Latest / Automotive State of The Union / $1.4B of Carvana Stock, Transparency Gap Closing, Dual IHOP-Applebees
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] All right, fresh new week, Monday, November- Yes... 11th. We're all kind of rocking and ready to go today. We're talking about- We're ready...
- 0:06a big Carvana stock sale, transparency glap- gap, closing with consumers, and here comes- Everywhere I go. People really wanna know...
- 0:13an IHOP/Applebee's collab Who I be, and who I be The one you've been waiting for Instead of wanting something that's a repeat This is... Oh, I got so many comments on this one, and it- it's gonna get sideways.
- 0:24I- I can feel it... I think. What is that? Monday's gonna get sideways. Oh. The ramp is gonna happen by the end of this show. I know. If you, if you're in for it, stay for it- Yeah... 'cause it's gonna be good.
- 0:31[laughs] We're here. We're here for this. We're here for this. Uh, we got a few things we wanna talk about. There is an ASOTU Edge webinar this Friday. We had to postpone it. It was gonna be last week.
- 0:39Now it's this week. Uh, you can go to asotu.com, and we are talking about auditing your 2024 ad performance with our friends at Stream Companies. This is part, uh, part one of a two-part webinar.
- 0:50First we're gonna be, like, walk you through, "Hey, here's some great ways to analyze your spend and your effectiveness." Part two is going to be, like, how do we plan to improve on that?
- 0:58So this is a very timely and effective webinar with our friends at Stream Companies. Uh, we got Suby Ghosh, Drew Deal, Sarah West. We got the, the A team out here, gonna walk us through some practical things.
- 1:09So make sure you sign up- Yep... and join that. Um, we also, this Wednesday, mark it on your calendar. It's this week now, not next week, not t- More Than Cars, episode four, is premiering on- Yes...
- 1:21Wednesday, November 13th at 1:00 PM or 2:00 PM. E- what, what time is it? 1:00 PM Eastern? One- 1:00 PM Eastern... 1:00 PM Eastern. So just the best way to watch that with us is to just join us on LinkedIn.
- 1:34Oh, it's the most fun. So if you go to LinkedIn, search ASOTU, click on Events- Yes... and then you'll see it right there. You can just join up, and, you know, we're in the comments. We're watching. We, we finally...
- 1:43People think we re- you know, edit these, like, way in advance. Like, no. [laughs] We don't. We're working hard around here, and last week we finally- That's right... got the final edit locked. The full drop. Oh.
- 1:52And boy, is it awesome. It's good. Yeah. You're gonna love it. Absolutely. And if you've ever- It's a good week... and if you've ever played 8-bit video games, you're gonna love it even more.
- 2:01You have to watch the episode to see what we mean by that. Yep. But, uh, it, it is an episode, I think, that really communicates the fun, the competitive nature, and just the, I don't know, the overall sass.
- 2:10I think a lot of dealerships, uh, a lot of dealerships will see themselves in, in Mohawk. Yeah. Right? Like, I think it's a, it's a very, like, I can see myself in that, right?
- 2:20The competitive nature, all, all of the things going on. Absolutely. And we also don't wanna forget... I probably should've did this at the top of the show. Probably should've led in with this shit. I know.
- 2:27I was about to do it. I'm glad you're doing it. Thank you. You do it. I, we didn't even talk about this- Oh... but I know you're gonna do what I was gonna do. Go ahead. Yeah.
- 2:33We just, like, today is Veterans Day, and especially all across the auto industry, there are so many veterans in the industry. Like, it is...
- 2:41For some reason, it is an industry ripe with veterans across the dealer side, the OEM side, the industry partner side and stuff. Yeah. Hard work, challenge, teamwork, serving the community. I wonder why.
- 2:51[laughs] We know what's necessary. Like, that, that community knows what's necessary, similar to the auto community.
- 2:56And for all the veterans out there that have served our country, and maybe even, uh, that have s- that are still serving our country, right? Yeah.
- 3:03There's a lot of, there's a lot of people in the reserves and, and, and that. Um, just thank you. It's a, it's a, it's a role that probably Paul and I would not ever play, right? Mm-hmm. Um, and so I...
- 3:15It is, it's something that I look to those people and am so grateful because it's something that is not easy to do, um, to leave your families and, and to serve in that way, um, and to see what you've seen.
- 3:27So on this day, know that you are thanked and remembered and, and, and blessed, so. Indeed. And, and one difference between Kyle and I is now I'm so old they don't want me anymore. [laughs] Get, get out.
- 3:41You'll be a strategist. Spea- You'll be a great strategist... speaking of being so old- Stop. Oh, no. It's about time. Oh, boy. Oh, yeah Or should I say old and rich? Old and rich. Old and rich. Ernie Garcia II.
- 3:52So we, a lot of us know Ernie Garcia- Right... III, CEO of Carvana. But the second, his father, founder of, uh, DriveTime and major investor in Carvana, has strategically sold 1.4, get the B ready- Get 'em...
- 4:06billion dollars of Carvana stock since April. Hey, it's about to be a party Oh, that's a lot of money. Benefiting from this rally in the company share price, uh, amidst this amazing restructuring and turnaround.
- 4:19So, uh, Mr. Garcia II, the older guy, has offloaded 10 million shares, transitioning his Class B stock- Wow... into Class A shares for liquidation. He still controls 69.2 million shares. [laughs] A couple two tree.
- 4:33[laughs] Making up the core of his, get this, $17.6 billion fortune. Oh. His last sell-off was in 2021 when shares had peaked then. Um, the stocks rebound from under $4 at 2020.
- 4:46I know a lot of dealers that bought Carvana stock- Oh, they did... honestly, personally. Oh, yeah. Um, and he held it until it's at 240. A lot of them sold at, like, 25 bucks. Like, "I just quadrupled my money," right?
- 4:55Right. Well, um, so, um, yet Sehun, a finance professor at University of Michigan, said, quote, "He might just have other alternatives and other investments, or maybe he expects the stock could fall.
- 5:07It's better to sell early than late." Who knows? But in this article, I don't know what it is, but there's a list of people he is richer than, and it was pretty impressive. [laughs] It is impressive.
- 5:15Look, I'm a, I, I'm gonna go on record. I don't think this stock is dropping. I think used cars are gonna be hot in the next- Mm...
- 5:2412 to 18 months, and Carvana is gonna get a large share of that market, and it's gonna be up to dealers and the whole industry to keep it rolling at the speed that I think the used car industry is going to go.
- 5:37And so I...
- 5:38Like, I'm on the side of, I'm just on the opinionated side that he's just got other things he wants to do with that cash, um, because my guess is Carvana is up and to the right, just like I think the majority of auto dealers are gonna be over the next 12 to 18 months.
- 5:53Interest rates are dropping. Political landscape is changing. There's still a lot of, uh, uh, opportunity in the market from sideline buyers. Yep. Like, it's gonna be fine.
- 6:01And, and anecdotally speaking, just been hearing from a lot of dealers that banks-Are just- Why not?... starting to get more aggressive, right? You're right.
- 6:08And that is a massive recipe for success, especially in used cars. Especially in used cars, and especially when we h- we are still dealing with some leftover negative equity. Yep.
- 6:19And you start to see a little bit of opening- Flexibility... in loan-to-value rates. Absolutely. Yep. Buying a little deeper to those people that are probably more affected by, uh, by upside-down trades.
- 6:29Like, it's gonna be good. What a great time to talk about consumer transparency and trust. Stop. Segway. Time. What a great time. [upbeat music] That is a good segway. Thanks, Ernie.
- 6:38Capital One's 2024 Buying Outlook, this new report highlights the role of trust and transparency in car buying, emphasizing the opportunity for dealers to bridge the digital and in-person experience.
- 6:50That opportunity still exists, apparently.
- 6:5288% of buyers complete at least half of their car buying process in person, which is up 5% from 2023, underscoring the fact that people still like to do things at the dealership.
- 7:02Dealer tools, uh, popular for the early steps, the shopping, research, and all that. However, once it starts to get down and dirty, people like to do the things in the dealership. Uh, digital tools... I'm sorry.
- 7:12Trust is driving loyalty. Buyers more than twice than likely to return to a dealer they say they trust. No surprise there with- Yep... get this, here's the big one.
- 7:22Almost half of them are willing to pay more if they feel secure in the relationship. Absolutely. Holy crap. Holy crap. Um- That's right... half, half are saying, "We'll, we'll give you more money.
- 7:32It doesn't need to be, it doesn't need to be the best price." Nope. How about that? It absolutely doesn't. Uh, here one... Well, we're get- We, we have a graph to put up. Let's put the graph up. Great.
- 7:41Transparency is important. While 73% of dealers see the process as, quote, "very transparent" or completely transparent, only 55% of buyers agree. So here's the graph.
- 7:52It shows from March 2022 all the way through June of 2024. And, uh, basically, what's... I gotta make this bigger on my screen. I'm doing it right now. Uh- Look,
- 8:01the, the story is that over the last three years, it's gone from 40% that, of consumers agree it's transparent, all the way dipping to 27% in July 2022.
- 8:12And then what happened in- And then in, in, in just two months after that, in September of 2022, we had a Sotoucon, and since then, it's been steadily on the rise. [laughs] We're not saying it's the reason.
- 8:24[laughs] Uh- I'm not saying- To where it's 55% now... [laughs] So it's 55%. The gap is closing. Yeah. But there's still a big gap. This is, th- This is what's interesting to me, is that gap doesn't just need to tighten.
- 8:36In my opinion, it actually has to flip, right? Because we've been in a situation where there's not parity between the dealer stance and the consumer stance,
- 8:48in order at, to actually achieve parity, the consumer has to over-believe that the tr- that the process- Over-believe...
- 8:55is so transparent that the dealer is actually trying to catch up to the, to the belief in transparency in order for there to be trust. Oh. Right?
- 9:05That's, that's the vision casting- So you have to literally flip the script... right there. That's vision casting. I'm not saying that we're Batman.
- 9:13[laughs] I'm just saying we've never been seen in the same room at the same time. Yeah, right. I mean, but look, this is what the More Than Cars movement is all about. It's all about.
- 9:23It's telling the truth about car dealers, that they desire deeply to be honest, to be transparent, to serve the community, to be great places to work. All of that adds together into one word, trust. Yep.
- 9:34And the more people trust, the more they're act- It feels dirty saying this, but it's like we're capitalists. We're for-profit. We're being responsible with what we do with those profits. More trust leads to more money.
- 9:46It's just, uh, a cause- Every time... and effect thing, right? Yep. I mean, Brian Bengtsok maybe said this better than anybody, but the reality is this graph, there's a gap. There's a 20% gap.
- 9:57That means 75% of us aren't self-aware, right? Yep. There's a 25% self-awareness gap, and like, we think, "Oh, well, you know, they, we're fully transparent." You, you know- And customers are like, "Eh."
- 10:09You know what I actually think it is? You know what I think it is? What, the gap? It's, the, the gap is actually 73% aren't self-aware. That's a dangerous- Explain that... that's a dangerous thing to say. But, like,
- 10:23I believe that if- Oh, I, I see what you're saying. Yeah, if- Like the 73%, we believe we're this high. We believe we are transparent. And we're not. But the consumer- That's, that's the truth...
- 10:31has not felt that, which means that, that, at some level, that group has not seen the consumer position on this.
- 10:39And until that group sees the consumer position and we flip to actually 100% believe we're transparent- Mm-hmm... which is, uh, uh...
- 10:47Because what I'm, what I'm seeing is actually the ones that don't believe we're transparent, there's probably a small sliver to that are like, "I'm the one, I'm the, I'm the one to blame." Yeah.
- 10:55There's actually probably more of those that are self-aware of the entire industry, that are looking at the entire industry as a whole saying, "Nope, we haven't achieved the transparency," or the trust, more appropriately, "that we need to."
- 11:08And so the self-awareness is of the 73% to look at the 55% of the consumers and go, "Whoop, we actually have it wrong." Maybe it's a communication issue. Maybe it's a, a, a, a pattern of sales issue. Whatever it is,
- 11:21we haven't achieved that parity, and until we do- I like what you're-... we're not there... I like what you're saying, 'cause it's not saying, like, mostly right is good enough. That's it.
- 11:29It's like, no, we have it wrong. That's it. We n- we have it wrong. We need to get it right. Speaking of getting it right. Ah. Stop. Segway. Time. But debatably.
- 11:39You're gonna be able to eat all day, 'cause Applebee's- [laughs]... and IHOP are launching their first ever dual-branded location in the United States, set to open in Seguin, Texas, in early 2025.
- 11:50Uh, the site will combine Applebee's lunch and dinner with IHOP's breakfast and brunch, maximizing, obviously, both brands' peak hours.
- 11:58With a shared kitchen and cross-trained staff, this setup aims to cut costs and improve profitability, um, hopefully trying to, like, bolster struggling locations for both.
- 12:08Um, it will feature a-Drive-thru to meet demand for off-premise dining What? A drive-thru at an Applebee's and IHOP That feels like two changes. You kidding me? Uh- What?
- 12:18Uh, Dine Brands is the brand that, uh, is leading the charge. They plan to roll out 15 dual-branded locations in the US, stating, "The addition of a second brand may improve unit economics."
- 12:29Uh, dual branding has gained popularity in hospitality, obviously, notably with hotels combining two brands into one location. Yeah. Hotels are different.
- 12:37You know, this, this is, like, okay- What's the, what's the KFC combo that you see a lot? Oh, Pizza Hut. It's like Pizza Hut and KFC. Come on. Right? Like, those two things don't go together.
- 12:47They don't go- It's just a way to fit two- This is what's interesting to me. This is like- But Applebee's and IHOP go together actually a lot better, I think. They do. I think, you know, they're both- It's breakfast.
- 12:56[laughs] Well, breakfast. It's breakfast. IHOP says... No, IHOP serves lunch and dinner, but IHOP doesn't serve alcohol, right? Right. So now you can have IHOP, I don't know if, is it 24 hours? I don't know.
- 13:06But- IHOP pancakes with mimosas... no, but now at IHOP you have mimosas, Bloody Marys- [laughs]... right? Like, like what could possibly go wrong, [laughs] right? This is... I think this is actually...
- 13:18They've, they've mislabeled it. This is just, uh, what's the restaurant that starts with a P? Um- Perkins? Perkins. This is just Perkins. Well, n- I don't know. Perkins is Denny's. [laughs] Like, I don't, I don't agree.
- 13:30Yo, Nathan's putting in notes, "Can I order breakfast all day?" That's a great question. Oh, see, this is gonna m- Be- It's gonna get- Either way- But here, here's the thing.
- 13:38This, like, yes, could you create a new restaurant? Could Dine-In just be like... Could Dine Brands just be like, "Wipe 'em out, create a new restaurant that serves breakfast- No, dude... lunch, dinner."
- 13:47No, you can't- That doesn't work... because- Brand equity... there's something unique about Applebee's Maybe...
- 13:50there's something unique about IHOP, and that little combination, it's like when you can get brunch and lunch, and they're both- [laughs]... well-qualified, and you get...
- 13:58Someone gets a burger and someone gets the brunch, like, this is gonna be a good thing, I think. Jason Reed in the live stream, "Okay, the Applebee's and IHOP news slaps." [laughs] There you go. It, it slaps really good.
- 14:07And if, if you don't ha- if you don't know what that word means, that means it's really good. [laughs] Yep. Like it's a really good thing. Yeah. He- Jason Reed's g- in, down with the Gen Z. He is. You know? He is.
- 14:15But here's, here's the deal, I think there's a lot of opportunity for dealers to just think of local brands and local partnerships that they can make to, you know, to draft on the brand equity.
- 14:25Especially- That's right... if you're an auto dealer and you have a good reputation, and back to the trust thing, you can actually bring a lot of juice and energy to a local business- Yep... who, they're always...
- 14:34Local businesses are always, look, coffee shops, you know- Look-... flower shops...
- 14:38I'm telling you, I was actually talking to, um, a guy at, out of Franklin that does, like, social media content advertising for a dealership, and we did this back in the day, and it's the m- e- quickest way to build brand equity locally, especially with restaurants and coffee shops.
- 14:52Like, give your social media person a $20 budget every single week.
- 14:56Get them in the car, drive to the coffee shop, order the thing, shoot it, g- drive along with a salesperson, talk to the people, ask them about their business. Spend your money at the local business intentionally. Yep.
- 15:09And then cross-post that joker. All those businesses are on Instagram, right? Re-post it. Thank you. Yeah. You're gonna become their favorite dealership- It's over... in, like, three seconds. Stop. Collabs are the way.
- 15:20All right. Veterans Day is kicking off to be an amazing day, and I think rightfully so. Celebrating all the things that we get to enjoy, like being able to just talk about IHOP and Applebee's on a podcast.
- 15:30Whatever it is, you have people in front of you, go and take care of them.
- 15:35[upbeat music]