Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Warren Buffett's Empire Free Money Machine Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're going to try and get
- 0:04to the heart of a real legend. We're talk about Warren Buffett
- 0:07and Berkshire Hathaway, and our mission here is to cut through
- 0:11some of the noise because I think for a lot of people, the
- 0:13thinking is, you know, pretty simple.
- 0:16You buy Berkshire stock because it's safe.
- 0:19It's run by a genius investor. It's almost like a an index fund
- 0:24but better. A God of investing fund?
- 0:26Yeah, that's the myth and it's just not the full picture.
- 0:29Not at all. And if you really dig into the
- 0:30sources, you find that viewing Berkshire is just this giant
- 0:34pile of stocks, well, you're missing the whole machine.
- 0:37You're missing everything that makes it work.
- 0:39It's not a fund, it's it's a business empire.
- 0:42I mean, a better term might be a money printing conglomerate.
- 0:45It's a system. A system.
- 0:47I like that. So the real secret weapon we
- 0:49want to unpack for you today isn't just about picking great
- 0:52stocks. It's about the art of capital
- 0:53allocation. Exactly how do you build a
- 0:57machine that gives you billions of dollars at almost no cost?
- 1:01And then how do you move that money around perfectly?
- 1:04That's the deep dive and to get it we have to start with the
- 1:07fuel for the engine. We have to talk about float.
- 1:10Mm hmm, it all starts with float.
- 1:11Let's use an analogy from the source material to make this
- 1:13really clear. Imagine you open a pizza shop.
- 1:17OK, but it's a weird pizza shop. The rule is customers pay you
- 1:21today, right now, for a pizza you won't deliver for another
- 1:25year. So I get the cash upfront.
- 1:27All of it. And for that whole year, you're
- 1:29just sitting on their money. You haven't bought the dough,
- 1:32the cheese, nothing. I can put it in the bank, I can
- 1:35buy some bonds. You can even use it to build a
- 1:37second pizza shop and as long as you make good on that pizza next
- 1:40year, that money was completely free for you to use.
- 1:43That's. Float and that analogy, well, it
- 1:46perfectly captures the idea. But the scale at Berkshire is
- 1:50just staggering. So connect it for us.
- 1:52What's the pizza shop inside Berkshire Hathaway?
- 1:55The pizza shop is its massive insurance business.
- 1:58We're talking about giants like GEICO, General Re.
- 2:02Think about it. We pay our insurance premiums
- 2:04today, but when does the claim happen?
- 2:07An accident? A catastrophe it could be years
- 2:11from now. Or even decades, I suppose, for
- 2:13some really complex stuff. Exactly.
- 2:15And that gap, that's the float. It puts hundreds of billions of
- 2:19dollars of cash directly into Buffett's hands before he owes a
- 2:23single cent. And this is the part that I
- 2:25think is so crucial. If we wanted to borrow, say,
- 2:28$100 million to invest, we'd go to a bank.
- 2:31And you'd pay interest 5 percent, 7%, maybe more.
- 2:35Right. But what's Buffett's interest
- 2:37rate on this float? It's near 0, but here's where it
- 2:39gets really mind bending. Sometimes his cost of capital is
- 2:44actually negative. Wait.
- 2:45Hold on negative costs. How are you paid to borrow
- 2:47money? That sounds like like a fantasy
- 2:50it. Does, but it's real.
- 2:51It all comes down to the insurance business itself being
- 2:53profitable. See, most insurers expect to
- 2:56lose a little money on the policies.
- 2:57So they collect $100 in premiums, but expect to pay out,
- 3:01say, 102 in claims and costs. Exactly.
- 3:05And they plan to make up that $2.00 loss by investing the
- 3:08float. But Berkshire is different.
- 3:11They are so disciplined, they often run their insurance
- 3:14operations at a profit before any investment income.
- 3:17So if they take in $100, their cost might only be $95.
- 3:22So they've already made $5. They've made $5, which means
- 3:25they were literally paid to hold and invest that initial $100.
- 3:30No bank on earth offers a deal like that that.
- 3:33That's an incredible advantage. So you have this giant reservoir
- 3:36of nearly free money. Yeah, that brings us to the next
- 3:40step, capital allocation. This is where Buffett becomes
- 3:44the master money mover. A normal fund manager gets cash.
- 3:47They have one option, buy stocks.
- 3:49Right, their hands are tied. But Buffett has two massive
- 3:53levers he can pull, and he can switch between them anytime.
- 3:55The first one is the one we all know about.
- 3:57Yep. Buying undervalued public
- 4:00stocks. Your apples, your Coca Cola's,
- 4:01The big famous investments. But it's the second lever that's
- 4:04the real game changer. It's the whole game, and that's
- 4:08acquiring wholly owned subsidiaries, buying entire
- 4:11companies. BNSF Railway Berkshire Hathaway
- 4:13Energy even sees candies this. Is where it stops looking like a
- 4:17portfolio and starts looking like like an ecosystem.
- 4:21These companies are like a herd of cash cows.
- 4:24That's a great way to put it. They just generate cash day in
- 4:27and day out. Now let's think about a normal
- 4:28company. The CEO has a pile of profit.
- 4:31What do they usually do with it? Well, they might pay it out as a
- 4:34dividend which gets taxed, or worse, they might make a dumb
- 4:38acquisition just to make their own little empire bigger.
- 4:41The capital gets wasted. It's inefficient.
- 4:43Very buff It on the other hand practices what our sources call
- 4:47non destructive transfer. Let's use See's Candies and BNSF
- 4:51Railway as the perfect example. Take it up See's Candies.
- 4:54Amazing business, makes a ton of money, but it doesn't need to
- 4:57build hundreds of new factories. It just prints cash.
- 5:00It's what you'd call low capital intensity.
- 5:02Exactly. Now on the other hand, you have
- 5:04BNSF Railway. Which is the total opposite.
- 5:06It needs constant massive amounts of cash to lay new
- 5:09track, buy new engines. Precisely so Buffett can act
- 5:13like a perfectly rational central banker.
- 5:16He can take the, say, 100 million in profit from SEES
- 5:18candies. Which sees doesn't need for its
- 5:21own growth. Right.
- 5:22And he can move it internally over to BNSF to fund a critical
- 5:25project. There are no taxes on that
- 5:28transfer, no friction, no bankers taking a cut.
- 5:31The money just flows to wherever in the empire it can be used
- 5:34best, whether that's a railroad or buying more Apple stock.
- 5:38That's the essence of Berkshire. It's a closed loop.
- 5:41The insurance float provides the cheap fuel and the subsidiaries
- 5:44create this internal tax efficient river of cash that can
- 5:47be directed anywhere by 1 rational mind.
- 5:50It just sounds so perfect. Which raises the obvious
- 5:53question, if this model is so good, why doesn't everyone just
- 5:56copy it? Because there's a huge trap
- 5:59hiding in plain sight. A trap.
- 6:00The entire beautiful system depends on one single
- 6:03unbreakable rule. The insurance business has to at
- 6:06least break even if it. Doesn't.
- 6:08If it doesn't that free money, the float instantly becomes high
- 6:12interest debt. The whole machine grinds to a
- 6:14halt and then goes into reverse. So there must be a way to
- 6:16measure this, a number that tells you if the engine is
- 6:19running smoothly. There is.
- 6:21It's the most important number in the insurance world.
- 6:23It's called the combined ratio. OK, break that down for us.
- 6:27What is it? It's pretty simple actually.
- 6:29You just add up all your claims paid out plus all your operating
- 6:32expenses and you divide it by the premiums you collected.
- 6:35So if the ratio is exactly 100. That means you broke even.
- 6:39For every dollar you took in, you paid out exactly $1.00.
- 6:43Your float cost you 0%. And under 100 is where the magic
- 6:47happens. That's the magic A ratio of 95
- 6:50means you made a 5 cent profit on every dollar of premium
- 6:53before you even invested a penny of it.
- 6:56But what if a company gets sloppy and the ratio goes above
- 6:58100? Let's say it hits 105.
- 7:00That's a catastrophe. It means you're losing $0.05 on
- 7:03every dollar you bring in. Your float is no longer free.
- 7:07You are now paying a 5% interest rate in a way just to hold your
- 7:11customers money. You're effectively borrowing at
- 7:13loan shark rates. And this is where we see the
- 7:16real, maybe misunderstood genius of Buffett.
- 7:19It's not just the big stock picks.
- 7:21No, not at all. It's the relentless iron fisted
- 7:23discipline on the insurance side.
- 7:26Berkshire's combined ratio is consistently way below 100.
- 7:29Year after year, he has said many times he would rather lose
- 7:33billions in potential business then write a single insurance
- 7:36policy that is guaranteed to lose money.
- 7:39That is the Moat. That's the whole secret.
- 7:42So to wrap all of this up for you, the listener, when you
- 7:45think about Berkshire Hathaway, don't just picture a basket of
- 7:49stocks. No.
- 7:50Picture a highly efficient commercial empire.
- 7:53It's built on 2 pillars that 0 cost insurance float and a
- 7:57ruthlessly rational system for allocating all the cash the
- 8:00empire generates. So when you buy a share of the
- 8:02stock, you're not just buying a tiny piece of Coca-Cola or
- 8:05Apple. You're buying a piece of the
- 8:07entire system. The funding mechanism, the
- 8:09allocation machine, all of it. That is what you own.
- 8:13And that brings us to a final provocative thought for you to
- 8:15chew on. We've established that the
- 8:17entire system hinges on that combined ratio staying below
- 8:20100. It's the linchpin.
- 8:22So what happens to this perfectly balanced machine when
- 8:24the world starts throwing things at it that are harder and harder
- 8:27to predict? I'm talking about sustained,
- 8:29massive, catastrophic losses from things like climate change
- 8:33or global pandemics. How long can even the most
- 8:36disciplined manager hold the line when the nature of risk
- 8:39itself is changing? Something for you to Mull over
- 8:41until our next deep dive.