Latest / The Vegan Report / Why Does God Allow Animal Exploitation? With Rabbi Akiva Gersh | Ep. 77
Transcript
- 0:00in our obscurity. In all this vastness, there
- 0:05is no hint that help will come from elsewhere
- 0:08to save us from ourselves. These words were spoken
- 0:13by Carl Sagan and were inspired by the pale blue
- 0:17dot, a picture of Earth taken by the Voyager
- 0:211 space probe from a distance of 6 billion kilometers
- 0:25or 3 .7 billion miles. In the spirit of that
- 0:31insight, I asked today's guest, Rabbi Akiva Gersh,
- 0:36also known as the vegan rabbi, why does God not
- 0:41intervene to stop the horrors of animal exploitation?
- 0:46That kicked off a fascinating conversation about
- 0:49religion and its place in the vegan movement,
- 0:52the nature of evil, antisemitism, and why does
- 0:57Rabbi Akiva think that the fight for animal rights
- 1:01is a holy fight. I am full of admiration for
- 1:07Rabbi Akiva's tireless work of using religious
- 1:11arguments to promote compassion for animals in
- 1:15the Jewish community. Connect with him on Instagram
- 1:19at veganrabbi or visit his website akivagirsch
- 1:23.com. Link in the episode's notes. There's this
- 1:30big problem that we're all aware of in the vegan
- 1:34community, which is animal exploitation. In terms
- 1:38of scale, the scale of this horror, it's unimaginable.
- 1:44There isn't something comparable to think about
- 1:50the billions of animals and the way they are.
- 1:53kept in captivity and then also tortured and
- 1:58killed. So, you know, it's just beyond, it's
- 2:04a category of its own, this type of horror. But
- 2:08then, you know, in... religious communities,
- 2:14and I consider myself a religious person. We
- 2:16believe in all sorts of supernatural beings,
- 2:20starting with God, capital G, but also God, small
- 2:24g, angels, spirits, the list goes on. And sometimes
- 2:31I ask myself, what are they up to? Why are they
- 2:35not intervening? Why is heaven, God, whatever,
- 2:40not doing something? about this horror that is
- 2:44unfolding. And of course, I can hear the skeptics
- 2:50say, because they don't exist. That's why they're
- 2:54not intervening. But what do you make of that
- 2:58question? A really powerful question. It's a
- 3:01really good question. And I'll say, please, God,
- 3:05help me with my answer in answering that question.
- 3:09Look, as a Jew and in Judaism, we believe and
- 3:13we teach the very important place of free will,
- 3:18free choice. And God created this world and God
- 3:21created creation and God created all these creations
- 3:24and this wonderful, magnificent, beautiful, gorgeous,
- 3:29wonderful world that we live in. and gave humans
- 3:32free choice. And that was both the best idea,
- 3:36and I think you could even say the worst idea
- 3:38on some level, with all due love and respect
- 3:40to God, of course, right? I mean, it was God's
- 3:43wisdom. God gave us free choice, but God knew.
- 3:46I mean, as part of the Jewish tradition, I imagine
- 3:49other religious spiritual traditions as well,
- 3:52that God knew with free choice, anything can
- 3:55happen. There's even an oral teaching, it's a
- 4:01teaching in the Jewish oral tradition that says
- 4:05that before humans were created that the angels,
- 4:08basically God asked the angels about creating
- 4:10humans, you know, as this different kind of creation
- 4:13and the angels were against it. The angels were
- 4:15actually against it because of what possibly
- 4:19could happen as a result of us being in the world
- 4:21and with our free will and God created us anyway.
- 4:25So there is great risk in creating A, being with
- 4:28free choice. But to answer your question, I feel
- 4:31like it all comes down to that, that God felt
- 4:34that it was very important that there be one
- 4:37creature in this world, that being the human
- 4:39beings, with free choice. Because with free choice
- 4:43can come incredible and magnificent things, but
- 4:46of course, unfortunately, the opposite can be
- 4:49true as well. So right, we're always, maybe not
- 4:53always, but often whenever there are moments
- 4:56of great challenge and suffering and tragedy.
- 4:59We're like, where is God? This would be a perfect
- 5:01time for God to intervene and save the day. Come
- 5:05down and swoop down and save the day like some
- 5:06magnificent movie scene where all the evil people
- 5:11or doers just get wiped out and good prevails.
- 5:14That's not the kind of world that God created.
- 5:16God created a world where humans are in the world
- 5:18with free will and with free choice. And with
- 5:20that comes great responsibility. and we are meant
- 5:23to. I mean the teachings of Judaism and other
- 5:25traditions as well are filled with moral and
- 5:28ethical teachings to teach us and to show us
- 5:30and to guide us how to use that responsibility
- 5:32and how to use that free choice in the best possible
- 5:35way. Unfortunately, we the human beings have
- 5:38not always made the best choices. Sometimes we've
- 5:41made horrible choices and we continue to make
- 5:43horrible choices and for some reason we are okay
- 5:46doing things that cause such great suffering
- 5:48and pain to other humans and to other creatures.
- 5:53And so God's role here is not to swoop down and
- 5:56save the day. God wants us to do it. We're the
- 6:00ones who are supposed to live the right way.
- 6:02And if we don't live the right way, then to make
- 6:03the corrections and to make the fixings in order
- 6:06to make this world a better place. It's on our
- 6:08shoulders and our shoulders alone. And so, yeah,
- 6:11it's painful for anyone who's sensitive and aware
- 6:15to see the suffering happening in the world.
- 6:17And we want it to be over in a second. Of course,
- 6:18we don't care how it ends. We just want it to
- 6:20be over. But this is the world where humans were
- 6:23created and humans have free will and we're meant
- 6:25to use our free will to solve the problems that,
- 6:27let's be honest, we created ourselves. Sometimes,
- 6:31unfortunately, it takes a while for us to find
- 6:34the solutions or to convince people to use the
- 6:38solutions that have already been found, especially
- 6:40in the case of how we eat and the food choices
- 6:43that we make. Is there a place in Judaism for
- 6:47evil, you know, for the belief that there is
- 6:51like a devil or something, something demonic?
- 6:56I often attribute, you know, or let me put it
- 7:02this way, if there was a evil, I guess the closest
- 7:05thing to it would be animal exploitation. So
- 7:09is there a place for that in Judaism? like there's
- 7:13a lot a lot has been written um about evil good
- 7:17and evil again connected to human free will uh
- 7:21over the thousands of years that judaism has
- 7:23been uh an organized and existing religion in
- 7:28in judaism we we talk about something called
- 7:30the which is the evil inclination okay first
- 7:34of all as you know as a monotheistic uh path
- 7:37we believe that there's one force only one force
- 7:40everything's from God. God is the only force
- 7:43that created and maintains everything in the
- 7:46world. So that of course brings up the big philosophical
- 7:49question that was related to your question before,
- 7:51like how can there be evil in a world that was
- 7:53created by an all -loving and all -good God?
- 7:58But there is a place for evil because of free
- 8:01will. Free choice gives birth to the possibility
- 8:05of humans choosing the opposite of good. And
- 8:10we see that. And while we don't have this belief
- 8:14of any spiritual force really being against God
- 8:17because everything's on God's side, everything's
- 8:19within the realm of God, when it comes down to
- 8:21this world, this physical world that we're in,
- 8:23yes, we the humans do have the possibility of
- 8:27choosing evil. We do have this inner kind of
- 8:29battle between us, between good and evil. We
- 8:31have this evil inclination, and that could, if
- 8:34acted upon, that can come out in all different
- 8:35kinds of ways. You know, selfishness, lack of
- 8:39compassion and greed, stealing, lying on and
- 8:46the like. And unfortunately, humans have and
- 8:50continue to choose that path of selfishness.
- 8:53And when we look at animal exploitation, You
- 8:57know, I think there's a lot of things that lead
- 9:02to that. There's a lot of factors, but I think
- 9:04one very strong factor is one selfishness, just
- 9:07focusing on myself. I don't care. I just like
- 9:09the taste and I want it to be cheap and I want
- 9:12it to be readily available, you know, and not
- 9:16thinking about it and not even caring about what
- 9:18happens behind the scenes, you know, before the
- 9:21animal is turned into a, you know, a piece of
- 9:25food. wrapped in plastic and sold in the supermarkets.
- 9:30I think it's also, in addition to selfishness,
- 9:36I want to say inability, but maybe a better way
- 9:39to say it is not yet tapped into ability to feel
- 9:42the pain and suffering of others, whether those
- 9:45others be humans or non -human creatures in this
- 9:48world. And I think also in there, and I've heard
- 9:51this, is the absurd belief that animals can't
- 9:56feel pain and suffering like we humans can. So
- 9:58I think it's also ignorance. It's a lot of different
- 10:02factors, but all those things that I just mentioned
- 10:05are rooted in evil, in using free will to choose
- 10:11the evil path and the evil side and the one that's
- 10:16not compassionate, that's not... loving and that's
- 10:19not seeking to bring goodness and justice into
- 10:22the world. Fighting this evil is not an easy
- 10:27business. And you know, I've had so many I've
- 10:32talked to so many activists who have felt, you
- 10:36know, burned out and tired and depressed from
- 10:41doing the work of advancing, you know, the vegan
- 10:46cause and being pro -animal. Is there any teaching
- 10:51in Judaism that helps us deal with being faced
- 10:57to that evil and fighting that evil as a weapon
- 11:04for our well -being and safeguarding our sanity
- 11:08in this fight? Right, right, which is so important.
- 11:12It's so important in order not to get burnt out
- 11:15so that we can continue to do this very important,
- 11:18and I even call it holy work. Judaism says a
- 11:21lot about this. You know, Judaism, when you look,
- 11:23when you go deep, when you go deep, when you
- 11:25go deep, Judaism at its core, I think we can
- 11:29say is an activist movement. It's an activist
- 11:33movement. Why? What is an activist movement?
- 11:35An activist movement or activist organization
- 11:37is focused on something that's wrong in the world
- 11:41or broken in the world and they want to fix it.
- 11:43They want to solve it. They want to bring wholeness
- 11:45to where there's brokenness. That's Judaism at
- 11:47its essence. Judaism is literally all about fixing
- 11:50the world. There's a concept called Tikkun Olam,
- 11:53which means fixing the world, literally, which
- 11:55is an ancient Jewish concept. It's talked a lot
- 12:00about in the mystical tradition. but also in
- 12:04the ethics and morals of Judaism, it shows up
- 12:07a lot. And it's really based on this idea that
- 12:09the world has a lot of brokenness in it and we're
- 12:13here to fix it. We can use our free choice. We
- 12:16keep going back to that theme of free choice
- 12:17and we can use a free choice or free will to
- 12:20fix it, but that's what we're supposed to do.
- 12:23And in Judaism, I think the tools that we can
- 12:25use to help us not get burnt out, not get overwhelmed,
- 12:29one is faith. Like the person you mentioned before,
- 12:33faith is very strong in Judaism. And knowing
- 12:35that even if I see so much wrong in the world,
- 12:38first of all, and I'm going to get back to this
- 12:40in a second, there's so much beauty. There's
- 12:42so much beauty in the world as well. We can't
- 12:44forget that. We have to open up our eyes to the
- 12:46constant. Beauty of the world and the constant
- 12:49goodness. It's not all evil. It's not all broken.
- 12:51There's so much Gorgeousness in this world and
- 12:55it's all from God and God created an incredible
- 12:57world And we have to really remember that one
- 13:00for the sake of knowing that you know to recognize
- 13:02the goodness of this world But also it helps
- 13:03us in terms of moving on but coming back to the
- 13:05idea of faith Faith is very strong in Judaism.
- 13:08Obviously, and it's the idea. Okay, you know
- 13:09what? This is how brokenness was built into the
- 13:12world. This is all from God, you know, and God
- 13:16wants us to do the work to fix it, and God's
- 13:19with me, right? God's giving me the strength.
- 13:21My strength comes from God, right? Like King
- 13:23David says, In Psalms, I'll say it in Hebrew
- 13:27because it's so beautiful and then I'll translate
- 13:29it into English. I lift up my eyes to the mountain.
- 13:35Where does my help come from? My help comes from
- 13:39God, makers of the heavens and the earth. So
- 13:42it's constantly, literally daily. constantly
- 13:46tapping into our faith, right? And from that
- 13:48faith comes so much, including the strength to
- 13:50continue on even in the face of challenge and
- 13:53brokenness. And the last thing I'll say just
- 13:54for now is that Judaism has built into it the
- 14:00celebration of life and the celebration of the
- 14:02beauty of the world. And that happens on a weekly
- 14:05level, a monthly level, and an annual level,
- 14:09weekly of Shabbat. Every single week, every seven
- 14:12days, we pause. We rest on Shabbat, on the Sabbath,
- 14:17not only to rest from our work, but also to create
- 14:19space to appreciate the goodness of the world
- 14:21and the beauty of the world. And the classic
- 14:24Jewish teaching is for six days of the week,
- 14:25we're doing our work, we're fixing the world,
- 14:28we're noticing, we're very aware of, even sometimes
- 14:31hyper aware of the brokenness, the challenges
- 14:34of a world, and on Shabbat, On some level, we
- 14:38stop being activists on Shabbat. Because now
- 14:40Shabbat is to fill myself back up, is to say,
- 14:43wow, what a world. What a gorgeous world. Give
- 14:46myself that rest. I'm not going to try to fix
- 14:48anything, either physically or figuratively.
- 14:53And I'm going to tap into the holiness of this
- 14:57day. And that fills me up for another six days
- 14:59after that. to keep doing the work. And then
- 15:01I have another Shabbat. Wow, again, amazing.
- 15:04I have a day of rest and I feel myself back up.
- 15:06Wow, and I go another six days, right? And it's
- 15:09this incredible institution, if you want to call
- 15:12it that, of reconnecting ourselves, plugging
- 15:15ourselves back in so that we have the physical
- 15:17and spiritual strength and ability to keep going
- 15:20on and not burning out. I feel like Shabbat at
- 15:23its core is all about not burning out physically
- 15:25and spiritually and as an activist. That's a
- 15:29priceless priceless tool. You mentioned King
- 15:33David and There's this recent TV series that
- 15:38was released on Prime video I don't know if you
- 15:43if you were aware of it. It's about King David
- 15:47and I guess it's the first time I've watched
- 15:50something, you know a Judaic story adapted to
- 15:57the movie format. This was the first time for
- 16:01me watching Dange. Did you watch it? No. Too
- 16:09bad. I wish I had your feedback on that. But
- 16:13something interesting in that TV series, I noticed
- 16:16as a vegan, of course. is, you know, they talk
- 16:19a lot about, you know, animal sacrifices and
- 16:23they do lots of animal sacrifices, but they never
- 16:26show, you know, the animal itself being sacrificed.
- 16:30You know, they always cut to the scene of here's
- 16:34the meat or whatever, the burnt sacrifice. And
- 16:40I found it very interesting that they would censor
- 16:45that part. you know, and not expose their audience
- 16:49to it. You know, they show armies battling with,
- 16:55you know, people dying left and right. But, you
- 16:59know, the sacrifice of the lamp that they don't
- 17:03show. What do you make of that editing and how,
- 17:08you know, they perceive people to be more sensitive
- 17:12to showing a lamp being sacrificed to armies
- 17:18killing each other. That is very interesting.
- 17:23Yeah, I think I think it's a reflection of human
- 17:29society in our modern -day world that people
- 17:31are disconnected from what really happens behind
- 17:34the scenes when they choose to eat animals and
- 17:37they don't want to see that because they don't
- 17:39want to know or they don't want to be reminded
- 17:40maybe they heard about it saw something once
- 17:42or twice even or three times but they want to
- 17:45forget about it and to be shown that it's a reminder
- 17:50of you know even though that's in the context
- 17:52of you know ancient sacrifices which we don't
- 17:54do anymore it's still a reminder of you know
- 17:57the that yeah it's intense to take an animal's
- 18:00life for your own personal needs whether it's
- 18:02a sacrifice or or for food is an intense thing
- 18:05and you should think about that and you should
- 18:08be aware of that before you do it and people
- 18:10don't want to do that people just want to eat
- 18:12the steak or the hamburger and nothing about
- 18:14what had to happen you know before that and that's
- 18:18that's a problem Um, I, I met people in the past,
- 18:21you know, um, who, you know, they would, they
- 18:23would only chicken if it was like in the form
- 18:26of like a patty, but no bones. Cause if they
- 18:29saw bones, they wouldn't be able to eat it. And
- 18:31it's like, you know, um, and yeah, I think it
- 18:37is a reflection of, of the disconnect today and
- 18:41the real kind of like, don't tell me I don't,
- 18:44I didn't see it. I don't know about it. I don't
- 18:46have to think about it. And then I can just keep
- 18:47doing whatever I want. I'm sure there's a big
- 18:51Jewish audience, you know, watching that TV series.
- 18:55What is the state of, you know, progressive veganism
- 18:59in the Jewish community? I know that, you know,
- 19:03when I look at Buddhists, I wish there were more
- 19:08vegan Buddhists. And I feel strongly that this
- 19:12is the natural way to be a Buddhist, you know,
- 19:17being vegan. that there should be more vegan
- 19:21Buddhists than there are right now. Do you have
- 19:25the same feeling? Yes, I do. I wish there were
- 19:29more Jewish vegans and specifically I wish there
- 19:31were more Orthodox Jewish vegans. As you might
- 19:33know, there's different kind of denominations
- 19:35in the Jewish world. The three main ones are
- 19:38Orthodox, Conservative and Reform. I'm part of
- 19:41the Orthodox Jewish community. um and definitely
- 19:45there's not that many orthodox jewish regans
- 19:47out there and i wish there were more for sure
- 19:49and my you know long story short i i was always
- 19:54jewish but i didn't grow up religious i grew
- 19:56up very secular in a secular family and a secular
- 20:00lifestyle in america i now live in israel um
- 20:04but uh as a result of a spiritual journey in
- 20:08college, searching for spiritual meaning and
- 20:11spiritual traditions, eventually that took me
- 20:14full circle to my own Jewish tradition, inspired
- 20:16actually by the environmental and animal welfare
- 20:20teachings that I discovered in Judaism at the
- 20:22age of 19 and 20, which nobody told me about.
- 20:25I was already at that point vegan. I went vegetarian
- 20:28when I was 18, vegan when I was 19. I'm now 49.
- 20:33So this fall, God willing, I'll be celebrating
- 20:3530 years of being vegan. And it was an environmental
- 20:40studies major and the environmental movement
- 20:42was a big part of my life. And I never knew anything
- 20:45about Judaism and the environment or Judaism
- 20:47and animal welfare. And when I started to discover
- 20:49that, I'm like, really? Judaism has what to say
- 20:52about this? And that really opened up the door
- 20:53for me to explore more of my Jewish roots, eventually
- 20:56more of the spiritual tradition in Judaism. And
- 20:58that's when I really got interested and then
- 21:01started learning and took on an Orthodox traditional
- 21:03lifestyle. For me, Judaism supports veganism
- 21:09100 % in very strong and powerful ways. So for
- 21:12me, I see, I mean, dozens if not hundreds of
- 21:16sources in Judaism that support going vegan today
- 21:19because of the horrors of the factory farming
- 21:21world and the negative impact of eating an animal
- 21:25-based diet. So yeah, I see it as a very Jewish
- 21:28thing. Unfortunately, not that many, not enough
- 21:31Jews. are vegan, more out of the Orthodox community,
- 21:37most if not all of the Jewish vegans that I know
- 21:40are not in the Orthodox community, a few of them
- 21:42are, but more in the conservative and reform,
- 21:46which are, you know, tend to be labeled as more
- 21:48kind of open to and interested in kind of progressive
- 21:52movements and causes and the like. But all that
- 21:58is rooted in the concept I brought up before,
- 22:00Tikkun Olam, fixing the world. It's so Jewish.
- 22:05If I'm choosing the way that I eat because I
- 22:08care about the world and I want the world to
- 22:10be a better place, both for the planet and for
- 22:12all the creatures and creations living on this
- 22:17planet, that's... that's tikkun olam that's fixing
- 22:20the world that's because i want this world to
- 22:21be a better place so it's very jewish but uh
- 22:25still not enough jews are choosing that path
- 22:27in my uh opinion i want to know more about what
- 22:32you discovered exactly i uh recently watched
- 22:35your teaching um about that dairy holiday and
- 22:40you can tell me more about it and um you were
- 22:44quoting that um jewish scholar who lived Like
- 22:48a long time ago and was already you know thinking
- 22:52and preaching about he was a rabbi. About vegetarianism
- 23:00and the the suffering of animals and i was really
- 23:03surprised like positively surprised about his
- 23:08existence and i was really not aware of that
- 23:12you know happening during that time so. Yeah,
- 23:17please tell me more. Yeah, so basically, you
- 23:20know, Judaism is filled with laws and values
- 23:23and ethics and teachings. And within the laws
- 23:27of Judaism are laws that obligate us to show
- 23:30compassion for animals obligate us. It's not
- 23:32a choice, it's not a suggestion, it's an obligation.
- 23:35There's laws on the books that you cannot cause
- 23:38unnecessary pain and suffering to animals, that
- 23:40you need to show compassion. And, you know, we've
- 23:43been around for over 3 ,000 years, so we have
- 23:45lots of books. You know, there's the book, the
- 23:47Torah, the Five Books of Moses, but then there's
- 23:49also all kinds of commentaries and other books
- 23:52and anything from Jewish law to Jewish mysticism
- 23:54and Jewish philosophy and everything in between.
- 23:57And so many Jewish rabbis, leaders, and writers
- 24:00have talked about throughout the generations
- 24:02about this, about compassion for animals. One
- 24:06very famous one is Rabbi Moshe Kordavero, who
- 24:08lived 500 years ago in Israel. He wrote about
- 24:12that if someone disparages, if someone shows
- 24:16disrespect to an animal, what they're really
- 24:19doing is disrespecting God, because God created
- 24:21that animal, which is a very powerful teaching.
- 24:25The class that you were referring to specifically
- 24:27about the holiday we recently had called Shebuot,
- 24:31which is a holiday that we commemorate and celebrate
- 24:33the giving of the Torah Mount Sinai over 3 ,000
- 24:34years ago, eventually became known as like the
- 24:38dairy holiday. It's not an obligation to eat
- 24:41dairy, but because Torah is compared to milk,
- 24:44you know, for various reasons, one, because milk
- 24:46gives life to newborn animals. So to Torah gives
- 24:51life. So there's no obligation whatsoever to
- 24:55eat dairy on Shavuot, but it became a custom.
- 24:58Judaism, like other traditions, is filled with
- 25:00customs as well, not obligations, but customs,
- 25:02which is a beautiful thing. Customs are beautiful
- 25:05traditions. But when a tradition gets in the
- 25:11way of an obligation, in this case eating dairy
- 25:15which causes incredible and immense pain and
- 25:19suffering both physically and emotional to God's
- 25:22creatures to eat those foods on a holiday that
- 25:27celebrates the giving of the Torah by God makes
- 25:29no sense whatsoever. We're celebrating, you know,
- 25:34our tradition through causing pain and suffering
- 25:37to God's creatures. That just doesn't make sense.
- 25:40So the rabbi whose teaching I shared in that
- 25:43class, his name was Rabbi Avraham Yitzhak Kulk.
- 25:47He lived from 1865 to 1935 and he was very, very
- 25:53holy visionary of a man. You know, we don't have
- 25:56prophets these days anymore, but if we did he
- 25:58would be included in them. He really saw the
- 26:01world in a very different way and he wrote quite
- 26:05a lot. He wrote a lot in general, but included
- 26:08in his teachings he wrote about animal welfare
- 26:11and about eating animals and how the original
- 26:14diet that was given to humanity in the Garden
- 26:17of Eden through Adam and Eve, which was a purely
- 26:19plant -based diet, as it says in chapter one
- 26:21of Genesis, verse 29, that that was the ideal,
- 26:26that that was the ideal, and that one day we're
- 26:28meant to return to that ideal. And so he wrote
- 26:31about that, he brought it into his own life,
- 26:35and yeah, he was one of the few rabbinic leaders
- 26:41to really talk about it in such a direct way.
- 26:46talk to Jews about all of that. What is their
- 26:51first reaction? I get a lot of pushback, a lot
- 26:59of pushback, specifically with all due love and
- 27:03respect to my Orthodox, my fellow Orthodox Jews,
- 27:07especially from Orthodox Jews. They say a lot
- 27:11of the things that they say are the same things
- 27:12I've heard from many people. many times. Well,
- 27:15God let us eat animals so there's no problem.
- 27:18It's kosher. That's all I care about. That's
- 27:20all I have to care about is that it's kosher.
- 27:23My rabbi does it. That means I can do it. My
- 27:26rabbi eats it so I can eat it. These are classic
- 27:29kind of responses and I always have my answers
- 27:34that I share back with them. Yeah, it's very
- 27:40much kind of rooted in like I'm allowed to so
- 27:42I do. Right? God let us eat animals, so I do.
- 27:46So don't tell me I can't or I shouldn't. And
- 27:49my response almost always is, it's yes, obviously,
- 27:53God gave us permission, right? Like we just said
- 27:54that God gave a purely plant -based diet in the
- 27:57Garden of Eden. That lasted until the generation
- 28:00of the Flood and the generation of Noah, after
- 28:04which, you know, after the Flood God then changed
- 28:07the diet and allowed humans to eat animals, the
- 28:11main word there is allowed, not obligated them.
- 28:14And so I always share back with them, it's like,
- 28:16yes, we do have the permission. Clearly, Judaism
- 28:18allows us to kill animals for food, right, in
- 28:24a very specific way, something called shchita,
- 28:26which is kosher slaughter, but we're allowed
- 28:28to, we're allowed to for sure. But if we're doing
- 28:32that in a way that's going against other obligations
- 28:38of the Torah, like not causing pain and suffering
- 28:40to animals. So what are we doing? We're doing
- 28:43something that's, you know, permissible, but
- 28:47in the process we're breaking a law that's an
- 28:50obligation. So how do you justify that? I don't
- 28:54really usually ever hear a good answer to that
- 28:56question. I'll be honest with you. You mentioned
- 29:00that this work of confronting people and convincing
- 29:04them to become vegan and care about animals,
- 29:07you consider that holy. What did you mean by
- 29:10that? Good question. I think it's connected to
- 29:15something you guys said before, is that of all
- 29:17the things that we do as humans, I really believe
- 29:21that our food choices, what we eat, has the greatest
- 29:25impact in so many different ways. on the world,
- 29:29on the planet, on creation. What I eat will impact
- 29:32the earth. It will impact the soil, the water,
- 29:35the atmosphere. It'll impact other humans. It'll
- 29:40impact other creatures, of course. It'll impact
- 29:43my health. It'll impact my family. It's pervasive.
- 29:48It's one of the few things that we do in our
- 29:51lives that has such a... diverse and wide -reaching
- 29:57impact and so when we and in addition to that
- 30:01we have you know we have desires for good tasting
- 30:04things and tavot as we call them in Hebrew like
- 30:06lusts and desires and it's not always easy to
- 30:10to hold ourselves back and to to not give into
- 30:13them especially if they're permissible right
- 30:15I'm allowed to eat a steak I'm allowed to eat
- 30:17burgers right I'm allowed to have a barbecue
- 30:21with you know meat hot dogs and the like. And
- 30:25when we overcome that desire for the sake of
- 30:28a value that takes a lot of strength, that takes
- 30:32a lot of self -discipline, and when that action
- 30:36of ours, when that change is for the sake of
- 30:40creating a better world, which is the ultimate
- 30:43mission and vision of Judaism, that's holy. That's
- 30:48holy. You're sanctifying life. What does it mean,
- 30:50holy? In Judaism, something that's holy is something
- 30:55that's been sanctified. Why is Shabbat holy?
- 30:57Because it's been sanctified. It's being elevated.
- 31:05And we're supposed to do the same thing with
- 31:07the world. We're supposed to sanctify this world.
- 31:09We're supposed to make this world a dwelling
- 31:12place for holiness, for godliness. And when we
- 31:15choose actions, for the sake of that, with that
- 31:19in mind, with that intention in order to make
- 31:21this world a more godly place, that's holy work.
- 31:25Do you feel like the vegan community is investing
- 31:32enough in supporting religious, not movements,
- 31:39but organizations, activists, because I feel
- 31:45like the best argument we can make for people
- 31:49to become vegans is a religious argument. I think
- 31:54that to make real change in this world, we have
- 31:59to focus on the religious aspect of this whole
- 32:04equation. I feel like we focus too much on the
- 32:11economic aspect of it. And I see, you know, lots
- 32:15of street activists and so on making the ethical
- 32:19argument for veganism. But then, like you mentioned
- 32:25before, if I take my moral, ethical cues from
- 32:30my rabbi, who are you to tell me, you know, what
- 32:34is ethical or not? Of course, we are all capable
- 32:41of, you know, being independent in our thoughts
- 32:44and mind, but there are people we consider moral
- 32:48authorities in our life. And so why aren't we
- 32:52doing more to reach those people, to support
- 32:59those, you know, Rabbi, Imam, Buddhist monks
- 33:04and priests that make the the argument for veganism?
- 33:11Another very good question. I think that a lot
- 33:14of people, I mean, I think we clearly see it
- 33:16in our world today. A lot of people are turned
- 33:18off to religion. People, even though I think
- 33:21we religious people see the real beauty and even
- 33:25purity of religion, we're still human beings
- 33:28and not everyone who is, quote unquote, religious
- 33:31or a member of a certain religious path. and
- 33:37community lives up to the values and the highest
- 33:40values of that religious community and path.
- 33:44And I think people today, a lot of people are
- 33:46turned off to religion and by religion because
- 33:49they see it as something that has been corrupted
- 33:55and they see a lot of corruption in religions.
- 33:58And even though that's not the essence of religion,
- 34:00that's human error. on the part of religious
- 34:03people. They kind of, you know, put it all together
- 34:06and they throw out religion. So I think there's
- 34:10a weakened interest in religion in general in
- 34:15our society today. And even if, you know, you
- 34:20were to target the people who are connected to
- 34:22religion, they often use those same arguments
- 34:24as like, where God created us as higher than
- 34:27animals, we're allowed to use anything we want
- 34:29in this world. We're better than the animals.
- 34:31So I don't have to think about this stuff. So
- 34:33don't tell me that I have to. And they have their
- 34:35own religious arguments, you know, against our
- 34:38religious arguments. So it makes it very challenging
- 34:42in that sense. But I think it's easier for most
- 34:47activists today to hold on to the ethical arguments,
- 34:53and that the religious arguments, though in my
- 34:55eyes, they're one and the same. Where do ethics
- 34:57come from? Ethics are rooted in these religious
- 35:01traditions. But yeah, and I'll be honest with
- 35:08you, I think there's not that many religious
- 35:12vegans out there, there's not enough for them
- 35:14to be known about, seen, heard. And so therefore
- 35:19their time, energy and resources are going to
- 35:21be invested elsewhere. Yeah, I'm thinking more
- 35:24and more, you know, what are we doing, creating
- 35:28fake meat in laboratory when there's this whole
- 35:32lane of developing the religious argument for
- 35:36veganism, that it is, you know, unexploited and
- 35:40pretty much neglected. And, you know, all the
- 35:43resources and funding goes to playing Dr. Frankenstein
- 35:47with, you know, lab -grown meat. Yeah, I agree.
- 35:57I'm totally on that page with you. I find it
- 35:59so interesting. You know, the way I look at it,
- 36:03he says, God created a world filled with food,
- 36:06filled with a diversity of colorful and and beautiful
- 36:10and nourishing and delicious food, why are we
- 36:14going into a laboratory investing tons of money
- 36:17and tons of energy and resources, right? This
- 36:20is an energy -intensive process that they are
- 36:23trying to perfect for the market. He said, why,
- 36:27why are we doing, we can take all that money
- 36:29and put it to education, into outreach, into
- 36:32all kinds of things. And we don't need that.
- 36:35We, I can get my health and nutrition from things
- 36:38that are already just simply growing in the world.
- 36:41I'm also a bit confused by it. Yeah. I'm, I,
- 36:45I used to look at this lab grown meat as, um,
- 36:49you know, using religious terminology, the Messiah,
- 36:52you know, I was thinking this will come, this
- 36:55will be developed and then it will be the end
- 36:58of animal exploitation. Nowadays, I'm thinking
- 37:02more and more that it won't, for many different
- 37:08reasons. I think that this fight is a religious
- 37:16fight, this fight is a cultural fight, this fight
- 37:18is a psychological fight, societal fight, not
- 37:22an economic one. changes. We will make and there
- 37:30has been tremendous changes on that front, but
- 37:34caused by, you know, economic pressure, but it
- 37:38won't resolve the problem, you know. But yeah,
- 37:43that's my opinion. Okay, let's talk about antisemitism.
- 37:51I think we cannot just, you know, have a conversation
- 37:54about Judaism and just, you know, forget about
- 38:01this, go over it. I did an episode on anti -Semitism
- 38:08in the vegan community. And I was thinking of
- 38:14you and how this must complicate your work in
- 38:18reaching out to to Jews because, you know, you're
- 38:22trying to make the religious argument for veganism
- 38:25and you're trying to influence Jews to adopt
- 38:32a vegan lifestyle. But then they look at the
- 38:35vegan community and there isn't, you know, a
- 38:40welcome party, you know, waiting for them quite
- 38:44the opposite. So this must really complicate
- 38:47your work. Very much so. Very much so. Um, already
- 38:52before October 7th, 2023 and way more since.
- 38:57Um, I remember years ago, I wrote this little
- 39:00booklet about Judaism and the environment and
- 39:02included in that was about animal welfare and
- 39:05our food choices. And I tried to put it, excuse
- 39:09me. I tried to get into, um, religious bookstores
- 39:15in New York and the first story I went to, the
- 39:20first thing that the book owner said is like,
- 39:22oh, is that that PETA stuff? I saw their advertisement
- 39:26comparing, you know, animal suffering to Holocaust,
- 39:30you know, victims. That was horrible, right?
- 39:34So right away, you know, there was this negative
- 39:37kind of perspective on the movement, you know,
- 39:42how dare they take something that's so sensitive
- 39:44to us Jews and use it in their campaigns. Right?
- 39:49That was years ago. That was like 25 years ago,
- 39:51if not more. But more recently, you know, more
- 39:56and more activists have been showing up and doing
- 40:01protests at something you might be familiar with
- 40:06called Kippot, which is a ritual that Jews do
- 40:09before Yom Kippur, which is all about asking
- 40:12God for forgiveness. Most of the Jewish world
- 40:15does it with money that then gets given to those
- 40:18who need it. Some, a minority, but unfortunately
- 40:22enough, in the ultra -orthodox community, you
- 40:25do it with chickens, live chickens, and they
- 40:27wave them around their head, and then they slaughter
- 40:28them right there on the spot, and it's a whole
- 40:31mess. It's a horrible, horrible mess, and me
- 40:35as a Jew, I'm totally against it, and many Jews
- 40:36are against it. They can still continue to do
- 40:38it. What happens is that oftentimes, you know,
- 40:42non -Jewish animal welfare activists will show
- 40:44up at these places and they just are screaming
- 40:48at them and they start you know being so offensive
- 40:50to them and so these orthodox jews see them as
- 40:53like the representation of the animal welfare
- 40:56movement and the vegan movement and they're just
- 40:58like see look how they act look what they're
- 41:00doing to us this is anti -semitic they're they're
- 41:02coming out here and they're getting involved
- 41:03with our religious rituals and things like that
- 41:06so that's just another example which has been
- 41:09a big turned off, at least in the Orthodox world.
- 41:13But by far the greatest damage to Jewish vegans
- 41:23and the general vegan world and movement has
- 41:27been post -October 7th. I've talked to countless
- 41:32Jewish vegetarians and vegans since then. and
- 41:36they just told me how they've been ostracized
- 41:39by their vegan community. Many of these Jewish
- 41:41vegans, their vegan community was a bigger part
- 41:44of their life than their Jewish community was,
- 41:46right? Their veganism is so important to them
- 41:49that it was their vegan community that they went
- 41:51to for gatherings and for events and social connections.
- 41:56And then post October 7th, they see their vegan
- 41:59friends posting all kinds of horrible stuff about
- 42:01Israel. There's always that fine line between,
- 42:04you know, criticism of Israel, anti -Israel,
- 42:08and anti -Semitism. And these people are, you
- 42:12know, these people are good people, you know,
- 42:15really open people wanting to make the world
- 42:17a better place. And they just felt completely...
- 42:22I mean, on some level, people would say to me,
- 42:25like... I know saying duped is a harsh and a
- 42:30hard word, but they felt really almost tricked,
- 42:36traumatized by the hate that was coming out of
- 42:39their fellow members of their vegan community.
- 42:44And they lost it all. Many of these people lost
- 42:46it all. Either they were kind of like pushed
- 42:50out or had to leave literally for their mental
- 42:52health. It was very, very traumatic and I've
- 42:56talked to many people. About a month or two into
- 42:59the war, I opened up a Zoom webinar, you know,
- 43:04for free for people just to join. dozens and
- 43:07dozens of Jewish vegans came on, and everyone
- 43:09said the same thing, everyone talked about the
- 43:11same thing. You know, this person, I know that
- 43:13for 15 years we've been so close in the vegan
- 43:15community, we've done such great work together,
- 43:17and now I see what they're saying, what they're
- 43:18sharing, what they're posting, it's like, it's
- 43:21horrible, it's traumatic. So yeah, anti -Semitism
- 43:23in the vegan community has been felt tremendously
- 43:27since October 7th, and it's caused a lot of Jewish
- 43:30vegans to go in there. I'll be honest with you,
- 43:33it's very unfortunate to lose trust in the general
- 43:38vegan world. Obviously it's not everyone, but
- 43:41it's been enough people and enough times that
- 43:43they feel like they're not sure if those connections
- 43:46can ever be rebuilt. And I guess you can say
- 43:50the silver lining of that, the benefit of that
- 43:52is that the Jewish vegan community has gotten
- 43:54really much more inner and stronger as a result.
- 43:59And our kind of inner ties and connections have
- 44:05become much stronger. And I've become connected
- 44:07to people, other Jewish vegans, who maybe I wouldn't
- 44:11have as a result of the anti -Semitism that has
- 44:14come out since October 7th. So it's unfortunate.
- 44:18It's real. It's there. It's visible and it's
- 44:22felt. And yeah, it's sad to say, but I don't
- 44:25know if it's reparable. I think this might be,
- 44:27you know, one and done thing that Jewish vegans
- 44:31are not going to look back to even try to repair
- 44:34that because it's been so hurtful and so damaging.
- 44:40Yeah, that was my my next question. What is the
- 44:44solution to that? And is there a path to, you
- 44:50know, reuniting and and and having a more, I
- 44:57guess, healthier unity in the vegan movement,
- 45:03is there a way to forgive, not forget, but to
- 45:08amend those offenses and have a new united front
- 45:18in terms of pro -animal movement Or is the solution
- 45:26or is the path forward to create new organizations
- 45:31this time that will not reflect those anti -Semitic
- 45:40positions? So what is it? I think it's continuing
- 45:47separately, doing the similar work, but doing
- 45:49it separately. I'm doing it within a Jewish context
- 45:52with other Jews. That's a safe space. It's a
- 45:55safer space. It's a supportive space and just
- 45:59too many people have seen too many things and
- 46:00heard too many things. I think to ever really,
- 46:03you know, kind of go back, you know, of course
- 46:07that's not everybody, but I think it's enough
- 46:10people and I just, I've heard it so many times.
- 46:12I mean, myself, we've all, those of us in the
- 46:15Jewish vegan world, we've seen it so many times,
- 46:17like big... vegan influencers, you know, they
- 46:20start wearing the the kaffir and saying all kinds
- 46:22of anti -Israel stuff and and uh you know when
- 46:25their whole page was just about like vegan food
- 46:27all of a sudden it's about politics now and they're
- 46:30bringing up Israel and they're saying this about
- 46:31Israel and that about Israel and it's a big turn
- 46:33off. I've went at the beginning of the war you
- 46:36know my vegan rabbi social media page up until
- 46:39October 7th 2023 I only talked about veganism
- 46:43I never talked about anything else on it on purpose.
- 46:46And then after October 7th, I had to. I had to
- 46:49talk about Israel. I had to talk about what's
- 46:52going on. And I lost tons of followers. I lost
- 46:56probably hundreds of followers, got all kinds
- 46:58of horrible either comments or messages. Every
- 47:01now and then I still get them. But what I also
- 47:06saw is all these influencers using their platforms
- 47:10and their pages to spew a lot of hate. against
- 47:14Israel, against the Jewish people. And that was,
- 47:17I mean, people I really, really liked and really
- 47:19looked up to. I had to unfollow them because
- 47:22I couldn't see it anymore. You know, there's
- 47:24this one, I wouldn't say his name, but this is
- 47:26one vegan chef. He's got like a million followers
- 47:28on Instagram. And all of a sudden he's like showing
- 47:31up at the cafe and saying all this stuff. Like,
- 47:33who are you? Like, what do you even know? What
- 47:35did you even know about any of this before October
- 47:367th? You know, so you watched a few TikTok videos
- 47:39and now you think, you know, you know everything.
- 47:42It's very disturbing. It's very disturbing. So
- 47:45it's very painful. And I'm not sure in our generation,
- 47:48you know, that there's going to be much healing
- 47:51there. So we're just continuing our work, you
- 47:52know, on our own and doing it together in our
- 47:56way. You mentioned comparisons to the Holocaust.
- 48:02Now, I believe that what Peter did with that
- 48:05Holocaust campaign was in pretty bad taste, and
- 48:10that is a euphemism. But at the same time, there
- 48:14is work, you know, for instance, the book, An
- 48:18Eternal Treblingham. And, you know, there is
- 48:21the fact that you can... or at least, you know,
- 48:26I've done it and other activists have done it
- 48:29to say, you know, there is a animal Holocaust,
- 48:33you know, I'm not going to put pictures of Holocaust
- 48:36victims in front of, but, you know, just saying
- 48:39it. Do you think that also is offensive to the
- 48:47Jewish community? What do you make of the book,
- 48:52An Eternal Treblinka, if you know about it? I'm
- 48:56aware of it, yeah. It's interesting. I 100 %
- 49:00understand why Jews take offense to it, without
- 49:03a doubt. I get it. The Holocaust is still very
- 49:09recent in Jewish history, just about 80 years
- 49:13since the end of World War II and the end of
- 49:15the Holocaust. Many of us have family members,
- 49:20you know, none that we met obviously, but that
- 49:23we've been told about that were murdered in the
- 49:26Holocaust. My own family on my mother's side,
- 49:28her parents were from Poland. They got out before
- 49:31the war, but more than half of their families
- 49:33were murdered in the Holocaust. So like we grew
- 49:35up with this stuff. Like we grew up with the
- 49:37Holocaust like fresh in our minds. So I get why
- 49:41Jews have that reaction. I think they're 100
- 49:44% right. I personally, as a vegan, I get it.
- 49:50I get the comparison because from the perspective
- 49:55of the animals this is, and this is very controversial
- 49:58what I'm about to say, it's worse than the Holocaust.
- 50:02The numbers are far greater like you said at
- 50:05the beginning. We're not talking about millions,
- 50:07we're talking about billions and that takes nothing
- 50:09away from the tragedy. and the horrors of the
- 50:13Holocaust. It takes nothing away from that. But
- 50:15at the same time, when we look at reality from
- 50:17the perspective of the animals going through
- 50:19the factory farming world, it is an absolute
- 50:21Holocaust. From the day that they're forced to
- 50:26be born to the day that they're forced to be
- 50:28killed. So I do agree that it's a Holocaust from
- 50:33their perspective on a magnitude that we can't
- 50:35even imagine. And so I personally do not find
- 50:40a fence in the comparison. I don't really talk
- 50:44about that opinion of mine because almost even
- 50:47other Jewish vegans that I'm connected to, they
- 50:50do take offense to it and I understand that and
- 50:53I respect it. So I think I'm a minority opinion
- 50:55on that. But I think if we understood what's
- 51:01going on in the factory farming world and what
- 51:03these animals are going through from their perspective,
- 51:07what they're going through, That maybe maybe
- 51:11we have a higher chances of people opening up
- 51:13their hearts and making changes So I I get Peter's
- 51:17tactics I get there like in your face intense
- 51:20like because it's real It's it is intense and
- 51:23it's actually happening every single second.
- 51:25So I I actually understand them why they did
- 51:28that Do you think that we should be at a certain
- 51:34level? I'm comfortable with offending people
- 51:39in our activism. Yes, I do. People have to be
- 51:47shaken out of their comfort zones. And there's
- 51:49lots of causes. There's lots of issues. I'm sure
- 51:51there's causes and issues that I need to be shaken
- 51:53out of my comfort zone for sure. Right. I'm sure,
- 51:58you know. People can come up to me and say things
- 52:00about my lifestyle choices. Where about my clothing
- 52:02from? You know, I don't buy all like, you know,
- 52:05sensitive and aware and conscious and organic
- 52:08and handmade clothing. I know my clothing comes
- 52:11from factories and that's a real problem. So,
- 52:14you know, I'm not perfect. None of us are perfect.
- 52:17We live in a very problematic world in terms
- 52:19of striving for perfection in our lifestyle choices.
- 52:23And I'm aware of that. But yes, I think people
- 52:26need to be shocked sometimes, not all the time
- 52:29because then you'll lose them. But I think shock
- 52:32activism is proper, in the right measure, at
- 52:37the right time and in the right way. Because
- 52:40people, you know, sometimes I, you know, I might
- 52:44be like, you know, on my phone and I'm on Instagram
- 52:46and I see, you know, Half of the things I see
- 52:48on Instagram have to do with veganism just because
- 52:49of the algorithm. Um, and so I'll see a video
- 52:52or a picture of animal suffering. And if someone's
- 52:54next to me who eats animals, I'll show them that
- 52:57right away. They got freaked out. Why did you
- 52:59show that to me? I'm like, hello, this is what
- 53:01you eat. You know, what are you talking about?
- 53:04So I think there's absolutely a space for that.
- 53:07Uh, we need a multi kind of, uh, multifaceted
- 53:12approach, but I think that's one that. It's important
- 53:15to use, again, in the right way and in the right
- 53:17measure at the right time. You said you're based
- 53:24in Israel. What is the state of animal welfare
- 53:27and animal rights in Israel? Horrible, just like
- 53:33most other places. There is a relatively large
- 53:38vegan and vegetarian community here. statistics
- 53:43come out and say that Israel per capita is one
- 53:45of the most vegan countries in the world, which
- 53:48is really nice to know. And about five percent
- 53:50of the population is vegan. If you include vegetarians,
- 53:53it goes up to 13 percent, which is pretty high.
- 53:57But at the same time, it's a meat heavy society
- 54:02and animals here are treated just as poorly as
- 54:05in other places. So unfortunately, you know.
- 54:09not much good to share when it comes to that.
- 54:12I feel like in Israel, but I think this is happening
- 54:14globally as well, like the vegan movement is
- 54:17growing, awareness is growing, but at the same
- 54:19time, the pace at which people eat animals is
- 54:23not slowing down. If anything, it's kind of growing.
- 54:28And so I feel like these two movements are growing
- 54:31simultaneously and parallel to each other. So
- 54:35yeah, so it's nice to see the vegan expansion
- 54:39in Israel, but it's upsetting to see what's happening
- 54:46in the animal agriculture world, that it's not
- 54:48very enlightened and it's just as bad as other
- 54:51places. Five percent is a gigantic voting bloc.
- 55:00Why aren't we seeing more pro -animal... progress
- 55:08reflected in Israeli politics? Or are we that
- 55:12I'm not aware of? Very good question. I'll say
- 55:16two things. One, there have been successes along
- 55:18the way in terms of animal rights and animal
- 55:22welfare in Israel. Certain things having to do
- 55:27with fur and certain kind of animal, I hate saying
- 55:32the word animal products, but you know, food
- 55:34that comes from animals, food products that come
- 55:35from animals, live transports. I believe if I
- 55:40remember correctly there was a law that was recently
- 55:42passed that by a certain year in the now for
- 55:47our future that that will be banned in Israel.
- 55:49I have to look that up again to make sure that
- 55:52that's correct but I remember seeing that. But
- 55:56it's an interesting question you're asking because
- 55:59as you can imagine, politics here in Israel are
- 56:01very different than politics elsewhere because
- 56:03we're dealing with so many security issues and
- 56:06politics here are very security driven. And so
- 56:10it's not, you know, like in other places where,
- 56:12you know, there's all these, you know, you're
- 56:13voting for someone because of what they say about
- 56:15the environment and what they say about this
- 56:17cause and that cause. It's like literally on
- 56:19some level, especially during wartime, it's like
- 56:22a single issue political It's like, what are
- 56:27you going to do for security? We're constantly
- 56:29facing real intense security challenges. So what
- 56:34are you going to do to make the country stronger
- 56:36and ensure our survival? So because of that,
- 56:40other issues get a back burner. And while there
- 56:43are members of the Israeli parliament that do
- 56:46care about these issues and do push forward legislation
- 56:49that does happen, I know a couple of politicians
- 56:52over the last few years who are members of the
- 56:57Knesset, who were vegan, which was amazing. But
- 57:02still, it doesn't get spoken about very much.
- 57:11It's really about, again, how you fight our enemies
- 57:15in the most effective way possible. And it really
- 57:19kind of takes up most of the space here politically.
- 57:22Yeah, that's really interesting. Sorry for being
- 57:29unfamiliar, but is it a proportional democracy
- 57:31system in Israel? Is there a place for smaller
- 57:37parties to win positions in the government or
- 57:45even elect MPs in the Knesset or something like
- 57:49that? There is on paper. Yes, absolutely You
- 57:53know, it's not a two -party system. It's a multi
- 57:56-party system It's dozens of parties when you
- 57:58go to vote here in Israel. You literally see
- 58:00dozens of choices Which on one level is great,
- 58:04but most of them never passed the threshold.
- 58:05So it's kind of pointless Doesn't really have
- 58:09an impact and and still it's usually the same
- 58:13kind of seven or eight political parties that
- 58:16make it through. And then they're the ones who
- 58:17have to kind of scramble around to make a coalition.
- 58:20Right. You know, the winning party gets the first
- 58:22chance to make a coalition. If they do great.
- 58:25If not, then the second one gets to and the second
- 58:28place is usually, you know, the opposition to
- 58:31the to the to the leading political party. But
- 58:35it does create space. And there are, you know.
- 58:39political organizations based on all kinds of
- 58:42issues, single issues as a result. But again,
- 58:45the problem is that they don't make it through
- 58:47the threshold so they don't have the impact that
- 58:50they're seeking. And they're never ever involved
- 58:52in the coalition, if they even get through the
- 58:55threshold, which they usually don't, except to
- 58:58get a certain number of votes to get into the
- 59:00parliament. So a lot of people look at it as
- 59:04wasted votes. Even if they care about that single
- 59:07issue, they're like I'm not gonna vote because
- 59:09they're not gonna get through I rather give my
- 59:11vote to this party who I believe in how they're
- 59:13gonna approach security issues that always goes
- 59:15back to that so it is very democratic in that
- 59:20sense, but in the end when when the coalition
- 59:24is coalition is actually built it's there's not
- 59:26a lot of if any of these single -issue parties
- 59:29represented Yeah, I'm asking that because I The
- 59:35bet here in Canada is to get, you know, proportional
- 59:40democratic system in order to get power for pro
- 59:47animal party and make, you know, more progress.
- 59:54Yeah, listeners will understand, you know, I've
- 59:56had many conversations about that. mostly with
- 1:00:00Liz White, who's the incredible leader of the
- 1:00:05Animal Protection Party of Canada. Okay, I want
- 1:00:09to end the conversation, Rabbi, with something
- 1:00:16else you're specialized in, which is matchmaking.
- 1:00:21And I want to hear how you got into that and,
- 1:00:25you know, What is your rate of success? And maybe
- 1:00:31if you have, you know, stories to share about,
- 1:00:34you know, happy stories about that, I would love
- 1:00:37to hear them. Great. Yeah. So I never thought
- 1:00:40I'd get into matchmaking after my vegan rather
- 1:00:42work. You know, the platform I started about
- 1:00:46four years ago, I've been doing Jewish environmental
- 1:00:48education for over 20 years. And within that,
- 1:00:51again, focus on animal welfare and veganism.
- 1:00:55But really with the creation of Vegan Rabbi,
- 1:00:59it was definitely the most focused work and outreach
- 1:01:03that I've done in my whole life. And it's become
- 1:01:07a big part of my life and a growing part of my
- 1:01:08life. And already within the first year of creating
- 1:01:12Vegan Rabbi, singles who are in my network...
- 1:01:16you know followers of mine on social media they
- 1:01:18got started getting in touch with me one after
- 1:01:20the other after the other asking hey i'm jewish
- 1:01:23vegan single looking for somebody do you happen
- 1:01:25to know anyone can help me and at first i'm like
- 1:01:27what do i know about any of this i'm not a matchmaker
- 1:01:29i'm not you know and then i just kept hearing
- 1:01:32from people i mean wait a minute there's something
- 1:01:34happening here right uh the jewish world is very
- 1:01:36much focused on matchmaking but maybe there's
- 1:01:39nothing specifically for jewish vegan vegetarian
- 1:01:41singles and I did some scouring around the internet,
- 1:01:45found nothing, and I decided I'm going to do
- 1:01:47something. I had no background, no experience,
- 1:01:51but I'm going to try. And I built a database
- 1:01:53and I invited people to join it. And shortly
- 1:01:57after that, a friend of mine built like a free
- 1:02:00matchmaking website. So I kind of uploaded my
- 1:02:04database members to his platform. And then shortly
- 1:02:06after that, I met a woman named Aliza Ben Shalom.
- 1:02:09who was the star of the Netflix show Jewish Matchmaking.
- 1:02:12She had recently moved to the town I live in
- 1:02:14in Israel. And I told her, this was before the
- 1:02:17Netflix show came out, but I knew she was a matchmaker.
- 1:02:19And I told her about what I was starting to get
- 1:02:20into. She was like, wow, we should talk. And
- 1:02:22I told her about what I was doing. She actually
- 1:02:23used to be vegan, interesting enough. She's no
- 1:02:26longer now. But I told her what I was doing and
- 1:02:28she invited me to train with her. I'm like, wow,
- 1:02:30I get to train with this top matchmaker. That's
- 1:02:33amazing. So I did a whole training with her.
- 1:02:35And then she invited me to join her team and
- 1:02:38her staff. which I did for over a year and a
- 1:02:40half. I recently left a couple of months ago,
- 1:02:43but basically that was just incredible experience
- 1:02:46learning the ins and outs of the, of the world
- 1:02:49of matchmaking and dating coaching. And that's
- 1:02:52become a part of my life as well. And so, you
- 1:02:55know, specifically since, um, leaving working
- 1:02:58with her, I've been kind of like investing my
- 1:03:00energies more again, uh, in my niche. in the
- 1:03:05Jewish matchmaking world for Jewish, vegan, vegetarian
- 1:03:07singles. I have a whole network of hundreds and
- 1:03:09hundreds of people and people reach out to me.
- 1:03:12You know, they heard about me, they get my number
- 1:03:15from somebody, they tell me their story, they
- 1:03:17share their bio and ask if I know of anybody.
- 1:03:20So, you know, I have lots of people in my network,
- 1:03:22lots of people I keep in mind and then there's
- 1:03:25some people I work with, like actually like in
- 1:03:26a very official one -on -one way in terms of
- 1:03:29whether it's dating coaching or full -on matchmaking.
- 1:03:32It's an ancient Jewish art, Jewish matchmaking,
- 1:03:36and you know, it's really based on these values
- 1:03:38that we're talking about and I understand it
- 1:03:40because I was in the same place many, many years
- 1:03:43ago when I was dating and looking, you know,
- 1:03:45to meet someone and looking to get married that
- 1:03:47I wanted to, one of the top, if not the top things
- 1:03:50on my list that was so important to me is that
- 1:03:53someone who shares this lifestyle with me, shares
- 1:03:56these food choices and lifestyle choices with
- 1:03:59me and these you know, the concern for the environment,
- 1:04:02for animal welfare. That was very, very top of
- 1:04:04the list for me. And I met, you know, different
- 1:04:08women, different great women, but not always
- 1:04:10did they share that passion and that compassion
- 1:04:15until I did, and that was my wife. And so the
- 1:04:20singles who I'm connected to with now or work
- 1:04:22with, I very much understand where they're coming
- 1:04:25from. Because again, I went through that. I was
- 1:04:27in that same place many years ago. And just for
- 1:04:30me, it's just, you know, to bring two people
- 1:04:33together is an incredible thing in and of itself.
- 1:04:35And to bring two, you know, people with shared
- 1:04:38values about the environment and about the animal
- 1:04:40welfare and about human health and protection
- 1:04:43of our world is even for me, even greater. So
- 1:04:46it's, you know, to build, to help two people
- 1:04:47come together, who will then build a home based
- 1:04:50on those values and raise children with those
- 1:04:52values. It's just, you know, talk about trying
- 1:04:55to change the world. It's, it's, it's one of
- 1:04:57the ways, you know, to make the world a better
- 1:05:00place. I know I said, you know, last question,
- 1:05:05but I lied. So you mentioned shared values. We
- 1:05:14often hear about chemistry, how important it
- 1:05:18is to have chemistry, but I feel not enough about
- 1:05:22shared values. Can you comment on that? Yeah,
- 1:05:25look, you know, again, I talk to all kinds of
- 1:05:27people. I'm in touch with vegan singles, or have
- 1:05:30been, or currently am. Like, I can only date
- 1:05:33a vegan. Only date a vegan. There's no way, you
- 1:05:35know. And then I know vegan singles who are like,
- 1:05:38you know, ideally she's vegan, but if she's vegetarian,
- 1:05:41that's fine as well. And even people like, you
- 1:05:43know what, I'm very open, you know, as long as
- 1:05:47we match up in other ways. And hopefully she'll...
- 1:05:51come towards my side you know or vice versa like
- 1:05:53a girl talking about a guy so I meet all kinds
- 1:05:55of people right but yeah you know for for the
- 1:05:59majority of them the shared value aspect is very
- 1:06:03very important and and they're just like I don't
- 1:06:05I don't want to open up my fridge and see you
- 1:06:08know, see chicken and steak and all these different
- 1:06:11things and it's really really important to them
- 1:06:14and they want their kitchen to be a reflection
- 1:06:17of their values and they want their spouse to
- 1:06:20also share in that. So it's really really important.
- 1:06:23Shared values is just so important in terms of
- 1:06:25relationships and marriage in general but especially
- 1:06:29for vegans and vegetarians who have made very
- 1:06:34specific choices in their life. And their lives
- 1:06:37and their lifestyles reflect that when it comes
- 1:06:40to finding someone to spend, God willing, the
- 1:06:42rest of their life with, this is just a very,
- 1:06:46very high importance and will help. It's not
- 1:06:49a guarantee, but it will definitely help to strengthen
- 1:06:53the bonds between them and to maintain the strength
- 1:06:55of their bonds. I want to ask more questions
- 1:06:58because we're going to actually record a special
- 1:07:02episode just about that with also, you know,
- 1:07:07vegan activist couples who will be participating
- 1:07:11in this group conversation. I'm really looking
- 1:07:16forward to having that conversation because every
- 1:07:20time I open social media, I feel like it's one
- 1:07:23of the top issue. People asking questions or
- 1:07:27commenting about how it is tough to find someone
- 1:07:31who's vegan. or being in a relationship with
- 1:07:35someone who's not vegan comes with a whole lot
- 1:07:39of troubles. And I feel people need help navigating
- 1:07:46the dating world, at least vegans. But yeah,
- 1:07:51I'm looking forward to that conversation. Same
- 1:07:54here. It was a great conversation to have. Looking
- 1:07:56forward as well. Wonderful. Rabbi, did you have
- 1:08:02anything to add before I stopped the recording?
- 1:08:06First of all, just say thank you so much for
- 1:08:08this opportunity to speak with you and about
- 1:08:11this very important topic. Really a pleasure
- 1:08:13and an honor. And just really to sum up, you
- 1:08:16know, kind of what we're focusing on before that,
- 1:08:18you know, I think a lot of people today look
- 1:08:22at veganism as extreme and vegans as extreme.
- 1:08:25But really, when you look at the root of it all,
- 1:08:26it's like We're just trying to be like nice people.
- 1:08:29We're trying to be the best people that we can
- 1:08:31be and try to create the best world we can create.
- 1:08:34It's really so much about such a basic value
- 1:08:37of creating a better world, more goodness in
- 1:08:40the world. Like who doesn't want less pain and
- 1:08:42suffering in the world? You know, who doesn't
- 1:08:44want more health in the world? Who doesn't want
- 1:08:46more wholeness and wellness in the world? That's
- 1:08:48what it's all about, right? And I think it's
- 1:08:52important for people to know that and I think
- 1:08:54it's important for us vegans to kind of broadcast
- 1:08:56that and share that in our messaging so people
- 1:08:59can really understand where we're coming from
- 1:09:01and why we're doing this work. Wonderful, great
- 1:09:03parting words. Again, Rabbi Akiva, thank you
- 1:09:08so much for your time and for answering my questions.
- 1:09:12Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 1:09:16you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 1:09:18know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:09:23Again, thank you so much for caring and I will
- 1:09:25see you next Tuesday for a new episode.