Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 95
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder, True crime cases five four, three, two, one one
- 0:21one one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure
- 0:30you are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, So let's
- 0:34get started. A night of pure hell robbery turned acid, torture, then
- 0:44murder. On the evening of April twenty second, nineteen seventy four, three
- 0:51men entered the High Fi shop in Ogden, Utah Dale Selby, William Andrews,
- 0:57and Keith Roberts were all in their early twenties and they had a plan
- 1:00to rob the store. The shop was just about to close and the two
- 1:06employees, twenty year old Stanley Walker and eighteen year old Michelle Ansley, were
- 1:11preparing to leave for the night. The three men surprised the employees and forced
- 1:15them into the basement of the store. They then proceeded to rob the store
- 1:19of about twenty five thousand dollars worth of merchandise, including stereos, speakers,
- 1:25and other electronics. The robbery itself was relatively straightforward, but what happened next
- 1:33was truly horrific. While the robbers were still in the store, sixteen year
- 1:38old Byron Nayspit entered the shop to run an errand for his mother. He
- 1:42was also taken hostage by the robbers, who were now holding four people captive
- 1:48in the basement of the store. As the hours wore on, two more
- 1:52people arrived at the High five shop looking for their loved ones. Stanley's father
- 1:57Orin Walker and n and Byron's mother, Carol Peterson Naspit both came to the
- 2:02store to check on their children, they too were taken hostage by the robbers.
- 2:09What followed was a knight of unimaginable horror for the hostages. The robbers
- 2:15subjected them to physical and psychological torture, using a ballpoint pen as a weapon
- 2:20to inflict pain and fear. Over the course of the night, the hostages
- 2:23were forced to drink a corrosive liquid that caused their lips, tongues, and
- 2:28throats to burn and the flesh to peel away from their skin. The robbers
- 2:34also sexually assaulted the female hostages, and at one point they forced the male
- 2:38hostages to perform sexual acts on each other. This was all done in an
- 2:43effort to break the will of the hostages and to ensure that they wouldn't try
- 2:46to escape. As the night wore on, the robbers became increasingly paranoid and
- 2:53agitated. They believed that the police were closing in, and they decided to
- 2:58take drastic action. They shot and killed three of the hostages, Stanley Walker,
- 3:04Michel Annesley and Carol Peterson Nayspit in cold blood. Orrin Walker and Byron
- 3:10Nayspit were also shot, but they somehow managed to survive the attack. They
- 3:15were left with permanent life changing injuries, both physical and psychological, and they
- 3:22were haunted by the events of that night for the rest of their lives.
- 3:25The aftermath of the High Five shop murders was devastating for the families of the
- 3:30victims, the survivors, and the community as a whole. The police launched
- 3:36a massive man hunt for the three robbers, and they were eventually caught and
- 3:38brought to trial. The trial was a spectacle, with the robbers showing no
- 3:44remorse for their actions and the survivors testifying about the horrors they had endured.
- 3:50Dale Selby, William Andrews, and Keith Roberts were all found guilty of murder
- 3:54and other charges, and they were sentenced to death. However, the case
- 4:00was not yet over. The three men appealed their sentences, and the case
- 4:04eventually made its way to the Utah Supreme Court. In a controversial decision,
- 4:10the court overturned the death sentences of Selby and Andrews, ruling that the trial
- 4:15judge had made errors during the sentencing phase of the trial. The executions of
- 4:19Selby and Andrews were delayed for several years as they awaited a new sentencing hearing.
- 4:26The Hyphi Shop murders were one of the most gruesome and shocking crimes in
- 4:30Utah's history. The brutal and senseless killings of innocent people left a lasting impact
- 4:35on the community and the families of the victims. The surviving hostages, or
- 4:41In Walker and Byron Naspitt spent years trying to come to terms with what had
- 4:45happened to them. They both suffered from post traumatic stress disorder and struggled with
- 4:50physical and emotional scars from the attack. The families of the victims also had
- 4:56to grapple with their grief and loss. They had to face the in fact
- 5:00that their loved ones had been taking from them in a truly horrific and cruel
- 5:03way. The case also had a lasting impact on the criminal justice system in
- 5:09Utah. The controversial decision by the State Supreme Court to overturn the death sentences
- 5:14of Selby and Andrews sparked a debate about the use of capital punishment in the
- 5:18state. Despite the passage of time, the hi Phi Shop murders remain a
- 5:24haunting and tragic reminder of the capacity for human cruelty and the devastating consequences of
- 5:30violence. The survivors and the families of the victims continued to mourn their loss
- 5:34and grapple with the aftermath of this heinous crime.