Latest / The Lancet Planetary Health in conversation with / Plastics on trial: counting the cost of a world wrapped in plastic
Transcript
- 0:03Matteo Simonetti: Welcome to this new episode of The Lancet Planetary Health.
- 0:06In conversation with I Am Mattel.
- 0:09And today I will be joined by Alistair Brown, the editor-in-chief of the
- 0:13journal to discuss about plastics.
- 0:22Hello Al. How are you doing?
- 0:24Alastair Brown: Hi.
- 0:24Um, yeah, I'm good.
- 0:25Thank you.
- 0:25Pleased to be here.
- 0:26Matteo Simonetti: There is a lot of discussion about plastic recently.
- 0:30For example, I just Google Plastic and Health, and the first result
- 0:34was a quite alarming title from CNN saying A common plastic toxin
- 0:39may be linked to infant deaths.
- 0:41Should we, we be worried about plastic as a health concern.
- 0:45Alastair Brown: Um, it's a, obviously, it's a tricky one.
- 0:48I mean, there's a lot of, a lot of the evidence in terms of health harms from
- 0:54plastics are still relatively early.
- 0:56But if you kind of take a step back and you look at the, the
- 0:59how much plastic is produced.
- 1:02And how sort of omnipresent has become in the environment and not only the
- 1:08plastics that we can see, um, but also the plastics that break down has
- 1:11spread throughout the environment.
- 1:13There've been, microplastics have been found in ice cores on the
- 1:15top of mountains and at the poles.
- 1:17So we know that plastics are getting around the environment and we know
- 1:21that they're relatively new because we know that they're increasing over time.
- 1:25So I think it's certainly something that we should be concerned about, even if
- 1:28we don't yet know what all the health consequences might be, we know that we're
- 1:32in a situation where we certainly want to understand what those concerns are and we
- 1:36want to understand before it's too late.
- 1:38So it's no good if, uh, in a number of years we find out that there're so
- 1:42omnipresent in the environment by then.
- 1:44It's very hard to do much about it.
- 1:45Matteo Simonetti: Yeah.
- 1:46Alastair Brown: So, um, yeah, as far as I'm concerned, it's definitely
- 1:49something that that warrants, um, looking at very seriously.
- 1:51Matteo Simonetti: I totally agree.
- 1:52I mean, I'm looking at my room now while we were recording, and I am surrounded by
- 1:56plastic from my kids' toys to whatever.
- 1:59It's everywhere.
- 2:01Alastair Brown: And increasingly all of the textiles in your house have, if
- 2:04they're not entirely made of plastic materials, then they, then there's a
- 2:07nick, you know, sine and all of these kind of things that are in modern clothing.
- 2:11Oh yeah.
- 2:11So, yeah.
- 2:12Matteo Simonetti: I hate that I'm struggling to find 100%
- 2:15cotton garments because I can't wear anything else, but anyway.
- 2:20Back in January, the Lancet Planetary Health published an article by
- 2:24Megan Dini from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine,
- 2:28and colleagues titled Global Health Burdens of Plastic, A Lifecycle
- 2:32Assessment Model from 2016 to 2040.
- 2:36This research presents a comprehensive lifecycle assessment of the global
- 2:40plastic system quantifying its impact on human health through
- 2:44disability adjusted life year.
- 2:46What is a lifecycle assessment?
- 2:49Alastair Brown: So, uh, lifecycle assessment is trying to look at the
- 2:54environmental and health impacts of something through its entire lifecycle.
- 2:58So from the extraction resources through to the, the production
- 3:02chain of the, of the materials.
- 3:04And its use and then disposal.
- 3:06A lot of the discussion around plastics focuses on waste, including most
- 3:11of the microplastics and plastics in the ocean we're concerned about.
- 3:14And so some people might argue that dealing with plastic waste
- 3:18is the solution to this problem.
- 3:20But if you look at the whole life cycle, that's only part of the waste
- 3:23phases, any part of that life cycle.
- 3:25And if we want to understand the effect of plastics in the round, then we need to
- 3:30understand, you know, all of the different phases including production phase.
- 3:34Matteo Simonetti: Here we are talking about climate change pollution.
- 3:37We are talking about affecting so many things, isn't it?
- 3:42Alastair Brown: Yeah, that's right.
- 3:43So, um, almost all industrial processes have, you know, significant
- 3:48energy requirements, for example.
- 3:49So one of the, um, factors is how much energy is required, that there's a
- 3:53kind of a climate change consequence of that depending on the energy
- 3:56mix and how the energy is made.
- 3:58And then that has a knock on effect on health.
- 4:00You know, in extraction there's usually some chemicals, uh, released into the
- 4:03environment and there's potential health consequences, and then there's potential
- 4:07release of particles into the air.
- 4:09So air pollution is another potential source of health consequences.
- 4:11So through the various phase of production there, there are many
- 4:14ways in which materials released in the environment and then that
- 4:17potentially interacts with people, obviously, and affects their health.
- 4:21Matteo Simonetti: The authors estimated that the plastic lifecycle
- 4:24is responsible for 83 million daes.
- 4:26It seems like a huge number.
- 4:28Alastair Brown: Sure.
- 4:28So yeah, it's, I mean, it's important to understand this is a global estimate and I
- 4:33think if we're talking about 2016 estimate
- 4:37Matteo Simonetti: 2016, yeah,
- 4:38Alastair Brown: those, yeah.
- 4:39So dalis are a measure of disability adjusted life years, and that's a
- 4:42measure of the years of life lost to, or a year of life lost to, um, ill
- 4:47health, disability, or early death.
- 4:50It's probably easiest to think of it as one year of healthy life lost.
- 4:54And I, I think it's a really useful, you know, compound measure that helps
- 4:58to include effects on, on wellness if you like, as well as early mortality.
- 5:03But it's quite a counterintuitive or it's quite hard thing to kind of intuitively
- 5:07understand, like how big a number.
- 5:09Is that, so 83 million, it sounds like a big number.
- 5:13It certainly sounds like something we'd like to be smaller, but it's quite hard.
- 5:16I think one of the challenges with using das is it's quite hard to kind of
- 5:19intuitively express how big that is in relation to the global population and
- 5:23how concerned you should be with that number compared to other things that
- 5:27are, that are reducing the number of healthy years of life that we experience.
- 5:32For, for the purpose of this paper, we can say it's a large number and we would
- 5:35definitely like that number to be smaller.
- 5:40Matteo Simonetti: If you think about it, we are spending so much
- 5:43resources and time in trying to make.
- 5:48Our life longer, and then there are things that will make our
- 5:52life longer but less healthy.
- 5:55There should be a balance in, in some way
- 5:57Alastair Brown: at certain point.
- 5:57Yeah.
- 5:58And also the context that we're living in is that there's, um, we're expecting
- 6:02very large increases in plastic production over the next few years.
- 6:05I think that the estimate roughly double by 2050, even if we, if we do very
- 6:10little, the situation's likely to get.
- 6:12Quite considerably worse, you know, doing very little is that could argue
- 6:15is like an active policy choice rather than it just being a, a kind of a passive
- 6:20thing to do, to doing nothing is gonna get us into a, is likely, I mean, we'll
- 6:23discuss what the, the findings say, but it's likely to get us into a much worse
- 6:27situation than, than the 2016 results.
- 6:31Matteo Simonetti: Yes, exactly.
- 6:32And actually very well to what I was thinking about the policy change
- 6:37scenario that the, the author suggest they, they propose some action that
- 6:42could help reduce the burden of plastic.
- 6:45And obviously the most optimistic scenario was the one that looked
- 6:51into the complexity of the lifecycle.
- 6:54But even in that scenario, that could reduce.
- 6:57By 43% the impact of plastic life cycle on L, the situation won't be resolved.
- 7:06In a way it will keep going worse and worse and worse.
- 7:09This is kind of a,
- 7:11Alastair Brown: yeah.
- 7:11Well let's take a step back and just have a like quick look at the,
- 7:14so what they did in the papers.
- 7:15So they were looking at material flow analysis, which quantified the
- 7:20amount of plastic flow through sectors and regions, and then they did.
- 7:24In combination with did a lifecycle assessment, which is a
- 7:27systematic approach to assess the environmental health consequences
- 7:30of those of that plastic flows.
- 7:33And then we've already discussed, they estimated what the health effects
- 7:37of that were in 2016, and then they produced a series of kind of policy
- 7:43scenarios, if you like, which they then projected forward to 2040.
- 7:47So those policy scenarios were.
- 7:49Business as usual, so no change.
- 7:51So basically they're just increase in plastics but no change in the
- 7:55kind of regulatory environment.
- 7:56They did a scenario which is looking at current commitments.
- 7:59So if they assume that all kind of notional commitments to, to make
- 8:04improvements are actually delivered, which doesn't always happen.
- 8:07And you know, we're seeing in climate change that lots of earlier commitments
- 8:11are being rolled back at the moment.
- 8:12So commitments aren't, don't necessarily guarantee.
- 8:15Delivery.
- 8:15But nevertheless, it's interesting to see where we would get if we delivered
- 8:18everything that's been promised so far.
- 8:21They had a scenario which is looking at collection and disposal, so expansion
- 8:24of waste collection and landfill and trying, basically trying to address
- 8:28part of that problem of, um, plastics released into the environment.
- 8:31They had a scenario looking, uh, in enhanced recycling.
- 8:34They had a scenario looking at reduction of plastic production,
- 8:37a substitution, for example, with cardboards and other materials.
- 8:41And then they had the last one was that, the one that you already mentioned was the
- 8:44systems change, which was basically all of the above and applied simultaneously.
- 8:48So there was no kind of sequencing.
- 8:49They were all applied.
- 8:51Um, and to see how those different scenarios panned out in terms
- 8:53of the amounts of plastics that were being used and then the
- 8:55associated health consequences.
- 8:57So the, these scenarios aren't about predicting the future.
- 9:00They're about understanding, you know, what the potential consequences of
- 9:03different policy actions might be.
- 9:04Then that can be used to kind of steer policy makers to decide
- 9:08what's likely to be effective and what's not likely to be effective.
- 9:12And you'll often find in the kind of political arena, they'll obviously
- 9:15be things that people want to happen because it's more convenient.
- 9:19But if you, if you look at the numbers, you might find that
- 9:20that's just not sufficient.
- 9:22So, you know from the outset that that's not sufficient.
- 9:24Even, even though.
- 9:26It's something that, that somebody might want and therefore they might push
- 9:29that narrative and these, this kind of scenario analysis really helps you to
- 9:32kind of explore that and how effective some of those policies might be.
- 9:37Matteo Simonetti: Yeah, absolutely.
- 9:38I believe the strongest pushback against these scenarios is politics
- 9:42Alastair Brown: is politically motivated politics and economics.
- 9:43Yeah.
- 9:44I mean, so what happens is that, you know, scientific evidence is
- 9:47put forward, but it's essentially thrown into a political arena where.
- 9:52People use it as only one form of evidence, you know, in the
- 9:56wider kind of policy context.
- 9:58And so, for example, with a plastics treaty at the moment, you can see
- 10:01that there's, there's kind of a disagreement between two groups.
- 10:05Uh, one group is lobbying for production limits on plastics, so,
- 10:11you know, sort of firm limits on how much we might produce in the future.
- 10:14And the other group who are mostly petrochemical producing countries are
- 10:19saying, you know, they, they want to deal with this purely as a waste problem.
- 10:22Uh, and this paper actually speaks to whi which of those is more plausible because,
- 10:26um, in this paper they show that the greatest effect is by reducing production.
- 10:33Matteo Simonetti: Yes.
- 10:33I think they say that's a plastic production accounted
- 10:36for 82% of the actually impact.
- 10:39So kind of look like,
- 10:41Alastair Brown: um, an easy choice.
- 10:41Yeah.
- 10:41I mean, in principle at least.
- 10:42Obviously if you're doing something and it's causing environmental and health
- 10:46harms and then you do less of it.
- 10:48It obviously intuitively is, is gonna help what they do.
- 10:52You know, they do look at in their scenarios, for example, if you
- 10:55replace plastics with paper that isn't environmentally neutral either.
- 10:58So they do look at some, you know, alternative effects on what the life
- 11:02cycle impacts of those might be.
- 11:05And there are some benefits.
- 11:07But the, the greatest benefits are by from reducing use.
- 11:11And an awful lot of this plastic is single use plastic.
- 11:14So, you know, there are, there is a question about whether we even need to use
- 11:20the amount of plastics that we're doing.
- 11:22You know, who's driving, what's driving the increase?
- 11:25We're expecting the demand to increase by around 50% by 2050.
- 11:30You know, what's driving that?
- 11:31Who is that serving?
- 11:32It's not serving the people getting ill as a, as a result.
- 11:35So, um, you know, there's a wider question which, not really necessarily
- 11:39a scientific question, but an important question about, you know, what do
- 11:42we want the world to look like?
- 11:43Do we want this kind of disposable culture?
- 11:45Or is, are there other, you know, more desirable futures rather seeing
- 11:49it than seeing this as some kind of, um, you know, curtailing something
- 11:53that we all desperately need?
- 11:55I don't think that many people would miss plastic.
- 11:57Packaging if we found, you know, useful alternatives.
- 12:00I don't think many people would feel that their lifestyle was, was impacted
- 12:04by having less plastics in their life.
- 12:06Right.
- 12:07Matteo Simonetti: I would.
- 12:08Alastair Brown: Yeah.
- 12:09And,
- 12:10Matteo Simonetti: but speaking of which, is there any, any country
- 12:13in the world that is trying to.
- 12:16Do this, I mean, trying to control at least the use of plastic.
- 12:20Alastair Brown: Yeah.
- 12:20So, um, so in 2017, Kenya had, um, quite sweeping plastic bans.
- 12:26I'm not super familiar with, with how successful that's been, but I,
- 12:30but it's definitely a country that's taken a really proactive role in.
- 12:35Reducing plastic use.
- 12:36And it would be really interesting, um, to see, you know, how effective that's
- 12:39being and, and whether there's a kind of a natural experiment there in terms of,
- 12:43you know, people's exposure to plastics.
- 12:46Uh, the problem of course, with a lot of pollutants and environmental exposures
- 12:49is, you know, they don't respect geographical or political boundaries.
- 12:52So you can still have some exposure, even if you are, even if you're
- 12:56banning the production yourself.
- 12:57But nevertheless, it is certainly something that is possible to
- 13:00take a more proactive approach.
- 13:04Matteo Simonetti: Absolutely, absolutely.
- 13:07From an editorial perspective, why this paper was interesting for you and why you
- 13:12Alastair Brown: decided to
- 13:13Matteo Simonetti: publish.
- 13:14So,
- 13:14Alastair Brown: I mean, I'll probably end up repeating myself about this
- 13:16in subsequent months because our kind of editorial approach and what we are
- 13:21looking for is kind of very similar in in each situation, but that perhaps it's
- 13:25not a bad thing to have a little bit of repetition and reinforcement of, um.
- 13:30Of ideas.
- 13:31I mean, as editors, I think it's most helpful to think of us as
- 13:35like a proxy for the readership.
- 13:36So rather than thinking of us as kind of gatekeepers of knowledge, although
- 13:40there's an element of truth to that, what what we're trying to do is we're trying
- 13:44to see in a research paper the potential.
- 13:48Interest of our readers.
- 13:50And when you're looking for to be published in a kind of a high
- 13:53impact journal, if you like, what you're really trying to do
- 13:55is just reach a broad audience.
- 13:57So you're just trying to reach usually beyond your immediate peers
- 14:00and to a much broader audience.
- 14:02And that might be academics in other fields, or that might be policy makers or
- 14:06maybe, you know, ideally, probably both.
- 14:08So you know what we believe those people want is that they want
- 14:11to learn something that is new.
- 14:13You know, they didn't know before because although, uh, replication in
- 14:17science and reinforcement of ideas is important, it's rarely the thing that
- 14:21kind of leaps out people and makes them understand something new or exciting.
- 14:25So there's certainly a role for that, but it's often not high impact research.
- 14:29So we're looking for something new, a new finding, and we are looking
- 14:32for a kind of, that it has relevance.
- 14:36Beyond an immediate field of research so that again, ideally it'll be
- 14:40moving into either influencing other fields of research or having kind
- 14:44of practical or policy implications.
- 14:49Matteo Simonetti: This paper kind of ticks all the boxes, isn't it?
- 14:52And it opens so many question to the narrative that is characterized
- 14:58the conversation about plastics.
- 15:00Alastair Brown: Yeah, I mean it's a very, it's a complicated, and it is
- 15:02common with planetary health papers that they're quite complex analysis, touch
- 15:06on a lot of different things, and it's quite hard to kind of cover entirely, you
- 15:10know, in a brief conversation like this.
- 15:11But I think.
- 15:13Uh, the, the problem with a paper like this and a topic like this is, it's so
- 15:17big that you're kind of always gonna come away feeling that you haven't fully
- 15:21done it justice, if you know what I mean.
- 15:23Like, it's just, it's just basically impossible to
- 15:27completely, um, do justice to it.
- 15:31Matteo Simonetti: I agree and I can only suggest to our listeners to follow
- 15:34the links in the episode description and read the paper@thelance.com.
- 15:38And thanks Al for
- 15:39Alastair Brown: joining very much this conversation.
- 15:40It was good to talk to you and yeah, I look forward to future
- 15:43conversations on future papers.
- 15:49Matteo Simonetti: Thank you for listening to In Conversation
- 15:51with the Lancet Planetary Health.
- 15:53If you enjoyed this episode, please liberating end review on Apple Podcast
- 15:58or Spotify, and subscribe to stay updated on our latest research and conversations.
- 16:04I'm your host, Matt Ti.
- 16:07Our editorial team includes Editor in chief, Alistair Brown, deputy
- 16:11Editor John Carson and Senior editor.
- 16:14How You Wong?
- 16:15This program is part of the land setting conversation with Sirius
- 16:19and was produced by Matto ti.