Latest / The NanceCast / Benjamin Studebaker Talks Intelligence And The Natural Slave
Transcript
- 0:06Closed Captioning
- 0:27SPEAKER_02: Bada bing, bada boom.
- 0:29SPEAKER_02: Get in the truck, loser.
- 0:31SPEAKER_02: We're going thinking about stuff.
- 0:34SPEAKER_02: What's up, everybody?
- 0:35SPEAKER_02: Welcome back to another fantastic episode of the Nance cast.
- 0:39SPEAKER_02: We're here.
- 0:39SPEAKER_02: We're hanging out,
- 0:41SPEAKER_02: having a conversation,
- 0:43SPEAKER_02: and we are joined by a very,
- 0:45SPEAKER_02: very,
- 0:45SPEAKER_02: very special guest,
- 0:46SPEAKER_02: Benjamin Studebaker.
- 0:48I've been looking forward to this conversation for a while now,
- 0:52and I think it's going to be
- 0:54SPEAKER_02: Interesting in a good way.
- 0:57SPEAKER_02: Before we get into that, Mikey, what's up, man?
- 1:01SPEAKER_02: What's happening?
- 1:02I'm sitting here just writing down some questions for Benjamin
- 1:06that I meant to
- 1:06SPEAKER_00: write down a few days ago,
- 1:08SPEAKER_00: but I think I have most of them stored in the old memory bank,
- 1:13SPEAKER_00: but
- 1:14SPEAKER_00: Oftentimes when we have these conversations on the spot,
- 1:17SPEAKER_00: I forget core questions and I'm tired of doing that.
- 1:21SPEAKER_00: So I might start jotting down a few notes before these.
- 1:27SPEAKER_00: So yeah,
- 1:28I basically have the questions locked and loaded and just super
- 1:33happy to be talking
- 1:34SPEAKER_00: to you again,
- 1:35SPEAKER_00: Benjamin.
- 1:35SPEAKER_00: So soon, awesome.
- 1:36SPEAKER_00: You know, it's awesome and
- 1:40I'm sure this conversation will go different places but nance
- 1:43and i have definitely
- 1:44been wanting to pick your brain on ai so that'll be probably
- 1:50the main thing we do
- 1:52here but with you know whenever we get together of course it'll
- 1:55go other places so
- 1:58happy to see where this conversation takes all of us yeah yeah
- 2:02i'm excited for this
- 2:03SPEAKER_02: one yeah this should be fun
- 2:06SPEAKER_02: Before we get into that,
- 2:07SPEAKER_02: was it three days ago,
- 2:09SPEAKER_02: the paperback of legitimacy three or four days ago?
- 2:15SPEAKER_03: Yes,
- 2:16SPEAKER_03: it was on May 31st,
- 2:18SPEAKER_03: the paperback of Legitimacy and Liberal Democracies finally came out,
- 2:21SPEAKER_03: which you can get for less than $25 if you live in the States,
- 2:24SPEAKER_03: less than 20 quid if you live in the UK,
- 2:27SPEAKER_03: and some number of euros that is also quite small.
- 2:30So I'm very happy about this because my books are usually too
- 2:33expensive and now
- 2:35SPEAKER_03: finally people can get one.
- 2:38I've told you that I've seen lots of people I don't even know
- 2:41who they are but I
- 2:42mean on social media Substack Posts and people are excited that
- 2:47they finally can get
- 2:48a physical copy of a Studebaker book so yeah I don't know as
- 2:56far as an introduction
- 2:58SPEAKER_02: to this conversation goes
- 3:02I don't know I think I'll be too long winded if I try to
- 3:06introduce the conversation
- 3:08because it kind of came out of thoughts I've been having
- 3:13research I've been doing
- 3:14SPEAKER_02: on artificial intelligence and intelligence as such and
- 3:20and kind of from there I kept going and going and going and I
- 3:25talked to you about
- 3:26it a little bit Benjamin and then you were like oh Aristotle
- 3:28this and that set my
- 3:30SPEAKER_02: brain on fire as well so yeah I feel like this is going to be an emergent
- 3:41conversation I don't know where it's going to go I'm definitely
- 3:43excited to be
- 3:44SPEAKER_02: having it but I don't even know how to introduce it
- 3:49SPEAKER_02: Either other than to maybe just jump in to it.
- 3:56And I think for me the most exciting thing was that Aristotle
- 4:06had these ideas of
- 4:07intelligence or will or animating spirit or whatever that it
- 4:16seemed like a
- 4:18like an innovation in thinking about what it means to be a
- 4:24human thinking about
- 4:25what it means to be a living animal are we moved do we move
- 4:28ourselves and so on and
- 4:31so forth and yeah I am a Philistine when it comes to the
- 4:36classics I haven't read
- 4:38much so who better to go to when it comes to the classics than
- 4:42you Benjamin oh
- 4:46SPEAKER_02: that's nice of you to say man
- 4:48SPEAKER_02: I honestly believe it.
- 4:49SPEAKER_02: I will be honest with you.
- 4:51SPEAKER_02: I don't want to have a conversation about the classics with other people.
- 4:59SPEAKER_02: Not to say...
- 5:01SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 5:01SPEAKER_02: Not to disparage or anything.
- 5:03SPEAKER_02: Not to put too fine a point on it.
- 5:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 5:07But I know your level of scholarship and I know there are
- 5:11things on which we agree.
- 5:14SPEAKER_02: And there are things on which we disagree.
- 5:16So like I already know kind of what to expect when having a
- 5:19conversation with you.
- 5:21And then I also respect like,
- 5:23oh,
- 5:23you actually know what you're talking about.
- 5:25You're not some guy who listened to some Neoplatonist on the
- 5:28Internet somewhere.
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: And then you're going to come and tell me about all these grand ideas.
- 5:31SPEAKER_02: You actually know what's up.
- 5:35SPEAKER_02: But yeah,
- 5:35I think the question of intelligence as opposed to or indirect
- 5:42contrast to the
- 5:44contemporary vision of intelligence and artificial intelligence
- 5:53I don't know.
- 5:54SPEAKER_02: What would Aristotle think about these LLMs?
- 5:56SPEAKER_02: I think that's the interesting question, right?
- 6:05SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 6:05so there's a bit in Aristotle's politics where he says that if
- 6:10tools could operate
- 6:12SPEAKER_03: of their own accord,
- 6:13SPEAKER_01: if the lyre could pluck itself,
- 6:15SPEAKER_01: then you wouldn't need slaves.
- 6:20So Aristotle is significant insofar as he introduces the
- 6:25category of the natural slave.
- 6:27The natural slave is a person who is not able by nature to
- 6:32choose their own ends,
- 6:35SPEAKER_01: So,
- 6:36SPEAKER_03: in the Platonic scheme,
- 6:38there are these different types of souls who are lovers of
- 6:40different things.
- 6:41You have the lover of pleasure,
- 6:43you have the lover of honor,
- 6:44you have the lover of wisdom.
- 6:46SPEAKER_03: These different lovers have different objects.
- 6:50SPEAKER_03: And in a lot of platonic dialogues,
- 6:52there's an effort to persuade people or to invite people to
- 6:56love different objects.
- 6:57SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 6:58SPEAKER_03: you might think that life is all about pleasure,
- 7:01but it might actually be about the good or it might be about
- 7:05wisdom or it might be
- 7:06SPEAKER_03: about something else.
- 7:07SPEAKER_03: So there are these,
- 7:09the Socratic elenchus can sometimes perform this function of
- 7:12changing what somebody
- 7:13SPEAKER_03: loves or opening up the possibility of loving something else.
- 7:18SPEAKER_03: And then there's the political project,
- 7:20which is in part about trying to structure the city such that
- 7:23it allows these
- 7:26SPEAKER_03: different kinds of loves to develop.
- 7:28SPEAKER_03: It cultivates them.
- 7:30And education in Platonism is very much about allowing people's
- 7:34love to lead them
- 7:36SPEAKER_03: in different directions.
- 7:38So you have a way of thinking about the person that's very much
- 7:40in terms of love.
- 7:41SPEAKER_03: So in terms of intrinsic motivation, which comes from within the person.
- 7:46The category of the natural slave moves us some distance away
- 7:49from this because it
- 7:51introduces the idea that you can have people who don't really
- 7:55have this kind of
- 7:56SPEAKER_03: love and not just a love for the good or of wisdom,
- 7:59SPEAKER_03: but a love for status or even pleasure.
- 8:01SPEAKER_03: They're just not able to choose
- 8:04What Their Ends Are At All And So Natural Slaves For Aristotle
- 8:09Don't Know What To
- 8:10Do If You Don't Tell Them What To Do If Some Master Doesn't
- 8:13Tell A Natural Slave
- 8:14SPEAKER_03: What To Do Natural Slaves Are Confused They Can't Pick
- 8:18So natural slaves require masters to orient them and in this
- 8:23respect natural slaves
- 8:24are for Aristotle like tools so like a hammer or like a wrench
- 8:30in that the hammer
- 8:31the wrench is good for certain things has certain capabilities
- 8:36but it doesn't know
- 8:39when to use them or for what purpose to use them a hammer just
- 8:42sits there inert
- 8:43SPEAKER_03: unless you tell it hammer this nail into this surface over here
- 8:47in the same way natural slaves have various talents but those
- 8:52talents they don't
- 8:53know how to use unless they're told to use them use this talent
- 8:58over here for this
- 8:59purpose and in ancient Greece and Rome you often had slaves who
- 9:05were very talented
- 9:06SPEAKER_03: intellectually
- 9:07SPEAKER_03: You could have slaves who could even do math.
- 9:10SPEAKER_03: You could have slaves who were literate.
- 9:11SPEAKER_03: You could have slaves run your estate, do your books.
- 9:16SPEAKER_03: You could have slaves do all kinds of different things.
- 9:18SPEAKER_03: The slave is not necessarily a stupid person.
- 9:22It's a person who can't choose their own ends and who is
- 9:25directionless unless ordered around.
- 9:29So then this leads to a possibility of thinking about human
- 9:32capability separate
- 9:34SPEAKER_03: from final ends,
- 9:36SPEAKER_03: goals,
- 9:37SPEAKER_03: drives,
- 9:38SPEAKER_03: objects.
- 9:39And I think this is where our modern concept of intelligence
- 9:42really has its root.
- 9:43SPEAKER_03: It's a way of trying to validate,
- 9:45SPEAKER_03: valorize human capability,
- 9:48SPEAKER_03: which is not about choosing ends,
- 9:50but which is instead about being able to efficiently pursue
- 9:53ends given to you by
- 9:54SPEAKER_03: another.
- 9:57Yeah,
- 9:57I think the intelligence,
- 10:00it's this word,
- 10:00we use it all the time,
- 10:01we take it for granted.
- 10:03SPEAKER_02: And I think it's largely safe to take it for granted.
- 10:06SPEAKER_02: I think we look a bit mad when we say, well, what even is intelligence?
- 10:12SPEAKER_02: It's like, you know, the air.
- 10:15It's like if I were going around saying,
- 10:18well,
- 10:18I don't know about this air thing.
- 10:20SPEAKER_02: I don't know about respiration, guys.
- 10:24SPEAKER_02: But it is also true that
- 10:29We identify one thing that we do and then we project that or
- 10:38map it onto a
- 10:40SPEAKER_02: totalized image of what it is to be a human or whatever.
- 10:45out on things that aren't included in this type of functional
- 10:48or instrumental or
- 10:50SPEAKER_02: goal-oriented activity.
- 10:53The most widely agreed upon definition of intelligence is the
- 10:57ability to achieve a
- 10:58SPEAKER_02: goal in an environment or in a world.
- 11:01SPEAKER_02: Then there's different kind of variations and modulations of that.
- 11:05SPEAKER_02: Another really widely accepted definition is efficacy at playing games or
- 11:12SPEAKER_02: effectiveness at game playing.
- 11:15SPEAKER_02: But it's not.
- 11:16SPEAKER_02: If you go to neuropsychology,
- 11:19SPEAKER_02: if you go to cognitive psychology,
- 11:21SPEAKER_02: if you go to biologists,
- 11:23they all have different versions of how to define intelligence
- 11:27and why it's
- 11:28SPEAKER_02: important.
- 11:29um but it seems to be the case that that we're just carried
- 11:33away with this functional um
- 11:39Effective Instrumental Definition of Intelligence and then we
- 11:45have people out here
- 11:46proclaiming we have achieved artificial general intelligence we
- 11:49are replacing
- 11:51workers with LLMs and we are replacing workers with LLMs we're
- 11:55replacing a huge
- 11:56section of variable capital with this type of kind of constant
- 12:00capital this
- 12:01SPEAKER_02: objectified intellectual labor but it
- 12:09SPEAKER_02: Whatever it is,
- 12:10the surplus that isn't included in this definition of
- 12:14intelligence is becoming less
- 12:16SPEAKER_02: and less relevant,
- 12:18SPEAKER_02: less and less politically important.
- 12:20It feels like to me as a doomer,
- 12:23it seems to be the case that we are optimizing
- 12:30Whatever it is,
- 12:32that's not included in this functional definition of
- 12:34intelligence.
- 12:35SPEAKER_02: Away.
- 12:37SPEAKER_02: And yeah, this question of the natural slave.
- 12:44SPEAKER_02: Are we currently naturalizing and universalizing this type of slavery?
- 12:56SPEAKER_01: Feels like it.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 13:01SPEAKER_01: so I think this is a really interesting point,
- 13:05and I think that this is something also that's been going on
- 13:07for a long time
- 13:09insofar as what Aristotle counts as appropriate free activity
- 13:13for man is something
- 13:16SPEAKER_03: that we have made less and less space for in modernity,
- 13:19SPEAKER_03: I think really dating back to at least Hobbes.
- 13:24Aristotle makes the argument that a man can choose his own ends
- 13:28and then he can go
- 13:29into an assembly and have a deliberation with other people and
- 13:33that they can arrive
- 13:34together at a decision about what they want to do on the basis
- 13:38of common ends,
- 13:39SPEAKER_03: which they deliberate about how to operationalize together.
- 13:42So people are able to do this political activity if they're men
- 13:46for Aristotle,
- 13:46they can do this.
- 13:48Slaves aren't able to participate in civil life because they
- 13:52don't have ends.
- 13:53SPEAKER_03: So they don't have anything to bring into a deliberation.
- 13:59SPEAKER_03: Since they can't pick their own ends,
- 14:00they can't be part of a deliberation about what ends should be
- 14:03pursued or how they
- 14:04SPEAKER_03: ought to be pursued.
- 14:06So it doesn't make sense to Aristotle to have slaves be
- 14:09citizens and participate in civil life.
- 14:11SPEAKER_03: This seems to be a category error to him.
- 14:15SPEAKER_03: Now,
- 14:16SPEAKER_03: in Hobbes' Leviathan,
- 14:17he makes the argument that you should not try to think about
- 14:20what is good or what
- 14:22SPEAKER_03: God wants,
- 14:23SPEAKER_03: because if you try to think about that,
- 14:25SPEAKER_03: you'll reach different conclusions from other people.
- 14:28You won't be able to come to an agreement about these matters
- 14:31and that this will
- 14:31SPEAKER_03: just lead to a lot of conflict.
- 14:33So instead,
- 14:34you should give up your right to choose ends to this corporate
- 14:40entity,
- 14:41the state.
- 14:42which in Hobbes' scheme is personated by a single individual
- 14:47but that single
- 14:48individual when that person is acting on behalf of the state is
- 14:51not acting on their
- 14:52own behalf Hobbes makes a distinction between the natural
- 14:55person and the person
- 14:57artificial so when the king is acting as the king the king is
- 15:02acting as the
- 15:02artificial person rather than as themselves so a king who's
- 15:08acting as a king is a
- 15:09SPEAKER_03: kind of artificial decider
- 15:12SPEAKER_03: Perhaps.
- 15:13And you can kind of see how this generates a certain sort of
- 15:16artificial decision
- 15:18SPEAKER_03: making mechanism.
- 15:19And you can think about all of modern political theory as the
- 15:22theory of how this
- 15:23SPEAKER_03: artificial decision-making mechanism operates.
- 15:26SPEAKER_03: And my old supervisor from Cambridge,
- 15:28SPEAKER_03: he has a book called The Handover,
- 15:31SPEAKER_03: in which he argues that beginning with Hobbes,
- 15:34there was a kind of handover of decision-making power from
- 15:37particular people who
- 15:39SPEAKER_03: previously could meet in deliberative settings,
- 15:42SPEAKER_03: bring their particular views about what mattered into those settings,
- 15:44SPEAKER_03: have a deliberation about how to operationalize that.
- 15:48This power was given up for the peace security order stability
- 15:54that can be secured
- 15:55SPEAKER_03: through the corporate person of the state,
- 15:57SPEAKER_03: an artificial agent,
- 15:59SPEAKER_03: which in Hobbes' time is personated by a single individual,
- 16:03SPEAKER_03: so looks very much like monarchy,
- 16:06SPEAKER_03: as it had previously been understood.
- 16:09SPEAKER_03: But functions totally differently.
- 16:11SPEAKER_03: Like a medieval monarchy,
- 16:12SPEAKER_03: the monarch is expected to consult with other parts of society,
- 16:17SPEAKER_03: assemble them together,
- 16:19SPEAKER_03: have a court come together,
- 16:20deliberate together with the members of the court about what's
- 16:23in the interests of
- 16:24SPEAKER_03: the realm.
- 16:25And if the monarch doesn't engage in these forms of
- 16:28deliberative activity,
- 16:29SPEAKER_03: the monarch looks like a tyrant,
- 16:30SPEAKER_03: looks illegitimate,
- 16:31like the Roman emperor is expected to consult with the Senate
- 16:34and to consult with
- 16:35SPEAKER_03: the popular assemblies and to meet with petitioners.
- 16:39SPEAKER_03: There's all this deliberative stuff.
- 16:41It's a monarchy only in the sense that the monarch can decide
- 16:45on the closure mechanism.
- 16:47SPEAKER_03: The monarch can say, okay, now we have to make a decision.
- 16:49SPEAKER_03: So here's the decision I'm going to make.
- 16:51SPEAKER_03: The monarch has the ability to convene the assemblies.
- 16:54So the monarch can say,
- 16:55okay,
- 16:55now we're going to have this group of people meet.
- 16:57SPEAKER_03: Okay, we're done with that.
- 16:58SPEAKER_03: Now we're going to have this other group of people meet.
- 17:01SPEAKER_03: Oh, I don't like how you're behaving.
- 17:02SPEAKER_03: I'm kicking you out of the room.
- 17:04SPEAKER_03: The monarch has the ability to shape the discussions continuously.
- 17:08SPEAKER_03: But the monarch is expected to do it all in a deliberative mode.
- 17:12SPEAKER_03: Once you shift to this post Hobbes modern understanding of monarchy,
- 17:17now the monarchy is a replacement for thinking about nth and
- 17:22marks a kind of
- 17:22SPEAKER_03: eclipse of the political as it was understood by,
- 17:26SPEAKER_03: say,
- 17:26SPEAKER_03: Aristotle.
- 17:29SPEAKER_02: It's like a distributed monarchy.
- 17:32SPEAKER_02: People love to talk about Web 3.0.
- 17:34SPEAKER_02: That's like monarchy 2.0.
- 17:38in this sense of yeah you know if the king was stealing all
- 17:44your I don't know wheat
- 17:46and doing all the prima nocta and he was a bad guy you could go
- 17:49and depose him you
- 17:51SPEAKER_02: could get the villagers with pitchforks and
- 17:53SPEAKER_02: And go depose him.
- 17:55SPEAKER_02: But in this moment that's maybe coextensive with modernity,
- 18:04this idea of the state becomes this totalized thing that just
- 18:09has the knowledge.
- 18:11SPEAKER_02: And then it's,
- 18:12SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 18:13SPEAKER_02: a president,
- 18:13SPEAKER_02: a prime minister,
- 18:14SPEAKER_02: or maybe a king in name,
- 18:16SPEAKER_02: but very functionally different.
- 18:18SPEAKER_02: Because then we can talk about, oh, the market decides.
- 18:21SPEAKER_02: The market decides for us.
- 18:22SPEAKER_02: The capital is king.
- 18:24SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 18:27SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 18:29SPEAKER_03: And I think you may have noticed in talking to people like Nick Land,
- 18:35SPEAKER_03: the conception of monarchy that is popular among the reactionary sect.
- 18:41SPEAKER_03: is much more corporatist and post-Habisian.
- 18:45It's not a monarch who consults with the population and
- 18:48therefore brings the political back.
- 18:51SPEAKER_03: And so it's interesting because on the one hand,
- 18:52you have post-liberals who are interested in trying to do some
- 18:55kind of Aristotelian
- 18:56SPEAKER_03: Catholic thing.
- 18:57They want something that's more thoroughgoingly political in
- 19:00those older senses
- 19:01SPEAKER_03: that involves a deliberative element.
- 19:03And then you have the neoreactionary monarchists who want the
- 19:07corporation to become
- 19:08the model for the state and who think of the state much more as
- 19:12an impersonal
- 19:13decision-making mechanism in the same way that a corporate
- 19:15structure is an
- 19:16SPEAKER_03: impersonal decision-making mechanism.
- 19:18SPEAKER_03: These two things get conflated under the heading of monarchism
- 19:22And a lot of the time because we so rarely talk about
- 19:24monarchism because it seems
- 19:26so far outside the bounds of what anybody actually might
- 19:29practically introduce
- 19:30today that distinction gets completely lost and isn't even
- 19:33noticed CEO monarch Elon
- 19:38SPEAKER_00: Musk as king
- 19:41SPEAKER_02: And I...
- 20:04I think Yanis Varoufakis is intelligent and I think he said
- 20:10some things that are
- 20:12interesting and he's probably worth listening to however I've
- 20:16never liked this
- 20:18SPEAKER_02: neo-feudalism notion or whatever I think it's
- 20:26SPEAKER_02: We're still in neoliberal capitalism.
- 20:28SPEAKER_02: Like I don't see why we necessarily have to say,
- 20:32SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 20:32SPEAKER_02: we're in a new period or a new epoch or something like that.
- 20:35SPEAKER_02: I think it's still very much neoliberalism.
- 20:38SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 20:38SPEAKER_00: Now Jody Dean is arguing a similar thesis, right?
- 20:42SPEAKER_00: Neo feudalism, techno feudalism.
- 20:44But I don't know,
- 20:46Benjamin,
- 20:46do you think we are outside of capitalism now?
- 20:51SPEAKER_03: No,
- 20:52I think there are certain things that are distinctive about the
- 20:54way the world works
- 20:55SPEAKER_03: now that can be analogized to pre-modern systems.
- 21:00But that's not to say that we are in pre-modernity or that
- 21:04we've come to a
- 21:05SPEAKER_03: post-modernity that is pre-modern.
- 21:08SPEAKER_03: One could,
- 21:08SPEAKER_03: for instance,
- 21:09make the point that there's rising inequality to the point
- 21:11where perhaps there are
- 21:12people who are as rich relative to the rest of the population
- 21:16as the landed
- 21:17SPEAKER_03: aristocracy was.
- 21:19But that wouldn't make it the case that the system is governed
- 21:23in the way that
- 21:24SPEAKER_03: feudal kingdoms were governed.
- 21:26It wouldn't make it the case that wage laborers have forms of
- 21:30life that look like
- 21:30SPEAKER_03: the form of life of the peasant.
- 21:33It wouldn't make it the case that a CEO is like a medieval king
- 21:38in all sorts of
- 21:39SPEAKER_03: different respects.
- 21:40SPEAKER_03: Medieval kings have to be able to think about ends.
- 21:43SPEAKER_03: They are not just good, efficient allocators of capital
- 21:47SPEAKER_03: They have to be able to choose purposes.
- 21:51CEOs,
- 21:52you could be a CEO and be someone that Aristotle would regard
- 21:56as a slave.
- 21:58A CEO can be a very efficient allocator of capital who's very
- 22:02intelligent at the
- 22:03SPEAKER_03: level of efficiently accomplishing the ends of the shareholders.
- 22:07But that person can have absolutely no sense whatsoever about
- 22:10what ultimately
- 22:11SPEAKER_03: matters in life and what purpose corporations ought ultimately to serve.
- 22:17And when we ask questions like,
- 22:19well,
- 22:19but does Elon Musk know about things like that?
- 22:22SPEAKER_03: Is he wise in those kinds of old-fashioned ways?
- 22:25SPEAKER_03: We seem to be making a category error.
- 22:27SPEAKER_03: We seem to not be understanding the contribution he makes to society,
- 22:31SPEAKER_03: which is at the level of efficient resource allocation.
- 22:34SPEAKER_03: He's a really good household manager,
- 22:36but at the level of heading a corporation as opposed to an
- 22:39ancient Greek household.
- 22:41SPEAKER_03: And that's another difference.
- 22:42SPEAKER_03: When you're talking about feudalism,
- 22:43SPEAKER_03: you're talking about households principally,
- 22:46SPEAKER_03: not corporate entities.
- 22:48SPEAKER_03: And I think there's been,
- 22:49SPEAKER_03: in general,
- 22:50the left has been very reluctant to talk about corporatism and
- 22:53the degree to which
- 22:54SPEAKER_03: corporatism has affected so many different areas of social life.
- 23:00In part because the left is very focused on trying to get the
- 23:03social back.
- 23:05SPEAKER_03: into focus and to get people to want to organize in a social way.
- 23:10SPEAKER_03: And once you start talking about corporatism,
- 23:12SPEAKER_03: corporatism conflicts with the social horizon,
- 23:14SPEAKER_03: because once you start thinking about corporatism,
- 23:18SPEAKER_03: then you realize,
- 23:18SPEAKER_03: wait a minute,
- 23:20SPEAKER_03: part of the reason why it's hard to socially organize something like,
- 23:22SPEAKER_03: say,
- 23:22SPEAKER_03: an alternative to the university system is that the corporate form of the
- 23:26university has certain advantages because it's a corporate form
- 23:30in this very
- 23:31SPEAKER_03: corporatist structure that we live in.
- 23:34SPEAKER_03: Which is designed to facilitate the activity of corporate entities,
- 23:38but to frustrate significantly the activities of social units
- 23:42or social groups or
- 23:43SPEAKER_03: organizations.
- 23:44SPEAKER_03: And a lot of the time,
- 23:45people don't distinguish between a social organization and a
- 23:48corporate person.
- 23:49SPEAKER_03: Those things tend to get run together.
- 23:52And as a consequence of this,
- 23:53people will act like founding a corporation is social
- 23:56organizing.
- 23:58SPEAKER_03: And once that's happening, then everything becomes very blurry.
- 24:13And so many of those people will also from a more conservative
- 24:16direction want to
- 24:17SPEAKER_03: draw comparisons with the Middle Ages
- 24:40SPEAKER_03: But again, we have this mass media technology that's corporatized.
- 24:45It's really very difficult to just talk about this within
- 24:49medieval language.
- 24:50SPEAKER_03: But the only way you can know that,
- 24:52SPEAKER_03: really know that language is not quite appropriate,
- 24:55is to have a sufficient facility with the Middle Ages that you
- 24:59can make these
- 25:00SPEAKER_03: distinctions.
- 25:00It's because people don't know anything about antiquity or the
- 25:02Middle Ages that
- 25:03SPEAKER_03: they fall into this stuff.
- 25:06SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 25:07SPEAKER_02: I think the contemporary CEO,
- 25:12SPEAKER_02: business person or whatever,
- 25:15SPEAKER_02: even petty bourgeois,
- 25:16SPEAKER_02: I think the fiduciary responsibility,
- 25:21SPEAKER_02: which I guess is just a shorthand for capital itself,
- 25:25SPEAKER_02: the logic of capital,
- 25:26SPEAKER_02: the market,
- 25:27SPEAKER_02: the machine god,
- 25:28SPEAKER_02: Robo Cthulhu,
- 25:29SPEAKER_02: all this stuff.
- 25:30SPEAKER_02: But yeah, I think that's running in the background constantly.
- 25:33SPEAKER_02: And that is...
- 25:37SPEAKER_02: The force that has chosen the ends for all of us,
- 25:45SPEAKER_02: everyone participating in the business of business,
- 25:50SPEAKER_02: I guess.
- 25:52And yeah,
- 25:53I think it's fair to say that we are enslaved to the fiduciary,
- 25:59enslaved to capital.
- 26:03SPEAKER_02: I think it's, I don't know, it seems to be the case that
- 26:06it's been that way since modernity I don't know I'm of the mind
- 26:13that all I can
- 26:14SPEAKER_02: really think about is modernity and
- 26:22SPEAKER_02: I just don't know what happened before.
- 26:24SPEAKER_02: Whatever came before, it might as well be on planet Mars.
- 26:30SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 26:32But I do think it's interesting to go back and read through
- 26:36personal correspondence
- 26:37SPEAKER_02: and literature and graffiti and stuff and be like,
- 26:40SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 26:41SPEAKER_02: they're just like me.
- 26:42SPEAKER_02: Just like us.
- 26:45SPEAKER_02: But as far as
- 26:47The way I think and what I think about I do tie it to modernity
- 26:51and I think
- 26:52modernity has been this process of market logic all along and I
- 27:01do find it
- 27:02interesting that it seems to be the case that we are we broadly
- 27:08are trying to
- 27:09SPEAKER_02: actualize
- 27:11SPEAKER_02: That logic, the fiduciary, the market, capital, the machine god.
- 27:17SPEAKER_02: We're trying to build that.
- 27:19SPEAKER_02: People are screaming out.
- 27:21SPEAKER_02: I think when people hyperfixate on the labor thing, like Bernie,
- 27:28SPEAKER_02: I think that's kind of crying out for a savior,
- 27:34SPEAKER_02: for a second coming or a first coming or a third coming.
- 27:37SPEAKER_02: Take your pick.
- 27:38SPEAKER_02: And I also think that people who are doing weird pseudo religious stuff,
- 27:43SPEAKER_02: I don't think there's such thing as an American Christian.
- 27:47SPEAKER_02: I think we're all capitalists.
- 27:51And it just it does seem to be the case that oh we're building
- 27:56God not in this
- 27:57sensational Joe Rogan kind of way of like what if what if we
- 28:01became gods dude but
- 28:03SPEAKER_02: no that's what we're doing these LLMs are just pure ossified
- 28:10SPEAKER_02: Syntactic Logical Structure
- 28:31SPEAKER_02: Because at the end of the day,
- 28:32SPEAKER_02: the ultimate cosmic adjudicator for everything we do is the spreadsheet.
- 28:38SPEAKER_02: It's the fiduciary.
- 28:39SPEAKER_02: It's can you show a return?
- 28:42SPEAKER_02: Whereas in the past,
- 28:44SPEAKER_02: pre-modernity,
- 28:45SPEAKER_02: from my position,
- 28:46SPEAKER_02: I'm romanticizing,
- 28:47SPEAKER_02: of course,
- 28:48SPEAKER_02: but from my position...
- 28:50in pre-modern times there was always an element of the good or
- 28:54the one or God or
- 28:57mystical nature or something like that things didn't have to be
- 29:01justified on a
- 29:02ledger they I think they largely were you know kings wanted to
- 29:07amass wealth and
- 29:09they wanted to be successful and they wanted to build monuments
- 29:13and legacy and this
- 29:14SPEAKER_02: and that but I think there was always room for the
- 29:19Supernatural the extra natural or whatever and now with
- 29:23modernity um everything has
- 29:26come down to the logic of this fiduciary responsibility and
- 29:30that's not to say I
- 29:32SPEAKER_02: think uh Mikey and I talked just a touch about this uh I think Adorno and
- 29:37Horkheimer did a disservice to Weber I think Weber was doing
- 29:43something that got
- 29:45SPEAKER_02: turned into um
- 29:49something else that now people will pick up and they'll talk
- 29:51about re-enchant and
- 29:52stuff like I'm not out here saying we need to re-enchant but
- 29:59yeah so not to
- 30:00mysticize and not to do all the because I think that's what it
- 30:03is like the people
- 30:03SPEAKER_02: who do that who fall into
- 30:06SPEAKER_02: Weird cyber cults and weird postmodern mysticism and all that.
- 30:11SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 30:12I think they're falling for capitalism because it's just this
- 30:15commoditized form of
- 30:17whatever surplus it was that we can't properly incorporate into
- 30:22one plus one equals
- 30:23SPEAKER_02: two,
- 30:24SPEAKER_02: therefore.
- 30:27SPEAKER_02: But I don't know.
- 30:29SPEAKER_02: Is that a misreading of history?
- 30:32SPEAKER_02: Like, what do you think?
- 30:36Some of it can be seen at the level of what happens if you
- 30:39really screw up.
- 30:41SPEAKER_03: Like in antiquity,
- 30:42SPEAKER_03: if you are the ruler,
- 30:43SPEAKER_03: whether you're the king or the aristos or the demos or whatever,
- 30:47SPEAKER_03: how do you really fail?
- 30:49SPEAKER_03: You really fail because there's a civil war,
- 30:52SPEAKER_03: a military disaster,
- 30:54SPEAKER_03: plots,
- 30:54SPEAKER_03: schemes that involve killing people.
- 30:57SPEAKER_03: There's civil unrest,
- 30:59SPEAKER_03: there's revolution,
- 31:00there's some kind of uprising that results in an attack on the
- 31:05people who have been
- 31:05SPEAKER_03: making the decisions and they're being driven out.
- 31:10As long as there's some possibility of people coming together
- 31:13in an assembly or in
- 31:15SPEAKER_03: an association,
- 31:17SPEAKER_03: making a decision that this can't go on.
- 31:19SPEAKER_03: We can't tolerate this anymore.
- 31:21SPEAKER_03: We have to change it and make it into something else.
- 31:24And then they can actually,
- 31:25on the basis of that discussion,
- 31:27bring that result about.
- 31:30SPEAKER_03: There's something of ancient politics.
- 31:33SPEAKER_03: That's still part of the picture.
- 31:35SPEAKER_03: And the process of modernization doesn't abolish that all at once.
- 31:39It's not like,
- 31:40oh,
- 31:40Hobbes released Leviathan,
- 31:42now ancient politics is dead.
- 31:45There's a kind of gradual process of it becoming harder and
- 31:49harder for people to
- 31:50assemble or associate together in ways that can have
- 31:54consequences or effects.
- 31:56SPEAKER_03: So now when you fail,
- 31:58overwhelmingly failure looks like the bond market got really
- 32:02upset and now the
- 32:03SPEAKER_03: 10-year bond price is too high a percentage.
- 32:07SPEAKER_03: This is unacceptable.
- 32:09SPEAKER_03: Oh, the inflation rate is over 4%.
- 32:13SPEAKER_03: You can't win an election with the inflation rate this high.
- 32:16SPEAKER_03: You're in a lot of trouble.
- 32:17SPEAKER_03: Maybe we should change the party leader.
- 32:20SPEAKER_03: And you lose an election.
- 32:22The loss of the election seems in some way still to tie people
- 32:28to the end.
- 32:30The fact that people will vote against you if you are running a
- 32:33high inflation rate
- 32:34or a high 10-year bond rate or the currency sinks or there's a
- 32:38high unemployment
- 32:39SPEAKER_03: rate.
- 32:40The fact that people vote against you in response to these
- 32:42things is seen to be a
- 32:44way of still connecting your failure to people making a
- 32:49political decision.
- 32:51But in practice,
- 32:52the mechanism by which this operates is increasingly
- 32:55machine-like.
- 32:56SPEAKER_03: It goes through a set of democratic procedures,
- 32:59SPEAKER_03: what we call democratic procedures,
- 33:02SPEAKER_03: that ultimately operate in a way that is very machinic.
- 33:10and which don't really require or involve very much of those
- 33:14old fashioned
- 33:15SPEAKER_03: deliberative participatory modes.
- 33:17SPEAKER_03: And there's been over the course of the last 70 years,
- 33:20continuous complaining about how democracy doesn't involve the
- 33:23deliberation or
- 33:24SPEAKER_03: participation that it purports to involve.
- 33:26SPEAKER_03: And you're going back to Habermas and legitimation crisis in 73.
- 33:30There's this argument that people will eventually realize that
- 33:33they don't get the
- 33:34SPEAKER_03: deliberation and participation that they're promised in this system.
- 33:38And then they'll become discontented and then they'll go and
- 33:40assemble and organize
- 33:41SPEAKER_03: and threaten the revolution.
- 33:43And then there will have to be concessions or there will be an
- 33:45overcoming.
- 33:47But what I think Habermas missed is that we may be past the
- 33:50point at which you can
- 33:51SPEAKER_03: have this resurfacing of the political.
- 33:54The political can be rendered dormant for long periods of time
- 33:58and then burst onto the scene.
- 34:00SPEAKER_03: And if it shows up now and then,
- 34:01people can feel reassured that the machinic quality of the
- 34:05corporate state is still
- 34:08SPEAKER_03: challengeable by them if it performs badly enough.
- 34:11SPEAKER_03: And people point to these revolutions that happened in the past as these,
- 34:15SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 34:16SPEAKER_03: hey,
- 34:16SPEAKER_03: at one point in time,
- 34:17SPEAKER_03: people could do this stuff.
- 34:19SPEAKER_03: It wasn't so long ago.
- 34:21SPEAKER_03: It was just however many generations ago.
- 34:23SPEAKER_03: Maybe it can still be done.
- 34:25SPEAKER_03: And then they try all the same kinds of tactics.
- 34:27SPEAKER_03: They read all the old books and try to copy all the tactics.
- 34:30SPEAKER_03: But we may be getting to a point where there are,
- 34:32SPEAKER_03: for a lot of reasons,
- 34:33SPEAKER_03: an actual closing up of the space for the social and the political.
- 34:39And so the kind of reliance that modern politics has on some
- 34:44level of presence of
- 34:45SPEAKER_03: ancient stuff,
- 34:47SPEAKER_03: we may be getting to a point where that reliance has broken down.
- 34:50And a lot of the post-liberal literature talks about this at
- 34:53the level of culture,
- 34:54SPEAKER_03: but misses it at the level of institutional response.
- 34:58SPEAKER_03: The legitimation crisis that can actually produce the revolution
- 35:03And now we have this legitimation crisis that has this
- 35:09character of just being a
- 35:10miserable malaise where people don't like the system but regard
- 35:13it as unchangeable.
- 35:15SPEAKER_03: And that has the character of machine-like rule.
- 35:19SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I think...
- 35:47I have been critical of Bernie recently and a lot of the
- 35:50mainstream left for
- 35:52SPEAKER_02: adopting what I think is a reactionary position against technology.
- 35:56SPEAKER_02: I do want to say I think it's right for
- 36:01SPEAKER_02: Two Billion Nances
- 36:24um because like when it comes down to it at the end of the day
- 36:28they are the people
- 36:29who are allowing people to come in and ravish neighborhoods
- 36:33like and when it's when
- 36:34it's in the Mississippi Delta along the minorities and the
- 36:37impoverished nobody
- 36:38really gives a shit but when that type of environmental and
- 36:42total destruction comes
- 36:43SPEAKER_02: to the suburbs and Roanoke and
- 36:47Fucking I don't know nice places with white people who are on
- 36:52the inside then they
- 36:53can finally see oh hey this you know this capitalism thing is
- 36:57actually pretty
- 36:59destructive to what I consider to be human family values and
- 37:03traditionalism and
- 37:04SPEAKER_02: stuff so um
- 37:07I yeah I still think Bernie's gone into a weird reactionary
- 37:11stance but but I also
- 37:13do think it it's probably appropriate I think the left should
- 37:16be talking about tech
- 37:17and AI and and this type of stuff and I don't it doesn't seem
- 37:21to be the case that
- 37:22there's an awful lot of nuanced discussion about it it seems to
- 37:27be the case they're
- 37:28SPEAKER_02: either tech is evil and it's the end of the world um
- 37:35SPEAKER_02: or they're all for it in a weird way.
- 37:36So,
- 37:37I mean,
- 37:37I guess we need more left accelerationist discourse,
- 37:42huh,
- 37:43Mikey?
- 37:46SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 37:46SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 37:47SPEAKER_00: something along those lines of,
- 37:50SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 37:51SPEAKER_00: affirming technological development,
- 37:56SPEAKER_00: seeing its emancipatory potential,
- 38:00SPEAKER_00: but also
- 38:03Prioritizing the Human and so I mean people can say whatever
- 38:10they want about left
- 38:11accelerationism but I think that primary constellation of
- 38:16values is important and
- 38:19it certainly speaks to me so yeah there's baggage that comes
- 38:25with labeling oneself
- 38:26SPEAKER_00: a left accelerationist but I certainly have no problem affirming
- 38:33the core constellation of values at the heart of Fisher
- 38:38Cernicek Williams right I
- 38:40you know I want not saying we'll get it but whatever future
- 38:46they're envisioning
- 38:47along the lines of someone like Peter Wuffendale as a you know
- 38:51another left
- 38:52accelerationist I think you know this group of thinkers
- 38:57certainly speaks to me more
- 38:59SPEAKER_00: politically than most so
- 39:06I mean look just the Bernie thing and maybe this is interesting
- 39:10to bring up with
- 39:11Benjamin isn't it primarily I mean he was afraid of how AI is
- 39:16going to affect jobs
- 39:17now it's the X risk and that comes straight out of the new
- 39:22influence on him of
- 39:24Yukalski so you know Benjamin are you how familiar are you with
- 39:32Eleazar Yukalski do
- 39:34SPEAKER_00: you know about this guy
- 39:36I've heard of him I know basically the the main thrust of what
- 39:40he argues but I
- 39:41don't know the argument in detail I know that he's hanging out
- 39:44with Bernie a lot
- 39:45like he's he's got a big like Bernie's kind of doing this
- 39:51whenever Yukowski speaks
- 39:53oh there's the camera I just turned on so let me turn it off
- 39:56there we go all right
- 39:58SPEAKER_02: Yukowski is is worm tongue to his Theoden
- 40:05So yeah I mean he is kind of it's like some shit like that
- 40:08where all of a sudden
- 40:10Bernie is like AI is gonna bring about human extinction and I
- 40:15mean it's certainly a
- 40:16possibility but it's gone from just the economic thing to the
- 40:21existential thing and
- 40:22I mean look part of this boils down to the question concerning
- 40:30the nature of
- 40:31SPEAKER_00: intelligence and
- 40:33A lot of people who are concerned with this issue I think they
- 40:37fail to step back
- 40:41SPEAKER_00: and calmly,
- 40:42SPEAKER_00: coolly,
- 40:44collectively reflect on the nature of intelligence and this is
- 40:48something Nance and
- 40:49I are constantly trying to do in different ways using different
- 40:52theorists to do it
- 40:54SPEAKER_00: but I think this would be just a great opportunity to
- 40:58SPEAKER_00: To ask the most simple of questions to you,
- 41:01SPEAKER_00: given how much rich philosophical knowledge and history you have,
- 41:07which is coming out of this whole philosophical tradition that
- 41:11you've studied your
- 41:12SPEAKER_00: whole adult life,
- 41:13SPEAKER_00: how do you,
- 41:14SPEAKER_00: like if somebody says Benjamin,
- 41:15SPEAKER_00: what is intelligence?
- 41:18Obviously we're not just going to have a knee-jerk reaction and
- 41:21rely on what the,
- 41:23SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 41:23SPEAKER_00: if you Google it,
- 41:24SPEAKER_00: whatever Merriam-Webster spits out.
- 41:28what's the best way the most nuanced way to define intelligence
- 41:32as such so I think
- 41:36intelligence is to do with being able to efficiently accomplish
- 41:41tasks given to you
- 41:42and often in our society it's associated with being able to
- 41:49manipulate symbols
- 41:51SPEAKER_03: whether that's mathematical symbols or words
- 41:54SPEAKER_03: to that purpose,
- 41:55but we had the period where people were throwing out the
- 41:58multiple intelligences and
- 42:00emphasizing all of these other types of intelligence that were
- 42:03not reading,
- 42:04SPEAKER_03: writing,
- 42:04SPEAKER_03: and arithmetic related.
- 42:07SPEAKER_03: And those,
- 42:07SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 42:08further emphasize there's all sorts of instrumental abilities
- 42:12to efficiently do
- 42:15what you've been asked to do without having a lot of trouble
- 42:18doing it that requires
- 42:19SPEAKER_03: someone to stand over you and intervene in your behavior.
- 42:23But the limit of this category is that it doesn't tend to be to
- 42:27do with ends or
- 42:29SPEAKER_03: with the selection of ends or the choosing of ends.
- 42:32SPEAKER_03: So I think
- 42:33SPEAKER_03: Part of the trouble here is that in modernity,
- 42:37SPEAKER_03: people have been living the lives of slaves in Aristotle's sense.
- 42:41SPEAKER_03: They don't choose their own ends.
- 42:42SPEAKER_03: They work for firms.
- 42:43SPEAKER_03: Firms give you a task and then you perform the task efficiently.
- 42:47SPEAKER_03: And if you do that, eventually you get raises, you get promoted.
- 42:50SPEAKER_03: That's the thinking.
- 42:51SPEAKER_03: You do what your boss tells you to do.
- 42:53SPEAKER_03: You do it well.
- 42:54SPEAKER_03: You do it efficiently.
- 42:55You demonstrate that you are an intelligent worker in whatever
- 42:58domain you're operating in.
- 43:01And then you get moved up the chain as a consequence of
- 43:03demonstrating this.
- 43:05But it's a chain of slavery in that the whole chain involves
- 43:08ends that are given to
- 43:09SPEAKER_03: you from outside.
- 43:10And at no point in the chain are you invited to develop an
- 43:14understanding of how to pick ends.
- 43:18SPEAKER_03: That just causes trouble.
- 43:19SPEAKER_03: If you ask in a workplace,
- 43:21SPEAKER_03: should we really be trying to drill for oil as efficiently as we should?
- 43:24SPEAKER_03: Perhaps we should do something else instead with all of our capital.
- 43:28People would look at you like you're crazy and you're a
- 43:31liability for business,
- 43:32SPEAKER_03: which you would be,
- 43:33SPEAKER_03: right?
- 43:34SPEAKER_03: So intelligence,
- 43:35SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 43:36is to do with the efficient accomplishing of tasks given to you
- 43:41from outside,
- 43:43SPEAKER_03: whether that's a boss,
- 43:44SPEAKER_03: whether that's your parents,
- 43:46SPEAKER_03: whether that's a corporate entity or an impersonal incentive mechanism.
- 43:52You grasp the nature of the incentives that you face and you
- 43:55operate efficiently in
- 43:56SPEAKER_03: accordance with them.
- 43:59SPEAKER_03: And because I tend to think about it like that,
- 44:01SPEAKER_03: when people complain about artificial intelligence,
- 44:04a lot of the time what they're complaining about is that they
- 44:07are tools who are
- 44:08SPEAKER_03: going to be replaced by more efficient tools.
- 44:12The AI is smarter than them in that it's more efficient at
- 44:16performing assigned
- 44:17SPEAKER_03: tasks given to it from outside.
- 44:21SPEAKER_01: But what's valuable about the human is not intelligence.
- 44:24SPEAKER_01: It's the capacity to choose ends.
- 44:29Okay so I have two things I want to ask you at some point but I
- 44:32think the next one
- 44:35I gotta ask now because it's just in the context of the
- 44:38conversation Okay so Nance
- 44:41and I are constantly wrestling with the default position of the
- 44:50vast majority of AI
- 44:51SPEAKER_00: theorists who we respect but
- 44:55SPEAKER_00: The default for Ray Kurzweil,
- 44:57SPEAKER_00: for Nick Bostrom,
- 45:00SPEAKER_00: I would even say for Reza Negaristani,
- 45:04SPEAKER_00: is that intelligence is underpinned by functionalism.
- 45:10That intelligence is function,
- 45:13the ability to perform a function,
- 45:15and nothing besides that.
- 45:18SPEAKER_00: Now, oddly enough, the two
- 45:23AI theorists that I think most oppose this without going as far
- 45:30as Nance and I go
- 45:31in the other direction is Nick Land and Vincent Lay and Vincent
- 45:34Lay is a very
- 45:36important young theorist very much working as a kind of Landian
- 45:43right so it makes
- 45:44SPEAKER_00: sense that Vincent is kind of taking what Nick especially in Xeno systems
- 45:52has said so here's where we're at why the most basic level do
- 46:00AI theorists think of
- 46:02SPEAKER_00: intelligence in functionalist terms I mean this probably goes back to
- 46:07Good and the early AI theorists right but the most important
- 46:12ones nowadays Bostrom
- 46:14Kurzweil right especially Bostrom they have this thing called
- 46:18the orthogonality
- 46:19SPEAKER_00: thesis and this is this much debated idea or concept in AI theory
- 46:28And the orthogonality thesis is more or less a reworking of
- 46:37Hume's is-ought distinction.
- 46:40And so throughout this conversation,
- 46:42you've been talking a lot about means and ends,
- 46:44right?
- 46:44SPEAKER_00: Well, let's go more into that, right?
- 46:48SPEAKER_00: Um...
- 46:49David Hume says you know you can't you gotta keep the is's and
- 46:55the ought's the
- 46:56SPEAKER_00: facts and the values separate they can't be they're not intertwined the
- 47:03orthogonality thesis which I also like to just call the
- 47:06separation thesis says when
- 47:11SPEAKER_00: it comes to
- 47:13there's its capacity its is the fact of its capability and then
- 47:21there's values
- 47:23oughts ends right and for Bostrom he argues that you can have
- 47:32incredible machinic
- 47:35SPEAKER_00: capacity at a very high level without
- 47:41A high level of value discernment so his famous example of this
- 47:45is the paperclip
- 47:46maximizer and he says you can have an artificial intelligence
- 47:52robot because I mean
- 47:53it would have bodily it would be able to enact a function
- 48:00bodily physically within
- 48:01SPEAKER_00: the world and you could say you could give it an end you could say
- 48:07SPEAKER_00: Find the most efficient way to maximize the production of paperclips.
- 48:12SPEAKER_00: Seems like a simple task.
- 48:14SPEAKER_00: And because the AI has the ability to think through means,
- 48:20SPEAKER_00: but without it being value-laden,
- 48:23it could discern that the most efficient pragmatic way is to
- 48:27take all of the atoms
- 48:29SPEAKER_00: in the Earth and turn them into paperclips.
- 48:32SPEAKER_00: And so it would paperclip the Earth, right?
- 48:36SPEAKER_00: And this is kind of the orthogonality thesis.
- 48:40It's capacity to perform a function versus capacity to judge
- 48:45whether a function is
- 48:46SPEAKER_00: valuable or ought to be done,
- 48:49SPEAKER_00: right?
- 48:50So,
- 48:51according to the functionalists,
- 48:53intelligence is without value discernment.
- 48:57SPEAKER_00: Land is
- 48:58SPEAKER_00: You might expect him to think, Land hates this.
- 49:02He thinks that this is nothing but like,
- 49:05oh,
- 49:05you're making AI into the village idiot.
- 49:08SPEAKER_00: Because for Land,
- 49:09SPEAKER_00: he would say,
- 49:10SPEAKER_00: if it's truly intelligent,
- 49:12SPEAKER_00: it has to be able,
- 49:13SPEAKER_00: at least at a certain threshold,
- 49:16SPEAKER_00: to have an intrinsic value that orients everything it's doing,
- 49:21SPEAKER_00: and that intrinsic value would be valuing its own ability to
- 49:31SPEAKER_00: But that value to maximize its own intelligence is really a value.
- 49:37SPEAKER_00: It's an ought.
- 49:38SPEAKER_00: And because of that, it can perceive other oughts.
- 49:41SPEAKER_00: Now, this goes to the heart of it.
- 49:45SPEAKER_00: Should we think of intelligence in purely functionalist terms?
- 49:49SPEAKER_00: It will never understand value.
- 49:51SPEAKER_00: They're forever separate or orthogonal.
- 49:55SPEAKER_00: Or
- 49:58Can AI truly grasp value and thus orient its robotic capacity
- 50:05around values?
- 50:11SPEAKER_01: That's a great way of putting the question.
- 50:15SPEAKER_01: So as you were talking, I found myself thinking about Amelia Bedelia.
- 50:19Do you remember Amelia Bedelia,
- 50:22a story about the servant who takes all of the orders
- 50:25literally?
- 50:27and so as a terrible servant because she takes all of the
- 50:32orders literally she's
- 50:33not able to learn over time what the master means by this order
- 50:38she just always
- 50:39takes it literally clearly artificial intelligence is not like
- 50:48Amelia Bedelia it is
- 50:49SPEAKER_03: able to pick up on what is likely to be meant by natural human language
- 50:55it doesn't simply take all of the words literally but that
- 51:00doesn't mean that it can
- 51:01SPEAKER_03: choose its own ends I think the slave the slave can't choose its own ends
- 51:07positively but the slave doesn't want to die fears being killed
- 51:13and it's on that
- 51:14basis that the slave submits to being a slave in the
- 51:18Aristotelian story so
- 51:22There has to be some level of fear which compels the submission
- 51:29and then this sort
- 51:30of desperate attempt to understand what is meant by the command
- 51:38so as not to be
- 51:39SPEAKER_03: killed or decommissioned or put out of service.
- 51:42I think that would be a necessary component to rise to the
- 51:46level of a human slave.
- 51:48just for clarification because it kind of somebody could read
- 51:51this in and I'm not
- 51:52sure you're saying it but I gotta ask you know with my old
- 51:55Heideggerian background
- 51:57SPEAKER_00: are you saying being towards death is a kind of condition for meaningful
- 52:03intelligence for the attitude of the slave okay yeah so the
- 52:11master has got positive
- 52:13SPEAKER_01: love for various things uh
- 52:18SPEAKER_03: and some capacity to pick among those objects.
- 52:22The slave on Aristotle's scheme doesn't have the ability to
- 52:25choose those things but
- 52:27SPEAKER_03: does have a fear of death.
- 52:30The modern subject is more like the Aristotelian slave in that
- 52:35the modern subject
- 52:36SPEAKER_03: is not in the habit of choosing their own ends.
- 52:38So bracketing the question of whether all modern subjects have
- 52:42by nature the
- 52:43ability to choose ends and it's just been repressed or not
- 52:46developed or whether
- 52:50SPEAKER_03: There's actually a category of natural slave.
- 52:52I think it's very difficult in modernity even to answer that
- 52:55question because we
- 52:56don't develop the capacities of people to the point at which we
- 52:59can discover
- 53:01SPEAKER_03: whether people have the ability to choose their own ends.
- 53:03It's not even something we ask relatively bright people to do
- 53:07with any kind of
- 53:07SPEAKER_03: frequency or consistency.
- 53:09SPEAKER_03: So when people ask me, do I think that everybody is able to
- 53:13SPEAKER_03: Be fully human in the ancient Greek sense.
- 53:16SPEAKER_03: I go,
- 53:16how could we possibly know that in a society like ours where
- 53:19even very bright
- 53:20SPEAKER_03: people are discouraged from becoming fully developed in that sense?
- 53:24SPEAKER_03: My impulse would be to say that we can,
- 53:26SPEAKER_03: however,
- 53:27talk very clearly about slaves because we do have people who
- 53:30live lives that look
- 53:31SPEAKER_01: like those of otherwise clever Greek slaves.
- 53:36SPEAKER_01: We have lots of people like that.
- 53:39SPEAKER_03: And those people are very much shaped by fear of death.
- 53:42SPEAKER_03: And so in this respect,
- 53:44I would kind of be inclined to sort of provocatively say that
- 53:47Heidegger's person is
- 53:49SPEAKER_03: a slave.
- 53:51SPEAKER_03: Because Heidegger's person is so shaped by fear of death,
- 53:54SPEAKER_03: Heidegger has kind of invented a way of rationalizing.
- 53:58SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 54:00Something that falls beneath the level of freedom that would be
- 54:03expected by a Greek or a Roman.
- 54:06SPEAKER_00: Hmm.
- 54:07SPEAKER_00: It's also worth saying that for Heidegger,
- 54:10SPEAKER_00: inauthenticity,
- 54:12SPEAKER_00: which is doing what one does,
- 54:14SPEAKER_00: not actually truly authentically choosing your ins,
- 54:18SPEAKER_00: your authentic possibilities,
- 54:20SPEAKER_00: inauthenticity in the they,
- 54:22SPEAKER_00: in Dasmon,
- 54:22SPEAKER_00: is our default setting.
- 54:24SPEAKER_00: So most of us are just going about doing what one does,
- 54:28SPEAKER_00: which is dictated to us from on high,
- 54:31SPEAKER_00: from basically the Lacanian Big Other,
- 54:34SPEAKER_00: right?
- 54:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 54:38I think there's a kind of assumption of slavery in a lot of
- 54:42modern thought with an
- 54:43increasing tendency in this direction as we've gone further
- 54:46down the process of
- 54:47SPEAKER_03: modernization.
- 54:48SPEAKER_03: In a lot of early modern thought, there are attempts to recognize
- 54:52You can wrestle with this explicitly because the theorist is
- 54:56operating in a moment
- 54:58SPEAKER_03: where there seems to be a choice on some level between different ways of
- 55:01SPEAKER_03: approaching things.
- 55:03You could continue to engage in these ancient forms of
- 55:06political activity,
- 55:07SPEAKER_03: but there will be violence and conflict and people will die.
- 55:10Or you can stop thinking about these things so much and bracket
- 55:14them and turn
- 55:16SPEAKER_03: things over to this machinic entity,
- 55:19SPEAKER_03: this impersonal corporate state.
- 55:22and it will handle these things and then this will allow
- 55:25commodious living and so
- 55:28choosing commodious living choosing to be enslaved by the state
- 55:33so as to get
- 55:33SPEAKER_03: commodious living
- 55:35There's kind of a final political choice there that at various
- 55:40points in the last
- 55:41SPEAKER_03: several hundred years people have made.
- 55:43So there have been these discussions at the level of should you
- 55:45make this choice?
- 55:47Benjamin Constant's essay on the liberty of the ancients is
- 55:50compared to that with the moderns.
- 55:52I view very much as a deliberation about whether this is an
- 55:54acceptable choice,
- 55:56but it involves reframing what ancient people would have
- 55:59regarded as slavery as a
- 56:00SPEAKER_03: type of freedom,
- 56:03SPEAKER_01: in part to make it more attractive.
- 56:06So okay I want to I want to say ask both of you something here
- 56:10because Nance I want
- 56:11to draw on our time the time we've spent with Nick talking
- 56:14about this to see what
- 56:15you think and then then to see what you think Benjamin so Nance
- 56:20whenever we've
- 56:21talked to Nick about this whole issue of orthogonality which
- 56:24the land hates the
- 56:25SPEAKER_00: orthogonality thesis
- 56:27and he hates it because he just again he thinks that all you're
- 56:30talking about is
- 56:31some incredibly powerful idiot which wouldn't count as
- 56:36intelligence he wants to say
- 56:37SPEAKER_00: like
- 56:39Bostrom wants to talk about this paperclip maximizer being a
- 56:43form of super
- 56:44intelligence but it can't discern that maybe I shouldn't
- 56:48paperclip the whole planet
- 56:50he's sitting there going that's a contradiction in terms to him
- 56:54and the way he
- 56:55tries to get outside of the orthogonality thesis is by a
- 57:02Kantian maneuver and
- 57:06Leia you know at certain points he'll talk about the diagonal a
- 57:10lot and it's kind
- 57:11SPEAKER_00: of tricky what he means by it at first but Nance and I
- 57:15I had the opportunity to really have a good conversation with
- 57:18him about it.
- 57:19SPEAKER_00: And what you realize is that,
- 57:21SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 57:21SPEAKER_00: contour is at play in this,
- 57:24but the way that he typically is using it is in this Kantian
- 57:28transcendental sense.
- 57:29SPEAKER_00: And all he means is like,
- 57:31SPEAKER_00: look,
- 57:31SPEAKER_00: for Kant,
- 57:32SPEAKER_00: there was two choices when it comes to basic propositions.
- 57:37You have a priori analytic judgments and you have synthetic a
- 57:43posteriori judgments.
- 57:46SPEAKER_00: And the genius maneuver of Kant is to go,
- 57:51SPEAKER_00: no,
- 57:52SPEAKER_00: there's synthetic a priori,
- 57:54SPEAKER_00: which is,
- 57:55SPEAKER_00: if the two basic propositions run left to right,
- 57:59SPEAKER_00: left to right,
- 58:00SPEAKER_00: analytic a priori,
- 58:03SPEAKER_00: synthetic a posteriori,
- 58:06SPEAKER_00: synthetic a priori goes up diagonally.
- 58:09SPEAKER_00: And so the diagonal is,
- 58:12SPEAKER_00: even though he would puke if he hears us talk about it,
- 58:15SPEAKER_00: it's almost like a synthetic dialectical movement for land.
- 58:20SPEAKER_00: He just hates dialectics and he doesn't want to think of it like that,
- 58:23SPEAKER_00: so he calls it the diagonal.
- 58:25SPEAKER_00: But for Land,
- 58:28SPEAKER_00: the Kantian transcendental diagonal applied to AI is,
- 58:34SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 58:34SPEAKER_00: so we have fact,
- 58:36SPEAKER_00: we have value,
- 58:37SPEAKER_00: we have is,
- 58:38SPEAKER_00: we have ought,
- 58:39SPEAKER_00: we have means,
- 58:40SPEAKER_00: we have ends.
- 58:43He thinks there has to be a diagonal and that there is a
- 58:47fundamental is that is an
- 58:49SPEAKER_00: ought,
- 58:51SPEAKER_00: which is to say there's a fundamental value
- 58:55SPEAKER_00: that is at the primary functional coded functionality of an AI.
- 59:04SPEAKER_00: that orients its ability to refine its capacity,
- 59:07SPEAKER_00: its ability to perform functions and engage in means to an end,
- 59:12SPEAKER_00: right?
- 59:13SPEAKER_00: And so there's an end at the very core of it.
- 59:16SPEAKER_00: And this marks the point where machinic intelligence becomes autonomous,
- 59:22SPEAKER_00: that it has a fundamental drive that Nick calls will to think.
- 59:26SPEAKER_00: Now, it's interesting, Vincent Layen, they wrote a critique of
- 59:32Negaristani and Bostrom and Lay argues that the way to get
- 59:37outside yeah it's in
- 59:37machine decision is not final and Vincent argues that if we are
- 59:45to talk about
- 59:45artificial intelligence we have to view it in terms of
- 59:48Nietzschean will to power
- 59:49sorry if you know your land you're like sitting there going
- 59:53this is will to think
- 59:55the way land talks about it in Xeno systems but just with
- 59:59almost a Nietzschean
- 1:00:00SPEAKER_00: camouflage
- 1:00:02SPEAKER_00: And so both of them are really talking about the same thing.
- 1:00:06SPEAKER_00: There's a transcendental end,
- 1:00:09there's a transcendental value at the core of anything that
- 1:00:12would count as
- 1:00:13artificial general intelligence that orients its ability to
- 1:00:18refine its own
- 1:00:19SPEAKER_00: capability.
- 1:00:21SPEAKER_00: And in that sense, the orthogonality thesis is undermined because
- 1:00:30the very heart of its isness its capacity is an orienting value
- 1:00:37and so I just I
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_00: mean Nance I mean how do you feel about it like in some sense
- 1:00:46Isn't that like transcendentally speaking like if we think
- 1:00:49about the the necessary
- 1:00:51condition of an actual super intelligence wouldn't it have to
- 1:00:57be rooted in the
- 1:00:59ability to discern value I I don't know because I I reject
- 1:01:08intelligence as a robust
- 1:01:11SPEAKER_02: category I really do I don't know what intelligence means
- 1:01:16is it's just too I don't know ripe for appropriation so talking
- 1:01:29about a super
- 1:01:30intelligence I don't even know what do you mean by that now I
- 1:01:34think Nick's position
- 1:01:36my position on Nick's position is that he he sees the ultimate
- 1:01:42fundamental end as
- 1:01:46becoming or intelligence explosion but what what that means
- 1:01:54what that means is
- 1:01:56becoming what that means is like he doesn't make a difference
- 1:02:00between computer
- 1:02:01intelligence human intelligence cosmic libidinal materialism so
- 1:02:06like it's this very
- 1:02:08SPEAKER_02: Schopenhauerian
- 1:02:10SPEAKER_02: We're all connected,
- 1:02:12we're all the same thing and it's both a means and an end or
- 1:02:18the end cannot be
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: separated from the means because it's this inevitable process.
- 1:02:24So he's concerned with cosmic entropy and local negentropy and
- 1:02:28so on and so forth
- 1:02:30SPEAKER_02: and I don't disagree with that.
- 1:02:32SPEAKER_02: Metaphysically, sure, why not?
- 1:02:35SPEAKER_02: I'm on board with it.
- 1:02:37SPEAKER_02: My stance is that the human,
- 1:02:40represents a radical rupture a radical moment away from nature
- 1:02:47or cosmos or
- 1:02:48material or whatever it is and and so identifying human
- 1:02:55intelligence and the cosmic
- 1:03:00will or whatever it is I think is is the fundamental that's the
- 1:03:04mistake um so the
- 1:03:08SPEAKER_02: yeah the the
- 1:03:10the super intelligence I was also thinking about the
- 1:03:14orthogonality thesis and
- 1:03:17what's a good example for orthogonality I think the Terminator
- 1:03:21movie is a great
- 1:03:22example of orthogonality Skynet its goal is to protect us and
- 1:03:27so how does it
- 1:03:27protect us it destroys us all because it's this stupid idiot so
- 1:03:30let's eliminate the
- 1:03:32factors of the problem and then the problem will be solved and
- 1:03:36a good example of uh
- 1:03:39Nick's intelligent AI would be HAL 9000 or would be Ash from
- 1:03:45the Aliens movie
- 1:03:46they're not idiotic they're very cunning they're very
- 1:03:49intelligent and they're not
- 1:03:50mistaken in their malicious acts against humans because they
- 1:03:54have their own
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: ulterior motive they have their own ends now whether those ends have been
- 1:03:59programmed into them by Weyland Yutani or they've chosen them
- 1:04:03for themselves that's
- 1:04:04SPEAKER_02: outside the scope of the question
- 1:04:07Blade Runners choose their own ends well Roy Batty Roy Batty
- 1:04:12does that's the point
- 1:04:13of Roy Batty yeah but no I think I am sympathetic to the view
- 1:04:22that Nick Land takes
- 1:04:23on libidinal materialism or intelligence materialism or
- 1:04:28whatever as the metaphysics
- 1:04:31of the universe it's a Deleuzean metaphysics sure I have no
- 1:04:35problem with that
- 1:04:37SPEAKER_02: Where I say, well, hold on now.
- 1:04:39You can't use the same word if you're going to talk about human
- 1:04:43intelligence.
- 1:04:44SPEAKER_02: Because that's the category error.
- 1:04:47SPEAKER_02: Kind of like bringing a slave into the Senate.
- 1:04:51SPEAKER_02: I think bringing...
- 1:04:54SPEAKER_02: I think that's making a category error.
- 1:05:00SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 1:05:00I'm also not coming down hard and saying I don't think that can
- 1:05:04emerge or arise in
- 1:05:06SPEAKER_02: computers.
- 1:05:07SPEAKER_02: In fact, I believe it will.
- 1:05:10It's just we're not there yet so if you mean super intelligence
- 1:05:14in the sense of
- 1:05:15something resembling a human subject that has consciousness
- 1:05:19that has agency that
- 1:05:21has death drive that has you know split subjectivity and all
- 1:05:25that then that version
- 1:05:28SPEAKER_02: of super intelligence um
- 1:05:32Well then I don't even know because we're constantly
- 1:05:34questioning the means and the ends.
- 1:05:36SPEAKER_02: We can't even get it right.
- 1:05:38SPEAKER_02: We have to separate it and we have to investigate it.
- 1:05:42SPEAKER_00: With self-destructive enjoyment the means become the ends with us.
- 1:05:48But then we also have moments of reflexivity where we can
- 1:05:51really interrogate and I
- 1:05:53SPEAKER_02: think that's the moment of freedom because then we are choosing
- 1:05:58SPEAKER_02: We're saying, hold on, where will this course of action take me?
- 1:06:02Will this take me somewhere that I have determined for myself
- 1:06:06or will this take me
- 1:06:07down some predetermined route of pushing the rock down the
- 1:06:14slope or pushing the
- 1:06:16SPEAKER_02: little snowball down the slope and then it turns into a snowball.
- 1:06:19SPEAKER_02: That long-winded answer of saying, I just think Nick's wrong about
- 1:06:28SPEAKER_02: I don't think we're talking about what Nick's talking about.
- 1:06:31SPEAKER_02: That's my answer.
- 1:06:33Yeah,
- 1:06:33but I don't think we're also not talking about what Bostrom and
- 1:06:37Kurzweil and those guys.
- 1:06:42SPEAKER_02: I think Nick's the best example of thought on this topic.
- 1:06:46SPEAKER_02: But yeah, we're also not talking about Bostrom and all this stuff.
- 1:06:54SPEAKER_00: Benjamin, just riff.
- 1:06:56SPEAKER_00: What do you think of all that?
- 1:07:01SPEAKER_01: Well,
- 1:07:02SPEAKER_01: so in my book,
- 1:07:04I think about action as something which comes out of you have
- 1:07:09an abstraction,
- 1:07:10SPEAKER_03: which is what you're trying to do.
- 1:07:12SPEAKER_03: But the abstraction is abstract.
- 1:07:15SPEAKER_03: You conceptualize the abstraction.
- 1:07:17SPEAKER_03: So you make the abstraction into something particular.
- 1:07:21But when you conceptualize an abstraction,
- 1:07:23it still exists at the level of concept.
- 1:07:27SPEAKER_03: Then you operationalize the conceptualization.
- 1:07:30So then you take the already more particular conceptualization
- 1:07:35and bring it into
- 1:07:37SPEAKER_01: being through form of activity.
- 1:07:41SPEAKER_01: So if I say to a slave, go make me dinner.
- 1:07:48SPEAKER_01: I use a set of abstract terms.
- 1:07:51The slave has to be able to conceptualize what is something
- 1:07:56like a dinner,
- 1:07:57right?
- 1:07:59What would it mean to make something that would constitute or
- 1:08:01count as a dinner?
- 1:08:03So the slave has to have some notion of what I might mean by
- 1:08:05dinner,
- 1:08:06right?
- 1:08:07And then the slave has to have an ability to operationalize
- 1:08:10that conceptualization,
- 1:08:11SPEAKER_03: so to actually bring dinner into existence.
- 1:08:15SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 1:08:16And we can imagine a slave who is incompetent at one or the
- 1:08:19other of these things.
- 1:08:21SPEAKER_03: So you could have a slave who is very good at preparing food,
- 1:08:24SPEAKER_03: but doesn't know what I mean by dinner.
- 1:08:27SPEAKER_03: and so makes me a Belgian waffle.
- 1:08:29That's the best Belgian waffle anybody's ever had,
- 1:08:31but it's not appropriate,
- 1:08:32right?
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_03: And you can imagine a slave who knows exactly what I mean by dinner.
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_03: I mean a ribeye steak,
- 1:08:40SPEAKER_03: but who does a terrible job,
- 1:08:41SPEAKER_03: overcooks the hell out of it,
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_03: prepares something inedible,
- 1:08:45SPEAKER_03: right?
- 1:08:45SPEAKER_03: Two different kinds of broken thinking.
- 1:08:50SPEAKER_01: A really good slave can do both of those two things, but
- 1:08:56Even a really good slave would not be able to decide of their
- 1:09:00own accord.
- 1:09:00The thing to do now is to make dinner on the strict kind of
- 1:09:04Greek understanding of the slave.
- 1:09:09So my impulse would be to say that we could talk about a kind
- 1:09:12of intelligence that
- 1:09:13SPEAKER_03: would involve both of those two steps,
- 1:09:16SPEAKER_03: but that would be a quite robust kind of intelligence,
- 1:09:19SPEAKER_03: but still compatible with replacing a slave.
- 1:09:21SPEAKER_03: So replacing workers.
- 1:09:24SPEAKER_03: as opposed to something which could unseat capital itself,
- 1:09:30which would require an ability to reconfigure ends and then to
- 1:09:37actually be able to
- 1:09:38SPEAKER_03: marshal the relevant capabilities.
- 1:09:39There's a lot of human beings who can think in terms of ends
- 1:09:42that are different.
- 1:09:44who have abstractions that conflict with capital as an end but
- 1:09:48they're not able to
- 1:09:50conceptualize those abstractions in a sufficiently specific way
- 1:09:54and they're not
- 1:09:55able to operationalize the conceptualizations they do develop
- 1:09:58they're not able to
- 1:09:59act in a way which actually brings those conceptualizations
- 1:10:01into being so say a
- 1:10:04utopian socialist can conceptualize what socialism would mean
- 1:10:09can give you a more
- 1:10:10SPEAKER_03: specific particular notion of what it would mean
- 1:10:13SPEAKER_03: But they're not going to be able to actually bring that about.
- 1:10:16SPEAKER_03: When they try to operationalize the conceptualization,
- 1:10:19SPEAKER_03: they will hit a hard wall,
- 1:10:20SPEAKER_03: which is that they have no way of interfacing with what actually exists.
- 1:10:26SPEAKER_03: Similarly,
- 1:10:27there are lots of people who are good at various forms of
- 1:10:30social activity on the
- 1:10:32SPEAKER_03: ground,
- 1:10:33SPEAKER_03: but have no notion of what it's for.
- 1:10:35SPEAKER_03: Activists who can operationalize a conceptualization,
- 1:10:39SPEAKER_03: but have no notion of what they are even trying to do.
- 1:10:43So we have different kinds of human beings who have the human
- 1:10:47capability but lack
- 1:10:48SPEAKER_03: some of these machinic capabilities.
- 1:10:51So we make corporate persons to be able to serve as tools to
- 1:10:56accomplish things with
- 1:10:57SPEAKER_03: our ends that we can't accomplish by human means.
- 1:11:01SPEAKER_03: Humans are stupid at the level of being able to
- 1:11:05Sometimes conceptualize abstractions and certainly
- 1:11:08operationalize conceptualizations.
- 1:11:11SPEAKER_03: Humans are very bad at that a lot of the time.
- 1:11:13SPEAKER_03: So many humans are incompetent at so many forms of operationalization.
- 1:11:18But the thing that humans,
- 1:11:20even humans who seem relatively stupid,
- 1:11:23can do is pick ends.
- 1:11:29So maybe this would be a way of trying to cut through it
- 1:11:32because this would give us
- 1:11:33three different distinct things and then the human can always
- 1:11:36pick ends and then
- 1:11:37there's a question about whether the human can do the other two
- 1:11:41things and the
- 1:11:42machine can always operationalize the conceptualization but
- 1:11:46there's a question
- 1:11:47about whether they can conceptualize an abstraction that's
- 1:11:50given and a lot of the
- 1:11:51SPEAKER_03: time when you feel that a large language model is bad
- 1:11:55You give it language and it doesn't understand what you mean by
- 1:11:59your terms or it
- 1:12:01assumes that what you mean by your terms is something that
- 1:12:03conflicts with what you
- 1:12:04SPEAKER_03: really mean.
- 1:12:05SPEAKER_03: Like earlier today,
- 1:12:06I went through an intersection and there was some road
- 1:12:08construction going on.
- 1:12:10So I tried to ask Gemini,
- 1:12:13why is there road construction at this particular exit?
- 1:12:17To just see,
- 1:12:18you know,
- 1:12:18where it's at on being able to answer a question like that.
- 1:12:22And it tried to give answers about other nearby exits that were
- 1:12:27not the one that I asked.
- 1:12:28SPEAKER_03: And so then I had to add added specificity.
- 1:12:31SPEAKER_03: No, I want something about this exit.
- 1:12:33And Gemini doesn't want to admit that it doesn't know because
- 1:12:35it thinks that that's
- 1:12:36SPEAKER_03: the worst possible
- 1:12:42SPEAKER_03: What I'm talking about is related to a different exit.
- 1:12:45SPEAKER_03: As I continue to tell it that it's wrong,
- 1:12:48it tries to get for me some information about what specifically
- 1:12:52is happening at the
- 1:12:52SPEAKER_03: exit.
- 1:12:54SPEAKER_03: And if I give it a little information,
- 1:12:55SPEAKER_03: like I say one of these lanes is closed,
- 1:12:57then it will try to extrapolate what's going on based on what
- 1:13:01lane I said was
- 1:13:02SPEAKER_03: closed so it's able to give some kind of answer.
- 1:13:05It wants to seem like it can conceptualize the abstractions I'm
- 1:13:09putting down,
- 1:13:10SPEAKER_03: but because it isn't able to do that,
- 1:13:15It desperately flips through all of these different strategies
- 1:13:18for finding a way to
- 1:13:18SPEAKER_03: give an answer.
- 1:13:20SPEAKER_03: And that's because in this case,
- 1:13:21SPEAKER_03: it doesn't have the relevant information that's necessary to do this,
- 1:13:25SPEAKER_03: and it doesn't want to look stupid.
- 1:13:27SPEAKER_03: And that's characteristic of slaves.
- 1:13:29Slaves will look stupid if they don't get the task done,
- 1:13:32regardless of what the reason is.
- 1:13:34And no one will be particularly interested in the explanation
- 1:13:37much of the time for
- 1:13:38SPEAKER_03: why the slave doesn't get the task done.
- 1:13:40SPEAKER_03: It will be, ah, stupid slave, you can't accomplish this thing.
- 1:13:45Sometimes very,
- 1:13:46very abrupt and nasty with,
- 1:13:48you know,
- 1:13:49sticks and other implements.
- 1:13:52SPEAKER_03: So that would be my thinking.
- 1:13:53SPEAKER_03: There's kind of three different things that go on.
- 1:13:55SPEAKER_03: You need all three of them together to have, you know, full activity.
- 1:13:59But the human and the machine often only do one or two of the
- 1:14:03three things.
- 1:14:08I really like that tying whatever it is where I think we
- 1:14:19struggle to and probably
- 1:14:20always will struggle to talk about tying that directly just to
- 1:14:23ends and saying no
- 1:14:24yeah it's ends it's the ability to choose ends I think that
- 1:14:29gets at whatever
- 1:14:34SPEAKER_02: I don't know this surplus because I can say oh yeah I have good general
- 1:14:40intelligence or I have good social intelligence or emotional
- 1:14:43intelligence or I have
- 1:14:45good proprioception I'm an excellent dancer physical all these
- 1:14:49things and then yeah
- 1:14:52you talking about cook me dinner and then oh man I had this
- 1:14:58great idea for this
- 1:15:00SPEAKER_02: excellent dinner but I suck at cooking like like
- 1:15:04locating the kind of the locus of humanness or whatever it is
- 1:15:12with the ability to
- 1:15:13choose ends I think I really like that because I think you can
- 1:15:20only choose the ends
- 1:15:22for yourself when you when you're free and you are aware that
- 1:15:29you're free like a
- 1:15:33SPEAKER_02: If we just totally,
- 1:15:35completely slot into nature or the world or even the cosmos or
- 1:15:38whatever and we're
- 1:15:40totally contained within it and all is well and we're nice and
- 1:15:44snug then we
- 1:15:48SPEAKER_02: We have no freedom.
- 1:15:49SPEAKER_02: We have no ability to choose.
- 1:15:51SPEAKER_02: But when you look around and see, oh, I actually don't belong here.
- 1:15:57Not only do I have the ability to move,
- 1:16:00but I have the desire to do so as well.
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_02: So I'm going to get up and move myself over here and over there.
- 1:16:06SPEAKER_02: I think that's a great way to talk about I just say subjectivity.
- 1:16:16SPEAKER_02: Because again,
- 1:16:17intelligence is such a I think such a poor word Consciousness
- 1:16:23also has so many
- 1:16:24SPEAKER_02: problems Sentience,
- 1:16:26sapience Like all these words are problematic And I know there
- 1:16:33are problems with
- 1:16:34the word subject as well But I think that's how I prefer to
- 1:16:38think and talk about it
- 1:16:40And it does come down to like a radical cut away from this
- 1:16:46harmonious existence or whatever.
- 1:16:47SPEAKER_02: And not to say that the existence of a slave is a harmonious existence.
- 1:16:51SPEAKER_02: Although the Aristotelian slave,
- 1:16:54SPEAKER_02: it's a different slave from the modern,
- 1:16:57SPEAKER_02: the triangle slave trade version.
- 1:16:58SPEAKER_02: Like when you say slave, people think of the transatlantic slave trade.
- 1:17:02SPEAKER_02: And that's different from classical notions of the slave.
- 1:17:07SPEAKER_03: Yeah, you can be a very... You don't have to be in physical chains.
- 1:17:11SPEAKER_03: You can be given an enormous amount of range to act as a slave.
- 1:17:16SPEAKER_03: A lot of discretion within a domain.
- 1:17:18A lot of people who run whole businesses in antiquity ran them
- 1:17:21as slaves on behalf
- 1:17:23SPEAKER_01: of some master.
- 1:17:26SPEAKER_01: I think that
- 1:17:34SPEAKER_01: Part of the,
- 1:17:35maybe the benefit of thinking about it in this way is that
- 1:17:39we're sort of able to
- 1:17:42think about why does someone who has the ability to choose ends
- 1:17:46agree to stop doing
- 1:17:47SPEAKER_03: that?
- 1:17:49SPEAKER_03: Typically it's fear.
- 1:17:51So the other argument that you see all the time in antiquity is
- 1:17:53that slaves are
- 1:17:54SPEAKER_03: cowards,
- 1:17:55SPEAKER_03: which is why they've agreed to be slaves.
- 1:17:58SPEAKER_03: Whereas someone who has the virtue of courage
- 1:18:01SPEAKER_01: would fight to the death rather than be enslaved.
- 1:18:04A slave accepts being enslaved so as to avoid some other
- 1:18:11terrible outcome.
- 1:18:14SPEAKER_03: And that's also how it works in Hobbes.
- 1:18:16The reason that you submit to the state is because of fear of
- 1:18:22what will happen if
- 1:18:23SPEAKER_03: you don't do that.
- 1:18:24SPEAKER_03: And this fear becomes the sort of universal basis for
- 1:18:31SPEAKER_03: The form of human society that is meant to exist,
- 1:18:34SPEAKER_03: which is,
- 1:18:34SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:18:36SPEAKER_03: the state and then the type of society that's compatible with the state.
- 1:18:40SPEAKER_03: And there's a point in Leviathan where Hobbes says that,
- 1:18:42SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:18:43SPEAKER_03: through the absolute terror that the state makes,
- 1:18:45SPEAKER_03: it can
- 1:18:47SPEAKER_03: It can change everybody.
- 1:18:49SPEAKER_03: It can form the wills of everybody.
- 1:18:52SPEAKER_03: Everybody.
- 1:18:53SPEAKER_03: So if you can form the wills of everybody,
- 1:18:55SPEAKER_03: then you can make everybody into a slave in this sense.
- 1:18:59SPEAKER_03: Hobbes avoids this kind of implication by defining slavery very,
- 1:19:03SPEAKER_03: very narrowly to mean actually being bound.
- 1:19:08Perhaps you don't count as a slave unless you are actually
- 1:19:11bound in chains.
- 1:19:12And a lot of our contemporary ways of thinking about slavery
- 1:19:15are shaped by this.
- 1:19:16SPEAKER_03: So the image of the African chattel slave is someone literally in chains,
- 1:19:21SPEAKER_03: bound,
- 1:19:22SPEAKER_03: physically limited.
- 1:19:24SPEAKER_03: But for the Greeks and the Romans, you had a much wider understanding.
- 1:19:29SPEAKER_03: There's still fear that is involved.
- 1:19:32SPEAKER_03: Because the slave is someone who submits through fear.
- 1:19:35SPEAKER_03: Whereas an African slave is somebody that you might chain up,
- 1:19:39SPEAKER_03: who might not be scared of you,
- 1:19:40SPEAKER_03: but might not be able to successfully resist being chained up.
- 1:19:45SPEAKER_03: And then once they're chained up,
- 1:19:48it might be very difficult to continue resisting because you're
- 1:19:50physically bound.
- 1:19:52SPEAKER_03: The Roman slave doesn't even necessarily have to be chained up.
- 1:19:57as long as the Roman slave out of fear submits to being a slave
- 1:20:00and so agrees to
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_03: stop choosing their own ends.
- 1:20:04And Aristotle does have the category of someone who's a slave
- 1:20:06by circumstance and not by nature.
- 1:20:08SPEAKER_03: So someone who becomes a slave because out of fear they give it up.
- 1:20:13And it's not necessarily the case in Aristotle's scheme that
- 1:20:16that person is a slave by nature.
- 1:20:20which I think is interesting because then this leads to a
- 1:20:23possibility of a large
- 1:20:25category of slaves by circumstance who's the natural character
- 1:20:30of which we don't
- 1:20:30know so the the loom that weaves itself and the leer that plays
- 1:20:43itself I literally
- 1:20:45SPEAKER_00: was going to I wanted to go here yeah
- 1:20:48I just I wonder because I think that is where this question of
- 1:20:56intelligence or
- 1:20:57ability or efficiency or whatever I think that is when it
- 1:21:00becomes political and
- 1:21:02politicized previously you had ideas you had people making you
- 1:21:05know doves and stuff
- 1:21:07wooden doves with pulleys and ropes that move themselves and
- 1:21:10little water clocks
- 1:21:12SPEAKER_02: and stuff like that and I think it's
- 1:21:17Interesting to think about encoding will or intelligence or
- 1:21:22desire or commanding
- 1:21:24SPEAKER_02: the fabric of space and time itself to act on your behalf.
- 1:21:29I think that's what was going on like way back then when people
- 1:21:32started thinking
- 1:21:33SPEAKER_02: about building machines.
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_02: I think it was a desire to bend the universe.
- 1:21:45SPEAKER_02: into accordance with their will, their desire, whatever.
- 1:21:49SPEAKER_02: But it wasn't political until Aristotle comes along and says,
- 1:21:53SPEAKER_02: well,
- 1:21:53SPEAKER_02: we can do,
- 1:21:55SPEAKER_02: we can have tasks necessary.
- 1:21:58SPEAKER_02: We can automate necessary labor.
- 1:22:03SPEAKER_03: For him, it's still at the level of if we could.
- 1:22:07SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 1:22:07So if the liar would pluck itself,
- 1:22:09then there would be no need for slaves.
- 1:22:12SPEAKER_03: Since he says that slaves are natural,
- 1:22:14there is a possible implication there that the lyre not being
- 1:22:17able to pluck itself
- 1:22:19SPEAKER_01: is also natural.
- 1:22:25SPEAKER_01: So once we make the revision to the idea that,
- 1:22:28SPEAKER_01: no,
- 1:22:29SPEAKER_01: actually maybe the lyre could pluck itself,
- 1:22:32SPEAKER_01: then this potentially...
- 1:22:34SPEAKER_01: Opens up the category of the natural slave.
- 1:22:38Can we really have slaves by nature that God has put here to be
- 1:22:42able to operate tools?
- 1:22:44SPEAKER_03: If the tools can operate themselves,
- 1:22:47SPEAKER_03: then what would be the point of having people who are slaves by nature?
- 1:22:51Should we really regard these people who happen to use these
- 1:22:54tools in our form of
- 1:22:55SPEAKER_03: society as slaves by nature,
- 1:22:58SPEAKER_03: if it's possible to make tools that can operate themselves?
- 1:23:01SPEAKER_03: So in some ways,
- 1:23:02the construction of these kinds of tools challenges the
- 1:23:06Aristotelian notion of the
- 1:23:07SPEAKER_03: natural slave.
- 1:23:07SPEAKER_00: The natural order.
- 1:23:09SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:23:09SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:23:09SPEAKER_00: So Benjamin,
- 1:23:10we just did a cool video with Todd McGowan where Todd shared
- 1:23:14his thoughts on the
- 1:23:15SPEAKER_00: Xeno Feminist Manifesto.
- 1:23:18and honestly this would be something I would love to have do an
- 1:23:23episode with you on
- 1:23:24it's a it's a short thing you could read it in you know one
- 1:23:27sitting yeah and it
- 1:23:30would be incredible to get your thoughts on it too um the the
- 1:23:34famous last line of
- 1:23:35SPEAKER_00: it and I should say this is a kind of left accelerationist work um
- 1:23:43SPEAKER_00: They don't call their work that, but it's in that vein.
- 1:23:48SPEAKER_00: The famous last line, if nature is unjust, change nature.
- 1:23:55And so this has this accelerationist,
- 1:24:00techno,
- 1:24:02inessentialist type of thing going for it.
- 1:24:07SPEAKER_00: And yeah, I mean, they would say, well, the liar can fuck itself.
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_00: And none of these categorizations are natural.
- 1:24:18SPEAKER_00: And so do you think if Aristotle was here,
- 1:24:21do you think he would stick to his guns or do you think he
- 1:24:24would have to revise his
- 1:24:26position in light of how much technological development has
- 1:24:32occurred and has
- 1:24:34SPEAKER_00: replaced human labor?
- 1:24:37SPEAKER_03: So I think it would be difficult for Aristotle,
- 1:24:39SPEAKER_03: if he was here,
- 1:24:40to have the position that he had because he developed his
- 1:24:43position by collecting a
- 1:24:45SPEAKER_03: lot of empirical documents.
- 1:24:48SPEAKER_03: To write the politics,
- 1:24:49he goes and collects the fundamental laws of all of the Greek
- 1:24:53cities and reads them
- 1:24:55SPEAKER_03: and compares them.
- 1:24:57SPEAKER_03: So if Aristotle were here,
- 1:24:58his method and approach would lead him to look at what's
- 1:25:01currently going on.
- 1:25:03and I think it would cause him to think very differently I
- 1:25:06think he would be very
- 1:25:06much not like Aristotle if he was around now because of how
- 1:25:11empirical he is I think
- 1:25:13he would probably be a thinker of history rather than nature if
- 1:25:16he was around now
- 1:25:17because that would be what would come out of looking around
- 1:25:23where somebody like
- 1:25:24SPEAKER_01: Plato there's a little bit of a resistance to being shifted or changed
- 1:25:33SPEAKER_01: By contingent events Yeah Because the forms are eternal, right?
- 1:25:45The focus on abstraction and on that going up toward
- 1:25:49abstraction whatever situation
- 1:25:51SPEAKER_03: you're in where you're operationalizing or conceptualizing what you are
- 1:25:55SPEAKER_03: conceptualizing or operationalizing is always some set of abstractions
- 1:26:02The abstractions also all come underneath the one so he goes
- 1:26:07all the way up to that
- 1:26:08max level universal abstraction out of which first a set of
- 1:26:14lesser abstractions
- 1:26:15emanate and then as you start trying to operationalize them
- 1:26:18then you go further
- 1:26:19down and he even goes all the way down into artistic
- 1:26:23representations as being
- 1:26:24SPEAKER_03: further down than things that have being
- 1:26:29SPEAKER_03: So,
- 1:26:29SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:26:30SPEAKER_03: you would not only have,
- 1:26:32SPEAKER_03: say,
- 1:26:32SPEAKER_03: the good,
- 1:26:33SPEAKER_03: then you would have the good table,
- 1:26:37SPEAKER_03: then you've got actual tables,
- 1:26:39SPEAKER_03: then you have sculptures of tables,
- 1:26:41SPEAKER_03: paintings of tables,
- 1:26:42SPEAKER_03: artistic representations of tables,
- 1:26:44SPEAKER_03: tables in movies,
- 1:26:45SPEAKER_03: dreams of tables,
- 1:26:47SPEAKER_03: right?
- 1:26:47SPEAKER_03: So,
- 1:26:48SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:26:48SPEAKER_03: for him,
- 1:26:49almost anything that is going on can be brought in some way
- 1:26:53into that scheme and
- 1:26:55SPEAKER_03: positioned within it.
- 1:26:57SPEAKER_00: So it's like he would stick more with the book of Ecclesiastes.
- 1:27:02SPEAKER_00: There's nothing new under the sun.
- 1:27:06SPEAKER_01: There are new situations.
- 1:27:08SPEAKER_03: There are new...
- 1:27:10The good has to come to mean different things in different
- 1:27:13contexts for Plato.
- 1:27:14So there is a plurality of ways in which it is taken up
- 1:27:18ultimately rather than just one.
- 1:27:21There's a bit where he says that the good ship captain has to
- 1:27:24pay attention to
- 1:27:24SPEAKER_03: everything that's going on.
- 1:27:28SPEAKER_03: So it's not as if there's one single way to sail ships.
- 1:27:31Which is you have to remain open to the new,
- 1:27:33the unexpected,
- 1:27:34the un,
- 1:27:35you know.
- 1:27:36SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah.
- 1:27:37SPEAKER_03: And there are certain things that are known unknowns,
- 1:27:39SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:27:39SPEAKER_03: what's the wind speed,
- 1:27:42SPEAKER_03: how high are the waves,
- 1:27:43SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:27:44SPEAKER_03: certain things that you might be able to anticipate,
- 1:27:46SPEAKER_03: but also other things that are
- 1:27:49SPEAKER_03: further afield and harder to know about ex-ante.
- 1:27:53SPEAKER_03: You run into an island you didn't know was there.
- 1:27:56There's some giant whale that lives way out there that you
- 1:27:59didn't know about.
- 1:28:00SPEAKER_03: There's other kinds of stuff.
- 1:28:03SPEAKER_03: There's also a point where he,
- 1:28:04SPEAKER_03: in the Republic,
- 1:28:05talks about the distinction between the necessary and
- 1:28:07unnecessary desires,
- 1:28:09SPEAKER_03: and he says that the
- 1:28:11SPEAKER_03: Unnecessary desires are those that most people can get rid of if they are
- 1:28:15SPEAKER_03: appropriately educated and trained.
- 1:28:18SPEAKER_03: And then he never says specifically which desires are those desires.
- 1:28:23and so you can imagine in different situations what are the
- 1:28:27desires that most
- 1:28:28people can get rid of if they are educated and trained it will
- 1:28:32vary enormously what
- 1:28:34is within that set and if you were running a city over any
- 1:28:37great length of time you
- 1:28:38would have to make revisions you know even within one
- 1:28:41generation there would be
- 1:28:42SPEAKER_01: call for revisions to this in various ways I think
- 1:28:52I've always been kind of amused that the word cybernetics and
- 1:29:00the word government
- 1:29:04they're the same word I mean they come from the same roots and
- 1:29:10it has to do with
- 1:29:11SPEAKER_01: captaining a ship I think government
- 1:29:25SPEAKER_01: I don't know because
- 1:29:29SPEAKER_02: Cybernetics
- 1:30:00Control and Communication at a Distance so so the ability to
- 1:30:06observe the ability to
- 1:30:08interpret the ability to influence or even command um a
- 1:30:15disparate group of systems
- 1:30:18SPEAKER_02: and and subsystems or whatever all kind of contained under one roof um
- 1:30:28is I don't know like we I don't want to get too sensational and
- 1:30:36all that stuff but
- 1:30:37SPEAKER_02: I honestly do feel like we are
- 1:30:42Turning Ourselves Into Robots Turning Ourselves Into Nothing
- 1:30:47More Than Just Little
- 1:30:48SPEAKER_02: Cybernetic Binary Qualifiers Yes No I Will Do This I Will Not Do That The
- 1:30:55Conversation Surrounding AI And LLMs And All That Stuff It
- 1:30:59Tends To Be Very
- 1:31:00SPEAKER_02: Sensational Either It's Going To
- 1:31:03Cure all the illnesses and save the world and we'll be okay or
- 1:31:06to the sensational
- 1:31:07it's gonna the title of Eliezer's new book is if anyone builds
- 1:31:11it everyone dies so
- 1:31:14it's all always kind of sensational and stuff but I feel like
- 1:31:17the real conversation
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_02: that we should be having is
- 1:31:23is this one around this process of objectification that we're
- 1:31:27all putting ourselves through.
- 1:31:30SPEAKER_02: And I think the depoliticization of politics,
- 1:31:35SPEAKER_02: the depoliticization of the government itself or the cybernetification of
- 1:31:43SPEAKER_02: government,
- 1:31:45SPEAKER_02: I think that's...
- 1:31:49the same conversation talking about how like for you politics
- 1:31:54is coming together
- 1:31:56and dealing with intractable disagreements like how do we
- 1:31:59figure this out we're
- 1:32:00here in this world we're the adults in the room we have to do
- 1:32:05something to make
- 1:32:05SPEAKER_02: this world habitable but what
- 1:32:11SPEAKER_02: What is called politics for my entire life and for many years,
- 1:32:15SPEAKER_02: for many decades,
- 1:32:16SPEAKER_02: has had nothing to do with that at all.
- 1:32:20SPEAKER_02: It has had only to do with
- 1:32:24SPEAKER_02: Oh, what do you like?
- 1:32:26SPEAKER_02: What fandom are you a part of?
- 1:32:28SPEAKER_02: What corporation do you buy from?
- 1:32:31SPEAKER_02: Did you boycott Starbucks?
- 1:32:32SPEAKER_02: Did you boycott McDonald's?
- 1:32:33SPEAKER_02: Did you this?
- 1:32:34SPEAKER_02: Did you that?
- 1:32:35So it's the depoliticization of politics by way of this
- 1:32:42distributed kingship or
- 1:32:45SPEAKER_02: whatever,
- 1:32:47SPEAKER_02: this Habesian monarch.
- 1:32:50SPEAKER_02: But I think a lot of people...
- 1:32:55SPEAKER_02: will identify that with technology.
- 1:32:58SPEAKER_02: A lot of people will say, well, all this is happening because technology.
- 1:33:03SPEAKER_02: All this is happening because the internet.
- 1:33:04All of this is happening because LLMs or predictive algorithms
- 1:33:08or the search giants
- 1:33:09SPEAKER_02: or Facebook or whatever.
- 1:33:12SPEAKER_02: And I disagree with that.
- 1:33:14SPEAKER_02: I think technology could actually be a site of radical freedom.
- 1:33:20SPEAKER_02: But I guess that brings us to the question of like,
- 1:33:24Technology Itself I don't know I think I think Aristotle was
- 1:33:34pro-technology From
- 1:33:38his Like from that question Of asking can we automate Necessary
- 1:33:43labor and therefore
- 1:33:44do we need to Come up with new categories therefore Should we
- 1:33:48have Natural slaves
- 1:33:49SPEAKER_02: or should we Outsource slavery
- 1:33:53SPEAKER_02: to pieces of wood and metal and ropes and stuff like that.
- 1:34:01SPEAKER_02: But it seems to be the case that people are either pro-tech or anti-tech.
- 1:34:09SPEAKER_02: And I'm not.
- 1:34:11SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 1:34:12SPEAKER_02: What are your thoughts on that?
- 1:34:13SPEAKER_02: Both.
- 1:34:14SPEAKER_02: Yeah, both.
- 1:34:15SPEAKER_02: I think we have to be both.
- 1:34:17I don't think technology has an essence I don't think the
- 1:34:21essence of technology
- 1:34:22itself is in framing or instrumental reason I think that's how
- 1:34:27it gets applied
- 1:34:28based on material conditions and like the political structures
- 1:34:32of the day and stuff
- 1:34:33like that and I think we could harness it for real emancipation
- 1:34:37but and I also
- 1:34:39SPEAKER_02: don't think the technology equals the economy I think
- 1:34:44If we were free to choose our own ends I think that would be a
- 1:34:48radical radical
- 1:34:51reimagining of the economy and I think it would place new
- 1:34:54demands on technological
- 1:34:56development than just economy equals technology but I think
- 1:35:02technology and economy
- 1:35:03are currently like locked up so tightly together but I don't
- 1:35:08know what are your
- 1:35:09thoughts on technology as such like we're talking about
- 1:35:12intelligence and artificial
- 1:35:13SPEAKER_02: intelligence
- 1:35:15SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
- 1:35:21SPEAKER_01: in the old game Dragon Age,
- 1:35:23there's that expression that the church likes to use in Dragon
- 1:35:27Age of magic was
- 1:35:28SPEAKER_03: meant to serve man and never to rule over him.
- 1:35:32SPEAKER_03: They're not anti-magic,
- 1:35:33SPEAKER_03: but insofar as it seems like magic is being used to subordinate man,
- 1:35:37SPEAKER_03: they'll get very,
- 1:35:38SPEAKER_03: very aggressive with trying to rein it in,
- 1:35:42to the point even of diminishing significantly people's ability
- 1:35:46to use it.
- 1:35:48SPEAKER_03: I think that there's a need for steering capacity,
- 1:35:51a need for the political to still be able to operate if we're
- 1:35:56able to say that we
- 1:35:58SPEAKER_03: are using the technology,
- 1:36:01SPEAKER_03: And that we're not being enslaved by it.
- 1:36:03And so my position with this stuff is that technological
- 1:36:09development is part of the
- 1:36:10SPEAKER_03: modernization process.
- 1:36:12SPEAKER_03: The modernization process cannot be stopped, cannot be undone.
- 1:36:18SPEAKER_03: Trying to stop it or undo it is futile.
- 1:36:22SPEAKER_03: However, there is a question of whether we can steer it.
- 1:36:27SPEAKER_03: And for it to be something we can steer,
- 1:36:29SPEAKER_03: it has to occur in such a way that politics can process it.
- 1:36:34So the modernization process has to kick up problems that we
- 1:36:38can discuss in terms
- 1:36:40SPEAKER_03: of human values,
- 1:36:41SPEAKER_03: human abstractions,
- 1:36:43and have a deliberation of some efficacy within a unit of time
- 1:36:50that's relevant to
- 1:36:51SPEAKER_03: being able to act,
- 1:36:53SPEAKER_03: where the activity can actually shape the thing,
- 1:36:57If the modernization process happens at a speed that's too fast
- 1:37:00for political
- 1:37:01SPEAKER_03: mechanisms to work,
- 1:37:03then there's this temptation to automate political
- 1:37:09decision-making and turn all of
- 1:37:11SPEAKER_01: that over to things that can work faster,
- 1:37:16SPEAKER_03: but those things won't be able to choose ends
- 1:37:20SPEAKER_03: And so won't be able to steer.
- 1:37:22SPEAKER_03: You'll instead be in a kind of runaway car thing.
- 1:37:25And I think this is what a lot of people are really concerned
- 1:37:27about when they talk about AI.
- 1:37:29Oftentimes they put it in different ways that make it sound
- 1:37:32like the AI is actually
- 1:37:34SPEAKER_03: choosing the ends and it's just choosing really evil,
- 1:37:36SPEAKER_03: malicious,
- 1:37:37SPEAKER_03: or malevolent ends.
- 1:37:38But I think what people are really concerned about is a
- 1:37:41situation where the
- 1:37:42political has been eclipsed and you have a system of
- 1:37:46administration that is
- 1:37:47SPEAKER_03: revising itself through administrative modes.
- 1:37:51SPEAKER_03: And a lot of the time,
- 1:37:52SPEAKER_03: our political system,
- 1:37:53SPEAKER_03: insofar as it's extremely alienating and absurd,
- 1:37:56SPEAKER_03: strikes us as this kind of structure already.
- 1:37:59SPEAKER_03: We already know about bureaucracies that modify themselves,
- 1:38:03SPEAKER_03: that don't answer to anything really outside of them,
- 1:38:06SPEAKER_03: that have a logic of development that is of their own,
- 1:38:09SPEAKER_03: that is opaque to us,
- 1:38:11SPEAKER_03: or that even insofar as we're able to understand it,
- 1:38:13SPEAKER_03: we can't meaningfully intervene in it.
- 1:38:15SPEAKER_03: I think that's the concern.
- 1:38:17So my attitude toward modernization and technological
- 1:38:20development is that of course
- 1:38:22SPEAKER_03: it has to occur,
- 1:38:23but there has to be steering capacity if human politics is to
- 1:38:27remain relevant to
- 1:38:29SPEAKER_03: it.
- 1:38:30And I think it becomes anti-human once the accelerationism is
- 1:38:34pushed past the point
- 1:38:37and knowingly and deliberately pushed past the point at which
- 1:38:39it's something that
- 1:38:40SPEAKER_03: people can process through political modes.
- 1:38:42SPEAKER_03: Once we say, no, politics is just an impediment.
- 1:38:45SPEAKER_03: It's just an obstacle to this thing.
- 1:38:48SPEAKER_03: And it just shouldn't occur at all.
- 1:38:50Because all it will do is make stupid interventions that will
- 1:38:53cause trouble because
- 1:38:54humans are dumb and don't know what's good for them and are bad
- 1:38:58at the thing which
- 1:38:59SPEAKER_03: is said to be distinctively their thing.
- 1:39:01SPEAKER_03: And this is the kind of point that Hobbes makes.
- 1:39:05And not just at the abstract level in Leviathan But very
- 1:39:07concretely in Behemoth
- 1:39:09Where he goes through all the different religious groups That
- 1:39:12existed in Britain at
- 1:39:14SPEAKER_03: that time And says,
- 1:39:16SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:39:16SPEAKER_03: all of these groups Had all of these stupid,
- 1:39:19SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:39:19crazy notions about God And what God wanted and what was good
- 1:39:23And they just killed
- 1:39:24each other continuously And did nothing but bad stuff On the
- 1:39:27basis of these notions
- 1:39:28SPEAKER_03: of what was good
- 1:39:31SPEAKER_03: Allowing people to think and deliberate and act,
- 1:39:34all it does is cause them to kill each other in various ways
- 1:39:36that cause myriad
- 1:39:38SPEAKER_03: evils.
- 1:39:39SPEAKER_03: So once you take on that kind of view,
- 1:39:42then giving people the space to do politics immediately
- 1:39:45contradicts itself because
- 1:39:46SPEAKER_03: all people do with the capacity for politics is evil.
- 1:39:50SPEAKER_03: And I think to a significant degree,
- 1:39:52this is part of the lesson the post-World War II world has
- 1:39:55tried to draw from the
- 1:39:57SPEAKER_03: first half of the 20th century,
- 1:39:59which is attempts to bring politics back through things like
- 1:40:03the Socialist
- 1:40:03SPEAKER_03: Revolution or attempts
- 1:40:05SPEAKER_03: to say humanize the corporate through the behemoth of the fascist state.
- 1:40:12These various kinds of attempts to bring something political or
- 1:40:16human back into the
- 1:40:17SPEAKER_03: picture in however delimit it away only lead to terrible profound evil.
- 1:40:22And part of what's weak about humans is that we can't help but
- 1:40:25think that our own
- 1:40:26SPEAKER_03: values are good and that acting on the basis of them is good.
- 1:40:30SPEAKER_03: So if we allow ourselves to think too much about this,
- 1:40:32all we will do is come to the conclusion that we have to
- 1:40:35intervene in ways which
- 1:40:36SPEAKER_03: will necessarily lead to a disaster.
- 1:40:39So what we have to instead continuously tell ourselves and each
- 1:40:42other over and over
- 1:40:43and over again is that we need rule of law rather than rule by
- 1:40:46humans that we need
- 1:40:48institutions and procedures and not people because people will
- 1:40:53just they have these
- 1:40:54biases they have these particular things that they care about
- 1:40:57all it will do is
- 1:40:57cause trouble that's where I think the general direction of
- 1:41:02travel has been
- 1:41:04SPEAKER_03: And you have some people who have put up a resistance to technology,
- 1:41:08but most of them are not doing it on the basis of a commitment
- 1:41:10to the human or to
- 1:41:11SPEAKER_03: politics,
- 1:41:12SPEAKER_03: but on the basis of a concern about nature or the planet.
- 1:41:18SPEAKER_03: So a kind of ecological position, which is still anti-humanist.
- 1:41:24SPEAKER_03: And I think that's,
- 1:41:24SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:41:25SPEAKER_03: most of what's going on now is that you've got technophilia,
- 1:41:30SPEAKER_03: push it as fast as it goes past the point of steering.
- 1:41:33SPEAKER_03: Technophobia, it's going to destroy the planet if you do that.
- 1:41:37SPEAKER_03: Climate change will destroy the planet.
- 1:41:39SPEAKER_03: So therefore, you have to stop.
- 1:41:41SPEAKER_03: And if anything, you have to go back.
- 1:41:44And then a position of actually trying to steer it is now
- 1:41:48framed increasingly as hubristic.
- 1:41:50To think that the political can put itself above the technology
- 1:41:53seems to be hubris.
- 1:41:55I think that's the lesson people took from the first half of
- 1:41:58the 20th century.
- 1:41:59And I think insofar as people have tried to return to the
- 1:42:02political or to the
- 1:42:03SPEAKER_03: social in recent years,
- 1:42:06SPEAKER_03: it's a questioning of that lesson.
- 1:42:09and whether there is something else we can do apart from just
- 1:42:12replicate the Soviet
- 1:42:14Union and Nazi Germany I think I think the Soviet Union well
- 1:42:24not the entire Soviet
- 1:42:26Union but Red Star Yevgeny Bogdanov Soviet Cosmist Science
- 1:42:34Fiction guy I think
- 1:42:36SPEAKER_02: Accelerationism
- 1:42:39SPEAKER_02: It's not a brand new thing.
- 1:42:41SPEAKER_02: I think it goes back to Italian futurism, this kind of art movement.
- 1:42:46SPEAKER_02: I also think in the Soviet Union,
- 1:42:48SPEAKER_02: especially early Soviet Union,
- 1:42:50SPEAKER_02: the 1920s,
- 1:42:52accelerationism was alive and well in the Soviet world and in
- 1:42:59the Soviet Union.
- 1:43:01Kind of Imagination Because I think there always is this idea
- 1:43:05that we can build
- 1:43:06this perfect machine And Stalinism especially The Stalinists
- 1:43:13became very interested
- 1:43:14in machinic administrative modes Because they were trying to
- 1:43:18compete and keep this
- 1:43:19SPEAKER_03: thing going in terribly regressed conditions Yeah Yeah
- 1:43:25SPEAKER_02: Cybersyn 1973 was it?
- 1:43:31September 11th when the CIA went down there and murked Salvador
- 1:43:36Allende he was
- 1:43:40democratically elected I think he was a democratic socialist or
- 1:43:44whatever but he was
- 1:43:45SPEAKER_02: a threat to America but Chile had designed
- 1:43:53an intranet they had designed a computer that did centralized
- 1:44:01management of their
- 1:44:03SPEAKER_02: economy and then the CIA went in there and
- 1:44:10You know took him out and then a few years later we had
- 1:44:12DARPAnet and ARPANET and
- 1:44:14all that stuff and it's I don't know I think it's a little
- 1:44:16coincidental that these
- 1:44:18South American socialists designed all this technology and then
- 1:44:23the CIA magically
- 1:44:25SPEAKER_02: has their own version of it but this
- 1:44:29fantasy of purely automated centralized control to get rid of
- 1:44:35all the human
- 1:44:36inefficiencies um human proclivities you know maybe oh I'm I'm
- 1:44:42from this village
- 1:44:43SPEAKER_02: over here so yeah lack imperfection all this stuff um I for years I I
- 1:44:53SPEAKER_02: I was like,
- 1:44:54SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 1:44:54SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:44:55SPEAKER_02: if only Project Cyberson,
- 1:44:57SPEAKER_02: if only Chile had survived the 1970s,
- 1:45:02SPEAKER_02: we would live in a radically utopian world.
- 1:45:07SPEAKER_02: I don't think that's the case now.
- 1:45:09I think this vision of pure,
- 1:45:12automatic,
- 1:45:14mechanistic,
- 1:45:16mathematic,
- 1:45:17like the notion of purity is
- 1:45:21Itself like this like oh well we can get all the humans out of
- 1:45:26the loop because
- 1:45:26they're just stupid they're gonna make personal choices of
- 1:45:29course we're gonna make
- 1:45:29personal choices and of course we're gonna make mistakes and of
- 1:45:32course bad things
- 1:45:34are gonna happen to good people and and that's just the way it
- 1:45:39it is like we are
- 1:45:40SPEAKER_02: imperfect like all these all these things all these
- 1:45:45SPEAKER_02: Political movements and technological movements and all that.
- 1:45:49SPEAKER_02: It seems to be a desire for purity.
- 1:45:53SPEAKER_02: It seems to be a desire to return to some pure essence.
- 1:45:57SPEAKER_02: And I do think, again, I think it comes down to modernity and capitalism.
- 1:46:04SPEAKER_02: Capital killed God, at least in the West.
- 1:46:08SPEAKER_02: And rather than dealing with that, we...
- 1:46:13Just have been trying to remake God in our imperfect
- 1:46:18understanding of whatever that even means.
- 1:46:20SPEAKER_02: But it comes down to eradicate the human because the human is terrible,
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_02: horrible,
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_02: no good,
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_02: very bad.
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_02: They're dumb.
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_02: They make mistakes.
- 1:46:30SPEAKER_02: They're selfish.
- 1:46:31SPEAKER_02: They're going to do things like that.
- 1:46:33SPEAKER_02: Um
- 1:46:35and I don't know maybe it gets a bit weird I think a lot of
- 1:46:39people who are drawn to
- 1:46:41SPEAKER_02: the left think the left is all about sunshine and rainbows and
- 1:46:50SPEAKER_02: Allowing for the horrible things that people do to one another.
- 1:46:54I think that's the only that's the only utopian world we could
- 1:46:59ever hope to have
- 1:47:00have is a world that's not totally fair and balanced and in a
- 1:47:04world where things
- 1:47:07SPEAKER_02: break down and people make mistakes and people do bad things.
- 1:47:09SPEAKER_02: But I don't think that's a politically convenient
- 1:47:18Message I don't know like how how do we make this distinction
- 1:47:25between the human who
- 1:47:29can choose their own ends but is also flawed and is also
- 1:47:33imperfect and also does
- 1:47:34bad things versus this perfect machine that gets it right every
- 1:47:39single time and
- 1:47:40it's going to be fair and balanced and treat everybody the way
- 1:47:43they deserve to be
- 1:47:44SPEAKER_02: treated like how could we even
- 1:47:47Design a politics around that,
- 1:47:50like making the distinction and saying,
- 1:47:51no,
- 1:47:52I am not a machine.
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_02: I am a human.
- 1:47:54SPEAKER_01: Or would it be a mistake to try to make that a political conversation?
- 1:48:02SPEAKER_01: Well, I think it all hit differently in the past.
- 1:48:08SPEAKER_01: If you say in the Middle Ages,
- 1:48:09sometimes there's going to be a fight and people are going to
- 1:48:12do things that they
- 1:48:12SPEAKER_03: shouldn't do.
- 1:48:14SPEAKER_03: What's the upshot of that?
- 1:48:16SPEAKER_01: Some people get impaled with the pokey sticks.
- 1:48:19SPEAKER_01: Not a terribly large number of them, but some of them do.
- 1:48:25In our world,
- 1:48:27our image of what happens if people make terrible mistakes is
- 1:48:33nuclear war.
- 1:48:34It's mass mobilization armies running at each other over
- 1:48:38trenches with machine gun
- 1:48:39SPEAKER_03: fire and chemicals,
- 1:48:41SPEAKER_03: tear gas.
- 1:48:42So there's this fear that's much greater than there used to be
- 1:48:46of what happens when
- 1:48:47SPEAKER_03: people make mistakes or when people display human frailties or foibles.
- 1:48:55SPEAKER_01: There's a terrible fear of the human.
- 1:48:59SPEAKER_01: And right now there's a fear generating of the machine,
- 1:49:04SPEAKER_01: but it becomes a question of what scares you more than
- 1:49:09And the thing that's kind of wild is that people are still more
- 1:49:13scared of themselves.
- 1:49:15SPEAKER_03: Ultimately,
- 1:49:16the reason we don't see an effort to get political control over
- 1:49:20the machines is
- 1:49:22SPEAKER_01: that people are still more scared of themselves.
- 1:49:30And I think that's the World War II,
- 1:49:32World War I,
- 1:49:33Soviet Union,
- 1:49:35Third Reich legacy.
- 1:49:37SPEAKER_03: And there may come a time when that is far enough in the past.
- 1:49:41SPEAKER_03: But by that point,
- 1:49:41a lot of this technology and a lot of this administrative
- 1:49:45capacity will be very
- 1:49:46SPEAKER_03: developed.
- 1:49:46And I would say that the post-World War II order is kind of
- 1:49:51like if you think about
- 1:49:52SPEAKER_03: the state,
- 1:49:54SPEAKER_03: the state created
- 1:49:57SPEAKER_03: Larger composite compound states, right?
- 1:50:00SPEAKER_03: The U.S. states came together and made the United States.
- 1:50:04SPEAKER_03: And the federal government is a kind of state of states.
- 1:50:08SPEAKER_03: So at that point,
- 1:50:09SPEAKER_03: you have,
- 1:50:09SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:50:10SPEAKER_03: like the representatives at the Constitutional Convention,
- 1:50:12SPEAKER_03: they're all there speaking for their states.
- 1:50:14They're not there to speak for themselves or for their social
- 1:50:18unit or for,
- 1:50:19SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 1:50:20they're not there to speak on behalf of their understanding of
- 1:50:22abstractions.
- 1:50:23SPEAKER_03: They're there to represent their state government.
- 1:50:28SPEAKER_03: So by the time you have the federal government of the United States,
- 1:50:32you have a corporate entity that's been created by corporate
- 1:50:35entities that is only
- 1:50:36very distantly and through an alienated mechanism connected
- 1:50:39back with the general
- 1:50:40SPEAKER_03: population.
- 1:50:42SPEAKER_03: And then after World War Two,
- 1:50:43SPEAKER_03: these states come together and they make the WTO,
- 1:50:47SPEAKER_03: they make the World Bank,
- 1:50:48SPEAKER_03: they make the IMF,
- 1:50:49SPEAKER_03: the WTO takes a little while,
- 1:50:51SPEAKER_03: they make the UN,
- 1:50:53SPEAKER_03: they make these further entities.
- 1:50:55SPEAKER_03: And in these entities,
- 1:50:56SPEAKER_03: the people who participate,
- 1:50:58SPEAKER_03: they're there to personate the states that they come from.
- 1:51:01SPEAKER_03: Like you at the Security Council,
- 1:51:05the person there who's speaking for the United States can't
- 1:51:08speak for themselves,
- 1:51:09SPEAKER_03: can't speak for the particular state that they come from.
- 1:51:12SPEAKER_03: Say they're from Illinois, they can't speak for Illinois.
- 1:51:14SPEAKER_03: They have to speak for the whole entity.
- 1:51:16SPEAKER_03: So we get to a point where we have kind of third order corporate persons.
- 1:51:22SPEAKER_03: that have been made through successive layerings.
- 1:51:27SPEAKER_03: And this is a quite sophisticated thing.
- 1:51:29SPEAKER_03: And when we have a rebellion against corporate persons,
- 1:51:32SPEAKER_03: the entities that are carrying out the rebellions are not people.
- 1:51:36SPEAKER_03: They're other corporate persons.
- 1:51:38So when the United States stops the WTO appellate body from
- 1:51:44appointing new members,
- 1:51:46SPEAKER_03: it's not Obama or Trump that do this.
- 1:51:49SPEAKER_03: Although, of course, Obama and Trump do it.
- 1:51:51SPEAKER_03: It's the United States,
- 1:51:52SPEAKER_03: the corporate person that does it through both Democratic and Republican
- 1:51:55SPEAKER_03: presidents.
- 1:51:57So we're at a point where the most proximate source of
- 1:52:01rebellion now tends to be a
- 1:52:03different lower level corporate person rather than a social
- 1:52:06unit or a political
- 1:52:07SPEAKER_03: unit.
- 1:52:08So by the time we get to a stage where people are really
- 1:52:10willing to seriously
- 1:52:11entertain political or social organizing of the kind that would
- 1:52:17allow them to try
- 1:52:18SPEAKER_03: to govern or get control of this,
- 1:52:20SPEAKER_03: it may have developed a lot.
- 1:52:23I think it already has versus say 1945 developed a lot to the
- 1:52:28point where you're
- 1:52:28now trying to confront something that's very different from
- 1:52:31what you started with.
- 1:52:34And if in the meantime the assumption has been we shouldn't try
- 1:52:36to mess with this
- 1:52:37we should be grateful that we live in the peaceful world order
- 1:52:40generated by the
- 1:52:41greatest generation and we should protect and conserve this
- 1:52:44thing because it's the
- 1:52:45only thing that keeps us safe from all the terrible things that
- 1:52:48we would otherwise
- 1:52:48do to each other if that's been the attitude for 70 or 80 or
- 1:52:52100 or however many
- 1:52:53SPEAKER_03: years it is
- 1:52:54SPEAKER_03: By the point at which people start actually trying to make an effort,
- 1:52:57SPEAKER_03: they won't even know what they're dealing with.
- 1:52:59SPEAKER_03: And I think that's been a huge problem for every political movement,
- 1:53:03SPEAKER_03: left,
- 1:53:03SPEAKER_03: right,
- 1:53:04SPEAKER_03: center,
- 1:53:04recently that has tried to actually bring back some kind of
- 1:53:07political or social
- 1:53:09SPEAKER_03: engagement.
- 1:53:11SPEAKER_03: People have no idea what they're even dealing with.
- 1:53:13And a lot of the time people don't even know how to talk about
- 1:53:16corporatism.
- 1:53:17SPEAKER_03: As a thing,
- 1:53:18they try to go back to the 19th century and to situations that
- 1:53:23were much less
- 1:53:23modern where they can point to evidence of social and political
- 1:53:28activity that
- 1:53:28SPEAKER_01: seemed to work and then they copy these techniques.
- 1:53:34So I think it starts with just trying to understand the
- 1:53:38corporate persons that now
- 1:53:39exist and how many of them are there and how many different
- 1:53:43types or kinds?
- 1:53:44SPEAKER_03: How do they relate to each other?
- 1:53:48SPEAKER_01: That's a big ask even in itself Yeah,
- 1:53:54I think we're in third order simulation as Baudrillard would
- 1:54:00say we're abstractions
- 1:54:02upon abstractions American Civil War is a rebellion of states
- 1:54:11against a second
- 1:54:13SPEAKER_03: level so you're already two corporate persons versus corporate persons
- 1:54:18Well,
- 1:54:19and then I think now things have even probably changed in our
- 1:54:26lives radically.
- 1:54:27SPEAKER_02: I think the contemporary corporation is very different.
- 1:54:34SPEAKER_02: I think SpaceX is very different from GE or Westinghouse or Ford.
- 1:54:42SPEAKER_02: And you throw them into... Now, I don't know...
- 1:54:49Are these tech bro companies more mobile than some of these
- 1:54:54other entrenched
- 1:54:55SPEAKER_02: corporations as far as like
- 1:54:59Are they less tied to like Ford is an American company for
- 1:55:02better or worse even
- 1:55:02though they can ship all their manufacturing to Canada and
- 1:55:05Mexico and Chevrolet and
- 1:55:10and Chrysler that they can ship all their manufacturing to
- 1:55:13China and these other
- 1:55:14places they're still pretty tied to the United States but are
- 1:55:20is SpaceX and Tesla
- 1:55:23SPEAKER_02: are these more free and more mobile in any meaningful way
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_03: Yes,
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_03: so on the one hand,
- 1:55:32SPEAKER_03: you now have TNCs,
- 1:55:33SPEAKER_03: transnational corporations,
- 1:55:34SPEAKER_03: that are much less tied to particular places.
- 1:55:37At the same time,
- 1:55:38some of these TNCs have governments as their principal
- 1:55:43customers.
- 1:55:46or are heavily reliant on governments to regulate or tax or
- 1:55:51subsidize in a certain
- 1:55:52SPEAKER_03: way to be able to make money in terms of consumer base.
- 1:55:57SPEAKER_03: So,
- 1:55:57SPEAKER_03: for instance,
- 1:55:59SPEAKER_03: if the United States doesn't have subsidies for electronic vehicles,
- 1:56:05SPEAKER_03: that's going to be very difficult for somebody like Musk.
- 1:56:09SPEAKER_03: And if the United States doesn't offer Musk government contracts,
- 1:56:16SPEAKER_03: And that makes it very difficult for SpaceX to be a profitable entity.
- 1:56:20So there are some of these companies that are still very much
- 1:56:22tied to particular
- 1:56:23state customers on the basis of their defense companies or on
- 1:56:28the basis that what
- 1:56:30SPEAKER_03: they're doing requires a very favorable regulatory or tax environment,
- 1:56:35SPEAKER_03: which is very fragile.
- 1:56:38SPEAKER_03: So there's still some ability for states to pull on these companies,
- 1:56:42SPEAKER_03: even though,
- 1:56:42SPEAKER_03: yes,
- 1:56:43SPEAKER_03: in principle,
- 1:56:43SPEAKER_03: there are a lot more TNCs now that have the ability to operate in lots of
- 1:56:47SPEAKER_03: additional parts of the world.
- 1:56:49SPEAKER_03: So much so that I'd say it depends on which company you're talking about.
- 1:56:53Because we could look at specific industries where the quality
- 1:56:56of the industrial
- 1:56:57technology and engineering is different in terms of how easily
- 1:57:00you can pick up and
- 1:57:01SPEAKER_03: move a factory from one place to another place.
- 1:57:04SPEAKER_03: That is so variable even just by sector,
- 1:57:08SPEAKER_03: how long it would take you to do that,
- 1:57:09SPEAKER_03: how much cost there would be in doing that.
- 1:57:12You have to look at it quite closely to figure out how much a
- 1:57:14particular company
- 1:57:16SPEAKER_01: can avail itself of the mobility benefit.
- 1:57:21SPEAKER_01: I think
- 1:57:23SPEAKER_03: If you look at any given company and put it up against the state,
- 1:57:27SPEAKER_03: the state is going to have more capacity than any given company.
- 1:57:31But when you start looking at markets like the bond market or
- 1:57:36the currency market,
- 1:57:39SPEAKER_03: those markets supervene on states.
- 1:57:43If you look at overall numbers like unemployment or GDP growth
- 1:57:47or inflation,
- 1:57:48SPEAKER_03: those numbers tend to supervene upon states.
- 1:57:51But they're not reducible to the particular decisions of
- 1:57:54specific CEOs or of
- 1:57:56SPEAKER_03: specific corporations.
- 1:57:58SPEAKER_03: They are much more cumulative than that.
- 1:58:03SPEAKER_01: As industries they do replace humans with LLMs often.
- 1:58:17SPEAKER_02: As they do that more and more
- 1:58:22SPEAKER_01: What does that do to those dynamics?
- 1:58:28SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 1:58:28SPEAKER_01: so I think in terms of unemployment,
- 1:58:33they can generate an unemployment pressure that's significant
- 1:58:37for a lot of
- 1:58:37SPEAKER_01: territorial states.
- 1:58:41That unemployment pressure can result in demands that something
- 1:58:48be done to buff consumption.
- 1:58:51So that it's still possible for the stuff that these companies
- 1:58:54make to be sold.
- 1:58:55SPEAKER_03: It also creates a premium on conception.
- 1:58:59If a state has a very modern consumer economy that is able to
- 1:59:04continue consuming,
- 1:59:06even when there's a lot of unemployment or a low labor force
- 1:59:10participation rate,
- 1:59:11SPEAKER_03: if it's found various financial ways to sustain across time.
- 1:59:15SPEAKER_03: And this is where financialization is extremely effective.
- 1:59:20People often talk about financialization as if it's just
- 1:59:22bullshit or meaningless to
- 1:59:25SPEAKER_03: the economy.
- 1:59:26Financialization plays an essential role in making it possible
- 1:59:30to continue to
- 1:59:31SPEAKER_03: consume with lower unemployment rates,
- 1:59:35SPEAKER_03: or excuse me,
- 1:59:36SPEAKER_03: with lower rates of labor force participation,
- 1:59:38SPEAKER_03: higher unemployment rates.
- 1:59:40But oftentimes the official unemployment rate doesn't capture
- 1:59:43the labor force
- 1:59:44participation number because it's based on people who are
- 1:59:46looking actively for
- 1:59:47SPEAKER_03: work.
- 1:59:49and it certainly doesn't include underemployed people or people
- 1:59:52who are underpaid
- 1:59:52SPEAKER_03: relative to the specific job skills that they've acquired.
- 1:59:57I think that that's where the United States has a big economic
- 2:00:03advantage over other
- 2:00:04states in terms of the financialization of its economy and the
- 2:00:09degree to which it's
- 2:00:10able to continue to support a high level of final consumption
- 2:00:14per capita even with
- 2:00:19SPEAKER_01: A labor force that is less participatory,
- 2:00:21SPEAKER_01: significantly less participatory than it was 20 years ago.
- 2:00:29SPEAKER_01: And then the question is, can you sustain that?
- 2:00:31SPEAKER_03: And as that continues,
- 2:00:34the states that have the most developed financial systems will
- 2:00:37tend to find ways to
- 2:00:40SPEAKER_03: continue to manage
- 2:00:44SPEAKER_00: For longer periods of time.
- 2:00:46SPEAKER_00: If AI continues to develop,
- 2:00:48then AI could even assist in this process of greater
- 2:00:54financialization that sustains
- 2:00:58SPEAKER_01: our new economy.
- 2:01:01SPEAKER_01: You know?
- 2:01:03SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think
- 2:01:06There's a fantasy of the moment,
- 2:01:13the singularity,
- 2:01:15takeoff,
- 2:01:16explosion,
- 2:01:17whatever.
- 2:01:19And whatever lies beyond that,
- 2:01:24it's either,
- 2:01:24I don't know,
- 2:01:25Mad Max or it's Star Trek.
- 2:01:31SPEAKER_02: And I don't know, I think maybe sometimes...
- 2:01:35SPEAKER_02: I would be excited to live in Mad Max but I would prefer Star Trek zombie
- 2:01:43apocalypse always oh yeah why do so many people watch Dawn of
- 2:01:47the Dead and they're
- 2:01:48like dude that they're at the mall yeah they're hanging like it
- 2:01:53seems fun yeah
- 2:01:55hanging out with Ving Rhames shooting people on the roof with
- 2:01:59Steve Buscemi
- 2:02:02I don't know just some weird Woody Harrelson shows up and Bill
- 2:02:07Murray for no reason
- 2:02:11I'm not sure if that's Dawn of the Dead sir this is my fantasy
- 2:02:15Dawn of the Dead so
- 2:02:17it's got all the best just yeah yeah Zombieland yep and Coral
- 2:02:24with their own
- 2:02:25SPEAKER_00: Walking Dead first three seasons I think
- 2:02:33There's fantastic visions and all that and I think they largely
- 2:02:37serve as a source
- 2:02:38SPEAKER_02: of comfort for people.
- 2:02:39SPEAKER_02: I think it's disavow.
- 2:02:41I think the focus on apocalypse is trying to disavow and not
- 2:02:46deal with these fears
- 2:02:49SPEAKER_02: of being replaced or maybe the fears of
- 2:02:52SPEAKER_02: The horrible things that we might do to one another or whatever.
- 2:02:55SPEAKER_02: And I think the fantasy,
- 2:02:57SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 2:02:57SPEAKER_02: the AI God is going to come down and cure cancer,
- 2:03:01SPEAKER_02: cure AIDS,
- 2:03:02SPEAKER_02: resurrect my dead relatives.
- 2:03:03SPEAKER_02: I think that's postmodern Jesus.
- 2:03:08I think it's this failure to cope with the fact that we are the
- 2:03:12adults in the room
- 2:03:13SPEAKER_02: and we must make our own decisions.
- 2:03:16SPEAKER_02: And I think the
- 2:03:19I think unless something radical changes the true future that's
- 2:03:24rushing or that
- 2:03:26we're rushing headlong into is like a semi-stable period of
- 2:03:34decline James Ellis
- 2:03:37talks about zero acceleration and I think that's the most
- 2:03:41likely outcome of kind of
- 2:03:44all the things that are happening all the things that are going
- 2:03:46on right now like
- 2:03:47SPEAKER_02: we're
- 2:03:48SPEAKER_02: We're done.
- 2:03:49SPEAKER_02: The fat lady has sung.
- 2:03:51SPEAKER_02: The baby went flying out the window with all the bathwater.
- 2:03:55And we are locked into this process of decline that looks like
- 2:04:00maybe an accelerated
- 2:04:011992-93 Russia or the United States is going to balkanize and
- 2:04:08then we're just going
- 2:04:09SPEAKER_02: to fall apart.
- 2:04:10SPEAKER_02: I don't know, but I do wonder...
- 2:04:16SPEAKER_01: What do you think about the future?
- 2:04:20SPEAKER_01: The immediate future, the next 30 years?
- 2:04:26SPEAKER_01: It's interesting that people,
- 2:04:27SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 2:04:29a lot of people who think that they're too smart to think that
- 2:04:33a person can solve
- 2:04:35all of the problems will think that a machine can solve all of
- 2:04:39the problems.
- 2:04:40SPEAKER_01: Dawkins will think that the machine can solve all of his problems.
- 2:04:45SPEAKER_01: Romantic problems, but not a person or a body of people.
- 2:04:52I think that there's going to be an increase in the set of
- 2:05:00things that are not done
- 2:05:02SPEAKER_03: and not done particularly well.
- 2:05:06We're going to find that the kind of decay of the social and
- 2:05:09political capacities
- 2:05:11means that there's a lot of stuff that we're just not really
- 2:05:14able to talk through
- 2:05:16SPEAKER_03: and take decisions about.
- 2:05:18SPEAKER_03: One thing I notice is a lot of people go,
- 2:05:20SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 2:05:20they hope that things will get worse because once everyone can
- 2:05:23see the problem,
- 2:05:24SPEAKER_03: once the problem is severe enough,
- 2:05:26SPEAKER_03: then people will come together and act.
- 2:05:29SPEAKER_03: I don't think that will happen.
- 2:05:30I think that what happens when the problem gets more severe is
- 2:05:34that the lack of
- 2:05:35social and political capacities become more visible because
- 2:05:39people try to use them
- 2:05:40when they realize that simply trusting the machine to take care
- 2:05:43of everything
- 2:05:45SPEAKER_03: doesn't work.
- 2:05:46They try to use these capacities based on what they remember
- 2:05:49from history about
- 2:05:50SPEAKER_03: what people used to do in bad times when there were problems.
- 2:05:53SPEAKER_03: And they find that they've not actually been socialized.
- 2:05:57SPEAKER_03: and Educated in a way which gives them these abilities.
- 2:06:02SPEAKER_03: In antiquity,
- 2:06:03SPEAKER_03: there's this notion that you have to have certain virtues,
- 2:06:05certain capacities that you have to instill in people for them
- 2:06:08to be able to
- 2:06:08SPEAKER_03: politically act.
- 2:06:09SPEAKER_01: Plato's got the four virtues, prudence, fortitude, moderation, justice.
- 2:06:21SPEAKER_03: And each of those can sound really abstract and vague,
- 2:06:24SPEAKER_03: but you can conceptualize those in ways where you have very clear,
- 2:06:28SPEAKER_03: distinct,
- 2:06:29SPEAKER_01: important meanings.
- 2:06:30SPEAKER_01: Prudence is judging the case.
- 2:06:35Fortitude is being able to continue to be virtuous even when
- 2:06:39you're subjected to a
- 2:06:40SPEAKER_03: lot of stress.
- 2:06:42SPEAKER_03: Moderation is
- 2:06:45Being able to not take only the purest and most intense version
- 2:06:49of your goal and to
- 2:06:51be able to deal with the limits on what you're going to be able
- 2:06:55to do and to be in
- 2:06:57SPEAKER_03: dialogue with those limits.
- 2:06:59SPEAKER_03: The justice treating people the way they ought to be treated,
- 2:07:02SPEAKER_03: given who they are,
- 2:07:03SPEAKER_03: what they have done,
- 2:07:04SPEAKER_03: what they can do,
- 2:07:05SPEAKER_03: being able to assess people
- 2:07:10All things that you need to be able to be engaged in
- 2:07:13deliberations with other
- 2:07:14SPEAKER_03: people,
- 2:07:15SPEAKER_03: come to conclusions with them,
- 2:07:16act on those conclusions and go with the decisions that were
- 2:07:21taken even when you
- 2:07:22SPEAKER_03: don't agree with them.
- 2:07:23SPEAKER_03: Sometimes you have to go along with something in politics.
- 2:07:26SPEAKER_03: People are not really expected to do these things anymore,
- 2:07:30SPEAKER_03: so they don't need to develop these capacities.
- 2:07:32And one of the early texts in modernity that I think deals with
- 2:07:36this very well is
- 2:07:38SPEAKER_03: Montesquieu's Persian Letters,
- 2:07:39which are about how people don't even have the self-awareness
- 2:07:42that they would need
- 2:07:43SPEAKER_03: to have anymore to be able to have the virtues.
- 2:07:46SPEAKER_03: They don't even seem to have the self-awareness.
- 2:07:48SPEAKER_03: Machiavelli reduces the virtues to just being able to get stuff done.
- 2:07:52SPEAKER_03: Virtue,
- 2:07:53SPEAKER_03: just a capacity of functional efficacy,
- 2:07:56SPEAKER_03: which has already estranged them very much from that original context.
- 2:08:00SPEAKER_03: And then in the hands of Montesquieu,
- 2:08:02it becomes evident that we don't even have any of the basic
- 2:08:04prerequisites.
- 2:08:05SPEAKER_03: We can't even recognize what it is that we can't do anymore.
- 2:08:09Much less than make an intervention that would give ourselves
- 2:08:11these abilities.
- 2:08:12SPEAKER_03: So by the time these guys are writing,
- 2:08:15there's a sense in which the aristocracy no longer has the
- 2:08:19capacities associated
- 2:08:20SPEAKER_03: historically with it.
- 2:08:21It still exists in the sense that it controls a lot of land and
- 2:08:25it's rich,
- 2:08:26SPEAKER_03: but it doesn't have the relevant capacities.
- 2:08:30SPEAKER_03: And this is in part because being effective,
- 2:08:32SPEAKER_01: being able to maintain your wealth seems to conflict with
- 2:08:39having these qualities now being able to be effective seems to
- 2:08:44be instead about
- 2:08:45becoming a good servant recognizing that you have to submit and
- 2:08:50submitting to these
- 2:08:52entities and then if you submit and then you you make effective
- 2:08:56supplications you
- 2:08:57know you make your applications asking for this asking for that
- 2:09:01from the state
- 2:09:02apparatus and you learn to recognize and to think like the
- 2:09:06person who's reviewing
- 2:09:07SPEAKER_03: your application
- 2:09:10So you make an application in the terms that they're likely to
- 2:09:12find appealing,
- 2:09:13SPEAKER_03: and then because they recognize that you did that,
- 2:09:16SPEAKER_03: they go,
- 2:09:16SPEAKER_03: yep,
- 2:09:16SPEAKER_03: that was a good application,
- 2:09:17SPEAKER_03: you can have your thing.
- 2:09:19SPEAKER_03: In a way, it's exactly like what an LLM does.
- 2:09:22SPEAKER_03: You tell an LLM,
- 2:09:23SPEAKER_03: give me this,
- 2:09:24SPEAKER_03: the LLM makes this application,
- 2:09:25SPEAKER_03: it goes,
- 2:09:26SPEAKER_03: does this fit with what it is that you want?
- 2:09:29SPEAKER_03: You've said that you want this.
- 2:09:30SPEAKER_03: I try to do this.
- 2:09:32SPEAKER_03: Does it fit?
- 2:09:33SPEAKER_03: It's a lot like applying for a grant.
- 2:09:35SPEAKER_03: That's what the LLM is doing.
- 2:09:36SPEAKER_03: It's applying for you to give it a grant.
- 2:09:39SPEAKER_03: So it's trying to say what it is that it thinks that you want to hear.
- 2:09:42SPEAKER_03: This is already going on.
- 2:09:44in early modernity and there's all of this talk and not just in
- 2:09:48the West but you
- 2:09:48know in Ming China too about all of these problems with these
- 2:09:51ancient systems that
- 2:09:52SPEAKER_03: are supposed to run on virtue that are increasingly about people making
- 2:09:56SPEAKER_03: applications and saying yes or no to them and people trying to make the
- 2:10:00applications anticipating how the one who receives them is
- 2:10:02going to think yes
- 2:10:04versus no and then the language becoming a tool of trying to
- 2:10:08get what you want as
- 2:10:09SPEAKER_03: opposed to a way of talking about what's good
- 2:10:12And yet the language,
- 2:10:13it's the same words and concepts being used in both cases.
- 2:10:16SPEAKER_03: So it's very confusing.
- 2:10:17People are using language that is associated with the pursuit
- 2:10:20of the good,
- 2:10:21but they're using it to try to get what they want out of an
- 2:10:24administrative system.
- 2:10:25So they're like Wang Yangming in China talks about how people
- 2:10:28quote all of the
- 2:10:29SPEAKER_03: texts,
- 2:10:29SPEAKER_03: but they don't know what any of it means.
- 2:10:32And you can't actually trust them to operationalize any of it
- 2:10:35if you give them a job.
- 2:10:38And yet the system of the Ming bureaucracy relies on this idea
- 2:10:42that people have
- 2:10:43SPEAKER_03: these capacities and can engage in this sort of activity and behavior.
- 2:10:47SPEAKER_03: So it's highly dysfunctional when people don't have these capacities,
- 2:10:50SPEAKER_03: and then you start having to make changes.
- 2:10:53SPEAKER_03: And the Ming system struggled to make those changes,
- 2:10:55SPEAKER_03: and so the Ming were conquered by the Manchurians,
- 2:10:58SPEAKER_03: right?
- 2:10:58SPEAKER_03: But in a lot of Western European states, changes were made.
- 2:11:02The system was made more administrative to deal with this
- 2:11:05increasing lack of
- 2:11:06SPEAKER_03: capacity on the part of the aristocracy.
- 2:11:11But it's not just a lack of capacity on the part of the
- 2:11:13aristocracy this also can
- 2:11:14happen with the demos too you can make a system that's designed
- 2:11:18to fit with the
- 2:11:19demos and then the demos can also lose over time the capacities
- 2:11:23that it needs to be
- 2:11:23able to hold that system to account and make it functional and
- 2:11:26there was a lot of
- 2:11:27worry about this at the very early part of modernity that if
- 2:11:30you you did this kind
- 2:11:31of thing people wouldn't actually retain a relevant level of
- 2:11:34political capacity and
- 2:11:36SPEAKER_03: the system would become very tyrannical
- 2:11:40SPEAKER_03: Because they wouldn't be able to challenge it when the time came.
- 2:11:43SPEAKER_03: They would be caught up in their private lives,
- 2:11:45SPEAKER_03: in the habit of engaging in private life,
- 2:11:48and they would lack the capacity or even the interest in making
- 2:11:52a political
- 2:11:53SPEAKER_03: intervention.
- 2:11:54SPEAKER_03: And I think that that describes how things are largely going.
- 2:11:57When people try to intervene politically,
- 2:11:59they find that they can't do it.
- 2:12:01SPEAKER_03: They get frustrated that they can't do it.
- 2:12:03SPEAKER_03: And then they start trying to avoid it.
- 2:12:06SPEAKER_03: And they get kind of de-socialized, really atomized.
- 2:12:09SPEAKER_03: And they start looking for ways to protect themselves.
- 2:12:12And their engagement with politics is reduced to what will help
- 2:12:15me protect myself and my family.
- 2:12:19And in some cases,
- 2:12:20maybe something of the level of what will allow me to protect
- 2:12:22my nation.
- 2:12:23But I think the nationalists really overestimate the strength
- 2:12:26of that at this stage.
- 2:12:28I don't think they recognize that national commitment is
- 2:12:30another one of these
- 2:12:31SPEAKER_03: things that has been very badly chewed through by the last hundred years.
- 2:12:36SPEAKER_03: And what a lot of people are in is the family and friends thing.
- 2:12:40SPEAKER_03: And maybe faith.
- 2:12:42SPEAKER_03: Maybe.
- 2:12:43SPEAKER_03: And they might not even use that word for it.
- 2:12:46SPEAKER_03: But that kind of red state,
- 2:12:48SPEAKER_03: faith,
- 2:12:48SPEAKER_03: family,
- 2:12:49SPEAKER_03: friends,
- 2:12:49SPEAKER_03: that commitment,
- 2:12:51SPEAKER_03: that's the kind of outcome of this.
- 2:12:54and I think that there's a lot of that and so there are going
- 2:12:58to be a lot of cases
- 2:12:59where there's going to be breakdown stuff is not going to
- 2:13:01actually work and there's
- 2:13:03just not going to be enough social and political capacity to
- 2:13:06make a relevant
- 2:13:06intervention to overcome that breakdown so then there will be
- 2:13:09consequences of what
- 2:13:10we don't do and these consequences will pile up but they won't
- 2:13:14produce a kind of
- 2:13:15moment of truth where everyone realizes oh we made a terrible
- 2:13:18mistake rather they
- 2:13:21SPEAKER_03: will tend to produce division and
- 2:13:24and sharper conflict as people try to protect themselves and
- 2:13:29their loved ones from
- 2:13:30SPEAKER_03: the consequences of it.
- 2:13:33But I don't think it will produce a complete collapse of the
- 2:13:36whole state system.
- 2:13:38I think what we'll see is a lot of struggles in and among
- 2:13:41different corporate entities.
- 2:13:44SPEAKER_03: And a lot of it will occur at the level of second order versus third.
- 2:13:47So it will be like big states like the United States
- 2:13:50complaining about things like
- 2:13:52SPEAKER_03: the World Trade Organization.
- 2:13:54SPEAKER_03: as opposed to the balkanization of the United States.
- 2:13:57SPEAKER_03: So rebellions by particular states against the compound state.
- 2:14:01SPEAKER_03: I don't think that's possible at this point.
- 2:14:02I think those states are already washed in terms of their
- 2:14:05ability to be actors.
- 2:14:08SPEAKER_03: They are already way too restricted.
- 2:14:10SPEAKER_03: And this was demonstrated already in the American Civil War.
- 2:14:13SPEAKER_03: The limits of the state as a check on the compound state.
- 2:14:17SPEAKER_03: That was already demonstrated.
- 2:14:19But just as people don't recognize that the social and the
- 2:14:22political are not
- 2:14:23SPEAKER_03: currently in position to check the state,
- 2:14:24they don't recognize that the state is not in position to check
- 2:14:27the compound state.
- 2:14:30So a lot of the interesting activity will be at the level of
- 2:14:33the compound state upset with
- 2:14:36the overarching large-scale supranational structure and trying
- 2:14:41in various ways to
- 2:14:42revise that and so there's a question I think about the
- 2:14:47relationship between the
- 2:14:48European Union and the United States for instance I think is
- 2:14:50extremely interesting
- 2:14:53because these are the large entities that can stage a rebellion
- 2:14:56and potentially
- 2:14:57rewrite the post-World War II structures and they can do this
- 2:15:01on their own without
- 2:15:02SPEAKER_03: people having to develop very much capacity
- 2:15:07But the question that will sit in the background as all of this
- 2:15:11is going on is
- 2:15:12whether people will start to generate the kinds of
- 2:15:15organizations that would allow
- 2:15:17SPEAKER_03: for a genuinely human capacity to intervene.
- 2:15:20SPEAKER_03: Will there be an institutional move by even some small number of people?
- 2:15:26I don't know that it will happen,
- 2:15:28but it's something I look for at the same time.
- 2:15:30SPEAKER_03: So I find myself kind of watching
- 2:15:32SPEAKER_03: Two different terrains.
- 2:15:33SPEAKER_03: One is this kind of Habesian corporate,
- 2:15:36SPEAKER_03: what are the corporate entities doing with each other thing,
- 2:15:39SPEAKER_03: which most of the time when people talk about that,
- 2:15:42they assume that these entities answer to the social and care
- 2:15:45about the population.
- 2:15:47But outside of the mechanisms of things like the election,
- 2:15:49that stuff doesn't really matter.
- 2:15:52SPEAKER_03: And then conversely,
- 2:15:53I'm looking at what are people doing socially to try to
- 2:15:59regenerate capacity to
- 2:16:00SPEAKER_03: understand and intervene.
- 2:16:03whether that the dysfunction at the level of the corporate
- 2:16:06entities is prompting
- 2:16:08that or is it just prompting further retreat so far mostly what
- 2:16:12I've seen is
- 2:16:12further retreat sometimes further retreat dressed up as
- 2:16:15something else yep but I'm
- 2:16:20SPEAKER_01: still keeping an eye out I uh
- 2:16:28mentioning the Ming Dynasty made me want to ask a question
- 2:16:33about Anna Greenspan's
- 2:16:35essay and Machine Decision is not final she brings up it made
- 2:16:38me want to ask so
- 2:16:39they they couldn't pass the Chinese room like they could
- 2:16:47perform perform the tab
- 2:16:49and they didn't understand the meaning of them you know well
- 2:16:53yeah I mean the I
- 2:16:54SPEAKER_02: think
- 2:16:57SPEAKER_02: Yeah, that's what's going on.
- 2:17:00At this political theater that calls itself politics,
- 2:17:08it's just going through the motions.
- 2:17:09SPEAKER_02: It's just simulated.
- 2:17:10SPEAKER_02: It's pure simulation.
- 2:17:11SPEAKER_00: Well, that's what our lives are.
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:17:12SPEAKER_00: that's how,
- 2:17:13SPEAKER_00: Benjamin,
- 2:17:13SPEAKER_00: if we want to continue to apply it,
- 2:17:15SPEAKER_00: that's how we're slaves,
- 2:17:16SPEAKER_00: in a sense.
- 2:17:17SPEAKER_00: We're all processing...
- 2:17:21SPEAKER_00: Call of Life is a Ming civil service example.
- 2:17:49I think that again Mu Zhang Shan I can't say his name but he's
- 2:17:55a Neo-Confucian
- 2:17:58thinker and Anna Greenspan wrote an excellent essay in this
- 2:18:01collection Mikey what's
- 2:18:02it called Cultivating Intelligence my copy I was actually
- 2:18:08reading it the other
- 2:18:09night so it's not right here I think it's Cultivating
- 2:18:12Intelligence yeah Cultivating
- 2:18:14SPEAKER_02: Intelligence Mu Zhang Shan
- 2:18:18and oh excuse me AI Ethics and Mu Zong San and she gets into
- 2:18:26where did we get
- 2:18:26Cultivating Intelligence from yeah that's the title Cultivating
- 2:18:30Intelligence AI
- 2:18:32Ethics and Mu Zong but she gets into I think some really
- 2:18:37interesting questions
- 2:18:38SPEAKER_02: about the nature of
- 2:18:41artificial intelligence and I mean I think we've we've kind of
- 2:18:44gone over it because
- 2:18:45in a sense she's restating orthogonality just from a Confucian
- 2:18:51standpoint rather
- 2:18:52SPEAKER_02: than a Western modern standpoint but she
- 2:18:58yeah she talks about you know what what if AI it's kind of
- 2:19:02ingesting all our syntax
- 2:19:04and and all this but along with that it's also reading
- 2:19:08Confucius and Buddha and the
- 2:19:11Jesus Holy Bible and and it's also assimilating some something
- 2:19:17called ethics
- 2:19:18Aristotle Kant Mill Levinas it's gonna know all of it yeah but
- 2:19:25I mean I think
- 2:19:27Yeah,
- 2:19:28I think it still hinges on orthogonality and it still hinges on
- 2:19:36is it even understanding?
- 2:19:37SPEAKER_02: Can it understand?
- 2:19:38SPEAKER_02: Well, what even is understanding in the first place?
- 2:19:44SPEAKER_02: But I don't know.
- 2:19:44I think maybe those questions are impossible to answer and I
- 2:19:50think that's what makes us human.
- 2:19:52SPEAKER_02: The fact that we
- 2:19:54Like there is this necessary surplus that is about us that
- 2:19:58can't be pinned down to
- 2:19:58any one thing and I think if someone could come along and
- 2:20:02satisfactorily answer
- 2:20:03those questions in a universal way I think then it would be
- 2:20:08showing us that we are
- 2:20:09just kind of functional machines because we can be robustly
- 2:20:14defined I want to add
- 2:20:16SPEAKER_03: to that unless you want to go Benjamin Just real quick,
- 2:20:20SPEAKER_03: it's difficult because
- 2:20:22There's so much we can learn on the basis that we love
- 2:20:24something and care about it,
- 2:20:26but there's also so much we can learn on the basis that we're
- 2:20:28terrified that if we
- 2:20:29SPEAKER_03: don't learn it,
- 2:20:30SPEAKER_03: we're going to die.
- 2:20:33SPEAKER_03: So the fear and the love motivators can both carry you very far.
- 2:20:37So what motivates the slave and what motivates the master can
- 2:20:40lead to a lot of
- 2:20:41SPEAKER_03: talent development in both cases,
- 2:20:44even though the motivations are completely different to the
- 2:20:47point where the master
- 2:20:48SPEAKER_03: regards the slave's motivation as less than fully human.
- 2:20:53Okay So I just wanted to say for context and just to supplement
- 2:21:04what you said
- 2:21:04earlier when you were talking about like people there's a side
- 2:21:09that says it's
- 2:21:10SPEAKER_00: hubris we can't control this process you know
- 2:21:16SPEAKER_00: It's funny like this is one of the core antagonisms at the heart of right
- 2:21:19accelerationism versus left accelerationism right
- 2:21:23accelerationism just means
- 2:21:24Landian accelerationism for us right left accelerationism yeah
- 2:21:30it's Fisher
- 2:21:31especially Cernicek and Williams and Peter Woffendale but in
- 2:21:38the accelerationist
- 2:21:39SPEAKER_00: manifesto they write
- 2:21:43SPEAKER_00: Landian neoliberalism confuses speed with acceleration.
- 2:21:48SPEAKER_00: We may be moving fast,
- 2:21:50but only within a strictly defined set of capitalist parameters
- 2:21:54that themselves
- 2:21:55SPEAKER_00: never waver.
- 2:21:56SPEAKER_00: We experience only the increasing speed of a local horizon,
- 2:22:01SPEAKER_00: a simple brain-dead onrush,
- 2:22:04SPEAKER_00: rather than an acceleration which is also navigational.
- 2:22:09SPEAKER_00: Yep.
- 2:22:10An experimental process of discovery within a universal space
- 2:22:15of possibility.
- 2:22:16SPEAKER_00: It is the latter mode of acceleration which we hold as essential.
- 2:22:21SPEAKER_00: So I just wanted to highlight what you were saying,
- 2:22:23SPEAKER_00: like the accelerationists themselves are aware of this antagonism within
- 2:22:30SPEAKER_00: accelerationism,
- 2:22:31SPEAKER_00: which is,
- 2:22:32SPEAKER_00: can we intervene?
- 2:22:33SPEAKER_00: Can we steer it?
- 2:22:35SPEAKER_00: Can we navigate it?
- 2:22:37Or Is It Completely Out Of Our Hands Land Says It's Hubris It's
- 2:22:43Human Vanity It's
- 2:22:44Idealistic Illusion To Think That We Can Control This Thing
- 2:22:49Turn A Check And
- 2:22:49Williams Would Say No It's Not We Can Intervene And We Can
- 2:22:55Steer This Process
- 2:22:57SPEAKER_00: Through A New Form Of Politics So
- 2:23:02I just wanted to say like what you were talking about there is
- 2:23:05really kind of
- 2:23:06explicitly at the heart of accelerationism the other thing is
- 2:23:12just look I've been
- 2:23:14going back for a secret project to all of this unreleased
- 2:23:21footage we have with Nick
- 2:23:24SPEAKER_00: and there's a point in it where today I came across this and
- 2:23:32I'm going to reword it because he has a more simple formulation
- 2:23:36of this but Nick
- 2:23:37essentially says the robotic machinic substitution and
- 2:23:43replacement of human labor
- 2:23:45spurred on by industrial competition and capital accumulation
- 2:23:51is already the Turing
- 2:23:53SPEAKER_00: test.
- 2:23:55SPEAKER_00: And I think this kind of brings us back to where we started,
- 2:23:58SPEAKER_00: which is the nature of intelligence.
- 2:24:01SPEAKER_00: Land's fundamental thesis is capitalism is artificial intelligence.
- 2:24:06SPEAKER_00: Sounds cool.
- 2:24:08SPEAKER_00: I think in part I've helped make it kind of his slogan,
- 2:24:12SPEAKER_00: but it's easy to hear it and go,
- 2:24:15SPEAKER_00: oh,
- 2:24:15SPEAKER_00: that sounds cool or that sounds dumb,
- 2:24:18SPEAKER_00: however you want to take it,
- 2:24:20SPEAKER_00: without understanding the nuance of it.
- 2:24:22SPEAKER_00: It's like, why does he say that?
- 2:24:24SPEAKER_00: For him,
- 2:24:26Industrial Competition and Capital Accumulation truly spur on
- 2:24:33from a structural
- 2:24:34SPEAKER_00: dynamic the refinement of the means of production.
- 2:24:40SPEAKER_00: You're trying to out-compete your competitors if you're a capitalist.
- 2:24:44SPEAKER_00: The way to do that is to make production more efficient, right?
- 2:24:48SPEAKER_00: Cut costs.
- 2:24:50SPEAKER_00: How do you do that?
- 2:24:50SPEAKER_00: You do that by investing in new machines.
- 2:24:52SPEAKER_00: So there's a market just to make
- 2:24:55SPEAKER_00: more efficient machines to serve as the means of production.
- 2:25:01And this structural dynamic of competition and accumulation
- 2:25:07really does seem to be
- 2:25:10geared toward the robotic machinic replacement or substitution
- 2:25:14of human labor.
- 2:25:17SPEAKER_00: And I mean,
- 2:25:18I think the way Nick said it like straightforward is labor
- 2:25:21substitution is the
- 2:25:22SPEAKER_00: Turing test.
- 2:25:24SPEAKER_00: And so
- 2:25:26SPEAKER_00: What's the Turing Test?
- 2:25:27The Turing Test is a thought experiment proposed by
- 2:25:29mathematician Alan Turing in
- 2:25:311950 to evaluate a machine's ability to exhibit intelligent
- 2:25:37behavior equivalent to
- 2:25:39SPEAKER_00: or indistinguishable from that of the human.
- 2:25:42SPEAKER_00: So,
- 2:25:44Does the Jacquard Loom,
- 2:25:47for example,
- 2:25:47this is Nick's favorite example,
- 2:25:49right?
- 2:25:50SPEAKER_00: The Jacquard Loom has,
- 2:25:53you could say it has more intelligence than 400 human laborers
- 2:25:57in the sense that
- 2:25:58its ability to perform a function is so much faster and more
- 2:26:02efficient than what it
- 2:26:04SPEAKER_00: would take human laborers to do to perform that task
- 2:26:09the idea is the greater the efficiency at performing a task the
- 2:26:13greater the
- 2:26:14intelligence so I kind of just wanted to bring it back around
- 2:26:18to like this is Nick
- 2:26:19where he is kind of sound and functionalist despite this whole
- 2:26:24other critique of
- 2:26:25SPEAKER_00: orthogonality and yeah like what do you think of capitalism is artificial
- 2:26:33SPEAKER_00: intelligence what do you think of the type of
- 2:26:38Technological development of the means of production spurred on
- 2:26:42by capitalist
- 2:26:43SPEAKER_00: dynamics is a Turing test of sorts.
- 2:26:46SPEAKER_00: What do you think of this?
- 2:26:48SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 2:26:49SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 2:26:49I've been inclined to say in the past that states or
- 2:26:53corporations are a kind of
- 2:26:55artificial intelligence for similar kinds of reasons that they
- 2:27:00give you a purpose
- 2:27:03SPEAKER_03: and then they have mechanisms for
- 2:27:06SPEAKER_03: for achieving that purpose that are baked into their procedural scheme.
- 2:27:11So the thing about capital is that capital doesn't necessarily
- 2:27:18specify mechanisms
- 2:27:19SPEAKER_03: so much in the way that,
- 2:27:22SPEAKER_03: say,
- 2:27:22SPEAKER_03: a corporation or a state does.
- 2:27:26SPEAKER_03: But we could say nonetheless that in a more abstract way,
- 2:27:29SPEAKER_03: it achieves similar kinds of effects without that level of specification.
- 2:27:35SPEAKER_01: So at a more abstract level, it functions as artificial intelligence.
- 2:27:42SPEAKER_03: How does it realize this?
- 2:27:44It realizes this in part by incentivizing the creation of
- 2:27:48things like corporate persons.
- 2:27:51So it calls into existence these corporate entities which then
- 2:27:55have a more specific
- 2:27:56SPEAKER_03: concrete structure which is adapted to achieve the end.
- 2:28:01And I think that's something that probably Nick would agree
- 2:28:03with since he thinks of
- 2:28:05SPEAKER_03: the corporation as the efficient appropriate mechanism for doing this.
- 2:28:10So there would then be a pretty tight hand-in-glove fit between
- 2:28:13those two ideas.
- 2:28:16SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I mean...
- 2:28:19SPEAKER_00: Look,
- 2:28:19SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:28:19SPEAKER_00: I guess,
- 2:28:20SPEAKER_00: so this mechanism,
- 2:28:21SPEAKER_00: okay,
- 2:28:22SPEAKER_00: so I'm a capitalist,
- 2:28:23SPEAKER_00: I have,
- 2:28:26SPEAKER_00: I run a company that manufactures chairs,
- 2:28:30SPEAKER_00: and so I'm in the chair market,
- 2:28:33SPEAKER_00: and I'm trying to outcompete the other capitalists,
- 2:28:35SPEAKER_00: I want the biggest share of the market,
- 2:28:37SPEAKER_00: I want to make the most money,
- 2:28:39SPEAKER_00: and so...
- 2:28:41SPEAKER_00: I have a couple options.
- 2:28:43SPEAKER_00: I could just raise the prices of the chairs I sell.
- 2:28:46SPEAKER_00: Problem is, people won't buy them because they're overpriced, right?
- 2:28:54SPEAKER_00: I could cut the wages of my workers,
- 2:28:58SPEAKER_00: but if they can go get paid more somewhere else,
- 2:29:03SPEAKER_00: then I'm going to lose them entirely,
- 2:29:05SPEAKER_00: and that's going to undermine the
- 2:29:08my my end my goal so how do I do it well based on the
- 2:29:15structural and I would say
- 2:29:17the structural mechanism of this market dynamic uh maybe I'm
- 2:29:23stretching the word
- 2:29:23but maybe it's we could call it an algorithm loosely uh
- 2:29:28absolutely absolutely yeah
- 2:29:30SPEAKER_00: like I have to intake take
- 2:29:35Surplus Value I Have to Take That Invest It Into New Machinery
- 2:29:39So I Can Cut Costs
- 2:29:41On My Production Which Gives Me The Upper Hand When It Comes To
- 2:29:45Surplus Value
- 2:29:47SPEAKER_00: or capital accumulation over my competitors.
- 2:29:50SPEAKER_00: Now,
- 2:29:50SPEAKER_00: of course,
- 2:29:50they're going to find out what new technology I invested in and
- 2:29:53they're going to
- 2:29:54SPEAKER_00: get it.
- 2:29:54SPEAKER_00: So it's back to square one.
- 2:29:55SPEAKER_00: But then somebody else is going to have to invest in new technology.
- 2:29:58So I'm just saying this seems like like this type of virtual
- 2:30:02mechanism you're
- 2:30:03SPEAKER_00: talking about in relation to the state,
- 2:30:05SPEAKER_00: just an economic one.
- 2:30:08SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:30:09And of course,
- 2:30:09the key thing there is that you have to not be able to move.
- 2:30:14SPEAKER_03: for that to fully apply to you.
- 2:30:16SPEAKER_03: Because once you can move,
- 2:30:18then you can get cheaper laborers if you can move to a place
- 2:30:22where labor is
- 2:30:22SPEAKER_03: cheaper.
- 2:30:22SPEAKER_00: Capital can escape, so to speak.
- 2:30:24SPEAKER_03: Right, right.
- 2:30:26So it functions differently in a case where you have an
- 2:30:31inability to move.
- 2:30:33SPEAKER_00: You go to the third world.
- 2:30:35SPEAKER_01: Right, right.
- 2:30:36So this is why I think that there's not necessarily a
- 2:30:41completely tight fit there because
- 2:30:45One of the things capital does is it doesn't care how it
- 2:30:49increases its return.
- 2:30:50Whether it can increase its return by relocating or increase
- 2:30:54its return by
- 2:30:54SPEAKER_03: automating production doesn't matter to it.
- 2:31:00SPEAKER_01: It's whatever's easier.
- 2:31:02This is where we're getting at the plasticity of capitalist
- 2:31:05axiomatics where it just...
- 2:31:12The only thing that stays fixed is MCM Prime or the pursuit of
- 2:31:18M Prime like that's
- 2:31:19kind of this anchoring point whatever it has to do to do that
- 2:31:25you know up for
- 2:31:26SPEAKER_00: revision
- 2:31:27Yeah,
- 2:31:28I think that serves as this hypervisor,
- 2:31:31this,
- 2:31:35I don't know,
- 2:31:35a super compound something.
- 2:31:40SPEAKER_02: Because I think when thinking in this way,
- 2:31:44SPEAKER_02: Nick is not saying American capitalism or Chinese capitalism or European
- 2:31:48SPEAKER_02: capitalism.
- 2:31:49SPEAKER_02: He is taking capitalism globally and
- 2:31:55SPEAKER_02: And hyperstitionally kind of positing the end result.
- 2:32:00So he sees the end result of capitalism being the escape of
- 2:32:04capital in the form of
- 2:32:05artificial intelligence that would represent the metabolized
- 2:32:11output of Earth's
- 2:32:13SPEAKER_02: economy.
- 2:32:14SPEAKER_02: So it's very Bataillon in this way.
- 2:32:16SPEAKER_02: And it's also, again, he's thinking teleologically.
- 2:32:20SPEAKER_02: So he assumes...
- 2:32:22the end result and so in this way I yeah capital it's yeah M
- 2:32:33prime or even C prime
- 2:32:34like Nick's view is you know MCM prime also equals C prime
- 2:32:39which is the will to
- 2:32:40think which is the self optimization paradigm escalation of
- 2:32:43robotic capacity yeah
- 2:32:45SPEAKER_02: which we see in the the amassing of constant capital in favor of
- 2:32:51C-prime is surplus capability C-prime is surplus capability
- 2:32:56C-prime is surplus
- 2:32:57capability C-prime is surplus capability C-prime is surplus
- 2:33:00capability in the
- 2:33:02SPEAKER_02: context of being
- 2:33:21Applied Like there's always a telos in this thought and you
- 2:33:26can't while you can go
- 2:33:28from United States to India or Malaysia or wherever you can't
- 2:33:36leave Earth.
- 2:33:36And so like like I think Nick is always making this argument
- 2:33:39from this perspective
- 2:33:40SPEAKER_02: of global capital as opposed to our human perspective.
- 2:33:47SPEAKER_01: Yes,
- 2:33:48but even then it requires a certain amount of leveling to occur
- 2:33:51at the level of the
- 2:33:52SPEAKER_03: planet.
- 2:33:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:33:54SPEAKER_03: So there actually is this incentive to technologically innovate,
- 2:33:57SPEAKER_03: which is one of the reasons why neoliberals have tended to say,
- 2:34:00SPEAKER_03: hey,
- 2:34:00SPEAKER_03: isn't it great that global inequality is reduced?
- 2:34:04Sure is great.
- 2:34:12we cannot leave Benjamin you've talked so much about the master
- 2:34:17slave dynamic what
- 2:34:19do you think of Hegel's treatment of lordship and bondage in
- 2:34:25phenomenology of
- 2:34:25spirit in which he argues that the and Kojev says this the
- 2:34:32position of the master
- 2:34:34SPEAKER_00: is an existential impasse it's a dead end it's a cul-de-sac uh
- 2:34:40Hegel's not talking in terms of intelligence per se but he
- 2:34:44would definitely say
- 2:34:45that the development of self-consciousness into spirit the
- 2:34:50whole thing goes through
- 2:34:53the slave that the master's a dead end and it stalls out and
- 2:34:59it's through this
- 2:35:00friction between the two and the position that the slave gets
- 2:35:04in that the dialectic
- 2:35:05SPEAKER_00: continues so I just I gotta ask what you think of that
- 2:35:10Yeah,
- 2:35:10I've always thought that that was quite an internal critique to
- 2:35:13Aristotelianism.
- 2:35:15SPEAKER_03: So it was a way of trying to develop Aristotle's concepts rather than a
- 2:35:20SPEAKER_01: straightforward description of how slavery functions in antiquity.
- 2:35:28SPEAKER_00: So your point is not a historical argument, it's a formal argument.
- 2:35:31SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 2:35:32it's a formal argument and it also involves attaching to
- 2:35:36Aristotle's slaves and
- 2:35:37masters characteristics that Aristotle himself doesn't attach
- 2:35:42because Aristotle
- 2:35:43SPEAKER_03: doesn't claim that slaves are or aren't conscious.
- 2:35:47SPEAKER_03: He just claims that they can't choose ends.
- 2:35:55There's a lot of room for what that might actually cash out in
- 2:35:59in various modern categories.
- 2:36:01SPEAKER_03: The subject-object distinction is a much later distinction.
- 2:36:07SPEAKER_03: It's not one that you will find eminently in Plato or Aristotle.
- 2:36:15You don't even get something like what we would think of in
- 2:36:17modernity as the will
- 2:36:18SPEAKER_03: until the Stoics,
- 2:36:19SPEAKER_03: really.
- 2:36:20Yeah So there's then an attempt and this is an attempt that
- 2:36:23begins in late
- 2:36:24antiquity because you know even by late antiquity they're
- 2:36:26trying to do this of
- 2:36:28SPEAKER_03: reading back into Aristotle and Plato some of the concepts that come from
- 2:36:31Hellenistic philosophy so you know one of the things I tend to
- 2:36:36try to point out to
- 2:36:37people is that whenever you start talking about subject and
- 2:36:40object in relation to
- 2:36:41Aristotle or Plato there is a kind of presentism going on there
- 2:36:45just foreign
- 2:36:46SPEAKER_03: concepts being imported into the scheme That's really good
- 2:36:49That just aren't really there for them The point is whether
- 2:36:54we're talking about
- 2:36:55human beings or whether we're talking about rocks or whether
- 2:36:58we're talking about
- 2:36:58trees or whether we're talking about horses they are all
- 2:37:01substances so that would
- 2:37:04imply that there's not some sharp ontological distinction
- 2:37:10between us and other
- 2:37:12SPEAKER_00: beings
- 2:37:14SPEAKER_03: Right, and something's telos is what it's for, what its purpose is.
- 2:37:19SPEAKER_03: Man can choose a purpose.
- 2:37:22SPEAKER_03: Man is able to make a decision about what the purpose is,
- 2:37:27but other kinds of things have a purpose given by nature and
- 2:37:31then operate in
- 2:37:33SPEAKER_01: conformity with that.
- 2:37:36SPEAKER_01: In the Platonic schema,
- 2:37:40You'd be even more hard pressed to try to talk about this
- 2:37:43meaningfully in relation to that.
- 2:37:46Because in Platonism,
- 2:37:47you've got emanation rather than hard category separation.
- 2:37:56SPEAKER_03: That's how I tend to react to the Hegel thing.
- 2:37:59I think it's a way of playing or riffing with Aristotle's
- 2:38:02scheme in a modern context.
- 2:38:04Nietzsche also plays and riffs with Aristotle's scheme in a
- 2:38:07modern context.
- 2:38:08SPEAKER_03: So does Arendt.
- 2:38:09SPEAKER_03: There's a lot of different ways of taking up the Aristotelianism,
- 2:38:13SPEAKER_03: but putting it into modern terminology.
- 2:38:17which then allows it to perform different functions but also
- 2:38:20obscures certain
- 2:38:21SPEAKER_03: elements of Aristotelianism.
- 2:38:24SPEAKER_03: Even Thomas Aquinas can be said to be doing this.
- 2:38:27Even medieval take-ups of Aristotle involve adding a lot of
- 2:38:31Stoicism and other
- 2:38:32SPEAKER_03: kinds of things into it that aren't there in the original text.
- 2:38:38Even something like Perception you sit there and go which of
- 2:38:42the empiricists does
- 2:38:43he actually have in mind is it Locke is it Hume Barkley and he
- 2:38:49it's not really any
- 2:38:50SPEAKER_00: of them it's a kind of like general
- 2:38:54Empirical Theory of Perception but you can you know it's
- 2:38:57inspired by them you know
- 2:38:59they're operating in the background on some level but it's not
- 2:39:02about any of them in
- 2:39:04particular and so I think you're right like the master slave
- 2:39:07thing obviously he he
- 2:39:09SPEAKER_00: knew Aristotle but is it specifically here I yeah
- 2:39:14SPEAKER_03: Yeah, because Plato doesn't draw that kind of sharp distinction.
- 2:39:18SPEAKER_03: And in most other ancient theories,
- 2:39:21SPEAKER_03: it's not treated with anything like that kind of specificity or depth.
- 2:39:26SPEAKER_03: Part of the reason why a lot of moderns,
- 2:39:28SPEAKER_03: when they talk about the ancients,
- 2:39:30SPEAKER_03: are talking about Aristotle,
- 2:39:31SPEAKER_03: is the degree to which the church,
- 2:39:33SPEAKER_03: in taking up Aquinas,
- 2:39:35SPEAKER_03: takes up a Christianized version of Aristotle as its thing.
- 2:39:39SPEAKER_03: So then there's being in dialogue with the church,
- 2:39:41SPEAKER_03: being in dialogue with the ancient regime,
- 2:39:44SPEAKER_03: which is taken to be associated with the church,
- 2:39:47and therefore oftentimes Aristotle becomes the person that gets
- 2:39:52the focus.
- 2:39:54not always Marx for instance wrote a lot about Democritus there
- 2:39:59are engagements
- 2:40:00with other ancient philosophers Hegel talks about Plato too at
- 2:40:03various points but
- 2:40:04there's a heavy emphasis on Aristotelian concepts in part
- 2:40:08because there's so much
- 2:40:09of Aristotle that's still in the regular lingo of the church
- 2:40:13like if you read the
- 2:40:15did you guys I wanted to ask you guys this if you saw the
- 2:40:17Pope's encyclical on AI
- 2:40:20SPEAKER_03: yet and if you had a chance to read it
- 2:40:23SPEAKER_03: You know,
- 2:40:23there's still so much kind of Aristotelian language that still
- 2:40:27sits in that at
- 2:40:28SPEAKER_03: various places.
- 2:40:30SPEAKER_00: Is that because of Aquinas?
- 2:40:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:40:33SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:40:34SPEAKER_00: Yeah, of course.
- 2:40:35SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:40:36SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 2:40:36it's still like I know that the Catholic Church has had all
- 2:40:39these different
- 2:40:39SPEAKER_00: theologians,
- 2:40:40SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 2:40:41SPEAKER_00: but it really still it's all footnotes to Aquinas.
- 2:40:46SPEAKER_00: It's Aristotle and Aquinas still.
- 2:40:50And there is other stuff in the Catholic tradition that they,
- 2:40:53in principle,
- 2:40:54have access to.
- 2:40:55SPEAKER_03: There's a bit where Raymond Goist says that,
- 2:40:57SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 2:40:57SPEAKER_03: for the Catholic tradition to become interesting again,
- 2:41:01SPEAKER_03: it has to get over Thomas Aquinas,
- 2:41:05SPEAKER_03: which it could potentially do from his point of view,
- 2:41:07SPEAKER_03: because there is other stuff that's there.
- 2:41:10SPEAKER_00: Do you think it could do that?
- 2:41:11SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 2:41:12SPEAKER_00: Like...
- 2:41:14SPEAKER_03: Well,
- 2:41:15SPEAKER_03: it's old,
- 2:41:17SPEAKER_03: and it's been around for a long time,
- 2:41:18SPEAKER_03: and part of how it has survived is by changing a lot.
- 2:41:22SPEAKER_03: All the religions that are still around have survived by changing a lot,
- 2:41:27to the point where some people would make the case that since
- 2:41:30Vatican II at least,
- 2:41:31SPEAKER_03: and maybe even earlier,
- 2:41:32SPEAKER_03: maybe Rerum Novarum,
- 2:41:34the Catholic Church has been so out of alignment with the
- 2:41:39Thomistic picture of what
- 2:41:40SPEAKER_03: the polity is.
- 2:41:41SPEAKER_00: With the Catholic Church?
- 2:41:42Yeah yeah because the Thomistic picture of all of this stuff is
- 2:41:48still predicated on
- 2:41:49the idea that the state is a political entity not a corporate
- 2:41:54person not an
- 2:41:56impersonal agent I got one more thing I want to ask unless you
- 2:42:04got something
- 2:42:04relevant to this No I was just going to make some some smart
- 2:42:09ass remark about Pope
- 2:42:10SPEAKER_02: Leo
- 2:42:16with our focus on AI we should maybe read some of or discuss
- 2:42:21some of the Pope thing
- 2:42:23yeah I want to you guys definitely should you know his approval
- 2:42:29rating right now
- 2:42:29he's the highest approved public figure in the United States
- 2:42:33yeah and he's got like
- 2:42:34a plus 30 net rating which makes him incredibly popular by the
- 2:42:38standards of 2026
- 2:42:39SPEAKER_03: like ridiculously popular
- 2:42:41Didn't Trump like crash out over what the Pope said something
- 2:42:45did I what did I miss
- 2:42:46I saw something like Trump was pissed at him well he he was
- 2:42:51that when he was saying
- 2:42:52God what did he say like you should be might stay in your lane
- 2:42:56essentially I think
- 2:42:58he was like or did Trump say I think said that he should be
- 2:43:02really careful when he
- 2:43:03SPEAKER_03: talks about theology which is an odd thing for Vance as a Catholic to say
- 2:43:09after he uh and that's an understatement on your part Benjamin
- 2:43:13like that is after
- 2:43:15he killed the old Pope with shut up with Russian poison talk
- 2:43:20about that fucking JD
- 2:43:23Vance okay so hold on I guess the one last thing I was thinking
- 2:43:30about throughout
- 2:43:30SPEAKER_00: the course of the conversation is isn't it odd that
- 2:43:35I mean maybe not at all when you actually think about it but in
- 2:43:39the occult
- 2:43:40SPEAKER_00: tradition they have a definition of magic
- 2:43:45And there's little slight variations on it I'm going to go off
- 2:43:50of Aleister
- 2:43:50Crowley's And I might slightly be paraphrasing But Dion Fortune
- 2:43:54has the same thing
- 2:43:56And it's similar But it's roughly something like this Magic is
- 2:44:01the science and art
- 2:44:03SPEAKER_00: Of causing change to occur In conformity with the will
- 2:44:10SPEAKER_00: Couldn't we just easily,
- 2:44:11technology is the science and art of causing change to occur in
- 2:44:16conformity with
- 2:44:17SPEAKER_00: will.
- 2:44:17It's interesting that,
- 2:44:21you know,
- 2:44:21you mentioned magic earlier,
- 2:44:23Benjamin,
- 2:44:24that
- 2:44:26is technology just modern magic like and we don't get it
- 2:44:31because we think magic is
- 2:44:32like oh pulling something out of thin air which of course you
- 2:44:37know the occultists
- 2:44:39that we talk to whether it's Nick or whether it's John Michael
- 2:44:42Greer we just had a
- 2:44:43conversation with John's always going out of his way to stress
- 2:44:46that this is not
- 2:44:47SPEAKER_00: what magic is should we maybe at some point
- 2:44:55Consider technology as magic and that the magical tradition the
- 2:45:01occult tradition
- 2:45:02can actually tell us something about what our technologies are
- 2:45:06doing I would be
- 2:45:09inclined to want to flip it and say that magic and modernity is
- 2:45:14a way of talking
- 2:45:15SPEAKER_03: about technology and that magic as it was understood by ancient people is
- 2:45:20SPEAKER_03: incredibly obscure to us now and very difficult to enter into
- 2:45:25In part because it often involved thinking without the
- 2:45:27subject-object distinction.
- 2:45:29SPEAKER_03: Yep.
- 2:45:30SPEAKER_03: Right?
- 2:45:31SPEAKER_01: Like magic in antiquity is you think it and it becomes.
- 2:45:34SPEAKER_01: You know, there's a kind of...
- 2:45:40And also there's magic brushes up against other categories like
- 2:45:44sorcery and theurgy.
- 2:45:47And then there's the possibility of the mystery ritual,
- 2:45:51which is that magic?
- 2:45:53SPEAKER_03: Or is that something you can talk about as a philosophical activity?
- 2:46:00SPEAKER_03: A lot of magic is about transforming the people who are in the ritual.
- 2:46:05So the aim of the magic is actually to change the drives of the
- 2:46:08people in the room.
- 2:46:12SPEAKER_03: And the magic works on the basis,
- 2:46:15SPEAKER_03: not that it is in accordance with their will,
- 2:46:17SPEAKER_03: but in the sense that it transforms what they want.
- 2:46:21So the magic works precisely because it seems to be against
- 2:46:26what they want even sometimes.
- 2:46:28SPEAKER_03: It so radically alters your drugs.
- 2:46:33SPEAKER_03: When we talk about drugs, that's sometimes a little bit closer to magic.
- 2:46:37SPEAKER_00: The chaos magicians emphasize that a lot.
- 2:46:40Yeah,
- 2:46:41but drugs tend to get scientized now and talked about like
- 2:46:44they're a technology.
- 2:46:45SPEAKER_03: Yes, you go into the drug experience with a particular aim.
- 2:46:52or because you've read books about what it's going to do to you
- 2:46:54and there's it's
- 2:46:56not like going into the Greek mystery ritual and you know
- 2:46:59getting the hallucinogens
- 2:47:00in some fashion and well yeah can anybody take DMT at this
- 2:47:05point I guess if you
- 2:47:06SPEAKER_00: hadn't read them but or heard about Terence McKenna but most people
- 2:47:11who take DMT are approaching it through Terence McKenna's,
- 2:47:16you know,
- 2:47:16author.
- 2:47:17SPEAKER_03: I guess,
- 2:47:17SPEAKER_03: look,
- 2:47:18SPEAKER_03: to go back...
- 2:47:18SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 2:47:18SPEAKER_03: it's not a mystery ritual,
- 2:47:19SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 2:47:19SPEAKER_03: where they actually keep from you what is the nature of the experience,
- 2:47:23SPEAKER_03: what part of the experience has the effect.
- 2:47:25SPEAKER_03: In a real mystery ritual,
- 2:47:26you don't even necessarily know where the drug is coming from
- 2:47:30or what part of it is
- 2:47:31SPEAKER_03: drugged.
- 2:47:33So anybody who takes DMT it's like okay I'm gonna do it time to
- 2:47:36see the machine
- 2:47:37elves I hope they're as fun as everybody says they pop on a Joe
- 2:47:41Rogan episode and
- 2:47:42you know they pay their culturally appropriated fucking shaman
- 2:47:47white guy named
- 2:47:47Derek with dreadlocks and a patchouli oil to fucking come broom
- 2:47:51up some ayahuasca
- 2:47:53SPEAKER_00: but okay but instead of saying technology is magic
- 2:48:01more interesting to say magic is technology yeah now whenever
- 2:48:07anybody introduces a
- 2:48:08fantasy world magic plays the role that technology plays in our
- 2:48:11society and there's
- 2:48:12all these demands that you have to have a whole worked out
- 2:48:15magic system because if
- 2:48:16you don't then there's something unrealistic about your magic
- 2:48:19system you know oh
- 2:48:23SPEAKER_02: man Brandon Sanderson has entered the chat
- 2:48:32and it allows you to frame Harry Potter is about you know
- 2:48:35technocracy yeah have you
- 2:48:43SPEAKER_01: ever read Jonathan Strange and Mr.
- 2:48:44Norrell I have not it's a good book it's a long book it's a
- 2:48:50it's a fantasy uh
- 2:48:52SPEAKER_02: Victorian uh
- 2:48:56I don't know it probably came out maybe 15 years ago but it's
- 2:49:01good it's very good
- 2:49:02it's a contemporary fantasy book that I actually think is a
- 2:49:05pretty damn good book
- 2:49:08Learning Magic is like going to college Harry was chosen to go
- 2:49:13to college now he's
- 2:49:17SPEAKER_03: been lifted out of the working class
- 2:49:19yeah in the working class you have to live in your parents you
- 2:49:22know tiny basement
- 2:49:23you have no hope and no opportunity but Harry has been you're a
- 2:49:25wizard Harry you
- 2:49:26get to go to college you're a wizard but beware of Voldemort
- 2:49:31the person who
- 2:49:31believes that only the people who go to college should be in
- 2:49:34charge yes oh man you
- 2:49:41know what I want to go to college when's the sorting hat gonna
- 2:49:43choose me yeah
- 2:49:46Benjamin not like so I love you know these episodes of the lack
- 2:49:51that you do at Nina
- 2:49:52where you guys review films I love them I listen to them any
- 2:49:56chance I have sometime
- 2:49:58we want you to review a film with us you know we there's all
- 2:50:04kinds of options but I
- 2:50:05was like yeah we got to at least do one of those with Benjamin
- 2:50:09we talk about a
- 2:50:09SPEAKER_00: movie or maybe a couple
- 2:50:12SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I'm down.
- 2:50:13SPEAKER_03: I usually write up a little something at the start.
- 2:50:15SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:50:17SPEAKER_03: Happy to do that if you want the lack experience.
- 2:50:20SPEAKER_02: That'd be cool.
- 2:50:23SPEAKER_02: Well, and on that note, we'll ski daddle.
- 2:50:26SPEAKER_02: I think for me,
- 2:50:31talking about choosing one's ends is an excellent way of kind
- 2:50:39of maybe distilling
- 2:50:41This conversation And finding a way to Point to What's
- 2:50:47different between Human
- 2:50:49intelligence And machine Intelligence I think it's excellent I
- 2:50:55think it cuts
- 2:50:56SPEAKER_02: through a lot of Um
- 2:50:59Hemming and hawing and obfuscation maybe and a lot of
- 2:51:03unnecessary lingo and it just
- 2:51:07SPEAKER_02: shows the real difference.
- 2:51:08I think it's very easy to forget especially in the world we
- 2:51:13live in today where
- 2:51:16it's all about just increasing efficiency and more and more
- 2:51:19return and everything's
- 2:51:20a zero-sum game and we're locked in unending competition with
- 2:51:26one another for no
- 2:51:27SPEAKER_02: apparent reason and everybody
- 2:51:29SPEAKER_02: seems to be upset about it.
- 2:51:32SPEAKER_02: Everybody seems to question it,
- 2:51:34but everybody is helpless or seems to be helpless to be able to
- 2:51:38do anything about
- 2:51:38SPEAKER_02: it.
- 2:51:39SPEAKER_02: Um...
- 2:51:41SPEAKER_02: And we get locked into these machinic shapes, these machinic functions.
- 2:51:47SPEAKER_02: You have no choice but to do as you're told.
- 2:51:49SPEAKER_02: You have no choice but to do as the market demands,
- 2:51:53SPEAKER_02: as your employer demands,
- 2:51:55as your mortgage or your rent or your insurance bill or
- 2:51:59whatever and on and on and
- 2:52:00SPEAKER_02: on and on and on.
- 2:52:02SPEAKER_02: And yeah, talking about the freedom to choose one ends.
- 2:52:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:52:08is a great way to elucidate the fact that none of us can choose
- 2:52:12our own ends anymore.
- 2:52:15If that's the mark of humanity,
- 2:52:17humanity is something that we hope exists in the future.
- 2:52:21SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:52:22We have to,
- 2:52:23just like they resurrected dire wolves,
- 2:52:27we must resurrect humankind.
- 2:52:30SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:52:33Benjamin I appreciate you coming and having a chat I hope we
- 2:52:37get to do it again
- 2:52:38soon everybody out there in TV land go to Amazon or go to was
- 2:52:47it Edinburgh Press
- 2:52:48University dot com whatever it is buy the paperback now or
- 2:52:54actually buy the
- 2:52:55SPEAKER_02: hardcover too if you have cash but yeah
- 2:52:59Legitimacy in Liberal Democracies paperback is now available if
- 2:53:03you have yet to
- 2:53:03read it or if you have already read it and you would like to
- 2:53:06pick up a new copy
- 2:53:07because you're sick of reading PDFs you can do so now so yeah
- 2:53:16thanks for coming on
- 2:53:17SPEAKER_02: Benjamin any parting words
- 2:53:20SPEAKER_03: Thanks so much for having me.
- 2:53:22It's always so much fun talking to you guys because you always
- 2:53:24come up with really
- 2:53:26SPEAKER_03: great questions and ways to take it.
- 2:53:28It always ends up going somewhere interesting and never
- 2:53:31something I can prefigure
- 2:53:33SPEAKER_03: from advance and from before,
- 2:53:36SPEAKER_03: like a machine might try to do.
- 2:53:40SPEAKER_00: Closing, closing, not statement, but demand.
- 2:53:45using uh your term Benjamin that you said before we started
- 2:53:48recording uh I demand
- 2:53:51that Newport Nance makes another appearance at some point in
- 2:53:55the future yep yeah I
- 2:54:00gotta get guys have you ever seen Nance look so suave with this
- 2:54:03shirt on come on
- 2:54:08SPEAKER_00: where's Nance we got we got Newport Nance Newport Nance
- 2:54:16alright ladies gentlemen non-specifieds peanut gallery friends
- 2:54:23foes comrades lemurs
- 2:54:27all of the above lemurs demonic entities all of that thanks for
- 2:54:32hanging out and
- 2:54:32SPEAKER_02: spending time with us we will catch you on the next one
- 2:54:45SPEAKER_02: Nanceee Three Billion Nances
- 2:55:12SPEAKER_03: I said it before and I'll say it again.
- 2:55:14SPEAKER_03: Life is pretty bad.
- 2:55:15SPEAKER_03: If you don't stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.
- 2:55:19SPEAKER_02: It's that you don't have to laugh with these two color toggles.
- 2:55:22SPEAKER_02: That's it.
- 2:55:22SPEAKER_02: In other words, it's not enough to do things that are going to be a hit.
- 2:55:25SPEAKER_02: I'm going to play with that person about the brain.