Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Netflix Q3 2025 Financial Analysis: Why the $1200 Stock Price Violates
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling a big one A
- 0:04a really critical mission, you could say, which is taking one
- 0:08of the market's highest Flyers, Netflix ticker NFLX, of course,
- 0:12and, well, dragging it through the mud of classic old school
- 0:15value investing. OK, yeah, that's a fascinating
- 0:19exercise. I mean, for years Netflix was
- 0:21all about growth, growth, growth, right?
- 0:23Subscribers, content, spend. Forget profits.
- 0:26Exactly. But now they're maturing,
- 0:27generating serious cash. So the question flips.
- 0:31Can a tech leader like this, you know, actually hold up under
- 0:34those really tough intrinsic value tests, the kind of someone
- 0:37like Warren Buffett would apply? That's the core tension,
- 0:40absolutely. That's what we need to unpack
- 0:41for you today. We've got a deep financial
- 0:43research report here digging into their Q32025 earnings, the
- 0:47business models, health, the Moat strength, and importantly,
- 0:50a cold hard valuation. We want to figure out if it's
- 0:54still just seen as a great stock or if it's finally crossed over
- 0:57into being a truly great business from a fundamental
- 1:00perspective. And we should probably say up
- 1:01front, the stakes are high here. This stock is, well, it's price
- 1:06for perfection. Any slip up, any deviation from
- 1:09amazing growth, the market just punishes it brutally.
- 1:12OK. Let's dive into that Q3
- 1:14scorecard then, because the results were definitely mixed.
- 1:18On the surface, revenue looked pretty solid, came in at $11.51
- 1:23billion. Which is a healthy jump, Yeah,
- 1:25about 17.2% year over year. Top line looks good.
- 1:28Seems solid, but then you look at the bottom line and initially
- 1:31it seems, well, disappointing. Right.
- 1:34And that's where just looking at headlines can trip you up.
- 1:37Operating income was $3.25 billion.
- 1:40That translates to an operating margin of about 28%.
- 1:43And that was below what they guided.
- 1:44For yeah, noticeably short management guidance was aiming
- 1:47closer to 31.5%, so a miss. OK, but this is where the deep
- 1:52dive really pays off, isn't it? Because you can't just stop at
- 1:55that headline number. Exactly.
- 1:56That margin miss wasn't really about core operations failing,
- 2:00it was almost entirely due to one specific thing, a huge one
- 2:03time charge. The Brazilian tax issue.
- 2:05That's the one, a $619 million hit from a pretty complex tax
- 2:10dispute down there. Wow.
- 2:11And management was very clear, strip out that one off
- 2:15regulatory cost, something they can't really control in the
- 2:18short term and their operating margin would have actually
- 2:20beaten their forecast. Right.
- 2:22So the underlying business, the cost control, the stuff they can
- 2:25manage day-to-day is actually healthier than that messy
- 2:29quarterly number suggests. Much healthier, yeah.
- 2:31Yeah, it tells you the core engine is running pretty clean.
- 2:34That's a really important clarification, especially when
- 2:37you connect it to cash flow, because that's where the Netflix
- 2:39story has fundamentally changed these last few years.
- 2:42They went from burning cash. To being a cash powerhouse.
- 2:45That pivot is the defining story of mature Netflix.
- 2:48I think free cash flow FCF for Q3 was huge, right, $2.66
- 2:52billion? Impressive.
- 2:54So strong, in fact, that management bumped up their full
- 2:57year 2025. The FCF forecast they're now
- 2:59expecting $9 billion. That's.
- 3:01From what range before? They were previously guiding 8
- 3:04to $8.5 billion. So a significant raise, and when
- 3:10a company starts reliably generating cash like this and
- 3:13raising guidance, it changes the whole investment thesis.
- 3:16OK. So where is that revenue growth
- 3:18coming from? It feels like they're finally
- 3:19firing on all cylinders using all their available levers at
- 3:23once. They.
- 3:24Pretty much are. First, you've got good old
- 3:25fashioned pricing power. Their brand still lets them
- 3:28raise prices periodically. Second is just organic growth in
- 3:32subscribers and importantly, engagement globally.
- 3:35And 3rd, the one that's getting a lot of attention is the
- 3:38advertising tier. Right, the ad tier.
- 3:40That's still pretty new in the grand scheme of things, isn't
- 3:42it? Yeah, it is still nascent,
- 3:44relatively small percentage wise, but growing quickly.
- 3:47For Q32025 analysts figure ads brought in maybe 0.66 billion
- 3:52dollars. OK.
- 3:53So what percentage of total revenue is that?
- 3:54Around 5.7% seems small right? But think about it.
- 3:57For decades almost 100% of their revenue was Subs.
- 4:01This is a totally new high margin stream.
- 4:03It diversifies things. That 5.7% might be small now,
- 4:06but it's arguably the key growth story going forward.
- 4:09Interesting. OK, so the cash is flowing, but
- 4:12is the business itself built to last?
- 4:15Let's talk foundation, the Moat, the scale, and, you know, the
- 4:19risks that won't just go away. Why is Netflix so resilient?
- 4:24Their Moat, their competitive advantage, it really stands on 4
- 4:27incredibly strong pillars I'd say OK.
- 4:30Laid them out. 1st just raw scale.
- 4:32They have this massive sticky global base, over 300 million
- 4:36subscribers worldwide now. That distribution footprint is
- 4:39almost impossible for anyone else to replicate quickly.
- 4:42Pillar 2 has to be the content, right?
- 4:44That's their main weapon. Absolutely.
- 4:45The content mode it's built on just pouring money into it.
- 4:48Projected spend is around $18 billion for 2025 alone. 18
- 4:53billion. Yeah, that kind of spending
- 4:55guarantees a constant flow of exclusive shows, movies, a deep
- 4:59library. It makes the service sticky.
- 5:01Hard to leave Third Pillar the brand itself.
- 5:04Synonymous with streaming. Pretty much they spent 25 years
- 5:07building that name recognition and the final pillar may be a
- 5:10bit underrated is the tech. The recommendation engine?
- 5:12The platform itself. Exactly their proprietary
- 5:15algorithms, how they personalized suggestions, the
- 5:17smooth experience across what 190 plus countries competitors
- 5:22have really struggled to match that global tech efficiency.
- 5:26OK sounds like an iron fortress, but every fortress has potential
- 5:30weaknesses. These non transient threats.
- 5:35If the Moat is content spend, isn't that spend also their
- 5:37biggest risk? It's definitely double edged
- 5:39sword. The number one long term risk is
- 5:41that content costs spiral. Their existing content
- 5:44obligations are already over $21 billion. 21 billion they owe for
- 5:49content down the line. Right.
- 5:50And you've got intense deep pocketed rivals, Disney Plus,
- 5:54galas, Amazon Macs, Apple all bidding up the price for talent,
- 5:58for intellectual property that guarantees the cost of their
- 6:01main raw material keeps rising. It puts long term pressure on
- 6:04margins. And if costs go up, they need to
- 6:06raise prices. But eventually they hit a wall,
- 6:09right? Market saturation.
- 6:10Especially in mature markets like the US and Canada, they're
- 6:12already in what, over 60% of households there?
- 6:15So future growth can't just be adding millions of new Subs like
- 6:18the old days. It has to come from getting more
- 6:20money out of each existing user. Exactly.
- 6:23ARPU, average revenue per user. That means more price hikes
- 6:26really pushing that ad tier, cracking down on password
- 6:29sharing effectively. But that intense competition
- 6:32puts a sort of ceiling on how hard they can push prices
- 6:35without losing people. OK.
- 6:37But what's genuinely positive though is seeing that
- 6:39operational efficiency finally kick in.
- 6:42Scale seems to be working for them now.
- 6:44Content cost is still the biggest chunk obviously, but
- 6:47look at marketing spend. Yeah, that's a really key signal
- 6:49of maturity. Marketing costs as a percentage
- 6:52of revenue have been steadily dropping, went from around 9%
- 6:55down to about 7.5% in 2024. So they don't have to spend as
- 7:00much proportionally to get new users anymore.
- 7:02Basically, yes. The brand is strong, they're
- 7:04everywhere. They can acquire users more
- 7:06cheaply now leveraging that scale.
- 7:08It shows the business model is maturing nicely on the cost
- 7:11side. All right, moment of truth time.
- 7:13Let's run the ultimate test. We're taking the classic value
- 7:16investing checklist, you know, the one designed for steady
- 7:19eddies like Coke or Amex, and applying it to Netflix.
- 7:22Can this streaming giant pass muster?
- 7:25We we have to start with the fails, the glaring ones, and
- 7:28they mostly circle around valuation discipline.
- 7:30For a traditional value investor looking for that margin to
- 7:32safety, Netflix is just priced completely wrong.
- 7:36Give us the hard numbers. Where does it fail?
- 7:37OK, priced earnings ratio PE Classic Value wants it under 15
- 7:42times earnings, maybe even lower.
- 7:44End of 2024, Netflix was trading at 44 X. 44 wow, that's
- 7:50astronomical. It's all future growth baked in
- 7:53right? Not current profit reality.
- 7:55Entirely massive expectations and the price of book ratio.
- 7:58PB tells a similar story about that growth premium.
- 8:01How bad is that one? Another instant fail by
- 8:03traditional standards. Buffett might look for PB under
- 8:061.5 Netflix trading around 15.7 X book value.
- 8:10OK. But wait a second here.
- 8:11That high PB isn't partly because their value isn't in
- 8:14factories or inventory. It's intangible stuff.
- 8:17The content library, the brand equity.
- 8:19That's a critical counterpoint, yes, And it absolutely explains
- 8:22why the number is so high. Yeah, but it doesn't change the
- 8:24fact that it fails the traditional test.
- 8:26Why not? Because a conservative value
- 8:28investors sees that high PB tied to intangible assets as more
- 8:32risk. Those assets are harder to value
- 8:35precisely harder to liquidate in a crisis.
- 8:38So even though we understand why it's high, it violates that core
- 8:42principle of protecting your capital with tangible backing
- 8:45margin of safety. Got it.
- 8:46And historically they failed another test too, didn't they?
- 8:49Free cash flow consistency. They burn cash for years
- 8:53building this thing. Precisely.
- 8:54For most of the last decade, FCF was negative.
- 8:57Deeply negative, sometimes. Now they did post a strong $6.9
- 9:00billion FCF in 2023, which is great, but that lack of a
- 9:04consistent positive track record over a full 10 year cycle?
- 9:08That's an immediate red flag for someone looking for rock solid
- 9:11dependability. OK.
- 9:12So valuation metrics are mostly fails.
- 9:14Let's look to the quality side though.
- 9:16Business execution, management, competence.
- 9:18This is where Netflix should shine, right?
- 9:19Like return on equity Roe? Yes, here the picture changes
- 9:23dramatically. Their Roe is phenomenal, truly
- 9:26world class. What?
- 9:27Are the numbers. It averaged around 1820% over
- 9:29the last 10 years, which is already good, but in 2024 it hit
- 9:33an astonishing 34.9%. 35% Roe. Yeah, that blows past the
- 9:38typical 15% benchmark value investors like to see.
- 9:42It shows management is incredibly good at taking
- 9:44retained earnings and turning them into more profit for
- 9:47shareholders. Very efficient.
- 9:49And the growth in their actual book value, the equity they
- 9:53built up. Staggering it compounded at, get
- 9:56this, a 41% compound annual growth rate over the last
- 9:59decade. 41%. Without a single year of
- 10:02contraction that is just textbook wealth creation through
- 10:05reinvesting earnings. You almost never see numbers
- 10:08like that outside of maybe early stage tech.
- 10:11And they've cleaned up the balance sheet too, right?
- 10:13Less risky now. Huge improvement there.
- 10:15A major strategic shift. Their debt to equity ratio was
- 10:19way up around 2 point O back in 2018.
- 10:21Highly leveraged. By 20/24 it had fallen
- 10:24dramatically to about .62. Much, much safer fiscally.
- 10:28They've successfully moved from needing outside debt to funding
- 10:31themselves with their own cash flow.
- 10:32OK, so summing up the checklist, the verdict seems pretty clear.
- 10:35I think so. Netflix is without doubt an
- 10:38exceptional franchise. The economics are demonstrably
- 10:41improving, becoming world class in terms of profitability, like
- 10:44Roe. But it is absolutely not a great
- 10:48company at a wonderful price in the classic Buffett sense.
- 10:51Correct. The market has always demanded a
- 10:53massive premium for this stock. The price has consistently
- 10:57violated that margin of safety principle because investors are
- 11:00always paying up for the growth they hope is coming, not the
- 11:03value that's actually there today.
- 11:05Which brings us perfectly to the ultimate reality check, the
- 11:09discounted cash flow analysis, the DCF.
- 11:12This is where we try to estimate the real intrinsic value based
- 11:15on projecting future cash flows starting from that $6.93 billion
- 11:21XCF baseline from Q3. Right.
- 11:23And when you do this and then you hold up the results against
- 11:25the actual market price, which late 2025 was trading around
- 11:30$1200 a share, the results are, well, they're pretty striking.
- 11:33Let's frame that gap. Start conservative.
- 11:35Assume competition heats up, saturation bites, and FCF growth
- 11:38slows to maybe a stable 6% a year going forward.
- 11:41What's the value then? In that scenario, the kind of
- 11:45steady state but competitive future, the intrinsic value
- 11:48estimate comes out to only around $272 per share. 272
- 11:52dollars, yeah. And if you're a discipline
- 11:54investor wanting a 25% margin of safety on top of that, your buy
- 11:59price target would be down at 204 dollars. $204.00 versus a
- 12:03$1200 market price. So the stock is trading at
- 12:06nearly five times its conservative intrinsic value.
- 12:09Roughly, yeah. The gap is enormous.
- 12:11OK, now let's swing the other way.
- 12:13Let's be wildly optimistic. Assume the ad tier is a massive
- 12:16home run. They conquer new markets, keep
- 12:18raising prices and FCF grows at a stunning 25% a year for the
- 12:22next five years. Super bullish case.
- 12:24Even then, yeah, even assuming everything goes perfectly, they
- 12:27crush all expectations. The DCF intrinsic value only
- 12:30gets up to $576 per share. 576 Still less than half the current
- 12:35trading price of $1200. Less than half.
- 12:37Wow, that disparity. It doesn't just suggest
- 12:41optimism, it suggests the market is pricing.
- 12:44Netflix like it? I don't know, cured aging last
- 12:47week? Yeah, that's not a bad analogy.
- 12:49To rationally justify $1200 a share with ADCF, you need to
- 12:54plug in FCF growth rates of like 40% or more, sustained for many,
- 12:59many years. Which seems unlikely.
- 13:02It implies Netflix has to find some revolutionary new business
- 13:06line, like gaming becoming utterly dominant very quickly,
- 13:10or somehow achieve complete global pricing power with no
- 13:14competitive pushback. It's pricing in a level of
- 13:16future success that seems, frankly almost impossible based
- 13:20on current trajectories. It is interesting though, that
- 13:23management seems to think the stock is undervalued relative to
- 13:26its cash generation. They're buying back shares,
- 13:29right? They are actively pursuing
- 13:30buybacks. They still have about $12
- 13:32billion authorized for future repurchases.
- 13:34Which is basically management saying we think the best use of
- 13:37our cash right now is buying our own stock.
- 13:39Exactly. It's putting their money where
- 13:40their mouth is. They're using that strong FCF to
- 13:43return capital shareholders by reducing the share, a classic
- 13:46move for a mature company that thinks that stock is cheap
- 13:49relative to its prospects. OK, let's try and wrap this up.
- 13:53Key takeaways for you, the listener from this deep dive.
- 13:56Netflix, fundamentally it's a robust world class operation.
- 14:01Definitely. It's built a powerful Moat
- 14:02around content and scale. The profitability metrics,
- 14:06especially that Roe, are now excellent and its ability to
- 14:09generate free cash flow is strong and improving.
- 14:12With FCF, Milton's consistently hitting over 17%.
- 14:15But, and it's a huge but, the valuation is the sticking point,
- 14:19the defining tension here. While the company quality is
- 14:21high, the stock price reflects these massive, arguably
- 14:25unproven, almost irrational expectations for future growth.
- 14:29Right. The intrinsic value, even using
- 14:31pretty aggressive assumptions in our DCF, puts the company's
- 14:34worth far, far below where it's actually trading in the market
- 14:36today. Which lose us with that final
- 14:38provocative thought. The big question for you to
- 14:41ponder as an investor or just an interested observer is this.
- 14:44What on earth is the market seeing or betting on that isn't
- 14:47captured in even the most optimistic, rational cash flow
- 14:50model? Is it truly banking on gaming
- 14:53becoming a revolutionary new pillar?
- 14:55Is it anticipating completely unchallenged global pricing
- 14:59dominance for the next decade? Or is the current valuation
- 15:03just, you know, market momentum, a great story that's become
- 15:05detached from fundamental reality?
- 15:07That's the next layer of the onion.
- 15:09That's the next deep dive you need to think about.