Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 229- Describing Cinema with Author/Professor Timothy Corrigan
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of Yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is doug Hess and if you're tuning into Forgotten Hollywood for the first time,
- 0:29what I do on this podcast is take you on the journey back in
- 0:32time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not know
- 0:37about. And today we have a professor, author Timothy Corgan, with his
- 0:43latest book Describing Cinema. Welcome Timothy to Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you very much,
- 0:49happy to be here. Oh it's a pleasure, and thank you for
- 0:52spending just a few minutes of your time to talk about your book Describing Cinema.
- 0:57And really the first question I'll ask you is maybe allow you to describe
- 1:02what the book is about to the audience. Yeah, well, it's about
- 1:04what the title suggests. It's about how how we describe cinema in the in
- 1:11the largest terms. That is, you know, how we talk about cinema,
- 1:15and uh, that has to do with you know, every dimension of
- 1:19what that implies. More generally, you know, I've always been interested in
- 1:26how we interact with films and movies, what the what the experience is like
- 1:32as a viewer spectator of onesoe or another. And that sort of led me
- 1:37to this, this particular part of that, which is on one hand,
- 1:42a really kind of basic experience, which is when we when we go to
- 1:47the movies, uh, you know, all of us, probably we come
- 1:51out of there with friends, we talk about movies. We run into friends
- 1:56or our acquaintances the next day and they say, oh, saw that movie,
- 2:00Tell me about it, and it seems like a fairly innocent act.
- 2:05That is how we describe movies. That in some ways it's most sort of
- 2:09fundamental, uh shape. But I'm also interested in writing quite a bit about
- 2:15how writing comes into play here, so that I want to move from that
- 2:19sort of fundamental experience about how we talk about movies, how we use words
- 2:23to describe what happened, which are not innocent acts, you know, frankly
- 2:28in mind, to how we write about movies. And that involves everything from
- 2:34you know, people who write reviews to people who write academic criticism and so
- 2:38forth. And I think frequently that's considered you know, a much more intellectual
- 2:45complex process as you get towards reviews and academic writing. But I think it's
- 2:52in some ways a very complicated process, and that you know, simply sitting
- 2:57down with three or four sentences describing, you know, what you saw last
- 3:00weekend involves a lot of values, a lot of assumptions, a lot of
- 3:05perceptions. And it's not like it's not as if I'm trying to deconstruct that
- 3:09in a negative way. I'm embracing it. I think that's a great part
- 3:13of our film experience. It's that dialogue we have with it, how we
- 3:16use words with it. Yeah, you know, it's interesting you were describing
- 3:22all that, and I got thinking here very quickly. Is in a way
- 3:25we all believe we're a film critic. Absolutely when we come out of the
- 3:31movie theater or we're watching and streaming, we may be with somebody and we
- 3:37immediately after the end of the film, we kind of give our thoughts,
- 3:39our review on that. But also we kind of take it a step further.
- 3:43I believe when it comes to social media. I you know, for
- 3:47a time you would read something in a magazine or a newspaper from a film
- 3:53critic, but now with social media, I feel like you see a lot
- 3:59more common folks, if I can use that word giving their two sentins,
- 4:03and it's more than just one or two sentences. I mean, I've been
- 4:06seeing paragraphs just individuals walking out of a movie theater, all right. And
- 4:13I think, you know, the social media has just exploded this in terms
- 4:15of things like letterbox or there's other sites where they do that. And you
- 4:20know, I've always said that, you know, as when I would teach
- 4:25THEMS at my university, Well, you know, the double edged sort of
- 4:29that as opposed to teaching physics or or I don't know, biology or something
- 4:33like that, is you're dealing with, for the most part, an audience
- 4:39who come in thinking and maybe knowing that they know a lot about movies,
- 4:45and nobody's hesitant to talk about them. We all have our opinions, we
- 4:48all our assumptions about them, and that's what makes the movie so exciting.
- 4:53You know, everybody loves to talk about them, and everybody has stronger opinions
- 4:57about them. And I want to sort of tease how you know that can
- 5:00become both rigorous and creative, an interesting and creative process at the same time.
- 5:09Yeah. Absolutely, And you know, with that social media and that
- 5:14word of mouth that can actually take a good movie that maybe somebody wasn't interested
- 5:18in seeing at first and move that along in the culture phenomena. Absolutely,
- 5:26And you know again, I think it's it's what makes the movies still today
- 5:30as always so central to kind of a cultural experience is because we're able to
- 5:36and we're very confident, I think, for the most part as viewers articulating
- 5:42our opinions and in some ways arguing our opinions. And I think that process,
- 5:47which is a linguistic process always in some ways is it kind of producing
- 5:54of ideas. You know, we produce ideas, we produce positions, and
- 6:00that even if it's just casual, if we're having a beer after with a
- 6:03friend, it's a thought process that's going on. Yeah. I mean I
- 6:09have to say in terms of you know, I have to say in terms
- 6:13of, you know, the history of this is, you know, I
- 6:16do sort of locate, you know, the sort of evolution of how we
- 6:20write about movies and how we talk about movies through the twentieth century. But
- 6:25you know, in some ways the watershed years for me are you know,
- 6:28the nineteen forties when there was this explosion of dynamic really articulate and creative critics.
- 6:35James A. G And Mandy Farber and these people they really redefined,
- 6:41certainly film criticism, but they also in some ways unleashed all the potential to
- 6:47be an articulate viewer and to take positions, even really debatable positions, I
- 6:54suppose. Yeah, Now, it's really interesting and I think with social media
- 7:00that has kind of created, you know, we've already talked about it,
- 7:03but a whole new level in a new world of critics out there. Some
- 7:10are more articulate than others, and it's just really interesting to see how individuals
- 7:18view a film. Some of them will take it at face value as completely
- 7:21entertainment and right it that way, and then somebody else wants to nitpick with
- 7:28history because the movie's got it all wrong or they ad lived or whatever.
- 7:33And it's just really interesting to see how we as a society kind of break
- 7:39some of that down. Yeah, And I think, you know, in
- 7:42many ways, you know, this is what we have to pay attention to,
- 7:46is what what is good criticism these days? What is a good response?
- 7:53And you know, there's no sort of you know, measuring right for
- 7:57that for me, but you know, what does allow me to think about,
- 8:01is you know, who's using words to articulate subtle or insightful perceptions of
- 8:07the movies or to enter debates in in in complex ways. And that's always
- 8:16been what I really enjoy is when you can read a critic or a review
- 8:24and it makes you stop and think. You know, to me, I
- 8:28think that's some of the best ones. I mean, because everybody can go
- 8:31out there and say it's a great movie. I liked it, and great
- 8:33acting or special effects or whatever. But to really move the conversation and to
- 8:39allow you to just kind of maybe sit there and ponder on the film that
- 8:43you just watched. To me, that that's the most important things. I
- 8:48agree completely. And you know, what what my book is is about is
- 8:54in many ways saying, let's get well beyond the thumbs up or thumb comes
- 9:00down relationship with movies. Let's start try and articulate in a very measured way,
- 9:05what it is that caught our eye, what it is that we heard,
- 9:09what it is that makes this movie good or bad or complex in some
- 9:13ways. And you know, that's you know, for me, what's most
- 9:18interesting about talking about the movie experience and movie reviews and movie scholarship and so
- 9:26forth. These days is how the writing itself invigorates the movies absolutely, because
- 9:31a lot of times I'll watch a film once for the pure entertainment value of
- 9:37it. A lot of times I just want to watch a film and do
- 9:41it. And then I love to read, whether there's a book about it
- 9:45or a review or a criticism, whatever, and then try to watch it
- 9:50through those lens, if you will. And it's amazing what you can take
- 9:54away from a film. And I a lot of times find myself changing my
- 10:00opinion on the film from the first to the second, showing yeah, absolutely.
- 10:05And I often find myself changing my opinion when I'm reading something that I'm
- 10:09going, well, I never thought about this. And you know, one
- 10:13of my analogies is a sports in the sense that you know, I like
- 10:20baseball, football, all that stuff. Sure, but I find myself,
- 10:24you know, I'll watch a game, but and then the next day I'll
- 10:28sit down and read, you know, the newspaper about the game, and
- 10:33I'm just as interested in how that game is being articulated by a good writer
- 10:37in some ways to make me think about it differently, to make me see
- 10:41it differently. Well, And sometimes I've even questioned myself and said that I
- 10:45just watched the same game or the same movie that they did, because they
- 10:50made me think about it in a completely different way. And I'm like,
- 10:54wow, they're spot on and I hadn't even thought about it in that Yeah.
- 10:58Yeah, you know, I actually don't enjoy anything more than if I
- 11:05have a friend or a colleague that I really respect, and I'll say to
- 11:09her, I'll say, you know, did you see Four Things or did
- 11:11you see Maestro? I loved that movie? And they respond I hated it.
- 11:18I hated it. And that's the beginning of I think a really great
- 11:24intellectual, cultural, personal conversation about things. Well why what for? And
- 11:31it all comes founded you know, what words are you using, frankly to
- 11:35you to describe that movie? Yep? Absolutely, and the culture that you're
- 11:39being brought up in. I mean all that goes into how you view a
- 11:45movie or a film. Yeah, And I mean I mean I have this.
- 11:48I mean I got interested in this project when you know, I'm retired
- 11:52now, but I you know, I've taught intro classes at my different universities
- 11:56for many, many years and go in there and as I said, I
- 12:01love teaching it because most people, most students come in, they go like,
- 12:05I know about movies. I'm just thinking because I want to see some
- 12:09movies. He's not going to do anything. And I love like showing a
- 12:16sequence or a scene from a particular movie, you know whatever I mean.
- 12:20In the book, for instance, I start off with Vincente Minnali's Meet Me
- 12:24in Saint Louis, and I say, okay, let's just look at this
- 12:28one scene here with Judy Garland, and I'm going to show it once the
- 12:35I'm going to show the sequence again, and I want you to describe it
- 12:39exactly. And then and it's astonishing how you know, you know what,
- 12:43I know what happened, you know how she's singing his arm and blah blah
- 12:46blah, and say no, no, I want you to describe what the
- 12:48colors look like. I want you to describe where the camera is. And
- 12:52as they begin to describe it and to look at it not just for what
- 12:56happens, but Howard's shown, you see in some ways just open up in
- 13:01terms of different ideas and they go, whoa, whoa. I've looked at
- 13:05that scene three times and now I'm looking at it completely differently. As I
- 13:09try and put it into words, yeah, because a lot of times they're
- 13:11just looking at face value, they're not looking at the I don't want to
- 13:16say hitting meeting. But sometimes there may be a hidden mean in there,
- 13:20or a message that the director or somebody is trying to portray to you.
- 13:26And sometimes some of those younger students just need to need a little help to
- 13:33reveal the code. For lack of a better word, well, yeah,
- 13:35or you know, the way I often put it is, you know,
- 13:37most of us, myself included, when we look at a movie, we're
- 13:41looking at what's happening. You know, how do they get you? How
- 13:46get there? You know? Who killed whom and all of that, And
- 13:50and you said, well, you know, yeah, that's really important.
- 13:52I love to know what's happened in the movie. But you know, tell
- 13:56me about the way those characters are blocked in that scene. Why is Bogart
- 14:00over here and Call over here? And why do they move around this way?
- 14:03And then they start to say, well, more than just what's happening,
- 14:07it's really about how it's seen, and how it's seen becomes for me,
- 14:13how do you describe what is seen? In a very much more subtle
- 14:16way, yes. And I have to say this, this, this,
- 14:20this, this book was really quite fun to write because once you sort of
- 14:28opened the door to the fact that there's not one particular meaning in a particular
- 14:33film, but you say, it has a lot to do with your own
- 14:35experience too. You can kind of play around with your experience and you know
- 14:41what you bring to that experience as you try to describe it. Yeah,
- 14:46anything surprised you doing your research and the writing of this book. I think,
- 14:52what what a couple of things. One is, you know, I
- 14:56try to, you know, look at films from around the world from nineteen
- 15:01forty five till today. But as I you know, to pick that decade
- 15:07of the forties, when I started to read more into these early critics,
- 15:13these these reviewers, these journalists like ag and Manny Farber and the rest of
- 15:20them during that period. I mean, man, those guys could write.
- 15:24They really knew how to write. And secondly, what they knew how to
- 15:30how they knew to write. And what surprised me is the extent to which
- 15:35when you let your personal opinions and your personal feelings get mapped out and worked
- 15:41out through a movie, it really creates a very thick canvas of what you're
- 15:46seeing, you know, and that it's okay to say I'm starting with you
- 15:50know, I hate Westerns, but for some reason I love this Western or
- 15:56something. Why so yeah, yeah. And the other thing is, you
- 16:00know, when you were talking and some of some things that just kind of
- 16:03came to my mind is, you know, remakes, how even directors will
- 16:11interpret a film that has been remade, you know, three or four times
- 16:15out there. I always find that to be interesting as well. You have
- 16:21what I'm going to recall, the original or the first and then how it
- 16:23has changed. Sometimes people love the original, and then sometimes you know,
- 16:29some of the remakes become a little bit better because of the way it's been
- 16:33interpreted or described right, and and and you know, in terms of that
- 16:37description of the remake, you know, somebody who maybe have not seen their
- 16:41original suddenly sees this and thinks it's sees it one way, but somebody who's
- 16:47seen the original is bringing a whole different set of experiences to how he or
- 16:52she describes it in some way or another. And it's also you know,
- 16:56it's you know, there's there are movies which you know, which we have
- 17:03forgotten. And I think that that's an interesting part of it. If somebody
- 17:07said, you know, can you do you remember how you know Vertigo opens?
- 17:11And you go, yeah, and you may have it all wrong,
- 17:14but it creates a really kind of interesting dynamic in terms of your memory and
- 17:18your experience of the movie. And you know, that's the really fertile ground
- 17:22for me is you know, how you know movies that you maybe misremember or
- 17:27I had a colleague or a book about unwatchable movies, movies which you just
- 17:32can't watch, and then how do you describe them? You know, they're
- 17:34just painful to watch. So there's all spectrum of experiences in terms of what
- 17:41we bring to the movies and how we like dislike them, but how we
- 17:45try and describe them in that way? Absolutely and you know, and I
- 17:49think you know the takeaway for me is at least at the end of the
- 17:52day, each of us have our own opinions or own thoughts, and there's
- 17:57really not a right or wrong. It's just a lot of times we think
- 18:03the other person is wrong because we're right, and really everybody has his or
- 18:07her own take on something. Oh that's absolutely right, Doug. And you
- 18:11know, I to just be a provocer too right now, I would say
- 18:15that, yeah, you're in that situation where everybody's got their own opinion.
- 18:18Who's going to win that argument is the one who knows how to use words
- 18:21better, somebody who can dance around somebody with good words. Absolutely, And
- 18:26I think that's a perfect way to end this episode, is making sure that
- 18:32you can defend your actions with those perfect words. Action to your actions,
- 18:37but your description of a film, well, your interpretation just you know,
- 18:41you don't have to have perfect words, but you you've got to pay attention
- 18:45to your words, yes, because they're going to have an effect on how
- 18:48others interpret how you see a film or how you watched it exactly, exactly.
- 18:56Well, Timothy, thank you so much for coming on and spending a
- 18:59few minutes with us today. I've forgotten Hollywood, and I'm going to strongly
- 19:03encourage our audience to go out and get a copy of Timothy's book, Describing
- 19:07Cinema. It's out there to out there now, it's out by Oxford University
- 19:12Press. I want to make sure that we give them a shout out,
- 19:15So please go out and get a copy of Describing Cinema. I don't think
- 19:19you're going to be disappointed. And again, Timothy, thank you so much
- 19:22for spending some time with us today. I really enjoyed our conversation. Thanks
- 19:26for inviting me. Doug again, it was a pleasure to be here.
- 19:30Yes, and thank you. Thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten
- 19:33Hollywood. Just search for Doug castor Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me
- 19:36on Twitter, Instagram at hes dog fourteen. If you listen to this podcast
- 19:38in another iTunes or another podcast service, please subscribe, rate and review this
- 19:44episode. Tune in next time for this episode Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for
- 19:48listening and we will see you then.