Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Kennerspiel des Jahres Special-Interview with Alan Moon and Matt Leacock on Ticket to Ride Legacy
Transcript
- 0:00Freshly dug from the cold face of the board game world. We bring you
- 0:06the five games for Doomsday News. So I am delighted to be sat here
- 0:14in a virtual room in my Shielders Yara Specials with Board Gaming Royalty, the
- 0:19eminent Alan Moon and the Regal Matt Leecock here to talk about Ticket to Ride
- 0:25Legacy. So my first question, Alan is what was your knowledge of the
- 0:31Legacy concept before this project was even pitched. Had you played the Legacy games
- 0:37were aware of what Legacy was? Oh? Sure, yeah. I mean
- 0:41once I had played Pandemic Legacy, you know, one, two, and
- 0:44zero, I was just like such a huge fan. I thought Pandemic Legacy
- 0:49zero was just probably my favorite gaming experience ever. I don't know, Matt
- 0:55and Rob probably aren't gonna do anymore, but like, I just that's sad
- 0:59for me because was so great. So, you know I I obviously at
- 1:03that point, even early on, after playing Pandemic Legacy one, I was
- 1:07thinking about like, oh, is it possible to do that with Tickets to
- 1:11Ride? And then the initial thoughts were, you know, because it's not
- 1:14Solitaire, might be a lot harder. But as as time went on and
- 1:18more Legacy games came out and I did play you know a number of them.
- 1:22I thought like, oh, we could, we could probably do this.
- 1:26And so my thought, actually my my biggest thought was like, well,
- 1:29if I'm going to do it, I'm not going to do it by
- 1:30myself because it seems like a lot of work. And like, then,
- 1:33who am I going to do it with them? Well? I want to
- 1:34do it with Matt and rob These are you know, the guys that you
- 1:38know, Why wouldn't I do it with them? So and so you got
- 1:41the ball rolling on the whole idea of a ticket to ride Legacy, then
- 1:45yeah, yeah, for sure. I talked to Adrian Martineau at Days of
- 1:48Wonder and said, you know, is there any interest? And he was
- 1:52like he always is kind of, you know, lukewarm about it, but
- 1:55not super excited. I mean not that he isn't you know, excited,
- 2:00but he just you know, he doesn't express that kind of excitement. And
- 2:02then I said, well, I was going to ask Matt and Robin see
- 2:06if they were interested, because I think if they had said no, then
- 2:08then it just would have stopped right there. So Matt, when you know,
- 2:14you'll the helm of a huge property within board gaming, Pandemic and the
- 2:19Pandemic Legacy games have been hugely successful. What was your feeling when you approached
- 2:24to tackle maybe one of the biggest properties in hobby gaming. I think Rob
- 2:30and I were both really excited about the opportunity. I mean, I'd played
- 2:32a bunch of Ticket to Ride and it seemed like a nice, tight system,
- 2:38and it would be fun to tackle a new project. You know,
- 2:39it's like this green field to explore where you know, Robin, I had
- 2:44done three Pandemic Legacy games before the thought of the fourth was sort of overwhelming
- 2:47and daunting. We really didn't want to go there. But Ticket Ride was
- 2:53this new fresh space, so it seemed like a fun opportunity. Yeah.
- 2:57So I spoke to you a while ago about Pandemic Legacy and you were sort
- 3:00of fairly adamant. I got the impression you were fairly adamant you weren't going
- 3:04to do another legacy game. This is clearly not the case. What was
- 3:09it about Ticket to Ride the Is it the size of the property, is
- 3:15it the renowned or is it something inherently about the game mechanistically that drew you
- 3:20to thinking we can do a legacy version. Of this, well, I
- 3:24think it's easier to do a legacy game on an existing property, and it's
- 3:28certainly a benefit if it's well known, and it really helps if it's a
- 3:30great game. And so Ticket to Ride had all those boxes ticked. You
- 3:34know, it's got a very simple core loop. You can build on top
- 3:38of that, like chassis relatively simply. So yeah, I think Rob and
- 3:44I are really excited when Alan approached us, and then we promptly sat on
- 3:47the idea for like a year. So when was the initial approach made to
- 3:53them? I think Rob knows these days better an idea, Ellen, do
- 3:58you remember it was a long time? Yeah, I think twenty sixteen maybe
- 4:02or yeah, somewhere in there. But they were busy, you know,
- 4:05and I knew that was one of the problems, Like these guys, you
- 4:08know, they've got all sorts of stuff going on, So I was I
- 4:12didn't know whether they would be interested or not. So I think it did
- 4:15allow us to collect some ideas, don't let those gestate for a little bit
- 4:18of time, and then when it was time to start, we're all kind
- 4:21of excited to get the ball rolling. And so Alan, you know,
- 4:25you're you're an eminent ball game designer. You've designed loads of games, you
- 4:28won the spield of yours, but I imagine, I mean, legacy is
- 4:31a different kettle of fish. Was there any trepidation into entering, you know,
- 4:40taking your baby and turning into a legacy game on? And what did
- 4:43you learn through the process of making Oh my god? Well, I mean
- 4:46certainly I was arrogant enough to feel like I could have done it by myself,
- 4:51But as soon as we started working on and I was like, there's
- 4:54no way I would have been able to do this. It's just Matt in
- 4:58particular. I mean the Robin Matt both have like huge skill sets, and
- 5:01like Matt does all the technical stuff and just even just setting up the files
- 5:06like it was. I was just amazed, Like he's a genius, and
- 5:11rob is a genius at you know, at writing the story and all sorts
- 5:15of other stuff, and so working with them was just I mean, it
- 5:18was a huge experience, and that was one of the things I was interested
- 5:21in. I was interested in their process because I feel like, you know,
- 5:27I would have to start from scratch, but these guys, they've been
- 5:29doing this for years. So like when I just find out what their process
- 5:32is and be a part of it. So it was a huge learning experience
- 5:35for me just to watch, you know, how they do things, and
- 5:41that was great. I mean, this was easily the best, you know,
- 5:44experience as a game designer of my life. And you know, I
- 5:46don't know whether we'll do another Ticket to Ride Legacy. I don't think we
- 5:50haven't decided at all, you know, but I sort of have mixed feelings
- 5:54about it, like I would love to do it, sort of because it
- 5:56was such a great process and fun. But on the other hand, you
- 6:00know, I don't know, it was so much work as sort of daunting
- 6:02to think about. I don't know how Mad thinks about it. So Matt,
- 6:08it's it's interesting. When Pandemic Legacy came out, it seemed the partnership
- 6:12seemed very logical. You're the Pandemic guy, Rob is the legacy guy.
- 6:16Is it strange to you that you've become synonymous not only with Pandemic but also
- 6:25with the legacy idea too. Yeah, I feel like I've been kind of
- 6:29read and Rob's coattails there because he's the legacy guy for sure. But we've
- 6:33we've had a partnership for like ten years now, we've we've kind of developed
- 6:36a process that works really well and it's really enjoyable, and we both bring
- 6:42sort of our own complimentary skill sets and it's been fun to be able to
- 6:46like use that knowledge and kind of apply it to different domains. So I'll
- 6:50take it. You know, I'm happy with it. But yeah, I
- 6:54think most of the credit ghost robbed there. So let's talk then. Oh
- 6:58sorry, Alan, please, I can tell you it's real fun to watch
- 7:00them work together. So, you know, like I always tell everybody in
- 7:04the beginning, you know, they have this marriage already, so I was
- 7:08kind of like the third persons of this marriage. And it took a few
- 7:11months till I was able to, you know, get into all the fun
- 7:14stuff. But they would they would kind of not squabble, but you know,
- 7:17discuss things back and forth. It was hilarious to watch and real but
- 7:21also, you know, again a good experience, like how they work together,
- 7:26and they and they worked together so well, it's it's I'm very jealous.
- 7:30So let's talk about about then. So what did each of you contribute
- 7:38to the process of designing the game? If you'd like to speak to them?
- 7:43Well, I think we have a process where we all meet together and
- 7:45discuss the design at large, so it's not like the design is like one
- 7:50person's thing, so it's very very much a synthesis of all three of us.
- 7:56But then we'd sign up for jobs basically, so we have a big
- 7:59board of all this stuff that we need to do, and then basically you
- 8:01just sign up and do it, and then we'd come back and I'll meet
- 8:05and review everything that was done. And each of us had specialties, so
- 8:09I did a lot of I did a lot of the production work, frankly,
- 8:11a lot of the un sexy stuff like getting files ready, like laying
- 8:16things out so you could see the domain that we're developing. Managed a lot
- 8:20of the notes, and a lot of the play test cycles. I did
- 8:26a lot of the product designs, so when you open up the box and
- 8:30you see those offices, I designed the way those actually work together physically.
- 8:35There's other surprises in some of the boxes that were really really fun to develop
- 8:41when it came to like how we do stickers in this novel way. So
- 8:45I think that's where I kind of spent a lot of my time. Rob
- 8:48in addition to the overall design, was in charge of the story and trying
- 8:54to figure out how that all integrated together and making everything kind of coherent and
- 9:00really great with like building anticipation and the overall development of that. And then
- 9:05Alan is our Ticket to Ride guy. So whenever there's any kind of question,
- 9:09it was so useful being able to I mean, like, Alan can
- 9:11sketch out a ticket to ride map on a nap kind of like five minutes,
- 9:15I think so, and then like, you know, kind of our
- 9:18brand guide, you know, is this straying too far or not? And
- 9:24I got to say Alan was really wonderful to work with and that he was
- 9:26just up for the craziest of ideas, and so it expanded our horizons for
- 9:31the kinds of things that we might attempt. It wasn't like, oh,
- 9:35you know, we have to play in this little little sandbox. It's like
- 9:37the sky's the limit. Let's go for it, guys. So that was
- 9:41really fun. And so on the Alan, you know, as I said,
- 9:45you know, it's your baby and you've got other people tinkering with your
- 9:48baby. When you came to see Ticket to Ride Legacy as it was,
- 9:54How exciting was that And how without any spoilers, does it differ from a
- 10:00sort of cool game to get to rind. Yeah, I think. I
- 10:05mean, I think since the game has come out, we've learned like what
- 10:09worked really well and what could have been better. But like when we were
- 10:13designing it, I mean, we spent the first year just talking about ideas,
- 10:16the three of us, and that was super fun. I mean,
- 10:18we just we'd get together once a week and just you know, brainstorm about
- 10:22like what could we do well potentially, and there was you know, there
- 10:26was so many great ideas. And then when we started talking seriously like okay,
- 10:31well, how are we going to start, you know, we all
- 10:33sort of tried to start slowly and then and then see what worked. But
- 10:39you know, the play testing was huge. I mean it's because there were
- 10:41definitely things that didn't work. What I found interesting about the process was sometimes,
- 10:46because there were three of us, two of us would really be in
- 10:50favor of something and one person would be against it, and you know,
- 10:52we generally try as much as we could. I think it was most often,
- 10:56you know, me and Matt against Rob all the time because he but
- 11:01he was And there was a really basic fundamental part of the game where we
- 11:05decided to do a nonlinear board where the board could come out in different ways,
- 11:11and that was you know, that was Rob. Rob was really pushing
- 11:15for that, and Matt and I were both worried about it for any number
- 11:18of reasons like oh what about this and this, But like Rob said,
- 11:20no, we should really go with this. So when we play tested that,
- 11:24I think the first time we played tested, I was like, Okay,
- 11:26he's right. We got to do that, you know, because it's
- 11:30something really different. And I think for me that was a that was a
- 11:33big breakthrough in the game, like we can do this. It did cause
- 11:39lots of you know, potential problems and we had to solve, but you
- 11:41know, we were able to do that, and that was just such an
- 11:45interesting process for me. I loved it. And you know, every time
- 11:48we had a I certainly had some proposals that Rob and Matt were not crazy
- 11:54about because they got too lot. But that's okay. I think in the
- 11:58end, you know, what we did was great and there's so many other
- 12:01ideas that we could have used. I mean, that's the amazing part.
- 12:05I say that's proposals are important now because they open the window even wider,
- 12:09so we really consider much more dramatic ideas just given and I think, you
- 12:13know, like I'm looking back at it now, you know, it's so
- 12:16easy to say, oh, we could have done this and this, or
- 12:18we should have done this and that. But I've played the whole campaign three
- 12:24times and I'm about to start another one, and it's fun. I mean,
- 12:26I I enjoyed and and I don't play my games a lot after they
- 12:31get published. Usually, I just you know, there are lots of my
- 12:33games that I've never played the published version because it's you know, it becomes
- 12:37work, and you know, it's not it's not that I'm not proud of
- 12:41it or something, but it's it's work. So but I love playing this
- 12:45game. It's it's just really fun. I'll say that. It's saying it's
- 12:48true for me. I have not played any of the Pandemic Legacies, and
- 12:50many of my other products have come out and they rarely get on the table.
- 12:54But I'm almost done with a second campaign of this, and it's it's
- 12:56really enjoyable being able to play your own So why then? Why is because
- 13:05I've played all the Pandemic Legacies and without blowing smoke where smoke shouldn't be blown.
- 13:09I mean, they're all fantastic, especially Season zero, I think is
- 13:13one of the as I It's one of the greatest gaming experiences I've ever had.
- 13:16What is it about this one then that encourages you to sit down and
- 13:20play your own work without going crazy. For me personally, it's competitive,
- 13:24so I feel like I can just go for it. You know, it's
- 13:28not like I have all this. I mean, I have some knowledge of
- 13:31where it's going, and so my competitors all feel like they're playing for second
- 13:35because I'm going to win, probably gonna win. It's been tight, you
- 13:41know, I'm pretty good at this after testing it so much. But yeah,
- 13:45I just feel like I can just go for it in a way that
- 13:46you know, with the pandemic stuff, there's there's secret information and I've I
- 13:50don't know, I don't want to be that completely dominant player, So I
- 13:56think that is one one element. And for you, Alan, what brings
- 14:00you playing playing this one? I certainly haven't won any of the games I've
- 14:05played, so I don't know about me or are you or my opponents?
- 14:13Was trying something different because I know some of the things that are coming obviously,
- 14:16and I try it. But one of the things that's really enjoyable for
- 14:20me is just to see the how delighted people are when they, you know,
- 14:24they play the game and they open every box and it's really fun.
- 14:28And so I just sit back and because I'm more interested in, like,
- 14:31you know, what works and what doesn't work, and watching them and they
- 14:35just have I played with a twelve year old boy the last year and he
- 14:39had like the best time imaginable. It was so fun to play with him.
- 14:45And he didn't play very well, you know, but it didn't matter.
- 14:48It was just such a fun experience. And I don't know, that's
- 14:52that's been great. My wife, you know, she's a jant. She's
- 14:54happy to play it again. And you know she's not a big gamer,
- 14:58but you know, she plays and she she won one of the games and
- 15:01she was just so thrilled to you know, to win. It was great.
- 15:05So I'm happy to have that experience over and over. It's it's fun.
- 15:09So what is the biggest challenge in designing a legacy game. I'm sure
- 15:13there are many challenges. I'm sort of very labyrinthine, very intense process,
- 15:18But what's the biggest challenge to making something satisfying and coherent? I think the
- 15:26scale is probably the best word for it. It's just it's it's a very
- 15:28large project. It's not designing one game in a sense, in this case,
- 15:31it was more like designing twelve. And so when it's when you do
- 15:37need to play test all of that, and your your prototypes are essentially disposable,
- 15:41and it takes a day and a half to make one of them,
- 15:45and you're doing you know, dozens of them, it really just adds up.
- 15:48It's a lot of like physical labor. And then while you're doing,
- 15:52all that you really want is there's a massive potential for the product. Because
- 15:58it's a huge toolbox, and this case it's such a well known brand,
- 16:02the stakes are really high. So it's it's like running a marathon, you
- 16:06know, there's a you just have to have a lot of stamina and keep
- 16:10your eye on the quality and just do it. Truin is amount of work.
- 16:15So I would say scale is probably the biggest problem for me. Yeah,
- 16:19I mean I would say I was just continually worried about like are we
- 16:23going to screw something up, and like the game is going to come out
- 16:26and there's going to be you know, a problem that just makes it hard
- 16:30to play and that was my biggest fear, Like I just wanted, you
- 16:33know, there's always going to be some little issues and questions, but like
- 16:37if there was anything major that had prevented people from really playing it and enjoying
- 16:41it. That was that was my fear during the whole process. Other than
- 16:45that, you know, I was having a great time designing it and playing,
- 16:48but it was a huge amount of work when we got to play testing,
- 16:52and that was something I hadn't really anticipated. Matt and Robb had had
- 16:56the experience, you know with Pandemic, but you know, just one play
- 17:00test through of Legacy. You know, we're talking like twenty hours of video
- 17:04that we have to watch and you know, go through and make notes,
- 17:07and that was over and over. That was a lot of work, you
- 17:11know, and not the most fun work as a game designer. Yeah,
- 17:17and so how did you do play testing? What was the logistics of it?
- 17:19Because you're not in the same place, right, So how do you
- 17:23do that? Yeah? I mean, go ahead, Well, I guess
- 17:27there's a combination. So early on we do some testing in person with the
- 17:32people playing it at conventions. So whether I think we probably tested a board
- 17:36game geek, But that's it's hard to get the three of us all together
- 17:40at same time because they're in three different places obviously, But Rob and I
- 17:44have done a lot of remote testing in the past, and that works really
- 17:45well because sitting in the same room with someone for like twelve to twenty hours,
- 17:49it's just in that natural experience, and when you're in the room with
- 17:52people, you color the experience tremendously. So we would send out prototypes and
- 17:57then ask people to video tape them selves on their phone or tablet and then
- 18:02post the video and that scales much better. You can go back and review
- 18:06things you're not in the room. You can use time codes to mark behaviors,
- 18:11and yeah, really just study things and it'll get a lot more data.
- 18:17But it does mean that you're building prototypes and mailing them and watching lots
- 18:19of video. But I think that's really the best way to do these these
- 18:23I mean to be a more specific. Then we would each make a prototype
- 18:27and send it out, so we'd have three, you know, three groups
- 18:30play testing at the same time, and Matt did again, Matt did a
- 18:33lot of We printed some of the stuff, the cards and things, but
- 18:38you know, we also had to print some of it ourselves and you know,
- 18:41put it all together, and it was it was a lot of work.
- 18:44Like Matt said, it was a day and a half of you know
- 18:47work just to get that prototype together and then you know it's a one time
- 18:51use and the next time you got to do it again. So let's talk
- 18:55now, let's move on to the award. So I've asked everyone this,
- 18:59I've interviewed a few people about these these upcoming awards. So did you watch
- 19:03the stream? Were you were you there on tenter hooks waiting to see and
- 19:07also was there any expectation that you would be nominated? Mass I one out
- 19:15of percent watched the YouTube stream. I got up and we were at an
- 19:18Airbnb rental and I streamed it from my phone under the TV. I woke
- 19:23up my wife when take it right Legacy made the shortlist because I gasped so
- 19:29loud, It's just like, what's going on? So yeah, I mean
- 19:34I I had my fingers crossed, and I tried not to think about it
- 19:38too much. I set aside that morning to it to watch, but you
- 19:44know, you don't want to jinx it, so I tried not to be
- 19:48too expected. And Alan, well, I did not know there was a
- 19:52live stream, or I probably would have watched. And I'm glad I know
- 19:59because now I know that there's one on the twenty first, too, so
- 20:02I definitely will be watching that. I you know, it's interesting. I'd
- 20:06sort of I don't know the award. I sort of hadn't thought about the
- 20:11award until it was announced, you know, and so I hadn't I really
- 20:15hadn't thought about. Like last year, I certainly was thinking like, oh,
- 20:18I wonder if this has any kind of chance, but coming into this
- 20:22year, I had sort of been distracted by other things. I wasn't really
- 20:25thinking about it. But yeah, I mean it's great even you know,
- 20:30I hope we win, but if we don't, that's that's okay. It's
- 20:33enough to have been nominated, so you know, it's a big deal.
- 20:36It's really hard people have, you know, when you read BGG, people
- 20:40have so many ideas about what the jury is and what they do and how
- 20:44they do it. I can tell you that none of that is relevant.
- 20:49The only thing I would say I believe is relevant is that if a game
- 20:53is doing well in terms of sales already, that it has a better chance
- 20:57of winning because the jury cares about not just about the sales, but they
- 21:03care about like they want to pick the game that's the most popular game.
- 21:07That's what they want to do. So I don't know where that leaves tickets
- 21:10ride a Legacy or Daybreak even. I don't know, you know, relatively
- 21:14how they look at it. But what I've seen over the last five years
- 21:17is they've nominated a bunch of legacy games, and I believe they want a
- 21:22legacy game to win eventually. So maybe this is the year. So you're
- 21:26both Spielders Yaris winners. You both have the trophy. How important? So
- 21:33there are there are business reasons why winning a Spielders Yours is significant, but
- 21:38I want to take that sort of grubby financial consideration away when I ask this
- 21:42question, how important is it for you as artists and creators to win an
- 21:49award like this smart Well, I think it's just been such a recognized award
- 21:56for so long. Like when I started getting into the really hobby in seeing
- 22:00Katan and it was associated with that award, it was like this gauntlet to
- 22:04kind of reach for, right and you know, it's just carried with me
- 22:08all this time. So it does feel like kind of like winning a gaming
- 22:11Oscar, So it's always been something that I've been excited about, and having
- 22:15gone to the ceremony now like five times, I think they do a great
- 22:18job of building anticipation and the community there is really wonderful. So even just
- 22:23going to Berlin is going to be such a treat. So yeah, I
- 22:27really get into it. I think it's a it's a delight to be you
- 22:33know, like nominated, and then to just participate in that culture is just
- 22:37a lot of fun for me. So it's something I look forward to.
- 22:41Yeah, I mean it's it's special. The two times, you know,
- 22:45where I won, it was just an incredibly special occasion in Berlin, and
- 22:49then then Essen is really special too because you're you're sort of king at the
- 22:56Essen for you know, king for a day or three a few days.
- 23:00So it's it's great. I mean, it feels really good. And I
- 23:03think there's so many game designers and it's just I wish they could all have
- 23:07the experience of winning, but obviously very few of them ever will, so
- 23:11I think it sort of separates, you know, how you are are seen
- 23:15within the community, like you know, you're an SDJ winner. I mean,
- 23:19I just think it has a so much prestige. Excellent and just finally
- 23:25to wrap up, and either one of you can choose to answer this question.
- 23:30If people watching this are thinking, hmm, should I should I give
- 23:37to Ride Legacy a go? Why do you think they should go? It's
- 23:48a well, I mean, I would say it's an excuse to spend a
- 23:49lot of quality time with your friends and family nothing else. I found it
- 23:55to be a really exciting game. It's full of lots of tension, and
- 24:00I think that's the secret to the game that it's pretty tense and then you
- 24:03develop a story as you play, but ultimately you're spending a lot of great
- 24:08quality time with your friends and family as you're doing it. Excellent. Well,
- 24:11Alan Moom, thank you very much. Thanks and Matt Lee Cox,
- 24:17thank you very much. Thanks. You can support the show by going to
- 24:21Patreon dot com Forward slash five GPD thank you for listening.