Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Industry Is Shrinking
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've been at your company for eighteen months. You're performing well—above expectations on your last review. But your industry is shrinking. Layoffs are in the news. Funding rounds are getting pulled. And you still want to ask for a raise. Is that realistic? Luna: I think a lot of people are in that exact spot right now. Especially in biotech, but also in parts of tech and cleantech. The instinct is to just stay quiet and be grateful you have a job. Lucas: And that instinct is understandable. But staying quiet can also cost you years of compounding earnings. So let's be concrete about when it makes sense to push—and how to do it without looking out of touch. Luna: Before we go deep—and I know this ties in—I wanted to mention something a few listeners have asked about. A handful of people chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's literally what funds making this many episodes. No ads, no sponsors. Just listener support. Lucas: Yeah, it's been that way since day one. And it means we can keep drilling into these specific scenarios without worrying about pleasing an advertiser. So if you've gotten value from the show, that's the mechanism. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Exactly. And now back to the raise question. I think the first thing people need to do is let go of the standard playbook. Lucas: Right. The standard playbook says: 'Come armed with market data. Show that you're paid below the seventy-fifth percentile. Threaten to leave.' In a shrinking industry, that argument collapses because there are ten qualified candidates for every open role. Luna: So instead of market comps, what do you use? Lucas: You anchor to retained value. The question isn't 'What could I get elsewhere?' It's 'What would it cost the company to replace me right now?' That's a much stronger card in a contraction. Because hiring freezes mean backfilling is a nightmare. Your manager might not be able to post your role for six months. Luna: So you're essentially saying: 'I'm already productive. A new hire would take three months to ramp. You can't even hire right now.' That's real leverage. Lucas: Exactly. And you need to quantify that. Not in a threatening way, but as a business case. Say: 'I'm currently leading the X project that's on track to deliver Y revenue. If I left, that timeline would slip by at least a quarter. A ten percent increase in my base is a fraction of the cost of that delay.' Luna: And you frame it as retention, not reward. That's a subtle shift but it changes the whole conversation. Lucas: Huge. You're not saying 'I deserve this because I'm great.' You're saying 'It is in the company's interest to keep me in this seat.' That lands very differently when budgets are being scrutinized. Luna: What about timing? If the company just did layoffs, you don't want to walk in the next week. Lucas: No. You want to find an internal inflection point. Maybe a major milestone just hit—a product launch, a funding extension, a key customer signed. That's the moment when your contribution is most visible. Avoid calendar anniversaries. Those feel like entitlements. Luna: And if your manager says no? That's pretty common in a downturn. Lucas: Then you pivot to non-salary concessions. Ask for an equity refresh—restricted stock units with a shorter vesting schedule. Or a guaranteed bonus if the company hits certain targets. Or a title change that positions you better when the market recovers. These cost the company less cash upfront but still move the needle for you. Luna: I've seen people get a 'senior' title and then use that to land a much better job eighteen months later. That's real value. Lucas: Absolutely. And one more thing: get any agreement in writing. Even if it's a simple email saying 'Per our conversation, we've agreed to revisit comp in Q1 contingent on X.' That creates a commitment your manager can't forget. Luna: So summary: anchor to replacement cost, pick your moment after a win, and have a plan B that isn't just cash. Lucas: Exactly. And if you do it right, you're not being tone-deaf. You're being strategic. The company needs to retain its best people even when times are tough. You're just helping them see that you're one of those people. Luna: I think that's a good place to leave it. Next episode we'll talk about how to handle a raise request when your manager says 'I'll get back to you' and then just never does. Lucas: That's a classic. See you then.