04:16Jimmy Akin: in the priest's presence
- 1:04:19Jimmy Akin: Why can't I confess
- 1:04:21Jimmy Akin: by letter without being in the priest's presence?
- 1:04:24Jimmy Akin: The same way I can have a proxy deliver my consent in a
- 1:04:29Jimmy Akin: in a marriage.
- 1:04:30Jimmy Akin: It's just here the postman is my proxy.
- 1:04:34Jimmy Akin: Well, I would think that uh
- 1:04:36Jimmy Akin: that could be valid
- 1:04:38Jimmy Akin: and it thus you
- 1:04:39Jimmy Akin: thus
- 1:04:40Jimmy Akin: you could
- 1:04:41Jimmy Akin: confess by telephone
- 1:04:43Jimmy Akin: in principle, and I'm not the only one who
- 1:04:46Jimmy Akin: is open to that possibility.
- 1:04:48Jimmy Akin: If you read
- 1:04:49Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:04:49Jimmy Akin: Henry Davis's
- 1:04:50Jimmy Akin: four volume
- 1:04:51Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:04:52Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:04:52Jimmy Akin: Moral and Pastoral Theology set
- 1:04:54Jimmy Akin: from the nineteen thirties, he says the same thing.
- 1:04:57Jimmy Akin: He just treats it as a given that you can confess by phone.
- 1:05:01Jimmy Akin: Not that you should, but you can.
- 1:05:03Cy Kellett: Uh-huh.
- 1:05:03Jimmy Akin: Um, I'm surprised he didn't warn against it stronger than he did because back in the nineteen thirties
- 1:05:09Jimmy Akin: people had party lines and there would other
- 1:05:12Jimmy Akin: be other people listening in.
- 1:05:14Jimmy Akin: But he treats it as valid.
- 1:05:16Jimmy Akin: And then when COVID raised the possibility again
- 1:05:19Jimmy Akin: because people couldn't
- 1:05:20Jimmy Akin: weren't allowed to get together
- 1:05:22Jimmy Akin: or couldn't get together safely.
- 1:05:24Jimmy Akin: Some priests did hear um
- 1:05:26Jimmy Akin: confession by phone and there was a a question about, well, is that going to be valid or not?
- 1:05:32Jimmy Akin: I don't see why it couldn't be.
- 1:05:34Jimmy Akin: Now I could be wrong, but I don't see why it couldn't be.
- 1:05:37Jimmy Akin: And if that's the case, then
- 1:05:40Jimmy Akin: using a
- 1:05:41Jimmy Akin: meat robot
- 1:05:43Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:05:44Jimmy Akin: be
- 1:05:45Jimmy Akin: the agent
- 1:05:46Jimmy Akin: through which you confess
- 1:05:48Jimmy Akin: would also be valid.
- 1:05:49Jimmy Akin: So I would say if uh
- 1:05:51Jimmy Akin: if the same rules apply pr
- 1:05:54Jimmy Akin: or same principles apply to
- 1:05:56Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:05:58Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:05:58Jimmy Akin: confession that apply to matrimony, then yeah, you would be able to do it through a meat robot.
- 1:06:04Jimmy Akin: So that's uh the first question that Damien has.
- 1:06:07Jimmy Akin: Then he asks
- 1:06:08Jimmy Akin: Uh, what
- 1:06:09Jimmy Akin: if I were to attend Mass?
- 1:06:10Jimmy Akin: Well, that would be like watching Mass on TV.
- 1:06:13Jimmy Akin: I'm not really there, but I'm still having an experience of the Mass.
- 1:06:17Jimmy Akin: What if I were to receive Holy Communion?
- 1:06:21Jimmy Akin: Okay, here
- 1:06:23Jimmy Akin: it would
- 1:06:23Jimmy Akin: here's where there's a difference, because
- 1:06:26Jimmy Akin: communion is
- 1:06:28Jimmy Akin: not an information
- 1:06:29Jimmy Akin: transfer sacrament.
- 1:06:31Jimmy Akin: You have to receive the communion into your body.
- 1:06:35Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:06:36Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:06:37Jimmy Akin: the priest would in the Mass
- 1:06:39Jimmy Akin: vowly consecrate the Eucharist, but if I send a meat robot.
- 1:06:45Jimmy Akin: And the priest puts the
- 1:06:47Jimmy Akin: host on the meat robot's tongue, then
- 1:06:52Jimmy Akin: I'm not receiving communion.
- 1:06:54Jimmy Akin: The meat robot
- 1:06:55Jimmy Akin: isn't even receiving communion because we've already stipulated it's not a real person.
- 1:07:00Jimmy Akin: This would be the equivalent of the priest, because the meat robot's saliva is going to dissolve the host.
- 1:07:06Jimmy Akin: Um, but this would be the equivalent of like taking a consecrated host and putting it in a petri dish full of water, and the water dissolves the host.
- 1:07:15Jimmy Akin: it's not a person receiving it.
- 1:07:18Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:07:19Jimmy Akin: that's not a
- 1:07:21Jimmy Akin: under
- 1:07:21Jimmy Akin: ordinary circumstances, unless there's a compensating reason, that's not a good thing
- 1:07:26Jimmy Akin: because the purpose of Jesus becoming
- 1:07:29Jimmy Akin: present in communion is to allow for personal communion.
- 1:07:34Jimmy Akin: And so I shouldn't be using a meat robot to
- 1:07:37Jimmy Akin: dissolve hosts any more than I should use a petri dish.
- 1:07:42Jimmy Akin: to di
- 1:07:42Jimmy Akin: with water to dissolve hosts.
- 1:07:44Jimmy Akin: Now, there are exceptions, like if the host has become soiled, maybe someone vomited it up and it's no longer consumable, well then you're supposed to dissolve.
- 1:07:53Jimmy Akin: it.
- 1:07:53Jimmy Akin: But apart from those circumstances, you shouldn't be doing that.
- 1:07:57Jimmy Akin: So I shouldn't be using a meet robot to risk
- 1:08:00Jimmy Akin: to try to receive communion on my behalf.
- 1:08:03Jimmy Akin: If I did
- 1:08:05Jimmy Akin: unknowingly
- 1:08:06Jimmy Akin: not realizing
- 1:08:07Jimmy Akin: I shouldn't do it, would
- 1:08:09Jimmy Akin: I receive
- 1:08:10Jimmy Akin: grace in my spirit through this?
- 1:08:13Jimmy Akin: Well, if
- 1:08:14Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:08:15Jimmy Akin: If uh
- 1:08:16Jimmy Akin: I can't say that I'd receive the full grace of communion, but I would be trying to please God here.
- 1:08:22Jimmy Akin: And if I'm trying to please God and trying to receive his
- 1:08:26Jimmy Akin: grace, then God knows that.
- 1:08:28Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:08:28Jimmy Akin: he can give me his
- 1:08:29Jimmy Akin: grace, and I would think
- 1:08:31Jimmy Akin: would give me his
- 1:08:32Jimmy Akin: grace, as long as I'm not knowingly
- 1:08:35Jimmy Akin: thwarting the purpose of
- 1:08:37Jimmy Akin: So I would say, yeah, you probably do would get some grace in that situation, but not if you understand what you're doing, because you're really not supposed to do this.
- 1:08:46Cy Kellett: Thank you
- 1:08:46Cy Kellett: very much
- 1:08:47Cy Kellett: for the question.
- 1:08:48Cy Kellett: Darren, am I at uh uh
- 1:08:49Cy Kellett: break time?
- 1:08:49Cy Kellett: Yeah, okay, I gotta take a quick break.
- 1:08:51Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:08:51Cy Kellett: coming up with more
- 1:08:52Cy Kellett: uh we're coming back with more
- 1:08:54Cy Kellett: weird questions for Jimmy Akin on Catholic Answers Live.
- 1:08:58Cy Kellett: Jimmy Akin here for weird questions.
- 1:09:02Cy Kellett: With Jimmy Akin, I am Cy Kelly, your host.
- 1:09:05Cy Kellett: Lots of good weird uh
- 1:09:06Cy Kellett: questions.
- 1:09:07Cy Kellett: And
- 1:09:08Cy Kellett: uh
- 1:09:08Cy Kellett: now we're gonna go uh
- 1:09:10Cy Kellett: do a little remote viewing.
- 1:09:11Cy Kellett: I remember you uh uh I I've I forget
- 1:09:14Cy Kellett: where I heard you tell this story, but it's a fascinating story and this per
- 1:09:17Cy Kellett: MT Wardell wants to know.
- 1:09:18Cy Kellett: I don't remember if you answered this during your show
- 1:09:21Cy Kellett: But in episode 330 of Jimmy's Mysterious World, you went over Lynn Buchanan's remote viewing experience for the military project, Stargate.
- 1:09:32Cy Kellett: Lynn recounts that when remote viewing Jesus, he turned and looked at Lynn.
- 1:09:39Cy Kellett: My question is, what did Jesus look at?
- 1:09:42Cy Kellett: Was it Lin
- 1:09:43Cy Kellett: 's mind?
- 1:09:45Jimmy Akin: Okay, so uh
- 1:09:47Jimmy Akin: first I'll set the stage on when this happened.
- 1:09:50Jimmy Akin: This was uh a few years ago
- 1:09:52Jimmy Akin: I went to
- 1:09:53Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:09:53Jimmy Akin: conference of the International Remote Viewing Association.
- 1:09:57Jimmy Akin: And they had a number of the former Stargate remote viewers there, one of them being Lynn Buchanan.
- 1:10:03Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:10:03Jimmy Akin: during one of the panel sessions, they
- 1:10:07Jimmy Akin: asked a question.
- 1:10:08Jimmy Akin: I forget what the question was, but it was basically about memorable
- 1:10:12Jimmy Akin: experiences
- 1:10:12Jimmy Akin: you had remote viewing.
- 1:10:14Jimmy Akin: And Lynn told a story where he had been assigned to remote view
- 1:10:19Jimmy Akin: Jesus, only he didn't know that, which is standard in remote viewing.
- 1:10:24Jimmy Akin: They don't tell you what you're supposed to view.
- 1:10:26Jimmy Akin: Because if you knew what you were supposed to view, then your beliefs and imagination would pollute the data that you're picking up.
- 1:10:35Jimmy Akin: Like if I if I
- 1:10:37Jimmy Akin: if I told you I want you to remote view
- 1:10:40Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:10:41Jimmy Akin: President
- 1:10:42Jimmy Akin: Trump.
- 1:10:44Jimmy Akin: then
- 1:10:44Jimmy Akin: your beliefs about President Trump, whether good or bad or indifferent, would tend to clutter up your mind as you're trying to pick up
- 1:10:53Jimmy Akin: the remote viewing information
- 1:10:55Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:10:56Jimmy Akin: it would distort the picture you get.
- 1:10:58Jimmy Akin: So they want remote viewers to be blind, not have any idea
- 1:11:03Jimmy Akin: what they're remote viewing.
- 1:11:05Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:11:06Jimmy Akin: someone assigned Lynn to Remote View Jesus, and he didn't know that's who he was viewing
- 1:11:13Jimmy Akin: He tells a story, and by the way, I've got a video clip of him telling this story.
- 1:11:17Jimmy Akin: It's episode 330A
- 1:11:20Jimmy Akin: of Jimmy Aken's Mysterious World.
- 1:11:22Jimmy Akin: You can find it on my YouTube
- 1:11:24Jimmy Akin: page at youtube.
- 1:11:25Jimmy Akin: com slash Jimmy Akin, just in the search field
- 1:11:29Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:11:30Jimmy Akin: my
- 1:11:31Jimmy Akin: channel, not for all of YouTube, but in the search field
- 1:11:35Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:11:35Jimmy Akin: my channel, just type in remote viewing Jesus
- 1:11:39Jimmy Akin: and it'll come right up.
- 1:11:40Jimmy Akin: So he starts perceiving this guy.
- 1:11:43Jimmy Akin: who
- 1:11:44Jimmy Akin: he says
- 1:11:44Jimmy Akin: looks Jewish
- 1:11:46Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:11:47Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:11:48Jimmy Akin: didn't look
- 1:11:49Jimmy Akin: unusual.
- 1:11:51Jimmy Akin: So, you know, he was presumably in modern clothing.
- 1:11:54Jimmy Akin: what he was perceiving.
- 1:11:56Jimmy Akin: And he got
- 1:11:57Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:11:58Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:11:58Jimmy Akin: he got the sense
- 1:12:00Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:12:02Jimmy Akin: who
- 1:12:02Jimmy Akin: this person
- 1:12:03Jimmy Akin: being innocent
- 1:12:05Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:12:06Jimmy Akin: that's unusual
- 1:12:08Jimmy Akin: for
- 1:12:09Jimmy Akin: the kinds of people they would typically assign remote viewers to look at.
- 1:12:15Jimmy Akin: You know, typically they'd want them to like look at a Russian spy
- 1:12:18Jimmy Akin: or look at a South American drug smuggler
- 1:12:21Jimmy Akin: or something like that.
- 1:12:23Jimmy Akin: They'd want information about a person who's not innocent.
- 1:12:26Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:12:28Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:12:28Jimmy Akin: in his experience, Lynn says that the person he was viewing looked at him
- 1:12:34Jimmy Akin: and it was like the person fully understood and accepted him.
- 1:12:39Jimmy Akin: in spite of all his flaws.
- 1:12:41Jimmy Akin: And it was very moving experience for Lynn.
- 1:12:43Jimmy Akin: And then after the remote viewing session
- 1:12:46Jimmy Akin: He he told his handler, um, I don't know what you think that guy did, but he's innocent, whatever you think he did.
- 1:12:54Jimmy Akin: And then the
- 1:12:56Jimmy Akin: then it was revealed to Lynn that he was he had in fact been assigned to remote view Jesus.
- 1:13:01Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:13:02Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:13:02Jimmy Akin: M.
- 1:13:02Jimmy Akin: T.
- 1:13:03Jimmy Akin: Wardell
- 1:13:04Jimmy Akin: is asking
- 1:13:05Jimmy Akin: what
- 1:13:05Jimmy Akin: when Jesus looked at him, what was Jesus looking at?
- 1:13:09Jimmy Akin: Would it have been Lynn's mind?
- 1:13:11Jimmy Akin: And I'd say, well, basically, yeah.
- 1:13:14Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:13:14Jimmy Akin: now
- 1:13:15Jimmy Akin: in any kind of telepathic experience, um
- 1:13:19Jimmy Akin: which
- 1:13:19Jimmy Akin: this
- 1:13:20Jimmy Akin: would have
- 1:13:21Jimmy Akin: been, um
- 1:13:23Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:13:24Jimmy Akin: the imagination fills in a lot of details.
- 1:13:27Jimmy Akin: That's why, for example, he might have seen this guy in modern
- 1:13:30Jimmy Akin: dress, because he assumed
- 1:13:33Jimmy Akin: that Jesus is in
- 1:13:35Jimmy Akin: is is that the person he's been assigned to view is is here on earth today
- 1:13:39Jimmy Akin: and thus
- 1:13:40Jimmy Akin: would be wearing modern clothing.
- 1:13:43Jimmy Akin: Just like, you know, when people see Jesus in apparitions, they tend to see him
- 1:13:48Jimmy Akin: at least often
- 1:13:49Jimmy Akin: in the clothing of their culture.
- 1:13:52Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 1:13:52Jimmy Akin: You know, uh
- 1:13:53Jimmy Akin: like
- 1:13:54Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:13:54Jimmy Akin: with our Lady of Guadalupe, she's dressed as
- 1:13:57Jimmy Akin: as a Native American.
- 1:13:59Jimmy Akin: Um, so the imagination fills in those details
- 1:14:03Jimmy Akin: and this whole experience is going to be like that.
- 1:14:05Jimmy Akin: But if I were to interpret
- 1:14:07Jimmy Akin: where
- 1:14:08Jimmy Akin: Jesus looks at him, um, I would, I
- 1:14:12Jimmy Akin: assuming this is a real experience and all that, I would assume that this
- 1:14:17Jimmy Akin: is his
- 1:14:17Jimmy Akin: mind's way of representing
- 1:14:20Jimmy Akin: Jesus'
- 1:14:21Jimmy Akin: awareness of
- 1:14:23Jimmy Akin: him.
- 1:14:23Jimmy Akin: You know, like
- 1:14:24Jimmy Akin: if I look at you,
- 1:14:27Jimmy Akin: you're gonna understand
- 1:14:28Jimmy Akin: I'm aware of you
- 1:14:30Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:14:31Jimmy Akin: if you want to put that in terms of, so I don't think Jesus was physically looking at anything.
- 1:14:37Jimmy Akin: I would say Jesus
- 1:14:39Jimmy Akin: Is aware of Lynn viewing him.
- 1:14:43Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:14:43Jimmy Akin: that's
- 1:14:44Jimmy Akin: w
- 1:14:44Jimmy Akin: and so if you want to describe that
- 1:14:47Jimmy Akin: as Jesus looking at Lynn's mind, well then you can do that.
- 1:14:51Jimmy Akin: We're mixing our metaphors
- 1:14:52Jimmy Akin: since it's not literal vision,
- 1:14:54Jimmy Akin: but I would say it represents awareness.
- 1:14:58Cy Kellett: All right.
- 1:14:59Cy Kellett: Uh uh, thank you very much for that one.
- 1:15:01Cy Kellett: Can I can I skip down uh uh
- 1:15:03Cy Kellett: um
- 1:15:03Cy Kellett: to the cowboy boots one?
- 1:15:04Cy Kellett: Because we've got a break coming up in a couple minutes.
- 1:15:06Cy Kellett: Do you mind, Jimmy?
- 1:15:07Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:15:08Cy Kellett: Eugene
- 1:15:09Cy Kellett: M
- 1:15:09Cy Kellett: -T10
- 1:15:12Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:15:12Cy Kellett: can I wear a cowboy hat and cowboy boots if I don't own a horse?
- 1:15:18Jimmy Akin: Yeah, sure
- 1:15:20Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:15:21Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:15:21Jimmy Akin: cow
- 1:15:22Jimmy Akin: cowboy hat and cowboy boots are items of clothing
- 1:15:25Jimmy Akin: and they're they are used to
- 1:15:28Jimmy Akin: signal, you know, cultural affiliations
- 1:15:31Jimmy Akin: or aspirations
- 1:15:32Jimmy Akin: or things like that.
- 1:15:33Jimmy Akin: And none of them are based on
- 1:15:35Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:15:35Jimmy Akin: none of them require owning a horse.
- 1:15:37Jimmy Akin: I mean my family from Texas.
- 1:15:39Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:15:40Jimmy Akin: ran a cattle ranch for years and years and years.
- 1:15:43Jimmy Akin: My my grandmother kept the cow till
- 1:15:45Jimmy Akin: cows
- 1:15:46Jimmy Akin: till she was in her eighties.
- 1:15:47Jimmy Akin: And well, people in my family wear cowboy hats and boots, but we didn't own a horse even when we
- 1:15:53Jimmy Akin: even when we were running a cattle ranch.
- 1:15:56Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:15:57Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:15:57Jimmy Akin: if you want to
- 1:15:59Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:16:00Jimmy Akin: wear a c a cowboy hat or boots and you don't own a horse, that's just fine.
- 1:16:04Jimmy Akin: You're just signaling
- 1:16:06Jimmy Akin: this is a culture I appreciate, this is a culture I admire, and I want to in some way
- 1:16:10Jimmy Akin: identify with this culture.
- 1:16:12Jimmy Akin: And that's that's totally fine.
- 1:16:15Cy Kellett: Are cowway boots
- 1:16:16Cy Kellett: are they pointed so that you can get them in the stirrups?
- 1:16:18Cy Kellett: Is that real?
- 1:16:19Jimmy Akin: That's their historical origin, yes.
- 1:16:21Jimmy Akin: So you could get the toes into the stirrups easily, but um
- 1:16:25Jimmy Akin: People uh actually hu
- 1:16:26Jimmy Akin: a lot of boots today
- 1:16:27Jimmy Akin: don't have the points, which
- 1:16:29Jimmy Akin: I regret
- 1:16:30Jimmy Akin: because I prefer them with the points, so I have
- 1:16:33Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:16:32Jimmy Akin: When I whenever I need to get new boots, I have to look for them special because a lot of modern boots don't have points.
- 1:16:38Cy Kellett: Yeah.
- 1:16:38Jimmy Akin: But uh that's their historical origin, but it just like
- 1:16:42Jimmy Akin: The historical origin of the hat is to shield you from, you know, the weather and the sun.
- 1:16:47Jimmy Akin: Well, people don't need to do it for that anymore
- 1:16:50Jimmy Akin: either.
- 1:16:51Jimmy Akin: It's
- 1:16:53Jimmy Akin: you know, it it
- 1:16:54Jimmy Akin: its
- 1:16:54Jimmy Akin: historical origin
- 1:16:55Jimmy Akin: has nothing to do with
- 1:16:57Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:16:58Jimmy Akin: its
- 1:16:59Jimmy Akin: modern function.
- 1:17:00Cy Kellett: So y your
- 1:17:01Cy Kellett: your grandmother raised cattle without horses
- 1:17:04Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 1:17:05Cy Kellett: They just that
- 1:17:05Cy Kellett: I
- 1:17:06Cy Kellett: because you feel
- 1:17:06Cy Kellett: like
- 1:17:07Jimmy Akin: horses.
- 1:17:07Jimmy Akin: She'd if she needed
- 1:17:09Jimmy Akin: I mean if she needed to go to a distant part of the ranch, she'd use her pickup.
- 1:17:14Cy Kellett: Oh
- 1:17:15Cy Kellett: yeah.
- 1:17:16Cy Kellett: There's that I guess.
- 1:17:17Jimmy Akin: Or her tractor.
- 1:17:18Jimmy Akin: You know.
- 1:17:19Jimmy Akin: Get on the
- 1:17:20Jimmy Akin: get on the tractor or get in the pickup
- 1:17:22Jimmy Akin: and just drive where you need to.
- 1:17:23Cy Kellett: Yeah, I was out
- 1:17:25Cy Kellett: with
- 1:17:25Cy Kellett: ranchers not too long ago in Wyoming and they were like the horse is now being replaced by the four-wheeler.
- 1:17:31Cy Kellett: The you know the the little four-wheeler things.
- 1:17:33Cy Kellett: All right.
- 1:17:34Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:17:34Cy Kellett: lots more uh questions coming up, including one I'm looking forward to from Joey.
- 1:17:38Cy Kellett: bag of donuts just because I like calling a guy Joey Bag of Donuts.
- 1:17:42Cy Kellett: Uh we'll continue
- 1:17:43Cy Kellett: Weird Questions with Jimmy Akin right after this on Catholic Answers Live.
- 1:17:49Cy Kellett: You just hang on there Joey Bag of Donuts.
- 1:17:51Cy Kellett: We're getting to you.
- 1:17:51Cy Kellett: I know you gotta
- 1:17:52Cy Kellett: I I I said
- 1:17:53Cy Kellett: We're getting to Joey Bag of Donuts, but there is a question before we get to Joy Bag of Donuts.
- 1:17:57Cy Kellett: And I
- 1:17:57Cy Kellett: now that I have a question from Joey Bag of Donuts, you can clearly see
- 1:18:01Cy Kellett: I am trying to say Joey Bag of Donuts as many times as I can on today's show.
- 1:18:05Jimmy Akin: I've noticed that.
- 1:18:06Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 1:18:06Cy Kellett: It's really cool.
- 1:18:08Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:18:08Cy Kellett: Mark Mariani, 1684, uh
- 1:18:12Cy Kellett: wants to know this.
- 1:18:14Jimmy Akin: And I think the donuts I think the donuts
- 1:18:16Jimmy Akin: have something to do with it.
- 1:18:22Cy Kellett: I wouldn't.
- 1:18:22Cy Kellett: No, that's not cool at all, Jimmy.
- 1:18:24Cy Kellett: That's the y
- 1:18:25Cy Kellett: that's the opposite of a cool name.
- 1:18:27Cy Kellett: As a matter of fact, that's a name someone else gives you.
- 1:18:30Cy Kellett: You don't say that as
- 1:18:32Cy Kellett: that's how
- 1:18:33Cy Kellett: there's nobody well, maybe there are people that would give themselves that name.
- 1:18:36Cy Kellett: If there are
- 1:18:37Cy Kellett: I'm sorry.
- 1:18:37Jimmy Akin: Hey
- 1:18:38Jimmy Akin: people use
- 1:18:38Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 1:18:39Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:18:40Jimmy Akin: poop emoji
- 1:18:41Jimmy Akin: and I it's like
- 1:18:42Jimmy Akin: stop
- 1:18:43Jimmy Akin: please
- 1:18:43Jimmy Akin: stop people
- 1:18:45Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 1:18:46Jimmy Akin: Did you ever see the uh
- 1:18:48Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:18:48Jimmy Akin: oh I'm blanking on his name, but the American version of Sherlock Holmes that was called elementary?
- 1:18:56Cy Kellett: I don't think I did see it.
- 1:18:57Cy Kellett: No.
- 1:18:59Jimmy Akin: It was actually a good show.
- 1:19:00Jimmy Akin: I mean
- 1:19:00Jimmy Akin: I'm a fan of detective fiction and I I happen
- 1:19:02Jimmy Akin: including Sherlock Holmes and I happened to watch all
- 1:19:05Jimmy Akin: the seasons of this, but they
- 1:19:08Jimmy Akin: portray uh
- 1:19:09Jimmy Akin: Sherlock, who is British in this even though it's an American show, they
- 1:19:13Jimmy Akin: portray Sherlock as
- 1:19:15Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:19:16Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:17Jimmy Akin: mentally odd,
- 1:19:19Jimmy Akin: which
- 1:19:20Jimmy Akin: he is in the s
- 1:19:21Jimmy Akin: original stories.
- 1:19:23Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:19:24Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:19:25Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:26Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:19:26Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:27Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:27Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:27Jimmy Akin: he
- 1:19:28Jimmy Akin: he's not uh he may know
- 1:19:30Jimmy Akin: he may be brilliant on some things, but he's totally clueless
- 1:19:34Jimmy Akin: on others.
- 1:19:34Jimmy Akin: And which is actually the way he is in the stories too.
- 1:19:37Jimmy Akin: Like in an early story, even though he knows two hundred and thirty-five different types of tobacco ash, he does not know about the heliocentric theory of the solar system.
- 1:19:47Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:19:49Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:19:50Jimmy Akin: and in this, there's an episode where
- 1:19:52Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:53Jimmy Akin: Dr.
- 1:19:53Jimmy Akin: Watson, who's played by Lucy
- 1:19:55Jimmy Akin: Liu, and
- 1:19:57Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:19:57Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:19:58Jimmy Akin: like one of the American cops he works with.
- 1:20:01Jimmy Akin: are
- 1:20:02Jimmy Akin: for some reason
- 1:20:03Jimmy Akin: showing he he uses he's got a print
- 1:20:05Jimmy Akin: up of the poop emoji
- 1:20:08Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:20:09Jimmy Akin: and they're like
- 1:20:10Jimmy Akin: Sherlock, why do you have that?
- 1:20:12Jimmy Akin: And he's like, what's wrong with chocolate ice cream?
- 1:20:17Cy Kellett: Oh, come on.
- 1:20:20Jimmy Akin: But you think about it
- 1:20:21Jimmy Akin: as like, yeah, okay, it's
- 1:20:22Jimmy Akin: you look at it, it could be chocolate ice cream, but that's not what it means
- 1:20:26Jimmy Akin: normally.
- 1:20:28Cy Kellett: But he just can't get
- 1:20:29Cy Kellett: he doesn't get what other people get.
- 1:20:31Cy Kellett: He doesn't see what other people see.
- 1:20:33Cy Kellett: Alright, this uh
- 1:20:34Cy Kellett: this one's from Mark Mariani, as I said, 1684.
- 1:20:37Cy Kellett: How does time work
- 1:20:39Cy Kellett: in purgatory?
- 1:20:40Cy Kellett: I think first of all, I think I just found out a little bit.
- 1:20:44Cy Kellett: Just went through a little bit of purgatory with that last discussion.
- 1:20:47Cy Kellett: But
- 1:20:47Cy Kellett: how does time work in purgatory?
- 1:20:50Cy Kellett: Will we have to revisit all the moments
- 1:20:53Cy Kellett: where we've fallen short in order to right those wrongs?
- 1:20:57Cy Kellett: Or are we
- 1:20:58Cy Kellett: Frozen in time until our final judgment?
- 1:21:01Cy Kellett: Or does time continue to flow linearly like it does on Earth?
- 1:21:05Cy Kellett: Or is there some other theory that I haven't mentioned or thought of myself?
- 1:21:10Jimmy Akin: Okay, uh
- 1:21:11Jimmy Akin: the answer is we don't know how time works in purgatory.
- 1:21:16Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:21:17Jimmy Akin: Mark mentions a bunch of different possibilities.
- 1:21:21Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:21:21Jimmy Akin: including others that he hasn't thought of, and I'm sure there are other possibilities no living human has ever thought of.
- 1:21:31Jimmy Akin: So w the truth is we just don't know.
- 1:21:34Jimmy Akin: Now
- 1:21:35Jimmy Akin: in
- 1:21:35Jimmy Akin: it
- 1:21:36Jimmy Akin: it's possible that time flows exactly
- 1:21:39Jimmy Akin: the same way there that it does here.
- 1:21:42Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:21:44Jimmy Akin: and I would take that possibility seriously.
- 1:21:47Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:21:48Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:21:50Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:21:50Jimmy Akin: however
- 1:21:51Jimmy Akin: I want to mention some other possibilities.
- 1:21:54Jimmy Akin: The main
- 1:21:55Jimmy Akin: possibility I want to mention is one that was developed in the Middle
- 1:21:59Jimmy Akin: Ages.
- 1:22:00Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:22:01Jimmy Akin: in the Middle Ages
- 1:22:03Jimmy Akin: theologians and philosophers like St.
- 1:22:05Jimmy Akin: Thomas Aquinas
- 1:22:07Jimmy Akin: proposed that time
- 1:22:08Jimmy Akin: does work differently in the afterlife between death and resurrection.
- 1:22:14Jimmy Akin: Now it's not that there's no time
- 1:22:17Jimmy Akin: Only God
- 1:22:18Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:22:18Jimmy Akin: outside of time.
- 1:22:19Jimmy Akin: The church teaches that all created reality
- 1:22:23Jimmy Akin: is in some way subject to time, even if it's not time as we experience it here on earth.
- 1:22:29Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:22:29Jimmy Akin: God Himself
- 1:22:31Jimmy Akin: and only
- 1:22:32Jimmy Akin: God Himself
- 1:22:33Jimmy Akin: is outside of time.
- 1:22:35Jimmy Akin: The proposal that was developed in the Middle
- 1:22:37Jimmy Akin: Ages is that
- 1:22:39Jimmy Akin: angels
- 1:22:40Jimmy Akin: and departed human spirits
- 1:22:43Jimmy Akin: Are in a state that has
- 1:22:46Jimmy Akin: some
- 1:22:46Jimmy Akin: similarities to eternity, which is the absence of time, and some
- 1:22:52Jimmy Akin: similarities to time.
- 1:22:55Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:22:55Jimmy Akin: it's kind of a middle
- 1:22:57Jimmy Akin: state between time and eternity.
- 1:23:00Jimmy Akin: And they had a special name for it.
- 1:23:02Jimmy Akin: They called it avaternity.
- 1:23:04Jimmy Akin: And they believed that avaternity
- 1:23:07Jimmy Akin: was measured
- 1:23:10Jimmy Akin: sort of in terms
- 1:23:11Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:23:12Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:23:12Jimmy Akin: was
- 1:23:13Jimmy Akin: divided into
- 1:23:15Jimmy Akin: stages
- 1:23:16Jimmy Akin: based on progress
- 1:23:19Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:23:19Jimmy Akin: but not
- 1:23:20Jimmy Akin: experienced
- 1:23:21Jimmy Akin: it
- 1:23:22Jimmy Akin: from moment
- 1:23:23Jimmy Akin: to moment the way we do
- 1:23:25Jimmy Akin: experience time.
- 1:23:26Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:23:27Jimmy Akin: it
- 1:23:27Jimmy Akin: kind of
- 1:23:28Jimmy Akin: like
- 1:23:29Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:23:29Jimmy Akin: whenever a soul in purgatory makes progress, it achieves a new stage in Ave
- 1:23:36Jimmy Akin: eternity, but it doesn't experience the gap.
- 1:23:39Jimmy Akin: between two
- 1:23:41Jimmy Akin: different jumps forward
- 1:23:44Jimmy Akin: as, you know, like listening to a ticking
- 1:23:46Jimmy Akin: clock.
- 1:23:47Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:23:48Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:23:49Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:23:49Jimmy Akin: there's something going on that involves progress and sequence, sequentiality, which is what you need for time.
- 1:23:57Jimmy Akin: You need something involving progress and sequentiality.
- 1:24:00Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:24:02Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:24:02Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:24:03Jimmy Akin: but it wasn't
- 1:24:04Jimmy Akin: it it didn't experience the way we experience time.
- 1:24:07Jimmy Akin: Now
- 1:24:08Jimmy Akin: that's just a proposal
- 1:24:11Jimmy Akin: And it's
- 1:24:12Jimmy Akin: it's an idea
- 1:24:14Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 1:24:14Jimmy Akin: is proposed by various medieval authors, but it is not church teaching, and there are other possibilities too.
- 1:24:23Jimmy Akin: Pope Benedict XVI, in his encyclical Spessalvi, said
- 1:24:30Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:24:30Jimmy Akin: purgatory cannot be calculated in earthly time.
- 1:24:36Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:24:37Jimmy Akin: so, and I don't know that purgatory
- 1:24:41Jimmy Akin: takes anything like earthly time.
- 1:24:43Jimmy Akin: I mean, we're told
- 1:24:44Jimmy Akin: that when
- 1:24:45Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:24:47Jimmy Akin: When Jesus comes back at the second coming, those who
- 1:24:51Jimmy Akin: Christians who were alive
- 1:24:52Jimmy Akin: will be transformed in the twinkling of an eye
- 1:24:56Jimmy Akin: into
- 1:24:56Jimmy Akin: their final resurrection form.
- 1:24:58Jimmy Akin: So it's going to be a virtually instantaneous transformation.
- 1:25:02Jimmy Akin: Well if God can do that at the end of time, he can do that at your moment of death
- 1:25:06Jimmy Akin: too.
- 1:25:07Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:25:08Jimmy Akin: for all I know, someone dies
- 1:25:10Jimmy Akin: and instantly, or virtually instantly, they're transformed into, they're purified.
- 1:25:17Jimmy Akin: And so purgatory
- 1:25:18Jimmy Akin: from an earthly perspective
- 1:25:21Jimmy Akin: might be
- 1:25:23Jimmy Akin: virtually instantaneous.
- 1:25:25Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:25:26Jimmy Akin: the way Pope Benedict describes the transformation, it takes the heart's time rather than like clock time or calendar time.
- 1:25:35Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:25:35Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:25:36Jimmy Akin: that's a possibility
- 1:25:38Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:25:38Jimmy Akin: he's n
- 1:25:39Jimmy Akin: he didn't impose this as a matter of church teaching
- 1:25:41Jimmy Akin: either.
- 1:25:42Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:25:43Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:25:44Jimmy Akin: so I would say the truth is
- 1:25:46Jimmy Akin: we don't know.
- 1:25:47Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:25:48Jimmy Akin: what
- 1:25:49Jimmy Akin: I can do
- 1:25:50Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:25:50Jimmy Akin: report data.
- 1:25:52Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:25:53Jimmy Akin: how
- 1:25:54Jimmy Akin: humans
- 1:25:56Jimmy Akin: have
- 1:25:57Jimmy Akin: reported
- 1:25:58Jimmy Akin: experiencing purgatory
- 1:26:00Jimmy Akin: either from the inside of the experience or from the outside.
- 1:26:04Jimmy Akin: There have been people who have had near-death
- 1:26:07Jimmy Akin: experiences
- 1:26:09Jimmy Akin: where they
- 1:26:10Jimmy Akin: seem
- 1:26:10Jimmy Akin: to experience purgatory and came back.
- 1:26:13Jimmy Akin: There have also
- 1:26:14Jimmy Akin: been
- 1:26:15Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:26:16Jimmy Akin: And this is the more useful set of data for our purposes.
- 1:26:19Jimmy Akin: There have been
- 1:26:21Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:26:22Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:26:23Jimmy Akin: apparitions
- 1:26:24Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:26:25Jimmy Akin: departed spirits
- 1:26:27Jimmy Akin: that are engaged in their purgatory right now.
- 1:26:30Jimmy Akin: And they've communicated with the living about this and said, like, I'm in purgatory right now, I need prayers, I need masses said, or
- 1:26:38Jimmy Akin: because I'm
- 1:26:39Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:26:40Jimmy Akin: because of things I did in this life, I'm that's why I'm here now
- 1:26:44Jimmy Akin: doing this task.
- 1:26:45Jimmy Akin: There's a famous example that Pope Gregory the Great
- 1:26:49Jimmy Akin: records in his dialogues uh
- 1:26:51Jimmy Akin: we're about a priest in Italy who
- 1:26:54Jimmy Akin: was going to the public bathhouse because back in the AD
- 1:26:57Jimmy Akin: 500s they didn't have
- 1:26:59Jimmy Akin: indoor plumbing the way we do.
- 1:27:01Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:27:01Jimmy Akin: he goes to the bathhouse to get bathed and there's this
- 1:27:05Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:27:06Jimmy Akin: bath attendant
- 1:27:07Jimmy Akin: who's
- 1:27:08Jimmy Akin: who
- 1:27:08Jimmy Akin: does a really good job and he thinks, well, this guy has always done a really good job for me.
- 1:27:13Jimmy Akin: Um, I want to do something nice for him.
- 1:27:15Jimmy Akin: So he gets a couple of loaves of bread and brings them to the bathhouse and
- 1:27:19Jimmy Akin: After he has his bath, he says, here, please accept these two loaves of bread.
- 1:27:23Jimmy Akin: I wanted to do something nice because you've been so good to me.
- 1:27:26Jimmy Akin: And the bath attendant
- 1:27:27Jimmy Akin: says, um, thank you, but I can't eat them
- 1:27:31Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:27:31Jimmy Akin: I'm not alive.
- 1:27:33Jimmy Akin: I'm
- 1:27:33Jimmy Akin: I'm from
- 1:27:34Jimmy Akin: I'm in
- 1:27:35Jimmy Akin: I'm in purgatory.
- 1:27:37Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:27:37Jimmy Akin: uh I'm here
- 1:27:39Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:27:40Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:27:40Jimmy Akin: I used to be the owner.
- 1:27:42Jimmy Akin: of the bathhouse.
- 1:27:43Jimmy Akin: And apparently he didn't appreciate what his bath attendants had to do.
- 1:27:48Jimmy Akin: And so now as part of his purgatory, he was experiencing what it's like to be a bath attendant.
- 1:27:56Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:27:56Jimmy Akin: and he he tells the priest, if you really want to help me, use the two loaves of bread to say mass.
- 1:28:02Jimmy Akin: And if you come back and I'm not here, that'll tell you I made it into heaven.
- 1:28:06Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:28:07Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:28:07Jimmy Akin: so that's what the priest does, and the bath attendant
- 1:28:10Jimmy Akin: goes to heaven.
- 1:28:12Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:28:13Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:28:13Jimmy Akin: you
- 1:28:15Jimmy Akin: this
- 1:28:15Jimmy Akin: involves a manifestation
- 1:28:19Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:28:19Jimmy Akin: a
- 1:28:20Jimmy Akin: human soul that's departed
- 1:28:23Jimmy Akin: that seems to be experiencing time the way we do on earth
- 1:28:29Jimmy Akin: You know, because he's able to interact with the priest
- 1:28:32Jimmy Akin: in normal, real time
- 1:28:34Jimmy Akin: without the priest even realizing
- 1:28:36Jimmy Akin: he's talking to a purgatorial soul.
- 1:28:39Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:28:39Jimmy Akin: even
- 1:28:40Jimmy Akin: though he's able to manifest in real time, that doesn't mean that he wasn't instantly purified upon his death.
- 1:28:48Jimmy Akin: It's just that experience of instant purification is somehow mapped on
- 1:28:54Jimmy Akin: to the flow of time here in this world.
- 1:28:57Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:28:59Jimmy Akin: you
- 1:28:59Jimmy Akin: could
- 1:29:00Jimmy Akin: look at the experience of this soul and others like them and say, well, time must work the same way.
- 1:29:06Jimmy Akin: in the afterlife than it does here, you could say that.
- 1:29:10Jimmy Akin: You know,
- 1:29:10Jimmy Akin: you could cite this as evidence of that, but it wouldn't be conclusive evidence, because even if God chooses
- 1:29:18Jimmy Akin: to purify people in an instant,
- 1:29:21Jimmy Akin: that doesn't prevent God from
- 1:29:23Jimmy Akin: allowing that instant
- 1:29:25Jimmy Akin: purification to manifest here on earth in a way that we would perceive it in terms of time.
- 1:29:33Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:29:33Jimmy Akin: we have to be careful about how we map these two different domains on each other, as Samantha Carter would say.
- 1:29:41Cy Kellett: Uh Mark, thank you very much for the question.
- 1:29:44Cy Kellett: That uh brings us uh to the break.
- 1:29:46Cy Kellett: I
- 1:29:46Cy Kellett: s
- 1:29:47Cy Kellett: the
- 1:29:48Cy Kellett: time
- 1:29:48Cy Kellett: is hard to think about.
- 1:29:49Cy Kellett: It's
- 1:29:50Cy Kellett: a time, eternity, all that, it's hard.
- 1:29:52Cy Kellett: It's
- 1:29:52Cy Kellett: very very abstract.
- 1:29:53Jimmy Akin: You know what St.
- 1:29:54Jimmy Akin: Augustine said about time.
- 1:29:57Jimmy Akin: He
- 1:29:57Jimmy Akin: he actually wrote a good bit about this.
- 1:30:00Jimmy Akin: He said
- 1:30:00Jimmy Akin: as
- 1:30:01Jimmy Akin: As long as nobody asks me what time is, I know exactly what it is.
- 1:30:05Jimmy Akin: But as soon as someone asks me, I don't know what to say.
- 1:30:08Cy Kellett: Yeah
- 1:30:09Cy Kellett: Yeah, I
- 1:30:10Cy Kellett: well I
- 1:30:10Cy Kellett: then I'm as smart as Aquinas.
- 1:30:12Cy Kellett: I
- 1:30:12Cy Kellett: I mean uh uh
- 1:30:13Cy Kellett: Augustine.
- 1:30:15Cy Kellett: Yes.
- 1:30:15Cy Kellett: I have achieved the exact status he achieved on this.
- 1:30:19Cy Kellett: All right, we'll take a very quick break.
- 1:30:20Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:30:21Cy Kellett: Jimmy Akin, our guest, good thing too, because it's weird
- 1:30:24Cy Kellett: questions with Jimmy Akin on Catholic Answers
- 1:30:26Cy Kellett: Live
- 1:30:26Cy Kellett: Welcome back.
- 1:30:27Cy Kellett: Kathy Cancer
- 1:30:28Cy Kellett: 's Live.
- 1:30:29Cy Kellett: I actually looked up the name Joey Bag of Donuts
- 1:30:31Cy Kellett: during the break
- 1:30:32Cy Kellett: and it comes from
- 1:30:34Cy Kellett: Billy Crystal in the movie
- 1:30:36Cy Kellett: Analyze This.
- 1:30:37Cy Kellett: And then it was in the T V
- 1:30:39Cy Kellett: show
- 1:30:39Cy Kellett: Um
- 1:30:40Cy Kellett: the
- 1:30:41Cy Kellett: Sopranos.
- 1:30:42Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:30:42Cy Kellett: I guess the
- 1:30:43Cy Kellett: I guess it's supposed to be
- 1:30:44Cy Kellett: you know, like the
- 1:30:45Cy Kellett: all the gangsters have
- 1:30:46Cy Kellett: f
- 1:30:46Cy Kellett: you know names like
- 1:30:48Cy Kellett: like
- 1:30:48Cy Kellett: Bobby Two
- 1:30:49Cy Kellett: shoes
- 1:30:49Cy Kellett: or
- 1:30:49Cy Kellett: or I
- 1:30:50Cy Kellett: guess I guess that's not one.
- 1:30:51Cy Kellett: I don't like
- 1:30:51Cy Kellett: okay I can't I'm not good at coming up with gangster names.
- 1:30:54Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:30:54Cy Kellett: but
- 1:30:54Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:30:55Jimmy Akin: you're such a blubby
- 1:30:56Jimmy Akin: two
- 1:30:56Jimmy Akin: shoes.
- 1:30:57Cy Kellett: I know that sounded so dumb.
- 1:30:59Cy Kellett: That sounded
- 1:31:00Cy Kellett: that was the dumbest gangster name
- 1:31:01Cy Kellett: ever.
- 1:31:02Cy Kellett: So I guess like uh Billy Crystal
- 1:31:04Cy Kellett: uh
- 1:31:04Cy Kellett: was like
- 1:31:04Cy Kellett: uh Joey Bag of Donuts.
- 1:31:06Cy Kellett: Like that's a a typical uh
- 1:31:07Cy Kellett: gangster name.
- 1:31:08Jimmy Akin: Mobster name.
- 1:31:09Cy Kellett: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:31:10Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:31:11Cy Kellett: all right.
- 1:31:11Cy Kellett: So this
- 1:31:11Cy Kellett: this c
- 1:31:12Cy Kellett: this question comes from Joey Bag of Donuts
- 1:31:13Cy Kellett: seventy six and thank you.
- 1:31:15Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:31:15Cy Kellett: I hope you uh
- 1:31:16Cy Kellett: will have a weird question every time so I get to say your name on every show.
- 1:31:20Cy Kellett: If a vampire is a cop,
- 1:31:22Cy Kellett: first
- 1:31:22Cy Kellett: of all, we have a movie right there.
- 1:31:27Jimmy Akin: Vampire cop
- 1:31:28Jimmy Akin: sounds totally 1980s.
- 1:31:30Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 1:31:30Cy Kellett: Vampire cop
- 1:31:31Cy Kellett: with a talking car, I hope
- 1:31:33Cy Kellett: If a vampire is a cop
- 1:31:36Cy Kellett: and I don't invite him or her in, would
- 1:31:39Cy Kellett: he or she
- 1:31:40Cy Kellett: be able to serve a search warrant on my home?
- 1:31:45Jimmy Akin: Okay, so
- 1:31:47Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:31:48Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:31:49Jimmy Akin: the search warrant
- 1:31:51Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:31:51Jimmy Akin: so a search warrant is a warrant issued by a court
- 1:31:56Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:31:56Jimmy Akin: allow
- 1:31:57Jimmy Akin: a particular
- 1:31:59Jimmy Akin: To allow a search to occur on a person
- 1:32:03Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:32:03Jimmy Akin: property
- 1:32:05Jimmy Akin: to look
- 1:32:06Jimmy Akin: for specific kinds of evidence.
- 1:32:08Jimmy Akin: This is an exception
- 1:32:10Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:32:11Jimmy Akin: what's
- 1:32:12Jimmy Akin: provided for in the amend
- 1:32:14Jimmy Akin: in the in the Bill
- 1:32:15Jimmy Akin: of Rights, in the first
- 1:32:16Jimmy Akin: ten
- 1:32:16Jimmy Akin: amend
- 1:32:17Jimmy Akin: amendments to the Constitution, it guarantees the right of the public to be free from
- 1:32:23Jimmy Akin: improper searches and seizures of their, you know, their persons, their effects, their papers, and so forth.
- 1:32:30Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:32:30Jimmy Akin: you have a general right
- 1:32:33Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:32:33Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:32:34Jimmy Akin: not have your stuff searched.
- 1:32:37Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:32:38Jimmy Akin: government loves to search stuff
- 1:32:40Jimmy Akin: and so
- 1:32:41Jimmy Akin: they're
- 1:32:42Jimmy Akin: there
- 1:32:42Jimmy Akin: are exceptions.
- 1:32:44Jimmy Akin: And what the police can do is go to a judge
- 1:32:48Jimmy Akin: and if they have
- 1:32:49Jimmy Akin: like
- 1:32:49Jimmy Akin: evidence that a crime
- 1:32:52Jimmy Akin: may
- 1:32:52Jimmy Akin: have been committed
- 1:32:53Jimmy Akin: or something like that
- 1:32:55Jimmy Akin: and they need to find that evidence, then the judge can write them a a warrant.
- 1:33:00Jimmy Akin: and allow them to search
- 1:33:02Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:33:03Jimmy Akin: you know
- 1:33:04Jimmy Akin: a given location uh
- 1:33:05Jimmy Akin: wherever they think the evidence is
- 1:33:07Jimmy Akin: like we've got evidence that there's a drug
- 1:33:11Jimmy Akin: lab
- 1:33:11Jimmy Akin: in this house
- 1:33:13Jimmy Akin: And so they can be given a search warrant to look for in this house
- 1:33:17Jimmy Akin: for that drug
- 1:33:18Jimmy Akin: lab.
- 1:33:19Jimmy Akin: Now that does not allow them
- 1:33:21Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:33:22Jimmy Akin: uh search for anything.
- 1:33:26Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:33:27Jimmy Akin: it would allow them to search for the drug
- 1:33:30Jimmy Akin: lab
- 1:33:30Jimmy Akin: and limited other things
- 1:33:32Jimmy Akin: connected with the search.
- 1:33:34Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:33:35Jimmy Akin: now
- 1:33:36Jimmy Akin: I've
- 1:33:37Jimmy Akin: I've done a good bit of research
- 1:33:40Jimmy Akin: on
- 1:33:41Jimmy Akin: on this type of situation
- 1:33:43Jimmy Akin: not with the vampire element added
- 1:33:45Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:33:46Jimmy Akin: about searches in general
- 1:33:48Jimmy Akin: And I'm not a lawyer, so I can't give legal advice, but I can tell you what I would do
- 1:33:55Jimmy Akin: if uh
- 1:33:55Jimmy Akin: if
- 1:33:57Jimmy Akin: law enforcement showed up at my door
- 1:34:00Jimmy Akin: for any
- 1:34:00Jimmy Akin: reason
- 1:34:01Jimmy Akin: and wanted to
- 1:34:03Jimmy Akin: come in and take a look around, my answer would
- 1:34:07Jimmy Akin: be
- 1:34:08Jimmy Akin: where's your search warrant?
- 1:34:10Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:34:10Jimmy Akin: without a search warrant they have no right to look.
- 1:34:14Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:34:15Jimmy Akin: any
- 1:34:15Jimmy Akin: any
- 1:34:16Jimmy Akin: any
- 1:34:16Jimmy Akin: allowing them in to look around if they don't have a search warrant
- 1:34:20Jimmy Akin: is consensual, meaning
- 1:34:23Jimmy Akin: you have to consent
- 1:34:24Jimmy Akin: or they can't do it.
- 1:34:26Jimmy Akin: In fact, I won't even open the door for 'em
- 1:34:29Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:34:30Jimmy Akin: any
- 1:34:31Jimmy Akin: I've got a glass door
- 1:34:32Jimmy Akin: and they can look in through the glass door and if they see something in the background that they can construe
- 1:34:39Jimmy Akin: as evidence of a crime, even though it's not, they
- 1:34:43Jimmy Akin: can then say, oh, we need to search about that.
- 1:34:46Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:34:46Jimmy Akin: this is called the plain
- 1:34:48Jimmy Akin: view doctrine
- 1:34:49Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:34:50Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:34:50Jimmy Akin: that's one reason
- 1:34:52Jimmy Akin: they're not coming into my house without a search warrant.
- 1:34:54Jimmy Akin: They're not even looking into my house without a search warrant
- 1:34:57Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:34:58Jimmy Akin: police are trained.
- 1:35:00Jimmy Akin: to look at things and think
- 1:35:02Jimmy Akin: how can I construe this as evidence of a crime even if it's not
- 1:35:06Jimmy Akin: so I can broaden my fishing expedition.
- 1:35:10Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:35:11Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:35:12Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:35:13Jimmy Akin: I
- 1:35:13Jimmy Akin: I would I
- 1:35:14Jimmy Akin: I would say
- 1:35:15Jimmy Akin: no search warrant, you're not coming in, I'm not even opening the door
- 1:35:19Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:35:20Jimmy Akin: having said that, if they got a search warrant, well then you gotta let them
- 1:35:24Jimmy Akin: in.
- 1:35:25Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:35:25Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:35:26Jimmy Akin: now let's put the vampire element back in.
- 1:35:28Jimmy Akin: If a vampire is a cop
- 1:35:31Jimmy Akin: And I don't invite him or her in, would he or she
- 1:35:35Jimmy Akin: be able to serve a search warrant on my home?
- 1:35:39Jimmy Akin: Well
- 1:35:40Jimmy Akin: service of a warrant is done with a person.
- 1:35:44Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:35:45Jimmy Akin: I I need to correct uh
- 1:35:47Jimmy Akin: or modify how this is phrased.
- 1:35:50Jimmy Akin: They could serve a search warrant to you.
- 1:35:54Jimmy Akin: and then
- 1:35:55Jimmy Akin: search your home, but they've got to use the warrant with
- 1:35:59Jimmy Akin: they use warrants with people.
- 1:36:01Jimmy Akin: This shows you
- 1:36:02Jimmy Akin: I am warranted in coming in.
- 1:36:05Jimmy Akin: to search your home, but they don't give it to the house.
- 1:36:08Jimmy Akin: They give it to a person who's at the house.
- 1:36:11Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:36:12Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:36:13Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:36:14Jimmy Akin: in
- 1:36:15Jimmy Akin: some
- 1:36:16Jimmy Akin: vampire lore, you have to invite a vampire in before they're allowed to enter.
- 1:36:23Jimmy Akin: This comes from some
- 1:36:24Jimmy Akin: uh Eastern European
- 1:36:26Jimmy Akin: vampire mythology
- 1:36:28Jimmy Akin: and it's not in all
- 1:36:31Jimmy Akin: vampire mythology.
- 1:36:33Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:36:34Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:36:35Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:36:36Jimmy Akin: that's a complication right there
- 1:36:38Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:36:39Jimmy Akin: if
- 1:36:40Jimmy Akin: this is a piece of mistaken vampire mythology
- 1:36:43Jimmy Akin: or if it only applies to some kinds of vampires and not others
- 1:36:48Jimmy Akin: then
- 1:36:48Jimmy Akin: there would be ways that a vampire could come in without your consent.
- 1:36:53Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:36:53Jimmy Akin: assuming that they can't come in without your consent, um
- 1:36:58Jimmy Akin: Th
- 1:36:58Jimmy Akin: that's not necessarily going to end the problem
- 1:37:02Jimmy Akin: because if a vampire
- 1:37:03Jimmy Akin: cop
- 1:37:03Jimmy Akin: shows up at your door and says, I've got a search warrant,
- 1:37:08Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:37:08Jimmy Akin: and you don't consent
- 1:37:10Jimmy Akin: to let him in, well, you might not even be there.
- 1:37:16Jimmy Akin: Someone else might come to the door.
- 1:37:17Jimmy Akin: You may not be home, and they can still come to your door and say, I've got a search warrant to search this place.
- 1:37:24Jimmy Akin: They don't necessarily have to give you the warrant.
- 1:37:28Jimmy Akin: They could give it to someone else who's in the home
- 1:37:31Jimmy Akin: and that person
- 1:37:32Jimmy Akin: could
- 1:37:33Jimmy Akin: potentially give them consent.
- 1:37:35Jimmy Akin: And so it wouldn't necessarily stop the problem.
- 1:37:38Jimmy Akin: However, if you have
- 1:37:41Jimmy Akin: A
- 1:37:42Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:37:42Jimmy Akin: if you have a vampire cop at the door
- 1:37:45Jimmy Akin: and they're the kind of vampire that needs consent to enter
- 1:37:49Jimmy Akin: and you and anybody else refuses
- 1:37:52Jimmy Akin: to give them that consent, then the mere fact
- 1:37:55Jimmy Akin: they have a piece of paper that legally allows them to enter
- 1:37:59Jimmy Akin: is not gonna overcome the metaphysical
- 1:38:02Jimmy Akin: barrier.
- 1:38:04Jimmy Akin: to them entering.
- 1:38:05Jimmy Akin: And so you could stop them, but what would probably happen then
- 1:38:09Jimmy Akin: is they would just go get a cop who's not a vampire.
- 1:38:13Jimmy Akin: and come
- 1:38:14Jimmy Akin: back.
- 1:38:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:38:16Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:38:16Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:38:17Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:38:17Jimmy Akin: deliver the search warrant either to you or someone else from your home
- 1:38:22Jimmy Akin: and just come on in.
- 1:38:24Jimmy Akin: Or
- 1:38:25Jimmy Akin: They might get a warrant for
- 1:38:28Jimmy Akin: to raid the house
- 1:38:29Jimmy Akin: without even delivering notification first.
- 1:38:32Jimmy Akin: There are like
- 1:38:33Jimmy Akin: no knock raids
- 1:38:34Jimmy Akin: and so forth, which
- 1:38:36Jimmy Akin: have
- 1:38:37Jimmy Akin: been horribly abused and have led to numerous deaths of civilians.
- 1:38:41Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:38:43Jimmy Akin: but there are other
- 1:38:44Jimmy Akin: options
- 1:38:45Jimmy Akin: even if you could stop
- 1:38:46Jimmy Akin: an individual vampire cop from coming in.
- 1:38:51Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:38:51Jimmy Akin: that's a general sketch of the situation, but
- 1:38:55Jimmy Akin: whether the cop
- 1:38:56Jimmy Akin: is a vampire or not, insist
- 1:38:58Jimmy Akin: on a search warrant before you have any further interaction.
- 1:39:03Jimmy Akin: with
- 1:39:04Jimmy Akin: police at your home.
- 1:39:05Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:39:06Jimmy Akin: That would be
- 1:39:07Jimmy Akin: that would be what I would do in any event.
- 1:39:09Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:39:09Cy Kellett: thank you for the question, Joy
- 1:39:11Cy Kellett: Bag of Donuts.
- 1:39:11Cy Kellett: I think Vampire Cop is a real show.
- 1:39:13Cy Kellett: I
- 1:39:14Cy Kellett: thought about it a little bit.
- 1:39:15Cy Kellett: His police dog is a werewolf.
- 1:39:18Cy Kellett: Uh
- 1:39:18Cy Kellett: nobody knows the dog is a werewolf.
- 1:39:20Cy Kellett: I I think this has got potential, Joey bag of donuts.
- 1:39:23Cy Kellett: Give me a call.
- 1:39:24Cy Kellett: All right.
- 1:39:25Jimmy Akin: Also
- 1:39:25Jimmy Akin: also this is good advice, even though I can't give legal advice.
- 1:39:28Jimmy Akin: It's good advice for a mobster, you know
- 1:39:32Cy Kellett: Especially because your name is Joey Bag of Donuts.
- 1:39:34Cy Kellett: Don't let the cops in, Joey.
- 1:39:36Cy Kellett: Clearly stuff's going on in there.
- 1:39:37Cy Kellett: I've heard Gia.
- 1:39:39Cy Kellett: This is from, oh I'm sorry, Lydia
- 1:39:40Cy Kellett: B.
- 1:39:40Cy Kellett: 13.
- 1:39:41Cy Kellett: I've heard geologists say that all dirt is fossilized dinosaurs and/or dinosaur matter, meaning they're waste and such.
- 1:39:48Cy Kellett: If this is true, when God made Adam,
- 1:39:51Cy Kellett: Would the dirt have been this dino matter or was he made with predyno
- 1:39:55Cy Kellett: dirt?
- 1:39:56Jimmy Akin: Okay, so
- 1:39:57Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:39:58Jimmy Akin: The
- 1:39:59Jimmy Akin: this is assuming that the account in Genesis is to be taken literally, that
- 1:40:05Jimmy Akin: God literally took a bunch of dirt and fashioned
- 1:40:09Jimmy Akin: um, you know, Adam's body out of it and then animated it.
- 1:40:14Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:40:15Jimmy Akin: that is not
- 1:40:16Jimmy Akin: the only interpretation.
- 1:40:17Jimmy Akin: The way the
- 1:40:18Jimmy Akin: the way recent popes have looked at this, it's just an affirmation that
- 1:40:23Jimmy Akin: God used matter to make man, that this is an affirmation of we're not pure spirits as humans.
- 1:40:29Jimmy Akin: We also
- 1:40:30Jimmy Akin: have
- 1:40:31Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:40:31Jimmy Akin: commonality with the material realm.
- 1:40:34Jimmy Akin: So we shouldn't take the
- 1:40:36Jimmy Akin: made out of
- 1:40:37Jimmy Akin: dirt bit literally.
- 1:40:39Jimmy Akin: Having said that, if you do take it literally, there's actually
- 1:40:43Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:40:44Jimmy Akin: There's actually some Jewish legend
- 1:40:47Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:40:48Jimmy Akin: this
- 1:40:49Jimmy Akin: where
- 1:40:49Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:40:50Jimmy Akin: God
- 1:40:50Jimmy Akin: made Adam out of this, you know, fairly refined earth, and then he made the first
- 1:40:58Jimmy Akin: Eve.
- 1:40:59Jimmy Akin: out
- 1:40:59Jimmy Akin: of uh
- 1:41:00Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:41:00Jimmy Akin: actually he made Lilith
- 1:41:02Jimmy Akin: out of the same earth he made Adam
- 1:41:05Jimmy Akin: and she was
- 1:41:07Jimmy Akin: too
- 1:41:08Jimmy Akin: equal to Adam
- 1:41:09Jimmy Akin: and she ended up not being a suitable mate
- 1:41:13Jimmy Akin: and so then God made
- 1:41:14Jimmy Akin: 'cause she was made out of exactly the same dirt.
- 1:41:17Jimmy Akin: So then
- 1:41:18Jimmy Akin: God
- 1:41:18Jimmy Akin: got some
- 1:41:19Jimmy Akin: lower quality dirt like mud
- 1:41:21Jimmy Akin: and made the first Eve, and she was too inferior to Adam
- 1:41:26Jimmy Akin: and was not a good mate.
- 1:41:28Jimmy Akin: So then God makes the second Eve out of
- 1:41:30Jimmy Akin: out of Adam's rib.
- 1:41:32Jimmy Akin: So you even have speculation in Jewish mythology
- 1:41:35Jimmy Akin: about what kind of dirt you get made out of
- 1:41:38Jimmy Akin: having an impact on what kind of human beings we ended up with.
- 1:41:42Jimmy Akin: Having said that,
- 1:41:44Jimmy Akin: dirt is not
- 1:41:46Jimmy Akin: fossilized dinosaur or fossilized dinosaur matter.
- 1:41:50Jimmy Akin: What dirt is, is
- 1:41:52Jimmy Akin: rock
- 1:41:54Jimmy Akin: that has been
- 1:41:55Jimmy Akin: weathered down into tiny, tiny particles.
- 1:41:59Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:41:59Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:42:00Jimmy Akin: and as
- 1:42:01Jimmy Akin: part of this, it's been merged with
- 1:42:04Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:42:04Jimmy Akin: biological matter
- 1:42:07Jimmy Akin: that has decayed.
- 1:42:09Jimmy Akin: It's not just dinosaurs.
- 1:42:11Jimmy Akin: In fact, dinosaurs
- 1:42:12Jimmy Akin: would be a very minuscule component of it.
- 1:42:15Jimmy Akin: It would be much more
- 1:42:17Jimmy Akin: microbes, microscopic organisms.
- 1:42:20Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:42:20Jimmy Akin: they
- 1:42:20Jimmy Akin: would be most of the organic matter that's in the dirt, but fundamentally the dirt is primarily rocks and minerals that have been weathered down.
- 1:42:30Cy Kellett: Thank you, Lydia.
- 1:42:31Cy Kellett: Thank you everybody who uh gave us their weird questions.
- 1:42:33Cy Kellett: We'll do it again.
- 1:42:34Cy Kellett: Next month
- 1:42:35Cy Kellett: with Jimmy Akin.
- 1:42:37Spidermail bumper: Look out!
- 1:42:39Spidermail bumper: Here comes the spider
- 1:42:41Spidermail bumper: ghost!
- 1:42:47Dom Bettinelli: Now we turn to our mysterious feedback brought to us by our feedback coordinator, Rob Leonardi, and this feedback is coming from our episode 430 on Buck Nelson, the Ozark Spaceman.
- 1:42:59Dom Bettinelli: And the first bit of feedback is a voicemail from Anonymous that you didn't leave your name.
- 1:43:04Dom Bettinelli: But
- 1:43:04Dom Bettinelli: folks, be sure if you can
- 1:43:06Dom Bettinelli: leave your name on your audio voicemail.
- 1:43:08Dom Bettinelli: And here it is.
- 1:43:10Listener voicemail: Hey
- 1:43:10Listener voicemail: Jimmy, I was just listening to episode
- 1:43:14Listener voicemail: 430 on um Buck Nelson, the Ozark Spaceman, and
- 1:43:19Listener voicemail: Um, I was just thinking a little bit about his theories
- 1:43:23Listener voicemail: and
- 1:43:23Listener voicemail: um
- 1:43:23Listener voicemail: wondering if you know we play a little devil's advocate
- 1:43:27Listener voicemail: that maybe um
- 1:43:29Listener voicemail: there's some aspect of it that's uh connected to the
- 1:43:32Listener voicemail: um
- 1:43:33Listener voicemail: concepts of
- 1:43:35Listener voicemail: uh
- 1:43:35Listener voicemail: uh uh
- 1:43:36Listener voicemail: C.
- 1:43:36Listener voicemail: S.
- 1:43:36Listener voicemail: Lewis's um space
- 1:43:38Listener voicemail: trilogy
- 1:43:38Listener voicemail: and that maybe there's something
- 1:43:40Listener voicemail: where
- 1:43:41Listener voicemail: these
- 1:43:41Listener voicemail: are things that we um you know it's the
- 1:43:43Listener voicemail: plans
- 1:43:44Listener voicemail: before they've um been introduced to uh
- 1:43:47Listener voicemail: original sin
- 1:43:48Listener voicemail: in some way, shape, or form.
- 1:43:49Listener voicemail: and maybe it's even in some alternative
- 1:43:52Listener voicemail: um
- 1:43:52Listener voicemail: reality
- 1:43:53Listener voicemail: or prior to
- 1:43:55Listener voicemail: all of the
- 1:43:56Listener voicemail: um
- 1:43:56Listener voicemail: our
- 1:43:57Listener voicemail: our solar system being the way it is today that
- 1:44:00Listener voicemail: in some time
- 1:44:01Listener voicemail: where
- 1:44:02Listener voicemail: It was before everything was the way it is today and those
- 1:44:06Listener voicemail: planets he saw at some other point in time um
- 1:44:09Listener voicemail: or in some other
- 1:44:10Listener voicemail: um
- 1:44:11Listener voicemail: dimension.
- 1:44:12Listener voicemail: So
- 1:44:13Listener voicemail: just thought maybe that might be a a fun way to look at it and see if uh
- 1:44:17Listener voicemail: you
- 1:44:17Listener voicemail: had any um thoughts on that
- 1:44:20Jimmy Akin: Well, um
- 1:44:22Jimmy Akin: certainly
- 1:44:23Jimmy Akin: the way
- 1:44:24Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:44:24Jimmy Akin: many contactees, not just Buck Nelson, but others, you know, like George Damski
- 1:44:30Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:44:30Jimmy Akin: Some of the others we'll talk about in future episodes.
- 1:44:33Jimmy Akin: The way that they
- 1:44:35Jimmy Akin: depicted the Space Brothers
- 1:44:38Jimmy Akin: They are more
- 1:44:39Jimmy Akin: spiritually enlightened than we earth humans
- 1:44:42Jimmy Akin: are.
- 1:44:43Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:44:44Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:44:45Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:44:45Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:44:46Jimmy Akin: could
- 1:44:47Jimmy Akin: signify or correspond to an unfallen
- 1:44:50Jimmy Akin: status.
- 1:44:51Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:44:52Jimmy Akin: there's at least some traction for that idea there.
- 1:44:55Jimmy Akin: When it comes to the scientific reality
- 1:44:58Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:44:59Jimmy Akin: their
- 1:45:00Jimmy Akin: claims.
- 1:45:02Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:45:03Jimmy Akin: one
- 1:45:04Jimmy Akin: can
- 1:45:04Jimmy Akin: just for fun
- 1:45:05Jimmy Akin: imagine oh maybe it's an alternate Venus
- 1:45:08Jimmy Akin: or an ancient Venus
- 1:45:10Jimmy Akin: or a future Venus.
- 1:45:13Jimmy Akin: But
- 1:45:13Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:45:14Jimmy Akin: or
- 1:45:15Jimmy Akin: and there were other possibilities that were suggested by the contactees themselves when it was pointed out that their
- 1:45:22Jimmy Akin: their
- 1:45:23Jimmy Akin: claims were flatly scientifically inaccurate.
- 1:45:27Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:45:28Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:45:29Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:45:30Jimmy Akin: The truth is that
- 1:45:32Jimmy Akin: there's no credibility here.
- 1:45:34Jimmy Akin: So these are just fun stories, and if part of making the story fun
- 1:45:39Jimmy Akin: for you involves imagining such things, well, you're welcome to do so
- 1:45:44Dom Bettinelli: Our next feedback comes from uh our patron, Anna H
- 1:45:47Dom Bettinelli: on Patreon, who writes, it's really convenient
- 1:45:51Dom Bettinelli: one of the aliens is also named Buck.
- 1:45:54Jimmy Akin: Yeah, um
- 1:45:55Jimmy Akin: it is.
- 1:45:56Jimmy Akin: It's unusually coincidental.
- 1:45:59Jimmy Akin: One could also view it as
- 1:46:01Jimmy Akin: not convenient, but um
- 1:46:03Jimmy Akin: as an element of
- 1:46:05Jimmy Akin: Introducing additional confusion as well, since you've got to keep Buck and Bucky separate in the story.
- 1:46:11Dom Bettinelli: And then
- 1:46:12Dom Bettinelli: N
- 1:46:12Dom Bettinelli: Raleigh on Spotify writes
- 1:46:15Dom Bettinelli: May God have mercy on Buck Nelson's soul.
- 1:46:17Dom Bettinelli: What a deplorable legacy to leave behind.
- 1:46:20Jimmy Akin: Yeah, I agree.
- 1:46:22Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:46:22Jimmy Akin: I think uh all of the contactees, but
- 1:46:26Jimmy Akin: Incl including
- 1:46:27Jimmy Akin: especially Buck Nelson
- 1:46:28Jimmy Akin: need
- 1:46:29Jimmy Akin: God's mercy, just like we all do.
- 1:46:32Dom Bettinelli: Then
- 1:46:33Dom Bettinelli: Sean
- 1:46:33Dom Bettinelli: on Facebook
- 1:46:34Dom Bettinelli: writes
- 1:46:35Dom Bettinelli: This was an enjoyable episode.
- 1:46:36Dom Bettinelli: I was disappointed that the segregation angle introduced early on didn't turn out to be more benign.
- 1:46:42Dom Bettinelli: On the other hand, when Jimmy mentioned that later space probes to Mars and Venus showed the story to be scientifically impossible
- 1:46:48Dom Bettinelli: I joked to myself that it was a
- 1:46:50Dom Bettinelli: shame the government had to spend all that money to disprove Buck's lie.
- 1:46:54Dom Bettinelli: Also, I was really surprised that when Jimmy later said he didn't know what a schoolboy sandwich was, he didn't think that it might be Uter
- 1:47:01Dom Bettinelli: or a sloppy jimbo from the Simpsons
- 1:47:03Dom Bettinelli: Halloween
- 1:47:04Dom Bettinelli: episode.
- 1:47:05Jimmy Akin: Well, there
- 1:47:05Jimmy Akin: have been a lot of Simpsons
- 1:47:07Jimmy Akin: Halloween episodes, and I've seen a bunch of 'em, but I'm not
- 1:47:11Jimmy Akin: having
- 1:47:11Jimmy Akin: one occur to me that
- 1:47:13Jimmy Akin: would explain
- 1:47:16Jimmy Akin: what
- 1:47:16Jimmy Akin: a schoolboy sandwich is.
- 1:47:18Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:47:18Jimmy Akin: although
- 1:47:19Jimmy Akin: if
- 1:47:20Jimmy Akin: given the context of Simpsons
- 1:47:22Jimmy Akin: Halloween episode, I assume that would be a sandwich
- 1:47:26Jimmy Akin: that has
- 1:47:27Jimmy Akin: real authentic schoolboy in it.
- 1:47:29Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:47:30Jimmy Akin: I suspect that is not what
- 1:47:32Jimmy Akin: the uh
- 1:47:33Jimmy Akin: the papers in southern Missouri were advertising in their school lunch menu
- 1:47:39Jimmy Akin: And I definitely agree that uh
- 1:47:42Jimmy Akin: with Sean
- 1:47:43Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:47:43Jimmy Akin: the segregation angle in this was an ugly
- 1:47:47Jimmy Akin: element.
- 1:47:48Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:47:49Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:47:50Jimmy Akin: and that's part of why I wanted to cover the story, to point out, look, I mean this
- 1:47:56Jimmy Akin: this
- 1:47:57Jimmy Akin: ridiculous
- 1:47:58Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:48:00Jimmy Akin: ideology
- 1:48:01Jimmy Akin: got into everything, including this area
- 1:48:03Jimmy Akin: in twentieth century culture
- 1:48:06Dom Bettinelli: Our next feedback comes from Bon Adventure the
- 1:48:09Dom Bettinelli: Duns
- 1:48:09Dom Bettinelli: on Discord, who writes, I will never understand why all of the alien contactees have such boring stories.
- 1:48:15Dom Bettinelli: Why are the aliens always just people?
- 1:48:17Dom Bettinelli: Life on Venus is absurd already.
- 1:48:19Dom Bettinelli: Why claim it's just regular dudes living there instead of something specifically adapted to the extreme environment?
- 1:48:25Dom Bettinelli: I want my aliens to be alien.
- 1:48:28Jimmy Akin: Well, I want my aliens to be alien
- 1:48:30Jimmy Akin: too, and that's why I like science fiction
- 1:48:34Jimmy Akin: like Larry Niven
- 1:48:35Jimmy Akin: that
- 1:48:36Jimmy Akin: does
- 1:48:36Jimmy Akin: at least
- 1:48:37Jimmy Akin: make the attempt.
- 1:48:39Jimmy Akin: to have
- 1:48:40Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:48:40Jimmy Akin: really
- 1:48:41Jimmy Akin: alien aliens.
- 1:48:42Jimmy Akin: And of course there's a lot of science fiction like that.
- 1:48:44Jimmy Akin: And some of it's even gotten into the movies recently, like the uh
- 1:48:48Jimmy Akin: the movie a few years ago, Contact based on the short story by Ted Chiang.
- 1:48:53Jimmy Akin: where they had the heptopods, which were very
- 1:48:57Jimmy Akin: alien
- 1:48:58Jimmy Akin: aliens.
- 1:48:59Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:49:00Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:49:01Jimmy Akin: I appreciate that
- 1:49:02Jimmy Akin: too.
- 1:49:03Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:49:03Jimmy Akin: but
- 1:49:04Jimmy Akin: uh you know the contactees
- 1:49:06Jimmy Akin: weren't exactly the sharpest knives in the drawer and may have suffered from a case of limited imagination syndrome.
- 1:49:14Dom Bettinelli: I want my aliens to be Rocky from Project Hail
- 1:49:17Dom Bettinelli: Mary.
- 1:49:17Dom Bettinelli: That's uh
- 1:49:19Dom Bettinelli: our
- 1:49:19Dom Bettinelli: next feedback comes from Zion
- 1:49:21Dom Bettinelli: Blade
- 1:49:21Dom Bettinelli: on YouTube who writes
- 1:49:23Dom Bettinelli: I agree that racism is evil and that segregation can be implemented because of racism, but I wonder if other factors could be the cause of segregation, such as voluntary preference.
- 1:49:33Dom Bettinelli: It's too bad that Buck isn't alive to have this point of view from the aliens
- 1:49:37Dom Bettinelli: interrogated.
- 1:49:38Dom Bettinelli: For instance, would
- 1:49:39Dom Bettinelli: Buck say that the aliens are racist?
- 1:49:42Dom Bettinelli: Would Buck say that the aliens just prefer to be among their own kind, and so they do voluntary segregation?
- 1:49:48Dom Bettinelli: How does this segregation conflict with the twelve laws of God?
- 1:49:52Dom Bettinelli: Would Buck say that the aliens, while segregated, are still equal to each other?
- 1:49:56Dom Bettinelli: I'm less hesitant to jump to racism as the cause.
- 1:49:59Dom Bettinelli: After reading so much science fiction over the years, you could come up with just about any reason why aliens might choose to segregate without racism having to be anywhere close to the reason for it.
- 1:50:10Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:50:11Jimmy Akin: what Zion
- 1:50:12Jimmy Akin: Blade
- 1:50:12Jimmy Akin: is trying to do is disentangle
- 1:50:15Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:50:15Jimmy Akin: the issue of segregation
- 1:50:18Jimmy Akin: from
- 1:50:19Jimmy Akin: racism.
- 1:50:20Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:50:21Jimmy Akin: You know, that's something that can be done in principle.
- 1:50:25Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:50:26Jimmy Akin: it's hard to do in specific cases like Buck Nelson
- 1:50:31Jimmy Akin: because he grew up in a specific
- 1:50:34Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:50:35Jimmy Akin: historical period in a his
- 1:50:37Jimmy Akin: in a specific country
- 1:50:39Jimmy Akin: and
- 1:50:40Jimmy Akin: it's obvious there are historical influences
- 1:50:44Jimmy Akin: from that time and place
- 1:50:45Jimmy Akin: on his views.
- 1:50:46Jimmy Akin: And so that makes it hard to pull these apart.
- 1:50:49Jimmy Akin: If we're treating this as an intellectual issue, though, could they be pulled apart?
- 1:50:55Jimmy Akin: Well, um
- 1:50:57Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:50:57Jimmy Akin: their
- 1:50:59Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:51:00Jimmy Akin: there
- 1:51:01Jimmy Akin: can
- 1:51:01Jimmy Akin: be
- 1:51:02Jimmy Akin: voluntary preferences that don't imply anything negative
- 1:51:07Jimmy Akin: about others
- 1:51:09Jimmy Akin: Um, and there are
- 1:51:10Jimmy Akin: some interesting illustrations of that.
- 1:51:12Jimmy Akin: For example, uh
- 1:51:14Jimmy Akin: back when the uh
- 1:51:15Jimmy Akin: late nineteen sixties
- 1:51:17Jimmy Akin: movie
- 1:51:17Jimmy Akin: Planet of the Apes
- 1:51:18Jimmy Akin: was being filmed and you had all these actors in ape makeup
- 1:51:23Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:51:23Jimmy Akin: they were either
- 1:51:25Jimmy Akin: they had either chimpanzee makeup, orangutan
- 1:51:28Jimmy Akin: makeup, or gorilla
- 1:51:29Jimmy Akin: makeup.
- 1:51:30Jimmy Akin: Even though they're all wearing makeup and they can't see, you know, what
- 1:51:35Jimmy Akin: skin color or anything like that they had underneath the makeup.
- 1:51:39Jimmy Akin: Um, it was noted by people on the set
- 1:51:42Jimmy Akin: that like at lunchtime when everyone went to the craft table to get lunch and then they sat down to eat afterwards
- 1:51:48Jimmy Akin: All of the chimpanzees would sit with other chimpanzees, and all of the orangutans
- 1:51:54Jimmy Akin: would sit with other orangutans, and all of the gorillas would sit with other gorillas.
- 1:51:58Jimmy Akin: And this isn't even their real face.
- 1:52:01Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:52:01Jimmy Akin: they're still preferentially sorting themselves
- 1:52:04Jimmy Akin: based on how they
- 1:52:06Jimmy Akin: understand they're projecting their appearance into the world.
- 1:52:09Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:52:10Jimmy Akin: That kind of
- 1:52:11Jimmy Akin: voluntary
- 1:52:13Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:52:13Jimmy Akin: self-sorting
- 1:52:15Jimmy Akin: wouldn't imply anything negative
- 1:52:18Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:52:19Jimmy Akin: you know, the other actors, um, they're all just playing parts.
- 1:52:23Jimmy Akin: They they just happen to be dressed a certain way and, you know, with
- 1:52:27Jimmy Akin: certain makeup on and they sort themselves on that basis.
- 1:52:31Jimmy Akin: Didn't matter whether the actor was white or black
- 1:52:33Jimmy Akin: or Asian or whatever.
- 1:52:35Jimmy Akin: Um, they all did this.
- 1:52:37Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:52:38Jimmy Akin: that would
- 1:52:39Jimmy Akin: indicate that
- 1:52:40Jimmy Akin: and they did it unconsciously without even realizing
- 1:52:43Jimmy Akin: it, at least as far as the reports go.
- 1:52:46Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:52:46Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:52:48Jimmy Akin: Certainly there was no effort to say, hey, let's all
- 1:52:51Jimmy Akin: only
- 1:52:52Jimmy Akin: all and only chimpanzees sit at this table
- 1:52:55Jimmy Akin: You know, it was just something that happened spontaneously.
- 1:52:58Jimmy Akin: So
- 1:52:59Jimmy Akin: I can imagine
- 1:53:00Jimmy Akin: some degree of
- 1:53:02Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:53:03Jimmy Akin: of
- 1:53:04Jimmy Akin: self-selection
- 1:53:05Jimmy Akin: happening that wouldn't be bad
- 1:53:07Jimmy Akin: because it doesn't imply anything negative.
- 1:53:10Jimmy Akin: um, you know, and
- 1:53:12Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:53:13Jimmy Akin: about
- 1:53:13Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:53:14Jimmy Akin: people in other groups.
- 1:53:16Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 1:53:16Jimmy Akin: the real
- 1:53:17Jimmy Akin: key is
- 1:53:19Jimmy Akin: whether
- 1:53:21Jimmy Akin: you're harboring negative views
- 1:53:24Jimmy Akin: about people in other groups.
- 1:53:25Jimmy Akin: And that's where it would conflict with the 12 laws of God, as Buck articulated them, because
- 1:53:31Jimmy Akin: included in the 12 laws of God were love your
- 1:53:34Jimmy Akin: neighbor.
- 1:53:35Jimmy Akin: And that's the important thing.
- 1:53:37Jimmy Akin: It doesn't matter if a group of black people
- 1:53:41Jimmy Akin: or Asian people
- 1:53:42Jimmy Akin: or white people want to hang out on a given evening, you know.
- 1:53:47Jimmy Akin: Um
- 1:53:48Jimmy Akin: the
- 1:53:48Jimmy Akin: the real
- 1:53:50Jimmy Akin: test, that's a matter of indifference, the real test
- 1:53:53Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:53:54Jimmy Akin: do you harbor
- 1:53:55Jimmy Akin: negative views about
- 1:53:57Jimmy Akin: other groups
- 1:53:58Jimmy Akin: and does it impact your decisions?
- 1:54:01Jimmy Akin: because
- 1:54:01Jimmy Akin: we are called to love everybody equally, regardless of what they look like cosmetically.
- 1:54:09Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:54:10Jimmy Akin: And so
- 1:54:11Jimmy Akin: voluntary
- 1:54:12Jimmy Akin: self-selection
- 1:54:14Jimmy Akin: and, you know, forms of sorting that don't
- 1:54:18Jimmy Akin: imply
- 1:54:19Jimmy Akin: anything negative about others would in principle
- 1:54:22Jimmy Akin: be okay, but in a fallen world like this, and especially given the
- 1:54:28Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:54:28Jimmy Akin: fractious history of American race relations
- 1:54:32Jimmy Akin: and the oppression that has been involved, it's really hard to pull those apart in practice, even if there is a distinction in principle
- 1:54:41Dom Bettinelli: And our next feedback comes from 1001011011010.
- 1:54:47Dom Bettinelli: That's binary if you convert it to decimal.
- 1:54:49Jimmy Akin: It's spoken like a true binar.
- 1:54:51Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 1:54:51Dom Bettinelli: If you convert it to decimal, it's 4826
- 1:54:53Dom Bettinelli: on YouTube, price
- 1:54:55Dom Bettinelli: Segregation isn't necessarily racist.
- 1:54:58Dom Bettinelli: Notice he didn't say this
- 1:54:59Dom Bettinelli: Martians
- 1:54:59Dom Bettinelli: segregated by race alone, but by nationality as well.
- 1:55:03Dom Bettinelli: In advanced civilization
- 1:55:05Dom Bettinelli: may prefer cultural uniformity due to shared values and norms, and they could do so without finding one race as superior to another.
- 1:55:12Dom Bettinelli: They don't even need to find one Martian culture as superior to another, theoretically, if they value uniformity.
- 1:55:18Dom Bettinelli: It's easy to imagine it in the setting of America at the time, and to be fair, legally segregation was supposed to be separate but equal, despite how
- 1:55:26Dom Bettinelli: unequal it apparently became in practice.
- 1:55:28Dom Bettinelli: But when I hear it, I think of earlier times when people quite simply were, for the most part, divided by geography.
- 1:55:34Dom Bettinelli: What if another planet simply stayed that way as the people advanced, instead of colonizing and mixing?
- 1:55:41Jimmy Akin: Well, again, this is
- 1:55:43Jimmy Akin: this is an effort to try to pull apart the issue of segregation from racism.
- 1:55:49Jimmy Akin: And I acknowledge you can do that in principle, but it's really hard to do in practice.
- 1:55:55Jimmy Akin: Theoretically, just like in American history, you can say separate but equal, but what ends up happening in a fallen world
- 1:56:02Jimmy Akin: is
- 1:56:03Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:56:04Jimmy Akin: separate does not end up being equal.
- 1:56:07Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:56:08Jimmy Akin: so
- 1:56:09Jimmy Akin: um
- 1:56:10Jimmy Akin: it's important
- 1:56:11Jimmy Akin: to counter our
- 1:56:13Jimmy Akin: fallen
- 1:56:13Jimmy Akin: tendencies by
- 1:56:15Jimmy Akin: making the effort to love
- 1:56:17Jimmy Akin: everybody.
- 1:56:18Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:56:19Jimmy Akin: that means
- 1:56:20Jimmy Akin: adopting a conscious orientation of
- 1:56:23Jimmy Akin: I'm not going to care what
- 1:56:25Jimmy Akin: someone is like cosmetically.
- 1:56:27Jimmy Akin: They are a fellow child of God
- 1:56:29Jimmy Akin: and I don't need to be separated from them
- 1:56:32Jimmy Akin: While it's possible
- 1:56:34Jimmy Akin: in principle
- 1:56:35Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:56:36Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:56:36Jimmy Akin: to imagine
- 1:56:37Jimmy Akin: a form of segregation where nobody is disadvantaged by that.
- 1:56:43Jimmy Akin: Um, you know, so everybody really is equal.
- 1:56:47Jimmy Akin: W
- 1:56:48Jimmy Akin: every
- 1:56:49Jimmy Akin: every decision
- 1:56:51Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:56:52Jimmy Akin: to
- 1:56:53Jimmy Akin: do
- 1:56:54Jimmy Akin: some kind of segregation.
- 1:56:56Jimmy Akin: And I'm not talking about
- 1:56:57Jimmy Akin: natural segregation that happens because some people live on one continent and other people live on another continent and they're living in an age before
- 1:57:06Jimmy Akin: Intercontinental travel, I mean that's unavoidable.
- 1:57:09Jimmy Akin: But if people are making choices to segregate
- 1:57:14Jimmy Akin: There's a cost
- 1:57:15Jimmy Akin: to every choice.
- 1:57:17Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:57:17Jimmy Akin: why
- 1:57:18Jimmy Akin: would
- 1:57:19Jimmy Akin: one
- 1:57:20Jimmy Akin: care, you know, if other people
- 1:57:23Jimmy Akin: are really
- 1:57:25Jimmy Akin: fellow children of God
- 1:57:26Jimmy Akin: who are just as valuable
- 1:57:28Jimmy Akin: in the idea
- 1:57:29Jimmy Akin: in the eyes of Jesus Christ as as
- 1:57:32Jimmy Akin: as you are
- 1:57:34Jimmy Akin: Why would you want to be separate from them?
- 1:57:37Jimmy Akin: You know, that just doesn't make any sense to me.
- 1:57:39Jimmy Akin: It doesn't I'm
- 1:57:40Jimmy Akin: I can imagine it in principle, but
- 1:57:43Jimmy Akin: But why?
- 1:57:45Jimmy Akin: It seems like a a
- 1:57:47Jimmy Akin: an impulse that is more likely not to grow out of a philosophical abstraction
- 1:57:52Jimmy Akin: and what could be logically possible, but something that's more likely to grow out of
- 1:57:58Jimmy Akin: a
- 1:57:59Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:58:00Jimmy Akin: a
- 1:58:01Jimmy Akin: devaluing
- 1:58:02Jimmy Akin: of other people
- 1:58:03Jimmy Akin: or a viewing other people
- 1:58:05Jimmy Akin: as threats
- 1:58:06Jimmy Akin: or somehow bad.
- 1:58:08Jimmy Akin: And that's an impulse that we need to fight.
- 1:58:12Dom Bettinelli: All right.
- 1:58:12Dom Bettinelli: Thank you everyone for your feedback.
- 1:58:14Dom Bettinelli: And now it's time to hear from you.
- 1:58:16Dom Bettinelli: What are your theories about the listeners' weird questions that Jimmy answered today?
- 1:58:20Dom Bettinelli: Let us know by visiting SQPN.
- 1:58:23Dom Bettinelli: com or the Jimmy Akin's
- 1:58:24Dom Bettinelli: Mysterious World Facebook page, sending us an email to feedback at mysterious.
- 1:58:29Dom Bettinelli: fm, sending a tweet to at MYS
- 1:58:32Dom Bettinelli: underscore
- 1:58:32Dom Bettinelli: world.
- 1:58:33Dom Bettinelli: Visiting the StarQuest
- 1:58:34Dom Bettinelli: Discord community at SQPN.
- 1:58:37Dom Bettinelli: com slash
- 1:58:37Dom Bettinelli: Discord
- 1:58:38Dom Bettinelli: or calling our mysterious feedback line at 619-738-4515.
- 1:58:44Dom Bettinelli: That's
- 1:58:44Dom Bettinelli: 619
- 1:58:45Dom Bettinelli: 738-4515.
- 1:58:48Jimmy Akin: Special thanks to Oasis Studio 7 for the video and animation work in this episode.
- 1:58:53Jimmy Akin: Check it out by going to my YouTube
- 1:58:56Jimmy Akin: page.
- 1:58:56Jimmy Akin: youtube.
- 1:58:57Jimmy Akin: com slash jimmyakin where I have not only Mysterious World but all kinds of other videos there for you
- 1:59:04Jimmy Akin: and uh while you're there
- 1:59:05Jimmy Akin: Help me fight the algorithm and get to the goal of 200,000 subscribers
- 1:59:11Jimmy Akin: by liking, commenting, uh
- 1:59:13Jimmy Akin: writing reviews, sharing the videos, hyping them, and
- 1:59:17Jimmy Akin: of course.
- 1:59:17Jimmy Akin: .
- 1:59:17Jimmy Akin: Subscribe in
- 1:59:18Jimmy Akin: and when you subscribe
- 1:59:20Jimmy Akin: tell the bell notification that if it doesn't notify you every time I have a new video
- 1:59:25Jimmy Akin: you're going to confine it to a small rural farm in the southern Missouri
- 1:59:31Jimmy Akin: Ozarks, just like Buck Nelson, where it doesn't have any city water, and it's going to have to rely on rainwater that may run out in the summer months.
- 1:59:40Jimmy Akin: if it doesn't keep you notified.
- 1:59:43Dom Bettinelli: That's very specific.
- 1:59:45Dom Bettinelli: Alright, Jimmy, what's our next episode going to be about
- 1:59:48Jimmy Akin: Well, uh, this is the last episode of our October
- 1:59:53Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:59:53Jimmy Akin: 2026
- 1:59:54Jimmy Akin: Weird Questions Month, and that means we're also up to Halloween, so have
- 1:59:59Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:59:59Jimmy Akin: a happy Halloween
- 2:00:01Jimmy Akin: and also a great All Souls and All Saints
- 2:00:04Jimmy Akin: Days.
- 2:00:05Jimmy Akin: Um
- 2:00:06Jimmy Akin: the schedule calls for our next episode
- 2:00:10Jimmy Akin: looking at what
- 2:00:11Jimmy Akin: demons are.
- 2:00:13Jimmy Akin: Now
- 2:00:14Jimmy Akin: It's very clear
- 2:00:16Jimmy Akin: in the way the term demon is used today in official Catholic theology
- 2:00:21Jimmy Akin: that it refers to fallen angels.
- 2:00:24Jimmy Akin: And so
- 2:00:24Jimmy Akin: when you read a modern church document
- 2:00:27Jimmy Akin: like the Catechism of the Catholic Church, when you see the word demon, it means fallen angel.
- 2:00:32Jimmy Akin: But the history of the term is actually more complex than that, and we'll be looking at some of that complexity, including how it may impact biblical passages
- 2:00:43Jimmy Akin: next episode.
- 2:00:45Dom Bettinelli: Very good.
- 2:00:46Dom Bettinelli: Folks, be sure to follow Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, TuneIn, your favorite podcast app, or at Jimmy's YouTube
- 2:00:54Dom Bettinelli: channel where you should hit that bell to get notifications.
- 2:00:57Dom Bettinelli: Check out our new designs for Mysterious World T-shirts, mugs, and more
- 2:01:01Dom Bettinelli: in our merchandise shop at sqpn.
- 2:01:03Dom Bettinelli: com slash merch.
- 2:01:05Dom Bettinelli: And you'll find links to Jimmy's resources from our discussion on our show notes at mysterious.
- 2:01:10Dom Bettinelli: fm slash 441.
- 2:01:12Dom Bettinelli: And remember, to help us continue to produce the podcast, please visit givemysterious.
- 2:01:18Dom Bettinelli: fm
- 2:01:20Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World is also brought to you in part by The Grady
- 2:01:25Dom Bettinelli: Group, a Catholic company bringing financial clarity to their clients across the United States.
- 2:01:30Dom Bettinelli: using safe money options to produce reasonable rates of return for their clients.
- 2:01:35Dom Bettinelli: Find them at Gradygroup.
- 2:01:38Dom Bettinelli: us
- 2:01:39Dom Bettinelli: And by
- 2:01:40Dom Bettinelli: Rosary Army, featuring award-winning Catholic podcasts, Rosary
- 2:01:45Dom Bettinelli: Resources, videos, and the School of Mary online
- 2:01:48Dom Bettinelli: community prayer
- 2:01:49Dom Bettinelli: and learning platform.
- 2:01:51Dom Bettinelli: Learn how to make them, pray them, and give them away while growing.
- 2:01:54Dom Bettinelli: Growing in your faith at rosaryarmy.
- 2:01:57Dom Bettinelli: com
- 2:01:57Dom Bettinelli: and schoolofmary.
- 2:01:59Dom Bettinelli: com
- 2:02:02Dom Bettinelli: Until next time, Jimmy Akin, thank you for exploring with us our mysterious world.
- 2:02:07Jimmy Akin: Thank you, Dom.
- 2:02:08Dom Bettinelli: And once again, I'm Dom Bettinelli.
- 2:02:10Dom Bettinelli: Thank you for listening to Jimmy Akin's Mysterious World on StarQuest.