Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / The Mongol Schism: How Religion Tore the Khanate Apart
Transcript
- Lucas: We’ve spent a lot of time talking about how the Mongol Empire broke apart due to broken promises, disputed successions, and battles like Ain Jalut or the Terek River. But there was another fracture line running through the heart of the khans’ tents, one that wasn’t just about land or gold, but about who they answered to in the sky. Luna: You mean religion? Lucas: Exactly. For generations, the Mongols operated under a system of aggressive pragmatism. They didn’t care much for theology as long as it brought them allies or didn’t anger their enemies. Under the Great Yassa, they protected everyone from Buddhists to Christians to Muslims, mostly because it kept their diverse empires from revolting while they were still focused on conquest. Lucas: But around the turn of the fourteenth century, that neutrality began to crack, specifically in the Ilkhanate, which ruled over Persia and Iraq. The khans started feeling less like universal conquerors and more like local rulers with specific loyalties, and that shift changed everything. Luna: What triggered that change in loyalty? Lucas: It really comes down to one man: Ghazan Khan. He ascended to the throne in 1295 after a period of intense civil strife within the Ilkhanate itself. Before him, his predecessors had been deeply influenced by their wives and concubines, many of whom were Nestorian Christians, which had already created tension with the majority Muslim population in Persia. Lucas: Ghazan, however, made a decisive break. He didn’t just tolerate Islam; he embraced it publicly and declared it the state religion of the Ilkhanate. This wasn’t a quiet cultural drift; it was a deliberate political statement that redefined the entire identity of the western Mongol khanate. Luna: Did the other Mongol groups take that well? Lucas: They took it poorly, especially the Golden Horde to the north. The Jochid dynasty had already grown sympathetic to Islam, but Ghazan’s conversion was seen by some as too aggressive, and by others as a betrayal of the steppe traditions. It turned religious difference into a border dispute. Lucas: When Ghazan converted, he immediately ordered the destruction of Buddhist temples and the closure of churches in his territories. More violently, he issued decrees against Jewish communities and subjected Nestorian Christians to heavy taxation and public humiliation, effectively ending the era of equal protection under the Yassa. Luna: That sounds like it caused immediate chaos on the ground. Lucas: It did. In the capital city of Tabriz, the shift was palpable. The city had been a cosmopolitan hub where merchants from all faiths traded freely. After the conversion, the atmosphere changed overnight. Muslim scholars gained prominence at court, while Christian clerics lost their protective status, leading to outbreaks of mob violence that the state either encouraged or failed to stop. Lucas: This wasn’t just internal policing; it reshaped foreign policy. The Ilkhanate had previously tried to ally with European Crusader states against the Mamluks in Egypt. But once Ghazan became a devout Muslim, those Christian alliances became politically toxic. He couldn’t be seen as friends with infidel kings anymore without losing legitimacy at home. Luna: So the anti-Mamluk wars changed direction too? Lucas: In a way, yes. Ghazan still fought the Mamluks, but the rhetoric shifted. He framed the wars not as imperial expansion but as jihad, or holy war. This mobilized different segments of his army and populace, but it also isolated the Ilkhanate diplomatically from any remaining Christian sympathizers in Europe and among the smaller Armenian kingdoms nearby. Lucas: The isolation extended northward to the Golden Horde. Relations between the two khanates deteriorated sharply. While both were nominally Muslim, the cultural gap between the Turkicized, Persian-influenced Ilkhanids and the steppe-hardened Jochids widened. They stopped seeing each other as brothers of the ulus and started seeing each other as theological rivals. Luna: Did Ghazan face resistance from his own people? Lucas: There was significant pushback from the traditionalist nobility, the noyans, who cherished Tengrism. Many of them viewed the abandonment of the sky god Tengri as a weakness, a softening of the martial spirit that had built the empire. There were plots and rebellions led by these conservative factions who wanted to restore the old ways. Lucas: Ghazan crushed these rebellions ruthlessly. He executed several high-ranking princes who opposed his religious reforms. This purging of the old guard weakened the central authority of the khanate in the long run, as it removed many experienced military leaders who were loyal to the steppe tradition rather than the new Islamic order. Luna: It seems like he solved one problem by creating another. Lucas: Precisely. He stabilized his rule by aligning with the powerful Persian ulama, the religious scholars, but in doing so, he alienated the core military base of the Mongol conquest. The army became less cohesive. The shared identity of being Mongol conquerors was replaced by a fractured identity of being Muslim subjects versus pagan rebels. Lucas: His successor, Oljeitu, actually wavered on this. He briefly considered converting to Christianity again to rebuild ties with Georgia and Armenia, then back to Islam, and even flirted with Shi’a Islam later in his reign. This instability showed how fragile the religious settlement had become. Luna: Why would he flip-flop like that? Lucas: Because the foundation was never truly settled. The Ilkhanate was caught between its steppe origins and its Persian surroundings. Oljeitu was trying to find a middle ground that satisfied everyone, but you can’t please the Tengrist warriors and the Islamic scholars simultaneously. His vacillation just deepened the confusion at court. Lucas: By the time Oljeitu died, the Ilkhanate was already descending into chaos. The religious schism had severed the economic and diplomatic arteries that held the empire together. Trade routes that relied on trust across faiths became dangerous, and the Yam system, the postal relay network, began to fail as regional governors prioritized their own sectarian interests. Luna: So the split wasn't just political, it was spiritual. Lucas: It was fundamental. Once the Mongols stopped being neutral arbiters and picked sides, they lost their unique advantage. They became just another kingdom in a messy, multi-religious region, fighting over borders and dogma instead of ruling over a vast, interconnected continent. Lucas: The legacy of this shift is visible today. The modern Middle East’s complex web of sectarian divisions has roots in this period, where Mongol power intersected with Islamic consolidation. The Ilkhanate didn’t just disappear; it transformed into something entirely different, leaving behind a map redrawn by faith. Luna: It’s crazy how one decision can redefine an entire empire. Lucas: It is. And it reminds us that empires don’t just fall from external pressure; they often crumble from the inside out when their founding myths no longer fit the reality they’ve created. Luna: If supporting this kind of deep dive helps keep the archive growing, you can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — that's F. E. X. I. N. G. O. Lucas: Thank you. It really does help. And speaking of foundations, I’m curious if you think any modern nation still struggles with this same tension between their steppe heritage and their settled religious identity. Luna: That’s a question for the next episode.