Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Can Faith and Politics Coexist?
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on this episode of the Together for Good podcast, they
- 0:05tell you that you're not supposed to talk about religion
- 0:07or politics. So let's talk about both.
- 0:10Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:13podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:16Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:20Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:24practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 0:27expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 0:29disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 0:33what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 0:36you. No matter where you are on your
- 0:38journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 0:41Welcome to together for good. OK, so religion and politics,
- 0:53two things that you're not supposed to talk about in polite
- 0:56company or settings. Not supposed to ask about.
- 0:58And I understand why that is. These are two deeply personal
- 1:03elements of an individual's life, what religion they
- 1:07practice and the religious convictions they have, and
- 1:10similarly the political convictions that they have.
- 1:13It it makes sense too, that these would be two topics that
- 1:17are so personal and as a result so taboo to discuss in any sort
- 1:22of conversation. When you think about politics in
- 1:24particular, politics are simply the way that we choose to care
- 1:30for the public. I think that's a pretty good way
- 1:32the the way that we will govern ourselves in polite society.
- 1:36And so you think about politics, it's dealing with the rules and
- 1:40the laws of the land and the way that our tax dollars are spent
- 1:44so that people can be cared for in different ways, building
- 1:47roads, supporting schools, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, if
- 1:52you get the idea. And now please don't read into
- 1:55whatever I listed there as my political viewpoints.
- 1:57Just trying to give us a broad overview of this and, and, and
- 2:01recognize the idea of why this is so personal.
- 2:04Yes, politics deals with elements that affect our daily
- 2:08life, our life every single day. And similarly, religion should
- 2:13be something, if we're, if we're actually committed and convicted
- 2:17to our faith, it should affect the way we carry ourselves in
- 2:21daily life, the decisions we make.
- 2:24And you're noticing automatically right here, we're
- 2:27getting to this space of ethics and morals.
- 2:31And certainly many of the things that we discuss and debate
- 2:35within a political setting often have a moral component to it.
- 2:39And and that's why we fight so fervently about it, because our
- 2:43moral position says that this is the right decision to make.
- 2:46While someone else might have a completely different viewpoint,
- 2:50but becoming at it from their moral space on a moral level.
- 2:54This is what I believe. Similarly, religion is
- 2:58oftentimes where we draw our morals from.
- 3:01If I believe God to be this way, and I believe that this is how
- 3:06God created us to be, and I believe that this is what God
- 3:09wants for us in this one precious life we've been given,
- 3:14well then that has certain ramifications for my morals, for
- 3:19what I think is the right thing to do, the right stance to take.
- 3:26And so I'm setting up. And you're seeing why politics
- 3:29and religion get so linked and lumped together because they
- 3:35deal with matters of the heart, matters of our deepest
- 3:40convictions about what life is all about.
- 3:45And so because of this, we often get into big debates and fights
- 3:49about it. People in many times within my
- 3:53career as a pastor, people have bemoaned the fact of the church
- 3:57becoming too political or they felt like something that was
- 4:00said was too political. And I need to tell you, this is
- 4:04a relatively new phenomenon, I think in generations past.
- 4:08I'm sure it still came up at different points throughout
- 4:10history, but it seems more common in this day and age when
- 4:14our political climate is so divided and divisive.
- 4:18This is the moment where people can start to feel like a
- 4:22particular comment or scripture passage was overly political.
- 4:27I remember reading about individuals who were some of my
- 4:32friends who were pastors at churches right after Donald
- 4:36Trump was elected to his first term back in 2016.
- 4:40And I remember people. One of the stories that my
- 4:44friend told me is that the gospel reading assigned for that
- 4:46Sunday was the Beatitudes. And this is where Jesus says
- 4:49blessed are the poor, blessed are the weak, blessed are the
- 4:52humble. And that was just the assigned
- 4:55reading. The church follows the
- 4:57lectionary cycle. We don't get to pick what the
- 4:59Scripture readings are on any given Sunday.
- 5:01They're assigned to us years ahead of time.
- 5:04And so that happened to be the Scripture passage.
- 5:06And there was an individual in this church who was very upset
- 5:09because he felt like the pastor was becoming too political, that
- 5:13by reading those words, he was somehow making some sort of
- 5:16statement about Donald Trump. We can argue about how, you know
- 5:21where we stand on that particular viewpoint all day,
- 5:24but I think it illustrates the ways that we hear things as
- 5:28political these days because everything is ratcheted up
- 5:33because the tension is so high. And so you hear these words and
- 5:37you automatically assume that it's the pastor making a dig at
- 5:40the candidate that you voted for, when in reality, it was
- 5:43just the words that Jesus said thousands of years ago that were
- 5:46assigned. Interestingly enough, the
- 5:49Beatitudes was also read at Donald Trump's inauguration in
- 5:53early 2017. And so clearly in that moment,
- 5:57his Cam felt like those were appropriate words to use at that
- 6:01moment. Whereas, you know, a few months
- 6:03prior, right after the election, when they were read from the
- 6:05pulpit on a Sunday morning, my friend's parishioner felt like
- 6:08it was an affront to the man. It just goes to show you how
- 6:12depending on your setting, depending on your mindset,
- 6:17anything can seem overly political.
- 6:22Anything can seem like it's an affront to your particular
- 6:27position. And so this is where we need to
- 6:31talk about religion and politics and we need to to be willing to
- 6:36engage the conversation because there's so much that we can
- 6:40learn from one another. There's so many ways that we can
- 6:43grow together. I think it it, it is so tragic
- 6:48that we're in this world where we will hear things in one
- 6:52particular way. And, and for good reason too.
- 6:55I don't want to discount my friend's parishioner who felt
- 6:59affronted by that. There were particular things
- 7:01going on in his head, in his heart that made him feel
- 7:05uncomfortable in that moment. And hopefully he was able to
- 7:08talk with his pastor and able to discuss what this was all about
- 7:12because because that's what we need in order to really grow as
- 7:16individuals and to grow in our faith and to grow in our
- 7:18political understanding and viewpoints.
- 7:21I will say, and I want to say clearly, I don't think it's
- 7:24appropriate for a church to take a particular political stance.
- 7:29My job as a pastor is not to tell you how to vote.
- 7:34My job is to tell you about the gospel and to tell you about the
- 7:38Scriptures. These are texts that I've
- 7:41studied carefully and for dozens of years now.
- 7:45I've written hundreds of sermons, Bible studies, blog
- 7:49posts about. And so my job is to prayerfully
- 7:53consider what I think the Spirit is leading me to say about a
- 7:58particular Scripture passage on a Sunday morning, for example,
- 8:03and to just offer to you that I will hardly, I, I hope I never
- 8:09do specifically say this is the way you need to vote.
- 8:15The reason being is that I think that politics is a deeply
- 8:19personal thing, just like our life of faith.
- 8:22I do believe your faith should influence your politics and This
- 8:26is why we need to continue to discuss matters of faith
- 8:31together. We need to continue to learn
- 8:34from each other and our life experiences and our viewpoints.
- 8:38But ultimately it's, it's up to you and the voting booth about
- 8:42how you're going to live out your faith in that moment when
- 8:46you act as a citizen of our country.
- 8:50Furthermore, in this idea about why I don't think it's
- 8:54appropriate for a pastor to endorse a specific candidate,
- 8:58because our belief and trust is ultimately in God and not in
- 9:04whoever is in power. All of our political leaders,
- 9:08senators, presidents, Congress people are temporary and they're
- 9:13flawed human beings just like you and me.
- 9:16And so none of them are going to get this exactly right.
- 9:20Only God can get this exactly right.
- 9:23And so since every single politician is flawed, it is not
- 9:30appropriate for the gospel proclamation to specifically
- 9:34support anyone individual. With that in mind as well, this
- 9:40is where what the gospel does is it continues to expose us to the
- 9:44good news of Jesus Christ and what God has been trying to do
- 9:48in the world since the very beginning, since God set this
- 9:51all into motion. And so through our acts of
- 9:54worship, through our study, through our conversation with on
- 9:58another and the sharing of our faith and the sharing of our
- 10:01life experience that leads us to the conclusions that we make
- 10:04through this communal practice of faith, that is where the Holy
- 10:10Spirit works and guides us. And so we need to hear about
- 10:15this on a Sunday morning. And hopefully this is the other
- 10:19thing that continually comes up within my practice is that
- 10:23people, yeah, well, hear something that I say and feel
- 10:25like it's very political, which is never my intent.
- 10:29And I'm positive that it happens because religion and politics
- 10:34are so intertwined and because frankly, Jesus was very
- 10:39political in what he said and what he did.
- 10:42When you think about it it in Jesus's day, obviously politics
- 10:45was incredibly different. And in the same sense, Jesus was
- 10:49incredibly engaged in speaking truth to power and in critiquing
- 10:56the politicians of his day. In Luke's gospel, this is where
- 11:01you can see it most plainly in the way that our Christmas story
- 11:06is written. Luke chapter 2.
- 11:08In those days, a decree went out from Emperor Augustus that all
- 11:10the world should be registered. This was the first decree and it
- 11:13was given while Kwairinius was governor of Syria.
- 11:16All went to their hometown to be registered.
- 11:19That little preamble in the beginning is letting you know
- 11:22about who was in power at that time.
- 11:25We get all of this mention of individuals who were political
- 11:28leaders at that moment, and it's Luke setting us up to say like
- 11:31this event will have political ramifications.
- 11:36And not only that, but later on in what Luke writes, he writes
- 11:39about the angels appearing in the sky.
- 11:40I've done other podcasts on this.
- 11:42If you want to go back and find it, I'll try and remember to
- 11:44link it for you about Luke chapter 2 and the political
- 11:47implications of that text. But the angels talk about that
- 11:52to you. This day is born in the city of
- 11:54David, a savior who will bring peace to all the earth.
- 12:00Bringer of peace is a phrase that was attached to Caesar
- 12:05Augustus. He was called the bringer of
- 12:08peace. That was part of how he was
- 12:09described. And he was also when he would
- 12:14commit, when he would conquer another country, they would call
- 12:18it good news, a, a, a UN gallion, a good news
- 12:24proclamation. And so that's what the angels
- 12:25say too. I bring you good news of great
- 12:28joy. All of it is meant to subvert
- 12:31those who were in power to say no, you are not ultimately the
- 12:35ones in control. There is a force that's stronger
- 12:38than this. There is a God who is control
- 12:41and his name is Jesus Christ. This is who we are as people of
- 12:47faith is that our trust is always, always, always in Jesus
- 12:52and what he did and what he proclaimed and what he showed
- 12:55us. And sometimes, yeah, that will
- 12:57have political implications because Jesus calls us to
- 13:03specific ways of caring about one another and caring about the
- 13:06world around us. And this, I will admit, is also
- 13:11where the debate comes because there are very good Christians
- 13:16who are Democrats and Republicans, and neither of them
- 13:20gets it exactly right. Oh, hit my microphone there.
- 13:22Sorry about that. Neither of them gets this
- 13:25exactly right, but that's again the point.
- 13:30What we need is a community of faith where we wrestle with
- 13:35these issues together and where we pray for the Holy Spirit to
- 13:39guide us and where we probably come to different conclusions
- 13:43than our neighbor. But that only pushes us deeper
- 13:46into this practice of loving and caring for our neighbor that
- 13:50Jesus commanded us to do and called us to.
- 13:56In particular, one of the things that I'm thinking about is the
- 14:01ways that our government is actually specifically set up to
- 14:06support this type of communal practice of faith.
- 14:11You see, our founding fathers, I firmly believe were geniuses,
- 14:17and this system of constitutional democracy that
- 14:20they set up is really brilliant for a world that is very
- 14:27diverse. Obviously there are some flaws
- 14:30within it and there that's why we continue to have amendments.
- 14:34There were contradictions in the beginning that they needed to
- 14:37fix and figure out, and that process continues.
- 14:40But the whole design of it was for this to be a slow form of
- 14:42government where things didn't happen quickly, where we debated
- 14:47issues and there were checks and there were balances so that we
- 14:52could become a more perfect union.
- 14:54And notice how this is exactly what I've been talking about the
- 14:58entire time when I speak about us being a community of faith
- 15:01that learns from one another. Your life experience is
- 15:04different than mine. And so you've come to different
- 15:06conclusions than me. And neither one of these is
- 15:10necessarily wrong. We, we only can do the best that
- 15:15we have with what we have. And that's why I need to learn
- 15:19from you about why you've come to the conclusion that you have.
- 15:23And it's why we need a church where we're continually diving
- 15:26into these sacred stories that were written thousands of years
- 15:30ago, but that people died to protect and pass on to the next
- 15:34generation. Because these scriptures are the
- 15:36wisdom of God that we've been given.
- 15:39And this wisdom of God is meant to, yes, guide our life.
- 15:43But because it was written so long ago and because life is so
- 15:47complex, there's a lot that we can continue to wrestle with and
- 15:52dive into when we get into these scriptures.
- 15:55And so my commitment is to do my best When I put that sermon out
- 16:00there for you, when I put that podcast or blog post out there
- 16:03for you, I'm doing the best with what I have available and what
- 16:06I've learned. And it's not perfect.
- 16:09It's very flawed. And I need to hear from you
- 16:13about how you're interpreting it.
- 16:16I need to hear from you about how your life experience
- 16:18actually contradicts something that I've said.
- 16:21Because then you help me become a better person of faith, a
- 16:26better preacher, a better pastor through that exchange.
- 16:30This is what the community of faith is all about, staying
- 16:34together and united despite our disagreements, because our
- 16:38disagreements are actually the fuel that helps us all grow.
- 16:43And that's exactly the way, like I said, the government was set
- 16:47up, is that the contradiction and the struggle and the
- 16:50compromise is how we form that more perfect union.
- 16:56Those are some thoughts for you about religion and politics.
- 16:59I know that these are hard and divisive times.
- 17:02And I know what's so fascinating is that I have had Republicans
- 17:07talk to me and Democrats talk to me, conservatives and liberals
- 17:11who have all said in their own ways, I just can't believe that
- 17:16my neighbor thinks this. I can't believe that my neighbor
- 17:21thinks that's OK. And they're saying it about one
- 17:23another. But but, but here's the thing.
- 17:25You got to talk about it because you're going to learn so much
- 17:29from their viewpoint. Tell, tell me how you got there.
- 17:33Tell me what in your life LED you to make this particular
- 17:36conclusion? You'd be shocked at what you can
- 17:39learn from one another. And and it's that type of deep
- 17:42compassion that I think Jesus calls us to.
- 17:47And that's at the very heart of what it means to be a Christian,
- 17:50is to be deeply humble and compassionate.
- 17:55That is what Jesus did with his whole life, eating with the
- 17:59sinners and the tax collectors, going to the cross, completely
- 18:08humbling himself for our sake. I'm going to stop there.
- 18:13Those are some thoughts on religion and politics.
- 18:16I know that this is divisive and difficult times, but we we got
- 18:19to talk about these things, which is why Ioffer this to you
- 18:21now. I'd love to hear from you
- 18:23because that's the whole point is for the conversation to grow,
- 18:27for us to learn from one another.
- 18:29It doesn't help anyone if we just get mad and take our toys
- 18:32and go home. We need to be a community of
- 18:35faith that learns and grows together.
- 18:38That's how we become a better version of a church, a better
- 18:42practicer of faith. Thanks for watching or listening
- 18:46everyone. Really appreciate your support.
- 18:48As always. Share it with a family member or
- 18:50friend. Maybe this will spark some
- 18:52really good discussion with someone you know and love and
- 18:54care about, but who you haven't been able to talk with lately.
- 18:57I hope it can be bad for you. As always, thanks for listening.
- 19:00Stay in peace everyone. Thank you for listening to this
- 19:12episode of the Together for Good podcast brought to you by
- 19:15Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co.
- 19:19For more great resources for your Walk of Faith, please visit
- 19:22our website bethany-denver.org.