Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Self-Assess Your Campaign | Politics with Paul #103
Transcript
- 0:00Come back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about one of the most critical parts of a campaign.
- 0:13That's how to assess the strengths and weaknesses in a campaign.
- 0:18Back in my grad school days at the University of Florida, I was in their political
- 0:23campaigning program.
- 0:24And in my first semester, we had a class that was simply called political campaigning.
- 0:29And eventually, we were given a Florida state house race that was going to happen the year
- 0:34after.
- 0:35So that that was in 2018.
- 0:37My first semester was in 2017.
- 0:39And we had to create a campaign plan for either the democrat or the republican that was
- 0:44expected to be in the general election.
- 0:49And a core piece of that campaign plan, one of the earliest things that we learned in that
- 0:54class is what is called a SWOT analysis, s w o t.
- 1:00SWOT is an acronym for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats.
- 1:05It's a two by two matrix with strengths at the top left, weaknesses in the top right,
- 1:11opportunities in the bottom left, and threats in the bottom right.
- 1:16And what you do is exhaustively list everything, and I do mean everything about the
- 1:22candidate and the election, the actual race that they're running in that can be either a
- 1:29boon or a bane to that candidate's campaign.
- 1:33And this analysis is a critical piece to figuring out campaign strategy, crafting the
- 1:39right messages for voters, effectively countering strategy from the opposition.
- 1:44Basically, anything that the campaign needs to do, a lot of it is informed by this SWAT
- 1:50analysis.
- 1:50And if you don't do the SWAT analysis properly, your campaign is going to fail at some point.
- 1:57So maybe you're thinking of working on a campaign.
- 2:00Maybe you're actually wanting to run for office yourself, and it doesn't matter if it's local,
- 2:05state, federal, really anything you're running for.
- 2:09And it doesn't even have to be for a candidate either.
- 2:11It could be for a ballot measure or for pushing for passage of a bill in congress or a state
- 2:18legislature.
- 2:19The basic tenets of a SWOT analysis can also be applied to nonpolitical context such as
- 2:24marketing words also used a lot.
- 2:27And aren't campaigns ultimately about marketing anyway?
- 2:30Or maybe you're just curious about the finer details of politics and the details of how
- 2:36campaigns work is one of those things.
- 2:39Whatever the reason you wanna know, I've got you covered.
- 2:42And so here is how campaigns assess or at least should assess the factors on their side and
- 2:49against them.
- 2:50And failure to do so properly can mean the difference between winning and losing the
- 2:55election.
- 2:55Now why is it that many campaigns falter in evaluating their campaigns?
- 3:00It seems kind of obvious to list strengths and weaknesses in your campaign.
- 3:07But even though these things are so important to do, these campaign self assessments, not
- 3:12every campaign is good at it.
- 3:13In fact, many of them aren't.
- 3:15And even if one campaign isn't good at it, the opposition might not be good at it either.
- 3:20So the one that does win may not even realize that their SWAT analysis stinks just because
- 3:26the other side was even worse at it.
- 3:31The thing is candidates and their campaign teams, a lot of times, have trouble being
- 3:38completely honest with themselves, and it's for several reasons.
- 3:41Part of human nature is that we downplay or disregard the faults of ourselves and the
- 3:47people we agree with, and then we exaggerate or overly focus on the faults of the people we
- 3:52don't agree with.
- 3:53And a lack of self awareness is rampant in politics where a candidate or campaign can't
- 3:59see their issues or think they don't have any problems in their campaign.
- 4:04But it's not always a matter of self awareness or dishonesty or anything like that.
- 4:10Sometimes it's just flat out embarrassment.
- 4:12I mean, do any of
- 4:13us want to admit something that we really don't like about ourselves?
- 4:18Do we wanna admit that openly?
- 4:19Of course, we don't.
- 4:21Or even if
- 4:21you're not admitting it to the public, you don't necessarily wanna admit it to the people
- 4:25on your campaign team.
- 4:27That's natural too.
- 4:28So something like a scandal or an awful comment you made in the past, like a gaffe you put your
- 4:34foot in your mouth.
- 4:35All those kinds of things are painful to admit.
- 4:38Or if you aren't the candidate, maybe you are afraid to tell the candidate things that are
- 4:44wrong with them because you're afraid that they're not gonna listen.
- 4:47They may demote you.
- 4:48They may fire you from the campaign.
- 4:51Maybe they're one of those quote unquote toxic positivity types where it's just it's always
- 4:56gotta be everything is is is great and hunky dory, and anybody who says otherwise needs to
- 5:02be pushed out.
- 5:04That's unfortunately, that is a thing that happens even in political campaigns.
- 5:11But you have to be able to put yourself in the shoes of various people, especially voters,
- 5:17because these are the people who are going to decide whether they choose you or not.
- 5:21Even if you think something is not a problem, it may not be a problem personally for you, but
- 5:27it may be a problem for some other voters, including ones that you absolutely need to win.
- 5:32Or you might think a voter's grievance isn't legitimate or it's unfair.
- 5:36And you know what?
- 5:37Maybe it is.
- 5:39Maybe it is a ridiculous thing that they don't like about you, but you still have to account
- 5:44for it.
- 5:45Anything that could possibly hinder your campaign, especially if you're running for an
- 5:50election that's expected to be tight, that's supposed to be a toss-up, you have to you have
- 5:55to be aware of any of these things that can and will be used against you.
- 5:59There's people that get paid a lot of money to do opposition research on you or oppo for
- 6:06short.
- 6:07And so you really have to be as thorough as you can with these things.
- 6:13And, also, these SWAT analyses are amendable throughout the campaign too.
- 6:18Sometimes even when people do have a good analysis of these strengths and weaknesses and
- 6:23opportunities and threats, they almost treat these things as static and unchanging, and they
- 6:30don't revisit these analyses.
- 6:34And that's not how they should be treated either.
- 6:36These are not static.
- 6:37Campaign plans in general are not static.
- 6:40Campaign seasons are long slogs, and lots of things are going to change during that time.
- 6:49And so you can revisit your plan and make changes when necessary.
- 6:54So now on to the actual details of these SWAT analysis, and let's compare strengths and
- 7:01weaknesses.
- 7:02These are mostly focused on your candidate or if you're on a campaign for a ballot measure or
- 7:08to try to get a legislative bill passed.
- 7:11These are things that are more controllable by the candidate.
- 7:16And what is it about your candidate specifically that can boost or hinder that
- 7:21candidate's campaign.
- 7:23And doesn't necessarily have to be things that most voters can see.
- 7:25It might be things that you see more internally, like the ability to fundraise.
- 7:31That's not necessarily things that most voters are going to see.
- 7:34So these are things like character traits.
- 7:37What are the skills that that candidate has?
- 7:40Their career background, their party affiliation, their physical attractiveness.
- 7:45Yes.
- 7:45None of us want to admit it, or a lot of us don't wanna admit it, but physical
- 7:50attractiveness does sway some people's votes.
- 7:53It doesn't necessarily completely change their vote, but it also makes us more amenable to
- 8:00listening to somebody that we might not otherwise agree with.
- 8:04The candidate's demographic profile, their name recognition, the endorsements that they have,
- 8:10if they are an incumbent, any prior actions that they've taken or have been involved in or
- 8:16previous comments they've made, their ability to fundraise.
- 8:19All of these things are to some extent things that candidates have control over more
- 8:25directly.
- 8:26And so, obviously, a strength of of these is any of these things that can be treated as a
- 8:31positive aspect of the candidate.
- 8:33So character traits that people like.
- 8:35Do people like that this candidate is seen as affable or this somewhat nebulous concept of
- 8:43authenticity, which I did an episode on not too long ago.
- 8:47If people perceive that candidate to be authentic or that they're considered strong and
- 8:55tough and that they'll they'll stand up to all these bad people, Or do they have good skills?
- 9:02Are they really good at public speaking?
- 9:05Or do they have really good body language?
- 9:07Or do they have expertise in certain issues that are gonna be relevant to that campaign?
- 9:14And relatedly, do they have a relevant career background in that?
- 9:18So if health care is going to be the driving issue in that campaign, maybe that candidate is
- 9:27somebody who has a background in health care, like they're a doctor or a nurse or an
- 9:32executive in health care.
- 9:34Does the district have more of an affinity for that candidate's party?
- 9:37So if you're a democrat in a democratic district or you're a republican in a republican
- 9:42district, that's a
- 9:43strength.
- 9:45If your candidate is good looking, we like somebody who's pretty.
- 9:52Or is the candidate demographically similar to the area that they are running for office in?
- 9:57So, for example, if it's a Black candidate in a majority minority district, that can play very
- 10:03well.
- 10:03Are they well known?
- 10:04So they already have name recognition because of how long they've been involved in the
- 10:10community, for example.
- 10:12Are they endorsed by officials that are popular with that district?
- 10:15Now as to some extent an outside consideration, but what the candidate does can be a direct
- 10:25directly impact whether they get an endorsement from a certain certain official that is popular
- 10:31with that district.
- 10:32Good publicity in the past.
- 10:34You you were well known for philanthropic endeavors or just working in the community in
- 10:41general.
- 10:41Are you good at fundraising?
- 10:43This is a critical skill.
- 10:45Nobody enjoys fundraising no matter how much money they rake in.
- 10:50Not a single candidate that I can think of actually enjoys fundraising, but you gotta be
- 10:54good at it.
- 10:56Because campaigns cost a lot
- 10:58of money, and some of them cost an exorbitant amount of money.
- 11:03And then obviously, weaknesses are any of these things that could
- 11:06be seen as a negative aspect of the candidate.
- 11:08So character traits that people don't like.
- 11:10Somebody just is perceived to be slimy and sneaky.
- 11:15Maybe it's not fair or legitimate, but maybe that's how they're perceived, and you have to
- 11:19know that people feel that way.
- 11:20They have weak skills like they're not good at public speaking.
- 11:24They have an irrelevant career background.
- 11:26So maybe they're in a very agricultural district, and they don't have a background in
- 11:31farming.
- 11:32Not necessarily that they can't win an election there, but they can't really use their career
- 11:39to say, hey.
- 11:40I'm a lot like the rest of you who are farmers.
- 11:43Actually, no.
- 11:43You're not because you don't have a farming background.
- 11:46So that can be a weakness for a candidate.
- 11:48If the district is more hostile to that party.
- 11:51So if it's a very republican district and you're a democrat, or if it's a very democratic
- 11:55district and you're a republican.
- 11:56If your candidate is not attractive, and, of course, attractiveness is to some extent in the
- 12:02eyes of the beholder, but there are some people that may be more generally considered to be
- 12:07unattractive.
- 12:09Maybe their candidate is demographically dissimilar to the area, so they don't really
- 12:15look much like the constituents over like the average constituent that they represent.
- 12:22They're little known, so they don't have a lot of name recognition.
- 12:25Or maybe they do have name recognition, but they're not viewed very well to begin with.
- 12:32So maybe, like, 80% of people know who this person is, but a majority of them don't like
- 12:37that person already.
- 12:39They're endorsed by unpopular officials.
- 12:41So if you're in a democratic district and you're endorsed by the local Republican party,
- 12:48probably not gonna work out well.
- 12:49Just like if you're in a Republican district and you're endorsed by the local Democratic
- 12:53party, probably not gonna work out well.
- 12:55A bad publicity.
- 12:56Like, you committed some sort of dumb error in the past.
- 12:59You said something really horrible and mean that has just followed you for a long time, or
- 13:05you were involved in a scandal.
- 13:06And then, of course,
- 13:07if you're bad at fundraising, you're probably not
- 13:10gonna go anywhere because you're just not gonna be able to generate enough money to keep
- 13:13yourself in the news or to get more ads on the air and to just generally fund all your
- 13:21campaign expenses.
- 13:22And so all of these strengths and weaknesses run the gamut of minor conveniences and
- 13:27inconveniences to major sticking points and everything in between.
- 13:32You can if you do this analysis, you can sometimes put like, hey.
- 13:35This one is a big strength or a big weakness or a small strength or a small weakness, but you
- 13:41have to list all of these things out.
- 13:43And so sometimes a candidate aspect can also be considered a strength in one election year, but
- 13:49then is a weakness in a different election year.
- 13:52So you're a republican running for the district in two years ago, but there's been an influx of
- 14:02democrats that have come in over those past two years.
- 14:04Now maybe it's actually a weakness in your campaign that you are of that party.
- 14:10But it's not always obvious whether something is a strength or a weakness.
- 14:14So you might have to think things over.
- 14:16Not only that, some things can be both a strength and weakness.
- 14:22What?
- 14:22That doesn't how does that make any sense?
- 14:24How can a strength also be a weakness?
- 14:26How can an asset of a political candidate also be a shortcoming?
- 14:30Well, for one, what plays well with one segment of voters won't necessarily play well with
- 14:36another segment of them, especially if you're in a very tight race.
- 14:39If we go back to the career background, maybe you're a a farmer or you have some sort of
- 14:46agricultural background.
- 14:47And so you have a large agricultural lobbying apparatus, or there's there's a lot of
- 14:53agricultural lobbyists and lobbyists groups that are involved in that district, but there's
- 14:58also another group of of people that are also powerful in that district.
- 15:05Maybe there's manufacturing, and sometimes maybe the manufacturing is at odds with the
- 15:11agricultural sector.
- 15:15So how do you tow that line there?
- 15:18Or you can fumble what should be a strength of your campaign.
- 15:21So if we talk about right now, be this would be more applicable to Republicans where you're
- 15:27running in a Republican district, but you're in a primary right now with several other
- 15:31Republicans, and you being a Republican should be a strength running in that Republican
- 15:37district.
- 15:37But maybe you're not seen as sufficiently supportive of Donald Trump.
- 15:43Or maybe you you could maybe be a democrat who's running, and you're not seen as
- 15:48sufficiently in opposition enough to Donald Trump.
- 15:53So what can be what should be a strength, you
- 16:00might not actually be able to harness very well.
- 16:04Or on the flip side, a weakness can be framed in a different way.
- 16:09Maybe you are an ex convict, and people generally don't like that.
- 16:14But you're able to parlay that into a redemption story where you say, I paid my debt
- 16:21to society, and this is how I've actually given back to my community now.
- 16:26And maybe now, you've actually turned that into strength.
- 16:30Because as much as we like to dog on people for all of their issues and things that they do
- 16:37wrong, we also love a good redemption story.
- 16:39So that could play well in a district.
- 16:42Whatever the case may be, you have to really make sure that your strength is a strength and
- 16:48your weakness is a weakness and that you can't actually turn that weakness into a strength and
- 16:54that especially that you don't turn that strength into a weakness because that can very
- 16:58easily happen.
- 17:01Now how about opportunities and threats?
- 17:04So these are mostly focused on outside factors that can propel your candidate or throw an
- 17:10obstacle in their way.
- 17:11So it's more external environment and and climate and also related to the other
- 17:18candidates in the election as well, especially if it they're in the opposition party if you're
- 17:24running as a republican against democrat or democrat against a republican or if you're
- 17:28running as an independent against a republican or a democrat.
- 17:31And so these are less controllable things by the candidate, and they're they require much
- 17:36more reactiveness and proactiveness.
- 17:40Some things are gonna come up in the election in in the race, and you're going to not be able
- 17:46to predict them, and you're gonna be have to
- 17:48be on your toes and be able to respond accordingly.
- 17:52Other things, you'll be have
- 17:55to be more proactive in, and you'll be able to be because you already listed all those
- 17:59potential threats and opportunities that you can, you know, the opportunities that you can
- 18:05take advantage of and the threats that you try to minimize.
- 18:07And so examples like that are the national political climate.
- 18:12If if your candidate isn't running for president is that's more relevant because
- 18:16you're not running for the entire nation.
- 18:19You're running for a a statewide race or a district, so only a section of that state.
- 18:27Yeah.
- 18:28The debate potential for debates.
- 18:30If if there's planned debates there, whether they're already set up in the first place or,
- 18:37you know, as a candidate, you're trying to call for debates to be held.
- 18:42And if there's some sort of spot in the campaign calendar where that can happen.
- 18:49Interviews and public speaking engagements, the opportunities for those because whether they're
- 18:55fewer or more of them, those can be opportunities or threats depending on your
- 19:02candidate.
- 19:03What your opponent or opponents do well or poorly, whether it's a matter of their
- 19:08character or their skills, polling trends, salient political issues, the economy, all
- 19:14these things are things that your candidate or you, if you are the candidate, have less
- 19:19control over.
- 19:21And so you have to react or be proactive in responding to those things.
- 19:26And so opportunities are whatever of those things that can be used to your campaign's
- 19:30advantage.
- 19:31So maybe the national political climate favors your party.
- 19:35Right now, we're in a midterm year, and so the headwinds right now favor Democrats, and they
- 19:39do not favor Republicans.
- 19:42And so if you're a Republican running in a district that is more balanced or only slightly
- 19:51Democratic or even if it's slightly Republican, that might hinder you because of your ties to
- 19:59Donald Trump.
- 19:59And midterms are always or almost always unfavorable to the party in power nationally.
- 20:07And in this case, it's republicans with them holding majorities in the US house and US
- 20:12senate and holding the presidency with Donald Trump at the helm.
- 20:17Debates can also be opportunities for you if your candidate is good at public speaking or
- 20:23they're trying to get their name out there.
- 20:25So you say, well, debates are a really good avenue for doing so.
- 20:29Let me get my name out there and start arguing for my views.
- 20:35And so you gotta be careful with debates because in general elections, they're not all
- 20:42that persuasive or at least they tend to have short term effects.
- 20:46But if you're in a primary, a debate can be a really good platform if because people are
- 20:52still trying to figure out who to vote for for their party.
- 20:57Favorable polling data.
- 20:58So if your if people know who you are so so name recognition is a
- 21:05as a common thing in polling.
- 21:08So if you have high name recognition, but people are neutral about you, they don't really
- 21:13know what they think about you.
- 21:14Well, now that's an opportunity that says, hey, They don't dislike me.
- 21:17So here's my chance to make them like me.
- 21:20And they already know who I am, so I don't have to tell them who I am.
- 21:23But let me tell them why they should like me.
- 21:26A salient issue that your candidate has experienced with.
- 21:29So maybe you are a doctor or a nurse, and right now, health care is the big thing in your
- 21:37district because of whether it's nationally or statewide or in your district, certain events
- 21:46related to health care have become more and more important.
- 21:49Well, now as a doctor or nurse, you can or anybody else involved in health care that is
- 21:54seen as a health care worker, probably not as a health care executive, probably not gonna work
- 21:58as well.
- 21:59But if you are a doctor or a nurse or something similar to that, you can use that as an
- 22:04opportunity to bolster your campaign because you are somebody who has more direct experience
- 22:09with health care and serving patients.
- 22:11A good economy with your party in power or a bad economy with your party out of power.
- 22:16So you can use that to say like, hey.
- 22:17Look.
- 22:18The other party is terrible at their job.
- 22:20With us in power, the economy is doing well.
- 22:24So why don't we just keep this train rolling?
- 22:26You should vote for me because I am tied to the party that is in power right now.
- 22:30Now, yes, it's not necessarily saying that that party is actually responsible for the economy
- 22:38being good or bad, but we're talking about campaign strategies here.
- 22:42So this is how they're trying to paint things.
- 22:45This is the angle that these campaigns are taking.
- 22:47So if the economy is doing well, when and you are of the party that's in power, you're gonna
- 22:53try to seize on that.
- 22:55If your party's out of power and the economy is bad, you're gonna seize on that too and say,
- 22:59look how terrible these guys are at running the country.
- 23:02You should vote for me because I am in the team that is not running the show.
- 23:07And then, of course, threats are anything that could be used to disadvantage your campaign.
- 23:12And whether that's from your opponents and their weaknesses or your campaign's errors.
- 23:18So the national climate is against your party.
- 23:21You're probably gonna be facing some headwinds.
- 23:24We go back to debates.
- 23:25If your candidate isn't a good speaker, debates might not be a good idea because your candidate
- 23:31might fumble the opportunity.
- 23:34Doesn't mean that they should avoid the debate because then they might get knocked forward.
- 23:38Well, why are
- 23:38they avoiding debates?
- 23:39But you
- 23:41have to be really careful there.
- 23:42It's a fine line that you're walking.
- 23:45Not enough chances for interviews.
- 23:46So you're just not able to gain enough traction or you're not getting in front of a wide enough
- 23:54audience.
- 23:55Like, you're getting only interviews with small scale media outlets, but not the really big
- 24:01ones.
- 24:02So if you're a republican, but you're not getting on Fox News enough, or if you're a
- 24:06democrat, you're not getting on certain liberal podcasts enough.
- 24:13It that that's that can be a threat to you.
- 24:16Something that your opponent does very well.
- 24:18So if you're a bad public speaker, but the other candidate is a good public speaker, Or
- 24:24unfavorable polling.
- 24:26So you are well known, but your perception is negative.
- 24:32People have a negative opinion about you.
- 24:35That can be unfavorable.
- 24:37A salient issue that your candidate is perceived to be bad at.
- 24:40So if you are a health care executive that's running and health care is a major issue,
- 24:46probably not gonna be a good look for you because generally speaking, people do not have
- 24:49good opinions about health care executives.
- 24:53A bad economy with your party in power or a good economy with your party out of power.
- 24:59So if your party's in power and the economy is bad, your party's gonna be blamed, and you have
- 25:05to be careful about how much you tie yourself to the party at large.
- 25:10And then likewise, if the economy is doing well and your party's not in power, it's it's gonna
- 25:16be harder for you to say, look how terrible things are here, or at least you can't focus on
- 25:21the economic aspects.
- 25:23You have to focus more on some social issues, for example.
- 25:28And so there's all sorts of different avenues you can go with for opportunities and threats.
- 25:36But just like how a strength can be a weakness or a weakness can become a strength, depending
- 25:41on the situation, an an opportunity can also become a threat, and a threat can also become
- 25:47an opportunity.
- 25:49The timing of these things matters greatly.
- 25:52So there could be a significant national event that can heavily influence a campaign.
- 25:57We're talking about the, for example, the war in Iran, how that is having a negative impact
- 26:05on the Republican Party as a whole.
- 26:08So that can suddenly become a threat.
- 26:10And when elections or when these campaigns were started, the Iran war was not even going on at
- 26:16that moment.
- 26:19You can also fumble an opportunity, and then it becomes a threat.
- 26:22So you are using a debate to try to bolster your candidacy, but then you make a really,
- 26:29really dumb error.
- 26:30You just completely put your foot in your mouth, and now all of a sudden, you have to do
- 26:36damage control.
- 26:36One example I can think of is back in 2016, there was the libertarian candidate, Gary
- 26:45Johnson, actually used to be a republican governor over in New Mexico, I believe.
- 26:49But he was running for president, and independents especially need any chance they
- 26:55can get at publicity because they generally have much more trouble getting themselves in
- 27:00the news and on interviews.
- 27:02But they also have an even smaller margin for error than a Democrat or Republican does
- 27:08because of all these perceptions about independents being whether they're considered
- 27:13goofy or they just don't have a chance.
- 27:15And so any gaffe that they make, any error that they commit can can tank any sort of potential
- 27:25that they have.
- 27:26And so for Gary Johnson, he was questioned on at the time what was going on in Syria in the
- 27:33city of Aleppo.
- 27:34And Gary Johnson said, what is Aleppo?
- 27:37And I mean, it's not like he was going to win if he answered that question correctly, but any
- 27:44sort of chance that he did have was significantly tanked at that point.
- 27:52And also, especially for him as a libertarian, libertarians are often considered to be heads
- 27:58in the sand because they generally are opposed to any sort of foreign intervention.
- 28:05So especially for independents, you have to really be careful of these threats.
- 28:11But any it it could still apply that to democrats or republicans where there's
- 28:15something that they absolutely should know, and they screw it up.
- 28:19And all of a sudden, now they're they've become a laughing stock.
- 28:23And in the same vein, though, you can also take what should be a threat to your candidate and
- 28:28turn it into an opportunity.
- 28:30So something that is a threat to your candidate, maybe that's actually also a threat
- 28:34to your opponent too.
- 28:36And so that could become an opportunity.
- 28:38Maybe you both are terrible at fundraising, but your opponent just happens to be worse at
- 28:44fundraising than you are.
- 28:45I mean, obviously, it could still be a problem for you, but you can turn that into an
- 28:49opportunity because you have a better chance at raising more money.
- 28:54Or what was once a threat can suddenly become an opportunity.
- 28:58So if we say
- 29:01just making this up as an example, I'm not
- 29:04saying that this is or isn't the case, but if we say Donald Trump is considered to be strong
- 29:08on foreign policy, but
- 29:10now with the Iran war, now all of
- 29:13a sudden people are turning on him and saying, well, now he's using too much force.
- 29:16Now that threat of, well, foreign policy was considered to be a strong point for
- 29:21Republicans. Now
- 29:21Now it's suddenly becoming an a threat to them.
- 29:25And if you're a Democrat, what was once a threat is now becoming an opportunity because
- 29:28now your party might be looked to for what we should do on foreign policy.
- 29:35And so these these analyses into what your candidate does well, what they don't do well,
- 29:43and what could help or hinder your campaign, it can it can take a while, but it's it's very,
- 29:49very important.
- 29:51And you can see that in a lot of actual examples of campaigns that we've seen.
- 29:58So with all these things in mind about strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and
- 30:01threats, now let's look at more practical applications of SWAT analyses in certain case
- 30:08studies.
- 30:10Campaign plans are rarely ever released to any extent in the public.
- 30:15Not gonna say that they never are because I don't think you can actually say that,
- 30:20But you rarely if you are working on
- 30:24a campaign, you rarely ever want to release your plan, either in part and especially not in
- 30:29full.
- 30:30You don't want to invoke public ridicule, for example, potential ridicule because somebody
- 30:35looks at something you said, and they're like, what?
- 30:38They really thought that that was a good
- 30:39idea?
- 30:41Maybe something that they thought was a strength that people if they're if the SWAT
- 30:46analysis becomes more public, somebody might look at that and say, why would you think
- 30:52that's a strength?
- 30:52Why would you think that's a weakness?
- 30:53And then that becomes more fodder for for media outlets to make stories about whether they're
- 30:59clickbait or not.
- 31:00Some info might be proprietary and belong to whoever runs the campaign.
- 31:04So there might be an actual organization that helps out that campaign, but they don't want to
- 31:12give any sort of information to their competitors about how they create campaign
- 31:18plans and SWAT analyses because then that competitor can eventually come and say to
- 31:24anybody who's so if company a is working for this candidate and how they create campaign
- 31:30plans gets out, company b can use that information to make their campaign plans
- 31:38better, but also to go to other candidates, prospective candidates that want to hire
- 31:43company a service and say, oh, company b can say, oh, no.
- 31:46No.
- 31:46Actually, you know what?
- 31:47Here's what we actually do better than them.
- 31:50And so you don't want your competition to get ahold of that.
- 31:52And then you especially don't want your opposition politically to gain any more insight
- 31:57into your strategy.
- 31:58So if you're a democratic organization and a republican organization gets ahold of that
- 32:04information, they can see how you strategize and then are more effective at counteracting
- 32:10anything that that democratic organization organization does in the future.
- 32:15Or, of course, if a democratic organization gets a hold of how a republican organization
- 32:21does their campaign strategies.
- 32:23So all sorts of understandable reasons why campaign plans in part or in full would never
- 32:30be released.
- 32:32Again, there might be a few instances where that does happen.
- 32:36There probably is.
- 32:37I just don't know of them off the top of my head.
- 32:39And SWAT analyses are definitely a big thing that you would not want to get out, especially
- 32:46if you are honest and thorough in your campaign and you do list the weaknesses or threats to
- 32:51your campaign.
- 32:52Now the opposition has that and realizes if your campaign if your candidate decides to run
- 32:59an election again, they can use those weaknesses and threats that you listed against
- 33:03you.
- 33:04So you wanna keep those things as tight as possible to some extent, but talk about that in
- 33:09a moment.
- 33:10There are there's also some reporting done on the internal workings of a campaign, especially
- 33:16in these postmortems where the campaign has finally suspended operations, which really just
- 33:23means that they've ended operations, but they don't wanna act completely take themselves off
- 33:28of the ballot.
- 33:30And so you'll see journalists report on those kinds of things like, oh, the final days of
- 33:35such and such or where this campaign went wrong.
- 33:38But the actual physical campaign plan will most likely not be available.
- 33:42So you probably won't be able to see the actual strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and
- 33:46threats listed or any of the other strategic or tactical considerations for that campaign that
- 33:54are not necessarily directly related to that SWAT analysis.
- 33:58But while you don't have evidence necessarily to verify whether or not they did a sound SWAT
- 34:04analysis and self assessment of the campaign, you can suspect whether their analysis was done
- 34:11well based on the candidate's actions and their responses to campaign related events and
- 34:18basically anything that the campaign says or does or that the candidate says or does.
- 34:23And there's many, many examples of politicians you can choose from, but I think a particularly
- 34:28good example to use in this case would be one that's very recent, Graham Platner and Maine.
- 34:33So Platner was in case you don't know or in case you need a refresher, he was running for
- 34:38US senate against Susan Collins, and he just suspended his campaign.
- 34:44And now Maine has a new democrat that is running in his place.
- 34:49But for Grant Plattner, there are quite a few potential opportunities to seize on.
- 34:54The national climate is against republicans this year in 2026, generally speaking.
- 34:59And his opponent, who's the incumbent, Susan Collins, she's sometimes at odds with Donald
- 35:06Trump and publicly so.
- 35:08So she's possibly not gonna be as strongly backed by Republicans this time, certainly not
- 35:13by Donald Trump, even if he gives a more tepid endorsement.
- 35:17But even if he gives a somewhat of an endorsement, there are going to be Republicans
- 35:22up there who say, well, you know what?
- 35:23Susan Collins has not been sufficiently supportive enough of Donald Trump, and they may
- 35:28just sit at home.
- 35:29But he also Graham Plattner has had some potential strengths to lean on.
- 35:34He had more of a common person background, a regular person background as an oyster farmer,
- 35:40and he had a populist leaning that was working fairly well.
- 35:43And he was doing decently well in fundraising and gaining support and polling.
- 35:48But Graham Plattner's candidacy was also marked by several controversies that he did not do
- 35:53well in preparing for or responding to.
- 35:56For one, he had a Nazi tattoo that he had covered up, and he said he did not know what it
- 36:01meant, though a couple of people that knew him said he didn't know the meaning of it when he
- 36:06got those tattoos or that tattoo.
- 36:09He also had Reddit posts in the past that advocated for violence, that he said he went to
- 36:15war basically to because he enjoyed killing people, something along those lines.
- 36:20He also downplayed sexual assault concerns, and he has since said he has disavowed those posts,
- 36:26but those posts happened.
- 36:29And there were also reports that he or that his wife told a campaign aide that Plattner had
- 36:35been sexting multiple women.
- 36:36And he said that stopped before the campaigning, and he got counseling for it.
- 36:40And then lastly, what ultimately did him in was that a former girlfriend accused him of raping
- 36:46and abusing her.
- 36:47And, of course, he denies that.
- 36:49So let's look at this through the eyes of a SWAT analysis.
- 36:53Any issues in the past, even if they were resolved or your candidate has changed as a
- 36:58person, those have to be internally and discussed or dis internally discussed and
- 37:03listed on that SWAT analysis.
- 37:05Doesn't matter how embarrassing it is or whether you have moved on.
- 37:08You have to talk about them because it's going to come up.
- 37:12There's lots of people that get paid lots of money to do opposition research on you, and
- 37:17they're going to find out, especially when you run for something like US senate.
- 37:21It's going to come out.
- 37:24You may think you're gonna be able to hide it, but it's gonna come up at some point.
- 37:27Maybe not in this election, but it'll come up in another election that you run for or while
- 37:31you're in office.
- 37:34And in campaigns, negatives are often more powerful than positives.
- 37:38It's human nature to latch onto the negatives, when it's a candidate we aren't predisposed to
- 37:44like.
- 37:45And it's why negative campaigning works so well despite us saying, oh, we're so tired of all
- 37:50this negative campaigning.
- 37:52Can't we just have something more positive?
- 37:54Well, no.
- 37:54Because we respond more to negative campaigning even if we don't want to admit it.
- 37:59And so while it's all well and good to capitalize on your strengths and opportunities,
- 38:03and you should, you must be prepared for lines of attack because they will happen, and there
- 38:08is always something to attack you on even if you don't think it's a problem.
- 38:15But candidate assessments like Graham Platner's bring up another critical question, and that's
- 38:21how do you get out in front of these potential threats to your campaign?
- 38:26So it's this divide between keeping things internal and externally sharing things.
- 38:34Again, you don't want to share your SWAT analysis with the public, but does it behoove
- 38:41your campaign to bring up any weaknesses or threats publicly before the opposition gets a
- 38:47hold of it.
- 38:49It's not always a clear answer, and some voters won't care whether you have changed or not or
- 38:54whether you have resolved an issue.
- 38:56And even though voters say they want honest candidates, being too honest can hurt that
- 39:02candidacy.
- 39:03So let's say, you know, he brought up the fact that he got that tattoo.
- 39:07And let's just let's just say whether we believe him or not, let's just take him at his
- 39:10word for this moment and say that he didn't know what that Nazi tattoo meant, and he got it
- 39:17covered up.
- 39:18And he was being honest about that.
- 39:20Well, would that have been better if he brought that up before it became an issue so that you
- 39:27can now turn that weakness into a strength and say, oh, well, you know what?
- 39:30He was actually very honest about that.
- 39:32He said that this thing he did in
- 39:34the past was not something he should have done, and here is him trying to
- 39:40make amends for that.
- 39:42Him not bringing up anything like that before, now you can be seen as a hypocrite.
- 39:50Again, whether or not he was honest or not, that's beside the point here.
- 39:55It's completely antithetical to how he painted himself as a candidate while he was running.
- 40:04And you can say the same thing about these Reddit posts that advocated for violence or
- 40:08downplayed sexual assault concerns.
- 40:11That is antithetical to the platform that he was running on.
- 40:16Would it have been better for him to have gone out in front of him and said, by the way, I
- 40:20made these posts.
- 40:22I'm not this person anymore.
- 40:23He could have possibly turned that into a way to say, actually, this guy is very honest.
- 40:29He he brought this up before anybody else did.
- 40:32But maybe people won't listen to that, and they'll just hear that, oh, we got a Nazi
- 40:37tattoo.
- 40:38What a jerk.
- 40:38What a terrible person.
- 40:40Which, yeah, obviously, should not be getting Nazi tattoos.
- 40:43And ignorance is not an excuse, but would that necessarily have been better for him to bring
- 40:49up beforehand?
- 40:52Maybe, maybe not.
- 40:55I can't I can't say for certain that it would, but it might have actually worked out better
- 40:59for him if he brought it up before so that the opposition didn't get to attack him as harshly
- 41:05on it.
- 41:06Now, obviously, it would be ideal to not have any rapists and abusers in office because they
- 41:10have no business being there.
- 41:12They certainly have no business running for it.
- 41:14But at the same time, you're not gonna expect somebody to say, oh, by the way, a former
- 41:19girlfriend says I sexually assaulted her.
- 41:22Yeah.
- 41:22There nobody's going to say that.
- 41:24But you still have to be thorough and examine any potential lines of attack.
- 41:30Even if you don't see things the way that somebody else does, you have to be aware of
- 41:36those things.
- 41:36And you have to put yourself in the shoes of voters who are gonna be choosing you and of the
- 41:42people you have personally interacted with in the past.
- 41:46Because if you're not,
- 41:48it's like you saw with Graham Plattner, is going to tank your candidacy.
- 41:53Whether your candidacy regardless of whether you were a good candidate or not or whether you
- 41:58had, quote, unquote, the right policies or not.
- 42:03You're talking strictly from a strategy perspective here.
- 42:09So you have to be a
- 42:12lot better in putting yourself in the minds of other people, which a lot of people, not just
- 42:17in politics, but a lot of people in general are just not good at.
- 42:21So SWAT analyses are an incredibly vital part of your campaign plan because if you don't do
- 42:30it right, it's probably gonna come back to bite you as you saw with Grant Plattner.
- 42:35So you have to think about what your strengths are, what your weaknesses are, what your
- 42:39opportunities to help your campaign are, what are the threats to hindering your that are
- 42:43gonna hinder your campaign or potentially hinder your campaign, and think about any ways
- 42:47that you can turn those weaknesses into strengths, ways you can turn those threats into
- 42:51opportunities, and ways to make sure that those strengths don't become weaknesses and that
- 42:55those opportunities don't become threats.
- 42:57And you can amend that SWAT analysis over time.
- 43:02But make sure if you are running for office or if you are working for somebody running for
- 43:10office that you are as thorough as possible in all those respects.
- 43:15And that's gonna do it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 43:19As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 43:22And if you're on YouTube watching, please like, share, and subscribe this podcast.
- 43:27That's on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple podcast.
- 43:30Any help you can provide is greatly appreciated in spreading the word and helping to improve
- 43:36civic education, political education that is so important to me and to what I do.
- 43:43And links in the show notes, my works, like my five day educational email course about how we
- 43:49can all more effectively mitigate toxicity and polarization in politics.
- 43:56My book on political independence and on on Amazon is on several other retailers, but the
- 44:03link to the Amazon page is is gonna be in the show notes.
- 44:07Mymedium.com profile where I write on from time to time.
- 44:11And also my other links, my Facebook, LinkedIn, website, and email.
- 44:16So that's where I'll leave you today.
- 44:19Thank you so much for listening and watching, and we'll see you next time.