Latest / MyRye.com Conversations with Doug French / Carolina Johnson, former Rye City Councilmember on Flooding in Rye
Transcript
- MyRye.com: Welcome to the MyRye.com podcast, Conversations with Doug French. I'm your host, Doug French, former mayor of the City of Rye. with this podcast, we will speak with the city leaders, ⁓ leaders, federal government, state government, local county, you name it. We'll speak with all the officials that help shape the decisions that are impacting Rye, as well as community leaders, ⁓ that you the resident get an understanding of how you can get involved and what the issues are. And in today's conversation, It's with Carolina Johnson, former council member, the topic is flooding in Rye. So Carolina, welcome to MyRye.com. Carolina Johnson: Thanks for having me, Doug. Glad to be here. MyRye.com: And so when you look at flooding, we went through a period of ⁓ 20 year period, from ⁓ 1980s the early ⁓ 2000s, ⁓ there not one flood. And then last 20 or so years, we've had five or six floods since then. So in your perspective, are the top two or three projects that are in the queue short term and the top two or three longer term that will reduce flood to have some ⁓ better impact for Rye? Carolina Johnson: Well, one of the very first ones that I would focus on and keep the focus on is measuring the flow of water on the Blind Brook from the Bowman Dam to about Highland Avenue. And that is important because that'll help us program the sluice gate at the top of Bowman Dam. So what that means is we're trying to regulate the flow of water coming down during an event. We need to have, they initially said about 10 years of data to be able to program the sluice gate. We're about a year, maybe four or five. And I know that there's been some issues with some of the recording the flow of water. I hope those have been resolved and need funding every year to allocate funding to keep the monitoring going. Once we the sluice gate, will be part of the solution. There will never be a complete 100 % solution because we can't control the amount of rain that comes down at any specific event. that, I would go for ⁓ much larger project, which would be ⁓ berms ⁓ were proposed by Ramble, the last serious detailed engineering and hydraulic study that was done. and they proposed berms around the SUNY Purchase area. One of the main findings that we discovered in the last study was discrepancy in altitude between the White Plains ⁓ and Rye. sit at sea level and the airport about 400 ⁓ feet above sea So that creates an enormous current. water ⁓ down. ⁓ MyRye.com: And I don't think people realize that, that the airport is 400 feet above where we are here in Rye so we're really in the valley. Carolina Johnson: Correct. So we are really at the end of the watershed and water wants to just splatter down. They call that the sinuosity ⁓ the brook or the river or water course. so it's very important that we understand ⁓ that that at SUNY Purchase which is really right below the airport, would provide us with ⁓ a a mechanism to slow down the water, not to pool it, not to create another dam, not at all. It's just to slow down how fast the water comes down because of the in elevations and the steep slope really that there is. That be very beneficial in terms of life saving ⁓ or saving opportunities. MyRye.com: And so those two, the sluice gate and the berms at SUNY Purchase, they seem like those can... Go ahead. Carolina Johnson: The other, those would be for flood prevention, say, or mitigation. There's flood proofing. ⁓ the flood proofing would be in the form of taking infrastructure and moving it out of harm's way. And in case, I'm referring to the Locust Avenue Bridge, for example. It's one of the main arteries in town. It's right near, it's right on the, firehouse and that passage way to all way down to the sound would alleviate some of ⁓ bottleneck that created. But also is a main artery for Rye. So we need to make sure that it's going to stay serviceable. The other, there are other Go ahead. MyRye.com: But these go in. Well, I was going say that those projects seem to be in the near term, right? So you think that we could accomplish those in the next couple of years? Carolina Johnson: Well, so we got a grant for five million dollars to replace the Locust Avenue Bridge when we did ballpark analysis of what it would cost is ten million dollars. So where do we get the other five million from? That's a big question. That's where bigger partners, other partners come in. MyRye.com: the berms mean that seems something that could be feasible. Carolina Johnson: The berms is something that is doable except for we don't have access to the land. The land is owned by the SUNY corporation. It's not a corporation, but it's the SUNY system. And long we don't get permits from them, ⁓ we can't the land. ⁓ And that's project that would not be as expensive ⁓ as some projects. So that's ⁓ a more, it's just basically moving dirt around. MyRye.com: So in the idea of the comprehensive plan, flooding being one of the central issues in Rye it would seem that should make sure that we have advocates that are supporting those three initiatives that you mentioned as priorities with our regional partners. Carolina Johnson: The comprehensive plan is a really nice idea, Doug, but I would caution people that the last comprehensive plan had already mandated. It's the comprehensive plan is not an enforceable document. It's sort of like the best ideas we have for what we want to accomplish for our town, but it's really not enforceable. So the last comprehensive plan had a series of floodgates to be put at Oakland Beach Avenue and other choke points and like flow points never happened. ⁓ this is, ⁓ a good exercise and we should do it and ⁓ through it. But your expectations need to be managed because there's really nothing Enforceable that comes out of it so we can say we should keep an eye on the ball and But really it's in the nitty-gritty. It's in every budget that goes through the council every year It is maintaining our lobbyists at the state level and at the federal level So we get the monies because we do not have the budget We do not we cannot come up with a budget to do a simple job like it is elevating the Locust Avenue bridge takes $10 million, takes a lot of time from city staff to go through all the paperwork. These are mountains and mountains of applications and paperwork that you have to go through and somebody has to manage that project. We don't have the capacity at City Hall to do that and do that in multiple areas at the same time. So we would have to balloon the city hall staff and budget just to cover the big infrastructure needs that we have. MyRye.com: Right. if you were to put your hat on, ⁓ started out as a Rye resident impacted by flooding. You built the whole advocacy network with a few folks to really push for flood solutions. ⁓ And you sat on the city council. If you ⁓ back in advocacy role, what are the things that residents can do to ⁓ expedite some these, maybe outside of the comprehensive plan, but really the flood plan to get that ramped up? Carolina Johnson: I think that people should stay educated on what they can do themselves because we all have a responsibility. Climate change is a serious thing. Climate change is very difficult to predict when and where it's going to hit. We know we're prone to flooding. But say, for example, the New York Times climate reporter wrote many years ago that ⁓ North Carolina was the safest place in the United to live ⁓ because was the safest in terms of ⁓ flood disasters climate disasters. And look what happened to it a couple of years ago. It is really difficult to know that going to be in a safe area, whether it is fires or earthquakes or flooding. We all to be prepared. So I think you prepare yourself by knowing where you are, knowing what the flood maps say, ⁓ knowing where house is and knowing what you can do. So let's say this is extremely expensive, but Some people have no other option but to elevate their homes. is something that the City of Rye, very ⁓ ago, determined ⁓ something that ⁓ doable. Each individual can safeguard their property by elevating their homes and flood proofing their homes. So I think that's an incredible way of looking at things and that new structures all have to be compliant, ⁓ compliant. ⁓ even though I would say sometimes the bar for FEMA ⁓ not the right bar, sometimes it's a little low. ⁓ you need to stay educated. And that's, I think, your ⁓ ⁓ tool. MyRye.com: Yeah, because I think when the Army Corps was looking at the cost-benefit analysis, the cost for people to raise is a lot lower than some of the upstream development or retention they looked at. Carolina Johnson: Correct. The cost benefit analysis we always lose on. It doesn't matter. And collectively, in 2007, we lost about $85 million worth of property damage ⁓ we racked up in Rye. ⁓ ⁓ cost of an infrastructure project as as an Army Corps of Engineers would plan ⁓ is the hundreds of millions of dollars, where the city ⁓ just cannot it. MyRye.com: So we've got these three short-term projects. What's longer term that the city should be focused on? Carolina Johnson: I mean, there are zoning, I think, is the really important you have that's enforceable, where you can really impact the most. ⁓ So. Although, mean, we have a code that was mostly said in the 60s. We have a town that we have multiple neighborhoods and houses that were built way before we had a zoning code. So it's a hodgepodge of things that is kind of difficult to manage. we are, people may not know, but New York State has an 800,000 unit deficit. housing units. ⁓ And that is, that's incredible. You know, people need to live mostly downstate, close to the city where the jobs are. Maybe that'll change with AI and people can move around the state a little bit more. But this is the, the concentration, the critical mass is downstate. So where we are, if you looked at the census numbers from the 1990s to now, in 1990, we had just under 15,000 people living in Rye. Right now we have over 16,000 16,000 and a half more or less It's not a huge increase. It really isn't. So Rye has been able to manage that. And then we have the push and pull between who want to come into the city to have the young family join the school system and people who want to downsize and they need a smaller place. so there's an interesting that we haven't mastered. We haven't really... found the right median of stock that we need to have for our housing. So there's a lot of pressure on both sides, right? Some people want to maintain things as they are, not build anything else because everything else will create flooding. But then we also need to open our doors. We need to have more people because we need to house more people. There is ⁓ an incredible demand for people to have housing. So we have to juggle all things and I think zoning is the best way where you can really have enforcing, you can enforce the laws on the books. mean that's ⁓ would be my number one priority. MyRye.com: And that sits with the City Council to change the law then. Carolina Johnson: Correct. It is the City Council responsible. The Zoning Board of Appeals can only provide relief for those people who have a project and they need to the impact ⁓ ⁓ the goals are for these application and what the neighborhood ⁓ But the City, the Board of cannot just ⁓ somebody, ⁓ think that's right. No, you have to go by what's acceptable in terms of the law, what's applicable, ⁓ what can you deny and ⁓ can you not deny. MyRye.com: So when you look at the comprehensive plan, there are lot of components to that comprehensive plan residential development, central business district, business development, environmental protection, flood control, coastal resources, community facilities. All of those have some element or impact flooding in some form or fashion. So as part of the comprehensive plan process, there should be a very distinct flood policy or flood mitigation policy in each one of these categories as we start to lay out the future. Carolina Johnson: It would be an interesting... perspective to hold a comprehensive plan, but the comprehensive plan, you will see that there's a lot of pressure from other from other areas. and so if they always keep flooding in mind, that would be great. They probably wouldn't be able to arrive where they need to arrive. Because it's ⁓ one you can only have one lens, right? You have to integrate all the lenses. So something is always that's why I go back to yourself and see what you can do to safeguard your property because ⁓ will be ⁓ best option. MyRye.com: And what about regionally? So flooding is a regional problem. What are the development projects that are impacting us ⁓ you see where we probably need to have ⁓ louder voice or influence in some of what's happening around us, like the airport, ⁓ the Brunswick development? What are some of those projects? Carolina Johnson: So there are projects all around us that impact us. They all around us. And the city of has been active in the this is we have New York is a, you can't, ⁓ it's a state rule, right? It's a, that's the term it. And so you cannot on any other on your neighboring towns. So in terms of traffic, terms of flooding, we cannot impose Port Chester and them stop developing. You've grown from ⁓ a thousand people to now tens of thousands of people living in your We can't tell them what to do or not to do. ⁓ So that very, very important. ⁓ And I think that unless the county really takes over, it's going to be impossible because we do have great partnerships with Rye Brook ⁓ Mamaroneck. Harrison and Port Chester are not as partnerable they have their own agendas and they have their own growth that they're they need to commit to and are working towards and it's very difficult ⁓ county really comes in and zones everyone in terms of watershed communities. MyRye.com: Well, that's interesting. saw ⁓ LISWIC was part of a regional planning, but I think that that's mostly on Long Island Sound versus some of the Brook. There should be a comparable that's looking at brook and stream flooding across county with all the different regional partners. Carolina Johnson: Yes, there's some, I mean, there should be one. Yes, Liswick is more, you know, determining the health of the sound, right? And we're trying to not so much clean the water that's coming down, but slow it from coming down or detain it or, you know, yeah, slow it down. So... ⁓ MyRye.com: Right, right. ⁓ What about the airport? Have they done everything that they should be doing to retain water? ⁓ Carolina Johnson: No, the airport should have, they have three scheduled detention basins. And Ida, we went on a tour and we a lot of phragmites in detention basin A. Detention B was pretty good, solid, working. Detention C was never built. So it would be great for the airport go ahead and clean out that detention base in A, maintain B, and build up C. Years ago when the folks from downstream is old New York City ⁓ water from Rye Lake, ⁓ diverted all the runoff from the airport from Rye Lake to go into the Blind Brook. so we need a little bit more mitigation there for sure. School also built ⁓ in enormous facilities that now impact SUNY Purchase and downstream from there. And from there Harrison has allowed a lot of building but like I said it you know they're not going to building when doesn't break their laws ⁓ so MyRye.com: Right, right. So it sounds like Rye has done all that it can do in terms of ideas and solutions and we really need action from our regional partners or some teeth behind that. Who are some of the key people? Is it that we still have the Flood Advisory Committee that's looking at these issues, building out our flood plan? Carolina Johnson: Well, the Flood Advisory Committee is what it is, right? It's advisory. So you're only called upon whenever the council wants an opinion from you. It's not that the Flood Advisory, and I just stepped down from it, it's not like the Flood Advisory Committee can take in ⁓ way, shape, or form. They can make a recommendation, ⁓ only ⁓ the council has said, please look into these. It's not like, yeah. MyRye.com: So who has the flood plan? If I were to say, where's the Rye flood plan and how are we tracking against that plan? that the city planner? Is that the mayor? Is it the city manager? Who's keeping track of ⁓ projects that you just mentioned and making sure we're getting funding and progress and making it a priority? Carolina Johnson: I think the city manager's best position to keep track on it, obviously, needs funding ⁓ by the city council ⁓ go after, you know, these lobbyists or that lobbyist. And that's the way the world works. And that's what we need to be doing. We need money from the state to accomplish these or that project. ⁓ we need to go after that. the grant, the three million grant we got a few years back. MyRye.com: my concern is there are a lot of new families that have moved into Rye. The flooding impact at a personal and emotional level is, and financially, it's tough. And when that happens, the next flood happens, the city has to be prepared with answers on what's gonna happen when, where do we need funding? And so we show some progress because some of the projects you mentioned, are 15 years old right you started getting involved 15 20 years old so we have to balance government time versus resident need for action and sounds like ⁓ making the right Progress, but not fast enough Carolina Johnson: Right and it just means that you know the on the council need to have the eye on the ball and just ⁓ pushing for the ⁓ studies are going on right now ⁓ so that we can ⁓ program the gate. The sluice gate was put in 15 years ago and it's not operational so when we have that that'll be amazing but ⁓ we MyRye.com: Yeah, I cut the ribbon. Carolina Johnson: on the flooding commission, we didn't know that this loose gate was not operational. We assumed it was. Then later we learned it wasn't. But we have no authority over anyone to ask for accountability. It's the council. MyRye.com: Right. Right. Yeah. And that's why this podcast is about speaking with local, city, state, federal, county leaders, community leaders, because a lot of the people in the council come and go, but there should be a plan that's tracked and made progress against. we jump to our last segment, I just want to... Let our listeners know if you have a or a topic that would like on ⁓ the podcast, Conversations with Doug French, shoot me an email at french at myrye.com and we have our crack staff consider it. So ⁓ Carolina, this been very educational and I want to move to our final segment, which is about one question and one sentence, okay? So if you could keep it brief to one sentence. ⁓ first thing I would say is why Rye Carolina Johnson: Why Rye because it's a beautiful community, community, great schools, great people, ⁓ proximity the city. So not just one reason, but many, and just best neighbors in the whole wide world. MyRye.com: And was the one insight on the council that you would share with yourself ⁓ a resident on flooding? Because you've worn three hats. Carolina Johnson: . I say stay educated on how things work. People have no idea the difference between the Planning Commission from the Board of Architectural Review, from the Zoning Board of Appeals. They don't understand how these works. So if you have a minute to peruse the website and see what each one of them does it's not saying, ⁓ planning, they should be looking at these or that. No, the Planning Commission has a very defined role on the projects they can look at or that need an application to go through their process. So stay educated. The website, the city website, is full of information. MyRye.com: your Rye pet peeve? Carolina Johnson: that we have garbage pick up twice a week. We don't need it. ⁓ my ⁓ my edible, my ⁓ And so I only need one, once week. ⁓ my gosh. It's like some people think this is a resort. It's not. MyRye.com: we moved here it was three days a week. Three days. In the late 80s. If you were to bump into our Congressman George Latimer or Ken Jenkins or Josh what is the one thing that you would say? Carolina Johnson: please help us get those berms at the SUNY Purchase level. We need the money and we need the permits to move forward with the berms so we can alleviate serious flooding we have. Upstream mitigation, I still remain our focus. of the MyRye.com: Good to know. Carolina Johnson: choke holds are important, but that one is the most important. I mean, obviously getting the culvert under or the Rye Metro North would be great, but we know that's going to take, I don't know, centuries to happen. MyRye.com: Do you have a topic or a guest that you would suggest for this podcast? Carolina Johnson: I would chat with Steve Otis. He knows a lot about flooding ⁓ he knows ⁓ to get the money. And we need him to stay focused on Rye. ⁓ MyRye.com: And what is the Carolina Johnson brand today if people want to connect with you? Carolina Johnson: Send me a postcard. MyRye.com: you're in Miami. Carolina Johnson: Yes, I'm in Miami part of the time. MyRye.com: Okay, well, Carolina it was a real pleasure and I want to thank you and I want to make sure I thank all of our listeners for listening to the MyRye.com podcast, Conversations with Doug French. You can find more local news and full episode transcripts at MyRye.com. If you found this conversation helpful, please follow or subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And with that, Carolina thank you again and we'll see you all next time. Carolina Johnson: Thanks for having me.