Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Covering Gender Based Violence" with Alexa Koenig
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled covering
- 0:06gender -based violence. This week we spoke to
- 0:09Dr. Alexa Koenig from UC Berkeley. Alexa has
- 0:13spent much of her recent career looking into
- 0:15how digital investigations could aid accountability
- 0:18for war crimes and gender -based violence. Within
- 0:21this discussion, we focused on her work covering
- 0:23gender -based violence and what lessons she's
- 0:25learned from the various groups she's spoken
- 0:27to and worked with, from legal professionals
- 0:30to survivor groups. This talk was hosted by me,
- 0:33Shaila Ma, on Thursday the 20th of February 2025
- 0:36in the Bellingcat Discord server. Greetings all,
- 0:42and welcome back. We're here with another Sage
- 0:45Talk. I know, so quick after last week. I wanted
- 0:49to bring you a series of talks on the topic of
- 0:52covering traumatic events. Many of you in this
- 0:55server have reported on or witnessed traumatic
- 0:58events in the past year. It's important that
- 1:01when we're in that research mode that we remember
- 1:04those that feature in the images or videos you
- 1:06might be focusing on are real human beings with
- 1:09thoughts and lives. But how do we continue to
- 1:12do our jobs and remain respectful and true to
- 1:16those featured in these atrocities? Well, Dr.
- 1:19Aleksa Konig next to me is co -faculty director
- 1:22of UC Berkeley's Human Rights Center and a research
- 1:25professor at UC Berkeley School of Law. She co
- 1:28-founded the Human Rights Center Investigations
- 1:30Lab and is a director of the investigations program.
- 1:33She's also an author, including of such titles,
- 1:36Graphic Trauma and Meaning in Our Online Lives,
- 1:39Hiding in Plain Sight and Digital Witness. She
- 1:41is a very busy lady. She's covered extensively
- 1:44how to report on potential war crimes and gender
- 1:46-based violence with open sources and today we're
- 1:50going to dive into her research on gender -based
- 1:52violence. Please note today's discussion will
- 1:56potentially reference abuse towards men, women
- 1:59and children. If you'd like to ask a question
- 2:02please do so in the chat as I mentioned it's
- 2:04in the top right hand side of your screen as
- 2:07we talk. Please note in your question, if you
- 2:10don't want me to mention your name, because this
- 2:13is being audio recorded. And please remember
- 2:16that there may be people within this space who
- 2:18have lived experience of what we're discussing.
- 2:21So please remain respectful. That all being said,
- 2:25Alexa, I'll pass on to you. Please introduce
- 2:29your work within this topic. And thank you again
- 2:32for joining us. Thank you, Charlie, for having
- 2:35me and thank you to all of Bellingcat and to
- 2:37everyone for being here today to talk about this
- 2:40issue that has become incredibly near and dear
- 2:42to my heart. As Charlie mentioned, our background
- 2:45at the Human Rights Center has really focused
- 2:48a lot on digital open source investigations.
- 2:51I started at the Human Rights Center at UC Berkeley
- 2:54back in 2007 when I was a graduate student and
- 2:57kind of stuck on in 2012 becoming the executive
- 3:00director and now co -faculty director. During
- 3:04the time that I was there, starting around 2010,
- 3:06one of the things that we noticed in war crimes
- 3:09investigations more generally was the deep need
- 3:11for better understanding how sexual violence
- 3:14happens in conflict. And we launched a sexual
- 3:17violence and conflict program that my colleague
- 3:20in Selinger, who's most recently been with the
- 3:22International Criminal Court, ended up directing.
- 3:25We also had begun working very closely with the
- 3:28International Criminal Court and other justice
- 3:30and accountability actors to think about the
- 3:32ways that new and emerging technologies were
- 3:35helping to establish evidence of potential crimes,
- 3:38particularly international crimes, that needed
- 3:41some sort of reconciliation. Back in 2010, 2011,
- 3:452012, the International Criminal Court was coming
- 3:47up on its 10 -year anniversary. And unfortunately,
- 3:51the Office of the Prosecutor was losing a lot
- 3:53of its cases. One of the things that a research
- 3:56team from our center determined was that the
- 3:59main complaint of the judges was that the prosecution
- 4:02was not bringing in corroborating information
- 4:04that would help support what survivors were saying
- 4:07they were experiencing in their communities.
- 4:09And so that really began this parallel quest
- 4:12for the last decade and a half of thinking about
- 4:14how things like information posted to social
- 4:17media sites, information captured on smartphones
- 4:20and disseminated might be useful as evidence
- 4:22in courts of law. Those two trajectories, though,
- 4:26on sexual violence and conflict and technology
- 4:28and war really did not converge until fairly
- 4:32recently. And I'd say in the broader field of
- 4:34war crimes investigations more generally, they
- 4:36still have not converged. When I did training
- 4:40in war crimes investigations with the Institute
- 4:43for International Criminal Investigations, we
- 4:45certainly had a unit on sexual and gender -based
- 4:48violence. But those specialized topics are kept
- 4:51very separate from digital open source And it's
- 4:54only been recently that we've begun to see a
- 4:56real hunger to try to begin to bring those worlds
- 4:59together because of the incredible utility of
- 5:02digital open source methods for helping us make
- 5:05sense of what's happened in the world. We now
- 5:07have a professional training program where we
- 5:10do try to train people on the careful use of
- 5:13these methodologies. There are really two, I
- 5:16think, big challenges in the space that today
- 5:19open source investigators are really trying to
- 5:21grapple with to figure out how we make this work
- 5:23as ethical, as efficient, and as effective as
- 5:27possible. One is the gross under prosecution
- 5:30and accountability for sexual and gender based
- 5:33crimes. We know that historically those crimes
- 5:36have been deeply under prosecuted. And even most
- 5:39recently at the International Criminal Court
- 5:41where there was a successful conviction of a
- 5:44gentleman by the name of Al Hassan who was accused
- 5:47of egregious international crimes in Timbuktu
- 5:50and Mali. He ended up being convicted of almost
- 5:54all of the charges brought against him with the
- 5:56exception of sexual and gender -based violence.
- 5:59This is despite abundant evidence. This is despite
- 6:02a lot of the incidents overlapping for other
- 6:04kinds of crimes like religious persecution. So
- 6:07there really, I think there is a recognition
- 6:10that we really do need to think through the evidentiary
- 6:12foundations of such cases and begin to identify
- 6:15the gaps that are allowing these kinds of crimes
- 6:18to go under addressed. At the same time, I think
- 6:21there's a real skepticism and in some cases a
- 6:25real concern. with bringing digital methodologies
- 6:28into these investigations and these prosecutions.
- 6:31So I work very closely with a few colleagues
- 6:33from around the world, Juan Ulick Egan. He and
- 6:36I've done a number of different studies of what
- 6:38is, how do we begin to fill that gap between
- 6:41the hunger to get more justice and accountability,
- 6:44the deep knowledge of methods that have been
- 6:46pioneered by groups like Belincat. to think about
- 6:49the use of these digital methods and actually
- 6:52getting some form of success. And so we've talked
- 6:55with three different sets of individuals. One
- 6:58group have been people who are trained in investigating
- 7:01sexual and gender -based violence through very
- 7:03traditional methodologies like face -to -face
- 7:06interviewing or collecting physical evidence,
- 7:08getting medical records, et cetera. Second have
- 7:11been digital open source investigators. What
- 7:13are the challenges that they've seen and that
- 7:15they're experiencing? And then the third are
- 7:18gender experts who really have kind of a broad
- 7:21sense of the ways that different gendered crimes
- 7:23can play out. What we have consistently found
- 7:27is that on the side of digital open source investigators,
- 7:30there's been sort of a response of I don't mean
- 7:34that in a negative sense. I just mean lack of
- 7:36awareness of some of the specialized ways that
- 7:39different kinds of terminology, different kinds
- 7:41of communication patterns happen, specifically
- 7:44with these deeply stigmatized crimes that may
- 7:47be different than other things that we're detecting
- 7:49through open methods, like attacks on hospitals
- 7:51or the bombing of buildings. On the side of the
- 7:55sexual and gender -based violence investigators,
- 7:57I'd say that their experience or their response
- 8:00has ranged from skeptical to even hostile to
- 8:03having digital investigators get involved. And
- 8:05they have some really good reasons for that.
- 8:08One of the things that we've seen in the sexual
- 8:10and gender -based violence community is that
- 8:12over the last 20 to 30 years, I pioneered a lot
- 8:16of new resources and tools for investigating
- 8:18these crimes. Those have all been, and I think
- 8:21rightfully so, putting the survivor at the center
- 8:24of those methodologies and trying to think about
- 8:26how to do no more harm with the investigative
- 8:29process. They've also really been trying to bolster
- 8:33the response of judges to the evidence that comes
- 8:35into courts. So getting the judges to not have
- 8:39a quote unquote he said she said type of situation
- 8:41where they basically are saying we need additional
- 8:43evidence to break that tie, but to believe survivors
- 8:47and to have that testimony have sufficient weight.
- 8:52So I think that one of the fears that we have
- 8:54heard repeatedly from those traditional investigators
- 8:57is If it begins to be that these cases bring
- 9:00in more video and photographic evidence or other
- 9:03stuff that may be pulled from social media, eventually
- 9:06the judges may demand that kind of evidence and
- 9:09actually have it weaken or in some ways undercut
- 9:12the oral testimony that these survivors may give
- 9:15in court. I do think that based on the research
- 9:18that I've been doing with my colleagues, one
- 9:20of the things that we're trying to basically
- 9:23communicate across these areas of practice is
- 9:25actually Even if that is the concern, there are
- 9:28still so many ways that digital open source information
- 9:30can be helpful. For example, digital open source
- 9:34information can help prove the crime base that
- 9:36sexual and gender based violence has taken place.
- 9:39And whether you're looking for that affirmatively
- 9:41or you stumble across it in the course of your
- 9:43investigative work, it is really important evidence
- 9:47that could potentially be helpful if it's handled.
- 9:50to forensic and ethical standards. The second
- 9:54is it can provide really valuable indirect evidence
- 9:57that sexual and gender -based violence has occurred
- 9:59and who may have perpetrated it. So everything
- 10:02from identifying the units who may have swept
- 10:04through a town where we believe these things
- 10:06have happened. to identify what are called proxy
- 10:10indicators of sexual and gender -based violence,
- 10:13I think can be really helpful. So by proxy indicators,
- 10:17if any of you aren't familiar with that term,
- 10:18I know there's a great piece that was written
- 10:21by Hannah Bagdazar, who used to be with Bellingcat
- 10:23on this. But war crimes investigators have identified
- 10:26a number of different phenomena that you might
- 10:30see in a conflict context that indicate that
- 10:33sexual and gender -based violence has taken place,
- 10:35even if you don't have the direct evidence itself.
- 10:37So some examples of that would be things like
- 10:40the separation of women and girls from men and
- 10:43boys, things like the burning of villages. I
- 10:46do think there's tremendous possibilities there,
- 10:48particularly with the advent of artificial intelligence
- 10:51-based technologies and machine learning, to
- 10:53begin to find the signal in the noise in ways
- 10:56that humans may not pick up on, particularly
- 10:58if you have a number of these proxy indicators
- 11:01that have all converged at a particular time
- 11:03and a particular place. The third category where
- 11:06I think digital open source information can be
- 11:08deeply helpful is on providing the context or
- 11:12the contextual evidence around a particular incident.
- 11:15This is especially relevant for when you're trying
- 11:18to establish it in an international crime like
- 11:20genocide or crimes against humanity or war crimes
- 11:23have taken place. In that case, you're not just
- 11:25trying to prove that a rape or other forms of
- 11:28sexual violence have occurred, but you need to
- 11:30establish that there's a nexus to war if you're
- 11:33establishing war crimes. You need to prove that
- 11:35this kind of pattern of behavior was systematic
- 11:38or widespread. If you're going to establish this
- 11:40as an international crime against humanity, and
- 11:43if you want to establish this as a piece of genocide,
- 11:45to establish that the intent behind the perpetrators
- 11:48was to destroy in whole or in part a particular
- 11:51group on the basis of their ethnicity and nationality,
- 11:54religion, et cetera. So I think overcoming that
- 11:58and making sure that more traditional investigators
- 12:00have a broad understanding of the full range
- 12:03of utility of these methods is deeply important.
- 12:06At the same time, I think there's some real opportunities
- 12:09for training among this community of practice
- 12:12to understand the fears and the concerns of both
- 12:15survivors and traditional investigators and to
- 12:18think through kind of the complementary function
- 12:21that this sort of information can share. The
- 12:25other thing that I might say is that We've heard
- 12:29from a lot of traditional investigators who are
- 12:31also just deeply concerned about anyone investigating
- 12:34these issues without specialized training. In
- 12:38part, it's because of the social stigmas and
- 12:40harms that can come from the revelation that
- 12:43someone has experienced sexual and gender -based
- 12:45violence. This obviously can have very differential
- 12:47harms depending on the community or culture from
- 12:50which the survivor's been impacted. So everything
- 12:53from honor killings, if it turns out that someone
- 12:55has been raped, to other forms of stigmatization
- 12:59and ostracization are really important to think
- 13:02through. I've certainly heard stories of open
- 13:06source investigators either trying to crowdsource
- 13:08who the perpetrators were for a particular rape
- 13:10and having that really create a negative backlash
- 13:13for them and for the survivor. I've also heard
- 13:16of information getting posted online or amplified
- 13:19online by members of the digital open source
- 13:21investigations community where survivors who
- 13:25were going to be testifying in court recanted
- 13:27their testimony when it came out more publicly
- 13:29that they had experienced sexual and gender -based
- 13:32violence. because in their communities and their
- 13:35cultures, the backlash would be so great that
- 13:37they may be expelled from their families or their
- 13:39communities, and they were not understandably
- 13:41willing to take that risk. So I think there's
- 13:45a few tools that are beginning to emerge that
- 13:47I would also just want to make this community
- 13:48aware of if you're not already. As part of this
- 13:52phenomenon of trying to make investigations and
- 13:55investigators really sensitive to the phenomena
- 13:59that are unique to this area of practice, There
- 14:02are a number of tools that have been created
- 14:04for more traditional investigations. One of those
- 14:07is an international protocol on investigating
- 14:09sexual and gender -based violence. I believe
- 14:11that came out initially around 2014. I do think
- 14:14even for the digital investigations community,
- 14:17it's good to review that set of guidelines, even
- 14:20though there's very little mention of digital
- 14:22methodologies, because a lot of the fundamental
- 14:24concepts of how to be sensitive in your investigations
- 14:28hold true. The second is something called the
- 14:31Maraud code. It is named after Nadia Murad, who
- 14:35won the Nobel Peace Prize for her activism around
- 14:38the treatment of sexual and gender -based violence
- 14:40survivors. She is herself a Yazidi activist who
- 14:45unfortunately suffered under the genocide perpetrated
- 14:48against the Yazidi community. And I think one
- 14:51of the things she became very overwhelmed with
- 14:53as this genocide was being investigated was how
- 14:57often journalists or war crimes investigators
- 15:00or trying to get information from her and really
- 15:02overwhelming individuals like herself and others
- 15:05who've experienced these kinds of crimes. And
- 15:07she really wanted to give back to the broader
- 15:09investigations community about how to and how
- 15:12not to handle these kinds of things, both confidentially
- 15:16and when putting information out publicly. So
- 15:19the Maraud Code was a partnership that was informed
- 15:22by a global consultative process. was coordinated
- 15:25by the Institute for International Criminal Investigations
- 15:28and can be accessed for free in a number of languages
- 15:31on their website. It was also in partnership
- 15:34with Nadia Murad's organization, and it was informed
- 15:38by the input of a number of survivors. The challenge
- 15:41with the Maraud code, however, is that while
- 15:45it does in a few places mention digital open
- 15:47source investigations, the primary focus really
- 15:51does assume that you are face to face with the
- 15:53survivor and that most of the evidence that you're
- 15:56collecting is testimonial evidence. So a number
- 16:00of us from a number of different open source
- 16:02investigative organizations have kind of worked
- 16:06together to begin to translate the Maraud code
- 16:09for digital open source investigative practice.
- 16:12This is a document. It's basically been called
- 16:14the Open Source Researcher's Guide to Systematic
- 16:18and Conflict -Related Sexual Violence. It will
- 16:21go up publicly in about two weeks, we're estimating.
- 16:24And the idea is that we'll have it open and available
- 16:27for people to use for approximately a six -month
- 16:30period and to give input. So we'll have an input
- 16:32form where, as you're using it, one thing we'd
- 16:35greatly appreciate is feedback on what works
- 16:37for you and what doesn't. It is probably the
- 16:40hardest project I have ever contributed to, to
- 16:43draft, even though it is again informed by global
- 16:46consultation of different units around the world
- 16:48and different individual investigators. in part
- 16:52because we're trying to bring those sexual and
- 16:53gender -based violence to very experienced investigators
- 16:56together with digital open source investigators.
- 16:59And I think from an ethics perspective, we've
- 17:02really needed both a push and a pull. So a push
- 17:05to encourage people to think about the ways this
- 17:07information can be useful as evidence and to
- 17:10not overlook it or undervalue it in the bigger
- 17:13arc of an international criminal investigation,
- 17:16but to also pull back a little bit and to think
- 17:18about sort of the how to keep the survivor centered,
- 17:22how to keep them in the driver's seat. I think
- 17:24one of the biggest challenges we've had is, you
- 17:28know, if rape is a crime that is characterized
- 17:30by a lack of consent of the survivor to what
- 17:33is done to them. The last thing we want is a
- 17:36lack of their own consent for how the information
- 17:39about their own experience is being utilized
- 17:42for investigation or court processes. So how
- 17:44we keep them in the driver's seat and don't gamify
- 17:47some of these investigations, but make it a true
- 17:49partnership where it's appropriate to do so.
- 17:52So that will be coming up. I think the last couple
- 17:55of things that I'd want to mention is I did write
- 17:58with two colleagues, Anthony Galli and Simone
- 18:01Levine, a piece that was again informed by a
- 18:03number of different people. input on the role
- 18:05of consent in digital open source investigations
- 18:08of sexual and gender -based violence. That came
- 18:11from a bunch of work that had been done by incredible
- 18:14researchers and investigators who would write
- 18:17about this topic and say, of course, we always
- 18:19need consent to use this material. I think one
- 18:22of the questions that I had as a practitioner
- 18:24on the side of we also run investigations in
- 18:27addition to doing kind of more the academic research
- 18:30was whose consent are we even talking about when
- 18:33we're in the digital context? Is it the person
- 18:36who captured the information on their smartphone?
- 18:38Is it the person who posted it? Is it the bystanders
- 18:42who may be in the background? Is it just the
- 18:44victim? Is the victim alive or dead or can they
- 18:48even be located? What is the best way to reach
- 18:50out to them when All we may have is a handle
- 18:53or a digital profile, and we may not know who
- 18:55was behind that or managing that profile. All
- 18:59of these, I think, were things that we didn't
- 19:01mean to make more complicated on purpose, but
- 19:03I think were very real questions that we were
- 19:05having as we were working on these things. And
- 19:07so I think one of the things that we ended up
- 19:09putting together was a typology of asking, as
- 19:12the open source investigator, what is the intended
- 19:15use of this information? So for example, the
- 19:18consent we may need if we want to use this as
- 19:21crime -based evidence, meaning evidence that
- 19:23this kind of crime has taken place, may be very
- 19:26different than just getting leads to who may
- 19:28have been present at the time or who may have
- 19:30taken additional video or may be able to testify.
- 19:34Whose consent are we really talking about? Are
- 19:37we trying to use this almost more for intellectual
- 19:39property reasons to illustrate something that
- 19:42we're putting out as an article? Or is this something
- 19:45that would actually come into a court of law
- 19:47to try to establish a fact at issue in a trial?
- 19:50And then, of course, the nature of the content.
- 19:52Is this direct evidence, indirect evidence, contextual
- 19:55evidence, et cetera? I've probably been talking
- 19:58for way too long, so maybe the last thing I'll
- 20:00mention that will be coming out that I hope is
- 20:02helpful is my colleague, Lulik, and I are working
- 20:05on a book right now that will hopefully be out
- 20:06next year from University of California Press
- 20:09that is specifically on all the ways that digital
- 20:12open source information. can hopefully help to
- 20:15strengthen these investigations and prosecutions
- 20:17of some of these deeply underappreciated or sometimes
- 20:21under -investigated crimes. Lynn, maybe I'll
- 20:24turn it back to you. Amazing. Thank you so much
- 20:29for running us through basically your entire
- 20:32career in 15 minutes. I really appreciate it.
- 20:38There's been a lot of people really liking some
- 20:42of the references that you've made. The Murad
- 20:44Code is actually pinned in our gender -based
- 20:46violence channel as well. So if you are interested
- 20:49in this topic and you want to dig deeper within
- 20:51the server, we actually have a space for that.
- 20:53It's called hashtag gender -based violence misogyny,
- 20:57and it's linked in the chat. We've also got a
- 21:00few people very excited about your two -week
- 21:02publication and your book, which is great. I
- 21:05can see that people are typing questions as we
- 21:07speak. Please make sure that you're asking your
- 21:09questions in the chat. But first, I wanted to
- 21:12ask, Alexa, and this is a little bit more personal
- 21:14before we delve into the gender -based part.
- 21:16What really made you start looking into this
- 21:19particular topic? Was it the gaps as you spoke
- 21:23about? Is that why you felt that this particular
- 21:27topic needed more research on it? I think part
- 21:30of it's a little, what is it? I think I enjoy
- 21:35the tricky gray zones where there doesn't seem
- 21:40to be much light being shown. And I do think
- 21:43it was sort of the unique confluence of working
- 21:45at the Human Rights Center. I was a graduate
- 21:47student researcher on the sexual and gender -based
- 21:49violence, sexual and conflict, sexual violence
- 21:52and conflict program when it was started in 2010.
- 21:54And so I had had the incredible experience of
- 21:59getting to... Kim and her work in that area and
- 22:02going places like Kenya and hearing from lawyers,
- 22:06from judges, from survivors. Particularly one
- 22:09of the things that we first started looking at
- 22:11was the 2007 -2008 elections in Kenya where there
- 22:14was unfortunately a tremendous amount of conflict
- 22:16that broke out and it was characterized by rampant
- 22:19sexual and gender -based violence. So hearing
- 22:22how that was playing out in various communities.
- 22:25and just the strength of survivors in demanding
- 22:29better accountability for what they had experienced
- 22:32and identifying the gaps in the law where the
- 22:35law was not well situated to actually address
- 22:37those challenges with illuminating. So one of
- 22:40the examples was that Kenya had a very progressive
- 22:43new set of laws to combat sexual and gender -based
- 22:45violence, but one provision at the time said
- 22:48that any woman, and they assumed that the survivor
- 22:50was a woman, not a man or a child, but any woman
- 22:53who reports or basically accuses a man of perpetrating
- 22:57sexual and gender -based violence. If she loses
- 23:00her case, she will be subject to the same punishment
- 23:03as the man would have been had he been convicted.
- 23:06Well, given the fact that it is so difficult
- 23:10to win sexual and gender -based violence cases,
- 23:13the standards of proof are very high, the available
- 23:16evidence is often very thin, particularly if
- 23:18people didn't go right away to a medical facility
- 23:21or that information wasn't collected in a forensic
- 23:24manner, that is a huge bar to ask any survivor
- 23:27to go through. And so it was little things like
- 23:30really seeing the leadership from these Kenyan
- 23:32survivor communities to push back against the
- 23:35way these laws have been formed. in ways that
- 23:37really didn't take into consideration their lived
- 23:39experience. So I became deeply dedicated to really
- 23:42thinking through some of these issues and what,
- 23:44as someone based in Berkeley, California, what
- 23:46we could be doing to survive these ground -up
- 23:49movements to make things better and to shine
- 23:52a light on these underlooked crimes. The second
- 23:54was... I was put almost like back in 2010, 2011
- 23:58on the International Criminal Court related work
- 24:01and that I became obsessed. We hosted a first
- 24:03workshop at the International Criminal Court
- 24:05in 2012 where we brought together people who
- 24:08were pioneering new uses of satellite imagery,
- 24:10people who were really thinking about the spread
- 24:12of the smartphone globally and how information
- 24:15could be captured. how information you capture
- 24:18on your smartphone, what tweaks needed to be
- 24:19made to make this have maximum weight in courtrooms.
- 24:23So things like capturing the 360 -degree pan
- 24:26so it was easier to geolocate this information
- 24:29or chronolocate this data. It was little tips
- 24:32and tricks that we began to work with a number
- 24:34of different NGOs to try to disseminate out to
- 24:36activist communities and conflict areas. That
- 24:39became my whole bread and butter was the new
- 24:42technologies piece, looking at drones, looking
- 24:44at big data sets and data analytics, the rise
- 24:48of machine learning processes and how we could
- 24:50harness this in more sensitive ways. Kim was
- 24:53running one program and I was running the other
- 24:56and they were very different cultures and communities.
- 24:58So her community of practice was almost all women
- 25:01led. The communities that I was part of, I was
- 25:04often the only woman in the room. I remember
- 25:06going to a meeting of legal investigators at
- 25:09one point, and there were probably 45, 40 to
- 25:1250 people in the room. They were seated in an
- 25:14O with kind of the investigative team at the
- 25:16front. And there was one woman, and I forget
- 25:20which country in Africa she was from, and there
- 25:22was me, and they put us at the top end of each
- 25:25U, and then the rest were all men around this
- 25:27giant circle. And I remember feeling like I was
- 25:29there to represent all kind of Western Northern
- 25:32women, and she was there to represent all women
- 25:34from the global South. And it was very, it was
- 25:37just a very different culture and climate. And
- 25:40then you take war and conflict investigations,
- 25:42and you add on top of that the tech layer. And
- 25:45it just was a different way of thinking. And
- 25:47I think very much we were leaning into war, conflict,
- 25:51more visible aspects of that, particularly because
- 25:54social media and smartphones had really helped
- 25:56to begin to build this open source investigative
- 25:59space. So it was very visually oriented. And
- 26:01we're talking about sexual and gender -based
- 26:03violence. Well, I had done a dissertation on
- 26:06the experiences of men in Guantanamo, many of
- 26:08whom unfortunately experienced sexual and gender
- 26:10-based violence themselves. But the thing that
- 26:12I remember from my interviews with them is that
- 26:14when issues of SGBV would come up, it would be
- 26:17very much looking down. It was much more subtle
- 26:19ways of communicating that this had happened.
- 26:22And it may be phrases like, I was tortured like
- 26:24all the rest. Oftentimes when we talk about men,
- 26:28The terminology that's used is very different
- 26:30than it is for women. It's almost always identified
- 26:32as torture and not a sexual and gender -based
- 26:34violence, which is why the end of prosecution
- 26:37and investigation for them is even greater than
- 26:39for women oftentimes. And just, it's often little
- 26:43physical things that you may not notice. There
- 26:46is a longtime war crimes investigator named Romeo
- 26:48Delaire, and he spent decades boots on the ground
- 26:52in places like the former Yugoslavia, I believe
- 26:54Rwanda, etc. He's written in his autobiography
- 26:57that it took him years to begin to even just
- 27:00recognize the subtle visual cues that come up
- 27:04when SGDB has happened. So noticing the ways
- 27:07that someone's legs may be apart, and I'm sorry
- 27:09if that gets too graphic, or there may be broken
- 27:11off, you know, shotguns or broom handles nearby.
- 27:15He would see that someone had been killed, but
- 27:17he wouldn't pick up these kind of more subtle
- 27:20visual indicators that this may also be a bigger
- 27:23set of crimes. So I became obsessed with how
- 27:26do we begin to bring those two worlds together
- 27:28in a way that can have greater impact understanding
- 27:31the gross under -prosecution of SGDV and knowing
- 27:35the deep dedication of this open source investigative
- 27:37community to bring the best that everyone can
- 27:40to these efforts to pursue justice. That is super
- 27:45interesting. Maybe towards the end of the talk,
- 27:48if you could just write Romeo's full name, because
- 27:51I had a little Google, but can't find him. And
- 27:55I think that research is incredible. And I think
- 27:58that book would be something that a lot of people
- 28:00would like to read in the server. It's interesting
- 28:03you mentioned judiciary, and it's really interesting
- 28:07that globally, there's this problem of convicting
- 28:11gender -based violence crimes globally. It's
- 28:14not just one country problem, it's everywhere.
- 28:17Malarika asked, is there a similar project underway
- 28:21to help establish guidelines for judges in analyzing
- 28:23different forms of evidence? You mentioned not
- 28:25wanting to devalue testimonial evidence by using
- 28:28too much digital OSINT evidence, but where else
- 28:31is this dialogue happening and is it codified
- 28:33anywhere? How does that work? Oh, it's such a
- 28:37great question. I think about eight or nine other
- 28:41NGOs got together a couple summers ago, and we
- 28:44have now just launched a judge's guide to digital
- 28:47open source investigations. And the idea is that
- 28:51it would be kind of a way to help explain some
- 28:54of the basics of open source investigative methodologies
- 28:57like geolocation and chronolocation, ways this
- 29:01information can come in as crime -based evidence
- 29:03or as lead or linkage information. So that is
- 29:07available. It's now available in a number of
- 29:09different languages, I think like seven or eight
- 29:10languages. If anyone wants a copy, please feel
- 29:13free to reach out. We can get that to you. It's
- 29:15all free. But it's not specific to this particular
- 29:19set of crimes. And I do think there's an extraordinary
- 29:22amount of work that still needs to go into strengthening
- 29:24every link in the chain of accountability. So
- 29:27what I deeply appreciate about the Bellingcat
- 29:30community and others like it, and kind of the
- 29:32broader ecosystem that we're all a part of, is
- 29:35that we put so much work into pioneering methodologies
- 29:38and thinking through how we can maximize the
- 29:42evidentiary value from the information that's
- 29:43put up in public spaces online. But then how
- 29:46do we think about the ways that trial attorneys
- 29:50are going to use it in court? Oftentimes, if
- 29:53they don't have a facility with how to explain
- 29:55these methodologies, then they're likely to either
- 29:59scrap them or not be able to defend them well.
- 30:03I think defense attorneys really need a lot of
- 30:06support and even knowing what the weaknesses
- 30:08are of this. My career has all been about pushing
- 30:11out these methods and trying to get them more
- 30:13mainstreamed, particularly in legal process.
- 30:15But it was probably about five or six years ago,
- 30:18triggered in part by the really phenomenal response
- 30:21to the Albert Folley explainer that was put out
- 30:24by Bellingcat. It's still one that I use in every
- 30:26class that I teach because it's such a good overview
- 30:28of how satellite imagery can be triangulated
- 30:31with video, with other bits of information to
- 30:34try to help establish the who, what, when, where,
- 30:35why, and how. What something in me was just the
- 30:40broad -based, oh my gosh, Bellingcat has proven
- 30:43it. it's so clear now legally what's happened.
- 30:46And that made me nervous as an attorney because
- 30:49as a lawyer, some of you have probably seen this
- 30:52piece, but there's one still from a video where
- 30:54there's a number of dark spots on the soil. Like
- 30:58as an attorney, just saying that these dark spots
- 31:00in the soil are likely blood or whatever is not
- 31:03going to be sufficient for actually establishing
- 31:05that this is in fact what you claim it to be.
- 31:07Like you would want soil samples, you would want
- 31:09testimonies. And so really helping Defense, understand
- 31:15what questions to even ask. If our goal is to
- 31:18get to the truth and full transparency, we really
- 31:21need robust teams on either side to help bring
- 31:24that to the surface. And this is kind of betraying
- 31:26my Western lawyer tendencies to even say that
- 31:28in the first place. So I do think there's a powerful
- 31:31role of storytelling and journalism in this entire
- 31:34ecosystem to drive up attention to things that
- 31:37need to be paid attention to and to motivate
- 31:40lawyers to even pick up these cases in the first
- 31:42place because people care. But then there's the
- 31:45legal evidentiary side where the standards are
- 31:47much higher and you're not necessarily telling.
- 31:50just one story, but you're having to really interrogate
- 31:52that story to hopefully make sure the right person
- 31:55goes behind bars and that this is in fact something
- 31:58where, you know, sometimes I think there's a
- 32:00lot of great research out there that says, as
- 32:03human beings, we over rely on what we can see
- 32:04with our eyes. And we tend to fill in a lot of
- 32:07gaps in our understanding with assumptions that
- 32:09we're not even aware we're making. And there
- 32:11is a lot of research that suggests that there's
- 32:14not a one -to -one correlation between confidence
- 32:16and accuracy in analyzing visual material. And
- 32:20as open source investigators, I think it's really
- 32:22important that we understand those weaknesses
- 32:24and potential fallacies, that we can do what
- 32:27we can to potentially offset them if what we
- 32:30really want is the truth. And I think I've drifted
- 32:33way too off stream. So that's a big piece. I
- 32:37do think one thing we would love is, as we're
- 32:40putting out this open source investigators guide
- 32:42to investigating sexual and gender -based violence,
- 32:46in addition to really hoping to crowdsource feedback
- 32:49about what works, what doesn't, where there's
- 32:51gaps that you wish could be filled for the final
- 32:53version. Any citations to great resources that
- 32:57you think should have more attention from this
- 32:59broader community of practice, we would love
- 33:01to make sure that we're integrating that, understanding
- 33:04that I think even among kind of the global consultation
- 33:07that we've been doing, that's obviously going
- 33:10to be a biased perspective and there may be some
- 33:12great resources that we've overlooked. Somebody
- 33:21in the chat has already found Romeo Delaire for
- 33:25me, so thank you so much. They've already put
- 33:29the links in there. Speaking of kind of recognizing
- 33:33science, Sarah, one of our lovely mods, has written,
- 33:38Hi Alexa, recently there have been articles about
- 33:41sexual violence occurring in the women's area
- 33:44of Muzanzi prison in Goma during the seizure
- 33:46of the city by the M23 rebels. There are a lot
- 33:50of open source videos of the interior of the
- 33:53prison. The articles which document this incident
- 33:56just use the traditional, there are reports,
- 33:59versus an examination of the scene. Based on
- 34:02Hannah's articles, which by the way I've linked
- 34:04in the chat, I can identify some indicators.
- 34:08Burning the scene down, burned bodies, some bottles.
- 34:11I feel like there's enough to talk about in an
- 34:13article, but frankly I don't feel good about
- 34:16writing it. I feel I'm... not educated enough
- 34:18to say, yes, this is a good example. Do you know
- 34:21of any further resources or subject matter experts
- 34:24I could talk to to help me evaluate what I've
- 34:27seen? Thanks. Such a good question also. Absolutely.
- 34:34I do think that one thing I really appreciate,
- 34:36Charlie, about your work and what you've all
- 34:39been leading on in Bellingcat is putting together
- 34:41a subgroup of people who are really interested
- 34:45in these particular issues that hopefully can
- 34:47be peer reviewers and resources for each other.
- 34:51Certainly, I think that if you wanted to reach
- 34:53out to us or to the Institute for International
- 34:56Criminal Investigations, we can always give insight
- 34:59and input. One of my extraordinary colleagues,
- 35:02Andrea Richardson, she worked as a war crimes
- 35:05investigator for a long time and her specialized
- 35:07area was open source investigation. She had graduated
- 35:11from our program alongside Hia and really kind
- 35:15of deployed those digital open source skills
- 35:17to work with this international investigative
- 35:19body looking at sexual and gender based violence
- 35:22crimes. But I think she's one of the best people
- 35:24that I can think of that really has a deep dedication
- 35:26to this intersection and can think that through.
- 35:31So yeah, I really, we then, and this is something
- 35:34I'd also love to bring back to the Institute
- 35:35for International Criminal Investigations. So
- 35:37they are working with us on developing these
- 35:39guides, but they also work and lead classes and
- 35:42trainings on sexual and gender -based violence.
- 35:44And they have an extraordinary roster. of experts
- 35:47in that space. What I'd love to see is more coming
- 35:49together of digital open source investigators
- 35:51with those traditional investigators, with the
- 35:54gendered crime experts, to be able to even see
- 35:57if we could create kind of a sub like group of
- 36:00all of us to help each other grow and learn about
- 36:02how to make these investigations as robust as
- 36:05possible. There's someone I had interviewed for
- 36:09Elix in my book who said, You know, one of the
- 36:12big challenges in the space, for example, is
- 36:14that when you learn a foreign language, you learn
- 36:16how to ask how to order food in a restaurant
- 36:18or where the bathroom is or how to find a particular
- 36:21location. But you're not taught the words for
- 36:24sex, certainly not the slang terms for sex. You
- 36:27might pick that up kind of colloquially. You're
- 36:29also just not taught the terms for parts of the
- 36:32body. And so there's a lot of kind of a lack
- 36:34of that understanding of language and how it
- 36:37plays out. I'm hopeful that machine learning
- 36:40processes can help us identify these proxy indicators
- 36:44that you're talking about in ways that we may
- 36:46not have a tremendous degree of confidence, but
- 36:49maybe this is a great way for machines to sort
- 36:51of complement humans in helping us make sense
- 36:54of what actually we may have and fully mining
- 36:57that and helping us understand the reliability
- 37:00and trustworthiness. I also think machine learning
- 37:03processes could help us begin to identify terminology,
- 37:06the way it's being used, the ways that subtle
- 37:08visual cues may be popping up that correlate
- 37:12with sexual and gender -based violence so that
- 37:14we just have an easier time as investigators
- 37:17not overlooking this. Definitely not alone in
- 37:20feeling like there's not enough to publish on
- 37:21this. I have talked with major media publications
- 37:24who've been very nervous about even saying, For
- 37:28example, in a very famous conflict that SGVB
- 37:30has happened, they're very confident in saying
- 37:32hospitals have been attacked or schools have
- 37:34been attacked. Not that, because the indicators
- 37:37are often so subtle. So I do think getting a
- 37:39couple of these experts to say, yeah, these things
- 37:41are subtle, but this makes so much sense and
- 37:43it's so common. And what we've seen repeatedly
- 37:46is that particularly in detention facilities,
- 37:48this is rampant. And here's what we know. I think
- 37:51that could be brought together. Yeah, the reason
- 37:56we wanted this talk and what we've been talking
- 37:58about quite a lot in the gender -based violence
- 38:00channel is the need for training, more training
- 38:03on this and reporting in general. And hopefully
- 38:08this discussion is very nice base layer for something
- 38:12that we can potentially pursue going forward.
- 38:16Just linked to that slightly. Alpha says, so
- 38:19it's kind of touched on culture as a significant
- 38:22issue in pursuing justice in many SGBV cases.
- 38:25What are additional precautions we can take to
- 38:28bypass cultural clashes and the issues they can
- 38:31create so the evidence is compelling whoever
- 38:34sees it? I think that with this topic and the
- 38:41subject area more than any others that I've personally
- 38:44investigated, it's It kind of calls on the best
- 38:47part of open source investigations, which is
- 38:49the collaborative component of it and the multidisciplinary
- 38:52component of it. I do think ideally that each
- 38:56of us, if we are working on these issues, kind
- 38:59of begins to build a roster for ourselves and
- 39:02for our teams if we're working as part of a team
- 39:04of like who's a gender expert that we can talk
- 39:06to who if we're not from that community or that
- 39:09culture is someone that has knowledge of sexual
- 39:12and gender -based violence in that community
- 39:14and culture who can help us understand the risks
- 39:17of what we may be thinking of putting out that
- 39:19also help us pick up the signals and the noise
- 39:21that we may not ourselves be detecting. I think
- 39:24having that one, you know, we're doing a lot
- 39:26right now in gender persecution in Iran. And
- 39:29one of the things that's been so invaluable is
- 39:31just having a couple of Iranian researchers on
- 39:34the team who had to leave the country, who deeply,
- 39:37I mean, And some of them just pick up things
- 39:40that would take me, like they can geolocate something
- 39:42in a matter of seconds because they're like,
- 39:44oh yeah, I used to walk on that street. I mean,
- 39:46I think we've all had that experience when we're
- 39:47from outside a community, how long it may take
- 39:49versus someone who's familiar with that community.
- 39:52I think particularly with sexual and gender -based
- 39:53violence and the ways that gets wrapped into
- 39:56cultures and relationships. It's important. So
- 39:59ideally, I think you'd have a digital open source
- 40:00investigative expert. You'd have someone who
- 40:03deeply understands the culture and context and
- 40:05someone who understands sexual and gender based
- 40:07violence and how it plays out. And ideally, that
- 40:09becomes your team or your circle of advisors
- 40:11as you're pulling this together. This community
- 40:14is so generous to each other that I do think
- 40:16that particularly being there for each other
- 40:19as we recognize that this area needs to be built
- 40:22out and built out very carefully and thoughtfully.
- 40:24I think is kind of an exciting opportunity, but
- 40:27I do realize it's a lot of extra work to begin
- 40:29to build those networks. As the internet grows
- 40:35and we're seeing new forms of media from the
- 40:39arrival of short form videos, for example, the
- 40:43control of your image as a general person has
- 40:46become a lot harder. Even now, we seek credit
- 40:52approval to show people's images and videos and
- 40:55things like that. But we don't necessarily do
- 40:57the same thing for people who have been videoed,
- 41:00as you mentioned, in these circumstances. You
- 41:03mentioned that you've done a lot of a bit of
- 41:05research on consent and the possibility of seeking
- 41:08consent. What has that research told you? And
- 41:11is there a future in any sense where we might
- 41:14be kind of contacting or reaching out to the
- 41:18survivor in question and asking them for consent
- 41:22to use a video that we possibly have analyzed.
- 41:26Yeah, that's again a great question. You know,
- 41:29I think when we were doing the research for the
- 41:31consent piece, which honestly took four years
- 41:33because there was such little guidance on this
- 41:36topic, who you are and what you're doing this
- 41:40for I think really does matter as to whether
- 41:42and if so how you should reach out. So one of
- 41:45the places where I think we ultimately landed
- 41:47is that If you're doing this for legal accountability,
- 41:51are you the right person to be reaching out?
- 41:54Or if you maybe think that you need consent from
- 41:57a survivor or someone who posted the video who
- 41:59may have been a victim in other ways themselves
- 42:01or in the same ways themselves. Should you reach
- 42:04out to someone in your network who is an expert
- 42:06in trauma -informed communication, who understands
- 42:10how survivors work in that community or have
- 42:13deep networks of NGOs? I think NGOs are often
- 42:17an overlooked resource, ones that help survivors,
- 42:20to basically even just call or contact one of
- 42:23those NGOs and say, Here's the situation. I've
- 42:26got this video. I'd like to write on it. I'd
- 42:29like to get consent. What would be the appropriate
- 42:31way for me to reach out? Or can I reach out through
- 42:33you, depending on what your internal code of
- 42:36ethics for your organization or that you have
- 42:38developed for yourself may be? And really think
- 42:41about if you're the right person and have the
- 42:43right training. I think that's one thing that
- 42:44we do discourage and the guide is reaching out
- 42:48directly without having someone, maybe you have
- 42:51trauma -informed training and maybe you're an
- 42:52expert in SGBV, in which case I think it's a
- 42:54different scenario. But if your predominant training
- 42:57and expertise is in digital open source investigations,
- 43:00who can I work with who may be the right person
- 43:02to do this in an informed way? The other thing
- 43:05is I think, you know, being really aware that
- 43:07digital modes of communication can be deeply
- 43:10dangerous. So for example, on Twitter, it used
- 43:13to be back in 2016, 2017, you'd tweet at someone
- 43:17and say, hey, can I use your video? And then
- 43:20I think the norm began to shift. OK, do this
- 43:22in a private space. Send them a DM instead. And
- 43:25then it began to be growing awareness, particularly
- 43:27when we're dealing with issues like this, since
- 43:29we don't really know who's behind an account.
- 43:31Even if it's a survivor saying that this is their
- 43:33account, it could be their husband or their partner
- 43:35or someone else who has control over them or
- 43:38their trafficker who actually has control, or
- 43:40maybe it is them, but someone else has access
- 43:43to it as well. And we could be raising risks
- 43:46just by reaching out that we're not aware of.
- 43:48So then I think it became about encrypted modes
- 43:50of communication, but that of course takes, that
- 43:53can be difficult to ascertain how and when. So
- 43:56again, I think this is where I think digital
- 43:58investigations planning is also really, really
- 44:01important. When we were building the Berkeley
- 44:03Protocol on digital open source investigations,
- 44:06I think the most valuable things in that, because
- 44:07they're just basically foundational principles.
- 44:09Everyone needs to develop their standard operating
- 44:11practices on top of it. They help the International
- 44:14Criminal Court do it, but we realize each team
- 44:16does that, has to do that for themselves, know
- 44:18what technologies and tools and processes they're
- 44:20using. But I think the most valuable things are
- 44:22the four annexes in the back. And one thing I've
- 44:25really become a huge proponent of is at the outset
- 44:27of any investigation, whether it's because you
- 44:30stumbled on something you think is important
- 44:31to write about or because you're deliberately
- 44:33investigating something, is building out that
- 44:36digital investigations plan and really kind of
- 44:39thinking about who that network of supporters
- 44:41that you want to have around you will be in advance
- 44:43and letting them know, hey, I'm up to reach out
- 44:45if you have a little bit of time. Invaluable
- 44:52advice. Yeah, I used to cover trafficking for
- 44:56BBC television and getting in touch with a trafficking
- 45:02charity who was very used to speaking to women
- 45:06who had experienced the sort of thing they were
- 45:11speaking to the women about prior to filming
- 45:13and prior to those interviews was incredibly
- 45:17important and really shaped the way that we approached
- 45:20that. conversation and led to much better testimony
- 45:24as well. So I really do encourage you to reach
- 45:27out to NGOs. I think they're fantastic at being
- 45:30able to guide journalists in that space. And
- 45:35yeah, I wanted to ask this question by Inez because
- 45:38it was asked a while ago. Do you have any experience
- 45:42with covering a violence directed towards trans
- 45:46people and gay people, especially those in countries
- 45:49where their sole existence is illegal. Do you
- 45:52see any differences to this when it comes to
- 45:55covering gender -based violence? One of the things
- 46:01that we recommend when we do trainings on doing
- 46:03digital open source investigations of sexual
- 46:05and gender -based violence is mapping out the
- 46:09legal situation in whatever country or context
- 46:13you're investigating. So, you know, even if you're
- 46:16from the country, sometimes some of the laws
- 46:18just are unclear or they're rapidly shifting.
- 46:21So understanding what's illegal in that country,
- 46:24whether it's homosexual behavior has been criminalized,
- 46:28if there's a death penalty attached to it, if
- 46:31trans people are particularly under attack, legally
- 46:34and socially, I think Mapping that out so you're
- 46:39aware of the risks of the scope of your reporting,
- 46:42I think that can help you to design an investigation
- 46:45and reporting plan that's sensitive to these
- 46:48issues. We are, in fact, doing work right now
- 46:51on looking at attacks on trans populations. I'd
- 46:55say the way that we have pivoted is to really
- 46:59try to be careful about whose story we feature.
- 47:02So we may, for example, have evidence of 30 different
- 47:06attacks. We will, of course, prioritize if we're
- 47:10going to do anything public facing. using materials
- 47:14from people who have said, I want my name attached
- 47:16to this. I want to be public. But we won't also,
- 47:20of course, just take that at face value. We'll
- 47:22assess, are they out of the country? Are they
- 47:24in a country now that is much friendlier to the
- 47:27kinds of issues and challenges that they're facing
- 47:29and much more supportive? Do they have a support
- 47:31circle around them? How can we even know that?
- 47:35I do think there's a heightened care. And a lot
- 47:38of times it comes down to the level of abstraction
- 47:40by which we'll report about these things. So
- 47:43will we represent 30 different people with a
- 47:47flower icon as opposed to their face? We'll really
- 47:50try and do that threat modeling and that risk
- 47:52modeling. Of course, if we have direct communication
- 47:55with that person, we'll also have a conversation
- 47:57with them. We just put out a report. It was co
- 48:00-authored by a colleague at the Atlantic Council
- 48:03and Andrea Richardson from our team on gender
- 48:06persecution in Iran. And we did a really careful
- 48:09assessment of all of the case studies that we
- 48:12feature. We, of course, had digital open source
- 48:14information relevant to a vastly greater number
- 48:18of incidents. featured the ones that were already
- 48:21very publicly known, where the risks to people's
- 48:24families were less because the families have
- 48:26left the country. There was one incident where
- 48:29we had identified a number of attacks on women
- 48:32who were accused of wearing improper hijab. And
- 48:35we blurred their faces, of course, and we didn't
- 48:37use their names in those instances. Their videos
- 48:39had gone viral, but they were not people who
- 48:42had come out publicly and said, we want greater
- 48:45amplification of our story. We did make the assessment
- 48:47that we could keep it enough obscured that we
- 48:52would not be doing additional harm. But we also
- 48:55went to a number of journalists who we knew had
- 48:57reported extensively on these issues on the ground
- 49:00in Iran and asked them, do you know where these
- 49:03survivors are that you reported on that we pulled
- 49:05information about? Now, do you feel that they're
- 49:09at risk? And so we did a number of checks of
- 49:11this with people that we knew were from frontline
- 49:13communities towards the people that we work with.
- 49:16So I do think it just takes a heightened level
- 49:18of care, heightened level of planning. I would
- 49:21get peer review on any threat modeling before
- 49:24you put anything out to just see if there's anything
- 49:26that you may be missing. And of course, if you're
- 49:28in contact with the survivors and they can review
- 49:30what you're going to put out before you do, I
- 49:32think this is one of those instances where I
- 49:34would really want their understanding. There's
- 49:36one time where I did an interview of someone
- 49:38and I have it recorded and on the record what
- 49:42this individual said they'd experienced. And
- 49:45when I put it in the book, I was so great in
- 49:47my book graphic. I was so grateful that I had
- 49:49run the quotes by every person that I quoted,
- 49:52because when I sent her those quotes, she was
- 49:54like, I never would have said that. There's just
- 49:57no way. It's there recorded. I have the transcripts.
- 50:00But from an ethical perspective, I scrapped that
- 50:02from the book because I realized what was probably
- 50:04happening was she realized that what she had
- 50:06shared, well, from the journalistic perspective,
- 50:09was something you want to put in the book because
- 50:11it just grabs attention that she had realized
- 50:14the risks were too great to have that piece of
- 50:16her story known. So yeah, I got scrapped. Yeah,
- 50:19I can't count on my hand how many times that's
- 50:22happened to me where I've interviewed someone
- 50:24And then after, when going back with their comments,
- 50:28they've been a bit shocked by what they'd said
- 50:31to me. And that informed consent is then taken
- 50:34away. And it's really important that you respect
- 50:37that decision. Talking about hostile environments,
- 50:42Sarah actually has to follow up question from
- 50:44her other one earlier and says, any tips for
- 50:47dealing with an audience who is actively hostile
- 50:49to the concept of sexual violence occurring,
- 50:52namely the side of the perpetrator? Often I hear
- 50:56things like, burn bodies are the result of munitions,
- 50:58for example. There are bottles all over and don't
- 51:01mean anything. Clothes come off when you drag
- 51:03a body, for example. Sexual violence will always
- 51:05have subtle indications and how do you push back?
- 51:09Yeah. That is calm. It's fascinating in this
- 51:16area of practice to see the deep psychological
- 51:19resistance to acknowledging sexual and gender
- 51:22-based violence, even when it may be right in
- 51:24front of you. I do think as an investigator,
- 51:27it's important to know what those pushbacks are,
- 51:30like those really powerful illustrations you
- 51:32just gave of like, you drag a body and the clothes
- 51:34come off, or the bodies are burned, you know,
- 51:38through ammunition, as opposed to deliberately
- 51:40set on fire, et cetera. I think this is where
- 51:44I see such tremendous potential and power in
- 51:47bringing some of the sexual and gender -based
- 51:49violence experts together with this community
- 51:51of practice, because I think they have the years
- 51:54of experience, the decades of experience and
- 51:56evidence that burning of these bodies after sexual
- 52:00and gender -based violence is common, that rape
- 52:04in prisons is almost always happening in these
- 52:07detention facilities and kind of overcoming some
- 52:11of the stereotypes and assumptions. And I think
- 52:14that's where we get in trouble as humans is we
- 52:17do have psychological resistance. At the same
- 52:19time, you are going to have to be able to defend
- 52:21your analysis. And sometimes it may be even getting
- 52:25ahead of those critiques and saying, here's what
- 52:28some people say, you know, here's what the pushback
- 52:31may be that bodies are dragged and clothes come
- 52:33off. However, I spoke with these experts and
- 52:36what they have communicated to me is and being
- 52:38really and I think this is the power of transparency,
- 52:41which I knew this community in particular has
- 52:43really promulgated is being fully transparent
- 52:46about the potential critiques, the potential
- 52:48limitations, the potential. flaws in analysis
- 52:51that could exist, but why you remain confident
- 52:54and really being for, and I think this is the
- 52:56lawyer training again of being able to counter
- 52:59those and almost counter them before they're
- 53:01even made. I used to train first year law students.
- 53:04And it was, you need to be able to make the other
- 53:06side's argument even better than they can if
- 53:08you really want your arguments to hold up in
- 53:10a court of law. Because you need to have thought
- 53:12through what is the response to each of those.
- 53:14And sadly, I think this is one area where we
- 53:18really do need to be ahead of that curve and
- 53:20be anticipating all the pushback and continuing
- 53:23to push back. And I think this is where it takes
- 53:24a spine. And I know everyone here has one. I
- 53:29have never received more pushback than on this
- 53:31topic, whether it's from the SGBV investigators,
- 53:34the traditional investigators themselves, who
- 53:35basically stay out at times. If you don't have
- 53:40specialized training, you shouldn't be touching
- 53:42this with a 10 -foot pole. to others who have
- 53:44seen so much of this and it's so underreported
- 53:47and undervalued that they're like we need to
- 53:49be doing everything we can to help people understand
- 53:52the full scope and scale and impact of this work.
- 53:55This is where peer groups become I do think invaluable
- 53:59in encountering and sharing resources. One more
- 54:05thing on assumptions. One of the first projects
- 54:07I ever worked on we had just founded the investigations
- 54:09lab at Berkeley in 2016. And we were working
- 54:13with a team of lawyers and there were pieces
- 54:16including potential SGVV that they had been investigating
- 54:19in a detention complex in a particular country
- 54:23that I have to keep meaningless because the case
- 54:25is still ongoing. But there was someone who'd
- 54:27smuggled a bunch of footage out of those detention
- 54:29facilities and fled to a third country and now
- 54:31had a hit man after him because the government
- 54:34was very unhappy with what this person smuggled
- 54:36out. So I flew to that third country. I brought
- 54:37the hard drive home. Our task at that time was,
- 54:40could we verify the videos that had been collected?
- 54:43And so we did that. And at the end of this, we
- 54:46asked the partner organization, do you want us
- 54:49to see what else might be out there in digital
- 54:50open sources? And they said, you can try, but
- 54:54you're not going to find anything. Like, this
- 54:55person had to smuggle this footage out of the
- 54:58country. Like, there's just no way. We found
- 55:00so much evidence on YouTube of similar patterns
- 55:04of sexual and gender -based violence and torture
- 55:06and other crimes that when we handed over all
- 55:09the digital open source information, what we
- 55:11were told was, oh my goodness, this may actually
- 55:13now no longer be a domestic -level crime, but
- 55:16an international crime against humanity because
- 55:18it's so widespread and systematic, or appears
- 55:21to be. And I think that's something that we've
- 55:23just seen is so hard to know what we don't know
- 55:26as investigators. But I think the SGBV investigators,
- 55:29traditional investigators, often don't understand
- 55:31the full depth and breadth of potentially invaluable
- 55:35information that may be now posted to online
- 55:37spaces where people are communicating. And I
- 55:40think the online investigators may not understand
- 55:42the full range of subtle ways that you can detect
- 55:45that this is happening so that you can pick it
- 55:47up as an investigator. I think we need these
- 55:49merged kind of research teams and find the right
- 55:54people who really have a passion for this to
- 55:56help grow this area of practice because I do
- 55:58think there is so much potential. Absolutely.
- 56:04I just wanted to highlight someone in the chat
- 56:06said thank you so much for this discussion. Just
- 56:09a reminder that this is being recorded so you
- 56:13can listen back as well. We've mentioned a lot
- 56:16of amazing resources so please do take the time
- 56:19to listen back and investigate those said resources.
- 56:24Talking about resources, just to end off, and
- 56:26we always ask this question when we're talking
- 56:29about particularly traumatic events and covering
- 56:33traumatic events. What practices can organizations
- 56:37or newsrooms put in place to protect their employees
- 56:40or to protect researchers from vicarious trauma
- 56:44and other harms? And what do you do personally
- 56:47when it gets too much? That was, again, some
- 56:51of my favorite questions. I think one of the
- 56:55most basic, and I'm guessing most of the people
- 56:57in this room do this already, is that when you're
- 57:00compiling information across large data sets,
- 57:03whether it's on a spreadsheet or on some other
- 57:05kind of particular platform, having a mechanism
- 57:08for flagging. For us, on every spreadsheet we
- 57:10do, it flags, yes, graphic, if it's graphic material,
- 57:13and it makes that whole line red. so that you
- 57:16know that this is going to be stuff you don't
- 57:18want to be doing late at night when you're by
- 57:20yourself alone in your bedroom, but it's stuff
- 57:22that you may prioritize for early in the morning
- 57:24or may have someone else work on. The other thing
- 57:26that I really like to do is have a column next
- 57:28to it that just without graphic detail says what
- 57:31kind of graphic violence it is. So if it's sexual
- 57:34and gender -based violence or it's decapitation
- 57:37or it's murder of children, the things that we
- 57:39know are big triggers for people. I like working
- 57:43as part of a team or even sometimes what we've
- 57:45done is created partnerships among people within
- 57:48teams. So there's two people who are always kind
- 57:50of watching for each other and can be saying,
- 57:53hey, you're suddenly not seeming like yourself.
- 57:55Are you doing okay? Or I've noticed you've missed
- 57:58a lot of our meetings, or maybe even flagging
- 58:01for me or some other person who's a manager or
- 58:03supervisor to say, hey, I'm worried about so
- 58:05-and -so. They're just not doing their normal
- 58:08stuff. So that we can keep an eye out for each
- 58:10other. But for example, I have a colleague who
- 58:13used to be really affected by violence against
- 58:16children. And for me, it has always been gunshots.
- 58:19And I was in what was a mass shooting. And there's
- 58:23this moment where you realize that this is guns
- 58:26and not backfiring of a car. That gets me every
- 58:30single time. So little things like I could take
- 58:33the children pieces. And she may take the active
- 58:36gunfire pieces. And we figure out how, as a partnership,
- 58:40we kind of protect each other, minimize the risks
- 58:42and maximize the value of what we can do. I also
- 58:44realize I may not have the greatest objectivity,
- 58:47ones where I'm already being triggered from whatever
- 58:49traumatic experiences I've gone through in my
- 58:51lifetime. So thinking constructively about where
- 58:54your lived experience is an asset because you
- 58:57understand the culture or context or language
- 58:59or whatever, and where it may be a liability
- 59:01because it's too close and it is something that
- 59:04you may have a difficult time with the objectivity
- 59:06of. I think there's three things that Andrea
- 59:09and I tried to point out in graphic that are
- 59:11become my touchstones. One is that awareness
- 59:13for myself and for others of what may be triggering
- 59:16and figuring out ways if there are ways to kind
- 59:19of mitigate some of those harms. Here's the tips
- 59:21and tricks. So things like, I never watch a video
- 59:25with the sound on the first time if I know something
- 59:27awful happens in that video. Or actually, any
- 59:29time I'm watching a video and I don't know what's
- 59:31coming, I'll keep it really low or I'll keep
- 59:33it off, just because I know the auditory content
- 59:36is what gets to people most of the time. You
- 59:40know, in the gray scale, sometimes speeding it
- 59:41up or slowing it down. I've personally found
- 59:44all those tactics really helpful. And then the
- 59:47third bucket is that community piece. I do think,
- 59:50you know, when working on really upsetting content,
- 59:52having a small community around you or doing
- 59:54it with someone else who understands what you've
- 59:56just looked at can debrief with you, or you don't
- 59:59talk about it all, but you know someone else
- 1:00:01has shared that experience. There is a camaraderie
- 1:00:03and power in that. I remember doing investigations
- 1:00:06and research in northern Uganda where the Lord's
- 1:00:09Resistance Army had unfortunately taken a number
- 1:00:12of people and used particularly women and young
- 1:00:14girls as in slavery contexts. And we had curfews
- 1:00:19every night at 6 p .m. and we would basically
- 1:00:21give money to the driver and say, could you buy
- 1:00:23us like, you know, some beers? And we would sit
- 1:00:25and we went over a drink, but once we were locked
- 1:00:28into our building at 6 p .m., we would kind of
- 1:00:30debrief what we'd seen and we'd have a beer or
- 1:00:32two and kind of talk through that. There's something
- 1:00:35about that boots on the ground camaraderie that
- 1:00:37we know protects military units, et cetera. We
- 1:00:40need to replicate that, I think, in this community.
- 1:00:42And that's, of course, an area on which Bill
- 1:00:45and Kat has truly led. Gosh, I could talk about
- 1:00:52this forever. And thank you so much for taking
- 1:00:56the time out to unpack all of this. I'm sure
- 1:01:00we'll ask you back in a couple of months once
- 1:01:03we've had a few other speakers on this topic.
- 1:01:06But thank you again for taking the time and for
- 1:01:09answering all these really important questions.
- 1:01:12You know, thank you for having me and thank you
- 1:01:14to this whole space for your passion for this
- 1:01:17topic or your interest in this topic. We need
- 1:01:19more people who are deeply skilled. Really thinking
- 1:01:22through these issues and carve you a future space.
- 1:01:25Amazing. All right, remember there is the hashtag
- 1:01:28gender based violence channel if you want to
- 1:01:30take this discussion further. But anyway, thank
- 1:01:32you everybody. I'm going to stop the recording
- 1:01:34now. Thank you for listening to the stage talk.
- 1:01:37If you'd like to catch a stage talk live where
- 1:01:39you can ask the guests questions, Join the Bellingcat
- 1:01:43Discord server by visiting www .discord .gg slash
- 1:01:49Bellingcat. The music you've heard is titled
- 1:01:53Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy of Artlist.