Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Attachment Healing and Family Dynamics
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. Welcome everybody, this is I
- 0:20love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It's Thursday, October 31st, 2024 at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight
- 0:26Time and it's Halloween, so happy Halloween.
- 0:32It's also the beginning of the holiday season.
- 0:36Christmas officially starts tomorrow, at least from a
- 0:39marketing perspective. I remember sitting around the
- 0:47the family holiday dinner table on Thanksgiving and everybody
- 0:52complaining that they were starting Christmas marketing the
- 0:56day after Thanksgiving, but that's long since gone.
- 1:07But I did want to talk about holidays approaching and the
- 1:11families gathering and relate that to attachment conditioning
- 1:16and attachment healing. In a sense, we have a bias here
- 1:25at Meta Group, which is really, if you can repair fractured
- 1:31family relationships, that you you do so.
- 1:36And that the basis for doing this is to actually see clearly
- 1:43the people in your family and to understand what their capacities
- 1:47are. One of the things that happens
- 1:50in family systems that are insecure or disorganized is that
- 1:58a lot of the needs that children have growing up in those family
- 2:01systems are unmet. And there's a continuing
- 2:05friction that happens later in life when we go, we return to
- 2:09the the family of origin and look for those needs as they
- 2:17manifest in the current moment and find again that they are
- 2:24unmet. And then that the disharmony
- 2:27that comes from that, particularly when it's
- 2:29aggravated with the long history of that.
- 2:38I suppose we don't talk so much about secure families here.
- 2:45Maybe the why we would is the mystery, but secure families
- 2:51tend to have a a good conflict resolution skills so that if
- 2:55something comes up, there's a way for the for the individual
- 2:59family members to negotiate it. There's a way for the family to
- 3:02gather around and and help with the process of negotiation so
- 3:07that things could be settled. And there's a sense really that
- 3:11the family is this thing of value and that you don't want to
- 3:14risk it unnecessarily and that it's enduring and carries
- 3:18forward. And it's a, it's not only is it
- 3:22a place to enjoy, but also a refuge.
- 3:30Something goes wrong. And in insecure family systems
- 3:35or disorganized family systems, that often isn't isn't really
- 3:38the sense of it. It's very tenuous.
- 3:42If you get more down toward the disorganized end of things,
- 3:51estrangement is not unusual. And I I bring that up at this
- 3:56point in the conversation because in family systems or
- 4:01needs are not met often in in often there's a hapless quality
- 4:07to that. The caregivers love their
- 4:10children. The the caregivers intend to
- 4:12provide for them in a way that's useful and they intend to
- 4:18support and encourage their children.
- 4:19But when those things don't happen and that's the intention,
- 4:25all the things that I say about coming together and attempting
- 4:29to repair it and to see what it is that you can actually find
- 4:36useful and meaningful in the family system does not apply
- 4:40when the caregivers intended to harm their children, which is a
- 4:45different a kettle of fish and something that happens.
- 4:53My mind just tweaked that. I used an accent of kettle of
- 4:57fish. So I'm I'm going to hear about
- 5:00that from the vegan community. Apologies, bowl of cherries.
- 5:22Sometimes, and Dan Brown used to say that about 11% of people who
- 5:29experience trauma in their family systems, it's
- 5:32intentional. And that's a whole different
- 5:37world of intentional harm. And I, I just want to be really
- 5:43clear that none of the things that I say about gathering
- 5:46together and attempting to repair and seeing the value of
- 5:49the family systems and gathering that up applies to that group of
- 5:54people where there was intentional harm.
- 5:56Christian. George, I'm curious, and you've
- 6:01worked with a lot of people, if you've actually ever seen a
- 6:05family with that level of dysfunction and abuse that was
- 6:08like able to kind of sort itself out?
- 6:19It's a good question, let me think if I can answer it.
- 6:30I have seen a ongoing relationship with siblings and
- 6:42other family members who were not intentionally harming and
- 6:46often with the one if if it was only one caregiver in the family
- 6:51system that was intentionally harming a relationship that that
- 6:57is repairable with the other one, even if the other one
- 7:00didn't intervene unless the the caregiver chose not to intervene
- 7:14when they had the opportunity to.
- 7:23But often not say more often, you know, it's very, it's one
- 7:36thing to have to be on the receiving end of not good enough
- 7:40care. That's a fairly ordinary
- 7:45experience. I mean, you know, imagine being
- 7:48a parent and and meeting your child's needs 100% of the time.
- 7:53It's just, it's unimaginable. But actually security, it's only
- 8:0330% of the time that you have to meet that bar.
- 8:06So it is an astonishingly low bar, which many people are able
- 8:09to do. Of course, when you think about
- 8:16it, you have an 85% chance of inheriting from your primary
- 8:22caregiver the attachment strategy that they use.
- 8:25And so secure family systems tend to produce secure family
- 8:30members who then go on to produce more secure family
- 8:33members. And because secure people do
- 8:37better in the world, you tend to come from more resourced family
- 8:41systems and more resource. Family systems have a better
- 8:44chance at at meeting the needs of children and family systems
- 8:49where there isn't resource. Obviously we're in a larger
- 8:53cultural container and certain societies within our culture are
- 8:59advantage over other societies. If you're born into an African
- 9:07American family, you're you know your family makes $0.51 on the
- 9:13dollar to your similar European descended Caucasian family.
- 9:23You're in a in a a family system that's head headed by a female
- 9:28instead of a male. You know, females make 4074% of
- 9:34what their male counterparts make the they're similar same
- 9:42way. So all things being unequal in
- 9:46our culture depending on that sort of genetic lottery.
- 9:56From the Buddhist perspective, of course, we're just talking
- 9:59about basic karma, but that one's harder for me to wrap my
- 10:05head around. But if you have good enough care
- 10:1230% of the time are better and you have enough resources so
- 10:16that there's not anxiety about, you know, the basics, food,
- 10:22shelter, clothing, medicine. If you have caregivers who are
- 10:30interested in you and what you find interesting and what you're
- 10:34good at and they're supportive and encouraging of that, you go
- 10:38on into a life come from that very early nugget of security.
- 10:46You go into the the the mid childhood experience where
- 10:51you're educated and you learn about the things that our
- 10:55culture values and basic skills. And then maybe you even have
- 11:02enough privilege and enough freedom to actually direct
- 11:06yourself into things that matter to you.
- 11:10This isn't obviously universal. And then you can follow that
- 11:16path of exploration in the way that you need to and that you
- 11:21have a family system that's interested enough in you that
- 11:24they they'd like to stay in touch with you.
- 11:26They like reports on the things that you're doing and you are
- 11:32interested enough in them and you like reports on what they're
- 11:35doing so that there's a synergy that connects and keeps the
- 11:39family together in that way. And generationally, if you have
- 11:44siblings and there's an involvement with the, with
- 11:53siblings and you know, it's not unusual for people to then move
- 11:58out of the, that core nuclear family and then to begin a
- 12:03family each of their own. And then the, the, the
- 12:07generations interacting in that way.
- 12:14In insecure family systems, you learn the family, the system of
- 12:20attachment that the family system offers you.
- 12:23And then it compounds often the difficulties of managing that
- 12:29whole description that I just gave in in different ways and
- 12:35managing relationships, managing the ability to gather resources
- 12:39so that you can pursue a primary exploration.
- 12:46I think that one of the things that's so unusual about the time
- 12:49that we live in is that we actually have this attachment
- 12:52theory framework, which is new. You know, this is the mid 80's,
- 12:59the mid 1980s that we're talking about in terms of the, the
- 13:03presentation of this. And really in terms of
- 13:06attachment interventions, we're, we're really in the 1st 10 years
- 13:12of meaningful attachment interventions.
- 13:18And so that this whole conversation about how we might
- 13:24change that early attachment conditioning and move in a
- 13:28direction that actually is more beneficial for us.
- 13:33And if we undertake doing that, then we're going to interact
- 13:39with our family systems. Maybe other people in the family
- 13:42systems are undertaking it, maybe they're not, but that
- 13:46won't matter so much as you undertaking your attachment
- 13:50repair and then showing up at the family system, no longer
- 13:55really fitting into the system the way that it was and actually
- 14:00no longer willing to participate in the same way that you
- 14:04participated before, which is going to change the entire
- 14:08dynamic of the family. And hopefully they just don't
- 14:11kick you out for disrupting things, which I think is one of
- 14:15the new things that happens. And then the dialogue that you
- 14:22begin to have to perhaps you have with other members of the
- 14:26family. One of the things about
- 14:30attachment theory, which you probably know for yourself is
- 14:33it's mind blowing and it's the easy mind blow.
- 14:37It's not even that hard to, to, to get into the conversation and
- 14:41have these aha moments of insight and then to actually
- 14:48without that much effort, see the advantage of undertaking the
- 14:53what you have to do to, to shift things.
- 14:58Insecure family systems, of course they're intimate and so
- 15:01that they're actually interested in you and insecure family
- 15:05systems, it's more role based. And then you may be able to
- 15:10examine what role assignment you had in the family system and how
- 15:16central to the operation of the family dynamic you inhabiting
- 15:21that role. And maybe as you recognize it,
- 15:24then you're no longer willing to do it.
- 15:26The whole dynamic of the family changing.
- 15:30Of course, if you have a coveted role in the family, everybody's
- 15:33lining up to get the role from you.
- 15:36They're very happy to do it. But if you have a, a
- 15:38disadvantage role, let's say you're the scapegoat in the
- 15:42family system, Nobody wants that role.
- 15:44They're going to be, it's going to be a lot of pressure on you
- 15:47to keep it so that the, the balance of the, the family can
- 15:52be maintained. And then you won't and you'll
- 15:54step, step back from that and the family will have to
- 15:58reorganize in a way that that keeps the balance going.
- 16:04And how welcome will you be in that role of disruptor of the,
- 16:10the, the balance that that is precariously held for so long?
- 16:23And one of the things that does often come up is this sense of
- 16:26what it was that you needed you, that unique person that you were
- 16:31growing up in the world that you found yourself in.
- 16:34And what were they able to do for you and what were they not
- 16:37able to do for you? And what was the cost of that to
- 16:41you in in having to go without the family system being able to
- 16:46meet those needs? And I alluded to this earlier
- 16:52on, but what often happens is in family systems where the
- 16:59resources aren't available to meet those needs, the needs go
- 17:04unmet, which creates in us an expectation that needs will be
- 17:09unmet, that there isn't a way to get those needs met.
- 17:13And depending on how the the you were responded to in, in your
- 17:20insistence on having those needs met, you know, some people grow
- 17:27up and they, they, they believe that they're, they're needy and
- 17:31that they're, they're demanding and that actually they're so
- 17:36needy, in fact, that that presenting needs to people will
- 17:40actually put, push people away from them.
- 17:45But if you put this into perspective, you're an infant
- 17:51and you're making outrageous demands on your caregiver for
- 17:55attention and care, which they're unable to provide for
- 17:59you, and you're shamed into this idea that you are infant needs
- 18:05are outrageous. Can you put that together?
- 18:12Yes, it's totally possible for a caregiver or or several
- 18:18caregivers to be overwhelmed by the needs of a child, but to
- 18:25imagine that a child could come up with outrageous demands that
- 18:29were completely uncalled for is also a stretch imagination or
- 18:41simply there weren't resources and you weren't cared for.
- 18:47Neglect is also something that happens quite often.
- 18:49So neglect, what we really talk about an attachment, the
- 18:53development of secure functioning is these pieces of
- 18:57what was the family loving? Did they provide the care that
- 19:01you needed? Were they neglecting they
- 19:04rejecting they involving in your mind states were requiring you
- 19:14to be involved with the caregivers mind states?
- 19:25So part of this healing process is to really recognize that for
- 19:32the most parts, the needs that you had as children that your
- 19:35caregivers were weren't unable to to meet was the
- 19:39responsibility of the caregivers and they didn't meet them.
- 19:42Not that your demands were outrageous and to touch into the
- 19:49terrible sadness of that that those needs were not met, but to
- 19:54change your relationship to them so that you don't understand
- 19:59that those needs are unmeetable. What what that does to us in the
- 20:04present moment, of course, is when those needs arise or the
- 20:09needs that are like them in the present moment that attach that
- 20:13memory thread to them. We don't make an attempt to get
- 20:17those needs met because we don't believe that it's possible.
- 20:22And that keeps us in a state of deprivation.
- 20:27And then when we return to the family system and those needs
- 20:32arise there and, and the family system can't meet them, it
- 20:36creates this anger that we often experience or the despair in
- 20:42engaging in the family system. And I think that the the
- 20:47reframing of these needs is that for people who could meet those
- 20:52needs, they're not outrageous. They're just the needs that you
- 20:58have in this unique experience of who you are and that actually
- 21:05in certain circumstances, they can even be a source of delight
- 21:09in the relationship. But you still may find that in
- 21:14in returning to the family system that they're unable to do
- 21:17it. They've never really been able
- 21:20to do it, and they're still not able to do it.
- 21:24And so the idea then is to see them clearly for the capacities
- 21:28that they have and the capacities that they don't have,
- 21:31and to receive the things from them that they do have to offer
- 21:37you. And to take the things that they
- 21:40can't do for you and go to other people who can meet those needs.
- 21:46Because often what happens is the things that they can do for
- 21:49you are poisoned by the things that they can't do for you.
- 21:54And the, and the, the this ongoing state of deprivation
- 21:59that you've carried with you interferes with valuing the
- 22:04things that they can do. And because we don't then turn
- 22:11away from the original family system to other people and
- 22:16connect there and to have those needs better than other place,
- 22:21the the deprivation amplifies the sense of distress.
- 22:28Most of the time. I think that the reason that
- 22:35they couldn't meet their needs is because they couldn't do it,
- 22:40not because they could do it and they withheld it from you.
- 22:47Let's see here. So the question in chat is what
- 22:56are the different types of needs which show up in adults?
- 23:02Well, physical proximity is 1, affection is 1A.
- 23:09Sense of valuing, a sense of safety, a sense of reliability
- 23:14and being able to keep agreements in the relationship
- 23:17if there's conflict and it arises, the sense that you could
- 23:20negotiate the conflict and find a settlement to it and not
- 23:34threaten the relationship particularly and insecure and
- 23:40disorganized our relationships. The threat to the relationship
- 23:44if something doesn't go the way that you need it to is is almost
- 23:47always on the table where it's insecure relational dynamics,
- 23:53the relationship is not threatened because there's such
- 23:56a confidence in the ability of the people to negotiate a
- 24:00solution that will work that making sense.
- 24:09If you grew up in a family system where there's no reliable
- 24:12means of conflict negotiation and there's an imbalance of
- 24:16power between the people that manage the the household, then
- 24:25you don't grow up with a sense of confidence that conflicts
- 24:28could be resolved. You grow up in a, in a, in a, in
- 24:36a sense that the world is unfair and you're disadvantaged because
- 24:40you're so powerless. And there's a few ways that
- 24:43people will address that. One is to try and gather as much
- 24:46powers as you can so that you are in the power position.
- 24:50And another one is simply to acquiesce passively to the power
- 24:59and position until you just can't do it anymore and
- 25:02everything blows up, depart, you huff, depart from the
- 25:12relationship. And you know, if you, you grow
- 25:19up in a family system where that those kinds of power balances
- 25:22are ongoing, you really don't rely on it on the relationship.
- 25:27You you develop a sense of independence, a hyper
- 25:32independence really where you're you, you always have an an exit
- 25:39strategy. Makes sense.
- 25:58So going home, Adam. Thanks George.
- 26:09What is the delineation between? Forget the word you use now, but
- 26:18non intentional abuse versus intentional abuse or diabolical.
- 26:25I can't remember the word. Hapless versus sadistic.
- 26:29Hapless versus sadistic. For example, you know, my father
- 26:36had a hell of a temper. And you know, I, I, I, I imagine
- 26:39there's a difference between being so pissed off Sometimes
- 26:43getting angry at your kids just feels good or a relief versus
- 26:49the sadistic abuse that you're talking about.
- 26:53Yes. Say that again.
- 26:58I I'm, I'm just trying to determine, yeah, sadistic abuse
- 27:06between hapless abuse. So you lose your temper, and in
- 27:19losing your temper, you don't inhibit yourself and you strike
- 27:24out and physically harm your child.
- 27:28And then as soon as the wave of anger passes, you're completely
- 27:32filled with remorse and you apologize and you attempt to
- 27:34repair it and attend to the needs of the childless best,
- 27:39best that you can. I would put that in Hapless, the
- 27:43hapless carrot category. You, you're, you completely lose
- 27:50your temper. You feel a sense of injustice in
- 27:53the world and you're going to take it out on your kid so that
- 27:58you feel better. That would be sadistic, but the
- 28:03outside appearance would look much the same.
- 28:07And then there would be a gaslighting experience of for
- 28:12the child rather than a sense of remorse, which is you, you
- 28:18brought this on yourself. You deserved it.
- 28:20It was had you not acted in the way that you acted, this
- 28:24wouldn't have happened. That's the kind of gaslighting
- 28:27that accompanies sadistic abuse. Now you may find that the the
- 28:33caregiver who loses their temper, while genuinely
- 28:37remorseful, does not solve the problem of their temper.
- 28:45And even though it remains in the hapless category, it's in
- 28:49the end is still destructive for the relationship, but not the
- 28:54same. There's a sense of betrayal in
- 28:58the caregiver who doesn't resolve their own problems, but
- 29:03it's not the same doesn't have the same corrosive effect as the
- 29:09betrayal of the the the caregiver who lays in wait to
- 29:15cause harm. Thank you.
- 29:20So and I think that it's it's easier to overcome the hapless
- 29:32abuse by seeing clearly the caregiver, whereas the other is
- 29:40is not solvable really. And then one of the other things
- 29:49about sadistic abuse is that often the attempt to repair it
- 29:54is, is just another opportunity to be sadistic.
- 29:59And so there's there, there's no safety even really attempting to
- 30:03repair it. And so often it makes the
- 30:07estranged. But that accompanies that kind
- 30:09of abuse is often necessary rather than preferable.
- 30:14That makes sense. Yes it does.
- 30:18You can protect yourself from further harm, but let's say it
- 30:33was hapless for the sake of this conversation, because the other
- 30:41is another category. So you attempt to see them
- 30:47clearly so that you can see what they really had to offer.
- 30:52And what we're attempting to discover is that the reason that
- 30:55they denied you the, the care that you needed as a child was
- 30:59not about you. It was really about them.
- 31:03And it wasn't even about volition in the sense that had
- 31:09they had it to give you, they probably would have.
- 31:13But it's really to be able to see that they didn't have it to
- 31:17give you and the experience of not actually having it to give
- 31:22you as in some way so painful for them that they couldn't
- 31:26acknowledge that part. And so they often LED you to
- 31:37believe that you that if you had behaved in a way, right, in a
- 31:46different way that they, they might have provided for you.
- 31:50But those are all protections, I think for themselves rather than
- 31:54for us. And to see them and to really
- 31:58understand what the chances were that that they could have done
- 32:03for you the things that you needed when they didn't.
- 32:10And to take that in that the main reason that they didn't do
- 32:14it is they didn't have it to give you.
- 32:16So they couldn't have given it to you even if you had performed
- 32:19in a way that they might have claimed you should have, even if
- 32:23you were the person that they said that you should be.
- 32:25I mean, often what we find is that we're, we're asked to be
- 32:29somebody that we're not. We're so not so able to do that.
- 32:33It's one of the reasons why it feels compelling to us that that
- 32:44we are we are actually responsible and also the the
- 32:48preserving of the good child, the good parent, bad child of
- 32:51the good caregiver, bad child. It's actually less anxiety
- 32:56producing for a child to think that if they were able to do
- 32:59something differently, that they would be able to have the care
- 33:02that they needed, rather than a caregiver not being capable.
- 33:11And so we look at the caregiver in this sort of idealized way of
- 33:15them being capable and the fault being our own as to why they
- 33:18don't meet our needs, when actually it isn't like that.
- 33:23And so the corrective piece, as hard as that may sound, is to
- 33:28see them the way that they are and to see their capacities the
- 33:32way that they are and to understand that, that they love
- 33:38us and that their intention for us is most of the time good.
- 33:44But they're not able. So we don't feel such
- 33:53disappointment that the things that they are able to offer to
- 33:56us, we don't accept because of that, that anger, that
- 34:04bitterness that sometimes accompanies it.
- 34:07And we're able to then connect with them and to accept from the
- 34:12them as expressions of love, these things that they are able
- 34:17to offer, even if the the bulk of our need needs to be
- 34:21addressed by someone else in a different context that making
- 34:27sense. And then we have the opportunity
- 34:30to connect. We have the opportunity to be
- 34:33with them. We have the opportunity to
- 34:35appreciate them and, and what they, they want to offer to us.
- 34:42And we can find in that the sense of being loved by them.
- 34:51You know, where we, we, we grew up in this human condition.
- 34:56And part of this human condition is that we're brought up by
- 35:00people. You know, we come into the
- 35:02world, you can't even roll over. We can't sit up.
- 35:09We're entirely dependent on somebody taking care of us.
- 35:14And the working model of ourselves we develop based on
- 35:19the response of the caregiver. And if the caregiver isn't so
- 35:24good at taking care of us, the working model we develop of
- 35:30ourselves is not based on we express our needs and somebody
- 35:36meets them. Imagine going through the the
- 35:40world like that. I have a need.
- 35:42Somebody will help me, I'll just express it.
- 35:54And the world will respond by meeting my needs.
- 36:08Where, you know, if we don't, if we as human, human babies don't
- 36:18think somebody's going to take care of us, we fail to thrive,
- 36:21even we'd be shut down and, and just die.
- 36:24It's, it's that deep. And so at whatever point in, in
- 36:32life that we can see clearly who our caregivers were and see what
- 36:36capacities that they have, they had then and the capacities that
- 36:43they have now. And to find in that the way in
- 36:49which they're capable of expressing love and, and, and
- 36:55then being able to experience it as loving is valuable to us
- 37:03really can go a long way to repair some of these difficult
- 37:08working models that we develop. But this in, in no way suggests
- 37:13that you should return to an abusive relationship and in no
- 37:19way suggests that you should be overcome by afflicted guilt.
- 37:27And in, you know, in, in Buddhism, we talk about emotions
- 37:31as neutral in the relationship to the emotion as beneficial or
- 37:34afflictive. And, and guilt is one of those
- 37:38emotions that arises and in a beneficial experience of it, it,
- 37:44it propels us to perform the functions that we're supposed
- 37:49to. And in in afflictive sense, it
- 37:53compels us to perform things that we're not actually supposed
- 37:59to be doing. So we do want still this sense
- 38:03of freedom where we we can engage or not engage and we're
- 38:07not compelled by an afflictive experience.
- 38:19This is also true, of course, with siblings, if you have them
- 38:26in, in, in a lot of households, the sibling relationships are
- 38:32are conflicted and difficult sometimes.
- 38:36And to be able to see often that some of the behaviors that
- 38:41happened were part of this process of the family system
- 38:46balancing itself and, and the the delivery of messages,
- 38:52caregivers and all sorts of involvements that may have
- 38:57precluded a bond, a sibling bond from forming.
- 39:04Of course some sibling groups gather up and, and form very
- 39:11tight bonds as a way of relating in the family system, but it's
- 39:16often that there's a separation that happens between them.
- 39:20Contact is difficult if there's a way there to to open a
- 39:27dialogue, particularly as you begin to address your own
- 39:33patterns of attachment conditioning and move from
- 39:39insecure, say a dismissing attachment or helplessly
- 39:43preoccupied or even disorganized, into a more secure
- 39:46functioning. Often there's an opportunity to
- 39:51repair that as well. So I, I think that it's really
- 40:04mainly this process of being able to see clearly what
- 40:09happened, what happened to you, what effect it had on you and
- 40:16how that led to a cascade of decisions that you made to end
- 40:20up where you are. And that that also unfolded for
- 40:23the other members of the family and.
- 40:26To begin to see clearly who they are, understand what you need
- 40:32from them, and then to understand their capacities,
- 40:38whether they could or could not manage that for you.
- 40:43And then allow an exchange of care in a, in a frame that's
- 40:50actually representative of of people's capacities.
- 40:53And then the things that aren't, you aren't able to get met in
- 40:58those in that frame, take those out into the world and and fill
- 41:05them with other people. So it's very different to return
- 41:09to the the family, seeing with your needs largely met by the
- 41:17community that you've put around yourself so that you're not a
- 41:21reactive to these deprivations that can arise.
- 41:27So that you're then free to engage more with with what
- 41:31happens with what with who people are.
- 41:37How did you end up in the family you ended up in?
- 41:44These are deeper questions. What do you say we do some
- 41:51loving kindness practice? So go ahead and settle into your
- 41:58meditation posture. We'll do some loving kindness
- 42:00herself and also for all right, let go of the meditation.
- 42:09But we have a work Adam. Thanks.
- 42:15Just you know, it it, it's always hit or miss.
- 42:21I mean, all these are and particularly with any kind of
- 42:28meta practice, I know you've mentioned in the past, you just
- 42:36in a, in a way have to be relentless, but there seems to
- 42:43be this, this line of frustration.
- 42:51In other words, I'll, I'll, I'll try to be relentless, but then
- 42:57that just turns into me getting pissed off.
- 43:00Or anger being the far enemy of loving kindness.
- 43:06Yeah, yeah. I just, I can't seem to
- 43:13cultivate this idea of of being relentless without that coming
- 43:26up can. You find the mind state.
- 43:33Yeah, sometimes I can, sometimes I can't.
- 43:36One of the things that seemed to to work this time was keeping my
- 43:42eyes open and just repeating it out loud over and over and over.
- 43:48Just basically doing whatever I possibly could to prevent
- 43:54anything else from coming into my, my, my, my mind visually.
- 44:01You know, for me, closing my eyes, I, because I'm so visual,
- 44:09seems to be not the right route for me because I will just, or
- 44:14maybe it's just a lack of concentration.
- 44:16I don't know. I just it, it's so easy for me
- 44:20to get pulled off track visually with my eyes closed.
- 44:24Does that make sense? Totally.
- 44:27Yeah. Can you hold a still image?
- 44:31In my mind, no. OK, so that would be a
- 44:36concentration object for that. See if you can hold a still
- 44:39image. So.
- 44:41So remembering a photograph or something like that often can be
- 44:45helpful. Yeah, I've So what I've done in
- 44:50the past, I actually did it this time too, was I, I will
- 44:54literally hold a photograph and I will look at it with my eyes
- 44:58open. And I mean, that's just what it
- 45:02seems to take sometimes. Yeah, that's fine.
- 45:06Cool. Why is that a problem?
- 45:08I don't know I because because there's that voice that says I'm
- 45:13doing it wrong, so I needed. So the response to that voice is
- 45:19always thank you so much for sharing.
- 45:21Now go stand in the corner and look at the wall.
- 45:27And go fuck yourself. Thanks.
- 45:36All right, somebody else. Good.
- 45:43So we have a workshop in November coming up on how to go
- 45:47home for the holidays, which is actually the topic that I just
- 45:50talked about. But we'll we'll do some
- 45:52meditation and some IPF around that so that we can ideal parent
- 45:57figures, so we can go a little bit deeper into that.
- 46:01And then the past upon us is the end of the year.
- 46:04So get ready to enjoy that. I do offer the teaching freely,
- 46:11but I do hope that if you your resource and can make a
- 46:14donation, you'll consider it. There's links on the website for
- 46:18making a donation. Oops, I realize I'm supposed to
- 46:25put one in the drop box. Let's see here and then.
- 46:43If I have it, here it is, oops, I I mean in the chat and then I
- 47:02hope to see you somewhere at the path.
- 47:06See you later. Bye.