Latest / The Inspired Speaker Network / Less No, More Yes: Building Cooperation without the Battle
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Guiding Parent Podcast, where you'll find the mindset and tools to parent with
- 0:05greater confidence, clarity, and purpose, even when there aren't any easy answers. Together,
- 0:10we're going to explore how to better nurture and guide our children to support who they are and
- 0:14who they're becoming so that they can fulfill their unique potential and thrive in our ever-changing
- 0:19world. I'm Tammy Ulrich, your host, parenting and early childhood educator, mom, and most fun,
- 0:26yammy. And I'm Shannon, your co-host. I'm Tammy's daughter and mom to a very energetic little dude
- 0:32called H. We're glad you're here. Let's get started. So what if I told you that I almost
- 0:39never tell my child no? Well, if I didn't know better, I'd say you are an overly permissive
- 0:46parent with a spoiled kid. But I don't know why we do have this feeling that, you know,
- 0:52we always have to say no. It's kind of like for many of us as parents, it's like this default
- 0:57response that we have to say no. I don't know if we feel like, you know, we have to be in control
- 1:03or we're afraid of spoiling our kids, but that does just seem to be like part of parenting is
- 1:10having to say no. Actually, though, you know, I really didn't end up telling you no very often
- 1:16either. And I didn't end up super spoiled.
- 1:21I don't think so. But I do remember telling you, and this was much later when you were a teenager,
- 1:27I do remember telling you that if you couldn't take it when I said no, that maybe you needed
- 1:32more practice with my giving you reason to hear no. You didn't like that very much. I certainly
- 1:38wouldn't say that to a very young child, but that was when you were lots older. And, you know,
- 1:44there certainly are times that we do need to say no, but there's a happy medium in how we do that.
- 1:49There's a lot of power in saying yes. In fact, we have an article in the gift vault that's all
- 1:54about the power of saying yes. But we're going to talk kind of about what that looks like and how
- 1:59we can turn no into yes. And it may seem kind of like silly or like we're, you know, being
- 2:06hypercritical around language, but this is one of those weird instances where I feel like it really,
- 2:12really, really makes a huge difference in preventing things like power struggles and,
- 2:17you know, where our words really do matter. You can avoid that battle and I feel like it
- 2:21minimizes resistance and it can create a connection. Absolutely. It makes us feel
- 2:27like we're on the same team and not in opposition. You know, it creates cooperation.
- 2:32It's really hard to argue with yes. You know, if I say yes, you know, even if it's yes but
- 2:38or yes and it's kind of hard to argue with that. So it kind of gets us out of that power struggle
- 2:44mode. So, you know, to give some examples of what this actually looks like, if you have a child
- 2:50who comes to you and says, mom, I really want a cookie. And obviously it's three minutes before
- 2:54dinner. You're not going to give your kid a cookie. So say yes, you can have a cookie after dinner.
- 3:00Or if you're running through the living room and we need them to not be running through the
- 3:06living room. Instead of saying no running, we can say you can run when we get to the playground.
- 3:13So there's a lot of ways where we can kind of, you know, just turn these
- 3:16no's into a yes when or a yes, you know, or, you know, something needs to be achieved. And then
- 3:22obviously the answer can be yes. So another example is like if you're trying to get,
- 3:30if your child wants to do something, but there's something that needs to be done,
- 3:33done ahead of time, like they want to watch a show, you can say, yes, you can watch the show
- 3:37after the toys are picked up. And that way you're going to have a win-win because you're also going
- 3:42to get, you're also going to get the toys picked up or whatever it is that needs to, needs to
- 3:47happen first. And there could, you know, not to say there won't be any resistance, but you're
- 3:51certainly going to minimize the resistance when, when things are stated in more of a positive like
- 3:55that. You know, we need to realize that we don't need to be the power that, you know, kids do need
- 4:01boundaries, absolutely. But we, we want to empower our kids. So we need to help them to know what to
- 4:08do so that they can get what they want in an appropriate way, as well as when they can't,
- 4:14how to deal with that disappointment. Yeah. And so, you know, part of that is turning us into
- 4:19no's and then another aspect may be finding places where you don't actually have to say no.
- 4:25Is this something that you are saying no to because it's safety concern or, you know,
- 4:29something that really, really matters? Or are you saying no, because it's obnoxious, you know,
- 4:34we want to focus on the ones where it's actually dangerous rather than, you know, picking a battle
- 4:39over something that, you know, just kind of hurts you. That being said, you know, from the outside
- 4:45looking in, there may be rules that you have in your family that are valid and they might look
- 4:50ridiculous from the outside looking in. That's still valid. I know for our family, one of the,
- 4:56you know, random rules we have is no whistling in the car. To the point that I was driving
- 5:01somewhere the other day with my son and one of his friends and his little buddy starts whistling
- 5:06and my kid was like, oh, but we can't whistle in the car. Mom's brain will explode. And, you know,
- 5:11so the reasoning behind that is that I have some auditory sensitivities and it's really,
- 5:16really hard for me to drive if I hear that sound in the backseat. And so, you know, we can kind of
- 5:22maybe it becomes a safety consideration, but really it's just something that I have a really
- 5:26hard time handling. And it's still obviously fine to have rules like that that are unique
- 5:31to your family and to different circumstances. And I think it is dangerous if your brain explodes.
- 5:40But it's also a great way to teach our kids that like we have these rules, not just for them,
- 5:45but for our entire family to create, you know, something that feels good for everybody rather
- 5:50than just, you know, you can whistle in the backseat because you want to with no consideration
- 5:54for other people. Right. And that is part of what we're what we want to make sure we're teaching
- 5:59is that, you know, things that apply to our family and make our family as an interconnected
- 6:05whole and that we're all taking care of each other. Yeah. And so if you have rules in place
- 6:10that help prevent a situation where you're going to build resentment or you're going to have to
- 6:15deal with your brain exploding or something like that, then those are absolutely considerations
- 6:19that you take into account. Like maybe it's something that sometimes, you know, you can
- 6:24handle and other times you need to, you know, they do not right now. Yeah, absolutely. You know,
- 6:30when kids do as much as we want to make sure that we give kids the opportunity to hear yes,
- 6:36and that we're not always negating, thwarting their efforts and, you know, being in that default mode
- 6:42of just, you know, kind of saying no. Our kids also do really have to be able to accept when we
- 6:49do say no. Like I used to tell you, you know, if you can't accept it when I do, maybe you need more
- 6:53practice. But there's also, besides saying no and being able for our kids to be able to accept that,
- 7:00part of that is letting them know why, why there is a particular reason. Like, you know, H knows
- 7:05there's the reason behind this supposedly or, you know, maybe on the surface looking silly rule that
- 7:11we don't whistle in the car. He knows why that's important. So we want to make sure that besides
- 7:16saying no, we're letting our kids understand what's behind that. And when we do that, we also
- 7:23make it more likely that we'll gain cooperation because they have some understanding. And we're
- 7:28also, you know, modeling decision-making and we're sharing what goes into making that decision. So
- 7:34they're starting to learn things like cause and effect, perspective taking, you know, safety
- 7:38considerations, you know, those kinds of pieces that, that all come into the decisions that we
- 7:45make. Yeah. And I was, you know, we were talking about this a couple of weeks ago and it kind of,
- 7:49you know, has just been in the back of my brain spinning around. And one of the things I realized
- 7:52is not only, you know, are you getting these sort of cause and effects when you explain rules,
- 7:58but it's also a way to reinforce like your family values. And so like, I know last weekend,
- 8:04Henry had one of his friends over and he really wanted a milkshake, which is typically something
- 8:10that's fine, you know, on a Friday evening, but we didn't have very much ice cream. And so I had
- 8:16to say no. And then I explained to him like, Hey, we don't have enough, you know, ice cream to make
- 8:20two milkshakes. So you're going to have to wait until your friend leaves because it's not okay
- 8:24to have something like that in front of a friend without also, you know, having that for your
- 8:29friends. And we had another, you know, similar situation where we were at the beach and one of
- 8:35the aunties had watermelon. And so each loves watermelon, had a bite and then wanted more.
- 8:40And I was like, bud, there's five pieces of watermelon for 10 people. Like you can't have
- 8:44seconds when everybody hasn't already had firsts. And so it's just another way to, you know,
- 8:49reinforce those kinds of values that you want centered in your family life.
- 8:53When you provide more explanation. Right. And, you know, I know for a lot of families,
- 9:00especially when we bring siblings into the, into the mix that can create, you know, there's a lot
- 9:05of that, a lot more opportunities for considering everybody's, everybody's feelings and why they
- 9:10can't do certain things, you know, and that's all part of a learning experience of gaining
- 9:15that empathy and learning to consider other people's, you know, other people's feelings.
- 9:19I remember when your younger, your younger siblings were, were little and often the boys
- 9:26might want to do something that they didn't really want their little sister involved in.
- 9:31And so they would very obviously exclude her. And so they had to learn, you know,
- 9:36we had to have conversations around, yeah, you can, you know, play on your own without her,
- 9:40but you can't, you can't just, you know, intentionally exclude her in a way that
- 9:46brings it up to her because that hurts her feelings. And so it's all a part of a process of,
- 9:50of helping them understand, you know, the whys and what's going on in terms of other people and
- 9:56consideration of other people. And that's part of, you know, one of the reasons we think we have to,
- 10:00we have to say no and our kids have to, you know, do certain things or, you know, just
- 10:07take them, take a no without any, any question is because we think we have to teach manners,
- 10:11but we can, we do better job teaching manners when we're explaining the why so they understand
- 10:16what's behind that and the considerations for, you know, for how we have, how we're thinking
- 10:22about other people. Yeah. When you just say, because I said so nobody learns anything. There's
- 10:29no, there's no value add to that statement. And it, you know, for me, at least always felt a lot
- 10:35of frustration. And like, I remember when I was, I had to have been probably like late elementary
- 10:44school, early middle school. And I think that, you know, I had a group of friends going to the
- 10:49beach and I really wanted to go and you had told me no. And so of course I was super annoyed,
- 10:54probably a little bit mad, but you explained it to me that, you know, this wasn't, you know,
- 11:02a family that we knew well, this was a trip to the beach where, you know, obviously this is,
- 11:07you know, there's some safety concerns. If you have, you know, parents, you don't know how well
- 11:11they're going to be watching kids in an environment like that. And so you just laid it out, you know,
- 11:15for me that, you know, your instinct as a parent was saying that this just wasn't a safe thing for
- 11:20me to do. And so you couldn't in good conscience, let me go. And so, yes, I was annoyed. I was mad,
- 11:25but I also understood your reasoning behind it. So I didn't like it, but I also didn't
- 11:31necessarily fight against it as hard as I would have otherwise, because I understood the why.
- 11:37And then I remember, you know, getting older, you know, the teenage years where there's definitely
- 11:41a lot more pushback to being told no. And I would have friends whose parents would,
- 11:46you know, just drop hard no's, like, nope, you can't do it. And no explanation. And so
- 11:50they did it anyways, because, you know, it just made them become more sneaky. And so they still
- 11:55got what they wanted to do. And there was no little voice in the back of their head with
- 12:00the explanation of why that wasn't a safe behavior or why something, you know, shouldn't be acceptable.
- 12:05It was just no. And so, yeah, we did it anyways. Right. Well, and really think about, you know,
- 12:12toddlers are the big, the ones that are always saying no. But really, the toddler and the
- 12:18teen years are kind of parallel stages of development. During both of those times,
- 12:25kids are really trying to develop their autonomy. And so they need the opportunities to have some
- 12:31power and to be able to do the things that they're trying to do. So it's especially important
- 12:36that we explain why and that we also provide ways for them to figure things out. And if there is a
- 12:42way for them to get to what they're trying to do. You know, kids aren't necessarily being defiant.
- 12:50You know, they're trying to figure out how to get what they want, how to meet a desire or want.
- 12:57And we really need to think about if our child is becoming exceptionally defiant,
- 13:03how much are we saying no? Are we saying no all the time? Are we continually thwarting their
- 13:07efforts towards, you know, towards that autonomy and independence? And modeling saying no.
- 13:11And what? And modeling saying no. If all you hear is no, then that's what you know how to say.
- 13:17Yeah, that's especially for two-year-olds. Absolutely. Yeah. You know, our kids absolutely
- 13:24need boundaries and they need limits. But we don't want to go to the extreme either, you know,
- 13:30with being overly permissive. So we're not about, you know, saying, well, always,
- 13:35you know, always have these, always say yes, or always have these big discussions about it.
- 13:39Sometimes no just has to be, has to be no. Limits have to provide safety. You know,
- 13:45they provide a sense of security and they, and they're, you know, it's up to us to guide
- 13:49development. So we really do need to also set the tone that sometimes no just means no. And
- 13:57we explain why, and we can also provide opportunities for them to work with us on
- 14:03things, but they need, there are times when it just, that's just the way it is. You know, kids
- 14:08need to learn to deal with this disappointment, but they, when, when they hear no and when there
- 14:12isn't further discussion, but it's with our support, you know, that they learn to be resilient
- 14:17in the face of disappointment. And, you know, we all have disappointments in life. So it's time,
- 14:22you know, we need to practice at the, at the beginning. If we're always just saying,
- 14:25you know, yes, whatever, do what you want. Our kids aren't learning, learning how to deal with
- 14:30when things don't go the way they, they want them to. And those emotions though, that they feel,
- 14:36those emotions are okay. You know, we often want to, want to make everything okay. Make them happy,
- 14:40not let them, not let them be upset. But disappointment comes with big emotions. It
- 14:46comes with feeling sad. Doesn't mean we're going to change our minds. You know, when we need to
- 14:52stay, stick with that, then, you know, we don't change our minds, but we can sit with them in
- 14:56that emotion. We can help co-regulate for little ones that need that support. And when they do
- 15:02have those really big emotions and they do get really upset when they can't get what they want,
- 15:06it doesn't mean they're spoiled. It means they're working through, through that. It's a process. And
- 15:11again, it depends on development. You know, the very, the very younger, the younger child,
- 15:15the more difficult those big emotions and that disappointment will be.
- 15:19Well, to a point, because we also know like, how do adults sometimes deal with disappointment?
- 15:23Sometimes adults have big emotions when they're disappointed as well.
- 15:26I think that we have this idea that, you know, children should be able to regulate all the time
- 15:34and have expectations on them that are ridiculous if you put the same on an adult. Right. And so,
- 15:39you know, I, you know, things happen. I get disappointed and sometimes they cry about it.
- 15:44So yeah, it's just part of, you know, it's part of being human. It is. And so in addition,
- 15:54I think to them learning how to deal with being told no, I think also we need to make sure that
- 16:00we're empowering our kids to be able to say no. You know, sometimes, sometimes there's times where
- 16:07it's really, really important. And, you know, for our little tiny guys, especially those two and
- 16:12three year olds, establishing that sense of autonomy is literally like their job at that
- 16:17age. It's a huge part of their development. And so it's not necessarily, I mean, it can read as
- 16:22defiance or, you know, whatever spoiled, whatever we want to call it, but really it's development.
- 16:29And so, you know, again, we're not necessarily going to change our mind. We're not going to let
- 16:34them, you know, then get what they want out of it, but we can, you know, just respond with a lot
- 16:39of empathy and recognize like, this is just part of being a little guy. And it's a lot to learn
- 16:44when you're just that small. It is. Yeah. I do think it's kind of a two year old's job to say
- 16:49no. Absolutely. But it, you know, back again to, you know, the modeling, you know, are we saying
- 16:57no all the time? In which case, especially for the little, little, little guys like this, you're
- 17:01going to get a lot more nos yourselves. This is a, you know, for two year olds, especially putting
- 17:06in the yes, win or yes, and really does make a huge, huge difference because it really is just
- 17:13about them trying to be, you know, trying to become independent and they're developing autonomy.
- 17:19We also need to let them, you know, have their own, let our kids have their own ideas and
- 17:24preferences. You know, we all, a lot of parents feel like, you know, we're telling our kids how
- 17:29they should think and feel because we know, we know best, but they're their own little people
- 17:34and they have their own ideas and they have their own preferences. And that's great,
- 17:39even if they're not ours, even if they're different. So, you know, let, let our kids
- 17:43have those and listen and hear what those, what their ideas are. Kids have fascinating
- 17:49information and ideas and insights. They really are. They really are. But that also leads to also,
- 17:57you know, developing problem solving and critical thinking skills, you know,
- 18:01the more that we draw that out from them and listen to their, their thought processes really
- 18:06helps develop that, you know, develop those problem solving skills in them. You were a master
- 18:13at negotiation and I would tell you, you know, no, give you the reason why, and then you would come
- 18:20back with your list of, well, you know, this, this problem, okay, I will resolve it this way,
- 18:27this, okay, I can resolve it this way. And, um, because if it had anything, if I could spin it so
- 18:36that it was like educational, I could almost always change your mind. Almost always. But
- 18:42there were still lots of times when it still meant, you know, no, but you were definitely
- 18:48gaining the ability to learn to compromise and to collaborate. And you were certainly
- 18:55honing those critical thinking skills if you thought of responses to all of my reasons,
- 19:00you know, why something wouldn't, wouldn't work. Yeah. I mean, and sometimes that meant that I would
- 19:05get a, you know, the answer is still no for today, but maybe next time, you know, we can think about
- 19:11this differently or, you know, every once in a while I could like legitimately change your mind
- 19:15in that moment. But most of the time, you know, you still have your boundary and it became a, well,
- 19:19we'll add that to, you know, future considerations kind of thing. You know, that there's been times
- 19:26where, you know, each has wanted something and, you know, we've talked about it and it's been
- 19:30like, all right, you know what? You make a pretty valid point. So for this time, you know, let's
- 19:35do it differently and we'll see if it works. And if it doesn't, then we'll go back to the
- 19:39previous boundary. And if it does, then great. And like, I think it's okay for our kids to see,
- 19:44you know, that we can think about things and potentially change our minds as long as, you
- 19:48know, for the most part boundaries hold. Absolutely. There are definitely times where,
- 19:53you know, you need to be like, we're not going to debate this anymore. You've heard my answer.
- 19:58That's it. That's, you know, that's the end of it. But again, you know, we can teach them
- 20:04appropriate ways to talk about things and make sure that they're, you know, getting what they
- 20:09want out of a situation. Right. Right. Well, and sometimes, you know, it can boil down to
- 20:15they're not developmentally ready yet. So is there a way we can break down skills or processes
- 20:20so that they can learn and, you know, to move in that direction? Or, you know, it's just not the
- 20:25right time or the place. I mean, there's a lot of times ways that we can over time help them to
- 20:30figure out, you know, so that they're learning appropriate ways to get what they want. Because
- 20:36we want to create a growth mindset in our kids. You know, that ability to think, you know, if I
- 20:41work hard at something, I will get it. I can get that. That they'll embrace challenges and keep
- 20:46persisting. You know, that persistence can be really, really annoying when you've said no and
- 20:51your child is still trying to negotiate. But it's also a really valid and important skill to, for
- 20:58life to get what you, you know, to get what you want in life, but to be able to do that appropriately.
- 21:04So we want to support our kids in how to learn appropriate ways to get what they want and to
- 21:08develop the skills that they need so that they can, you know, enable them, empower them to be
- 21:15able to do the things that they're wanting to do. Yeah. And when we support them, you know,
- 21:21in all of this, and then also supporting them being able to say no back to us, you know, there's
- 21:27a respectful way to do that. Kids need to learn how to, you know, we're not trying to get them to
- 21:31just drop like, nope, I'm good. I'm going to go over here. Like there needs to be a respectful
- 21:37way to phrase it and to, you know, push back in a way that's appropriate for your family's values.
- 21:42But, you know, you start with saying that to your parents and then that builds to being able to say
- 21:47it to your peers and, you know, potentially to unsafe adults. And so, you know, we don't want
- 21:53children that 100% acquiesce all the time. That's potentially dangerous for them. And so, you know,
- 21:59there's a whole lot of considerations that we build into them learning how to say no to other people,
- 22:04but it is really, really important. Absolutely. I mean, you know, especially, you know, thinking
- 22:09about those peers, you know, when our friends are making decisions that aren't the best,
- 22:14we want our kids to be able to think for themselves and make a different decision. And if
- 22:19they haven't had practice going against what's being, you know, what they're being told to do
- 22:24in any given moment with support and in an appropriate way, that's going to make it all
- 22:29harder than to say no to peers. And especially think about teenagers when those risky behaviors
- 22:35start. And, you know, we really want them to have the power to say no. I also think about-
- 22:42I know this is something we definitely have seen with H because, you know, I will joke that he's
- 22:47never the one to start the fire, but he will 100% dance around it. Meaning that he's usually not the
- 22:55one to start, you know, veering off course in class or something like that. But once a peer does,
- 23:00he is happy to go along with whatever mischief has been created. And so again, over the last
- 23:05couple of years, this has been a, you know, pretty consistent point of conversation of, you know,
- 23:10if your friends are doing something that isn't okay, you need to not go along with that. And,
- 23:17you know, sometimes that means straight up saying like, hey guys, I'm not going to be a part of this.
- 23:21And sometimes it just means separating yourself from the situation. But I know he came home
- 23:25from school last week and was very pleased with himself that he had walked away from something.
- 23:30And so, you know, watching him struggle through that in elementary school, again,
- 23:36sets him up much better when it's big things as a teenager. And it does take literal years of
- 23:43practice for these kinds of skills to develop and grow. Right. So we do want to start, you know,
- 23:49start young. Plus I think about, you know, as adults, how many of us often will say yes to
- 23:56something that we don't really want to do. That we're, you know, we're total people pleasers.
- 24:01You know, it's like somebody asked something of us, our plate is already full, but we feel like,
- 24:06you know, we have to say yes. We don't want our kids to grow up having that feeling where
- 24:12they can't set boundaries for their own sanity, you know, their own selves. So,
- 24:18it's really important that we give them that power that they can have their own boundaries.
- 24:23They can say no. But again, you know, in an appropriate, polite way. So, you know,
- 24:30all in all, we want to support our kids in learning to think things through,
- 24:34having the tools to make decisions for themselves, and learning overall that they can get what they
- 24:40want out of life, but also at the same time, developing that resiliency to deal with
- 24:45disappointment when things don't go their way. So, as we come to an end, we have three tips for you.
- 24:52So, the first one is consider asking when you hear no about to come out of your mouth,
- 24:59why are you saying no? Is it a safety issue? Would somebody get hurt? Property is going to get
- 25:05damaged? Is it a conflict with a family value? But if there isn't really an issue, how could you
- 25:10turn the no into a yes? And then the second one is practice changing no into yes. Yes,
- 25:17you can have a cookie after dinner, or yes, you can go outside to play after the living room is
- 25:22cleaned up. You know, if it's simply just not the time or the place, or developmentally they just
- 25:28aren't able yet, think about how you can support your child in growing in that way, so that you can
- 25:34collaborate with them that ultimately they can begin to reach their goals. And then third,
- 25:39support the no with a why, and then when there are feelings of disappointment, let those feelings
- 25:45be okay, and just be there with your child in those feelings. Yeah, and so for our try this,
- 25:52I would really just invite you to pay attention when you try these skills. You'll notice a
- 25:58difference in energy if you tell your child yes when versus a hard no. You know, do you feel
- 26:03different? Does your kiddo feel different? Do you notice a little bit more ease in that relationship?
- 26:08As you, you know, try and change your language. And then also, you can try going to our gift vault
- 26:16so that you can check out our article, The Power of Yes. Until next time.