Latest / The PR Bunker / Elevating Donor Relations: Susan Kahan
Transcript
- Don Martelli: Welcome back to the PR bunker, friends. I am down here a very chilly Boston basement. It is about two below nothing at literally 26 degrees here in Boston. But ⁓ bringing the heat today is my new friend Susan. We met through alignable, which is one of the largest platforms for small owners in North America to help folks like us meet people. Learn from other folks and get connected and do business. Susan, like me, works in a nonprofit space, but on the other side, she's the one that actually gets in there and raises money. But before we get on that, Susan, thanks for joining me down in the PR bunker. Pleasure to have you here today. Susan Kahan: Thank you, Dawn, it's great to be with you. Don Martelli: Well, when we first met I said I got to have her on my podcast. I love her story because as I said to you before, feel everybody's story is a little messy and we get to where we get and that's it. And you've learned some things over the years. So before we begin, tell us about your business, your work and how you got here. Susan Kahan: Great, so my company is Sapphire Fundraising Specialists. I founded it almost five years ago, which is crazy how time really flies. But I founded it to help establish nonprofits on their fundraising strategy ⁓ ensure that their staff and their board feel more confident ⁓ clear about what they're trying to do to raise more money. Because the goal is never the money, it's to get great impact in the work. And I help them provide the resources that they need to do that. Don Martelli: love that, which is really hard these days to do because anybody's attention on anything is really, really hard, especially to give money if it's not really important, but get that in a second. So but how'd you get here? Clearly, you wake up one morning up, I'm going to be in the fundraising space like what would you go to school for? What's your journey to today? Susan Kahan: Yes. to know. Yes, well, great question. I joke that no little girl or little boy says when I grow up, I want to be a fundraiser. I do think we need to figure out a way to change that. But that's a project for a long term project of mine. But no one really thinks that way. And I definitely did not. thought I would work in the nonprofit sector. ⁓ of my family had been involved in nonprofits for a while. ⁓ in college, I actually thought I'd be more of the marketing PR type of person. ⁓ when I was looking for a job after college, was, you know, this amazing opportunity fell into my lap where I would get to work at an endowment and plan giving team at a national nonprofit. And it was part marketing, it part finance, was part fundraising, and it was administrative, and it was a great learning experience. And I always say to anyone who's looking to get started right out of college, you're not looking for your peak job at 22. And if you are, that's a long career ahead of you if you're peaking at 22. So you want to find a job that's It gives you lots of exploration, lots of learning, lots of trying new things, lots of observing other people. And this job was definitely that. And I really fell in love with fundraising. And so I did fundraising for the next 12 or so years until I thought, you know, I'm ready to do something a little different, be entrepreneurial. And I started my own company in 2021. Don Martelli: Wow. How scary was that? Stepping on the dance floor when there's nobody else on the dance floor? must say it's as an entrepreneur, I get it. But like, walk me through your brain at that moment. Like what was the moment when you decided to cut the cord? And like, what's what was that like? Susan Kahan: Enough. yeah, you know, going back, ⁓ had been thinking about consulting for a little while prior. And then I actually, I really credit this one person who I know was not a close person to me, but we chatting and schmoozing and ⁓ he started his own company and he had said, you know, you could do this too. And I said, you know, me, like, what are you talking about? And I had never really thought of it, but once the was in my mind, I was like, wait, I could do this. ⁓ And I started talking with people I trusted and respected and some people who'd started their own company. they were like, you absolutely could do this. And what's the worst that can happen? And in my case, the worst that could happen was I had to get another development job. And that didn't feel that scary at the time. ⁓ starting a business, especially a consulting business like you or I have, ⁓ extremely heavy, excuse me, not heavy, expensive to get started. So, you know, like there's some costs for sure, but it's not a huge outlay of cash. like if you're opening a store or something like that, or you need to distribute materials. So I thought I'm at an age and at a point in my life where this made sense. And so I was like, let's go for it. Don Martelli: Wow. Wow. And so what are the early days like? I mean, how do you get a how do you get a book of business and how do you get going? And as you talk through that, like as you get engaged with the client, what are the things you start on day one? What's the work look like? Susan Kahan: Yeah, well, would say to get started is you got to tell everybody you know that you're doing this and you can't be shy about saying this is what I'm doing. I'm still learning. I'm you know, I've never started a business before, but just telling people this is what I'm offering and being open to conversations and networking. I think that is extremely important and most of my clients originally start with people I had already known and think actually ⁓ the part is not the first book of business, but the second book of business. Once you've exhausted your network, that second list is much, harder. So I would say after year two or so, it's harder to maintain it. I don't know if that's similar for you, Dawn, but. Don Martelli: But you're right, you're nailed it. For me, it's if you were starting your business today, you're gonna call probably 10 2030 4050 people who are your top 50. Because if you don't have that top 50 to your point, you're just out there with a sandwich board going, hey, I take business for food, right? You just like you've got to build that network. And I think of my networking, my network as an asset. Like I built this thing, right? I wouldn't be where I am today. Without it. Susan Kahan: Absolutely. Absolutely. Don Martelli: And I probably wouldn't have been connected to you because now we're on the platform doing that same thing because of it. So I, a thousand percent agree with you, nailed it. Susan Kahan: Absolutely, absolutely. So yeah, and I also think with networking is this is not a one time thing. This is not you think about it one time of year. This has to be a constant part of business to keep it going, especially. Yes, high five to you. And the thing again is that, you know, people only remember so much about you and only remember you so. Don Martelli: Agreed, Preach it, preach it girlfriend. have pre- 1000%. I love that. High fives. Susan Kahan: so frequently. And it's not that they're not, don't care, they don't want to be helpful, but people are focused on themselves just like we all are. And so with networking and business development, you really have to stay top of mind. So I, you know, get a newsletter, I post a lot on LinkedIn, I go to a lot of networking events. So all of those things have helped me to get to where I am. And so hope that answers the first part of the question. And then this, ⁓ Don Martelli: great. It does. does. That's great. That's good. Because you built it organically. You build your network, conversations, marketing, you told your story, leverage those relationships and every every every Django block you stack just led to the next one. Susan Kahan: Absolutely. Absolutely. It's all a lot of little seeds being planted. And the other thing I'll also just add is, you know, I'm a company of one. I like to show, I like to maybe project a little bit bigger and I maybe work with some people here and there, but really I'm a company of one. And I can't compete financially or really in any way in terms of SEO AIO. You know, I can't get that paid. Don Martelli: Yeah, you're right. Susan Kahan: ⁓ marketing or sponsorship levels like a bigger company can. And that again is where your network, someone remembers, you you Don, Don who does this one thing or me Susan who does this one thing in a way that they're not going to think of the company hopefully. again, I think that also is why networking is so important. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. smart smart. as you you clearly as you start working your network, bringing in business in, even if the nonprofits in the same industry, no, no nonprofit is exactly the same, the people, the systems, all that. I mean, it can be messy, right? I you get in there, you're in your, you're seen as the the, know, the white princess on the on the horse coming in saving the day, right? But it's, it's, it's Fight Club in there, right? So you're more like, you're one those fighting Disney princesses than the typical princess, right? Susan Kahan: That's right. Don Martelli: What's it like going in there when you're day one and you're looking around opening underneath the hood? What's that like for you? And tell me it talk to us about the process. Susan Kahan: Absolutely. Yeah. Well, I joke that I like to be the bad guy. I don't like to be the princess that's going to save the day. I'm going to be the bad. I am the badass and I'm the one who's actually going to punch them where it hurts and say, this isn't working. That's really where I see myself because oftentimes, like you said, each nonprofit has their own little quirks and strengths and things. But oftentimes, what is a big obstacle is internal politics. Don Martelli: You wanna be the badass. Love that. Love it. Love it. Love it. Susan Kahan: personalities, maybe some bored influences and getting people to be like, why are you doing this this way? I know this is our you know, I can't tell you how many times I've heard it. I'm sure you've heard this too, Don, where it's like, well, this is the way we do it. Right? This is the way we do it. And we've always done it this way. And it's worked for us. And let me tell you, you know, you're talking a lot about it's hard to get seen. It's hard to get attention. It is a busy, busy world out there. People are Don Martelli: Love that. All the time. Susan Kahan: inundated with messages and content from all types. And, you know, what might have worked two years ago, five years ago, 25 years ago, is we are in a different world and it is changing ever more. And, and so you've got to think, well, maybe, and this is where I think having a trusted consultant and a trusted partner come in and say, perhaps we should try this. Could we try it? Don Martelli: yesterday. Mm. Mm. Susan Kahan: And so that's where I again, I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna solve the problem for you. I don't do that. But I'm gonna help you think about maybe we need to shift our strategy because what you wanted wasn't working. Don Martelli: are some of the the biggest challenges you feel nonprofits have these days that you're there to unlock? mean, is it things like, you know, having a ⁓ as as having a solid email list? Is it as simple as segmentation? Obviously, I know this world real well, because of my space. But like for those that are getting into ⁓ the space or ⁓ running a nonprofit, what are some of those common mistakes that they make that you see day one that you want to fix? Susan Kahan: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think it depends a little bit on what stage the nonprofit is at. If they're newer or emerging, I think, you know, which I work less with, I work usually with the organizations that have been around for several years already. But if they're newer, yes, they don't have an email list and they don't prioritize, even if they are interacting with a whole bunch of individuals, they're not saying how do we get that contact information, organize it in one place. track people in the right way so that we can see their development over time, whether that's giving or just engagement or opening of emails and all of those things. And they just think, well, we've just got to do the work of the organization or the mission, I should say. And they're not thinking about the business structure. And if you don't have the good operations, which means having the right email list, having a website that functions properly, your story out, asking for money and generating more money every year. If you don't have the, know, having a good account. Counting policies. mean, like all of these things that aren't the sexy, exciting things are really critical for organizations to survive and thrive moving forward. And if you're just focused on the mission work and you're just focused on, well, we've got to meet these needs of our people, but you're not thinking about the backend, it's really going to be unsuccessful. And I'll say, you know, in relation to our business, it's the same thing. If you're only focused on client work and you're never thinking about... Don Martelli: Any questions? Susan Kahan: The accounting of, know, and making sure you're getting paid for your work and you're never thinking about how you market and you're never thinking about is my message resonating with the people I want and building an email list and all those things, it's exactly the same. So I really think you need to have both the external and the work and you got to the operations. Don Martelli: Got it. Got it. So I have to assume that as you get into these engagements, know, month one, six, 12, 24, there's just the jangle blocks that get built, right? So clearly you go in day one to day 60, things change. But, you know, after you've done this a cycle or two, because, you know, clearly there's a, you know, there's a financial cycle. Most of these nonprofits follow and annual giving appeals, end of year appeals, that sort of stuff. You know, how does your work like morph and change with the nonprofit from year two to year four or five. Clearly, you're still delivering the strategy. how are those adjustments made? you're probably forecasting out six to 12 months because you're seeing the field when they may not be able to because you have that ability. How do you always stay in front of them so they stay engaged and like, we got to have like she is a partner, not a vendor. How do you stay in front of that? Susan Kahan: Right. Well, would say typically I'm not working with clients for two to four years. That's usually not what I do. Sometimes for a capital campaign type of thing where it is a longer engagement, a longer project, but usually we're not working that long. But I will say with fundraising is you're not going to see immediate results. And especially I focus mainly on major gifts, plan giving and real transformational types of gifts. So those don't happen in 30 days. Don Martelli: Got it. Okay. Yeah. Got it. No, no, no, no, no. Susan Kahan: Those don't happen in 60 days. You know, if you might have a conversation and an agreement in that period of time, but it usually going to take longer and real strength and change and growth is going to take years. And you have to have the right staff in place. You have to have the right, you know, asks in place. You have to be working with the donors and building those relationships. So what I really focus on with my clients is thinking about, where are we right now? Where we want to be a year from now? Where do we want to be five years from now? and what are the steps we need to do to get there? And that's gonna vary. It might be focusing more on major gifts, bringing in new people, increasing the current people who are giving. It might be thinking about different ways of giving. So again, I mentioned plan giving, which is really growing and only going to get bigger given, and this is an important factor in our field is that we have a generational change happening and a wealth transfer happening between generations. So there's a lot of things to be considering, but I think what's really important is building strong donor relationships. That's critical. You've got to get leadership involved in fundraising. CEO can't say it, which once was said to me, I hate fundraising. want nothing to do with it. Not okay, not acceptable. You're not going to grow and be a strong organization when you have the leadership, have that mentality. And three is you've got to be thinking, you know, you've got to be trying new things. You can't just be doing things that used, that worked in the Don Martelli: Yep. Yeah, agreed. Susan Kahan: because it's not going to work anymore. Don Martelli: Yeah, you're right. You're right. One thing I love about the space and you kind of alluded to it is that it's kind of like networking for your business, right? You million dollar gift doesn't happen because they got an email. It gives because you somebody like you prep the ED to go into the room. Here's who you meeting. This is what makes them tick. This is why they give they got three kids. They've got a dog by the name of Charlie, like literally the entire, you know, phone book of information at them to get prepared. Susan Kahan: Absolutely not. Exactly. Yes. A donor profile. Yes. Don Martelli: And it's yeah, donor profile and it's still I mean, yeah, you can still get up, you know, maybe $1,010 gifts, but it's really where that top what eight to 5 % of those donors at that top level that really drive a big majority of those dollars. Susan Kahan: Yeah, I mean, again, it really different organizations are structured differently and have different ratios of their top donors to their lower donors. But for the most part, many, many nonprofits, a lot of their individual gifts come from a few top donors. And also what's really important, why I keep talking about generations, not every nonprofit, but I would say 75 % plus of US based nonprofits, their top donors are all over the age of 60, or most of their donors are over the age of 60 at that at those top levels. Don Martelli: Wow. Susan Kahan: And so it's just something to be thinking about that are those donors, what's going to happen when they're no longer able to make those gifts? Do their kids care about the mission in the same way and thinking about how can you make this a family gift and keep that giving going? Or do you need to find the younger donors? But yes, the building of the relationships and making sure that the CEO or the board chair, whomever the chief advancement officer understand this donor cares about these things. This is how they got connected to us. This is what they've done before. And oftentimes those really big million dollar asks, that's not a one time meeting. That might be three meetings over a year and having a conversation because perhaps the gift is intended for a specific purpose. And so really making sure that they excited about the gift because you want the donor to be happy about the giving, not feel like their arms were twisted because I guarantee they're not going to want to give again when they feel like they weren't happy about how voluntarily gave that money to you. Don Martelli: Yeah, valid. Yep, and they want to see the impact, right? They're doing out of the kindness of their heart, but they also want to make sure that there's some sort of impact that they feel they're connected to in some way, shape or form, which leads me to my next question. Love to, you know, just, I feel like folks that work in this space, there's a reason why they do it. And it's something about the work that fuels their energy and their passion around it. So what like what fuels fuels you to do what you do? Susan Kahan: 100%. Absolutely. You know, I strongly believe in the power of philanthropy. believe, you know, ⁓ this one phrase, it's a Hebrew proverb that really is sort of my main thing, which is, ⁓ you change one life, you change the world. ⁓ so I think that if you can make a difference in one person's life, can ⁓ the world better. ⁓ so I believe that philanthropy helps to do that. And if I can help more organizations, Don Martelli: Hmm. Susan Kahan: raise more money so that can help more lives, make a cleaner planet, safer communities, diseases, ⁓ people better, all of the things that we all care about. I think what a I'm giving, and I feel so good about helping that in my small part, in my small way. Don Martelli: Hmm. here. We're aligned there because I mean, for me, it's mission driven impact focus, right? I want to work with good people doing good things impacting the lives of other people in a positive way. And you can still make good money, have a great life and live a lifestyle. But at the same time to have your thumbprint on any of those campaigns, I think is just an incredible thing. And to see the impact and the smile on people's faces and just the I also think the connection you make with people your clients in this space is different. Right? Susan Kahan: Thanks, Luke. ⁓ Don Martelli: is you don't really get that vendor part like relationship. It's like, I know my EDs really well. And I know what makes them tick and they know me really well. We've gone to dinner, we've had some experience is just this makes that his relationship, it goes again back to our networking point, which I think is so fruitful for you know. Susan Kahan: No. Yeah. Absolutely. Well, you the number of times I've had a client say, you know, this was like my fundraising therapy, because, you know, fundraising can be really hard. And I, you know, parts, I'm part cheerleader. I'm part motivator. I'm a part accountability partner, you know, especially for a CEO or executive director. They don't have a lot of people they can be vulnerable with, especially, you know, career wise, at least. And I think being someone who they can trust, Don Martelli: Ha ha ha ha. Yeah, they can trust, yeah. No, you're right. Susan Kahan: being someone who they can bounce off ideas with, who they can, you know, test ideas. know, something I do with a lot of my clients is we will role play the solicitation experience. So I will pretend to be the donor and they pretend to be themselves and go through that. And I can provide feedback for them in real time, because so often in those types of experiences, you don't really know how you're being perceived because the person who you're talking to isn't going to give you that type of feedback. And so that's another thing that Again, being a partner and not a vendor. mean, yeah, I mean, I would never think of myself as a vendor. And, my goal again is how can I be as supportive to them as possible? But like you said before, again, I'm not a nonprofit. I'm here to make money. I'm here to do great, but I'm here to do great work with other organizations. Don Martelli: an example of your work you're most proud of when people ask you about the work that you do? Susan Kahan: Well, something I'm very excited about that is coming up is ⁓ one of my clients, was working with a university and they ⁓ a black college. soon they, they had decided before I started with them, ⁓ they had that one of their revenue producers would be to get a football team to the school because there's a whole, I knew nothing about this, but there's a whole bunch of stuff about having football and how it provides income for a school. And, needed to raise money to get started. So we worked together and I'm very excited. Football is coming in the fall, which is thrilled. Again, I had a small part in it, but I'm excited for them. I'm excited what this will do for the community at large and the school. ⁓ And I, I'm proud. Don Martelli: yeah. That's cool. I mean, I'm a big football fan. So I really appreciate that. And plus, I mean, you've got building of a stadium, which creates jobs, you know, jobs for those that manage the team, head coach, assistant coach, personal trainers, equipment, fundraising opportunities, right, going from probably a D1, D2, or D3, D2 to maybe some point D1 competitive school and all types of revenue comes as well. It's like when schools try to go to a research institute, because they're have access to dollars to do those research. So athletics, Susan Kahan: Yes. Yeah. Athletic, it's really interesting because again, you might have people who are able to attend a four year university and that they otherwise would never have been able to and what that can do for the rest of their life. But forget just the athletes. You also have the community after a football game. There's talk about vendors, there's restaurants, there's different places that can build up a community that could really use the financial support and development. So that's huge. Beyond just athletes, there's the band that's going to be involved, the cheerleaders, there's all this other Don Martelli: No, it's, yeah, it is. Totally. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ yeah? Yeah. Susan Kahan: infrastructure that goes into place, but getting started is sometimes the hardest part and getting that funding. And so that was where I was involved. Don Martelli: Right. Got it. Well, so somebody wants to get into this space and they're interested in learning more. I what's some of the advice that you would give your younger self when you were maybe not thinking about going to this place? What are the things that like you've you're amazed that you've learned about or the skills you've picked up today versus what you thought you were going into, you know, 10, 15 years ago? What's some advice would you provide as somebody coming into the field? Susan Kahan: Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think I don't know if you mean ⁓ fundraising or consultant or both, but yeah, well, I would say number one, and you know, we started with this is the importance of networking is and you know, is so important. And again, it is often about who you know, and you don't always want to admit that that you you found out about this thing. But I'll also share I did a thesis in college that was called elderly gossip in retirement communities. ⁓ Don Martelli: Yeah, well both, Yeah. Really? Susan Kahan: learning about gossip and the thing that's so critical about gossip, I think it gets a bad rap. But if you know things first, you can get ahead. it's same thing in, I mean, you could talk journalism is kind of like gossip, but you know, job opportunities, all that stuff. If you know things and you're talking to more people, and again, more people know about you, I think it will only help your career. So that's, and again, staying in touch with people, I wish I had done more of that in my early career. And another thing that I really wish I did, Don Martelli: Yeah, yeah, I agree. Same. Susan Kahan: early parts of my career that I definitely did not do, and I'm telling anyone who's listening to this to do this right now, is track the work that you do. Because I don't have a list of what I did from age 22 to 27. I I know theoretically, but I don't have a list of what I did or the accomplishments or really good data about that. And I think you forget. You think you'll remember, but you forget. So I would say network. Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Susan Kahan: and track the work that you do in your achievements because as time goes on, your memory will fade. And so I highly encourage you to track that information. Don Martelli: Smart. Smart, smart. That's good stuff. So what's next for you in your business? What's on the horizon? Susan Kahan: you know, again, I'm approaching my five year anniversary, which feels like a big accomplishment in business. ⁓ You know, that feels pretty damn good, I have to say. I'm pretty proud of myself. And so right now I'm just looking to I love what I do. I'm really proud of it. And I just want to keep working with other established nonprofits that Don Martelli: it. Yeah, you made it. Susan Kahan: ⁓ have interesting stories to tell and need some help on that donor strategy and thinking through all the changes we're going through as a society and how do they continue to thrive in ⁓ this market and environment. And that's really where I see my business going is to keep working as we're doing. Onto the next, yeah. Don Martelli: Now on to the next five years, right? Love it. So if people want to learn more, if you're a nonprofit out there that needs help, where can they find you? Susan Kahan: Sure. So they could go to my website, which is sapphirefundraisingspecialist.com. I'm sure we could add a link because that's a long title. Oh, other, will say for anyone who's starting a business, naming their company, it can be really difficult. And if there's one thing I would do differently, it was find a way to make a shorter name because I didn't know at time how many times you have to write out your name. That would be my other recommendation, shorter name for the company. Don Martelli: Absolutely. Mm-hmm. Yep. That's why mine's the PR bunker, nice and short and sweet. ⁓ Susan Kahan: I can't even tell you, it's, my name is too long. I thought about changing it and I'm like, a mess anyways, but that would be the other thing. So find me there or find me on LinkedIn. I'm pretty active there. You could find my email address that way. And my name again is Susan Khan and I'd love to connect there. Oh, I'm actually not really in alignable. I don't know that's how we met, but I thought we went through Lee Tucker. Yes. I'm probably on alignable. Yeah, but I I don't really use it. Don Martelli: perfect. And I can find you on alignable as well. That's ⁓ no, I'll have to get there. Maybe not. Probably leave LinkedIn. I mean, what are these like, to your point earlier? Yeah, probably. But your point earlier, I mean, like, the amount of channels we have access to to meet people, right? It's email, it's social, it's in person networking, it's to folks like Lee Tucker, shout out Lee Tucker, by the way, if you're in the nonprofit space, you don't go to Lee Tucker's nonprofit. Susan Kahan: Yeah. Yes. Don Martelli: executive meetup every single month, you are missing out. That's why you find, you know, talented people like Susan and elsewhere. So I mean, I agree, I'm kind of on all the platforms that I sort of have to but at the same time, it's, you know, it's really what we're doing now, which really matters, which is getting to know people having several conversations, figuring out where you have gaps in your business, and finding other talented people to your point. Susan Kahan: Yes. Absolutely. Don Martelli: to build those Jenga blocks to add those stacks, but it's good stuff. well, congratulations on five years and congratulations on you to spell out the name of your company the accurate way because it's so long but looking forward to the next five years. Again, if anybody can find you again, what's the website address one more time? Susan Kahan: Yeah. Thank you. It's Sapphire Fundraising Specialist dot com. Don Martelli: Perfect. All right. Well, thank you for joining me down here in the PR bunker. Congratulations on five years. I'm sure we'll be talking. But again, if anybody wants to need some help in fundraising and just can't figure out what is blocking or stopping or just don't know where to start, please reach out to Susan and her team and herself and everything she's learned can bring those skills to the table to help you unlock those things. But Susan, thanks again for joining the PR bunker. It's been a pleasure. Susan Kahan: Thank you, Don it great to be here. Don Martelli: Excellent.