Latest / The imuRgency Room / The Gen Z 'Initiative' Recession
Transcript
- 0:00Gen. Z is the laziest generation, or
- 0:01at least that's what all of the other older generations are
- 0:05saying about us. We're lazy, we don't want to
- 0:07work, we don't take initiative. Blase, blase, blase.
- 0:09These older generations love to come on the Internet and tell us
- 0:12about ourselves. But is there any merit to what
- 0:15they're saying? Like if everyone is saying the
- 0:17same thing, is there some truth to it?
- 0:20Like just for the sake of conversation, is Gen.
- 0:23Z the laziest generation? Hey guys, it's up to emergency
- 0:26and welcome, welcome back to my channel.
- 0:27And today I'm in a little colored shirt because no one's
- 0:31going to tell me that I did not take the initiative to try and
- 0:34look good today. Got a new haircut, try to dress
- 0:36up. Got a little pussy bow going on
- 0:37right here. I am locked in in trying to take
- 0:40the initiative because today's video, it is about the
- 0:42conversation that's been happening online over whether or
- 0:44not Gen. Z is lazy and or I can just take
- 0:47initiative to do anything for them.
- 0:48And before the pitchforks come out, my friend, let me assure
- 0:51you that I have not abandoned you and I am not succumbing to
- 0:54the stereotypes of our older generation of our older
- 0:57brethren, my Gen. Z comrades.
- 0:58But I do think after taking a look and doing a little bit of
- 1:02research, it is time we have a honest conversation about
- 1:06initiative and whether or not we do have it.
- 1:09And obviously, I'm not talking about Gen.
- 1:10Z being the laziest generation and that we are entitled and
- 1:13undisciplined. That is such common rhetoric
- 1:15that is like skewed at us from like older generations because
- 1:17we've talked at length in other videos about how that just
- 1:20simply is not true. However, when it comes to the
- 1:22initiative piece, I do fear that there may be, and again hold
- 1:27when I say this, there may be some points and our general lack
- 1:31of initiative may be contributing to more aspects of
- 1:35our lives than we care to admit. Now let me explain what I mean
- 1:38here. Gen.
- 1:39Zers, the Gen. Zers that people are talking
- 1:40about will be going into a job interview that's on the second
- 1:44floor of a building. They came in on the first floor
- 1:47of that building. They text the interviewer.
- 1:50Hey, I'm here. Mind you, in the e-mail it said
- 1:54that the interview would be on the second floor of the building
- 1:57and it gave you the room number, but you decided to text the
- 1:59interviewer. Hey, I'm here instead of going
- 2:02to where? It said in the e-mail.
- 2:04There's a number of videos going around right now talking about
- 2:06this article from Fortune magazine published in January of
- 2:10last year. All the reasons why Gen.
- 2:12Z is being fired at alarming rates.
- 2:14Now, I don't want to talk about why this checks out.
- 2:16What I do want to talk about is the number one reason that's
- 2:18been attributed to this, which is a lack of initiative.
- 2:22Now, I hope by the end of watching those two Tik Toks that
- 2:24we do equally feel some frustration here.
- 2:26And unfortunately, this is the kind of behavior that is all too
- 2:29common in our generation. And I've personally experienced
- 2:31this from other young people in my life, whether they be Gen.
- 2:33Z, Gen. Z2, Point O, or Gen.
- 2:35Alpha. And it is kind of frustrating.
- 2:37And from those two examples, as well as witnessing it digitally
- 2:40and in real life, it seems like we can be too passive.
- 2:43It seems that we as a generation come off, it's too passive,
- 2:45lacking common sense and critical thinking and don't
- 2:48really know how to advocate for ourselves.
- 2:50And again, do not jump me. I'm saying this with love.
- 2:55And I'm not saying this on some holier than thou tip because I
- 2:57know a lot of times I come on here and talk about like, oh,
- 3:00people got to critically think media literacy is so down.
- 3:03And that may make it seem like I'm above it.
- 3:04And I have all those things when it comes to common sense, you
- 3:08can ask anyone in my life, that shit ain't super common with me.
- 3:12So again, this isn't me pointing the finger and calling y'all
- 3:14out. This is more of a holistic,
- 3:16let's call each other in and see where we can grow and where the
- 3:20older generations are getting a little off base and taking a
- 3:22little bit too many liberties. So please, let's listen and
- 3:25internalize with an open heart, open mind, open spirit.
- 3:28Yeah. And if whatever reason you're
- 3:29like, what do you mean by common sense?
- 3:31I have to say my favorite example of this is that whole
- 3:33iconic bean soup debacle. We're a creator posted A7 bean
- 3:36soup and they were comments asking like essentially, how do
- 3:39you make a 7 bean soup without beans Because they don't like
- 3:42beans. You know, are you seeing what
- 3:48I'm getting at now? Like baby, if you don't like
- 3:51beans, why are you watching A7 bean soup video?
- 3:55Maybe you're not the target audience.
- 3:56Maybe make some other kind of soup.
- 3:58Like quite literally keep scrolling and find you another
- 4:01one if you don't like it. But like even the fact that
- 4:03someone needs to come online to explain that to the commenter is
- 4:06part of this whole thing. And just be clear, because we
- 4:08will be talking about jobs in the job market and specifically
- 4:11how we're seeing this phenomena in the context of jobs.
- 4:13I am in no way shape or form blaming anyone for not having a
- 4:16job. Like that is not the intention
- 4:18here. That is not how I'm meaning for
- 4:20this to land because we have made too many videos on this
- 4:22channel talking about the current job market and the real
- 4:24impacts and reasonings behind why it is the way it is right
- 4:27now. And that's just not something
- 4:28you're going to see me flip flop on.
- 4:29Like that's just not the vibe. And as we get into, there are
- 4:32external reasons that I think boomers and the like are quick
- 4:35to jump on Gen. Z on for.
- 4:36And while the majority of those I do not agree with at all,
- 4:38there are some things that I feel like we should look inward
- 4:42and reflect on. And the first one of those
- 4:43things that we should reflect on is specifically getting into why
- 4:46our generation seems to need so much guidance and getting into
- 4:49the learned helplessness of it all.
- 4:57It feels like we need so much guidance, and there are a few
- 4:59things that we can attribute this to, but also a few things
- 5:01that we do need to take accountability for.
- 5:03Like, we can to some extent wake up and control our own lives,
- 5:06but clearly there have been external forces outside of our
- 5:09control that certainly haven't helped develop these skills, at
- 5:12least in our time on this earth. Genesee hasn't learned
- 5:14helplessness problem and we're the only ones that can do
- 5:17anything about it. But in order to do something
- 5:20about this problem, we're going to have to realize that we were
- 5:24never helpless in the first place.
- 5:26And I think a combination of these external things and maybe
- 5:28just like the general overwhelm have caused this as a generation
- 5:31to adopt this learned helplessness.
- 5:33And before I say what I'm about saying X, do not blame me
- 5:35because I bring this up in damn near every video.
- 5:37But if we're playing the blame game, we got to blame the big
- 5:40two. Number one being COVID and #2 be
- 5:42in that damn phone. I know I say this in pretty much
- 5:46every one of these videos, but I don't think y'all are hearing
- 5:48me. And I don't think y'all
- 5:49understand how big and pivotal these two things are.
- 5:52And we can't just write them off as like 1 little thing that
- 5:54happened in history or just like 1 invention that has come
- 5:57around. Like these have had lasting
- 5:58impacts that we are still feeling the impacts of.
- 6:01Like why are we asking ChatGPT what we should do today?
- 6:03Like, why are we relinquishing so much control of our own
- 6:06autonomy and our own decisions to AI, to algorithms, to other
- 6:09people, to the general collective instead of
- 6:11interrogating internally what you want to do with your leg?
- 6:14What do you mean? You're asking TikTok?
- 6:15What are we wearing this summer? Like, what are you wearing this
- 6:18summer? Like, ask yourself and figure it
- 6:19out, diva. Like, what are we talking about?
- 6:21And one thing and one explanation, I guess that comes
- 6:24to mind when it comes to this sort of learned helplessness is
- 6:27just the way that we grew up and how information was provided to
- 6:29us. We as Gen.
- 6:31Z or maybe the first generation that from literally popping out
- 6:33the womb could just Google anything.
- 6:35Like think about it. Do we really have to learn
- 6:37anything? Like, did we have to learn the
- 6:39Dewey Decimal system? Like, do you know what that is?
- 6:41Do they still even teach that? Like, what I'm trying to say is
- 6:43that we didn't have to actively seek information for ourselves
- 6:45because we had and have search engines like Google, Bing,
- 6:48etcetera, to essentially pass by us without making us necessarily
- 6:51dig in deeper. And I want to have a big caveat
- 6:53here for, I want to say the older sections of Gen.
- 6:56Z, just because I can remember with my upbringing of like the
- 6:59Internet, there was definitely a drilling to think more
- 7:01critically and trust the Internet and the internet's
- 7:04results less and less coming from older people.
- 7:07But as time went on and older people kind of just like
- 7:09relinquished control of the Internet to younger people, that
- 7:12kind of faded away like Wikipedia used to.
- 7:14We see it as like an untrustworthy source of
- 7:16information. And now who cares?
- 7:19And this whole thing is becoming worse with AI platforms like
- 7:21Claw, Gemini ChatGPT, whatever would have you requiring you to
- 7:23have less and less context and think less and less about what
- 7:26you're searching and what you're trying to find.
- 7:28Because you're going to get an answer right away in a very
- 7:30quick and efficient summary that may or may not include the
- 7:33entire context, which you're not really looking for in the 1st
- 7:35place. And one of these days, we will
- 7:37have fully insighted studies on how COVID truly disrupted
- 7:40generations in different ways. But thinking of Gen.
- 7:42Z and Genopo, this occurred in the formative time for Gen.
- 7:45Alpha, obviously in the child development phase, but for Gen.
- 7:47Z and the formative social phase like high school, college,
- 7:50middle school, where that's the time we were supposed to start
- 7:52figuring out who you are and start forming your own opinions,
- 7:54your own identity, and slowly learn what kind of adult you'll
- 7:56shape up to be. And that can't really happen if
- 7:59you're locked, boxed into your childhood bedroom from ages 12
- 8:03to 21. And of course, this has created
- 8:05a plethora of outcomes and some coming out with induced social
- 8:08anxiety. The practice of asking questions
- 8:10and being a human with follow through in the world didn't
- 8:13really matter at that time. And as we've talked about in
- 8:15many previous videos and in some of the not nicest terms, the
- 8:18most grueling soul sucking hellscape of a job market right
- 8:20now. Like we entered the job force at
- 8:22such a unique and anti employee time.
- 8:24You need to be aggressive and advocate for yourself.
- 8:27But like even when you do so, that still isn't guaranteeing
- 8:29you a job. But we don't have to succumb to
- 8:31this as our ultimate reality. We have the power to change
- 8:33this, we just have to take the initiative to do so.
- 8:36You meet a time where you have to rise to the to the case.
- 8:39You have to do something to save yourself, to change the
- 8:41circumstances and you fold. You think that you cannot do
- 8:45anything to better your circumstances.
- 8:46You rely on other people to come save you and nobody's coming to
- 8:49save you, Pookie. That's what learned helplessness
- 8:51is. You believe that you are
- 8:52helpless when it comes to changing.
- 8:53Your life. The wonderful thing is if we
- 8:55identified the main issues and have an awareness of our own
- 8:58behaviors, then we can act with that in mind and hey, who knows,
- 9:01maybe even switched up a bit. And I do also want to say that
- 9:04we are not the first or last generation to do this.
- 9:06This is not something that's specifically unique to us, nor
- 9:08am I implying that it is. I just think that we are the
- 9:10youngest generation and there are many factors that contribute
- 9:13and shape our behavior. So it just looks a little bit
- 9:15different than previous generations and we might be a
- 9:17little bit more vocal and obvious about it, but this is
- 9:20nothing new. These are just growing pains of
- 9:22becoming adults. And I think that older
- 9:24generations need to give us a brick because, again, we've all
- 9:28gone through it. And yes, for this video, I'm
- 9:29talking to Gen. Z because that's where I
- 9:31resonate. I see it in myself, my peers,
- 9:33and online. But this is not specifically
- 9:35only Gen. Z.
- 9:36And I know that older generations had a form of this,
- 9:38maybe going by a different name or for different reasons.
- 9:41But again, don't act like this is only us.
- 9:44OK, so when we're talking about this whole initiative thing, why
- 9:46does it seem like we as Gen. Z see initiative as extra work
- 9:50and going above and beyond? And how has this been extending
- 9:52into our professional lives? According to Fortune, the
- 9:54numbers are stark. According to a survey, 6 in 10
- 9:57employers and admitted that they had already sacked the Gen.
- 10:00Z workers they had hired fresh out of college, meaning a few
- 10:02months after hiring them. Employers gripe with young
- 10:04people today is their lack of motivation or initiative. 50% of
- 10:08the leaders surveyed cited that as the reason why things didn't
- 10:10work out with their new hire. Bosses also pointed to Gen.
- 10:13Z being unprofessional and organized and having poor
- 10:15communication skills as their top reasons for having to sack
- 10:18grads. And this whole issue really can
- 10:20be twofold in that there is a learning curve in the
- 10:23professional world for new young employees as well as a lot of
- 10:26times companies often do cut corners and do not invest in
- 10:29properly training new employees at times.
- 10:31And there are also scenarios where we can take that
- 10:33accountability. It almost feels like job
- 10:34proficiency is getting confused with going above and beyond.
- 10:37I'm struggling with Genz learned helplessness.
- 10:40I work at a job where all of us have a lot of different roles
- 10:45and every day you know what role you are assigned and it's on
- 10:48your schedule and there's like 3 or 4 different places you can
- 10:52check your schedule, you can print your schedule.
- 10:54There's so many ways to know what your job is.
- 10:57Every day at my job and consistently, I find that a lot
- 11:01of Gen. Z employees, they just don't
- 11:04look or they don't care, or a lot of them are showing up to
- 11:08work and saying what do you want me to do?
- 11:10And then there's the whole acting your wage debate that we
- 11:12so often hear when it comes to the corporate conversation.
- 11:15And with how things are going, it really begs the question,
- 11:17like, how have we taken this a little too far?
- 11:19And my answer to this might be a little nuanced.
- 11:20Like I think the saying in this quote can be useful because this
- 11:23can be helpful in jobs where you couldn't care less about a
- 11:26business. But I think in order to find
- 11:28success, you do still got to at least act, even if it is your
- 11:31wage. Like the whole performance of
- 11:33productivity, it sucks, it's stupid, and I personally hate
- 11:35it. I think it is so dumb, but
- 11:37unfortunately it's one of the things that we just got to learn
- 11:40because at the end of the day, work is transactional.
- 11:43And that's not saying that you should just like excuse
- 11:45everything and just let everything fly by without asking
- 11:47for it, demanding more. I think there still needs to be
- 11:49major reforms to the general working environment and work
- 11:52culture. But at the same time, you are
- 11:55hired to fulfil a service of the job description.
- 11:57So we at least got to do that without being handheld.
- 11:59Like, those personal boundaries still 100% should be there
- 12:02because we have learned from the mistakes of previous generations
- 12:05that, like, no matter how much you work and how much you put
- 12:07into a company, they're still not going to care about you or
- 12:09think twice to lay you off, cut your pay or just generally treat
- 12:12you terribly. But it begs the question whether
- 12:14or not the pendulum has shifted too far to the other direction.
- 12:16And I found this TikTok very interesting because, like, yeah,
- 12:19a lot of Gen. Z couldn't get a job in high
- 12:20school because of lockdown. 50% of Gen.
- 12:24Z did not work in high school. That is a huge difference from
- 12:27any generation before them. It's societal progress.
- 12:30It's amazing, but it means that 50% of this generation coming
- 12:34into the workforce did not work for pay, meaning they didn't
- 12:39learn how to show up. They didn't learn how to work
- 12:41with the boss, they didn't learn how to get feedback.
- 12:44They didn't learn how to progress their career.
- 12:46They didn't learn. And so this is their first time
- 12:49learning. Because of that, many, not all,
- 12:53maybe not you or your friends, but many, have the executive
- 12:57functioning skills of teenagers. But that kind of adds support to
- 13:00what I said earlier with missing out on critical social moments
- 13:02that develop these skills. Like these are the kind of
- 13:04skills that are foundational in learning how to earn your
- 13:07dollar, how to work for someone, how to learn customer service,
- 13:10as many of the jobs that are available to high schoolers are
- 13:12mostly in food and retail. And now we got to talk about
- 13:15Gen. Alpha for a quick second,
- 13:16because I think that Gen. Alpha is at a very unique moment
- 13:20in this whole situation around critical thought initiative and
- 13:23essentially wanting to put in the personal work to get the
- 13:26results that you're looking for. In a study about the critical
- 13:33thinking skills in Generation Alpha in Twenty, 2460% of the
- 13:37students demonstrated an average level of critical thinking, 20%
- 13:39showed a high level, and 20% showed a low level.
- 13:42All the children perform best in tasks related to inductive
- 13:45reasoning and fast evaluation, but struggled with analysis and
- 13:48critical assessment of information.
- 13:50And like, no shade to that article because studies are
- 13:52important, but I feel like teachers have been clocking that
- 13:54tea for a while now, saying that more and more they feel the need
- 13:57to over explain themselves. And while I guess school is the
- 13:59environment to ask questions, relearn things to understand,
- 14:02that's not this. Like that's not what's happening
- 14:04here. This was quite possibly one of
- 14:07the most irritating things when I was a teacher.
- 14:09I I've never seen anything like it.
- 14:11Like I would give students a worksheet, I would explain the
- 14:15worksheet, I would go over examples on the worksheet, I
- 14:18would answer questions about the worksheet and I'd check in on
- 14:22the students like 3 minutes later and I'd walk over to a
- 14:24student and they'd be like, I don't I don't get it.
- 14:29Read. Did you read the directions?
- 14:31No. Did you ask a friend for help?
- 14:33No. Did you ask me for help?
- 14:34No. Are you staring at your phone?
- 14:36Yes. Like just the inability to
- 14:39overcome minor hiccups in one's path was crazy to me.
- 14:45The learned helplessness was like the hand holding was
- 14:48something that I just couldn't do.
- 14:50And I taught high school so I was hoping this would not be the
- 14:52case, but this was something that and drove me nuts.
- 14:56Teachers are having to lead the horse to water, so to speak,
- 14:58multiple times like they're having to wrangle that horse to
- 15:00the same pond and back multiple times in the same day.
- 15:04And it's only getting more noticeable with Gen.
- 15:06Alpha. But it certainly started with
- 15:08Gen. Z because while we're the first
- 15:09generation that grew up with technology, Gen.
- 15:12Alpha is going to be the first generation that grew up with AI.
- 15:14And as we know from that MIT study on AI, ChatGPT users had
- 15:18the lowest rate engagement and consistently underperformed at
- 15:22neuro linguistic and behavioral levels, Basically consistent AI
- 15:25I use eroding critical thinking skills.
- 15:27And I can only imagine that this lack of initiative and
- 15:29self-sufficiency is only going to worsen with the next
- 15:32generation if we're already seeing this in this one.
- 15:34Like again, we already live in a world where information is just
- 15:36thrown at us and we're trained and expected to just take it at
- 15:39face value. Like we see it with the way that
- 15:40our media has evolved. We see it with the way that our
- 15:42news has evolved, the way that we consume news.
- 15:44Oftentimes, news outlets just giving out inflammatory or
- 15:47eye-catching headlines and then providing like a three sentence
- 15:50summary of like what they consider to be the main points
- 15:53that are important that almost always leave without the
- 15:55important context to explain the story and reasoning behind the
- 15:58headline. But that was a quick aside.
- 16:00Getting back to the studies of it all, while the MIT studies
- 16:02serve by people from 18 to 39, which thus including
- 16:05millennials, it's important to consider who's using it most.
- 16:07And I do think scrutiny falls on younger people because they are
- 16:11entering entry level positions or at least different schools.
- 16:14So they're more likely to be observed by teachers, managers,
- 16:17and bosses. But so far in this conversation,
- 16:19we've talked a lot about how this lack of initiative has been
- 16:22impacting US career wise, professionally and tangential in
- 16:25schools. But I think that this general
- 16:27lack of initiative does trickle down into other facets of life.
- 16:34Like, let's ask ourselves, does the loss of critical thinking
- 16:37and self advocacy extend the past, the academic and
- 16:40professional? Yeah.
- 16:42And this is purely observational.
- 16:43But I do think that this plays out in our social scenarios.
- 16:46Again, not every situation is the same.
- 16:47And this isn't me blaming you for certain aspects of your life
- 16:50maybe not working out. But I do think this is seen in
- 16:53our friendships and our romantic relationships at the moment.
- 16:55Because think about it, some of the main gripes and problems
- 16:58that we see talked about on social media when it comes to
- 17:00friendship, community and relationships is that no one
- 17:03wants to put in the work and that people are non committal,
- 17:05non commutative, not emotionally regulated.
- 17:07And I think some of that can be attributed to the lack of
- 17:10initiative that we see from us. And again, when it comes to the
- 17:13friendships and the romantic aspect, we do have other videos
- 17:15going more in depth in that. But when it comes to things like
- 17:18building community and these struggles that people express
- 17:20with that, with that being like the lack of people following up
- 17:23or the general maintenance that's required or personal
- 17:25relationships, like sending those follow up texts, going to
- 17:27events that you don't necessarily 100% feel like going
- 17:30to, or just even being forward or proactive with establishing,
- 17:33making and maintaining plans. Like when you want to make
- 17:35plans, establish a date, time, place and location.
- 17:37Babes. Like why does it feel like when
- 17:39you want to hang out with people, you've got to hold your
- 17:40hand through the whole process to jump through so many hoops
- 17:42just to meet with people you already know you like in real
- 17:45life. And don't even get me started on
- 17:47dating. Like the lack of initiative
- 17:48that's taken in dating from both sides is kind of crazy.
- 17:51Like, what do you mean? What do you bring to the table?
- 17:53What do you mean you want a hunch on me?
- 17:54Like table dinner first, but you won't even plan that.
- 17:58And I do almost believe that we have this irrational fear is
- 18:00like coming across as annoying or too clingy or like caring too
- 18:03much or like being too shalant. If you ask follow up questions
- 18:07are just too eager to plan things out right away.
- 18:09Like I always think of that one meaning of like Squidward in
- 18:11like the box when he's like homeless and people are like,
- 18:13this is what it feels like to ask your friends to hang out,
- 18:16which real? But I do also think that we need
- 18:18to detach from that idea or at least reframe it and see it as
- 18:21taking initiative. Like, if you want to go see that
- 18:23movie with friends, you better ask them.
- 18:25At least hand them down a little bit.
- 18:26Like, it's OK to want things. And I feel like when it comes to
- 18:29the social side of this all, we as a generation have idolized
- 18:31the sense of detachment in the sense of nonchalance, the sense
- 18:34of numbness that comes with social interaction, where work
- 18:37is like, oh, we don't need to chase anyone or chase any social
- 18:39interaction. Like, if it's meant for us,
- 18:41it'll come for us. And in some cases that is true.
- 18:43And there are pieces of that that are true.
- 18:46But I think we also do need to acknowledge that we need to put
- 18:49in work to have things arrive to us.
- 18:51Like not chasing does not mean not putting an effort because
- 18:54the chase is to pursue something without reciprocation almost
- 18:57indefinitely. What I'm asking is to put in a
- 18:59little bit of that elbow grease, to put in a little bit of that
- 19:01effort to get the outcomes and efficiently attract the outcomes
- 19:04that you're trying to perceived. And I really don't want this
- 19:07come across as like a dig towards us as Gen.
- 19:10Z, and I don't want to give older generations any more
- 19:12ammunition to rag on us. But I do think there is some
- 19:14merit in what is being said. I also do think that older
- 19:17generations are doing too much with it and are refusing to also
- 19:21acknowledge their participation and involvement in the
- 19:24cultivation and contribution of this behavior.
- 19:26Like again, there are reasons why we're like this and y'all
- 19:29are also like this too. It just presents a little
- 19:32differently per generation. But trust and believe you will
- 19:36be dealt with.